Don't forget about my Tampa Bay Buccaneers. In their entire franchise history, since 1976, they've never signed a quaterback they drafted to a second contract.
If literally their best quarterbacks are a 40-year-old Tom Brady, one consistent year of Brad Johnson, Shaun King, and a Doug Williams you wouldn't pay for some reason, then the Buccaneers really have a problem with developing a quarterback.
Colts should’ve been given a dishonourable mention. They don’t call it the glue factory for nothing. Nearly put Peyton’s career 6 feet under despite getting a ring outta him.
2:18 "One-legged Alex Smith" 😂😂😂 he always gives players some funny nicknames, in one video he called Brett Favre "the Reverse Robin Hood" 😂😂😂 I love these videos
Both shoulder injuries were particularly egregious. He was never right again after the one in 18. Also can't forget Teddy BridgeQB. He should've been done after he got hurt against the Bucs but they let him play on. And people wondered why his play took a nose dive after that game.
@@Crush1084 yeah good point. About Bridgewater, I wondered why he was playing so awful. I mean he was never a phenomenal quarterback, but he was a decent quarterback. He played pretty good for Denver in 2021.
@@FlyHenryFly honestly though even Aaron Rodgers would have a difficult time with this OC. Ben MaCadoo is a horrible OC. His play calling may get better as the season goes on, now that Rhule is gone.
Cam was truly great as a QB, he just had this thing where it was legal for defensive players to do literally anything to him. All QBs who can run get this a little bit, but Cam would take shots even running backs and WRs would draw flags on and the refs would just stand there. It was pretty sickening to watch sometimes. Of course the Panthers themselves never protected him either, dude would trot back out there after almost anything, no matter how comprised his ability to play or defend himself was. It was like nobody cared about his career longevity at all, and so of course it had none. It's pretty sad.
I really hope Fields can break the Bears' curse at quarterback. He's not there yet, but the signs have been tantalizing - especially now that the offense seems to be more suited to his strengths.
I would say Tepper's issue since buying the team is that he's a businessman, not a football guy like Richardson was. I think he's willing to invest (as evidenced by that contract given to Matt Rhule and paying Teddy Bridgewater 20+ mil) but since he's not a football guy, he doesn't make good football decisions and when those initial decisions don't pan out, the businessman in him decides to not continue throwing good money after bad.
Let’s be fair. In 2018, Alex Smith really gave Washington hope on winning the division, I mean he carried Washington to a 6-3 start being 1st in the division right before that gruesome injury. Alex Smith wasn’t declining at all before that injury, it wasn’t until after the injury when his play declined, and even in 2020 when his play had been declined, he still had flashes of his old self, being a field general, and managing the clock PERFECTLY well, and led us to the playoffs in 2020 despite being 7-9, even tho our record could’ve and SHOULD’VE been 10-6/11-5 if it weren’t for Dustin Hopkins selling on field goal attempts. If Alex Smith never gotten injured in 2018, he would’ve given us a wild card bye, straight to the divisional round, meaning he would’ve gotten us close to the SB if we won the divisional round
I’m a Utah Utes fan and I am amazed at the success Smith was able to have in spite of the many hurdles and setbacks he had to deal with in the pros. The man was a warrior and very skilled at what he did. Under different circumstances, he may have been far more successful than he was. I also think Washington did him dirty by tossing him out even though the team was only winning with him as QB. That has been an easy team to dislike for quite a while now
@@FivePointsVids Smith was the king of bad luck. He was doing amazing in San Fran till a concussion took him out and got replaced by Kaepernick. He was doing amazing in KC until they replaced him with Mahomes. Then that bad injury in Washington pretty much killed his career. That guy deserved better.
@@coletrickle1775 Yessir, the Dolphins need to look over there and talk about their plans for the alphalfa and the rabbits and let the franchise move to a state that isn't Florida.
@@E_tiBEAMERBOY qb plays a big factor in that. And the main difference is how there have been plenty of good recievers while the best bears qb is jay cutler
Despite being the joint oldest NFL team (with the Cardinals), a Bears QB has never had a 4000 yard passing season. For reference: Jay Cutler did have a 4000 yard season… with the Broncos.
I remember when I was told that the Bills were the place QBs went to die, but the last few years they've shown that that is no longer the case. All that work on helping Allen figure out his weaknesses, and then also supplying him some weapons, and now I expect a lot of QBs would like to go to the Bills. The Bears? They've had the same issue for at least six years straight. Receivers who like to drop balls(Usually into the defenders hands), bad playcalling/coaching, and an O'line that can't hold back a sneeze.
If anything the Texans are the opposite of a QB graveyard. They’ve elevated some really bad QBs into playoff starters with supporting casts and defense, they didn’t ruin any careers.
It was like after David Carr they had this pathological fear of drafting a QB earlier than the 3rd round. I will admit when they drafted Deshaun, I was like "finally" because even if he didn't pan out, at least they tried to find a good QB for once
David Carr, on almost any other team, would have been an NFL MVP. The offensive line just sucked. No real running backs. Andre Johnson was about the Only bright spot on the offense.
