I think it would be quite informative if you told us how much each coin cost you to do this service. I disagreed with them on the grading of all 5 coins. BUT AGAIN that is their OPINION which doesn't make so...Another interesting process is to break them out and send them to PCGS for their OPINION....Wonder how many would come back the supposed same grade.. .just IMHO!
What a difference! its night and day... the conservation team do a quality job. Just waiting for my first results to come back from ngc. I sent in some early British copper, pennys and half pennys . Im looking forward to the results. I have a couple of coins in reckon would benefit from conservation after watching this im definitely going to try them out . Thanks alot for the upload.
I was surprised you didn’t see the hairlines on the Boone before restoration. As I watched, predicted the Boone would be the dud. Home run on the others though. Congrats. Great video as always.
Love the format, Ben. I think this will go down as one of your more popular videos. Takes time and patience to put it together but awesome for us viewers.
The trade dollar is a wow, and so far out of my range. I still would like a trade dollar even with chop marks in Fine condition. Even that stretches the budget but I enjoyed this before and after video. Thanks for sharing.
I really enjoyed this format, seeing the coins before, hearing your predictions, and then seeing the results, all in the same video. The SLQ and Merc were awfully nice.
I still can't get over the fact that if you clean a coin and send it in, you get a "details - cleaned" grade, but if they clean the coin ("conserved"), they give you a straight grade. Seems a bit disingenuous to me. Love the SLQ and the Trade $1.
Have to admit there Ben that the SLQ turned out better than i thought, that was the real win in my book. This video has me thinking of sending some coins into NGC. Ive been having bad luck lately submitting coins, alot of cleaned coins and i dont clean them at ALL. Anywho. Merry Christmas and Have a Happy New Year!!!
That standing liberty came back looking spectacular. I agree with you, i think that merc looks better than a 64. And that gold still looks great. Very nice eye appeal
Ben, great video and lemme tell you why I think so. You showed all your work, like on a math test. For each coin raw you explained exactly your reasoning for the forecasted grade. Then, you went through it all again after conservation and grading to explain what happened and why. Super educational and interesting. I'd love to see more videos like this. Happy holidays and best wishes in 2023.
All really nice coins but thanks for walking us through the critical approach you take to your grading. We'd all be better off if we could learn to ignore that extra point that ownership seems to provide to a coin's grade.
Nice job. I'm now collecting the same type of coins. I really love commemorative coins. I just sent pcgs a 1900 Lafayette in Mint State condition. Plus a 1938 New Rochelle coin . a 1921 standing liberty quarter in AU condition. Plus . 59 coins total.
I have used the NGC conservation service many times!1 especially on early proofs, they do wonders and will not disappoint!! You should try and make it to FUN!!
Cool video ! Funny if we muck about with a coin , it is called cleaned/polished/wiped/scarred/or generally screwed up ! If a coin grading company cleans a coin it is called conservation ! edit glad a few worked out
I love these time travel shows. I was not surprised by the Boone coming back cleaned, but was really surprised at the Trade Dollar NOT being cleaned. Called the 63 on the Type Prude SLQ. 😎That '16-S Merc seemed grossly undergraded, but it seems like whenever a coin doubles in price between grades... I dunno, far be it from ME to accuse the grading companies of picking winners and losers. 🙄
I value my opinion much more than NGC regarding the 1875-S Trade Dollar which their ”professional graders” 🤔 😲😳😬 🤣😂🤣 determined to be in Mint State-62 condition. In numismatic jargon the coin has been messed with, and is AU Details, Cleaned, in my opinion.
With the 16s, what hurts it is the vertical mark that runs near the center of the obverse. If that wasn't there, it would have graded higher. Still think it is a 65 but that mark stops a 66 in my mind and stopped a 65 in their mind.
I had a Isabelle quarter submitted to ncs/ngc a few years ago. It had a black spot the size of a pen point on it. It removed almost all of it. The luster was reduced though making the finish look kind of flat. It graded ms63. One grade lower than the submitter was thinking and in that case a bit of value
I got the dime and quarter right but missed on the gold as well as the Boone and the Trade Dollar. I also thought 60 on the $10 gold. I thought AU details on the trade dollar and I thought AU 58 on the Boone. I thought I caught a break in luster on the Boone. I like this type of video. Thanks
This video came out just in time for me to send off a PCGS MS65 Norse American Medal to NCS. I have never done it before but figured I'd give it a try since the medal has what I think is very ugly toning. I was thinking of dipping it myself but it is the thin variety so it is higher end in value and I would hate to screw it up. It gives me hope seeing how the SLQ turned out for you in this video.
Very interesting Ben. Is it possible to get a better grade from a previously graded coins if it were restored? For example I have a 1926-D Peace dollar graded by PCGS at a MS 66+ with CAC bean that in my opinion is rather ugly! Would resubmission with the restoration bump it up to an MS 67? I know that's a tough question to answer without seeing the coin, but is it too risky?
