They moved fast on this becauss the threat tiktok poses israel. It's the main platform that's pushing the agenda of the palestinians which is detrimental to israel's legitimacy
@@1saamor897 just wow, i dont know what to say... so a mindless entertainment app is worse than the killing of thousands of people. my friend whats your logic? now if youre a sociopath i would understand lmao
As a boomer, my question with selling tiktok is how does that guarantee that the new owners wouldn't also sell information? Isn't that exactly what Facebook and Twitter did/does?
Well FB yes along with other things. But twitter... some lunatic bought it and decided to turn it in to a 50 billion dollar ant farm full of memes so people would think he was cool. and Tik tok would probably not sell at all because odds are that active manipulation is not happening but ... china would probably not let them sell without a backdoor. the data may be tooo enticing. this is a game of chicken between two superpowers. and it is very stupid. god this is so stupid on so many levels.
Exactly. Just google Zuckerberg sells user data and you'll see the chinese government doesn't need tik tok to get your info. The US lawmakers are just mad that they can't control the narrative and that people are seeing the horrors we are funding in the middle east and they don't want young people to know that American exceptionalism is a lie.
It's an easy answer. As a boomer, you may excuse yourself monitoring your kids; you cannot excuse your neighbor let alone someone with conflict of interest monitoring your kids.
Because selling data is not the issue. The Chinese government has a law that says Chinese companies (like Bytedance, the company which owns Tik Tok) must share data upon request. Hope this clears things up for you.
The monetizing of the data, while scummy, isn't the main issue here. It's everything else the Chinese gov't can and will do with the data. Just one example is take what Russia did in 2016 and make it so much worse as they would own the means rather than just subverting it like Russia did Facebook.
@@brianwilliams766 they can do the same with Facebook more easily, this is just racism and the American imperial impulse to never compete fairly, especially with non-white people. In 2016, the whole thing was done by BRITISH company, Cambridige Analytica. Also since there is a huge overlap between people who hate immigrants and who hate TikTok for the reason you said, do you think immigrant software developers would still want to come or stay here if they had home-grown companies as big as Google and Facebook?
@@brianwilliams7661.) It’s not owned by China. The man is from Singapore. 2.) You act like all the other platforms to sell to other countries worldwide. 3.) The Twitter Files should’ve opened your eyes to what and how the government expects Social Media platforms to behave 4.) When both parties agree on something, the people should oppose it wholeheartedly. They don’t have our privacy or best interests in mind
17 times in the last 5 years I've been involved in class action lawsuits about my data being stolen. Not a single one was tiktok. It was Twitter and Meta. I hope this was worth it Steve.
Yeah, but records weren't able to spy on you while instantaneously transmitting what they see back. They also weren't made by a foreign government that has stated intent to harm you
America ia a contient, the federalised states bit in the middle is the Yankee Doodle dandy place. Most of the North American continent is covered by Canada......... Just so you know.
Tiktok is owned by the Chinese government. This is a concrete fact. The way they run the country, they have made it a science to track citizens on social media, watching everyone. Chinese citizens who speak against the government disappear. Minority groups are just rounded up and either sent to labor camps or are harvested for organs. China wants our phones to have Tiktok, do you guys understand? It is a threat to our national security. The reason that this is bipartisan is because the threat is real. Why do so many people think this is a joke? If you had the chance to see how the Chinese government operates, you would realize this is no joke.
It might surprise you to learn that last year Brazil’s congress was voting to pass into law that for a platform to operate there it would have to reveal how its algorithm curates content for its users and the next day Google’s home page had a message telling its Brazilian users that the law was going to take away their freedoms and for them to contact their representatives. I wonder what country runs that company? 🤔
It's such a crap because Google, Facebook, Amazon all collect our data and how many times have you talked about something and suddenly you have ads for it across all your platforms?
Well if we're being honest that's the US government collecting the data of its citizens. Not the Chinese government...who's landmark goal is to bump the United States out of the it's number 1 country in the world status. It's very political.
ill be honest with you, the "data security" is just the legal pathway theyre taking here. In reality propaganda is the primary concern. You SHOULD be concerned about the propaganda the app could and does allow And considering tiktoks response was a notification that got a bunch of braindead app users to call congress without a legitimate reason...it should be banned.
Banning TikTok is a form of healthcare. Think about how much bs gets spread through TikTok, for example the “trans” trend. Began with TikTok. Everything and anything stupid that people do, ultimately comes from this app.
@user-uo9eq9fj1l wait, you're saying that digital security, something that's pretty complicated is ''obvious'' to ''both sides'' of Americans meanwhile, both presidents are getting yelled at for taking top secret documents home and showing them around?! xD Oh God Are you American? Be honest!
No interest in doing that, and the US would probably put up a fight if the EU wanted to regulate Instagram or Facebook. :) Yeah, it's hypocrisy' Ultimately this campaign would look no different if TikTok were a French platform. The point where the butt hurts is that it's not American and still globally used.
@@bhcbhc so if the “you” is USA, the answer is no. At least China regulates all social media regardless of nationality of owners, unlike the US, who targets Chinese and Russians only. Think.
That TikTok users think that TikTok is only the platform showing the horrors in Gaza baffles me. Do they not view or read literally any other news sources than TikTok and therefore have no idea that that content is shown on other social media as well as television and newspapers and their online versions?
@@JCasey-ch2uxTo be honest I don’t trust any large media company reporting on it. There are other sources but I did not see near as much footage on other socials than I did on tik tok.
@@JCasey-ch2ux That is older media targeted at an older audience that is already indoctrinated into accepting the status quo. TikTok is for the younger generations and it's raising awareness which challenges the establishment.
a word is called imported inflation，it means the price will increase with the human resource cost increase，your salary is more than before but the object is also more expensive than before，if your hope is improve your life，the secret is decrease the price of object ，such as tariff reduction，or use the oil from cheap regions.
@@雍义麾 While it's true that increasing the minimum wage can potentially lead to higher costs for businesses, it's important to consider the broader context. Importantly, the relationship between minimum wage increases and inflation is not as direct as some may suggest. Firstly, modest increases in the minimum wage often have minimal effects on overall inflation. The impact of wage increases on prices depends on a variety of factors, including the elasticity of demand for goods and services, the competitive structure of markets, and the ability of businesses to absorb higher labor costs through increased productivity or adjustments in other areas. Secondly, it's crucial to recognize the significant benefits that increasing the minimum wage can bring to workers and the economy as a whole. Higher wages can reduce income inequality, lift people out of poverty, stimulate consumer spending, and improve overall economic growth. Moreover, when low-wage workers have more purchasing power, they can contribute to increased demand for goods and services, which can potentially offset any upward pressure on prices. Lastly, addressing inflation requires a multifaceted approach that goes beyond simply controlling labor costs. Measures such as tariff reduction and efficient use of resources can certainly play a role, but they are just one part of the larger economic puzzle. Ultimately, policies aimed at balancing the needs of workers and businesses while promoting overall economic stability are key to achieving sustainable growth and prosperity for all.
I wish people could get as motivated to call representatives and congress members about issues like climate change, sexual rights, and gun violence as they are about TikTok. I'm a millennial and I think a lot of my peers have lost track of where their priorities should be. I absolutely don't think TikTok should be banned, but I hope this stimulates those who are calling about the bill to call about more critical topics too.
Thank you for getting it. FB actually collects data on people that do NOT have FB. That's why closing your FB profile can be pointless: they're collecting data on practically everyone.
They're not banning tic tok for collecting data there forcing tic tok to devest from their parent company with ties to the CCP after they were caught breaking the law and sending data overseas.
As a 38 year old unhinged millennial woman.. yeah, sure some of my fyp is trivial stuff that brings me some minor joy in this current hellscape.. The rest is about learning how women keep losing basic bodily autonomy or are at risk of losing more of it. My fyp has real time updates on genocides currently happening.. oh and thank god a kitten video to help me back up from hearing the voice of a young man who set himself on fire in protest of what is happening in Palestine. To say it’s all silly trends and unhinged women with our Hogwarts houses is just lazy. We share information, we mourn, and yes sometimes we try to remember a time we were less afraid.
Agree 100% Especially as they reach ‘retirement age’ they should be removed. If you are not of a current working class generation you don’t get a say anymore. You’re voice is reduced to a citizen vote, like the rest. PoS white wig wanna bes.
In this case, it's the people who are on social media all the time that are out of touch with the real world. Those poor people who were manipulated by the app are like teenagers who get into eating disorders because "society" tells them they are fat.
Don’t get me wrong, the GOP are monsters, but this bill was unanimously approved by a committee of both democrats and republicans, so in this one particular instance it’s not just the republicans who are doing something stupid.
TikTok iOS subscribes to every keystroke (text inputs) happening on third party websites rendered inside the TikTok app. This can include passwords, credit card information and other sensitive user data. While most people dont care it is problematic when high level engineers, executive, and military personal might do this. It is not as crazy as it sounds.
A lot of adult women are calling their government reps about TikTok...because they want to keep talking about their Hogwart's houses? What a dismissive, garbage take. Adult women do a LOT on TikTok. The very idea that it's a "dancing app for kids" is so outdated, I can't even process. Colbert has always been great at getting to the heart of current issues and punching up. Missed the mark on this one.
