Can Israel Ignore World Court's Order? Experts Weigh in on ICJ Genocide Case
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 มิ.ย. 2024
- Support our work: democracynow.org/give
We continue to look at the International Court of Justice's interim ruling in South Africa v. Israel with Stockton University professor Raz Segal and human rights lawyer Diana Buttu. We discuss Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's response to the ruling, the role of the United States in stymying international action and more. We also hear more from ICJ president Joan Donoghue's delivery of the ruling, including the court's acknowledgement of the dire humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs on over 1,500 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream at democracynow.org Mondays to Fridays 8-9 a.m. ET.
Subscribe to our Daily Email Digest: democracynow.org/subscribe
*“The biggest insult to the memory of the Holocaust is not denying it but using it to commit genocide against the Palestinian people.”*
*- Norman Finkelstein*
the sheep are now the wolves ..
so true 100%
Finkelstein is just a degenerate, self-hating sociopath. The guy should just be ignored.
When will anyone of you learn history genocide ? Are you there ? Do you even know what a fuxken genocide is ? Pathetic are you all 12 and worship tik tok
He's a gross person
Israel will ignore it and the Us will cover for the in the UN.
@@vivavasquez hahha good luck
If the court had been firm on a ceasefire I'm 100% convinced that the court would no longer exist.
Izrael’s supporting countries will have to think twice from now on before handing blind check to izrael as they can be charged with complicity in potential genozide
The US can't even cover Biden's diaper. The US helped the Nazi party come to power and destroy Israel. In the end, the US elite will lose nothing, but Israel will pay for everything.
But the whole world will refuse to ignore
Einstein said : The problem is not the evil in the world. The problem is that we let it happen
The problem is mankind , human nature . God should have quit , before he created man .
I strongly disagree. The problem is both the evil in the world and also the fact that we let it happen. Both can be true at the same time. Einstein was clearly wrong in this quote
@@Antithesist ok. Fact is that there are people that act evil, wich is propably difficult to change. Fact is as well that many people could be more active to stop evil.
He also warned that the Zionist project will become fascism
He also warned 🇮🇱 would become fascist
The older I get the less I understand this horrrible world we live in
It helps when you realize that we humans are actually the Most evil brutal species on the Planet Once you accept that You'll sleep better
Lol what 'mEsSiAh'? The messiah who made most of us in this comment section poor and powerless and sad and lonely and unable to stop this genocide!? That 'meSSiaH?
I feel the same way about this insanity of needing to protest against genocide... But if you think about it, this has nothing to do with anything more than greed. Money. Power. Control. Cheap goods and corporate profits. That's the inhumanity of humanity.
@@injusticeanywherethreatens4810... I was really hoping at the very least a bolt of lightning would strike down that monster of a prime minister instead of making ancient dreamy promises of free land to those stealing it from the native owners first place. I guess that was too big of an ask.🤦🏻♀️
Make sure u leave with a bang, and invite a Israel to come along.
Thank you jews, muslims, christians, athieist etc. etc (basically the humanity) to stand up for what is right. We need to continue our efforts and make sure genocide happens NEVER AGAIN.
This lukewarm ruling may just encourage it to happen again.
You mean the October 7 genocide
Rastafarians except Ziggy Marley who defended Israel, we also thank atheists. Spiritualists. Buddhists, witches and so many more people of many backgrounds.
@@scottwilliams7726
You mean that killing 600 Jews is genocide but killing 30,000 Palestinians isn't?
Tell that to Isrealis, American, Germans and British... All with extensive history of Genocide.
My tax money is not for Weapons that kill the innocent! DISGRACEFULL!
Why are you paying taxes then? lol
What about the innocent killed on 10/7? Many of those "innocent" Palestinians voted for, and continue to support the ones who did 10/7!
@@DavidJohnson-tv2nn Zionist Israel as you know is an ILLEGAL occupier of Palestine, and it gives the people of Palestine the right to resist their occupiers. Zionist have murdered thousands of Palestinians before 7/10. Their Mow the Lawn policy have murdered and maimed and deliberately targeted children. Zionist Israel has placed the a food, water and fuel embargo on Gaza, before 7/10.
Zionist Israel has now murdered over 10 000 children, and over 5000 women in this genocide.
@@DavidJohnson-tv2nnmost killed on October 7th were killed by IDF under the Hannibal Directive. This verified common knowledge by now. Palestinians have the right to self defense.
@@jayleeper1512 More blame the victim anti-Semitic BS. Do you actually support Hamas????
May humanity and basic decency be restored as soon as possible. Thank you to the ICJ, to South Africa and to Democracy Now.
lol
Love you Amy! I worked with Bonnie Faulkner on Guns N' Butter at KPFA back in the late 90's. She turned me on to your program. You have stayed hard and true to your craft and still doing great journalism. You are an American treasure and a voice for the world.
There is a sanction on Israel shipping by the Houthi. But the US and UK are saying that they are a terrorist organization. Who is upholding international law and who are supporting continuation of genocide?
