The Best Pistol for Concealed Carry? 9mm vs. .45 ACP | Ammo Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มิ.ย. 2024
- Which is better, the 9mm or the .45 ACP? This is the age-old question that Greg Essenlohr and Matt Ferland from Otis Technology will be diving into in today's video. We will be putting these bad boys to the test, testing both the 9mm and the .45 ACP on plastic bottles, watermelons, metal, and more! See first hand how the impact, and results vary between each pistol, and how even changing the type of bullet can affect the testing outcome. Matt and Greg will also be giving us a quick history lesson on the 9mm and the .45 ACP, and how these two handguns have been used throughout history.
Stick around to the end of the video to see a guest appearance from the 10 mm, one of Matt’s favorites!
►VIDEO CHAPTERS
Intro: 0:00
9mm vs. .45 ACP Ammo Differences: 0:51
Ammo History: 3:22
What ammo is right for you?: 5:52
Different Bullets and Their Features: 10:21
Gun Size/Comfortability : 14:15
9 mm vs 45 ACP Shooting Test (Bottle): 16:20
9 mm vs 45 ACP Shooting Test (Watermelon): 18:49
Hollow Point) vs FMJ (Watermelon): 22:23
9 mm vs 45 ACP Shooting Test (Steel Plate): 25:05
Recoil Differences: 27:21
10 mm Comparison Test: 29:45
Final Thoughts: 31:19
Outro: 34:18
►ABOUT OTIS
Otis Technology was born in 1985 when our founder, a 16-year-old Doreen Garrett, fell into cold mud while deer hunting with her father. The barrel of her grandfather’s Model 94 Winchester was full of mud and the day's hunt was over.
That day sparked the beginning of an endeavor to create a smarter solution to a problem every hunter, soldier, shooter, and firearm owner has encountered. On that day, Doreen had a vision for innovating gun care. That is where we began, in the mud, pulled down by our roots to reveal a tireless drive to create a quality product that will serve the men and women that depend on their firearms to feed their families and protect our country. Now, it is our uncompromising purpose and the big picture reason why we show up to work every day.
At Otis, our mission is to rethink and redefine gun care, giving gun owners better and smarter ways to keep their most cherished firearms in the best condition possible. That’s why our products are American-made and backed by a No-Nonsense Guarantee.
We are #AmericasGunCare.
►CHECK US OUT!
Facebook: / otistechnology
Instagram: otistechnology
TH-cam: / otistechnology
Website: otistec.com/
Full30: www.full30.com/channel/otiste...
Subscribe today: th-cam.com/users/OtisTech...
►FEATURED PRODUCTS
Pistol Ripcords:
otistec.com/45-cal-pistol-rip...
otistec.com/38-cal-9mm-357-ca...
Pistol Cleaning Kits:
otistec.com/9mm-pistol-cleani...
otistec.com/45-cal-pistol-cle...
otistec.com/universal-pistol-...
otistec.com/professional-pist...
Lubricants/Cleaners:
shooters-choice.com/fp-10-lub...
shooters-choice.com/mc-7-bore...
shooters-choice.com/synthetic...
Hearing Protection:
otistec.com/earshield-hearing...
Song ID: MB01DK0AJMSLMH9 - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Glad to see a lot of .45 ACP in circulation these days!
It comes down to your personal preference. I love carrying my 9mm and I switch them in and out of my rotation every now and again. With that being said more often I'm going to carry my compact 45 Glock just because of the power and it will definitely stop the threat.
Any pew pew will work when SHTF. I’d rather have something vs nothing. But I will say thank God for the 45.
Both calibers are OK, but the 45 is more powerful and have advatage
I personally own & my EDC is my Glock G21. I absolutely love that 13+1 .45 capacity!!
What holster do you use?
Personally, I love my .40S&W, G23. 👍
I’m (71 years old been carry my “colt GOV. 80 for long time, and love it!!
Been watching the body cam police shows on tv. I was surprised at how many times a perp was hit (some multiple on one guy) with 9mm and didn’t go down.
