I don’t think people understand that this is literally a business. Pay into taxes and get no benefit from it is like saving money you can never cash out on but others can use. The citizens benefit from it. It’s literally modern day slavery but by choice.
What is concerning is the fact that you completely unaware of the past of your ancestors. Learn about the history of your people then you will overstand.
*The Government encourages it, Interestingly... to keep the Economy going, without these UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS, Hospitality, Construction or Agriculture Sectors, would collapse.*
As an Indian immigrant who works in the west, if people cannot appreciate the values of the society they immigrate to then they shouldn’t be allowed in. Coming to France and challenging French laws and culture is just ridiculous.
.26, 'here to fight for his rights' WTF! He entered the country illegally, ripped off someone's social security number and some how he is entitled to 'rights'?!
I was surprised by this. Seriously? He's going to proudly admit that here? It doesn't feel like stupidity as much as a rebellious attitude. I wouldn't trust this guy at all with anything after that statement. There is a country I might like to move to. They are rather strict in their immigration policies. If I did what this guy did there, it would be right for me to be removed. I'm glad they have those policies in place. Otherwise, the country I appreciate so much wouldn't be the same country. It wouldn't be run by the same values I appreciate. I don't know what others want of a country when they come in for what it is but also to break it. Perhaps once they've broken it, they'll move on to another "kind" place?
@@gabriel7120 If every nation starts paying for the sins of their ancestors there would be no nation left on this earth,no human beings would be left on this earth actually.And i actually think that colonialism brought much good ,yes countries inriched them selvs from the colonies but they also brought industrialization ,knowledge and technology and made less developed nations much more educated and developed...
Yeah just the way France laugh at the laws in African and rob them Of their resources, thank God the coup de ta that is going in some of these African nations. France should leveave African
@@gabriel7120 "France still have some colonies". "I'm on team Europe". Dude, you obviously aren't. And you're spreading misinformation here. Every "Territoire d'outre-mer" of France can vote for their independence, many already have. And the laws are nearly identical to France's mainland laws, by definition it's not a colony.
As an Asian skilled worker who immigrated to Germany, I agree with French government. If you want to move and live in Europe, you should respect its culture and the law. You want a better life, but you don't follow the law to keep the better life for others, that doesn't make sence.
@@fzakrzewski Was just offering help. One of us knows better English, one of us knows how to be a good immigrant...but what do you know... How to state the obvious? Good job bud here's your award 🖕
As someone who is interested in moving to France, I could never imagine entering the country illegally and then demanding rights and papers. The entitlement is insane.
Again, your naive insight reaffirms my argument: easy to show off your law abiding self righteousness when you are speaking from a privileged position. People usually do not feel desperate but become desperate due to unforeseen circumstances.
@@maneshipocrates2264 considering you lack my life experiences and insights, you can’t possibly understanding my argument. Your position of entitlement, in contrast to mine, leaves you incapable of suggesting I’m wrong…. See how ridiculous that is?
I have not compared myself with those trying to cross the Mediterranean with boats. And preach my self righteousness as the one who is obeying the law. Only one person did - and that is you! I am privileged and I know this. Will never ever abuse or demean people who are desperate to seek better life for themselves and their loved ones. The authorities must find ways to stop this. We are human and any desperate person can be pushed to do desperate things.@@LukeTaylorPhotography
As a skilled immigrant in France, I agree 100percent with French government. I was not a single day in illegal situation. People are openly abusing France's generosity.
France collects more than 500 billion dollars a year in colonial taxes from 14 African countries. That might be one reason why people don’t stay in their native country.
@@dustybuster78the entire GDP of that god forsaken continent doesn't exceed 500billiom a year yet France is somehow taxing them for all that money?? Man, you're just drinking the koolaid now
If You've been to France recently you'll understand why. France has always welcomed immigrants historically, but now the situation has gone out of control, parallel societies are already a reality. I'm a non-europpean immigrant myself here.😊
It´s not the same migration with western heritage that people that don´t want to assimilate. France have to decide to remain an European country with European Heritage or become a cultural balcanized country... the latter usually dont go well
I sympathize with people trying to build a better life. But many act so entitled. They will have to close the lid on this immigration insanity in the West and in the US.
France cannot talk about immigration without talking about its continued economic stranglehold over countries in Africa. The chickens have come home to roost and proping itself up by standing on those countries and retarding their individual growth and economic independence has turned out to be a very bad idea.
@@Maximiliano896 sub saharan countries are poor regardless of if they were a colony of France or not. France is used as a scapegoat to avoid self accountability. The reality is France wastes money there with development aid and military aid.
@@Maximiliano896 okay. But many other countries are doing the same, so why does France only have to pay? This makes me think that people are just using history to justify illegal immigration. Don't get me wrong, what france did was horrible, but we can't scapegoat it for every problem just because it has accepted some immigrants, while other countries who have done the same didn't.
And quick. It's already heating up and this isn't going away. Nothing better to increase wages for the real locals by kicking out several 100k illegals, and esp the criminal ones. I bet it has a good effect on housing availability also. Its insane to think that mass immigration doesn't exacerbate wage and housing pressure. The left completely and utterly failed. Shame on all leftist parties who let this happen. Shame on you.
They'll be deterred if France is serious about deportation. Illegals are always going on about "xenophobia" and their "rights," but never about their responsibilities, like entering legally.
