DeWalt or Milwaukee? Which Compact Impact Wrench Reigns Supreme?! [DCF921 vs M18 2855]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ธ.ค. 2024
- With the release of the new @dewalttv DCF921 ATOMIC Compact Impact Wrench, everyone wants to know how it stacks up against Milwaukee. We paired the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2855 Compact Impact Wrench with the DCF921 to see if one could outperform the other. Thankfully, there was no bloodshed, but that doesn't mean we won't see some tears shed. Both compact impact wrenches cost $199 for the bare tool. The @MilwaukeeTool 2855 comes with a 5-year warranty, while the DeWalt DCF921 only includes a 3-year warranty.
Milwaukee 2855 Compact Impact Wrench: homedepot.sjv....
DeWalt DCF921 ATOMIC Impact Wrench: homedepot.sjv....
Keep current with our great content:
Facebook: / shoptoolreviews
Twitter: / shoptoolreviews
Instagram: / shoptoolreviews
TH-cam: / shoptoolreviews
![POWER STACKING - DeWalt DCF921 ATOMIC Impact Wrench Review [5Ah vs. PowerStack]](/img/n.gif)
As a Dewalt fan I gotta say, it’s nice to see something yellow keep up with big red for a change.
They dont compete with the jobs no more they jus competing with each other now
They both are worth it.
Hammer drill, rotary hammers, circular saws, Miter saws, chainsaw, trimmer, Router. This is just a small List of tools that are way ahead of Milwaukee.
@@Zozo806 don't forget stronger impact wrenches and stronger ratchets and better cut off tool
Been a dewalt fan since i became an electrician but I’m making the jump to Milwaukee next week
@@Filthyserb262 th-cam.com/video/5nzGnqBGAtE/w-d-xo.html
The dewalt is slightly shorter, slightly stronger, and has more features being able to adjust the led lights, so Dewalt for the win on one of the most versatile most used tools and one of the most popular tools
Are you talking about the DCF921? Because STR could only get it to break 450, this is breaking over 100lb*ft more. Edit: Something is messed up here! Comments (like above) on this video are from 2 years ago yet the video was posted 8hrs ago???
Really appreciate the comparison, both impacts are just beasty and plenty powerful for what they put out in power and torque.
Ya but the dewalt is clearly stronger
I love these videos. I've made multiple purchases based on the results of some of these videos. So, please keep making them. 👊
the precision mode on dewalt impact wrenches works real good.
Fuel toosl were designed to use high output batteries. Wish Milwaukee would package these tool with at least the 3ah ho battery no to mention be tested with them as well!!!
How can you say these Compacts, notably the Dewalt one, aren’t made for wheel nuts and such when Dewalt themselves markets it as busting AXLE-nuts with ease (and they were using a 3/8, not even a 1/2!)? Other than the obvious point, too, that 450 ft-lbs is MORE than enough for any average car? It’s like these torque wrenches telling me not to use them on wheels that have 90 ft-lbs to spec? What gives?
As always great video Thanks for the time you spend in recording and posting the videos.
The M18 3/8 drive broke 450ftlbs in the 3/8 vs 1/2 video. I would like to see the 3/8 drive between these same 2. Dewalt is has an angled head like the M12 Stubby but is running the same battery class as the M18. With the M12 and M18 claiming the same specs Dewalt takes out 2 birds with one stone. Dewalt has had an amazing releases for the 2nd half of 2021.
I can tell you I put 8 inch by 3/8 lags into hickory tree with both these tools to hold my bow hunting. And the m12 can do it just slower even with the 6.0 battery. Only reason I tried the m12 3/8 stubby first is it’s lighter and smaller than the dewalt to fit in my bag.
The m12 stubby and the dcf901 both hit this exact same range of about 450 ft lbs of break away. I’d stick with the 12 volt tools for the weight reduction and reduction in battery size without giving up any power. I have a dcf901 and it’s a fantastic little tool. The m12 stubby is awesome as well.
So I had this Milwaukee impact and sold it awhile ago. I thought it was just a little underpowered and really not even an upgrade from the M12 version. I just got this Dewalt 921 and I like it much more. I also tried out the Dewalt 12v 1/2" impact and didn't like that one either. But any of these may not be first choice if your a tire mechanic but for rest of us these work great for lug nuts. Won't find many cars or pickups with over 250 ft/lbs on its lug nuts. btw can get a "free" battery with the Dewalts right now at HD.