It's a shame Carr never panned out. I saw him play in college and he ranks as the second best I ever saw in person. The guy had the talent, but I imagine getting assaulted on the field every week and being unable to press charges really messes with a guy's head after awhile.
Ouch, it hurts to see my team in the thumbnail, but it's true. Our incompetence normally flys under the radar because no one cares about the team outside the Carolinas.
I liked Rivera as a Coach, and as a person. One thing he didn't handle well though, was Cams health. Either he let the team rush Cam back to the field, or he let Cam rush himself back before he was fully healed. It may have been Rivera's doing, who knows? Either way it's HIS job as the Coach not to let that happen.
They've had some good quarterbacks and gotten good mileage from them. Look at how long they stayed with Stafford. Personally I think they got the steal dealing him to the Rams. He's maybe got three seasons left in him and is not fitting in with the squad. Meanwhile Goff is leading one of the most potent offenses in the league. Too bad the defense is wet tissue paper.
@@fredlougee2807 that is extremely true, i always think back to the Joey Harrington days and Kitna, Jeff Garcia, Dan Orlovsky. But I forget that was only a couple years
@@glaciersmash4118 Kitna...what a feel-good story. He went to Central Washington, a D2 school in a small town about 100 miles east of Seattle on I-90 and was ready to go back to his to high school to teach math. Had been hired and everything. But one of his teammates was nephew of then-Seahawks HC Dennis Erickson. Called Uncle Dennis, told him to come check Kitna out. As a result he was signed as a UFA. So the school put the job on hold for him, it would be ghere whenever he ended his NFL career. Turned out he didn't start teaching there until 14 years later.
I'm amazed Detroit didn't make this list. I was almost certain we would be on here. I mean we were 0-16, got Stafford and wasted 12 years of his career for him to finally escape to L.A. .
You guys didnt ruin stafford however, he was there for a decade giving lions fans something worth cheering for and he immediately won a super bowl when he was freed from deteoit.
I'm not sold on Watson. Watch him look like a bust when he returns. He hasn't touched a Football in 2 years I doubt that he's going to be the savior they you all hope for.
Im pretty sure the Colts should be on this list, have you seen the QB 🎠 they've been in for the last 4 years, not to mention Peyton Manning and Andrew luck
How are the Jaguars not up there? We've been devoid of QB talent and incapable of getting one to play one, ever since Brunell was unceremoniously yeeted out of town!
Pay attention to how the Bengals are NOT on this list and learn something from it people and stop acting like they are such a poorly ran organization. Last 20 years they've gone from Palmer, to Dalton, to Burrow with no gaps in between. They've also won 5 division titles, made the playoffs 8 times, and gone to a super bowl in that same stretch. That's pretty damn good compared to most teams around the league.
@@charlespoopydoodle Yeah, but he also quit on the team. Before him since 1991, we had David Klingler, Eric Whilhelm, Jeff Blake, Neil O’Donnell, a retiring Boomer Esiason, Gus Ferrote, Akillme Smith (misspelling intentional), and Jon Kitna. Damn, remembering the 1990s gives some of my brethren PTSD…
How could you ignore the Jets? And, to a slightly lesser extent, the Lions. Though the Jets can at least still talk about their Super Bowl win, which got its AARP membership a few years ago, with the most overrated QB in NFL history, with the possible exception of Fran Tarkenton.
True. He did win like 7 or 8 games the year after Peyton retired. Something like that. But after that everything went downhill. Then y'all drafted Paxton Lynch the mega bust. Dude was so bad that you decided play Siemien for the rest of the season and had 5 or 6 wins I think.
Top 5 NFL Teams That Always Have Good Quarterbacks 5. Los Angeles Chargers 4. Indianapolis Colts 3. Pittsburgh Steelers 2. Dallas Cowboys 1. Green Bay Packers
As much as the rest of our fans hate it, Kirk Cousins is the only one keeping the Vikings from being on this list. Otherwise since the 90's it's been a long string of failed draftees and signings that would give the Browns some serious competition: Rich Gannon (Became the franchise QB for the Raiders) Warren Moon Brad Johnson Tarvaris Jackson (rip) Donovan McNabb Christian Ponder Matt Cassel Josh Freeman Teddy Bridgewater Sam Bradford Kellen Mond (We drafted him last year and he's already cut.) And the occasional one-hit wonders like Randall Cunningham, Jeff George, Brett Favre and Case Keenum. The only real franchise QB we had during that period was Dante Culpepper, and he too ended up ruined.
Chargers def deserve a dishonorable mention on this list. Every QB they ever draft in the past 20 years always gains the curse of horrible luck no matter how talented. Its actually a talent at this point
Surprised you didn't mention the Vikings. Since Fran's retirement, they've started a different QB in the playoffs each time they've gone other than Culpepper and Kramer. And they've been to the playoffs 30 times.
Old Indiana High School story. Starting SS against the aforementioned Rex Grossman....3 QB sacks, 2 INT, AND ran a kickoff all the way home....sounds ridiculous right? 0.00 on the clock, we lost to Rex Grossman 78 - 13. He WAS that damn good in HS. Passing was ridiculous 33 for 38, 560 yards and 7 TD's.