Is conservation something to be done on xf to au coins from the capped bust era to do exactly what it says . Conserve to stop toning and clean off dirt and/or PVC that will cause future damage ?
No, do not use cleaners such as EZ-est, unless the coin has terminal toning and mint state. To remove green, PVC, bath the coin in acetone (fingernail polish remover) then pay dry with a towel. Done correctly, TPGs will not detect it.
”That iridescent color on the coin ... and that all got gone.” (In referring to the 1936 Daniel Boone commemorative half-dollar) 🤔 😲😳😬 🤣😂🤣 I’m just wondering how Ben, ”The Coin Geek”🤓 came to believe that Daniel Boone ever served in the U.S. House of Representatives as a Congressman ? Of course, he did serve four times as a delegate to the Virginia General Assembly in the latter part of the eighteenth century. However, I’m fairly certain that he and David Crockett were two different people.
Leave it to NGC to bill you for cleaning a coin and then label it as cleaned, that is ridiculous, conservering a coin is just a fancy word for cleaning it.
Seeing the before and after was a lot of fun. That SLQ was a huge win. Thanks for sharing!
I think it would be quite informative if you told us how much each coin cost you to do this service. I disagreed with them on the grading of all 5 coins. BUT AGAIN that is their OPINION which doesn't make so...Another interesting process is to break them out and send them to PCGS for their OPINION....Wonder how many would come back the supposed same grade.. .just IMHO!
Time traveling with Ben is a great idea for submissions!
A couple of pleasant surprises there. Their conservation service is a lot better then I thought it would be
That dime came back real nice!
What a difference! its night and day... the conservation team do a quality job. Just waiting for my first results to come back from ngc. I sent in some early British copper, pennys and half pennys . Im looking forward to the results. I have a couple of coins in reckon would benefit from conservation after watching this im definitely going to try them out . Thanks alot for the upload.
I was surprised you didn’t see the hairlines on the Boone before restoration. As I watched, predicted the Boone would be the dud. Home run on the others though. Congrats. Great video as always.
Great video. You rarely see the before and after in such a straightforward format. Thank you!
Love the format, Ben. I think this will go down as one of your more popular videos. Takes time and patience to put it together but awesome for us viewers.
The trade dollar is a wow, and so far out of my range. I still would like a trade dollar even with chop marks in Fine condition. Even that stretches the budget but I enjoyed this before and after video. Thanks for sharing.
I love playing guess the grade. More videos like this please!!!
Really enjoy videos like this. I always learn something new. Thanks. Merry Christmas! 🎄🎅🎄
I really enjoyed this format, seeing the coins before, hearing your predictions, and then seeing the results, all in the same video. The SLQ and Merc were awfully nice.
You have amazing coins. Speak for themselves. Thanks for videos.
Good video excellent camera work. I really like the format. Thanks. Mike
Just found you. Great video fam! Liked and subscribed 💯🔥💪
I still can't get over the fact that if you clean a coin and send it in, you get a "details - cleaned" grade, but if they clean the coin ("conserved"), they give you a straight grade. Seems a bit disingenuous to me. Love the SLQ and the Trade $1.
Have to admit there Ben that the SLQ turned out better than i thought, that was the real win in my book. This video has me thinking of sending some coins into NGC. Ive been having bad luck lately submitting coins, alot of cleaned coins and i dont clean them at ALL. Anywho. Merry Christmas and Have a Happy New Year!!!
I wonder if you cracker those out and sent them back anonymously and if they would grade CLEANED?
This is very helpful for beginners like me. Thank you!
That standing liberty came back looking spectacular. I agree with you, i think that merc looks better than a 64. And that gold still looks great. Very nice eye appeal
Really liked seeing the before and after in the same video. It nicely illustrates the change that takes place. Wouldn’t mind owning that SLQ!
Great coins Ben!! Thank you!!
Really enjoy the all-in-one videos, would love to see more please!
Nice video! Like the before/after in the same sitting.
Ben, great video and lemme tell you why I think so. You showed all your work, like on a math test. For each coin raw you explained exactly your reasoning for the forecasted grade. Then, you went through it all again after conservation and grading to explain what happened and why. Super educational and interesting. I'd love to see more videos like this. Happy holidays and best wishes in 2023.
Nice to end the year on a high note with NGC!
All really nice coins but thanks for walking us through the critical approach you take to your grading. We'd all be better off if we could learn to ignore that extra point that ownership seems to provide to a coin's grade.
The type of toning on the SLQ reminds me of black mold.
Nice job. I'm now collecting the same type of coins. I really love commemorative coins. I just sent pcgs a 1900 Lafayette in Mint State condition. Plus a 1938 New Rochelle coin . a 1921 standing liberty quarter in AU condition. Plus . 59 coins total.
I have used the NGC conservation service many times!1 especially on early proofs, they do wonders and will not disappoint!! You should try and make it to FUN!!
Thanks! Informative!
Fantastic video.
Cool video !
