It definitely fits, but honestly, I prefer the silence in that moment with Ymir. It really emphasizes the moment between the three of them. Then the dark and foreboding music after.
Each time I see Ymir tears, it breaks my heart because when u think about all she went through during 2000 years... happy that Eren is the only one that realize who's the main victim of all the story
I just realised the reason those with royal blood can command the founding titan/Ymir, is not because they carry the blood of Ymir, but because they carried the blood of the "King", who acts as her Master/slaver.
But that makes sense and doesn’t makes sense all at the same time because the subjects of Ymir are descendants Of Ymir’s daughters Maria Rose and Shina. Who are the daughters of the king. So all subjects of Ymir has to have some blood of the King in them. So idk… Maybe there was some incest happening with 1 of the daughters? Idk
@@juni8313 it does make sense if u think about it. While the commoners went about having kids with each other the blood of Ymir became to thin. However, the royal families prob kept the blood pure with a little incest or mating with other royal fmsily keeping the blood at a normal level
Absolutely love Light & Shadow over Eren speaking to Ymir as a person. The buildup gives the scene this feeling--Ymir, after living in an endless hell, finally someone is here to free her, save her, and to end the cycle of suffering
@@meurum2561 Not entirely. If you look at perspective. The rumbling is the embodiment of Ymir's wrath and hatred. All the pain and resentment she held for the world. And to note, this is 2000 years of hatred. A world that would not let her rest and would exploit her even in death. A hatred she doesn't entirely shre with those who are descended from her cause they exist because of exploitation too. Her own daughters forced to cannibalize her corpse. This was the only way she could be free. The world had to end so that things could be reset and she could finally die.
Ymir was waiting for someone like Eren for 2000 years. The episode 1 of AOT is named "To you, After 2000 years. Episode 80 is named: "From you, 2000 years ago"
i did the same edit on my yt channel but the only different is that i synced every single scene with the beat even the end of it using the useebiggirl ost
Something about Eren saying “your not a slave, your not a god, your just a person” pulls emotionally in a way that I can’t explain it in words but hits deep non the less.
I think it’s because in this world, society or people or whatever always forces one to feel like they have to be this ultimate power that can change the world. The weight of this pressure pulls and hurts carrying this anxiety around all the time. So having somebody, even if it’s just an anime character saying, “hey. You’re not God or the Devil. You don’t need to be a hero. Just you. A normal human being.” Is so,... relieving
@@justinchalifoux4424 This! As a child abuse survivor, who has been subjected to so many negative core beliefs (&told I shouldnt have been born (and acts upon that notion)), this scene has brought me tremendous healing. Rewatching it makes me bawl.
same. World always cares about world. But no one cares about those who are abused and ignored by world. Everyone choses the world, no one wants to stay with those who were victim....
Eren, what a man you are Ymir was totally waiting for you this whole time, i want everyone to think that for the rest of their lives, for 10 years at least
AOT literally states "anyone can be a hero or devil, it just takes people to believe" when describing what people think of the founder ymir to be entirely fair
"She was only a slave." Nobody told her she can be more than that "She's loving and kind in nature" she also wants to be loved, therefore wanting to belong somewhere. Being a weapon was probably all the "love" she ever gotten.
I'am deeply saddened Our Eren, he broke the literal "Chains of Fate" he was bound by to save Ymir and give her a choice What a beautiful and powerful scene this is, I will never forget this The author made Eren say he is an idiot with power in the last Episode I cannot take this misery
People still confuse Eren on this scene. He clearly understood Ymir's suffering, and how her descendants had been pursued, and oppressed, but also if they rose in power how THEY too would again become a force of oppression. A vicious cycle of suffering where people were tethered together for years and years. THIS is the whole issue with his desire for Freedom, because even if he dies, he would be part of the Paths where all past Titans reside and are passed down to the new bearers. His power granted him vision of the past and future, and he wanted to destroy the cycle to be free, but also for his close friends like Armin and Mikasa. Yet he knew that there needed to be ONE evil where all would focus, and by becoming that evil and eliminating the vast majority of the population of the world, even when there would be tensions, this time people would worry more about surviving than to fight for power and dominance over one another. And also he set Ymir free of her own self imposed enslavement, she was a victim of Stockholm Syndrome in her life and when she merged with Hallucigenea and became the Founding Titan, that never changed her attachment to her abuser. So as she resided in the Paths, she continued her Zombielike existence bowing to the will of her king and father of her progeny, but she yearned to end the suffering bind and Eren understood this as kinship. In the end she didn't have the will to become free until Eren gave her the choice and made her see that she mattered more than something to be used. She then released Hallucigenea and It merged with Eren. In a way Eren was not necessarily evil for the sake of being evil, he wanted to be the ultimate evil to in fact save the world from itself and the pettiness of others. He wanted his friends to not have to continue in the same cycle and by extension humanity itself...this is a parallel with the character of Muad'Dib in DUNE, who sees far into the future and sees the extinction of humanity, although it is his son that takes up the mantle to save humanity by becoming the ultimate evil and free them from the rule of others and extinction by stagnation. I wonder if Izayama was also inspired by the DUNE novels when he wrote AOT.
