Chinese and Indian Science - How Advanced?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2024
- “Science and Society” is a science series arranged by TheBlackHole Islamabad. Designed for high school and above audiences, this session is hosted by Pakistan’s acclaimed nuclear physicist Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.
“Chinese and Indian Science - How Advanced?” is one of the lectures of this series. It will be a 45-60 minute presentation followed by interactive Q&A with audience.
Nobody in India claims that heart transplants happened in ancient times.
But yes, Sushruta, the "founding father of Surgery" was performing rhinoplasty (nose reconstruction) and other forms of plastic surgery 2600 years ago on the banks of river Ganga.
bro, i heard it myself. and also the fact that they had planes. also, rhinoplasty is way different then what was performed back then.
Also performed cataract surgery.
@@heavenlypot it's not the same as modern one. I think people miss the idea of it.
@@kh-fk3ko That's not the important thing. Have you looked at the first models of atoms or physics ideas given by Greeks? They are ridiculous and hilarious, yet they are taught to students in the beginning of the course because it is the fact that they tried it for the first time. You are mistaken to think that people are assuming a modern doctor wearing gloves and holding precision tools was doing surgery?
@@heavenlypot what are you talking about? No where in school was I taught that greeks invented atoms or physics, nor is it believed, infact in many academia their descriptions are laughed at. The only ones that like to talk about it are euro centric or ultra Greek nationalists. Same goes with alot of these Indian pseudo scientists as well.
Sir, @51:05 u mention that Aryabhatta believed that the earth was stationary and that the sun revolves around it, this is absolutely untrue.. Aryabhatta in his calculations of a Yuga (which is appx 4320000 years) mentions that the earth revolves eastwards on its axis 1582237500 times, this translates to 23 hours 56 mins and 4.1 secs, which is remarkably close to the now known number of 23 hours 56 mins and 4.09 secs.. he’s also presented a calculation of the number of rotations of earth per lunar orbit which matches the correct figure up to 7 decimal places..
I know u are a man of science sir, but I humbly request you to kindly go through a few such works by Rishi’s in the ancient past of India.
As far as ancient Hindus believing in the earth being flat, the Hindi word😢 for Geography is ‘Bhugol’, which is made by combining 2 different words : Bhu - means land/earth and Gol - means round.. the name itself is self explanatory: Round earth..
His Muslim & Pakistani identity makes him suffer from an inferiority complex to Hindus & India..So, he has avoided India for most part of his life..that's why such ignorance & sometimes insult also towards Bharat
BTW, what's the reference of Aryabhatta facts you put here..Is it Wikipedia? I want to read further
Combination of Sanskrit and math is a difficult topic... We can manipulate math equations and show both geocentric or heliocentric model.. we can also manipulate as if Mars is center of universe , different people need different calculations.. few need sun in center few need Earth in center.. but how actually universe looks is different.. depends on need and depends on perspective...
He is completely baised scientist.
in India, Geography is called Bhu-gol, Bhu means Earth, and Gol means Sphere.
@Arvind Singh Bhugola is sanskrit. In the vedas, there is a 'bhu suktam' as well
@@goodsong_views *but according to popat sahab earth is flat, wo bhai paidal chale jara usko laga flat hi hoga* 😂
*Fruits me khazoor k alawa uss khazoor ko kuch ni pta tha 😂 iss bechare k paida hone se 10000 saal pehle bhi humari civilisation exist kar rahi thi , jitni advanced open minded society Mohenjo-Daro k time me thi humari waisi to aaj ki muslim duniya me nahi hai*
@Arvind Singh thoda padh le ...Navgath is also a sanskrit word
@@user-bv8xw5co7t Bhugōḷika śāstraṁ
even our temples that date 1000+ years back have nav graha ( 9 planets ) center of which is surya ( sun ) , our calendar is based on Surya Siddhanta.. again shows sun🌞 is the centre not earth 🌎
Hoodbhoy missed several people like Bhramagupta and Hemachandra. But clearly over the years his knowledge of indian historical science has improved significantly.
Aryabhatta never said earth was stationary 😂😂😂 pleasee dont spread fake info
What you accept from pakistani fake history
@@firstcopy8449 😂🤣🤣🤣😂
His Muslim & Pakistani identity makes him suffer from an inferiority complex to Hindus & India..So, he has avoided India for most part of his life..that's why such ignorance & sometimes insult also towards Bharat
even great devil king of shri Lanka noted scholar Lord Raawan had raised query.... if 🌍 is stationary & centre of s☀lar system !!! Then why every commet ☄️attracted by the☀ ... no commet come into 🌍's orbit. means🌍is not centre of our solar system☀•✨🌎🌙✨🔴 ° 💯% ✅ 👍
jai shri Raawan 🙏
@@sharadmishra5596 sorry he is not typical sunni wahabi 🤲🧔💍🧕🏻🧕🏻🧕🏻🧕🏻??? he is Qadiyan Ahmadiyya (a branch of SHIRDI-SHIYA sect., based on Guru-bhakti) ✅
If aryabhatta correctly calculated solar and lunar eclipses, how would he do that without knowing that earth orbits around the sun ? Can you explain? I think Dr hoodboy has presumed without any basis that the planetary model used by aryabhatta is wrong! Is it a coincidence that his calculations were correct but his model was wrong? Wonderful!
