Sax workers? Women of the night was RIGHT THERE!!! And honestly Jim throwing Batman around like a rag doll was absolutely unbelievable. But when they stood next to each other it was like wow… I didn’t realize how in this world Jim was much bigger than Batman. And it’s like because you’re right we were so calm around him we ignored his imposing stature 🤦🏾♂️
Wait a minute, you're telling me they actually used King Snake? That is guy is one of Robin's lamest foes. Also, no, Penguin was in about one page of the book Doom. Harvey was some we would check in on and sort of care about, but that's it. Freeze had much less time as I remember it. They all serve about the same role. The book is better, but the movie is fine.
I've seen all the batman movies you showed and I loved them all, they all had an interesting premise and take on the characters that made it such a new and unique style to batman, they kept it fresh while also having aspects of the characters we know and love, you should definitely do a part 2
I actually liked Soul of the Dragon, it showed his close friendship with Richard and how that friendship was being put to the test against their old master. I’d honestly love to see more Richard Dragon in future animated movies, he’s a good dude.
You know, the story was good, but the Batman himself didn't interest me as much. But I find it funny that when Russian Superman exists, Batman also has to be Russian. Can't have an American Superman with a Russian Batman or vice versa
I love Gotham By Gaslight tbh It was one of my favorite Batman movies in recent history, the opposite of which can be said about Batman Hush. God I hated their interpretation of Hush. So f%ckin lame.
The guys from soul of the dragon may look like mortal Kombat characters, because they're based off of the same genre of movies. Mortal Kombat was also inspired by old martial art movies, hence some of the mistakes.
To be fair, the Talia in the Batman: Doom that Came to comic has even less details than the movie gave. She even dies due to her father's actions rather than being another roadblock for Bruce to fight. For that and one OTHER element of the movie: Kai Li Cain. So Kai Li isn't even in the original comic, it's Tim. Who basically is a walking plot ehance device and nothing with Oliver is ever earned. In that regard given Kai Li is a Frankenstein of Cassandra Cain and Carrie Kelly with the Tim Drake elements from the book put in there. It gives the film a far better pathos to Bruce hanging onto his humanity along with giving Ollie and Harvey extra scenes (yeah your wish isn't really granted on Harvey sadly. The movie actually expanded Harvey's role). I really love Batman: The Doom that Came to Gotham and how the makers of the film expanded the roles along with changing them up enough (save poor Jay. Even changing the race, Jay is basically the same character). Also the filmmakers added the fallen friends/adopted kid angle which works SOOOO much better. Compared to Batman fighting a pair of werewolves. Yes, werewolves.
Every time I see footage of that Gotham by Gaslight, I wonder what could have been. Maybe it wouldn't have been very good. But I would love to see them take a proper shot at it with current gen hardware.
Pronunciation - Giles - Not like "Guile" (Street Fighter). It's said with a soft G. Like a "J", like "Jiles". Like gelato is said with the same sound as Jello. Grey DeLisle - not "delesee". It's "duh-lyle" like the "I" sound in "Island". The "Isl" portion is said like " I'll "
Batman: Soul of the Dragon is an AMAZING film and actually one of my favorite Batman films (bar one more in this video). You're just viewing it in the wrong lenses. See, the reason why it's amazing is because every protagonist character used in the flick (Batman, Richard Dragon, Bronze Tiger, and Lady Shiva) were cherished characters by Denny O'Neil (three of them began in the Richard Dragon comics by O'Neil in the 70s, later on he brought Tiger into Batman along with Richard/Shiva. Though the later two showed up in the Question). The whole film is a love letter Denny O'Neil and in a way those inspired by him. You view the film in that regard, it becomes much better experience.
I agree with almost everything you said about gotham by gaslighting except for Gordon being the culprit, it's too far-fetched for me. It was said that Jack the ripper could be a cop and it is an interesting take, but in this story, I don't think Gordon could be a serial killer even in an elseworld, let alone torturing his wife. However the action scenes are really cool and the other references were great too ! I think I will read the comic, like for the doom that came to gotham, the movie was meh but the comic was great (for me).
Nah, it actually makes perfect sense. James Gordon Jr. It's already in the Gordon DNA, it just usually skips that generation but strikes his son instead.
