Yes I realise I kept saying Hostile Skies when I meant Wings of Glory lol, sorry! All of the honourable mentions are in the description now! Had to reupload it due to TH-cam issues, sorry if some of you got double pinged! Hope you enjoy and do please tell me how you guys would rank them!
Nope! I still talk to Wes every now and then, he’s doing very well (other than the fact he was a bit ill these last few days). He’s just taking some time off TH-cam, he might come back he might not, that’s up to him.
Its no contest, I want to enjoy the wonder of flying, not engage in repetitive labor for hours IN A VIDEOGAME. CMON THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE AN ESCAPE FROM REAL LIFE XD In all seriousness, grinding is a hard thing to make fun, and gets a bad rap thanks to simulators, but I dont think I want a flight simulator to be a grinding game.
@@anasadio3040 for me aero is kinda to grindy but also isnt pay to win and the content is equal to neo so its top 1 the pay to win is for wings of glory which is more hellish after 8.9 and the grind to but then gin just buy to many medals so u can skip the grind and get every thing and the devs re nerfing every ok and non brain dead ( mig 9 players)
Aeronautica was well deserved, I personally found it in it's extremely early stages, before the Avalon continent update is how I have to put it, but I saw big potential and it has been an absolute joy to see such a small team flourish into over 20 odd people and grow into a massive community of over 15 thousand people which is massive!, and for that I applaud them, they turned a web browser into a piece of aviation art, and to be honest, they didn't remake wingz world, they reimagined it.
0:31 Emergency Landing 1:25 Hostile Skies 2:23 Acceleration 3:22 Wings of Glory 4:33 Airplane simulator 5:37 Neo Warefare X 6:40 Project Flight 7:38 Flight Line 8:54 PTFS (Pilot Training Flight Simulator) 11:00 Aeronautica The time stamps are up there not down here
Having started playing Wingz World back in 2013 or so, it has always been a dream of mine to see this kind of game be popular, but never really expected it. Now as a part of the Aeronautica team I'm absolutely baffled by how much the game has evolved, now being a match for the leading Roblox flight sims. Massive salute to Patron for this awesome result, and even featuring one of my planes, the B-17 :) And also a big thank you to the development team for having allowed me on board this project. PS: I'd like to mention one of the most recent updates which introduced custom liveries, already available for over 70 aircraft. It allows players to create any real or fictional livery, rather than being bound to the generic pre-made 3-color liveries. In my opinion it's one of the most significant updates so far.
Incredible work with Aeronautica, it’s an incredible game with an incredible team behind it, really been amazing seeing it progress to where it is today
As a part of the Aeronautica Community I am filled with so much joy that my favourite game has made it to the list, even better it's number one on the list! (In your opinion of course) and my smile won't simply fade away from this video, thank you!
Interesting reasoning lol, I feel like taxi lines are a relatively small issue in the grand scheme of things, I’d much rather have Aeronautica’s dynamic weather, ALS and ATC features than taxi lines at the end of the day.
I must say, it was quite surprising to see Neo Warefare X at 5! But with this being flight SIMULATOR review (and with neo being a combat sim) Aeronautica definitely deserves first place.
Neo is super awesome, but not a great solo experience and you really need to play it with friends who know how to play in order to get the full experience. It’s also a spaghetti code and an absolute mess of UIs and ideas. Really needs a cleanup and a menu update.
@@PatronRBLX Hopefully that new “Combined Arms” game they just announced fixes Neos Issues. I feel like (if pulled off correctly, which considering the weight of the devs behind it, is likely) it could easily overtake most of the games on this list simply by offering satisfying, accurate ish combat gameplay that doesn’t turn your computer into Chernobyl. It’ll turn it into three mile island instead.
@@tywilliams4332 I like playing Neo but it rarely gets actual updates, and all the bugs are incredibly annoying now Such as the CV “Back-and-forth” unless you have attachable catapults (I mostly use WW2 era things, which explains my hatred) Also models, some of them are high quality (Ticonderoga, Cleveland, Fletcher, North Carolina, Montana…) while most of them are awful (Yorktown, Shokaku, Kaga, Des Moines, Worcester, Taiho, even maybe the Essex, and all the Soviet Destroyers)
Thanks for mentioning Wings of Glory! It's easily my favourite flying game and I am fortunate enough to work on it with the team, you are absolutely right with the community, it's what also led me to apply for the job. Awesome, have a good 1. :)
Wings Of Glory imo is one of the most fun and entertaining games ive played. Over 60 aircraft keeps you always wanting to unlock and fly new planes, while the grind is still fun and not punishing. The kills are satisfying, the community is friendly and loyal. There is so much I could talk about!
I was really hoping for aeronautica to be first from the start. I was glad to see ptfs as second and then just hear that iconic aeronautica music. So deserved. Great list bro
As a true lover of Wings of Glory I gotta be slightly sad it’s so low but it’s understandable, If anybody hasn’t checked ed it out you really should. The dogfights are incredible, especially in high tier with supersonic fighter jets and Fox 2 missiles
I have personally dedicated so much of my life with AFS, (acceleration) and VFS, their former velocity flight sim. It really saddens me to see what happened to those wonderful games, after grinding so much with so much high anticipation, I was brutally let down with what the developers had in mind for the game, and how they basically all went on to do different things with their lives that wasn't AFS or VFS. VFS was such an awesome nostalgic FS, but now you cannot even play it without the game freezing on the loading screen, really annoying and a shame.
