The more I listen to this piece the more I understand that this is a very serious symphonic work, very modern, monumental, and this is music for 21st century.
Much like Stravinsky, Schnittke often uses the instruments outside their normal registers, giving their sound an intense, more harmonically complex quality. Plus, he regularly uses less common instruments such as the celesta, snare drum, gong, tubular bells, etc. His orchestrations are pure genius.
Начало прошлого века - расцвет символизма. Посмотрел фильм "Агония", многое понял, Элем Климов создал фильм, опираясь на символы. Также и гениальный Шнитке.
I am so glad my mom bought some Schnittke CDs when we lived in Moscow back in 1986. I was 15 then. Still love his deeply beautiful and disturbing music.
Amazing for 15 years old to appreciate such a complex music. I was so stupid musically at that age. I took me half a century and I studied music too. What happened to you now, I wonder? In the West?
He was one of the last great musical geniuses. An innovator. Time was cruelly against him. But he created wonderful work. It is always commitment music that makes you sit up, touches something deeply. I heard his music at the Proms, possibly early 90s. He came out after the work was played, looking extremely frail, acknowledging the huge clamour of Proms appreciation! Never to be forgotten.
I honestly think it's wrong to say: "one of the last" Exactly this is why great musicians only get discovered decades after their masterpieces are created.
@@florianstasch6435 simply meant, in scope seemed to belong to the "great composer" tradition. Meant nothing about the likelihood that many future generations will "discover" his work. They surely will.
It was not very long ago that there was very little of Schnittke's music in/on You tube and now all of a sudden a much larger amount is available. His symphonies range from total satire to very serious and his choral music is being performed more often in more places. When I purchased a CD of his 8th Symphony w/ his "Suite from The Census List" it became obvious that his ability to compose in very different styles was like changing clothes!
Schnittke was a master of making his full scale symphonic works accessible for general public, good example, he made his music lighter, more conventional and yet it is the same complex Schnittke, 21st century music. His music for cinema is beautiful, opens new horizons, prepares you for his symphonic works.
@@НоваяЖизнь-г2г Правильное наблюдение, качественно 21 век пока это 20, в частности многие события это продолжение распада Советского Союза, т.е. корректировка границ ближе к этническим границам. А менталитет, политические подходы не изменились совершенно - это таже Холодная Война, на самом деле мы отброшены назад ко временам Хрущева. А если взять культуру и конкретно серьезную музыку, то впечатление творческого застоя - испольнительское искусство растет, а новых шедевров нет, ну если не считать "Киркорова". Я давно не был в России, не знаю что происходит на выставках живописи, стараюсь читать, но пока ничего особенного, а музыке точно застой. Вот мысль-вопрос, который меня будоражит уже много лет: вот советская власть, разруха-нужда, низкий уровень культуры полуграмотной массы народа, партийная цензура, свободы нет, человека могут арестовать за не совсем "политически выверенную" постановку спектакля, а великие произведения появляются во всех сферах культуры. А может быть "свобода" тут и вовсе не причем? Или можеть быть свободу просто невозможно отнять: ты ее в дверь, а она в окно?
@@YThome7 а железная поступь истории, объективный фактор? Это куда девать? Все, что вы перечислили, фактор субъективный. И хотя роль личности в истории никто не отменял, главное это базис. Ну что вы герра Карла Маркса не читали?
@@НоваяЖизнь-г2г Ничего не понял из Вашего ответа, но поставил Лайк, потому что больше некому, ведь мало кто даже пытается ответить на мой вопрос. Пробовал читать в зрелом возрасте, но трудно читать, но в объме Краткого Курса и в объме университетской программы "изучал", вернее меня учили. Не понял Вас, попрубуйте еще раз. Я говорю - свободы не было, а рыба в Каме была и великие симфонии сочиняли. Вот Американские мызыковеды критикуют Пятую Шестоковича, мол, написал чтобы угодить Сталину, а ведь именно эта симфония в Америке и по сей день самая популярная! Не Четвертая, а Пятая! Значит что, Сталин знал что нужно всем "народам"? А Катерину Измайлову в Америке никто не ставит и не слушает, но все твердят что это великая опера. Лично я считаю что все три перечисленные великие и я их все люблю. Так причем тут свобода? Ему запретили это, а он написал то. Его раскритиковали за это, а он создал то. И все равно то, что он создал талантливо! Вот Киркоровщина совершенно свободна сегодня - хоть нагишом, а ведь это все не более чем развлекательный балаган! Сорочинская ярмарка! Поступь истории всегда железная, и сейчас тоже, вон как гремит, не просто железом а с ураном 235! А где симфония чтобы зал битком как это было в те времена!
