'Grab bag of unhinged hot takes' - Chlöe Swarbrick blasts new Government's policies | TVNZ Breakfast
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 พ.ย. 2023
- Green Party MP Chlöe Swarbrick has let rip at the new Government's priorities this morning, comparing the coalition's policies to "hot takes from your uncle at Christmas".
Swarbrick joined Breakfast today alongside ACT MP and Cabinet minister Brooke van Velden.
---
Subscribe to 1News: bit.ly/1NEWSSubscribe | For the latest news from Aotearoa and overseas: 1News.co.nz
This is the official channel of TVNZ's 1News, where news and current affairs reports are uploaded from 1News, Seven Sharp, Breakfast, Q+A, Fair Go and Sunday.
![[#SHORTS CLIP] ครูอึ้ง กรรมการอึ้ง ฮ่าๆ l ซานิเบาได้เบา l One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qeBTuMJs4t0/mqdefault.jpg)
![อยู่ได้แล้ว - LIPTA feat. Mirrr [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-9-hpntNym4/mqdefault.jpg)
It's good to see the comment sections open. New Zealand should be a country that stands by free speech. Even if that speech is stuff we don't like. Without free speech and a fair democracy we can hardly call ourselves a great nation.
Who's been calling NZ a 'great nation' ? 😂😂😂
every single person that stays at the motel I work at and every tourist,
@@cmt89497
Maybe they want to get some fresh ideas on how to run a business now that they don't have funding... Never trust a lefty...
@@cmt89497Well I do.
Highest youth suicide on earth, second most unaffordable housing on earth (second to Hong Kong ffs..) More kiwis are leaving this country than are being born here, and we're replacing them with anyone who'll float on a chillibin. This country has been rooted since the 90's and it's a damn shame. @@geraldperyman6535
So... one day of a new govt... and suddenly the TVNZ comments section is open... imagine that...
Because the lines of RW trolls are feeling soooo justified now, even though their drivel still makes no sense.
@@berkulous289 it’s the incomprehensible, screeching hysteria of the left that makes no sense.
Well noted.
@@berkulous289 RW Trolls = someone i dont agree with and i wanted to sound intelligent on the internet but the only thing i could think of was calling them RW trolls.
@@throughput6674 Always the way of the left - shoot the messenger‼
The greens are one reason fuel is soo expensive
Good. So it should be.
If you love paying more for all services, public or otherwise, just wait until the lunatics at ACT get going
Swarbrick is out of touch with majority of nz. Her priorities are crazy
Swarbrick should....go.
Chloe can't see how 200 "random" policies affect our lives in NZ. I guess that's why the Greens/Labour government delivered so little. Many of these policies are fixing the ideological damage wreaked on our country by the previous government.
Policies like... action on climate change and fair wages it mean?
@@phillipbridge5009 Her ego wont let her.
Chole using the word that describes her perfectly"UNHINGED'
too much pot
She hardly comes across as unhinged, very well spoken, maybe your closed off simpleminded views are the problem 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
She's not wrong though. They're scrapping Smokefree legislation, handing out tax breaks to the rich, ending the ban on oil and gas exploration, and reintroducing charter schools, which don't work. Really, it's ACT that's unhinged.
@@kiwisrule6757 no,its you.
@@ShirleyZhang-bt4dj not sure what point you are trying to make but hey I doubt you know yourself
the comment section should be open for every tvnz news story, what they are doing is utterly disgusting to free speech especially with a state owned enterprise.
I agree, but interesting our msm have suddenly decided to open the comments sections, while the funding discussion is ongoing and the labour coalition are gone. This new approach to free speech wasn’t needed for the previous 3 years.
@@winstonsmithsoul yes exactly.
It's amazing how the TVNZ Media Corporate refuse Kiwi's to have a say in the comments section.WHY do they get to once again control that forum ?WINSTON was absolutely right !!
Free speech is not TH-cam comments. You guys sound more and more like MAGAs every day.
Chloe is 100% unbearable
Oh thank goodness I'm not the only one who thinks this!
yes exactly, the extreme left does not define all of new Zealand.
Totally - the way she smirkily gobs off from her position of utter ignorance is sickening
She's definitely not playing with a full deck.
A shining example of why the Kiwis media needs to be defunded.
Chloe's look on her face says it all...
Bitter?
@@foamyone101 Get your popcorn ready because this new coalition government will divide Aotearoa more so then ever before. It'll be an absolute s**t show over the next 3 years.
Chloe is a complete waste of space. Zero real world skills which is why she's a politician. Like the rest of the Greens and Labour Party. Ideologues and students.
Yep
@kayaboosha what real world experience outside of politics does David Seymour have?
Lol Chloe thank god you never got in.