Honestly it wasn't Gordon in the original that's what made the so called twist actually a twist they basically removed an entire character from the movie and that's Batman's uncle Jake created for this story who actually travels with him from London to Gotham after Bruce completes his training with Sigmund Freud yes the historical psychologist Sigmund Freud....for those who have read the comic the Gordon twist seemed like a cheap stunt compared to the twist in the book
@@tahern8043 exactly the trend of the unnecessary twists started with this movie Gotham by gaslight and the followed it up with hush a seriously missed opportunity to not only introduce hush but also have a call back to under the red hood all of those scenes are panels were missing from hush plus hush needed to be a two parter considering how long the story actually was....this is exactly why I'm dreading the 3 part crisis on infinite earths movie cause they will yet again do some different things and call it a twist
Gotham by Gaslight was decent until the climax, which just felt too bizarre to me. I also felt a little thrown with how Penguin was teased early on, then basically ignored. Same with Manbat, that was a red herring. I'm also extremely tired of Ra's al-Guhl (spelling) and the League of Shadows. Talia reminded me of Curare which was cool, but still. Not the worst movie, but not the best either.
@@kubamcmillan3078 No, I'm a big Mythos fan. It wasn't bizarre in general to me, just with where I thought they were going. I really thought Penguin was the Lovecraftian element, they hinted strongly at that right off the bat. I don't know what I was expecting I guess
30:30 The bizarre thing about this is it would have been _so_ easy to rewrite this Freeze to keep his motivations in line with the original. Have the hellish creatures beyond mortal comprehension promise to cure his ailing wife in response for his service. Hell, modern day Freeze wouldn’t think twice about doing this if it meant it would save Nora.
Gotham By Gaslight is a terrible adaption of the first Elseworlds comic. Everything in the comic was changed in the film, There was no Catwoman, Posion Ivy, or any version of the robins, Batman did not have a motor bike, and Gordon is not Jack The Ripper, that was Jacob Parker, who was killing women who resembled Martha Wayne, after he was rejected by her and she laughed in his face. They missed including a great scene where Bruce was talking to sigmund Freud.
Love your channel so much and so glad you covered my childhood batman which I just got the blu-ray for this year batman 2004 anytime I think batman I think of rino ramono
I read it many years ago they is a reference to the 89 batman when the 3 robin talk abount johnny gobbs which the 2 robbers talk abount on the roof before batman attack them in the 98 film
Am I watching too much of your channel if I don’t know if this is a reupload / compilation and I’m pissed that it’s (maybe) not new but also I don’t remember any of it when I JUST found your channel. Ah brains (Gotham by gaslighting)
The "weird ones" from the DCAU I enjoy as their own thing, along the lines of the Elsewhere books. I'm not a huge supers fan (live action ones have me burnt), the DCAU is a slight departure from the comic books & graphic novels because of the change in media type. You have to change things around for pacing, visuals, ect because of the change in media. When I hear people bitching about the DC live action stuff, or when I am bitching about the Marvel movies being the same recycled story line since Iron Man I mention that the only franchise that has mature story lines tend to be the DCAU (there are flaws in them) but they by far a superior product when you compare them to other mainstream labels. At least with the DCAU I get done watching it and i don;t feel like my intelligence has been beat over the head with a dead fish of mediocrity or bordem at knowing every beat that will take place in the movie 5 minutes before it happens.
Top 5 Batman movies The Dark Knight Under The Red Hood The Batman Gotham By Gaslight Dark Knight Returns pt 1&2 (Honorable Mentions) The Long Halloween pt 1&2 Batman vs Robin
I rather like Batman stories set in earlier time periods making his regular gadgets technological marvels by the period’s standards is rather fun details.
Gotham by Gaslight's Selena Kyle is honestly the most stunningly beautiful version of her ever. The eyes, the hair, whether it's up or down. Everything is just amazing.
When is he going to review the best piece of Batman media "Lego Justice League Gotham City Breakout" it may be promoted as a justice league movie but it is really a Batman movie with the justice league having a bit of a B plot to deal with
Gotham by gaslighting.
that never happened 🍇
@@romulusbonaparte320yet
@@romulusbonaparte320yes it did and I enjoyed it
"I'm not Batman. And you're crazy for even suggesting that
Gotham by Gaslighting is an actually good movie and I’m sad the game never came to be
omg fr, is definitely one of my fav batman animated movies
I personally liked It
Sax workers? Women of the night was RIGHT THERE!!!
And honestly Jim throwing Batman around like a rag doll was absolutely unbelievable. But when they stood next to each other it was like wow… I didn’t realize how in this world Jim was much bigger than Batman. And it’s like because you’re right we were so calm around him we ignored his imposing stature 🤦🏾♂️
I loved "Gotham By Gaslight". It's a movie where Batman uses his mind and wisdom more than his gadgets. Great movie!
16:27 Honestly this movie should’ve been a Richard Dragon movie featuring Batman like the Justice League Dark Film.