Eren’s a great character, we all agree. Though I once imagined what if Ymir has been waiting for the day to be free and once Eren freed her, Ymir would turn 180 on him and resurrect herself into the real world as the Founding Titan. She’ll give every Subjects of Ymir her message how she’ll not only stomp the rest of the outside world to a pancake but also will save Paradise Island for last, because she’s filled with brutal anger on everyone who used her and saw her as a god who can make any Titan in existence. So she wants to destroy the entire world to end everyone
@@taluca8474 She was a scared child that obtained immense power, in contrast Hallucigenea was a primitive live form that instead of evolving retained its form for millions of years while its progeny evolved. One was stuck in by love, attachment to abuse and the other was stuck in existence, yet both felt the need to survive. When they bonded the common drive was to survive, but each one just functioned by their drive. The only one that could be reasoned to understand herself was Ymir and Eren seeing that common bind of subjugation, prompted her to be free of her own self-imposed torment. She wouldn't had turned on him because she saw that he too wanted to be free, but would sacrifice himself for her and then eliminate the chains of subjugation of the world for not just her, and her descendants, but for his fallen and living close friends and loved ones. At the same time, he too would be free entirely when he'd die.
Omg yeah now Im genuinely curious if any of the authors of AoT or Dune, (or Code Geass I’m remembering had something like that too) had seen each other’s work cause they all have that common one evil trying to make all of humanities different factions stop fighting each other to become allies to defeat them or whatever as a whole.
@@catm590 Well, DUNE was created, written and published by Frank Herbert in 1965 approx, so in reality CG and AOT may have taken from DUNE. DUNE was so influential that George Lucas even softly (not that softly) plagiarized it to make his Star Wars franchise. GAME OF THRONES also took so many elements from DUNE, those novels were extremely influential that the movies and mini series never really do justice to the books. That being said, AOT had the right amount of time to flesh out characters and that is the only way DUNE can be made. You also have to look at Neon Genesis Evangelion, which also inspired AOT.
@@happypepper9326 Anime stories are a reflection of hope for unity in people. Japanese believe in Harmony that is why you see a repetition of the message of love, sacrifice, unity and hope in their stories. Even when you hate a bad guy, many times you can get a monologue of regret or sympathy from them before their final moments and feel pity or respect towards them.
Ymir's endless suffering ended. I feel so relieved for her. Both in life and in death, she's suffered and suffered. Finally someone like Eren came and spoke to her as a person. Not a slave. Not a tool. Not anything but a person. On a different note, I hope that douche King Fritz is still burning in hell. That ultimate lowlife!
Note she also doesn't try to kill off the eldians too while she's at it. Because they are also victims, they are the descendants of her poor daughter who were forced to cannibalize her.
@@taddad2641 100% true, I'm still traumatised with that event. Sometimes I wanna ask Hajime Isayama if everything's ok, cause holy smokes AOT is not a light universe to create in your mind.
@@EnclosedPoolArea if she didn't want to help Eren you think she would? It's not because you are helping someone do their bidding that you are some mindless slave. And if anything, the way this scene is made, I would say the actual master there is Ymir, not Eren.
I’ll never forget how a year ago I watched a video of a guy doing the fan made voiceover for this scene and he used Light and Shadow. It was so well done that it became my expectation for the anime, when the anime shined by itself. Seeing this song used for the anime version puts a smile on my face still, brings big nostalgia back :D
As good of a character as Eren is, I think this will always be my personal favourite moment of his, just because I love Ymir (she might actually be my favourite character) and seeing her finally, finally, finally find the one person that could understand her and allow her to make her own choices is one of the most relieving moments I’ve seen in any story ever.
What I love about this scene is that we really see how Eren feel for Ymir. Although we know that most of what he did in season 4 was pretending to be THAT guy, he really just seemed mad cold and seeing him feel compassionate, emapthetic and sad for Ymir warms my heart
This song bringing a heroic vibe is kinda how Ymir felt in this scene. After so long of being the victim, there is finally someone there for her. Freeing her from the torment that she've endured. Eren was the hero in her eyes
Erens goal isnt to destroy the world, its more likley he wants paradis to save the world from him, making them seen as heros instead of monsters. He purposefully made his friends hate him by lying about disliking them. Hes trying to be hated on purpose.
@@meurum2561 I don't think you get my point, this scene is supposed to be horrific because of what's about to happen (literal genocide of the life beyond the walls btw), not a heroic action at all, I'm not saying aot is a horror anime
@@user-qx1id1dt8x I’d say it’s a heroic action depending on the pov. Eren knows to achieve true freedom for him and his loved ones, he has to kill literally everyone outside of the island. Sometimes threatening people with absolute destruction isn’t enough. They won’t accept that, they’ll eventually try to counter you, then the cycle will repeat. But if no one is alive then the issues will never come.
