Hogwarts felt so magical, unpredictable and huge in the first two PC games. I remember trying a spell on everything I came across looking for secrets. The lighting set the mood in every single room. As the games progressed, they became darker en more dull in my opinion, having lost the magic of the first games. The same happened with the movies imo.
They intentionally became dull, because the plot became more and more serious, but i agree with you that the later games/movies becomes a bit *too* bleak for my tastes. Deathly Hallows is the most guilty about this...
Modern games in general, although they look great, have lost the magic and charm of the older days. Back then games felt like games, were simple and fun, now it’s getting too real and predictable in a way.
@@DarthCovider I have faith that this new Harry Potter game will bring back the magic, literally and metaphorically. It’s looking like just a much better version of the first 3 games made in modern graphics, which excites me immensely
I Believe gameplay in both versions is very good for its time, I like ps1 gameplay a bit more. I feel the other way around for the chamber of secrets Game.
The one thing I loved about the old HP games, was that Hogwarts always looked a bit different every time, so it felt like you were exploring everything again for the first time. Just like how it will feel with Hogwarts Legacy. I'm hyped!
Not even this new hyper realistic Hogwarts game, no matter how good it is, will revive the unique moments that I’ve experienced playing these classic HP games. Back then everything was a novelty to me, everything was filled with wonder joy, and uncertainty. Most games nowadays follow a predictable pattern and they try so hard to be real and complex that they forget about being just games.
@@DarthCovider Well, I have a good feeling about this one.. Lots of little secrets everywhere from what I've heard, and that is how the classic games were. I know there was a certain charm about them that can't be replaced, but I believe this be a very good experience, I feel it in my gut. Especially for those who have loved the books and films and want to immerse themselves in this world that from what I know will have decent replay value.
@@Satrina777 plus the people developing Hogwarts Legacy essentially grew up with the books, movies and games. they are definitely going to take some inspiration in terms of atmosphere from the old games IMO
Honestly i liked PS1. I used to play from day one on PS1 and loved it. It felt to me like eating the tasty food i never had in my life. I never had good PC till like 2006, back then games like TES IV: Oblivion ran very poorly which i had to replace graphic card for better. It ran smooth, at least inside of prison. Outside had choppy because of loading the areas. Nowadays i like both. Seriously they never got the praise for having different team working on both and they did terrific job. Wish the studio was still alive if EA wasn't going south with greediness. They started to be like that between Burnout 3 and NFS Carbon when they didn't allow them more time to work on games.
I remember when i was a kid during summer break id go to the library and they had pc games you could rent and install on their computer. Id play this game all day till i beat the entire game. Favorite level was ironically the library level where filch was trying to find you! God.... bring me back to these days
i played the PC version, and i saw so many people talk about how bad the first one is, and im just thinking: "Guys, it wasnt that bad, it looked pretty nice and charming and its an old game". But then i saw the PS1 version that they were talking about. Its like day and night. they are so different might as well be 2 different games.
@@zinc2zinc2 They technically were different games. All versions followed the same plot, but each was very different in every other aspect as they were made by different studios.
Jesus Christ, nostalgia blast, I remember I had the PC version. Though I was a dumb stupid kid so I never got far into the game, also remember the imps scared the heck out of me.
I played both and I can tell that each one has their good things... For example the fluency of movement in the ps1 was excellent bit the graphics of the PC version where more than good, maybe a combination of both could be perfect, that's why I like a little bit more the PS 2 version, but there's something that still doesn't like about PS 2 version and is that they where too fast and doors didn't exist, they Just passed through squares and that was weird 🤨
I played both versions a lot, but I liked the ps1 version better. I couldn't forgive the pc version for not having the forbidden forest part, for me the story was better on ps1.
