Only JB could overcome gravity...this guy gets close to a deep understanding what music can be......brilliant performance, reminds me on young John Williams.......playing Bach is like a KATA PERFORMANCE in Shotokan Karate......open hands.......there was some early Jazz in it and even gypsy influence.......thank you for this outstanding performance.
Everything you did here was absolutely incredible. Every single note. But - that Sarabanda - something very special about the way you played that. And then... the Giga - wow! Impressive! Bravo!
All my appreciation for this incredible performance and musical achievement. You need a very special state of mind to play and fell Bach like that, that goes beyond the technique and it puts you in front of yourself and the life's challenges.
It never ceases to amaze me how You Tube takes every opportunity to destroy the continuity of performances by inserting inane, moronic commercials which no one wishes to see, Must we all be sold something to experience art ? if the answer is yes, than so be it. I would have almost zero possibility of experiencing this guitarists artistry otherwise.
Here are the five movements : 0:54 : Allemande 6:18 : Courante 8:45 : Sarabande 13:04 : Gigue 17:50 : Chaconne Amazing work Sanel, I hope hear more from you.
Congratulations to Mr. Redzic, and the director and producer of this wonderful recording. Bravo is all I can say. I won't even be curious about the 16 thumbs pointing down - even when Bach was around his music was thumbed down by his employer at the church for being inharmonious or strange sounding. A polished performance beautifully captured. How can one not be moved by this composition , the depth of the human mind which created it? Makes me wish for the umpteen million times that this kind of technology and recording technique had existed before the old master left this world. Just one Sunday recording at the old Thomaskirche in Leipzig is enough, just one. Video would be nice too, but I'll settle for audio alone :). Toccata & Fugue by....well, Bach. It might interest the audience that the 14-minute Chaconne was written in memory of Bach's first wife who passed away while Bach was travelling on foot to pay tribute to another composer. We should be thankful that he actually outlived half of his own children. Perhaps music has something to do with the auto-immune system? Sorry I digressed.
@愛 What a harsh comment! Mr. Khor didn't say anything about his sons but about his children. I think what he meant is that we should be thankfull for the longlivity of JS Bach. To understand what a persons intentions are is also an art :-).
@愛 it baffled my mind how you actually thought I was cheering the untimely deaths of his children. It is obvious that I was thankful of Bach's longevity. Please be respectful. It baffled my mind because if you were a fan of Bach like I am, there is no way your heart could allow such negative criticism. As for the other 2 points, I have no clue how I could have offended you, or the points you were trying to make. I don't apologize for my love of Bach and my love for Bach.
Very very good! He plays even fast parts meaningfully, expressing fine details and emotions. He plays both strongly and sensitively. Sound quality is excellent. He understands counterpoint, he doesn't rush, his articulation is clear, he has much more dynamics in his play than most... One of the best for sure!
You make everybody to think it is easy, but believe me it is so hard to play this well! Only a very few can do it as good as this. I assume many,many hours study and practice is needed to reach this level of excellence. Many thanks for this wonderful music !!
I have heard all the modern guitar interpretations of this piece under the Sun (TH-cam). This one is absolutely unbeatable. The only one who may be able to improve on this may be Sanel himself! Bravo!
I thought Sanel Redzic had made the ultimate guitar recording of the Chaconne in 2007... until I listened to this one! At par with Itzhak Perlman's violin version! Thank you for sharing your talent with us.
193 people disliked this performance?!? Who? Why? Clean exacting playing. Impeccable sound. Bach played with all the emotion, bravado and sensitivity that Bach deserves. Thank you young man.
Only an amateur who has struggled with his guitar for 55 years knows the effort need to reach this level. Rich sound from the instrument..and don't forget Bach who was the voice of god....