Same
With the correct barrel length, and the correct speed behind the bullet. The 9 mm is plenty to take down a full size man.. unfortunately today handguns have only gotten shorter and shorter… while ammo has gotten hotter and hotter.. so we keep running into the same problem where we don’t get ballistic improvement no matter what we do… the best specifications for whatever handgun round you and it will be more than enough… for instance I would rather have 35 inch barrel where I could get some serious speed out of that 9 mm hollowpoint.. rather than a little that will only produce 3/4 of the same speed and performance…
One of the main reasons why my duty rifle is a 5.56 16 inch 1/7 twist AR, and my emergency combat rifle is a 20 inch loaded with 55gr.. the way it was designed to be the most lethal
Great discussion fellas. Whether it's the 9mm or the .45ACP, it really boils down to one's personal preference. 😎
Like my 45. Mainly for going off grid. Normally just stick to my 380 while on grid or near town, 9 mm seems like you need more rds. In grid down them magic hollow points for 9 or 45 might be hard to get. But fmj 45 work good. Fmj 9 mm do not work well. We learned in the 90s.
9mm overall best for defense. Hollow point if you’re not from New Jersey. What a dumb azz law.
Always hollow points for defense
Need to throw in .357 too, it’s the best of all of them!
Well, here's my opinion on whether to go with the 45 or the 9mm. For some people the 9mm is best and for some people the 45 is best. It really depends on you. If you're a girlyman then the 9mm is for you. If you're a man's man then the 45 is best for you. If you're a girlyman you want the 9mm because to you the noise and recoil are iccky, and you can't shoot straight so you need lots of bullets. If you're a man's man you are trained and disciplined; you like the noise and recoil and you can shoot straight. So let's say that at three o'clock in the morning you wake up in bed and there's a stranger in your bedroom and he says "I gonna kill you sucka." If you're a girlyman you grab your 9mm and empty the 14 round magazine in his direction. Since you can't shoot straight maybe you'll get lucky and one bullet will graze his head. At that point he's going to come at you and slash your throat, and since you're a girlyman, that's exactly what you deserve. But if you're a man's man you only need one shot and the intruder is going down. If you don't think a 230 grain bullet loaded up with 7.2 grains of Unique, moving out at 960 FPS isn't knock down power, then you need to go back to ballistics class. After you fire that one round you can roll over and go back to sleep because the intruder is history.
Or maybe some people choose 9mm because they don't wanna pay 50 dollars a 100 rd box for ball ammo lol. Not sure why 45 is the "manly" round. It doesn't even kick hard. It feels like a push. 40 S&W has more of a "snap" to it than 45 auto. By your metrics, the real "manly" cartridge for semiauto is the 10mm. Its wipes up the floor with 45 acp. There's a reason hunters choose this as their sidearm in bear country.
I own and shoot 9mm with 15-round magazines and 45acp with 12-round magazines. Love them both.
For self-protection in urban areas, I prefer the 9mm loaded with 147grain FMJ or JHP ammo.
For self-protection in rural areas, I prefer the 45acp loaded with 255 grain flat-nose hard-cast solid-lead ammo.
However, my personal favorite handgun is a 6-inch .357 magnum with two speed loaders filled with 180 grain or 200 grain ammo.
If I need to carry something smaller and lighter than .357 magnum, 45acp, or 9mm, I will carry a .380acp with two 7-round magazines loaded with 100 grain flat-nose hard-cast solid-lead ammo.
Thanks for the video.
I have two 45’s one a Kimber 4 inch, one is a baby glock 36.
Both of these pistols are easy to carry. Both are extremely accurate.
I’ve owned a 9mm, it was a great pistol but did not have the power of a 45.
Great job!
45 acp with 185 +p hollow points = way better than any 9mm +p+++
My experience with the .45 is, they don’t get back up!
I have put down deer, cattle, etc... with 9mm many times. Never had to use more than one shot. 9mm is just fine.
I live in a prison town. I know some guards. They all talk about all the inmates who tell stories about being shot, some multiple times, by 9mm, and, of course, they survived. None of them have told stories about being shot by a .45.
@RTaggs I see your point about 9mm being "enough" but that's an unarmed animal you probably have time to place shot well and not high stress self defense situation. Before you say hunting is high stress environment you must have never been actually fearful of life and want more than enough.