Don't worry, I hate tiktok. But clearly it changes since they renamed it from Musically to TikTok. Musically is a dancing app, TikTok is whole nother level.
it's not just tiktok. from what this one's been told, the law would allow the government to ban ANY social media they suspect could be a security risk. And given how things have been going, do you think ANY government should have that kind of power? Whether you lean left or right, progressive, conservative, or regressive, we should all agree that the government, especially EITHER government that could take power in 2025, shouldn't be able to ban social media so easily. Especially since if it were really such a security risk, pretty sure there's already ways to shut it down.
My friend, Tiktok is not a normal company. It is owned by the Chinese government, and over there, the government uses their version of Tiktok as a way to watch and track people. Tiktok is a tool used by a dictatorship to watch and control their citizens. Please do not compare normal companies to a tool that China uses to oppress and control people.
@@Coolestmovieseven if the ban on this one company doesn't last, it's still, A) strongarming a foreign company into selling to local investors(getting real shades of banana republics) and B) going to leave a far reaching law on the books that they could use both to repeat this tactic as well as to generally nuke any site they don't like.
@@ircjesselee no, but this one DOES have wares if you have coins :P The reasons for the peculiarities of this one's speech are unrelated to elder scrolls
Just make up the info. They are stupid any way. Microsoft collected my info and got them ALL wrong. They want me to verify. Fat Chance. But most info are harmless, just annoying.
@@1Deep43VA "I want the courts to uphold our rights to privacy. But I’m not asking the government to do sh!t" - What do you think the courts are? Do you honestly believe the courts and the government are separate entities?
"Regulate social media. They all collect our info" - Non-social-media websites collect our data, too, as does a ton of software, as well as our phones, tablets, computers, TVs, cars, online stores, department/retail stores, supermarkets... The list goes on and on. It's almost easier listing the things (and companies) that DON'T collect (and share/sell) our data.
They can try and ban TikTok something most Americans don't want but they still haven't gotten rid of Daylight Savings Time something most Americans do want.
The thing is while they say it's to ban tiktok, if you look at the bills, it basically says "banning free speech". So banning tiktok is just a cover up for the biggger agenda.
Yeah, ban it. It's literally just snooping for the CCP anyway. And real Chinese will *never* be able to regain control of their home, so long as we all pretend that the invaders aren't occupying that land. Go find out about the security gaps that were built in to spy on the West, then do a little critical thinking and straighten your facts; then get back to us with a comment that will teach everyone a little more about the situation, from your limited perspective.
Please ban all media outside the United States so that we will never know that Israel is massacring innocent women and children in Gaza, so that we will believe that all Palestinians are vicious terrorists. Let us ban all other media and let us have no psychological burden to support Congress in destroying the Palestinians.
@realnzall that is correct, but Elon Musk also became a US citizen and did not have to give up his South African citizenship (or his Canadian citizenship-his mother was born in Canada)
Got turned off at that point. Just keep recycling the same joke, always bash us Millennials who are just trying to survive in the world his generation and those before screwed up.
As a Millennial, meh. It's clearly a joke, not bash. Like his joke about how old old people think TikToks are TicTacs. And if you don't find their jokes funny, maybe the show isn't for you. Nothing wrong with that.
@@TheRawrnstuff I usual find him very funny but it might be I'm just sick of all those jokes. It's also been a hard night at work so I may have not been in the right mood for those types of jokes.
They are saying to tik Tok is under the thumb of an adversarial government. (Defined as China, Russia, North Korea, and Iran). I didn't believe those other companies are at the mercy of those governments.
@@chromewarnock9681you can't seriously be this naive if you don't think American government doesn't do the same thing and has time and time again proven, they do the exact same thing.
@@chromewarnock96811) That's not better 2) I can guarantee you they sell your info to the government, the cops, anyone who will pay money for it. You're a fool if you think your data is only being sold for ads
The prohibition of TikTok unless it is sold is a measure that appears logical primarily within the United States. Even as someone who does not use TikTok, it's evident to me that concerns over national security are not the real issue here. Is this really how competition is now being approached, by exerting pressure on another country? It's as if we're suggesting that if China were to require Apple to sell its operations in China to Huawei, citing national security reasons, it would be seen as a comparable action.
@@TheFinalChaptersBombardier forced divestment of its c series to airbus is a clear indicator that US gonvernment abuse their authority to remove a competitor on the behest of Boeing. Nothing new here. They are doing it again on the behest of the likes of meta and Google who is having significant trouble competing with tiktok. The whole data thing is smoke and mirrors. Do you really think China is gonna gain some national security advantage from knowing you a no one likes spaghetti or go to work in downtown somewhere? Banning it on gonvernment phones and employees make sense if national security is the actual concern. Just for the record I don't use tik tok and never will but that us my choice and not some forced action by the gonvernment that would violate the first amendment.
Yeah this isn’t going to go the way they think it will. In fact it doesn’t take an oracle to see that it’s going to have the opposite of the intended effect and is going to royally piss off a lot of people. I’m no fan of Tik Tok and don’t really care what happens to it either way but even I can see how this will play out. And I can say that if they pass it I wouldn’t want to be in their shoes when the backlash inevitably hits. It’s like watching a disaster happen in slow motion yet you can’t look away even though you can already see how horrible the fall out will be.
I understand you see this as an invasion of freedom. Tiktok is not a normal app. It was created by the Chinese government, and is currently used by the Chinese government as a tool to watch and track the people over there.
Here is a question someone should ask congress, where do think that phone that has tik tok installed on it was made? The router in your home you are connected to? The infotainment system in your car? The 6 TVs in your house, where were they made? China made products that have data collection capabilities are woven into the American lifestyle and you are worried about one single app? And for some extra fun, flip over that red MAGA hat and read the tag, it says MADE IN.... To those that have commented in this thread, I have made several replies but TH-cam seems fit to hide/delete my replies. I suppose I have angered the algorithm.
Gotta start somewhere. The CCP is failing China and tanking their economy, so they’re desperate for every opportunity to screw with the west, and an app like TikTok is invaluable to them in shaping public opinion, especially about China and the evil CCP. And I’m writing that as someone left of centre, not some right-wing maga freak. There’s a new kind of warfare going on with this seemingly innocuous tech, and China’s influence needs to be curtailed, one step at a time.
I've thought about this. From what I understand, our engineers and tech companies have made sure the phones themselves do not give the Chinese government access. I'm not a software engineer, but that's what they seem to be doing. Installing Tiktok is opening a door, allowing them access. That is exactly why we buy Chinese made phones but are now trying to ban Tiktok. Over there, in China, you know that the Chinese government uses their version of Tiktok as a tool of their oppression? It's one of many ways the Chinese government watches and controls the people.
@@izzyxblades I certainly would not put much trust in American companies' ability to safeguard chinese electronic devices, they can't even safeguard their own airplanes, trains and automobiles. I remember back in the "good ole days" of IC manufacturing many of the engineers took pleasure in embedding secret lithography within the silicone. With todays multitude of devices and their connectivity and IOT platforms these devices could easily be delivered "clean", pass any inspection and be one firmware update away from uploading data. America's Cyber Defense capabilities are laughable at best. You would be appalled at how many government and medical facilities are still running Windows 95, 98, 2000 or Windows 7.
Haven't you ever seen the news from "Under the Desk News??" Insightful, concise, incredibly informed reporting. The Tiktokkers stood with you during the strike, turned down studio contacts in support of your strike. A little respect would be awesome.
Love under the desk news and I came to see the clip in context and it disheartening to see how much he bashes people who use the app and make the great content on there. There is so much content on the app that is insightful and educational in addition to being entertaining.
Yes, an app developer should not allowed to share user data with a government... but of course, they should be able to sell that data for profit to any and all companies that are willing to pay for it.
Yes. But the Chinese government has no respect for any rules or law or human decency. Tiktok is not a normal app. It is owned by the Chinese government, and over there, they actually use it to watch and track people. Tiktok is one of many tools that the Chinese government uses, that ultimately oppresses their people. Tiktok is not a normal app.
Well, those things are very different. The Chinese military aren't just trying to sell you something; they're trying to control the worlds economy and undermine democracy.
Yet there’s absolutely zero proof that TikTok gives user data to Chinese government. They even spent 1 billion back in 2020 to move their server to the US to comply with US laws, but they are shooting at a moving goal post because data security was never the true issue. It’s about crushing Chinese competitors that are winning.
Tik Tok is a huge organizing resource for antiwar activists and people sharing the truth about government and history. The danger is not about privacy at all, or nationality - all these companies are multinational and the Tik Tok CEO is famously Singaporian, not Chinese. The danger of Tik Tok is that people are being educated and empowered to free themselves and others. It threatens the ruling class whose existence depends on people being ignorant and isolated.
Ma'am you are the first comment that hit it on the head. THAT is the heart of the matter, that is why the support was bipartisan and why they moved so quickly on this bill. I wish more people would understand this.
For example, it can showcase the true life of Uyghurs in China to the world, which is different from the biased reports of media influenced by political parties and conglomerates behind the scenes.
