Three for the largest part, four when Neil Young stuck around, and various duos, depending on the time, as well as each of them had quite successful solo careers.
As much disharmony as there may have been off-stage...on-stage these guys were magic. Rest in peace, David Crosby. This remains my favorite song they ever performed.
Damn, all the music I grew up on. I am sooo happy to have grown up when I did. I'm 65 year old "girl", lol, & I wouldn't trade it for anything. I was raised on some of the best music ever. Perfect example right here.
I discovered this song (and this version of it) about 6 years ago. I haven't been able to stop listening to it since. A vocal harmony masterclass and a beautiful song ❤
Absolutely. To be able to leave something so incredible for everyone is amazing. My Dad introduced me to CSN. He passed away last year and I really miss talking with him about these guys.
This is my favorite Crosby, Stills and Nash song. I've grown old now and can understand what they were singing about. Life is too short to fake it, you'll feel a lot better standing up for who you are.
I bought this album in 20 year anniversary of the summer of love 1987 for those of you who were around in 67 an cant remember because you were tripping your face off . I also graduated high school that year in 87 . I was 17 getting ready to turn 18 that August . I have been in love with CSN for 33 years and I will always love wasted on the way I didn't have to turn 50 which I do this August to figure it out but I can say there are friends that I can't wait for them to figure it out .Cause I love you guys Travis Barcomb Andy Latimer Joel Allenbaugh and John Hope come on guys it's been 30 yrs this summer and I still love you all
NEVER WILL I TIRE OF STEPHEN STILLS , GRAHAM NASH AND DAVID CROSBY WHEN I HEAR THEM SING IT'S GOD GIFT TO MY EARS BEAUTIFUL HARMONY SING ON MY BROTHERS ✌🖖🙏
Look around me I can see my life before me Running rings around the way It used to be I am older now I have more than what I wanted But I wish that I had started Long before I did And there's so much time to make up Everywhere you turn Time we have wasted on the way So much water moving Underneath the bridge Let the water come and carry us away Oh when you were young Did you question all the answers Did you envy all the dancers Who had all the nerve Look round you know You must go for what you wanted Look at all my friends who did and got what they deserved And there's so much time to make up Everywhere you turn Time we have wasted on the way So much water moving Underneath the bridge Let the water come and carry us away And there's so much love to make up Everywhere you turn Love we have wasted on the way So much water moving Underneath the bridge Let the water come and carry us away Let the water come and carry us away
I saw these guys at Woodstock 1969! Harmonies were second to none! Thank God some things never change! Rock in Peace David! You are loved and will be sorely missed!❤🎶🎼🎵🎤🎸
Everyone says I was born late. I was only 4 years old when Woodstock took place, yet I would have been there if I was older. Peace, pot and microdot my friends😊
My son's high school class sang "teach your children" to their parents at invocation. I will never forget it, and every time I hear this, no matter where I am, I can't speak or I'll cry 😢❤❤
2 guitars and 3 guys singing and they sound better than 99.9% of so called artists of today with their billion dollars of electronics helping them! This is real music!
Their harmony in that song is so beautiful. A lot of groups had good harmony, but something about Dave, Steve, and Graham's voices blending is even now after over 50 years, so magical
God, I love all three of these guys, and all of them together. Look at them -- three such different personalities, singers, people, but put them together and -- YIKES! We were so lucky to have their music during our coming-of-age years. I think I am a better person for it.
From another 60/70s geezer...these guys are the best, sans question. True rock and roll & meaningful. Best harmony. Just saw them...after 30+ years...awesome!
Just pure magic, these three guys....My heart is broken that "and now we are two", as Croz has flown away. But his music ....wow, such a legacy to live on. Timeless.
These were my college days.... marching in Washington.... marching in NYC.....Tin Soldiers and Nixon's coming......and now we have Trump.....LOL,. without the magnificent music......!!
Lionel Ducote Thank you for your service. My best friend is a Vietnam Vet. AND he told me that he and several fellow vets hoped, after Vietnam, that the US had learned its lesson around colonial wars and being " the police of the world. " Sadly, in my opinion and his, valiant men and women continue to be sent into harm's way to make Corporations and their CEOs richer.
tantraman10 Do you think your marching will be recorded? History is all about who won the war! Nothing else. Rich people hire us poor people. I have never been hired by a poor person. your you and I'm me, were different, You are acting in Your Own interest I am acting in the Country's interest. Should we have let the Nazi's win?