Had both of these when I was a kid because my parents split up and one got me the other lol. PC is superior in every way if you ask me. Still played the hell out of the ps1 version too I was a little nerd
why are people in the comments comparing the graphics? pcs were much more capable than consoles even in 2001, its unfair to compare. they are both good games of their own and as a kid i loved both of them, i didnt care how the pixels look
I’m hoping that Hogwarts Legacy can give some semblance of the magical feeling back when I was a child playing the early Harry Potter games and the first Harry Potter movie
I’ll tell you one thing, games nowadays look great and all, but nothing beats the magic of being a kid experiencing these classic HP games. They were so simple, cozy, fun, unpredictable and educational to my young mind that nothing will ever come close to these joyful days. Once you grow old the enthusiasm is never the same, and with all these technological advancements modern videogames are resembling more the real world than just games, so in a way they lose that unique charm and simplicity we used to have. I’m just glad that this was part of my childhood, it was one in a lifetime experience that I’m grateful for.
A lot of titles tend to blend together nowadays, or they rely on servers that will die in 5 years and the game will disappear. I started collecting because i dont like where gaming is headed honestly 😂
Graphic- and texture-wise the PC version has the edge (shocker) but in terms of gameplay the PS1 is way more innovative and has more variety. I played the PS1 Version first and the PC version afterwards and I have to say I was kinda bored because the PC version almost feels like a walking simulator in comparison.
hello i playerd the PC 1 version thats what ever force that made ne one of the lucky once that did i also played the last 2 games. Question!!! now!!! how many verton of the HP2 are there i see that the ps1 has the second game in its library, is the PC version also diffrent like withthe first HP1 GAME ?? OR IS IT SAFE TO PLAY IT !!????
I had the PC version and absolutely adored it. I was actually really disappointed when we later got the PS1 versions and they were… not the same 😂 Not nearly as many details, and the level designs weren’t as intricate.
Graphically the PC version is better and we all agree on that. But in terms of gameplay and content, I would say that the PSX one wins by a wide difference. On PSX you have additional adventures such as looking for secrets behind paintings, going to the Gringotts bank, more enemies and more places to explore things that the PC does not have. On PC we have to lengthen the spell challenges where we must collect 10 stars and some other adventure like avoiding Filch and Mrs. Norris or going to the fire cave to look for seeds, challenges that as I said, were extended on PC to justify the game duration. However, there is something that the PSX does very well and the PC does badly. An open world where we can go anywhere we want. That is not possible on PC. Once we go through a door, we can't go back. So I'll take PSX in first place and PC in second place.
I always loved the fact that they even came up with an idea for the "troll chamber" between the chess board and the potions puzzle. The developer team really deserves better.
The ps1 version look like more animated in scenes, even though fell "poor visuals' compared to PC - PS1 version have more "visual fun" [smell like a kind of "game remaster' of period] I love the cartoon style of Harry book covers sensation that PS1 version present. S2
ugh. not a timed flying through rings section with a ticking clock that gradually speeds up. i can't even _watch_ a timed flying through rings section with a ticking clock that gradually speeds up. it's like the equivalent to a puppet combo villain chasing you. i can see why emulated ps1 footage is used, but i think it would be interesting to show how the ps1 actually looked in comparison to the pc version as well.
I grew up with the PC games, I have alot of fond memories of them. Even for a pretty old game, the first one still looks really good, the PS1 is just ugly.
У ПК версия графика намного лучше, но при этом стрёмная из-за отсутствия анимации ртов при разговоре. Ну и чем же ваша ПК версия лучше? ) Плоечная хотя бы имеет озвучку и анимацию ртов, хоть и графика ЧУТЬ-ЧУТЬ хуже.
The PS1 version completely lacks the magic because of how ugly it looks and how it barely even has music. The PC version gives you amazing music throughout the entire game
@@TheKing-ns4re to be honest I've never played pc versión, but maybe I don't need to play it. Pc versión looks good. But the aesthetic of ps1 for me its better. Maybe its the nostalgia. But well I need to play pc version to change my own mind.
@@drackfreeee Imo both versions have their pros and cons. The big con of the PS1 version is indeed the lack of music. PS1 on the other hand has more elements of the source material like Hagrid gifting the Quidditch book to Harry or Harry searching for the unicorn in the Forbidden Forest which are missing from the PC verison. The PC version on the other hand luckily doesn't feature Hagrid going to Diagon Alley with Harry which imo is the weakest part of the PS1 version.
Ah the quidditch minigame on PC where they gave you full flight controls and expected you who, as a child, probably haven't played a single flight sim until that point to figure out full 3D movement.
