Xiaomi Cyber Dog vs. Boston Dynamics Spot! (Watch their reveals)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ส.ค. 2021
- Both companies now have robotic dogs that can perform amazing tasks. Watch their respective reveals and see how the two products compare, right here.
#cyberdog #spot - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![ไม่ต้องมีที่ที่ให้ฉันอยู่ แต่ขอแค่มีฉันอยู่ก็พอ (Spaceless) - getsunova [SHORT FILM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MuT0d_cvJkc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Evolution of Boston Dynamic’s Robots [1992-2023]](/img/n.gif)
No need to compare, Boston made to be a working dog, Cyber Dog made to be a pet.
@Dijhili lol
Get a real living breathing dog if you want a pet, not that useless pointless battery powered machine.
*toy
Pet is different from toy. It's not a pet by any means
Pet is different from toy. It's not a pet by any means
Boston Dynamics Spot is for working and creation, Xiaomi Cyber Dog is just for fun.
Get a cat or a dog, but not just for entertainment, an animal have feelings and can give you much more love and happines than the Xiaomi cyber dog, thats why is useless.
FoxyFazbear001 or get Sony aibo
What work? Become food delivery robot? Its just a waste of money
that is the normal evolution.
@@wumaobot like the video said, spot is meant for dangerous sites where it isn't safe for humans and needs to have kept maintenance, or just the process of automation. Just because you have no use for one, or will ever likely see one doesn't mean the product is useless, it just means you are not the targeted demographic.
Lets be honest the comparison is between $2000 vs $70,000
No it's about a robotics company vs a phone company.
@@bright5967 bruh, Xiaomi sells a lot of things , not just phones
¥9999 RMB=$1540 USD
@@yudogcome5901 hello, add tax and shipping = $2000. I know because I just got one😁
@@Fightback2023 我也想要一个
The outlookings are pretty much the same, but the key is if they show the similar performances. Cyber Dog ($1547) is designed for home automation purposes, and Boston Dynamic Spot ($74500) is meant for professional usages.
What do u mean by home automation? What does it actually do?
CyberDog is also waterproof you can take outdoor. People on TH-cam are commenting as if they know everything but in fact they don't.
@@RIZFERD Cyberdog is actually not waterproof, Xiaomi claimed it's life-waterproofing, which is in fact water resistant. And sure, no one said that you cannot take it out. I do agree with you that some people are commenting like they know everything, but in fact they don't. LOL!
Where did you get 1547? It's going for $5k
Didn’t take long for the Chineses to buy a version of Spot and make a cheap toy copy of it…
Ikr, how unusual
Thats how its done.
The Chinese are efficient, they turn something expensive and limited into something good and cheap and with a million versions Xiaomi is the best at it!!
@@leonardobernardoalves for sure! They’re the model of design and production! And the quality of work and reliability is just off of the scales! Awe inspiring
@@leonardobernardoalves research and development costs billions. Copying years of research and mass production does not cost much.
Cyber: " Do you know Sarah Connor "
Spot: " I have detailed files "
Cyberdog is a good robot, but can it pee beer into a cup for thirsty party guests?
Michael reeves that crazy youtuber 😂😂
Lol, good idea!
no chance, cyberdog cant hold that big piss shooter
🤣
Why do you want that? 😹😹
Of course when you just copy and paste from the original you can sell it for cheap.
Sound good..
0 innovation Just copy.
lol, you try copy & paste one? do a mechanical engineering degree before you open your hole.
yeah open source not copy
I want to see you face when you realize that Unitre robotics created the first robot dog and not Boston dynamics
bruh this is not a competition. spot has almost every feature we would need
for 75000 vs 1500, yeah, it's not a competition, its a massacre
@@zes3813 fair point
It is not a competition??? You have not met the CCP...
The price difference puts them in 2 different tiers, it’s fair to compare keeping that in mind
Nah the world need da one cheaper
if Cyber Dog is for fun, they should at least give them a cuter look
its used in world war 3. who says anything about cute.
Velcro fur and a tail.
Opportunity for third party developers to provide Cyber Dog accessories, like fuzzy pajamas, floppy ears, wagging tail and sloppy wet tongue. After all, Barbie has fashion clothes, pink Mercedes, Dream House and a mobile home. Maybe next Christmas?