@@Rnankn France has no problem with International tourism, only welfare grifters that arrive off boats having paid zero taxes and then expecting to be clothed, fed, housed, educated, given access to jobs conforming to their skills and then access to subsidised healthcare. Why should a native French citizen lose access to their pension and social services just because foreign pirates show up demanding state resources without having contributed anything?
@@Rnankn Really? You'd feel differently if several people decided to "exist" in your home without your permission and without paying for food, rent, upkeep, etc. 😆
It’s great that u can rock up illegally into a country and protest against the laws of the land 😂 it should be illegal for any foreigner to protest in a country they’re not even a citizen of. Absolute madness
Funny, I said yesterday, that the cops should be snapping photos and running background checks to see who is actually a newly landed/illegal immigrant and deport them. I'm not saying you can't protest but that right is earned. I also feel any sense of complaining is instant deportation. It's a lot cheaper to fund one-way tickets than trying to integrate/support illegals.
I believe in France you can absolutely be arrested and deported for protesting, that’s only for the French! They love their protests and the leaders listen but they’re not going to listen to outsiders they’re pretty stubborn and proud
I'm Nigerian. It's a pretty ridiculous notion that a country can't expel illegal immigrants who commit crimes - so France suffers for the crime, and also has to bear costs of imprisonment? At the same time, African countries need to take steps to squeeze the neck of countries like France with respect to the unfathomably cheap raw materials/resources they now receive and expel their presence from their countries. For me, that's a perfect and fair state of affairs.
@@norbertfontaine8524 do you think France extracts raw materials from its former colonies at the competitive market price? Maybe a good example for you is the fact that France still forces it's former colonies to pay colonial taxes. If that isn't France exploiting it's once African colonies, I don't know what is.
@@ras3054 My husband is a so-called 3rd country passport holder, and had to apply legally to enter my country (Denmark) - and pay .. a lot of money. We're married, I'm a Danish citizen, yet he still doesn't get any rights, neither of us are able to receive any benefits, he has to learn the language and live up to certain rules. If everyone just entered and demanded things based on it being difficult to enter .. the countries would crumble. Your argument has zero logic.
@@thisisditte737 You can make your point without misrepresenting what I wrote here. I don't remember saying that people should demand benefits based on it been difficult to enter. My point is that some passport holders from certain countries are not able to enter "like the rest of us" because different rules applies to different passports... That is my point..
Exactly! I am fed up with that disrespect and blames of “colonialism” or whatever else what happened 100 years ago.. Europe must remain European in values! If they don’t like it here they must go! Congratulations France for taking it right finally!
Listen carefully...The French have had enough...Enough of the vast majority of Arabo-immigrants and Afro-immigrants who do not wish to integrate... If they are all fully embracing the French way, look how they behave while demonstrating...the makak dances etc.
@@risottoyagami4151 as if before colonialism they had a peaceful democratic utopia. Tribes and ethnic groups have been at war long before European colonialism. The infrastructure in many of these countries comes from Europe. Do you think Morocco's high speed rail(TGV) would exist without the French?
given the scope of the problem in france which is worse then the UK not enough are going to england or other places.....Sweden and France are in the most dire straights Belgium is pretty bad to@@thepatriot4076
"Experts have been telling me that these changes in the law have had practically no impact on the number of (illegal) immigrants per year. Most of those coming to France are looking for a better life and will not be deterred by tougher immigration rules." The mass number of protest say otherwise. France has the right and responsibility to its citizens to protect its boarders and should use every means necessary to curb illegal immigration. If there was a mass influx of French people illegally entering and working in Morocco we would all find that a bit strange and concerning and would correctly say that Morocco should be able to run its country and immigration the way it wants to. But when the French people say it's a bit strange and concerning that a bunch of people illegally entering and working in France they are now somehow labeled as racist.
@@geoffoakland , just to make me clear, where would those walls be? On the border with Belgium, Germany, Switzerland, Italy, Spain? Or maybe around the city of Paris (as if France cares about anything out of Paris)?
If "immigrants" dont like it in a country they illegally entered, then they should probably never have come in the first place. The entitlement is unreal.
I agree with France on these immigrations laws, as long is being done fairly and with no race discrimination, i do support these laws across all Europe. Africans need to stay in Africa and develop the continent, without the intervention of Europe countries, which most of the time they do more harmful than help! Thats the answer
Our national security is more important than rights of asylum seekers.. we helped them and all we got is crime and disrespect.. wish them luck in their home countries! You don’t like it here? GO!
Every country in Europe should pass a law like this if not more stricter. Also check if student visa immigrants are studying or not. If they are failing deport them
As a immigrant I stand with France. Europe should increase the threshold of toughness. Its alarming. You should not give easy access to illegal. And these illegal do not respect the diversity
I find it horrible that newcomers to the country want their cake and eat it while local citizens get neither. But to call local citizens racist because they complain about the nonsense of mass migration and the environmental impact of mass migration.
Immigration for me isn’t the issue…it’s immigration from countries where the culture is completely Opposite of Europeans and they bring with them cultural behaviours that are not compatible in western democracies.
From my little direct knowledge it seems like the bill would actually help France more than it'd hurt it. So the protesters might be right. But being an undocumented person in a country and then protesting trying to change the country to suite you isn't a recipe for success or to make the French people sympathetic to your cause haha. They sound about as entitled as actual French citizens haha
Maybe when the government can make an immigration policy that abides by international law like the right wing government in Italy has and what France is planning. So have you ever asked yourself why it is YOU are expected to give rights up to stop immigrants?
