You ask me, Logan was flawless. Nothing felt forced, everything felt very organic and natural, which is very good considering were talking about the world of fantasy.
Anything. Lucy Thing is comment is really wrong. Logan is great because of the Gore, yes, but frankly Logan is great with it's plot, and I feel Logan should be praised for its plot in correlation with the Gore. If Logan was put into PG-13, it'd STILL be great.
@@GastonVenegasRdz dude they've confirmed Deadpool will stay R Rated so there is a possibility we will get a lot of new and r rated Marvel movies even under Disney I mean Disney did release a R-Rated movie after 6 years in Stuber so you can't just say that's never going to happen seeing as Disney have not only confirmed an r rating for characters like Deadpool but are even doing R-Rated movies again
King Nachin and the best thing is they use the violence to fit the story not just spreading blood for entertainment, I mean watching Logan slice throats is pretty damn entertaining
Well she did have an appearance in a show called 'The Refugees' but Logan was her first movie performance so it is still special to Dafne and us. Also it's spelled 'Dafne' not 'Dephanie' but I can see why you would think that
8ulls3y3 - I have to admit I was very surprised how quickly Logan aged, considering it was only a little over 10 years after X-Men Days Of Future Past. Like what happened?
Dennis Murphy true, but this was probably the most realistic futuristic movie out there, self driving cars are already a thing and the farming stuff could easily happen in years, most future movies have like time machines and other unrealistic crap
+Bowser from Sonic That would actually be a TERRIBLE thing. You wouldn't be able to admire the detail of the violence or see what is going on during the farm fight scene.
Logan a 10 out of 10 Masterpiece The Wolverine 8 out of 10 it's not as bad as a lot of people think it is. I still enjoyed it and it is on my top 5 favorite X-Men movies.
+Jonathan Uriostegui The timeline in the X-Men movies really are incredibly incompetent from a narrative point of view. Thanks for watching and commenting Jonathan!
Why logan is the best superhero movie ever made: First , the cinematography is very new to such material and it felt like an indie movie , and when the camera used to move slowly into the characters it had this weird creepy suspenseful feeling to it , and lets not forget the farm use scene at the beginning , absolutely astonishing. Second , this must be the best character driven movie since the dark knight but the problem (in my opinion) with the dark knight that it had too many of them , do not get me wrong they were all fleshed out pretty well but still was not as satisfying as seeing three main characters try to interact and get to appreciate one another through a deadly and tragic cat and mouse chase. And we also got to see a broken logan , a mentally ill Charles xavier , and a kid so broken she did not say a word till the last 30 minutes , now that is depressing and all but so fucking fresh. Third , the performances in this movie is fan fucking tastic from patrick stewart who undeniably gives one of the best performances I have seen in a long time and his best but also hugh jackman , i cried alot of times in this movie because when he did something that feels tragic i lost it because i grew up watching his character from x men 1 to x men days of future past so seeing him pull off such performance filled with deep and clear motivation was so great , and by the way i liked callibean although he was kind of shoe horn in , i really thought that stephan merchant made this character look very realistic not the greatest but pretty good , dafne keen was also fantastic but liked her character more than her performance just because she was not really given that much to act till the last 30 minutes which I thought was great but the scene at the end with logan made me fucking weep like a baby. The villains performances was good but i thought they could have been better if their characters was better but it does not really matter since its about the three heroes interactions with one another. Fourth , the action is outstanding and unbelievable, i feel like that opening scene with wolverine is kind of overlooked and not talked about enough because i got chills watching it . Well choreographed , fast paced , and gory (very gory) action made this movie so much better for me , and about x-24 , he creeped the fuck out of me seeing him beside the old wolverine. My favorite part was the beginning action scenes . Last but not least , the soundtrack was amazing till the third act where it got a little jumbled but from beginning to end i was blown away with this kind of western / sad music and lets not talk about old man logan ost which is so emotional and thats nit a choo choo which is so suspenseful and creepy. Note:They chose very good settings for he movie especially the farm house. Overall it ranks first for me and then the dark knight
Great video, Logan is easily one of the best superhero movies of all time. Nice stabs at Nostalgia Critic. His "review" was such bullshit, left me wondering if he even watched the movie.
this is such a great comparison, when I finished watching it I thought wow I agree with everything you said then I realized the lack of Subscribers you had and was shocked you didn't have more considering the great video quality, keep it up
Eric, if it helps, Rob Walker, Doug's brother, is also as baffled as you regarding to Doug's treatment of Logan. For me, personally, Logan is my new favorite comic book movie of all time. I like it more than The Dark Knight, Civil War, Wonder Woman, Richard Donner's Superman and his cut of Superman II. And still, I love watching Nostalgia Critic episodes, and Doug's vlogs. Why? Because I love his style, the way he explains his opinions, and I trust him. I know, from reading your comment from his Non-Review of Transformers The Last Knight, that his review negatively affected your opinion on him and his reviews, but I wouldn't say he's untrustworthy. He's been critical on movies I've loved before(Iron Man 3 being a big example), and I still trust him to voice his opinion on movies I haven't seen before. He even inspired me to give back my DVD of Michael Bay's Pearl Harbor(which is just awful), and even helped me gain a certain mindset of what I really want out of movies nowadays. I don't think your a jerk for hating on his opinion, but I wouldn't let it be the deciding factor of how to judge him and his reviews from now on, because that is incredibly petty. P.S. Also, do you really need to hate on the Marvel Cinematic Universe so much? I get that your not a fan, but come on...
