Every concert I attended with Celibidache conducting was a major event. You has the correct feeling that it was something you would never forget no matter longer how long you lived.
Playing slow is harder than dashing through the musical piece. An excellent example of bringing forward emotions and tunes that otherwise would be missed. This is a very refreshing and unique reading of Tchaikovsky's music.
Impressionante la somiglianza tra la spalla e Gigi Marzullo. Scemenze a parte il grande Celibidache mi ha fatto riscoprire e ascoltare in modo piú coinvolgente questo capolavoro di Chaikovski. Quasi quasi la preferisco alla sesta. Straordinario Celibidache, grande orchestra!
@@paololaconi4036questa è una cantonata colossale. James Levine al tempo di questo concerto era già direttore musicale del Metropolitan di New York da 8 anni!
Caro Raffaele! Celibidache, il cui Bruckner a Monaco nel 1990/91 mi ha cambiato davvero la vita, almeno come musicologo, è per me inseiem a Toscanini e a Furtwängler il più grande direttore d'orchestra del XX secolo (di quelli del XXI non ho neanche voglia di parlarne...). Grazie!!
This Tchaikovsky's 5th symphony, MPO and Celibidache, all together move me to tears, make me cry out of happiness since the very first note until the last one. Immense ¡¡ @Friedrich Edelmann, the bassoon soloist, magnificent!!!
Quelle majestueuse interprétation! Les tempi choisis pour chaque mouvement rendent à cette symphonie toute sa dramaturgie. Quant au Maestrissimo Celibidache, il est comme toujours admirable de maîtrise et de retenue. Souvenons-nous des quatorze concerts donnés à la tête de l'Orchestre National de l'O. R. T. F. devenu Orchestre National de France pendant qu'il était Chef Principal.
Wow... it's been said a lot already but I'm continually amazed how he can take such slow tempos yet make everything work so wonderfully. I'm blown away, wasnt expecting his Tchaikovsky to be this good. The orchestra also is absolutely fantastic, rivals some of the "big name" orchestras.
And the even more extraordinary thing is that "how does" he made it available to everyone, explained it, told it, made it understood and without ever getting tired of explaining it and replicating it precisely because he fully believed that" we are music", that is, all human beings. I advise you to listen to some Celibid interview which and then, absolutely important to understand, especially this question of " slow times "the lesson" ideas about music " - RTSI. You can find it on youtube, it's in Italian but there are also English subtitles. Now if I find it, I'll point it to you. Welcome to us. Here is the link th-cam.com/video/IcvLYXp0Vbs/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=RaffaeleNapoli
That was his specific approach to music, and I completely agree, even about piano music, sound should be let to form and gain power.If you play everything fast and faster...there-s no vibration anymore,Just percution.I think the tempo is just perfect for the music.
Interpretazione stupenda nel solo del corno con il pianissimo degli archi che lega perfettamente con il corno del resto fantastico, grande maestro Celibidache.
How do you all decide who is the best conductor? Based on the similarity of preferred kind of interpretation, based on who moved you the most (or in this case, what Celibidache calls "trancendental experience"), or what?
1:00 Andante - Allegro con anima (E minor) - Molto più tranquillo (D major - E major) 18:40 Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza (B minor - D major) - Non allegro (F♯ minor) -Andante maestoso con piano (D major) 36:10 Valse. Allegro moderato (A major) (Trio in F♯ minor) 43:02 Finale: Andante maestoso (E major) - Allegro vivace - Molto vivace (E minor) - Moderato assai e molto maestoso - Presto (E major)
Terzo e quarto tempo spesso negletti e declassati ad accompagnamento dei primi due tempi sono qui perfettamente integrati nell’ opera, profondissimi! Fantastico Maestro!
What is that magic, at the second i listen Celibidache i breath better!
3 ปีที่แล้ว +17
Sin duda alguna el Maestro Celibidache fué una de las grandes figuras de la historia de los directores de orquesta,no solo por su estilo que lo hace único, amado por unos y criticado por otros, un gran artista.
Durante mi juventud no comprendía ni reconocia a Celibidache. Que equivocado q estaba. Ud Hace magia con su batuta. Magistral como logra la quinta sinfonía
Tchaikovsky should be one of the most misunderstood musicians, the deepness in his music is único, of corse swan lake and nutcracker, is part but his most The symphonies are great master works, and his chamber music are exceptional Hope this work brings to mind of many what is a deepness of concept
Celibidache was in fact Greek descent : Σέργιος Τσελεπιδάκης Perhaps the most sincere and authentic conductor. Mathematician , philosopher (doctoral studies at the Friedrich Wilhelm University in Berlin where he studied philosophy with Nicolai Hartmann). He had the German perfection (Hochschule für Musik in Berlin). He had the French style (he was buried in the Cimetière de Neuville sur Essone). And yes, somehow he was Romanian...
