You can tell how much the Doctor misses Gallifrey. The eyes and the shaking of his voice. But the way he reminisces and speaks is so beautiful and sad. I miss Ten and Eleven so much. ❤️
This was my favorite thing about Martha Jones. She made the Doctor talk about things on HER time table. Made him confront the things he always tried to sweep under the rug, and it helped him.
The Doctor needed Martha, in a number of ways. It's just the fact that things ended up coming down to her falling for him, and him not being over Rose yet, meant she got fed up and left. But her attitude as a _friend_ what exactly what he needed to give him that push to talk about things, and realizing finally how she felt and why she was leaving also gave him that push to really try and move on properly and get over Rose. After Martha, Donna then filled the perfect niche. A good friend who would push him to do the right thing, but was sassy, could verbally spar with him by virtue of sheer attitude, and was not romantically interested.
@@Blazieth Donna is my favorite companion from the revival series, you're right about Martha being necessary for the Doctor because of the place he was at, but Donna/Ten were so good together they even brought them back lol
The dude was a whovian all the time before he was cast as the doctor, makes sense how he completely embodies the Doctor in his own unique way. Best doctor and my childhood doctor. Matt brought his own style and so did Peter, but this is the only doctor I’ll forever stand by. Thank you David for being my sci fi hero
yeah :( i’d say Ninth and Tenth are the most melancholic Doctors. the weight of the war on both of them is visible. and i don’t know why, but i miss this melancholy of him being the last Time Lord. it started to disappear with Eleventh and by Twelfth we got to see very little of it. and then Hell Bent came.
Oh it was honestly the biggest character development in doctor who history the weight of carrying out their legacy, no one could ever understand how it is to be so truly alone and the regret of knowing that it was by his hand. But don't worry good ol Midday comes to retcon all that who wants to be sad ever anyway right? The timeliness are back and they are good now Happy endings for everyone!
My god, people have said it before but David in this scene just radiates pure, raw emotion. You can see The Doctor is on the verge of tears remembering his home. Describing things that, when you stop and think about it, he probably took for granted. Growing up on Gallifrey, those things were just normal to him, a second sun rising over the shining mountains, the silver leaves catching the light to look like a forest on fire. As the old saying goes, "You don't know what you have until it's gone." You can see the sadness in his eyes remembering a home he can never go back to, sights that he will never see again. This is why, in my opinion, David Tennant is the best Doctor of New Who, he brought forth The Doctor's pain and anguish better than anyone else. Eccleston never really had a chance to shine, Smith played a man so stricken with grief he chose to forget his pain, Capaldi played a Doctor who refused to lose anything else, breaking his own rules in order to get what he wanted. Whittaker, despite the awful storylines, played a woman who's entire life was a lie, who didn't know who she was. But Tennant? He played a man who once had everything, and now has nothing. His past keeps coming to haunt him, and he can do nothing about it. The more he runs from it, the more it comes right back into his face. Bravo David Tennant, bravo.
When he says “there was a war…” the lyrics of the hymn say “earth’s joys grow dim, it’s glories fade away, change and decay in all around I see” Impeccable timing.
The Doctor: You should've seen that planet Martha: What about your people The Doctor: Them? They were the most evil and corrupt people you could imagine, but then again, 10 million years of absolute power will do that.
TheBrokenMadMan Now I REALLY feel sorry for the Tenth Doctor, because he misses Gallifrey and the few Time Lords who weren't at least partially corrupt so much that he's deluded himself into thinking that the Time Lords were the angels of the universe.
DalekTheSupreme I wouldn't say he deluded himself too much, remember, in "The End of Time Part 2" the minute he realized the Time Lords were returning he grabbed the nearest revolver and got ready for battle.
'You should have seen it, that old planet...!' god, his delivery of that line, the depth of the heartbreak in his face... gets me every time. What a phenomenal actor David Tennant is.
This was actually an incredibly touching moment. Amongst the backdrop of a million souls singing a song of freedom, peace and renewal, an old war veteran describes the paradise he once called home, lost to the war that claimed his family, friends and all else.
3:03 That’s why the singing towers of Dirillium was so sentimental to The Doctor beyond his last date w River as number 12. The wind blowing through the towers giving you a song when you need it the most reminded him of the breeze through the trees on Gallifrey. A piece of home right there to share with a piece of his heart.
I would've done the same thing as Martha in this scene. Pull up a chair, sit down, and stand my ground until I got a real answer. Cause honestly, I would've gotten pretty sick of the way the Doctor was acting too. "Not until you answer me properly." Respect, Martha. Respect.
Well, it was a very sensitive subject and I think this scene makes Martha seem kind of rude and insensitive. Obviously she couldn't know that his planet had been destroyed, but it was obvious at he wasn't comfortable talking about it and I at least think it was a little rude to pressure him into telling her
well she had do deal with the whole "being ignored cause he's so hung up on Rose" which I understand that the Doctor misses her, but Martha's been doing everything trying to get noticed and he's just ignoring that. She was fed up with all the times he would push away the subject or get a short answer that was a lie, and said "you know what, I think it's about time he told me the truth." but the truth just so happened to be a bit too much "Only ask him a question if you know you can stand the answer."
+Rachel -Not-Again- Armamus Agreed. This scene summarises why Martha was awesome. Still miss her. Hey, Moffat, you realise she's one of the easiest characters to bring back, yes? Her and Jack. *puppy dog eyes*
One of the best series and story arcs in Doctor Who history. The way the Doctor got restored to youth in the final episode was disappointingly corny but the buildup and in particular the 'Sound of Drums' episode were astonishing, absolutely must-see TV. Even the creepy 'Vote Saxon' trailers leading up to 'Drums' were a nice touch.