One is meant to be a toy, and the other a tool. It is like comparing a robot vacuum to a $5 Walmart remote controlled toy car.
Then tell me which company bought BD Spot for what tasks.
@@feifeishuishui Spot is meant for tasks like search and rescue, or emergency response like in a nuclear reactor failure. I do not know anyone is actively using it as such. You can see this in the ad they have.
@@Mariobrownio1989 , SpaceX actually uses Spot to go inspect rocket launch sites right after a launch/landing. It's way too dangerous for humans as the propellants are toxic to humans and/or there are risks of explosion. Spot shines in this use case.
@@debayanDas That's great, lol, I did not know it was in actual use. Thanks for sharing. The xiaomi one is just a toy unfortunately, Maybe next generation they can add some functionality.
Yeah a single Spot is more useful than a single Cyber Dog, but for the price of a single Spot, you can get like 50 Cyber Dogs.
but, the Cyber Dog can do EVERYTHING that Spot can.... not sure you have done your research here.
Yes, spot is for firms. Cyberdog for pet.
@@orion7741 not even close, are you actually blind?
if you go to a shelter you can get a free real dog
... that do absolutely nothing 50x.
If the Cyber Dog can't piss beer, it doesn't hold a candle to Spot.
Boston dynamics: makes something that looks cute and unintimidating
Xiami: eh yo, you guys ever watch robocop
It’s like anything consumer-level vs. pro/industrial-level. Cameras (photo or video) are 10-20X as much at the pro level. Same with computers/servers. Same with shelving. Because the pro/industrial-level products work fully 99.99999% of the time, can take abuse, and provide solutions for complex workflows and integrations with other software/hardware- because businesses can count on them. CyberDog is consumer-level- if you’ve ever seen people using them out in the wild, they fall over, they trip on things, they get their routes confused, and they’re relatively weak (can carry/pull much of anything).
Spot and CyberDog are completely different classes of products. CyberDog roughly looks like Spot, but is much closer to a Sony AIBO- an expensive toy that’ll do things right 75-90% of the time and has a few cute canned tricks. They only seem similar on the surface.
:0
Ok
The quality is directly proportional to their cost.
Doing an assignment by oneself compared to copying another's assignment while adjusting values so that they look different.
That's ALL they do is copy and steal. Not one original thought in a thousand years.
@@THE-X-Force Yes the US loves to copy and steal just ask the Germans.
@@THE-X-Force BD copied Xiaomi. What a disgrace. After Hyndai bought BD, guess what, Hyundai realized that 80% of BD projects are CGI. lmfao
I want this kind of mechine fixed with a high end camera and a two way voice communication to watch/observe my parameters. at home through remote access . This will come very handy for people who wanna keep a track of what is happening in a remote location.
Not sure what you actually want but Spot is supposed to be able to be installed with sensors and do remote site surveys. You can have a look at their youtube channel.
That's what spot does, I guess this might do it as well
U can use drones though
@@lucretius8050 thank you. I shall look in to it. But how about the cost ? I think the cyber dog is less expensive . Thank u for the reply
@@hrsh042 drons are really hard to manoeuvre even in line of sight. Im sure it is not that effective to control over internet .
I wonder when the Chinese government downloaded Boston dynamics database.
@@TimTheMusicMan Does it means that Americans are complete idiots? I don't know, when you're saying somebody is stealing from you, and that keeps happening over and over, it starts to sound like you're an idiot who never learns.
@@feizai245 Chinese Americans enjoy the same right, freedoms and opportunities as any other Americans. Preventing Chinese Americans from working in American labs, industries or universities is against Constitutional Rights. Unfortunately, anybody can be bribed with enough incentive from the CCP Regime.
@@chrisgraham2904 So you're saying, American top companies, that employ the best talents money can buy, spending hundreds of millions on think tanks and RnD, couldn't figure out how to safekeeping their IP from being stolen, over and over and over and over...? You seriously find that makes sense?
I wish it could run at least 40kmph and follow me on my EUC. I have the maveric pro zoom, but with drones you have to worry about them flying into tree branches and/or crashing from heights.
