The History Underground You can only have so many leaders. Most educational institutions, particularly public ones, are in the business of creating followers, whether by design or by natural tendencies.
@@DutchHolland77 "Big daddy" government is what people want it to be. Public schooling should be mandatory, so no indoctrination could ever take place...
Mikke Boström Yeah! When has big daddy government ever tried to brainwash it’s citizens?! Oh shit, that’s right, only in every communist nation ever...
I appreciate your guys’ conversations. This helps me refine my mentality. still needs a shit ton of work but it gradually gets better as long as I keep swinging the axe and chopping the wood.
Jocko needs an app with push notifications that gives you short tidbits like this... This is the stuff that keeps you going. We need more people like Jocko in our world. Great leader and role model.
Jocko is beyond Intelligent. Wise. He is Wise. How Rare. Been listening to Jocko TH-cam Podcasts for about a year now. It seems to be so trite to use words like ....Cool....Great....Fascinating...Refreshing. More like----" This is What I NEED....what is necessary....What EVERY YOUNG person should hear. To hear Jocko. Not Jocko....But TRUTH and REALITY thru the Medium of Jocko. Overwhelming. Stunning to hear such Concise Common Sense and PURE Foundation .
Jocko got this in the bag. How many people always talk about what they want in life, but it's the choice that effects the outcome. Down to how you are born and how you leave this world thanks guys.
Another awesome clip, Jocko. I finished reading your book discipline equals freedom and it’s been a big eye opener to a few parts of my life; which already have started improving with some small but effective changes. Thank you for your efforts
We all have a natural bent or tendency (personal perspective) that leads us to a certain lane that if we work it, leads to success. Some people can work hard in the wrong lane & still not succeed even with nurture.
Jocko only spoke about peoples nurture: socioeconomic status, location of living, family surroundings etc. He didn't consider nature at all which is personality traits, genetics and the IQ you were born with. that stuff can be influenced but mostly can't be helped. he describes the hard workers and go getters but that's simply people who are disagreeable, high in openness, high in conscientiousness and low in neuroticism which is all simply the traits of a persons nature. from what i see i think his answer should be "mostly nature".
Im on the opposite side of the fence! I say it is BOTH! Nature & Nurture! We need to stop separating the two! I hear what Jocko is saying, about the choices we make in order to be successful, however I think the Nature VS. Nurture debate is about AFTER you make your choice, i.e. is it your genes that are going to carry you to your goal or is it your upbringing that is going to give you the edge? I personally think it's BOTH! Fat people have a hard time with running but if you can "Nurture" them or lead them to the goal it can be done and the people skinnier ones who are good at running can also be cut down and bullied out of meeting their goal! So it is a complex equation and both play an equal part in completing the goal you chose to pursue! Long comment I know! But I CHOSE to finish it to the best of my ability! LOL
I love podcast like this but sometimes they’re not realistic your environment definitely does have an effect on how you turn out not saying that you can’t make it but some situations are set up better for people to do better and we just have to be real about that
I found this to be very true, both in my time as a civilian and in my path to becoming a competent NCO. You decide what you want, then you overcome any obstacle to getting it.
He says it's nature but claims he isn't. He's saying external factors don't play a role therefore it's purely the persons nature that it the causing facing of there choices
Breathing is over rated.... He is a great example of simply getting up one more time. Anyone that thinks they had the deck stacked against them should pick up a copy of the book.
Yes but do they choose to make that decision because of their environment, or based on their dna? All things are connected. Every fruit was grown from a seed.
Echo stay away frim the gym for a day please. You're not gonna be able to wear a shirt with sleeves lol. Keep fucking hammering boys, much love from Cleveland
Fun fact, genetics determine more than 50% of what you look like, how you grow up, intelligence and even your personality. But it is a mix of nurture and nature, never forget that
@@williamh.gatesiii8183 I did watch the whole video. He literally says, "In my opinion" before going on his mini speech. Yes I agree with what Jocko said, that we still have a choice on if we want to succeed or not. I didn't say he was wrong, I am just adding the fact, and not junk science there has been valid and reliable studies done on this, of how much genes impact who you are. But we are still left with a choosing what we do. Hence why I said it is a mix of nature and nurture. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk
Oh... People that are succesful have CHOSED to be that way? Ok, then what about those that aren't succesfull??? In his ideology, they have too CHOSED not to be... That is just not true, not at all.
@Melancholy Soldier point taken, however everyones situation is different ..so dont be quick to judgment on things you do not know about me.....have a nice day.
You're not saying this is "nature", but what you're saying is the "nature" argument. A corgi isn't going to choose to be faster than a greyhound and then do it.
“They aren’t inhibited by nature or nurture. They overcome BOTH.”
This needs to be entry level instruction in every school.
The History Underground You can only have so many leaders. Most educational institutions, particularly public ones, are in the business of creating followers, whether by design or by natural tendencies.