I ponder why there is so much dislike for Martha. I liked Martha and think she was a great companion. Jealous? Yes. However she was brilliant and still was very loyal to the Doctor. I liked her as a companion. Is she my favorite companion? No. That's a tie between Rose and Donna.
Alex K I don't wanna bring this up, but many have been lead to believe that she is hated because she is a women of color. I say that's not the case, but it makes sense. No one who hates her can give a well thought out reason as to why. Not even now.
nodnarb2151 if anyone hates her because of her color should be ashamed. I think she's a great companion, very loyal even if she isnt what she wanted to be to the Doctor.
Alex K Thats the thing they don't feel ashamed. They say thats not the case, they hate her because she is "stupid", "useless", and "whiney" throughout all her appearances. I don't agree for obvious reasons, but if thats their problem with her and not her being the only women of color in a major part then I just have to accept that.
Alex K I actually think Donna and Amy were the best because they were the most entertaining in general Martha was alright but I actually really dislike Rose I dont understand how people love her so much
Megan Versteeg Donna is soooo hilarious. OI!!!! My wife and I absolutely love Donna. Amy and Rory took awhile for me to warm up to. I do like them as companions.
All these years later after first watching this and it still gets me, David’s acting is superb. It might be just nostalgia but this for me was when Dr who was at its peak and I remember my family always waiting each Saturday for this. I remember eps like this was always shrugged off the week before but when they had this scene to end it nothing could be more perfect. Dr who or any tv show will ever captivate an audience in the way that this scene and season 3 ever will. David tennant was at his best this year. Anyway.....whenever I feel a bit unsure about myself I look back at this and it takes me back to a simpler time. Ah to have it all back
It's these kind of scenes that are the highlights of the show. Funny comedy and eccentricity may be great, but without an emotional anchor the seriex wouldn't work imo.
When I think of typical sadness I just think of someone crying for only a short period of time but when I think of true sadness I think of this scene with that face he makes which instantly shows the face of someone who has not just lost something small but something truly special in his/her eyes that is just too much for him to let go of or its basically depression...
Thus why they stopped saying that after the Timelords were brought back. Just because something stops being the case doesnt mean what came before stops holding weight, things don't need to stay exactly the same forever.
It doesn’t really change anything because it’s true at this point. The time lords aren’t back until right near the end of 11s run. He changed what happened, and the doctors before will not be allowed to know that until they reach that point.
Dan Johnson I loved S9, aside from the obligatory mess Gatiss gives us every season. Throughout the episodes there were some moments that were brilliantly acted. However I still feel like the type of empathy conjured in this scene was still missing.
@@nunyabizniss7643 I wouldn't say that. It just recontextualizes it, so the tragedy isn't that Gallifrey is gone, but that for all this time the Doctor has thought he truly was the last Time Lord, when they've all been there, just out of reach.
If I recall right the tenth doctor hadn't done that yet, none of the doctors had not until 12s tardis had finished the calculations then through time paradox fuckery pulled all the previous doctors into one moment because time is not a linear progression from cause to effect with doctor who so from tens perspective gallifrey has burnt because he hasn't been pulled to that moment after he had fled.
I understand why they couldn't have that plot with Gallifrey being gone last forever but I really do miss it. I feel like it added so much to the Doctor and introduced a lot of new ideas for episodes. I don't think it would even matter if they kept it to this day considering all Gallifrey seems to do is get blown up (Thanks Chibnall...)
I watched The Lazarus Experiment and Blink yesterday. It's those scenes where the Doctor reflects on his age, all he's seen, and all he's been forced to endure, including the (supposed) death of Gallifrey, that really grips your heart.
Agreed. Despite the "Lazarus Experiment" episode's flaws, I LOVE the Doctor's quote to Lazarus in the church, really resonated with me and still does: "In the end, you just get tired. Tired of the struggle. Tired of losing everything that matters to you. Tired of watching everything turn to dust. If you live long enough, Lazarus, the only certainty left is that you'll end up alone."
Can’t we all just stop for a moment and just appreciate David’s acting in this scene? I mean you can see all his pain, all his grief all his sadness in his face expression! Playing the Doctor is really hard since he has experienced so much and is so complicated but David just delivers it so perfectly (especially at 2:36). That’s why he’s my #1 favorite actor of all time
Years later... The doctor arrives on Gallifrey, and promptly chucks a fit. I really wish when they had made Capaldi's return to Gallifrey a bit more emotional. Give him some time to enjoy it, rather than what we got. Oh well...
@@tf2excession it makes perfect sense in context, but i can't help but wish coming home could be a positive moment for them, at least for a little while :(
"My people fought...for the sake of all creation, and they lost." I've always been struck by that line. It makes me think of the great final battles in epic stories going the wrong way, and the world a hundred, maybe a thousand years later, trying to pick up the pieces.
Martha's place in this series was pure genius. People loved Rose and were slower to love Martha because of it. Likewise, The Doctor loved Rose and distanced himself from Martha for the same reason. The written dynamic between The Doctor and Martha mirrored perfectly the dynamic between the audience and Martha. Superb.
this acting from the 10th is why i see him as the best. 2:23 The ability to transfer emotion. making you feel sad for him. The only other time iv actually felt a character do such a thing, was in the Metal Gear series.
My favourite Doctor, he made it seem so real describing his home world, his facial expression after saying "you should have seen it that old planet"; fantastic acting.
This brings back the feels. I was 8 at the time, and this was something me and my brother would wait for on a Saturday. When I was young episodes like this was boring, when I watch it back it makes me realise, this scene is magical!
Or why are they driving behind each other like on roads lol. I'd be driving like a mad man... not following other cars like they were for all their lives
If anything I think DotD makes scenes like this even more sad. The Doctor carries all that pain with him while his people are safe and hidden away in a pocket universe. Yet he still has to suffer. He has to suffer this memory for hundreds of years all the while the people of Gallifrey are clinging to hope.
