What is Psychoanalysis?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2024
- A lot of Sigmund Freud's ideas have been debunked over the years (Oedipus Complex, penis envy, psychosexual stages of development...to name a few). But Freud's greatest invention, psychoanalysis, has lived on. Granted, today it is not nearly as popular and there are gaping holes in research and evidence. However, psychoanalysis marked the beginning of psychotherapy as a field. Its influence on psychology is remarkable and likely solidified it as a discipline. Therapy would not be the same without it. In this episode of Micah Psych, we explore the definition of psychoanalysis, its underlying theories, how its practiced, its effectiveness, and if your attraction to your mom is normal...just kidding! Or am I?
Sources:
Prochaska, J. O., & Norcross, J. C. (2009). Systems of psychotherapy: A transtheoretical analysis. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole Pub.
www.simplypsyc...
Check out the extra Rorschach inkblots on Patreon -
/ posts
HUGE thanks to our Patreon supporters, particularly to Ryan M. Shaver and Carrie McKenzie - our Patreon Producers. You are both like a cool shower on a hot, sunny day! Also, big shoutout to our newest patrons, Ali Mattu, Daniel L, and Eric Earley!
Neuro Transmissions is a channel on a mission to bring neuroscience to everyone. It's not rocket surgery, it's brain science! Learn all sorts of fun and interesting things with Alie Astrocyte and Micah Psych every other Sunday by subscribing to the channel. Have a topic you want covered? Let us know in the comments. Share, like, and subscribe for more videos to come! Over and out.
Neuro Transmissions is on the other social medias too:
/ neurotransmissions
/ neuroyoutube
/ neurotransmissions
www.neurotransm...
/ neuroyoutube
Snapchat - @neuroyoutube
**Credits**
The following images were used for educational purposes and fall under fair use laws:
orig00.deviant...
24.media.tumbl...
cdn.shopify.co...
vignette.wikia...
41ndn22xvhmr2l...
www.pngmart.com...
i.pinimg.com/o...
cfmedia.deadli...
www.sideshowto...
iconbug.com/dat...
i.imgur.com/dWg...
Footage from Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi and I Heart Huckabees were used for nonprofit educational purposes and were intended to benefit the public by teaching scientific concepts through relatable content. Therefore, they fall under fair use.
Vector images from freepik.com
“nucleus of life” by Dee Yan-Key is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike License.
freemusicarchiv...
“Massive” by Podington Bear is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 International License.
freemusicarchiv...
“In The Mist” by Trackmanbeatz is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
www.trackmanbea...
All other content is original and/or owned by Neuro Transmissions.
DUDE! a little warning would have been nice before I played this video out loud in my living room with my wife and mother nearby
Ikr
Bro same
Oof...must have been a hell of an awkward time...I want to watch
PLS-
I was not spared of that humiliation!!
The bookshelf is filled with video games XD
😂😂😂
Make him even look better...! 😆😆
Gaming is art
You know that means he's a TRUE professional
You’re cadence is pretty great. Well explained topic and I vibe with it
the intro caught me off guard
I screamed "NO" out loud
my partner was beside me and he looked at me very shocked. I don't blame him:))))
@@haos5046 man I so wish I could see that awkward moment when you go "no it's study I don't actually want to..." and your partner cuts you off and goes "if you want to speak about it I won't judge you" and you're like "noooo"
@@ayouxy as a joke yes but we both have very fucked up jokes so it's ok😂😂
@@haos5046 shame...would've worked better if you were the wholesome polite type
For the word association thing, I mostly found myself just repeating the word you'd said. Not sure what that says about me...
I just pictured the thing/person, but didn't have an automatic/immediate word association.
I guess you've gotta force yourself to say a different word. Haha. But it's hard! Maybe it just says you're lazy. 😝 Me too, though.
Interesting! In an actual session, the analyst would wait for you to say a word, but would probably take note of how long it takes you to respond back. I don't really put much stock in word association, but it is a fun experiment!
Or maybe it means I'm just too good at following directions...
Lol, true true.
I love how he's sitting in the arm chair with a suit on in front of the bookcase giving off the traditional look of someone who is well educated and perhaps an authority on the subject, but when you look close you see there is nothing but video games and novelty items on the shelves lol That was so refreshing! The content of the video was A+ and I love the authenticity. He's a smart dude just being himself and letting the content speak for itself. I just subbed!