Nazi's and the Vietnamese are apples and oranges. Vietnam was part of French Indochina... A COLONY to make French Corporations ( Michelin Rubber) rich. We just took the place of the French and made some American Corporations richer...the beginning of the Military-Industrial- Congressional Complex that General Dwight David Eisenhower warned us of..WW II and Vietnam....not even CLOSE to analogous!
Each of C,S,&N are special in their own way. Nash is a very careful musician, Stills is never afraid to go and thrash his guitar, and Crosby is amazing in that his vocals never stand out, meaning his blending is so seamless as to be invisible. 💙🙏🏼
@loristoneking5671 listen to David and Graham do Guinnevere by themselves in concert, with Graham playing harmonica - haunting - the ending is EPIC, and the audience is blown away.
Just found this piece couple weeks ago. What a discovery! So beautiful harmonies, lyrics and melody. I will cherish this particular track for the years to come.
When this song came out 40 years ago it just reminded me so much of my two best friends and I. We were in our 30s at the time and we're not quite where we should have been financially. I always wished we had more money to do more things that we love to do together. They are both gone now and I miss them so much . This song is how I stay in touch with them. Sleep well my brothers I will miss you forever.
@wesweldon8350 No you don't but it does afford you a lot more opportunities then you would have if you were broke . I have been very very poor and also pretty well off not rich but very comfortable and believe me life is a lot easier if you're not worrying about paying bills . Hanging out is a lot different then being able to afford to go on trips together . It's all relative to how much money you actually have
crosby was epic in taking the high part of those harmonies... you look at him, his completely relaxed face, and you can't believe it is he who is hitting those high notes with such ease and purity.
Songs with meaning...real heart felt experiences behind each and every word...such music is timeless...I look back on my brief moment on earth and I review my actions, my efforts and I realize I could have treated people better, done things with more commitment and used time more thoughtfully...then I aspire to live the next half of my life making up for this...doing better...having learnt...from these mistakes...thats what "living" should be about...
Nash has said that he likes his music to be personal--it doesn't get much more personal than this. And I love the views of them in profile singing together. It's how I'll always remember them, now that Croz is gone.
I listen everyday. Just bought the autobiography of Croz and Nash. These guys were my escape from reality when I was young and troubled. No bigger fan then myself. See you in Omaha in August, Graham.
Back 9 years later (from my last comment). Even though it was already very unlikely, it's sad now with the final realization that we won't hear / see these 3 voice sing live together ever again. You can practice all you want, but these 3 unique voices just blended heavenly. I've played this repeatedly since the news yesterday of Croz's passing. Heaven may include being transported back to this performance.
Got misty eyes here watching this... And it's 2020 with COVID-19 Pandemic still on its run... They should come back together again + Young... For good & forever... Setting aside their egoes once and for all... Sigh...
The first time I heard this, I felt shattered, and every time the same. Bonnie's voice imbues these songs with such vulnerability. Her version of 'Love has no Pride' another heartbreaker ❤
I was lucky enough to stand about ten feet from the stage over 20 years ago and watch these guys showcase their artistry, from the first note, I got chills, imagining them at Woodstock and knowing for a fact I was seeing history and feeling some of the best music ever played. thank you guys, we love your music.
@@emm352 I was about to say that. Saw them on CBS this morning a few months ago. They could be making incredible music and are really blowing it by being petty.
🙏 Gott segne die guten musikalischen Botschaften !!! Aus Solingen ganz liebe Grüße, die Ihre wunderbare Musik auf der Insel Föhr in Süderende live erleben durften! Diese Erinnerung ist auch nach Jahren in unseren Herzen geblieben! Danke 🙏💕
My generation made music that has stood the test of time. Oldies but goodies.
I think the music from the early 70s was the best songs there's ever been.
This was longer than 12 years ago but one of the best songs ever. This group of 3 talented artists is still listened to today and loved!
Four.
Three for the largest part, four when Neil Young stuck around, and various duos, depending on the time, as well as each of them had quite successful solo careers.
