In the last election, Uttar Pradesh voted based on religion; this time, it was caste. In the next election, it will likely revert to religion again. Uttar Pradesh has never prioritized development in its voting patterns, and it likely never will. This is why the state faces alarming infant and maternal mortality rates. The people of UP seem unable to look beyond caste-based and religion-based politics, preventing the state from addressing its critical developmental needs. Do suggest solutions in the comments, and tell me us how can we help? We need citizen journalists, local leaders, local businesses to join our team of MisFits
rural population of UP waited for "acche din" for 10 years and they got nothing except unemployment and inflation.They concluded that;s its better to protect immediate interest of reservation bcz there is no visible rural development!
sir ji mai UP se hu , apki knowledge and reseach bhoot limited hai UP politics ko lekr . IN the last election, Uttar Pradesh voted based on DISAPPOINTMENT , HOPE and FOR LAW AND ORDER ; this time, it was DISAPPOINTMENT , HOPE , AND UNEMPLOYMENT. In the next election, it will likely TO DISPPOINTMENT AND HOPE again. DEPENDS KON ACCHI STORY SUNATA HAI
You propagating his agenda only Samajwadi party give position to everyone such as 17 SC and 12 kurmis,rajbar,pal etc to represent their communities and work.And not only UP whole country cast vote on caste. General category votes for bjp and SC/ST votes mayawati shorens,Yadav votes samajwadi that's the truth.Your knowledge about UP is very less.Don't try to read it try to explore the UP because it very big state sir.If you wants to check the development then Do RTI and cross check the development sir. A mass of population of youth are looking for army vacancy from many year but government gives him a agniveer.And youth in uttar pradesh cast votes against agniveer.
I m from up muzaffarnagar and i remember the tenure of Akhilesh yadav they ruined this state in terms of robbery , gunda gardi chain snatching they always support mafias in state
How did the same BJP win in Bihar and lose in UP? Because despite Caste and despite Hindu Muslim, people have problems and voting preferences. To say that this time UP voted Caste and last time UP voted Religion is too reductive and very hurtful to that Rural Indian who went out to vote his mandate in the Middle of heat wave with no hope for Victory. People are not educated and they are not good English speakers. But they respect the Constitution and that is a fact.
@@app.lebyte Naah , he knows how to get more reach , that's all he's trying to do . Tbh dude knows nothing about the real India and their issues , here in Gurgaon Yadavs always vote for BJP. Alot of factors regional, national,personal dignity are involved. Making a statement that people only vote their caste is a fallacy.
In a constituency of bihar RK singh(former IAS officers) lost the election against a not even 10th pass candidate just because the candidate belonged to the caste of majority population of my constituency...
RK Singh was MP from Arra since 2014 ( Rajput majority area ) . How many projects RK Singh initiated in Arra being a cabinet minister ? NDA got 30+ seats in 2014 and 2019 , what they did for Bihar ? Did Modi gave special status and 1 Lakh crore rupees to Bihar which he promised earlier ? NDA is in power in Bihar from almost last 20 years . If anybody is responsible for Bihar's misery is NDA . BABU वो समय गया, जब सवर्ण बिहार की हर दिक्कत के लिए लालू जी को जिम्मेदार ठहरा देते थे और कोई उन्हें expose नहीं करता था ।
@@RishuYadav-vk5fu Yadav logon ka yahi to dikkat hai , khoon me hi kamina pan aur kaam chori bhara hua hai, loot paat aur gunda gardi k alawa mehnat ki roti khani aati to hai nai. Lalo ka gungan is liye hi karoge kyon ki tum yadav ho.
BJP called hindus sold out, hijdas and also made remarks such as hindus have a history of treating their king badly. Modi is not a king no matter he is biological or not he has got a red nose for being too arrogant and too divisive.
I disagree with you Sir on this....People of UP have not voted on Caste but just to remove BJP as they didn't get anything in the mean time so they just changed it.
Don't take UP (or any other Indian state) voters for granted, that one state had probably the worst MPs across whole of India who continued to perform pathetically bad and didn't raise any voice when agniveer scheme and farmers bill was introduced hope you know how much UP is dependent on gov jobs for employment which is shrinking like anything, then you have never ending series of paper leaks one after another, delayed gov recruitment on top of exploding unemployment and so many things. I know SP (or even congress) is not the party that can fix all these issues in next 5 years, but they had no other option.
@bindaasmard if government job is only option of employment for you. Then better you stay unemployed. Goverment can't spoon feed you. Upgrade your skills and get job. Stop barking on government for not creating opportunities in government sector. People like you just want to go in these jobs to do corruption. This is the utter truth. SP means Gunda Raj, this everyone knows. Yadav can't look beyond their caste and Muslim as usual are the problematic community, just want to grow in number to take freebies.
If UP voted on caste, why did BSP lose like this? UP wanted to change things, it had no good options. SP put up fewer muslim and yadav candidates this time. If it's all about religion and caste, why not this time religion and last time caste, even the Mandir was inaugurated months back.
Everytime I hear that BJP do a religion politics but I want to know how? Like UCC was everyone it's main agenda was for equal law for every individual no matter from which community you are, and this same law America and other European countries have...Second thing was CAA-NRC what's wrong in this act? This law Cleary stated that all the persecuted communities except Muslims of pakistan and bangladesh will be given citizenship of india.. so what's wrong in this? Did not they created bangladesh and pakistan for Muslims only? If Muslims are persecuted in bangladesh and pakistan then what was the reason for creation of pakistan and bangladesh? Ram mandir was case since 500 years...If you will see most of the yojnas of BJP gave more support to minorities then majority even development in defense, manufacturing, logistics, infrastructure was also at its best...
True. There are 22% Dalits in UP and BSP has less than 1% vote. All Dalit vote shifted to SP because of viral vedios of BJP leader barking about changing Constitution and Democracy. Manisha valmiki case also left huge psychological truama on Dalit community.
@@youtubersdub4339 bro can say for defence and infra but not for manufacturing. make in india failed to reach its targets, there has been a low job creation. in GDP terms upa (2004-2013) did a better job than nda (2014-2023) but around 1% every year. ucc is a good step but the pointers are too much like excluding Muslims from many factors, giving women special rights, that just defeats the perk of having ucc. every body is talking about ram mandir. i came through an article by the hindu about how many houses, temples and shops have been destroyed to form " ram path " just for tourists without giving them proper or mostly no compensation. then came though an article that there would be more destruction of homes in ayodhya for another path. and ya there was no news channel covering that. caa nrc is good shit
lol bro are u on weed or something the voteshare of bsp mainly comprising of lower caste simply switched to the party of chandra shekhar azaad.... what r u smoking its so clear up simply voted for caste lol
You are saying that there was no voting based on caste just because bsp didn't get dalit votes.. But the fact is that bsp only got dalit votes that's why it didn't win. Bsp didn't get other votes because it didn't contested well.. The whole election it was passive. No rally no roadshows nothing. This whole election was based on caste and one religion voting against the so called Hindu party..
@@nareshchoudhary1466 have you heard of bajarang dal, names associated with Lord Bajarang bali, do you know how much violence they have done, mob lynching, religious based hate slogan in front of state gov but no that's not Gunda Raaz, that's not Bhagwan ka apman
@@Shiva-05 brother ask your father gunda raj and much more dangerous before yogi. gunda kill people from pistol in roads and any where and people fear and no action taken by police
UP voted for caste(indi 40+/80) but Bihar voted for development(NDA 30/40), Bihar has higher IMR than UP. But you choose to make video on UP the same UP where in 2019 NDA won 60+ seats. In last 5 years there is hardly any change in population composition but in 2024 people of UP choose caste over their actual concerns. BJP made Ram Mandir in Ayodhya and they lost Ayodhya seat this year(unplanned demoltion and construction in the city created problem for people). BJP candidate from ETawah constituency winning for last 2 terms never seen in etawah except election time why people will vote for him. Your analysis is very far from reality.
He is a pseudo intellectual who loves BJP to its core and just does a drama of being neutral , the fact that PM asks people to vote in his name and forget the candidate is itself the biggest insult to th concept of Parliamentary Democracy, MPs MLAs of BJP started taking things for granted as they realised that just keep on harping Modi's name and keep on winning elections , they stopped connecting to the people and resolving their daily issues as they found a easy way of misguiding their voters in the name of religion
A simple google search will tell you that IMR is much lesser in Bihar compared to UP. In fact, IMR in Bihar is lesser than the national average. 2020 data says, it is 27 in Bihar and 38 in UP.
The people of this country had never stood with the growth and development of this country but then caste and religion is a primary mean for them to select their leaders.
@@joshkarunakar3752 He's talking about a perfect scenario where our only problem is nepotism and vote based on cast. That was the least of the problems this time around. The very fabric of democracy was under threat and fighting against that was the top priority.
@@joshkarunakar3752 but no, I don't feel like he's a bhakt... He's been vocal against the BJP on many occasions... He has his biases but that's just human.