Yeah. That is what Nazi-ideology was all about...
@@DutchHolland77 "Big daddy" government is what people want it to be. Public schooling should be mandatory, so no indoctrination could ever take place...
Mikke Boström Yeah! When has big daddy government ever tried to brainwash it’s citizens?! Oh shit, that’s right, only in every communist nation ever...
Thank you Mr. Willink for posting these as I use them a lot in my high school classes. Your wisdom is much appreciated.
I appreciate your guys’ conversations. This helps me refine my mentality. still needs a shit ton of work but it gradually gets better as long as I keep swinging the axe and chopping the wood.
Tony Robbins agrees with this too. And Jocko's fluent answer was excellent and makes so much sense!
Tony Robbins ? LOL
CHOICE. Hit me to my core Jocko. Thank you.
Jocko needs an app with push notifications that gives you short tidbits like this... This is the stuff that keeps you going. We need more people like Jocko in our world. Great leader and role model.
I think this is his best ever.
*Nature AND Nurture.* Source: Introduction to Psychology.
Jocko is the man
Jocko is beyond Intelligent. Wise. He is Wise. How Rare. Been listening to Jocko TH-cam Podcasts for about a year now. It seems to be so trite to use words like ....Cool....Great....Fascinating...Refreshing.
More like----" This is What I NEED....what is necessary....What EVERY YOUNG person should hear. To hear Jocko. Not Jocko....But TRUTH and REALITY thru the Medium of Jocko.
Overwhelming. Stunning to hear such Concise Common Sense and PURE Foundation .
As one of the kids that were abused, thank you. I needed to hear that.
This world could use a few more men like jocko.
This is why I listen! I feel this deeply.
Jocko got this in the bag. How many people always talk about what they want in life, but it's the choice that effects the outcome. Down to how you are born and how you leave this world thanks guys.
We need more of these short clips Jocko. I love the long podcast but sometimes I just need these short clips to get me out of bed.
Check out his "Psychological Warfare" stuff on iTunes.
This is powerful. Definitely truth.
Jocko has a knack for getting you to feel like whatever it is you're doing, you could and should do more, be more, achieve more. ..
I was slacking off. I accidentally clicked on this vid
Back to work
Hardcore wisdom. Real self empowerment! Thank you Jocko!
Of course Jocko says, "Neither."
Although I don't necessarily wholly agree with this speech, It was very powerful and motivating.
*His answer was very different than i thought it'd be!* 💪
We should all be grateful that we live in a society that lets us choose in the first place. It may not be the best, but it'll do.
I remember this moment from BACK IN THE DAY. Great segment. AGENCY, BROTHER!
DAMN that was powerful Jocko
"Choose..." how to choose, when your decision are driven either by your nature, or how were you nurtured. How to break "that" point?
Another awesome clip, Jocko. I finished reading your book discipline equals freedom and it’s been a big eye opener to a few parts of my life; which already have started improving with some small but effective changes. Thank you for your efforts
Because nature or nurture isn't under your control but your Choices are.
Truth being spoken aloud.
Commitment and Dedication
Just threw ages of psychological ideology in the dirt in a few minutes!
We all have a natural bent or tendency (personal perspective) that leads us to a certain lane that if we work it, leads to success. Some people can work hard in the wrong lane & still not succeed even with nurture.
i love that there’s no shitty emotional music in the background of this.
You overcome both!
They need to put every word said in this video in school books.
Atta boy Jocko.. right on right on!
Jocko only spoke about peoples nurture: socioeconomic status, location of living, family surroundings etc. He didn't consider nature at all which is personality traits, genetics and the IQ you were born with. that stuff can be influenced but mostly can't be helped. he describes the hard workers and go getters but that's simply people who are disagreeable, high in openness, high in conscientiousness and low in neuroticism which is all simply the traits of a persons nature. from what i see i think his answer should be "mostly nature".
Perfectly Said - Wow
"The difference in people's life's, are the difference in their standards." Tony Robbins
I know what this is. This is GOOD!
I like what you put out brother. Keep up the great work.
That's some awesome advice and intensity
Jocko makes me wish I was still in the military. Thank you.
Im on the opposite side of the fence! I say it is BOTH! Nature & Nurture! We need to stop separating the two! I hear what Jocko is saying, about the choices we make in order to be successful, however I think the Nature VS. Nurture debate is about AFTER you make your choice, i.e. is it your genes that are going to carry you to your goal or is it your upbringing that is going to give you the edge? I personally think it's BOTH! Fat people have a hard time with running but if you can "Nurture" them or lead them to the goal it can be done and the people skinnier ones who are good at running can also be cut down and bullied out of meeting their goal! So it is a complex equation and both play an equal part in completing the goal you chose to pursue!