One of the outstanding features of Mr. Redzic's artistry is his shaping of every note into an equally shaped phrase - dynamically and colorwise - in a kind of "narrative" which is the wonderful music we experience. His right hand produces different colors and dynamics effortlessly and without any radical shifts. Like a writer who starts with the meaningful sentence, and then creates a meaningful paragraph and then another, and another and says something meaningful in a superbly well-crafted text that represents language at its most concentrated. Mr. Radzic is the instrument who seemingly dissappears so that we only experience the musical statement. This is another level of guitar playing that transcends the mere digital facility or technique of just very talented players. This is the kind of musicianship one experiences among the world class performers of other instruments. The guitar is indeed doing well with musicians (not just mere players or guitarrists) like Mr. Redzic who I would number among the top 10, 5 or 3 currently active such as Paul Galbraight, Marcyn Dilla et al. Even among the créme de la créme, Mr. Redzic is in a class of his own. This whole Bach Suite congels into a single organically-structured musical narrative from the Allemand to the Chaconne. And it is thus that his first-rate musical mind conveys the beauty, essence and profound transcendental feelings and emotions. What a rare moving experience! With deep appreciation for your artistry, intelligence and musical soul which bring much joy and pathos.
I just can’t even. I can’t even put it into words. Especially the chaconne. You’ve ruined it for me - I can’t listen to anyone else perform this piece anymore. Well, I can, but it seems like I’m viewing an adolescent child’s reproduction of the Mona Lisa vs viewing the real thing. You truly take the listener on a journey.
I’m so glad that there are people with skill and dedication who share them through such wonderful playing as this. It takes any aspiration of playing so well completely out of my reach that I don’t need to practice so much but can just smile and enjoy your playing. Thank you.
Esta música calma mi alma que tengo muy dañada por la vida. Me ha ido costando disfrutar de la música de J. B Bach a la que he considerado muy complicada, en algunos casos, hasta, demasiado mental. Hoy, como digo, me calma el alma y me reconcilia con la mente. Gracias por una interpretación tan limpia y desde el alma
One of the "traps" of listening to classical guitar is the focus on a player's digital facility with scales and arpeggios (believe me, pianists and violonists take all that for granted). And also with "clean" playing and gorgeous tone (this latter is the basis for the even greater musical expression since music is organized sound that conveys something...just what...who knows or cares...the experience is esthetic...and spiritual...without necessarily implying any religious doctrine....it is a feeling.) This Bach suite has many performances, but is rarely heard at the level here. Bach is often lost in transcription, but here the music unfolds in its original grandeur (which surely Bach had in mind and heart when he wrote it...and that Bach was a devout Christian does not circumscribe his music or limit it within only the Christian sensibility). This is the really difference between a great musician like Mr. Redzic and just great guitarrists. It seems as if Bach wrote this with Mr. Redzic in mind and dedicated it to him as the perfect candidate to interpret his (Bach's) intentions and sense of arquitecture. Yes, the magnificent chords, the cascading scales and arpeggios...the gorgeous full-bodied tone that guitarrists contemplate in awe. But the music here goes beyond all those provincial concerns: you want fast scales, listen to Angel or Pepe Romero...they'll blow you away. But you want music: listen to Mr. Redzic...you'll feel the transcendence...that certain, undefinable or spiritual quality of music. Like a religious feeling...without any religion. Great visual production as well. The tilted camera angle as if the music were soaring upwards. But this music is so much more than the beliefs or credo of its composer.
Bravo, maestro! The chaconne from this partita is a favorite piece for many players (including myself), but this is one of the top renditions I ever heard. And of course, the other parts are superb too. Such a beautiful musically advanced performance!
Koliko je samo dubine utkano u svaki ton, u svaki pokret leve, a posebno desne ruke. Gospodine Redžić, Vi sa godinama dobijate sve ono što Bahove note traže. I duh, i intelekt, i srce. Slušajuci Vaše sviranje već nekoliko godina unazad i prateći sve ono što snimite, sa zadovoljstvom primećujem kako svaki novi snimak odaje za nijansu dublji duhovni zanos i Vaše promišljanje Bahove muzike. Ne mogu ni da zamislim kako će Bahove note, koje budete svirali za nekoliko godina, zvučati. Ako se iko uspeo približiti gotovo savršenom sviranju klasične gitare, to ste, u ovom momentu, svakako Vi. Samo, molim Vas, budite i dalje toliko temeljni i uporni u traženju značenja Bahove muzike.Ta dubina prosto nema kraj...