Just some warnings, since a lot of people doesn't seem to read the description neither the video title: 1 - The song name is Light & Shadow, it's composed by Hiroyuki Sawano (The same composer of Shingeki's past seasons). Yes, it was made for League of Legends, for the Star Guardians video. You can find the song just by searching "Light & Shadow" or "League of Legends Light & Shadow". 2 - This is an animated version of J05H manga motion video, where he used the same song to the same scene, but with the manga. I just wanted to see how it would look like in the anime version. At that time, the anime wasn't out yet, so we didn't know which song would fit the scene. 3 - Making the scene "heroic" or "epic" wasn't my intention, I just wanted to put Hiroyuki Sawano song because I like Hiroyuki Sawano and it fits Shingeki, that's it. I don't care what you think about the Rumbling, I know is not a good thing and it wasn't my intention to make it look like a good thing. I literally just like the song, that's it. 4 - What this video is about is literally in the title. If you prefer the original song, good. There's no problem in that, but I don't know what you were expecting when you clicked on this video after reading the title. 5 - I'm not very good at editing stuff, so some parts are indeed not synchronized. I apologize for that. This was not a serious video, I just wanted to see what would the scene look like with this song. Anyways, that's it. c:
It's cool to see an animated version of that one trending video that used this combination, but honestly, the official version we got is supreme in every way and incredibly dark and chilling.
Yo this was on point! The moments hit with the music just right!! It matched a perspective I learned after realizing the first episode was titled To You, in 2000 Years
If you think about it, it is really sad how it took Ymir 2000 years to be finally free. She was a slave to the Royal Blood descendants all this time. Eren set her free.
Honestly, the hero we thought Eren was died at the end of season 3. The moment he kissed Historia's hand, everything came full circle and fate took over.
I lowkey wanna see the rumbling played in a heroic theme while they show the brutality of the casualties. To portray that the universe of AOT is never just black and white.
Mate, let me tell you something... This is one of the best scenes of the anime, seeing Ymir crying gave me goosebumps like few scenes do. She really was waiting for Eren.
The eren zeke and ymir moment in the paths is definitely better with light and shadow but the part where the walls fell down and the colossal titans started to emerge is way better with the footsteps of doom.
This looks good as a single scene, but what Mappa is doing awesomely is making a whole episode, they have to make sure everything flows smoothly. And also dont forget that we r now in war era, not some inspiring shits of previous seasons anymore.
The speech of Eren with this OST is incredibly best of just silence of the official one I found, because it amplify the power of this scene, and all emotions So perfect 👌
Ymir be like: "Alright, fine. You want this Titan fiasco to end? Be my guest. But if you're asking ME how I want it to end, then I'm going to take a big fat shit on this entire world on my way out."
It’s actually sad. Eren does it all out of genunine kindness He truly wants to protect his home and family And even as he wanted to use Ymir, he also wanted to set her free of her suffering and let her choose for herself It’s the biggest twist of all time, how the protagonist does all this suffering and doesn’t really change and still wants to help those that matter to him
He does it out of selfishness to see a flat world. Doing it for his friends and Paradis was just him trying to rationalize his inevitable actions that he saw.
OH GOD! You nailed the match between the music and the scenes! I love this video 👍 This music replaced the 'Armageddon' feeling from music before with 'Hope' nuance 😁.
This really fits imo, Ymir was outright treated like a pig and she was so deprived of her humanity that she was desperate to please literally any person, you would think that her kind meek demeanour would get her some attention or approval but no, she was the the one living amongst pigs, all she got was a betrayal by EVERYONE she knew with false accusation, an arrow and cruel sentence. Then she fell into the "Tree of Life" and lucky her, obtained Godly Power- so maybe this time she will get approval or even find love, but no once again she is meerly and arrogantly called worthy to bare the children of his, by the King and how grateful she must be for this honour, she was so deprived of her humanity, her self, that she accepts even with overwhelming power, still hoping in being a part of her fellow humans, part of atleast 1 "circle" or family. Then only sacrifice her life to save the Vile Creature they call "King", To have him disgrace her death by calling her weak to die from an arrow and thereby decided by the filthy f*ck that their own children to eat there mother (alive) to preserve her power for his use. I know it's an anime but damn that ticks me the wrong way. The soundtrack is amazing with this scene for the fact that after all of that she still has love, hope and wishes for someone in this humanity to free her, waiting 2000 years just for that someone to give her the mere words of acknowledgement and affirmation of her humanity, of her own free will, so she may finally, Be free from her own compulsive restraints not knowing how to do anything for herself and Eren does just that while Zeke tries to assert his bloodline of "royalty" and false control over her freedom and choices just like the King.
i did the same edit on my yt channel but the only different is that i synced every single scene with the beat even the end of it using the useebiggirl ost
The original music doesnt need to be emotional with this scene because is not about the most emotional thing ever, is about a person to end a lot of lives, and a lot of people trying their best to stay alive or fight it. Thats why the original still fits even if this one would fit for ymir suffering.
as person above me said! this scene is not supposed to heroic or epic, it is emotional to an extent, but in this scene, ymir literally comes to term with her hatred for the world and decides to give eren the power to flatten it and kill everyone, the music may fit without context but to me it just seems tone deaf to the meaning of what's actually going on! in the episode the silence with zeke shouting in the back, slowly leads up to dark music as they show ymir's face, revealing that we're about to see the rumbling happen, it's perfect that way, atleast imo
@@shesus1986 that has more to do with the fact that this video doesn't have the best editing and directing that gives this OST along with the scene justice. The video below is much better despite being way less popular th-cam.com/video/sopVTTlLZ38/w-d-xo.html
Goodness, I cried a lot when this OST came out... For that whole patch I banned Zoe in every draft and ranked game out of rage because she corrupted Xayah and Rakan 😭
I honestly felt Ymir because all I ever wanted was to sought freedom, my own hope and dream was to be able to follow whoever I want other than my parents who expect me to follow them because they produced me and the fact that I was blind my entire life until a samurai who doesn't even exist came, he was the one who showed me the truth about what it means to be rebellious and independent because it was what freedom means, to be able to have a choice rather than a command. My parents gave me commands, this man gave me the ability to sought choices
![Eren's death, but its youseebiggirl [4K 60 FPS] | Attack on Titan: Final Season](/img/n.gif)
Zeke gave her a command.