CSN Daylight Again tour 1983
This was 42 years ago :) filmed/ recorded at the Los Angeles Ampitheater In 1982
I used to hate listening to them when I was a kid because it was all my father ever listened to and now when I'm older I can't stop listening to them😂
great comment! Now my kids listen to them
Life's kinda 'funny' like that.
It works that way somehow, sometimes...
Same, now they make my heart happy and let my soul dance.
That's simply because truly talented musicians are becoming scarce and you realize now how good vocal harmony and tasteful guitar licks sound.
As much disharmony as there may have been off-stage...on-stage these guys were magic.
Rest in peace, David Crosby.
This remains my favorite song they ever performed.
Listening to this over and over; there is NO harmony like the harmony they produced. What an amazing sound.
Pure magic when they combine their voices.
favorite song and best performance of it.
these guys got people to chill and be peaceful ,
None of them could deny they were born to sing together
2023 and still smiling as I listen to that perfect harmony! Man that’s the best!!
Damn, all the music I grew up on. I am sooo happy to have grown up when I did. I'm 65 year old "girl", lol, & I wouldn't trade it for anything. I was raised on some of the best music ever. Perfect example right here.
I totally agree 👍
If I can click ‘like’ a million times I’ll do so just to show my admiration.
Those harmonies are the best you will ever hear.
Just sorry as can be. David you will be misssed
They sure where the best at it..
True story
@@Everythinghasasoulu no thats right nvr ever ever in our lifetime or your kids and your grand kids will u ever here something like that again
Perfect!!!
The harmony on this song is so good. I've listened to it for 40 years and it never ceases to amaze me .
oh i so agree
Breath taking.
me too......................
And let's talk about Crosby for a minute.. it's just so natural
I discovered this song (and this version of it) about 6 years ago. I haven't been able to stop listening to it since. A vocal harmony masterclass and a beautiful song ❤
Beautiful. Tearful. Hopeful. The world is temporal. These lads are forever.
Absolutely. To be able to leave something so incredible for everyone is amazing. My Dad introduced me to CSN. He passed away last year and I really miss talking with him about these guys.
@@peterbuckmaster581 The harmonies of these guys were the best.
Vote Blue ballot down
They will be listening to this music 1000 years from now. Thank you boys….R.I.P DC
RIP David Crosby. Thank you for the music. You will never be forgotten 🙏
Thank you David for beautiful songs!! RIP!!
The man lived longer than he should have, David Crosby lived with reckless abandon as a rock star.
Certainly never will be forgotten.
This is my favorite Crosby, Stills and Nash song.
I've grown old now and can understand what they were singing about.
Life is too short to fake it, you'll feel a lot better standing up for who you are.
And just being who you are :)
Contakum
Movie
Some of us end up in prison for being real though 😐
couldnt have said it any better. this song is about life
I bought this album in 20 year anniversary of the summer of love 1987 for those of you who were around in 67 an cant remember because you were tripping your face off . I also graduated high school that year in 87 . I was 17 getting ready to turn 18 that August . I have been in love with CSN for 33 years and I will always love wasted on the way I didn't have to turn 50 which I do this August to figure it out but I can say there are friends that I can't wait for them to figure it out .Cause I love you guys Travis Barcomb Andy Latimer Joel Allenbaugh and John Hope come on guys it's been 30 yrs this summer and I still love you all
After the years of youthful power plays, such mature mutual love. Go ahead, guys...Make me cry.
The best part of being old is all the great music we got!
Well You speak out of my heart.
I've been listening to them for over 50 years
Me too😊
A legend has died today. David Crosby, fare thee well. You shall be missed.
2024 and I'm dreaming about the water carrying us away.
me too! 💙
NEVER WILL I TIRE OF STEPHEN STILLS , GRAHAM NASH AND DAVID CROSBY
WHEN I HEAR THEM SING
IT'S GOD GIFT TO MY EARS
BEAUTIFUL HARMONY
SING ON MY BROTHERS ✌🖖🙏
pure LOVE!!!!❤
Another classic Graham Nash tune. So beautiful.
the very best harmonies ever!
th-cam.com/video/F2SDf42guB4/w-d-xo.html
@Artie .g. Then you add Neil.