No, I think the guilt that the doctor carried knowing he was the one who pulled the trigger that killed his whole race to the point where he couldn't look at his face for years after the fact is way more sad. But that's just me.
It cheapens it. DotD ruined it by basically just going “hey haha the time lords weren’t actually wiped out after all, all that drama and those emotional moments over the years are actually completely pointless, teehee”. Its bullshit
This acting is Oscar level acting. Just because it’s a “kids programme” it’ll never get the credit it deserves. David Tennant as the doctor is one of the most inspired pieces of casting in television history. It’s somehow been created into a debate about who the best doctor is. I don’t understand, it’s not even close. This is THE Doctor. Unmatched
I live on Oahu, Hawaii i live in a small town on the westside of the island during very cloudy overcast days just before the sunsets the sun rays would shine, painting all the clouds and making the whole sky burnt orange just like Gallifrey
I don't blame you. I kinda teared up too. =') Gallifrey sounds like a wonderful place to live.(As long as when the Timelords do return to our Universe, the Time War doesn't continue.) This makes me miss David and Matt a little more.
“Aww, you should’ve seen it, that old planet. The second Sun would rise in the south and the mountains would shine.” The Fourteenth Doctor was born on a cliff, in the light of a sunrise…
One of the best scenes with David tennant no cgi battle no lighting beams shooting towards the sky just great acting and very beautiful music playing in the background absolutely wonderful
When the doctor talked about gallifrey and the camera moved to overlook the city of the planet they were on, It made me think of coruscant from star wars
Oh how I miss the Davies years, which is weird because I didn't start watching until 2012. But I could always tell there was something off about the Moffet series, I just kept coming back to the ninth and tenth doctors and their companions. Even the stinkers were entertaining.
Ionut Maris I never typed anything about RTD or moffat writing of any episodes. I said I liked RTD's run of the show better, that includes directing, writing, and incidental music, Not RTD himself.
Hearing The Doctor talk about his home planet really makes you uneasy like hearing a sad ghost story knowing we've SEEN the Time Lords before. Prior to Day Of The Doctor they were dead so hearing this has this aging feeling knowing they've all been dead for a VERY long time.
One of my favourite scenes paired with my absolute favourite Hymn. Perfection. "Abide with me; fast falls the eventide; The darkness deepens; Lord with me abide. When other helpers fail and comforts flee, Help of the helpless, O abide with me. Swift to its close ebbs out life's little day; Earth's joys grow dim; its glories pass away; Change and decay in all around I see; O Thou who changest not, abide with me. Abide with me; fast falls the eventide; The darkness deepens; O Lord with me abide."
Hearing him talk about the second sun rising southward over shining mountains in an orange sky, only for the end to pan up and reveal a southward sunrise over manmade mountains in an orange sky makes me tear up a bit.
Love this scene. A moment that doesn't get talked about enough is Martha mirroring Rose saying "you've got me" and the Doctor crushes her with "I don't think so".
Yeah, he always made her feel bad for trying to be there for him. As said on the commentary with the actors and showrunner, Martha stands her ground though, something that the Doctor admires.
I like this scene and David Tennant's acting. His acting was especially good at 2:34 when he says "You should had seen it, that old planet." One of his best moments as The Doctor.
perfect song for a war-torn doctor, telling his story. here in australia, we always sing this song on anzac day and remembrance day, remembering those boys who went off to war and sang this in the trenches as they watched the world and their mates fall apart around them. "in life, in death, oh lord, abide with me", indeed.
Martha, only the second after Rose to force a confession from the Doctor like this. I don't think I've ever seen anything quite like that ever again. Which make Rose and Martha quite special in my opinion
We have been putting up videos from the classic series as #ThrowbackThursday choices over the last few months, we just want to give a bit of variety to your choices. More to come!
David Tennant was, by far, the best at communicating the fact that he was an old, old soul in a young man's body. His slightly detached look, the memories flooding back, a weariness yet still a spark of life...a great actor.
I remember this was the second episode that I watched of the tenth doctor. There was something about David Tennant being the doctor that capture me that made me like him as the doctor. Not sure was it the way he deliver his lines or his charismatic that he is that you just want to watch the episode to be with him.
I loved how Martha went and had enough of the Doctor not telling her anything. Rose wouldn't have done that. How could Martha travel with a man who talks a lot but never actually says anything? She managed to get him to give in and tell her everything. Martha was so great, she didn't deserve the hate she got. I think everybody was still upset over Rose. Still I do hope Martha comes back at some point
One of the truly great moments of modern Doctor Who featuring David Tennant at the top of his game. Whoever chose "Abide With Me" as the music behind this moment was, too, at the top of their game. A moment of cathartic grief tinged with new hope. Brilliant.
Don't mistake me: I understand clearly what you're saying, in story terms. But as I'm one of those Whovians who doesn't like Rose, the explanation grates on me. My whole point was an indirect compliment to Freema Agyeman; please don't be so literal in responding to my question.
I know everyone hates Martha, and yes, she was probably my least favourite companion, but the doctor was so mean to her sometimes! She may have been jealous, but it was completely reasonable considering she was like, transparent to him!
That's the point. He had just lost rose who we know he had a "special" connection with. He had a hard time getting over it and pulling himself together
findingbuglantis Very true, although to be fair Martha does seem to get the MOST hate from what I can tell. (Look at the Teens React to Doctor Who). But yes, Whovians ARE impossible to please. And help make up the angriest fans I've ever met.