In my opinion, and maybe it's just because I played the PS1 version more, but while I think the PC version has better presentation in every way especially graphically and I feel out of all the versions it has the best execution of the sneaking past Filch section even if I preferred having the invisibility cloak powerup in both PS1 games, there's just something more memorable about the PS1 versions.
Probably, because the PC version has awesome music and just overall feels more magical and immersive. The PS1 version’s graphics also kind of ruin the feeling it’s that bad lol
Its not really fair to put those two up against one another, the PS1 is from 1994, and only had so much power and capabilities while PC's could keep improving and evolving their power and capabilities, i played both version and love them both, but you can't really compare them.
I legit didn’t know the game looked so bad on PS1 in comparison, people praise its mechanic but without the magic and the graphics, it just doesn’t have the same magic. Glad I played the PC version back then, such a great experience.
![Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone [PS1] Any% Speedrun World Record - 1:12:43](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1zke8NcwCqI/mqdefault.jpg)
I grew up playing the PC version. So Nostalgic!
i had first 3 games on PC since 2004 but now i need admin rights just to run the first 2 games it's annoying...
Hogwarts felt so magical, unpredictable and huge in the first two PC games. I remember trying a spell on everything I came across looking for secrets. The lighting set the mood in every single room. As the games progressed, they became darker en more dull in my opinion, having lost the magic of the first games. The same happened with the movies imo.
They intentionally became dull, because the plot became more and more serious, but i agree with you that the later games/movies becomes a bit *too* bleak for my tastes. Deathly Hallows is the most guilty about this...
@@artemis1993 Yeah. I still hate Rowling for killing Dobby, for example.
i can't agree on the movies i loved them more and more as they progressed
Modern games in general, although they look great, have lost the magic and charm of the older days. Back then games felt like games, were simple and fun, now it’s getting too real and predictable in a way.
@@DarthCovider I have faith that this new Harry Potter game will bring back the magic, literally and metaphorically. It’s looking like just a much better version of the first 3 games made in modern graphics, which excites me immensely
It's uncanny how much better the gameplay with PC version is.
Also the games were too different
@@baradona11 its the inverse ps1>>>>>>>>pc
pc
I Believe gameplay in both versions is very good for its time, I like ps1 gameplay a bit more. I feel the other way around for the chamber of secrets Game.
The one thing I loved about the old HP games, was that Hogwarts always looked a bit different every time, so it felt like you were exploring everything again for the first time. Just like how it will feel with Hogwarts Legacy. I'm hyped!
É. Eu também estou. O jogo que queríamos na infância.
@@wervlleybandeira I agree
Not even this new hyper realistic Hogwarts game, no matter how good it is, will revive the unique moments that I’ve experienced playing these classic HP games. Back then everything was a novelty to me, everything was filled with wonder joy, and uncertainty. Most games nowadays follow a predictable pattern and they try so hard to be real and complex that they forget about being just games.
@@DarthCovider Well, I have a good feeling about this one.. Lots of little secrets everywhere from what I've heard, and that is how the classic games were. I know there was a certain charm about them that can't be replaced, but I believe this be a very good experience, I feel it in my gut. Especially for those who have loved the books and films and want to immerse themselves in this world that from what I know will have decent replay value.
@@Satrina777 plus the people developing Hogwarts Legacy essentially grew up with the books, movies and games. they are definitely going to take some inspiration in terms of atmosphere from the old games IMO
I feel like the PS1 version doesn't get enough love... it maybe looks worse than the PC version but it's still a lot of fun 😁
because i grew up with the first 3 games the PC versions would rip the console versions apart...
I had the pc version so many memories. I used to think the graphics were amazing as a kid. Filch part always scared me 😂
Honestly i liked PS1. I used to play from day one on PS1 and loved it. It felt to me like eating the tasty food i never had in my life. I never had good PC till like 2006, back then games like TES IV: Oblivion ran very poorly which i had to replace graphic card for better.
It ran smooth, at least inside of prison. Outside had choppy because of loading the areas.
Nowadays i like both.
Seriously they never got the praise for having different team working on both and they did terrific job. Wish the studio was still alive if EA wasn't going south with greediness.