Besides PTFS being one of my only favorite flight sim, I personally like Flightline due to its features and the outstanding graphics of the game. I'm definitely gonna try out those other flight sims as well, they look fun. Merci (P.s. I donated a few bux in your previous vid which got sadly removed but, anyways hope you got the tip.)
fligthline is cool but as me a fan of ptfs flightline has so much controls and a little more harder to understand everything but its cool and realistic
I do honestly agree with your rating system. Although aero is a pain to grind, it does have many features other aviation games have + even more variation the planes one could choose. There's also a whole bunch of player made liveries that now make the game even more immersive in my opinion. For ptfs i'd say it is indeed a great game but at times can feel a bit stale.. it's kinda there but doesn't give you much of a goal to work towards and although the map is great and the plane models too, the choice is still a bit limited in my opinion
I am a brain ded avgeeks that has grinded in Aeronautica for months, I played since like maybe September or june 2022 and now i have grinded my self a lot of aircraft! Tips if you know how to make liveries: Do livery commision, I got payed about 2.8 MILLION WP just for making 5 liveries so yeah, Fun game!
PTFS is cool but aeronautica takes the cake for me. The game is a pain to play but then the game would be boring as crap without WP and Money. Aeronautica is becoming better and better every year, and I love it. They are making the map ginormous where it will probably take 2 hours to cross and they expand the old areas too or rebuild them. Recently, Æsir was released, and more like Arabia or Afrika are getting added soon. It also has advanced liveries so you can make ANY livery you want! Although, you have to learn how to make them. Sadly, gear tilt, flaps, spoilers and animation wont *maybe* get added but it is not confirmed. If you get bored in the game look for crates. Also the song used for aeronautica here was the loading screen VFX, Also there are many other things like some airports are based off real life airports. I like that idea more cause they are airports I know but most of the community wants fictional airports and I super disagree. Long comment ends here.
Me as a loving aviation community, its crazy how those games was from blocky games to something that is very cool, that means how roaviation is one of the best communities on roblox.
I am truly in love with this video and I think that Project Flight will grow a lot in the new year with updates somewhat frequently but it’s kind of P2W
Thank you so much! Really exciting to see how all of the games grow this year! Hopefully the list shakes up enough that’ll be worth making another top 10. Project flight to me just looks like it’s funding it’s intense development.
It's not p2w. The amount of time, that the developers put into the game is just stunning... Every update that comes out is high detailed and well checked before. I think that the devs just want a small payout for their really good work. I'm pretty sure that if they continue to work as hard as they do it now, they will easily pass any other plane game on roblox, by the end of the year.
i'm a member of the aeronautica community, i just love how the game differs from ptfs and/or neo warfare x, but i completely agree with your list. nice video btw
The reason why Flightline takes ages to update is because mostly if I'm correct there is only one developer in the game and because he focuses on adding new planes and more gameplay features, alot goes into these updates hence the time. Tho currently things that are coming soon are the A320, E190, Cockpit for the Saab, map expansion including a new far away airport. And that's pretty much all ik now. Tho good video.
It’s the same situation I talked about with PTFS, having only one developer means that the game just can’t keep up with the amount of updates that other games get. Games like Aeronautica have massive teams of devs and therefore get huge amounts of content faster.
@@PatronRBLX I agree. PTFS, Flightline or any game entering any competition must have a decently good team because while updates may take ages to come, games don't take days to die.
@@PatronRBLX And keep in mind he's developing much, MUCH higher fidelity aircraft than PTFS and Aero. His aircraft have working instruments. The others don't.
@@FurryMLG true, and a lot of players will love that, but the sad truth about Roblox flight simulators is that realism isn’t what most players are looking for, it is Roblox after all and so most players tend to be a little younger and just looking for something fun, easy and satisfying. What some people like others don’t, that’s what makes all of the games so hard to rank.
@@PatronRBLX Have to agree.but a flight simmer i love it.The physics feel real because they have delay and realistic flap speed ratios.Rn looking for 8 yr olds sayin BUT PTFS IS MUCH MUCH BETTER REALISTIC AND ALL!!!!11.
Honestly this video is motivating me to get back to roblox flight sims, especially aeronautica, since it’s never really properly grinded in that game and I’d really love to have one of the airliners
great rankings, I agree with most of them, though I think you could of added aircraft carrier onto the list, their missile system is incredible, plus they have some great handling on the aircrafts
flightline is an amazing and large part of my roblox flight sim journey and a kickstarter to my entire flight sim journey, my first butter landing was in it.
Totally agree with this video. Especially aeronautica, I play that game for ages in a row. I saw the wingz world game and played it, and i can see that the two games are fairly similar, Clarence and harden are included. Truly the best flight game on Roblox.
Well deserved to aeronautica, what a game, have been playing it since the beginning and seeing it evolve is just amazing, the aircraft are well detailed, and the slightly arcade style flying experience as well as the wide range of aircraft puts this simulator at the top, Well deserved.
I can understand why Aeronautica came in first place. It's extremely detailed and has a lot of functions and features. The cool thing is that Aeronautica and Neo Warfare is made by the same people. You can clearly see their made by the same people, looking at the GUI and general design of the game. Personally, I think Neo Warfare is the best. One of the reasons are, i dont like the grind so... I love the complex combat features about Neo Warfare. The decal system is also crazy, and people make some super detailed skins.
As a person whos played for over 150 hours and has donated to the game, i am extremely happy that aeronautica is number 1, as i also think it is the best flight simulator in Roblox (and one of the better flight sims just in general for its ability to be played completely for free). I highly recommend playing aeronautica if you haven't already. Amazing game 10/10.
PTFS feels missing so I like how someone finally acknowledges that PTFS seems to be missing what it needs to feel good. Aeronatica I only played once for some reason and didn't think much of but it was a good game.
