Dear Carson, I am a songwriter from Germany, now 65 years old. I wrote the lyrics to this song in his photo album for the birth of our second son because the lyrics to this song mean so much to me. My son is now 38 years old. That's how long ago it was. Today I hear your interpretation of this song. I'm sitting here at the computer right now and crying. Carson, you have a voice, a timbre that goes straight to the heart. Gorgeous! I think it's great that your generation is recreating all the beautiful songs of my generation. I'm a big fan of yours and I really like your own songs! I know you have a great career ahead of you. Always stay the way you are. Authentic!
The mixture of this song, the budding trees and the chirping birds outside, and my upcoming graduation makes for such an indescribable feeling that I can only humbly thank you for, Carson :)
In all my 65 years I have never read a more heartfelt and beautifully phrased comment. Congratulations on your graduation. You have a wonderful future ahead of you.
My daughter is now 24. My granddaughter is now 18.... I have had this song in the wings for so many years... But, my daughter-in-law is now turning 50! I'm going to sing this song to her. May she always be forever young... ❤❤❤
I love the comments on yours and Josh's channels. Always wholesome. And your music has a way of bringing together the generations. It's rare to find old folks agreeing with young people these days, but I think we can all agree that your music warms the heart. Thanks from England.
Yea, I am 58 and was just about to give up on current musicians but these guys and a lot of the others featured with them have really brought a spark of enjoyment and a rekindling of faith in their generation. I just love Carson’s voice and his musical selections, especially the really old stuff like the old starlet brothers song and 15 tons, it doesn’t get any better than that.
Carson, you, my brother from ...I'm certain, a loving mother....I only say because what I'm hearing is 'authentic'. Thank you....greetings again from Melbourne Australia
Well done sir!!When my girlfriends ' daughter graduated from college I put these lyrics in her congratulations card! She she too started crying! You definitely did the song justice!
Everything in your cover Carson is so perfectly executed . Your voice sublimes this cord progression. The choice of this partial 3 cords capo. Just simply brilliant !
I’m gonna share this with the rest of the family as we celebrate our grandson’s 1st birthday this weekend. Truly remarkable rendition, Carson. Thanks for sharing your talents. ~ Mark
@@williamsrmonroe8406 when a musician plays a cover he's not "drafting". This performance was beautiful and respectful. I'm not his mom and I don't know Carson but your comment is disrespectful and offensive. Crawl back under your rock.
I used to make more comments on Carson's videos because it was shocking how good they were. Now I'm like... yeah, that's exactly what I expected. Fantastic.
I choose this song for my daughter’s wedding song from the band the last waltz. This is my #2. Crisp. Clean perfect tune. Perfect pitch. Perfect voice. Happy anniversary. Will be sharing. Thank you
You may never know what you need or why or when. but when those needs are met and joy is shared, it calls for gratitude and appreciation. With that, all I have is a sincere THANK YOU. Cheers, friend.
Carson I have heard this song sung many,many times over the last 50 or more years and this is the most moving and beautiful version I have ever heard. You have done a masterpiece with this timeless Dylan tune >That Harmony guitar sounds wonderful!!! and you voice is superb!!!
There’s no way that you’ve just posted this. Been listening and playing this song all day. When I saw the video pop up I presumed it to be an old video but nope! Great as always Carson
@@majas4922 yeah, I thought about that and it could work but there is something about this song that begs for a single lonely cello, juxtaposed with guitar and vocalist, as the object of the message….
Nice cover. I am 77 and have been performing band and solo gigs for 66 years. I do many Dylan songs but never this one. I decided to add to my rep and am looking at covers to get a feel. I note you do this in A.
Great song...excellent cover, as usual, Carson. Although we love our Minnesota native, ol' Bob (Zimmerman) Dylan, you have a more listenable voice while still retaining lots of that Dylan soul.
Yo...I did it again. Listened to Carson then straight to a live performance by Dylan in 1993 on David Letterman. The comparison is staggering. No need to go over it again. You get it. We all get it.
Best cover ever and I mean better than the A-listers and I have heard a lot of covers of this song being a Dylan fan Carson you NAILED it Bob would love this cover.
Carson, this was way out of the park! I LOVE IT! THANK YOU so very much for gifting us with this. At a loss for words: as the words to this song are beyond beautiful. As ALWAYS, Perfection.
Man you have voice that was gifted from God. I would love to hear you step into some old classic gospel music, kinda the Pappy O’Daniel flour hour, you know steeped in the classics.