These impure tones right at the beginning of the introduction. Is this a kind of hopelessness? What`s going on with these tones. Can you believe it? You cannot understand great art. Great art is overwhelming.
Музыка стопроцентно иллюстрирует содержание фильма. Помню свои ощущения при просмотре, жуть, жуть. И музыка помогает ощутить это в полной мере. Гениальный Шнитке, что ещё сказать...
Symphonic and chamber works can sound good. If the musicians and conductor are giving their all. If the sound engineers did their job well. If the recording transfers well to TH-cam. If the piece itself is worth your time. Rare is it when all of these things coalesce. And rare is my pleasure now, hearing this splendid piece yet again for the veritable "umpteenth" time.
I had to write a homework about Vivaldi. While doing this, I heard to "Agony". My mother stepped in and looked on the things I was writing. After some time she looked to the computer. Time flew when she finally said:"This isn't Vivaldi." Of course this isn't Vivaldi!
This musical themes he repeats for most of his career makes his work even more curious and interesting. My life is another composer after knowing the works of Schnittke.
Spannende Interpretation dieses relativ melodischen Meisterwerks von Schnittke mit gut phrasierten und perfekt vereinigten Töne aller Instrumente. Der geniale Dirigent leitet das hoch funktionelle Orchester im ein bisschen bedrohlichen Tempo mit völlig effektiver Dynamik. Echt atemberaubend!
Oh wow ! I'd never really listened to Schnittke but he has my attention now. The outer movements are mightily intense and captivating. The Waltz and Tango are reminiscent of Shostakovich's Jazz Suites, and good as they are, less memorable. The Tango seems to go on forever without much variation.
Schnittke was one of favorite students of Shostakovich, but certain influence you noticed is not only an impact of a mentor. The whole Soviet concert stage was dominated by great two: Shostakovich and Prokofiev. And not all among Soviet musicians liked it. In recent times, many began to question whether it was really good: the dominance of these two left several others in a shadow for too long. I like both of them Shostakovich and Prokofiev as well as Schnittke and Sveridov (both favorite students of Shostakovich) but there is some validity in challenging the two giants.
This sounds much clearer than (and probably a different recording to) the CD I have of Alfred Schnittke film music. Some amazing stuff in this soundtrack.
I hear you. Some recordings may not be the best possible performance, but they are the best possible recording, like when they set the Mike's up properly and distribute the sound appropriately so that we can hear the tempany rolls like a distant Thunder behind the trumpets French horns violas and whatever the hell else is playing.
The Walts is greatly influence mainly by Prokofiev and Shostakovich. Shnittke used to be one of the great avant-gaudes of the 20th century but his film music is a different story.
16:00 the finale begins in a gentle way 17:20 the ongoing bell/trumpet begins 18:44 the trumpet (I think) begins in the background for the next 25 seconds
Merci pour cette musique. La Valse (4'33") est clairement inspirée de la valse de son quintette avec piano (ou son Requiem pour la version orchestrale).
Il s'agit en réalité d'un thème récurrent dans la musique de Schnittke. Un vrai Leitmotiv, retrouvable dans de très nombreux morceaux du compositeur, à travers l'entièreté de sa vie.
No foreigner composer has ever understood tango as good as Schnittke. I am curious to know if there is some info regarding this matter (interviews, articles, etc.)