Emergency Landing is not a pay to win game in the slightest. I understand how having gamepasses to skip grinding is annoying but you can get everything in the game for free with the currency you earn for surviving. Once you get everything there is nothing left to progress, it is understandable to make skipping the grind a gamepass - the developer needs to get paid too.
Whilst I agree to an extent, the amount of grinding that has to be done is wayyy too extreme, after spending hours on the game I was only able to unlock one of the basic perks.
@@PatronRBLX It took me only a few hours of gameplay with zero gamepasses to get the airline captain perk - it took me 300 survivals before the Eaglet update (which made it so much easier to get Eaglets) and just barely 100 survivals to get the airline captain perk after the Eaglet update. I would agree with you if it was prior to the Eaglet update but after that update it became incredibly easier to grind Eaglets. If you keep dying then of course you will find the grind tiresome. The problem with making the grind too easy is that you lose the retention of players, the developer took the feedback of the grind being annoying and made it way more attainable to get but for some reason people are still saying it is too hard (despite it not being hard at all now). I am beginning to think it is a skill issue...
I completely agree with aeronautical being number 1, at first I didn't love it because it took hours and hours to do only a few missions but I came to love it and now it's one of my favorite games on roblox
Ptfs is less detailed compared to most of the game but i would say it's the casual approach that win..you can hop in and fly easily even with some military that is usually locked behind gamepasses..at least you have some of them free. But ye if you search realism ptfs is probably not the game to go for
Aeronautica and PTFS both use CSG models whilst Project Flight and Flightline use mesh models. Mesh is what most real games use for their models but it’s completely personal opinion what people prefer. CSG definitely fits Roblox’s ‘aesthetic’ better, but I prefer the more realistic look that Mesh models give in this context.
@@PatronRBLX If we're talking about how the plane feels, then I guess PTFS would've been over Aeronautica based on that criteria (added on to everything said on the video), because Aeronautica seems more like a grind game than a flight sim on itself, since the physics are questionable at best, even for Roblox standards. Altough I've said it, one little quirk that I dont see people talking about is one of the reasons I love Aeronautica: aircraft performance. Aeronautica has one of the most realistic acceleration/braking aircraft performance ive ever seen. When you takeoff in an A350 for example, you feel that you are getting that beast into the air by how much runway it takes and how the speed slowly goes to VR, and the braking is the same thing
Im so happy that ptfs or flightline is one time not on 1st place. Aeronautica really desrrved 1st place this time, its just that amazing for roblox flight sim standards and generally the features are endless kinda
I'm surprised you don't mention about the aeronautica update frequency like it gets pretty decent updates every 3 or so days. Areo is defo my fav plane game and I'm happy to be a part of the community.
What started as a nostalgic Wingz World remake. Has now out ranked even Flightline. Sure, it's not in the same category as Project Flight & PTFS. But with what it's based on. I think Aeronautica deserves the top spot. I mean look at Neo-Warfare X. If you think Aeronautica isn't for everyone, that flight sim makes them run away in fear! Anyways, yeah that's about it with my opinion about Aeronautica. It's a cool game overall 10/10
Genuinely in my opinion ptfs is the the best role player game because of the multiple roles ,atc, military convoys it is really good for rps in that reason
Not gonna lie im glad i found aeronautica like 2 months after it was made, ive been playing before the avalon revamp and seen the map and game develop and grow, i dont play the game as much as i used to cuz i have everything i want in the game but i do join the game and mess around every now and then
Thanks for video. But I think Flightline is the best because all things have this game Realistic Crashs more and more... So I think Flightline 1. Have a good day!
I literally started watching your videos today. Firstly, they are great, and secondly I have only played airplane simulator and Aeronautica, and surprised that airline simulator even made it in. For the whole video I was wondering where Aeronautica would place, because of the hype around PTFS I was surprised that dinner win.
Hey pat great vid i just think you should have added a honorable mentions section where games like air x and aircraft carrier would have been in and maybe aircraft carrier should have been placed higher then.
the only roblox flight simulator that i could think of other than ptfs was aeronautica because like its the only think that could possibly beat ptfs in terms of flight sim. great video also another is that i always come back to this channel to find new flight sim on roblox so tysm :D
Acceleration is pretty good game if you wanna feel the speed and do cool stunts you can never do in real life or any flight simulator that have extreme realism on it
Actually emergency landing isn't as p2w as u would think, if I'm not mistaken, you can get most or all of the game passes for free if you just play enough
i used to play aeronautica a while ago back in 2021 but then stopped playing because i had gotten supersonics and many rare vehicles, but then i made the difficult choice to reset my data in the game and now ive been playing ever since
Here is my opinion of the best flight sims: 10. Emergency landing 9. Hostile skies 8.acceleration fs 7. Wings world V 6. Airplane simulator 5. PTFS 4. neo warfare 3. Project flight 2. Aeronatica 1. Flight line (3 2 and 1 was really hard to choose but i think ima go with this)
A lot of these aren't really flight simulators, they're flight arcade games because they aren't properly simulating flight by being highly unrealistic (Hostile skies, and Neo warfare X, PTFS)
My Flight Simulator Rankings: 1: Pilot Training Flight Simulator PTFS is good if you want to fly planes in Roblox, but not as extreme as the others. It’s really chill for a bit of fun, which can be good if you want to unwind. 2: Aeronautica It’s honestly not for me. But, the graphics, the realism, and the array of aircraft you can choose from really gives it a “thumbs-up 5 stars” rating. 3: Project Flight Project Flight is very realistic. It’s regularly updated with a few but decent planes. The fact you can choose emergencies as well triggers creativity for many players, which to me is good. 4: Neo Warfare X Very nice gameplay and graphics. The fact that it has military combat functions is really cool, and also I haven’t played this. 5: Wings of Glory It’s a fairly decent game, with a grinding system similar to Steel Titans. All the freedom you have to fly around and shoot other players really brings me joy. 6: Flightline It doesn’t have much, but it’s ok. I mean, it has crash physics, but other than that, not much. 7: Airplane Simulator It’s not as bad as all the previous ones, but it’s low-poly. But, I feel like that low-polyness fits it, so it passes. 8: Hostile Skies It’s very similar to Wings of Glory, but not as good-looking and functional. It’s mid, I guess. 9: Acceleration I haven’t played this, but 99R for a sort of shitty graphic and function game? Not worth it. 10: Emergency Landing Honestly, it doesn’t have much functionality. To actually pilot the plane you need a gamepass, which isn’t fair to me.