The usa and uk and hell izrahell are all terrorist organizations,
No there isn't. Most of the ships they attacked were bound for the Suez Cannal.
Time for talk's on both sides.
@@robfl100Ignoramus. The Yemenis attacked Israeli-owned and operated ships (whether they use the Suez Canal or not). Since the US and UK deemed it necessary to illegally attack another sovereign country, the Houthis are now attacking Yankee cargo ships as well. 5D chess move by the Anglo-Saxons gas backfired.
Yemen has apparently passed a law calling UK and US terrorists too.
I believe that in the future history will remember this period as one of the dark ones in which many, indeed too many, pretended not to know and became complicit.
They'll remember it as the second time people fell for anti-Jewish propaganda.
Humanidade age com loucura será havera futuro??????
@@MustardSkaven ...says the guy with a gamer channel. This isn't a game.
@@MustardSkavenAnti-Jewish? Do you think this war has made Israel safer? Ask the many people who have left Israel. The people pushing for this war are guilty of being anti-Jewish.
@@MustardSkaven I condemn all forms of discrimination, without distinction anti-Semitism and Islamophobia but I believe that the real enemy of the Jews are the Zionists themselves with their behavior before but especially after October 7th
IDF targeted a UN refugee camp just the day before ICJ's ruling, for goodness' sake. With ICJ's overwhelming ruling, it will be interesting to see how this plays out.
if you watch the whole thing you would see that Israel gave an evidence that there was a missile launcher inside it... but i guess its better stay ignorant
Some of the strongest voices speaking against the injustice in Palestine have been Jewish to include Raz Segal, Ilan Pappe, Norman Finkelstein, Sam Seder and Gideon Levy. Kudos to all and apologies to the names I have forgotten to recognize.
I'd like to add Miko Peled to your list.
Noble Jewish people and they should be made distinct from Zionist's who are Fascist in every respect!!!!
Max Blumenthal
@@ValerieGriner OMG…can’t believe I forgot Mr. Peled and also Max Blumenthal as well. Thanks!
Aaron Mate , Gabor Mate , Kate Halpern , countless more journalist too
So long as Bibi enjoys 100% support from the US media and government they can do what they want with no repercussions.
Those behind Bibi are even more extreme. Even the left wing are racist af
Can Biden do that and win reelection?
Indeed, never underestimate the evilness of Zionism in any form.
Or over estimate their immunity.@@Stop-and-listen
There will be repercussions for a very long time.
The court is asking Israel to prevent doing what they've already done.
Little late isn’t it
UNSC ruling on Dec 22nd should be an indication of how serious they'll take it
i would rather say the court was asked to step in after the international community has failed horribly for over 100 days. by ICJ standards this ruling came rather quickly.
@@tomthecasual5337 But the ICJ rulings are enforced by the UN Security Council, and any of the 5 permanent members can veto enforcement.
So, the same international community that failed for more than 100 days is the same international community that can block enforcement of law.
@@DrejaAndi yeah but the situation is different right now. before, if the UN SC vetoed the measures against israel, in the public eye it went against the opinion of academics, protestants and activists. but now it is a legal order from the highest court based on established facts.
going against that would make the members look really really bad in the public eye. and that matters a lot more than people think. if it wouldn't, propaganda wouldn't exist.
for example, right now polls are showing that biden will likely lose reelection due to his handling of the war on palestinians.
public opinion forces regime changes in powerfull democratic countries. fortunately or unfortunately, that's how it works
Enough of empty Words ...WE NEED ACTIONS RIGHT NOW!!!...........thank you Democracy Now you are the best !
As a Palestinian, I don't seek revenge, only my rights to be free in my country, peaceful Jew's are also welcome, no Zionists.
Nevertheless, if those Zionists don't respect the court's orders today, how do you expect me to respect the same rules when time comes?
@@jorgerubenstein8669
Trolling Much?
And you wonder why nobody, not your Arab neighbors, the western powers nor the ICJ, are moving an inch to save you from your hatred and violence. The time you're delusionally referring to, isn't coming.
Yes you are facts matter @@Tina-qn8bg
@@jorgerubenstein8669 I know my family's history for at least 5 generation, how about you? Go check your DNA and u Will know where u belong, for sure not in Palestine.
I wouldn’t judge you for treating them the way they treated you.
The ICJ, like any other court, has no real power without an executor of its will. The executor is the US, and they say no.
We people have the power. Israel should not take part of the Olympic Games. for a starter.
US to rejects and thus inflicting huge moral CREDIBILITY damage internationally, likely an apocalypse
That‘s not true their is a possibility in the UN especially in case the security council fails to enforce such decision.
The USA is now in a bad situation cause if they ignore it, they will be even more weakened and isolated on the world stage which will benefit all authoritarian regimes across the world and further limit its influence. Also it will put to debate to reform the UN which the USA certainly don’t want to happen.
So it is a dangerous geopolitical situation for the USA.
