The Doctor And Rose Say Goodbye | Doomsday | Doctor Who | BBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- Voted #1 greatest moment in sci-fi, horror and fantasy by SFX magazine readers in their 250th issue! In the most gut-wrenching of goodbyes, the Doctor and Rose meet on the beach of Bad Wolf Bay to see each other one last time. Subscribe: bit.ly/Subscrib...
WATCH MORE:
GERMAN: bit.ly/DoctorW...
FRENCH: bit.ly/DoctorW...
ITALIAN: bit.ly/DoctorW...
The Brand New Doctor Who Website - www.doctorwho.tv
Doctor Who TH-cam Channel / doctorwho
Doctor Who Facebook: / doctorwho
Doctor Who Twitter / bbcdoctorwho
This is a commercial channel from BBC Studios. Service & Feedback www.bbcstudios...
"I'm burning up a sun just to say goodbye."
Love that line.
The most romantic thing I've ever heard
That how much loved her
Just to clarify incase anyone thinks this. The Doctor didn't burn up the sun himself. He found a supernova in history and siphoned the power from it. He's not a psychopath who absorbs suns, potentially dooming millions of nearby ecosystems.
I love the sound the tardis is making
"And I suppose if it's my last chance to say it...Rose Tyler" will ALWAYS make me cry😭
The way Rose says 'I love you' breaks my heart every time.
I seem to remember reading somewhere that Billie Piper was so distraught after filming this scene that she had to go to her trailer and it took nearly an hour before she could get herself under control. She had channeled so much emotion into this scene and submerged herself so completely into the character of Rose she had difficulty turning it off when the director yelled cut.
It Shows That A Long Time Friend WILL NEVER FORGET and Always Love The Other
@@chooseyourpoison5105 oh my God 😢, I mean props to her she did a magnificent job, I always loose it when she says I love you to him I just start badly tearing up 😭
@@chooseyourpoison5105 if you watch the Doctor Who confidential it shoes what you said about Billie Piper be distraught after filming this scene
@@chooseyourpoison5105 no wonder, her crying in the whole last bit of the episode is what actually made me clutch my chest in sympathy- amazing actress
Billie piper's performance in this scene was outstanding.
There needs to be a word to replace "outstanding" I had no respect for her the first time I saw her. So much for intuition and first impressions. This was, by far the greatest scene in cinematic history. Perhaps because of their real life connection and our own life experiences. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
IKR! I miss her so much😭😭. Doctor Who isn't the same without Rose Tyler. 😭💔
@@BelleJedi Couldnt agree more. Could not agree more!
My heart broke seeing her heartbreak over this goodbye.
@@BelleJedican’t believe it’s been almost 20 years since we first saw her.. that’s crazy
It’s funny how when the doctor says, “both universes would collapse,” and Rose says, “so?” you can tell she actually means it. She’s not joking.
This is the first time i actually cried just watching a TV screen
same.. same.
You should see Donna or Amy's goodbye scene
Welcome to the club.
Yeah, same here. I was actually in front of the tv on the floor sobbing.
Me too.
Someone remind me why I am constantly torturing myself with this episode.
+Sorry I'm Late! CORNER NOW.
+Sorry I'm Late! You're a whole new level of evil, aren't you?
+Kayla K Their profile pics are of Darth Vader and The Daleks, you think (s)he's a hero
gaaah i know!
LadyStarkgaryen because you don't have a boyfriend?!
THE FIRST THING THE DOCTOR TOOK ROSE TO WAS TO SEE THE SUN BURN OUT
THEY SAID GOODBYE BY A BURNING SUN
why must you hurt me in this way?
YOU SHUT YOUR MOUTH
NO
+Envy Shiny Hunter GO SIT IN THE CORNER
+Jayashree Roopchand okay...
''rose tyler...'' *dissappears*
OH MY GOD TENNANT THATS NOT COOL
it wasnt his fault. he only had a short time to be there.
or maybe he closed the rift because he could not say it, like in satan pit, where he cant say it, whatever it may be. he did not say anything, cuz he thought it would hurt to much. again just a theory of mine
Roses are red
the TARDIS is blue
The doctor once said
"Rose Tyler..."
Patikli Abim he lost energy
+Jessi Altmiks and u know what he said he said. Rose Tyler will you marry me
What makes this duo so unbearably painful is how well their end reflects and depicts a break up in real life. Suddenly separated into two different worlds, you know that the other person is out there living their life only you cannot be together for whatever reason and you feel changed forever. Rose explains how the doctor has shown her a new way of life and she cannot simply return to how she was before after all their amazing experiences.