It is interesting. I have seen from Wikipedia that Schnittke was a second generation "Russian" (Jew) as his father moved to Russia. Nevertheless his music seems to be profoundly influenced by Russian/Soviet music. I love it.
Филмът е въздейства. Разпад и гротеска. Това, което, очевидно, е било цел на режисьора е постигнато забележително добре. Актьорите са на изключително високо ниво, впечатлен съм. Но! Единствено музиката на Шнитке е гениална.
This is the most legitimate of modern music we know of written in the later part of the 20th century and yet it's given no legitimacy by the conservatories or the 'production' companies - as long as they appease the 'night at the pops' loving unsophisticated dregs of the audience that claim to love the masterworks never include diamonds in the rough like Schnittke or Sviridov disgusts me as they shovel their write-off money to sustain a nostalgia they call art.
When I hear stuff like this, and compare it to the sadly very cliched stuff that film scores have become, it makes me wonder "Where are the film scores of yesteryear?"
Not to mention "Where are the good movies?" "Oh yet another remake or superhero movie." All I can say is stay the hell away from the typical Hollywood blockbuster fare. Look elsewhere.
То, что предначертано - не выучить. Можно и нужно быть готовым к "контрольной".... Читай последнюю главу библии... Ш нитке ее прочёл... И пересказал... (Мое мнение)
@@alexandratchepournova2867 у меня автоматическое исправление на клавиатуре, немного не уследишь ( и например, автоматическое исправление на не у следишь). Так бывает...
The more I listen to this piece the more I understand that this is a very serious symphonic work, very modern, monumental, and this is music for 21st century.
Потрясающе! Гениальный композитор! !!!! Созвучно нашему времени! Трогает и волнует Душу! Благодарю!!!!!!
Much like Stravinsky, Schnittke often uses the instruments outside their normal registers, giving their sound an intense, more harmonically complex quality. Plus, he regularly uses less common instruments such as the celesta, snare drum, gong, tubular bells, etc. His orchestrations are pure genius.
i totally agree with you
Согласен! Шнитке и Стравинский большие экспериментаторы в музыке.
These new harmonies bring sounds of the street, everyday noise, this is what Shostakovich did it too. Great!
@@YThome7 th-cam.com/video/5gRGf4aNtkE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=xBpgOMOpaFHb_A7o
Когда б кто знал - из какого сора, пыли, боли и страданий родилась эта музыка
My biggest mistake but my last chance:
I heard Schnittke first time in my age of 67.
never too late to find something new)
wernertrptube I'm 63 !! and a musician .. first time also
wernertrptube There is no age to discover such a great masterpiece..
I first heard him last month. I'm 68. He brought me back to orchestral music. I am now listening to everything from Haydn to Goercki.
21 years old here. Now I feel pretty good about myself. Thanks.
Начало прошлого века - расцвет символизма. Посмотрел фильм "Агония", многое понял, Элем Климов создал фильм, опираясь на символы. Также и гениальный Шнитке.
I think I've listened to this about 100x now. Keeps getting better and better!
agreed. Something about it.
@@davidfloren5339 согласен. Что-то в этом
I am so glad my mom bought some Schnittke CDs when we lived in Moscow back in 1986. I was 15 then. Still love his deeply beautiful and disturbing music.
Amazing for 15 years old to appreciate such a complex music. I was so stupid musically at that age. I took me half a century and I studied music too. What happened to you now, I wonder? In the West?
Крутая музыка и замечательный фильм!! 😊
Just unbelievable complexity, dynamic and beauty.
Arte, oficio, maestría y genialidad. No me canso de escuchar esta música. Schnittke es uno de mis músicos favoritos.
0:00 - Introduction
4:34 - Waltz
9:46 - Tango
15:59 - Finale
Kaleriya Orlova Obrigado!
Thanks!
Final!
enfin! 15:59
Danke sehr!
Сильно,Вечно.Достойно,и по доброй традиции-неистрибимо.Легко пилить,но растить в 100- крат.Шнитке-вечен!