The graphic novel "Murder By Gaslight" was incredible. The movie is still entertaining but I would love to have seen a faithful adaptation.
Soul of the Dragon is like seein' your custom character pop up in cutscenes bahahahahahahaha
I really like The doom that came to gotham with giving green arrow a fighting chance against that world's position ivy
No, as it turns out, Penguin and Harvey Dent have exactly the same role in the comic as they do in the movie.
Also, Gotham by Gaslighting.
Gotham by Gaslight, Gotham by Gatekeep, Gotham by Girlboss
Gotham by Ghostbusting
Wait a minute, you're telling me they actually used King Snake? That is guy is one of Robin's lamest foes.
Also, no, Penguin was in about one page of the book Doom. Harvey was some we would check in on and sort of care about, but that's it. Freeze had much less time as I remember it. They all serve about the same role. The book is better, but the movie is fine.
I've seen all the batman movies you showed and I loved them all, they all had an interesting premise and take on the characters that made it such a new and unique style to batman, they kept it fresh while also having aspects of the characters we know and love, you should definitely do a part 2
“Man that guy is great in everything he just…what a good man.”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
GOTHAM BY GASLIGHTING!!!
I really like this film. I would love an animated Batman film set during the medieval times.
Considering the current Knights Storyline, it could happen
@@darkservantofheaven
👌
I mean Justice League War World has a segment where Batman is basically Conan. The movie kinda sucks though
The Gotham by Gaslight book was one of my favorite Batman stories so when they put out an animated feature on it I was all on board.
I actually liked Soul of the Dragon, it showed his close friendship with Richard and how that friendship was being put to the test against their old master. I’d honestly love to see more Richard Dragon in future animated movies, he’s a good dude.
Harvey Dent had a bit more of a role in the comic (not by too much), but the Penguin is exactly the same. I think he only appears in one panel.
Gotham by Gaslight is the so-called loose adaptation of the great graphic novel!!!
Russian batman has to be one of the best batman interpretations ive seen animated
You know, the story was good, but the Batman himself didn't interest me as much. But I find it funny that when Russian Superman exists, Batman also has to be Russian. Can't have an American Superman with a Russian Batman or vice versa
Gotham by gaslighting
I think the scaring of Jim's wife's face absolutely the creation of this worlds two face
When I saw this movie I loved it. It was like you said different but good
Cheek bones appearing and disappearing on characters in animation is always weird for me.
I love Gotham By Gaslight tbh
It was one of my favorite Batman movies in recent history, the opposite of which can be said about Batman Hush.
God I hated their interpretation of Hush. So f%ckin lame.
The guys from soul of the dragon may look like mortal Kombat characters, because they're based off of the same genre of movies. Mortal Kombat was also inspired by old martial art movies, hence some of the mistakes.
To be fair, the Talia in the Batman: Doom that Came to comic has even less details than the movie gave. She even dies due to her father's actions rather than being another roadblock for Bruce to fight. For that and one OTHER element of the movie: Kai Li Cain. So Kai Li isn't even in the original comic, it's Tim. Who basically is a walking plot ehance device and nothing with Oliver is ever earned. In that regard given Kai Li is a Frankenstein of Cassandra Cain and Carrie Kelly with the Tim Drake elements from the book put in there. It gives the film a far better pathos to Bruce hanging onto his humanity along with giving Ollie and Harvey extra scenes (yeah your wish isn't really granted on Harvey sadly. The movie actually expanded Harvey's role).
I really love Batman: The Doom that Came to Gotham and how the makers of the film expanded the roles along with changing them up enough (save poor Jay. Even changing the race, Jay is basically the same character). Also the filmmakers added the fallen friends/adopted kid angle which works SOOOO much better. Compared to Batman fighting a pair of werewolves. Yes, werewolves.
That said, I'd love another tale from this universe. You don't just give us Kai Li like she is and not don the cape/cowl too and teams up with Batman.
Every time I see footage of that Gotham by Gaslight, I wonder what could have been. Maybe it wouldn't have been very good. But I would love to see them take a proper shot at it with current gen hardware.
Victorian era setting works really well in a batman story and batman going after jack the ripper on top of that
Those are the only three animations that doesn't have The Joker on it...
I really liked this movie it was different for sure but thats literally the charm of the entire idea imo.
In the Gotham by Light comic book it's Harvey Dent who is the killer Ripper
This is great keep up the good work.
Pronunciation -
Giles - Not like "Guile" (Street Fighter).
It's said with a soft G. Like a "J", like "Jiles". Like gelato is said with the same sound as Jello.
