Nest x Yale vs. August (Yale Assure & 4th Gen): Finding the Best Smart Lock After Testing Ten Models
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2024
- There are more than five August locks, but the Yale Assure (w/ August) is by far the best.
Yale Assure: amzn.to/3fazaSr
Yale Assure SL: amzn.to/2Z3ViHm
August 4th Gen: amzn.to/2D9kinV
Nest x Yale: amzn.to/2ZOQzZ6
Blog Post: powermoves.blog/comparisons/a...
Summary:
August is still the best smart lock platform because it’s compatible with all smart home platforms and has an amazing Auto Unlock feature that can’t be matched.
The August locks made by August don’t have a keypad, but the Yale Assure has a keypad and works with the August app, which makes it the most well-rounded lock on the market.
Nest x Yale does everything that it promises, but it’s locked into Google’s ecosystem and is missing a couple of key software features (Auto Unlock and DoorSense).
Yale Assure (w/ August)
There are ten different ways to lock and unlock it. It works with three different smart assistants, the August phone app, and the August Apple Watch app. A traditional key and keypad are options too.
Auto-Unlock puts your home in Away Mode once you leave your home’s perimeter. Then, when you arrive back home and come within Bluetooth range, the lock automatically unlocks itself. It works 19 times out of every 20, and it’s pure magic when it works correctly. Once you come home, with your hands full of groceries, and the door unlocks itself, you won’t be able to go back to a normal lock.
With most smart locks, the app thinks your home is secure as long as the lock is locked. But what if someone didn't shut the door fully? August’s DoorSense alerts you when your door isn’t fully shut.
Nest x Yale
Nest works well and does everything that it claims to do, but the lack of Auto-Unlock is disappointing.
Nest x Yale provides four ways to lock and unlock the door.
Nest doesn't play nice with smart home platforms because it only works with Google Assistant.
It doesn't have a keyhole, which makes the lock look sleek and minimalistic, but if you only have one entry door, it may be risky.
August 4th Gen
It’s shaped like a hockey puck and replaces your current deadbolt lever. You keep all the other components from your current lock system and your original key will still work too.
It’s a great option for renters because some landlords won’t allow you to replace your entire deadbolt. But if you’re not a renter, there’s no reason to buy the August 4th Gen because the Yale Assure models do everything that the August 4th Gen does, plus has a keypad.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
1:11 Features: August
2:25 Features: Nest
3:05 Smart Home: August
3:22 Smart Home: Nest
3:58 Installation:
4:38 Unlocking: August
5:44 Unlocking: Nest
6:40 Locking: August
7:13 Locking: Nest
7:40 Design: Nest x Yale
7:56 Design: Yale Assure
8:11 Design: Yale Assure SL
8:23 Design: August 4th Gen
10:05 Which is best for you?
Disclosure: I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. If you purchase something via my links, it helps out my channel and lets me continue to make videos for you. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
In my neighborhood having ANY KEY HOLE anyone can unlock your door. I’ve literally been at the laundromat drying my clothes, while a neighbor used my washing machine, overflowing the water, then apparently turned on the furnace to attempt to dry up the water in mid summer.
Move out of the ghetto
This is the ONLY video you need to watch before you buy a smart lock. Thank you so much!
You make a VERY good point in saying that a lock devoid of key bypass 'may be risky' if it's the only entrance to the dwelling.
Best video I’ve seen on smart locks. Can’t believe I haven’t see this video before. Keep up the great work man!
Thank you so much. I just bought the August w/the key. It was so clear I followed your recommendation. Kudos, you are clear and well organized in your review.
By far the best video on smart locks. I was so confused after watching dozens of videos. Thank you!
Really appreciate all the info. Nice and clear with pros and cons
I love your videos man!!!! You put a lot of thought into them. I didn't know you had this more recent video. Most people don't go into as much detail as you. I do think the words/the distinctions can get confusing sometimes. Part of that is because we don't know them. :D Here is my question and I know this may change. I contacted Yale about MATTER. They said all their wireless locks will be compatible with MATTER. Since I don't know enough about the differences between Nest x Yale and Yale August locks, I don't know what questions to ask. But it would appear that with MATTER, the distinctions should disappear. It is also hard to believe that Yale will move forward with both flavors. So... I assume one of these will be sunset if not both at some future point. This scares me a little because I'm not buying just 1 lock. I'm buying 10. But I know based on your video to go with August for the most flexibility. I don't know if you can ask a few questions and give me some thoughts. I'm sure more will be forthcoming in a few months. I'm hoping these locks go on sale for prime day.