US CREDIBILITY is the prices to pay and it's permanently, Mark My words
If the US deligitimises the court, then they can't use the same court in the future for other countries
This is a very important ruling. It gives the US less credibility when they claim they have no power to end this abhorrent cleansing of Gaza.
It’s not a matter of “can they?”, it’s a matter of “what will the UN do when they ARE ignored?”.
Amy, you read my mind. Netanyahu claims that there is no one that can regulate his behavior but his government enlisted and sent a whole team of lawyers etc. to the Hague to represent Israel. That's insight into his usage of intimidatory language to manipulate and fear monger those who oppose his genocidal intentions and actions. If he was truly unconcerned he wouldn't have shown up.
The court has no jurisdiction over Israel, they're like the US, a nonmember and outside their jurisdiction.
All he cares about is the cash from the USA; he has Bidumb in his pocket
...To ruin the Chinese people so they cannot be saved, the red demon
First brings you down with a culture of fighting and slovenly conduct
Then fills you up with wicked desire for sex, fame, and gain
"Don’t Follow the Red Demon Anymore
Cosmic bodies are decaying in the process of formation, stability, degeneration, and disintegration
Most people in the world are Gods incarnated, seeking the Creator before disaster
Gaining Dafa [Great Law] and remolding your divine bodies-that’s your wish upon coming here
In the treacherous human world, how many can keep their nature amid delusion
People all know the evil Party is bad
Yet they follow along when it lies and persecutes Dafa disciples
All know the evil Party is destroying traditional culture
Why praise it at its feet when it smears history
To ruin the Chinese people so they cannot be saved, the red demon
First brings you down with a culture of fighting and slovenly conduct
Then fills you up with wicked desire for sex, fame, and gain
Before disaster comes, I still want you to hear the truth
As the vow you made before coming to the world was pledged on your life
March 15, 2017"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin V, from Falun Dafa teachings)
This is factually incorrect. Both the US and Israel have ratified the Geneva convention, and this is likely the reason why the state of Israel showed up. @@LunaLapin-ho5tk
World wide public opinion is against the occupiers of Palestine ! ! !
Respect Raz Segal for his professionalism and objectivity.
I don't see why anyone would take pride in murdering women and children and again claim self defense
How evil can that be?🤔
Thats Hamas for you.
Thank you Democracy now for helping fight for justice 🙏
What a wonderfully balanced panel. An anti-Israeli Palestinian, and an anti-Israeli Israeli. It’s good to know that you are so intent on providing diverse viewpoints.
Exactly. Thank you. So diverse in their positions…
The real question is: Can the US ignore World Court's Order!
The US is not a signatory to the Genocide convention, just let that sink in for a minute.
@@sayjustwordstome Show me a better one! This is the one with at least some legitimacy!
And the US shows its worst side of exceptionalism here. The highest court overall is trust, and the US cannot be trusted in this matters, if it defends Israel no matter what! Ask your youth!
@@sayjustwordstome The US is complicit in genocide...and therefore the US is a terrorist state!
I want to add: The good side of US exceptionalism is, that the US could stop this mess immediately. I still remember, how Reagan stopped a mess in the Middle East (or Near East, how we call it)...
US ignore it. Their judge voted against it in the court. They just pretend to give us democracy but in reality they are the true dictators.
Sadly, Israel can because no one can really stop it. The party who could make the most impact in doing so (USA) will continue to give Israel military aid and diplomatic cover.
And the other Arab countries who hate Hamas.
US and UK together but the consequences will be the CREDIBILITY and is the prices to pay permanently
@@mengreat6982 What credibility does the West have?
True, and it's because the ZIONISTS rule the U.S. (in EVERY aspect). I'm so ashamed to be an American. Israel is Mystery Babylon (in the Bible) and the U.S. is the WHORE of Babylon. We fit the bill.
@@LunaLapin-ho5tk USD, bonds, treasuries......the final nail in the coffin
I can’t believe one country can bully in such way that no one can come forward to save such suffering of humans
What part of - realease the hostages - is difficult to understand?
The part where we're on the side of the kidnappers
The Court has no jurisdiction over Hamas.
@@maryhuckaby2239 you are plain rude, and wicked😡
So proud of Stockton University for providing tenure to independent thinking!!!
Stockton is a lovely place.
Try living there.
So true in these times of powerful influence suppressing voices of truth.