@@JuanGonzalez-cl4md In civilian life I have had two instances where I have had guns in my face. Along with serving in two different military services ( Army and Navy) 1985 -2006. So I think I know what a stressful environment is for sure. I must have done something right because I'm alive and well.
@RTaggs First off all thank you for your service. Understand your experience and given that level of situation wouldn't you want a little more reassurance?
Most people’s stockpile of ammo is ball rounds, not hollow points. Advantage 45..
Isn’t 9 much more common and cheaper?
@@alex-ki5wm yes, but it’s also the rounds missing from the shelves when people get scared
@@silverhorder1969 I mean wouldn’t 45 also be taken off the shelves? It’s a popular cartridge as well
@@alex-ki5wm probably, but maybe not as fast as 9mm. .40 would be the last left most likely
As a trauma nurse I’ve seen people shot 7 times with a 9mm were just pissed off. Pretty sure they were FMJ though. Get the right ammo
Its all about shot placement
1 in the heart and done
9mm is lighter, easier to carry, easier to shoot follow up rounds with, and is cheaper to shoot, that's why i carry a 45. LOL i carry both.
Why not build one gun that feeds both 9mm and 45acp. A clip having two kinds of rounds. But I still doubt the debate will end. 😂
The problem with the percentage of rounds on target statistics is that it includes larger capacity magazines being used during the shootings. So is the percentage smaller because more rounds are being fired? How many of those rounds were not needed and or missed because more rounds were being fired with progressively worse accuracy as each additional shot is fired?
I'm a retired CSI and I have worked hundreds of shootings including officer involved shootings. In many of those cases the shooters sprayed and prayed and missed with their first magazine of rounds but hit the first or second shot from the second/reload magazine. The deciding factor was not magazine capacity but whether the shooter truly aimed!
The concept of fire superiority is for military combat, not civilian combat where innocent bystanders are more likely!
I believe the key to surviving a shootout Is not magazine capacity but fire discipline. Shooters with automatic pistols should practice firing two shot groups in succession On multiple targets with a one or two second pause between each group until it is second nature. Those pauses will greatly improve accuracy!
Practice firing two shoots and in your mind say Mississippi then fire two more until one or two rounds are left in the pistol then reload. Don't fire to empty. Reloading with one left in the chamber is faster than reloading and having to work the slide. Plus you develop the Good habit of counting your rounds.
If you're at an indoors range with one narrow lane get a target with multiple bulls eyes on it in addition to the silhouette targets! 31:40
As far as effectiveness on target, from the hundreds of cases I've worked with everything from a22lr to a 44 magnum or 12 gauge, I'd say bigger is always better!
I have both 45 ACP and 9 mm pistols that are suitable for EDC I find that using the 45 ACP that carries the 200 grain bonded defense round from double tap comes out of the barrel at 1100 ft./s is most definitely worlds apart from almost all 9 mm loads. My calculations put this round at 537 foot pounds of energy which is approximately 150 foot pounds of energy more than any standard 9 mm self-defense load..
I refuse to put the 9mm down however because I do 😢find myself carrying the Glock 19 on many occasions. Day to day I carry both the 9mm and 45acp half & half.
The multiple assailant issue isn’t an issue in a home invasion in my experience. After putting the first two down the other three left in a hurry.
Outside, like a riot situation is a different ballgame. You’ll want as much ammo as you can carry. No one answer for everything.
January 6th US Capitol attack was riot? 😅
When shooting at paper you don't need to go down range to see your hits with a 45.
It really is all about the hole.
Self defense? Isn't it really about killing someone before they kill you ??
Millions of rounds shot in WWII was with .45acp
9mm was in German pistols
To dainty
Remington 870 next to the bed. Springfield XDs Mod 2 .45 for concealed carry in my home town, and Springfield XDm .45 plus the XDs when down on the border out west. The XDs .45 is single hole accurate when I take my time. Follow up shots get progressively worse. I'm 76, it is a lot to handle so I'm ordering the new optics XDs in 9 mm to see how it does. I love the slim frame on those pistols for easy pocket holster carry.