Dear.. 1. You used the TERM "FREEDOM GIVEN TO YOU".. Are you not Indian.. 2. YOU DON'T USE THE WORD "GIVEN TO US" IT IS TAKEN FROM US.. And left.... I used the word ""LOTTED AND LEFT US""DON'T USE that word "GIVEN".. 3. Comming to the video. A. who used it well, ? The proudly said Democratic people of India....or The proudly said the Democratically elected by the people of India...
This year up voted for employment, paper leak and autocratic mindset, instead of religion and caste if they voted for caste they will not lose whole ayodhya mandal . They estimated the arbitrariness and autocrat mindset of current ruling government. I appreciate their efforts for making india a balanced democracy 👍
I am from UP and as a woman i still don't feel safe here at all ........ from past four five years i have seen my friends becoming more castiest and doing hindu muslim drama without any reason......and i have also witnessed the level of education dropping here day by day ...... before commenting on any state know the ground reality first !!! 😮💨 Issue of paper leak and agniveer was one of the reason for this bajrang dal and also those so called sanghi gooons ...and qlso hathras me to hadd ho gai seedha laash he jala di gai .......now neet scam 😂😂 talk about issues nobody wants nonsensical judgements 😂😂
Don't take me in wrong manner, but ma'am inha ka culture hi aisa hy, female foeticide main 20-30 lakh ladki sirf UP main mari hogi see sex ratio, honor killings of girls in intercaste marriage happening. So jo samaj ladkio ke sath aisa kr rhe hy unha girls kaise safe hy?!
You are right ...but see the hate comments in these section...thing is ye log sbko apne jaisa sochte h....khud propganda chalate h to normal rational voter ko bhi propaganda ka shikar samjh lete h
People don't have any choice as noone asks to vote them for development , environment, etc.... One will ask vote for religion Another for caste ... What the people should do...?
Everytime I hear that BJP do a religion politics but I want to know how? Like UCC was everyone it's main agenda was for equal law for every individual no matter from which community you are, and this same law America and other European countries have...Second thing was CAA-NRC what's wrong in this act? This law Cleary stated that all the persecuted communities except Muslims of pakistan and bangladesh will be given citizenship of india.. so what's wrong in this? Did not they created bangladesh and pakistan for Muslims only? If Muslims are persecuted in bangladesh and pakistan then what was the reason for creation of pakistan and bangladesh? Ram mandir was case since 500 years...If you will see most of the yojnas of BJP gave more support to minorities then majority even development in defense, manufacturing, logistics, infrastructure was also at its best...
I guess UP did not vote for Samajwadi party rather against Modi,not BJP. Sir you are on point . Up needs to move on from this caste,religion based. This brings nothings but darkness.
No one is Neutral, do not expect a human to be Unbiased ever. Also, My naive mind ones thought AI or Robots can be neutral but now I have seen Chat gpt spreading straight up lies.
@@Theabyss456 I understand that humor can be very subjective and sensitive, especially when it involves religious figures. It's important to be respectful towards all cultures and beliefs. If you'd like, I can share a light-hearted joke that doesn't involve any religious figures. How about this one? Why don't scientists trust atoms? Because they make up everything!
@@Theabyss456 Respecting cultural and religious sensitivities is important. Instead, here's a general, light-hearted joke: Why did the scarecrow win an award? Because he was outstanding in his field!
I don’t agree with BJP in most of the issues but Wanted it to gain a majority because 2nd generation reforms were required for economic growth. I understand that inequality is for sure a problem but our main focus should be poverty eradication which is possible only with high economic growth. But I don’t think a coalition government can deliver it. Kuznets curve theorises with growing economy inequality then stabilises and then decreases. I hope the opposition will be sensible and do a constructive criticism rather than opposing every move of the government.
Lol it's only possible with min wage law. One day India will become 50 trillion economy and still employees will get 10-15k salary. What's the use of increasing economy if ur employer will pay u only 10-15k. Not everyone can get Govn job or white collar job in India.
Do you literally think Opposition will bring sensible criticism... They will try their best to break NDA... I think coalition is even more dangerous than 400 paar
bro with the money power that bjp has I think even if they cant gain majority but can form a stable government, cant say that for upa/india alliance as the seat distrubution of upa is to volatile compared to nda
LOL Living in delusion? The growth chart began its upward trajectory with the liberalization policy in 1991. During the BJP's tenure, the benefits of rising economic growth were going to the BJP and a few allies, leaving the common people at a downward scale to rising unemployment.
This caste based voting pattern is detrimental for polity, economy and society.In the political discussions caste based ticket distribution is hot topic today...such a shame... Suggestions 1. As a responsible citizen we should vote for candidates not for party or some hero. 2. We should vote on issues such as job, employment opportunities, health infrastructure, school and higher education.
Right. People just vote on emotions and no logic. This becomes the weapon of choice for politicians. It's like the one with the spoon can stir the glass.
So religion based voting is progressive 🤧 in ur eyes Btw , the fact Yadavs , SCs despite being more than 30-40% in UP dont get proportionate repr is the sole reason which keeps caste politics alive When PM shamelessly uses words like Mutton , Mujra , spreads fake rumors on Manifesto of opposition is progressive according to u BJP too plays Caste politics , installing Dummy ST lady as Prez is also part of Caste politics where u rely on symbolism to carve out newer vote banks Why does PM keep on reminding that he is from Backward caste , and why Baniyas treat BJP as their party The fact is Indian society is caste ridden , Constitution just made it invisible in public lyf but in pvt spheres and sub consciously , it still remains as significant as before
Up people voted on caste the jatav,Dalits n jats , Thakur's gujjar,kayasthas,rajputs,kshtriyas,all tribals, chamar,patil,Patel,Punjabi,Brahmins,are the main castes they are all divided . @@pocketsfullofdynamite
Yes ofcourse We were expecting sanity from jahil people who once betrayed Mata Seeta Th3 poor and lower claas doesn't even know about the manifesto They only had those cards handed out by congress which promised 1 lakh rupees, govt jobs and all
Wait for one year. Will review this comment section with evidences. It will be a lesson for people of UP to chose candidate so blindly to uplift their caste based low living.
@@smith_manish caste based low living?! As if u would allow ur sister to marry to educated lower caste, every year honor killings happen in up, be it BJP be it others. People were always castist
I know that BJP is not a saint party but why Samajwadi party. Don't they remember what SP did to UP. Mafias as politicians , Increase in Crime rate and riots , Shooting on Kar sevaks
Mp from ayodhya is a dalit from samajwadi party... And he won their, what does it indicates sir... Total 4 yadav ( family ) mp contested election from samajwadi party and the rest of them were from dalit, minorities and they won ...
Although i am from UP and belong to Yadav Caste but i would not be baised here, Politics of UP is somewhere oriented towards castism but it was long before now things have been changing. Now youth wants jobs, people want peace as well as good infrastracture, education etc. The best example of it could be lost of bjp in UP. i would not say that UP is intirely castism free state, still some people vote for leader who belong to their own caste but as people are being educated, they are changing thier perspective.
Ohh you mean to say sapa n congress gonna give up job, school, clg hospital or any kinda development l, like seriously, have you count how many year they rule over up, but they just rule never done anything great, if they never gona buy island for themselves or gonna buy house in foreign country. Sapa n development are to opposite things n now when sapa with congress its ghee in fire
Best possible solution. Gov should break UP in atleast 3 parts, it will 1)Improve administration 2)better participation and poltical reach. 3)speed up development 4 )most imp, single state shouldnt have this much share in center. 5) it will reduce cast and religion impact in election, and atleast other will not suffer due to them ( ex whole west UP will suffer due to east UP, west is giving tax they deserve developmemt.... East is just sucking blood but deciding state's fate)
Also that easts is providing agro products, west got developed cuz it is closer to Delhi no other reason than that, in the same way if Punjab stop sending wheat and rice than west up won't be eating anything
Could you create a video discussing Pooja Khedkar's IAS case? It would be great if you could explain how UPSC ensures its integrity and fairness in its processes. how UPSC is not corrupt organization ?
Mp में इतना बड़ा व्यापमं घोटाला हुआ 50-60 लोग मारे गये इसके बाद भी Mp की जनता ने कोई आवाज नहीं उठाई मेरा up होता तो जनता सड़क पर आ जाती सर और तो और दुबारा BJP की ही सरकार बनाई आप लोगों ने में mp में job करता हूं 8 साल हो गये हैं में आए दिन देखता हूं कैसे sc, st, को suppress करके रखा है
Hello, respected Naman Shrivastava, I request you to make a podcast talking about your ideologies and rules through which you live as a human as well as a citizen. I think what people lack nowadays are leader with correct humanist ideology, not even Dhruv rathee is close to my principles. You are the closest yet. You would be one of the best Idol which resonates with me. I am turning 18 this year and I request you to guide this generation with your rational thinking.