THANK YOU, AFRICA, FOR STANDING WITH GAZA!!!LET'S REMEMBER ARMENIAN GENOCIDE FROM 1915-1922. HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE STORIES. BUT THE WORLD IS SILENT, AND AZERBAIJAN CONTINUES WHAT TURKS DID TO ARMENIANS. NOWADAYS, THE ARMENIAN POPULATION OF NAGORNO-KARABAKH HAS BEEN FORCIBLY DISPLACED ON SEPTEMBER 19,2023. THE FIRST CHRISTIAN NATION IN THE WORLD WAS DISPLACED FROM THE LAND OF THEIR ANCESTORS, WHO LIVED THERE FOR MANY CENTURIES. JUST BECAUSE AZERBAIJAN PROVIDES EUROPE WITH OIL AND GAS, EVEN THOUGH AZERBAIJAN IS A DICTATORSHIP COUNTRY, EUROPE, AND THE US DON'T PUT SANCTIONS ON AZERIS. AND TURKEY IS STRONGLY INVOLVED IN ALL EVIL DOING AGAINST ARMENIANS. TURKEY DOESN'T DENY IT. TURKEY SAYS WE ARE ONE NATION, TWO STATES.
Independent racist cannot even get a ceasefire
@@georgemetesky5519 I think it's Stockton University, which is located in South Jersey. Not such a lovely place.
I salute you Amy for your good works
I'll second that . Thanks , Amy , we need all the truth and light we can get , it's in short supply these days.
Uganda FO reacted astonishingly fast after discovering Judge Julia Sebutinde wild vote.
The EU has a trade deal with Israel which includes that human rights have to be respected. In 2006 Sweden put forward a motion to temporaly hold the trade agreement because Israel violated international law in Gaza- sadly nothing did come of it. They must do it now!!! The EU put sanctions for Russia in place in 5 Minutes, Israel is long overdue!
Sadly, my grim assumption on that is that they will probably somewhat "stop" in Gaza, and transfer the genocide focus to the West Bank, or Lebanon. They've seen blood, now they lust for it.
The West Bank isn't run by a terror group like Gaza elected.
I totally agree. THEY are the inhumane "animals"...not the Palestinians.
what is there to ignore? the icj hasn’t done anything basically saying « yes we can see there’s genocide but you can keep going as long as u don’t cross the red line and after 1 month of continuing your carnage you can come back to us and show us you TRIED to avoid a genocide and we ll let u go with a tap on the back ».
Maybe the courts and the abetters will but the collective memory of the world won't....karma works slow but ruthless!
Israel has been cited NUMEROUS times for crimes against humanity and NOTHING has ever changed.
Israel are basically playing by Hamas rule book!
Forced to. In the ME, might is right.@@PB111627
Untrue, but I understand why this could be an opinion.
ALL countries belonging to the UN can pressure Israel to abide by the Genocide Convention.
These Nations could, in fact, bring their own evidence to South Africa and this to the ICJ.
Case in point: Russia ignored much the same type of order from the ICJ so sanctions CAN be applied to Israel as Russia found out.
Military weapons can be blocked from Israel, money also.
International pressure is entirely possible, in fact very likely on the USA, UK, European countries and Canada.
Thank you all specially professor Segal 🙏 ❤️ 🙌
Finally! after 75 years justice prevailed for the first time and the world welcomes that.
- Netanyahu let the attack happen on his own country, despite knowing about the attack 3 days before it happened.
- Music festival was organised with lot of foreigners just 3 miles away from the border. On whose order?
- Music festival was extended by one day as the attack did not happen when it was thought to happen. On whose order?
- Noticing that music festival casualty were less, used IDF to increase the casualties in the music festival. On whose order?
Shhh. You got the truth posted, but be careful the "TheirTube" censoring bot doesn't discover it.
Yes, very strange!? 🥺
That's right - 10/7 was an Inside Job just like 9/11! They had knowledge from their own intel a year out, they received intel from Egypt beforehand and Netanyahu ordered "stand down" on 10/7. It was an inside job to colonize the land and also draw Iran into war with the US & Britain backing it all.
Those are things no ody talks about. In the end, was attack really done by hamas? Idf killed lots of people there.
@@liepa7768 20 years ago, a WMD lie was told to the world and a country was destroyed based on that lie, when the crazy politicians knew very well from the beginning that they have cooked up the lie. The puppet media deliberately did not ask the questions then. Puppet media is doing the same again.
“Genocide is intention and execution”
And that's precisely what's happening...
Genocide!!!! Genocide!!! Genocide!!! Genocide!!! Genocide!!!....You silly, ignorant children just LOVE to say that word, huh...Try learning what the word actually means. Israel is in a war, after they were attacked FIRST...NO genocide happening
There is always hope when there are honest people like Raz Segal - telling the truth !!!!
I whole heartedly welcome the courts rulings. Now, does anyone know what metrics will be used to adjudicate on compliance to the rulings? For instance what would we expect to find in Israel's first report to the court, due in 30 days?
This is a preliminary hearing ,no court proceedings have been carried out yet
Overwhelming majority even from US Judges. SA makes Africa proud!
So the decision was the same as what US and EU says, that it would be nice if Israel would abide with international law. Basically, lip service.
Israel isn't under international law just like the US isn't under international law. You have to be a member of the court before it has jurisdiction over you.
Essentially
As the first guest said, if Israel does not respect the decision of the International Court of Justice, the next step will be sanctions. This time, Israel finds itself in a dire situation. Now our voices can bring real change.
Exactly. Unbelievable, really.