You should have gotten the Milwaukee mid-torque.
I have the Milwaukee mid torque but am going to purchase this Dewalt as well. What can I say I like tools 🤷🏻♂️
"Won't find many cars or pickups with over 250 ft/lbs on its lug nuts." Really??? Tell that to the tire shop who overtightened the crap out of lug bolts on my Mercedes van. I didn't have with me 3/8 m12 FUEL stubby nor 3/8 M18 FUEL Compact, so I used 1/2 M18 FUEL mid-torque with Pittsburgh impact 1/2 to 3/8 reducer. After pounding for 10 seconds, none of five bolts broke lose. So I brought M18 FUEL high-torque, and after a few seconds, Pittsburgh impact 1/2 to 3/8 reducer snapped. I had to use breaker bar to get lug bolts lose.
Also, listen again from 19:15 about "air ugga duggar wrench" lol
10:55 starts what you've been waiting for!!
I like to see Makita with it. Tried all three, Makita feels better in the hand and more refined impact shake than brutal impact shake from both.
Not trying to be rude but why is that always the excuse for every Makita fan and I have some Makita tools. When they get outperformed the go to excuses the Makita feels so good in the hand. I have read this same comment on so many different channels more times than I can remember.As someone who owns all three tools doesn’t feel all that different.
@@steffendetrick9403 maybe because he has a preference for how it feels in his hand? I don't think it's an excuse based on feel not torque and power readings. Not going to use a tool if it doesn't feel right in my hands and whatnot
Dewalt bringing the heat! Got the 3/8s 12v extreme and it surprises me every day! Glad team yellow stepped up and shook the cages! Great video like always!
My yelow 3/8 still works like charms after 2 yrs of beat on
Yea I just got the atomic impact driver and I'm so impressed with it! I sure hope they update the xr impact and male it look more like the atomic
Good to hear.. I want one
Picked up a 3/8 also. Almost went for the 1/2 but after debating 3/8 is what I needed for this size of tool. Been pretty happy with it
These are perfect for me. I don't use impacts on my lugnuts because I have very nice looking McGuard lugnuts that I don't want to chip the finish on them. I just use a breaker bar. I'm pretty sure show car owners do the same thing.
Both are great tools. From personal experience having owned both DeWalt and Milwaukee impacts, I prefer Milwaukee. I'm not a fan of how DeWalt's "Precision Wrench" mode functions in actual use. There is no practical advantage to having the tool snug up a nut, then stop, then start again at full power. If you want to snug up a nut, the tool should run it down, then stop and not restart (like the Milwaukee does). I also really dislike how cheap and unsatisfying the DeWalt forward/reverse switches always feel, and they tend to be placed where they are exceptionally easy to bump out of position with your hand (particularly when wearing gloves).
So... Both great tools, but I'd go home with the Milwaukee. It has a better forward/reverse switch, better auto mode, performs nearly as well, is slightly smaller, can be purchased bare, w/batteries, or in tool bundle, and has a longer warranty with better warranty service provider reputation.
this guy speaks facts ^
The dcf921 is smaller than the Milwaukee. ..
Anyways it has a variable trigger.. just use that.
@@juanc5149 You must not have watched the part of the video where he measured both tools and determined that the Milwaukee is smaller.
The Milwaukee M12 compact which is old compared to the two, does 450 ft/lb on your tests - comes to something when a 12v beats the 18v.
the 12v dcf901 does 450 ft lbs too
@@theflipflopfabshop yup, on the torque test channel the dewalt was stronger too
I personally prefer Milwaukee tools
I like Milwaukee alot, but woo hoo I made a great buy going with( the winner) dewalt this time. Nothing better than having the best of both worlds in power tools for these 2 brands.
Great comparison, Tim! Still gonna use the DeWalt on lug nuts though 😅
4.2v per cell x 5 cells is 21v peak. If you actually meter it DeWalt batteries fresh off the charger typically start at 21.1 to 21.3v
Also altho the voltage of the cells and the number of cells are identical, multiple tests have shown that DeWalt batteries have around .25 volts more fresh off the charger compared to either of the Ms
I don't have the 1/2 inch compacts but I have the 3/8" drive from both brands. I like them both but tend to grab the milwaukee more often in the shop. I do feel like the dewalt does have more torque but I don't feel like it's the 200 more in reverse they advertise. If I need any more power than the compact I grab the mid torque gen 2 1/2" or the 2767. Just my 2 cents. Either brand has yet to let me down, but I do like the warranty on the milwaukee.