Great!.. Thank you!..
I have used HTML and JavaScript to design web pages, is there something similar being developed for robotics - a general all purpose cross platform robotics language?
ROS
APIs
@@z0x not dumb, just curious if a cross platform language has been developed, robotics is kind of new so it many not have happened like it had for HTML and the web. Otherwise you use a lower level language such as C or assembler. Essentially every new project starts from scratch.
Maybe c++?
@Zeb truee ....
"Mom, I want a Boston Dynamics robot dog!"
"We have a robot dog at home"
Robot dog at home: Xiaomi cyber dog
cyber dog is more like a testing and development kit, they make it cheap with no profit because they want everyone to join and develop together. While Spot is fully developed by Boston dynamic and ready for commercial use
And cyber dog may be stolen tech
@@josephgrn2818 i think they copy the idea, if they have stolen tech from Boston Dynamic, it should work better
Quite literally the other way around. Spot is a true test bed for companies (not individual consumers yet) to adapt and find a use for. Cyber dog is just for bored amazon surfers to feel like the own a Spot. Plus cyber dog is a quintessential chinese knock off; stolen tech + cheap materials with only 1% of the features.
Pfffttt develop. Money oriented. 😀
Commercial and Industrial use
CNET: "see how the two products compare"
How can we when there's no translation? Why upload a video with a minutes-long segment in Chinese with no translation?
he's not saying anything interesting. just talking to a "dog"...
He’s right- just talking to a dog
learn Chinese and stop being ignorant
@@savagefrito Hmmm yes, they sure are ignorant for not knowing a language to understand an internet video. It's not like asking for a translation is a reasonable thing and being a translator is a profession that takes skill.
U don't expect english language from a country who had been independently successfully for decades and created a Dog AI robot
They only managed to make a pet out of it. Nothing close to Boston Dynamic's Spot, which is a utility robot for helping humans and not merely for entertainment.
that is just the civilian model. The Chinese military will have a war model. Plus they can scale it up and beef up the motors and plug new software.
@@maolo76 You make it sound like the americans wont be able to do that. Pretty sure they already have.
How can the spot help human? Sending food?
@@wumaobot please check the video and you should see that it's capable of going to places hazardous to humans like a construction site to understand the work status just an example. And may be delivering food 🍲, but that can be done by drones 😀
so you are comparing only the intention but not the actual tech.
Boston Dynamics 1000000x times better in all ways.
Example in what ? Has a more rugged look and both are drones, so what exactly those "better" things? Their physical abilities are same/similar and their operational software as well. One looks like made for contraction the other looks more like a toy...but abilities same/similar. The main difference that Boston Dynamic is specialized on this since 1992 spent hundreds of millions developing things...whole Xiaomi is a phone company started in 2010 with way less money but tons of men power. Teenager kids can build drones these days and BD is stuck/minimal growth (am certain we got a military version super bot) at a level that they were basically 10 years ago. We are not as advanced as I wish we were.
whats the price spanish hora
@@thetruthalwaysscary cry
@@adolfhitler7394 lol...if I got your name, I would
Thats a lot of zeros O.O
Were the flashing lights and blaring EDM music necessary Xiaomi?
Yeah i think im sticking to my golden retriever. At least they are cute
Do both of those know when they're lowbat and dock themselves like a roomba?
Roomba sucks!
@@siphotheguy1870 now you didn't , roombas will now haunt you in your sleep
I know the spot will. Not sure about the other one
not fair, create vs copy
hey i got 2000 does it come in yellow??
I would like to buy a cyber dog. Boston dynamic has to sell dog with lower price, and has to be checked with security purpose. To make sure no bug in the dog.
If anything, this communist lab rat worker is making American products sound better.
@@abrahamg3354 I swear bro these Chinese companies only copy paste and people support them as if they make a breakthrough discovery
I swear bro india and usa been stealing, copy and paste China's invented inks, papers and explosive powders and people support them as if they make a breakthrough discovery
The USA stolen German military Technologie 🤷♂️
Xiaomi: A CCP spy cam, that faithfully follows you around your home.
Boston Dynamics: A spy cam that that snitches on your extended work break.
Boston Dynamic's Spot will immediately report you to the feds.