They started to be like that between Burnout 3 and NFS Carbon when they didn't allow them more time to work on games.
Wow I never know what a stark difference there was between the two versions
I remember when i was a kid during summer break id go to the library and they had pc games you could rent and install on their computer. Id play this game all day till i beat the entire game. Favorite level was ironically the library level where filch was trying to find you! God.... bring me back to these days
We had PSX Hagrid memes but PSX Dumbledore is equally nightmarish.
The PC Harry Potter games along with Spider-Man was all I played growing up, good times
PC version is the best and they took it to another level in Chamber of Secrets ^^
PC had better graphics, PS1 had better gameplay IMHO.
Agreed
And then the PS2 version came along (while also keeping a more consistent version of Hogwarts)
ps1 its better wimp
Wow. I never played this game, so I just assumed all versions of it were as bad as the PS1. The PC versions looked pretty good for its time.
i played the PC version, and i saw so many people talk about how bad the first one is, and im just thinking:
"Guys, it wasnt that bad, it looked pretty nice and charming and its an old game". But then i saw the PS1 version that they were talking about. Its like day and night. they are so different might as well be 2 different games.
@@zinc2zinc2 They technically were different games. All versions followed the same plot, but each was very different in every other aspect as they were made by different studios.
nop
PS2 was even better. Looked more different and had more content.
The PC ones were pretty awesome for the time. Lots more details.
I know ps1 game has free roaming component, missing on pc edition. But PC edition is very smooth, beautiful graphics and very replayable
Jesus Christ, nostalgia blast, I remember I had the PC version. Though I was a dumb stupid kid so I never got far into the game, also remember the imps scared the heck out of me.
Sadness and happiness at the same time.
Damn nostalgia !
I played both and I can tell that each one has their good things... For example the fluency of movement in the ps1 was excellent bit the graphics of the PC version where more than good, maybe a combination of both could be perfect, that's why I like a little bit more the PS 2 version, but there's something that still doesn't like about PS 2 version and is that they where too fast and doors didn't exist, they Just passed through squares and that was weird 🤨
I played both versions a lot, but I liked the ps1 version better. I couldn't forgive the pc version for not having the forbidden forest part, for me the story was better on ps1.
PC has better gameplay though, much better immersion and music, so that kind of makes up for losing 1 level
The PS1 Dumbledore has better glasses, the PC One is rocking some cyberpunk shit haha
Had both of these when I was a kid because my parents split up and one got me the other lol. PC is superior in every way if you ask me. Still played the hell out of the ps1 version too I was a little nerd
The colors and lighting in the PS1 version are still beautiful, even if the textures and models aren't so much.
Harris on ps1 is legendary
9:37 I'm literally crying
Jeez the screen on the right looks terrifying
PS 1👍👍👍👍👍
this just makes me happy that i played on PC
Considering how there are people making extended mods for the PC game, I'm surprised nobody's tried to do it with the PS1 version.
Unbelievable contrast here, sheesh.
my childhood❤😢
why are people in the comments comparing the graphics? pcs were much more capable than consoles even in 2001, its unfair to compare. they are both good games of their own and as a kid i loved both of them, i didnt care how the pixels look
I’m hoping that Hogwarts Legacy can give some semblance of the magical feeling back when I was a child playing the early Harry Potter games and the first Harry Potter movie
Nostalgia ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Nostalgia 😍
Nice video
It's PHILOSOPHERS Stone. My dad got out his PlayStation 1 and the first ever Harry Potter game so I could play it
I’ll tell you one thing, games nowadays look great and all, but nothing beats the magic of being a kid experiencing these classic HP games. They were so simple, cozy, fun, unpredictable and educational to my young mind that nothing will ever come close to these joyful days. Once you grow old the enthusiasm is never the same, and with all these technological advancements modern videogames are resembling more the real world than just games, so in a way they lose that unique charm and simplicity we used to have. I’m just glad that this was part of my childhood, it was one in a lifetime experience that I’m grateful for.