Grey DeLisle - not "delesee". It's "duh-lyle" like the "I" sound in "Island". The "Isl" portion is said like " I'll "
14:35 that’s my only problem. They could of been a lot more faithful
Great video bro
Batman: Soul of the Dragon is an AMAZING film and actually one of my favorite Batman films (bar one more in this video). You're just viewing it in the wrong lenses. See, the reason why it's amazing is because every protagonist character used in the flick (Batman, Richard Dragon, Bronze Tiger, and Lady Shiva) were cherished characters by Denny O'Neil (three of them began in the Richard Dragon comics by O'Neil in the 70s, later on he brought Tiger into Batman along with Richard/Shiva. Though the later two showed up in the Question). The whole film is a love letter Denny O'Neil and in a way those inspired by him.
You view the film in that regard, it becomes much better experience.
I agree with almost everything you said about gotham by gaslighting except for Gordon being the culprit, it's too far-fetched for me. It was said that Jack the ripper could be a cop and it is an interesting take, but in this story, I don't think Gordon could be a serial killer even in an elseworld, let alone torturing his wife. However the action scenes are really cool and the other references were great too ! I think I will read the comic, like for the doom that came to gotham, the movie was meh but the comic was great (for me).
Nah, it actually makes perfect sense. James Gordon Jr. It's already in the Gordon DNA, it just usually skips that generation but strikes his son instead.
@@PosthumanHeresy it's true that James Gordon jr story is frightening 😰😱
Honestly it wasn't Gordon in the original that's what made the so called twist actually a twist they basically removed an entire character from the movie and that's Batman's uncle Jake created for this story who actually travels with him from London to Gotham after Bruce completes his training with Sigmund Freud yes the historical psychologist Sigmund Freud....for those who have read the comic the Gordon twist seemed like a cheap stunt compared to the twist in the book
@@brancorocks it's like the movie " Hush" all over again, I will read the comics then.
@@tahern8043 exactly the trend of the unnecessary twists started with this movie Gotham by gaslight and the followed it up with hush a seriously missed opportunity to not only introduce hush but also have a call back to under the red hood all of those scenes are panels were missing from hush plus hush needed to be a two parter considering how long the story actually was....this is exactly why I'm dreading the 3 part crisis on infinite earths movie cause they will yet again do some different things and call it a twist
I would love to see Anthony Stewart Head play Alfred in a live action movie or show.
when you mentioned "doom" I paused the video and watched the movie. I loved it, I love the premise of it and I am a fan of lovecraftian stories.
Gotham by Gaslight was decent until the climax, which just felt too bizarre to me. I also felt a little thrown with how Penguin was teased early on, then basically ignored. Same with Manbat, that was a red herring.
I'm also extremely tired of Ra's al-Guhl (spelling) and the League of Shadows. Talia reminded me of Curare which was cool, but still. Not the worst movie, but not the best either.
Do you mean the doom that came to Gotham because if its to weird for you then lovecraftian stuff is just not for you
@@kubamcmillan3078 No, I'm a big Mythos fan. It wasn't bizarre in general to me, just with where I thought they were going. I really thought Penguin was the Lovecraftian element, they hinted strongly at that right off the bat. I don't know what I was expecting I guess
30:30 The bizarre thing about this is it would have been _so_ easy to rewrite this Freeze to keep his motivations in line with the original. Have the hellish creatures beyond mortal comprehension promise to cure his ailing wife in response for his service.
Hell, modern day Freeze wouldn’t think twice about doing this if it meant it would save Nora.
Gotham By Gaslight is a terrible adaption of the first Elseworlds comic. Everything in the comic was changed in the film, There was no Catwoman, Posion Ivy, or any version of the robins, Batman did not have a motor bike, and Gordon is not Jack The Ripper, that was Jacob Parker, who was killing women who resembled Martha Wayne, after he was rejected by her and she laughed in his face.
They missed including a great scene where Bruce was talking to sigmund Freud.
Lol Gotham by gaslighting lets get the train rolling for once 😅
If you haven’t seen it yet i recommend the Doom that came to Gotham. It’s a really good Elseworld movie
Never mind I should have watched the video longer
One Theory about the IRL Jack the Ripper is that he was a Policeman. That's how he knew all the police routes and knew wich roads to avoid.
what show is the clip 29:07 from?
Gotham by Gaslighting. I would like to see you do comic videos.
It has to be good, to be underrated and this movie was mediocre.
Love your channel so much and so glad you covered my childhood batman which I just got the blu-ray for this year batman 2004 anytime I think batman I think of rino ramono
Did I ever tell you I got jumpscared
By batman once when I was little.