Frick, this is the best comment on here
on the plus side at least she got to be with her father again even if he was an alternate universe version plus her whole family are in a better world now anyway
“Rose helped him move on from his terrible grief he’s been dealing with. She knocks off the Time Lords edges and humanizes him, as he time lords her. They were what the other was lacking, they were inseparable.” -Russell T Davis
This quote makes me wanna cry 😢
Very well said. )-:
Rose: am I ever gonna see you again?
Doctor: you can't
Producers, thinking about series 4: who's gonna tell them?
producers: no let them cry haha
+had it Haha! Your comment made my day 😂😂😂😂
ponytailsforlunch LOL!😂
Producers: *evil smile* lets break their hearts....then mend them.. *slowing morphing into Davros voice* ...then break them all over again and again and again!! *evil laugh*
Roro Halstead Producers: Their fears and compassion will be their greatest weakness. (Sinister chuckle) Then when they think the Doctor wins and everybody lives! We tear out both of his hearts, and theirs too.( Malevolent Laughter )
Roses are red
The TARDIS is blue
The Doctor once said
"Rose Tyler..."
-i love you-
Sheamus WWE YOU
BAD WHOVIAN GO TO YOUR CORNER DONT MAKE ME CRY AGAIN
Roses and red
The TARDIS is blue
Hey Donna there's the Doctor
She said
Doctor Who ?
+Waluigi ...:'((
OMG beautiful 💕
The very first time a tv show left me absolutely gutted. Cried like an idiot the first time I saw it.
That episode still gets me everytime I watch it too!
Same first time I ever cried at a tv show and it got worse from there
RorySeizeTheDay So did I!
+RorySeizeTheDay Yesss!
Yeah and then we saw what happened to Ned Stark.
Doctor: How long are you gonna stay with me?
Rose: Forever
Doomsday:
Rose: How long have we got?
Doctor: About two minutes...
Lollipop 10 . Don’t rub it in
Its funny becuase that was the episode before this story
Two minutes is forever when you know your love will be gone after it.
Oh come on man that's like rubbing salt into an open wound 😢
Katarina Brunk I’m sorry mate😭
As a child I got emotional at this farewell. For me Rose will always Be my favourite dr who companion.
@lukedaley17 That's why I find it pretty stomach churning. The overemotional, oversexualised, over-whiny Ten is why I stopped watching. The trouble with modern drama (& I quote RTD in his first Dr Who Magazine here ) ''Is that it has to make you care all the time''. That's a way of storytelling I find manipulative & dishonest, it also invalidates the show when it's trying to make a serious point/comment/observation. I'm watching a fantasy drama, not a charity appeal, doc, play for today or news item. That doesn't mean Dr Who can't make a point just that it should do so w/o laying it on with such manipulative, dishonest & cheap tactics. TBH I find Ten either too whiny or aggressive to take seriously, there's no middle ground with him.
@@mortdewerewolfe691 damn dude what’s ur take on the current series because 💀
And mine. Always.
The connection lasts 3:38 minutes, or 180+38= 218 seconds.
The time there is used saying "Rose Tyler" (by him) and "I love you" (by her) is about 4 seconds.
218/4= 54,5.
He could have said _"Rose Tyler, I love you."_ 54 times, but they wasted them by talking about the beach and her mother, so he used just the 0,5 to proclaim his love for Rose.
*FIFTY-FOUR TIMES*
***** For a Time Lord, he sure does have poor time management...
That's really bad, Carter Anne.
He should have joined the army, as his loom-dad said in 8x04
*(not spoiler free)*
No more.
Carter Anne He counts like this, "1...B, wait 2!" What did you expect?
at least he said the right name... can you imagine him saying Romana I-, wait no sorry, er which are you again? or something along those lines
Voted #1 greatest moment in sci-fi, horror and fantasy by SFX readers in their 250th issue!
Could you please possibly release the clip of Donnas mind being wiped by the Doctor.
I personally cried a lot more at that sequence and when the Doctor entered the Tardis alone afterwards then I did on this Scene :)
Unconventional Jack u should have voted jack
Haha first comment to say first
Oh please. Considering the majority of Doctor Who fans these days don't want to acknowledge anything outside Tennant's era, it's no surprise this shlock made #1. If you think this is the best moment in Doctor Who history, then you obviously haven't been paying attention.