Yes I realise I kept saying Hostile Skies when I meant Wings of Glory lol, sorry!
All of the honourable mentions are in the description now!
Had to reupload it due to TH-cam issues, sorry if some of you got double pinged!
Hope you enjoy and do please tell me how you guys would rank them!
wings of glory 1 for sure love the game
@@goofydoober-cu1fs Good choice!
@@PatronRBLX is Wes dead?
you should also try aircraft carrier it has gotten better so far after the year and aslo Nerv Military airbase there all real nice
Nope! I still talk to Wes every now and then, he’s doing very well (other than the fact he was a bit ill these last few days). He’s just taking some time off TH-cam, he might come back he might not, that’s up to him.
Aeronautica is the simulator you play if you can handle a grind. PTFS is the simulator if you want a chill experience. Well done to all mentioned!
Thanks!
I handled the grind all right, and sometimes, I even hop back on to grind for more planes. Can't do it on any other game.
Its no contest, I want to enjoy the wonder of flying, not engage in repetitive labor for hours IN A VIDEOGAME. CMON THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE AN ESCAPE FROM REAL LIFE XD
In all seriousness, grinding is a hard thing to make fun, and gets a bad rap thanks to simulators, but I dont think I want a flight simulator to be a grinding game.
@@HANKSANDY69420 the absolute definition of online labor is War Thunder
@@MirrorBusta2nd *sounds exaggerated*
Excellent to see Aeronautica up there
9
For me aeronautica shoud be in 4
@@anasadio3040 for me aero is kinda to grindy but also isnt pay to win and the content is equal to neo so its top 1 the pay to win is for wings of glory which is more hellish after 8.9 and the grind to but then gin just buy to many medals so u can skip the grind and get every thing and the devs re nerfing every ok and non brain dead ( mig 9 players)
Aeronautica was well deserved, I personally found it in it's extremely early stages, before the Avalon continent update is how I have to put it, but I saw big potential and it has been an absolute joy to see such a small team flourish into over 20 odd people and grow into a massive community of over 15 thousand people which is massive!, and for that I applaud them, they turned a web browser into a piece of aviation art, and to be honest, they didn't remake wingz world, they reimagined it.
I was am still am very proud to be 8 out of those 20. Regularly seeing hyper ant join the game was funny, and before the server list
Im an og too! Still remember when some of the cyber cities were still there!
not a fan of Aeronautica, it has a cash system and stuff like that isnt my thing for flight sims
edit: why you guys so rude?
@@H-E-S-Cnah you just suck at it
@@littletikesdrugmoblie nah i just dont like the system, tis why i dont play, dont gotta be so rude about it though
0:31 Emergency Landing
1:25 Hostile Skies
2:23 Acceleration
3:22 Wings of Glory
4:33 Airplane simulator
5:37 Neo Warefare X
6:40 Project Flight
7:38 Flight Line
8:54 PTFS (Pilot Training Flight Simulator)
11:00 Aeronautica
The time stamps are up there not down here
Thanks man appreciate it!
Np
Anyone else notice that he called Wings of glory Hostile sky’s at 4:25?
Oops! I wrote a lot of the script at 3am and I guess I didn’t notice when I recorded it!
Wings of glory
Having started playing Wingz World back in 2013 or so, it has always been a dream of mine to see this kind of game be popular, but never really expected it. Now as a part of the Aeronautica team I'm absolutely baffled by how much the game has evolved, now being a match for the leading Roblox flight sims.
Massive salute to Patron for this awesome result, and even featuring one of my planes, the B-17 :) And also a big thank you to the development team for having allowed me on board this project.
PS: I'd like to mention one of the most recent updates which introduced custom liveries, already available for over 70 aircraft. It allows players to create any real or fictional livery, rather than being bound to the generic pre-made 3-color liveries. In my opinion it's one of the most significant updates so far.
Incredible work with Aeronautica, it’s an incredible game with an incredible team behind it, really been amazing seeing it progress to where it is today
Hello titanium
Love Aeronautica. I've spent an unhealthy amount of hours on it and I don't regret it.
@@PatronRBLX…
The update sure is significant, I already uploaded and used a fictional "Sunny Side Airlines" livery to my 767-200ER.
As a part of the Aeronautica Community I am filled with so much joy that my favourite game has made it to the list, even better it's number one on the list! (In your opinion of course) and my smile won't simply fade away from this video, thank you!
Thank you so much! Glad to hear it!
aeronautica dosent even have taxi lines lol
Interesting reasoning lol, I feel like taxi lines are a relatively small issue in the grand scheme of things, I’d much rather have Aeronautica’s dynamic weather, ALS and ATC features than taxi lines at the end of the day.
@@kylo_yeager L bozo, go play ptfs on your ipad or whatever
Wait aren’t you blaskava airline’s founder?