A lot of titles tend to blend together nowadays, or they rely on servers that will die in 5 years and the game will disappear. I started collecting because i dont like where gaming is headed honestly 😂
i miss playing this
When I was a kid, I played the PSX version. Today, at 33, I will play the pc version for the first time ♥️
Graphic- and texture-wise the PC version has the edge (shocker) but in terms of gameplay the PS1 is way more innovative and has more variety. I played the PS1 Version first and the PC version afterwards and I have to say I was kinda bored because the PC version almost feels like a walking simulator in comparison.
Cách hát của đức phúc luôn làm hài lòng tất cả mn.
The PS1 Hermione looks like Molly Weasley.
Or Luna Lovegood
This Hogwarts Legacy Nintendo Switch edition looks 🔥
hello i playerd the PC 1 version thats what ever force that made ne one of the lucky once that did i also played the last 2 games.
Question!!! now!!!
how many verton of the HP2 are there i see that the ps1 has the second game in its library, is the PC version also diffrent like withthe first HP1 GAME ?? OR IS IT SAFE TO PLAY IT !!????
💝💝💝
I had the PC version and absolutely adored it. I was actually really disappointed when we later got the PS1 versions and they were… not the same 😂 Not nearly as many details, and the level designs weren’t as intricate.
It would be fairer to compare the pc vs ps2 version
Can someone explain to me why they are comparing the Ps1 version with the Pc and Ps2 game, as if they were the same game?
Ps1 dialogues were savage
I ran the pc version in a soo low framerate o guess it was like 5 fps and still played it multiple times
Well, well, well, well, if it isn't the 'famous' Harry Pottter.
Even though I only played the PC version the console is superior in at least one aspect. PS 1 Hagrid is a sight to behold.
Earrape vs eyerape
Chúc anh luôn sức khỏe và hát cho chúng em nghe nhé
Graphically the PC version is better and we all agree on that. But in terms of gameplay and content, I would say that the PSX one wins by a wide difference. On PSX you have additional adventures such as looking for secrets behind paintings, going to the Gringotts bank, more enemies and more places to explore things that the PC does not have. On PC we have to lengthen the spell challenges where we must collect 10 stars and some other adventure like avoiding Filch and Mrs. Norris or going to the fire cave to look for seeds, challenges that as I said, were extended on PC to justify the game duration. However, there is something that the PSX does very well and the PC does badly. An open world where we can go anywhere we want. That is not possible on PC. Once we go through a door, we can't go back. So I'll take PSX in first place and PC in second place.
I always loved the fact that they even came up with an idea for the "troll chamber" between the chess board and the potions puzzle. The developer team really deserves better.
The ps1 version look like more animated in scenes, even though fell "poor visuals' compared to PC - PS1 version have more "visual fun" [smell like a kind of "game remaster' of period]
I love the cartoon style of Harry book covers sensation that PS1 version present. S2
Crazy how the ps1 version has lip sync but pc doesn't
PC had it in the 2nd game
Love the PC version more than I do for the PS1 game. Same goes for the Chamber of Secrets game as well
ugh. not a timed flying through rings section with a ticking clock that gradually speeds up. i can't even _watch_ a timed flying through rings section with a ticking clock that gradually speeds up. it's like the equivalent to a puppet combo villain chasing you.
i can see why emulated ps1 footage is used, but i think it would be interesting to show how the ps1 actually looked in comparison to the pc version as well.
It's not the same without the broken faces
I grew up with the PC games, I have alot of fond memories of them. Even for a pretty old game, the first one still looks really good, the PS1 is just ugly.
Same. The PC games were my childhood. I first played the PC version when I was no older than 5 and didn't play the PS1 version until I was 14.
same
For PC standards I would think it would look a lot better.
And it will not change even on PS5 vs PC for Hogwarts Legacy.
У ПК версия графика намного лучше, но при этом стрёмная из-за отсутствия анимации ртов при разговоре. Ну и чем же ваша ПК версия лучше? ) Плоечная хотя бы имеет озвучку и анимацию ртов, хоть и графика ЧУТЬ-ЧУТЬ хуже.
PC version its cool but PS1 rules! 😎
The PS1 version completely lacks the magic because of how ugly it looks and how it barely even has music. The PC version gives you amazing music throughout the entire game
@@TheKing-ns4re to be honest I've never played pc versión, but maybe I don't need to play it. Pc versión looks good. But the aesthetic of ps1 for me its better. Maybe its the nostalgia. But well I need to play pc version to change my own mind.