As a graduate student, this video made it so easy to understand the basics of psychoanalysis. Your form of presenting made listening and watching easy.
So?? How do you break into their subconscious mind?
Dreams and Transference.
I find it disappointing that you neglected to inform the viewers that there are probably around 10 different schools of thought in psychoanalysis today. Almost no one is doing classical Freudian analysis anymore. Whenever I see someone conflating the field as a whole with Freud, I know this is someone who does not know what they are talking about. Freud was a long time ago, so why hold the entire field to what he had to say? There are many prominent psychoanalytic therapists and psychoanalysts who have contributed to the field and Jonathan Shedler has researched and written quite a bit about the efficacy of psychodynamic therapy.
Freud was literally coming from the Victorian era, people tend to overlook that. He was a visionary who couldn't even grasp the fulness of his own ideas, that's how radically new they were. Today, there are plenty of therapeutic modalities and mental illness treatment, as well as therapy in general, have developed immensely. To talk about Freudian psychotherapy only is just... weird.
Sorry, didn't pay any attention. Couldn't stop admiring your Tiffany-style lamp and looking through the game collection.
Lol, we got the lamp for free. Somebody put that beautiful thing by the dumpster! The video games, on the other hand, are all in working order. Come on over, we'll play!
Oh, lucky you! And thanks for the invite, but your place seems to be outside of my neck of the woods... like across-the-ocean outside. Maybe some other time, then.
words words words
Problems of being multilingual... when you said the words I just thought them in a different language... good practice exercise thou...
It's weird. When you did the word association thing, I repeated the word "pain" with heart. Kinda surprised me.
_Example of transference:_
-Are you being yourself?
-How am I not myself?!
How am I not myself? Myself. How am I not myself? How am I not myself? How am I not myself? How am I not myself? How am I not myself? How am I not myself? How am I not myself? How am I not myself?
Italicized how?
@PlayTheMind
I’ve never been so relieved that my mother is borderline deaf.
This is a lot easier to understand than my Psy 101 textbook, looks like your gonna be helping me through this class. Whether you like it or not.
i concur
Thank you for this video. After reading my text book's chapter on psychoanalysis and being introduced to Freud, I was blown away (and a bit disgusted) at Freud's theories. I was getting very confused too at what psychoanalysis really is, and how it works and this video explained it much better for me to understand. Thank you!
The intro took me out😭😭😭but luckily I passed my exam with this video, thank you!
When he said mother.... my mind went racing abt I couldn't think of a word.......i wonder what that means..
@@pipp972 the maybe just maybe points to a cientific aproach, that of curiosity. Yours points to the enclosure of investigation.... If its more likely, It wont hurt to investigate right? What u have to lose from It? Now If It means something and u keep It repressed, It will still be there, "iching"...
Does your mother put a lot of pressure on you?
Dude Person i was doing the same thing an yes she stresses me out an i honestly don’t like my mom
@@ae7698 Interesting. Guilt could be another culprit.
Strange her mind went 'racing', yet she couldn't think of a word. If it was racing with emotional distress, sounds like pressure. But if it was racing with words, then she clearly had a word that came to mind and didn't even realize it. If it was a negative word, she might feel guilty for even thinking such a thing, even if that's how she truly feels.
Wonder if OPs mom likes to play the victim.
What word were u trying to find oedipus?
Your theory is - Learning through examples. I just love it.
Your example of transference @6:22 is displacement, not transference. Your depiction on the couch was spot on. Transference requires that the person onto which there is transference reaction remind the patient of some other person in their life. Displacement is simply expressing an emotion felt toward someone or something onto some other person or thing.
As a graduate student i appreciate this information being presented this way. easy to digest.
Cool, now I know that my boyfriend is using transference on me when he's pissed off with his family, so instead of getting upset internally at the fact he's being abusive, I can say to myself " oh, he's using transference" so I can take it less personally when he's directing anger towards me and become less defensive! 👍
Even if you're aware of it now, that doesn't mean projecting frustrations onto you is ok. That's bad for the relationship. My ex was like this and we didn't last. It would be wise to set boundaries.