I must say, it was quite surprising to see Neo Warefare X at 5! But with this being flight SIMULATOR review (and with neo being a combat sim) Aeronautica definitely deserves first place.
Neo is super awesome, but not a great solo experience and you really need to play it with friends who know how to play in order to get the full experience. It’s also a spaghetti code and an absolute mess of UIs and ideas. Really needs a cleanup and a menu update.
Neo warfare X is amazing and fun to play, especially the carrier scripts :)
@@PatronRBLX Hopefully that new “Combined Arms” game they just announced fixes Neos Issues. I feel like (if pulled off correctly, which considering the weight of the devs behind it, is likely) it could easily overtake most of the games on this list simply by offering satisfying, accurate ish combat gameplay that doesn’t turn your computer into Chernobyl. It’ll turn it into three mile island instead.
@@tywilliams4332 I like playing Neo but it rarely gets actual updates, and all the bugs are incredibly annoying now
Such as the CV “Back-and-forth” unless you have attachable catapults (I mostly use WW2 era things, which explains my hatred)
Also models, some of them are high quality (Ticonderoga, Cleveland, Fletcher, North Carolina, Montana…) while most of them are awful (Yorktown, Shokaku, Kaga, Des Moines, Worcester, Taiho, even maybe the Essex, and all the Soviet Destroyers)
@@PatronRBLX NFX does have airliners and freighters but the choices are limited.
Thanks for mentioning Wings of Glory! It's easily my favourite flying game and I am fortunate enough to work on it with the team, you are absolutely right with the community, it's what also led me to apply for the job. Awesome, have a good 1. :)
Bootleg war thunder
Wings Of Glory imo is one of the most fun and entertaining games ive played. Over 60 aircraft keeps you always wanting to unlock and fly new planes, while the grind is still fun and not punishing. The kills are satisfying, the community is friendly and loyal. There is so much I could talk about!
Wins the most satisfying award by a huge margin!
@@PatronRBLX Yup!
Tbh it copied warthunder
@@blatantac2799 If Wog copied War Thunder, then Aeronautica copied Microsoft Flight Sim XD
@@beetledesert8642 I think PTFS is more of a copy than Aero. Aero is an economy game where you have to unlock licenses to get better planes.
I was really hoping for aeronautica to be first from the start. I was glad to see ptfs as second and then just hear that iconic aeronautica music. So deserved. Great list bro
As a true lover of Wings of Glory I gotta be slightly sad it’s so low but it’s understandable, If anybody hasn’t checked ed it out you really should. The dogfights are incredible, especially in high tier with supersonic fighter jets and Fox 2 missiles
i agree with you mate, i have grown from a ultra llight pilot to a airline pilot you deserve more for your content
I have personally dedicated so much of my life with AFS, (acceleration) and VFS, their former velocity flight sim. It really saddens me to see what happened to those wonderful games, after grinding so much with so much high anticipation, I was brutally let down with what the developers had in mind for the game, and how they basically all went on to do different things with their lives that wasn't AFS or VFS. VFS was such an awesome nostalgic FS, but now you cannot even play it without the game freezing on the loading screen, really annoying and a shame.
This is such a gorgeous creation. Your eye for composition is simply unmatched 😱 😀
Aeronautica is really awesome, i clearly remember playing it back in 2021 while in a zoom meeting 🤣
Crazy how different the game is now
Great Video! I'm extremely exicted that aeronautica got first place ive been playing that game for a while it is has well deserved first.
I feel like if project flight was rated today, it would definitely get top 2 as it has just had a massive update
Even after playing it I personally feel it wouldn't beat ptfs, to me it just feels janky and honestly quite annoying but that's just my opinion.
So happy aeronautical is in top position, it was my fav flight sim last year, and it still is my favourite flight simulator
Besides PTFS being one of my only favorite flight sim, I personally like Flightline due to its features and the outstanding graphics of the game. I'm definitely gonna try out those other flight sims as well, they look fun. Merci (P.s. I donated a few bux in your previous vid which got sadly removed but, anyways hope you got the tip.)
Sorry about that but thank you so much for your support! Really appreciate it
fligthline is cool but as me a fan of ptfs flightline has so much controls and a little more harder to understand everything but its cool and realistic
and ptfs dont have the titles on the passenger windows so in that things flightline wins
@@Luhshowflightline is a more hardcore game that is trying to be a pure flight sim while ptfs is simply a fun simplified game
Hi there! I am in the Emergency Landing community (aroblon if you are curious) and I would like to simply say thanks for recognizing our game!
Thanks!
PATRONIMOOOOOOOOOOOO (again)
nah srsly, cheers to an excellent video!
Thanks again! Really glad you enjoyed it Bulls!
Wasn’t expecting to hear my main theme used in the video lol, thanks for putting aero at the number spot
Of course! Keep up the awesome work!
I do honestly agree with your rating system. Although aero is a pain to grind, it does have many features other aviation games have + even more variation the planes one could choose. There's also a whole bunch of player made liveries that now make the game even more immersive in my opinion.
For ptfs i'd say it is indeed a great game but at times can feel a bit stale.. it's kinda there but doesn't give you much of a goal to work towards and although the map is great and the plane models too, the choice is still a bit limited in my opinion
Agreed!
PTFS's biggest limiting factors are scale and the fact there is only one person working on it
I am a brain ded avgeeks that has grinded in Aeronautica for months, I played since like maybe September or june 2022 and now i have grinded my self a lot of aircraft! Tips if you know how to make liveries: Do livery commision, I got payed about 2.8 MILLION WP just for making 5 liveries so yeah, Fun game!