Rose was a terrible companion. CHARACTER DEVOLOPEMENT RUSSELL T YOU GAVE HER IT AND THEN YOU BROKE IT OMG OMFG
Oh look
Someone left a rose on the beach
Who invited you here? Do you like making things worse for us, or for yourself?
(screams)
Who let you in here?!
Why must you hurt me in this way
Noah Daglio BURN.
this is the most heartbreaking departure of a companion tbh
i really need to sneeze but i cant Ikr
i actually cried more at amy leaving tbh
i really need to sneeze but i cant. Apparently Billie hated the way she had
to leave and tbh I hated it to. 😒😞😔😟😕🙁☹️😣😖😫😩🥺😢😭🤧
nope
@@bee8425 Actually she was talking about the series 4 version.
For me David Tennant will always be THE DOCTOR ...his acting is a true masterpiece
He appears different. Like the world gave him a few lessons. That happens. I hope he deals with it well. He is one of my very favorite thespians.
I"f it's the last time to say it...
Rose Tyler...
Bananas are a good source of potassium."
+LemonPie Rocks HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!
HahahhahahahHhHahhahahahahhahshahahahahhahahhzhaha
god bless you
Always take a banana to a party
John-Paul Garzon XD
My soul hurts
Oh god you're depressed again aren't you
Oh why won't saturday come around faster
Ikr 😥
*sobs* I cried when I first watched this. Haven't stopped crying since....
Jess Dempsey I don't have a soul.
Brunette
Love it how Matt smith just appears at the end lol
Makes you feel a little better lightens the mood
sproutickler That’s what I thought.
I thought you were talking about Donna 😂
What do you mean?
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
The Doctor just left Rose on read at an interdimensional level
Me as an oblivious 9-year-old watching this: “Why did he just say her name? What was so meaningful about that?”
Crystal that was me when I was like 5. I never used to understand
Exactly, but still cried my heart out, and cried again few years later, and cried some more today
Havent seen this scene since i was like 9 or 10, I dont remember it being this painful
Just in case you were feeling sad:
I just want to point out that in doomsday, (before this scene of course) the Tenth Doctor explained to Jackie Tyler that "every single decision we make creates a parallel existence". So there has to be at least one version where they stayed together, and that brings me joy. Also I want to say that when the doctor was repairing the TARDIS, he mentioned that if the time lords were still alive transferring universes would have been an easy thing to do. Guess what the time lords are still alive. Hope still exists in reuniting these two again. :)
This comment made me so happy :)
I'm on the Season 4 Animated Special right now... The only other (pure) Time Lord is dead. The other part-Time Lords are either in a parallel universe OR given amnesia for protection. But that's all I know now. Please don't post spoilers :D
Nicole Paris thank you for that 😍😍
And then you realize that Billie Piper is legit done with the show. She's not ever coming back to the show.
@@VincentDoesThings sure... that's why she's not in a new audio play featuring her character and starring her as Rose.
I watched Sherlock before Doctor Who and I thought nothing could ever be more traumatizing than The Reichenbach Fall.
I was wrong.
That was exactly me! I seriously thought nothing could be worse-very wrong!
I HAD THE EXACT SAME THOUGHTS
+Jazzmine Colleen Both broke my heart(s)
jcolleen k No truer words....
Jazzy YAS ME TOO
"Rose Tyler..."
"Sherlock is actually a girls name"
They both fail to confess their love.
Yep, I only just found Sherlock this year, just watched the abominable bride. Didn’t think I could get any sadder until I re-watched Doomsday for the 5th time. I swear, why do I torture myself with such sadness?
@@badwolf029 I relate to you😭
Look. At him. So broken inside but laughing, joking, and being strong. Because Rose needs it.
When Rose says "I can't think of what to say" is what does it for me. The "I love you" is emotional, yes, but the 1st line is more subtle, realistic and natural. They had all that time together where they said what they wanted, whenever they wanted to each other when they had all the time in the worlds (see what I did there? ;)). Now its their last 2 minutes and they believed they'd never see each other again, the only thing to say is the one thing they never said: how they truly feel. That one line sums i up for me.
agreed!
Definitely. Also Rose's smile after the Doctor says "quite right to" - it's almost like she knows it's a weird thing to say, but it's very him, and she's appreciating every little thing that makes him unique in the little time they have left. Very realistic reaction to me.