I liked the comparison between calibers. 👍
So many people talk about the advancement of tech making the 9mm a more viable defensive round with modern hollow-points. Then for a SHTF situation, they stock up on a few thousand rounds...OF FMJ! Fact - in FMJ, the .45 is quite a bit superior. And with JHPs, the .45 has a slight advantage. I'm not so concerned about the modern fad, ie: capacity. My EDC 1911 Commander holds 9 rounds. And I have a very reliable Wilson Combat 10 round spare mag. That's 19 rounds for a situation that typically requires 2 or three.
I carry different things for different situations; From Mouse guns to Magnums. My house gun is a full size 9 mm with a 20 round magazine. My truck gun is a sub compact 9 mm. But, my main carry is a 45. The reason is versatility. I generally carry 120 grain at 1420 FTPS in one magazine, one magazine of 255 hard cast at 920 FTPS, extra mags of 185 or 200 grain. They are all factory loads. I have lots a black bear where I live, including in my yard sometimes and that’s why the hard cast 255s. The bear haven’t attacked us or our livestock, but they have attacked peoples dogs in the area. I have an autistic son, and he will run, and they may chase him. When he is outside, the hard cast magazine is in my pistol. To me the 45 is the most versatile auto loader in existence. If I really need more power, I can run 45 Supers as well. It’s amazing that all of that variety can be used easily in one pistol. When hunting with a handgun, I will use a 357 or 44 magnum revolver, but for most days, the 45 is much easier to conceal, very thin for caliber, easier to shoot well, and lighter than my big magnums. Thanks for the video.
I went with the .45acp because of wild boar around the outskirts of my village. I was carrying a 3.5'' 9mm(in case of people attack), now a 3.5'' .45acp.(for both)
Nice informative and entertaining talk.
Glad you enjoyed it!
: .45cal. The bigger the hole the more they bleed.
45 drops blood pressure faster than 9mm, case closed.
I gotta say, I'm really sick of these 9mm fan boys comparing a 1911 with 7 round capacity to a modern 9 mm with 17 round capacity. Guys... Let's stop pretending that we don't have multiple high capacity 45's now!
My XDM is 13 plus 1 and 16 plus 1 with my extended plus 3 base plates. But even with "standard" sized, unmodified mags, you're still talking 14 rounds of 230 grain bullets. Combine that with plus p HST bullets that damn near expand to an inch in diameter! That's 14, 1 inch wound channels penetrating 14-18 inches. That beats ANY standard capacity 9 mm on earth as far as damage inflicted on your target. Even a brown bear isn't walking through that much lead. ☝️
I've got a Smith and Wesson Governor, 45acp with Speed reloader. I carry 2 extra clips it's accurate and has 410 shell options as well as 45 long cult. it's definitely my favorite weapon it's just hard to conceal even with my chest holster everyone knows I've got it lol which isn't necessarily a bad thing lol
It's all fun and games till someone shows up with a 10 mm.
No problem, they won’t be able to hit anything 😂
What they made a 45 ACP?
I (still) be rocking the 45 Colt!
The “Taylor Knock Out Index”: Velocity (in fps) x Weight (in grains) x Diameter (in inches) = _ divided by 7,000 [to convert into foot pounds of energy].
9mm: [1901 AD] (Original)
Standard P - 1180 x 115 x .355 = 48,173.5 divided by 7,000 = 6.88 ft pd
Underwood Ammo 9mm:
Standard P - 1300 x 115 x .355 = 53,072.5 divided by 7000 = 7.58 ft pd
+P - 1100 x 147 x .355 = 57,403.5 divided by 7000 = 8.2 ft pd
+P+ - 1550 x 90 x .355 = 49,522.5 divided by 7000 = 7.07 ft pd - (?)
Notice how big and slow is better than little and faster every time? Well now, it ain’t just what she said anymore!
And on that note -
45 ACP: [1904 AD]
Standard P - 835 x 230 x .451 = 86,614.55 divided by 7,000 = 12.37 ft pd
Underwood Ammo 45 ACP:
+P - 925 x 255 x .452 = 106,615.5 divided by 7000 = 15.23 ft pd
Fools Figure, but Figures don't Fool! Which now leads us to the Facts -
45 Colt: [1872 AD] (Original)
Standard P - 1000 x 235 x .456 = 107,160 divided by 7,000 = 15.3 ft pd Original
Underwood Ammo 45 Colt:
Standard P - 1000 x 250 x .452 = 113,000 divided by 7,000 = 16.14 ft pd - Xtreme Penetrator
+P - 1400 x 250 x .452 = 158,200 divided by 7,000 = 22.6ft pd - Xtreme Penetrator +P
This is the results of big getting faster. So, "faster can be goods so long as size is not compromised!" And I quoted her on that.
