Those people discussing the 'best interpretations' are obviously missing the point. This performance was THE event of many of those children's lives. This was something they will never forget. How many ultra poor Venezuelans ever had a chance to sing music of this sort in such a huge group with a huge orchestra with extra instruments? They stepped outside of their poverty and gained a new richness by performing this great work. Yes, Dudamel was the vehicle through which the performance took place, but the supreme organisation of the local conductors and teachers and the whole El Sistema machinery gave those children a unique experience. It was wonderful.
Isn't it amazing how the inspiration, imagination, and dedication of one person can affect the lives of so many people so long after their creative efforts. Humanity has some pretty cool stand out individuals. I bet a lot more of us have formidable and historic creative potential within us than we realize. But that takes belief, vision, and a lot of work.
This version was off limits for a long time but now it is back. This was the first time I listened this symphony. Now I realize that it is the absolutely very best version. The tempi are just precisely what Mahler intended, I think. Terrific everything. Congratulations to all with my deepest thanks.
I totally agree, it was phenomenal in every way! I wish I knew what the choir was chanting at the end! They all seemed so emotional about the performance for good reason!!
@@gregemerson7648Thank you Greg for your comment. We seem to agree in every respect. Dudamel is perhaps the best conductor we have these days. And the choirs were magnificent. I also wish I knew the words of the choirs. Greetings to you from Sergio!
Thank you so much for your reply and greetings from cold Canada lol 🙏certainly this piece is warming me up♨️ I just loved how it ended the after footage and around 1:08 oh just incredible with the the singer I think she's alto or mezzo soprano. This music brings me back to University Toronto studying performance music, clarinet.. and I did a seminar on this piece 50 minutes I really don't remember what I said but I just became obsessed with it🌤
Uno de los días más maravillosos de mi vida! Gracias a nuestro maestro Abreu por darnos la oportunidad a la juventud Venezolana de poder vivir estas fantásticas experiencias. -Integrante del coro sinfónico Simón Bolívar.
En una gran experiencia,yo acabo de cantar esta sinfonía el pasado domingo con motivo de 50 aniversario de festival internacional cervantino en Guanajuato Mexico y es absolutamente grandiosa asi como también muy difícil. Enhorabuena.
This performance is a monumental human artistic achievement that will not be surpassed for a very long time. What I almost love more than the music is watching the celebration that followed. I have this performance on DVD; we are so very fortunate that it was recorded, because it is the stuff of legend.
Unforgettable finale. Keeps ringing in my ears. The most majestic and epic symphony I have ever heard. Great performance overall. Conductor was fantastic.
What an outstanding performance of one of the musical Wonders of the World. Depending on the day, this finale, that of the second or the third. Each of the them a wonder of the world in its own right.
MONUMENTAL!!!!!!!! I have never seen such JOY for MUSIC. I am beside myself, crying like an innocent child, at the utter thrill and excitement of this truly HISTORIC occasion. I bow to Dudamel, the musicians and singers and thank you deeply. Many heartfelt thanks to the pioneering Venezuelan people!
We prepared this monumental work for maybe a half-year or even more, was a country compromise before, then and even now, 10 year later, the high-quality that it still has shows this.
That is because Higher forms Of ART are reserved only for the few of us, who can understand, reflect, focus and admire infinite beauty of human creation :-) I'm actually positively surprised, that the number reached 80 thousand viewers out of approx. 4 billion internet users around this planet. So, there still is a hope !
40:00 This sequence is an amazing, un-rushed, and heartfelt performance. Dudamel and the strings are so sensitively in-sync, giving space for Mulligan (the singer) to pour everything into it. Beautiful.
He's singing: Ewiger Wonnebrand, Glühendes Liebeband, Siedender Schmerz der Brust, Schäumende Gotteslust. Pfeile, durchdringet mich, Lanzen, bezwinget mich, Keulen, zerschmettert mich, Blitze, durchwettert mich! Daß ja das Nichtige Alles verflüchtige, Glänze der Dauerstern, Ewiger Liebe Kern. which can be translated as: Rapture which yearns for ever, Love that burns for ever, Seething pain in my breast, Frothing love of God. Come, arrows, and pierce me through, Lances - subdue my flesh, Maces, come batter me, Lightnings - shatter me! That nothingness Might drown all in emptiness, Let one constant star shine: The kernel of eternal love.