It always surprises me when people don't understand illegally entering the country and illegally working in the country is illegal. And of someone who isn't a citizen of your country commits a crime why should the government have the option of deporting them. Citizenship exsists for a reason
Europe has more than enough workers but they need paying. The government and business owners want very cheap labour. So they can profit while goings are good. It is all about money money money for the investigator's.
Yes absolutely ! How about respecting actual human rights and paying workers properly instead of paying cheap labour from abroad, when foreigners could contribute to developing their own country ! (Of course without any Western intervention)
agree,. its been 7 years now that i am still here in europe. this is your home, for me its my second home. you have to protect it, as for me im just a worker here but i dont complain. whenever your gov. want me out i'll accept it. i will forever cherish the moment i stayed here even though i had some bad experience but i take it as a challenge to work more for my family. thanks to you dear europeans for hiring me. now i had my jeepney painted with "sweat in europe". i'll be sitting down infront my karaoke and singing "final count down".. europe had kept as alive,,,thanks...
Do what the majority of the French population ask, or elect better politicians. they are in the parliament to do what the people demand. Back in the days they used the guillotine if they misbehaved.
Coming illegally to Europe and asking for rights and criticizing the government...doing protests about it? What ? What happened to the world ? France should accelerate the adoption of this law and more !
some people from African nations tend to attribute their country's challenges to European influences. In contrast, I've observed that Asians typically focus on enhancing their own countries rather than placing blame on nations like the UK or the USA.
And I'd also like to add that colonization was also present (Japanese in China, and Korea as well), but that didn't prevent those countries from developing after WWII. So ....
@@thesaviorvsevilqueen1218 I didn't realize that colonization in China was so intense that the Chinese now speak Japanese and were forced to adopt their economic systems too.
If every person from poor countries what to move to EU for better life , our life in EU will be not worth living, Statistically speaking it’s recipe for disaster look at Germany 😢
Without fail. Always on the side of the other. I especially love when they present a non-German reporter talking about why it's bad that Germans want to retain some semblance of their traditional culture.
If all people from Africa, Middle East and Central Asia migrates to Europe, where Europeans have to go? Too many people. Everyone should stay home and build their countries..
Non-European legal immigration must be limited to minimal levels, otherwise the continent will decay into oblivion. One simply has to look at what happens to areas in Sweden with high numbers of foreigners. If you scale that continent-wide, the problems will be the same.
I feel for the European countries, They’re not America (forced melting pot) they actually have a common shared culture with values and customs and the immigration is disrupting that! Absolutely not fair for these white countries when white people are the minority
@@christineopiyo7769 Europeans created the greatest nations on Earth. Why didn't the aboriginals do anything with the land or use the resources? They had thousands of years. I would actually say the citizens now have it better than if colonization never happened. Would these same people want to to live in, say, Central Africa instead?
@@kenake8465 so you're saying it was ok for White European settlers to colonize indigenous Australians, Africans and native Americans take their land and wealth change their cultures and language and it is not ok for others ethnicities to come to Europe? What nonsense is this? Help me understand this double standards where some people are entitled and others aren't 🙄🤔. All these native populations were very much ok with their cultures, today as we speak the indigenous Australians were almost wiped out through genocide by the settlers I'm glad they still exist though sadly in minority and practice their culture and art!!
A country has a right to choose the people it allows inside their country. Countries facing internal trouble are responsible for their citizens, just exporting them does not make them France or hosting countries problem. Lawmakers are just playing politics and ruining it for all legal citizens.
écouter, France is not a country, it is one of the member states of the EU, they signed away their rights to chose who they allow into their states when they became signitories to the Schengen Area.
They want to choose the job. They want to illegally enter someone else's country and choose their job. Well if that is what he wants maybe it's better for him to stay in his country of origin. Choosing a job involves leaving a job that involves not having a job. So someone who has broken the law to illegally enter France wants to be unemployed for even a short time it would seem he would have motive to break the law again thru theft or fraud because he feels he is owed. Owed the right to illegal entry owed the right to be unemployed this seems to be odds with what the interests of the French people are.
French now just eat what you have planted, and these ilegal immigrants have actually good points. My nephew is receiving money, here in Portugal, every month from the French social security without doing nothing, he just goes in the summer doing this extra work for 2 months in the farms and now he receives free money, well...good for him because im his uncle but we all know that doesnt make sense at all, obviously French tax payers are paying someone for doing nothing, and he works in Portugal so he has this extra free money....sweet
Illegally present in France Committing identity fraud Openly protesting law that cracks down on above violations.. wow France should give him two options - Mali or Rwanda (ala UK)
Why Europe is not taking these Immigrants seriously, they dont have an idea with whom they are dealing with, with what sort of Ideological people they are dealing with.
Most European countries are overwhelmed by mass migration from foreign countries. Therefore, the issue of rejecting the entry of immigrants to any one particular European country must not be compromised.
Illegal immigrants shouldn't have come in the first place. Let's bring common sense back to the table, please. And immigrants should also know and respect the culture of the nation they're living in. If you disagree, off you go.
Why can't skilled workers be home-grown, and trained. I have NEVER understood the premise that they have to be imported !!!!!!! Provide the opportunities damn it !!!