Carolina recently has been bad but I don't think you can have them on here over the Jets. Carolina has had Steve Beurlein, Jake Delhomme and Cam Newton be successful QB's. Who have the Jets had outside of 2 decent years of Mark Sanchez and one year of Brett Favre?
But Carolina let their O-line go to shit. Say what you will about Marty Hurney's tenure as GM, but he never allowed the offensive line go as bad as it's been the past several years.
The browns don’t ruin qbs. We just suck at drafting them. Although we did kinda ruin mayfield though considering the offensive line and coaching he had to deal with
Two team to mention because they have been historically QB gravediggers: Rams and Cardinals. Rams have had only one good QB career since Norm van Brocklin and that was Warner. Just within my memory, guys like Roman Gabriel and John Hadl were wasted or dealt away. They even had Namath for a particularly painful season. It got worse when Carrol Rosenbloom died and his widow got the team. The only QB worth mentioning in her misbegotten tenure was Warner. But someone decided he was surplus goods and he wound up being the only decent QB in the Cards' time in Arizona for a couple of seasons. He was shelved in favor of Bulger, who was given far too long to prove himself, and then a carousel up until Goff was finally allowed to play by the incoming McVey. They have maybe turned a corner, but I don't see Stafford playing more than three years before he retires. As for the Cards, Warner was about it. I think Neil Lomax is still the franchise leader in passing yards, career.
As a Broncos fan myself, I think I speak for all of us when I say Trevor Siemien was our favorite QB since Manning retired. Why? Because after being selected in the 7th round nobody expected anything from him. After Manning retired and Osweiler left we threw Siemien into the fire. And he guided us to a respectable 9-7 season. I think had he been given a better o-line and a little better coaching he probably would’ve made a decent QB
My nephew has been playing QB since middle school and I told him if he ever got drafted into the league I'd demand a trade like Eli Manning did before I let him play for.....What's their name, my bad the Washington Commanders
With exception of the Green Bay Packers with 2 main Starting QBs for 3 decades the rest of the NFC north has been a Mess. The Detroit Lions finally broke that mold with Stafford and now Goff(so far). But, over all The Chicago Bears, Minnesota Vikings, and Detroit Cowardlies, in the same time that the Packers have had Favre, and Rodgers, the Lions, Bears, and Vikings have had over 30 each for a total off about 100z
Love the video man but I think Cleveland deserves to be number one, no other franchise has had the idiocy of the Browns especially at QB and now with all hands himself, Mr Grabass going to Ohio things don't look to be getting any better, except for sexual assault attorneys.
@@FivePointsVids Cliché sure but with all the bad days in Cleveland you should at least give them the credit they deserve, even if it is showing how inapt they are and the fact that no one can match their inaptness.
Not to mention that the only QB success the Broncos had in the past 40 years wasn't even with their own drafted QB's. Elway and Manning both got picked by the other horse team. And the former is a prime example that being good at a sport as an athlete says nothing about one's skill as an executive (much like the Hornets owner). But because of his status as saint in Denver Elway gets away with mismanagement on the position he is supposed to know best.
Say what you want about Flacco but he brought stability to the QB position for the Ravens. The Ravens drafted Chris Redman, Kyle Boller and now they have Lamar.
I still think the Commanders, and really, NFL teams in general, should build a team with a placeholder QB like Taylor Heinicke, until they think they're truly ready for spending a 1st on a QB. He's Jimmy G/Flacco tier, sure, but he could win a ring. Build a Defense, get an O-Line ready and when the time comes, draft the 1st round QB and get a running game. Josh Allen came into a Bills team with a defense and fresh off a playoff birth, even if it wasn't the best team, but the defense could hold and gave Allen time to figure things out. Alternatively, their QB will be good enough with the team.
Before Tua, the Dolphins would've surely been on this list. They were so horrible at drafting O-linemen, even serviceable QB's got screwed into the ground!
The problems with the Bears QBs over the years has been bad OCs, a meddling nepotism of executives, and just bad picks. Jim Miller was never a gunslinger or an OP arm talent, he managed the games well enough to win. Shane Matthews had been in/out of that pool. Cade McNown was a bust. Rick Mirer was because Michael McCaskey is a moron. Offensive Coordinator list from the 90s to today that you'd rather forget ever existed. Rex Grossman's OC was Ron Turner, but he had a good OL and RBs to hand off to, never had any receiving talent. Kyle Orton was another game manager but he knew how to make the offense work with what he had. By the time we get Cutler, the OL from rex's days is mostly gone and we get J'Marcus Webb....woof. Cutler also suffered from OC Regime Change, his longest running OC with him was 18 months of Mike Martz. Then we have Glennon, Trubisky, and now Fields. Fields is most certainly the best talent we've had at QB in a while, but he has an offensive line made up of cheap players, a decent RB tandem to hand off to, and nearly no name brand talent at WR. The strides are there, but now can the Bears put together enough tape by year's end on what we have and then get ready to roll out the amount of picks we're going to have (if we're a top 10 pick in a QB heavy draft class, it may behoove us to trade down for more picks) and the sheer clearance of cap space in $125 million ready to spend next year. If Poles is the agent of change and modernizing the Bears front office, this offseason will show us.