Yaa you are right Aryabhatta never said that earth is stationary and sun is revolving around earth ..... Facts about Indian science of Pervez hoodbhoy needs update .....and he is somewhat want to undermine our achievements but inki bhi problem nhi hain class .... Political correctness
As far as I know the first nose transplant and the first cataract surgeries were actually done by Sushrutta in India - I haven't watched the video but the prof seems to have dismissed that claim alongside the vimana stuff
Dont expect much from Pakistani professors.
Aryabhatta opined that earth rotates on its own axis and sun & moon revolve around earth in epicyles.
So we can deduct from this that Aryabhatta consider earth to be the centre point of the solar system.
And for the calculation of eclipses, Aryabhatta thought that when the two epicycles of sun & moon overlap, eclipses occur.
@@Vishal_Chintal So he was still correct relatively, because he worked on the principles of relative motion. Even if that's assumed, one can't say that he assumed earth to be the centre of the universe. If relatively sun rotates around the earth, then earth also rotates around sun. Doesn't prove anything really. It would only prove anything if we have any manuscript of aryabhatta that specifically states that earth is the centre of the universe, otherwise things remain inconclusive and hoodboy is assuming things unnecessarily!
Sir we Kafir Hindu have very little knowledge...of math and astrology....🤣😂.....But a big salute to your channel for knowledge purpose.....
O tteri. Just great point.
Don't worry sir we are Indian ....hum apni position bana lege ....app mano ya na mano .... knowledge ko leke jo bhokh Indians me hai na wo kisi aur jagah ni ...one day we lead the word in science as well adhyaatm...
Rahne de tu to, harr baar chati peetne lag jata hai
We are leading the world already.
You didn't mentioned Ramanujan ,he was also a great mathematician
Ramanujan is contemporary.
Then what is Shakuntala Devi
Chinese student used to come to Ancient Hindu Universities in India to study Mathematics, Science, Astronomy, and Philosophy.
At that time there is no pakistan .
Aryabhatta never said that earth is stationary and sun and other planets are revolving around it ..... Your fact is wrong in this case ..... You should correct it ....
Pislamic blood inside him can never be diluted by any amount of knowledge he gains.
You refer to indian science like it is from another land . Pakistan was at the centre of most of it with the University of Takshashila at Taxila and the indus Valley.
You should refer the Surya Sidhanth, most hindu festivals are based on astrological events and revolve around the planting and harvest cycle . Predicting weather was one of the major functions of the astrology.
India also had the caste system which was one of the first and most efficient systems of management and social sciences .
In the question answer session, I found it disturbing that the audience seemed incapacitated to allow their minds to aentertain any idea that departed from the Holy Quran . You fight a loosing battle with an audience that will not cross the lakshman rekha of the Holy Quran .
His Muslim & Pakistani identity makes him suffer from an inferiority complex to Hindus & India..So, he has avoided India for most part of his life..that's why such ignorance & sometimes insult also towards Bharat
@@sharadmishra5596 That's what happen when you convert a hindu forcibly--Their leaders have done a very good job in making people hate hinduism. They were afraid, they will convert back that's why they did this
TRUE... TRUE.... 👍🏻
Caste system was responsible for demise of Indian civilisation.
in a society where the professor is afraid of being blasphemous ( the first question asked by the student) ; that society is doomed
Whether I agree or disagree with historic reference of Indian Science or not, doesnt matter, I respect atleast someone touched this topic in pak..however I am sad to see that very less people in this classrom against a overcrowded hujum in TLP rallies and PTI non sense jalsas...
Bas tum itane me hi khush rahena, wo apan propaganda kar ke chale gaye
itna respect kahan se laate ho?
Inspite of lack of audience in the class room ( Jahalat in Pakistan as far as Maths, Science is concerned), this is a commendable initiative by Dr. Hoodbhoy.
by spreading misinformation about Indian science history?