[Liberty Ammunition 45 Colt:
Standard P - 1800 x 78 x .452 = 63,460.8 divided by 7,000 = 9.0658 ft pd - Civil Defense
Showing little going fast is just that, and nothing more!]
+P - 1325 x 325 x .452 = 194,642.5 divided by 7,000 = 27.8 ft pd - Long Flat Nose Gas Check Hi-Tek Coated Hard Cast +P
This is the results of big getting bigger! As so did her eyes!
Standard P - 900 x 220 x .452 = 89,496 divided by 7,000 = 12.785 ft pd - Maximum Expansion (before it expands)
Standard P - 900 x 220 x 1.75 = 346,500 divided by 7,000 = 49.5 ft pd - Maximum Expansion (after it expands)
This is the results of big becoming HUGE! At this point she was speechless(?).
From experience, almost all hollow point rounds that go through a person dressed for winter, become the same as a FMJ round, a lot of penetration and very little damage. The more modern solid copper rounds, as the Underwood rounds, are some of the most barrier blind rounds and still do even more damage than larger rounds.
I can't shoot a 9mm for shit but I can run the hell outta .45acp. But that's just me, everyone's experience is different.
The capacity conversation with today's platforms is completely irrelevant.
Everyone tries to compare it to a 1911, which I think is more about a convenient disparity between the 2 platforms, but there are plenty of high capacity 45 acps on the market including sub compact.
A glock 30S, carries 10 + 1 in a compact package, that is only 1 to 2 rounds less than a similar subcompact in 9 mm....
Hst and gold dot 45 great expansion and penetration.
I have a ruger sr9 and a Springfield xds 45 Springfield my choice fits me perfectly
My personal experience is that .45 ACP drops bad guys faster and better than 9mm.
But THE best gun combo to have?
Is the one that your carrying and have trained with.
Many years ago, I did a lot of research to decide on which caliber and style handgun to get. Since it seemed everything was measured against the 1911 in 45acp, that's what I gravitated to and bought. Concealing it was a challenge, it was heavy, and bulky, but it shot like a dream. So, for purposes of carrying concealed, I moved to a subcompact 9mm that I carried in the hip pocket of some of my pants. Still slightly bulky but manageable. But some years back I moved to a 22lr Beretta M21A Bobcat loaded with hyper velocity rounds (for reliable cycling). I can hit quite well with it at self defense distances and have done stress tests with it and found that it is a GREAT point and shoot handgun. When my pants will allow, I now sometimes carry a micro 9mm, but for the most part my Beretta is in my hip pocket.
That's a heck of a slide from a 1911 in 45, to a single stack 22 with horrible sights.
@@snek9353 At close range, I've trained to point and shoot with the M-9 during my time in the military. The 1911, all the sub 9s I've had, and my Beretta M21 all have the same grip angle, so really no sights necessary at plus or minus 20'.
@@RonALampman Well first of all, I don't know why your saying "M" 21, there's no M. Secondly no they don't, I have a 21A Bobcat it's a completely different thing.
@@snek9353 OK, model (M) 21. Didn't think nomenclature would be that big a deal. But I should have known, you have an account with no info on it so you can troll others.. have fun!
The sad part is he makes a simple joke about the support inside a hollow point being explosive and there’s at least 1 prosecutor in the nation that believes hollow points explode 🙄😂
It’s funny listening to people who never been in high stress situations talk about high stress situations.
The form factor is also relevant. .45 makes more sense in a larger duty pistol, not so much in a single stack. The two merge in the Compact. I have a .45 XDM Mod 2 with a 9 flush mount mag and you can get extended mags that have 13 rounds in an easily concealed package. I have a Glock 19 that carries 15 rounds in a sub compact format that is super light. Both work. I shot a hog and dropped it with a .45. I don’t know that a 9mm would not.