Eren gave her a choice.
🙏
hxh alluka and nanika 😳
So true bro 🙏
Zeke behave like her old husband
@@ginadelacruz4644 wdym "his"?
This theme makes it look like a heroic moment, while the original makes it look like a terrifying apocalypse
It is though 😂
It can honestly be both.
@@meurum2561 it really can't
@@gotyou4239 yes it can. Eren is doing this for the freedom of his people.
@@meurum2561 Bruh. The scene is horryfying. Not heroic. Heroic music would be lame and out of place.
It definitely fits, but honestly, I prefer the silence in that moment with Ymir. It really emphasizes the moment between the three of them. Then the dark and foreboding music after.
Trash opinion.
@@Vanzgars thank you for your trash opinion.
@@Vanzgars L + Ratio + Bad opinion
@@adriel6634 Your boos mean nothing. I know that I'm right.
@@Vanzgars lmao stay delusional
Each time I see Ymir tears, it breaks my heart because when u think about all she went through during 2000 years... happy that Eren is the only one that realize who's the main victim of all the story
yeah but then he genocided everyone 💀
@@popothethird1733 read the manga it’s for good reason.
@@popothethird1733 Because he had no choice LOL
@@popothethird1733 all the people that pointed fingers at ymir for the accusations of her releasing 1 pig should die
2000 years? Don't forget that the time inside that place goes way way slower
I just realised the reason those with royal blood can command the founding titan/Ymir, is not because they carry the blood of Ymir, but because they carried the blood of the "King", who acts as her Master/slaver.
But that makes sense and doesn’t makes sense all at the same time because the subjects of Ymir are descendants Of Ymir’s daughters Maria Rose and Shina. Who are the daughters of the king. So all subjects of Ymir has to have some blood of the King in them. So idk… Maybe there was some incest happening with 1 of the daughters? Idk
Exactly
@@juni8313 it does make sense if u think about it. While the commoners went about having kids with each other the blood of Ymir became to thin. However, the royal families prob kept the blood pure with a little incest or mating with other royal fmsily keeping the blood at a normal level
@@juni8313 the og king fritz probably made Ymir sleep with other men
@@Isaac-ez8jc that’s unlikely. The king made her his concubine. Only he was allowed to touch Ymir. While he was able to sleep with other woman.
Absolutely love Light & Shadow over Eren speaking to Ymir as a person. The buildup gives the scene this feeling--Ymir, after living in an endless hell, finally someone is here to free her, save her, and to end the cycle of suffering
Yeah it’s honestly perfect for saving her but afterwards I feel it’s out of place
Yeah
Don't get used by him...get used by me instead! :P
@@meurum2561 Not entirely. If you look at perspective.
The rumbling is the embodiment of Ymir's wrath and hatred. All the pain and resentment she held for the world. And to note, this is 2000 years of hatred. A world that would not let her rest and would exploit her even in death. A hatred she doesn't entirely shre with those who are descended from her cause they exist because of exploitation too. Her own daughters forced to cannibalize her corpse.
This was the only way she could be free. The world had to end so that things could be reset and she could finally die.
@@johntumahab323 Not really.
Eren, the attacking titna, is the embodiment of this desire for freedom and hatred towards the world.
Ymir was waiting for someone like Eren for 2000 years.
The episode 1 of AOT is named "To you, After 2000 years.
Episode 80 is named: "From you, 2000 years ago"
Damn that's cool
damn
Ymir is waiting for "someone"
"For eren"
I know already
I'm JUST out of WORDS. JUST WANT TO THINK OF THIS MASTERPIECE
i did the same edit on my yt channel but the only different is that i synced every single scene with the beat even the end of it using the useebiggirl ost
Something about Eren saying “your not a slave, your not a god, your just a person” pulls emotionally in a way that I can’t explain it in words but hits deep non the less.
I think it’s because in this world, society or people or whatever always forces one to feel like they have to be this ultimate power that can change the world.
The weight of this pressure pulls and hurts carrying this anxiety around all the time.
So having somebody, even if it’s just an anime character saying, “hey. You’re not God or the Devil. You don’t need to be a hero. Just you. A normal human being.”
Is so,... relieving
@@justinchalifoux4424 This! As a child abuse survivor, who has been subjected to so many negative core beliefs (&told I shouldnt have been born (and acts upon that notion)), this scene has brought me tremendous healing. Rewatching it makes me bawl.
@@ootenba5910 I hope your ok now friend
You're
@@davidaugustine399 don’t care
When ymir crying, I just felt her pain. Man her life is just slavery
even after her death, she still stuck with slavery ... :' (
Just like what happened in America to Europe (ey don't be mad at me)
made me start to cry silently as well
And to have that much power and still be a slave 😢
The way Ymir doesn't care Fritz's lineage anymore and gives her strength to the Eren. She chooses herself for the first time. Thanks for edit.
