Prokofiev - Classical Symphony - Celibidache, MPO (1988)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.พ. 2018
- Sergei Prokofiev - Symphony No. 1 in D major Op. 25 "Classical"
Munich Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sergiu Celibidache
Live recording: 1988
Watch the rehearsal footage here: • Prokofieff - Classical... - เพลง
i've never heard this symphony played so elegantly and clearly before. he played it as if i've never heard it. how beautiful the melody flows. what a performance!
Especially the larghetto is so utterly beautiful
The clarity and phrasing are impeccable. So many orchestras play this piece as a throwaway. For them it's a foot race from start to finish and much that is in the score cannot be heard. Celibidache lovingly presents the Prokofiev as the jewel that it is!
Questo direttore mi fa impazzire. Unico straordinario
Ett koncentrat av den klassiska musiken med den främste dirigenten genom tiderna❤️
It sounds so beautiful in this tempo, it lets the music breath. And I love that conductor apparently loves this symphony :)
I love this version. So elegant, so pure, so enjoyable! My favorite of all versions :)
Nowadays , most of classic music are played too fast and we lost the soul of everything, the time of living a time of dreaming in it and with Mr Celidibache we feel the lost dimension of space in time inside each note everything his time deeper it's much better like that.
With his "slow" style Celi got and squeezed to the last drop of the juice of beauty
We all know that the second movement is already marked largo which means slow! So l found it so amusing that this celebrated brilliant, now legendary conducter, would still insist on slowing down even the slow movement of this symphony to a snail's pace!!!!. But what a stroke of genius this was!!! I suddenly found myself hearing certain nuances in this piece that I never knew existed!!! And these nuances could only be heard at this seemingly absurd elementary pace!!! Continue to flow maestro Sergio at your own pace because l have discovered you can do no wrong!!!!!......
Celibidache had a great sense of rythm which I've very rarely seen in other conductors.
Cuanto amo esta sinfonia!
this is a truly musical performance. i love it, cant get enough of it
Prokofiev is so underrated. here he shows that he totally knows how to "do" the romantic style in this nice recording. For something a bit more extravagant try Alexander Nevsky!
Brilliant !
Me gustó demasiado esta interpretación.
Gracias por compartir.
Me gustó mucho esta interpretación.
Gracias por compartir.
I really love this, and don't mind the fact that it's slower than the versions I'm used to. Watching the conductor ham it up is also adding to the pleasure. I'm pretty good at reading micro expressions, and you can see the "professorial" aspect of his conducting come through. It's interesting to notice a lot of the players are paying a lot more attention than usual to the conductor given that he's conducting it so much more slowly than what the score must indicate.
This tempo is just right and it makes this symphony even more classical!
Lebhafte und gut detaillierte live Aufführung dieses pseudoklassischen Meisterwerks mit seidigen Töne aller Streicher und milden Töne aller Bläser. Der erfahrene Maestro dirigiert das kompakte und ausgezeichnete Orchester im relativ langsamen Tempo mit perfekt kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach wunderschön!
God bless Him
This interpretation is nothing short of a revelation for me,ok I understand the criticism of the slow tempos,but the it allows the music to breath,and the sound quality is astonishing.
Merci beaucoup
I like the slow interpretations of Celibidache.
By That way you have the opportunity to hear all the detailles
it is very joyfull to listen to this.
YES someone who understand why that piece is so well conducted
Outrageous advertisement in the middle of the performance
The best!
5:00 Larghetto
10:38 Gavotte
12:43 Finale Molto Vivace
4:40 I like how he feels the music 😅
Genio♥️
Amazing indeed!
Un fuoriclasse
Celibidace bräuchte kein Stab, noch eine Bewegung. Sein Gesichtsausdruck zeigt alles!
Concertmaster is Ingolf Turban? so young!
How mutable is the world ！
Life is full of vicissitudes .
3:04.. My teacher is playing Trumpet!
0:07
0:19
2:07
4:32
7:45
12:31
Es un tema para estudiar. La interpretación del ensayo, es mejor que la del directo. Son de las pocas interpretaciones autorizadas por el Maestro.
Grazie! Great 1:47 🌹
洋阿相
質問！第1楽章の速度表記はallegroではないのですか？第2楽章はLentoですか？
これがチェリビダッケ先生のプロコフィエフ・スタイルですか？この演奏で古典交響曲を初めて聞いた方は作品の評価を間違えてしまうのでは？
[5:24] Does anyone know what this lady's name is ?
느림의 미학...
i like slow interpretations - if they're proportionate to other tempi, and if they have an underlying pulse. celli's are sluggish. the classical symphony of prokoviev is one of the most brilliant sounding pieces written. not so here. maybe he liked a piece to last longer than it should. you can also 'hear' everything at faster tempi. i.e. szell.