The most amazing thing about Cyber Dog is that it understands Chinese language! Seriously, Boston Dynamics Spot! is clearly intended to work alongside humans in dangerous environments and act as a practical extension to humans capabilities. The BD presentation emphasizes its capabilities and these interactions. On the other hand the Cyber Dog presentation of Xiaomi is showy and flashy and shows a robot that can do some tricks and looks cool. My impression is that it is an expensive toy for rich people. It is however remarkably similar looking to Spot!. I guess imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
Obviously they intend to iterate.
Patents please.
You know' xaomi is introducing cyberdog to the people to learn more and adopt before going to heavy industry.
the secret is cyberdog was remote controlled from back stage. :)
20 plus years R&D, versus 1 year of copying and reverse engineering. And yes, Aibo exists and you would never suspect they copied Spot.
they are looks similar. which one the original dog robot ?
A little bit of a strobe light warning would have been nice
I can guarantee that it will turn out like most chinese copies that's it just looks good as for what it can do it's like in iron man 2 the famous line "I can make them salute"
But for research purposes, that it has a price that makes it more "disposable" (relatively speaking) may make it more attractive than spot
Man but some Chinese brands are becoming leaders in their field. Xiaomi is one of them, also the biggest consumer drone company right now is a chinese brand DJI.
Healthy competition is good
@@12xenn45 Their are many open source projects that copy what spot does they just took those designs and used economy of scale to capitalize. Its what theyve been doing for over 10 years now.
@@12xenn45 most of the time it is cheaper either due to no R&D costs(copy) or due to Chinese government subsidization.
What's this I can used to war vibe (cyber ) vs I can be integrated into your daily life (spot) vibe
1:50 if one of my employees shot an $80,000 robot in the face / cameras with sparks from a grinder they would be so fired lol.
I'll buy one when it has the capability to attach a gun
man, too late, boys have tried months ago
well spot is programmable so?
That robot is Atlas.
it has a paid load of 2-3Kg , easily able to mount a hand gun with firing mechanism.
CyberDog is a toy. Spot is a true robot! Boston Dynamics for the win!
They look almost similar to the dot. Enter "Hey, wait a minute!" meme. :)
For learning, for the price of a high-end mobile I can give initiation courses in robotics to my child. That's just cool!
I'm not about to pay $70k (money I don't have) to rent something that I can own for $2k.
If you think they are the same product then that explains why you're broke.
I love how Boston Dynamic showed it navigating difficult terrain which was just a ramp with junk attached to the side.
True, but there was a sprinkle of wood pieces on the otherwise perfect ramp🤣
And then a staircase that the Chinese toy probably wouldn't even recognize, but it can make nice turns, right?
와우! 더 진화하고 멋있어졌네! 👍👍👍👍👍
Wait, you changed the music for spot launch!
Xiaomi once again casually stealing the market :3
Chinese traditon!
🤣
It’s what ccp does best
@@kushalvishnu8266 Only thing they can do!
@Mit Shuler Chinese companies are known for stealing and copying others.
It's Chinese tradition. No doubt
Lets be honest, The US Army will purchase hundreds of it, fit a machine gun on top and parachute it down to enemy line.
Then they'll leave everyone there, and leave with their tails between their legs!!
That robot is call Atlas.
Cyber dog looks like it could make a good guard/patrol dog
I don't get the Cyberdog... People like dogs because they're cute and loyal and playful and that thing is just... not that.
The construction site commercial for Spot is awesome, in that it really displays the capabilities, but it failed to show any compelling use-cases. That's top priority - how will it be useful?
Seems, at the moment, that it's use-cases are pretty niche. Looking forward to what Atlas can do. And, in the future, Tesla Bot.
NYFD uses it in rescue situations with a FLIR. Great tech
Boston dynamics is far ahead of everyone else... Come on Dog kkk
Can you make a robot cat? Or no. A robot ME to go to work 4me
Sure..... But, can you afford it?
@@gamedemo6589 thanks for helping me with it
cyber dog, such an original name
I bet the ATF has a whole unit working hard at how they are going to handle their 3am raids when these become ubiquitous
Make em fight!!
u mean make em shoot?
To the Chinese there is no Copyright just copy right.