Uh... where are NY Jets? Their best QB, Namath, had one good game in the superbowl, but was awful throughout his career. Look up his stats. Less than 50% completion rate in his career and an abysmal TD:INT ratio.
what ever happened to Wentz, he came into Killadelphia on top the world, Got injured a few games before the big one and then never came back the same. Its just strange how he never recovered back into a star QB and now just seems to trade around.
Cleveland’s QB graveyard is practically a Halloween decoration of reality, and it never ceases to make me laugh lmfao
Good for this time of the year.
All part of the Factory of Sadness.
And this all happened in the last 20 years or so, when the franchise was resurrected in Cleveland.
As a bengals fan I gotta say I loved Andy Dalton 1 once a month loved Carson Palmer and lo would kill for Joe burrow
Don't forget about my Tampa Bay Buccaneers. In their entire franchise history, since 1976, they've never signed a quaterback they drafted to a second contract.
And they squandered Doug Williams and Steve Young too
@@OCs_And_Stories They wouldn't pay Williams. As for Young, he wasn't going to do anything in Tampa let's be honest.
If literally their best quarterbacks are a 40-year-old Tom Brady, one consistent year of Brad Johnson, Shaun King, and a Doug Williams you wouldn't pay for some reason, then the Buccaneers really have a problem with developing a quarterback.
The best Buccos QB is legit 45 year old Tom Brady lmfao
Did Testaverde not get a second contract?
Colts should’ve been given a dishonourable mention. They don’t call it the glue factory for nothing. Nearly put Peyton’s career 6 feet under despite getting a ring outta him.
True I was gonna say they've ruined every QB since luck but it's a retirement home for QBs.
Peyton Manning should have had at least 4 or 5 rings in his career, but the Colts were so awful they could only give him 1
@@AussieAvgeek98 Peyton's playoff record didn't help either
@@bigbearkat2010 gonna blow your mind here, but football is a team game. It’s 11 on 11, not 1 on 1
Indianapolis has been the QB retirement home
2:18 "One-legged Alex Smith" 😂😂😂 he always gives players some funny nicknames, in one video he called Brett Favre "the Reverse Robin Hood" 😂😂😂 I love these videos
Thanks Ivan
The 'reverse robin hood' is because he's literally stealing from the poor with his medicare fraud!
@@petertrudelljr he also built a volleyball court with that money, that's why it's funny when he calls him reverse Robin Hood🤣🤣
Carolina never handled Cams health well. He came back to the field WAY to early a few times.
Both shoulder injuries were particularly egregious. He was never right again after the one in 18. Also can't forget Teddy BridgeQB. He should've been done after he got hurt against the Bucs but they let him play on. And people wondered why his play took a nose dive after that game.
@@Crush1084 yeah good point. About Bridgewater, I wondered why he was playing so awful. I mean he was never a phenomenal quarterback, but he was a decent quarterback. He played pretty good for Denver in 2021.
@@nasis18 exactly. he was actually a decent quarterback. obviously not great, but an average quarterback that would be good to have right now.
@@FlyHenryFly honestly though even Aaron Rodgers would have a difficult time with this OC. Ben MaCadoo is a horrible OC. His play calling may get better as the season goes on, now that Rhule is gone.
Cam was truly great as a QB, he just had this thing where it was legal for defensive players to do literally anything to him. All QBs who can run get this a little bit, but Cam would take shots even running backs and WRs would draw flags on and the refs would just stand there. It was pretty sickening to watch sometimes. Of course the Panthers themselves never protected him either, dude would trot back out there after almost anything, no matter how comprised his ability to play or defend himself was. It was like nobody cared about his career longevity at all, and so of course it had none. It's pretty sad.
Al Michaels dying on TNF..🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I really hope Fields can break the Bears' curse at quarterback. He's not there yet, but the signs have been tantalizing - especially now that the offense seems to be more suited to his strengths.
If he turns out to be good, he’ll get injuries like the only good QB in Bears history, Jim McMahon
Mitch Trubisky could have been that guy but he regressed after 2018
This aged well
I'm shocked the Jets are not mentioned at all here. That was the first time I thought of when I saw the title.
As a Jets fan, I agree
I would say Tepper's issue since buying the team is that he's a businessman, not a football guy like Richardson was. I think he's willing to invest (as evidenced by that contract given to Matt Rhule and paying Teddy Bridgewater 20+ mil) but since he's not a football guy, he doesn't make good football decisions and when those initial decisions don't pan out, the businessman in him decides to not continue throwing good money after bad.
^This.