man just find your channel and I have to say I LOVE IT its the videos are made so well and if I dont really agree with u thanks to your explenetaion I can understand why u have that opinion Im sorry if I have a bad english
i actually watched alot of animated wolverine shows when i was young, now that im older and seeing an ageing wolverine bad tempered, weary, serious, covered in scars and war hardened it really feels like i grew up watching and knowing wolverine or Jimmy as i like to call him
If you want to get realllyyyy technical with it, aren't there 3 wolverine movies? X-Men Origins (it wasn't really and xmen movie, they just smacked the title in it) The Wolverine Logan
I personally like Wolverine more than Logan, don’t get me wrong I love Logan the characters is just so amazing and x-23 is the best but the reason why I like wolverine is that it’s the first time I see wolverine after that I became such a big fan of the character. I read a lot of comics I watched a bunch of movies
even though I was 12 watching this movie I cried so hard in the end and I just walked out the theater with a red face, and my favorite scene was when logan said to xaviar it wasn't me!!!! when x-24 stabbed him in the chest, and seeing that gave me a jump, and this movie was perfect
Dragonfirestudios 233 nice, I feel like the most impactful moments was when Charles was like "I'm sorry, im so sorry" when he had the seizure at the casino, and when Laura called him daddy
+Dragonfirestudios 233 Agreed. The movie was awesome and I don't see any other comic book movie from this year and the next taking its place. Thanks so much for watching and commenting buddy!
If you think THIS video is one of the best you've seen. Then check out my more recent versus videos. I am proud to say that they have gotten significantly better over time. Thanks for watching and commenting!
There was SOME future stuff, like the auto trucks and the bad guys having guns for hands (I get they're like that in the comics). But there shouldn't be a ton of futuristic stuff, it's only 12 years in the future
I agree that Loki is not exactly a villain. He is more like "chaos personified". He is anything he wants to be, which makes him such an interesting character to me.
I agree with many of the points regarding Logan and The Wolverine movies Eric. For me, The Wolverine felt underwhelming and boring. I enjoyed and loved Logan vastly more. Thank you very much for this video Eric, I really enjoyed hearing your view on them.
Dude, I know that it’s been a while since the dark knight rises came out...like 7 years, but I would actually enjoy sitting through a dark knight trilogy comparison. Because I think that it would be a cool video idea.
Nice review, Eric. But I must say, with respect (and as a fan of the Wolverine comics pre 2000) The Wolverine was actually a movie that fans would enjoy more than non-comic book readers (for the most part, anyway, there was NO excuse for a means to EVER cut adamantium. EVER!). And Wolverine Origins was very faithful (again for the most part) to the Weapon X story, and most especially the Wolverine Sabretooth relationship. However, I will agree with anyone, that the "Deadpool" interpretation was probably it's greatest flaw/sin. That and I personally think that Gambit's character could have used a little upgrade (but that's just me). Despite these flaws mentioned (amongst others that both movies possess), it's safe to say that no comic book movie can ever be 100% like the comics and still be good (be it outfits, plot points, etc.) I considered both movies to be very close to the comics (yes, even with the love interests (which had purpose and are very iconic in the entire Wolverine canon)) and what personal complaints I have I already mentioned. That said, I can respect your review, as well as your point of view and preferences. You always make great vids, mate, this is just my two cents from my own point of view. Cheers to good movies, brother ;). Looking forward to your next vid. Again, great job.
+Jon D I. An understand your view point. The relationships I know ARE important and hold a lot of weight in the comics. It's just that in the movie's paticularily with The Wolverine, they ended up being sidelined and ignored which ultimately made them feel pointless in the movie's interpretation. I'm glad you like my videos buddy. :) Thanks so much for watching and commenting!
I really agree with that shade toward the nostalgia critic, he seems so only enjoy classics too, always hating on remakes. (A lot of remakes don't do well but he rarely gives them a chance)
Hold up.. He's not soo old.. As you stated.. He's suffering from adamantium poisoning... And its basically depleted his power to heal.. And remain young.. He still can take damage and heal.. But its slow and very painful to experience... As you saw in the beginning where he now has to physically push the bullets out of his tissue.. His healing factor is trying , yet struggling ..so now he has to meet his healing factor half way.. And if he received major trauma or excessive trauma he will die..
Well the movie does have some new technologies that we don't have but will have soon like self driving trucks and massive automatic farms, plus somewhat sci fi limb replacement
My top 5 superhero movies. (my personal opinion don't hate haha) 1. The Dark Knight 2. Logan 3. Hancock 4. Avengers: Age Of Ultron 5. The Dark Knight Rises
The director, James mangold, said that he didn’t want the movie to look futuristic...he said that he wanted it to feel more gritty and in the middle of nowhere...he didn’t want it to be a world with high technology, as he just wanted it to be a world that hasn’t changed.