Gracias por expresar la paz entre el Norte y el Sur de América a través de la música, la Octava Sinfonía de Mahler. El Nuevo Mundo de América es una tierra de posibilidades. Las voces cantantes de la gente que vive en esta tierra han llegado a lugares muy lejanos de Asia. Espero sinceramente que todos sigáis siendo felices.
Thank you dear "Michele Spagnolo" for this wonderful post, and thanks to the owners, DEUTSCHE GRAMMOPHON, LOS ANGELES PHILARMONIC, and SIMON BOLIVAR FOUNDATION, for allowing many people to experience these gems of music. Otherwise, they simply wouldn't have the opportunity to experience the unique work, and that wouldn't be creative...
People talk a big game about Bernstein and Gergiev being the "Mahler" guys. But Dudamel hangs with the very best of them. And his version of the 8th here is no exception. Love it!
Bernstein may be a big name but that's about all.The choir was often to loud, not subtle enough and the Orchestra going into a crescendo was not gradual enough we were almost half way there at the start, but otherwise okay..
Bernstein brought the Mahler symphonies out of the world of curiosities and made them mainstream. His original recordings were landmarks. Improvements in sound recording have certainly made more recent recordings amazingly full blooded, but his 2nd and 8th are treasures. I find that Gergiev does better with Shostakovich than Mahler. He rushes Mahler, like he cannot wait to get done.
As regards the 8th, you have to think about it apart from the other malher symphony, because the means it required to be perform appropriately is a big factor that impact the performance greatly. This is why Berstein failed it many times. By the way, in term of malher symphony, the top 1 remains Abbado ...
the "People & Blogs" notation is "right on!" with the camerawork as it puts 'me' "right there in the scene!" that the audience cannot experience and such the director has the one value for us viewers that otherwise can't be experienced. All video directors henceforth should keep in mind.
This masterpiece is surpassed only by the Resurrection Symphony! Both of them tear me up every time! Such beauty and strength and pathos all at once. Only Mahler! 💘💘💘💘💘
@@jakesmith3724 no deed to wait....Who is the new conductor of the New York Philharmonic? conductor Gustavo Dudamel New York Philharmonic Co-Chairmen Peter W. May and Oscar L. Tang, Linda and Mitch Hart President & CEO Deborah Borda, and Executive Director Gary Ginstling today announced that conductor Gustavo Dudamel will become the Orchestra's next Music Director, beginning in the 2026-27 season, succeeding Jaap van Zweden.Feb 7, 2023
Hermoso momento tan solo hace 4 años , esos niños esos jóvenes , esos abuelos y abuelas presente disfrutando del placer de la música si como yo pueden retener y repetir seguramente lo harán para mitigar los tristes de hoy 17/ 05/ 2017
Thanks. This is called "(Live From ...". I'm thinking it's likely quite unusual to have Mahler's 8th Symphony recorded in a studio, I bet the people next door complain.
@@grahamwilliams8926 That is the man who founded the whole of El Sistema that launched a multitude of youth orchestras across Venezuela, giving birth to the Simon Boliver Orchestra, and launching Dudamel's career. His name is (was) Jose Antonio Abreu. He died a few years ago. He started the whole enterprise in an underground car park on the outskirts of Caracas when he gave musical instruments to a small number of poor children and began a musical venture. He was an economist, politician and musician. He was a real mover and shaker. El Sistema has been copied internationally.