You sound glorious mate. Dulcet tones and a keen musical sensibility if ever there were. Thank you for being the musical you that we all know and love, from sunny South Australia. 8)
Thank you. Not so sunny right now! Still, here's another gem that might have gotten lost on the way to you. 8) th-cam.com/video/fTGwkOjQkug/w-d-xo.html
Une belle reprise avec une très belle voie. Continu mon ami, j'adore t'écouter et revivre des moments qui n'ont de valeurs que ce que tu aime a nous représenter. Thanks
Beautiful! Much as I love the Dylan, I do have a fondness for other people singing his songs… and you are now firmly one of my favourites (ha!). This is a great song, and you did it so well - thank you for sharing it!
Estimado Carson, me ha emocionado lo que te escribio Anke Zohm, además coincido totalmente con su opinión, tienes una voz hermosa y mucho gusto para interpretar canciones que llegan al alma. Salud y Larga Vida¡
Greetings from England. I have enjoyed listening to your Bob covers immensely. While you are clearly an excellent guitarist and singer in your own right you treat Bob’s songs with the utmost respect. Your take is clear and identifiable but you present the original lyrics and tune superbly. Many thanks and good luck in the future. In my listening to Bob’s music over many years I should add that Forever Young, with it’s anthemic base, is very hard to cover with just a simple guitar and voice. Congratulations. Keep posting!
I listen to this while looking at some photographs of important places, people and moments for me. Now, there are tears falling from my eyes. Thank you, Carson! Keep up with the good music!
Such a beautiful version Carson, thanks so much for sharing.....it's just the perfect rendition for me to learn and share with my dear Grandchildren. 😍
If memory serves me, Carson, your Dad, gave you the partial capo. That is a nice tool to have in service of making music carry emotion....and a sweet bond father to son and son to father.
Dear Carson, I am a songwriter from Germany, now 65 years old. I wrote the lyrics to this song in his photo album for the birth of our second son because the lyrics to this song mean so much to me. My son is now 38 years old. That's how long ago it was. Today I hear your interpretation of this song. I'm sitting here at the computer right now and crying. Carson, you have a voice, a timbre that goes straight to the heart. Gorgeous! I think it's great that your generation is recreating all the beautiful songs of my generation. I'm a big fan of yours and I really like your own songs! I know you have a great career ahead of you. Always stay the way you are. Authentic!
Great comment !
Thank you for posting !
You've got a witness to that right here! Amazing!!
My dad did the same. Every Birthday he sent me this song. He passed away 4 years ago. Coincidentally i am also 38 years old.
The mixture of this song, the budding trees and the chirping birds outside, and my upcoming graduation makes for such an indescribable feeling that I can only humbly thank you for, Carson :)
Congrats on graduating!! My parents put the first verse of this song as a quote in my 8th grade yearbook ☺️
Ah, my dear beef stroganoff has grown up! When fettuccine alfredo graduates I don't know what I'll do 🥺
In all my 65 years I have never read a more heartfelt and beautifully phrased comment. Congratulations on your graduation. You have a wonderful future ahead of you.
Great tune, excellent rendition, I sang this at my father's funeral. Crying my eyes out..
Much love to you and your family!
Music doesn't get any purer than this. A guitar, and fabulous voice! So effortless! You're better than 98% of the crap on the radio. Bravo Carson!!!
My daughter is now 24. My granddaughter is now 18....
I have had this song in the wings for so many years...
But, my daughter-in-law is now turning 50! I'm going to sing this song to her. May she always be forever young...
❤❤❤
I love the comments on yours and Josh's channels. Always wholesome. And your music has a way of bringing together the generations. It's rare to find old folks agreeing with young people these days, but I think we can all agree that your music warms the heart. Thanks from England.
Same thoughts, thanks for posting !
Yea, I am 58 and was just about to give up on current musicians but these guys and a lot of the others featured with them have really brought a spark of enjoyment and a rekindling of faith in their generation. I just love Carson’s voice and his musical selections, especially the really old stuff like the old starlet brothers song and 15 tons, it doesn’t get any better than that.
That voice, performance just beautiful. I had it on repeat
When an inspired song meets with a sensitive artist--heart-touching music like this happens. You are a gift, Carson. May God bless you.
This was my wife and my first dance at our wedding. One of my favourite Dylan tunes.........very well done
Ah... Carson. Every time you reach back to this wonderful age of music you make me feel young again. Thank you, so much.
Every parent sings these thoughts in their heart as they look at their children. Excellent work Carson.
Absolutely gorgeous. Thank you for sharing your gifts with us. 💕
Carson, you, my brother from ...I'm certain, a loving mother....I only say because what I'm hearing is 'authentic'. Thank you....greetings again from Melbourne Australia
Well done sir!!When my girlfriends ' daughter graduated from college I put these lyrics in her congratulations card! She she too started crying! You definitely did the song justice!