QVC was selling like some DC merch
And flashed a picture of Batman at
Me.😂
The Kano character is a Chuck Norris reference I also recommend you watch the Bruce Lee vs Norris fight.
I read it many years ago they is a reference to the 89 batman when the 3 robin talk abount johnny gobbs which the 2 robbers talk abount on the roof before batman attack them in the 98 film
Am I watching too much of your channel if I don’t know if this is a reupload / compilation and I’m pissed that it’s (maybe) not new but also I don’t remember any of it when I JUST found your channel. Ah brains (Gotham by gaslighting)
This Is one of my favorite alternate versions of Batman and of of my favorite Batman's stories because I'm a Sucker for jack the ripper stories
That shocked the hell out of me to hear
thing with elseworld storiess is they remind me of the game that retells yakuza but itsa set very far in the past
What are your view on the Animanacs reboot on Hulu?
Gotham by Gaslighting
I didn't hate this movie, I just thought the twist was pretty lame.
The "weird ones" from the DCAU I enjoy as their own thing, along the lines of the Elsewhere books. I'm not a huge supers fan (live action ones have me burnt), the DCAU is a slight departure from the comic books & graphic novels because of the change in media type. You have to change things around for pacing, visuals, ect because of the change in media.
When I hear people bitching about the DC live action stuff, or when I am bitching about the Marvel movies being the same recycled story line since Iron Man I mention that the only franchise that has mature story lines tend to be the DCAU (there are flaws in them) but they by far a superior product when you compare them to other mainstream labels. At least with the DCAU I get done watching it and i don;t feel like my intelligence has been beat over the head with a dead fish of mediocrity or bordem at knowing every beat that will take place in the movie 5 minutes before it happens.
Top 5 Batman movies
The Dark Knight
Under The Red Hood
The Batman
Gotham By Gaslight
Dark Knight Returns pt 1&2
(Honorable Mentions)
The Long Halloween pt 1&2
Batman vs Robin
Gotham by gaslight was a good fuckin time
gotham by gaslight didn't need an adaptation. they opened it up, and we basically got the broadway version.
That wasn't Kano, that was meant to be Chuck Norris from Enter the Dragon.
I rather like Batman stories set in earlier time periods making his regular gadgets technological marvels by the period’s standards is rather fun details.
Gotham by Gaslight's Selena Kyle is honestly the most stunningly beautiful version of her ever. The eyes, the hair, whether it's up or down. Everything is just amazing.
This is the one time they adapted the comic and it was better than the book. They ruined HUSH, but GbG was brilliant.
I feel these movies are very underated
Honestly not Gotham by gaslighting here I love love elseworld, what if and mutltiverse storys in General
Does anyone remember the Batman movie that had the teenagers who skateboarded and talked about the different versions of Batman they saw?
That was an episode of the original animated series
Gotham Gaslight is a Elseworld movie pretty much
Gotham by gaslight-ing.
Batman being trained by Sensai is comic book cannon and not an elsworld
please make a video on dexter
GOTHAM by GASLIGHTING
SanJay Todd, JaySan Todd, Jason Todd. Sanjay is just Jason but a little different
Rip kevin conroy
That’s not a handlebar moustache on Bullock, just so you know. Otherwise great job
I genuinely loved Batman Gotham by gaslight, it fel fresh to me and the story was done in a way I could still enjoy it
Am I stupid? What arkham quote should i use for this?
I just know you’re not slandering Soul of the Dragon smh….ahhh but you mess with my favorite scene tho…ok sir. We agree to disagree on the rest.
The kool kobra kult.........wait a minute
Gotham by gasskidding
GOTHAM BY GASLIGHTING!!!
Gatham by gaslighting
i hope Batman Anime is on here
gotham by gaslighting
Love it
Batman ninja that was the weirdest
We're so back
Greetings from Germany, just call him "Snake Fist", cuz that's what his name means 🤣🤣 And I can't blame you, his name is hard to pronounce XD
Rip kevin 😢
I was a basic btch so I just thought Jack the Ripper would be the Joker cuz... Why not
When is he going to review the best piece of Batman media "Lego Justice League Gotham City Breakout" it may be promoted as a justice league movie but it is really a Batman movie with the justice league having a bit of a B plot to deal with
Can you people not say gaslight?! 😂
Gotham by gas farting!
._. What? *points gun* Do it.
Odd ...
Wdym, this movie was never made, it's all in your head
Gothlighting by gasam
🦇 👍
i am the gothambygaslighter
I meant to say the 89 film
Early but late. Hello 25k. Let’s see that go up. Like this comment, the creators comment, and every comment under this. 😊
no.