Yk what I wish they made a film called Logan Vs The Predator just like AVP except it’s wolverine fighting the predator which would be rated R due to being a horror with blood and gore and language obviously
The only part I appreciated in the Wolverine movie was the yakuza fight at the funeral and the ninja fight at the Yashida mansion (R version of course because of the blood and the added fight scene)
Just because a movie's set in the future doesn't mean it has to look futuristic. People living in the 1960's had that same sentiment about the year 2000 and onwards, and look at us today; no flying cars, no jet packs etc. If it was set a hundred years from now, I'd personally not be surprised if nothing was different.
Logan did have futuristic technology...there was the auto trucks before the family with the horses crashed, then later the big robot things in the corn fields aswell as the reavers' bionic limbs, but it made sense not to show much of it since it's not set too much in the future (only about 12 years) and most of the film is set in rural locations
Speaking of awesome movies like Logan, have you seen Children of Men? That film is an absolute masterpiece and the best science fiction I have personally seen so far this century.
Literaly LOGAN has ben the only marvel movie thats about a fictonal character brought to our world with our sences and emotions and is literali the definiton of GREAT you would want in an R reated and (especialy) *The Wolverine*
here is how I think Marvel Studio should continue the story, don't recast Logan make him stay dead and make X23 take the mantle as the All New Wolverine. Just like in the current comics!
Logan is arguably the next great superhero movie that nearly everybody (but not really everybody obviously) will remember fondly for years; the wolverine is basically what Logan eventually became but never could because of the studios and the lack of a good Deadpool movie and real reason to do so.
Logan's healing ability didn't slow down because of his age. It was because the adamantium was steadily poisoning him, though that's the most illogical sh*t ever, considering his cells regenerate almost instantly, but okay. Also, you may be tired of Wolverine being in love, but the thing that defines the Wolverine mythos is tragedy; the loss of the people he trusts & loves. He will undoubtedly outlive just about everyone he ever loves, which adds to his pain and fuels his RAGE. His love for Charles & Laura is what made him become the Wolverine again, in "Logan". He literally fought to the death, to protect the last person that he loved. Whether it was a romantic love, the love of a surrogate son for a surrogate father, or the love of a father for his daughter, Wolverine's story is all about fighting for what he loved.
I remember giving it a 6 when I first saw it in theatres. But after watching it the second time I gave it a 5. I saw Logan twice and I came away with the same 9/10 both times. Thanks for watching and commenting Eddie! I really appreciate it.
Ok actually yeah that review from doug actually kinda just irked me a bit. I'm usually all like, "have your own opinion" but I just did not understand his criticisms
10:35 our present day technology? The villain who tried to capture Laura had a half arm being robotic and it was fully functional which is not possible in 2023 so imagine in 2017
How does your channel not have at least 100,000 subscribers already? you're content is very good. I also agree with you I think Logan is an amazing movie! I do think the nude scene in the movie was unnecessary though.
What do you think guys? The Wolverine would've been better if they moved on from Jean's love story, no Viper, Mariko's grandfather actually dead, no Silver Samurai and no ex boyfriend of Mariko. So that will keep it at a small scale and give room for the important characters to shine. Like Logan, Yukio, Mariko, Mariko's corrupted husband and Shingen Yashida. just five characters that can shine through. Less is more. For example of what could make the Wolverine better: - If Logan moved on from Jean, his motivation in the film would be a bit clearer and us as the audience would root for him a bit more Premise: A Japanese soldier during the Nagasaki bombings in his dying days, gives the reluctant Logan a job to protect Mariko from the Yakuza, Ninjas and her father who prevents her to take her place from her company. (It's simple) - If Shingen was the main villain, he would be seen as a barrier of honour, just like in the Wolverine comic solo series. He is the reason why Mariko cannot takeover Yashida after her grandfather died. - I think the idea with Logan struggling with the beast conquering over the man which Mariko hates but Yukio wants him to embrace. If they play that a bit more, Shingen could've used that as his advantage. Putting choices like the Joker did in the Dark Knight. The greater the pressure, the more of Wolverine's character being defined - No taking away the healing factor. Seeing Logan's vulnerability is interesting but it's better to explore the humanity of him just like in the film Logan did. - An R rating in the Japanese story would make the film better. Not because of the slicing/dicing but I feel like if Mangold really wanted the Japanese noir/samurai film with superhero characters is the way to go. The Yakuza and ninjas are ruthless to be PG 13 - Speaking of that, the fight scenes could've been a bit longer and a bit more meaningful to the point that you worry for the character like in the film Logan. The stakes will be high personally. - Finally, if only the third act matches the tone of the film and not make it an X-Men movie, the film would be much better. Fight against the ninjas and Yakuzs a bit more. Have a sword fight against Shingen. Logan winning Mariko's heart and wants to marry him. Yukio finally walks free from the ninjas.