Everything out of Chloe’s mouth after her first question is why they were not put in government
Yep! She’s an activist, not a “Politician.”
And a crank with a huge ego.
Chloe is grab-bag of unhinged hot takes.
specially baked hot takes..I mean cakes.
Stop picking and choosing which stories you will let us comment on! Time to change the rules if engagement if you want millions of tax payer dollars.
True, but I'm encouraged this is the second 1 news clip I've seen today that has the comments open, I'd nearly given up watching because comments were always turned off. Hopefully no coincidence .
You vill comment vhen ve say, you vill eat ze bugs, a you vill be happy.
Clause Shhhwab.
@@silverdale3207 our new broadcast minister at work already G O W I N S T O N
That's what happens when the left wing has bribed you. You'll pick and choose the agenda and narrative on what people can talk about. (Yes. Been given $50 million is a bribe. It's the same with your boss. Your hardly going to shit talk them in an environment where they'll find out. Same with the media. They won't shit talk labour as labour has paid them off. Keep out the private sector)
We all need to point this out on every video they post with open comments.
Did Chloe just ask how focussing on things like literacy and mathematics going to help our children?
Because people who know numbers will never vote for a lefty...
No she didnt! Listen properly!
Yes, she thinks sex is more important for our tamariki than reading and writing 🤢 predatory behaviour
You need to listen @@horitauri
@@redishwine2041 What numbers are you referring to? The tax breaks for millionaires?
Your opinion Chloe, never mind criticisms of the new government , you and your crew had six years to make a difference, you succeeded in getting us halfway down the drain….so go away and sit in a corner somewhere quietly
I get tired of explaining this, but you guys DO REALISE that the New Zealand Labour Party didn't cause global inflation, right? People in the UK and Europe and the US aren't looking at interest rates and saying "This is all the New Zealand Labour Party's fault! Because Jacinda Ardern took away their AR-15s!"
what a relief the greens and labour gone PHEW+++
If Luxon's performance so far is anything to go by, Greens and Labour will back in government next election. And I'm not a fan of either.
Exactly.
Yep !!
Chloe's only trick is childish ridicule of her opposition. Sad.
Its the only thing you can do to lies.
Chlöe is quite clearly one of the most intelligent and informed politicians we've got, who forms her opinions based on factual evidence and the values of compassion and sustainability. She doesn't need any tricks.
The members of ACT, on the other hand, seem to rely almost entirely on the trick of sophistry, taking advantage of the ignorant and undereducated voters that haven't learned to recognise such bullshit, even at a time when it's never been easier for people to look up the actual facts for themselves.
@@kiwidave8930 the lies all came from them, and still lying even after they lost
Chloe's a childish loony.😂
Someone should have told Chloe that the adults were having a conversation, it was not all about her.
Anyone notice that One News and Newshub have been opening their comment sections recently?
I suspect it’s cause they know the new government are more free speech friendly and want to keep their funding up 👀
No, the media dislike the slightly right leaning government. For some obscure reason they loved the sainted Ardern and protected her at any cost. Can’t wait for Winston to keep getting stuck into Jacinda’s little lap dogs, Jessica and Tova again.
I have noticed the opening of the comment section.
they have now shown you guilt
Tvnz are the government, funded by advertising and some special bonuses
Television New Zealand (TVNZ) is the most established broadcaster in New Zealand and is government owned but Commercially funded through advertising
Welcome to politics Chloe, policies are always going to be subject to change, its what democracy is about. Dont forget, you randomly shout a grab bag of slogans without thinking when you go to protest marches.
to the river to the sea is fine to say get over urseld
@helloboi901 oh yeah, it's as fine as "expell all muslims from western lands"
@@helloboi901 Nah, its pretty stupid, the genereation "immune" to propaganda are looking like clowns at the moment, identity politics going crazyi
@@helloboi901fine to say if you are an anti-semite...
Actually not true. The first to use the expression were the founders of Israel. The expression can be used by both sides equally, and Israel has no right to tell the Palestinians that they cannot express a wish to continue to live in their ancestral lands too. @@davevanderzwet1209
Good to see the comments section open, it seems the new era is open to hearing the public's views on whether or not they think their policies are a good idea. That in itself is a huge tick in the progress column so far.
Edit: I just realised that not all 1news TH-cam uploads have comments enabled. Not sure what their criteria is, but it should definitely be open for all.
Yes, interesting... maybe they want to get some fresh ideas on how to run a business now that they don't have funding... Never trust a lefty...
The govt doesn't control the comment section for TVNZ on TH-cam.
@@fudobakari Tvnz is state owned.
Their bubble will be well and truly popped.
They thought Act would get destroyed in this comments section. That's the only reason it's open. Hilarious self own.
Nz is smaller than Sydney, why should we as a tiny country of 5m people send 1.4billion dollars oversea to lower other countries carbon emissions.