テンポは総じてきびきびしていて躍動感があり、才能を感じます。 意外とこういう感じの音楽を作れる指揮者が多くはないと感じます。(だから人気が出るのでしょう。) 演奏を聴いていると出来そうな気がするのですけれどね。私自身は躍動感のある深みのある音楽を自分の指揮で表せる気がしてしまう。この曲と、第2番「復活」、チャイコフスキーの4・5・6番のシンフォニー、ストラビンスキーの「春の祭典」、ムソルグスキー/ラヴェル編曲の「展覧会の絵」、リムスキー=コルサコフの「シェエラザード」などは、是非とも指揮してみたい曲です。 でも、TH-camでこの曲のいろいろな演奏を聴くと、感動したとは言えない指揮者も案外多い気がするのです。物足りないとか、そこはもっとテンポを上げ上げで盛り上げるべきでしょうよとか。それが単に自分の音楽の好みとの違いかもしれないと言われればそれまでですが。 でも、私はスコアリーディングも出来るし、声楽ソロや合唱のことに至るまでよく理解しているつもりです。指揮法も学んでいるし。だからなおさら好みの問題があるのかもしれません。 ならば私自身が指揮者になればよかったんじゃないのか? と言われれば、「はい、その通りでした」 指揮者になれば、あとは自分の音楽が人々に評価されるか否かです。やってみなければそれは誰が指揮者になる場合でも分かりません。全く箸にも棒にも引っかからないかもしれないし、人気指揮者になるかもしれないし。けれど私には自分の音楽性に自信があります。 ところで、そういう読者からは怪訝な目で見られるといいますか、アンチが沢山出てきそうな自己承認欲求的な話はこのくらいにするとして、 Los Angeles Philarmonic | Simon Bolivar Symphony Orchestra of Venezuela Coro Sinfonico Juvenil Simon Bolivar de Venezuela | Ninos cantores de Venezuela | Schola Cantorum de Venezuela | Schola Juvenil de Venezuela とのことですが、拍手と歓声を見ていると、まるでベネズエラのお祭りの様でもあります。単に演奏への評価だけの拍手では全くなさそう。
In Europe, the audience clap like seals when the music pauses between movements (parts in this case); the Venezuelan public show their class here - respect.
I do not have any respect for the political party that dominates Venezuela. They are bloody dictators. But I have to say that I was really moved to watch all these children, some of them probably from poor neighborhoods in Venezuela, singing this wonderful piece of Mahler.
Siempre la sinfonía de los mil impresiona. Desafortunadamente noto que Dudamel esta perdiendo la frescura que le caracterizó al inicio, esta perdiendo esa fuerza emotiva qué imprimió a sus primeras partituras. Trata de suplir esos defectos con obras volcánicas como el presente caso, la obertura 1812 o un ya desangelado Huapango de Moncayo. Lastima, fue bueno mientras duró.
Those people discussing the 'best interpretations' are obviously missing the point. This performance was THE event of many of those children's lives. This was something they will never forget. How many ultra poor Venezuelans ever had a chance to sing music of this sort in such a huge group with a huge orchestra with extra instruments? They stepped outside of their poverty and gained a new richness by performing this great work. Yes, Dudamel was the vehicle through which the performance took place, but the supreme organisation of the local conductors and teachers and the whole El Sistema machinery gave those children a unique experience. It was wonderful.
Mahler is one of those rare composers, like Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, who have the power to unite the world.
Isn't it amazing how the inspiration, imagination, and dedication of one person can affect the lives of so many people so long after their creative efforts. Humanity has some pretty cool stand out individuals. I bet a lot more of us have formidable and historic creative potential within us than we realize. But that takes belief, vision, and a lot of work.
No shit. You discovered it by yourself!!!
This version was off limits for a long time but now it is back. This was the first time I listened this symphony. Now I realize that it is the absolutely very best version. The tempi are just precisely what Mahler intended, I think. Terrific everything. Congratulations to all with my deepest thanks.
I totally agree, it was phenomenal in every way! I wish I knew what the choir was chanting at the end! They all seemed so emotional about the performance for good reason!!
@@gregemerson7648Thank you Greg for your comment. We seem to agree in every respect. Dudamel is perhaps the best conductor we have these days. And the choirs were magnificent. I also wish I knew the words of the choirs. Greetings to you from Sergio!