There is a video on youtube where Mr. Redzic shares a little bit on how he went to pursue further education. Not only is he an accomplished musician he works very hard for this result. I am happy I came to hear this version, it is fantastic!
May the golden era of the guitar last forever, may virtuosos and masters like this gentleman live long for our enjoyment, and may the grandiosity of Bach, the immortal, continue to be the musical highway to heaven, not there somewhere, but here in our intimacy.🙏👍🙏
I do not play an instrument of any kind, I do not have a trained ear to judge any performance, and I have not studied musical theory, so any comment I make is purely as a listener who knows what he likes when he hears it. I found this to be flawless in execution and the video production to be first rate. Again, no education or qualifications to make such statements. But as one that enjoys classical music I found this a wonderful performance and like some have mentioned, who in the world gives this a thumbs down? What were they expecting to see or hear that wasn't there? Great video and performance.
This has left our world a better place, bringing truth,beauty and meaning, to make existence worthwhile. What the heck is wrong with that. Absolutely nuttin. R
Absolutely astonishing. Only a few guitarist can interpret the vibe of Bach. Playing Bach does not soley really on a musicians skill. Instead, music intuned with the spirit is a abstract essence of connection between man and musical tranquility. TIMELESS performance. Thank you
Words can simply not express how much I love this performance, or how many times I have watched it over the last few days. It is truly Bach as worship.
I understand the sentiment, this is a breath taking performance but respectfully I think you are wrong, Bach would probably have preferred to hear Raphaella Schmidts performance which is the most emotionally expressive and most unique interpretation.
@@soundknight agree! guitarists always do whatever they want and call it "music". how ridiculous! all should listen to other instrument master to learn how to "taste" the beauty of music
This is a pure guitar touch. No matter what Mr. Redzic is playing at all, it means just music to the full and proper form. It doesn't need to be composed by any high name, as such, it puts the musical form to the secondary stage. Mr. Redzic aims it definitely to be that quality. It's not just talent, it's the idea in mind and 'Maestro' perfectly accomplishes it through an absolute dedication. Bravo many times...
J.S. Bach was to music what the Apostles were to the New Testament and Sanel Redzic is a commissioned angel like but one, who don’t talk and just do their job. The kind of flaw you might hear in his performances might only be picked up by another angel who has the same job. These pieces are played with sustained perfection where playing over a hard part is practiced most then begun by holding your breath so to speak, and hope for a smooth transition into what’s next. If it’s not just a matter of practicing a piece then what is it. An audio only reproduction can be “photoshopped” but a video not so much. Such playing is usually heard only after 200 years of 6 hours a day practice unless there has been a supernatural anointing.
So, I really like all the things that are necessary, to make music out of a pre- defined note text: Your dynamics are sensitive - your agogic way to choose the tempi is simply beautiful (although some people might say that the tempi are too romantic, but that's after all these years no more important for me!) - your phrasing is precise and aesthetic - your articulation is colourful and quite a bit versatile. The only thing that is not really my personal cup of tea is your way of producing the vibratos - in my mind they are far out too quick and dramatic, but in spite of the fact that everything else is exactly according to my personal taste and my aesthetic conception, the vibrato is indeed not that important. You use quite seldom anyway. So in the end it remains only to say: Thank you very much for the extremely good work and that you let us (or better here especially me) enjoy this wonderful historical timeless milestone of music of J. S. Bach!
In my semi-retirement I have a chance to visit You Tube and see all the fine guitarists play beautiful music. The player is educated and does well. The guitar has a certain edge that is quite resonant, which to me, washes out the real voice... but what I hear underneath is the voice that is quite appealing, trying to get out and express its beauty. So I think that time played will help the voice to come to be dominate and the guitar will be great. Congratulations.
Thank you, Mr. Redzic, for making me hear J.S. Bach, as if for the first time. You made clear that he was the first and still among the best jazz musicians of all time. . . . a spiritual experience I take with me. Thank you. Your Chaconne is a prayer ... answered.