You ain’t lying
Beautiful song. Simple and elegant.
Great song, great harmonies. Rest in peace, David. 🙏🕊🎶
RIP David Crosby listening to this amazing Graham Nash song and the amazing harmonies these guys made together. Still beautiful as ever.
Thank You Crosby , Stills , Nash …to this day the biggest fan of Stephen Stills …. Thank You Sir’s !
Use your time on earth to help others and be kind.
Agreed!!! At the very least, as a benchmark, for ALL social interactions, COMMON MUTUAL RESPECT. Love, peace and oneness for all sentient beings♥
Go for what you wanted...yes live !
Robert - Amen. Well said
screw that noise
Nope - use your time on earth to find and fulfill your own purpose, not tell other people what there’s is! 😁😂😅🤣
Look around me
I can see my life before me
Running rings around the way
It used to be
I am older now
I have more than what I wanted
But I wish that I had started
Long before I did
And there's so much time to make up
Everywhere you turn
Time we have wasted on the way
So much water moving
Underneath the bridge
Let the water come and carry us away
Oh when you were young
Did you question all the answers
Did you envy all the dancers
Who had all the nerve
Look round you know
You must go for what you wanted
Look at all my friends who did and got what they deserved
And there's so much time to make up
Everywhere you turn
Time we have wasted on the way
So much water moving
Underneath the bridge
Let the water come and carry us away
And there's so much love to make up
Everywhere you turn
Love we have wasted on the way
So much water moving
Underneath the bridge
Let the water come and carry us away
Let the water come and carry us away
Thank you for posting the lyrics!! 👍👍
Beautiful, meaningful lyrics.
Thanks
I really appreciate the meaningful and beautiful lyrics. 😘
❤❤❤❤
I saw these guys at Woodstock 1969! Harmonies were second to none! Thank God some things never change! Rock in Peace David! You are loved and will be sorely missed!❤🎶🎼🎵🎤🎸
Everyone says I was born late.
I was only 4 years old when Woodstock took place, yet I would have been there if I was older. Peace, pot and microdot my friends😊
My son's high school class sang "teach your children" to their parents at invocation. I will never forget it, and every time I hear this, no matter where I am, I can't speak or I'll cry 😢❤❤
I love it that the audience responded David's "shhhhhhhh" ....such a beautiful tune...
So nice and simple. Just the musicians. No flashing lights or distracting stage paraphernalia. And no one is expected to dance while singing
I never get tired of CSN and this song always moves me to tears. I love it!!! Where are songwriters like this today??
2 guitars and 3 guys singing and they sound better than 99.9% of so called artists of today with their billion dollars of electronics helping them!
This is real music!
Now I am 83 and I still love these guys. First heard them during my military days in Asia. Great harmonies!
Once in awhile you need a reminder of the perfect harmony of these three voices! Never gets old!!!
Their harmony in that song is so beautiful. A lot of groups had good harmony, but something about Dave, Steve, and Graham's voices blending is even now after over 50 years, so magical
Well said.
That's the Real thing!
God, I love all three of these guys, and all of them together. Look at them -- three such different personalities, singers, people, but put them together and -- YIKES! We were so lucky to have their music during our coming-of-age years. I think I am a better person for it.
RIP David - heaven got some great harmony today.
They brought it live. Impeckable, gorgeous harmonies.
What a calming break from the turmoil in our country.
RIP David what a sad day lossing him. Breaks my heart
Umas das 3 vozes mais lindas do mundo d música, e olha que tem muitas. Obrigada, Crosbi, Nash e Stills ❤
From another 60/70s geezer...these guys are the best, sans question. True rock and roll & meaningful. Best harmony. Just saw them...after 30+ years...awesome!
Rest in peace, David Crosby. I'll treasure your songs.
Rest in peace David. Tears in my eyes now.
Just pure magic, these three guys....My heart is broken that "and now we are two", as Croz has flown away. But his music ....wow, such a legacy to live on. Timeless.
WOW can we please go back in time????
These were my college days.... marching in Washington.... marching in NYC.....Tin Soldiers and Nixon's coming......and now we have Trump.....LOL,. without the magnificent music......!!
And I was Fighting a war, are you complaining?? Love it or leave it. Did you learn how to paint in College?