Didn't BD make some big versions for the military several years ago? It got shelved for being too loud or something. Makes me wonder how long these ones are
No, BD just got caught shilling CGI crap.
Do you want to say anything about the Intellectual Property here CNET??
Boston Dynamics is the god father of all
xioami is the Godfather in tech
@@BlackMamba-lt8oe are you dumb these Chinese companies only copy paste why don’t you look it up
Boston Dynamics robot is just better in every way, Cyber Dog is just a pet for kids
a pet for rich kids
When one cost 70,000 and the other 1,000 you'd better pray to god that the 70,000 one is better..
But is it better than 70 of them operating as a drone swarm? It's not even better than two of them if we're talking about surveillance purposes.
Cyber dog also moves at 3km/s, spot only 1.5km/s. Cyber dog also has twice the battery life as spot and operates twice as long before needing charge.
Spot can take the specialist role for rich people, while cyber dog will be the one in everyone's homes.
In the end even us military will buy Chinese cyber dog, just like they bought Chinese DJI drones instead of American drones. Even after USA congress banned military from using it, they did not listen and still used it because the American one cost twice as much while having half the ability.
@ex0duzz because cyberdog doesn't do anything. 20 cyberdogs still wouldn't be able to get you a drink from your fridge, spot can do that. Spot is being sold to construction companies, firemen and cops right now. And the cyberdog is being sold to Gangnam Insta kids
@@0x0michael It doesn't do anything? Hahahaha. That's like saying small surveillance drones dont do anything. These are the first model and basically prototype. Wait until they put some bombs on them, or guns.
Cyber dog can be marketed as home.defense or surveillance, patrol your house and be remote controllable etc, put a bomb or gun on it and it's a self walking home defense system, or csn be used by military..
Ask usa military if they prefer DJI drones for cheap or they prefer ones that cost 70x more but do basically the same thing.
The construction thing is a joke, and we all know it. The real use will be for military and surveillance, where price and numbers mean everything.
You think Xiaomi cannot make the same thing as spot if they spent 70x more? They could probably make exactly the same as spot for 10x more but they know it's just dumb and no one would buy it and basically not much profit compared to mass market vs specialist rich people market..
Lol you will pay 70,000 just to get a beer from the fridge? Lmao if you csn afford that you already will have a human butler in your house. If xiaomi wanted to do that they could do it easily.
But I'm curious, show me the video where it csn get the beer from the fridge by itself? I didn't know spot had arms that could grab.
Spot on, with spot!
Helping bring the end of days closer and closer
I prefered a lot boston comparâtes to xiaomi
If cyberdog malfunctions, are they gonna eat it?
Yulin festival
I love the challenge! 😹😹
It's not much of a challenge when all they do is steal other people's hard work and innovation. That's everything they have _"created"_ in the last 100 years.
Cyber dog looks like straight out from sci-fi movies. Wish that they could add ton of functional features.
does Cyber Dog watch out Uyghur or Tibet?
Im14andThisIsDeep
Europe is just a peninsula of Asia
@@PLATONU why does Chinese attach Uyghur & Tibet so badly all the time?
Spot's target is construction, while Cyber Dog's target is humanity.
But what do they do?
That's astonishing
people being affectionate to a robot dog n petting it is weird vibes
Agreed.
Imagine your dog help you in many works instead of just being cute 🔥
Can I get one to ride to work instead of my Ebike?
"Big Dog"by Boston Dynamics carries up to 400 lbs.
xiaomi made a cute circus dog, boston dynamics is working on functional anatomy, resistance, programming capabilities and space tech uses and human needs.
If spot can do this, imagine what atlas could do
Use for what? Food delivery?
I feel bad for Boston d they done all the hard work and some thug came and copy paste it
is a samsumg phone a copy of an iphone? no they're competing products serving different segments of the market. cry more american
@@afgor1088 eh people r so jelous of America on American site,am not American though
@@hardeeps4159 sure you're not 🙄
@@afgor1088 It's not the same thing, use your brain, Samsung and Iphones have different designs and different OS, in this case they took the same product, made it worse and sold for entertainment as a pet? Just because those imbeciles eat dogs?!?! Btw i'm italian, saying this because it seems you have a fetish about the american getting angry when someone deliberatly copies their work, which for you is legit.