You finally smiled- thanks for your informative videos
So i’m interested in the Yale Assure but it’s Outside Temp Range only goes down to -30c and it can hit -40c where I live. Would this be too much of a problem? How good is the touch screen with snow/ice?
Thank you so much, you saved me from buying something that I wouldn’t liked. Good thing I decided to watch one more smart lock video lol.
I'm sold on the Yale lock. Many reviews have rated it as the best, but you really hit the features that matter. I'm currently using the budget 3rd gen August lock and the auto unlock feature is something that I just couldn't live without after having it for almost 2 years already. At the time, the lock only cost around 120 USD and it REALLY surprises me that no other lock brand implements this feature when they cost twice as much money. I would just add an August Connect bridge, but I really just want everything in one, self contained, unit with everything attached to the door. I bookmarked this video in case your links are affiliate links for when I actually purchase the lock.
Great video! Amazon is discontinuing cloud app, is there any replacement that you'd suggest that allows you to control the lock while seeing the camera/ using a two way audio feature?
Great review, Cam. Curious as to how you got the neater DoorSense sensor? The one I got with the Yale Assure SL lock needs to be installed on the door frame, which kinda looks ugly.
The link you had for Yale assure doesn't have the august module. How do you get that? I also don't stt the Door Sense included with it. Help!
Hey Cam, thanks for the vedio. Wonder if I need to buy bridge to enable remote access? I saw the official website selling as a bundle.
Does the Yale assure have wifi built in (like the hockey puck August 4th gen) or do you have to have the bridge thing you plug into the wall like the old 3rd gen August lock?
Best review I’ve ever seen!
Thanks for the video! Any thoughts on the Latch locks vs Yale/August?
Nice vid! a leap ahead from the old one :)
Great video. I'll be getting the Yale Assure lock after this.
Dont buy it. They are trash
Good video - It's worth saying that August was acquired by Yale and since then it seems that most new products are under the Yale brand with a Yale app, though it appears that it's 100% the august technology/design underneath. I couldn't find availability for the Yale Assure with August but was able to find the Yale with Home module that works with the rebranded app.
Yeah, this video is a bit old now. All the Yale products use a rebranded August app now. It’s awesome!
I'm confused by the multiple names and which one is which. Which lock(s) have the geofencing ability to autounlock, basically sense when I've returned home and unlock the door without me having to do anything?
Great stuff, Cam! I picked up an August Assure SL on your recommendation. At some point can you do a video on best outdoor cameras for homekit?, of if that’s not in the plans, which one would you recommend ?
Amazing content. Thank you!
great video! thank you for making. I don't actually find the auto unlock to be a safe/secure feature , auto lock is however. If you do a bit of tinkering with an opensource home automation solution like Home Assistant or OpenHab you can make a zwave based lock do ANYTHING you can dream up.
Great Video! How do you unlock the door if the wifi is out and you don't have the key? Thanks
Does the Yale Assure integrate into the Google Nest Hub (Google Assistant) just as well as the Next x Yale lock?
Great content
May i ask , will the yale Assure lock works with Google nest app . Like Google nest camera ? TIA
I agree, Yale/August locks are the best. I have six of them and my family members love them. To me, best feature is the door sense feature.
Does the Yale assure lock august need to be connected to the cloud? I want to use it in Florida where I will be only be there months and have internet only 6 months of the year Can the combination work when I have no internet?
Once you go proximity unlock, it's hard to get another but the voice unlock is a good bullet point.
Thanks! Can you create temporary/expiring codes?
Hey Cam, can you make a comparison between the "no installation" locks? Especifically the August lock and the Switchbot lock.
Hey Cam! That last comment… We just moved in to a new place and I am in the process of setting up a comprehensive smart home… I have a learning nest, nest protect (x8), ring pro doorbell, ASUS ET 8. Currently working on filling out the rest… How the hell did you automate a voice command that activates all of those things when going to bed?