Mr Mackrel appearing to be doing something whilst doing nothing, trying desperately to deny Marine and the Rassemblement National, the only hope that France has.
Illegal immigrants "fighting for their right" to stay in a country illegally sounds almost like a bad joke
My thoughts exactly
Everything macron does is a bad joke
sounds like col***m.
I don’t think people understand that this is literally a business. Pay into taxes and get no benefit from it is like saving money you can never cash out on but others can use. The citizens benefit from it. It’s literally modern day slavery but by choice.
It sounds like 'zionism'. ...😅
The fact than illegal immigrants are open, on camera, everyone knows who they are, and yet nothing is being done, is incredibly concerning.
What is concerning is the fact that you completely unaware of the past of your ancestors.
Learn about the history of your people then you will overstand.
@@badoundiaye5624 If your mind is stuck in the past you can stay there. There rest of us a concerned about the present and the future.
@@badoundiaye5624what a bad argument
If they really pay taxes without even using state services, they are not causing a problem, on the contrary!
@@IceQueenaliasIQhow is someone taking up limited housing and taking a job from a local not bad?
He is committing fraud using false documents and he wants a reward ?
And France illegally mining’s companies
in African and they expect to be respected ..?
*The Government encourages it, Interestingly... to keep the Economy going, without these UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS, Hospitality, Construction or Agriculture Sectors, would collapse.*
Yup
Think of this way too, someone is letting him use their details and earn benefits for free.
That is why he wants a chance to work legally
As an Indian immigrant who works in the west, if people cannot appreciate the values of the society they immigrate to then they shouldn’t be allowed in. Coming to France and challenging French laws and culture is just ridiculous.
The United States and its “British puppet” betrayed France on the AUKUS project. India is trustworthy.
ok bot
@@Saucisse_Praxis if you don’t like what you read you call that bot How convenient
.26, 'here to fight for his rights' WTF! He entered the country illegally, ripped off someone's social security number and some how he is entitled to 'rights'?!
He worked 2 days straight as dishwasher, istnt it a huge merit? 😂
I was surprised by this. Seriously? He's going to proudly admit that here? It doesn't feel like stupidity as much as a rebellious attitude. I wouldn't trust this guy at all with anything after that statement.
There is a country I might like to move to. They are rather strict in their immigration policies. If I did what this guy did there, it would be right for me to be removed. I'm glad they have those policies in place. Otherwise, the country I appreciate so much wouldn't be the same country. It wouldn't be run by the same values I appreciate. I don't know what others want of a country when they come in for what it is but also to break it. Perhaps once they've broken it, they'll move on to another "kind" place?
@@gabriel7120 If every nation starts paying for the sins of their ancestors there would be no nation left on this earth,no human beings would be left on this earth actually.And i actually think that colonialism brought much good ,yes countries inriched them selvs from the colonies but they also brought industrialization ,knowledge and technology and made less developed nations much more educated and developed...
Yeah just the way France laugh at the laws in African and rob them
Of their resources, thank God the coup de ta that is going in some of these African nations. France should leveave African
@@gabriel7120
"France still have some colonies".
"I'm on team Europe".
Dude, you obviously aren't.
And you're spreading misinformation here.
Every "Territoire d'outre-mer" of France can vote for their independence, many already have.
And the laws are nearly identical to France's mainland laws, by definition it's not a colony.
As an Asian skilled worker who immigrated to Germany, I agree with French government. If you want to move and live in Europe, you should respect its culture and the law. You want a better life, but you don't follow the law to keep the better life for others, that doesn't make sence.
Sense*
@@AFROJOE2323 cool, you know better english, while he still knows how to be a respected immigrant 😆
Amen 🫡
Glory to u
@@fzakrzewski Was just offering help. One of us knows better English, one of us knows how to be a good immigrant...but what do you know... How to state the obvious?
Good job bud here's your award 🖕
As someone who is interested in moving to France, I could never imagine entering the country illegally and then demanding rights and papers. The entitlement is insane.
Because of your entitlements, you can never be that desperate. Stop comparing your status with that of very desperate people.
Let’s allow everyone who feels ‘desperate’ to break the law… Let’s see how that works out.
Again, your naive insight reaffirms my argument: easy to show off your law abiding self righteousness when you are speaking from a privileged position. People usually do not feel desperate but become desperate due to unforeseen circumstances.
@@maneshipocrates2264 considering you lack my life experiences and insights, you can’t possibly understanding my argument. Your position of entitlement, in contrast to mine, leaves you incapable of suggesting I’m wrong…. See how ridiculous that is?
I have not compared myself with those trying to cross the Mediterranean with boats. And preach my self righteousness as the one who is obeying the law. Only one person did - and that is you! I am privileged and I know this. Will never ever abuse or demean people who are desperate to seek better life for themselves and their loved ones. The authorities must find ways to stop this. We are human and any desperate person can be pushed to do desperate things.@@LukeTaylorPhotography
As a skilled immigrant in France, I agree 100percent with French government. I was not a single day in illegal situation. People are openly abusing France's generosity.
France collects more than 500 billion dollars a year in colonial taxes from 14 African countries. That might be one reason why people don’t stay in their native country.
@@dustybuster78 Don't lie. PLEASE.