Thank you so much for your reply and greetings from cold Canada lol 🙏certainly this piece is warming me up♨️
I just loved how it ended the after footage and around 1:08 oh just incredible with the the singer I think she's alto or mezzo soprano. This music brings me back to University Toronto studying performance music, clarinet.. and I did a seminar on this piece 50 minutes I really don't remember what I said but I just became obsessed with it🌤
Greetings to you from warm Arizona. Thank you very much for your comment. It is really inspiring. Thanks a lot! Sergio@@stellafokas12
Uno de los días más maravillosos de mi vida! Gracias a nuestro maestro Abreu por darnos la oportunidad a la juventud Venezolana de poder vivir estas fantásticas experiencias.
-Integrante del coro sinfónico Simón Bolívar.
En una gran experiencia,yo acabo de cantar esta sinfonía el pasado domingo con motivo de 50 aniversario de festival internacional cervantino en Guanajuato Mexico y es absolutamente grandiosa asi como también muy difícil.
Enhorabuena.
Shivers at seeing those kids singing this german text by Göthe BY HEART!! One of the strongest emotions ever!!
It is my dream to watch this symphony live, I love it so much and this version gave me goosebumps!
LOL the first 25 minutes richer and more epic than any predecessor's work. And there is still an hour to go!
This performance is a monumental human artistic achievement that will not be surpassed for a very long time. What I almost love more than the music is watching the celebration that followed. I have this performance on DVD; we are so very fortunate that it was recorded, because it is the stuff of legend.
I completely agree - I also have the DVD and really enjoy the celebrations at the end
Thanks for mentioning the DVD. I just bought it!
Unforgettable finale. Keeps ringing in my ears. The most majestic and epic symphony I have ever heard. Great performance overall. Conductor was fantastic.
What an outstanding performance of one of the musical Wonders of the World. Depending on the day, this finale, that of the second or the third. Each of the them a wonder of the world in its own right.
Non sono mai stato un entusiasta di Dudamel. Ma chi non si commuove per una performance del genere, è senza cuore.
Surely the definitive version of this masterpiece. Watching such a vast ensemble united in the execution of a single work is life-enhancing.
MONUMENTAL!!!!!!!! I have never seen such JOY for MUSIC. I am beside myself, crying like an innocent child, at the utter thrill and excitement of this truly HISTORIC occasion. I bow to Dudamel, the musicians and singers and thank you deeply. Many heartfelt thanks to the pioneering Venezuelan people!
Nicely put friend. I share with you.
@@johnvaughan7096 Thank YOU, friend. I rarely get this effusive with praise. It just felt right for me to express my admiration! ♥
39:24 Gracias maestro Gustavo por regalarnos esos maravillosos 10 segundos con un exquisito matiz
There just may be 1000 musicians onstage... this is really magnificent!
I will never get tired of that ending... #EpicBeyondAllMeasure
Spectacular interpretation. Master Dudamel's conducting was impeccable.
We prepared this monumental work for maybe a half-year or even more, was a country compromise before, then and even now, 10 year later, the high-quality that it still has shows this.
Such a shame that the amount of TH-cam views this has is only around six times the number of musicians performing it.
I think they may not have 1000 performers in this performance.690 strong is consider big.
Harvegal Brian's Gothic Symphony has even less !
LOL!
+ MCfractal. Not really Dudamel is conducting it what do you expect get real.
That is because Higher forms Of ART are reserved only for the few of us, who can understand, reflect, focus and admire infinite beauty of human creation :-) I'm actually positively surprised, that the number reached 80 thousand viewers out of approx. 4 billion internet users around this planet. So, there still is a hope !
Dudamel is the greatest in the world today!
THE BEST PERFORMANCE, BEATIFUL !
Gran música, grande Dudamel, magníficas orquestas y coros, una versión inspiradora. La huella de Abreu
Beyond this world. That’s ending is the best ever composed with the ending of Resurrection.
Greatest performance i've ever heard of this work
Brilliant! Extremely delightful right down to the kids noticing the camera and NEVER missing a beat! Remember, this is VISUAL, too.
Ongelooflijk grootse muziek. Alles van klassieke muziek komt hier tot uiting. Prachtig geregistreerd. Wereldklasse dirigent.