People DID vote to save the constitution and not on caste line. Go and ask people why they voted. It was because of Agrarian and Rural distress, and because of decreasing constitutional values. Akhilesh Yadav has raised his party from 5 to 37 without media, without money, and without power. He is competent to run a political party. He is like YSR. Both of them have maintained their party by themselves after their father. They have proved their competence of politics, at least once. Caste is everywhere in India. Look at Bihar and Madhya Pradesh. The rural agrarian distress is not as sever in MP and no champaign in any other State revolved around protection of constitution. Caste was there last time as well but BJP won and Hindus were here this time as well but BJP lost. Give more credit to that Indian in poor rural UP for whom Ram Mandir matters less than the constitution. Go and see the villages. Talk to the SC dominated areas. People might not know how to read and they might not know BR Ambedkar but they believed that THEIR constitution given by THEIR leader BR Ambedkar ji was under threat. Hence they voted. What ground level workers of SP and Congress had to do here was just play clips of BJP MP candidates talking about Constitutional change to end secularism. Give the poor man his credit.
No, people in rural areas don't care about topics like Secularism, constitution. What worked was freebies and the narrative that their reservations will be taken, people didn't vote for some righteous goal like saving the constitution, they saw their immediate interests and voted
@@Theabyss456 Have you been to rural India? Have you talked to anyone from there? Not your Sar Panchs but the poor and destitute who makes up the Cesspool that is Rural India? Talk to them and you can understand that Secularism and Socialism are in fabric of our country.
@@divyanshusingh7124 yes, I have seen it, the reasons I gave above are not the only ones I acknowledge that, but I have not seen anyone say that they didn't vote Modi because he was going to change the constitution or He was going to end Secularism.
So from UP and not a bjp supporter tbh but cannot deny they did a great job in terms of saftey devlopment then other parties like Samajwadi did would hope people wake up and realise bjp is ofc not a saint but still much better for UP its literally there they are a family party tbh
Bhai tu shi h most of the videos me par aaj galat h, ground pe reality kuch aur youth ko job nhi, farmers ko price nhi, development ke naam pe demolition of houses of poor peoples wont they topple the govt, aur BJP ki seate aati to Tu li likhta up people voted for mandir insted of development....
Stop spreading biased narrative, around 5 of the family members did contest, which is way lesser than it was before.Akhilesh ji knows that giving tickets to family members is not the way to win and he changed his strategy to include members from different social and caste background which worked. It worked so well that BJP couldn't even hold its Ayodhya and there were so many grievances of constiteuency members not happy with local leaders
Naman, a hard truth, one can never bring a change in India without some extreme measures. No matter what how much you educate people, they will stand with their caste. I have seen multiple IAS and IPS promoting caste based polittics.
U.p is the worst state i have ever visited...they are really unaware of their situation...and they think we people from Kerala (or entire Southern part) are the ones who lives in the worst part of the country...i was really shocked by the life they are living... children working in shops,undeucated people following their own laws, unhygienic surroundings and many more...our kerala is a heaven in comparison to them...🙌
Those who feel bhagwant maan is an idiot are real fools ...bhagwant maan did not alied with congress in election ...he wanted Amritpal singh and khalsa from faridkot to win .... Never vote for AAP ......full on fireign funding.....i respect only 2 parties congress and bjp..... Because there is no better choice than them
Although your assessment of the current voting behaviour of the people of U.P. is correct to a large extent but it evades from offering a solution. That's something we as people need.
i agree UP voted for caste but whats wrong in this . if BJP can ask votes on religion then why cant they ask vote on caste . its always way better to vote for caste then on religion . its absolute that you cant leave your caste youve got be with it until death . and selectively on the basis of caste, discrimination happens in country . so whats wrong in it. baba sahab also was supporter of it. samjwadi party gave representation to all caste people . despite getting votes of all just MY they gave just 9 seats to MY out of 80 seats . akhilesh yadav did way more development in UP then BJP did in last 10 years . just look gdp stats to all infrastructure work they did during their tenure. i agree there was law and order problem but they workeed there level best to improve it.
In UP Brahmin and Thakur are the core vote bank of BJP and the main reason for their defeat in UP was this casteist factor which can be seen by looking at the cast of all 33 BJP MPs who have been elected this time, almost 50 Percent of them are Brahmin or Thakur
@@PRAKHAR-c1i उत्तर प्रदेश में बीजेपी ने जो 33 सीटें जीती है उसमें से 17 से अधिक सिर्फ ठाकुर - पंडीत है, यानी 60 प्रतिसत से अधिक, और यू.पी में हारने के बाद इन्होंने ठाकुर - पंडीत नाराज़ का " मुजरा" शुरू कर दिया 😂 ये दिखाता है कि बीजेपी सबसे बड़ी जातिवादी पार्टी है।
Being from UP I'm too ashamed that UP has lost its cause long back. There are thousand years of slave mentality. In majority Jaichands are still alive there.....
IN THIS election most of the youth of UP appose BJP policy Like-bafalo kse khet ki problem, agniveer ,PET, lekhpal, UPPCS, UPP, RO ARO, DELAY OF EXAM ,RAILWAY VACANCY, 4:26 SSC GD, TGT& TEACHER VACANCY SCAM, 8 Year se koi teachers vacancy na niklna Ye sab yuuth and farmer +Infletion in seeds, oil , food etc
Law and Order is a state subject, so what are people upset about ? MPs dont control law and order and even without SP rule UP has seen some of the worst rape cases. Hathras, Unnao, IIT BHU...? IIT BHU had BJP and RSS IT cell members involved. So crime in UP has always been there. Just because BJP has a state govt, media never reported it but since SP won Ayodhya media will try and report every possible crime.
Bjp is best for the poeple who aren't suicidial but sp will be best for people to divide kar n caste n create dangerous outcomes for dangas rapes happen everywhere but genocide happens only one time there are 1 millionregistered cases of rape in usa knew it is in census 😂😂😂 but India's are only registered from 1947 is 200000 approx .if a single danga can cause a huge genocide now in up which is a threat
Accepting truth is little difficult but this is true..the early we understand is good for a helthy sociaty.... every body know for which up known for...but we love our state that dosnt mean we always be blind..how many people feel safe and come to our state for work....do you ever think on it....
Sorry Naman but this is why can't poor people be rich argument. UP Bihar have their issues not just because of Politicians but because of the heavy caste oppression. If the development is only done for the few then it is just creating more caste dynamics. They vote for caste because that is the only way they can get any pennies for themselves. What is the use of building schools when kids from lower castes will be segregated. It's fuckedup over here. Between nothing and swabhiman, they choose swabhiman
Bhakts feel UP was low in gundaraj bjp & bhakto ka vin diesel yogi just cuz media wasn’t showing and they aren’t aware of,go and read some cases and numbers the way UP rose to gundaraj in yogis regime. Nywayz bhakts will b bhakts😂😂
Law and Order is a state subject, so what are people upset about ? MPs dont control law and order and even without SP rule UP has seen some of the worst rape cases. Hathras, Unnao, IIT BHU...? IIT BHU had BJP and RSS IT cell members involved. So crime in UP has always been there. Just because BJP has a state govt, media never reported it but since SP won Ayodhya media will try and report every possible crime.
Your criticism of the ruling party is valid. I want to change the situation of our country by creating employment but it will take lots of efforts and support. The people with power are corrupt who are supported by people because they don't think with their consciousness. I am afraid about what should be done to develop our country and the mentality of people supporting corrupt because I don't have the solution. I believe that for honest people, it will be very difficult to get into power and stay honest.
he is scared of bjp, as bjp is still is in power, as most of his videos sound like anti BJP, so with this video he is trying to play safe side. and giving his limited gyan here in this vid.
It's not true that all U.P has voted on caste based if this was the case then fethpur Sikri seat should be won by CONGRESS AND not by BJP and Rajveer Singh from Etah constituency (the father of Education minister of U.P) should not have loses his election. The youth of U.P voted against BJP because of high unemployment & for last 5 ys there is no major govt recruitment in department like basic education & police, & on top of it the saaga of paper leak,which govt first doesn't admitted & after huge protest only they cancelled the exam only bcoz of election was around the corner. So don't judge the U.P election only on caste based only.
Dear sir you are belong from MP i do job in MP for long time sir about two decades more in Mp exist BJP Government but sir castism is exist in extreme level now in 21th era sc, st and obc suppressed badly. Please give me answer Do MP’s people cast his vote to right party.
Up voted for caste, this is called a sensible and true anylsis, hatts off, I have seen almost all the liberal media and opposition is saying up has voted for employment, Constitution 😂
The thumbnail and picture itself shows your prejudice towards SP. Interestingly, you choose to emphasize the issues being faced by UP without any mention of those who are in government for last 10 yrs. Also, no mention of other states with similar issues and voted to BJP.
What about unemploymemt ? Reduced vaccancies in state public commission, paper leak , no vaccacy of teachers, stalled joining of lekhpal..youth is dissatified.