@@dustybuster78 where'd you get that number??? 😂
@@dustybuster78 France does not have any colonies
@@dustybuster78the entire GDP of that god forsaken continent doesn't exceed 500billiom a year yet France is somehow taxing them for all that money?? Man, you're just drinking the koolaid now
If You've been to France recently you'll understand why. France has always welcomed immigrants historically, but now the situation has gone out of control, parallel societies are already a reality. I'm a non-europpean immigrant myself here.😊
Get out !
@@jorgeomarjaimesviafara6061Tell your govt. to do that first! Currently seems that your govt. don't want it.
Not just recently.
I saw it long time ago like 12 years ago and I know it’s not going to be good in all of the Europe.
It´s not the same migration with western heritage that people that don´t want to assimilate. France have to decide to remain an European country with European Heritage or become a cultural balcanized country... the latter usually dont go well
I sympathize with people trying to build a better life. But many act so entitled. They will have to close the lid on this immigration insanity in the West and in the US.
France cannot talk about immigration without talking about its continued economic stranglehold over countries in Africa. The chickens have come home to roost and proping itself up by standing on those countries and retarding their individual growth and economic independence has turned out to be a very bad idea.
@@Maximiliano896 sub saharan countries are poor regardless of if they were a colony of France or not. France is used as a scapegoat to avoid self accountability. The reality is France wastes money there with development aid and military aid.
@@Maximiliano896 okay. But many other countries are doing the same, so why does France only have to pay? This makes me think that people are just using history to justify illegal immigration. Don't get me wrong, what france did was horrible, but we can't scapegoat it for every problem just because it has accepted some immigrants, while other countries who have done the same didn't.
And quick. It's already heating up and this isn't going away. Nothing better to increase wages for the real locals by kicking out several 100k illegals, and esp the criminal ones. I bet it has a good effect on housing availability also.
Its insane to think that mass immigration doesn't exacerbate wage and housing pressure.
The left completely and utterly failed. Shame on all leftist parties who let this happen. Shame on you.
he is paying taxes
he should be entitled
They'll be deterred if France is serious about deportation. Illegals are always going on about "xenophobia" and their "rights," but never about their responsibilities, like entering legally.
Legality is not the issue, since existing is not criminal. That’s why it is xenophobic.
@@Rnankn France has no problem with International tourism, only welfare grifters that arrive off boats having paid zero taxes and then expecting to be clothed, fed, housed, educated, given access to jobs conforming to their skills and then access to subsidised healthcare. Why should a native French citizen lose access to their pension and social services just because foreign pirates show up demanding state resources without having contributed anything?
@@Rnankn Really? You'd feel differently if several people decided to "exist" in your home without your permission and without paying for food, rent, upkeep, etc. 😆
@@Rnankn Existing in other people’s countries without permission is definitely illegal
@@Rnankn What does existing have to do with being illegally in another country? They can exist in their home countries.
It’s great that u can rock up illegally into a country and protest against the laws of the land 😂 it should be illegal for any foreigner to protest in a country they’re not even a citizen of. Absolute madness
Funny, I said yesterday, that the cops should be snapping photos and running background checks to see who is actually a newly landed/illegal immigrant and deport them. I'm not saying you can't protest but that right is earned. I also feel any sense of complaining is instant deportation. It's a lot cheaper to fund one-way tickets than trying to integrate/support illegals.
Illegally? You destroy their country and still continuously loot them you deserve them coming to your land. Your actions have consequences.
I believe in France you can absolutely be arrested and deported for protesting, that’s only for the French! They love their protests and the leaders listen but they’re not going to listen to outsiders they’re pretty stubborn and proud
Absolutely
Only in this new woke and entitled world can somebody have the juevos to do this.
Legal foreigners in a country pay taxes. Why shouldn't they have the right to protest?
I'm Nigerian. It's a pretty ridiculous notion that a country can't expel illegal immigrants who commit crimes - so France suffers for the crime, and also has to bear costs of imprisonment? At the same time, African countries need to take steps to squeeze the neck of countries like France with respect to the unfathomably cheap raw materials/resources they now receive and expel their presence from their countries. For me, that's a perfect and fair state of affairs.
"unfathomably cheap raw materials/resources" example?
@@norbertfontaine8524 do you think France extracts raw materials from its former colonies at the competitive market price? Maybe a good example for you is the fact that France still forces it's former colonies to pay colonial taxes. If that isn't France exploiting it's once African colonies, I don't know what is.
Well said. Now someone is talking rationally and seeing the faults on both sides.
A Nigerian that speaks perfect English and sounds like an American? Nothing is real online anymore, sheesh
@@robbiep742 Perfect example of American ignorance of other countries, any one who speaks good English is from America.
Burglars have the right to chose the houses they break into .
LOL. The way you put it, it sounds crazy 😂
How can you demand rights, when you dismissed the laws by entering illegally?
If you want rights; enter like the rest of us.
Go get a passport from Mail and apply to enter "like the rest of us" and see how difficult it is for to get a visa to enter France "legally".
It’s difficult for a reason
@@ras3054 My husband is a so-called 3rd country passport holder, and had to apply legally to enter my country (Denmark) - and pay .. a lot of money.
We're married, I'm a Danish citizen, yet he still doesn't get any rights, neither of us are able to receive any benefits, he has to learn the language and live up to certain rules.
If everyone just entered and demanded things based on it being difficult to enter .. the countries would crumble.
Your argument has zero logic.
@@thisisditte737 You can make your point without misrepresenting what I wrote here.
I don't remember saying that people should demand benefits based on it been difficult to enter.