PTFS is cool but aeronautica takes the cake for me. The game is a pain to play but then the game would be boring as crap without WP and Money. Aeronautica is becoming better and better every year, and I love it. They are making the map ginormous where it will probably take 2 hours to cross and they expand the old areas too or rebuild them. Recently, Æsir was released, and more like Arabia or Afrika are getting added soon. It also has advanced liveries so you can make ANY livery you want! Although, you have to learn how to make them. Sadly, gear tilt, flaps, spoilers and animation wont *maybe* get added but it is not confirmed. If you get bored in the game look for crates. Also the song used for aeronautica here was the loading screen VFX, Also there are many other things like some airports are based off real life airports. I like that idea more cause they are airports I know but most of the community wants fictional airports and I super disagree. Long comment ends here.
Me as a loving aviation community, its crazy how those games was from blocky games to something that is very cool, that means how roaviation is one of the best communities on roblox.
Agreed!
I am truly in love with this video and I think that Project Flight will grow a lot in the new year with updates somewhat frequently but it’s kind of P2W
Thank you so much! Really exciting to see how all of the games grow this year! Hopefully the list shakes up enough that’ll be worth making another top 10.
Project flight to me just looks like it’s funding it’s intense development.
It's not p2w. The amount of time, that the developers put into the game is just stunning... Every update that comes out is high detailed and well checked before. I think that the devs just want a small payout for their really good work. I'm pretty sure that if they continue to work as hard as they do it now, they will easily pass any other plane game on roblox, by the end of the year.
Hostile skies is just war thunder's air battles
You know it’s a Patron video when he begins with “Ok so”
howdy! just a helper from project flight team. Just want to say thanks for your ratting and enjoying our experience!
Thank you so much! :D
Astro turf
i'm a member of the aeronautica community, i just love how the game differs from ptfs and/or neo warfare x, but i completely agree with your list. nice video btw
Thank you so much! :)
i can totaly agree on grinding games they give u a goal and they give u that little happines when u finally unlock what u wanted
The reason why Flightline takes ages to update is because mostly if I'm correct there is only one developer in the game and because he focuses on adding new planes and more gameplay features, alot goes into these updates hence the time. Tho currently things that are coming soon are the A320, E190, Cockpit for the Saab, map expansion including a new far away airport. And that's pretty much all ik now. Tho good video.
It’s the same situation I talked about with PTFS, having only one developer means that the game just can’t keep up with the amount of updates that other games get. Games like Aeronautica have massive teams of devs and therefore get huge amounts of content faster.
@@PatronRBLX I agree. PTFS, Flightline or any game entering any competition must have a decently good team because while updates may take ages to come, games don't take days to die.
@@PatronRBLX And keep in mind he's developing much, MUCH higher fidelity aircraft than PTFS and Aero. His aircraft have working instruments. The others don't.
@@FurryMLG true, and a lot of players will love that, but the sad truth about Roblox flight simulators is that realism isn’t what most players are looking for, it is Roblox after all and so most players tend to be a little younger and just looking for something fun, easy and satisfying. What some people like others don’t, that’s what makes all of the games so hard to rank.
@@PatronRBLX Have to agree.but a flight simmer i love it.The physics feel real because they have delay and realistic flap speed ratios.Rn looking for 8 yr olds sayin BUT PTFS IS MUCH MUCH BETTER REALISTIC AND ALL!!!!11.
And aeronautica keeps improving, giving us custom liveries and more destinations to go to
The best part of the video is always the "Ok soo"
Ok Soooooooo!
this is the best top 10 video i've ever seen, i absolutely agree with you in every single thing
Honestly this video is motivating me to get back to roblox flight sims, especially aeronautica, since it’s never really properly grinded in that game and I’d really love to have one of the airliners
It does take a while to get up to your first airliner, but once you have one the game moves a lot faster. Hope you have fun with it!
great rankings, I agree with most of them, though I think you could of added aircraft carrier onto the list, their missile system is incredible, plus they have some great handling on the aircrafts
It did come very close to be fair!
flightline is an amazing and large part of my roblox flight sim journey and a kickstarter to my entire flight sim journey, my first butter landing was in it.
Extremely common aeronautica W
Big W
Totally agree with this video. Especially aeronautica, I play that game for ages in a row. I saw the wingz world game and played it, and i can see that the two games are fairly similar, Clarence and harden are included. Truly the best flight game on Roblox.
Well deserved to aeronautica, what a game, have been playing it since the beginning and seeing it evolve is just amazing, the aircraft are well detailed, and the slightly arcade style flying experience as well as the wide range of aircraft puts this simulator at the top, Well deserved.
I can understand why Aeronautica came in first place. It's extremely detailed and has a lot of functions and features. The cool thing is that Aeronautica and Neo Warfare is made by the same people. You can clearly see their made by the same people, looking at the GUI and general design of the game. Personally, I think Neo Warfare is the best. One of the reasons are, i dont like the grind so... I love the complex combat features about Neo Warfare. The decal system is also crazy, and people make some super detailed skins.
Definitely agree with aeronautica
:)
As a person whos played for over 150 hours and has donated to the game, i am extremely happy that aeronautica is number 1, as i also think it is the best flight simulator in Roblox (and one of the better flight sims just in general for its ability to be played completely for free). I highly recommend playing aeronautica if you haven't already. Amazing game 10/10.
PTFS feels missing so I like how someone finally acknowledges that PTFS seems to be missing what it needs to feel good.
Aeronatica I only played once for some reason and didn't think much of but it was a good game.
I love PTFS, it was the first Roblox Flight Simulator I played, and on my first flight I flew a Cessna-172 upside down! Lol
Emergency Landing is not a pay to win game in the slightest.