I didn't like this interpretation but after repeatedly listening I found it very tasty and love it. This is the pieve where people are split in halves -many dislikes Celli's slow tempo and others hate Gergiev brutally fast tempo. Me personally preffer this although Gergiev did also slower tempo. Anyway I found it important that we have also this slow Celli's tempo so we can compare and have a discussion. Moreover I love when I can choose from so many interpretations (and not only based on instruments playing) but also tempo.
I think that Cellibidache was, more than many conductors, a teacher. Both to audiences and to orchestras. To get an orchestra to play musically at a slower tempo taxes their preconceptions of the music. It also challenges their temperament, a tendency to hurry along, mentally in rehearsal and consequently in performance as well. This tendency applies to many conductors I might add. One should note that this video was of a rehearsal, not a concert. That might have played a part in the tempi as well. Finally, I must say that especially in the finale, I think the tempo was spot on. Why? Because the orchestra was able to articulate the fast passages very cleanly. In many recordings the fast passages are simply sloppily played as the tempo is impossibly fast. This should never happen.
@@eagle1ear th-cam.com/video/NpLsHBC43tc/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=MusicLover I wouldn't call this a sloppy live performance.
2:35
It looked like one of violin players thinking “fuuuuuuck why is this soooo damn slow…” 😉🤣🤣 In all seriousness though, it was nice to hear a different perspective at a slower tempo. Still prefer a fast speed….
4:20 anticipo
If you look carefully, you can find a Sean Aston look like in the violin section and a Elijah Wood look alike in the clarinet section…🤣
For the purists commenting on the slow speed: if you watch it at 1.25x the tempo will sound closer to typical for this piece, and of course the sound quality will suffer. It's probably a good idea to revert to normal speed for the fourth movement!
雖然不知道有沒有會講中文的，但我還是留個言好了，看到這句話的老外會以為我在發表什麼長篇大論呢？想到就想笑。喔對了這個指揮某個角度看有點像川普。
:DDD
Under tempo, but good.
Ha ammazzato anche questa, però è un omicida di classe!
Questo è un commento che mi piace, ti tengo. Assassino di rara brillantezza ma così son buoni tutti. Klemperer era l'unico a tenere tempi lenti e con tensione e "senso" sempre, Celibidache? Basta dire che non ha mai diretto i cantanti (la cosa più difficile dell'emisfero boreale) in un'opera...e ho detto tutto.
Dissenso amici. Le andature lente sono difficilissime e senti tutti gli strumenti. Le andature veloci spesso sono sporche e coprono imperfezioni. De gustibus ....
5:00
Not slow enough
por que sera que celibidache siempre dirige tan lento?
- Hay que comer lento para saborear gustos y matices y la digestión sea saludable.
- Un placer o un dolor, es más intenso cuanto más lento.
- Cuanto mayor te haces, más saboreas cada instante...casi parando el tiempo.
- Es más dificil dirigir lento, y que no se caiga todo el andamiaje. Y sobre todo es necesario un conocimiento absoluto de las fuerzas tectónicas que rigen la orquesta. Y un tempo de acero.
Tengo entendido que él tenía una influencia relacionada al hinduismo o budismo, o algo así. Entonces, debemos saber que en el hinduismo se tiene mucho a la importancia al sonido, que penetre en el alma. A ello le llaman mantra. Por ello es que usted puede ver a hunduistas y hasta budistas decir "Ohm" mientras cierran los ojos y lo hacen lento. Ello justifica el porqué el Maestro lo hace lento.
Pero, ajenos a ello, Kemplerer (en las obras de Beethoven) y Knappertsbusch (En la 3ra de Beethoven) también lo hacen lento. Y puedo decir, en lo personal, que la de Knappertsbusch es una de las más asombrosas que he escuchado.
Un saludo desde el Perú
No entiendes nada. Ve te a comer un asado.
Too slow, by far!
celibidache always do all pieces TOO slow for some reason
What's the point to rush? In faster tempo many melodic parts are just buried. Here Celi nicely "extracted" them out and really enjoy them.
Play it 1.25x its nice
@@Titanandenceladus Ha! Genius
@@larumbemar hahahha its the complete oppisite
ich wünschte, er würde nicht herumbrüllen, "Dü", "Dü". Das stört und ist respektlos den Musikern gegenüber
Es ist Eine Probe.
Dreadful. 1st mvt sounds like a rehearsal tempo. Should be great once they take the tempo Prokofiev actually indicated in the score, minim = 100 or nearly twice as fast as Celi. But what did Sergei know, he's only the composer.
It is a rehearsal.
Too slow.