My point is that some passport holders from certain countries are not able to enter "like the rest of us" because different rules applies to different passports...
That is my point..
@@ras3054 My apologies, I misunderstood your comment :)
I’m confused. Why do they want people committing crimes to stay in their country?
We're working illegally and not getting any of the services.... Brilliant
I'm sure he can get that in his country.
Work is a private exchange, it cant be illegal unless work is abolished. Laws can’t discriminate.
@@Rnankn
Obviously it can be illegal, which is why we have labour laws.
he's a liar too, illegals have their healthcare fully covered in France with the AME (state medical aid)
The idea of removing people who commit crimes from your country is terrible ?
I know, it’s just cray-cray !
When you go to a country for a livelihood, just follow their rules and respect their way of life. Why is it so hard to understand?
Mistook it for America
@@anamerican481 Ha ha, good one
@@moorthykumar7494America and it’s illegal immigration issue is out of hand. It’s time to stop people from anywhere from coming to it.
Exactly! I am fed up with that disrespect and blames of “colonialism” or whatever else what happened 100 years ago.. Europe must remain European in values! If they don’t like it here they must go! Congratulations France for taking it right finally!
@@jol7772 France should annex Algeria
Listen carefully...The French have had enough...Enough of the vast majority of Arabo-immigrants and Afro-immigrants who do not wish to integrate... If they are all fully embracing the French way, look how they behave while demonstrating...the makak dances etc.
same in Denmark
Then leave their lands and stop exploiting them; you have a comfortable life only because of their suffering.
how are they not integrating? they live in France, speak French and pay taxes to the French government.
@@risottoyagami4151 as if before colonialism they had a peaceful democratic utopia. Tribes and ethnic groups have been at war long before European colonialism. The infrastructure in many of these countries comes from Europe. Do you think Morocco's high speed rail(TGV) would exist without the French?
@@geoffoakland *EUROPE(!)* did not have a "peaceful democratic utopia" before the age of colonialism. We took our own time to arrive at this point.
Undocumented Immigrant ?
is that a woke way to say illegal immigrant ?
"The chickens came home to roost", 200 million Africans should move to Europe.
It was fun when it was "The scramble for Africa" from 1884-1914.
@@sheldonthomas8773 I agree.
Looks like Mexico will be getting some of their US lands back in a few decades.
This madness in Europe has gone on for long enough. Restore sanity and expel illegal immigrants.
It's crazy that someone comes into your country illegally and makes demands about how you have to treat them.
France is screwed. "You have let them in through the front door, but they will not depart that way."
France infamous “no-go zones.”.
The enter France through the front and leave the back door to only cross into England 😂😂😂
given the scope of the problem in france which is worse then the UK not enough are going to england or other places.....Sweden and France are in the most dire straights Belgium is pretty bad to@@thepatriot4076
"Experts have been telling me that these changes in the law have had practically no impact on the number of (illegal) immigrants per year. Most of those coming to France are looking for a better life and will not be deterred by tougher immigration rules." The mass number of protest say otherwise. France has the right and responsibility to its citizens to protect its boarders and should use every means necessary to curb illegal immigration. If there was a mass influx of French people illegally entering and working in Morocco we would all find that a bit strange and concerning and would correctly say that Morocco should be able to run its country and immigration the way it wants to. But when the French people say it's a bit strange and concerning that a bunch of people illegally entering and working in France they are now somehow labeled as racist.
Exactly what I have been saying.
'..changes in the law have had practically no impact on the number of illegal immigrants ' Then the solution is simple, build walls!
7:05
@@geoffoakland in factl they come from the ocean by boats and put feet on tourist beach. It's not like the US coming from land.
@@geoffoakland , just to make me clear, where would those walls be? On the border with Belgium, Germany, Switzerland, Italy, Spain? Or maybe around the city of Paris (as if France cares about anything out of Paris)?
"Rights of undocumented immigrants"
The west is getting woke.
Get woke, go broke.
Haha! Exactly 😂😂😂😂
If "immigrants" dont like it in a country they illegally entered, then they should probably never have come in the first place. The entitlement is unreal.
Exatcly ! Also I LOVE your profile picture !
they're not treating you as if you were nothing, they're treating you as scammers, which you are.
I agree with France on these immigrations laws, as long is being done fairly and with no race discrimination, i do support these laws across all Europe. Africans need to stay in Africa and develop the continent, without the intervention of Europe countries, which most of the time they do more harmful than help! Thats the answer
I agree
Yep, exactly
"The chickens came home to roost", 200 million Africans should move to Europe.
It was fun when it was "The scramble for Africa" from 1884-1914.
If you are illegal then you are illegal... deport.
I doubt the memory of this old lady. Remind her few months ago France was on fire. few days ago someone was stabbed.
I guess the human traffickers in African countries already have luxurious life.
Our national security is more important than rights of asylum seekers.. we helped them and all we got is crime and disrespect.. wish them luck in their home countries! You don’t like it here? GO!
Make it a crime punished with prison time for anyone hiring illegal immigrants.
That will make companies think tvice and u might see some change
YES !
Every country in Europe should pass a law like this if not more stricter. Also check if student visa immigrants are studying or not. If they are failing deport them
Mass deportation now. I'm sick of this.
Criminals proudly demonstrating their criminality on the streets. Lock them up, throw them out.