@Kittymancer78 I still don't understand why that matters....I go on tiktok to watch some funny vids while I pass the time literally could care less what someone could be preaching
@@herosio270Except that content about Uyghurs is literally banned on tiktok LMAO You guys are such sheep that have convinced yourself you are free thinkers
@@drooooop Because TikTok does not spread obvious rumors. In fact, thieves of tUyghurs are not punished, and even vendors who engage in unfair transactions will not be expelled. Uyghurs have privileges in China. It's not as you imagine. Although there are indeed some undemocratic aspects in this country, it is precisely this that has prevented differences and riots. Supporting opposition forces make them fight to eachother to weaken a country is what the United States most wants to do to China. You must understand that things have their multifaceted nature.
This is the most hideous precedent of all time. If any foreign company can be forced to be sold like this, then should China reciprocate the same to American companies having businesses there?
drama .is on BY. ALL HIDERS OF MADHAB AND NEEWS .NON-BUSLIM COUNTRIES NO EXIS .APP IS SURE BAUSLIMS .2 PARTIES GOING NAKIE LIVERS OR BUSLIMS . 3-4 GARDER WERE 90% IN PAKISTAN AND IN ALL COUNTREIS ...FOUND FREEDOM FORM THESE ARMEI SIN 1980S .......THESE ARE SHI PICKERS ...TOO CIRMINLAS , AND TOO KAANAIN . UR ALL PAGE SITES ALL ON EM HIDDING SMAE NEWS TOP MADHAB ..TOLD ON TOP ON SITS ... ON FB ..IF ...NET SPREAD IS URS TO ALL OF THIS GANG AMOUNG WHERE EVER NET APP CAN ... REWARDS ARE BEEN TOLD ON SITS ... ITS UR MEDIA OF ALL WORLD SINCE EVR 1 MAN SHOW ...HOW .....CALLL WAHAB .. AGAIN ... MICROSFT ......CALL HIM IF NAY THING IS SPARED ....DMA OR GRID IS SURE ..MISSING ......
Weak move punching down at online creators when your target should be the federal government forcing the hostile sale of a foreign company. But sure, let's make fun of people having fun on the internet.
When both parties agree on something, it's 100% in favor of reducing the power of the people. When gov owned late night shows support an issue, it's 100% in favor of reducing the power of the people.
I'm 44 and I'm in Gryffindor. It's not just the Millennials. If my grandma had been into the internet when she was younger, she might have taken the quiz too. She's 94 and she read the Harry Potter books before I did.
Please, remember that that stone was thrown by a fifty-something gentlenman who quotes the lord of the rings verbatim regularly, lmao. I love and respect Mr. Colbert immensely but even I had to pause and mentally ask "Really sir, did YOU seriously just throw that stone?" 😂 I'm 45 and was sorted in to Slytherin last I checked.
Pukwudgie myslef. (I'm an American, so I'll take assignment of an *American* house. 🤪) @lynntaylor6686 You're grandma sounds cool. Glad to hear she's made it to an old age. I raise my energy drink in toast to her continued longevity. @Kittymancer78 Never have I more wished that Mr Colbert responded to these comments than to yours.
Americans will never stop to ask why laws banning drag performances, TikTok and teaching ANYTHING that could possibly make straight white men uncomfortable happened quicker than taking the necessary legal measures to prevent more mass shootings.
@chunkymonarchy5686 you’re going to PROTEST Trump? Where has that gotten anything? Register for a gun and take firearms courses if it’s not possible for you to find another country to live in if Trump wins again. Project 2025 is much more of a threat than Biden’s health and it’s not being talked about because the media wants it to happen.
Huh, Stephen going AGAINST free expression and young people being politically engaged is not what I expected. But as my dad was fond of saying, "Better to lose a friend than to miss out on a good line."
If that's a security risk, what are all the made in China smart phones? What's to stop them quietly passing data about their owners back to China? I'm not claiming they do, but if you're going to be paranoid about one Chinese product, why not all of them?
I thought about that, and from what I understand, our own cyber security experts have been watching to see if the devices have been giving them access, and they aren't. Remember a few years ago, they caught a Chinese phone brand that actually did give China access, and they immediately banned it. We are lucky that we have white hat hackers, cyber security experts who work for us, they protect us
Totally dull and useless take to have. Maybe we should not be judging if its ok for Congress to ban a phone app based on whether or not we personally use it, and rather that its a ridiculous overstep in Congress' authority that can set precedent for them doing it more often in the future.
@@Zerolink30 "Sorry my personal opinion offended you?" - You should be. There's a valid reason your opinion offended that person. First, they came for...
You have to understand that this goes beyond singular personal experience. People are upset because there’s a hypocrisy because data is being sold on other platforms as well so the reason that they gave for banning it is not valid so if they banned based on a lie, it affects everyone’s freedom. That is the discussion here And the way he portrays it that it is a dance app is completely wrong. There are scientists philosophers teachers musicians, all sorts of people from all walks of life and areas of expertise, sharing their work not to mention the millions of people that actually make a living off of this. The band is because Amazon is being hurt by the TikTok shop and the second reason is because people are being mobilized and galvanized for political issue. Stephen Colbert cannot speak on this issue because he himself works for immediate conglomerate controlling his freedom of speech but I get it if you don’t use it and have nothing to do with it it is hard to plug into the conversation about it.
The fact is to over simplify things in such a way is dismissive and dangerous. The app has met the previous demands of the US government and has an American company in Texas handling the data of American users. This is just the American platforms like Facebook and insta mad they are losing traffic on their platforms. This approach is disappointing Stephen, as I have been a fan of you for years and supported your act during the strike. Funny how American rights become so trivial when the do not directly impact you....
Read the license agreement u have to opt in on. TikTok makes u share your geolocation, personal info like phone numbers etc, your IP address, browser searches, and all of your social media contacts. That’s something I don’t want my own government or even parents to have access to, much less a foreign government. There’s a reason why if u a government issued business phone, u can’t have TikTok on it and it’s not because they’re afraid you’ll be goofing off. You give up a bunch of vulnerable information.
Then why doesn’t congress regulate what information platforms are allowed to collect? Giving the government power to just ban apps they consider a ‘security’ risk is a ridiculous power grab.
@@NoThatRyan US companies getting your personal information is your problem. Companies from adversarial countries like China getting your personal information (or worse) is the US's problem.
No. Please DO NOT ban TikTok. This is not just me saying it cuz I use it. Millions of people lose their job and this is where young people can communicate. American the land of the “free”. But they ban one of the biggest social media platforms
This is so disappointing... Especially after the support and loyalty Stephen got from huge tiktokers who refused to create content for any network during the writer's strike.
drama .is on BY. ALL HIDERS OF MADHAB AND NEEWS .NON-BUSLIM COUNTRIES NO EXIS .APP IS SURE BAUSLIMS .2 PARTIES GOING NAKIE LIVERS OR BUSLIMS . 3-4 GARDER WERE 90% IN PAKISTAN AND IN ALL COUNTREIS ...FOUND FREEDOM FORM THESE ARMEI SIN 1980S .......THESE ARE SHI PICKERS ...TOO CIRMINLAS , AND TOO KAANAIN . UR ALL PAGE SITES ALL ON EM HIDDING SMAE NEWS TOP MADHAB ..TOLD ON TOP ON SITS ... ON FB ..IF ...NET SPREAD IS URS TO ALL OF THIS GANG AMOUNG WHERE EVER NET APP CAN ... REWARDS ARE BEEN TOLD ON SITS ... ITS UR MEDIA OF ALL WORLD SINCE EVR 1 MAN SHOW ...HOW .....CALLL WAHAB .. AGAIN ... MICROSFT ......CALL HIM IF NAY THING IS SPARED ....DMA OR GRID IS SURE ..MISSING ......
I was going to say I'm old enough to remember the Web in the 1990s and that there's nothing wrong with website owners, in the capacity of them being community leaders, to protest against new laws and asking the users to do what they can. But then I remembered that this is just not the case anymore. If a billion dollar website tells their millions of users to do a thing, how much of that thinking is about "we need to do what's genuinely the best and most rational thing for the community" and how much of it is about "I have a giant website/app and a whole lot of idiot users who do just what I tell them to, and we need to do what's best for my bank account"?
Off hand I’d say it’s because they want to use it to spy on and or influence their own people instead of letting China do it. Basically they’re butt hurt because they can’t use the platform to influence people like they can with Facebook, Instagram and other American owned social media companies. So instead of leaving well enough alone they’re risking nuking their own career’s by screwing over millions of Americans rights to freedom of expression over a stupid app.
my guess would be that in the govt’s eyes, American ownership would mean the company that owns it is subject to US laws and regulations, and could be pressured to do or not do certain things with the data, for better or worse
His show has a TikTok account but he thinks everyone that uses it is a moron? And the guy who knows every detail about Lord of the Rings is making fun of Harry Potter fans? The arrogance smells even worse when mixed with hypocrisy.
During the writers' strike, a lot of tiktok influencers got reached out to by companies that wanted them to take the pressure off. Tiktok which is pretty aggressively leftist chose solidarity. Stephen's response is coming off as very "fuck you, got mine" and it feels really gross. Solidarity when you need help, but not when someone else is asking for help. Remember this next time.