Of course I used to know the Ciaconna. But not the whole suite and I fell in love with the giga. Although I’m not good enough for the ciacona I think I m gonna put the giga in my todo-list before I die.... And after my death I will see Bach and apologize 😁 Your extraordinary musicality inspires me and makes the best of my humanity comes from the depth to my mind... thank you for sharing this wonderful gift and huge amount ok work upon it.
Jeu sensible et précis, beau timbre, tempo juste, bravo ! Merci pour le partage. Bach nous permet de savoir ce que nous sommes au meilleur de nous-même.
Only JB could overcome gravity...this guy gets close to a deep understanding what music can be......brilliant performance, reminds me on young John Williams.......playing Bach is like a KATA PERFORMANCE in Shotokan Karate......open hands.......there was some early Jazz in it and even gypsy influence.......thank you for this outstanding performance.
Everything you did here was absolutely incredible. Every single note. But - that Sarabanda - something very special about the way you played that. And then... the Giga - wow! Impressive! Bravo!
I listen to his music every morning. He makes me calm and helps me start my day good. 멋진 연주 감사합니다.
gracias maestro Sanel ...por esta interpretación, tan elevada en todos los sentidos
I've watched this video dozens of times. I'm blown away every time. Thank you!
Great Artist, Amazing Performance!
superb recording.
All my appreciation for this incredible performance and musical achievement. You need a very special state of mind to play and fell Bach like that, that goes beyond the technique and it puts you in front of yourself and the life's challenges.
excelente. saludos de Mexico
Sonido y reproducción excelentes. El instrumento es demasiado bueno. Las interpretaciones son bravas, magníficas y fluidas. Muchas gracias.
oh maan.. tks😊
so beautiful!!!
Timbre especial, sonoridade, acústica ótimas. Primas as figurações e dinâmica.
fantástico....
Hoy por hoy y para mi gusto pienso que esta obra no se pude tocar mejor en guitarra.
Simply -Wow! =D
Who is the builder of this guitar? What materials went into it?
It never ceases to amaze me how You Tube takes every opportunity to destroy the continuity of performances by inserting inane, moronic commercials which no one wishes to see, Must we all be sold something to experience art ? if the answer is yes, than so be it. I would have almost zero possibility of experiencing this guitarists artistry otherwise.
Here are the five movements :
0:54 : Allemande
6:18 : Courante
8:45 : Sarabande
13:04 : Gigue
17:50 : Chaconne
Amazing work Sanel, I hope hear more from you.
I should've bought bach's 6 violin partitas and sonatas for violin, so I could've played it on guitar.
@@brandonwoodson9348 No need to buy it, my friend! It's in the public domain for a long time now ;-)
Beautifying music, however you failed to mention the 0:56min brickSky fingerprint intro.
Galou le Bougalou thank for marking the movements (sections)🙏
@Konstantin Ridaya In fact, most of Bach’s harpsichord concertos are transcriptions of his own earlier works.
Congratulations to Mr. Redzic, and the director and producer of this wonderful recording. Bravo is all I can say. I won't even be curious about the 16 thumbs pointing down - even when Bach was around his music was thumbed down by his employer at the church for being inharmonious or strange sounding. A polished performance beautifully captured. How can one not be moved by this composition , the depth of the human mind which created it?
Makes me wish for the umpteen million times that this kind of technology and recording technique had existed before the old master left this world. Just one Sunday recording at the old Thomaskirche in Leipzig is enough, just one. Video would be nice too, but I'll settle for audio alone :). Toccata & Fugue by....well, Bach.
It might interest the audience that the 14-minute Chaconne was written in memory of Bach's first wife who passed away while Bach was travelling on foot to pay tribute to another composer. We should be thankful that he actually outlived half of his own children. Perhaps music has something to do with the auto-immune system? Sorry I digressed.
How could anyone give a thumbs down? The performance was perfect! Proof positive that the world is full of idiots.