"fight for hes rights" - what rights?...load of 💩
They are using other people's identities to remain in the country illegally and they are demonstrating for their "rights"? 🥺
As a immigrant I stand with France. Europe should increase the threshold of toughness. Its alarming. You should not give easy access to illegal. And these illegal do not respect the diversity
Get them OUT
I was in Paris last summer and shockingly didn’t see french there
Paris isn't not France. You need to go to the countryside.
@@thesaviorvsevilqueen1218 Jewell of Europe build by french for french, occupied by uninvited residents
@@dirtyharry6297 Yes but not anymore unfortunately. But you are welcome to visit plenty of regions that are quite beautiful !
"The Strange Death of Europe" by Douglas Murray.......Europe is doomed.
I find it horrible that newcomers to the country want their cake and eat it while local citizens get neither. But to call local citizens racist because they complain about the nonsense of mass migration and the environmental impact of mass migration.
Lives in a country illegally.
Trashes the government for treating them a such.
Hmm. Nothing to see here. *Grabs Baguette*.
You come here to "protest for your rights" ???
Why don't you protest in Africa???
And what are your rights? Free accommodation? Free food? Free ride?
ABSOLUTELY !!!!
Immigration for me isn’t the issue…it’s immigration from countries where the culture is completely
Opposite of Europeans and they bring with them cultural behaviours that are not compatible in western democracies.
"The chickens came home to roost", 200 million Africans should move to Europe.
It was fun when it was "The scramble for Africa" from 1884-1914.
From my little direct knowledge it seems like the bill would actually help France more than it'd hurt it. So the protesters might be right. But being an undocumented person in a country and then protesting trying to change the country to suite you isn't a recipe for success or to make the French people sympathetic to your cause haha. They sound about as entitled as actual French citizens haha
This!
My first thought as well. A bill that stops illegal immigration and extremism? Why not?
When will the bloody UK wake up????
Maybe when the government can make an immigration policy that abides by international law like the right wing government in Italy has and what France is planning.
So have you ever asked yourself why it is YOU are expected to give rights up to stop immigrants?
It always surprises me when people don't understand illegally entering the country and illegally working in the country is illegal. And of someone who isn't a citizen of your country commits a crime why should the government have the option of deporting them. Citizenship exsists for a reason
Europe has more than enough workers but they need paying. The government and business owners want very cheap labour. So they can profit while goings are good. It is all about money money money for the investigator's.
Yes absolutely ! How about respecting actual human rights and paying workers properly instead of paying cheap labour from abroad, when foreigners could contribute to developing their own country ! (Of course without any Western intervention)
Nobody asked them to do this work or to be here. You’ve gotta have nerve to protest for this.
agree,. its been 7 years now that i am still here in europe. this is your home, for me its my second home. you have to protect it, as for me im just a worker here but i dont complain. whenever your gov. want me out i'll accept it. i will forever cherish the moment i stayed here even though i had some bad experience but i take it as a challenge to work more for my family. thanks to you dear europeans for hiring me. now i had my jeepney painted with "sweat in europe". i'll be sitting down infront my karaoke and singing "final count down".. europe had kept as alive,,,thanks...
@@stiflerliyu9499 You are exactly the kind of person who should remain!
They shouldn’t have entered the country illegally in the first place. This goes for every country.
Do what the majority of the French population ask, or elect better politicians. they are in the parliament to do what the people demand.
Back in the days they used the guillotine if they misbehaved.
If you don't stick to the rules, how can you protest concerning the introduction of rules?
Deportation.
Coming illegally to Europe and asking for rights and criticizing the government...doing protests about it? What ? What happened to the world ? France should accelerate the adoption of this law and more !
It’s too late. They’re already in France. This toughness should have been implemented two decades ago.
some people from African nations tend to attribute their country's challenges to European influences. In contrast, I've observed that Asians typically focus on enhancing their own countries rather than placing blame on nations like the UK or the USA.
Because that is the African mindset - nobody ever takes responsibility for anything. Ask me, I have been living in Africa for 50 years.
And I'd also like to add that colonization was also present (Japanese in China, and Korea as well), but that didn't prevent those countries from developing after WWII. So ....
@@thesaviorvsevilqueen1218 its literally all because of mindset. south korea was as poor as africa mid 20th century, now look at them.
@@thesaviorvsevilqueen1218 I didn't realize that colonization in China was so intense that the Chinese now speak Japanese and were forced to adopt their economic systems too.
Make yourself legal before talking about your rights
If every person from poor countries what to move to EU for better life , our life in EU will be not worth living,
Statistically speaking it’s recipe for disaster look at Germany 😢
German here: Sadly, you're spot-on.
You can always rely on DW to present only whatever side of the story that harms western society.
Without fail. Always on the side of the other. I especially love when they present a non-German reporter talking about why it's bad that Germans want to retain some semblance of their traditional culture.
Translation: I hate it that DW is not a fascist mouthpiece, which is what I want it to be.
@@bramposthumus9300 In fact biased reporting like this is a hallmark of authoritarian regimes like the one you mentioned.
Well why don’t they do it legally, then they wouldn’t be illegal. If France sorts its boarders might help ours 🇬🇧
"all work is slavery" is a really dumb take
Do you speak French?
Deportation now
Undocumented immigrant rights 😆
Ilegal inmigrants always protest on other countries for rights but not on theirs 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Crazy how its controversial to want to kick out immigrants that commit crime..