The thing about the word assosiation exercise was that I was thinking of words to say before you said them regardless of what the word was. For dog I said "apple", for toy I said "pineapple", mother I actually went "errr, I dunno" for work I said "work", coat I said "tiring" and for heart I said "pain"
Now, I dunno what this says about me, but I'd like a second opinion as to what this could suggest (psychologically, obviously)
Thank you for this video!! Your explanation on the psychoanalysis was on the point.. I liked the way you connected the Jabba of the hut, the captain America and jugde jury to Id, superego and ego... And when I tried out the word section, I could find the total different answers... I guess that its my unconscious mind, thought running in my mind... Thanks for this video... I hope you continuing doing this great work.👍
Psychoanalysis helped me when no other forms of therapy worked! Extremely grateful to Freud
Hi , i am in Analysis for last 4 years ,more than 1100 sessions ,but no emotional change, my psyche is very complex. Can u explain ,what do you mean with change , what have you experienced after psychoanalysis?
@@ceyhunabdullayev1442 not OP, but how about changing the therapist and the therapy? Gestalt therapy, for example, emphasizes on exactly what psychoanalysis doesn't - emotional release and staying in the present moment with feelings of past trauma. Everyone's psyche is complex, some have things buried deeper than others.
Psychoanalysis is still dominant in France and the Flemish areas of Belgium. Doctors in France continue to treat autism with Freudian techniques instead of CBT. BBC News published a story about it in 2012 and the French magazine L'Obs also also discussed how popular psychoanalysis is in France
100%%🤦🤦
Im currently studying psychology in the french system and its all about psychoanalysis 🤦🤦
I'm in France, and I just don't know how to get people to understand that psychoanalysis is BS. "But Lacan..." they answer, as if they just can't fathom that a frenchman could be wrong. 5
And thank you for the links!
I like the subtle as above so below reference toward the end there.
I loved this! Do you know much about the findings of this theory? You mentioned in the beginning that mental illnesses happened when the subconscious and conscious were in conflict. Or when captain America and that Star Wars thing are in conflict. Is there a theory to what types of conflicts manifest themselves to different mental illnesses? For example, anxiety
Well, Freud proposed psychosexual stages of development (which are widely debunked). He proposed that different mental illnesses would manifest depending on what developmental stage the patient becomes fixated on. So, for example, If you become fixated on the "oral" stage, you might have an oral fixation. Or if you become fixated on the "anal" stage, you might be anal retentive (this is why we call some people "anal" when they're super organized or neat). Pretty interesting, even if it's a bunch of bologna!
haha have you ever seen the movie "Dangerous Method"? With Kiera Knightly and Michael Fassbender. It gives a pretty funny depiction of Freud and it's a super good movie anyway. I think you guys would really like it.
I have seen it! In fact, I saw it in the theater and, immediately after, got to talk to John Kerr who wrote the book that the movie was based on. Interesting stuff! Btw, I noticed your Freudian slip. 😝
@@neurotransmissions Oh man, now I'm curious about that Freduain slip she did. fuuuccc........
Petrescu Radu i think the slip was when she used the word "pretty" for "really". Most freudian slips happen because of how similar some words sound 😁
". Psychoanalysis is a futile exercise because it changes nothing: it does not create a new man, it does not bring peace to you. In fact even the founders of psychoanalysis like Sigmund Freud were so much afraid of death that you cannot believe it. No normal being is so afraid of death.
The founder of psychoanalysis was so afraid that even the word “death” was not to be pronounced in front of him - it was taboo. It was not to be talked about. Three times it had happened that somebody mentioned death and Sigmund Freud fell in a swoon, in a fit, became unconscious. He was so afraid of death that he avoided going to any cemetery, he avoided going to anybody who was dying, even a friend or disciple. Wherever there was anything concerning death he was absolutely panicked - and this man gives you psychoanalysis!
His problems are not solved. He gets angry just like anybody else. He is jealous, more jealous than anybody else. He is greedy. He wants to monopolize, he wants to dominate people. He creates almost an empire of psychoanalysts around the world, but everybody has to repeat like parrots whatever he says. Anybody who says anything different is immediately expelled. It seems it is not science but a political party or a fanatic religion - not scientific research.