I love the baritone. He's pouring everything he has into his Pater Ecstaticus.
40:00 This sequence is an amazing, un-rushed, and heartfelt performance. Dudamel and the strings are so sensitively in-sync, giving space for Mulligan (the singer) to pour everything into it. Beautiful.
He's singing:
Ewiger Wonnebrand,
Glühendes Liebeband,
Siedender Schmerz der Brust,
Schäumende Gotteslust.
Pfeile, durchdringet mich,
Lanzen, bezwinget mich,
Keulen, zerschmettert mich,
Blitze, durchwettert mich!
Daß ja das Nichtige
Alles verflüchtige,
Glänze der Dauerstern,
Ewiger Liebe Kern.
which can be translated as:
Rapture which yearns for ever,
Love that burns for ever,
Seething pain in my breast,
Frothing love of God.
Come, arrows, and pierce me through,
Lances - subdue my flesh,
Maces, come batter me,
Lightnings - shatter me!
That nothingness
Might drown all in emptiness,
Let one constant star shine:
The kernel of eternal love.
1:10:: Mater Gloriosa totally nails it: "C'mon! Lift yourself to higher spheres!"
Gracias por expresar la paz entre el Norte y el Sur de América a través de la música, la Octava Sinfonía de Mahler. El Nuevo Mundo de América es una tierra de posibilidades. Las voces cantantes de la gente que vive en esta tierra han llegado a lugares muy lejanos de Asia. Espero sinceramente que todos sigáis siendo felices.
A great performance of this masterpiece
QUE NOTABLE DIRECTOR...GRANDE DUDAMEL
Thank you dear "Michele Spagnolo" for this wonderful post, and thanks to the owners, DEUTSCHE GRAMMOPHON, LOS ANGELES PHILARMONIC, and SIMON BOLIVAR FOUNDATION, for allowing many people to experience these gems of music. Otherwise, they simply wouldn't have the opportunity to experience the unique work, and that wouldn't be creative...
una delle migliori esecuzioni della 8 di Malher.Bravo Dudamel.
magistral : cette oeuvre de Gustav Mahler, nous parle directement au coeur
People talk a big game about Bernstein and Gergiev being the "Mahler" guys. But Dudamel hangs with the very best of them. And his version of the 8th here is no exception. Love it!
Bernstein may be a big name but that's about all.The choir was often to loud, not subtle enough and the Orchestra going into a crescendo was not gradual enough we were almost half way there at the start, but otherwise okay..
Bernstein brought the Mahler symphonies out of the world of curiosities and made them mainstream. His original recordings were landmarks. Improvements in sound recording have certainly made more recent recordings amazingly full blooded, but his 2nd and 8th are treasures. I find that Gergiev does better with Shostakovich than Mahler. He rushes Mahler, like he cannot wait to get done.
Solti’s out of the game then? I think his earliest recording of Mahler 8 with Chicago is phenomenal!!
As regards the 8th, you have to think about it apart from the other malher symphony, because the means it required to be perform appropriately is a big factor that impact the performance greatly. This is why Berstein failed it many times. By the way, in term of malher symphony, the top 1 remains Abbado ...
Doubt Abbado is the top ... There are better conductors and interpretations out there.
unbelievablely stirring! an experience of a lifetime. Mahler, Dudamel and all the kids unite the world (and soccer)
the "People & Blogs" notation is "right on!" with the camerawork as it puts 'me' "right there in the scene!" that the audience cannot experience and such the director has the one value for us viewers that otherwise can't be experienced. All video directors henceforth should keep in mind.
Why has it taken me so long after loving both Bruckner and Mahler to finally take the time to listen to this !
This masterpiece is surpassed only by the Resurrection Symphony! Both of them tear me up every time! Such beauty and strength and pathos all at once. Only Mahler! 💘💘💘💘💘
congratulations 3 years in advance to Dudamel on being announced conductor 2026 of the NY Phil!