Let’s be fair. In 2018, Alex Smith really gave Washington hope on winning the division, I mean he carried Washington to a 6-3 start being 1st in the division right before that gruesome injury. Alex Smith wasn’t declining at all before that injury, it wasn’t until after the injury when his play declined, and even in 2020 when his play had been declined, he still had flashes of his old self, being a field general, and managing the clock PERFECTLY well, and led us to the playoffs in 2020 despite being 7-9, even tho our record could’ve and SHOULD’VE been 10-6/11-5 if it weren’t for Dustin Hopkins selling on field goal attempts. If Alex Smith never gotten injured in 2018, he would’ve given us a wild card bye, straight to the divisional round, meaning he would’ve gotten us close to the SB if we won the divisional round
Oh for sure but they rewarded his comeback effort by immediately cutting him 😢
I’m a Utah Utes fan and I am amazed at the success Smith was able to have in spite of the many hurdles and setbacks he had to deal with in the pros. The man was a warrior and very skilled at what he did. Under different circumstances, he may have been far more successful than he was.
I also think Washington did him dirty by tossing him out even though the team was only winning with him as QB. That has been an easy team to dislike for quite a while now
@@FivePointsVids unfortunately 🤦🏾♂️ but Washington is gonna do Washington things until Dirty Dan finally sells the team
Alex Smith deserved better.
@@FivePointsVids Smith was the king of bad luck. He was doing amazing in San Fran till a concussion took him out and got replaced by Kaepernick. He was doing amazing in KC until they replaced him with Mahomes. Then that bad injury in Washington pretty much killed his career.
That guy deserved better.
need more 5pointvids in my life
The Dolphins remind me of a make-a-wish kid. They don't just ruin QB's they send them to the actual graveyard.
Damn!! 😆 🤣
Yeah I didn't notice until the whole thing with Brian Flores just how painfully irrelevant the Dolphins have made themselves since Marino retired
@@bigbearkat2010 Yeah they're my favorite team and it's easy to be a fan. I have my sunday's free and already know they lost.
I just wanna pet the bunnies, George
@@coletrickle1775 Yessir, the Dolphins need to look over there and talk about their plans for the alphalfa and the rabbits and let the franchise move to a state that isn't Florida.
If it wasn't for Peyton Manning & Matt Stafford, both the Colts & Lions would be in this video.
As a bears fan i knew this day would come
They can get every position right, except the QB it seems.
Wr? No consistent long term player ever as well no player over 5k receiving yards :(
@@E_tiBEAMERBOY qb plays a big factor in that. And the main difference is how there have been plenty of good recievers while the best bears qb is jay cutler
Despite being the joint oldest NFL team (with the Cardinals), a Bears QB has never had a 4000 yard passing season. For reference: Jay Cutler did have a 4000 yard season… with the Broncos.
@@michaellyga4726 that is crazy to think about.
Another great video. I'd love to see the reverse of this, the QB factories. And I fully expect Adam to take a shot at the Eagles LOL
I remember when I was told that the Bills were the place QBs went to die, but the last few years they've shown that that is no longer the case.
All that work on helping Allen figure out his weaknesses, and then also supplying him some weapons, and now I expect a lot of QBs would like to go to the Bills.
The Bears? They've had the same issue for at least six years straight.
Receivers who like to drop balls(Usually into the defenders hands), bad playcalling/coaching, and an O'line that can't hold back a sneeze.
I genuinely can’t believe the Jets didn’t make it into this video.
If anything the Texans are the opposite of a QB graveyard. They’ve elevated some really bad QBs into playoff starters with supporting casts and defense, they didn’t ruin any careers.
Texans have had the second most starting QBs since 02 behind the Browns. We've only had 2 out of many that have seen any kind of real success 😅
It was like after David Carr they had this pathological fear of drafting a QB earlier than the 3rd round. I will admit when they drafted Deshaun, I was like "finally" because even if he didn't pan out, at least they tried to find a good QB for once
@Cold Snap I never said it was Carrs fault, I remember that stat pretty well too.
David Carr, on almost any other team, would have been an NFL MVP. The offensive line just sucked. No real running backs. Andre Johnson was about the Only bright spot on the offense.
I play ESPN NFL 2k5 just so i can bring Carr to a third super bowl in a row in my franchise 😂
It's a shame Carr never panned out. I saw him play in college and he ranks as the second best I ever saw in person. The guy had the talent, but I imagine getting assaulted on the field every week and being unable to press charges really messes with a guy's head after awhile.
03:20 Ummm, it's pronounced like this: Cuh Cough Any. Say that fast like it is one word. Cack cuh fuh knee is hilarious lmao.
Bears, Browns, Lions, Commanders, Texans, Jags, Jets and I know there are more
Rams
Chicago Bears. That is all
The Trent Williams situation with cancer was awful and a clear example of the joke of an organization Washington is.
Ouch, it hurts to see my team in the thumbnail, but it's true. Our incompetence normally flys under the radar because no one cares about the team outside the Carolinas.
At least the Canes are good now, so you have that going!
I liked Rivera as a Coach, and as a person. One thing he didn't handle well though, was Cams health. Either he let the team rush Cam back to the field, or he let Cam rush himself back before he was fully healed. It may have been Rivera's doing, who knows? Either way it's HIS job as the Coach not to let that happen.