I ve read the Yale Assure SL with HomeKit has been less reliable when showing the status away from home.. what has been your experience so far
Great video, I will go with Yale SL
Amazing review. Need to cover Wyze next.
Great video. Thanks 😊
thanks for the great review
Love the clear pros and cons what to get why
Can you go into your Google app to lock your door if you forget and are away from your home if you have the Yale assure?
Thanks for creating this video. Very useful. IIIUC, Google Home app allows non Nest product to be integrated inside Google Home app?
@@power_moves thank you!
Can you change the code using the app for the Yale assure lock?
great video, which lock would you use if you have a AIRBNB, or rent a condo? I plan to use Google Nest since e I will have a Nest Thermostat. Thanks
THAT'S how you make a review. Other "reviewers" should take notes.
For real. Really like your style. Thanks for the very helpful and concise comparison.
Thanks for the video
I have many Nest products but am intrigiued by your review of the Yale Assure and Assure SL, especially the auto-unlock. Is that feature enabled by the smart lock recognizing the phone when you come close to the door? You said the only difference in app functioning is that Assure will not work on the Nest app, so it would require downloading the Assure app, correct?
@@power_moves It appears that the lock now works with Google home app based on others input. Still don't get how the auto-unlock works? Would I have to have my phone close to have it auto-unlock?
thanks for the video,Cam! Is Yale assure a mortise lock? I am looking for a mortise product with the smart features. what will be your recommendation? thx
house who have high traffic will find themself have to keep changing the battery a lot . it might sound small but in the long run it is add up a lot .
Great job
Thanks for the video, Cam! I've narrowed down my decision to either Yale Assure or Yale Assure SL. What are your thoughts between the two (besides purely based on aesthetics)? Thanks in advance!
@@power_moves Great tip-thanks for the response!
I will be sharing your channel and videos with all my friends and family.
I bought the lock with your link via amazon, but despite the described components (Yale Assure Lock SL, Connected by August Module, August Connect Wi-Fi Bridge, August DoorSense, Deadbolt, Strike Plate, Mounting Hardware, Installation Manual), what I got has written "Yale access" in the smart component. Did the link changed or did August stopped working with Yale assure (I got the keyless), or do I need to buy the smart component separately, as well the door sense (I don´t see it in the package). If I understand correctly the auto-lock and unlock are exclusive to august, same as door sense? not sure if I should return it :(
@@power_moves I bought it new at $299. I called the yale support line and they said the smart component says "Yale access" now but works with August app, or the Yale app. Also the door sense is now different like smaller and differently shaped from what the video shows. I specifically asked if I will be benefited from the two features that your video talks about, and they said yes. I hope they are right :/, will fInd out this week when they come and install it. The model in the box says YRD256-CBA-BSP. Thank you for replying.
@@power_moves pls can we use it in Africa a country called Ghana
@@Arely2678 I'm in the same boat. Lock just arrived today cuz my new front door gets installed tomorrow. I opened the box and saw everything you said. The module doesn't say "August" so I freaked! Did your install go well? I'm somehow comforted because the module has a HomeKit code sticker, but I won't find out till tomorrow. Do you use the Wifi module at all? Is it necessary for use with Homekit? Can this lock be used simultaneously with Homekit and Alexa? I'm also curious about the apps because it says to use your same user credentials from your August app, in the Yale Access App. So I don't know if I can just exclusively use the August app.
your fail safe option is the 10s lock pick problem for me hahahah
Dork
Are all thses locks wifi, i can see and control from anywhere
can you now use the Google home to open the Yale assure lock? it works with the schlage one, with pin.
The Auto-Unlock feature, while most convenient, is not a good idea if you're from where I'm from; and definitely not if security is a priority.
I have the NestxYale and in the app it would appear that there is an auto-unlock feature, but I can't get it to work. Any new integrations that would be a solution for this?
There is not, only auto lock.
How does auto unlock work if there are more than one person living in the house?
I'm a locksmith. I've made good money taking these locks OFF doors when they have either failed or been kicked in with only one footprint on the door. In my opinion, these locks are for convenience, not security. But bear in mind that i also only see them under the above circumstances.