This scene was one of the many that I really connected to as a child browning up and watching the Doctor. Martha standing her ground and not taking any of his half-baked answers as good enough was amazing to me, because no other companion (other than the newer ones e.g. Clara, Bill, Nardole) would have done that. The Doctor finally giving us an insight onto how gallifrey looked from how remembered it, was brilliantly done and you can see that David was close to tears in that scene. It shows you that the Doctor does miss his home and would be overjoyed to see it in the sky without the aftermath of the time war. Those bright silver trees and the wind that sang through them, creating natural music. A burnt orange sky and the citadel. Watching this scene after seeing DOTD, it really does break your heart because he still believes that he pressed the button. I love the acting in this scene and to this day, it is still one of my favourites.
You can tell how much the Doctor misses Gallifrey. The eyes and the shaking of his voice. But the way he reminisces and speaks is so beautiful and sad. I miss Ten and Eleven so much. ❤️
Deep down, he's just a man who wants to go home but can't
They did bring it back, all together
@@aaronkenyon7112I know exactly how he feels 😢
This was my favorite thing about Martha Jones. She made the Doctor talk about things on HER time table. Made him confront the things he always tried to sweep under the rug, and it helped him.
I honestly preferred her to Rose.
@andrewbyrne2173 I liked rose but I did prefer Martha tbh
The Doctor needed Martha, in a number of ways. It's just the fact that things ended up coming down to her falling for him, and him not being over Rose yet, meant she got fed up and left. But her attitude as a _friend_ what exactly what he needed to give him that push to talk about things, and realizing finally how she felt and why she was leaving also gave him that push to really try and move on properly and get over Rose. After Martha, Donna then filled the perfect niche. A good friend who would push him to do the right thing, but was sassy, could verbally spar with him by virtue of sheer attitude, and was not romantically interested.
@@Blazieth Donna is my favorite companion from the revival series, you're right about Martha being necessary for the Doctor because of the place he was at, but Donna/Ten were so good together they even brought them back lol
She was the Doctor's doctor, the Healer's healer.
I sometimes feel like david tennant forgets he's really a human!
kam hagh That's good acting.
thats called true acting.
That's why he's the best version of the Doctor.
The dude was a whovian all the time before he was cast as the doctor, makes sense how he completely embodies the Doctor in his own unique way. Best doctor and my childhood doctor. Matt brought his own style and so did Peter, but this is the only doctor I’ll forever stand by. Thank you David for being my sci fi hero
I thought he for got he was human a lot when I watch him and 11 too.
I love the fact that they incorporated Susan’s line about “the leaves on the trees are silver” in this scene. 10 will always be my favourite dr!
2:35 his expression and the way his eyes dart around slightly looks like he really was gripped by his memories of Gallirey. brilliant acting
He’s not just saying lines, it’s like he’s reliving memories and feeling all the emotions that come with them.
its always been heartbreaking to hear the doctor talking about him being alone
agreed. he looks absolutely heartbroken in this scene
yeah :( i’d say Ninth and Tenth are the most melancholic Doctors. the weight of the war on both of them is visible. and i don’t know why, but i miss this melancholy of him being the last Time Lord. it started to disappear with Eleventh and by Twelfth we got to see very little of it. and then Hell Bent came.
Oh it was honestly the biggest character development in doctor who history the weight of carrying out their legacy, no one could ever understand how it is to be so truly alone and the regret of knowing that it was by his hand.
But don't worry good ol Midday comes to retcon all that who wants to be sad ever anyway right? The timeliness are back and they are good now Happy endings for everyone!
@@ldmt1995 Man I hate that shitty retcon.
The way he paints a picture of his planet. It's gorgeous
My god, people have said it before but David in this scene just radiates pure, raw emotion. You can see The Doctor is on the verge of tears remembering his home. Describing things that, when you stop and think about it, he probably took for granted. Growing up on Gallifrey, those things were just normal to him, a second sun rising over the shining mountains, the silver leaves catching the light to look like a forest on fire. As the old saying goes, "You don't know what you have until it's gone." You can see the sadness in his eyes remembering a home he can never go back to, sights that he will never see again.
This is why, in my opinion, David Tennant is the best Doctor of New Who, he brought forth The Doctor's pain and anguish better than anyone else. Eccleston never really had a chance to shine, Smith played a man so stricken with grief he chose to forget his pain, Capaldi played a Doctor who refused to lose anything else, breaking his own rules in order to get what he wanted. Whittaker, despite the awful storylines, played a woman who's entire life was a lie, who didn't know who she was.
But Tennant? He played a man who once had everything, and now has nothing. His past keeps coming to haunt him, and he can do nothing about it. The more he runs from it, the more it comes right back into his face.
Bravo David Tennant, bravo.
David Tennant does a really good job delivering some pretty unnatural dialogue.
His expressions are fantastic
Makes sense since he did theatre for ages including hamlet ( by our standards really unnatural dialogue especially the soliloquies )
Or you could say.... _supernatural._
Sorry
He’s been practicing.
Is it possible to learn this power?
When he says “there was a war…” the lyrics of the hymn say “earth’s joys grow dim, it’s glories fade away, change and decay in all around I see”
Impeccable timing.
The Doctor: You should've seen that planet
Martha: What about your people
The Doctor: Them? They were the most evil and corrupt people you could imagine, but then again, 10 million years of absolute power will do that.
Orlando Soto Leyton Nostalgia'll do that.
TheBrokenMadMan Now I REALLY feel sorry for the Tenth Doctor, because he misses Gallifrey and the few Time Lords who weren't at least partially corrupt so much that he's deluded himself into thinking that the Time Lords were the angels of the universe.
DalekTheSupreme I wouldn't say he deluded himself too much, remember, in "The End of Time Part 2" the minute he realized the Time Lords were returning he grabbed the nearest revolver and got ready for battle.
Orko He didn't hate all of them
TheBrokenMadMan well yea i overstated again. He obviously only didn't like what they did stand for.