One of the very few here…
As a Lions fan, I was absolutely floored to not see them on the list
They’re so irrelevant he just forgot about them 🤣
@@VianoMusicAcademy #pain 😂😂
They've had some good quarterbacks and gotten good mileage from them. Look at how long they stayed with Stafford. Personally I think they got the steal dealing him to the Rams. He's maybe got three seasons left in him and is not fitting in with the squad. Meanwhile Goff is leading one of the most potent offenses in the league. Too bad the defense is wet tissue paper.
@@fredlougee2807 that is extremely true, i always think back to the Joey Harrington days and Kitna, Jeff Garcia, Dan Orlovsky. But I forget that was only a couple years
@@glaciersmash4118 Kitna...what a feel-good story. He went to Central Washington, a D2 school in a small town about 100 miles east of Seattle on I-90 and was ready to go back to his to high school to teach math. Had been hired and everything. But one of his teammates was nephew of then-Seahawks HC Dennis Erickson. Called Uncle Dennis, told him to come check Kitna out. As a result he was signed as a UFA. So the school put the job on hold for him, it would be ghere whenever he ended his NFL career. Turned out he didn't start teaching there until 14 years later.
I'm amazed Detroit didn't make this list. I was almost certain we would be on here. I mean we were 0-16, got Stafford and wasted 12 years of his career for him to finally escape to L.A. .
You guys didnt ruin stafford however, he was there for a decade giving lions fans something worth cheering for and he immediately won a super bowl when he was freed from deteoit.
The Jets don’t even get an honorable mention? Damn
Jets were the last team cut.
Cleveland's QB graveyard about to gain a few more tombstones in the near future.
I'm not sold on Watson. Watch him look like a bust when he returns. He hasn't touched a Football in 2 years I doubt that he's going to be the savior they you all hope for.
I'm surprised that the Dolphins (post Marino), Jets, Bengals (between Boomer and Palmer), Jags (post Brunnell) and Detroit were not on this list.
thanks for giving me something to watch during my break ‼️
I'm an OG Carolina fan and I have wondered myself what the hell happens to a QB when they get here. I'm just a casual observer and even I've noticed.
Im pretty sure the Colts should be on this list, have you seen the QB 🎠 they've been in for the last 4 years, not to mention Peyton Manning and Andrew luck
How are the Jaguars not up there? We've been devoid of QB talent and incapable of getting one to play one, ever since Brunell was unceremoniously yeeted out of town!
Our one good qb so far, was not even drafted by the jags
The Broncos dont destroy QBs, they just cant draft QBs.
Pay attention to how the Bengals are NOT on this list and learn something from it people and stop acting like they are such a poorly ran organization. Last 20 years they've gone from Palmer, to Dalton, to Burrow with no gaps in between. They've also won 5 division titles, made the playoffs 8 times, and gone to a super bowl in that same stretch. That's pretty damn good compared to most teams around the league.
That's because KB took over the front office and her dad just sells billboards now. She turned it around somehow
Man, if it wasn’t for Joe “Hope Incarnate” Burrow, my Bengals would’ve certainly been on this list.
Pretty soon he will be the next luck
Carson Palmer got you to the playoffs
@@kyleball20 I’m actually confident the o-line will continue to improve. Now, if we’d just run the ball more…
@@charlespoopydoodle Yeah, but he also quit on the team. Before him since 1991, we had David Klingler, Eric Whilhelm, Jeff Blake, Neil O’Donnell, a retiring Boomer Esiason, Gus Ferrote, Akillme Smith (misspelling intentional), and Jon Kitna. Damn, remembering the 1990s gives some of my brethren PTSD…
No way man. Past 20 years have been pretty damn good for the Bengals at QB going Palmer, to Dalton, to Burrow with literally no gaps in between.
Top 5 NFL Teams That Always Ruin Quarterbacks
5. Jacksonville Jaguars
4. Cleveland Browns
3. Carolina Panthers
2. New York Jets
1. Chicago Bears
How could you ignore the Jets? And, to a slightly lesser extent, the Lions. Though the Jets can at least still talk about their Super Bowl win, which got its AARP membership a few years ago, with the most overrated QB in NFL history, with the possible exception of Fran Tarkenton.
To be fair to Trevor Siemien, as a 7th round pick he’s had a solid career
True. He did win like 7 or 8 games the year after Peyton retired. Something like that. But after that everything went downhill. Then y'all drafted Paxton Lynch the mega bust. Dude was so bad that you decided play Siemien for the rest of the season and had 5 or 6 wins I think.
As a Jets fan, I am shocked that they aren't on this list.
Where are the colts anytime a qb does there, their career dies
Top 5 NFL Teams That Always Have Good Quarterbacks
5. Los Angeles Chargers
4. Indianapolis Colts
3. Pittsburgh Steelers
2. Dallas Cowboys
1. Green Bay Packers
Kyle Orton > Cutler.
Hopefully, Carolina can right the ship.
They don’t ruin QB they recruit bad QB, for example panthers recruiting Fat Mayfield
I can't believe the Cleveland qb carousel is officially ending with woman rights activist Deshaun Watson 😳
Sure it is. Just like how Russ is supposed to be the Broncos savior.
First and if the Browns aren’t #1 I’ll be suprised
As a Vikings fan I am both happy yet surprised that they weren't on there
As much as the rest of our fans hate it, Kirk Cousins is the only one keeping the Vikings from being on this list.