For home defense I have 45 185 gr ➕P, but for carry 9mm only because round count in public
The way he holds that Glock.
The argument for increased capacity of 9mm, is moot in states where magazine limitations are in effect. Bullet designs have been improved and developed in both calibers . In case of home invasion and multiple assailants, perhaps a shotgun is the best response. The 45 acp even if it does not expand, is still .45, the 9mm if it does not expand is .356 . This may not matter, but it may mean all of the difference. Do you need increased capacity, that’s a good question and it’s up to each of us to decide. It all comes down to personal preference and choice. What you can shoot better and hit with is the best choice for you.
Ive never found the recoil of .45 acp to be an issue. Its pretty low pressure.
The US adopted 9mm because of logistics. Nato adopted it because of the abundance of surplus ammo after ww2.
The fact that this is even a comparison discussion is ridiculous.
My edc is a Glock 27 with a G23 mag, occasionally I’ll carry my Kimber Custom II .45.
I bought two pistols: Glock 17 and CZ Shadow 2. Both 9mm and the reason is just the price of the ammo. I shoot my pistols, practice is the key for mastery, and .45ACP has higher price here for at least 40-50%.
I carry 24/7 45 acp 12 +1 gen1 have a 9 mm gc2 and the kell teck 22 lr love them all but prefer the 45 fits nice in the hand, 200 grn hits hard,
Great content especially comparing 9mm vs 45acp. Camera man needs to zoom out so when you are both speaking i can see both of you. Currently I could hear both of you but only half of the man in the foreground and see the man in the man the background. Several times I could not see the target like watermelon or bottles during impact. I would suggest 2 cameras. One to view you and one for impact on targets. I liked the subject matter, but several times I could not see the results. I look forward to future videos.
In a state 10 rd Mag. .45ACP
IMHO it comes down to which one you shoot better under simulated combat conditions with your EDC.
When outside 9mmn124 hst When inside at home glock 30s 45acp hst nasty round.
I carry EDC X9 9mm and Kimber Pro Carry II 45acp all day long
SOCOM did extensive testing on this in the mid 90s. A few 9mm rounds back then met their parameters. More than 15 .45 rounds did. 9mm has gotten better since then but the same tech applied to .45 is still better. The wound channel and penetration through walls, windshields and car doors then wound data favors .45. Again a few 9mm rounds are close.
It comes down to your practice, skill and the situations you expect to be in. Unless a double stack .45 fits your hand well then it’s not much of a debate to have. I have both. I use both depending on circumstances.
They both do their job, it's just the 45 does it better and probably with less bullets!
I’ve seen multiple posts over the years of ER docs/nurses saying how much damage is done by all calibers from 380 - 45, so there’s some input from those who actually see the wounds. I’m all for the physics of things (e=mc^2), but also realize the comfort factor to ensure one actually carries. I’m less swayed anymore by capacity because of the amount of data showing 1-3 shots stopping the encounter when shots are fired and the data of encounters stopped just with presentation.
All that said, how do y’all feel about 40 in this same discussion? I’m a fan of the 40.
Great conversation but really wouldn't the 40 be best of both worlds if you're on the fence between 9 and 45?
The smaller watermelon had less surface area to absorb the impact of the .45acp, and should have been swapped, the smaller watermelon for the the 9mm would have been a more fair comparison.
9mm for carry hands down. I also like .40 for carry. .45 is third place for me.
My CCW is a P365xl with a red dot. It’s a thin small gun that shoots like a larger gun. Still very easy to hide and light enough to carry all day. My Colt Officer weights twice as much and larger.
FBI findings
“Increased bullet mass will increase penetration. Increased velocity will increase penetration but only until the bullet begins to deform, at which point increased velocity decreases penetration. Permanent cavity can be increased by the use of expanding bullets, and/or larger diameter bullets, which have adequate penetration. However, in no case should selection of a bullet be made where bullet expansion is necessary to achieve desired performance.35 Handgun bullets expand in the human target only 60- 70% of the time at best. Damage to the hollow point by hitting bone, glass, or other intervening obstacles can prevent expansion. Clothing fibers can wrap the nose of the bullet in a cocoon like manner and prevent expansion. Insufficient impact velocity caused by short barrels and/or longer range will prevent expansion, as will simple manufacturing variations. Expansion must never be the basis for bullet selection, but considered a bonus when, and if, it occurs.”