Long comment I know! But I CHOSE to finish it to the best of my ability! LOL
Do we always have the option to make choices?
Thanks for this one, really good points.
you are great. Keep up the good work.
Every sinner is a saint, and every saint is a sinner.
Outstanding
I love podcast like this but sometimes they’re not realistic your environment definitely does have an effect on how you turn out not saying that you can’t make it but some situations are set up better for people to do better and we just have to be real about that
Nature all the way.
A person has a lot of balls to thumb down this wisdom and blueprint for life. Those souls are the lost ones in society.
They made their choice
Thumbs down!
I found this to be very true, both in my time as a civilian and in my path to becoming a competent NCO. You decide what you want, then you overcome any obstacle to getting it.
Love it.
Impressive answer
I choose.
Sometimes you can’t choose!!!
You can always choose.
To deny this is to choose to be a victim.
Easy... It is nature - without it one can't do anything.
I WISH SOMEBODY WOULD NURTURE MY....
SKINNY KNEES
How do you know if someone was a Seal? They tell you within the first five minutes.
He says it's nature but claims he isn't. He's saying external factors don't play a role therefore it's purely the persons nature that it the causing facing of there choices
Get well soon Goggins!!!
No.
Breathing is over rated.... He is a great example of simply getting up one more time. Anyone that thinks they had the deck stacked against them should pick up a copy of the book.
I must eat better! I really want a hearty breakfast right now
Yes but do they choose to make that decision because of their environment, or based on their dna? All things are connected. Every fruit was grown from a seed.
CHECK
I like Jocko, but I don’t understand the concept of the podcast. Is there always someone asking him questions and that’s it?
maxval54 nope they cover books and have guest.
You didn't add #nature on the title... Women are naturally nurturing....
Jocko looks like the protagonist of Wolfenstein
11/10
#NATURE VS #NUTURE. Captain Ahab in #MobyDick..
I do believe that you just saved my life
DEFCOR Recondo, sir!
Aloha!
👌
🎸👍🇺🇸
Jocko Jocko Jocko.... Say it three times and all your wishes will come true! Lol.... I'm goofy .
aka nurture
I woke up thinking about food.
“It not about what you’ve been through” pseudo psychology at its finest
Off the X!
You were supposed to say neither, it’s micro-aggressions.
genetics are everything
Making decisions and the choices you make, is everything. Perhaps you should listen again.
@@mauriciojaramillo174 fuck his opinion he is a puppet for the us and for israel if you have good genetics you automatically are 20 steps ahead
Echo stay away frim the gym for a day please. You're not gonna be able to wear a shirt with sleeves lol. Keep fucking hammering boys, much love from Cleveland
Fun fact, genetics determine more than 50% of what you look like, how you grow up, intelligence and even your personality.
But it is a mix of nurture and nature, never forget that
Please watch the video before commenting because he just invalidated your junk science.
@@williamh.gatesiii8183
I did watch the whole video. He literally says, "In my opinion" before going on his mini speech.
Yes I agree with what Jocko said, that we still have a choice on if we want to succeed or not. I didn't say he was wrong, I am just adding the fact, and not junk science there has been valid and reliable studies done on this, of how much genes impact who you are. But we are still left with a choosing what we do. Hence why I said it is a mix of nature and nurture.
Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk
Women are naturally #nurturing and all men are sinners by #nature. How to use nature and nurture in sentences. #ESL
How the Fuck are you not our President?..
the asker sound so weak but actually he very muscle lol.
💯 any other way of thinking would make you the victim and give you an excuse.
isn't that nurture?
Oh... People that are succesful have CHOSED to be that way? Ok, then what about those that aren't succesfull??? In his ideology, they have too CHOSED not to be... That is just not true, not at all.
😓 big words
BS shakes of terror when is in plain sight of jocko
Being poor it's difficult to eat healthy.
@Melancholy Soldier point taken, however everyones situation is different ..so dont be quick to judgment on things you do not know about me.....have a nice day.
10k cals of lobster/day is cheap.
@@Sealed_Chamber lol.... Lobster is expensive here. 😁
You're not saying this is "nature", but what you're saying is the "nature" argument.
A corgi isn't going to choose to be faster than a greyhound and then do it.
The it's a good thing we aren't corgis.
Sunshine_Shooter I know right. You can choose to run a sub 2 hour marathon and a sub 10 second 100m anytime you wish.
You’re totally not a corgi.
Have Jordan Peterson on again, please!?
Nature vs nurture... It's narrative.... narrative narrative!!!!! Shut up Jocko!!!!
This guy is actually low on the intellect level.. He doesn't write his own script as you can see.
Did ya really tho?? Jacko? Did ya really? Ivy League and ghetto gang bangers??? Trying put for seals? Ugh. Hard pass. Next.
Yea he's lying to please you. Yea, you're that important. Really, this dude and all his accolades are scared of what you think of him. No really...