@愛 What a harsh comment! Mr. Khor didn't say anything about his sons but about his children. I think what he meant is that we should be thankfull for the longlivity of JS Bach. To understand what a persons intentions are is also an art :-).
Barry Khor It is said that the Chaconne embodies the very pinnacle of Bachs’ work.
Barry Khor thumbs down means only jealousy.
@愛 it baffled my mind how you actually thought I was cheering the untimely deaths of his children. It is obvious that I was thankful of Bach's longevity. Please be respectful. It baffled my mind because if you were a fan of Bach like I am, there is no way your heart could allow such negative criticism. As for the other 2 points, I have no clue how I could have offended you, or the points you were trying to make. I don't apologize for my love of Bach and my love for Bach.
What an achievement - gorgeous playing and video production.
Very very good! He plays even fast parts meaningfully, expressing fine details and emotions. He plays both strongly and sensitively. Sound quality is excellent. He understands counterpoint, he doesn't rush, his articulation is clear, he has much more dynamics in his play than most... One of the best for sure!
Let us be deeply thankful that Bach wrote such beautiful music and that there are wonderful musicians like Sandel Redzic to play for us.
You make everybody to think it is easy, but believe me it is so hard to play this well! Only a very few can do it as good as this.
I assume many,many hours study and practice is needed to reach this level of excellence. Many thanks for this wonderful music !!
I have heard all the modern guitar interpretations of this piece under the Sun (TH-cam). This one is absolutely unbeatable. The only one who may be able to improve on this may be Sanel himself!
Bravo!
JA S :)
It never cease to amaze me the capability of humans to possess extreme talent like yours. Thank you so much for sharing.
I thought Sanel Redzic had made the ultimate guitar recording of the Chaconne in 2007... until I listened to this one! At par with Itzhak Perlman's violin version! Thank you for sharing your talent with us.
Ich bade in Tränen vor Freude, wenn die Chaconne erklingt - Spitzenperformance, die mir aus dem Herzen spricht
Ja, geht mir auch so!
What an outstanding transcription and performance.....I listened to it every day!
Aida Markiw :)
193 people disliked this performance?!? Who? Why?
Clean exacting playing. Impeccable sound. Bach played with all the emotion, bravado and sensitivity that Bach deserves. Thank you young man.
No excuses. Sorry to say those 193 individuals might have a limited soul and sensitivity
@@GataIsabel I completely agree.
193 individuals who are quite preoccupied playing Smoke on The Water out-of-tune on floor Schecter models in guitar centers around the country.
@Petercross Agreed.
Those 193 are deaf.. and they are frustrated of not being able to listen to that wonder... only possible explanation !
Perfect performance!! Amazing place 😉
What he said.
This stuff can save the internet from itself. That right there.
@@johanmatzen9940 urfiieuriduwi
_Did someone say, "He knocked it out of the park?_
_The Chaconne was simply AMAZING!__GOD bless you Sanel!_
Wonderful playing and wonderful interpretation. I really like the harmonic additions that he made to the score, very tasteful.
Only an amateur who has struggled with his guitar for 55 years knows the effort need to reach this level. Rich sound from the instrument..and don't forget Bach who was the voice of god....
Poignant line and apt comment... thank you, dear Meister Redzic, for this profound performance. Compliments from Germany :)
Figgy 4 hahaha what an idiot comment.
@Figgy 4 epic comment
@Figgy 4 What does that even mean?
OK, I AGREE.
One of the outstanding features of Mr. Redzic's artistry is his shaping of every note into an equally shaped phrase - dynamically and colorwise - in a kind of "narrative" which is the wonderful music we experience. His right hand produces different colors and dynamics effortlessly and without any radical shifts. Like a writer who starts with the meaningful sentence, and then creates a meaningful paragraph and then another, and another and says something meaningful in a superbly well-crafted text that represents language at its most concentrated. Mr. Radzic is the instrument who seemingly dissappears so that we only experience the musical statement. This is another level of guitar playing that transcends the mere digital facility or technique of just very talented players. This is the kind of musicianship one experiences among the world class performers of other instruments. The guitar is indeed doing well with musicians (not just mere players or guitarrists) like Mr. Redzic who I would number among the top 10, 5 or 3 currently active such as Paul Galbraight, Marcyn Dilla et al. Even among the créme de la créme, Mr. Redzic is in a class of his own.