To return to the FBI test protocols, it will be remembered that in penetration tests the .45 ACP FMJ scored 100%, while the 9mm achieved a slightly lower 95.5% success rate. While the minimum acceptable penetration for police use was established to be 12 inches, the FBI tests concluded that a penetration of 18 inches was even better. During the tests, however, the FBI assigned no points for penetration beyond the optimum 18 inches. The .45 ACP FMJ bullets penetrated an average depth of greater than 28 inches, while 9x19mm FMJ bullets were a full 4 inches less. Some might consider this over penetration, but for military applications, greater penetration is both acceptable and desirable. As previously mentioned, penetration is only one aspect of bullet effectiveness. The size of the permanent wound cavity must also be considered, and the .45 ACP FMJ bullets in the FBI tests achieved average permanent wound cavities of 3 cubic inches, while the 9mm bullet permanent wound cavities were a full cubic inch less. This significantly increases the prospect of the .45 striking a bone or internal organ. This can be summed up in the FBI’s overall wound value that assigns a value of 2.91 to the military .45 ACP and only 1.65 to the M882 9x19mm. This value is “... the index of demonstrated wounding effectiveness, not potential, as measured by the FBI Ammunition Test results.”
I typically carry a Glock 21 (it’s a .45 ACP handgun). It must also be noted that ammunition capacity (while important) is often over-exaggerated. Most self defense shootings are 3 rounds (shots fired), 3 yards (distance away) and 3 seconds (in time of altercation). Sources can vary, but this is typically taught (from what Ive seen). So even a 8-9 shot M1911 handgun will generally be more than enough in most self defense cases.
@@factsoftheconfederacy7151 glock 21sf, 13+1 wins.
@@kylehansen6580 it’s a great gun, I hear a Glock 21 Gen 5 is in the works.
Noticed you guys didnt include the 40 s&w in this test. Capacity + energy.. better than either round you tested..imo
The best defensive .45 ACP ammo against a human threat is 185gr hollow points with a +P charge behind it, the 230gr. hollow points are just too slow to expand well and are best left to .45 Super powered guns and up. 230gr. non-expanding bullets are good for certain animals where penetration through heavy bone and thick hide are needed but for two legged varmints especially out of compact and sub-compact pistols 185gr. and 200gr. at the most bullets are best.
Depends on the projectel you use, 9 has higher velocity so in short barrel it has better chance of expansion, ball ammo 45 is better
I prefer 9mm with hollow points.
Ft/Lbs comparison between??
IMO- it’s the one which you can control. A single stack 9 for maybe smaller “ weaker” people? Of course with the adrenaline rush maybe weaker goes out the window. And nearly all defense shoots are only 2-4 shots? I prefer the .45 1911 for an EDC with HORNADY critical defense. If this round will drop a 200#+ wild hog- well there’s your answer.
Speer GoldDot +P 124 gr . 1200ft per second and 396 lbs of force.
I love,the,45 acp. That being,said my,carry guns are,a,ruger,lcp2 in,380 or a,Taurus 856 in 38,plus p or,a,kahr cm9. Now my,bedside weapon,is,a,glock g30 s with,26,round,mags. So,my,45 is,fine,for,ammo,count.
45 super?
you need to shoot some 450 SMC (Small Magnum Cartridge)in your 45 ACP VS your 10 mm
Can you explain 450 smc to me?
This is never any mention of collateral damage when comparing 9mm vs 45. The review is very good but if one misses with the nine for all the reasons stated as favorable could be negative. Hitting an unintended target is never forgiven.
You can miss with a 45 too….
I carry a 45 everyday
Welcome to San Francisco, CA with 9mm 😂😂😂
I guess you really won’t know what will stop the threat faster until you have to shoot someone . Police officers would share stories or even ww2 veterans about the 45 would be good. I believe a slower bigger round would be more devastating than a round that goes burning through. Most in a shtf scenario would have ball ammo anyway. Conceal carry with hollow points is best.
9mm < 45acp < 10mm I love all three! ❤️🩹
9mm for carry 45 for the range.
But something is better than nothing.