@@michelsimion5134 He had the Romanian style and the romanian psyche. Lots of Romanians are descendant from Greeks, that does not mean we are less Romanian. Quite frankly it strengthenes the romanianess even more. There's nothing western about him, he shouts, he is passion and sometimes he is an arrogant douche. He has all the Romanian psychological characteristics. The reason why he slow down the tempo because it's fits the religiosity of the Romanian mind shaped by the greatness of orthodox christianity. The great Romanian composer Dimitrie Cuclin had exactly the same philosophical and spiritual vision of slowing things down in a manner. You should listen to him, he is on par with Bruckner.
@@michelsimion5134 dacă te cheamă michel și nu mihai încep să mă lămuresc. în fond, de dragul adevărului trebuie adus la cunoștință și faptul că mama era româncă născută Brăteanu. deci, așadar și prin urmare luând în considerare tradiția evreilor, par examplu, nația se stabilește după originea mamei. nu de alta, dar cine e mama se știe sigur pe când tatăl poate fi doar confundat cu cel oficial.
Un grande direttore sa valorizzare un opera un mediocre direttore, la stessa opera, la rende banale. Qui sta la differenza e la grandezza di Celibidache
Mi sento di condividere questa affermazione e aggiungo che Celibidache è stato anche generoso perché non si è risparmiato mai nell'offrire agli altri i suggerimenti e indicare la via da percorrere per ottenere gli stessi risultati e gli stessi livelli di consapevolezza.
It is not a miracle it is the difference between musicians and those who do not understand anything about music. Whoever does not understand anything falls asleep, whoever understands instead enjoys it!
@@MrBohuslav sens of humor? “Fall asleep” it's not just a joke. Judging Celibidache's times as "too slow" was the torment of Celibidache's life. Making jokes about this does not imply “sens of humor” but is instead an indication of pure idiocy, it means not understanding that you are playing with fire and in addition to not having understood anything it makes you accomplices of the ignorance that surrounds us, other than “sens of humor”.
Second Trombone: Abbie Conant, right? Fighting for years and years for her right as a woman to play first trombone (Celi: ‚You know the problem, we need a man for the first trombone position‘)
If I were the 100th person in line to state that Celi was a supernatural being and the greatest genius ever holding a baton, would that be more to your taste?
@@joachimsaxer4812 I would have reacted the same way here. I find all comments idiotic, both from inconclusive "detractors" and "fanatical" idolaters 😉
@Joachim Saxer I'm glad that in that interview she played a bit. She played cruelly, horrible, and I haven't heard anything so bad. No wonder that Maestro Sergiu Celibidache did not tolerate such a thing.
This reading spoiled me. Even though I know that his tempi are much too slow compared to what Tchaikovsky actually asks for, and for example Karajan is much closer to the composer's ideas of how fast it should be played, this here just works. So much that I think Tchaikovsky was wrong and Celibidache was right.
![คบซ้อน - วงL.กฮ. [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5MtesqJ0I1c/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D3 | Summer | ไม่อยากเหนื่อยวันเสาร์ ก็ต้องจัดเต็ม](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CbsHmoJXjvE/mqdefault.jpg)
Every concert I attended with Celibidache conducting was a major event. You has the correct feeling that it was something you would never forget no matter longer how long you lived.
Onoare și glorie eternă Sergiu Celibidache! Cel mai mare dintre cei mai mari dirijori mondiali !
Celibidache one of the conductor of the century
I am shocked!!! This is one of the best interpretations ever!!!
Try to listen to Leopold Stokowski's...!
Grande maestro, grazie!
Playing slow is harder than dashing through the musical piece. An excellent example of bringing forward emotions and tunes that otherwise would be missed. This is a very refreshing and unique reading of Tchaikovsky's music.
YES IT’S TRUE!
Un simț perfect al muzicii!! 💙💛❤️Celibidache!!
Finally, a Tchai 5 that doesn't sound hysterical. Fantastic performance.
Wrong! Tchai 5 is hysterical!.
Pure garbage. Celi is a joke.
Impressionante la somiglianza tra la spalla e Gigi Marzullo. Scemenze a parte il grande Celibidache mi ha fatto riscoprire e ascoltare in modo piú coinvolgente questo capolavoro di Chaikovski. Quasi quasi la preferisco alla sesta. Straordinario Celibidache, grande orchestra!