This whole Bach Suite congels into a single organically-structured musical narrative from the Allemand to the Chaconne. And it is thus that his first-rate musical mind conveys the beauty, essence and profound transcendental feelings and emotions. What a rare moving experience!
With deep appreciation for your artistry, intelligence and musical soul which bring much joy and pathos.
Such passion, you have brought a reason to my life to carry on. Thank you for you absolute lovely playing 😊
One of the best most appropriately sounding Partita 2 renditions, possible!👌👏👏👏
I just can’t even. I can’t even put it into words. Especially the chaconne. You’ve ruined it for me - I can’t listen to anyone else perform this piece anymore. Well, I can, but it seems like I’m viewing an adolescent child’s reproduction of the Mona Lisa vs viewing the real thing. You truly take the listener on a journey.
I’m so glad that there are people with skill and dedication who share them through such wonderful playing as this. It takes any aspiration of playing so well completely out of my reach that I don’t need to practice so much but can just smile and enjoy your playing. Thank you.
there's always that person who looks at your playing and thinks the same
Those hand stretches in Chaconne, holy moly.
Esta música calma mi alma que tengo muy dañada por la vida.
Me ha ido costando disfrutar de la música de J. B Bach a la que he considerado muy complicada, en algunos casos, hasta, demasiado mental. Hoy, como digo, me calma el alma y me reconcilia con la mente.
Gracias por una interpretación tan limpia y desde el alma
One of the "traps" of listening to classical guitar is the focus on a player's digital facility with scales and arpeggios (believe me, pianists and violonists take all that for granted). And also with "clean" playing and gorgeous tone (this latter is the basis for the even greater musical expression since music is organized sound that conveys something...just what...who knows or cares...the experience is esthetic...and spiritual...without necessarily implying any religious doctrine....it is a feeling.) This Bach suite has many performances, but is rarely heard at the level here. Bach is often lost in transcription, but here the music unfolds in its original grandeur (which surely Bach had in mind and heart when he wrote it...and that Bach was a devout Christian does not circumscribe his music or limit it within only the Christian sensibility). This is the really difference between a great musician like Mr. Redzic and just great guitarrists. It seems as if Bach wrote this with Mr. Redzic in mind and dedicated it to him as the perfect candidate to interpret his (Bach's) intentions and sense of arquitecture. Yes, the magnificent chords, the cascading scales and arpeggios...the gorgeous full-bodied tone that guitarrists contemplate in awe. But the music here goes beyond all those provincial concerns: you want fast scales, listen to Angel or Pepe Romero...they'll blow you away. But you want music: listen to Mr. Redzic...you'll feel the transcendence...that certain, undefinable or spiritual quality of music. Like a religious feeling...without any religion.
Great visual production as well. The tilted camera angle as if the music were soaring upwards. But this music is so much more than the beliefs or credo of its composer.
Bravo, maestro! The chaconne from this partita is a favorite piece for many players (including myself), but this is one of the top renditions I ever heard. And of course, the other parts are superb too. Such a beautiful musically advanced performance!
Impeccable techniques and clarity. Thank Sanel for playing wonderful Bach.
Koliko je samo dubine utkano u svaki ton, u svaki pokret leve, a posebno desne ruke. Gospodine Redžić, Vi sa godinama dobijate sve ono što Bahove note traže. I duh, i intelekt, i srce. Slušajuci Vaše sviranje već nekoliko godina unazad i prateći sve ono što snimite, sa zadovoljstvom primećujem kako svaki novi snimak odaje za nijansu dublji duhovni zanos i Vaše promišljanje Bahove muzike. Ne mogu ni da zamislim kako će Bahove note, koje budete svirali za nekoliko godina, zvučati. Ako se iko uspeo približiti gotovo savršenom sviranju klasične gitare, to ste, u ovom momentu, svakako Vi. Samo, molim Vas, budite i dalje toliko temeljni i uporni u traženju značenja Bahove muzike.Ta dubina prosto nema kraj...