I love watching your videos. These are actual in feild test on tools rather than a laboratory test with hydraulics or other fancy stuff that does not pertain to the use of the tool
Excellent Dewalt 💯
I have been using M12 3/8 stubby since 2018 on multiple car van twice a year
it has more torque than my bosch version when comes to seize bolts between 85- over 100 ft/lb
For M18, if you use them with High Output batteries and you watch it to next level
Excelente comparación de compactos, tengo la bestia de Bosch de 200nm pero para reparar autos en espacios pequeños he visto la necesidad de que sea más compacta la herramienta, el DeWalt me gusta. Veo a Bosch que le falta más tecnología en cuanto a motores, aunque en amoladoras tienen la mejor igualmente el motor de las mismas puede ser más pequeño. Bosch también tiene lo mejor en martillos , menor tamaño más golpes
The vibration on the Dewalt looks horrendous.
Tim excellent comparison. I have the Ridgid Mid Torque Impact Wrench. Ridgid claims 450 lb. forward and 650 lb. reverse. I would to see these no# tested with Octane Battery vs Max Output 4ah.
January 7th 2022, home depot still has the battery bundle deal going on the Dewalt with 5.0 battery for 199
I'd get the milwaukee cause the modes are a bit better and the light is brighter when working under cars
I timed it. On the 450 pound he only impacted the Milwaukee for a fraction over 8 second not 10 seconds and it did start to move. I call a redo.
Stop crying
@@Lee-lb9qh wow, how mature....
@@4673962 says the person crying lol
I bought DeWalt but I admire Milwaukee for understating the specs. What a pleasant surprise.
At 13:16, does anyone know what room that was?
As compact as these 1/2" drive impacts are, they're either one smaller than a air powered 3/8" drive impact. So, as long as socket girth isn't an issue, these can make light work of many tasks were considered challenging.
Transmission bell housing bolts for instance.!? Flywheel bolts without fully removing the transmission on some models.
Obviously, talking professional, industry craftsman type guys, here, y'all know who you are, cause you're already thinking the same things I'm typing.
Both the M12 1/2" stubby and M18 3/8" compact have broke 450ft lbs on previous videos.
In the UK the Dewalt is marketed as an 18v XR battery and not a 20v!
Always appriciate the good match up's you post. Hopefully Milwaukee will come out with a refreshed version of the stubby since I still prefer it over these two compacts. For me the stubby is overall a better tool since I can get into some tight spaces these can't. If I need more power with almost the same foot print my Gen 2 mid with a 3.0 HO fits the bill plus it's almost the same size as these new compacts with way more power LOL. Great work as always👍
I have the DeWalt and I don't see any difference between high power mode and the wood screw mode. It's not a problem but it's a bit odd. Good machine though.
Can you do Decibel ratings for the impacts?
Great! Now I have to add Dewalt to my tool arsenal.
If they are not made for removing car & truck lug nuts which are torqued at less than 150 ft lbs, than what are they made for? I have used my compact Makita all the time for the last two years with no issues.
Milwaukee and Dewalt are back and forth for #2 & #3 for me. Specific things I like and dislike about both.
whats your #1?
@@guanqiaowang7586 makita
Hi Tim, love your channel but you can see in the comments the public has spoken. Please bring in the makita xwt 14 or xwt15 compact to compare to these tools. You reviewed the Makita in the past and during that review you never tested that impact to its Max nut busting ability only to its advertised Max which was very disappointing to me. That's not what you usually do on your channel, we all tune in to see its absolute Max capabilities. So again please retest the Makita compact and put it to the true test of Max capabilities and show us how it stacks up. Thanks
I use my dewalt every day I don’t know what I would do with out this thing it’s taking things off that I never thought it would
I'm more interested in that torque gun. I didn't know it existed. That would be so much faster than using a torque wrench!
I want one too but it’s thousands of dollars
Still prefer the M12 stubby in 3/8. 1/2 M18 mid torque 🏆 Atomic line is their trash line too.
Atomic isn't their trash line really
Lol somebody is salty that Dewalt💪 just beat Milwaukee 😂😂 that "trash" impact wrench just punked out Milwaukee
Would like to see them go again with the Dewalt powerstack battery vs. M18 H.O. battery
The PowerStack delivers the same. You can see our review of the DCF921 by itself and we tested the 5Ah and the PowerStack. Very impressive battery, especially for the size. Thanks for watching.