Sir, You did mention that you are not a historian, and I am happy that you made an effort to enlighten students. You did not touch upon metallurgy in ancient India, Zinc purification was first done in India, and Indian steel was supposed to be superior. The iron pillar in front of Qutub Minar in Delhi is rust free after more than a thousand years or more. As far as Ayurveda is concerned, it is a holistic approach to healthcare, that includes Yoga, nutrition, mental health, herbal medicine, surgery etc. Rhinoplasty is used today in the same techniques that Sushruta had described 2600 years ago. Shshruta had created 126 surgical instruments that resemble today's instruments. He did many major surgeries including intracranial surgery (written in Sushruta samhita). I am a general surgeon , and modern medicine is moving towards a holistic approach. Sushruta is acknowledged as the father of surgery by the surgical fraternity all over the world. I believe there is a statue of Sushruta in front of the Royal Australian College of Surgeons in Melbourne.
There were 12 universities in ancient India. Takshila, and Nalanda were the more famous. 60 subjects (streams including medicine, politics, economics, mathematics, astronomy etc} with a faculty of 3000 (in Nalanda). Nalanda library was burning for 3 months after Bakhtiar Khilji's attack. He slaughtered the faculty and students., and more than one lakh original manuscripts were burnt. Students came from all over the world to Indian universities. Takshila university was built many centuries before Alexander.
I appreciate your efforts. Takhshila university was in present day Pakistan. Perhaps you will consider going into depths of history.
Pakistan has no history before 1947 . So what are you advising ? Pakistan is going through identity crisis . They consider themselves to be the descendants of Arabs , Mughals , Turks etc . They are denying their roots which is of pre Islamic era . Just for the sake of Islam they aren't acknowledging Indus valley civilization. Their roots is there but unfortunately they are searching everywhere but there . They don't want any connection with Hindu . They are confused with whether superiority or inferiority complex only they knows 😂😂😂😂
mercury was discovered by an indian chemist
Ayurveda is a definite science. In India there are big labs and companies who do r&d. Yoga is a part of ayurveda. And veryone knows it's effect.
Ramdev is thug . Coronil can’t create covid
Don’t explain bro. Bandar kya Jane adrak ka swad
1) So long as religious teachings continue to influence our school and college curriculum we cannot make progress 2) The main reason for Bangladeshi for going ahead of its neighbors is that they don’t spend much on defense
Bangladesh is not ahead of its neighbours. Its way exaggerated. They are progressing but not at a better pace than others. And regarding religious teachings. There was never a concept of religion in Subcontinent. Philisophy as a matter of fact is wat included debate, discussions , manuscripts and it goes way back. Back in the day you could argue, debate and hence improve the hypothesis. And sastrartha as we say in sanskrit happened everywhere.
Ancient Indian Works on Mathematics, science and Medicines are the PIONEERS of modern science and technology. Dr. hoodboy also has deen ki tleem...so, wouldn't expect anything .
you have to realize, when he talks about india, he is talking about his background as well. its just the sad reality of things.
😅you are correct 💯 इतना तो MSC WALA LDAKE हमारे इनसे बेहतर और अधिक ज्ञान रखते हैं। ये प्रोफेसर भी सिर्फ़ मुस्लिम लेखक को ही पढ़ना पसंद करते हैं जिसका नतीजा प्रो Hodiboy निकलते हैं
Indians since ancient times knew that Earth is not stationary. "Jagat" is the sanskrit word used for Earth or our world. This world is again made up of two sanskrit words, ja and gat, meaning that which is in motion..
Dr Hoodbhai, I hold high regards for you, but it appales me when I see you deliberately denying ancient indian advances is fields of Science, Maths, and Astronomy..
Hello Pervez Hoodbhoy ji,
Sushruta is considered the "Father of Plastic Surgery". He did surgery somewhere between 1000 to 800BC. This is even taught in western university.
Hes considered that only in india bruv.sadly
Sir, what are your views on Bhakshali manuscript found near Peshawar, Pakistan? Below is the snippet on the approach used to solve complex problem of that time. Surprisingly it does have the concept of proof.
A highly structural and methodical approach in solving problems as per Bhakshali.
Sutram - The rule :The subject matter is divided into rule
:In each rule matter is arranged as follow
Tada - The example how this rule could help us in words
Sthapanam - The example in numbers. Numerical elobaration of same example
Karanam - The solution. Actual solution. mathematical solution
Pratyayam - The proof
Principles:
Minimum alphabets
Unambiguous
Concise
Universal
Non redundant
Without a flaw
Sir Good Evening Your topics are very knowledgeable but I am sorry to say that please do some research work Aryabhatta and Bhaskar and Susurti . I further request pronounce the name of these great personality respect. For example tha , Aryabhatta tha please speak Aryabhatta the . JaiHind and Jai Pakistani people.
Chinese travelers came to India, studied in Indian universities, and took back loads of books and manuscripts, got the mandate from the emperor of xian to translate in to Chinese. This was in 3-4 century ad. Surya siddhant is more than 12000 years old.
You have to deepen your study about Indian science and mathematics.