Great review. What are your thoughts on the level touch ? Cheers
@@power_moves thanks. Curious if you ever have the time and energy, would love to hear your thoughts - level touch vs Yale assure). Cheers
Thanks Cam, Does the Yale Assure SL come without August?
@@power_moves which one do you recommend?
Can you use the keypad with gloves on?
Does the Yale Assure unlock with Google Assistant via voice? It does not with Nest Yale--you can LOCK with your voice, but unlock requires the app.
@@power_moves cool. Ended up grabbing August WiFi smart lock (because I wasn't sure), and my Nest x Yale died after just 4 years! For the trouble, Yale sent me a 20% off coupon to their website, but all of their products are on backorder with no estimated date. Oof.
Hiiii… i have a lift Master garage door and am getting a pedestrian gate and a driveway gate. I want a smart lock for the ped gate that is compatible with ‘lift M’. I also was the key pad and key hole. Which product do u auggest for my ped Gate? I will alao be using the ‘lift master to open the driveway gate….
Woo!
🥴
Sent back the August puck, last gen. Worked great with pixel 4, but would not work with LG
is the August great for kids ?
Hi Cam, great video and those medusa blue eyes are distracting.. August battery life is up to 6 months but heard it is way less. there a way to increase the batt life? can a wifi bridge be used so the lock is not using its inbuilt wifi to reduce the batt..? is it my assumption that the keypad uses bluetooth so even is the wifi is down the lock will work with the keypad? finally, i heard the software app gives a false reading that he batt is low at 20% when it is not, is that fixed now or do we just ignore the notification??
Cheers Cam. So is it my understanding that even at low battery the lock will work with the keypad (assuming because of the Bluetooth connectivity)? I just bought a set today so thanks .. looking forward to trying it out. Hopefully it be a good experience.. cheers from Sydney
Amazing review 👌 Is the Yale Assure SL lock Bluetooth or Wifi? How about battery life? Thanks
@@power_moves does the August smart lock need some kind of bridge for the wifi? If so, does it come with the product?
@@power_moves Does the Assure w/ August Module report battery life in the mobile app? At least enough info to know it is running low? Wondering about a remotely managed AirBNB situation where I'd like some warning the battery was getting low before it failed for a renter.
My issues with Yale are that it doesn't have a variety of color-matched lower pull-type handsets for a front doors. Schlage comes in full front-door sets. Yales August module also requires a separate Wifi module. Yuck! And if you have two deadbolts (front door and garage), you'll have to use two of these pucks. I'm only still considering this option because I'm trying to move everything to Homekit. Now iOS 15 beta shows support for something they are calling "HomeKey", but no one is talking about existing hardware compatibility yet. I'm still very confused, but great video nonetheless.
Hey Cam.. I'm looking for a Smart Lock that I can open from my cellphone from far away. This is what I mean.... if someone needs to enter my office and I am not around, I'd like to be able to open the lock from my phone from far away. Is there a lock that exists like that?
@@power_moves really?? I can be 5 miles away and then press a button on my phone to open the lock?
Estás cerraduras se le puede hacer una llave en formato tarjeta y en los relojes como los de appel
We ended up exchanging this model for the slimmer version th-cam.com/users/postUgkx0jZ_lGlDVJhDnmagEU8gn47cmfPNlLQU because it was too wide for the only door trim area that made sense to mount it on. However, we should have just noted the dimensions prior to purchasing. Otherwise, we love the doorbell. It works perfectly, and the video is very clear, even at night.
Good video 💜💜💜💜💜
Thank you for making this wonderful review. I will soon move in a new flat installed with a smart lock. The landlord said I can change the code and use the key to open the door in case I have forgotten the new code. I was wondering if the former tenant or anyone has a copy of the key, they can get into my flat easily even if I have set a new security code. Am I right? Similarly, can the former tenant use his phone to unlock my door? Please kindly advise. Thank you.
What do you think of the Eufy Smart Lock Touch & Wi-Fi ?
@@power_moves Thank you for your answer, I'm going to check your video on it for sure !
One crucial thing you didn't mention is, among all of those options, august 4th gen allows you to use more secure dead bolts, all the other options with keys are pieces of jokes and can be opened within seconds.