David Tenant is a legend. He can convey exactly the right emotions needed for a scene. He was, and remains, my favourite Doctor
Tom Baker is the best. Tennant is a pussy.
Mayo Tango131 I love em both equally
@@mayotango1317 the fuck
Well do I have news for you
@@TaeSunWoo I know and I'm so excited
'You should have seen it, that old planet...!' god, his delivery of that line, the depth of the heartbreak in his face... gets me every time. What a phenomenal actor David Tennant is.
This was actually an incredibly touching moment. Amongst the backdrop of a million souls singing a song of freedom, peace and renewal, an old war veteran describes the paradise he once called home, lost to the war that claimed his family, friends and all else.
3:03 That’s why the singing towers of Dirillium was so sentimental to The Doctor beyond his last date w River as number 12. The wind blowing through the towers giving you a song when you need it the most reminded him of the breeze through the trees on Gallifrey. A piece of home right there to share with a piece of his heart.
The burnt orange sky and the light reflecting from silver leaves...
New New York in this scene is presented as a reflection of Gallifrey... :D
Holy shit you're right, that's brilliant.
I never realised that
I would've done the same thing as Martha in this scene. Pull up a chair, sit down, and stand my ground until I got a real answer. Cause honestly, I would've gotten pretty sick of the way the Doctor was acting too.
"Not until you answer me properly."
Respect, Martha. Respect.
Well, it was a very sensitive subject and I think this scene makes Martha seem kind of rude and insensitive. Obviously she couldn't know that his planet had been destroyed, but it was obvious at he wasn't comfortable talking about it and I at least think it was a little rude to pressure him into telling her
well she had do deal with the whole "being ignored cause he's so hung up on Rose" which I understand that the Doctor misses her, but Martha's been doing everything trying to get noticed and he's just ignoring that. She was fed up with all the times he would push away the subject or get a short answer that was a lie, and said "you know what, I think it's about time he told me the truth."
but the truth just so happened to be a bit too much
"Only ask him a question if you know you can stand the answer."
+Rachel -Not-Again- Armamus Maybe that's why she ended up with Mickey. They have a lot in common in that regard.
DakNJaxter yeah, they do
+Rachel -Not-Again- Armamus Agreed. This scene summarises why Martha was awesome. Still miss her. Hey, Moffat, you realise she's one of the easiest characters to bring back, yes? Her and Jack. *puppy dog eyes*
One of the best series and story arcs in Doctor Who history. The way the Doctor got restored to youth in the final episode was disappointingly corny but the buildup and in particular the 'Sound of Drums' episode were astonishing, absolutely must-see TV. Even the creepy 'Vote Saxon' trailers leading up to 'Drums' were a nice touch.
Totally agreed.
CORNY! THANK YOU! I had completely forgot about that word because of the sudden influx of the word "cringe"
He wasn't made young. That was how old he would look if he never regenerated and just kept growing older, and then even further.
@@PerovNigma no at the very end when he Jesus'd it up and returned to his normal age and started t posing aggresivly at the Master
@@Fridge_Fiend
Yeah, you're right. I misread and thought they meant "when he got turned into a baby."
I ponder why there is so much dislike for Martha. I liked Martha and think she was a great companion. Jealous? Yes. However she was brilliant and still was very loyal to the Doctor. I liked her as a companion. Is she my favorite companion? No. That's a tie between Rose and Donna.
Alex K I don't wanna bring this up, but many have been lead to believe that she is hated because she is a women of color. I say that's not the case, but it makes sense. No one who hates her can give a well thought out reason as to why. Not even now.
nodnarb2151 if anyone hates her because of her color should be ashamed. I think she's a great companion, very loyal even if she isnt what she wanted to be to the Doctor.
Alex K Thats the thing they don't feel ashamed. They say thats not the case, they hate her because she is "stupid", "useless", and "whiney" throughout all her appearances. I don't agree for obvious reasons, but if thats their problem with her and not her being the only women of color in a major part then I just have to accept that.
Alex K I actually think Donna and Amy were the best because they were the most entertaining in general Martha was alright but I actually really dislike Rose I dont understand how people love her so much
Megan Versteeg Donna is soooo hilarious. OI!!!! My wife and I absolutely love Donna. Amy and Rory took awhile for me to warm up to. I do like them as companions.
Martha was so underrated. One of the best companions.
Lol no she wasnt
@@gordinflas99 She's better than the gang the current dr has, was better than the 12th's companions
Mmmmmmmmnope not even close.
Xomnipotentz yes she was
@@sreddi83 they're not companions mkay they're her *FAM* 😉🤣
All these years later after first watching this and it still gets me, David’s acting is superb. It might be just nostalgia but this for me was when Dr who was at its peak and I remember my family always waiting each Saturday for this. I remember eps like this was always shrugged off the week before but when they had this scene to end it nothing could be more perfect. Dr who or any tv show will ever captivate an audience in the way that this scene and season 3 ever will. David tennant was at his best this year.
Anyway.....whenever I feel a bit unsure about myself I look back at this and it takes me back to a simpler time. Ah to have it all back
It's these kind of scenes that are the highlights of the show. Funny comedy and eccentricity may be great, but without an emotional anchor the seriex wouldn't work imo.
The classic Series never need that emotional manipulation.
You like Chibnall?
@@mayotango1317 how is it manipulative?
@@mayotango1317 This is a terrible take, fyi
When I think of typical sadness I just think of someone crying for only a short period of time but when I think of true sadness I think of this scene with that face he makes which instantly shows the face of someone who has not just lost something small but something truly special in his/her eyes that is just too much for him to let go of or its basically depression...
I think it's post trauma stress depression indeed.