Maharishi charak,Maharishi shushrut,Maharishi wagbhatt,Maharishi Aryabhatt, Vishnu Gupt, Mahavir acharya,Maharishi kanad,Maharishi Patanjali, Maharishi parashar, Maharishi viyas, Maharishi vyadhi and Maharishi Baudhayan was Indian scientists.
Bahuto ka naam abhi mujhe yaad nahi aa raha tha isiliye shayad unlogo ka naam chhoot gaya hoga uske liye sorry...
GOOGLE KAR LENA PAKISTANIO. Pata chal jayega Indian science 🤣😂😅😂😅😂😅😂
Aryabhatta, a mathematician and astronomer, wrote Aryabhatiyam. He stated that day and night were caused by the rotation of the earth on its axis. He developed a scientific explanation for eclipses. He also found a way of calculating the circumference of a circle. He wrote how the Earth was not the centre of the universe, but in fact revolved around the Sun.

1




Any topic on science always provokes most Pakistanis- they have to refute them giving references to Qur’an. Pakistanis get surprised when they know of India’s progress, but get provoked when they face science.
People of Indus Valley Civilisation traded with the Arabian peninsula during the time of Harappa and Mohenjodaro (ancient Harappan seals were found in the Arabian peninsula). So contact was from many thousands of years ago.
Allopathy (not modern medicine) is treatment of symptoms, and Ayurveda means knowledge of life.
It’s amazing how easily the Prof says that “Ghaznavi is a hero for us … he destroyed lot of temples” .. it tells you that breaking temples is an accepted fact and not necessarily a bad thing in Pakistan 🤷♂️ .. subconsciously the Prof agrees with that philosophy
BAMS (Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine and Surgery) is an undergraduate degree program in India that focuses on the study of Ayurveda, a traditional system of medicine that originated in India over 5,000 years ago. The program includes the study of both traditional Ayurvedic practices and modern medical sciences.While BAMS incorporates modern scientific disciplines such as anatomy, physiology, and pharmacology in its curriculum, it is primarily rooted in the ancient medical traditions and concepts of Ayurveda. These include the understanding of the body, mind, and spirit as interconnected entities and the use of natural remedies for treatment and prevention of diseases.
What great initiative “the black hole” is! Gives perspective and hope and dose of reality to Pakistan and also everyone else ( including India). Kudos Dr. Hudbouy🎉🎉
You talked about Quadratic equation but not tell that it is *Sri* *Dharacharya* who gives the formula of solving Quadratic Equations and the method of solving it is known as *SriDharacharya's* method.
Zinc smelting was investigated in India. It was difficult to extract zinc from ore at it has low melting point.
Cheraman Juma Masjid is the first mosque to be built in India. It is a popular pilgrim centre in Kodungallur in Thrissur district. On first glance, Cheraman Juma Masjid resembles a traditional Hindu temple, and this historic spot draws in devotees in large numbers to this day. Built in C.E 629, it is the first mosque in India and the second in the world where Juma prayers were started. Situated just 2 km from Kodungallur town, its calm and mystical charm must be experienced if one is in the vicinity
2:15 Please do not quote Hindustan.... When you do not know about it.... You are a scientist in Physics in Pakistan.... Bas uthana hi kaafi hai
He is confused. He doesnt know anything about ancient india.
@@riturajput2462 knowing ancient India means knowing his roots .
Astrology is a very close part of Indian culture.....even in our marriage and child birth....or fast....we see planets situations....
Who says sir, if you had learned Sanskrit, your thinking would have been different. Read about Takshila University today that part is in Pakistan Read about the book called Sushruta Samhita, then your confusion can be removed.
It is not like that in India and China Scientific Revolution Couldn't happen-- We focused more on spiritual advancedment. We developed science to a necessary limit so that we can use it for human advancement. We focused on keeping the mind and body healthy. Ayurveda and Meditation.
Ayurveda is exceptional form of medicine
Donot forget sir Pak was part of India
there is no 'acceptable level' of science, as was shown in the islamic invasions and european colonization.
@@echosmith5256 your books won't show it
Its a shame to see so few people attending such a nice lecture. Sir, if you come to India a stadium will be full to hear you. I like the way you explain complex issues in simple urdu/Hindi.
Sir,
Please note down these were old universities of India... And you have not talked about Chankya ....the great economist...
Takshashila, Kashmir Smast, Nalanda, Valabhi University, Sharada Peeth, Pushpagiri Vihara, Odantapuri University, Vikramashila, Somapura Mahavihara, Bikrampur Vihara, Jagaddala Mahavihara.
I love it when the Pakistanis call their own forefathers "Indian".
