As someone who has taken a robotics class he was trying to simplify for you. Going into Hamiltonian and laplacian systems along with chaos theory and non linear controls is too technical for cnet's audience. Hence why you didn't even understand why he stated what he did smh.
I would disagree to that opinion, because Boston Dynamics Atlas robots work with hydraulics, which seems to be more agile at the moment, but it is also more error prone, because the system has very often hydraulics failures, ending in fatal crashes of the robots. A system build on electric motors is much more reliable. Also Atlas is a "dumb robot" which is preprogrammed and which is NOT capable of doing tasks on his own decisions, although Boston Dynmamics are working on robots since founded in 1992. Their software is not even close to Teslas humanoid Robot Optimus which is still in alpha development status and which is using the same software platform as their Full Self Driving Tesla vehicles. Correct recognition of the surrounding and navigation through that obstacles and objects and successfully manipulating objects in such areas is a very hard task for each robot manufacturing company. Time will show who is more succesfull. Probably in a few years we will be able to compare them better.
Compare their dog with a real and live one. The abyss. A real dog can adjust its speed, it can change the direction of movement, it classifies objects, it distinguishes objects, it is able to find a pack of cigarettes in the space of a square kilometer. A dog from Dynamics has no sense organs, it has no consciousness, it does not know how to take definitions, it does not have a position in one-dimensional space that turns an object into a subject. Therefore, Dynamics is not far away at all, what they do can be done by any student.
@@Ken_1971 I disagree, Atlas is still learning, and the hydraulic actuator systems they use will only get better. I don't know what you mean by being "preprogrammed". It's running an AI is still learning. it uses many sensors in its limbs and head. probably as much as a tesla vehicle now that the new models don't have nearly as much sensors. being frank here, teslas robot is embarrassing
@@Koroleva_O_A wtf are you arguing bro, you're seriously inferring spot can't change speed, direction, classify or distinguish objects? dude it can do all those things
@@IowaMan I don't see it in the video. The speed and direction of movement of the animal are regulated by external signals, which have a value of. The magnitude of the signal sets the magnitude of the speed or the magnitude of the angle by which the animal evades. When moving in the coordinate space, the movement is reduced to the direction towards the stimulus or away from the stimulus. The robot's movement is not directional, it cannot be changed through the environment, therefore, the robot does not interact with the environment, it is not a source of commands (instructions) to regulate its own behavior. To separate something into a separate object is to give it a name and a value. The name will be associated with a reaction, this is some action that the robot performs. And the value determines the difference between the value of the robot and the value of the selected object. This value is incoming, it sets the reaction (the magnitude of the action, its intensity and duration). I don't see anything like that in the video. What I see in any animal or human as a variety of robots. This video is intended for those who do not know psychology, who do not know programming, and so on. They can be shown a humanoid robot that walks like a human, and delight is provided. But for a specialist, everything looks different. The robot does not do any of the things listed.
@@ayoutubechannelname Engineered Arts is doing just that, It's really impressive; check them out. At this point Boston Dynamics, Engineered Arts and Open AI and Tesla Self-driving AI could combined their technology and expertise to give us a really incredible humanoid robot like tomorrow. We have the technology, it's just scattered.
@@stephdep8825 No, that's not what they mean. What about a robot that can pick up a quadriplegic/disabled person, and lift them from bed to toilet? THAT is something that is actually useful. Especially for disabled people that need this when paying for nanny service is not an option.
Well to be fair it is for say a robot used in space for outside repairs. Not so for earth every day use. But then again it depends on what it can do. If you can replace a human worker and it lasts 5 years 100k is suddenly not that bad. Robots dont need breaks and dont sleep. Its all just a question of "can it do useful things"
Atlas is not really comercial product and Optimus is slated to be five time cheaper so this one being much better is to be expected (hopefuly it can be good enough to be worth that price)
@@Xi_Jinping_is_Pooh I would say only 10 years for a perfect working mass produced bot and the price will be around 30.000 US Dollars ( for a Tesla Optimus bot )
In the name of national security we aren’t allowed to see those. Unless that’s what the US is currently shooting down. The recent octagon with strings, sounds more like a rouge Ai building high tech devices to spy on us. That tech flying around up there lately is way beyond ours hence problems tracking them etc. if it wasn’t for the Chinese spy balloon we would of never seen this other stuff ‘flying’ around up there.