Some people want privilege of capitalism for themselves and curse of socialism for others. Capitalism -->unequal sharing of blessings Socialism -->equal sharing of miseries
Sir u right, But according to NCRB data of 2023 number of crimes against dalits has been increased in BJP government if u compare to overall data of country which is 28% that is highest to all other states. BJP government didn't do anything regarding job in state if they conduct any exam then their paper leak or either they were cancelled. BJP does the politics of separatists. People are with those who raise their voice let be take an example Chandrashekhar Azad from Nagina constituency of up. So u are not right in all way.
Sir Apka josh dekh ke achha lagaa I suggest it should reach every individual so for that can you add a little Hindi so that your message can reach out more.
Samajwaadi = parivaarwaadi. Exactly. Samaajwaadi won 37 seats in LOK SABHA. Yogiji is CM. (10 years) He should answer for HIGH ... IMR Up never voted for development. Thats why UP BIHAR MP are poorest states of country.
I feel ashamed off the fact in today's world of AI-driven generation our political leaders are still playing the caste and religion card. India will soon become Syria!
sir, we all know U.P. performed very low on socio-economic indicators. but the question is how to choose a good candidate? I mean every party has been indulged in caste or religion-based politics. U.P. had tried every possible alternative in terms of the ruling party. is it not too much to ask a hugely uneducated population to understand the true nature of participatory democracy?
UP VOTED against the hatred Against the unemployment against the inflation. Result UP CM today took a meeting to complete all the government requirement within the stipulated timeline. * No vacancy in the last six years in UP Though u can say anything sir but that’s the fact.
I am from Gorakhpur. My village is in Sant Kabir Nagar. After the win of SP candidate from Sant Kabir Nagar, Armed Robberies and burgalaries have again started after a long time after 2018 and every villagers there are now living in fear and have to guard their village home. People there voted for SP due to the following reasons - 1) Bad candidates of BJP 2) Caste. Muslims and Yadavs have got most houses under PM Awas yojana but haven't casted a single vote to BJP. 3) Inactive local cadre of BJP and due to which the Constitution will be removed falsehood worked. 4) 8500 per month wil be provided to women. They have distributed guarantee cards and BJP did nothing to counter these. Now people see that the same SP candidate supports and protect those who are committing burglaries and are regretting voting for SP.
Appreciate the knowledge. But almost sounded like the class was getting scolded by masterji! A lighter tone might make the bitter pill easier to swallow. Ofcourse commentators will comment, but you're not here to fight the unwilling but to engage the willing. Thank you and may you keep growing.
sir I agree with your research on samajvadi party. But BJP is also not very clean. They ignored unemployment, most of the people here in UP struggling for food and education on daily basis. Overall bjp sp congress all are same, no difference .
At first, I was a little pissed off due to Naman's brutal honest. Kudos to you Naman Sir for bringing a change int he narrative, be it through more emphasis on voting for the MP/MLA and what he means for our constituency, and for highlighting the brutal insanity of the high IMR rates of some of the states. It is disappointing and indeed shameful for us that the narrative still tends to revolve around either religion caste and hate, and not genuine markers such as employment, education, malnutrition, basic literacy, collective society and more. You are doing what the media doesn't do, and are changing the landscape of Indians. More power to you, Naman Sir!
Agree .....if you speak in hindi your voice will reach to millions of people ... If people like you (intellectual) counter the baseless statement,one sided motivated story by youtuber journalist ...it would be great impact.....its humble request
In the last election, Uttar Pradesh voted based on religion; this time, it was caste. In the next election, it will likely revert to religion again.
Uttar Pradesh has never prioritized development in its voting patterns, and it likely never will. This is why the state faces alarming infant and maternal mortality rates.
The people of UP seem unable to look beyond caste-based and religion-based politics, preventing the state from addressing its critical developmental needs. Do suggest solutions in the comments, and tell me us how can we help? We need citizen journalists, local leaders, local businesses to join our team of MisFits
Same for bihar also. Hindi states that's why at the bottom development.
rural population of UP waited for "acche din" for 10 years and they got nothing except unemployment and inflation.They concluded that;s its better to protect immediate interest of reservation bcz there is no visible rural development!
sir ji mai UP se hu , apki knowledge and reseach bhoot limited hai UP politics ko lekr . IN the last election, Uttar Pradesh voted based on DISAPPOINTMENT , HOPE and FOR LAW AND ORDER ; this time, it was DISAPPOINTMENT , HOPE , AND UNEMPLOYMENT. In the next election, it will likely TO DISPPOINTMENT AND HOPE again. DEPENDS KON ACCHI STORY SUNATA HAI
You propagating his agenda only Samajwadi party give position to everyone such as 17 SC and 12 kurmis,rajbar,pal etc to represent their communities and work.And not only UP whole country cast vote on caste. General category votes for bjp and SC/ST votes mayawati shorens,Yadav votes samajwadi that's the truth.Your knowledge about UP is very less.Don't try to read it try to explore the UP because it very big state sir.If you wants to check the development then Do RTI and cross check the development sir.
A mass of population of youth are looking for army vacancy from many year but government gives him a agniveer.And youth in uttar pradesh cast votes against agniveer.
Is it correct to say that you are milking islamophobic thumbnail to get clickbait. I really appreciate if such thumbnail is avoided.
I m from up muzaffarnagar and i remember the tenure of Akhilesh yadav they ruined this state in terms of robbery , gunda gardi chain snatching they always support mafias in state
Yogi government have low crime rate because Police don't even file FIR. They just force victims to compromise. You call this better?
Cm Yogi hi hai 2027 tak
But in muzaffarnagar thakur voted against BJP
Mai bhi Muzaffarnagar se hu ❤😢
अरे भाई गुंडागर्दी तो केसरगंज आयो bjp की सरकार है
How did the same BJP win in Bihar and lose in UP? Because despite Caste and despite Hindu Muslim, people have problems and voting preferences.
To say that this time UP voted Caste and last time UP voted Religion is too reductive and very hurtful to that Rural Indian who went out to vote his mandate in the Middle of heat wave with no hope for Victory. People are not educated and they are not good English speakers. But they respect the Constitution and that is a fact.
he is scared of bjp, as bjp is still is in power.
Coz this time RaGa gave guarantee of caste census ..tried his best to do caste divide. Also khata khat paise ki guarantee 😂
@@app.lebyte Naah , he knows how to get more reach , that's all he's trying to do .
Tbh dude knows nothing about the real India and their issues , here in Gurgaon Yadavs always vote for BJP.
Alot of factors regional, national,personal dignity are involved. Making a statement that people only vote their caste is a fallacy.
Bjp MPs didn't do on the ground that's they lost
Did you know congress just pranked up people do you know the full story if don't then go and see why up is lost then come here and cry
In a constituency of bihar RK singh(former IAS officers) lost the election against a not even 10th pass candidate just because the candidate belonged to the caste of majority population of my constituency...
Who?
Indian dont want development they want only jaatiwaad
Constituency - Arrah Bihar
RK Singh was MP from Arra since 2014 ( Rajput majority area ) .
How many projects RK Singh initiated in Arra being a cabinet minister ?
NDA got 30+ seats in 2014 and 2019 , what they did for Bihar ?
Did Modi gave special status and 1 Lakh crore rupees to Bihar which he promised earlier ?
NDA is in power in Bihar from almost last 20 years . If anybody is responsible for Bihar's misery is NDA .
BABU वो समय गया, जब सवर्ण बिहार की हर दिक्कत के लिए लालू जी को जिम्मेदार ठहरा देते थे और कोई उन्हें expose नहीं करता था ।
@@RishuYadav-vk5fu Yadav logon ka yahi to dikkat hai , khoon me hi kamina pan aur kaam chori bhara hua hai, loot paat aur gunda gardi k alawa mehnat ki roti khani aati to hai nai. Lalo ka gungan is liye hi karoge kyon ki tum yadav ho.
BJP is being offencive towards Hindus who voted against them ...
बोया पेड़ बबूल का तो आम कहां से होय
What did BJP even say against Hindus?
I wish it was true. BJP should learn constitution and democracy from Bengal's TMC
BJP called hindus sold out, hijdas and also made remarks such as hindus have a history of treating their king badly. Modi is not a king no matter he is biological or not he has got a red nose for being too arrogant and too divisive.
No it's not.. Infact if anything happens it'll come out to be more pro hinduvaadi
I disagree with you Sir on this....People of UP have not voted on Caste but just to remove BJP as they didn't get anything in the mean time so they just changed it.
Haha yadav for a reason.
@@loneWolfSourav That explains your mentality cause I'm not a Samajwadi Party or Congress Supporter....But a BJP Supporter😄
Enjoy danga from a certain community.
@@loneWolfSouravBjp's hindu crying 😭
Do not troll like this I'm pro hindu first then Yadav . @@loneWolfSourav
Don't take UP (or any other Indian state) voters for granted, that one state had probably the worst MPs across whole of India who continued to perform pathetically bad and didn't raise any voice when agniveer scheme and farmers bill was introduced hope you know how much UP is dependent on gov jobs for employment which is shrinking like anything, then you have never ending series of paper leaks one after another, delayed gov recruitment on top of exploding unemployment and so many things. I know SP (or even congress) is not the party that can fix all these issues in next 5 years, but they had no other option.