Funny if we muck about with a coin , it is called cleaned/polished/wiped/scarred/or generally screwed up !
If a coin grading company cleans a coin it is called conservation !
edit
glad a few worked out
I love these time travel shows.
I was not surprised by the Boone coming back cleaned, but was really surprised at the Trade Dollar NOT being cleaned. Called the 63 on the Type Prude SLQ. 😎That '16-S Merc seemed grossly undergraded, but it seems like whenever a coin doubles in price between grades... I dunno, far be it from ME to accuse the grading companies of picking winners and losers. 🙄
I value my opinion much more than NGC regarding the 1875-S Trade Dollar which their ”professional graders” 🤔
😲😳😬 🤣😂🤣 determined to be in Mint State-62 condition. In numismatic jargon the coin has been messed with, and is AU Details, Cleaned, in my opinion.
With the 16s, what hurts it is the vertical mark that runs near the center of the obverse. If that wasn't there, it would have graded higher. Still think it is a 65 but that mark stops a 66 in my mind and stopped a 65 in their mind.
Hi, Ben. Is a Quarter Dime 2 1/2 cents? The Merc looks better than 64. **HAPPY HOLIDAYS, EVERYONE!**
🤑💰💸
I had a Isabelle quarter submitted to ncs/ngc a few years ago. It had a black spot the size of a pen point on it. It removed almost all of it. The luster was reduced though making the finish look kind of flat. It graded ms63. One grade lower than the submitter was thinking and in that case a bit of value
I got the dime and quarter right but missed on the gold as well as the Boone and the Trade Dollar. I also thought 60 on the $10 gold. I thought AU details on the trade dollar and I thought AU 58 on the Boone. I thought I caught a break in luster on the Boone. I like this type of video. Thanks
Not bad Mr Geek!
i like this content
Really good video.
Breaking news, PCGS and NGC uses eZest
This video came out just in time for me to send off a PCGS MS65 Norse American Medal to NCS. I have never done it before but figured I'd give it a try since the medal has what I think is very ugly toning. I was thinking of dipping it myself but it is the thin variety so it is higher end in value and I would hate to screw it up. It gives me hope seeing how the SLQ turned out for you in this video.
Very interesting Ben. Is it possible to get a better grade from a previously graded coins if it were restored? For example I have a 1926-D Peace dollar graded by PCGS at a MS 66+ with CAC bean that in my opinion is rather ugly! Would resubmission with the restoration bump it up to an MS 67? I know that's a tough question to answer without seeing the coin, but is it too risky?
Great video. What's the Greysheet price for the 1893 $10 Liberty head in MS61 vs MS62?
Hi Ben, great video. I was wondering, what they do to the coin to "conserve" the coin? And what is the extra cost? Thanks
I am curios on how much it cost to clean/conserve a coin and what your time turn around is ?
I just saw the polishing
Let us know if that haze comes back in the future Ben!
That is a really slanted S-mintmark on that 1916 dime.
I guessed them all accurately except the gold I said AU53, and the Trade Dollar I said AU58. They were nice to you...
That Boone was so flat I knew something was wrong with it those come nice
what is that column thing on the back of mercury dimes?
What are your preferred gloves for handling coins?
Is NGC conservation better than PCGS restoration services?
good afternoon...would you tell me if it's worth having a 1928 $100 bill graded. thank you
Usually only worth grading if it is in uncirculated condition…or if you want to preserve it for yourself .
@@TheCoinGeek alright...thanks!
Is conservation something to be done on xf to au coins from the capped bust era to do exactly what it says . Conserve to stop toning and clean off dirt and/or PVC that will cause future damage ?
No, do not use cleaners such as EZ-est, unless the coin has terminal toning and mint state. To remove green, PVC, bath the coin in acetone (fingernail polish remover) then pay dry with a towel. Done correctly, TPGs will not detect it.
”That iridescent color on the coin ... and that all got gone.” (In referring to the 1936 Daniel Boone commemorative half-dollar) 🤔 😲😳😬 🤣😂🤣 I’m just wondering how Ben, ”The Coin Geek”🤓 came to believe that Daniel Boone ever served in the U.S. House of Representatives as a Congressman ? Of course, he did serve four times as a delegate to the Virginia General Assembly in the latter part of the eighteenth century. However, I’m fairly certain that he and David Crockett were two different people.
Extremely rare for a liberty eagle to get a 60
on the 1917 quarter im geuseing ms 62 thats better then au i think.
Leave it to NGC to bill you for cleaning a coin and then label it as cleaned, that is ridiculous, conservering a coin is just a fancy word for cleaning it.
I believe the ‘cleaning’ that lost the grade was because it was done too harshly. Can see hairlines on the coin after conservation (seen in video).
Where was the harp flourish....? Come on, everyone knows the trope for time passing (and beauty revealing) is the harp flourish!
Awesome vid, thanks Ben
Killer video 👐! Promotion that works = *Promo SM* !!!