And the same is true about Jung. Jung came to India to meet someone… because in the East people have been working on the mind for thousands of years. But they have never developed anything like psychoanalysis; they developed meditation - a totally different approach.
What is the use of analyzing the rubbish of the mind? - sorting it out… it takes years. There are people who have been in psychoanalysis for fifteen years and they have reached nowhere. They have changed their psychoanalyst in the hope that perhaps somebody else will help, but they have not reached anywhere else. They cannot, because all that psychoanalysis does - all the schools, whether Adlerian or Jungian or Freudian - is to sort out the rubbish of your mind, interpret it according to their minds. And what is the point of it all?
In the East we have not developed psychoanalysis, we have developed meditation. Meditation simply takes you away from the garbage, takes you beyond the garbage - it is not worth bothering about. And if you want to bother about it you can go on bothering for lives. You will not come to an end.
But just being a witness to your mind, without doing anything to the mind - just being aloof, just seeing it as if thoughts are moving on a screen and simply watching it without any judgment of good and bad - a strange experience happens: thoughts slowly start disappearing. Soon a moment comes when there is only an empty screen - no thoughts. And when there is no object, no thought for your consciousness, it turns back upon itself because there is nothing preventing it; that is exactly the meaning of the word ‘object’ - it prevents, it objects.
When there is no object the consciousness goes… and just as everything moves in circles in existence, consciousness also moves in a circle. It comes back upon its own source. And the meeting of the consciousness with its own source is the explosion of light, the greatest celebration that a man is capable of, the greatest orgasmic experience.
And it is not something that happens and is finished. No, once it has happened, it continues. It remains with you. It becomes almost like your breathing. You live in it twenty-four hours a day.
Jung had come to India in search of someone, to find out what the East has done to create so many people like Gautam Buddha - not one but hundreds who have gone beyond mind and all its troubles and problems, worries, anxieties. What is the secret? He was going to universities, meeting psychoanalysts, and everywhere he was told, “You are wasting your time. These people are not the right people. These people have gone to the West to learn psychoanalysis and they are teaching psychoanalysis in the universities. You have come to search and seek somebody who is absolutely untouched by the West. And there is a man.”
And there was a man - Shri Raman Maharshi. Wherever Jung went - and he was there for three months - everywhere the same name was given to him. “Go to Arunachal in South India and meet this man who is uneducated, who knows nothing of psychoanalysis; he is the man the East has been able to produce. Just go and sit with him and talk with him and listen to him. If you have some questions, ask him.” But you will be surprised: Jung never went there.
And later on, feeling that he will be criticized, Jung wrote, “I consideredly did not go to Raman Maharshi because the East has its own way, the West has its own way, and they should not be mixed” - just to protect himself from criticism. Then why did he go to India at all? He was told again and again to go to a man who was available, which is rare, and he did not go there, although he went up to Madras, from where it was only a two hour journey to Arunachal!
Jung did not go to the man, whom just by meeting he would have seen how a clear man is, how a man is who has cleaned his mind completely - his eyes, his gestures, his words, his authority. He does not quote scriptures, he knows himself.
Jung did not go there, and he himself felt guilty. To defend himself he started writing that the East and the West have different ways. This is nonsense, because man - whether in the East or in the West - is the same. And it is strange that he was teaching Eastern students Western psychology. He should have refused because this is mixing East and West. If he was really honest then he should have said, “You go back to the East.”
He was teaching Eastern students Western psychology, but he was not ready to go to an Eastern meditator, just to meet him. What is the fear? The fear is that Jung is as normal a person as you are - just knowledgeable. He has gathered from books, but he has no authentic experience of his own.
Western psychoanalysis is just a business. It is cheating people. It is simply exploiting people without any help, and because there is no other alternative people have to go to it. The psychoanalysts themselves go to other psychoanalysts. And psychoanalysts go mad more than any other profession! They commit suicide more than any other profession; they are more perverted in every way than any other profession."
I enjoyed your informative and well-explained video, thank you :).
However, I would be a bit careful with concluding that the effectiveness of psychoanalysis hasn't been proven. There are studies that show the significant positive effects and non-inferiority of psychoanalysis compared to CBT (e.g. Driessen et al., 2015; Leichsenring & Leibing, 2007). The question much rather is, is the goldstandard of RCTs the fitting tool to measure such an abstract form of therapy, which focuses much stronger on the subjectivity and complexity of human nature?