Logan felt like how The Wolverine was trying to be. The Wolverine would have been R as well, but sux stud- I mean Fox studios called it off. Hugh Jackman even had to take a pay cut to get this movie R rated.
i dunno the topless scene was just sorta... because but it was a nice little comedy moment of how wolverine would react. i mean he is a full time limo driver. he can't just claw drunk passengers.
+The LOL Man Doug said both the violence and language was forced to remind you that the movie is a hard R. He was wrong. Thanks for watching and commenting!
I like logan better because i just like all the bloody and gorey violence from wolverine and Laura and x 24 cutting their arms and heads off and the wolverine has very less bloody violence but no gore where they dont bleed alot from getting stab or cut by wolverine claws but he never cuts off limbs and logan has more bloody violence and limbs getting cut off was more impressive.
I love that it's directed by the same guy, James Mangold. I absolutely hate The Wolverine. But it seems Mangold learned from that schlock storytelling so Logan was excellent.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 78 | คู่เอก "ปกรณ์ vs ฟาบิโอ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LSOmgl0Th2c/mqdefault.jpg)
You ask me, Logan was flawless. Nothing felt forced, everything felt very organic and natural, which is very good considering were talking about the world of fantasy.
@TJP 123 what did he say? I swear if he shitted on this movie...
If logan was pg-13 it would have been trash in my opinion , they did a good job making it R rated
Anything. Lucy Thing is comment is really wrong. Logan is great because of the Gore, yes, but frankly Logan is great with it's plot, and I feel Logan should be praised for its plot in correlation with the Gore. If Logan was put into PG-13, it'd STILL be great.
Thanks to 20th Century Fox for this... It will be imposible to see this kind of adaptations with Disney - Marvel.
@@GastonVenegasRdz dude they've confirmed Deadpool will stay R Rated so there is a possibility we will get a lot of new and r rated Marvel movies even under Disney I mean Disney did release a R-Rated movie after 6 years in Stuber so you can't just say that's never going to happen seeing as Disney have not only confirmed an r rating for characters like Deadpool but are even doing R-Rated movies again
King Nachin and the best thing is they use the violence to fit the story not just spreading blood for entertainment, I mean watching Logan slice throats is pretty damn entertaining
Unlike venom
Whhhaaaat...? Ik Dephanie is 12 but it was her FIRST PERFORMANCE? She's amaziiing!
I know right! She was awesome!
Days of Future Past was in 2023, Logan is in 2029.
Well she did have an appearance in a show called 'The Refugees' but Logan was her first movie performance so it is still special to Dafne and us. Also it's spelled 'Dafne' not 'Dephanie' but I can see why you would think that
There were a couple of futuristic elements, as driverless freight cars and the crop equipment on the farm both come to mind.
Exactly. It's only 10 or so years in the future, I really think that aspect was handed really well.
8ulls3y3 - I have to admit I was very surprised how quickly Logan aged, considering it was only a little over 10 years after X-Men Days Of Future Past.
Like what happened?
THE CROPS WERE POISONED SO WHATEVER HE ATE FUCKED HIM OVER
Dennis Murphy true, but this was probably the most realistic futuristic movie out there, self driving cars are already a thing and the farming stuff could easily happen in years, most future movies have like time machines and other unrealistic crap
Great review man
Thanks buddy!
imagine if Logan was actually in 3D... that would either be a good thing or a bad thing.
+Bowser from Sonic That would actually be a TERRIBLE thing. You wouldn't be able to admire the detail of the violence or see what is going on during the farm fight scene.
3D blood would look terrible.
Pretty sure the breast scene was there to take advantage of the R rating, not the other way around.
Hugh jackman will be remembered as the Wolverine but who is excited for x-23 to be the new wolverine
The Awesome Tag I wanna see her as a kid tho,I'm afraid they are going to do a thing where it's like bam she's old
The Awesome Tag bruh she's still a kid there so gonna be a different story of course wait you know maybe that's gonna happen dude
Me
I just hope that they keep her actress in the MCU instead of recasting her
Can't wait
Logan a 10 out of 10 Masterpiece
The Wolverine 8 out of 10 it's not as bad as a lot of people think it is. I still enjoyed it and it is on my top 5 favorite X-Men movies.
Agreed, only issue with the wolverine was the tacked on silver samurai..
actually only 6 years pass inbetween days of future past and logan. DOFP takes place in 2023 and logan takes place in 2029
casual complaints Have you seen the movie?
casual complaints No duh
Well yeah but that intro future was rewritten by the end and other prequel movies
casual complaints no Wolverine woke up in the 70’s in one scene
Days of Future Past was in 2023, Logan is in 2029.
+Jonathan Uriostegui The timeline in the X-Men movies really are incredibly incompetent from a narrative point of view. Thanks for watching and commenting Jonathan!