Colui che chiami "spalla" è James Levine che diventerà, a sua volta, direttore d'orchestra.
@@paololaconi4036questa è una cantonata colossale. James Levine al tempo di questo concerto era già direttore musicale del Metropolitan di New York da 8 anni!
@@rasdrapano È vero !
He makes us all inhab it ..... take tempo and smell all there in.....what an example........ SO REAL so true...and how rare...
Un mare dirijor își motivează orchestra să fie perfectă! Respect Sergiu Celibidache.
Caro Raffaele! Celibidache, il cui Bruckner a Monaco nel 1990/91 mi ha cambiato davvero la vita, almeno come musicologo, è per me inseiem a Toscanini e a Furtwängler il più grande direttore d'orchestra del XX secolo (di quelli del XXI non ho neanche voglia di parlarne...). Grazie!!
Ottimo.
Maestro lo vada a dire a quei due sapientoni ignoranti di Stinchelli e Suozzo
Makes me proud to be Romanian!
Sergiu Celibidache did it again! Masterpiece!
This Tchaikovsky's 5th symphony, MPO and Celibidache, all together move me to tears, make me cry out of happiness since the very first note until the last one. Immense ¡¡ @Friedrich Edelmann, the bassoon soloist, magnificent!!!
Me to
Stupenda musica.. grazie Celibidache e a tutta l' orchestra ❤
EXCEPȚIONAL ȘI ORCHESTRA ȘI MAESTRUL SERGIU CELIBIDACHE, OOOFFF DOAMNE, CE PĂCAT CĂ NU-L MAI AVEM ÎN VIATĂ
Celibidache e genial….
Celi je najveci dirigent svih vremena jednostavno fenomen!
Mereu e sărbătoare la mîne în suflet când ascult această minunată simfonie! Mulțumesc pentru împărtășire!
Quelle majestueuse interprétation! Les tempi choisis pour chaque mouvement rendent à cette symphonie toute sa dramaturgie. Quant au Maestrissimo Celibidache, il est comme toujours admirable de maîtrise et de retenue. Souvenons-nous des quatorze concerts donnés à la tête de l'Orchestre National de l'O. R. T. F. devenu Orchestre National de France pendant qu'il était Chef Principal.
Wow... it's been said a lot already but I'm continually amazed how he can take such slow tempos yet make everything work so wonderfully. I'm blown away, wasnt expecting his Tchaikovsky to be this good. The orchestra also is absolutely fantastic, rivals some of the "big name" orchestras.
And the even more extraordinary thing is that "how does" he made it available to everyone, explained it, told it, made it understood and without ever getting tired of explaining it and replicating it precisely because he fully believed that" we are music", that is, all human beings. I advise you to listen to some Celibid interview which and then, absolutely important to understand, especially this question of " slow times "the lesson" ideas about music " - RTSI. You can find it on youtube, it's in Italian but there are also English subtitles. Now if I find it, I'll point it to you. Welcome to us.
Here is the link
th-cam.com/video/IcvLYXp0Vbs/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=RaffaeleNapoli
That was his specific approach to music, and I completely agree, even about piano music, sound should be let to form and gain power.If you play everything fast and faster...there-s no vibration anymore,Just percution.I think the tempo is just perfect for the music.
With the slow movement its impossible to hold back the tears. The greatest slow movement from the romantic era in my opinion!
Grande direttore con una spiccata personalità artistica
Merci beaucoup
A very nuanced and beautiful performance by a great orchestra and conductor.
Interpretazione stupenda nel solo del corno con il pianissimo degli archi che lega perfettamente con il corno del resto fantastico, grande maestro Celibidache.
Sublime,merci. Un génie Monsieur Celibidache.
こんな映像が残されていたんですね。チェリビダッケはチャイ５を人見に聴きに行きましたが、人見がこれほど鳴ったのは後にも先にも聞いた事のない、凄まじい音でした。こんなもの生で聴けた幸せを胸に抱いて生きていきます。
Great timpanist and great performance. So rare to see a real red blooded timpanist.
ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL ! I LOVE HIS TALENT., HIS ABILITIES TO INTERPRET THE PIECE....AND DELIVER IT TO IT'S ZENITH AND BEAUTY.
O incantare sunteti Maestre! Si o orchestra pe masura!