While I agree that Psychoanalysis is not for everyone and also not fitting for all mental illnesses, it would have been nice to include which cases this method is suitable for, e.g. Boderline Personality Disorder.
Agree. I would go so far to say that CBT is not for everyone. It is considered the most scientific approach these days and psychology tries so hard to be recognised this way which may be good for recognition of the discipline but not so much for patients/clients. Human soul is not quantifiable and thus qualitative approaches are much better. Although working with thought-feeling-behaviour CBT model is very helpful as the ground work, I don't like CBT personally. I think combination of humanistic, transpersonal, Gestalt/drama/psychomotor, somatic, Jungian (work with imagination, archetypes), psychosynthesis is the way to heal. CBT is a good step for people to understand their cognitive and behavioural process but then it does stop there. What about exploration of unwanted parts, the unknown - that brings self-compassion and acceptance. I like working with Hillman, Donald Kalsched, Bosnak, Assagioli, Jung etc. Much much better.
What you said about tranfererence is wrong, that is actually displacement. Transference is expressing your feelings which you hold for your close one's towards the therapist.
Hey there! I can see why you would say it is displacement and not transference. Displacement is releasing emotions on a "safer" target because you could not express them towards the original target. Perhaps I should have clarified that the emotions (like anger) were *also* present in the original situation with the boss or with the brothers. It was not my intention to confuse the two terms, though I see why it sounds like that. Thanks for the feedback!
When I'm gaining a lot of information from my prof but, still wanted to explore more to learn about my chosen field
ANONYMOUS BLINK which you chose when you were 17 and probably took out a huge loan for something you can learn here on TH-cam
when you say mother my words was loyalty , work= power, toy =west of time , heart: decision . even i'm actually more rational than hear person was supprise i associate it with decision making .
CBT is crap. Psychoanalysis is not perfect but the concepts Freud came up with are revolutionary. And the impact on the broad discipline is extremely positive. Pscyhodynamic approach rules.
that first 4 seconds hit me like a semi-truck
People who don't know how to use their minds tend to rely on others to understand themselves. People with an able mind don't have to get such therapies. They can understand themselves through introspection. But it takes courage, curiosity, and honesty to truly understand oneself. And most people lack those character traits. So I found out that working on your character traits is the foundation for understanding yourself and freeing you from all conditioning, scripts, or beliefs that detached you from your authenticity.
I didn't do any kind of therapy with a psychiatrist or psychologist. Through consistent self-development, I freed myself from my past traumas, negative beliefs, and social conditioning. Now I feel free of shame even if others keep bringing up my past and insulting me. I feel enthusiastic, optimistic, and daring to achieve my dreams.
The Rorschach image looked like cars driving up a hill. What does that mean?
you speak like if psychoanalysis stopped being studied after Freud died. Pretty narrowed opinion you have there at the end.
He said work and I was like "me", which doesn't make sense
retro games and analog cameras, what are those suppose to mean ...
Do you think the psychoanalysis theory applies to the movie joker?
As someone who refers to and uses psychoanalysis a lot in my videos, I better start putting in disclaimers on its doubtful scientific basis and diminished popularity in modern psychology. :-\
Yeah, it definitely isn't popular anymore. Only about 1% of people seeing a therapist go to a psychoanalyst! However, psychoanalysis has had a huge impact on therapy, particularly on how it is portrayed in media
Incidentally, I also used Jabba as an image of the Id! :-)
I just loosely apply it in a kind of philosophising way without claiming truth. It's just fun to speculate. :-)
Sadly, at least in Uruguay and Argentina Psychoanalysis is the most popular ''therapy''. It's a very bad situation.
The psyche is immensely complex. Depth psychology learns a lot from observing active imagination and dreams, which with the current tools wont lead to solid scientific evidence. That doesn't mean that the theories coming out of these observational studies are wrong though, they might contain very deep truths about our nature. Just because something doens't (yet) have a solid scientific basis doesn't mean it should be abandoned (its not that you guys are saying that). You end up throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
You lost me when you said Judge Judy listens to both sides.
im working on my assignment now thanks to your help..