Im still trying to figure out what is so different about TikTok in regards to user data for the other social media apps. I've read it. They all do the same shit.
Banning TikTok would be a logistical nightmare and a waste of time and tax dollars. The only people who would benefit from it would be VPN service providers.
Watching an old guy fumble through a basic understanding of any kind of free expression that isn't stamp collecting or some sh!t is embarrasing. If congress cared about data mining they'd be after facebook and twitter. They just don't like information sharing that they can't control.
@@izzyxbladesis not taking sides, other countries are still using it, while ur congress suddenly wants to ban it and wat does my last name gonna do with it? lol
Following all the news i mean they do not want to banned it. USA made it clear they want TikTok and if they can't have it then they will banned it forever.
I’m 28 and I think banning tik tok would be AMAZING!? Why the hell is he against it?? Big business got to him?? Ban all social media, it’s completely fucked up our world
but they're not thinking of banning all social media, just the one owned by the "official enemy". And banning tiktok gets them no closer to banning facebook or twitter.
Money. Too much money is involved. China only allowed people under 18 45 min of social media time per day. Their tech stock took a dive. What is not being told here is Americans own 52% of tiktok and ALL congressmen on the committe have benn receiving donation from Suckeerberg, This is a battle of the Billionaire.
Because Meta and Twitter don’t spy on us?
They pay they money though which TikTok apparently isn't.
Meta and twitter(X) sells their data to US government. Tiktok does to Chinese government. so there is some differences..?!?
ban those too..
That's different. That's 'merica spying on everyone!
They are banned in China, remember
It is simply amazing how fast Congress can move on this issue when they refuse to move on much much more important things.
Agreed! Let's ban Federal politicians from the stock market, ban AIPAC, ETC ETC
Now the republicans have at least one thing to run on.
u realize this is more important than hamas
They moved fast on this becauss the threat tiktok poses israel. It's the main platform that's pushing the agenda of the palestinians which is detrimental to israel's legitimacy
@@1saamor897 just wow, i dont know what to say... so a mindless entertainment app is worse than the killing of thousands of people. my friend whats your logic? now if youre a sociopath i would understand lmao
As a boomer, my question with selling tiktok is how does that guarantee that the new owners wouldn't also sell information? Isn't that exactly what Facebook and Twitter did/does?
Well FB yes along with other things. But twitter... some lunatic bought it and decided to turn it in to a 50 billion dollar ant farm full of memes so people would think he was cool.
and Tik tok would probably not sell at all because odds are that active manipulation is not happening but ... china would probably not let them sell without a backdoor. the data may be tooo enticing. this is a game of chicken between two superpowers. and it is very stupid. god this is so stupid on so many levels.
I assume the government would try to place a puppet like we always do- it's in our blood.
Exactly. Just google Zuckerberg sells user data and you'll see the chinese government doesn't need tik tok to get your info. The US lawmakers are just mad that they can't control the narrative and that people are seeing the horrors we are funding in the middle east and they don't want young people to know that American exceptionalism is a lie.
It's an easy answer. As a boomer, you may excuse yourself monitoring your kids; you cannot excuse your neighbor let alone someone with conflict of interest monitoring your kids.
Because selling data is not the issue. The Chinese government has a law that says Chinese companies (like Bytedance, the company which owns Tik Tok) must share data upon request. Hope this clears things up for you.
US is worried China is doing with TikTok what we do with Google, Facebook, Twitter, and every other website that contains ads....
China is a hostile foreign power.
China does not allow American social media on their platforms why should we open our doors to them?
The monetizing of the data, while scummy, isn't the main issue here. It's everything else the Chinese gov't can and will do with the data. Just one example is take what Russia did in 2016 and make it so much worse as they would own the means rather than just subverting it like Russia did Facebook.
@@brianwilliams766 they can do the same with Facebook more easily, this is just racism and the American imperial impulse to never compete fairly, especially with non-white people. In 2016, the whole thing was done by BRITISH company, Cambridige Analytica. Also since there is a huge overlap between people who hate immigrants and who hate TikTok for the reason you said, do you think immigrant software developers would still want to come or stay here if they had home-grown companies as big as Google and Facebook?
@@brianwilliams7661.) It’s not owned by China. The man is from Singapore. 2.) You act like all the other platforms to sell to other countries worldwide. 3.) The Twitter Files should’ve opened your eyes to what and how the government expects Social Media platforms to behave 4.) When both parties agree on something, the people should oppose it wholeheartedly. They don’t have our privacy or best interests in mind
The US should not ban TikTok, but they should severely restrict the data mining all social media platforms abuse.
That's reasonable, makes total logic
But if they did that, then how would the US government mine all that data?
Can't prevent data mining on foreign platforms China's outside the EU and US
They can't restrict it on tiktok since it is owned by CCP
I suspended FB bc I was getting comments from peeps in China. 😮
Welcome to America, the land of the “free” !
true
lol they banned a toxic app so what life goes on
@@rochekalifa2074 then ban on the terms of it being toxic, oh wait.
You're literally demanding to let China know you better than you know yourself.
@@ivdg46e dont be self-sentimental，you are not important for them😂
There are more important things for Congress to do than this.
17 times in the last 5 years I've been involved in class action lawsuits about my data being stolen. Not a single one was tiktok. It was Twitter and Meta. I hope this was worth it Steve.
It's ok it's our guys doing it so no problem
you are not gonna know if tiktoc stole it because ccp is not gonna let you know
@@chromewarnock9681 could you please use your brain to do a research before you say something? Tiktok American store ALL DATA IN AMERICA HOMESOIL, OK?
@chromewarnock9681
you don't know china do it or not. so you think they maybe criminal.
you know America but its all righr because freedom!!!!!
@@chromewarnock9681metadata
I’m old enough to remember when they tried to ban rock and roll as a threat to national security.
And there were record burnings at local churches.
Yeah, but records weren't able to spy on you while instantaneously transmitting what they see back. They also weren't made by a foreign government that has stated intent to harm you
Are you really comparing a video platform to a whole ass music genre?
That was clearly dumb. Also, rock and roll isn't owned by the Chinese government. Tiktok is.
@@c0mpu73rguy No, Einstein. The OP is stating a sad fact of "conservative" mindthought.
They love guns and their worried about tik tok…america is a joke
yup.
i live in a deep red hellscape so my outlook on the USA is pretty bleak.
America ia a contient, the federalised states bit in the middle is the Yankee Doodle dandy place. Most of the North American continent is covered by Canada......... Just so you know.
TikTok is a very serious issue actually, and you should probably think harder about it. Guns are a serious issue too, but a different one.
I’m sorry but an app is more frightening than the idiot with a gun 😊
Tiktok is owned by the Chinese government. This is a concrete fact. The way they run the country, they have made it a science to track citizens on social media, watching everyone.
Chinese citizens who speak against the government disappear. Minority groups are just rounded up and either sent to labor camps or are harvested for organs.
China wants our phones to have Tiktok, do you guys understand? It is a threat to our national security.
The reason that this is bipartisan is because the threat is real. Why do so many people think this is a joke?
If you had the chance to see how the Chinese government operates, you would realize this is no joke.
It might surprise you to learn that last year Brazil’s congress was voting to pass into law that for a platform to operate there it would have to reveal how its algorithm curates content for its users and the next day Google’s home page had a message telling its Brazilian users that the law was going to take away their freedoms and for them to contact their representatives. I wonder what country runs that company? 🤔
It's such a crap because Google, Facebook, Amazon all collect our data and how many times have you talked about something and suddenly you have ads for it across all your platforms?
American companies vs the Chinese communist party. Every company that is in China is owned by the Government.
Well if we're being honest that's the US government collecting the data of its citizens. Not the Chinese government...who's landmark goal is to bump the United States out of the it's number 1 country in the world status. It's very political.
ill be honest with you, the "data security" is just the legal pathway theyre taking here. In reality propaganda is the primary concern.
You SHOULD be concerned about the propaganda the app could and does allow
And considering tiktoks response was a notification that got a bunch of braindead app users to call congress without a legitimate reason...it should be banned.
They're not obligated to cooperate with the Chinese Government.
@@10Exahertz Yes, every other social media company is completely free of propaganda. /s
“Hey congress, can we have affordable healthcare?
“Nope, but we’ll ban your favorite video app though! Is that good enough?”
As much as I hate TikTok, it is still stupid they can’t lower down healthcare OR anything relating to taxes
mental health will be better, just you wait!
@@colingraham1585not really. a lot of people make money from tiktok and if the us bans
it, their taking away someone’s
main source of income
@@colingraham1585lmfao cause mental health was so great before TikTok right? Hahahaaaaa
Banning TikTok is a form of healthcare. Think about how much bs gets spread through TikTok, for example the “trans” trend. Began with TikTok. Everything and anything stupid that people do, ultimately comes from this app.
The Chinese government doesn’t need TikTok. They can simply buy this information from Facebook and other data brokers.😂
Nobody is posting plans of the F-35 on Facebook or TikTok
@@alexshi9320only in war thunder forum 😂
China really need Tiktok to control your mind.