Logan is a masterpiece, but if only the song of the credits was "Hurt" By Johnny Cash, I would've given it an 10/10 but no movie is ever a 10/10
Why logan is the best superhero movie ever made:
First , the cinematography is very new to such material and it felt like an indie movie , and when the camera used to move slowly into the characters it had this weird creepy suspenseful feeling to it , and lets not forget the farm use scene at the beginning , absolutely astonishing.
Second , this must be the best character driven movie since the dark knight but the problem (in my opinion) with the dark knight that it had too many of them , do not get me wrong they were all fleshed out pretty well but still was not as satisfying as seeing three main characters try to interact and get to appreciate one another through a deadly and tragic cat and mouse chase. And we also got to see a broken logan , a mentally ill Charles xavier , and a kid so broken she did not say a word till the last 30 minutes , now that is depressing and all but so fucking fresh.
Third , the performances in this movie is fan fucking tastic from patrick stewart who undeniably gives one of the best performances I have seen in a long time and his best but also hugh jackman , i cried alot of times in this movie because when he did something that feels tragic i lost it because i grew up watching his character from x men 1 to x men days of future past so seeing him pull off such performance filled with deep and clear motivation was so great , and by the way i liked callibean although he was kind of shoe horn in , i really thought that stephan merchant made this character look very realistic not the greatest but pretty good , dafne keen was also fantastic but liked her character more than her performance just because she was not really given that much to act till the last 30 minutes which I thought was great but the scene at the end with logan made me fucking weep like a baby. The villains performances was good but i thought they could have been better if their characters was better but it does not really matter since its about the three heroes interactions with one another.
Fourth , the action is outstanding and unbelievable, i feel like that opening scene with wolverine is kind of overlooked and not talked about enough because i got chills watching it . Well choreographed , fast paced , and gory (very gory) action made this movie so much better for me , and about x-24 , he creeped the fuck out of me seeing him beside the old wolverine. My favorite part was the beginning action scenes .
Last but not least , the soundtrack was amazing till the third act where it got a little jumbled but from beginning to end i was blown away with this kind of western / sad music and lets not talk about old man logan ost which is so emotional and thats nit a choo choo which is so suspenseful and creepy.
Note:They chose very good settings for he movie especially the farm house.
Overall it ranks first for me and then the dark knight
Heisenberg 2 your stupid the dark Knight was awesome then logan
Omar Lopez No Logan is clearly better.
Charlie sheen I love both but your spelling and grammar is laughably bad and it makes your argument sound weak
Great video, Logan is easily one of the best superhero movies of all time.
Nice stabs at Nostalgia Critic. His "review" was such bullshit, left me wondering if he even watched the movie.
Never liked Nostalgia Critic either
this is such a great comparison, when I finished watching it I thought wow I agree with everything you said then I realized the lack of Subscribers you had and was shocked you didn't have more considering the great video quality,
keep it up
+tortopalist • Thanks so much for the awesome comment buddy. I really do appreciate it. :)
Logan is The Best X-Men film. Period
And the best superhero movie ever with the dark knight
Fun fact just like Harley Quinn and Batman Beyond X-23 made her first appearance in a cartoon
The Wolverine going to Japan sounds awesome right now.
Best movie ever, I watched it 4 times
I’ve watched it 16 and I’m not ashamed to admit I’ve cried on every viewing.
Eric, if it helps, Rob Walker, Doug's brother, is also as baffled as you regarding to Doug's treatment of Logan. For me, personally, Logan is my new favorite comic book movie of all time. I like it more than The Dark Knight, Civil War, Wonder Woman, Richard Donner's Superman and his cut of Superman II. And still, I love watching Nostalgia Critic episodes, and Doug's vlogs. Why? Because I love his style, the way he explains his opinions, and I trust him.
I know, from reading your comment from his Non-Review of Transformers The Last Knight, that his review negatively affected your opinion on him and his reviews, but I wouldn't say he's untrustworthy. He's been critical on movies I've loved before(Iron Man 3 being a big example), and I still trust him to voice his opinion on movies I haven't seen before. He even inspired me to give back my DVD of Michael Bay's Pearl Harbor(which is just awful), and even helped me gain a certain mindset of what I really want out of movies nowadays.
I don't think your a jerk for hating on his opinion, but I wouldn't let it be the deciding factor of how to judge him and his reviews from now on, because that is incredibly petty.
P.S. Also, do you really need to hate on the Marvel Cinematic Universe so much? I get that your not a fan, but come on...
7:25 and 12:34 In Deadpool 3, Wolverine is resurrected
man just find your channel and I have to say I LOVE IT its the videos are made so well and if I dont really agree with u thanks to your explenetaion I can understand why u have that opinion Im sorry if I have a bad english
i actually watched alot of animated wolverine shows when i was young, now that im older and seeing an ageing wolverine bad tempered, weary, serious, covered in scars and war hardened it really feels like i grew up watching and knowing wolverine or Jimmy as i like to call him
+joseph doyle I feel the exact same way. It really was the best way to end this version's of the character's legacy.
If you want to get realllyyyy technical with it, aren't there 3 wolverine movies?