One of the best by Hoodhboy Sir. He has very clearly explained about Science in Chinese and Indian people. Hoodhboy is a highly knowledgable person and he is in Pakistan! We can see very rarely such persons from muslim world! Salute to him!! I am from India.
आर्यभट के बारे में गलत बताया था न चरक सुश्रुत और धनवंतरी के बारे में बताया और आयुर्वेद के बारे में भी गलत बताया।
We Hindus do not believe the earth is flat Dr Pervez! That’s an abhrahamic belief. In fact, we were one of the few civilisations who made accurate calculations about space.
Also, Aryabhatta never said the earth is stationary. Where on earth as you getting this information from? This is absolutely disappointing.
He is not respectable historian, he is pakistani science communicator just like Neil degrass Tyson of USA. They have their flaws and not expert.
Professor is wrong that Aryabhatta said earth is stationery. Please check through google search or from an authentic books. Aryabhatta told much before Copernicus that earth rotates on its axix and sun is in the centre where planets revolve.
Disagree with Dr. hoodbhoy on certain points about india (especially about indian medical science). It's well established among scientific and historian community across the world about the Origin of Plastic surgery procedure and medical tools associated with that. The effectiveness of some aspects of Ayurveda is visible but the problem is that authentic Ayurvedic knowledge has been very much diluted by unnecessary noise and false information due to which people think it's a sham. However, still i very much liked the fact that someone discussed it in detail and specially the conclusion part that no single civilization can claim the credit for discovery of entire science.
Great initiative...unfortunately not many people seem interested! Maybe they're all attending Khan's nonsensical rallies!! All the best 🙏 🇮🇳
Absurdity of your observation betrays the shallowness of your intellect
You are unfit for intellectual dicourse
जब आप आज भी कहने से डरते है की कुरान की साइंस गलत है, तो आप कैसे तरक्की कर सकते है?
Decimal system, even calculation (with certain approximation) of Pi was done in India during the time Chinese did it
Ancient Indian mathematics made significant contributions to the development of mathematical concepts and techniques. Here are some key aspects of Indian mathematics, explained in detail:
1. **Decimal System**:
The Indian decimal system, also known as the Hindu-Arabic numeral system, is one of the most important contributions to mathematics. It is based on the concept of place value, where the value of a digit depends on its position in a number. This system uses ten symbols (0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9) to represent all numbers, making it highly efficient and versatile.
For example, in the number 1234, the "4" represents units, the "3" represents tens, the "2" represents hundreds, and the "1" represents thousands. This positional system allows for the representation of very large and very small numbers with ease.
2. **Zero**:
The concept of zero (0) as a numerical placeholder is a fundamental development in mathematics. In ancient India, zero was symbolized by a dot or a small circle. This innovation allowed for the development of more sophisticated mathematical operations, including addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.
3. **Numerical Notation**:
Indian mathematicians also developed a system of writing numbers using a combination of letters and numerals. This was particularly prevalent in texts like the "Aryabhatiya," where syllables and words were used in conjunction with numerical symbols to represent mathematical ideas.
4. **Aryabhata and the Aryabhatiya**:
Aryabhata, an ancient Indian mathematician and astronomer, made significant contributions to mathematics through his work "Aryabhatiya." This text contains a wide range of mathematical ideas, including:
- **Trigonometry**: Aryabhata introduced trigonometric concepts and formulas, such as sine and versine functions.
- **Algebra**: He developed algebraic techniques and equations for solving problems related to astronomy and mathematics.
- **Approximation of π (Pi)**: Aryabhata provided an accurate value for the mathematical constant π (Pi) as approximately 3.1416.
- **Quadratic Equations**: He addressed solutions to quadratic equations and their roots.
5. **Brahmagupta and Brahmasphutasiddhanta**:
Brahmagupta, another ancient Indian mathematician, made significant contributions to algebra and arithmetic in his work "Brahmasphutasiddhanta." He introduced concepts such as negative numbers and operations with zero. He also worked on solving quadratic equations and discussed the properties of squares and square roots.
6. **Sulba Sutras**:
The Sulba Sutras are ancient Indian texts that contain geometric principles essential for constructing altars for religious rituals. They provided knowledge related to right angles, Pythagorean triples, and the calculation of the square root of 2, demonstrating an understanding of advanced geometric concepts.
7. **Infinite Series**:
Indian mathematicians explored infinite series, such as the Madhava-Leibniz series, which represents π (Pi) as an infinite sum. This work predated similar developments in Europe by several centuries.
8. **Contributions to Astronomy and Geometry**:
Indian mathematics was closely intertwined with astronomy, and advancements in trigonometry and geometry were essential for accurately predicting planetary positions and eclipses.
These contributions demonstrate the profound impact of ancient Indian mathematics on the development of mathematical concepts, not only in India but also on a global scale. The decimal system and the concept of zero, in particular, have become fundamental to modern mathematics and scientific endeavors.
parvez ji, best wishes to you from india. you are always an inspiration for the young scientists.