This is the saddest moment ever on Doctor Who! 😥😰
Forget that this is the saddest thing in the entire universe
Dante Giello your right, it's not the saddest thing. david tennant's final line as the tenth Doctor is the saddest thing; "i don't want to go."
that is the only line that can bring me to the edge of tears.
Kraai Kyne actually now that I think about it I think i don't want to go and doomsday are tied because seeing rose bawled up and crying is as emotional to me as seeing David say I don't want to go they both literally make tears run down my cheek and I don't really show that much emotions yeah yeah I know what your thinking BLASPHEMY!!!
Dante Giello nah, doctor who and scorpion are the only two shows ever made that can make tears run down my face too. nothing else hits me emotionally as those two shows do.
SP Murphy And what about the episode "Angels in Manhattan" ?
No matter what people say...Rose is the love of his life!!! I'm speaking of 9th and 10th at least....I believe it
It's been confirmed by Steven moffat himself that 11 the doctor still loved rose after all that apart it doesn't matter if he changing into a woman people seem to forget he still the same person
@@charlenerafferty3534 that's what make people confused the doctor's face change then he completely changed, it doesn't mean his personality or his mind do change he is the same person with a new face.
@@atlasjackson8192 well no he becomes a new person he just has all his memories and knowledge of his past lives, you can see his personality and mannerisms change.
I loved this video but it was sooo sad I mean Billie Piper put in
a lot of emotion in that scene I remember seeing something
about this video Billie Piper said she wanted it to be like she
was really losing a good friend that's why you gotta love
Billie Piper for playing Rose she's a great actress.
i was in my room in the middle of the night seeing this episode. All my family were sleeping. DO YOU EVEN KNOW HOW HARD IT WAS TO BE THERE CRYING LIKE IT WAS THE END OF THE WORLD AND TRYING NOT TO MAKE ANY NOISE?!?! That night i laid in my bed crying until i fell asleep.
Yes!! When I cry when I'm hurt or sad, its NOTHING compared to how I cry every time I see this episode. So, when I watch this, it literally takes all my energy not to start bawling out loud. I feel like my heart breaks a little bit, each time I watch this.....
Claire Cleveland exactly. Still hurts.
That`s why i watched this episode alone first not with my mom like usually because i knew it would make me cry
Happening to me rn......I want to scream and sob and here I am crying in silence.......WHY DID THIS HAPPEN MY SOUL HAS BEEN RIPPED APART AND BROKEN INTO A BILLION PIECES
Same
To be honest I like River Song, she was perfect for the Doctor and a great character, but Rose was an amazing, sweet character. The Doctor loved River Song, but he was IN LOVE with Rose Tyler.
Yes. That right there. That is the best way to put it. To explain it. SO many River and Rose fans are at war over this issue, and whilst it pains even me, the most diehard fan of Rose til the bitter end to see River go on about how no one knows the Doctor better than her.... she can't help it. She was in love.... and whilst the Doctor undoubtedly loved her as he is compassionate and kind with EVERYONE he meets.... he was in love with Rose.... she knew him the most... she knew him when he didn't even know himself.
So, this is the reason why I hate River
The Doctor loved River Song, but he was IN LOVE with Clara Oswald.
@@Kiraya No, Clara was more of a bestfriend/daughter figure to him.
@@delinquent8176
Rose is the one he loved the most, but their relationship is impossible.
Clara is, at best, a girlfriend. Both (11 and Clara) didn't say it but thats the way they look at each other.
River Song got lucky. Yes, the Doctor loves and married her. But if Rose is ALSO available, I'm sure he gonna choose Rose.
Rose Tyler, The Bad Wolf, gets the most heartbreaking departure.
Martha walks out the door. No feels.
I thought Martha had a great exit... she took control of her life and walked out of a negative situation. I felt proud of her. I know quite a few people who could learn a lesson from her.
What about Donna? Her exit was heartbreaking as well.
DONNA, AUGUSTA! DONNA!
Seriously though!! same
I love Donna.
3:37 The first time I watched thisI literally yelled "NOOOO!" at the screen
Same bro
same here
I couldn't even use words, I was too busy crying. D:
Taza y Charla doesn’t everybody do that or is it just us 😂😂
Same 😭
bet you this is why they made Skype
strong guy taylor David tennant won’t know what it is
Billie pipers acting in this is phenomenal. The part where is tells him she loves him is just so heartbreaking. You can just feel how much he mattered to her from the vast amount of emotion put into those three words
2020 and still broken heartedly sobbing over this scene. 😢
Lexie Ashmore I feel you bro
same
2021 and here we are again 😭
@@NekoMurasakiX3 I don’t know how but it just gets worse every time doesn’t it?