X-Men Origins (it wasn't really and xmen movie, they just smacked the title in it)
The Wolverine
Logan
I personally like Wolverine more than Logan, don’t get me wrong I love Logan the characters is just so amazing and x-23 is the best but the reason why I like wolverine is that it’s the first time I see wolverine after that I became such a big fan of the character. I read a lot of comics I watched a bunch of movies
I DONT CARE ABOUT SPOLIERS
nice review like always man!,"other ppl" miss points alot sometimes not understanding where characters come from
+Nesty Thanks for that buddy. :) I am working on my next versus video right now.
Great video Eric :) !!!
Thanks a lot Wesley!
I really like Logan's soundtrack, particularly Forest Fight.
+Nick Hoad Likewise. I even like the final death soundtrack.
I wonder if your score on Logan has gone up recently, like with Aquaman.
even though I was 12 watching this movie I cried so hard in the end and I just walked out the theater with a red face, and my favorite scene was when logan said to xaviar it wasn't me!!!! when x-24 stabbed him in the chest, and seeing that gave me a jump, and this movie was perfect
Dragonfirestudios 233 nice, I feel like the most impactful moments was when Charles was like "I'm sorry, im so sorry" when he had the seizure at the casino, and when Laura called him daddy
+Dragonfirestudios 233 Agreed. The movie was awesome and I don't see any other comic book movie from this year and the next taking its place. Thanks so much for watching and commenting buddy!
No prob!!!!!
THE FEEEEEEEEEEEEELS
CGI Garbage Can
ROFLMFAO
One of the best videos I've ever seen ☺️☺️🤯🤯
If you think THIS video is one of the best you've seen. Then check out my more recent versus videos. I am proud to say that they have gotten significantly better over time.
Thanks for watching and commenting!
Beast is dead in the days of future past timeline which i think is the same as Logan’s so that’s probably why he’s not in it
That doctor strange joke was good bruh
This is ridicolous, Logan literally wins in everything against The Wolverine. Logan deserves a true contender.
The wolverine 8/10
Logan 10/10
Logan Vs. Dark knight??
The best of both, idc which ones win I love them both
Eric carter u make really great videos
+Trick shots and gaming That ms very much buddy. I really appreciate that. :)
Do Avengers 1 vs Avengers 2
+Henry Reinoso How about Justice League VS The Avengers?
The Film doesn't need future tech, it's apocalyptic where everything's run down
not being rude just saying something
Are you still going to do a video of Logan vs Deadpool?
There was SOME future stuff, like the auto trucks and the bad guys having guns for hands (I get they're like that in the comics). But there shouldn't be a ton of futuristic stuff, it's only 12 years in the future
dont you know in 12 years there will be space travel, spartan program and instantaneous teleportation
Wait... Yukio... setting up for DP2!
Yea she was at the end
Great Video, Your channel is underrated but awesome
Thanks for the kind words buddy. :)
All the best guys and wish you more success...and just like you After The Dark Knight Logan is my favourite superhero movie....
I agree that Loki is not exactly a villain. He is more like "chaos personified". He is anything he wants to be, which makes him such an interesting character to me.
9:27 why did you show loki on the screen? loki is a great villain
LOL Lmao
Not as good as you
I agree with many of the points regarding Logan and The Wolverine movies Eric. For me, The Wolverine felt underwhelming and boring. I enjoyed and loved Logan vastly more. Thank you very much for this video Eric, I really enjoyed hearing your view on them.
Dude, I know that it’s been a while since the dark knight rises came out...like 7 years, but I would actually enjoy sitting through a dark knight trilogy comparison. Because I think that it would be a cool video idea.
I need to get this of my chest it’s a cliche to have future tech in movies
Fantastic video keep up the good work you earned a sub!
+TheyCome FromTheSkies Thanks buddy. :) I am working on my next versus video right now.
Nice review, Eric. But I must say, with respect (and as a fan of the Wolverine comics pre 2000) The Wolverine was actually a movie that fans would enjoy more than non-comic book readers (for the most part, anyway, there was NO excuse for a means to EVER cut adamantium. EVER!). And Wolverine Origins was very faithful (again for the most part) to the Weapon X story, and most especially the Wolverine Sabretooth relationship. However, I will agree with anyone, that the "Deadpool" interpretation was probably it's greatest flaw/sin. That and I personally think that Gambit's character could have used a little upgrade (but that's just me). Despite these flaws mentioned (amongst others that both movies possess), it's safe to say that no comic book movie can ever be 100% like the comics and still be good (be it outfits, plot points, etc.) I considered both movies to be very close to the comics (yes, even with the love interests (which had purpose and are very iconic in the entire Wolverine canon)) and what personal complaints I have I already mentioned. That said, I can respect your review, as well as your point of view and preferences. You always make great vids, mate, this is just my two cents from my own point of view. Cheers to good movies, brother ;). Looking forward to your next vid. Again, great job.
+Jon D I. An understand your view point. The relationships I know ARE important and hold a lot of weight in the comics. It's just that in the movie's paticularily with The Wolverine, they ended up being sidelined and ignored which ultimately made them feel pointless in the movie's interpretation.