I get a feeling that parvez Saab is reluctant to answer few questions to avoid wrath of mullahs and Islamists
Respected sir please aap apna join button open ker diye hum apko donations dena chate hai ya koi dusra tarika bta diye❤❤
In ancient India, physics was intertwined with philosophical and practical aspects. Notable contributions include:
1. **Optics and Light**: Early Indian scholars explored the properties of light, reflection, and refraction. The "Prasnopanishad" discussed the nature of light and vision.
2. **Astronomy and Celestial Mechanics**: Astronomers like Aryabhata and Brahmagupta formulated models of the solar system and made observations related to celestial motion.
3. **Acoustics**: Ancient Indian treatises like the "Natyashastra" delved into the physics of sound and music, including musical scales and the properties of sound.
4. **Concepts of Space and Time**: Philosophers like Kanada and Nagarjuna explored abstract concepts of space and time, impacting both physics and metaphysics.
5. **Heat and Thermodynamics**: The concept of "tapas" (heat or energy) had significance in both physical and metaphysical contexts.
6. **Scientific Instruments**: Ancient India produced scientific instruments such as astrolabes and sundials for astronomical observations.
These contributions laid the groundwork for later scientific developments, particularly in astronomy, and enriched the understanding of the physical world.
V good hoodbhoy. Very informative lecture based on rational appeoach
In his introduction he laughed at Plastic&CosmeticSurgery and flying machines. Sushruta is the father of plastic surgery and his statue is at the entrance of royal college of Surgoens in Australia. His Islamic background is forcing him to underplay this.
The way he ignore much accept of Ancient India ........is quiet astonishing but not surprising!!!!
Like always, very enlightening Hoodbhoy 👍
It behooves on Pervez sir to do some research on Sushrutha who did cosmetic surgery of the nose.
His Muslim & Pakistani identity makes him suffer from an inferiority complex to Hindus & India..So, he has avoided India for most part of his life..that's why such ignorance & sometimes insult also towards Bharat
🇮🇳Student ask some questions about your video @the black hole
56:41 Ayurveda -if ayurved is nothing then why present day world used as full scale? My opinion -you are wrong.
1:03 If brahmins not shared knowledge then how Al-baruni learn Sanskrit? My opinion -you are wrong we have Gurukuls (Mandir)-they teach skills not religious in ancient time.
1:27 Culturally Baniya/Munshi calculation is great?My opinion-vedic mathematics, and world first university is Takshila (pakistan)this is the irony , pakistan not except knowledge.
1.27 Nalanda university -ancient indian teachers have good practice,they have written knowledge,so islamic ruin such thing to redraw new history like british and others,may be you praise gore....
1:37 if you praise Ivory Tower is good ,but what about Gurukul ? My opinion- Gurukul (Mandir) is open school, knowledge shared hub and its deep rooted in india . My opinion-99% pakistani are not known Ancient time mandir is not religious they shared knowledge to everyone included your old grand parents.
But your session is amazing,learn lots of knowledge and also i assumed if you represent online please correct and real statement.thank you. 🇮🇳 IndianStudent
even our stupid person in India will get good marks in Pak education system . 😂
You need to refresh your mind with Indian Science and Indian Mathematicians..?
Sir in the world of TH-cam, you should have taken reference from"project shivoham"TH-cam channel for Indian science....many more minor but interesting details you missed
@@AnandJoshi just like your comment
Please, make video with English subtitles 🙏
Aaryabhatta never said that earth is stationary and sun and moon revoles around him. Plz correct that statement
That is incorrect that there was an empty space after 1_ for 10....Take a look at how ten is written in roman numerals. That gives a good clue of what the issue was. It was written as X. 50 was written as C. Multiplications & divisions wasnt possible other than to count.
India has a long and rich tradition of philosophical thought, with numerous philosophers contributing to various schools of philosophy over the centuries. Here is a list of some notable Indian philosophers:Sankara (Adi Shankaracharya): An influential philosopher and theologian known for his work in Advaita Vedanta.Ramanuja: A philosopher and theologian known for his work in Vishishtadvaita Vedanta.Madhvacharya: Known for his work in Dvaita Vedanta, a dualistic interpretation of the Vedas.Gautama Buddha: The founder of Buddhism, whose teachings have had a profound impact on Indian philosophy.Mahavira: The founder of Jainism, known for his teachings on non-violence and asceticism.Charvaka: An ancient Indian materialist school of philosophy, known for its skepticism and emphasis on direct perception.Kapila: The founder of the Samkhya school of philosophy, which focuses on the duality of purusha (consciousness) and prakriti (matter).Patanjali: A sage who compiled the Yoga Sutras, an important text in the philosophy of yoga.Bhagavad Gita: While not a philosopher, the Bhagavad Gita is a key philosophical text in Indian thought, containing a dialogue between Krishna and Arjuna.Chanakya (Kautilya): An ancient Indian teacher, philosopher, and author of the Arthashastra, a treatise on statecraft and politics.Swami Vivekananda: A 19th-century Hindu monk known for his work on Vedanta and his role in introducing Indian philosophies to the Western world.Sri Aurobindo: A philosopher, poet, and yogi known for his spiritual teachings and the concept of integral yoga.Jiddu Krishnamurti: A 20th-century philosopher known for his emphasis on self-inquiry and the importance of freedom from conditioning.Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan: A philosopher and statesman who played a major role in interpreting and promoting Indian philosophy.