MAESTRO......... MASTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
5番でこれほどの感動のを呼ぶ演奏は・・・空前絶後です。
Is great celibidache to do Tchaikovsky , who’s regularly misunderstood, Celibidache and Tchaikovsky two geniuses
Siempre en nuestros corazones,Maestro Celibidache💝
Sergiu, you are my HERO!!!!!! I am a student even 30 years after University!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wonderful. The best conductor ever.
No, best was Furtwängler.
How do you all decide who is the best conductor? Based on the similarity of preferred kind of interpretation, based on who moved you the most (or in this case, what Celibidache calls "trancendental experience"), or what?
@@wolfgangperner3082 no is Sergiu Celibidache
What about the mad monk guy?
So a great performance.
Прекрасная интерпретация Чайковского. Изумительные темпы. Нет бешеных темпов, и ничего не затянуто. Челибидаке - бог!
Un monumento a la esperanza,la grandeza y la buena voluntad es la gran sinfonia 5 de Tchaikovsky...Great slow performance by the great Celibidache!
Thank You!!💖💖💖
1:00 Andante - Allegro con anima (E minor) - Molto più tranquillo (D major - E major)
18:40 Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza (B minor - D major) - Non allegro (F♯ minor) -Andante maestoso con piano (D major)
36:10 Valse. Allegro moderato (A major) (Trio in F♯ minor)
43:02 Finale: Andante maestoso (E major) - Allegro vivace - Molto vivace (E minor) - Moderato assai e molto maestoso - Presto (E major)
Terzo e quarto tempo spesso negletti e declassati ad accompagnamento dei primi due tempi sono qui perfettamente integrati nell’ opera, profondissimi!
Fantastico Maestro!
What is that magic, at the second i listen Celibidache i breath better!
Sin duda alguna el Maestro Celibidache fué una de las grandes figuras de la historia de los directores de orquesta,no solo por su estilo que lo hace único, amado por unos y criticado por otros, un gran artista.
Esecuzione maestosa e molto intima...straordinaria!
Tremendous masterpiece of music.
Este Andante Cantabile me hace llorar de emoción desde la 1a nota hasta la última. Delicioso Celebidache
This is surprisingly exciting
legend celibidache！ NO.4moment let me😭
Siempre que me siento perdido,vuelvo a esta Gran Interpretacio'n del Maestro Celi, me llena el Alma!!!!.-
Atâta minune!!!
Monumental !!
RESPECT!
Finalmente si sente la musica... grazie...il Maestro.C. rimane il Top
Tchaikovsky siempre!
This conductor is stunning. What an education!
Durante mi juventud no comprendía ni reconocia a Celibidache. Que equivocado q estaba. Ud Hace magia con su batuta. Magistral como logra la quinta sinfonía
Desde mi perspectiva, el Maestro Celibidache es el mejor director de orquesta de todos los tiempos!
Tchaikovsky should be one of the most misunderstood musicians, the deepness in his music is único, of corse swan lake and nutcracker, is part but his most
The symphonies are great master works, and his chamber music are exceptional
Hope this work brings to mind of many what is a deepness of concept
Grazie, Raffaele. Un ascolto che è un'esperienza mistica. Ilaria
Un genio
Потрясающе!
MAESTRO!!!!!!!!! why you are not with us??? ............
I wish he were........... The BEST¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
Super !
Estasi sinfonica, grazie a due splendidi MAESTRI...
He was/IS a romanian conductor, I'm very proud of that - if I'm aloud to. Great musician, astonishing performance (like usual).
allowed*
Celibidache was in fact Greek descent : Σέργιος Τσελεπιδάκης
Perhaps the most sincere and authentic conductor. Mathematician , philosopher (doctoral studies at the Friedrich Wilhelm University in Berlin where he studied philosophy with Nicolai Hartmann). He had the German perfection (Hochschule für Musik in Berlin). He had the French style (he was buried in the Cimetière de Neuville sur Essone). And yes, somehow he was Romanian...
@@michelsimion5134 Celibidache came from romainian word celibe ithen Simion is Romanian name
@@michelsimion5134 He had the Romanian style and the romanian psyche. Lots of Romanians are descendant from Greeks, that does not mean we are less Romanian. Quite frankly it strengthenes the romanianess even more. There's nothing western about him, he shouts, he is passion and sometimes he is an arrogant douche. He has all the Romanian psychological characteristics. The reason why he slow down the tempo because it's fits the religiosity of the Romanian mind shaped by the greatness of orthodox christianity. The great Romanian composer Dimitrie Cuclin had exactly the same philosophical and spiritual vision of slowing things down in a manner. You should listen to him, he is on par with Bruckner.