I want to hug Ymir too. She's a victim of the world's cruelty.
FBI open up!
yeah i would too
@@弱智这是娱乐都看不出 idk man but saying that implies it was suppose to be sus.. and you having a internet posioned brain
same. World always cares about world. But no one cares about those who are abused and ignored by world. Everyone choses the world, no one wants to stay with those who were victim....
She's so cute
Eren, what a man you are
Ymir was totally waiting for you this whole time, i want everyone to think that for the rest of their lives, for 10 years at least
This is perfection! I know they couldn't use that ost but it fits so well, thank you!
This ost is from league of legends, that's why. The music was made from the same compositor
After ymir gives eren powers it doesn’t rlly fit as it doesn’t show the terror in the rumbling compared to the original sound track
This works but with the different music it almost makes Eren seem like a hero.
He is the hero. Of the Eldian Empire.
Thats because he is the hero
@@John-rn1nm
For the most part lol
AOT literally states "anyone can be a hero or devil, it just takes people to believe" when describing what people think of the founder ymir to be entirely fair
the hero, the saint, tirant and terrorist are the same, but depends on who youre asking
The original was how everyone else saw the Rumbling. This is how Eren saw it.
So It’s Ymir singing here
"She was only a slave." Nobody told her she can be more than that
"She's loving and kind in nature" she also wants to be loved, therefore wanting to belong somewhere. Being a weapon was probably all the "love" she ever gotten.
I'am deeply saddened
Our Eren, he broke the literal "Chains of Fate" he was bound by to save Ymir and give her a choice
What a beautiful and powerful scene this is, I will never forget this
The author made Eren say he is an idiot with power in the last Episode
I cannot take this misery
Fuck the ending
This scene is just beautiful. Zeke treats her like a slave, Eren treats her like a human.
People still confuse Eren on this scene. He clearly understood Ymir's suffering, and how her descendants had been pursued, and oppressed, but also if they rose in power how THEY too would again become a force of oppression. A vicious cycle of suffering where people were tethered together for years and years. THIS is the whole issue with his desire for Freedom, because even if he dies, he would be part of the Paths where all past Titans reside and are passed down to the new bearers. His power granted him vision of the past and future, and he wanted to destroy the cycle to be free, but also for his close friends like Armin and Mikasa. Yet he knew that there needed to be ONE evil where all would focus, and by becoming that evil and eliminating the vast majority of the population of the world, even when there would be tensions, this time people would worry more about surviving than to fight for power and dominance over one another. And also he set Ymir free of her own self imposed enslavement, she was a victim of Stockholm Syndrome in her life and when she merged with Hallucigenea and became the Founding Titan, that never changed her attachment to her abuser. So as she resided in the Paths, she continued her Zombielike existence bowing to the will of her king and father of her progeny, but she yearned to end the suffering bind and Eren understood this as kinship. In the end she didn't have the will to become free until Eren gave her the choice and made her see that she mattered more than something to be used. She then released Hallucigenea and It merged with Eren.
In a way Eren was not necessarily evil for the sake of being evil, he wanted to be the ultimate evil to in fact save the world from itself and the pettiness of others. He wanted his friends to not have to continue in the same cycle and by extension humanity itself...this is a parallel with the character of Muad'Dib in DUNE, who sees far into the future and sees the extinction of humanity, although it is his son that takes up the mantle to save humanity by becoming the ultimate evil and free them from the rule of others and extinction by stagnation. I wonder if Izayama was also inspired by the DUNE novels when he wrote AOT.
Eren’s a great character, we all agree. Though I once imagined what if Ymir has been waiting for the day to be free and once Eren freed her, Ymir would turn 180 on him and resurrect herself into the real world as the Founding Titan. She’ll give every Subjects of Ymir her message how she’ll not only stomp the rest of the outside world to a pancake but also will save Paradise Island for last, because she’s filled with brutal anger on everyone who used her and saw her as a god who can make any Titan in existence. So she wants to destroy the entire world to end everyone
@@taluca8474 She was a scared child that obtained immense power, in contrast Hallucigenea was a primitive live form that instead of evolving retained its form for millions of years while its progeny evolved. One was stuck in by love, attachment to abuse and the other was stuck in existence, yet both felt the need to survive. When they bonded the common drive was to survive, but each one just functioned by their drive. The only one that could be reasoned to understand herself was Ymir and Eren seeing that common bind of subjugation, prompted her to be free of her own self-imposed torment. She wouldn't had turned on him because she saw that he too wanted to be free, but would sacrifice himself for her and then eliminate the chains of subjugation of the world for not just her, and her descendants, but for his fallen and living close friends and loved ones. At the same time, he too would be free entirely when he'd die.
Omg yeah now Im genuinely curious if any of the authors of AoT or Dune, (or Code Geass I’m remembering had something like that too) had seen each other’s work cause they all have that common one evil trying to make all of humanities different factions stop fighting each other to become allies to defeat them or whatever as a whole.