Guys don't blame him, he is still Pakistani.
Sir can you read wrong book about ariya Bhatt
Search Bakhshali Manuscript from Peshawar. It was start of Algebra.
Brahmagupta, Varahmihir are also distinguished scientists and mathamaticians,
Indian CEOs who lead major global companies. Here is a list of some notable Indian CEOs of big companies:Sundar Pichai - CEO of Alphabet Inc. (Google's parent company)Satya Nadella - CEO of Microsoft CorporationArvind Krishna - CEO of IBMShantanu Narayen - CEO of Adobe Inc.Rajeev Suri - Former CEO of Nokia (as of 2020, replaced by Pekka Lundmark)Ajay Banga - Executive Chairman of MastercardRajesh Gopinathan - Former CEO of Tata Consultancy Services (TCS)Indra Nooyi - Former CEO of PepsiCo (Nooyi stepped down in 2018)Laxman Narasimhan - CEO of Reckitt BenckiserVasant Narasimhan - CEO of Novartis
The kid asked question about Indians getting into it as leaders
Numerous Britishers and foreigners, especially from Europe came to India to research "Ved" and for that, they learned "Sanskrit". The language of gods...that language which the Greatest scientist JP Oppenheimer learned and made the first Atomic bomb after Guidance from "Bhagavad Gita" . I request you to learn Sanskrit and read ved in Shlok form to understand sanatan dharma
1st slide is itself wrong.
Pi irrational (root of a polynomial equation) nahin hain, pi transcendental (non-algebraic real number) hain.
I Love you pervez hoodhbai your style of lecture. Very informative and impartial
He is a learned professor and often relies on misguided books and research.
Here is a list of Indian Nobel Prize winners in the fields of science and medicine:C. V. Raman - Nobel Prize in Physics (1930): For his work on the scattering of light and for the discovery of the effect named after him, the Raman effect.Har Gobind Khorana - Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine (1968): For his interpretation of the genetic code and its function in protein synthesis. He shared the prize with Robert W. Holley and Marshall W. Nirenberg.Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar - Nobel Prize in Physics (1983): For his theoretical studies of the physical processes of importance to the structure and evolution of the stars. He shared the prize with William A. Fowler.Venkatraman Ramakrishnan - Nobel Prize in Chemistry (2009): For his studies of the structure and function of the ribosome. He shared the prize with Thomas A. Steitz and Ada E. Yonath.
Good that some scholar is trying to tell Indians' contribution to science. He is a good man. Sorry to say that in today's Pakistan there are less and less persons who will like his efforts. Still, this is great effort.
The professor was very afraid to say positive things about India in front of Pakistani students. His life would have been in danger if he was too positive about India's ancient knowledge of science and mathematics. Pakistani's hate India and the progress India has made since Independence and especially the rate of progress has accelerated under the leadership of PM Sri Narendra Modiji.
🇮🇳🕉️
Excellent lecture.
how to attend black hole sessions
Important analysis
I think I am the first Pakistani who is commenting on this video. Sir your channel is nothing less than a treasure to learn things.
Wrong and half baked knowledge lead you to gutter
And till now the only Paxtaani too. Still wondering what you were doing here? Maybe reached by accident.
Pakistani sirf tariq jameel ke videos dekhte hain..😊
Mr. Hoodbhoy it is also incorrect the claim that they didnt know earth was round. You can look at even Varaha's statues....look him up holding the earth. The statues were 200 to 700 AD.
In Iran they are successfully implementing the herbal medicines system alongwith the modern medical allopathy system. So far so that even modern physicians are also prescribing herbal medicines and it is also officially recognized by the Health Dept.
So one can not totally reject the Tibbe Unani or even Ayurveda Medicine System.
I believe that Chinese mathematician invented abacus for easy understanding.
How can you say Ayurveda is not based on science .... India mein mbbs jaisi padhai hoti hain ayurveda ke ..... Clinical trials hote hain ..... BAMS ke degree milti hain .... Doctors registered hote hain ..... I think you need to update yourself regarding Indian medicine
Taklif hoti hai en ko . Rehne do bro. They don't want to learn and admit.