FINALLY we see a bit of Christopher Eccleston's Ninth Doctor reflected in David Tennant's eyes.
I adore this scene. It's the sort of bitterness and tiredness of his PTSD at this point in his life, that Tennant is just a incredible at portraying
"Abide With Me" ths song playing is a beautiful backdrop to this speech...it expresses great grief and desperate reliance on a higher power.
“I’m not just a timelord…I’m the last of the timelords” one of the
Most iconic lines from doctor who, shame it doesn’t really hold any weight anymore.
We’re just back to how it was during the classics. Doesn’t change TOO much
@@TaeSunWoo >looks a modern doctor who
uh huh sure thing sweat heart.
@@americanpride5540 I mean with the time lords being back
Thus why they stopped saying that after the Timelords were brought back. Just because something stops being the case doesnt mean what came before stops holding weight, things don't need to stay exactly the same forever.
It doesn’t really change anything because it’s true at this point. The time lords aren’t back until right near the end of 11s run. He changed what happened, and the doctors before will not be allowed to know that until they reach that point.
Have I just grown old and grumpy or do we not get moments as well done as this in Who anymore?
+obbly1234 Capaldi's anti-war speech was really impressive
We don't. I've decided I'm done with this show. Matt smith was a good doctor, but I feel like the new one isn't as good because of bad script writing.
Sesshomaru25U everyone I know who wasn't keen on the last couple if seasons admits season 9 is the strongest the shows ever been
Dan Johnson I loved S9, aside from the obligatory mess Gatiss gives us every season. Throughout the episodes there were some moments that were brilliantly acted. However I still feel like the type of empathy conjured in this scene was still missing.
+Dan Johnson
Totally agree. series 9 was better than Series 1-3.
My favourite scene ever. I always come back to it. Its just so beautiful.
David is such a good actor. It's all in the eyes.
Watching this scene makes it slightly easier to accept Ten's hair in DOTD
It deflates when he’s sad
Dom Townsend DomTowenesnd
Likes&Favorites Actually it’s because Tennant had another role to play at the time and they couldn’t change his hair.
@@nettlesmoothie594 it got erect when "Bad Wolf Girl?" though lmao.
@Likes&Favorites no... it's because Tennant had to grow is hair for filming something else...
At 2:37 David looks like he's going to cry
Lx_ignite Bro his face is funny
That's what you call great acting. He's showing the pain the Doctor felt while trying to hide it from Martha.
tbh he looks ready to cry in most of this scene
Yes.
I could make a joke about his sad scenes... but *I don't wanna go* there
"You don't talk. You never say. Why not?"
Because it hurts, Martha, it hurts him even more than Rose.
Poor Ten. He doesn't realize Gallifrey isnt dead, its just frozen in a single moment in time. He just remembers it wrong. :(
Oh yeah, I forgot they retconned it so all these moments mean jack shit and are completely pointless now
@@nunyabizniss7643 I wouldn't say that. It just recontextualizes it, so the tragedy isn't that Gallifrey is gone, but that for all this time the Doctor has thought he truly was the last Time Lord, when they've all been there, just out of reach.
@@nunyabizniss7643 Yeah, that was a writing failure. Tragedy gave the doctor his gravitas.
If I recall right the tenth doctor hadn't done that yet, none of the doctors had not until 12s tardis had finished the calculations then through time paradox fuckery pulled all the previous doctors into one moment because time is not a linear progression from cause to effect with doctor who so from tens perspective gallifrey has burnt because he hasn't been pulled to that moment after he had fled.
I understand why they couldn't have that plot with Gallifrey being gone last forever but I really do miss it. I feel like it added so much to the Doctor and introduced a lot of new ideas for episodes. I don't think it would even matter if they kept it to this day considering all Gallifrey seems to do is get blown up (Thanks Chibnall...)
I watched The Lazarus Experiment and Blink yesterday. It's those scenes where the Doctor reflects on his age, all he's seen, and all he's been forced to endure, including the (supposed) death of Gallifrey, that really grips your heart.
Sadly Chibnall ruin this.
@@mayotango1317 Nah, Moffat ruined it first.
Agreed. Despite the "Lazarus Experiment" episode's flaws, I LOVE the Doctor's quote to Lazarus in the church, really resonated with me and still does: "In the end, you just get tired. Tired of the struggle. Tired of losing everything that matters to you. Tired of watching everything turn to dust. If you live long enough, Lazarus, the only certainty left is that you'll end up alone."
@@ecthox-1mork909 ¿With the Timeless Child retcon?
@@ecthox-1mork909 That sound out of character for the Doctor. I not can see Tom Baker say that.
The eyes starting at 2:44, such depth and so much emotion
Can’t we all just stop for a moment and just appreciate David’s acting in this scene? I mean you can see all his pain, all his grief all his sadness in his face expression! Playing the Doctor is really hard since he has experienced so much and is so complicated but David just delivers it so perfectly (especially at 2:36). That’s why he’s my #1 favorite actor of all time
2:36 first, you can see him kind of smile, but that smile fades into sadness... So powerful!
And how he tries again to smile, but it doesn't quite work
You can feel the pain in his eyes and his voice
You know, this episode is probably better than I remember.
Years later... The doctor arrives on Gallifrey, and promptly chucks a fit.
I really wish when they had made Capaldi's return to Gallifrey a bit more emotional. Give him some time to enjoy it, rather than what we got. Oh well...
@@tf2excession it makes perfect sense in context, but i can't help but wish coming home could be a positive moment for them, at least for a little while :(
Oh boy, now Chibnall ruin it.
I really liked this scene! It shows how Martha could get him to open up and it reveals some painful truths about the Doctor's thoughts.
Martha was such a wonderful companion.
"I could pretend....."
😭
"My people fought...for the sake of all creation, and they lost."