Lionel Ducote Thank you for your service. My best friend is a Vietnam Vet. AND he told me that he and several fellow vets hoped, after Vietnam, that the US had learned its lesson around colonial wars and being " the police of the world. " Sadly, in my opinion and his, valiant men and women continue to be sent into harm's way to make Corporations and their CEOs richer.
tantraman10
Do you think your marching will be recorded? History is all about who won the war! Nothing else. Rich people hire us poor people. I have never been hired by a poor person. your you and I'm me, were different, You are acting in Your Own interest I am acting in the Country's interest. Should we have let the Nazi's win?
Nazi's and the Vietnamese are apples and oranges. Vietnam was part of French Indochina... A COLONY to make French Corporations ( Michelin Rubber) rich. We just took the place of the French and made some American Corporations richer...the beginning of the Military-Industrial- Congressional Complex that General Dwight David Eisenhower warned us of..WW II and Vietnam....not even CLOSE to analogous!
You can't beat harmonizing like this, absolutely brilliant.
Each of C,S,&N are special in their own way. Nash is a very careful musician, Stills is never afraid to go and thrash his guitar, and Crosby is amazing in that his vocals never stand out, meaning his blending is so seamless as to be invisible. 💙🙏🏼
When I want to hear David's voice more isolated, I listen to Guinevere.
@@loristoneking5671 Love that Song
Great song
@loristoneking5671 listen to David and Graham do Guinnevere by themselves in concert, with Graham playing harmonica - haunting - the ending is EPIC, and the audience is blown away.
Three voices and a couple guitars. Real music.
Just found this piece couple weeks ago. What a discovery! So beautiful harmonies, lyrics and melody. I will cherish this particular track for the years to come.
Loved growing up in the 60’s ….ya, I’m old but we had the best music!
Rest in Peace David Crosby. Thanks for the memories.
POCO and CSNY are in my lists of my Fav bands
Harmonic perfection! I absolutely love this song! RIP David Crosby. Your vocal talent is sorely missed.
How can you not Love these guys!!!
When this song came out 40 years ago it just reminded me so much of my two best friends and I. We were in our 30s at the time and we're not quite where we should have been financially. I always wished we had more money to do more things that we love to do together. They are both gone now and I miss them so much . This song is how I stay in touch with them. Sleep well my brothers I will miss you forever.
Sorry but you not need a bunch of money to hang with your friends.
@wesweldon8350
No you don't but it does afford you a lot more opportunities then you would have if you were broke .
I have been very very poor and also pretty well off not rich but very comfortable and believe me life is a lot easier if you're not worrying about paying bills .
Hanging out is a lot different then being able to afford to go on trips together . It's all relative to how much money you actually have
crosby was epic in taking the high part of those harmonies... you look at him, his completely relaxed face, and you can't believe it is he who is hitting those high notes with such ease and purity.
It’s PERFECT
Wish they could play together again before the end. Pure brilliance!!!!
They are just awesome ❣️
Ain't gonna happen. Too much hate baggage going on between them now. Shame
@@n40tom such a shame indeed, that’s makes me so sad :(
I rember this song during my hi school days, we used to sing this with my best friends, now Im older now,,,, this song never fades,
RIP David Crosby. You will live forever in our hearts through your music. 😢🙏❤️
I was lucky enough to see these talented musicians twice. They will always have the best harmonies in the business.
Heard this when I was a pre teen. Here it is 50 years later and still relevant...I still listen....Salute CSN
LOL--not! It is from 1982. I remember when it came out. 😂😂😂
Yea... at the time of this comment more like 35 years. lol.
We all have wasted on the way. These guys just put it into words for us. Truly great artists.
Agreed . That’s life.
RIP Mr. Crosby.. thank you for your gift of music and song.
Icons that were pioneers and truly shaped modern music. Foundational.
Songs with meaning...real heart felt experiences behind each and every word...such music is timeless...I look back on my brief moment on earth and I review my actions, my efforts and I realize I could have treated people better, done things with more commitment and used time more thoughtfully...then I aspire to live the next half of my life making up for this...doing better...having learnt...from these mistakes...thats what "living" should be about...
Well said my friend!
What harmonies!
so true..I hope I am not too late to make things right in my life..