Sanctions will begin. It destroys economies. Let's boycott US and UK too. 😘
Did it stop over there yet? I hadn’t heard a word about the verdict of the South African trial of genocide
Of course they are, just say it , we can all see it!
Of course Israel is going to ignore it and they know they can because they have the backings of a superpower. The United States
The most important thing was the ruling that S. Africa's claim that Israel is engaging in Genocide is "Plausible." The Court has essentially put Israel under Court Supervision for the alleged crime of Genocide. It did not reject S. Africa's claim as "meritless" or "without foundation" as the Western Powers, America & Germany claimed. Israel has to report back to the ICJ in 30 days on effective measures to prevent Genocide.
😂😂😂 They don't have any power
@@Molly-uk2uf they’re all the people who oppose genocide have. Gfy
Not only that but the judgements were 15-2, 16-2, in favour of South Africa. So it shows that despite everything that Israel tries ito its propaganda, even the ICJ, did not agree with them.
They can ignore it, and the Security Council via the US, will veto (that this is even allowed, is such an abomination of justice) any judgement against Israel. So it is important that the people and countries places pressure on the US, and the UK, who remain the biggest cause for all of this genocide.
@@Don.M.
My comment was not rather genocide has occurred. My comment was that No one can stop another Country.
It's a War. Genocide occurres in EVER WAR.
@@rada9748
Genocide happens in EVER WAR.
PROTEST ALL WARS.
Thank You All for all the information. I love your work. ❤️ 🕊️
How do all the measures of restraint outlined by the judge not add up to a CEASEFIRE?
What is the ICJ supposed to do?
Hypocrisy
This matters so much.... It's a first step of the Global South standing up and demanding that the international institutions hold the Global North accountable to the same standards. Israel will be the undoing of the the Global North.... The strategic partners can no longer pretend that the conditions Israel is creating with their support is deniable and they can and will be complicit..... There is nowhere to hide. The other countries of the Global South have a precedent as they approach the ICC....
You think South Africa has moral high ground? You have parts of that country that refuses LGBTQ rights. You have governments that support the killing of wh!te farmers.
💯
Facts!
Will you like following the Global South's rules of believing in Allah and Mohammed?
@@al67849 Islamophobia much?
Thank you so much for this video. It was very beneficial. Keep up the Great Work! Much appreciated!
Thank you Judge , for sharing this on your HF platform. This is a critical time for the world .
I didn't expect the 15-2 vote. I thought it would be 8-7
Do we know who were the two against?
@@argentinaramirez868 one was Uganda.
@@argentinaramirez868surprisingly it wasn’t the US judge. One was Israeli judge or official and that person voted against Israel once or twice I can’t remember.
@@argentinaramirez868 The Ugandan judge was the only judge to vote against all provisional measures, even the two voted in favour of by the Israeli judge. Not sure what is going on there.
@@rada9748 Uganda's are tribal and backward and are easily duped by Evangelical lies. I am betting this woman believes that Israel is 'God's people' and that voting against them would incur God's wrath. Now you can ask how can an educated person believe such basic guff, well you can start by checking their record on human rights. It is the country that created Idi Amin and Museveni. Both of whom are cretins from a primodial swamp. Ask Kenyans what they think of Ugandas and you'll get a good description.
Why should Isriael not be called as a teirroirist, for what they did and are still doing? Especially, for 10,000 children killed, 250 schools destroyed and 110 journalists killed.
Sadly, West don't recognize ....
Maybe Hamas shouldn’t have attacked Israel? You guys are arguing that, “yes we can attack Israel and take hostages. But you can’t retaliate or it’s genocide.” You guys want it both ways. Your arguing from a far left intersectionality worldview.
@@RedWing88 You are thinking from a historically blind "right" talking point. You ignore all of the innocent Palestinians who have been killed and are being starved long before the attack happened. Do some research instead of relying on current U.S. perspective talking points.
@@RedWing88hasbara account 😂😂
sada,it is israel land that arabs occupied for 1400 years,ur land is arabia,u would destroy the only jewish nation on earth,thats some evil stuff with ur lies
Thank you Great South Africa.😮😮😮😮
Peace for all
The real tragedy is that the court has allowed a one month timeline. Is that not the same as impunity?
Everyone including their dog knows Israel will not stop! The ICJ has give them a one month license to continue.
Would you stop fighting for your loved ones to be returned?
@@mn9181 They have bombed and sniped the hell out of their "loved ones". All they care is killing women and babies.
@@mn9181You must not be following this very closely.
Knowing Israhell, they'll double down and erase twice as many civilians and cry foul to Sugardaddy US when even a hint of criticism is directed their way
The court doesnt want Israel to dismiss them as Hamas supporters. So it has given them a rope to hang themselves. By reporting monthly to the court, Israelis, are forced to be more circumspect on what they do. And if you know the Israeli society, their need to be recognized is very important. Hasbara exist for that very reason. So with the ruling, their credibility is in tatters and it is has been officially stamped with the 'genocide' brand. And as one of their supporters let it slip, 'you cannot commit genocide to defend another genocide'. So they have devalued their 'holocaust' currency and a new reality has been created. Branding Israel as a genocidal state. Most nations in he global south where majority of the world lives, now accept that reality. Their project is finished.