I've always been struck by that line. It makes me think of the great final battles in epic stories going the wrong way, and the world a hundred, maybe a thousand years later, trying to pick up the pieces.
Martha's place in this series was pure genius. People loved Rose and were slower to love Martha because of it. Likewise, The Doctor loved Rose and distanced himself from Martha for the same reason. The written dynamic between The Doctor and Martha mirrored perfectly the dynamic between the audience and Martha. Superb.
This scene broke my heart. His voice and the sadness in his eyes.
You could feel the sorrow in this.
She can tell he’s burying his sadness, loneliness, and guilt in this scene
this acting from the 10th is why i see him as the best. 2:23
The ability to transfer emotion. making you feel sad for him.
The only other time iv actually felt a character do such a thing, was in the Metal Gear series.
My favourite Doctor, he made it seem so real describing his home world, his facial expression after saying "you should have seen it that old planet"; fantastic acting.
This brings back the feels. I was 8 at the time, and this was something me and my brother would wait for on a Saturday. When I was young episodes like this was boring, when I watch it back it makes me realise, this scene is magical!
One of the greatest-- and most underappreciated --scenes in all of Doctor Who.
why is everyone still driving around, id be out trying to get the biggest house
guitaroidman524 I always wondered the same lol
I always thought it was Gallifrey at the end
@@HenryBrewerCalvert.. We see the people singing in the episode
Or why are they driving behind each other like on roads lol. I'd be driving like a mad man... not following other cars like they were for all their lives
@@kyle18934 It's an automated system. They can't.
The greatest actors act with their eyes.
I always getting a little teary when he describes how it looked
I still remembers when i first watched this episode, gosh this made me felt real homesick..
I like the bit at 1:14 where you can see him trying to think of what to say. David Tennant is a really good actor.
Imagine it was him just trying to remember the lines
The leaves of silver are actually mentioned by Susan in "The Sensorites".
Nice nod.
If anything I think DotD makes scenes like this even more sad. The Doctor carries all that pain with him while his people are safe and hidden away in a pocket universe. Yet he still has to suffer. He has to suffer this memory for hundreds of years all the while the people of Gallifrey are clinging to hope.
No more after Chibnall ruin all.
No, I think the guilt that the doctor carried knowing he was the one who pulled the trigger that killed his whole race to the point where he couldn't look at his face for years after the fact is way more sad. But that's just me.
It cheapens it. DotD ruined it by basically just going “hey haha the time lords weren’t actually wiped out after all, all that drama and those emotional moments over the years are actually completely pointless, teehee”. Its bullshit
@@nunyabizniss7643 Agreed. Gallifrey was a tale of the power and hubris, and they should've left it that way.
"There was a war" he sounds so sad.
2:34, those few lines reduce me to tears, David’s acting was something else
This acting is Oscar level acting. Just because it’s a “kids programme” it’ll never get the credit it deserves. David Tennant as the doctor is one of the most inspired pieces of casting in television history. It’s somehow been created into a debate about who the best doctor is. I don’t understand, it’s not even close. This is THE Doctor. Unmatched
I live on Oahu, Hawaii
i live in a small town on the westside of the island
during very cloudy overcast days just before the sunsets the sun rays would shine, painting all the clouds and making the whole sky burnt orange just like Gallifrey
David Tennant is such a good actor he can really make me feel nostalgia for a place that I can never go to. Just bravo sir.
She's just like "We aren't going ANYWHERE until you're straight with me".
"Just what every city needs, cats in charge" lol
Is it bad that I teared up during this...?
No why would it be
itd be worse if you didnt
I don't blame you. I kinda teared up too. =') Gallifrey sounds like a wonderful place to live.(As long as when the Timelords do return to our Universe, the Time War doesn't continue.) This makes me miss David and Matt a little more.
Most peoples reaction:😐😕😦
Mine:😪😢😩😫😖😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
There were the other Timelord cities too. The Death Zone was only a small portion of a Large Planet.
“Aww, you should’ve seen it, that old planet. The second Sun would rise in the south and the mountains would shine.”
The Fourteenth Doctor was born on a cliff, in the light of a sunrise…
So happy for them, honestly. I can't wait for the new season!
One of the best scenes with David tennant no cgi battle no lighting beams shooting towards the sky just great acting and very beautiful music playing in the background absolutely wonderful
Capaldi got a scene like this without the music and it’s the best moment in the show, scenes like these are what makes this show great!
Dude just imagining what this would be like if a human lost earth, that is absolutely scary and sad and tear jerking-
That's why David will forever be THE Doctor, he is the best.
Overrated lol, still my second favourite but I never thought he was as good as people make him out to be
When the doctor talked about gallifrey and the camera moved to overlook the city of the planet they were on, It made me think of coruscant from star wars
“The leaves on the trees were silver” is this a reference to when Susan described Gallifrey?
Oh how I miss the Davies years, which is weird because I didn't start watching until 2012. But I could always tell there was something off about the Moffet series, I just kept coming back to the ninth and tenth doctors and their companions. Even the stinkers were entertaining.
+nodnarb2151
Yeah.....except that most RTD episodes weren't written by RTD.... (same goes with Moffat's era).
Ionut Maris I never typed anything about RTD or moffat writing of any episodes. I said I liked RTD's run of the show better, that includes directing, writing, and incidental music, Not RTD himself.
The Moffat era is the golden age of the Series.
Chibnall kill the show.
@@mayotango1317 “the Moffat era is the golden age of the series” and other hilarious jokes you can tell yourself
@@nunyabizniss7643 Ah, so you like the Timeless Children and the Woke era?
This was when I teared up the most.
This entire season was just 10 getting therapy. I think that’s why he chose a doctor for his companion, good bedside manner.