Otherwise since the 90's it's been a long string of failed draftees and signings that would give the Browns some serious competition:
Rich Gannon (Became the franchise QB for the Raiders)
Warren Moon
Brad Johnson
Tarvaris Jackson (rip)
Donovan McNabb
Christian Ponder
Matt Cassel
Josh Freeman
Teddy Bridgewater
Sam Bradford
Kellen Mond (We drafted him last year and he's already cut.)
And the occasional one-hit wonders like Randall Cunningham, Jeff George, Brett Favre and Case Keenum.
The only real franchise QB we had during that period was Dante Culpepper, and he too ended up ruined.
@@scaryhobbit211 preach it
Chicago takes the cake. No comparison
Washington a close second
I feel bad for baker he got brought in to be a scapegoat
its his throws he gets all jumpy
Scapegoat? Man the narratives
If it weren’t for Flacco and Lamar, The Ravens would definitely be on this list.
Chargers def deserve a dishonorable mention on this list. Every QB they ever draft in the past 20 years always gains the curse of horrible luck no matter how talented. Its actually a talent at this point
Surprised you didn't mention the Vikings. Since Fran's retirement, they've started a different QB in the playoffs each time they've gone other than Culpepper and Kramer. And they've been to the playoffs 30 times.
What about the Raiders? They haven't had an elite QB since Rich Gannon.
@@ggMwaniki ... and Rich Gannon was no elite QB either. Imagine that. Better go all the way back to Ken Stabler.
Old Indiana High School story.
Starting SS against the aforementioned Rex Grossman....3 QB sacks, 2 INT, AND ran a kickoff all the way home....sounds ridiculous right?
0.00 on the clock, we lost to Rex Grossman 78 - 13.
He WAS that damn good in HS.
Passing was ridiculous 33 for 38, 560 yards and 7 TD's.
Derek saved the Raiders from being on this list. 😁
Yeah they definitely should be on this list
No he caint win in the playoffs so we should definitely be number 1 on this list
I'm sure the bears is featured in this video sadly.
I've been a Bears fan for 52 years. I'm still waiting to see my first good quarterback.
Funny how the Haslems made Cleveland a living hell
BUT they SAVED THE Columbus Crew
Carolina recently has been bad but I don't think you can have them on here over the Jets. Carolina has had Steve Beurlein, Jake Delhomme and Cam Newton be successful QB's. Who have the Jets had outside of 2 decent years of Mark Sanchez and one year of Brett Favre?
But Carolina let their O-line go to shit. Say what you will about Marty Hurney's tenure as GM, but he never allowed the offensive line go as bad as it's been the past several years.
RIP Dwayne Haskins 🙏
Thanks 5 points for criticizing the Bears. Apparently that’s all it took to have a good QB
Nailed it with the Panthers' ownership. We will never have success with Tepper
Fuck. "The late Dwayne Haskins" hit so different. Rest peacefully. Damn.
The browns don’t ruin qbs. We just suck at drafting them. Although we did kinda ruin mayfield though considering the offensive line and coaching he had to deal with
Tim Couch was ruined
Two team to mention because they have been historically QB gravediggers: Rams and Cardinals.
Rams have had only one good QB career since Norm van Brocklin and that was Warner. Just within my memory, guys like Roman Gabriel and John Hadl were wasted or dealt away. They even had Namath for a particularly painful season. It got worse when Carrol Rosenbloom died and his widow got the team. The only QB worth mentioning in her misbegotten tenure was Warner. But someone decided he was surplus goods and he wound up being the only decent QB in the Cards' time in Arizona for a couple of seasons. He was shelved in favor of Bulger, who was given far too long to prove himself, and then a carousel up until Goff was finally allowed to play by the incoming McVey. They have maybe turned a corner, but I don't see Stafford playing more than three years before he retires.
As for the Cards, Warner was about it. I think Neil Lomax is still the franchise leader in passing yards, career.
As a Broncos fan myself, I think I speak for all of us when I say Trevor Siemien was our favorite QB since Manning retired. Why? Because after being selected in the 7th round nobody expected anything from him. After Manning retired and Osweiler left we threw Siemien into the fire. And he guided us to a respectable 9-7 season. I think had he been given a better o-line and a little better coaching he probably would’ve made a decent QB
My nephew has been playing QB since middle school and I told him if he ever got drafted into the league I'd demand a trade like Eli Manning did before I let him play for.....What's their name, my bad the Washington Commanders
Yep. Good uncle..that Damn fine culture is toxic in DMV area
With exception of the Green Bay Packers with 2 main Starting QBs for 3 decades the rest of the NFC north has been a Mess. The Detroit Lions finally broke that mold with Stafford and now Goff(so far).
But, over all The Chicago Bears, Minnesota Vikings, and Detroit Cowardlies, in the same time that the Packers have had Favre, and Rodgers, the Lions, Bears, and Vikings have had over 30 each for a total off about 100z
Until Alex Smith and Patrick Mahomes came around, you could make the argument that the Chiefs should be on this list
Len Dawson and Trent Green
Texans nearly got David Carr killed. And many others. Good you put them on this list.