True brother
@bindaasmard if government job is only option of employment for you. Then better you stay unemployed. Goverment can't spoon feed you. Upgrade your skills and get job. Stop barking on government for not creating opportunities in government sector. People like you just want to go in these jobs to do corruption. This is the utter truth. SP means Gunda Raj, this everyone knows. Yadav can't look beyond their caste and Muslim as usual are the problematic community, just want to grow in number to take freebies.
What are you talking about, you want to say that if given chance UP will vote for some nirdaliya candidate
That doesn't make sense voting was pure caste based in up this time
In 2020, 5.97 lakhs applied for uppcs against 495 vacancies what do you think all will get government jobs???
UP said , " We miss Danga "
Law and order comes under up state govt and BJP is in Power
@@d.coder.bk1078if they can vote for caste in loksabha they will do the same in rajyasabha election as well
For your kind info rajya sabha election isn't direct election, people don't vote for members of rajya sabha directly.@@AWAKENHAYATO-ic1cw
I wonder inc. in mob lynching started in whose tenure, hmmmm?
@@Shiva-05 and what about Genocide?
If UP voted on caste, why did BSP lose like this?
UP wanted to change things, it had no good options. SP put up fewer muslim and yadav candidates this time.
If it's all about religion and caste, why not this time religion and last time caste, even the Mandir was inaugurated months back.
Everytime I hear that BJP do a religion politics but I want to know how? Like UCC was everyone it's main agenda was for equal law for every individual no matter from which community you are, and this same law America and other European countries have...Second thing was CAA-NRC what's wrong in this act? This law Cleary stated that all the persecuted communities except Muslims of pakistan and bangladesh will be given citizenship of india.. so what's wrong in this? Did not they created bangladesh and pakistan for Muslims only? If Muslims are persecuted in bangladesh and pakistan then what was the reason for creation of pakistan and bangladesh? Ram mandir was case since 500 years...If you will see most of the yojnas of BJP gave more support to minorities then majority even development in defense, manufacturing, logistics, infrastructure was also at its best...
True. There are 22% Dalits in UP and BSP has less than 1% vote. All Dalit vote shifted to SP because of viral vedios of BJP leader barking about changing Constitution and Democracy. Manisha valmiki case also left huge psychological truama on Dalit community.
@@youtubersdub4339 bro can say for defence and infra but not for manufacturing. make in india failed to reach its targets, there has been a low job creation. in GDP terms upa (2004-2013) did a better job than nda (2014-2023) but around 1% every year. ucc is a good step but the pointers are too much like excluding Muslims from many factors, giving women special rights, that just defeats the perk of having ucc. every body is talking about ram mandir. i came through an article by the hindu about how many houses, temples and shops have been destroyed to form " ram path " just for tourists without giving them proper or mostly no compensation. then came though an article that there would be more destruction of homes in ayodhya for another path. and ya there was no news channel covering that. caa nrc is good shit
lol bro are u on weed or something the voteshare of bsp mainly comprising of lower caste simply switched to the party of chandra shekhar azaad.... what r u smoking its so clear up simply voted for caste lol
You are saying that there was no voting based on caste just because bsp didn't get dalit votes.. But the fact is that bsp only got dalit votes that's why it didn't win.
Bsp didn't get other votes because it didn't contested well.. The whole election it was passive. No rally no roadshows nothing. This whole election was based on caste and one religion voting against the so called Hindu party..
Not sure about heading towards Afghanistan but,slowly it might return to its former state .
Yeah.... Gundaraj will be back... I think BJP was quiet successful in removing gundaraj bcoz of Yogi
nah i dont think so cause yogi would still be the cm of up
@@nareshchoudhary1466 have you heard of bajarang dal, names associated with Lord Bajarang bali, do you know how much violence they have done, mob lynching, religious based hate slogan in front of state gov but no that's not Gunda Raaz, that's not Bhagwan ka apman
Must be a khangress propoganda to create Hindu terror bcoz for secularism against jihadis @@Shiva-05
@@Shiva-05 brother ask your father gunda raj and much more dangerous before yogi. gunda kill people from pistol in roads and any where and people fear and no action taken by police
UP voted for caste(indi 40+/80) but Bihar voted for development(NDA 30/40), Bihar has higher IMR than UP. But you choose to make video on UP the same UP where in 2019 NDA won 60+ seats. In last 5 years there is hardly any change in population composition but in 2024 people of UP choose caste over their actual concerns. BJP made Ram Mandir in Ayodhya and they lost Ayodhya seat this year(unplanned demoltion and construction in the city created problem for people).
BJP candidate from ETawah constituency winning for last 2 terms never seen in etawah except election time why people will vote for him.
Your analysis is very far from reality.
💯💯💯
True
He is a pseudo intellectual who loves BJP to its core and just does a drama of being neutral , the fact that PM asks people to vote in his name and forget the candidate is itself the biggest insult to th concept of Parliamentary Democracy, MPs MLAs of BJP started taking things for granted as they realised that just keep on harping Modi's name and keep on winning elections , they stopped connecting to the people and resolving their daily issues as they found a easy way of misguiding their voters in the name of religion
@@ananb7747 he is scared of bjp, as bjp is still is in power.
A simple google search will tell you that IMR is much lesser in Bihar compared to UP. In fact, IMR in Bihar is lesser than the national average. 2020 data says, it is 27 in Bihar and 38 in UP.
The people of this country had never stood with the growth and development of this country but then caste and religion is a primary mean for them to select their leaders.
And then they migrate to Mumbai and dirty the streets and do gundagardi
And then they migrate to Mumbai and spoil the roads by you know what.
They mass migrate to Mumbai
Atleast South Indians stood for development some times 😂😂😂😂
UP voted against BJP, not for SP... I feel like...
Yes bro , this guy is a bhakt in disguise.
they voted out of fear to SP, by the fake narrative of Opposition of removal of reservation and so called Dictatorship.
@@joshkarunakar3752 He's talking about a perfect scenario where our only problem is nepotism and vote based on cast. That was the least of the problems this time around. The very fabric of democracy was under threat and fighting against that was the top priority.
@@joshkarunakar3752 but no, I don't feel like he's a bhakt... He's been vocal against the BJP on many occasions... He has his biases but that's just human.
Well said👍
Previously British used to divide in the name of caste and religion. Now(political leaders) ourselves are dividing in the name of caste and religion.
The difference is you could not vote the British out. Freedom has been given to you. Using it well was the point of the video.
Dear.. 1. You used the TERM "FREEDOM GIVEN TO YOU".. Are you not Indian..
2. YOU DON'T USE THE WORD "GIVEN TO US" IT IS TAKEN FROM US.. And left....
I used the word ""LOTTED AND LEFT US""DON'T USE that word "GIVEN"..
3. Comming to the video.
A. who used it well, ? The proudly said Democratic people of India....or The proudly said the Democratically elected by the people of India...
This year up voted for employment, paper leak and autocratic mindset, instead of religion and caste if they voted for caste they will not lose whole ayodhya mandal . They estimated the arbitrariness and autocrat mindset of current ruling government. I appreciate their efforts for making india a balanced democracy 👍
I am from UP and as a woman i still don't feel safe here at all ........ from past four five years i have seen my friends becoming more castiest and doing hindu muslim drama without any reason......and i have also witnessed the level of education dropping here day by day ...... before commenting on any state know the ground reality first !!! 😮💨 Issue of paper leak and agniveer was one of the reason for this bajrang dal and also those so called sanghi gooons ...and qlso hathras me to hadd ho gai seedha laash he jala di gai .......now neet scam 😂😂 talk about issues nobody wants nonsensical judgements 😂😂
Right
Don't take me in wrong manner, but ma'am inha ka culture hi aisa hy, female foeticide main 20-30 lakh ladki sirf UP main mari hogi see sex ratio, honor killings of girls in intercaste marriage happening. So jo samaj ladkio ke sath aisa kr rhe hy unha girls kaise safe hy?!
You are right ...but see the hate comments in these section...thing is ye log sbko apne jaisa sochte h....khud propganda chalate h to normal rational voter ko bhi propaganda ka shikar samjh lete h
Castesim???
Hindu - Muslim??
Have you ever seen number of hindu girls getting killed by muslims in whole India ?? Ye sab kese likh deti ho ?
@@Nirvana363 it's not our problem until it happens with our closed ones.
People don't have any choice as noone asks to vote them for development , environment, etc....
One will ask vote for religion
Another for caste ...
What the people should do...?
Development nhi Kari naa bjp ne up me isiliye toh haar gayi . Log bohot samjhdaar hain development ke naam pe hi vote dete hain bhai .
@@himanshujaiswal6261 wow bro what a Irony...