Boston dynamics has the motion and agility down, Tesla has the actual brain down. I'm not entirely convinced NASA is contributing much that boston dynamics and tesla haven't done better.
if a robot works 24/7, it can replace 4 workers, (which is excellent) but $100.000 is still steep if you add hardware & software updates, especially weekly checkups, and monthly service. But it will drop!
@@Hindu_Ram121 If the retail hardware of Optimus is in the +/- $20k budget (or less either with leasing) its the training and software adaptation and updates that will cost on a yearly contract. But this is speculation, lets see how it evolves over the months to come. As an artist 🎨 I would love one for the studio!
I heard tesla's robot would be around 20, 000 dollars so that will be a huge difference and will probably make the Apollo robot obsolete as far as selling is concerned anyway.
Forget about Tesla Optimus. It can barely walk. Agility Robotics can run and grab boxes. It is less bulky than Boston Dynamic humanoid robots. It is a winner.
I think a few extra arms and hands would be useful, and would still be suitable for the human environment. Similarly for eyes on the ends of stalks, and some built-in tools.
A micro atmosphere & toxic realm places, is mostly where a robot will be needed to task. From building infastructer to sustain bio lifeforms in other worlds, to assembling super megalithic structure and security.
And yet this company's former robot with just the hands being controlled by a human have more practical uses then the youtube video making atlas. Atlas looks cool. Thats it.
A human in a blindfold would have similar difficulty keeping footing with blocks of wood all over the floor... Give the robot some good down-angled crotch cameras and it'll be good to go! :)
It still exists and some tests are still being done with it but nothing compared to their initial phase. The Humanoid Robotics Project (HRP) was sponsored by Japan's Ministry of Economy to see the viability of general domestic helper robots, they weren't really trying to sell their own design, they were just trying to convince the private sector that it was indeed a truly possible goal. Even if they wanted to sell the HRP-4c, they likely would fail to find a market, since it costed around $2.5 million to develop and $200,000 per unit to build. It's a cool trick it's pulling off but $200,000 cool? I dunno lol
@@rowshambow That was the price when it was built. I honestly wasn't even thinking about how time would've driven down the price and this is very likely to be true with the advancements and proliferation of technology. Although, I'm unfamiliar with the specific hardware utilized by machine itself so I'm unable to truly know if the parts used were really affected by this trend.
Even though the end goal is noble, it doesn’t yet make any sense to try to create a general purpose humanoid robot : the technological pieces to achieve that are not there yet. However, remotely controlled humanoid robots makes much more sense : they could be somewhat autonomous for some tasks, and would benefit from the help of human conciousness when needed. That the way Waymo is doing their autonomous robotaxi : time to time, some remote human intervention to take decisions when the robotaxi doesn’t know what to do
🤯One hundred thousand Dollars!!? And Do you call that affordable???🤣 Man that cost more than a Tesla, CNC or an industrial robot it almost cost like an American house, 😵wtf men that is just not affordable in any planet you visit
"Dynamic walking is walking dynamically." That's the kind of intellect that makes you CEO.
As someone who has taken a robotics class he was trying to simplify for you. Going into Hamiltonian and laplacian systems along with chaos theory and non linear controls is too technical for cnet's audience. Hence why you didn't even understand why he stated what he did smh.
If he ever reads your comment, I bet he will wipe his tear with his dollars
@@johnnyBrwn As a God i can understand your frustration but no
@@cooleregg5577 same hahaha
It's all about the white privilege card.
Thought I was watching a Boston dynamics video from 10 years ago !
Its unbelievable how much father advanced BD is above all other competitors
it's crazy how far ahead boston dynamics are in this field
I would disagree to that opinion, because Boston Dynamics Atlas robots work with hydraulics, which seems to be more agile at the moment, but it is also more error prone, because the system has very often hydraulics failures, ending in fatal crashes of the robots.
A system build on electric motors is much more reliable.
Also Atlas is a "dumb robot" which is preprogrammed and which is NOT capable of doing tasks on his own decisions, although Boston Dynmamics are working on robots since founded in 1992. Their software is not even close to Teslas humanoid Robot Optimus which is still in alpha development status and which is using the same software platform as their Full Self Driving Tesla vehicles. Correct recognition of the surrounding and navigation through that obstacles and objects and successfully manipulating objects in such areas is a very hard task for each robot manufacturing company. Time will show who is more succesfull. Probably in a few years we will be able to compare them better.