I have a Toyota Prius V , which one you recommend to remove my tires please.? 🙏 Thanks 👍
What am I doing wrong ?
I've broken all my studs from my Honda while removing the nuts with my new M18 Fuel cordless impact. The nuts cross-thread while removing then the bolt brakes.
Any help will be appreciated.
That means the nut we're put on cross threaded they can't cross thread reversing unless they were put on cross threaded to begin with
Righty tighty, lefty loosey; not reverse thread. Try again.
Makita XWT15 (DTW300) is the king of compacts, it even beats some midtorques. Torque Test Channel said "Its not even close", XWT15 is in a class of its own. For even more power it also comes in XGT 40vMax. The dewalt sounds like a box of steel pellets being abused by a gorilla in heat so Milwaukee should be your choice if you cant get the Makita. I respect the nutbusting abilities of the dewalt but that sound cant be healthy, that anvil cant expect a long and happy life.
Also, significantly larger in length, and diameter. Weights more too.
Have you done one for the dewalt dcf891?
I’m getting the 923b for work in my backpack. I have a 890b currently. Someone had a Bauer I’m assuming mid-torch that absolutely destroyed it on some muddy year old Polaris wheels. I wish I knew about these earlier.
The 890 is old tech now, Dewalt didn’t release anything new for like 6 years or something lol. Then they realized they were stuck in the past and pushed out the Atomic stuff and started making the XR stuff decent.
I been looking at one of these I hs ve both platforms I don't know which one
@ 13:01 you do something different with the Milwaukee...
You use it to snug up 7 bolts.
You didn't do that with the DeWalt tool.
So much for a fair comparison.
Thanks! 🤪
Well I think a better choice would be the milwaukee gen 2 impact wrench . Just a better tool .
The whole point is compact
@@jesusbarajas8067 the two are very close in size except the gen 2 packs a punch .
how much is the dewalt in philippine currency?
Love watching these! Wish you would have added the makita xwt14z to the mix
Been waiting for this comparison thank you. go Dewalt! 💪
U got a video of the big boys?
DeWalt is stepping up, but was hoping they kept the prices lower than the Milwaukee brand.
Great video 👍
I coulntt tale lugnuts by hand and use a atomic 1/2 imch it took them rith off how can a little tool have more power than me lol im impressed
I’d like to see the 3/8 model comparison since the video he had shown the 3/8 2854-20 beat the 1/2 2855-20
Great video! Any word on when Dewalt is going to release its cordless ratchet? I seen a video on the tube of a price tag of the coming tool.
Tim... awesome videos you make
Anybody got news if a new m12 stubby is coming out ?
What does the general public think the gains would be for these two tools, using this form of measurement, with both tools respective newest and most powerful 5Am battery….?
I like this test Thank you Mr.
Glad you like it. Thanks for watching.
I like your torgue gun. Were can i get 1 of that pls
I would like to see a comparison of the DCB921 with the old battery and the new POWERSTACK say they deliver more power and I would like to prove
Hey Tim can you guys do a test review on the Milwaukee m12 1/4 impact driver.
Please try, the skil impact wrench 20V. I can’t find any vids any where for it, it’s on sale from time to time, I grabbed a deal for 99$ with 5 amp and changer, please but it to the test I can’t wait 🙏🏻
You gotta remember. That Milwaukee impact is older. I’m sure Milwaukee is holding some secret surprises for this year
the new dewalt 12v impact seems to be as strong?
But the most important thing is that which one is build better, which one will live longer and you don’t have answers for that
Wonder what would happen if the Milwaukee had one of the newer batteries
Milwaukee 2662-21 M18 1/2" High-Torque Impact Wrench Vs Dewalt Any Electric Impact
Hi Tim, both are awesome and very powerful for a compact, your right about lugs I take lugs off with my 921 all day long and torque them afterwards , this 921 is very comfortable with light to carry around the shop at work it’s very easy to use, I’m interested in the Milwaukee I may try it I’d rather get a later model just don’t know what one it is, excellent demonstration Tim ty, Bob,
I think you heard him differently than I did. He was saying not to depend on the DCF921 for lug nuts unless it was under perfect conditions. I disagree with Tim. I got my DCF921 last week and tried it out on several vehicles lug nuts and no problem with any. My old rusty truck lugs have been on for at least 5 years and those were broke free in a couple of impacts. If you have a shop tightening your lugs to over 350 ft lbs, find a new shop!