Everytime I hear that BJP do a religion politics but I want to know how? Like UCC was everyone it's main agenda was for equal law for every individual no matter from which community you are, and this same law America and other European countries have...Second thing was CAA-NRC what's wrong in this act? This law Cleary stated that all the persecuted communities except Muslims of pakistan and bangladesh will be given citizenship of india.. so what's wrong in this? Did not they created bangladesh and pakistan for Muslims only? If Muslims are persecuted in bangladesh and pakistan then what was the reason for creation of pakistan and bangladesh? Ram mandir was case since 500 years...If you will see most of the yojnas of BJP gave more support to minorities then majority even development in defense, manufacturing, logistics, infrastructure was also at its best...
Jo Ram ko laaye hain ham unko layenge, kapde dekh k pahchan lo, @@youtubersdub4339
@@himanshujaiswal6261 Agar log development pe vote karte to atal ji ki sarkaar kabhi girti hi nahi
UP People voted for change knowingly or Unknowingly... They may or may not get better life but atleast they gave slap to current BJP politics.
UP didn't vote for caste they voted against Agniveer. They voted against unemployment. They voted against people who use religion to win elections
I guess UP did not vote for Samajwadi party rather against Modi,not BJP. Sir you are on point . Up needs to move on from this caste,religion based. This brings nothings but darkness.
Exactly just like people never voted for Modi bt voted against Congress
Sir I think you are anti-BJP.Why are you not talking about other parties like Congress and DMK?Talk about West Bengal.Neutrality is very important
No one is Neutral, do not expect a human to be Unbiased ever. Also, My naive mind ones thought AI or Robots can be neutral but now I have seen Chat gpt spreading straight up lies.
chat gpt like how chat gpt can biased any questions that I can try
@@COCSensai you can ask Chat gpt to make a joke on Muhammad and then to make a joke on hanuman.
@@Theabyss456 I understand that humor can be very subjective and sensitive, especially when it involves religious figures. It's important to be respectful towards all cultures and beliefs. If you'd like, I can share a light-hearted joke that doesn't involve any religious figures. How about this one?
Why don't scientists trust atoms?
Because they make up everything!
@@Theabyss456 Respecting cultural and religious sensitivities is important. Instead, here's a general, light-hearted joke:
Why did the scarecrow win an award?
Because he was outstanding in his field!
UP saved India from Autocracy , be honest ,they clearly saw it coming and rejected it.Thank you UP.
U r very right, why not people see this.
Joker
I am from UP and voted for SP only because to remove BJP !!
@VishalGupta-xe2eu With or without reading their Manifesto?
And in akhilesh times there was democracy 😅😅😅😅
I don’t agree with BJP in most of the issues but Wanted it to gain a majority because 2nd generation reforms were required for economic growth. I understand that inequality is for sure a problem but our main focus should be poverty eradication which is possible only with high economic growth. But I don’t think a coalition government can deliver it. Kuznets curve theorises with growing economy inequality then stabilises and then decreases.
I hope the opposition will be sensible and do a constructive criticism rather than opposing every move of the government.
Lol it's only possible with min wage law. One day India will become 50 trillion economy and still employees will get 10-15k salary. What's the use of increasing economy if ur employer will pay u only 10-15k. Not everyone can get Govn job or white collar job in India.
Do you literally think Opposition will bring sensible criticism... They will try their best to break NDA... I think coalition is even more dangerous than 400 paar
bro with the money power that bjp has I think even if they cant gain majority but can form a stable government, cant say that for upa/india alliance as the seat distrubution of upa is to volatile compared to nda
Reform does not need Majority Governments. Look at Narshima Rao. What he did was as a minority leader.
LOL Living in delusion? The growth chart began its upward trajectory with the liberalization policy in 1991. During the BJP's tenure, the benefits of rising economic growth were going to the BJP and a few allies, leaving the common people at a downward scale to rising unemployment.
This caste based voting pattern is detrimental for polity, economy and society.In the political discussions caste based ticket distribution is hot topic today...such a shame...
Suggestions
1. As a responsible citizen we should vote for candidates not for party or some hero.
2. We should vote on issues such as job, employment opportunities, health infrastructure, school and higher education.
Right. People just vote on emotions and no logic. This becomes the weapon of choice for politicians. It's like the one with the spoon can stir the glass.
So religion based voting is progressive 🤧 in ur eyes
Btw , the fact Yadavs , SCs despite being more than 30-40% in UP dont get proportionate repr is the sole reason which keeps caste politics alive
When PM shamelessly uses words like Mutton , Mujra , spreads fake rumors on Manifesto of opposition is progressive according to u
BJP too plays Caste politics , installing Dummy ST lady as Prez is also part of Caste politics where u rely on symbolism to carve out newer vote banks
Why does PM keep on reminding that he is from Backward caste , and why Baniyas treat BJP as their party
The fact is Indian society is caste ridden , Constitution just made it invisible in public lyf but in pvt spheres and sub consciously , it still remains as significant as before
Again you inserted religion and caste in the discussion....this is the very issue we should refrain from as human and citizen of India
@@dhirajpandey2812 He said caste based voting is a shame...which is true to your reply.
Up people voted on caste the jatav,Dalits n jats , Thakur's gujjar,kayasthas,rajputs,kshtriyas,all tribals, chamar,patil,Patel,Punjabi,Brahmins,are the main castes they are all divided .
@@pocketsfullofdynamite
What about Madhya Pradesh? what did they vote based upon?
Development..
Making Clean cities like Indore🗿
Lmao development and cleanliness my ass, I've been there and I'm never going back to that shitty place
For giving 24*7 electricity in rural areas, and at time of Congress it was a privilege
Well we love Shivraj and Modi
I'm proud to vote for change
I voted for Congress in UP
Tu Aaj bahar mil
Party karenge🎉🎉🎉
@@Godson7278 bhai
.
chara 😂
phir apni mumy ka byah krwao akhilesh bhaiya se
@@Godson7278 lekin kya pike party karoge akhilesh ke mutra
@@supervideo3938 tu toh roj kotha p bhejta hai na
Abhi tak West Bengal Pakistan bann raha tha, aur UP me Ramrajya tha.. jaise hi seat hare UP me usko Afganisthan bol diya.. kya baat hai..
Up main jo intercaste marriage pe honor killings, aur female foeticide hoti hy, woh west Bengal main nhi hoti
Jao phir dekh ke aao West Bengal.
Yes ofcourse
We were expecting sanity from jahil people who once betrayed Mata Seeta
Th3 poor and lower claas doesn't even know about the manifesto
They only had those cards handed out by congress which promised 1 lakh rupees, govt jobs and all
Wait for one year. Will review this comment section with evidences.
It will be a lesson for people of UP to chose candidate so blindly to uplift their caste based low living.
@@smith_manish caste based low living?! As if u would allow ur sister to marry to educated lower caste, every year honor killings happen in up, be it BJP be it others. People were always castist
All dailt, lower caste, victim minorities should unite against of any injustice
All Brahmins, Baniya and Thakur should unite against any injustice
all dalits lower caste victim minorities and brahmins ,baniya thakur should form their own nations
Sometimes I also think this. Why are we living together @@hajmolakigoli
☪️ Ondom box don't used
@@muditsingh5628 tum ho jao unite....brahmin bhagao desh bachao
I know that BJP is not a saint party but why Samajwadi party.
Don't they remember what SP did to UP. Mafias as politicians , Increase in Crime rate and riots , Shooting on Kar sevaks
Mp from ayodhya is a dalit from samajwadi party...
And he won their, what does it indicates sir...
Total 4 yadav ( family ) mp contested election from samajwadi party and the rest of them were from dalit, minorities and they won ...
Right, there are only 5 yadav from 37 and rest of all other caste as like Dalits etc..
jeet ke kya karega UP ko kya USA bana dega
@@ulala9729usa nahi par danga hoga bohut yaha pe
Who cares man ? Up Bihar will always be the same no matter who's elected
जब अधूरा मंदिर बनाओगे तो रामजी पूरी सीटें क्यों देंगे।
Although i am from UP and belong to Yadav Caste but i would not be baised here, Politics of UP is somewhere oriented towards castism but it was long before now things have been changing. Now youth wants jobs, people want peace as well as good infrastracture, education etc. The best example of it could be lost of bjp in UP. i would not say that UP is intirely castism free state, still some people vote for leader who belong to their own caste but as people are being educated, they are changing thier perspective.
U can not start a start up in up if noida factor is out...but want jobs..but can not provide jobs
@@KillerEyes-vk4vycame to Lucknow once and do your state have any nodia vala factor , how much your state perform??
Ohh you mean to say sapa n congress gonna give up job, school, clg hospital or any kinda development l, like seriously, have you count how many year they rule over up, but they just rule never done anything great, if they never gona buy island for themselves or gonna buy house in foreign country. Sapa n development are to opposite things n now when sapa with congress its ghee in fire
Very good thought
What if upsc exam paper gets leak its not impossible anymore 😂😂😂😂
It will if sp comes at centre. Don't worry.
@@loserang2877Lol 😂
What are your views about amritpal winning? It's a serious issue.
Totally agree with Speaker. UP voted for Caste / Muslim Minority Interests this time.
Best possible solution.
Gov should break UP in atleast 3 parts, it will
1)Improve administration
2)better participation and poltical reach.