That’s brilliant, check out the Avett Brothers, they are amazing people with beautiful harmonies and meaningful lyrics.
❤️
I can't listen to this,.....way too soon,......David will truly be missed........
!!!!!!
Nash has said that he likes his music to be personal--it doesn't get much more personal than this. And I love the views of them in profile singing together. It's how I'll always remember them, now that Croz is gone.
..."they're finally make friends. Got rich. Was good!" Steve is genious😅
I have loved these guys since they started out in the 60's!!! wonderful group. great music...
one of the best vocal-guitar bands!
harmony and melody won't let me leave this song! since the 70's up to now 2022! Classic and legendary!
I listen everyday. Just bought the autobiography of Croz and Nash. These guys were my escape from reality when I was young and troubled. No bigger fan then myself. See you in Omaha in August, Graham.
Back 9 years later (from my last comment). Even though it was already very unlikely, it's sad now with the final realization that we won't hear / see these 3 voice sing live together ever again. You can practice all you want, but these 3 unique voices just blended heavenly. I've played this repeatedly since the news yesterday of Croz's passing. Heaven may include being transported back to this performance.
Great intro chat. Tearjerker of a song. Powerful..
Got misty eyes here watching this... And it's 2020 with COVID-19 Pandemic still on its run...
They should come back together again + Young... For good & forever... Setting aside their egoes once and for all... Sigh...
They won't. Crosby made sure of that.
Fuck off
loved their reunion concerts . every time they could still bring it
This is a complete nostalgia blast. If you're over the age of 40 in 2020, this song is probably part of your childhood in some way.
Maxxx Modelz you got that right!
th-cam.com/video/ovoXNhuds7s/w-d-xo.html check this out someone's recreating the csn harmonies
didnt realize gram Nash wrote this song.....and at 73 oh my years wasted along the way...but still going...still dancing here....
Such great harmony, words, everything. Miss this kind of music.
Hello Pat, How are you doing?
@@kellyofuller4974: This is not a pickup joint! Leave women alone!
This makes me miss friends who have passed before me. So many happy memories shared.
This song is so beautiful..gives me goosebumps
Best song Graham Nash wrote.
This guy belongs in the top 5 all time best songwriter's.
No question.
Wish they could put there differences behind them and play music together again. It’s to bad we may never hear this again. 💔
Musicians. They are this way all the time. Like Don Henley once said, Every band is one concert from breaking up. Sad but true Don.
That's because David was a drugged out idiot for so many years they will never get back together
Godspeed David; thanks for all that you gave us in so many years.
They've earned their place in music history as the tightest 3 part harmony singers - EVER!
Those guitars sound so full and smooth!
Doesnt make sense that this song has so little views. It's brilliant.
Oh my…this is a gem 👍✌️
The first time I heard this, I felt shattered, and every time the same. Bonnie's voice imbues these songs with such vulnerability. Her version of 'Love has no Pride' another heartbreaker ❤
Can't get this one out of my head, since hearing of David's passing this week, at 81 years old.
I was lucky enough to stand about ten feet from the stage over 20 years ago and watch these guys showcase their artistry, from the first note, I got chills, imagining them at Woodstock
and knowing for a fact I was seeing history and feeling some of the best music ever played. thank you guys, we love your music.
When I saw them @ Woodstock, Young would not give permission to be filmed, so that small myth began...it was mostly the four of them. Always.
May Cros' memory be a blessing.
A great song with an important message. Life is too short for pettiness.
And for misremembering
Seems like they need to learn that lesson again
@@emm352 I was about to say that. Saw them on CBS this morning a few months ago. They could be making incredible music and are really blowing it by being petty.
The song speaks volumes about this OLD JARHEAD ❤ THANKS GUYS. DOBIE WAN KANOBIE
Their best song, best harmonies, defines their lives.
🙏 Gott segne die guten musikalischen Botschaften !!! Aus Solingen ganz liebe Grüße, die Ihre wunderbare Musik auf der Insel Föhr in Süderende live erleben durften! Diese Erinnerung ist auch nach Jahren in unseren Herzen geblieben! Danke 🙏💕
Pure harmonising peace be upon you man!
What a song, what an album Daylight Again. My Favourite.
RIP David Crosby.