@@drackfreeee Imo both versions have their pros and cons.
The big con of the PS1 version is indeed the lack of music. PS1 on the other hand has more elements of the source material like Hagrid gifting the Quidditch book to Harry or Harry searching for the unicorn in the Forbidden Forest which are missing from the PC verison.
The PC version on the other hand luckily doesn't feature Hagrid going to Diagon Alley with Harry which imo is the weakest part of the PS1 version.
PC forever!! this is a ==the era where PC games had far farrr better graphics then the consoles !!! :)
And once again PC master race chad wins
Ah the quidditch minigame on PC where they gave you full flight controls and expected you who, as a child, probably haven't played a single flight sim until that point to figure out full 3D movement.
Well, they gave you the flight lesson first
@@O.M- hated flying in the 1st and 2nd game. was too hard for me personally as a kid and even as an adult.
Ps1 is One generation behind !
In my opinion, and maybe it's just because I played the PS1 version more, but while I think the PC version has better presentation in every way especially graphically and I feel out of all the versions it has the best execution of the sneaking past Filch section even if I preferred having the invisibility cloak powerup in both PS1 games, there's just something more memorable about the PS1 versions.
Probably, because the PC version has awesome music and just overall feels more magical and immersive. The PS1 version’s graphics also kind of ruin the feeling it’s that bad lol
PS1 The Best!! I Love game HP!
game collab
I've play the PS1 version it wasn't that bad.
The dreamcast could run this game at 60 fps.
Its not really fair to put those two up against one another, the PS1 is from 1994, and only had so much power and capabilities while PC's could keep improving and evolving their power and capabilities, i played both version and love them both, but you can't really compare them.
poor you how have grown up with ps1 and not pc
Vote for PS1 version
Trust me playing the first Harry Potter game on the ps2 the graphics were crap
The PS2 version was the best of all. It had Diagon Alley to explore and even better visuals. Back when only the rich kids got the best versions.
PlayStation 1🔝Nostalgia ❤️
PC only
두 게임의 장점만 합치고 싶어요
ps1 is the best ever 🥰
Hideous graphics and lack of music. The PC version actually feels magical because it has both of those
Switch?
I'd pick the ps1 version i think, gameplay looks better.
The PC version also have a ton of dynamic lighting, maybe too much of the good you know?.
I enjoyed both, but I think I would choose the pc version over ps1
for pc ....soo good .. nad ps1 hmmm. not ok grafik
Dumbledore in PS1 version is insanely creepy and terrible…
Anyone know where I could buy this game in PC? Does GOG have it?
I checked both GOG and Steam. Neither have it. They just have the Lego Harry Potter games. My best bet is to just pirate the game.
@@Patrick19833 Do you know how I could pirate it? I’ve never tried that haha
I don´t know why but I prefer ps1
Me too.
It might look like trash but it was our childhood after all. Sure Pc version looks better but I only played the ps1 one so it’s gonna be a win for me.
Ps1 has The Legend PS1Hagrid so PS1 takes the win easily
PS1 with emulated.........
I legit didn’t know the game looked so bad on PS1 in comparison, people praise its mechanic but without the magic and the graphics, it just doesn’t have the same magic. Glad I played the PC version back then, such a great experience.
Same.
The gameplay on PS1 is simply superior.
El mejor es el del PS1 en cuanto a jugabilidad y el de la PC en gráficos.
Pc >>>>>>>>>ps1
psx better always
The PS1 version is the better designed game.
The PC version is the better Harry Potter game.
The pic version... So nostalgic, the PS1 version is ugly...
The graphics of the PC version are better but the PS1 version is superior. I never liked the PC version; too boring.
PS1 version was probably more fun to play but graphically it was an eyesore
@@qk1050 What are you saying? Hagrid was pure beauty.
The PC version felt more magical though because it actually had good music…
@@TheKing-ns4re Nah, I liked the PS1 version's music a lot more. Whenever I hear that ost I feel like a child again.
@@TheKing-ns4re didn't the PC and PS1 versions share the same soundtrack?