Lie
The only thing we can get a bipartisan agreement on is this…? What a joke. 🤦🏼♀️
@user-uo9eq9fj1l ‘digital security’ while acquiescing on the evil behavior of meta, twitter, google, etc
@user-uo9eq9fj1l Election results are pretty obvious too ...
@user-uo9eq9fj1l wait, you're saying that digital security, something that's pretty complicated is ''obvious'' to ''both sides'' of Americans meanwhile, both presidents are getting yelled at for taking top secret documents home and showing them around?! xD
Oh God
Are you American? Be honest!
@user-uo9eq9fj1l😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@user-uo9eq9fj1lBut ok for American companies, right?
Could you start regulating US American freaking social media corporations too??
Depends on who is "you." If it's China, yes, they already did. Think.
No interest in doing that, and the US would probably put up a fight if the EU wanted to regulate Instagram or Facebook. :) Yeah, it's hypocrisy'
Ultimately this campaign would look no different if TikTok were a French platform. The point where the butt hurts is that it's not American and still globally used.
No they sell personnel data to US government agencies and it is ok
@@bhcbhc so if the “you” is USA, the answer is no. At least China regulates all social media regardless of nationality of owners, unlike the US, who targets Chinese and Russians only. Think.
Come on. American government won't hurt you, would they?
And of course the fact TikTok has been showing everyone what's actually happening in Gaza has nothing to do with this bill, right?
I know.. did you hear the leaked call?
That TikTok users think that TikTok is only the platform showing the horrors in Gaza baffles me. Do they not view or read literally any other news sources than TikTok and therefore have no idea that that content is shown on other social media as well as television and newspapers and their online versions?
@@JCasey-ch2uxTo be honest I don’t trust any large media company reporting on it. There are other sources but I did not see near as much footage on other socials than I did on tik tok.
@@JCasey-ch2ux That is older media targeted at an older audience that is already indoctrinated into accepting the status quo. TikTok is for the younger generations and it's raising awareness which challenges the establishment.
@@JCasey-ch2ux Ikr?!
So is America really free? It seems ironic to use a China-made iPhone while worrying about the dangers of China.
Yet china bans YT AND FB.....DUH cadre
Yet CCP BANS MOST FOREIGN WEBSITES....DUH
Free compared to every other place on the planet every place has rules
Why not vote on a minimum wage increase? Just my thought!!
a word is called imported inflation，it means the price will increase with the human resource cost increase，your salary is more than before but the object is also more expensive than before，if your hope is improve your life，the secret is decrease the price of object ，such as tariff reduction，or use the oil from cheap regions.
Parque no Los Dos
@@雍义麾 While it's true that increasing the minimum wage can potentially lead to higher costs for businesses, it's important to consider the broader context. Importantly, the relationship between minimum wage increases and inflation is not as direct as some may suggest.
Firstly, modest increases in the minimum wage often have minimal effects on overall inflation. The impact of wage increases on prices depends on a variety of factors, including the elasticity of demand for goods and services, the competitive structure of markets, and the ability of businesses to absorb higher labor costs through increased productivity or adjustments in other areas.
Secondly, it's crucial to recognize the significant benefits that increasing the minimum wage can bring to workers and the economy as a whole. Higher wages can reduce income inequality, lift people out of poverty, stimulate consumer spending, and improve overall economic growth. Moreover, when low-wage workers have more purchasing power, they can contribute to increased demand for goods and services, which can potentially offset any upward pressure on prices.
Lastly, addressing inflation requires a multifaceted approach that goes beyond simply controlling labor costs. Measures such as tariff reduction and efficient use of resources can certainly play a role, but they are just one part of the larger economic puzzle. Ultimately, policies aimed at balancing the needs of workers and businesses while promoting overall economic stability are key to achieving sustainable growth and prosperity for all.
Won't help
@luckytexasgambler But wages do not have an impact on national security
😂
Oh please this has nothing you do with security. Our representatives deserve every single uncomfortable call
In what way do you think this is a malicious move?
I wish people could get as motivated to call representatives and congress members about issues like climate change, sexual rights, and gun violence as they are about TikTok. I'm a millennial and I think a lot of my peers have lost track of where their priorities should be. I absolutely don't think TikTok should be banned, but I hope this stimulates those who are calling about the bill to call about more critical topics too.
作为一个中国人，我不理解那种担心中国共产党利用TikTok危害美国的逻辑是如何成立的，为什么认为只有TikTok能做到这样的事，其他的app也可以盗取个人信息。
Hmm. Hadn't thought of that, maybe this situation could at least have one tiny good thing to come out of it. People getting more involved in politics.
weird how they are targeting tiktok even though fb and others take and sell the exact same user data.
TikTok is Chinese. The Zuck is American and white. That's the difference.
Thank you for getting it. FB actually collects data on people that do NOT have FB. That's why closing your FB profile can be pointless: they're collecting data on practically everyone.
Yes, but Facebook and others are selling data to American companies that pay the extra income of members of Congress, SCOTUS and other politicians.
Fb doesn't record keystrokes, aka passwords etc
They're not banning tic tok for collecting data there forcing tic tok to devest from their parent company with ties to the CCP after they were caught breaking the law and sending data overseas.
this is about the US not being able to censor TikTok the way they do Facebook and Instagram
Exactly and the truth just might come out before Nov and they don't like that. Wow! Terrible!
I think its TikTok not giving their user data to the FBI and CIA at a discount like the other social media companies.
是舆论权，无关审查。你们政府不会允许舆论权有可能在别的国家手上。
This is correct
Tiktok is already heavily censored….
As a 38 year old unhinged millennial woman.. yeah, sure some of my fyp is trivial stuff that brings me some minor joy in this current hellscape.. The rest is about learning how women keep losing basic bodily autonomy or are at risk of losing more of it. My fyp has real time updates on genocides currently happening.. oh and thank god a kitten video to help me back up from hearing the voice of a young man who set himself on fire in protest of what is happening in Palestine.
To say it’s all silly trends and unhinged women with our Hogwarts houses is just lazy. We share information, we mourn, and yes sometimes we try to remember a time we were less afraid.
This is one of the many reasons that we need term limits for Congress and the Senate. These people are so out of touch with the real world.
Agree 100% Especially as they reach ‘retirement age’ they should be removed. If you are not of a current working class generation you don’t get a say anymore. You’re voice is reduced to a citizen vote, like the rest. PoS white wig wanna bes.
In this case, it's the people who are on social media all the time that are out of touch with the real world. Those poor people who were manipulated by the app are like teenagers who get into eating disorders because "society" tells them they are fat.
And yall worried about social media ban but not real problems in the world congress isn't passing?
@@JoeyWilliams-q5m truth
@@JoeyWilliams-q5m Social Media is a big problem to be honest.
I hope the clock is running down on the GOP House of Representatives...tick-tock, tick-tock.
So, the -GOP- GQP got TIME to bring a vote on this TikTokCrap yet no time to bring a vote on the border bill & aid to Ukraine?! 💔
Don’t get me wrong, the GOP are monsters, but this bill was unanimously approved by a committee of both democrats and republicans, so in this one particular instance it’s not just the republicans who are doing something stupid.
Tick tock tick tock, vote for Trump and we shall have new world totalitarian order😂😂😂
TikTok iOS subscribes to every keystroke (text inputs) happening on third party websites rendered inside the TikTok app. This can include passwords, credit card information and other sensitive user data. While most people dont care it is problematic when high level engineers, executive, and military personal might do this. It is not as crazy as it sounds.
So...Chinese spies look like Charli Damelio, and Russian spies look like Jim Jordan and Ted Cruz. Gimme the Chinese spies. Thanks
A lot of adult women are calling their government reps about TikTok...because they want to keep talking about their Hogwart's houses? What a dismissive, garbage take. Adult women do a LOT on TikTok. The very idea that it's a "dancing app for kids" is so outdated, I can't even process. Colbert has always been great at getting to the heart of current issues and punching up. Missed the mark on this one.
It is still largely a dancing app for kids. Lol
Don't worry, I hate tiktok. But clearly it changes since they renamed it from Musically to TikTok. Musically is a dancing app, TikTok is whole nother level.
@@Sailor183 depends on your algorithm, if that is what you see that is what you searched for
it's not just tiktok. from what this one's been told, the law would allow the government to ban ANY social media they suspect could be a security risk. And given how things have been going, do you think ANY government should have that kind of power? Whether you lean left or right, progressive, conservative, or regressive, we should all agree that the government, especially EITHER government that could take power in 2025, shouldn't be able to ban social media so easily.
Especially since if it were really such a security risk, pretty sure there's already ways to shut it down.
Ultimately, though, they just want to shift its ownership, so any ban wouldn’t last long.
Are you a Khajiit?
My friend, Tiktok is not a normal company. It is owned by the Chinese government, and over there, the government uses their version of Tiktok as a way to watch and track people.
Tiktok is a tool used by a dictatorship to watch and control their citizens.
Please do not compare normal companies to a tool that China uses to oppress and control people.
@@Coolestmovieseven if the ban on this one company doesn't last, it's still, A) strongarming a foreign company into selling to local investors(getting real shades of banana republics) and B) going to leave a far reaching law on the books that they could use both to repeat this tactic as well as to generally nuke any site they don't like.