Compare their dog with a real and live one. The abyss. A real dog can adjust its speed, it can change the direction of movement, it classifies objects, it distinguishes objects, it is able to find a pack of cigarettes in the space of a square kilometer. A dog from Dynamics has no sense organs, it has no consciousness, it does not know how to take definitions, it does not have a position in one-dimensional space that turns an object into a subject. Therefore, Dynamics is not far away at all, what they do can be done by any student.
@@Ken_1971 I disagree, Atlas is still learning, and the hydraulic actuator systems they use will only get better. I don't know what you mean by being "preprogrammed". It's running an AI is still learning. it uses many sensors in its limbs and head. probably as much as a tesla vehicle now that the new models don't have nearly as much sensors.
being frank here, teslas robot is embarrassing
@@Koroleva_O_A
wtf are you arguing bro, you're seriously inferring spot can't change speed, direction, classify or distinguish objects? dude it can do all those things
@@IowaMan I don't see it in the video. The speed and direction of movement of the animal are regulated by external signals, which have a value of. The magnitude of the signal sets the magnitude of the speed or the magnitude of the angle by which the animal evades. When moving in the coordinate space, the movement is reduced to the direction towards the stimulus or away from the stimulus. The robot's movement is not directional, it cannot be changed through the environment, therefore, the robot does not interact with the environment, it is not a source of commands (instructions) to regulate its own behavior.
To separate something into a separate object is to give it a name and a value. The name will be associated with a reaction, this is some action that the robot performs. And the value determines the difference between the value of the robot and the value of the selected object. This value is incoming, it sets the reaction (the magnitude of the action, its intensity and duration). I don't see anything like that in the video. What I see in any animal or human as a variety of robots.
This video is intended for those who do not know psychology, who do not know programming, and so on. They can be shown a humanoid robot that walks like a human, and delight is provided. But for a specialist, everything looks different. The robot does not do any of the things listed.
NASA should save time and money and get Boston Dynamics bots.
I bet you NASA team members have stakes in Apptroniks.
With multiple teams you could discover different things and advance faster
Yes but these kids have the white privilege card.
Or tesla
This is unbelievable. We’re truly living in the future.
We r living in present
@@edittube Actually, we are living slightly in the past
The future will be terminator
Yeah look at DARPA'S ATLAS and NASA'S VALKYRIE! Imagine what they don't show us and where we will be in 5-10 years
And then mix that with A.I.
Boston dynamics is on another level
*SKYNET* _CONFIRMED_ 💀
Robots and probes are what we need to send for space exploration not humans.
Amen
“Dynamic Walking”? Boston Dynmics
Boston dynamics: we got robot that can dance and do backflips and don’t need a wire nor look drunk
All of our environment is designed for human form, so we need a robot that works in our environment, and not a environment for the robot to work in!♥️
Boston Dynamics is way ahead.
They are largely focused on the robot’s gross motor skills. What about fine motor skills?
@@ayoutubechannelname Engineered Arts is doing just that, It's really impressive; check them out. At this point Boston Dynamics, Engineered Arts and Open AI and Tesla Self-driving AI could combined their technology and expertise to give us a really incredible humanoid robot like tomorrow. We have the technology, it's just scattered.
RLM lol
I can't wait til they build a robot that can pick me up and carry me around!
It's there already.. it's called a car bro... may be an smartcar
@@stephdep8825 No, that's not what they mean. What about a robot that can pick up a quadriplegic/disabled person, and lift them from bed to toilet? THAT is something that is actually useful. Especially for disabled people that need this when paying for nanny service is not an option.
A combination of prosthetics and a exoskeleton would be better.
100K, and you call it "pretty affordable" ?
Well to be fair it is for say a robot used in space for outside repairs. Not so for earth every day use. But then again it depends on what it can do. If you can replace a human worker and it lasts 5 years 100k is suddenly not that bad. Robots dont need breaks and dont sleep. Its all just a question of "can it do useful things"
Atlas is not really comercial product and Optimus is slated to be five time cheaper so this one being much better is to be expected (hopefuly it can be good enough to be worth that price)
Are they going to add GPT3 / GPT4 or some other LLM into the robot?
its going to take more than an LLM, you need vision and an understanding of the environment. And know how to translate language into action.
If it cleans my house, I’m sold
Tesla bot will destroy all the competition with cheap manufacturing and advanced computer vision and AI.
Can't wait for the first real Robot for Consumers
The Future I waited for 20 Years
Can’t wait !!!!!!!!!!!