What do you think is the reason why Sigmund Freud created the Freudian theory? And what is the application of it to our society?
If psychoanalyzing didn't work, why were there patients who were cured from it like Sabina Spielrein?
Thank you a lot for this magnificient video that permitted me to go further beyond the understanding of psychoanalysis
Silent hill brought me here and I have no regrets cause this is really interesting
bro my laptop was full volume when i opened this video chill
My free association:
friend,cheerful,help,hard,cold,frail
Nice video! I hope this helps me with my unit 1 Psych test tomorrow... also 1:50 gave me an idea for a drawing lol.
Haha, if you send me that drawing, I will cherish it forever. Good luck with your test!!
Neuro Transmissions If you actually want a drawing of that I will gladly do it haha, but after I take my test.. I will let you know how it goes if you like. That photo can be like a reward from me to you if I do well lol
I would love that!
TRIGGER WARNING:
My mother. My father. My husband. All three of them took me to clinical death thru the years.
🙈🙉🙊
I had a near death experience at 4 years old after an extremely brutal lashing. When i came back in my body, i told God "oh no! You're leaving me here with these people who are going to keep hurting my body" i was instantly hopeless & in despair. I became suicidal that moment. A millisecond before i had been flying thru puffy, white clouds with God... Right by my side! I never saw Him, but i heard His voice. When he said "NO"! that was all He said. At the same moment i was thrown , HARD, back into my body. It hurt. I spent from age 4 to age 50, off and on thru the years, in suicidal ideation. Mostly on. At age 18 i discovered that i had been abused. I started doing intense work on myself as I had no other choice but to. I had my fair share of stays in the psych ward. the pain of the memories that were forcing themselves to my conscience incapacitated me. I would sit, basically nearly catatonic, on the couch and stare out the window for hours, for weeks sometimes. I remember thinking I should blink. I spent my twenties recovering memories, one by one. Then I'd process them. By myself. I had two different therapists tell me they couldn't work with me as they found my story too upsetting. Lmao! What losers! If i dared to share with anyone they were basically always revolted, they would say they didn't believe me. Or that no mother would ever do that to their child. Or they'd say "but he is so quiet, sweet, soft spoken. He seems so nice".I shattered my hip running for my life from him. I got most of my teeth knocked out over 20 years. I recommend going no contact & if you can't, you get some BIG, SOLID, HEALTHY, PROTECTIVE boundaries and enforce the hell out of them. You could get a taser. Or a gun. Personally i count on my Angels. I have a legion God graced me with! My rosary is my weapon!
Long Live Christ the King!
Mary wears combat boots!
Amen
My mom was right there when the video began.......
"Mother"
Brain : Fu.. shit
Very helpful video. Thanks you. Is there anywhere I can read about the 4 months case study on Psychoanalysis and Behavioural therapy?
I love the suit glasses and fancy lamp in front of a gaming shelf
Sare ache lectures to English me ha hm kiya kre
I've been going to therapy twice a week for 8 years and only recently realized this was "weird" when I had clients myself who were therapists (I'm a dietitian / nutrition counselor in private practice).
One session is individual and the other is group with 10 people.
I used to not sleep well and it has helped with getting me to identify and explain my emotions. I just still don't trust the therapist because it has been 8 years, the fee has gone up, and I still know very little about him.
But that could be more about me not trusting people in general?
Surprising it isn't respected in the counseling world...my therapist describes himself as a modern psychoanalytic and is a LCSW.
jrg305 geez, change therapists. He’s probably like, why does this patient want to know so much about my personal life? And 8 years? Holy cow move on
If you feel that its still helpful, there's no problem in continuing. Studies have shown that there tends to be a dose-response relationship in psychotherapy, where more sessions also mean more improvement. The idea that psychotherapy should always be short-term is debatable. Most forms of CBT have between 40% and 70% relapse, which means that many people who have CBT and stop treatment start becoming anxious or depressed again after one or two years. And when I do long-term treatment with clients we don't focus only on symptoms but also on more general personality change and personal growth. So continuing for years doesn't have to be a bad thing per se. But if you feel that you're stuck and not making much progress, it may be better to change therapists.