@@ircjesselee no, but this one DOES have wares if you have coins :P
The reasons for the peculiarities of this one's speech are unrelated to elder scrolls
Regulate social media. They all collect our info. 🖕
Just make up the info. They are stupid any way. Microsoft collected my info and got them ALL wrong. They want me to verify. Fat Chance. But most info are harmless, just annoying.
Uh no… I don’t want to give the Government more power to “regulate” anything.
@@1Deep43VAyou dont have privacy on social media 😂
@@1Deep43VA "I want the courts to uphold our rights to privacy. But I’m not asking the government to do sh!t" - What do you think the courts are? Do you honestly believe the courts and the government are separate entities?
"Regulate social media. They all collect our info" - Non-social-media websites collect our data, too, as does a ton of software, as well as our phones, tablets, computers, TVs, cars, online stores, department/retail stores, supermarkets... The list goes on and on. It's almost easier listing the things (and companies) that DON'T collect (and share/sell) our data.
TikTok kept people informed during the writers strike.
and supported Stephen. Wholeheartedly. I'm kind of disgusted with this take.
TikTok is rife with misinformation and lies and dangerous “trends”, how dare you say it keeps anyone “informed”.
I don't think security breach and supporting slave labor is worth it.
And?
They can try and ban TikTok something most Americans don't want but they still haven't gotten rid of Daylight Savings Time something most Americans do want.
Ikr???
See also tax breaks for rich vs basic federal gun regulations, or most logical legislation other nations already have
Most Americans want DST? 🤔
The thing is while they say it's to ban tiktok, if you look at the bills, it basically says "banning free speech".
So banning tiktok is just a cover up for the biggger agenda.
Yeah, ban it. It's literally just snooping for the CCP anyway. And real Chinese will *never* be able to regain control of their home, so long as we all pretend that the invaders aren't occupying that land. Go find out about the security gaps that were built in to spy on the West, then do a little critical thinking and straighten your facts; then get back to us with a comment that will teach everyone a little more about the situation, from your limited perspective.
The only TikTok Donnie should worry about is the one coming from his own personal doomsday clock.
Still banging out rippers 👌
@@wertnog6379
So the Donald didn't cause the Republicans to stop the border bill? And he isn't influencing them to cut off aid to Ukraine? Get real.
@wertnog6379 its congress not the executive branch
Yeah, still waiting for that and it haven't happened yet. Off topic by the way.
Please ban all media outside the United States so that we will never know that Israel is massacring innocent women and children in Gaza, so that we will believe that all Palestinians are vicious terrorists. Let us ban all other media and let us have no psychological burden to support Congress in destroying the Palestinians.
I understand they were aiming for laughs, but it really overlooked how much good, interesting information gets shared on tiktok.
Because they are with the congress on this issue.
@@IamExcaliburThey are essentially forced to be. The government controls the media and controlled opposition
You can’t even share links or cite your sources on TikTok. You believe everything that’s fed to you by the algorithm and that’s “information” 😂
Isn't Elon Musk South African?
That's the joke.
He is an American now. It's easy to get citizenship when you are white and rich.
He's white though, so they're ok with that
@realnzall that is correct, but Elon Musk also became a US citizen and did not have to give up his South African citizenship (or his Canadian citizenship-his mother was born in Canada)
Not only Elon but every whites living in USA are European immigrants 🤡🤡🤡
Stop bashing Millennials please! I'm 37 and I don't identify with any Hogwards house. I am Pokemon Blue true through and through!!
To hell with that. Hail Sithis!
Got turned off at that point. Just keep recycling the same joke, always bash us Millennials who are just trying to survive in the world his generation and those before screwed up.
As a Millennial, meh. It's clearly a joke, not bash.
Like his joke about how old old people think TikToks are TicTacs.
And if you don't find their jokes funny, maybe the show isn't for you. Nothing wrong with that.
@@TheRawrnstuff I usual find him very funny but it might be I'm just sick of all those jokes. It's also been a hard night at work so I may have not been in the right mood for those types of jokes.
@@NicoleCamp88even a hufflepuff would be stronger than this
If they ban Tic-tok, they should ban Facebook, Instagram, Amazon and Google as all of them do what they say Tic-tok is doing.
They are saying to tik Tok is under the thumb of an adversarial government. (Defined as China, Russia, North Korea, and Iran). I didn't believe those other companies are at the mercy of those governments.
they do it for ads not for ccp
@@chromewarnock9681you can't seriously be this naive if you don't think American government doesn't do the same thing and has time and time again proven, they do the exact same thing.
@@chromewarnock96811) That's not better 2) I can guarantee you they sell your info to the government, the cops, anyone who will pay money for it. You're a fool if you think your data is only being sold for ads
@@chromewarnock9681tiktok does it doe the ads too 🤦♂️
The prohibition of TikTok unless it is sold is a measure that appears logical primarily within the United States. Even as someone who does not use TikTok, it's evident to me that concerns over national security are not the real issue here. Is this really how competition is now being approached, by exerting pressure on another country? It's as if we're suggesting that if China were to require Apple to sell its operations in China to Huawei, citing national security reasons, it would be seen as a comparable action.
Nailed it in one.
This has nothing to do with Tik Tok competing with US companies.
@@TheFinalChaptersit has everything to do with that.
@@TheFinalChaptersBombardier forced divestment of its c series to airbus is a clear indicator that US gonvernment abuse their authority to remove a competitor on the behest of Boeing.
Nothing new here. They are doing it again on the behest of the likes of meta and Google who is having significant trouble competing with tiktok.
The whole data thing is smoke and mirrors. Do you really think China is gonna gain some national security advantage from knowing you a no one likes spaghetti or go to work in downtown somewhere? Banning it on gonvernment phones and employees make sense if national security is the actual concern.
Just for the record I don't use tik tok and never will but that us my choice and not some forced action by the gonvernment that would violate the first amendment.
@@ralphslucher5417*No one dares to call it race - based crap now ha ha 🤭 🤭 US need it to be European Heritaged Owners 🤭 bunch of fake liberals*
Yeah this isn’t going to go the way they think it will. In fact it doesn’t take an oracle to see that it’s going to have the opposite of the intended effect and is going to royally piss off a lot of people. I’m no fan of Tik Tok and don’t really care what happens to it either way but even I can see how this will play out. And I can say that if they pass it I wouldn’t want to be in their shoes when the backlash inevitably hits. It’s like watching a disaster happen in slow motion yet you can’t look away even though you can already see how horrible the fall out will be.
I understand you see this as an invasion of freedom.
Tiktok is not a normal app. It was created by the Chinese government, and is currently used by the Chinese government as a tool to watch and track the people over there.
Any backlash is preferred to the alternative where it's left as Chinese malware installed on a third of the country's phones.
@@TheFinalChapters You mean on the phones that are MADE IN CHINA?
@@chezsuzie It's a lot easier to inspect foreign hardware than foreign software.
Especially software that can update at any time.
@@TheFinalChapters 😂😂😂
The writers really showed their position on the matter
Omg almost like every show that’s ever existed
Here is a question someone should ask congress, where do think that phone that has tik tok installed on it was made? The router in your home you are connected to? The infotainment system in your car? The 6 TVs in your house, where were they made? China made products that have data collection capabilities are woven into the American lifestyle and you are worried about one single app? And for some extra fun, flip over that red MAGA hat and read the tag, it says MADE IN....
To those that have commented in this thread, I have made several replies but TH-cam seems fit to hide/delete my replies. I suppose I have angered the algorithm.
Gotta start somewhere. The CCP is failing China and tanking their economy, so they’re desperate for every opportunity to screw with the west, and an app like TikTok is invaluable to them in shaping public opinion, especially about China and the evil CCP. And I’m writing that as someone left of centre, not some right-wing maga freak. There’s a new kind of warfare going on with this seemingly innocuous tech, and China’s influence needs to be curtailed, one step at a time.
I've thought about this. From what I understand, our engineers and tech companies have made sure the phones themselves do not give the Chinese government access. I'm not a software engineer, but that's what they seem to be doing.
Installing Tiktok is opening a door, allowing them access.
That is exactly why we buy Chinese made phones but are now trying to ban Tiktok.
Over there, in China, you know that the Chinese government uses their version of Tiktok as a tool of their oppression? It's one of many ways the Chinese government watches and controls the people.
Meta got caught doing psychological tests on users without consent and still do it. Yet they were never truly punished.
@@izzyxblades I certainly would not put much trust in American companies' ability to safeguard chinese electronic devices, they can't even safeguard their own airplanes, trains and automobiles. I remember back in the "good ole days" of IC manufacturing many of the engineers took pleasure in embedding secret lithography within the silicone. With todays multitude of devices and their connectivity and IOT platforms these devices could easily be delivered "clean", pass any inspection and be one firmware update away from uploading data. America's Cyber Defense capabilities are laughable at best. You would be appalled at how many government and medical facilities are still running Windows 95, 98, 2000 or Windows 7.
@@izzyxblades I'm in China now, it's all about money, all governments are the same.
We only want home grown tech bros spying on us through our phones!