Very sad....... Indeed.
His little nod at 3:02... I mean, this entire scene is acted impeccably by both of them and still shreds my heart into ribbons with its soul-crushing excellence, but something about that nod speaks so many words. That he knows he's going to be on his own, that Rose won't be there, that he knows how much that concept will devastate her, and that she won't be able to give him the forever she promised him... I mean damn. Billie is remarkable in this scene, but I will never stop saying David Tennant is one of the best actors of all time. He doesn't have to say a word to say *EVERYTHING.*
@@jonbaszkiewicz “On your own?” 😞
Ten's "You're not.." could either be him hoping she didn't move on that quickly and have a baby with Mickey, or him fearing it's his because they absolutely had a physical relationship even if it wasn't shown.
Probably moved on
Well she was his girlfriend
I'm definitely of the opinion (and will always be unless one of them actually comes out and says it one day) that they never made it to a physical relationship. I have a laundry list of reasons why I believe that, but one relating to that line would be the fact that I think he'd react a hell of a lot differently if there were any even remote chance that he was finding out she was pregnant with HIS child. I've seen this so many times and I've only ever taken that line and delivery to mean, "Oh my god, you've not only moved on, but you've moved on enough to get yourself pregnant? Bitch, I'm still over here MOURNING your ass!"
"because they absolutely had a physical relationship"
Literally no evidence of this
@@Dead25m Actually, to add to your point, since posting my comment, I have since verified that they did *not* have a physical relationship!
Via ContactMusic in 2005:
“Tennant, who plays the Doctor in the cult BBC show, refuses to allow the writers to introduce anything other than the most innocent romance into the cult series. He says, ‘The story between the Doctor and Rose is basically a love story without the shagging’… ‘It’s still absolutely celibate. I think that's very important.’”
Not that you need more proof, but just to hammer it home… David Tennant at Wizard World 2015, when discussing Tentoo (the Metacrisis tenth Doctor from Journey’s End):
“How galling it is to watch someone who looks like you, who basically *is* you, get to do all the shagging you didn’t get to do.”
As a fanfiction writer who specializes in Ten/Rose “first time fics”, I was over the moon with this validation, hahaha. What’s important to note, however, is that canonically, the Doctor and Rose DO have a physical relationship now. They’re married and in love and have a daughter named Mia Tyler and (I mean we’re all just assuming this bit but) they absolutely fuck all the goddamn time. Amen.
[Source on that last bit: ‘Empire of the Wolf’, ‘Flight Into Hull!’]
I applaud the writers of doctor who, it's so brilliant how you can make your audience feel such sadness when no main character even died! now that's excellent writing, I agree this has to be one of the greatest moment in sci fi film I have ever seen, not because of 10 and Rose's romance, but because of how well the scene was delivered and the thought of leaving your loved ones in a parallel world, man it was mind-boggling to think of!
Never mind "sci fi film" It was the greatest scene in cinematic history and I've been there since 3 channel black and white tv.
3:07
Have you ever felt that? When it’s so strong, so hard to say, it just hurts so much to even say it, that you just can’t on the first try?
I have. Props to Billie Piper. She got it across.
So powerful :(
I am extremely well read, anything and everything from the last 2 centuries in Europe and the US, I've probably read. I am also an etymologist which means that I am "into" the science of the root origin of words and their subtleties and nuances. Yet, still, with all that at instant recall, many times I find that words are completely inadequate for the depth of things I feel; the love I feel for my 4 children. The baby (now 26) is the only one that lives close by. I tell her all the time that I wouldn't take the entire universe in exchange for her, and that if I had to choose between the universe and her it's her every time. That I would give up my life for her with not a second's thought for her. I hope she believes me because it's the truth. I am so very proud to be her dad.
The way Rose says “Am I ever gonna see you again?” absolutely breaks me
There’s such genuine pain and anguish in her voice
And at the end, where you see The Doctor’s mouth open, then close along with his eyes while lowering his head; you can see him pushing down the wave of sadness that almost overwhelms him, the tears still going down his face
Roses are red,
The TARDIS is blue,
The Doctor once said,
Rose Tyler I....