No ceasefire? Useless.
Very predictable. Nobody can ask a ceasefire while there are hostages and military capabilities of Hhumus. In the end Hummus will be held accountable for their own people deaths
@@fernandez6143 If you must you must. Can't let a good excuse go to waste.
It's the ICJ, by mandate they have no power to enforce anything they advise. That's just basic civics.
Why was Professor Mamdani cut from the video? Can youbpls publish a full video of the discussion?
"Surely there is a future and your hope will not be cut short." I feel this ruling is significant and the number of votes in favor of this ruling significant as well. As are all the other cases involved, checking the American governments complicity in the situation. There is hope and hopefully this is a light shining through the darkest times I've seen in my days. May God be with all who stood for a people who are barely able to stand for themselves under the horror they have found themselves enduring after years of oppression and sorrows. May God be with them. I ask this in Jesus name, Amen.
Agree. The Court's ruling is historic. South Africa's case and presentation were stunning. I never ever thought I would see such a ruling on Israel in my long lifetime.
I remember writing - some 20 years ago - that Israel was destroying itself with its vicious apartheid policies and its alliance with U.S. warmongers. Too bad they couldn't think of a more creative, peaceful way to live. I currently feel despair for both Israel and for my own country, the USA. I see no path to reform and nothing but more trouble ahead. My only hope now is that China, Russia and the Global South will be able to prevent WW III, without too much more suffering to ordinary people in all of our countries.
Does Amy Goodman read these comments? I hope so. I just wanted to give her kudos on her remarkable career. It's been a long time since we were both aspiring journalists in our high school publication, "The Maroon Echo". Mr. Nash and Mrs. Myerson were our faculty advisors, and Nash told me once that Amy had a bright future in journalism. Sometimes they get it right. I never had Amy's talent and wound up playing poker. I'm proud of your accomplishments Amy!
I used to really trust Amy. But she then decided to push the Russian Collusion conspiracy theory. No matter how much evidence was against the Russian Collusion conspiracy theory, they still pushed it.
When I lived in Peru the president at the time, Fujimori, cracked down on local terrorist groups so hard that he ended up getting a life sentence for crimes against humanity. Anyways, thats the only time I can recall the world court ever actually having a successful prosecution and conviction and sentencing of anybody in cases like this.
Yes he got convicted for murder and kidnapping-killing Indigenous Peruvians, I think
@@shadowboxer3583 It’s been so long I don’t remember all the details. I do remember that he had “death squad’s” that acted under his authority and those squads committed very aggressive and deadly acts. It was crazy times. The local groups the government was fighting at the time were also very violent.
because Peru is not a rich and powerful country.
Yes, Netanyahu fits in that category all right, but he is going to weasel his way out supported by the USA and the Europeans.
I wanna know why people are saying Israel committed genocide (that's to erase a race ) when they gave warning to the people of palestine
The ICJ ordered Hamas to unconditionally release the hostages. Does anyone think that Hamas or any Palestinians will comply?
The ICJ did not "order Hamas to unconditionally release the hostages." They have no jurisdiction over Hamas (which may be the reason - or one of the reasons - they didn't directly order an Israeli ceasefire). They merely recommended that Hamas hostages be unconditionally released.
@@maryhuckaby2239 As you say, this is the closest thing they can do to an order.
Would you agree that Hamas is the Defacto or perhaps the actual government of the Gaza Strip?
PaulTeich©️01/28/24
As queen Amidala of the Nabu have stated people are dying. We cannot sit back and watch politicians and whistle debate the death of people in session.
Stop the wars
It will also be interesting who has access to or benefits from the new gas fields off the coast of Gaza and who the contracts go to for rebuilding Gaza
This should show every Muslim that turning to other means will not help us. We must support each other to protect each other.
Trust Allaah and the resistance is sunnah..no colonial western judges can give just judgement..what did we expect.
True that turning to other means will not help but to rely solely upon Almighty Allah in all conditions
Muslims are a majority so why is Israel still doing what they’re doing?? Why did uae send psychiatrists to Israel (not Gaza) to help Israeli soldiers trauma?? Because religion is what got us here. It’s NOT the solution. Just be human!
This hearing was not about judging Israel as guilty of Genocide. We already know they are. It was about confirming they have a case of Genocide to answer and that was confirmed with the reiteration of the compelling evidence summarized by the head judge. In the meantime it is irrelevant whether they abide by the courts provisional orders which we know wont be adhered to.
The International community in solidarity with Palestine continues to grow massively as part of the beginning of the end of 75 years of atrocities and is now in full swing towards bringing this criminal, rogue, colonial Zionist project to an end.