He was one of the last great musical geniuses. An innovator. Time was cruelly against him. But he created wonderful work. It is always commitment music that makes you sit up, touches something deeply. I heard his music at the Proms, possibly early 90s. He came out after the work was played, looking extremely frail, acknowledging the huge clamour of Proms appreciation! Never to be forgotten.
I honestly think it's wrong to say: "one of the last" Exactly this is why great musicians only get discovered decades after their masterpieces are created.
Why was time agaist him? He worked very much in cinema and was well known .
@@florianstasch6435 simply meant, in scope seemed to belong to the "great composer" tradition. Meant nothing about the likelihood that many future generations will "discover" his work. They surely will.
@@ТатьянаГубина-и1и sorry didn't clarify, I meant due to his poor health - it's sad he died relatively young.
@@stuartgoodall7258 Yes, Mozart died still younger, alas!
He makes your pain and agony feel epic.
It is epic; it is beautiful in its own right, in the larger context of what reality is and the greater purpose it serves.
Такие у нас пути
It was not very long ago that there was very little of Schnittke's music in/on You tube and now all of a sudden a much larger amount is available. His symphonies range from total satire to very serious and his choral music is being performed more often in more places. When I purchased a CD of his 8th Symphony w/ his "Suite from The Census List" it became obvious that his ability to compose in very different styles was like changing clothes!
Богата моя страна талантами! 🙏
Molto interessante, particolare, questo tango poi ti prende l anima, grande questo compositore russo che io fino ad oggi non conoscevo🙏💐💕
Schnittke was a master of making his full scale symphonic works accessible for general public, good example, he made his music lighter, more conventional and yet it is the same complex Schnittke, 21st century music. His music for cinema is beautiful, opens new horizons, prepares you for his symphonic works.
21 век это незавершённый 20. Отсюда и моры и голод и войны. Реставрация это не новое, а попытка пришить заплаты на прорехи.
@@НоваяЖизнь-г2г Правильное наблюдение, качественно 21 век пока это 20, в частности многие события это продолжение распада Советского Союза, т.е. корректировка границ ближе к этническим границам. А менталитет, политические подходы не изменились совершенно - это таже Холодная Война, на самом деле мы отброшены назад ко временам Хрущева. А если взять культуру и конкретно серьезную музыку, то впечатление творческого застоя - испольнительское искусство растет, а новых шедевров нет, ну если не считать "Киркорова". Я давно не был в России, не знаю что происходит на выставках живописи, стараюсь читать, но пока ничего особенного, а музыке точно застой. Вот мысль-вопрос, который меня будоражит уже много лет: вот советская власть, разруха-нужда, низкий уровень культуры полуграмотной массы народа, партийная цензура, свободы нет, человека могут арестовать за не совсем "политически выверенную" постановку спектакля, а великие произведения появляются во всех сферах культуры. А может быть "свобода" тут и вовсе не причем? Или можеть быть свободу просто невозможно отнять: ты ее в дверь, а она в окно?
@@YThome7 а железная поступь истории, объективный фактор? Это куда девать? Все, что вы перечислили, фактор субъективный. И хотя роль личности в истории никто не отменял, главное это базис. Ну что вы герра Карла Маркса не читали?
@@НоваяЖизнь-г2г Ничего не понял из Вашего ответа, но поставил Лайк, потому что больше некому, ведь мало кто даже пытается ответить на мой вопрос. Пробовал читать в зрелом возрасте, но трудно читать, но в объме Краткого Курса и в объме университетской программы "изучал", вернее меня учили. Не понял Вас, попрубуйте еще раз. Я говорю - свободы не было, а рыба в Каме была и великие симфонии сочиняли. Вот Американские мызыковеды критикуют Пятую Шестоковича, мол, написал чтобы угодить Сталину, а ведь именно эта симфония в Америке и по сей день самая популярная! Не Четвертая, а Пятая! Значит что, Сталин знал что нужно всем "народам"? А Катерину Измайлову в Америке никто не ставит и не слушает, но все твердят что это великая опера. Лично я считаю что все три перечисленные великие и я их все люблю. Так причем тут свобода? Ему запретили это, а он написал то. Его раскритиковали за это, а он создал то. И все равно то, что он создал талантливо! Вот Киркоровщина совершенно свободна сегодня - хоть нагишом, а ведь это все не более чем развлекательный балаган! Сорочинская ярмарка! Поступь истории всегда железная, и сейчас тоже, вон как гремит, не просто железом а с ураном 235! А где симфония чтобы зал битком как это было в те времена!