I just got this gun I use the insane 1400 ft-lbs Milwaukee 1/2" impact wrench I usually set it on the hight setting for removing lugs but fastening them back on I use it on power mode 1 or 2 for trucks hand fatigue is my biggest reason for moving on over to the 921 20v just got the 5ah battery im thoroughly impressed. I'm not loyal to red or yellow I think both make awesome tools.
Fantastic driver
I’m surprised I haven’t seen any comments mentioning the high output battery for the Milwaukee. Being a fuel it can utilize the high output batteries and deliver a significant amount of power boost.
Just bought the 899 heavy duty impact wrench by DeWalt...can't wait to use it. Did notice you shorted the Milwaukee battery by torquing the bolts with it before using to loosen...battery diminished a bit...still...I am sold on DeWalt...price is reasonable....can buy 2 for what Milwaukee costs
Replacement for the 899 is due very shortly!
Milwaukee m18 fuel beat the dewalt 20v on the torque channel but they were close look up the torque channel results
The Atomic, the DCF 911, and the 901(12volt) all were more powerful than the stubby M18 wrench. The Atomic had a nice lead on the others.
@@seano932 I was talking about impact guns
I love your testing but I think with Milwaukee you should use regular battery and high output. They do have decent power different with the fuel line of Milwaukee. Just so everyone can see the difference
At this point he could also use Powerstack battery on the Dewalt, which provide up to 50% more power
@@guillaum.g a even better test. True enough look up impact driver torture test. Dude shoots them with shotty, they all live lol
These individual powertool comparisons are futile. More important would be a comparison of entire brand since contractors usually want to buy one platform of cordless tools.
Unless you are a hobby guy and don't need a full line up of tools.
I don't know nothing about tools so I came to this video to decide which to buy, I'm go with DeWalt.
wait a minute. so dude recommends a mid torque impact gun for lugs, but not the gun he's using. when I Google mid torque impact gun, this same one shows up. I'm confused
These are both compact impact wrenches, not mid-torque impact wrenches. Mid-torque impact wrenches have larger dogs and impact mechanisms, as well as springs, so they're better suited for heavier work. If you want to be really safe for lugs, then go to High Torque impact wrenches. Regardless of what Google says, these are compact impacts. Thanks for watching.
Longevity winner? As far as batteries, I'm guessing the Red team battery last longer. 🤔
Dewalt dcf850 vs Milwaukee gen 3
It’s so similar to the Milwaukee they should almost be ashamed. And DeWalt usually does a good job on Ergonomics.
13:30 on the Milwaukee
Milwuakee its very good
Great Review..👍 I have the DeWalt dcf923 3/8" impact wrench and its as little Beast no doubt. But if you like a lot of features , the Makita 18v xwt15 is the way to go , plus it's more Powerful and smoother than Both of Those ...
Makita is whack
@@Lee-lb9qh lol did granite for ten years makita grinders are the best around nothing compares they outlast any other
@@heathjohnston4352 😂damn I left that comment a long time ago, anyway I'm just clowning, makita, Dewalt and Milwaukee and like chevy, ram, and Ford trucks, all good
@@Lee-lb9qh 😆🤣
Milwaukee is always copying Dewalt but can't beat Dewalt I can send you some rubber gloves with thumbs if needed I see yours are defective also great video,, you need more yellow on you wall behind you as the one yellow tool is lonely, the DCF921B, DCF923B, DCF850B are all actually $149 its $199 because of the free 5ah battery and the DCF850P1 is regularly $199 plus get a second 5ah battery until December 31st... They have to show $199 until the sell is over then they will drop back down
Put a high output battery on it and watch it break loose
Pretty cool! But the Milwaukee mid-torque reigns supreme within its class.
This isn't a mid torque video this is about compact. The mid torque dewalt will never be in the league of the Milwaukee compact either way. I'm with ya there
DeWalt🏁
Almost identical. Price will be the winner
"維德"基本製造~就比"米沃奇"力量大
所以比較無法確定 孰勝?! 孰負?!
但是~兩者都很棒...........
Good video buttttttt
you only switched the milwaukee to the second level and not to the third where it has the greatest moment of release, it is clearly to see in the video
I just bought the dcf911. 50 less ft/lbs but seems to work good. No stupid mode buttons. I can precision tighten a bolt with my finger on the trigger. It's not hard lol. It behaves differently than my 899. The high torque brushless kinda ramps up and is a little slow to react. Almost like early fly by wire throttle body's