Nope, he only said Rose Tyler. Never said the word I at all
Loras? Weren't you, like, blown up or something?
Lupin? aren't you supposed to be dead 19 years ago or something?
just another Hufflepuff Touché.
Rose is blond tho
and the TARDIS is blue
I see this "joke" ones more
I'll hit all of you.
10 years and i'm still cry like a baby when i see this. What the hell you did to me BBC?!? :(
Saddest scene in Doctor Who history
Wait how? I've never seen DW before is there an inside joke I don't understand?
+bearisol he's cruel,don't listen to him.😂😭😭😭😭
+EnderPro nope adric getting blown uo trying to save the world was, u are a newbie
+Tommy Orr Jr It was truly one of the saddest moments from the new series.
for me the most emotional moment was wilf saying goodbye to the doctor at donnas wedding
“two universes would collapse”
“so?”
:’(
9 and 10 were my favorite doctors. The era with Rose was a part of my childhood, so maybe I'm biased. This scene made me almost die choking on my own tears. I've seen the classics, I've seen a little bit of the newer ones (however the newer ones were just so difficult to get through) David Tennet is such a sweetheart and an amazing actor as The Doctor, and Billie Piper completely took my heart as Rose
2:55
Doctor: Same old life. Last of the Time Lords.
Rose: On your own?
Me: (Thinks of Martha, Donna, River, Amy, Rory, Clara)
Doctor: …
Burning the sun, just to see you here,
You see me blurry, then so clear.
You cry and bawl, I have to hold back my tears,
I have to tell you something, I can't have any fears.
Now I'm going to be fancy, and say your name first,
But my time is up and in tears we both burst.
Almost said the words, I was oh so close,
But it still goes through my mind, "I love you my Rose."
My feeeellllllssss!!!!
Such beautiful lines😌😍👍
yashi verma Thanks. The 10th doctor can do that to you.. Or any doctor actually.
+Famia Qureshi THAT WAS BEAUTIFUL *sobs*
*quietly sobs in a corner*
I don't even watch Doctor Who and I'm crying like a baby.
Same here!
Emily H. I was looking for this comment. I've never watch it either. This makes me want to watch it.
If you watch it , watch it from the ninth doctor not himmm watch fron the beginning
Hayleigh Smith awesome thanks for that info
Rood Nverse have you watched it by now? ^^
10th Doctor: Rose, I love you.
*MESSAGE NOT DELIVERED*
3:57 omg OMG HE TRIES TO GET IT OUT BUT HE CHOKES ON HIS WORDS I CAN'T IM CRYING
* scrolls down, sees Doomsday video on Subscription feed *
Me: "Am I gonna do this to myself?"
Me: ...
* clicks *
Me: "Yep, I'm gonna do this to myself."
Gods, I remember sobbing and ugly crying at this
Same. Heaving sobs from my gut.
i just finished watching this for the first time today and my eyes are puffy fron ugly crying.
Nope nope nope nope nopeity nope [flies away] nope nope nope
nope nope nopeity noo i'm dead goodbye just no..... UGLY CRYING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm laughing so hard😂
“I’m burning up a sun just to say goodbye”
If that's not love...then I don't know what is
Rose: “Am I gonna see you again?”
Ten: “You can’t.”
The Moment: “Hold my wibbly wobbly timey wimey thingy... stuff.”
When I started watching Doctor Who I thought that Rose would be with the Doctor forever. Every time I watch this scene I still cry like a baby c.c
I know your comment is crazy old now, but Rose DID wind up getting to stay with her Doctor forever :)
It broke my heart too:(
This was pretty much the last time I ever cried over the leaving of a companion. I mean the others were sad, but this one sucked the rest of the tears out of me.
Tell me I wasn't the only one crying the whole time
And when I saw the doctor's face I broke
4 years later, I tell you that your are not alone at all. I saw this episode with my father, fortunately he wasn't looking at me, so I cryied all the freaking time in silence. Then I stayed all the night crying and thinking about this.
3:59
Excuse me Matt I was having a MOMENT
The way she proclaims her love and the fact he never got to tell her the same absolutely crushes whatever heart remains in my chest
How many tears did the doctor cry? A river, enough to fill two ponds at least enough to water a rose.
MrGillerhoon THIS COMMENT HOLY SHIT
Get out.
He looks so old when hes talking to Rose, like the 900 years start to show.