Haven't you ever seen the news from "Under the Desk News??" Insightful, concise, incredibly informed reporting. The Tiktokkers stood with you during the strike, turned down studio contacts in support of your strike. A little respect would be awesome.
Love under the desk news and I came to see the clip in context and it disheartening to see how much he bashes people who use the app and make the great content on there. There is so much content on the app that is insightful and educational in addition to being entertaining.
Banning tik tok before guns is crazy
and onlyfan
Yes, an app developer should not allowed to share user data with a government... but of course, they should be able to sell that data for profit to any and all companies that are willing to pay for it.
Yes. But the Chinese government has no respect for any rules or law or human decency. Tiktok is not a normal app. It is owned by the Chinese government, and over there, they actually use it to watch and track people. Tiktok is one of many tools that the Chinese government uses, that ultimately oppresses their people.
Tiktok is not a normal app.
Yep. Like fb that has a ton of scammers
Including the gonvernment.
Well, those things are very different. The Chinese military aren't just trying to sell you something; they're trying to control the worlds economy and undermine democracy.
Yet there’s absolutely zero proof that TikTok gives user data to Chinese government. They even spent 1 billion back in 2020 to move their server to the US to comply with US laws, but they are shooting at a moving goal post because data security was never the true issue. It’s about crushing Chinese competitors that are winning.
Tik Tok is a huge organizing resource for antiwar activists and people sharing the truth about government and history. The danger is not about privacy at all, or nationality - all these companies are multinational and the Tik Tok CEO is famously Singaporian, not Chinese. The danger of Tik Tok is that people are being educated and empowered to free themselves and others. It threatens the ruling class whose existence depends on people being ignorant and isolated.
Ma'am you are the first comment that hit it on the head. THAT is the heart of the matter, that is why the support was bipartisan and why they moved so quickly on this bill.
I wish more people would understand this.
For example, it can showcase the true life of Uyghurs in China to the world, which is different from the biased reports of media influenced by political parties and conglomerates behind the scenes.
@Kittymancer78 I still don't understand why that matters....I go on tiktok to watch some funny vids while I pass the time literally could care less what someone could be preaching
@@herosio270Except that content about Uyghurs is literally banned on tiktok LMAO
You guys are such sheep that have convinced yourself you are free thinkers
@@drooooop Because TikTok does not spread obvious rumors. In fact, thieves of tUyghurs are not punished, and even vendors who engage in unfair transactions will not be expelled. Uyghurs have privileges in China. It's not as you imagine. Although there are indeed some undemocratic aspects in this country, it is precisely this that has prevented differences and riots. Supporting opposition forces make them fight to eachother to weaken a country is what the United States most wants to do to China.
You must understand that things have their multifaceted nature.
Idc if they ban tik tok, but i do wish they'd ban TRUMP.
Exile would be a very lenient penalty for treason.
Ahhhahahaha! I wish they would
Biden committed treason as well...
Tell him there is no country for old men, as you put him on a boat that will never get close to land again.
Trump 2024🥳🥳🥳🥳
This is the most hideous precedent of all time. If any foreign company can be forced to be sold like this, then should China reciprocate the same to American companies having businesses there?
They could start with Apple, im sure that won’t affect anyone’s 401k 😬
Facebook, Twitter etc are already banned in China lmao they set the precedent themselves
You are so ignorant that you don’t know that CHINA LITERALLY DOES EXACTLY THAT.
Dude, tiktokers had a hella opportunity to make mad $$ during the writers strike & the vast majority stood with y'all & you do them dirty?
On the same grounds the rest of the world should ban office 365, Meta, Google, Apple, ... Now! Do it!
... the tiktok ban is a clear example of how Americans love free market competion,
as long as it doesn't give someone else the upper hand ...
They already do, all of that is banned in China
I fecking hate office 365 😠
@@MrMarcosema HUH, China is the whole rest of the world?
Why are you shitposting on youtube?? Jesus Christ, the irony is dead to Boomers who can't recognize YOU ARE POSTING ON SOCIAL MEDIA 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Like tik tok or not, this is a dangerous precedent and clearly violates the first amendment.
drama .is on BY. ALL HIDERS OF MADHAB AND NEEWS .NON-BUSLIM COUNTRIES NO EXIS .APP IS SURE BAUSLIMS .2 PARTIES GOING NAKIE LIVERS OR BUSLIMS . 3-4 GARDER WERE 90% IN PAKISTAN AND IN ALL COUNTREIS ...FOUND FREEDOM FORM THESE ARMEI SIN 1980S .......THESE ARE SHI PICKERS ...TOO CIRMINLAS , AND TOO KAANAIN . UR ALL PAGE SITES ALL ON EM HIDDING SMAE NEWS TOP MADHAB ..TOLD ON TOP ON SITS ... ON FB ..IF ...NET SPREAD IS URS TO ALL OF THIS GANG AMOUNG WHERE EVER NET APP CAN ... REWARDS ARE BEEN TOLD ON SITS ... ITS UR MEDIA OF ALL WORLD SINCE EVR 1 MAN SHOW ...HOW .....CALLL WAHAB .. AGAIN ... MICROSFT ......CALL HIM IF NAY THING IS SPARED ....DMA OR GRID IS SURE ..MISSING ......
Where in the first amendment does it enshrine social media platforms? 😊
People's idiocy is astonishing...
never underestimate the power of stupidity.
Yes. But people will still keep voting for them.
😏 This is clearly ABOUT big corporations and money they don't have control over ... Just yet!!!
What do you think would be the reason for a country to ban a piece of software? A blockade of information? Or to protect the country's businesses
The whole world can use TikTok, but not USA. 😂😂😂
Soon, except for other Asian countries, it will not be available, because the government will force them to ban tiktok
We don't want that shit anyway 😂🤡😊
Yeah, not yet. It's just a bill.
what is bill? @@thatswhatisaid8908
CHINA:WE EAT MCD ,KFC,STARBARK,COLA,PIZZA HAT,BUGKING,....AND USE IPHONE TESLA.....EVERYDAY, ITS TIME TO TAKE OVER ALL OF THESE SHIT
Weak move punching down at online creators when your target should be the federal government forcing the hostile sale of a foreign company. But sure, let's make fun of people having fun on the internet.
When both parties agree on something, it's 100% in favor of reducing the power of the people. When gov owned late night shows support an issue, it's 100% in favor of reducing the power of the people.
Which government do you imagine owns the show?
@@TheGreatAtario I'd be more concerned about who owns the government. Trickle down social engineering at its finest.
I support this bill
"You're not in Huffelpuff, you're in marketing!"
This 33 y/o would like to think one can be both!!
I'm 44 and I'm in Gryffindor. It's not just the Millennials.
If my grandma had been into the internet when she was younger,
she might have taken the quiz too. She's 94 and she read the Harry Potter
books before I did.
Please, remember that that stone was thrown by a fifty-something gentlenman who quotes the lord of the rings verbatim regularly, lmao. I love and respect Mr. Colbert immensely but even I had to pause and mentally ask "Really sir, did YOU seriously just throw that stone?" 😂
I'm 45 and was sorted in to Slytherin last I checked.
Pukwudgie myslef. (I'm an American, so I'll take assignment of an *American* house. 🤪)
@lynntaylor6686
You're grandma sounds cool. Glad to hear she's made it to an old age. I raise my energy drink in toast to her continued longevity.
@Kittymancer78
Never have I more wished that Mr Colbert responded to these comments than to yours.
@@Kittymancer78 Mr. Colbert was actually in The Hobbit. I'm not making that up.
@@MyFiddlePlayerlol, oh, I know. I watch regularly. I remember when they showed the footage and talked about it.
"You're 59 Stephen, you're in television, not Lord of the Rings"
He's in The Hobbit, though.
Yes please, Ban TikTok at now.
No
Really instead of lowering the cost of living
Americans will never stop to ask why laws banning drag performances, TikTok and teaching ANYTHING that could possibly make straight white men uncomfortable happened quicker than taking the necessary legal measures to prevent more mass shootings.
@chunkymonarchy5686 you’re going to PROTEST Trump? Where has that gotten anything? Register for a gun and take firearms courses if it’s not possible for you to find another country to live in if Trump wins again. Project 2025 is much more of a threat than Biden’s health and it’s not being talked about because the media wants it to happen.
@chunkymonarchy5686 “TikTok and drag queens never caused a mass shooting”
Huh, Stephen going AGAINST free expression and young people being politically engaged is not what I expected. But as my dad was fond of saying, "Better to lose a friend than to miss out on a good line."
The only problem American Marketing firms have with TikTok is that the data being harvested isn't given to them, too. Just SHARE IT
Or restore American citizens' right to privacy? 🤔
LOL
and the fact that tiktok doesn't parrot U.S propaganda angers them, how dare Tiktok tell american people what's going on in Gaza !
Nah, don’t ban TicTok without banning Facebook and XTwitter!
Stay outta this, China 🇨🇳. 👀
😘 🤭🤣
Why is he licking Tiktok's boots? 😂😂
If that's a security risk, what are all the made in China smart phones? What's to stop them quietly passing data about their owners back to China? I'm not claiming they do, but if you're going to be paranoid about one Chinese product, why not all of them?
I thought they were an issue a few years ago. On to something new, they are forgotten.