There is a video on youtube where Mr. Redzic shares a little bit on how he went to pursue further education. Not only is he an accomplished musician he works very hard for this result. I am happy I came to hear this version, it is fantastic!
i have to say this but it sounds better on the guitar than on the violin
Absolutely amazing. This is one of the performances that I keep coming back to again and again. Breathtakingly beautiful every time. Thank you!
Clearly an interpretation and performance of the highest standard. It merits greater attention.
Viva Bach!!! Thanks for such extraordinary musicality. Heaven music
Всё звучит так, словно это написано для гитары. Потрясающая работа!
Браво, Санел! Спасибо за великого Баха!
In the Chaconne, it always amazes me how Bach juxtaposes such tense and dissonant chords to form a beautiful song.
If I could only play on piece for the rest of my life that would be the chaconne
Simply amazing! I was transfixed for the whole 33 minutes. What an amazing artist!
May the golden era of the guitar last forever, may virtuosos and masters like this gentleman live long for our enjoyment, and may the grandiosity of Bach, the immortal, continue to be the musical highway to heaven, not there somewhere, but here in our intimacy.🙏👍🙏
And I can't even breathe for 33 minutes straight without messing up.
This was beyond words on so many levels. Bravo!
awesome... your Bach playing is pure poetry.
Spectacular!!! Such a great musician. Inspiring!! 😎👏
I do not play an instrument of any kind, I do not have a trained ear to judge any performance, and I have not studied musical theory, so any comment I make is purely as a listener who knows what he likes when he hears it. I found this to be flawless in execution and the video production to be first rate. Again, no education or qualifications to make such statements. But as one that enjoys classical music I found this a wonderful performance and like some have mentioned, who in the world gives this a thumbs down? What were they expecting to see or hear that wasn't there? Great video and performance.
Bravo! Your performance is outstanding.
Divno zaista! Bravo Sanele u svakom pogledu! :-)
Vojislav Ivanovic :)
This has left our world a better place, bringing truth,beauty and meaning, to make existence worthwhile.
What the heck is wrong with that.
Absolutely nuttin.
R
Hello, thanks for such wonderful interpretation, where can i buy this arrangement?
Absolutely astonishing. Only a few guitarist can interpret the vibe of Bach. Playing Bach does not soley really on a musicians skill. Instead, music intuned with the spirit is a abstract essence of connection between man and musical tranquility. TIMELESS performance. Thank you
This brought tears to my eyes, the mastery and instrument are exquisite.
I teared up as well, such clear,lucid and touching rendition...
Beautiful. Thank you for such a beautiful performance.
Blown away by this fantastic performance
Listening moved to tears.
Words can simply not express how much I love this performance, or how many times I have watched it over the last few days. It is truly Bach as worship.
A masterpiece!!!
¡¡¡Una pieza maestra!!!
A deeply engaging performance with superb control and admirable economy of effort. Thank you so much!
there is no impossibility for a guy like Sanel.... *i am still questioning how this is possible, though...*
I just enjoyed your performance... you get my deep RESPECT! Congratulation, Madame!
Wenderlin Koswara :)
The words to try to define your majestic way of play are just an intent...Wonderful and lovely, thank you!!
The guitarist that bach would have to hear
I understand the sentiment, this is a breath taking performance but respectfully I think you are wrong, Bach would probably have preferred to hear Raphaella Schmidts performance which is the most emotionally expressive and most unique interpretation.
@@soundknight agree! guitarists always do whatever they want and call it "music". how ridiculous! all should listen to other instrument master to learn how to "taste" the beauty of music
@@willc5924 what a ridiculous statement.
@@willc5924 th-cam.com/video/IloI83lOQF0/w-d-xo.html
Great performance , hope to see more of those amazing work , absolutely beautiful music , thank you
This is a very beautiful performance! Congratulation!
Unbelievable control, mastery at every level. Bravo, this is an amazing performance!