@@afgor1088 actually yes. When a company steals or copies the patents developed by another company for its own products, it is theft. What's more, iPhone sued and there were several lawsuits against Samsung. Even several US companies have sued Chinese companies for the same, one is the case of Tesla with its cars.
There's no comparison, Boston dynamics have years of experience in robotics department, Xiaomi, well... just copied BD robot. That's what Chinese companies do best, copying everything. Tbh, cyber dog looks more like a toy than BD robot, that is actually a tool.
agreed
@@JohnKuang-rf6fb years of experience can be replaced in months with a super computer, you are the first, doesn't mean you are the best!
Just liked 5G from Huawei, when the West losing the lead? Banned it. Lol! So called free market. 😂
@@albertwang5974 Stealing others technology better keep the mouth shut
ภาวะกาแฟ ก็เหมือน กัน กับ เบอดี้ แต่เป็น ตรงอีกร้านนึง
Spot seem to be the one to get the job done.
The Xiomi one looks like a bigger cockroach 😂
Xiaomi created a machine that can flip! Hmmmm… I wonder what the purpose is…
It's a metal pet
if a robot dog can flip mean it motor is strong and it speedy to react to it environment , check youtube many build their own robot dog, a few can jump and the holy grail is they can flip but they require very expensive motor to do the job.
@@jetli740 $a dollar toy can flip too.
One = Hype
One = Proper tech
But… can cyberdog pee beer in a cup?
I DON’T THINK SO! 😆
Mrs Jane is legit and her method works like magic I keep on earning every single week with her new strategy
Wow I' m just shock someone mentioned expert Mrs Jane I thought I' m the only one trading with her
She helped me recover what I lost trying to trade my self
I think I'm blessed because if not I wouldn't have met someone who is as spectacular as expert Mrs Jane
I think she is the best broker I ever seen
Mrs Jane is obviously the best, I invested $3,000 and she made profit of $28,000 for me just in 15 days
Cyberdog is a toy and spot is a tool thats the difference
getting closer to those Terminators. i mean at least red lights
Feels like watching those phone comparison videos that's made just to get views. Take some stock videos and bam!
90 minute runtime? Hard pass ill wait for version 10
If it charges fast enough.. it can do maybe 270(90x3) minutes which is a little more than a part time position.
Meant to say 270 minutes within 24 hrs
worth the features
you can also put additional batteries on its back if you need it
Boston had been researched for decades, Xiaomi just came out from no way, they omit the research phase, show us the research progress over the years as what Boston did, if not, most likely is another 'copy and past'. Check out this video: The Evolution of Boston Dynamics
the evolution comes from academia, robotics researchers from all over the world, that's why it can be copied quickly. nothing new or outstanding from state of the art robotics research.
Yes, some just do the copy part, just like Xiaomi has done. This goes the same include fighter jets.
I want one 😫
you can put a machine Gun on the robot dog or a mini Gun that would be awesome
target=spot.locate_target();
spot.weapon.charge();
spot.weapon.aim(target);
spot.weapon.fire_once();
target.locate_next();
spot.repeat();
LOL xD
if dead then
@@THE-X-Force spot.respawn();
End if
You can tell that Xiaomi just kinda copied some(?) parts
They copied everything, just left out a few things to seem more unique and less copy & paste.
Question is who copy who ?
Does CCP has invented anything before anyone else?
Spot isn't a comparison to Cyberdog even if look alike. Spot is just for heavy usage and also construction. Cyberdog is just a home pet
Boston Dynamics Spot!
walking spycam by Xiaomi
Yes, and the unwitting public will lap it up - like they always do.
@@museonfilm8919 Yep ! Helping bring the end of days closer and closer
Xiaomi the new Huawei, making a living by copying what other creative people have been developing. I'm totally unimpressed and disgusted.
Hawei doesn’t copy in their mobiles ever but this is a dumb move by xiaomi
@@voltgaming2213 typical Chinese company
@Mit Shuler that’s a lie but Chinese companies are known for copy pasting
It's interesting that they both look similar. Who copied who?
How can the copy be better than the original?