I will remember this comment and see if you were right in 2 years…
@@jakesmith3724 no deed to wait....Who is the new conductor of the New York Philharmonic?
conductor Gustavo Dudamel
New York Philharmonic Co-Chairmen Peter W. May and Oscar L. Tang, Linda and Mitch Hart President & CEO Deborah Borda, and Executive Director Gary Ginstling today announced that conductor Gustavo Dudamel will become the Orchestra's next Music Director, beginning in the 2026-27 season, succeeding Jaap van Zweden.Feb 7, 2023
Mit Recht
Simplemente hermoso, hasta las lagrimas....... excelente obra, majestuosa orquesta y monumetal coro
Hermoso momento tan solo hace 4 años , esos niños esos jóvenes , esos abuelos y abuelas presente disfrutando del placer de la música si como yo pueden retener y repetir seguramente lo harán para mitigar los tristes de hoy 17/ 05/ 2017
Magnificent performance of this epic symphony!!
Amazing! Soon we will sing it in Sofia, Bulgaria! This is a great experience and once in a lifetime!
Extraordinaire Dudamel! Chœur merveilleux! Mahler divin! Venezuela!!!
Magistral interpretación!! Emociona hasta las lágrimas! Grandes los coros, grandes los solistas, la Orquesta y por supuesto el director
Conmovedor hasta las lágrimas
Orgullo latinoamericano. Viva Venezuela...abrazo desde México.
Thanks for uploading.
This is magnificent!!!
Éste es el verdadero espíritu de Venezuela sus artistas..
Capolavoro, di Male, bravo Dudamel.
"Male"
majestuoso !!!!!
thx for your sharing
Thanks. This is called "(Live From ...". I'm thinking it's likely quite unusual to have Mahler's 8th Symphony recorded in a studio, I bet the people next door complain.
Bravo!!!!
Bravo!!
10 years and not even 200k views🥺🥺🥺💔 this is excellence!
Quedamos mudos ante tanta magestuosidad-
majestic
That moment where you see that this is where John Williams pinched the Schindler's list theme! xD
Well I am viewing it.
The Toscanini of our age!
That is a remarkable and striking comparison. Excellent comment!
なんて感動的なドキュメント！
合唱の子供たちが倒れてしまわないか心配になる
このあとトイレは大丈夫だったのか？
一糸乱れぬ演奏なんてくそくらえ！
みんな全力で演奏してる
ひれ伏すべき音楽
特に第２部！
クラシック音楽の宝ですね☺
beautiful. what more can be said about Mahler, and this finale?
素晴らしい👍日本で聴きたい！
Blimey, that was something.
Unique!
You know a piece is super big and complex when even Dudamel conducts from a score.
I was there! Such an amazing experience!
Who is the old guy that stands up at the end of the performance?
@@grahamwilliams8926 That is the man who founded the whole of El Sistema that launched a multitude of youth orchestras across Venezuela, giving birth to the Simon Boliver Orchestra, and launching Dudamel's career. His name is (was) Jose Antonio Abreu. He died a few years ago. He started the whole enterprise in an underground car park on the outskirts of Caracas when he gave musical instruments to a small number of poor children and began a musical venture. He was an economist, politician and musician. He was a real mover and shaker. El Sistema has been copied internationally.