I recently re-watched series 1-4 (including the specials) and it made me appriciate how good David Tennant was. He always was my favourite Doctor and always will be, but it put in perspective how Doctor Who has changed since not only Matt Smith came along, but Moffat came along. It has changed into something that is for children, with cheesy plot lines and stupid defeats. I understand why people like him and I agree he has written some amazing stories. But all in all I miss T.Davis because in my opinion it was so, so much better.
I agree in 110%.
I agree, Russell was so much better, however Moffat did make some pretty good stories back in day being 'The Empty Child' 2 parter. Now he just takes ideas from other shows and makes them dr who, also Capaldi is so boring!
Thomas Gilbert I agree with everything you said except for Capaldi being boring. He's awesome. His episodes suck, but he's good.
toypuppet I mean yes, sometimes Davies' writing would not be at the best he could do, it was still good and he was good at being a show runner. He would 'hirer' good writers and make sure the stories where good. I think Moffat can be a good writer (like he has shown) but I think he finds it hard to run the show and write. Also, the monsters we get know, big, un-scary robots?! The thing I liked about RTD was that he would make a basic design so scary or creative - Moffat just seems to see how many SFX shots can get in!
Dickson Productions I dunno, Moffat did pretty awesome with the Vashta Nerada and the Weeping Angels (well.. the first time he used them in Blink). That thing in Time Heist was pretty cool, but then again, I thought that entire episode was fantastic.
Watching this in 2021 - still crying like a baby.
This breaks my heart. Doctor was never the same ever since :'-(
1:40 his face is so sad, and it's either because he thinks it's his or that Rose has already moved on, either way his face makes is so damn sad how is Tennant so good at acting
Best Doctor David Tennant we miss you u.u
no we don't
This will continue to break my heart:(
I So Agree *My Heart Breaks*
wait... the way that she paused as if she was unsure if she was going to tell him about the baby, what if she really was pregnant and just didn't want him to know, Plus the way that he looked at her when she said "-and the baby" that must mean that they...
*creepy laughter that turns into crying*
Help I've been stabbed in the feels :(
Dancing Hufflepuff I thought his reaction was weird too, but I assumed he would have felt hurt if she said she's already with someone else (moving on quite fast). Your theory is interesting.. but nah! I don't think the Doctor would do that with his companions. I mean even falling in love was something he tried to stray from and after failing at it with Rose, he learned from his mistake.
Karrie Dreammind Then again he has had kids before and he’s close enough as a human to compatibly have sex with her, I wouldn’t be too surprised if they did have sex. It would definitely be Rose making the first move, but if she was in a right state of mind I think the Doctor would go along with it. They’ve mentioned physical attraction between them both before, not just romantic.
Get that fanfiction out of here son! This comment section should be a place of mourning!
Jackie says in series 4 she had a baby
This guts me even harder knowing later on when River tells Clara, "he hates endings"
Knowing how many people he loses is devastating but I'd argue that Rose is really the love of his life until River, and even with River it was never this special. I wish we had been able to see more of River like we got with Rose. But alas
Billie Piper is an amazing actress omg
I STILL wonder why he will never say those 3 words
"I love you"
He was about to, but the star burnt out.
I think doctor already knew when it's gonna burn. He just didnt find that courage. Cus he likes his proud more than he likes Rose.
wELL IT HITS ME IN THE HEART AND I GET SENSITIVE WHEN I SEE HIM CRY ,w,
Because that would've been a kick in the balls to all of us who hate Rose.
*****
Eh.
Why would they care if we hate her lel
I'm here again... breaking my own heart...
10 years on and this scene still gets to me 😭
It's not just you. It is the greatest scene in cinematic history. Bar none.
I don't know why but Doomsday is one of the only TV shows episode/movies that I have ever cried at more than once...I mean it been 11 years and it still kills be every single day 💔
Still. Makes. Me. Want. To. Shrivel. Up.
It's not just you. It is the greatest scene in cinematic history. Bar none.
I was 9 when this aired and I sobbed my little 9 year old heart out.
I’m now 27 rewatching this, sobbing my little 27 year old heart out.
When I first saw this episode my heart broke :( And everytime I remember how great Rose and The Doctor were I feel so sad. I love the Eleventh Doctor, Amy, Rory and the other doctors and companions, but Rose will always be that special person that made the Doctor truly happy
**Disclaimer**
Rose went away so the doctor was blue
Ask Donna where's the doctor
She'll reply "Dr. Who?"