Well I saw a guy on my insurance for about 6 months after breaking up with my aforementioned therapist. I wouldn't have done so, but he repeated a trauma I had around coming out and being repeatedly invalidated around that. Well, I switched political parties last year from dem to republican and he didn't approve at all.
The new therapist was not as good. But he was a good interim. I'm now working with a lady who does attachment trauma via NLP and family constellations since my main issue is still never in a romantic relationship and I'm now 36...I think I have disorganized or ambivalent attachment, and she says she shifts that. She isn't a therapist tho, but she is an empath and very good.
@@lordtains Well put!
does that mean it's kind off useless to walk this road if I am looking for an answer regarding psycological disturbance and pain
In the example you gave at 5:36 - would the therapist eventually say to the patient "hey so pay attention to this- you're angry at your brothers but your pointing that at me" ? cause you said they mostly don't talk... so what do they do actually? and what do they do with all the notes? 5 years make tons of notes... I get that the end goal is, like you said, to get yourself conscious about you're unconscious defense mechanisms, but is it done by the therapist pointing them out to you? or if he doesn't then how does it eventually happen?
Thanks
As for the word association, I said 'buffalo'. I didn't even see that coming outta my mouth but, thanks. Great content.
hello, great work! only a few questions
1) wouldn't Freud call them patients? not clients? (humanists would call them clients)
2)Is'nt client centered therapy the involvment of active listening where the therapist doesnt talk much? if they are similar how do you spot the differences??
Client centered therapy is about the acceptance that the client is the real expert of his subjective world. its a humanistic approach based on Phenonenology philosophy that tries to give a rigourous frame to help client elaborate his subjective experience of his challenges (with Rogers being the first person to do systematic research on what work in therapy).
In the client centered therapy, therapist talk. Not as much as client, for sure, but a lot more than in psychoanalysis where the therapist is a lot more neutral. In client centered therapy, if the therapist, after careful consideration, think revealing something about himself or herself, a opinion, will help the client improve toward congruence of the self, they will do it. The therapist is not seing, as in psychoanalysis, as a neutral projecting white board. Active listening doesnt mean being neutral (but require to refrain from answering too fast to let the empathic work do it job).
Look at Rogers video with Gloria online, you will see Rogers was talking and his non verbal was way more active than what psychoanalysis does (they stay behind the client couch).
Normally, "intellectual" people have their bookshelves behind them in their videos. But a video game library? Lol.
Fun video, great to help retain information I need while I study for the NCE. Thank you for your contribution.
psychoanalysis gave me answers that other types of therapy never did. 2x a week, still about to make a year... I don't know if it`s disappearing
Thanks for the introduction, very gripping.
Omg im in grade10 highschool but is taking a grade 12 class on psychology, and we have to do our own research on topics for our project literally the 3rd day of class and this helped ALOT. Thanks!
This guy looks like Steve Rogers
Thank you so much !! I have a homework and your video was just what I needed :D
Perfect! I'm glad to hear it. 😁
عملٌ يُجهِد خير من فراغ يفسد what you need is to stop going to school
As far as I know, psychoanalysis is still going relatively strong in France and Italy...
In Argentina and Uruguay as well. Actually, Buenos Aires is one of the main centers of psychoanalysis in the world.
Hi, I want to ask you a question. If some psychologist comes to know about a patient's psychological problems. How can he cure them? I mean, pieces of advice do not usually have much effect on these patients. Moreover, if you tell the patients that this is wrong with you does not cure anybody automatically. Just want to know what should a person do after getting all this data.
Great video, I am gonna subscribe and watch all of them. Just a question, by what you say, cognitive therapy is more scientific tan psychoanalysis?
Sweet! That's nice of you to say! CBT and its techniques have been extensively studied and there is a lot of empirical data to support its effectiveness with different disorders. Psychoanalysis, on the other hand, has a lot of anecdotal support from therapists who use psychoanalysis. However, there has not been enough controlled research conducted on psychoanalysis to classify it as an evidence-based practice. I hope that's helpful!
Neuro Transmissions Thought this video was on what it is not on the effectiveness as a whole?
I didn’t realize psychoanalysis was so rigorous
what the heck was that introduction my volume was so loud
Video was doing well until you expressed your limited idea of how psychoanalysis works nowadays and dismiss Freud’s work…
Has psychodynamic therapy also fallen out of favor?