Same, it just needs to be priced at around $10,000.
We'll have to wait for 20 more.
@@Xi_Jinping_is_Pooh I would say only 10 years for a perfect working mass produced bot and the price will be around 30.000 US Dollars ( for a Tesla Optimus bot )
If you have a spare seventy-four and a half thousand dollars lying around, you too can own your very own spot robot!
Wait till you see robocop patroling near your house
Humanoid robots should called Androids..
Boston Dynamics is laughing at the corner
Um the dang thing still cant walk on its own in the (9 years later) 2023... Call Boston Dynamic STAT!
Yea, yea, yea.... Boston dynamics is already doing this...
Still haven't matched human gait yet though
What happened to Honda's ASIMO robot??
Looks like Digit From Agility Robotics
SMH, it's like NO ONE has seen terminator.
Everyone knows the Risk but we are greedy
I have seen air force one, I don’t think any president irl can do what Harrison ford did though
3:29 pretty affordable $100,000 😂
Why doesnt NASA collabarate with Boston Dynmamics for that ?
What about the latest military soldier robots, I'd like to see what they look like :(
In the name of national security we aren’t allowed to see those. Unless that’s what the US is currently shooting down. The recent octagon with strings, sounds more like a rouge Ai building high tech devices to spy on us. That tech flying around up there lately is way beyond ours hence problems tracking them etc. if it wasn’t for the Chinese spy balloon we would of never seen this other stuff ‘flying’ around up there.
No fair they have aimbot 😭
When are you all going to review the Clarisys Audio Panel Loudspeakers ?
$100,000 sure is affordable. People must be growing money on trees these days.
If I ever manage to save up that kind of money just to buy a humanoid robot then I could just say ‘good bye’ to ever buying an actual house.
I mean, everyone I know makes more than $100k these days. Just get into a good university and you are essentially set for life...
They will never forget the Kick
“Pathetic hahahahahahahahaha” Boston Dynamics
Ladies and gentlemen, let's welcome terminator with both of our hands.
Boston dynamics has the motion and agility down, Tesla has the actual brain down. I'm not entirely convinced NASA is contributing much that boston dynamics and tesla haven't done better.
Robot got a dumpy
So awesome humanoid robot 🤖 😀
Legs are like stepping in place but not heel and toe walking, or marching
if a robot works 24/7, it can replace 4 workers, (which is excellent) but $100.000 is still steep if you add hardware & software updates, especially weekly checkups, and monthly service. But it will drop!
Well go for the Telsa's robot optimus. Expected to be around 20k
@@Hindu_Ram121 If the retail hardware of Optimus is in the +/- $20k budget (or less either with leasing) its the training and software adaptation and updates that will cost on a yearly contract. But this is speculation, lets see how it evolves over the months to come. As an artist 🎨 I would love one for the studio!
Boston dynamic did it years ago
So we could actually sent robots to interstellar planets like Alpha Centauri!!!
For some reason I always imagine these with Ak's; having that same gate strutting down the street.
LOL at NASA. Tesla already got beat 'em with their spandex robot, and that thing can dance.
I've seen the ARTEMIS robots in person down at NASA's Houston center. That thing is way more versatile than this.
But is it "Three Laws Safe?"
I would PPV to see a unrestricted Atlas bot in a cage fight with a (unrestricted) Teslabot
I heard tesla's robot would be around 20, 000 dollars so that will be a huge difference and will probably make the Apollo robot obsolete as far as selling is concerned anyway.
I predict Apple Siri will be a hot humanoid seggs robot that can help you with almost anything by the year 2040.
Can anyone say "Skynet"? I knew you could.
What is LB?????
Well guys , with all this AI and Robot tech around it seems like we aren't far from seeing Skynet
Sounds a lot similar to what Tesla recently presented. Even the "General purpose" use case the musk spoke about! 👀
Forget about Tesla Optimus. It can barely walk. Agility Robotics can run and grab boxes. It is less bulky than Boston Dynamic humanoid robots. It is a winner.
Seriously! Boston Dynamics shud get an AGI out soooon!
Maybe this robot will visit Europa and Titan instead of humans.
That's not walking. That's marching. And not a good use of energy.
2:50 they used a valve index to control the robot lol. Now the only people that can use it are gamers with taste.
I think a few extra arms and hands would be useful, and would still be suitable for the human environment. Similarly for eyes on the ends of stalks, and some built-in tools.