Everything in your cover Carson is so perfectly executed . Your voice sublimes this cord progression. The choice of this partial 3 cords capo. Just simply brilliant !
I’m gonna share this with the rest of the family as we celebrate our grandson’s 1st birthday this weekend. Truly remarkable rendition, Carson. Thanks for sharing your talents. ~ Mark
Happy birthday to your grandson, and congrats!! Thank you so much, Mark.
Hey Carson, did you get hacked? See above. ~ Mark
You know Carson, if Dylan had your voice his career may have gone somewhere. Great job as always. Thanks for posting.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nonsensical given Dylan’s career.
@@jorgejohnson451 it's a joke
Do you live under a rock. If Carson had a career he wouldn’t have to draft off a real musical genius. Is this Carson’s mom?
@@williamsrmonroe8406 when a musician plays a cover he's not "drafting". This performance was beautiful and respectful. I'm not his mom and I don't know Carson but your comment is disrespectful and offensive. Crawl back under your rock.
I danced with my mom at my wedding to this song. It’s beautiful. We played the Audra Mae cover.
I used to make more comments on Carson's videos because it was shocking how good they were. Now I'm like... yeah, that's exactly what I expected. Fantastic.
I choose this song for my daughter’s wedding song from the band the last waltz.
This is my #2. Crisp. Clean perfect tune. Perfect pitch. Perfect voice. Happy anniversary. Will be sharing. Thank you
You may never know what you need or why or when. but when those needs are met and joy is shared, it calls for gratitude and appreciation. With that, all I have is a sincere THANK YOU.
Cheers, friend.
Carson I have heard this song sung many,many times over the last 50 or more years and this is the most moving and beautiful version I have ever heard. You have done a masterpiece with this timeless Dylan tune >That Harmony guitar sounds wonderful!!! and you voice is superb!!!
Carson is a joy to listen to. He is very talented and I am sure he captures an audience in a live performance. Well done.
Your voice is simply perfect in harmony with the guitar, softness and intensity in equal parts, a real wonder, thanks carson. 🙏
Music just flows out of Carson he is just such a fine musician .
There’s no way that you’ve just posted this. Been listening and playing this song all day. When I saw the video pop up I presumed it to be an old video but nope! Great as always Carson
At 71 I just had my first grandchild. I just saw this and it almost brought me to tears. Great job Carson
Dit is supa! Beste Cover wat ich jemals jehört habe. Nicht dylanesk, nicht epigonenhaft, sondern mit eigener Stimme, Seele und Kraft!
Carson your voice is a gift to all listening in these crazy times. Thank you and keep them coming 🙏
Great! And now a version together with Skylar please! Would be great too. I'm sure.
The high E string rings there so beautifully without the capo. And man, your playing improved so much in terms of timing and smoothness! 👏🏻 !!
He did a good job. Wish I could get my skills up to par.
Pete Seeger is smiling down at you from the heavens above.
I feel so young after this
My brother and I sang this song at my youngest sons wedding. Absolutely love your version Carson.
Beautiful....
The best cover ever done of this awesome song by the one and only.
Love to hear this as a duet with cello….
String quartet
@@majas4922 yeah, I thought about that and it could work but there is something about this song that begs for a single lonely cello, juxtaposed with guitar and vocalist, as the object of the message….
Nice cover. I am 77 and have been performing band and solo gigs for 66 years. I do many Dylan songs but never this one. I decided to add to my rep and am looking at covers to get a feel. I note you do this in A.
Just always a perfect song. And a great talent.
Harmony guitar! Cool! Sounds great CM!
Great song...excellent cover, as usual, Carson. Although we love our Minnesota native, ol' Bob (Zimmerman) Dylan, you have a more listenable voice while still retaining lots of that Dylan soul.
Bob Dylan would love this.
Yo...I did it again. Listened to Carson then straight to a live performance by Dylan in 1993 on David Letterman.
The comparison is staggering.
No need to go over it again.
You get it.
We all get it.
Dylan suits you so well, my friend ♥️
Best cover ever and I mean better than the A-listers and I have heard a lot of covers of this song being a Dylan fan Carson you NAILED it Bob would love this cover.
Great performance as always!
Carson, witnessing your development as an artist has been one of the pleasures of the last six, or so, years. Keep going!
Carson, this was way out of the park! I LOVE IT! THANK YOU so very much for gifting us with this. At a loss for words: as the words to this song are beyond beautiful. As ALWAYS, Perfection.
I would love to buy this song. I really need this cover on repeat for the foreseeable future.
Your voice is so pure, it hits me every time. There is something timeless about it that I love. May god bless you Carson !
I love Bob Dylan ! I really like this song! You definitely did it justice! Well done my friend!!😅
Dear friend Carson, you make great any song you cover, the authors Will thank you and so will your followers. Thank you.