@@НоваяЖизнь-г2гглаза проглядели (где субъективный фактор)
A giant -- no other way to describe him...
These impure tones right at the beginning of the introduction. Is this a kind of hopelessness? What`s going on with these tones. Can you believe it? You cannot understand great art. Great art is overwhelming.
Soy argentino. No conocía a este compositor. Y me encanta. ¡A los 12.25 tiene un tango!
Это просто счастье, иметь возможность слышать эту прекрасную музыку...
Это нечто, что выходит за пределами музыки; что невозможно описать словами обыкновенного человека.
goes beyond music, certainly!
C'est peut-être plutôt la musique qui va parfois au delà des limites du langage ordinaire.
@@vasiliyknyshev2569 Вася, ты в какой клинике Бердычева сидишь, дай адресок!
Адресок? Вы что туда хотите? Каким местом думаете, задавая столь глупый вопрос?
Агония иногда вызывается неправильным вопросом@@alexandratchepournova2867
Very interesting! Thanks for sharing!
Музыка стопроцентно иллюстрирует содержание фильма. Помню свои ощущения при просмотре, жуть, жуть. И музыка помогает ощутить это в полной мере. Гениальный Шнитке, что ещё сказать...
Нина Коломийцева Стопудово?
@@leonid9971 to : Leonid Beyzerman Stupovich.
Farha'd Frank Nakhai. Persian in North California.
Вот это было чудовище! Когда слушаешь музыку Шнитке, озноб по коже. Какая то фантасмагория, что хотел со страной, то и делал.
@@Столица-с3н всё! Звучит Финал. Кончилось их время.
Как когда то Распутина.
Твои слова побуждают меня хотеть посмотреть фильм. (google translation).
Your words make me want to watch the film.
This piece has Russia written all over it. Love it!
Symphonic and chamber works can sound good.
If the musicians and conductor are giving their all.
If the sound engineers did their job well.
If the recording transfers well to TH-cam.
If the piece itself is worth your time.
Rare is it when all of these things coalesce.
And rare is my pleasure now,
hearing this splendid piece yet again for the veritable "umpteenth" time.
Потрясающая музыка Альфреда Шнитке...
I had to write a homework about Vivaldi. While doing this, I heard to "Agony". My mother stepped in and looked on the things I was writing. After some time she looked to the computer. Time flew when she finally said:"This isn't Vivaldi."
Of course this isn't Vivaldi!
+Salbei17
Thanks for the tongue in cheek comment ! :o)
This is a burlesque! What a fabulously composed piece of music.
This musical themes he repeats for most of his career makes his work even more curious and interesting. My life is another composer after knowing the works of Schnittke.
Great composer. Great music.
Loving this. So cool to hear ideas from the Concerto Grosso no. 1 and the Piano Quintet.
I would bow in front of this man!
Spannende Interpretation dieses relativ melodischen Meisterwerks von Schnittke mit gut phrasierten und perfekt vereinigten Töne aller Instrumente. Der geniale Dirigent leitet das hoch funktionelle Orchester im ein bisschen bedrohlichen Tempo mit völlig effektiver Dynamik. Echt atemberaubend!
Genau
No conocía a este compositor. ¡Me fascina!
never would've guessed "Schnittke" had I heard this on the radio!
Oh wow ! I'd never really listened to Schnittke but he has my attention now. The outer movements are mightily intense and captivating. The Waltz and Tango are reminiscent of Shostakovich's Jazz Suites, and good as they are, less memorable. The Tango seems to go on forever without much variation.