@@catm590 Well, DUNE was created, written and published by Frank Herbert in 1965 approx, so in reality CG and AOT may have taken from DUNE. DUNE was so influential that George Lucas even softly (not that softly) plagiarized it to make his Star Wars franchise. GAME OF THRONES also took so many elements from DUNE, those novels were extremely influential that the movies and mini series never really do justice to the books. That being said, AOT had the right amount of time to flesh out characters and that is the only way DUNE can be made. You also have to look at Neon Genesis Evangelion, which also inspired AOT.
@@happypepper9326 Anime stories are a reflection of hope for unity in people. Japanese believe in Harmony that is why you see a repetition of the message of love, sacrifice, unity and hope in their stories. Even when you hate a bad guy, many times you can get a monologue of regret or sympathy from them before their final moments and feel pity or respect towards them.
Ymir's endless suffering ended. I feel so relieved for her. Both in life and in death, she's suffered and suffered. Finally someone like Eren came and spoke to her as a person. Not a slave. Not a tool. Not anything but a person. On a different note, I hope that douche King Fritz is still burning in hell. That ultimate lowlife!
Note she also doesn't try to kill off the eldians too while she's at it. Because they are also victims, they are the descendants of her poor daughter who were forced to cannibalize her.
@@taddad2641 100% true, I'm still traumatised with that event. Sometimes I wanna ask Hajime Isayama if everything's ok, cause holy smokes AOT is not a light universe to create in your mind.
@@endofyraaaaryfodne3389 even if aot is dark it's a poetic story to be honest.
She is still doing what someone else wants. Now her master is just more polite. We have never seen her do anything she wants.
@@EnclosedPoolArea if she didn't want to help Eren you think she would? It's not because you are helping someone do their bidding that you are some mindless slave. And if anything, the way this scene is made, I would say the actual master there is Ymir, not Eren.
Nah that silence and cut to Ymir crying after the last drum is unbeatable.. this is cool too
01:00 very emotional and fits for that, really awesome.
yeah
I’ll never forget how a year ago I watched a video of a guy doing the fan made voiceover for this scene and he used Light and Shadow. It was so well done that it became my expectation for the anime, when the anime shined by itself. Seeing this song used for the anime version puts a smile on my face still, brings big nostalgia back :D
Got the source of the fandub?
This song wasn't used for the anime version?
As good of a character as Eren is, I think this will always be my personal favourite moment of his, just because I love Ymir (she might actually be my favourite character) and seeing her finally, finally, finally find the one person that could understand her and allow her to make her own choices is one of the most relieving moments I’ve seen in any story ever.
Ymir is also one of my favorites and this scene is definitely my favorite
What I love about this scene is that we really see how Eren feel for Ymir. Although we know that most of what he did in season 4 was pretending to be THAT guy, he really just seemed mad cold and seeing him feel compassionate, emapthetic and sad for Ymir warms my heart
This song bringing a heroic vibe is kinda how Ymir felt in this scene. After so long of being the victim, there is finally someone there for her. Freeing her from the torment that she've endured. Eren was the hero in her eyes
The fact that Eren did that obviously to achieve his goal, buyt also because he understood that she should also have freedom after all those years
Don't care what people think, i support eren and his decision.
hope this will change ur mind th-cam.com/video/iX9vp5zhMHI/w-d-xo.html
@@newt2120 WOOOOO WORLD GENOCIDE!!
Erens goal isnt to destroy the world, its more likley he wants paradis to save the world from him, making them seen as heros instead of monsters. He purposefully made his friends hate him by lying about disliking them. Hes trying to be hated on purpose.
@@jeo228 true i thought it was obvious, considering what made eren change his entire personality into a genocidal person
@@jeo228 I think Erin knew his friends would kill him, but was so broken by this point he didn't care if they did or not.
I still think of this edit. It's incredible, thank you for this.
This music actually makes this scene more epic in my eyes.
Edit: I feel after the part she gives Eren the power it didn’t fit.
It fits the horror, this is too heroic for the literal apocalypse
@@user-qx1id1dt8x I don’t consider AOT a horror anime
@@meurum2561 I don't think you get my point, this scene is supposed to be horrific because of what's about to happen (literal genocide of the life beyond the walls btw), not a heroic action at all, I'm not saying aot is a horror anime
@@user-qx1id1dt8x I’d say it’s a heroic action depending on the pov. Eren knows to achieve true freedom for him and his loved ones, he has to kill literally everyone outside of the island. Sometimes threatening people with absolute destruction isn’t enough. They won’t accept that, they’ll eventually try to counter you, then the cycle will repeat. But if no one is alive then the issues will never come.
@@meurum2561 It may be but he still intends to genocide the entire world. The deed itself is not heroic and it shouldn't be viewed as one.
FINALLY WITH LIGHT AND SHADOW THEME
Just some warnings, since a lot of people doesn't seem to read the description neither the video title:
1 - The song name is Light & Shadow, it's composed by Hiroyuki Sawano (The same composer of Shingeki's past seasons). Yes, it was made for League of Legends, for the Star Guardians video. You can find the song just by searching "Light & Shadow" or "League of Legends Light & Shadow".
2 - This is an animated version of J05H manga motion video, where he used the same song to the same scene, but with the manga. I just wanted to see how it would look like in the anime version. At that time, the anime wasn't out yet, so we didn't know which song would fit the scene.