And who’s the drunk camera guy? LoL
Never understood the "heavy and slow" comments on the 45. I can shoot a 200gr critical defense (Hornady) at 1090 fps. How about a Grizzly 185gr. at 1200 fps. Underwood and Buffalo Bore get the big girl moving too. Not sure anything competes in the same platform.
No matter how you spread sugar on a turd it's still a turd , I love a 9 but if i have a ,,bull ,,running at me I'll use a 45,
drinking game, take a shot every time they say UM. Guaranteed alcohol poisoning
Well, ALLOW me to Break it down, I don't think I would want to get Hit by either one of them 🇺🇸👍
60 million fps? Must be Liberty Civil Defense.
Too bad the 357 Sig didn't catch on. Also, they watered down the 40 loads now...the 40 gives more capacity than the 45 and more punch than the nine.
💯💯💯💯💯
People are completely misinformed when they sit there and think the 45 doesn't penetrate as well as a 9 mm.
When the FBI did their comprehensive ballistic testing in the late eighties, 9mm wasn't even considered as an option, because it wasn't capable of penetrating various barriers and still capable of going deep enough and soft tissue to hit vital organs.
The caliber's tested that was capable of this, was 45 ACP, 10 millimeter, and 357 magnum.
It's amazing what adding 9 grains of weight to a 115gr. bullet will do.
@@robwilson3749
Adding 9 grains didnt turn it into a magic bullet that can now match a 45 ACPs performance.
I love the 45acp, it’s a man stopper.
But…
The concealed carry 45acp firearms are low on ammunition compared to a 9mm.
I would rather have more ammunition and more chances to hit a target, and the technology of 9mm ammunition has come a long way.
Now for home defense and as a side arm while hunting, 45 ACP!
I was carrying a 200 grain and I accidentally bought + p. I didn’t want to use them in my aluminum frame I had bought some 165s frangible rounds so I got two midsize water melons. The 200 was not impressive. The 165 disintegrated the melon, it was a OMG moment. I thought is this even legal.
Good video guys, but I have a queston: if you have to reload more often shooting the lower capacity .45, isn't that offset by being quicker to reload compared to reloading a higher capacity 9mm? 🤔
"Wait hold on attacker let me hand load my next mag because I ran out of bullets before you did"
I ask all pro 9mm advocates, if you had only 8 rounds, in each weapon, which would you choose, if being faced against a bear?
They'd say 9mm bc "the insane amount of penetration " lmao. I just like big holes. federal hst hp gets about 1in wide
Smart people and people experienced with bear use 10mm for bear.🤷🏻
I don’t even watch the video anymore. I just read all the stupid cliche comments.🥴
9mm hollow point 2x the capacity always wins in ccw
All things being equal, the .45 is better. If shtf, most likely only ball will be available. One 230 vs how many 9mm hits to knock someone down.
9 is lighter round per round but a 17-18 rd 9mm mag is significantly heavier than an 8rd 45 mag. A lot of the so called new and improved bullets show spotty expansion. If my bulled gets plugged and doesn’t expand, I’d rather it be 45 rather than .356. Ad to,that the reality that most civilian fights start when one has allowed there situational awareness to lapse and even one shot will require greAt speed and luck. Again only one to three rounds between me and a loss. I’m going big, to go home 😉 P.S living tissue is very elastic, so no carry handgun is going to create a powerful enough shockwave to create meaningful damage beyond bullet diameter. so “wound channels” in gel or explosive results on fluid targets aren’t relevant for comparison of effectiveness
I don’t want to get shot by either caliber
The one that works the best is the one that stops the threat with the least amount of rounds fired.
It all comes down to combat skills and training for such an incident.
But adrenaline is a problem as well and it does happen.
That's why you see cops mag dump in shootings.
Adrenaline folks.
Fight or flight is animalistic in nature
OTIS elevators. " Going Up" 🤣
9mm = target plinking sport
.45acp = killing
What 9 easy to get then 45.so I guess yall don't experience the ammo crunch?9 was not in existence cents every one has a 9.but good 45 no problem and it was cheaper than 9mm too
We've seen 9mm returning to store shelves, and depending on the brand it is approximately 10¢-18¢/round less than 45.