Schnittke was one of favorite students of Shostakovich, but certain influence you noticed is not only an impact of a mentor. The whole Soviet concert stage was dominated by great two: Shostakovich and Prokofiev. And not all among Soviet musicians liked it. In recent times, many began to question whether it was really good: the dominance of these two left several others in a shadow for too long. I like both of them Shostakovich and Prokofiev as well as Schnittke and Sveridov (both favorite students of Shostakovich) but there is some validity in challenging the two giants.
Absolutely stunning music. I am in awe...
I can't get enough of this.
17:24 финал!
Дождались
Дождемся 🙏
A bright mind and a deep heart.
:) The 'Tango' makes use of Schnittke's own Concerto Grosso #1.
Thanks for uploading this, excellent.
This sounds much clearer than (and probably a different recording to) the CD I have of Alfred Schnittke film music. Some amazing stuff in this soundtrack.
I hear you. Some recordings may not be the best possible performance, but they are the best possible recording, like when they set the Mike's up properly and distribute the sound appropriately so that we can hear the tempany rolls like a distant Thunder behind the trumpets French horns violas and whatever the hell else is playing.
@@BrucknerMotet BIS records has some Schnittke recording
@@BrucknerMotet actually i looked up since i got one myself and they have 25... obviously im a decade late
WOW!!!! I'm only 63 :)
What a great composer and a enthusiastic music!!
Ayak basan iik Türk beyi olarak selam olsun Alfred beye diye selamlıyorum :)
The Walts is greatly influence mainly by Prokofiev and Shostakovich. Shnittke used to be one of the great avant-gaudes of the 20th century but his film music is a different story.
Wonderful music. Great composer! Thank you, Alfred Schnittke, RIP
Genial! Habla el sonido del alma!
More timely than ever. Digging the photo of Rasputin too. Thank you!
The tango leitmotiv is used later in the Concerto Grosso no. 1
The Waltz material is also used in the Piano Quintet.
music from the very beginning will be in the 2th cello concerto later
main theme is also used in concerto grosso no. 1, as a backround figure.
The tango on Schnittke repeats everytime there is a tango only with few differences
И фильм хороший, хоть и не правдивый, как все фильмы о царской семье и Распутине. Но музыка правдиво передает атмосферу времени.
Superbe Tango. Il y a du Chostakovitch dans cet homme là!
et je cherche partout la partition
a genius, that's it
***** I think he is, but Agony is a film about Raspoutin, which explains the picture.
Holy crap.
Holy crap.
Holy crap.
Holy crap.
Holy crap.
Holy crap.
I need to watch Агония.
Wonderful! and Beautiful!
What a masterpiece
Schnittke certainly knew how to compose agonizing music.
He depicted the struggle: good vs evil. He was a religious man but knew he was decidedly not living in heaven and would not, here on earth.
550 likes and 1 dislike. Thats the best rated video I've ever seen.
*Don't jinx it*
Too late
21 dislikes now.
Ah, some nice, easy listening. Compared to most of his work, that is.
Благодарю вам
-- Un univers musical fort intéressant. --
Great composer !
Thanks a lot
Schnittke is a genius. Stroble too.
Thanks for the upload, this is fantastic!
So inventive and skillful
16:00 the finale begins in a gentle way
17:20 the ongoing bell/trumpet begins
18:44 the trumpet (I think) begins in the background for the next 25 seconds
The finale is always unexpected for those who deserve it
Now I already want bells, festive, victorious. So tired of enjoying this dregs, pouring from empty to empty.
Romanticka muzika prichazejici jako pohlazeni z poslední klidne chvile carske rodiny.
Гениальная музыка к гениальному фильму.
What film?
@@charmantbeaugarcon8306 Agony (about Grigory Rasputin).
@@charmantbeaugarcon8306 АГОНИЯ- ФИЛЬМ
Это Шедевр ......
Expression at its finest.
What an incredible mind this man had! It's as if we are front and center as witnesses to the tragic end of the Romanov Dynasty.