If that's the case then their beloved unani is also not based on science.
@@harikrishnanr1971 unani originated in greece bro. Muslims show it as islamic achievement . though It has nothing to do with islamic 'civilisation'.
This so called muslim civilisation produced nothing in the name of science. Search. You will find nothing 😅.
@@harikrishnanr1971 unani is greek 😊☺️❤️🥰
@Rajib Shaw ha bhai .. Pakistan hai
Number of people Listening his lecture shows the interest of people of Pakistan about science
They don't want to learn science
Pls teach him zihad
47:35 He is completely wrong about Ayurveda.
I would venture to offer Indus valley civilization (which was primarily in present day Pakistan) and it's corresponding science was ahead of Chinese civilization. Please look into it Prof.Hoodbhoy.
Sir ji aap ba-kamaal ho. Aap app hi ho. Aapki place koi dusra Nahi le Sakta. Indian from London. Thanks sir ji and Allah Bless You
It appears that this man is India phobic. We understand where he is coming from. Good bless him. 🙏
Very nice lecture but astonished to see the number of attendees
This is why Pakistani never succeed in their life.....
53:51 Value of pi upto 31 digits, I learnt this in class 10th from Vedic Mathematics:
गोपीभाग्य मधुव्रातः श्रुंगशोदधि संधिगः |
खलजीवितखाताव गलहाला रसंधरः ||
gopeebhaagya maDhuvraathaH shruMgashodhaDhi saMDhigaH
Jise devnagari script na aaye wo English (latin script) dekh le.
Once do a simple Google then you'll get to know how to find value of pi upto 31 digits after decimal.
Aur professor sir bol rahe h, koi nhi bolta h k Aryabhatta ne zero diya also saying Aryabhatta used to say earth is static and he was astronomer too😂.
Bhoo-gol batana bhool gaye syd ya fir Islam ko science se connect krna nhi bhoole.
Students ko aadha knowledge kha jata h kafi baar
H G Rawlinson, in his book, 'Ancient and Medieval History of India', "The first Arab Muslims began settling in the towns on the Indian coast in the last part of the 7th century." They married Indian women and were treated with respect and allowed to propagate their faith.
They were traders also looters
Doc saab, Salman Rashid has written a fair bit about Al Beruni. He was drawn by knowledge he had heard about India (his learning of Sanskrit). Richard Dawkins once said Oxford University has more Noble laureates than whole of Islamic world. Doc saab Your effort, TBH, is incredible but I have differences with you. I admire you altogether.
Also ancient cities like Mohanjodaro required planning and scientific
construction methods
Hoobhoy does not know much about Ancient Hindu Mathematics, Science, Astronomy, Surgery, and Philosophy.
Aryabhatta calculated circumference of earth with an accuracy of +- 60 miles. Bahot hand waving kar dia Dr. Sahab ne. Indian achievements ko ye log man mahi sakte warna reality difficult ho jati hai inke liye. Confused kaum hai.
maybe you need to use your brain a bit more instead of being a troll. The oldest calculation of Earth circumference is from Eratosthenes, which is 500+ years older than Aryabhatta. Why tf should proff waste time on things that were not discovered by Hindus. He gave credit wherever it was really due
57:46 India ne science me kuchh nhi kiya 😂
here are some ancient Indian scientists and their specializations:
1. Baudhayan - Geometry and Mathematics
2. Aryabhatta - Astronomy and Mathematics
3. Brahmagupta - Mathematics and Astronomy
4. Bhaskaracharya (Bhaskara I) - Mathematics and Astronomy
5. Mahaviracharya - Mathematics and Jain Philosophy
6. Kanada - Philosophy and Atomic Theory
7. Varahamihira - Astronomy, Mathematics, and Astrology
8. Nagarjuna - Philosophy and Alchemy
9. Charaka - Ayurvedic Medicine
10. Atreya Rishi - Ayurvedic Medicine
11. Sushruta - Surgery and Medicine
12. Patanjali - Yoga and Philosophy
مارکٹنگ فنڈزاور تجربہ generateکرتی ہے فنڈز سائنس کو طاقت دیتے ہیں۔ تدریسی علم روشنی ہے۔ فیلڈ عمل کی دنیا ہے- جب عمل کو جب علم کی روشنی ملتی ہے تو دو آتشہ ہو جاتا ہے یونیورسٹی اور صنعت لازم ملزم ہیں مگر یونیورسٹی اگر تجارتی ادارہ بن جائے تو تو گویا روشنی کو کام کرنے سے روک دیا گیا
Hoodbouy is selling his version of science.
Take it with a kilo of salt.