If all people from Africa, Middle East and Central Asia migrates to Europe, where Europeans have to go? Too many people. Everyone should stay home and build their countries..
Simple pragmatic and A VERY GOOD POINT !
Non-European legal immigration must be limited to minimal levels, otherwise the continent will decay into oblivion. One simply has to look at what happens to areas in Sweden with high numbers of foreigners. If you scale that continent-wide, the problems will be the same.
Oblivion? Everyone in Europe immigrated there. The only people on earth who are not immigrants are Africans.
I feel for the European countries, They’re not America (forced melting pot) they actually have a common shared culture with values and customs and the immigration is disrupting that! Absolutely not fair for these white countries when white people are the minority
This is how Africa, Australia and Americas felt when European settlers colonized and took over indigenous peoples land and wealth 😢
@@christineopiyo7769 Europeans created the greatest nations on Earth. Why didn't the aboriginals do anything with the land or use the resources? They had thousands of years. I would actually say the citizens now have it better than if colonization never happened. Would these same people want to to live in, say, Central Africa instead?
@@kenake8465 so you're saying it was ok for White European settlers to colonize indigenous Australians, Africans and native Americans take their land and wealth change their cultures and language and it is not ok for others ethnicities to come to Europe? What nonsense is this? Help me understand this double standards where some people are entitled and others aren't 🙄🤔. All these native populations were very much ok with their cultures, today as we speak the indigenous Australians were almost wiped out through genocide by the settlers I'm glad they still exist though sadly in minority and practice their culture and art!!
Europe for Europeans
And when china steps in you all kow tow to the real masters
African resources for African
like the french national football team
@@antonykamundia7802
I bet they have no loyalty to France. Just a pay check
HUMANITY FOR HUMANS
But if you are illegal in one country You are already a criminal! So what rights one criminal person can have?
A country has a right to choose the people it allows inside their country. Countries facing internal trouble are responsible for their citizens, just exporting them does not make them France or hosting countries problem. Lawmakers are just playing politics and ruining it for all legal citizens.
écouter, France is not a country, it is one of the member states of the EU, they signed away their rights to chose who they allow into their states when they became signitories to the Schengen Area.
France, especially Paris, is lost. Coming from London, where the white native population has been decimated, I feel their pain.
They want to choose the job. They want to illegally enter someone else's country and choose their job. Well if that is what he wants maybe it's better for him to stay in his country of origin. Choosing a job involves leaving a job that involves not having a job. So someone who has broken the law to illegally enter France wants to be unemployed for even a short time it would seem he would have motive to break the law again thru theft or fraud because he feels he is owed. Owed the right to illegal entry owed the right to be unemployed this seems to be odds with what the interests of the French people are.
They never interview people who suffer from the effects of mass migration
THAT. Amen.
When you go to other countries to earn a living Behave. They don't owe you anything.
As a Indian i don't understand how europe people has no problem with Islamization of europe.
Want to come legally? Prove you are value.
French now just eat what you have planted, and these ilegal immigrants have actually good points. My nephew is receiving money, here in Portugal, every month from the French social security without doing nothing, he just goes in the summer doing this extra work for 2 months in the farms and now he receives free money, well...good for him because im his uncle but we all know that doesnt make sense at all, obviously French tax payers are paying someone for doing nothing, and he works in Portugal so he has this extra free money....sweet
Portugal is part of the EU. Your nephew is an european citizen, not an illegal immigrant.
She says legal papers but the men says he is using illegal papers through a loophole.
So let me get this straight.... they're complaining about being deported but came here illegally.....
Why European welcoming people outside country without proper documents😢
Illegally present in France
Committing identity fraud
Openly protesting law that cracks down on above violations.. wow
France should give him two options - Mali or Rwanda (ala UK)
For my French friends I pray he passes this law quickly
That law is a joke, that's why the left AND the right voted against it
“I think Europe belongs to the Europeans.”
Dalai Lama
Without any qualifications or legal status, what job are they expecting? A white collar job?
Why Europe is not taking these Immigrants seriously, they dont have an idea with whom they are dealing with, with what sort of Ideological people they are dealing with.
Slavery lol? Nobody forced u to stay here to work
France is right. If you live in Europe, you should respect its culture and the law.
Now Europe understand imigration problems make it more rough
Most reasonable people believe that asylum law is being abused.
International asylum law needs to be completely rewritten. It is not fit for purpose
Most European countries are overwhelmed by mass migration from foreign countries. Therefore, the issue of rejecting the entry of immigrants to any one particular European country must not be compromised.
Illegal immigrants shouldn't have come in the first place. Let's bring common sense back to the table, please.
And immigrants should also know and respect the culture of the nation they're living in. If you disagree, off you go.
Why can't skilled workers be home-grown, and trained. I have NEVER understood the premise that they have to be imported !!!!!!! Provide the opportunities damn it !!!
Even the so called skilled workers don’t even wanna come to Europe
Why did you run away from your country's and then start protesting in France.
It takes a sense human to avoid becoming legalized while expecting benefits of legal working citizens
I just visited France recently, I have to say I was shocked at the large number of Africans I saw there.
Mr Mackrel appearing to be doing something whilst doing nothing, trying desperately to deny Marine and the Rassemblement National, the only hope that France has.
Looking forward for this bill and better future for French people. All illegal activities should be halted and dealt with. Greetings from Berlin