Gorgeous. Moving. I can’t think of another song in this moment. This one is sufficient. Filling. Hopeful. A legacy to one we love.
Yes, some magic in the air! Awesome!
Man you have voice that was gifted from God. I would love to hear you step into some old classic gospel music, kinda the Pappy O’Daniel flour hour, you know steeped in the classics.
Beautiful, Dylan could not have done it better. Wish you great success!
Thanks for this gift to all of us who love your music (and you).
Your voice, dude. Timbre, phrasing, everything. Amazing. Thanks for sharing.
Hmm. I wish I could sing you back my emotional response. that sure was lovely and soul affirming.
Just close your eyes and listen. Enjoy! So beautiful!
You sound glorious mate. Dulcet tones and a keen musical sensibility if ever there were. Thank you for being the musical you that we all know and love, from sunny South Australia. 8)
Wow, great comment you made! from another Australian (NSW)
Thank you. Not so sunny right now! Still, here's another gem that might have gotten lost on the way to you. 8)
th-cam.com/video/fTGwkOjQkug/w-d-xo.html
Thank you for reminding us about Bob Bob
Une belle reprise avec une très belle voie. Continu mon ami, j'adore t'écouter et revivre des moments qui n'ont de valeurs que ce que tu aime a nous représenter. Thanks
Beautiful! Much as I love the Dylan, I do have a fondness for other people singing his songs… and you are now firmly one of my favourites (ha!). This is a great song, and you did it so well - thank you for sharing it!
You nailed this one. Wow.
Every cover you do is perfect. I love this song and this cover makes all the better.
Estimado Carson, me ha emocionado lo que te escribio Anke Zohm, además coincido totalmente con su opinión, tienes una voz hermosa y mucho gusto para interpretar canciones que llegan al alma. Salud y Larga Vida¡
Wow!!! An absolutely riveting performance. Gave me goosebumps. Thanks for sharing!
Dude, when I needed it most, be blessed beautiful soul.
Greetings from England. I have enjoyed listening to your Bob covers immensely. While you are clearly an excellent guitarist and singer in your own right you treat Bob’s songs with the utmost respect. Your take is clear and identifiable but you present the original lyrics and tune superbly. Many thanks and good luck in the future. In my listening to Bob’s music over many years I should add that Forever Young, with it’s anthemic base, is very hard to cover with just a simple guitar and voice. Congratulations. Keep posting!
Ti ascolto sempre con gran piacere, saluti a te dall'Italia sei un grande
I have heard this song many different ways. This is far and away the best. Great job Carson!
I am going to play this at a funeral for a friend this weekend. Thank you for the video. Beautiful rendition
Absolutely superb !!! beat that Josh !
Man this gave my withdrawals from seeing you live in Chicago, come back!
One minute in and this is my favorite of yours!
Holy Moley! What a great rendition of a beautiful song. Made my day. Thx.
Keep on riding your ocean of talent and soul.
You just get better and better. Thank you.
I listen to this while looking at some photographs of important places, people and moments for me. Now, there are tears falling from my eyes. Thank you, Carson! Keep up with the good music!
Wonderful. Thank you.
Outstanding as always! Thank you.
You're such a singer!
Awesome! A sweet cover of a song that
I love . Thank you
Best version I've ever heard,and I'm pretty sure I've heard them all!!!
Carson, not many can do justice to Bob Dylan. Thank you for this. It's really great.
Such a beautiful version Carson, thanks so much for sharing.....it's just the perfect rendition for me to learn and share with my dear Grandchildren. 😍
This is really beautiful. You are a hero on the guitar. One could easily miss that you are even a better singer. Thanks.
If memory serves me, Carson, your Dad, gave you the partial capo. That is a nice tool to have in service of making music carry emotion....and a sweet bond father to son and son to father.
He did, and not only that, he taught me how to play guitar!
Wonderful voice!! Great!! Regards from Rome, Italy
Beautiful version.
Great job as always. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks a lot, M. Carson !!
What a pleasure to have this cover released on my 24th birthday, thank you Carson :)
Hey, happy birthday!!
@@carsonmckeemusic thank you!!
Lovely. This brought me joy. Thank you. Peace, Kevin
Wonderful, Carson. Just absolutely wonderful. May you stay forever young, too!🥰
You do the great man justice every time Carson. capture the feeling like no one else does
This is now and forever my favorite version of this song. Just so smooth and beautiful and heartfelt.
Beautiful arrangement and beautifully sung,...may you stay, Carson...forever young.
So well done Carson
Thank you so much Carson! That is really, really beautiful!! I admire you so much! Keep that youthful spirit...it looks good on you!