I understand how having gamepasses to skip grinding is annoying but you can get everything in the game for free with the currency you earn for surviving. Once you get everything there is nothing left to progress, it is understandable to make skipping the grind a gamepass - the developer needs to get paid too.
Whilst I agree to an extent, the amount of grinding that has to be done is wayyy too extreme, after spending hours on the game I was only able to unlock one of the basic perks.
@@PatronRBLX It took me only a few hours of gameplay with zero gamepasses to get the airline captain perk - it took me 300 survivals before the Eaglet update (which made it so much easier to get Eaglets) and just barely 100 survivals to get the airline captain perk after the Eaglet update. I would agree with you if it was prior to the Eaglet update but after that update it became incredibly easier to grind Eaglets. If you keep dying then of course you will find the grind tiresome.
The problem with making the grind too easy is that you lose the retention of players, the developer took the feedback of the grind being annoying and made it way more attainable to get but for some reason people are still saying it is too hard (despite it not being hard at all now). I am beginning to think it is a skill issue...
Fair enough, but on the other hand that’s enough to turn a lot of people away myself included.
@@PatronRBLX That is a shame to hear.
I do need to play more of it, it’s a fun game, it just seems *too* grindy for my liking.
I completely agree with aeronautical being number 1, at first I didn't love it because it took hours and hours to do only a few missions but I came to love it and now it's one of my favorite games on roblox
Some of these are kinda like war thunder 🤨
True dat
Very true, I think that both Hostile Skies and Wings of Glory took heavy inspiration from War Thunder.
I think this is a pretty fair ranking. Like I don’t think he was off at all with the rankings. Nice!
Thank you!
Nah thank you! For making this video…
Me waiting for ptfs: 😐
It does come eventually!
I’m not gonna lie, but Project flight is better
@@Bacons4life-r8y it is better, but it doesnt have a passenger cabin, i have acess to pf but i play ptfs atc more xd
Game is mis
Ptfs is less detailed compared to most of the game but i would say it's the casual approach that win..you can hop in and fly easily even with some military that is usually locked behind gamepasses..at least you have some of them free.
But ye if you search realism ptfs is probably not the game to go for
i already knew about aeronautica and I've never heard a better description.
I’d give aeronautics best map and flight sim and give ptfs best plane models
Honestly I think I’d give best models to either project flight or Flightline
worst take I've seen this week holy shit
Aeronautica and PTFS both use CSG models whilst Project Flight and Flightline use mesh models. Mesh is what most real games use for their models but it’s completely personal opinion what people prefer. CSG definitely fits Roblox’s ‘aesthetic’ better, but I prefer the more realistic look that Mesh models give in this context.
@@PatronRBLX If we're talking about how the plane feels, then I guess PTFS would've been over Aeronautica based on that criteria (added on to everything said on the video), because Aeronautica seems more like a grind game than a flight sim on itself, since the physics are questionable at best, even for Roblox standards. Altough I've said it, one little quirk that I dont see people talking about is one of the reasons I love Aeronautica: aircraft performance. Aeronautica has one of the most realistic acceleration/braking aircraft performance ive ever seen. When you takeoff in an A350 for example, you feel that you are getting that beast into the air by how much runway it takes and how the speed slowly goes to VR, and the braking is the same thing
@@PatronRBLX aeronautica uses mesh models, scenery is mixed csg and mesh
Great video, personally love Aeronautica, Acceleration is apparently now 399 so
PTFS has had a few good updates like catapults on the uss Gerald and some bug fixes.
Aeronautica really deserved the 1st place with all the features. Im really happy to see it up there
Now aeronautics ain’t just a flight simulator, it has boats! This game starting to evolve past a flight sim
Im so happy that ptfs or flightline is one time not on 1st place. Aeronautica really desrrved 1st place this time, its just that amazing for roblox flight sim standards and generally the features are endless kinda
Aeronautica W
When i hear that loading screen OST, I already knew who won lol!
When I heard the airplane SIM music started playing I got genuinely exited
Excited
the new update is fire 🔥
@@mrmewgen ikr they revamped everything, but the new flight system is total trash
@@reecedefoe3277 frrr
I'm surprised you don't mention about the aeronautica update frequency like it gets pretty decent updates every 3 or so days. Areo is defo my fav plane game and I'm happy to be a part of the community.
I mentioned it in my last eat news video lol :)
3 days is inaccurate, its more like every week and a half
Holy crap I have to say thanks for making this. Now me and my friend can make funny moments
Glad you enjoyed!
Flight line theme music is just amazing
I was hoping to see plane crazy in here, but I’m really glad hostile skies and wings of glory were in here.
Love Plane Crazy too!
I put all of the honourable mentions in the description!
I have an airline in Aeronautica. It was awesome and I still fly a lot there
Wait what?? Verified user on aeronautica? Since when
I have been here for a year or more. I am lemonmyrtleyt I own Qantas. Well owned Qantas now I own Qantas Link and COO of Qantas @@noIDEA33439
What started as a nostalgic Wingz World remake. Has now out ranked even Flightline.
Sure, it's not in the same category as Project Flight & PTFS. But with what it's based on.
I think Aeronautica deserves the top spot.
I mean look at Neo-Warfare X. If you think Aeronautica isn't for everyone, that flight sim makes them run away in fear!
Anyways, yeah that's about it with my opinion about Aeronautica. It's a cool game overall 10/10
Very cool! Thanks for sharing :)
This is the best presentation ever 😮😮
Genuinely in my opinion ptfs is the the best role player game because of the multiple roles ,atc, military convoys it is really good for rps in that reason
Wings of glory will always be my favourite game on roblox, I love playing war thunder but when i need a break it’s a great thing to play.
It’s awesome fun!