It has not. See Shedler's paper on the efficacy of psychodynamic therapy. The core tenets of good psychotherapy are psychodynamic elements.
If it wasn't for Frued, where would we be.. hmmmm
This video was hard to watch for a number of reasons, partly because the speaker doesn't speak to the extensive research supporting the efficacy of psychodynamic/psychoanalytic therapies, and because he presents an outdated, extremely narrow version of analysis via a caricature (the stuffy Freudian suit and the DVDs in place of books on the shelf - although that did make me chuckle). I think what makes me sad is that close to 400K people have watched the video, and many of them have likely come away with the impression that psychoanalysis - composed of *many different kinds of therapy* that honor the depths and complexity of the human soul - is just expensive quackery. In fact, many analysts take on pro bono or reduced-fee patients, and people can often find cheaper treatment through analytic training institutes. The condescending tone of the video, plus the rather uninformed nature of the speaker's comments, plus the video's popularity... ah, what to say?! I wish therapists were more respectful of orientations besides their own, or that at least they would do their homework before declaiming, especially when they have such a large audience as this channel has.
It sounds like a powerful tool but it also sounds like by not sharing with the patient what they are observing, they are just slowing the patients healing. Most people are not aware of their own behaviors. For example if you go to a anger management meetings you will slowly see your own bad behaviors.
Yes, I agree, that was a problem of psychoanalysis that it is a blank screen therapist approach which is pretty difficult imo. Schools like psychosynthesis, humanistic approach bring a bit more "honesty" from the side of the therapist. Connecting with a therapist through him sharing his empathy and showing a bit of himself (not oversharing though) can be extremely healing. I have had a few therapist in my life and the blank screen did not work for me.
But which is better, Fable II or Fable III. Tough one.
Fable 3 for sure, but Fable 1 is better than them all imho
I do not agree with a lot of Freud's findings, but I do like this one!
Good video thanks for the information. By the way, why do you have games on your shelves?
Thanks a lot for watching! I'm a big video game dork. I collect games that interest me, but now that I have so many I never play most of them!
😂😂
Now I am going to go on a binge inkblot test.
is that a shelf full of books or a shelf full of game CDs behind him?
Useful for me .. studying MSc psychology ..
Oh wonderful! What do you hope to do after you graduate?
I don’t agree that psychoanalysis is falling out of favor. In fact it tends to be the most popular psychology topics from attachment style theory to transactional analysis. I don’t agree to much with Freud, but he was on to something that we have built on that’s seeing great results at least antidotally from patients on online forums.
I do agree however through serious mental illness it’s probably not the right approach. But for your broken soul who struggles with relationships and with themselves, I think it’s a revelational.
That Freudian spoof 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol he plays a lot of video games look at his background halo and other stuffs......
Nice.. red dead redemption. For xbox..... what was your vid about again..?
Im reading the xbox titles. Damn adhd
for heart i said hunger, and i’m now sad.
I said dead, im concerned
WHY WOULD YOU START IT LIKE THAT😭🤚
Captain America isn't obsessed with any higher ideals, he simply has an insatiable hunger for justice.
I'm only now learning that this exists. I use the word psychoanalysis a lot, in the literal sense, that I'm observing and analyzing my psychology from the inside out. Freud's take on psychoanalysis has some similarities but just as many differences. I'll be more careful using that word from now on, now that I know it has other meanings.
Lovely vide. Great explanation of the theory of pleasure vs reality. Memorable and valuable posting! Thank you!
Why are people with Bipolar Disorder not a good candidate for this kind of therapy
awesome video! you should do a video on freuds theory of personality and Regression, projection, sublimation, denial
the most creepiest intro i ever seen
Who start. Conversation with that...
this video makes it much easier for me to understand! Thank you!
I'm a student of psychology Honors..I would like to learn how to counselling to others ? Plzz make video on it as soon as possible..
Your view is outdated. Many empirical studies made by Mark Solms on Neuroscience confirm much of Frued's theory. Hehehe.
Where can I find these studies?
Which I should read about to know psychoanalysis...
@Ana Calderon-Brau what bro
well that escalated quickly