The Zionist propaganda machine has become a hard sell and rendered virtually obsolete to the majority.
Can Israelis ignore the court. Yes, they have ignored anything which critizises them for years, they are the "entitled", at least they believe they are.
Thanks for this and the information about the Oakland, CA, court case happening today.
Come to Oakland!
Don't leave ANYTHING in your parked car, tho, and be aware of your surroundings when exiting or entering your vehicle. We have carjackings every day, and close to zero law enforcement.
But, don't let that stop you from enjoying the show trial 😊
It will not change anything. They own the U.S. gov.
@@georgemetesky5519It’s that bad? I feel for you guys. If you really wanted to see a messed up city, come to flint Michigan lol.
Just imagine the reparations that will have to be paid.
The UK isn't that clean either
It is UK that gave Arabs land to Isreal and cause all the conflicts.
Government in Britain is up on charges too
@@PalestineSupporter23when did that happen 😅😅😅
@@ballerinatop5483 sorry what coloniser?
Does NOBODY remember October 7, 2023???
Yes. let me remember it to you:
Furthermore, during a lengthy interview on Israel's Channel 12, Porat speaks of intense gunfire after Israeli forces arrived and elaborates that, although the resistance fighters were heavily armed, she never saw them shoot captives or threaten them with their guns.
She also highlights that the Israeli army announced their arrival at the settlement “with a hail of gunfire,” catching the resistance fighters and their captives by surprise.
Source: TheCradle -> Survivor of Hamas assault says Israeli army 'undoubtedly' killed their own civilians
Excellent guests Amy !
Fantastic reporting !
Segal goes on Al Jazeera two days ago, and predicts today's verdict to be a "game changer". Nice.
BOYCOTT ISR@EL
The Western World is for Israel.
😅😅😅😅😅
Criminals like to think, that they are not guilty - that's why we need executive organisations....
Not true. Many criminals know for a fact they're guilty, and just lie about it.
I would like to remind everyone that while tRUmP is wrong about Palestinians celebrating 9/11 in New Jersey; they were on the streets in Gaza and the West Bank. Iranians went on the street sympathizing with America.
Why wouldn't they celebrate? The US has been funding and arming their oppressors for 80 years.
They want to give Netanyahu the Nobel Peace prize.
There's a special prize waiting for Bibi in hell.
😂😂😂😂
Nobel pieces prize!!!?😂
Did you mean Nobel Genocide Price!!!!!
Probably a bunch of Left-wing Christian groups. Believe me as a person in Christian circles - I hate how our Left-wing Christians gush over virtue signaling. I don't think Netanyahu needs a medal, even though i approve of his work.
The Left-wing vs Right-wing dynamic in the Churches.
Me Raz, thank you for your analysis- very impartial and professional
SA did not and could request a ceasefire as it is not a party to the conflict. The original request was for halting military activities and protecting civilians. Ordering a ceasefire is the prerogative of the security council and not the ICJ.
The original demands by South Africa are articulated on page 82 of their submission before the ICJ.
Ryme Katkhouda
The icj disappointed us by not ceasing fire
I have great respect for South Africa and the independent media. Their tireless efforts have yielded success, in my opinion, as a member of the global community who values liberty and justice for all. Their commitment to these values is truly commendable.
💯
That’s hilarious. You should check out their policies on the LGBTQ community. Also how they treat white farmers.
@@RedWing88 we are talking about genocide of innocent civilians. Have some compassion!
The ICJ ruling very disappointing ; it could have done more to protect the people of Gaza. It should have ordered an immediate cessation of the war
Only the Gazans themselves can protect themselves. Firstly, they get their Regime to surrender unconditionally. Then they must release the Israeli hostages.
Finally, they must compensation to the Israelis for all their suffering.
And.. what about the Gazans? N9 compensation for all the innocent killed? Shameful. @@victormeidan1062
@@victormeidan1062You are evil😮😮😮
Elena-htno you are
@Elena-ht7ku You think it's evil to not start a war? What evil is there?
Notwithstanding the ruling of the ICJ, the Israeli authorities do not seem to understand that war criminals should be afforded an all-expenses paid trip to the International Criminal Court in the Hague. Netanyahu should join them there.
It is such a sad life for young children to see horrific senes of that magnitude and not be affected. And this is what we are doing as adults with such bitterness and hatred.
The ruling of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) is effectively calling for a ceasefire because it mandates actions that inherently require a cessation of hostilities and aggressive actions. The key elements of the ruling include:
1. Prevention of Genocide Acts: The ICJ orders Israel to prevent acts that could be considered as genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. This includes stopping killings, serious bodily or mental harm, and other acts that could lead to the destruction of Palestinians.
This direction fundamentally requires an end to violent actions, which is a core aspect of a ceasefire.
2. Immediate Cessation of Specified Military Acts: The order for the Israeli military to not commit any acts described in the first point (such as killing or causing harm to members of the Palestinian group) is directly aligned with the principles of a ceasefire.