@@michelsimion5134 dacă te cheamă michel și nu mihai încep să mă lămuresc. în fond, de dragul adevărului trebuie adus la cunoștință și faptul că mama era româncă născută Brăteanu. deci, așadar și prin urmare luând în considerare tradiția evreilor, par examplu, nația se stabilește după originea mamei. nu de alta, dar cine e mama se știe sigur pe când tatăl poate fi doar confundat cu cel oficial.
19:51 Eric Terwilliger on the 1st horn! Like Furtwängler said: So geblasen schwebt es (blow so that it hovers). Great, thx!
No soy fan de las sinfonías de Tchaïkovski, pero con Celibidache es otra cosa
Grazie mille!
Grazie mille ciao .
Un grande direttore sa valorizzare un opera un mediocre direttore, la stessa opera, la rende banale. Qui sta la differenza e la grandezza di Celibidache
Mi sento di condividere questa affermazione e aggiungo che Celibidache è stato anche generoso perché non si è risparmiato mai nell'offrire agli altri i suggerimenti e indicare la via da percorrere per ottenere gli stessi risultati e gli stessi livelli di consapevolezza.
Grazie, Raffaele, per il post!
Bellissima video
Grazie a voi
Saluti da Marsiglia !!!!!!
Superb - What a Man !
Superman ! 😅 🤟🏻😜💎
Multumesc
alin radeanu Cu placere
참으로 귀하고 소중한 영상입니다~!!!
Vision personnel mais valable !
Fantástico!!!
EXQUISITO DIRECTOR
If you like Tschaikovsky with a strong bent to heavy Germanic music, then this is actually very good...i enjoyed it..
Horn Solo, 2nd Movement: 2 minutes, 30 seconds.
Holy Shitttt, amazing
Listen to the 1st Horn Eric Terwilliger. Richard Allen Fiske Celibidache _What an Unbelievable Maestro.
Ciao, amicco RFFwlw...Tanti grazie...
A miracle indeed! (that the musicians do not fall asleep)
It is not a miracle it is the difference between musicians and those who do not understand anything about music. Whoever does not understand anything falls asleep, whoever understands instead enjoys it!
And this is the difference between people having a certain sense of humour and people having not a certain sense of humour
@@MrBohuslav sens of humor? “Fall asleep” it's not just a joke. Judging Celibidache's times as "too slow" was the torment of Celibidache's life. Making jokes about this does not imply “sens of humor” but is instead an indication of pure idiocy, it means not understanding that you are playing with fire and in addition to not having understood anything it makes you accomplices of the ignorance that surrounds us, other than “sens of humor”.
Diagnosis confirmed: definitely no sense of humour
How deeply I disagree with this statement......pacing ...delayed gratification !!!!!
Sergiu rege até com a ajuda das sobrancelhas, agitadas durante a execução.
The Great Celibidache
Second Trombone: Abbie Conant, right? Fighting for years and years for her right as a woman to play first trombone (Celi: ‚You know the problem, we need a man for the first trombone position‘)
oh, and ... the purpose of this comment? After reading it, what musical benefit do we derive from it? 🤔
If I were the 100th person in line to state that Celi was a supernatural being and the greatest genius ever holding a baton, would that be more to your taste?
@@joachimsaxer4812 I would have reacted the same way here. I find all comments idiotic, both from inconclusive "detractors" and "fanatical" idolaters 😉
You are inappropriately rude.
@Joachim Saxer
I'm glad that in that interview she played a bit. She played cruelly, horrible, and I haven't heard anything so bad. No wonder that Maestro Sergiu Celibidache did not tolerate such a thing.
I like the tribute to the dead channel Addiobelpassato.
צ'ייקובסקי הוא צ'ייקובסקי !
מה אתה אומר בדיוק?
צ’ייקובסקי של צליבידקה הוא צ’ייקובסקי או לא?
55:38 best final ever
🥰😍💘💘💘💘❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sound QUALITY is...
!!
Optisch ist dieses Video wegen seiner veralteten Aufnahmetechnik kein echter Genuss, akustisch aber schon - trotz aller Widergabeschwächen.
Perché di questo video non si può fare il download?
th-cam.com/video/dbYmJotXr2w/w-d-xo.html
Start 1:06
Finale 43:06
This reading spoiled me. Even though I know that his tempi are much too slow compared to what Tchaikovsky actually asks for, and for example Karajan is much closer to the composer's ideas of how fast it should be played, this here just works.
So much that I think Tchaikovsky was wrong and Celibidache was right.
Quotenwagnerianer ..Pyotr would be pulling his hair out.
Sak