Sara Jane and Martha and now both the Ponds
Had their fun with the Doctor
And now they're all gone
So ask me again
Why the TARDIS is blue
There's a sad man inside
With both his hearts... Turn in two
By jupis0990
Out of here.
♡
Wow
ANee LL2 This poem is just going all over the place isn't it
Dude that is clever and heart breaking what the frick
You could never accuse Rose of being a great beauty but that was one of *the* most heartbreaking scenes ever in Doctor Who, and possibly on television ever. I can't recall anything in the past 60 years that caught me the way that scene did. I was *so* pleased when she finally became the only 'companion' ever to have kept her doctor. That's why I voted the Rose Tyler arc the greatest storyline ever and Rose herself as the greatest companion, she did what none of the others ever did... she got her man!! :D
"You could never accuse Rose of being a great beauty" What?!
BlueSwede92 ok... I was being polite. Rose was no beauty at all. She was sort of pretty and cute in her own way but even that is doing her a favour. The *character* was well portrayed by Billie Piper, but in real life I doubt she'd be looked at twice!!
I mean it's fine if you think she's not pretty, but that's so not the point. She wasn't chosen to be just a pretty face you know.
@@pandariri2694 rose is pretty even Cassandra says she surprising beautiful
@@charlenerafferty3534 oh yeah I agree, but the og comment didn't seem to think so
his true love. the one person to help him feel love again. after a millennia. Someone the doctor can never forget.
And that’s how you tell a truly heartbreaking love story. The whole River thing felt like it was being shove down our throats.
We were repeatedly told how great River Song was and how great their relationship was, but the chemistry was never that good.
@@andrewtucker94 River actually work with 12 in my opinion (but only with him)
Just watched "The Last September" with Maggie Smith, Michael Gambon, Fiona Shaw (Aunt Petunia), and the man himself, David Tennant.
I mention this because, in one of the scenes, a distraught soldier (played by David Tennant) leans over to pick up a fallen rose. The look on his face was so heartbreaking. He had recently been told he could never have the woman he loved.
The movie came out five years before Christopher Eccleston even began his role as the Ninth Doctor.
It's funny, isn't it? The little coincidences in life. Those random acts of karma or of irony.
It was as if, even then, the world knew that one day another soldier would pick up a rose. And it would change both their lives forever.
I think he was going to say "see you in two years time"
He was gonna say," I love you" I think
(as I cry/laugh/ cough/choke/ convulse/TRY to keep from peeing on myself) I HATE YOU BUT YOU'RE BRILLIANT!! That's one of the FUNNIEST comments I've ever seen, none of your business!
+Lorelei O'Brien phan
Not crying, just a time vortex in your eye.
Lol totally
Damn it I have a TARDIS in my eye.
Damn it I have a TARDIS in my eye.
One of the saddest moments in Doctor Who history for me. Rose was my favorite companion, and she loved the doctor so much and would never leave him. First time seeing the doctor cry..
2:59 always makes me think of, "who's gonna hold his hand now?" from Fear Her.
Thanks mate, as if this scene wasn't sad enough
I bet he fell in love with her at the end of series 1 when she absorbed the time vortex it made her see what until then only he could see and if that doesn't build close bonds I don't know what dose
I'm not sure when he fell in love with her, I know he was definitely jealous of her and Mickey in "Boom Town" but I don't think he#d reached the love stage just yet.
Well he definitely felt closer to her
@@Charizarzar the TV tropes states that rose for both 9and 10 was rose was not just a companion she was also his partner and rose became the doctor best friend and love
The way he looked after she said baby killed me
Wait when
This scene always breaks my heart every time. They had such a deep bond, a powerful beautiful love for each other.
0:45 can we talk about her reaction to his smile? Thinking that she’s not gonna see him smiling again hurts her this much 😭 it’s been over a decade and I still cry like a baby every time I watch this episode 💔
0:12 you can tell he's gonna cry when he's done talking to her
Good acting by David Tennant at 3:52. Such a heartbreaking moment.
This would've been the perfect ending for Rose. It was sad yes, but good. Personally I didn't like that they brought Rose back in the 4th series. And the ending with the Meta Crisis Doctor and all that.. didn't like it :/
His face and the way he asked her if she is pregnant made me understand that he was worried its his and if he thought that it is his, its only mean one thing.
this is actually the only scene that's ever got me to actually full blown start crying over fictional characters :,)
how could they tear my babies apart? I will never recover.