It requires stopping aggressive military operations.
3. Prevention and Punishment of Incitement to Genocide: By mandating Israel to prevent public incitement to commit genocide, the ruling aims to reduce tensions and hostilities, which is consistent with the objectives of a ceasefire.
4. Provision of Humanitarian Assistance: The directive to facilitate the provision of basic services and humanitarian assistance implies creating a peaceful and secure environment for these activities. In conflict zones, such humanitarian efforts are often facilitated by ceasefires.
5. Preservation of Evidence: The requirement to preserve evidence related to allegations of genocide acts suggests a halt in actions that could lead to the destruction of such evidence, implying a reduction in conflict-related activities.
6. Reporting on Measures Taken: The demand for Israel to report on measures taken to implement the order adds a layer of accountability and monitoring, which often accompanies ceasefire agreements.
Overall, while the ruling does not explicitly use the term "ceasefire," the measures it prescribes are aimed at reducing violence, ensuring safety, and facilitating humanitarian efforts, all of which are in line with the objectives of a ceasefire.
Both parties must agree and adhere to a ceasefire before it can be successful. Hamas has never adhered to a ceasefire. They use it to their advantage.
Even if the ICJ straightforwardly said ceasefire which is wouldn’t because they are suppling this genocide; israhell will continue to ignore it and flip the script.
@@LunaLapin-ho5tk Unlike Isrl, Hmas is NOT a state party, nor a member of the UN therefore not bound by or eligible as a defendant in the ICJ.
They have never the less claimed that they would abide by the ruling if Isrl does, wether or not this means anything or holds any water - is up for debate.
But the fact does remain, that Isrl as the only self-proclaimed democracy in the region and UN member state is bound by this ruling.
@@LunaLapin-ho5tk Another Zionist troll spreading lies
@@hanina2976 In 2022 - 2023, Russia had massive record breaking sanctions, boycotts, seizure and freezing of assets etc imposed on it, one of the main justifications for this was the ICJ ruling against them in 2022. In a similar vein it opens up the legalizing any such actions against Isrl by all other UN member states.
FREE PALESTINE
There has never been a state named Palestine.
@@CC-xn5xi that's coz isr@el has occupied their land
No Palestine!! What's Palestine?? Ha
@@msclaudiarosales learn your history.
I know...wua, wua😭😭😭
Truth hurts ha?!!!!!😂 @Mona20204
Thank you South Africa 🇿🇦 ❤
I second that. Moral superiority is now possessed by the global south.
If Israel doesn't abide by the provisions, ICJ can make an application to a higher UN authority to block US veto so the provisions are met by Israel. It is a binding agreement that Israel has committed to follow as it is a member of the ICJ organisation.
"...a higher UN authority to block US veto...". Do you mean the General Assembly? This is the first I've heard of a means to block as U.S. veto. Please explain more.
How can Israel claim to respect international law? Israel had already cumulatively violated 28 legally binding resolutions of the UN Security Council.
The question is for Hamas. Are they returning the hostages?
No. This is on Isreali genecide crime. Not on Hamas releasing hostages.
@@JasmineHuang Then the whole trial is a non-starter.
This continues until hostages are released, that's the mandate on the ground.
Thank you very much!
@@georgemetesky5519you can't use that excuse when Israel refused multiple offers.
What authority does this court have over any nation? None.
It's never all right to hurt a child 💯
Unless it's a Jewish child, right?
Always above the law
Means danger on world peace
As the first guest said, if Israel does not respect the decision of the International Court of Justice, the next step will be sanctions. This time, Israel finds itself in a dire situation. Now our voices can bring real change.
The US will veto sanctions but it is still important to try
This ruling is essentially repeating what the Biden administration has already stated: Israel must comply with the international law and let humanitarian help into Gaza. The ruling highlights the risk of genocide but apparently for the court there was not enough evidence yet to rule on that, instead the ruling on genocide will take years. In the meantime Israel must provide monthly reports on its war activities. The ruling sounds very lenient and trustworthy of Israel, giving it plenty of time to change the genocide narrative and asking Israel, the potential genocide perpetrator, to provide evidence of its own potential acts of genocide. Despite the ruling, this court case is historical and helps drawing support to Palestine from the global public, which will be eventually the true judge of what is happening in Gaza. Thank you South Africa for such an incredible fight for justice.
Me not watching as, upon introduction, the two dudes were sooo not looking at their phones...
the dues will just scream "but hollow cost" and get away with like they always do.
If in effect, to get aid into Gaza, they would practically need to be a ceasefire, then why didn't the ICJ just say ceasefire?
If Israel continues to withhold aid etc it will seal its own fate re genocide charge. It would ignore a straight order to ceasefire, this I think is harder to ignore.
Israel is not withholding aid, Hamas terrorists take food, water, medicines, away from civilians at gunpoint.
@@gillps5130 they have already ignored the UNSC aid resolution, why would they respect this one?
As long as people can be bought or canceled, they won't be forced to stop.