Hearing The Doctor talk about his home planet really makes you uneasy like hearing a sad ghost story knowing we've SEEN the Time Lords before. Prior to Day Of The Doctor they were dead so hearing this has this aging feeling knowing they've all been dead for a VERY long time.
One of my favourite scenes paired with my absolute favourite Hymn. Perfection.
"Abide with me; fast falls the eventide;
The darkness deepens; Lord with me abide.
When other helpers fail and comforts flee,
Help of the helpless, O abide with me.
Swift to its close ebbs out life's little day;
Earth's joys grow dim; its glories pass away;
Change and decay in all around I see;
O Thou who changest not, abide with me.
Abide with me; fast falls the eventide;
The darkness deepens; O Lord with me abide."
Hearing him talk about the second sun rising southward over shining mountains in an orange sky, only for the end to pan up and reveal a southward sunrise over manmade mountains in an orange sky makes me tear up a bit.
Love this scene. A moment that doesn't get talked about enough is Martha mirroring Rose saying "you've got me" and the Doctor crushes her with "I don't think so".
Yeah, he always made her feel bad for trying to be there for him. As said on the commentary with the actors and showrunner, Martha stands her ground though, something that the Doctor admires.
It came out since April 2007 and it was filmed in September 2006 - October 2006
He's the Doctor who counted all the children on Gallifrey.
I like this scene and David Tennant's acting. His acting was especially good at 2:34 when he says "You should had seen it, that old planet." One of his best moments as The Doctor.
At 1:35 I was aching for him to say “I’m not just a time lord, I’m an M&S time lord” lol
Doctor's grand daugther Suzanne gives the same description of Gallifrey in the very first episode back in 1963. Emotional.
perfect song for a war-torn doctor, telling his story. here in australia, we always sing this song on anzac day and remembrance day, remembering those boys who went off to war and sang this in the trenches as they watched the world and their mates fall apart around them. "in life, in death, oh lord, abide with me", indeed.
Martha, only the second after Rose to force a confession from the Doctor like this. I don't think I've ever seen anything quite like that ever again.
Which make Rose and Martha quite special in my opinion
Can we please have some classic clips! #throwbackthursday The seventh doctor gets locked at the top of the stairs as the dalek escalates up.
#Throwbackthursday
We have been putting up videos from the classic series as #ThrowbackThursday choices over the last few months, we just want to give a bit of variety to your choices. More to come!
Charlie E wasn't that episode just on the horror channel the other day?
gridlock is one of the sadly under rated gems of 2000s Who. The song part still makes me cry.
David Tennant was, by far, the best at communicating the fact that he was an old, old soul in a young man's body.
His slightly detached look, the memories flooding back, a weariness yet still a spark of life...a great actor.
I remember this was the second episode that I watched of the tenth doctor. There was something about David Tennant being the doctor that capture me that made me like him as the doctor. Not sure was it the way he deliver his lines or his charismatic that he is that you just want to watch the episode to be with him.
I loved how Martha went and had enough of the Doctor not telling her anything. Rose wouldn't have done that. How could Martha travel with a man who talks a lot but never actually says anything? She managed to get him to give in and tell her everything. Martha was so great, she didn't deserve the hate she got. I think everybody was still upset over Rose. Still I do hope Martha comes back at some point
One of the truly great moments of modern Doctor Who featuring David Tennant at the top of his game. Whoever chose "Abide With Me" as the music behind this moment was, too, at the top of their game. A moment of cathartic grief tinged with new hope. Brilliant.
Is that the Tabernacle Choir I hear?!
Doctor, how DO you say "no" to a face like Martha's?!
+Nick Hentschel its the arse thats the key imo
Nick Hentschel Because of Rose...probably.
That makes even LESS sense: Rose isn't very pretty, IMO.
Nick Hentschel Not because of the face, because he loves her and misses her. Right...
Don't mistake me: I understand clearly what you're saying, in story terms. But as I'm one of those Whovians who doesn't like Rose, the explanation grates on me.
My whole point was an indirect compliment to Freema Agyeman; please don't be so literal in responding to my question.
Martha is still the favourite new who companion for me
the classic who is Sarah Jane
They're both amazing companions 🧡
What a beautiful scene.
I know everyone hates Martha, and yes, she was probably my least favourite companion, but the doctor was so mean to her sometimes! She may have been jealous, but it was completely reasonable considering she was like, transparent to him!
That's the point. He had just lost rose who we know he had a "special" connection with. He had a hard time getting over it and pulling himself together
It's not just Martha. Every companion receives a lot of hate. So does every incarnation of the Doctor. Ah, Whovians. They're impossible to please.
findingbuglantis
Very true, although to be fair Martha does seem to get the MOST hate from what I can tell. (Look at the Teens React to Doctor Who). But yes, Whovians ARE impossible to please. And help make up the angriest fans I've ever met.
That's the point, she knew about Rose, she can't be jealous. Plus, she had just met the Doctor.
ellawelly I really like Martha. My second favourite after Donna
the music for this scene
What a fantastic piece of writing!
This scene was one of the many that I really connected to as a child browning up and watching the Doctor.
Martha standing her ground and not taking any of his half-baked answers as good enough was amazing to me, because no other companion (other than the newer ones e.g. Clara, Bill, Nardole) would have done that.
The Doctor finally giving us an insight onto how gallifrey looked from how remembered it, was brilliantly done and you can see that David was close to tears in that scene. It shows you that the Doctor does miss his home and would be overjoyed to see it in the sky without the aftermath of the time war. Those bright silver trees and the wind that sang through them, creating natural music. A burnt orange sky and the citadel.
Watching this scene after seeing DOTD, it really does break your heart because he still believes that he pressed the button. I love the acting in this scene and to this day, it is still one of my favourites.