@@trevorjones3273 Thanks TJ👍
Part 1: Hymnus: Veni, creator spiritus 1:15
Part 2: Final Scene from Goethe's Faust 25:38
Dudamel es proper director del segle xxI quina meravella de director..... Pelegrí bernial de Mollet
Premiere #otd in 1910 ❤❤❤
テンポは総じてきびきびしていて躍動感があり、才能を感じます。
意外とこういう感じの音楽を作れる指揮者が多くはないと感じます。(だから人気が出るのでしょう。)
演奏を聴いていると出来そうな気がするのですけれどね。私自身は躍動感のある深みのある音楽を自分の指揮で表せる気がしてしまう。この曲と、第2番「復活」、チャイコフスキーの4・5・6番のシンフォニー、ストラビンスキーの「春の祭典」、ムソルグスキー/ラヴェル編曲の「展覧会の絵」、リムスキー=コルサコフの「シェエラザード」などは、是非とも指揮してみたい曲です。
でも、TH-camでこの曲のいろいろな演奏を聴くと、感動したとは言えない指揮者も案外多い気がするのです。物足りないとか、そこはもっとテンポを上げ上げで盛り上げるべきでしょうよとか。それが単に自分の音楽の好みとの違いかもしれないと言われればそれまでですが。
でも、私はスコアリーディングも出来るし、声楽ソロや合唱のことに至るまでよく理解しているつもりです。指揮法も学んでいるし。だからなおさら好みの問題があるのかもしれません。
ならば私自身が指揮者になればよかったんじゃないのか? と言われれば、「はい、その通りでした」
指揮者になれば、あとは自分の音楽が人々に評価されるか否かです。やってみなければそれは誰が指揮者になる場合でも分かりません。全く箸にも棒にも引っかからないかもしれないし、人気指揮者になるかもしれないし。けれど私には自分の音楽性に自信があります。
ところで、そういう読者からは怪訝な目で見られるといいますか、アンチが沢山出てきそうな自己承認欲求的な話はこのくらいにするとして、
Los Angeles Philarmonic | Simon Bolivar Symphony Orchestra of Venezuela
Coro Sinfonico Juvenil Simon Bolivar de Venezuela | Ninos cantores de Venezuela | Schola Cantorum de Venezuela | Schola Juvenil de Venezuela
とのことですが、拍手と歓声を見ていると、まるでベネズエラのお祭りの様でもあります。単に演奏への評価だけの拍手では全くなさそう。
Was Daniel Barenboim für Beethoven, ist Gustav Dudamel für Mahler. ❤❤❤
cosmos like finale.
15:38 the little girl looking straight int the camera like "bitch what up" is priceless
ladved get some glasses or a psychotherapist
+Alex Reik get a life, maybe
I disagree with your reaction. That's a narrow interpretation of the little girl's momentary lapse in concentration.
+Enrique Sanchez It was weird
I found you funny, unlike these dry-humored assholes
In Europe, the audience clap like seals when the music pauses between movements (parts in this case); the Venezuelan public show their class here - respect.
I'd love to hear the bass soloist as Hagen or Boris.
I do not have any respect for the political party that dominates Venezuela. They are bloody dictators. But I have to say that I was really moved to watch all these children, some of them probably from poor neighborhoods in Venezuela, singing this wonderful piece of Mahler.
Wilson hermano! Tu y yo estuvimos aquí!!!
24:05 with the two kids, lol
The little guy at 47:30 doesn't look happy at all. Oh, good. He's got it back together at 1:07:
El Principio del Fin. Majestuoso 1:15:43
Con audífonos creo se escucha, sonido delby atmos
goddamn captions are wanting. how can these first timers even understand
18:00
58:23 1:13:25--
Puxa como estará essa grande orquestra nesta crise comunista na Venezuela?
By all that is good, stop using that awful marketing title. Mahler himself hated it.
With the exception of Titan and Nachtmusik, he hated all the titles that were given to his symphonies
only Bernstein
And Dudamel in Venezuela. First time 1987 Guiness Record with the biggest choir.
Is this guy a conductor or just for show !
perhaps if you had a musical education you would know
This sort of pretentious comment is exactly what turns people off to the classical music scene. He's a conductor.
He's a metal-head. What should we expect?
Im a metal head,Ive also been a musician for more than 30 years.Ive conducted have you ?
Composer, pianist, some violin, conducted choirs and strings since 1974
This is Mahler trying to be Beethoven.
Hello, already!!!
Mahler running rings round Beethoven😂
Miserable electronic substitute for a massive pipe organ… such a pity for a further spotless performance.
Siempre la sinfonía de los mil impresiona. Desafortunadamente noto que Dudamel esta perdiendo la frescura que le caracterizó al inicio, esta perdiendo esa fuerza emotiva qué imprimió a sus primeras partituras. Trata de suplir esos defectos con obras volcánicas como el presente caso, la obertura 1812 o un ya desangelado Huapango de Moncayo. Lastima, fue bueno mientras duró.