I thought about that, and from what I understand, our own cyber security experts have been watching to see if the devices have been giving them access, and they aren't.
Remember a few years ago, they caught a Chinese phone brand that actually did give China access, and they immediately banned it.
We are lucky that we have white hat hackers, cyber security experts who work for us, they protect us
You know hardware can be inspected, right?
Whether it goes or stays, it doesn't affect me. I've never used it, will never use it or any other media app for that matter (excluding YT).
Totally dull and useless take to have. Maybe we should not be judging if its ok for Congress to ban a phone app based on whether or not we personally use it, and rather that its a ridiculous overstep in Congress' authority that can set precedent for them doing it more often in the future.
@timf7679 Sorry my personal opinion offended you?
@@Zerolink30 "Sorry my personal opinion offended you?" - You should be. There's a valid reason your opinion offended that person. First, they came for...
You have to understand that this goes beyond singular personal experience. People are upset because there’s a hypocrisy because data is being sold on other platforms as well so the reason that they gave for banning it is not valid so if they banned based on a lie, it affects everyone’s freedom. That is the discussion here And the way he portrays it that it is a dance app is completely wrong. There are scientists philosophers teachers musicians, all sorts of people from all walks of life and areas of expertise, sharing their work not to mention the millions of people that actually make a living off of this. The band is because Amazon is being hurt by the TikTok shop and the second reason is because people are being mobilized and galvanized for political issue. Stephen Colbert cannot speak on this issue because he himself works for immediate conglomerate controlling his freedom of speech but I get it if you don’t use it and have nothing to do with it it is hard to plug into the conversation about it.
The fact is to over simplify things in such a way is dismissive and dangerous. The app has met the previous demands of the US government and has an American company in Texas handling the data of American users. This is just the American platforms like Facebook and insta mad they are losing traffic on their platforms. This approach is disappointing Stephen, as I have been a fan of you for years and supported your act during the strike. Funny how American rights become so trivial when the do not directly impact you....
I can't believe Stephen can be pro freedom and pro banning tiktok disgraceful
Read the license agreement u have to opt in on. TikTok makes u share your geolocation, personal info like phone numbers etc, your IP address, browser searches, and all of your social media contacts. That’s something I don’t want my own government or even parents to have access to, much less a foreign government. There’s a reason why if u a government issued business phone, u can’t have TikTok on it and it’s not because they’re afraid you’ll be goofing off. You give up a bunch of vulnerable information.
Hey sports fan, if you don't think other social media sites track your data this way then I have a bridge to sell you.
@@NoThatRyanwake up, buuuuuuddy.
@@NoThatRyanThe other social media sites aren't a direct arm of a Communist government 😂 take a civic class.
Then why doesn’t congress regulate what information platforms are allowed to collect? Giving the government power to just ban apps they consider a ‘security’ risk is a ridiculous power grab.
@@NoThatRyan US companies getting your personal information is your problem.
Companies from adversarial countries like China getting your personal information (or worse) is the US's problem.
Tik tok is educating people about real shit and it’s becoming a problem. People are getting exposed
No. Please DO NOT ban TikTok. This is not just me saying it cuz I use it. Millions of people lose their job and this is where young people can communicate. American the land of the “free”. But they ban one of the biggest social media platforms
This is so disappointing... Especially after the support and loyalty Stephen got from huge tiktokers who refused to create content for any network during the writer's strike.
The USA needs data protection laws pronto.
drama .is on BY. ALL HIDERS OF MADHAB AND NEEWS .NON-BUSLIM COUNTRIES NO EXIS .APP IS SURE BAUSLIMS .2 PARTIES GOING NAKIE LIVERS OR BUSLIMS . 3-4 GARDER WERE 90% IN PAKISTAN AND IN ALL COUNTREIS ...FOUND FREEDOM FORM THESE ARMEI SIN 1980S .......THESE ARE SHI PICKERS ...TOO CIRMINLAS , AND TOO KAANAIN . UR ALL PAGE SITES ALL ON EM HIDDING SMAE NEWS TOP MADHAB ..TOLD ON TOP ON SITS ... ON FB ..IF ...NET SPREAD IS URS TO ALL OF THIS GANG AMOUNG WHERE EVER NET APP CAN ... REWARDS ARE BEEN TOLD ON SITS ... ITS UR MEDIA OF ALL WORLD SINCE EVR 1 MAN SHOW ...HOW .....CALLL WAHAB .. AGAIN ... MICROSFT ......CALL HIM IF NAY THING IS SPARED ....DMA OR GRID IS SURE ..MISSING ......
I was going to say I'm old enough to remember the Web in the 1990s and that there's nothing wrong with website owners, in the capacity of them being community leaders, to protest against new laws and asking the users to do what they can. But then I remembered that this is just not the case anymore. If a billion dollar website tells their millions of users to do a thing, how much of that thinking is about "we need to do what's genuinely the best and most rational thing for the community" and how much of it is about "I have a giant website/app and a whole lot of idiot users who do just what I tell them to, and we need to do what's best for my bank account"?
How would American ownership solve anything?
Off hand I’d say it’s because they want to use it to spy on and or influence their own people instead of letting China do it. Basically they’re butt hurt because they can’t use the platform to influence people like they can with Facebook, Instagram and other American owned social media companies. So instead of leaving well enough alone they’re risking nuking their own career’s by screwing over millions of Americans rights to freedom of expression over a stupid app.
my guess would be that in the govt’s eyes, American ownership would mean the company that owns it is subject to US laws and regulations, and could be pressured to do or not do certain things with the data, for better or worse
so they can be the ones spying on the rest of the world instead of China
✋🏿Excuse me sir I'm a 40 year old Ravenclaw accountant. I can do whatever the hell I want.
I'll never own real estate or get to retire, just let me be a Hufflepuff
Show starts at 0:40
Wow, I never would have known. Thanks
WTF? What’s the actual point 😂😂😂
You think we’re worried about 40 seconds of the day 😂
On the upside, if this can get American teenagers more interested in politics, that's a win.
His show has a TikTok account but he thinks everyone that uses it is a moron? And the guy who knows every detail about Lord of the Rings is making fun of Harry Potter fans? The arrogance smells even worse when mixed with hypocrisy.
Maybe our govt should focus on stuff like housing and not allowing corporations to buy up all the inventory to artificially raise the price....
Lol @ the Hogwarts joke. I feel personally attacked 😂😂
These jokes feel like they were written by a group of people who have only read about TikTok trends and not actually been on TikTok.
so many tiktok creators backed you up during the writers stike, and you do this Steven ?
Old people trying to tell young people how to act, has never worked.
During the writers' strike, a lot of tiktok influencers got reached out to by companies that wanted them to take the pressure off. Tiktok which is pretty aggressively leftist chose solidarity. Stephen's response is coming off as very "fuck you, got mine" and it feels really gross. Solidarity when you need help, but not when someone else is asking for help. Remember this next time.
💯
Im still trying to figure out what is so different about TikTok in regards to user data for the other social media apps. I've read it. They all do the same shit.
That's not what this is about. It's about censoring people's opposition to what's going on in Gaza.
Banning TikTok would be a logistical nightmare and a waste of time and tax dollars. The only people who would benefit from it would be VPN service providers.
Yes
Watching an old guy fumble through a basic understanding of any kind of free expression that isn't stamp collecting or some sh!t is embarrasing. If congress cared about data mining they'd be after facebook and twitter. They just don't like information sharing that they can't control.
Yes,followed by only fans
Did the hydraulic press channel just make the late show?
lol i tot America support freedom of speech and freedom, but ban the things they feel uncomfortable.
Bro, you have a Chinese last name, right? You know the Chinese government owns Tiktok, right?
Why you taking their side?
@@izzyxbladesis not taking sides, other countries are still using it, while ur congress suddenly wants to ban it and wat does my last name gonna do with it? lol
Following all the news i mean they do not want to banned it. USA made it clear they want TikTok and if they can't have it then they will banned it forever.
@@izzyxbladesmost companies steal data
@@RandyChoy1987They want it to be sold to an American company, not banned. Unless they don't sell it then it will be banned.
Tik tok sneaks Chinese propaganda into its contents
Say goodbye to everyone younger than about 50 repugs! 🤣🤣🤣
So happy to have never been on TikTok.
that Hogwarts joke felt like a personal attack 4:37
Yes, let's stop this crazy freedom of speech nonsense. 😑
Yeah, you should shut-up. . .
I’m 28 and I think banning tik tok would be AMAZING!? Why the hell is he against it?? Big business got to him?? Ban all social media, it’s completely fucked up our world
but they're not thinking of banning all social media, just the one owned by the "official enemy". And banning tiktok gets them no closer to banning facebook or twitter.
Money. Too much money is involved. China only allowed people under 18 45 min of social media time per day. Their tech stock took a dive. What is not being told here is Americans own 52% of tiktok and ALL congressmen on the committe have benn receiving donation from Suckeerberg, This is a battle of the Billionaire.
@@Unlyricallyrics Banning TikTok does theoretically get them closer to banning facebook or twitter. It sets a precedent.
And it will keep you locked up in your own little world
TikTok does not need to be banned 😡