3 - Making the scene "heroic" or "epic" wasn't my intention, I just wanted to put Hiroyuki Sawano song because I like Hiroyuki Sawano and it fits Shingeki, that's it. I don't care what you think about the Rumbling, I know is not a good thing and it wasn't my intention to make it look like a good thing. I literally just like the song, that's it.
4 - What this video is about is literally in the title. If you prefer the original song, good. There's no problem in that, but I don't know what you were expecting when you clicked on this video after reading the title.
5 - I'm not very good at editing stuff, so some parts are indeed not synchronized. I apologize for that. This was not a serious video, I just wanted to see what would the scene look like with this song.
Anyways, that's it. c:
The lesson I've learned:
Don't let yourself be a slave, but don't be arrogant too...
Just be a normal and simple person😊
It's cool to see an animated version of that one trending video that used this combination, but honestly, the official version we got is supreme in every way and incredibly dark and chilling.
this will be my favourite video on YT for at least the next 72h
straight into my "play it til you hate it" playlist
Holy cow! The insert song match perfectly with the video. Truly masterpiece!!!
Man, the animation team sure knows how to make creepy faces… I mean, this shiz gives me goosebumps.
Can you imagine how powerful that hug felt to her?
Finally someone cared
The words definitely hit her even more, but the hug was also powerful
The density of the moment is just too much to handle. Its impossible to decribe what that does to you in words.
Eren is/acts like a true king 🤴. (Leader)
One who wished to protect his people and their future even at the cost of his own life....
Yo this was on point! The moments hit with the music just right!! It matched a perspective I learned after realizing the first episode was titled To You, in 2000 Years
Eren giving his great great grandma a hug
That was the moment when Zeke realized that his dreams will never come true, only Eren's just as their father foresaw in the future
If you think about it, it is really sad how it took Ymir 2000 years to be finally free. She was a slave to the Royal Blood descendants all this time. Eren set her free.
Knowing how the manga ends, the way the music re-contextualizes this scene fits really well.
1:03 RIP ALMOST a perfect sync HAHAHA still amazing tho
This is one of the most incredible scenes!! I’m still not over it
one of the most powerful moments
Zeke be like “heh what’s he going to do? It’s pointless I already gave her a command!” And then is like “oh S*** he’s treating her like a person!”
Funny how his dad literally said Eren gonna win yet Zeke still choose to do nothing
I am totally with Eren. Destroy this world and everything in it.
#teamjaegerists
Okay they should’ve played this song with Eren freeing Ymir because it fits so well
This is addictive. I've seen this now 20 times. And gets better each time
Honestly, the hero we thought Eren was died at the end of season 3. The moment he kissed Historia's hand, everything came full circle and fate took over.
I lowkey wanna see the rumbling played in a heroic theme while they show the brutality of the casualties. To portray that the universe of AOT is never just black and white.
"Vogel im kafig" would be perfect in my opinion.
So damn mysterious how Music changes ways you would see if you know the plot in the End Eren looks more like a Hero than a Villain
Cuz he is a hero of eldians....
Eldians outside the wall is joke to you ?
I really feel sad for Ymir.. everyone used her,, until eren understood her hidden pain..
This should be called, "The Rumbling, But, Eren is the Hero"
AoT really did shift the tone to "nobody is the hero/villain" just for the cheap excuse of not making more epic OST's
@@ryuukami__ the OST in this show is so amazing tho!
@@K4V3man yes but I just miss the old ones
Isn’t that just regular AoT?
Been waiting for someone to do this
Mate, let me tell you something...
This is one of the best scenes of the anime, seeing Ymir crying gave me goosebumps like few scenes do. She really was waiting for Eren.
Nah bro she was actually waiting for mikasa. The ending ruined this scene. Eren couldn't free her at all. Mikasa did.
@@jyotirani8187it doesn't ruin anything wtf are you talking about lmfao
Fits so well in my opinion
Suggestion: adjust it to make it sync It probably still works and will be more legendary
Thank you! I'm still new at editing stuff, but I will see if I can do better with this video tho c:
@@noir6171 aight bro can't wait for u to make history :)))
The eren zeke and ymir moment in the paths is definitely better with light and shadow but the part where the walls fell down and the colossal titans started to emerge is way better with the footsteps of doom.
I didn't know how much I needed this
And this is how he began his world tour with his only single "The Rumbling"
Funny how Eren hugged Ymir when mikasa didn’t know
This feels like when Eren first blocked the hole in the wall. Tatakae!
Incredible. It brings out the emotions
yeah
Generations upon generations of abuse of one girl who had done nothing wrong leads the destruction of the world.
Eh, or she could’ve just not let the pigs out. :|
It all happened because of king fritz
man, Japanese voice actors are straight up 🔥
This track : The World will be a better place when there are no more human left to kill each other.
"it's hard to beat someone who doesn't want to quit"
I loved it so much ! 😍😍😍The songade me extraa emo🥺. Nicejob man!!!!
This looks good as a single scene, but what Mappa is doing awesomely is making a whole episode, they have to make sure everything flows smoothly. And also dont forget that we r now in war era, not some inspiring shits of previous seasons anymore.
The speech of Eren with this OST is incredibly best of just silence of the official one I found, because it amplify the power of this scene, and all emotions
So perfect 👌
Damn I got goosebumps from this, I love both versions of this scene!