3)speed up development
4 )most imp, single state shouldnt have this much share in center.
5) it will reduce cast and religion impact in election, and atleast other will not suffer due to them ( ex whole west UP will suffer due to east UP, west is giving tax they deserve developmemt.... East is just sucking blood but deciding state's fate)
hmm
Also that easts is providing agro products, west got developed cuz it is closer to Delhi no other reason than that, in the same way if Punjab stop sending wheat and rice than west up won't be eating anything
@@faisalahmed3902 bro, we are in one country, when you have heard that stat stop sharing grown crop.
Could you create a video discussing Pooja Khedkar's IAS case? It would be great if you could explain how UPSC ensures its integrity and fairness in its processes.
how UPSC is not corrupt organization ?
Mp में इतना बड़ा व्यापमं घोटाला हुआ 50-60 लोग मारे गये इसके बाद भी Mp की जनता ने कोई आवाज नहीं उठाई मेरा up होता तो जनता सड़क पर आ जाती सर और तो और दुबारा BJP की ही सरकार बनाई आप लोगों ने
में mp में job करता हूं 8 साल हो गये हैं में आए दिन देखता हूं कैसे sc, st, को suppress करके रखा है
Sabse jyada jati pati UP me hota hai
MP lost it's spine,need surgical help.
Sabse jyada jaati bhed Bhai mp Maharashtra Mai hota hai@@rohitkushwaha1262
@@rohitkushwaha1262mp mortality rate of child is 50😂😂😂
Hello, respected Naman Shrivastava, I request you to make a podcast talking about your ideologies and rules through which you live as a human as well as a citizen.
I think what people lack nowadays are leader with correct humanist ideology, not even Dhruv rathee is close to my principles. You are the closest yet.
You would be one of the best Idol which resonates with me. I am turning 18 this year and I request you to guide this generation with your rational thinking.
People DID vote to save the constitution and not on caste line. Go and ask people why they voted. It was because of Agrarian and Rural distress, and because of decreasing constitutional values. Akhilesh Yadav has raised his party from 5 to 37 without media, without money, and without power. He is competent to run a political party. He is like YSR. Both of them have maintained their party by themselves after their father. They have proved their competence of politics, at least once.
Caste is everywhere in India. Look at Bihar and Madhya Pradesh. The rural agrarian distress is not as sever in MP and no champaign in any other State revolved around protection of constitution.
Caste was there last time as well but BJP won and Hindus were here this time as well but BJP lost. Give more credit to that Indian in poor rural UP for whom Ram Mandir matters less than the constitution.
Go and see the villages. Talk to the SC dominated areas. People might not know how to read and they might not know BR Ambedkar but they believed that THEIR constitution given by THEIR leader BR Ambedkar ji was under threat. Hence they voted. What ground level workers of SP and Congress had to do here was just play clips of BJP MP candidates talking about Constitutional change to end secularism.
Give the poor man his credit.
No, people in rural areas don't care about topics like Secularism, constitution. What worked was freebies and the narrative that their reservations will be taken, people didn't vote for some righteous goal like saving the constitution, they saw their immediate interests and voted
@@Theabyss456 Have you been to rural India? Have you talked to anyone from there? Not your Sar Panchs but the poor and destitute who makes up the Cesspool that is Rural India? Talk to them and you can understand that Secularism and Socialism are in fabric of our country.
@@Theabyss456 andhbakti main abhi bhi kami nahi aayi
@@0bajwa0 where did I say that I was a Bhakt?
@@divyanshusingh7124 yes, I have seen it, the reasons I gave above are not the only ones I acknowledge that, but I have not seen anyone say that they didn't vote Modi because he was going to change the constitution or He was going to end Secularism.
UP Voted for Nepotism, Casteism, Religion, Regionalism
UP is Missing the Gundaraaj of SP and BSP
Jaat k naam thakur bjp ko vote de pr woh jaatiwaad nhi.
Dogla theory
all people in comment section sying bjp mp candidates have no dark spots.
So from UP and not a bjp supporter tbh but cannot deny they did a great job in terms of saftey devlopment then other parties like Samajwadi did would hope people wake up and realise bjp is ofc not a saint but still much better for UP its literally there they are a family party tbh
Namanji, what's your viewpoint regarding Neet 2024 Scam?
Bhai tu shi h most of the videos me par aaj galat h, ground pe reality kuch aur youth ko job nhi, farmers ko price nhi, development ke naam pe demolition of houses of poor peoples wont they topple the govt, aur BJP ki seate aati to Tu li likhta up people voted for mandir insted of development....
Stop spreading biased narrative, around 5 of the family members did contest, which is way lesser than it was before.Akhilesh ji knows that giving tickets to family members is not the way to win and he changed his strategy to include members from different social and caste background which worked. It worked so well that BJP couldn't even hold its Ayodhya and there were so many grievances of constiteuency members not happy with local leaders
U can't expect unbiased review from casteist who prefer casteism for years now give lecture on castes.
Naman, a hard truth, one can never bring a change in India without some extreme measures. No matter what how much you educate people, they will stand with their caste. I have seen multiple IAS and IPS promoting caste based polittics.
Naman sir you are an inspiration. Keep inspiring and motivating us for a better future
U.p is the worst state i have ever visited...they are really unaware of their situation...and they think we people from Kerala (or entire Southern part) are the ones who lives in the worst part of the country...i was really shocked by the life they are living... children working in shops,undeucated people following their own laws, unhygienic surroundings and many more...our kerala is a heaven in comparison to them...🙌
What BJP did with people in Faizabad is just international crime. Destroying peoples homes would definitely cost them their hold
So as per your knowledge who should UP people's vote form development
Same bro same, same in khadoor sahib , punjab
Those who feel bhagwant maan is an idiot are real fools ...bhagwant maan did not alied with congress in election ...he wanted Amritpal singh and khalsa from faridkot to win .... Never vote for AAP ......full on fireign funding.....i respect only 2 parties congress and bjp..... Because there is no better choice than them
Although your assessment of the current voting behaviour of the people of U.P. is correct to a large extent but it evades from offering a solution. That's something we as people need.
I can go and on write a rap song on this.😂😂😂😂
Just make it , it will be appropriated.
i agree UP voted for caste but whats wrong in this . if BJP can ask votes on religion then why cant they ask vote on caste . its always way better to vote for caste then on religion . its absolute that you cant leave your caste youve got be with it until death . and selectively on the basis of caste, discrimination happens in country . so whats wrong in it. baba sahab also was supporter of it. samjwadi party gave representation to all caste people . despite getting votes of all just MY they gave just 9 seats to MY out of 80 seats . akhilesh yadav did way more development in UP then BJP did in last 10 years . just look gdp stats to all infrastructure work they did during their tenure. i agree there was law and order problem but they workeed there level best to improve it.
Stop giving financial aid to UP.
yah give to adani
I too am concerned with malnourishment healthcare.
Followed the recent discourse by R Rajan
Sir ab kya mid term election ho sak the hai kya kyu ki history reh h ki jb bhe collation government bani h vo giri h
Plz reply ❤
yes, very likely
In UP Brahmin and Thakur are the core vote bank of BJP and the main reason for their defeat in UP was this casteist factor which can be seen by looking at the cast of all 33 BJP MPs who have been elected this time, almost 50 Percent of them are Brahmin or Thakur
Lol 😆
@@PRAKHAR-c1i उत्तर प्रदेश में बीजेपी ने जो 33 सीटें जीती है उसमें से 17 से अधिक सिर्फ ठाकुर - पंडीत है, यानी 60 प्रतिसत से अधिक, और यू.पी में हारने के बाद इन्होंने ठाकुर - पंडीत नाराज़ का " मुजरा" शुरू कर दिया 😂
ये दिखाता है कि बीजेपी सबसे बड़ी जातिवादी पार्टी है।
Being from UP I'm too ashamed that UP has lost its cause long back. There are thousand years of slave mentality. In majority Jaichands are still alive there.....
IN THIS election most of the youth of UP appose BJP policy Like-bafalo kse khet ki problem, agniveer ,PET, lekhpal, UPPCS, UPP, RO ARO, DELAY OF EXAM ,RAILWAY VACANCY, 4:26 SSC GD, TGT& TEACHER VACANCY
SCAM, 8 Year se koi teachers vacancy na niklna
Ye sab yuuth and farmer +Infletion in seeds, oil , food etc
Law and Order is a state subject, so what are people upset about ? MPs dont control law and order and even without SP rule UP has seen some of the worst rape cases. Hathras, Unnao, IIT BHU...? IIT BHU had BJP and RSS IT cell members involved. So crime in UP has always been there. Just because BJP has a state govt, media never reported it but since SP won Ayodhya media will try and report every possible crime.