0:40 why does he look computer generated?
Can that Robot 🤖 fix a flat tire
It can call AAA.
Astrobot - a general purpose robot Astronaut.
them robo hams got me actin unwise
Great, they invented a drunk robot. Stu. Pid.
It sounds like they want it to be as flexible and diverse as Spot the robot dog
A decade, and we will see this in the market, another decade and it will be everywhere
We've heard that for the last three decades.
Speaking optimistically
@@synchro505the difference is there is enough progress now for the actual functioning of the robot and the jobs it will do
A micro atmosphere & toxic realm places, is mostly where a robot will be needed to task. From building infastructer to sustain bio lifeforms in other worlds, to assembling super megalithic structure and security.
why is the robot using vans?
why give a big robot a small foot? maybe if you give him an adult foot size it will stop marching
The thing is Atlas can dance better than most summer salts better than most humans
And yet this company's former robot with just the hands being controlled by a human have more practical uses then the youtube video making atlas. Atlas looks cool. Thats it.
Happy birthday holy spirit marketing
Isn't this how we winded up getting 'The Matrix' eventually? 🤔
Amazon will be interested in ordering 18000 units
It'll need a head if it's going to copy the diverse range of specific human body balance patterns seen in the world
100.000, I'll do my own tasks around the house.
So that's where all that budget has been going, cause you know we lost the technology to go back to the moon.
This isn’t new. This style robot went viral more than five years ago
Ok, is it just me or is the CEO of that company a look alike of the drummer from Mastodon?
Why aren’t we optimizing two legs standing upright is pointless when you can just have 4 or 6. They don’t have their thinking caps on
Do you wanna develop an app?
This is what they chose to show the public. Imagine what's being kept secret.
Send it to mars and prepare the planets
A human in a blindfold would have similar difficulty keeping footing with blocks of wood all over the floor...
Give the robot some good down-angled crotch cameras and it'll be good to go! :)
Have they not see the movie Megan???!!
Waiting for fighting wars robots
Boston’s dog bot is $25,500 cheaper and looks more capable and durable than this thing. For one, it has an ACTUAL HAND.
Look At MEGAN y’all.
Even at this early stage this robot makes that POS Musk unvelied last year look like a spastic marionette.
Looks like tesla has competition.
Also, what ever happened to HRP-4C?
It still exists and some tests are still being done with it but nothing compared to their initial phase. The Humanoid Robotics Project (HRP) was sponsored by Japan's Ministry of Economy to see the viability of general domestic helper robots, they weren't really trying to sell their own design, they were just trying to convince the private sector that it was indeed a truly possible goal.
Even if they wanted to sell the HRP-4c, they likely would fail to find a market, since it costed around $2.5 million to develop and $200,000 per unit to build. It's a cool trick it's pulling off but $200,000 cool? I dunno lol
@@benj8242 but is that 200,000 when it was built? Or present day price?
I feel like 10 years of advancement could drive down the price no?
@@rowshambow That was the price when it was built. I honestly wasn't even thinking about how time would've driven down the price and this is very likely to be true with the advancements and proliferation of technology. Although, I'm unfamiliar with the specific hardware utilized by machine itself so I'm unable to truly know if the parts used were really affected by this trend.
wait... affordable and 100000 dollers in same sentence ?
Why are robots legs always bent when it walks?
God bless robotics.
Great News,go and build more humanoid robot
Unless it is much more flexible and capable such as applying forces at awkward positions. Otherwise, it will also Inherited the flaws of human form.
Human employee priced at 100k 🤔 not bad
00:29 oh oh they are bullying the robot, I have seen this movie before...
Great, they invented a drunk robot. Stu. Pid.
He sounds like a robot 🤣
For moon and mars.
Even though the end goal is noble, it doesn’t yet make any sense to try to create a general purpose humanoid robot : the technological pieces to achieve that are not there yet.
However, remotely controlled humanoid robots makes much more sense : they could be somewhat autonomous for some tasks, and would benefit from the help of human conciousness when needed.
That the way Waymo is doing their autonomous robotaxi : time to time, some remote human intervention to take decisions when the robotaxi doesn’t know what to do
🤯One hundred thousand Dollars!!? And Do you call that affordable???🤣 Man that cost more than a Tesla, CNC or an industrial robot it almost cost like an American house, 😵wtf men that is just not affordable in any planet you visit