This is a pure guitar touch. No matter what Mr. Redzic is playing at all, it means just music to the full and proper form. It doesn't need to be composed by any high name, as such, it puts the musical form to the secondary stage. Mr. Redzic aims it definitely to be that quality. It's not just talent, it's the idea in mind and 'Maestro' perfectly accomplishes it through an absolute dedication. Bravo many times...
J.S. Bach was to music what the Apostles were to the New Testament and Sanel Redzic is a commissioned angel like but one, who don’t talk and just do their job. The kind of flaw you might hear in his performances might only be picked up by another angel who has the same job. These pieces are played with sustained perfection where playing over a hard part is practiced most then begun by holding your breath so to speak, and hope for a smooth transition into what’s next. If it’s not just a matter of practicing a piece then what is it. An audio only reproduction can be “photoshopped” but a video not so much. Such playing is usually heard only after 200 years of 6 hours a day practice unless there has been a supernatural anointing.
Beautiful playing and I love the arrangement. Congratulations!
Calm ,sincere, creative, distintive, manificent progressions and what else? Thank you for sharings.🤗
Bach would have been proud!
Espetacular, maravilhoso e perfeito, parabéns!
Really great work Sanel! Listened to the whole thing and it's truly wonderful! Congrats!
Bravo! Outstanding in every way.
The most flawless technique I've seen since John Williams.
Look xavier jara
So, I really like all the things that are necessary, to make music out of a pre- defined note text: Your dynamics are sensitive - your agogic way to choose the tempi is simply beautiful (although some people might say that the tempi are too romantic, but that's after all these years no more important for me!) - your phrasing is precise and aesthetic - your articulation is colourful and quite a bit versatile.
The only thing that is not really my personal cup of tea is your way of producing the vibratos - in my mind they are far out too quick and dramatic, but in spite of the fact that everything else is exactly according to my personal taste and my aesthetic conception, the vibrato is indeed not that important. You use quite seldom anyway.
So in the end it remains only to say: Thank you very much for the extremely good work and that you let us (or better here especially me) enjoy this wonderful historical timeless milestone of music of J. S. Bach!
Excellent Video an interpretation thanks From MEXICO
Antidote to chaos.
As far as I 'm concerned you really seem to understand the emotional content of Bach's notes. Superb!
In my semi-retirement I have a chance to visit You Tube and see all the fine guitarists play beautiful music. The player is educated and does well. The guitar has a certain edge that is quite resonant, which to me, washes out the real voice... but what I hear underneath is the voice that is quite appealing, trying to get out and express its beauty. So I think that time played will help the voice to come to be dominate and the guitar will be great. Congratulations.
This is really very good: Performance, recording, and presentation. Bravo!
Congratulations Maestro
Amazing performance & rendition!👍👍👍💕
Thank you, Mr. Redzic, for making me hear J.S. Bach, as if for the first time. You made clear that he was the first and still among the best jazz musicians of all time. . . . a spiritual experience I take with me. Thank you. Your Chaconne is a prayer ... answered.
Amazing. Simply a joy and privilege to listen and see this artistry. I knew not of this artist before. My ignorance has been to my detriment.
Of course I used to know the Ciaconna. But not the whole suite and I fell in love with the giga. Although I’m not good enough for the ciacona I think I m gonna put the giga in my todo-list before I die....
And after my death I will see Bach and apologize 😁
Your extraordinary musicality inspires me and makes the best of my humanity comes from the depth to my mind... thank you for sharing this wonderful gift and huge amount ok work upon it.
Jeu sensible et précis, beau timbre, tempo juste, bravo ! Merci pour le partage. Bach nous permet de savoir ce que nous sommes au meilleur de nous-même.
To Sanele, perfektno - osjećajno, Bachovski intelektualno.
Bravo! Excellent playing! Thanks for sharing such amazing rendition of Bach's work.
Magnificent wonderful and superb performance of my favourite piece. Thank you so much!.
On par with Parkening, Williams. Light years better than 99.9% of guitarists. Unbelievable musicianship.
Incredible adaptation, astounding performance. Bravo!