0:32 Ngl, that was so good
Damn i miss sawano but this honestly fits pretty well
Sawano = AOT
Light and shadow is such a powerful song. Truly represent ymir background. And that tear😢
0:07 best line in anime
To you, in 2000 years.
From you, 2000 years ago💔💔
"You're not a slave! You're not a god! You're just a person!"
This hits hard
"You're not a slave, but you're not a god either. You're just a human"
1:38. It's amazing. It's like Eren peojects its rage onto the Titans in the Wall.
Ymir be like: "Alright, fine. You want this Titan fiasco to end? Be my guest. But if you're asking ME how I want it to end, then I'm going to take a big fat shit on this entire world on my way out."
It’s actually sad. Eren does it all out of genunine kindness
He truly wants to protect his home and family
And even as he wanted to use Ymir, he also wanted to set her free of her suffering and let her choose for herself
It’s the biggest twist of all time, how the protagonist does all this suffering and doesn’t really change and still wants to help those that matter to him
He does it out of selfishness to see a flat world. Doing it for his friends and Paradis was just him trying to rationalize his inevitable actions that he saw.
For 2000 years she's suffering.... Zeke gave her an order,Eren gave her a choice.... The choice to chose rage over mercy
OH GOD! You nailed the match between the music and the scenes! I love this video 👍
This music replaced the 'Armageddon' feeling from music before with 'Hope' nuance 😁.
Eren: "You get to choose"
Also Eren: **Only gives her two options**
-And then she spent a "few" more years making Erens founding titan
When the music starts playing, I've goosebumps everywhere.
just a little reminder that Eren did nothing wrong
True
This really fits imo, Ymir was outright treated like a pig and she was so deprived of her humanity that she was desperate to please literally any person, you would think that her kind meek demeanour would get her some attention or approval but no, she was the the one living amongst pigs, all she got was a betrayal by EVERYONE she knew with false accusation, an arrow and cruel sentence. Then she fell into the "Tree of Life" and lucky her, obtained Godly Power- so maybe this time she will get approval or even find love, but no once again she is meerly and arrogantly called worthy to bare the children of his, by the King and how grateful she must be for this honour, she was so deprived of her humanity, her self, that she accepts even with overwhelming power, still hoping in being a part of her fellow humans, part of atleast 1 "circle" or family. Then only sacrifice her life to save the Vile Creature they call "King", To have him disgrace her death by calling her weak to die from an arrow and thereby decided by the filthy f*ck that their own children to eat there mother (alive) to preserve her power for his use. I know it's an anime but damn that ticks me the wrong way. The soundtrack is amazing with this scene for the fact that after all of that she still has love, hope and wishes for someone in this humanity to free her, waiting 2000 years just for that someone to give her the mere words of acknowledgement and affirmation of her humanity, of her own free will, so she may finally, Be free from her own compulsive restraints not knowing how to do anything for herself and Eren does just that while Zeke tries to assert his bloodline of "royalty" and false control over her freedom and choices just like the King.
I'll say this is canon for me, the soundtrack of the original kinda lacks the emotional impact so I'm going with this one, gives me goosebumps!
i did the same edit on my yt channel but the only different is that i synced every single scene with the beat even the end of it using the useebiggirl ost
The original music doesnt need to be emotional with this scene because is not about the most emotional thing ever, is about a person to end a lot of lives, and a lot of people trying their best to stay alive or fight it. Thats why the original still fits even if this one would fit for ymir suffering.
The original suppose to be a scary thing, a thing that is going to be almost post apolyptic, not a thing filled with emotions or too much epicness.
as person above me said! this scene is not supposed to heroic or epic, it is emotional to an extent, but in this scene, ymir literally comes to term with her hatred for the world and decides to give eren the power to flatten it and kill everyone, the music may fit without context but to me it just seems tone deaf to the meaning of what's actually going on! in the episode the silence with zeke shouting in the back, slowly leads up to dark music as they show ymir's face, revealing that we're about to see the rumbling happen, it's perfect that way, atleast imo
@@shesus1986 that has more to do with the fact that this video doesn't have the best editing and directing that gives this OST along with the scene justice. The video below is much better despite being way less popular th-cam.com/video/sopVTTlLZ38/w-d-xo.html
Ymir fritz took my heart with just 1 episode ♥️
Fan-fucking-tastic! A perfect ost to start any omnicide with!
Ymir didn’t deserve what happened to her she was a whole child! She needed to hear that! She needed that hug
this ost was used for league of legends. But lets be fair - Eren told hiroyuki sawano to make it for this scene.
Goodness, I cried a lot when this OST came out... For that whole patch I banned Zoe in every draft and ranked game out of rage because she corrupted Xayah and Rakan 😭
I honestly felt Ymir because all I ever wanted was to sought freedom, my own hope and dream was to be able to follow whoever I want other than my parents who expect me to follow them because they produced me and the fact that I was blind my entire life until a samurai who doesn't even exist came, he was the one who showed me the truth about what it means to be rebellious and independent because it was what freedom means, to be able to have a choice rather than a command. My parents gave me commands, this man gave me the ability to sought choices
I just wish Wit studios had this chance to animate this scene.
They would be absolutely burnt out 3 episodes in with their low manpower 😣
@@jugemujugemugokonosurikire4735 low manpower? ha
The perfect theme for such an uplifting and heroic moment.