Bjp is best for the poeple who aren't suicidial but sp will be best for people to divide kar n caste n create dangerous outcomes for dangas rapes happen everywhere but genocide happens only one time there are 1 millionregistered cases of rape in usa knew it is in census 😂😂😂 but India's are only registered from 1947 is 200000 approx .if a single danga can cause a huge genocide now in up which is a threat
Accepting truth is little difficult but this is true..the early we understand is good for a helthy sociaty....
every body know for which up known for...but we love our state that dosnt mean we always be blind..how many people feel safe and come to our state for work....do you ever think on it....
Sir I'm from up and I know what amount violence and ineffective law and order situation we faced during SP rule
Sorry Naman but this is why can't poor people be rich argument. UP Bihar have their issues not just because of Politicians but because of the heavy caste oppression. If the development is only done for the few then it is just creating more caste dynamics. They vote for caste because that is the only way they can get any pennies for themselves. What is the use of building schools when kids from lower castes will be segregated. It's fuckedup over here. Between nothing and swabhiman, they choose swabhiman
Bhai ayodhya me 1400 ghar tute uspe koi nhi bolega hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai
Bhakts feel UP was low in gundaraj bjp & bhakto ka vin diesel yogi just cuz media wasn’t showing and they aren’t aware of,go and read some cases and numbers the way UP rose to gundaraj in yogis regime. Nywayz bhakts will b bhakts😂😂
Law and Order is a state subject, so what are people upset about ? MPs dont control law and order and even without SP rule UP has seen some of the worst rape cases. Hathras, Unnao, IIT BHU...? IIT BHU had BJP and RSS IT cell members involved. So crime in UP has always been there. Just because BJP has a state govt, media never reported it but since SP won Ayodhya media will try and report every possible crime.
@@satviksharma78see the schools system in mp they re one of the least illiterate state but somehow they got moderate selections in jee n neet
@@satviksharma78The mp adivasi samaj mai shaadi 13-15 saal Mai hi ho jaati hai
@@krishgaming9080
Beta gaming kar whatapp gyan mat pel.. 😂😂
Your criticism of the ruling party is valid. I want to change the situation of our country by creating employment but it will take lots of efforts and support.
The people with power are corrupt who are supported by people because they don't think with their consciousness.
I am afraid about what should be done to develop our country and the mentality of people supporting corrupt because I don't have the solution.
I believe that for honest people, it will be very difficult to get into power and stay honest.
I like how 😂 some comments calling him Andhbhakt and Some Anti-ABJP
he is scared of bjp, as bjp is still is in power, as most of his videos sound like anti BJP, so with this video he is trying to play safe side. and giving his limited gyan here in this vid.
@@app.lebyte lol no. He criticised bjp a lot. He even said that they are a useless party
It's not true that all U.P has voted on caste based if this was the case then fethpur Sikri seat should be won by CONGRESS AND not by BJP and Rajveer Singh from Etah constituency (the father of Education minister of U.P) should not have loses his election.
The youth of U.P voted against BJP because of high unemployment & for last 5 ys there is no major govt recruitment in department like basic education & police, & on top of it the saaga of paper leak,which govt first doesn't admitted & after huge protest only they cancelled the exam only bcoz of election was around the corner. So don't judge the U.P election only on caste based only.
"Hamare yaha asa he hota hai".
Sir ji kya option ha janta ke pass
Election ke liye kitna paisa chahiye u know that
Ache leader kase ayege
Good point ☝️ I never thought about this. Damn! You are smart.
Dear sir you are belong from MP i do job in MP for long time sir about two decades more in Mp exist BJP Government but sir castism is exist in extreme level now in 21th era sc, st and obc suppressed badly.
Please give me answer
Do MP’s people cast his vote to right party.
Up voted for caste, this is called a sensible and true anylsis, hatts off, I have seen almost all the liberal media and opposition is saying up has voted for employment, Constitution 😂
Tu bhi toh Jaat k naam p bjp m vote deta hai pandit
In 2020, the state of Madhya Pradesh, with 47 infant deaths per 1,000 live births, recorded the highest rural infant mortality rate in India
BJP is also the same 😂.
The thumbnail and picture itself shows your prejudice towards SP. Interestingly, you choose to emphasize the issues being faced by UP without any mention of those who are in government for last 10 yrs. Also, no mention of other states with similar issues and voted to BJP.
UP voted for Cast. Thats Fact.
Cast Won again. Shame on These Selfish people.
toh kya religion ke base pai vote daalein
@@0bajwa0 Development Naam suna hai?
Caste apni apni maange bhi hogi , bina maange development kaise hogi ?
@@SHANSHOW- caste se 70 saal mein development ho gyi?
What about unemploymemt ? Reduced vaccancies in state public commission, paper leak , no vaccacy of teachers, stalled joining of lekhpal..youth is dissatified.
Naman shame on you. Akhilesh did so much development that next government took credit and you are biased
That same world Bank has praises yogi adityanath for amazing development in last 6 years
Sir, if your team put captions in Hindi and other major languages it will reach lot many more people. Lot many people will be educated.❤
Some people want privilege of capitalism for themselves and curse of socialism for others.
Capitalism -->unequal sharing of blessings
Socialism -->equal sharing of miseries
I have seen AMBEDKAR'S interview video on BBC and I'm totally agree with him about democracy and political views in India.
Sir u right, But according to NCRB data of 2023 number of crimes against dalits has been increased in BJP government if u compare to overall data of country which is 28% that is highest to all other states. BJP government didn't do anything regarding job in state if they conduct any exam then their paper leak or either they were cancelled. BJP does the politics of separatists. People are with those who raise their voice let be take an example Chandrashekhar Azad from Nagina constituency of up. So u are not right in all way.
Sir Apka josh dekh ke achha lagaa I suggest it should reach every individual so for that can you add a little Hindi so that your message can reach out more.
Samajwaadi = parivaarwaadi.
Exactly.
Samaajwaadi won 37 seats in LOK SABHA.
Yogiji is CM. (10 years)
He should answer for HIGH ... IMR
Up never voted for development.
Thats why UP BIHAR MP are poorest states of country.
IMR figure is of 2011 , yogiji is since 2017
I feel ashamed off the fact in today's world of AI-driven generation our political leaders are still playing the caste and religion card. India will soon become Syria!
sir, we all know U.P. performed very low on socio-economic indicators. but the question is how to choose a good candidate?
I mean every party has been indulged in caste or religion-based politics. U.P. had tried every possible alternative in terms of the ruling party.
is it not too much to ask a hugely uneducated population to understand the true nature of participatory democracy?
Very intellectual analysis 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
UP VOTED
against the hatred
Against the unemployment
against the inflation.
Result
UP CM today took a meeting to complete all the government requirement within the stipulated timeline.
* No vacancy in the last six years in UP
Though u can say anything sir but that’s the fact.
Government jobs Dena impossible hai sabko I hope humlog apni soch badal ke aage badhe aur business me aur tech me carrier pursue kre 😊
Yadavs be like either dihadi majdoori or government job.....
@@G28399
your comment explaining your bigoted thinking..
username में यादव लिखा है तो कुछ भी बोल देता हूँ
अबे चल
@@mukuldevyadav1839he is right.
Casteism has dumbed down UP beyond repair. Intelligent people leave and make a life in other states.
Well they can’t keep voting for religion all the time
I am from Gorakhpur. My village is in Sant Kabir Nagar. After the win of SP candidate from Sant Kabir Nagar, Armed Robberies and burgalaries have again started after a long time after 2018 and every villagers there are now living in fear and have to guard their village home. People there voted for SP due to the following reasons -
1) Bad candidates of BJP
2) Caste. Muslims and Yadavs have got most houses under PM Awas yojana but haven't casted a single vote to BJP.
3) Inactive local cadre of BJP and due to which the Constitution will be removed falsehood worked.
4) 8500 per month wil be provided to women. They have distributed guarantee cards and BJP did nothing to counter these.
Now people see that the same SP candidate supports and protect those who are committing burglaries and are regretting voting for SP.
Appreciate the knowledge. But almost sounded like the class was getting scolded by masterji! A lighter tone might make the bitter pill easier to swallow. Ofcourse commentators will comment, but you're not here to fight the unwilling but to engage the willing. Thank you and may you keep growing.
sir I agree with your research on samajvadi party. But BJP is also not very clean. They ignored unemployment, most of the people here in UP struggling for food and education on daily basis.
Overall bjp sp congress all are same, no difference .
Justice for NEET Aspairants 2024
At first, I was a little pissed off due to Naman's brutal honest. Kudos to you Naman Sir for bringing a change int he narrative, be it through more emphasis on voting for the MP/MLA and what he means for our constituency, and for highlighting the brutal insanity of the high IMR rates of some of the states. It is disappointing and indeed shameful for us that the narrative still tends to revolve around either religion caste and hate, and not genuine markers such as employment, education, malnutrition, basic literacy, collective society and more. You are doing what the media doesn't do, and are changing the landscape of Indians.
More power to you, Naman Sir!
So much knowledge 🔥
Kaha pe
Video mai😂😂
Agree .....if you speak in hindi your voice will reach to millions of people ... If people like you (intellectual) counter the baseless statement,one sided motivated story by youtuber journalist ...it would be great impact.....its humble request