If using a key for the Yale lock do automations get triggered?
Is there an option where automations occur while using the pin and nothing when using the key?
(in the August app are you notified when the key is used?)
Level lock has auto-unlock also.
Great vid. Are there any locks that would open without wifi that you would recommend (if the power or the wifi is down)?
@@power_moves Thank you. What is the advantage of the electronic keypad vs traditional push lock? My concern is if the internet goes out, people will not be able to get in inside. I'm thinking about August lock that has a key option and a combo push lock installed near by with the key for August inside
how about wyze lock?
Does the Yale Assure work with Google Home?
@@power_moves thank you for the reply!
Does it work with android?
Does auto unlock works with more than one person?
@@power_moves Thank you for reply! I wonders does it also work while there is people inside and someone is coming to door?
@@power_moves that's awesome. Thank you so much! It's now in my blackfriday list :D
do you know of any dead bolt lock with keypad, WIFI & key function outside but ONLY key inside?? It's for a steel door made of 1x1 tubes for Central America. The inside part, anyone can reach in and unlock so that's why I need ONLY KEY INSIDE. PS, would love it here in the US also because I have 2 french doors with glass in them and if someone breaks the glass and reaches in, they unlock the door. NEED KEY ONLY INSIDE.
For me, it's Eufy, all the way.
But one cannot "lock pick" the nest-yale lock and one doesn't have to care about keys also right
Really appreciate your insights but there is more to consider that is a bit beyond your scope. Consumer reports covers a couple of security features that will help separate the locks regardless of "smart" features. Lets not forget the basics of any quality lock. Do your homework on the "Dumb" features and you might not be pleasantly surprised that your favorite smart lock fails to hold up under that scrutiny..
My august doesn't work with mesh wifi
August gen 4 is junk, had two, first one i had a super hard time to set up, finally it worked few months until my internet was down and after that i could not connect the lock, i purchased new one and the app couldn't find it , tried everything i could. The august support is worthless, 40 minutes on the phone, no luck.
What if you lost your phone or the phone is stolen? Someone can access your home without being detected as a break in.......
What if your key is lost or stolen?
@@power_moves Your phone has a lot of info on it. A key is just a key 🔑 without a 🔒 if found. 🤦🏽♂️
@@cdawgg21 How is someone getting into your phone? Shouldn't you have a fingerprint or face authentication.
@@power_moves, Dude I Have A Nest X Yale Lock. I am not trying to debate you on the product. You're talking like you invented the lock and have an investment in it. i was just saying that if you lost or had your phone stolen, that it has a lot of info like addresses, owner info, etc...., which makes it more likely to be used to gain entry. Not saying that someone would even know to use it that way. If you lose a key, it's just a piece of metal with no lock to be used on. I would not use that feature that's all. I guess with me being Retired Military and working in A Security Field After My retirement. It just enhances my awareness when it concerns security issues. Thanks For Your Input and I did Enjoy You Video. Great Job.....
@@cdawgg21 I was just trying to understand your perspective because I didn't understand the difference.
What if someone steals your phone
in China, locks have cameras, two batteries (one for backup), type-c charging, human detection, conversation mode, unclosed door detection, fingerprint identification, facial recognition and more. I am quite disappointed in the choices we have here in North America
China???😅😅
You forgot communist party access.
@@hellasboy8243 cool. Cameras make me feel safer. Do you think NSA is not listening in your calls? Lol
why so gwapo uy
August app works better than the Yale assure app
@@power_moves Wow, I got a reply from the man himself. To tell you the absolute truth, you are the reason I got the lock. You are 100% on your game.
discount Bradley Cooper weighs in....
Any lock with keyhole is unsafe. Even a kid with no experience at all in using a bump key can break in to a house.
sucks that its ugly as shit
There’s another one you missed it’s still under august platform it’s ((((Emtek assa abloy smart lock )))) and I’m pretty confused why it’s sponsored to be a high end of august platform or their them self as a brand wise ,but pretty confused youtube there only one or two video b it … and one is even from their own official channel 😂😂😂😂 plz go checking it out it’s pricey then all those u talked with in this video actually , but wired not much people knowing 😅😅😅😅😅