I'm glad you like my videos buddy. :) Thanks so much for watching and commenting!
Is Patrick Stewart better as Jean Luc Picard or Charles Xavier?
+Joseph He does an excellent job playing both. However I prefer him as Xavier.
Picard I like Xavier but why they killed him off in Logan that pissed me off.Plus he need to come back I hated James Mcavoy.
I really agree with that shade toward the nostalgia critic, he seems so only enjoy classics too, always hating on remakes. (A lot of remakes don't do well but he rarely gives them a chance)
"... a feat, no other superhero movie since The Dark Knight has reached!"
Joker (2019): *I'm about to shoot this mans whole career!*
Ehh joker is great but not as good as Logan and tdk
😂😂😂Good reference and underrated comment
Infinity War > all Marvel and Dc movies
2 for rated R marvel I think they learned a lesson.Will most likely see alot more rated R marvel movies! ^.^Dead Pool and Logan = Great reviews.
Most of Marvel belongs to Disney. So no.
Hold up.. He's not soo old.. As you stated.. He's suffering from adamantium poisoning... And its basically depleted his power to heal.. And remain young.. He still can take damage and heal.. But its slow and very painful to experience... As you saw in the beginning where he now has to physically push the bullets out of his tissue.. His healing factor is trying , yet struggling ..so now he has to meet his healing factor half way.. And if he received major trauma or excessive trauma he will die..
Well the movie does have some new technologies that we don't have but will have soon like self driving trucks and massive automatic farms, plus somewhat sci fi limb replacement
My top 5 superhero movies. (my personal opinion don't hate haha)
1. The Dark Knight
2. Logan
3. Hancock
4. Avengers: Age Of Ultron
5. The Dark Knight Rises
Missael Guzman-Ramos civil war was alright
The director, James mangold, said that he didn’t want the movie to look futuristic...he said that he wanted it to feel more gritty and in the middle of nowhere...he didn’t want it to be a world with high technology, as he just wanted it to be a world that hasn’t changed.
Wonder what the film would like with Beast instead of Plot Connivance Man
Yk what I wish they made a film called Logan Vs The Predator just like AVP except it’s wolverine fighting the predator which would be rated R due to being a horror with blood and gore and language obviously
Wolverine is 2 hours but it feels like 3 hours
The only part I appreciated in the Wolverine movie was the yakuza fight at the funeral and the ninja fight at the Yashida mansion (R version of course because of the blood and the added fight scene)
Just because a movie's set in the future doesn't mean it has to look futuristic. People living in the 1960's had that same sentiment about the year 2000 and onwards, and look at us today; no flying cars, no jet packs etc. If it was set a hundred years from now, I'd personally not be surprised if nothing was different.
Logan did have futuristic technology...there was the auto trucks before the family with the horses crashed, then later the big robot things in the corn fields aswell as the reavers' bionic limbs, but it made sense not to show much of it since it's not set too much in the future (only about 12 years) and most of the film is set in rural locations
Logan *does* have a prominently featured love interest; it's just not romantic love. His love for Laura (X-23) shines throughout the whole story.
It's a father daughter love
We need a vs video on the original trilogy of x men
one thing why I dont watch logan so much is because I always cry at the end and its hard to process that
Logan was really depressing to me and is my 1st favourite now
You should do the newer Point Break movie vs The original Point Break
+Corby Cunningham That's a good idea. Thanks for the suggestion!
Thanks, you keep up the good work!
Speaking of awesome movies like Logan, have you seen Children of Men? That film is an absolute masterpiece and the best science fiction I have personally seen so far this century.
The Wolverine was a good movie, except for the last act... But I liked the oriental adaptation.
Literaly LOGAN has ben the only marvel movie thats about a fictonal character brought to our world with our sences and emotions and is literali the definiton of GREAT you would want in an R reated and (especialy)
*The Wolverine*
The best thing about The Wolverine is the deleted scene where we see the comic accurate Wolverine suit
Eric how would u rank The Dark Knight trilogy
here is how I think Marvel Studio should continue the story, don't recast Logan make him stay dead and make X23 take the mantle as the All New Wolverine. Just like in the current comics!
If they would've kept the deleted end credit seen with The Wolverine movie.. oml it would've been the best thing ever just for that moment
Logan is arguably the next great superhero movie that nearly everybody (but not really everybody obviously) will remember fondly for years; the wolverine is basically what Logan eventually became but never could because of the studios and the lack of a good Deadpool movie and real reason to do so.
Logan's not dying because he's getting so old... The adamantium in his system is poisoning him. Besides this, love your videos man lol!
Keep up the work m8!
Thanks a lot buddy. :D
Logan's healing ability didn't slow down because of his age. It was because the adamantium was steadily poisoning him, though that's the most illogical sh*t ever, considering his cells regenerate almost instantly, but okay. Also, you may be tired of Wolverine being in love, but the thing that defines the Wolverine mythos is tragedy; the loss of the people he trusts & loves. He will undoubtedly outlive just about everyone he ever loves, which adds to his pain and fuels his RAGE. His love for Charles & Laura is what made him become the Wolverine again, in "Logan". He literally fought to the death, to protect the last person that he loved. Whether it was a romantic love, the love of a surrogate son for a surrogate father, or the love of a father for his daughter, Wolverine's story is all about fighting for what he loved.