Love the video man but I think Cleveland deserves to be number one, no other franchise has had the idiocy of the Browns especially at QB and now with all hands himself, Mr Grabass going to Ohio things don't look to be getting any better, except for sexual assault attorneys.
it's too cliche to put them at #1 :)
@@FivePointsVids But sometimes the cliche answer is the correct one
@@FivePointsVids Cliché sure but with all the bad days in Cleveland you should at least give them the credit they deserve, even if it is showing how inapt they are and the fact that no one can match their inaptness.
Fitzmagic is a legend
Small nitpick but Trevor Siemian was actually a pretty good draft pick. Much better than most 7th round QBs (Purdy notwithstanding).
Not to mention that the only QB success the Broncos had in the past 40 years wasn't even with their own drafted QB's. Elway and Manning both got picked by the other horse team. And the former is a prime example that being good at a sport as an athlete says nothing about one's skill as an executive (much like the Hornets owner). But because of his status as saint in Denver Elway gets away with mismanagement on the position he is supposed to know best.
Thanks for giving my texans the benefit of the doubt. Makes us fans feel better that this is still an expansion team that barely turned 20 years old.
Hail Zachary Wilson, the fourth "franchise savior" drafted by the JustEndTheSufferings since 2010.
Say what you want about Flacco but he brought stability to the QB position for the Ravens. The Ravens drafted Chris Redman, Kyle Boller and now they have Lamar.
I coined Let's Hide, FIRST! On That's Good Sports.
I knew my Bears will be on here but no Lions?
They have been consistent at QB since Stafford was drafted until yesterday when Goff coughed up 4 turnovers
A good start for the Texans was that Jack Easterby, the preacher is gone. Now the rebuild starts.
Min 0:37 Dave sounds too good to be true so he probably is!
OAKLAND?!?!?!?! Are you kidding me???? I've been a Raiders fan since the late 90s tell me a good QB they had. Go ahead I'll wait
Umm the Jets? Not even a mention? Seriosuly?
Five points country.. LET’S RIDE !
That Bryce young joke at the end hits different now 😭
It took years for the Lions to ruin Matthew Stafford.
Jets also seem to go through QBs
I still think the Commanders, and really, NFL teams in general, should build a team with a placeholder QB like Taylor Heinicke, until they think they're truly ready for spending a 1st on a QB.
He's Jimmy G/Flacco tier, sure, but he could win a ring. Build a Defense, get an O-Line ready and when the time comes, draft the 1st round QB and get a running game.
Josh Allen came into a Bills team with a defense and fresh off a playoff birth, even if it wasn't the best team, but the defense could hold and gave Allen time to figure things out.
Alternatively, their QB will be good enough with the team.
Yeah, I'm gonna need more than $500 from Dave.
No one wants to put in work and develop talent/players, they expect everything to work out for them just cause
Also Bears had Kyle Orton
Before Tua, the Dolphins would've surely been on this list. They were so horrible at drafting O-linemen, even serviceable QB's got screwed into the ground!
The problems with the Bears QBs over the years has been bad OCs, a meddling nepotism of executives, and just bad picks. Jim Miller was never a gunslinger or an OP arm talent, he managed the games well enough to win. Shane Matthews had been in/out of that pool. Cade McNown was a bust. Rick Mirer was because Michael McCaskey is a moron. Offensive Coordinator list from the 90s to today that you'd rather forget ever existed. Rex Grossman's OC was Ron Turner, but he had a good OL and RBs to hand off to, never had any receiving talent. Kyle Orton was another game manager but he knew how to make the offense work with what he had. By the time we get Cutler, the OL from rex's days is mostly gone and we get J'Marcus Webb....woof. Cutler also suffered from OC Regime Change, his longest running OC with him was 18 months of Mike Martz. Then we have Glennon, Trubisky, and now Fields. Fields is most certainly the best talent we've had at QB in a while, but he has an offensive line made up of cheap players, a decent RB tandem to hand off to, and nearly no name brand talent at WR. The strides are there, but now can the Bears put together enough tape by year's end on what we have and then get ready to roll out the amount of picks we're going to have (if we're a top 10 pick in a QB heavy draft class, it may behoove us to trade down for more picks) and the sheer clearance of cap space in $125 million ready to spend next year.
If Poles is the agent of change and modernizing the Bears front office, this offseason will show us.
Ka cough annie
2:25 Carson Wentz never had a prime 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Uh... where are NY Jets? Their best QB, Namath, had one good game in the superbowl, but was awful throughout his career. Look up his stats. Less than 50% completion rate in his career and an abysmal TD:INT ratio.
What I wanna know is why my Bills sign washed QBs as our backups (Mitch Trubisky, Case Keenum to name two).
Hey luckily it seems like Bears coaching staff have figured out how to best utilize Fields.
what ever happened to Wentz, he came into Killadelphia on top the world, Got injured a few games before the big one and then never came back the same. Its just strange how he never recovered back into a star QB and now just seems to trade around.
How do you put up the panthers over a team like the jets or miami?