Not gonna lie im glad i found aeronautica like 2 months after it was made, ive been playing before the avalon revamp and seen the map and game develop and grow, i dont play the game as much as i used to cuz i have everything i want in the game but i do join the game and mess around every now and then
Thanks for video. But I think Flightline is the best because all things have this game Realistic Crashs more and more... So I think Flightline 1. Have a good day!
i agree with you but i think one of the honourable mentions is aircraft carrier
I literally started watching your videos today. Firstly, they are great, and secondly I have only played airplane simulator and Aeronautica, and surprised that airline simulator even made it in. For the whole video I was wondering where Aeronautica would place, because of the hype around PTFS I was surprised that dinner win.
Glad you enjoy it!
Hey pat great vid i just think you should have added a honorable mentions section where games like air x and aircraft carrier would have been in and maybe aircraft carrier should have been placed higher then.
Good point, I’ll add them to the description now! I put them in my discord server but you’re right I should have mentioned them in the video.
I remember playing a game I think it was called dynamic planes or something I forgot and I was dumb back then I couldn’t figure out how to take off
the moment I heard that music I knew it was Aeronatica. This is by far my favorite game on roblox.
the only roblox flight simulator that i could think of other than ptfs was aeronautica because like its the only think that could possibly beat ptfs in terms of flight sim. great video also another is that i always come back to this channel to find new flight sim on roblox so tysm :D
That’s what I try to do so I’m really glad it helped and that you enjoyed it!
Glad I see you like Aeronautica!
Acceleration is pretty good game if you wanna feel the speed and do cool stunts you can never do in real life or any flight simulator that have extreme realism on it
Seeing how project flight is still really new and all the progress it's done
I'm sure is gonna get really big
Epic re-upload moment
Thank you patron, for yet another awesome video.
Glad you enjoyed it
Well deserved Aeronautica. You can even have an Airline. For example my Airline is BOAC
Actually emergency landing isn't as p2w as u would think, if I'm not mistaken, you can get most or all of the game passes for free if you just play enough
i used to play aeronautica a while ago back in 2021 but then stopped playing because i had gotten supersonics and many rare vehicles, but then i made the difficult choice to reset my data in the game and now ive been playing ever since
3:48 reminds me of warthunder i got to tier V but quit
project flight is so good now
Fr and connect a joystick is top tier
As an avid plane-crazy player, kinda sad but at least it made to honourable mentions
While i was surprised to see Aeronautica beat out Ptfs, it was very well deserved.
lets go, PTFS second place, lovely.
I think that Cabin Crew Simulator should have been an honorable mention. yeah its not really a flying game, its still a very cool flight game.
I agree with you there :)
Now ptfs has a second carrier(uss g. ford) and it has katapults and arrest wires now.
Here is my opinion of the best flight sims: 10. Emergency landing 9. Hostile skies 8.acceleration fs 7. Wings world V 6. Airplane simulator 5. PTFS 4. neo warfare 3. Project flight 2. Aeronatica 1. Flight line (3 2 and 1 was really hard to choose but i think ima go with this)
Good list!
I play PTFS the most, but flight line, neo, and aeronautica are my favorites.
Awesome stuff!
epic! i agree with most of your ratings.
Awesome! What don’t you agree with? 👀
@@PatronRBLX I'd put my top 10 ranking like this:
10. Emergency Landing
9. Hostile Skies
8. Wings of Glory
7. Airplane Simulator
6. Acceleration
5. Neo Warfare X
4. Flightline
3. Aeronautica
2. Project Flight
1. PTFS
@@PatronRBLXpersonally, I would have put wings of glory in the top 5, especially with the most recent update including tons of new missiles
7:17 yes you can click shift and u I think. it's probably in the controls section on how to exit but if not its here on TH-cam.
I said “although you can jump out of your aircraft there isn’t any reason to do so” :)
@@PatronRBLX oh. I heard you can’t. But at least it’s a tip.
Oki
A lot of these aren't really flight simulators, they're flight arcade games because they aren't properly simulating flight by being highly unrealistic (Hostile skies, and Neo warfare X, PTFS)
As soon as I heard the wings of glory music, I knew it! I LOVE WINGS OF GLORY! the only problem is the insane grind for the missiles :)
My Flight Simulator Rankings:
1: Pilot Training Flight Simulator
PTFS is good if you want to fly planes in Roblox, but not as extreme as the others. It’s really chill for a bit of fun, which can be good if you want to unwind.
2: Aeronautica
It’s honestly not for me. But, the graphics, the realism, and the array of aircraft you can choose from really gives it a “thumbs-up 5 stars” rating.
3: Project Flight
Project Flight is very realistic. It’s regularly updated with a few but decent planes. The fact you can choose emergencies as well triggers creativity for many players, which to me is good.
4: Neo Warfare X
Very nice gameplay and graphics. The fact that it has military combat functions is really cool, and also I haven’t played this.
5: Wings of Glory
It’s a fairly decent game, with a grinding system similar to Steel Titans. All the freedom you have to fly around and shoot other players really brings me joy.
6: Flightline
It doesn’t have much, but it’s ok. I mean, it has crash physics, but other than that, not much.
7: Airplane Simulator
It’s not as bad as all the previous ones, but it’s low-poly. But, I feel like that low-polyness fits it, so it passes.
8: Hostile Skies
It’s very similar to Wings of Glory, but not as good-looking and functional. It’s mid, I guess.
9: Acceleration
I haven’t played this, but 99R for a sort of shitty graphic and function game? Not worth it.
10: Emergency Landing
Honestly, it doesn’t have much functionality. To actually pilot the plane you need a gamepass, which isn’t fair to me.
I like how no. 7 and 8 has g forces