That good ol tango haha schnittke will be schnittke!
Merci pour cette musique.
La Valse (4'33") est clairement inspirée de la valse de son quintette avec piano (ou son Requiem pour la version orchestrale).
Il s'agit en réalité d'un thème récurrent dans la musique de Schnittke. Un vrai Leitmotiv, retrouvable dans de très nombreux morceaux du compositeur, à travers l'entièreté de sa vie.
Even Rasputin looks epic
Rasputin was epic anyways, man!
No foreigner composer has ever understood tango as good as Schnittke. I am curious to know if there is some info regarding this matter (interviews, articles, etc.)
ASTOR PIAZZOLLA!
Великая музыка Великого Шниттке...
Thanks for the upload! (I've seen this film a few times)
Танго шикарно!!!
Hearing this echoes from a dark era I ask myself: has changed the core of the World?
So interesting to hear how he used ideas from the Waltz in his Piano Quintet.
amazing piece. dig it 1000
Как человек может такое ЧЮДО придумать?????!!!!!!!!!?
4%, Воронеж.
Всегда тянет послушать еще раз
Эпитафия XX веку
It is interesting. I have seen from Wikipedia that Schnittke was a second generation "Russian" (Jew) as his father moved to Russia. Nevertheless his music seems to be profoundly influenced by Russian/Soviet music. I love it.
György Bánhegyi
, no wonder. he graduated from Moscow Conservatory. and his nationality has nothing to do with his profession
why did you have to put Russian in quotation ? because he was Jewish ?
you realise that's maybe anti-semitic ?
@@authenticbaguette6673 If you think me anti-semitic, you do not know me
@@authenticbaguette6673 it's totally not though
beau intensément
Филмът е въздейства. Разпад и гротеска. Това, което, очевидно, е било цел на режисьора е постигнато забележително добре. Актьорите са на изключително високо ниво, впечатлен съм.
Но!
Единствено музиката на Шнитке е гениална.
Тарковский,Шнитке,Дали,Гаудио...Будет ли следующий?..
This is the most legitimate of modern music we know of written in the later part of the 20th century and yet it's given no legitimacy by the conservatories or the 'production' companies - as long as they appease the 'night at the pops' loving unsophisticated dregs of the audience that claim to love the masterworks never include diamonds in the rough like Schnittke or Sviridov disgusts me as they shovel their write-off money to sustain a nostalgia they call art.
Holy shit, this is FILM MUSIC?
When I hear stuff like this, and compare it to the sadly very cliched stuff that film scores have become, it makes me wonder "Where are the film scores of yesteryear?"
Not to mention "Where are the good movies?" "Oh yet another remake or superhero movie." All I can say is stay the hell away from the typical Hollywood blockbuster fare. Look elsewhere.
All commerce now, sigh.
guys guys. don't cry it obbviously have the reason that todays entertainment is owned bt satanists. don't worry enjoy the good stuff.
Listen to Prokofiev's film music Aleksandr Nevsky! That is also a superb music.
у меня НЕТ СЛОВ!!!
sounds like movie music... this is a really good combination...
It's really movie music.
Sweet agony!
Wonderfule! Have a listen to "Iron Foundry", Mosolov.
Полностью описал что будет творится в России в 80-90 годах, вероятно не выученные уроки необходимо проходить снова и снова.
МОИ МЫСЛИ ТОЖЕ
То, что предначертано - не выучить. Можно и нужно быть готовым к "контрольной".... Читай последнюю главу библии... Ш
нитке ее прочёл... И пересказал... (Мое мнение)
Ищешь смыслы там, где их нет
Портняжка, подтяни глаголы! Твориться-это неопределённая форма, всегда-Ь! Плохо теперь учат в школе!
@@alexandratchepournova2867 у меня автоматическое исправление на клавиатуре, немного не уследишь ( и например, автоматическое исправление на не у следишь). Так бывает...
Amazing!
extraordinaire
The waltz really sounds like he just rewrote Prokofiev's Waltz from Cinderella
Genius!