I fell asleep in the theatre while watching the wolverine lol.
5 is a little low for The Wolverine. I'd give it 6.5 to 7.
I remember giving it a 6 when I first saw it in theatres. But after watching it the second time I gave it a 5. I saw Logan twice and I came away with the same 9/10 both times. Thanks for watching and commenting Eddie! I really appreciate it.
Eric Carter did you find the adamantium bullet death lazy?
Steve Rogers No, I personally liked it. It was a good story element to include and it was put to good use in the film's climax.
Ok actually yeah that review from doug actually kinda just irked me a bit. I'm usually all like, "have your own opinion" but I just did not understand his criticisms
I'm thinking of watching Logan but I'm not sure, thankfully this video helped me
There's love between Logan & Prof X, they're just too old to do anything about it. ;)
I really hope your joking.
Steve Lee Whaaa????
Eric Carter So am I.
Lol
All the other scifi films got it wrong man, there are no major change in technology in 2029!
10:35 our present day technology? The villain who tried to capture Laura had a half arm being robotic and it was fully functional which is not possible in 2023 so imagine in 2017
How does your channel not have at least 100,000 subscribers already? you're content is very good. I also agree with you I think Logan is an amazing movie! I do think the nude scene in the movie was unnecessary though.
One thing I don't understand is why logan didn't get adamantium poisoning when he lost his healing factor in the wolverine
What do you think guys?
The Wolverine would've been better if they moved on from Jean's love story, no Viper, Mariko's grandfather actually dead, no Silver Samurai and no ex boyfriend of Mariko.
So that will keep it at a small scale and give room for the important characters to shine. Like Logan, Yukio, Mariko, Mariko's corrupted husband and Shingen Yashida. just five characters that can shine through. Less is more.
For example of what could make the Wolverine better:
- If Logan moved on from Jean, his motivation in the film would be a bit clearer and us as the audience would root for him a bit more
Premise: A Japanese soldier during the Nagasaki bombings in his dying days, gives the reluctant Logan a job to protect Mariko from the Yakuza, Ninjas and her father who prevents her to take her place from her company. (It's simple)
- If Shingen was the main villain, he would be seen as a barrier of honour, just like in the Wolverine comic solo series. He is the reason why Mariko cannot takeover Yashida after her grandfather died.
- I think the idea with Logan struggling with the beast conquering over the man which Mariko hates but Yukio wants him to embrace. If they play that a bit more, Shingen could've used that as his advantage. Putting choices like the Joker did in the Dark Knight. The greater the pressure, the more of Wolverine's character being defined
- No taking away the healing factor. Seeing Logan's vulnerability is interesting but it's better to explore the humanity of him just like in the film Logan did.
- An R rating in the Japanese story would make the film better. Not because of the slicing/dicing but I feel like if Mangold really wanted the Japanese noir/samurai film with superhero characters is the way to go. The Yakuza and ninjas are ruthless to be PG 13
- Speaking of that, the fight scenes could've been a bit longer and a bit more meaningful to the point that you worry for the character like in the film Logan. The stakes will be high personally.
- Finally, if only the third act matches the tone of the film and not make it an X-Men movie, the film would be much better. Fight against the ninjas and Yakuzs a bit more. Have a sword fight against Shingen. Logan winning Mariko's heart and wants to marry him. Yukio finally walks free from the ninjas.
That definitely sounds better than what we ended up getting.
Logan felt like how The Wolverine was trying to be. The Wolverine would have been R as well, but sux stud- I mean Fox studios called it off. Hugh Jackman even had to take a pay cut to get this movie R rated.
i dunno the topless scene was just sorta... because but it was a nice little comedy moment of how wolverine would react. i mean he is a full time limo driver. he can't just claw drunk passengers.
logan shued have been the end of xmen franchise not dark pfenix
Dark Phoenix was *MEH*
Uhh I watched Dougs review of Logan and he loved the blood and gore in it. What are you talking about?
+The LOL Man Doug said both the violence and language was forced to remind you that the movie is a hard R. He was wrong. Thanks for watching and commenting!
Eric Carter it's true, Doug felt it was flashing its R rating which it wasn't. Doug should watch it again
Wanted to watch the video but haven't watched the movie as yet... Too many spoilers
ICE Starboy Well it's a good thing I left a spoiler warning at the beginning of the video. :)
I like logan better because i just like all the bloody and gorey violence from wolverine and Laura and x 24 cutting their arms and heads off and the wolverine has very less bloody violence but no gore where they dont bleed alot from getting stab or cut by wolverine claws but he never cuts off limbs and logan has more bloody violence and limbs getting cut off was more impressive.
I love that it's directed by the same guy, James Mangold. I absolutely hate The Wolverine. But it seems Mangold learned from that schlock storytelling so Logan was excellent.