Government should drill for oil sell it and use the money to pay for roads etc, be like Dubai that pays no tax because the country runs on oil.
We could be a wealthy country, just drill and sell our oil before everything goes electric.
TV1 and the Chloe Swarbrick show …. Seems pretty biased one way to my observations
Just you wait… DPM Winnie is coming for them! 😅
Yeah, it would have been fitting to have Chloe and Anna sitting at the same desk, so they can reach each other for high fives
Brooke is just so calm, clear and personable! Chloe comes across as an emotional mess - hopping from one clickbait topic to the next. Good for you Broke. Very respectable.
Chloe is smart and informed. this government are about slogans
Why does calm or not matter when the calm person is lying
@@barryduff3047 chloe was the one slinging out the slogans. Greens have lost their purpose. No longer the environmentalists, just slogan slingers
Chloe was telling the truth. That has been proven. The greens are not just an environmental party. They have a broader reach and have done for sometime.
Brooke is spouting well rehearsed talking points that have no substance. Chloe is speaking passionately about actual issues. That’s the contrast.
Chloe average New Zealanders(A small minority does), don't give enough of a toss on Gender politics and other WOKE policies. We need money on the table to feed our families and service the high interest rates and cost of living.
Agee 100%
Gender politics isn't a thing. Its a made up story to make you angry at people who just think we should all be nice to each other.
Chloe is out of touch as usual.Her ego gets in the way.
Chloe sooooo desperate 😂
Thank God we had a change of Govt. The Insanity of the last Govt😢
Yes, just hopeless.Chloe, have a drink and lie down.
Details, please. What "insanity"?
@@AnthonyFlack Almost any Labour/Greens/TPM legislation and process, including C19. Ardern, Hipkins, Robertson, Mahuta, the Labour Maori Caucus - all ideological wastrels that have sunk NZ for the next 2 decades.
Chloe you had your time and Nz voted .See ya.Brooke is refreshing and I look forward to a better government.
New Zealand voted Chloe back into parliament again, so yes you will be seeing her.
Brook is so well spoken! Chloe is too easily riled up in my opinion :/
Chloe lets her emotion and ego get in the way.
One of these ladies is humble and deserves her success, the other is arrogant, ideologically indoctrinated, immune to truth and enjoying a free ride on the taxpayer. I used to think that Swarbrick was merely crazy and foolish. In light of her recent pro-terror anti-Israel chanting I now realise that she’s also evil. Best wishes to Miss van Velden, she takes her responsibilities seriously and has a worthy work ethic.
Superbly said
Swarbrick's out the door, out of the limelight, irrelevant and pissed off to blazes. Maybe the silly girl will stick on a vest and squat on the road.
Yhank you for giving Logic back to free thinking
Brooke worked really hard for her seat.
Perhaps Chloe can live in North Korea for a while.Give us all a break.
Why is Chloe so intent on teaching kids about sex? Teach them how to do their taxes and function in a world where they've been reduced to a replaceable commodity. Teach them how to maintain their sanity paying 2/3rds of their income on a 30 year mortgage.
Because she’s a lib left and they don’t have any limits, there is no, ooh that’s a bit much isn’t it, going on in their heads
ABSOLUTELY SPOT ON
You had your chance Chloe, the adults are back in charge
LOL
In charge of jokes 😄💤
Bollocks
Neither Luxon nor Seymour has ever been a cabinet minister - hardly bringing any experience to the job.
@@robertvanruyssevelt7159 I would not trust the greens and Chloe with a lemonade stand, they are morally bankrupt
It's refreshing to see comments section now that we are moving away from authoritarian over reach. 😅 hopefully nz will return to one of the best places on earth for kids. Let kids be kids, teens be teens and mums and dads get the responsibility, respect and honour of being the heads of households once again and the leaders within their communities. Families first. Arohanui NZ ❤
So you're basically saying you have no idea how the comments section works.
@@fudobakari how did you draw that conclusion?
the comment section should be open for every tvnz news story, what they are doing is utterly disgusting to free speech.
@@rikicurtis522 I read the comment where they say that havng a new govt has opened the comment sections on a TH-cam channel. Did I miss something?
Very well said it's been a long time coming now they're all scared of what Winston will do
And what have you done chole since you have been in goverment,you have done nothing it was your labour party that has put us in this woke mess I'm glad you are gone and labour
She did nothing, just talked a lot and that too nothing of value most of the time. Just go and add her voice to every fringe issue and Propagate worthless identity politics. That’s all the Greens are good for.
But do you think scrapping world-leading law to ban smoking for future generations to help pay for tax cuts for the rich is going to improve the lives of the many or just the few of Nationals rich folk???
This coalition led government will divide Aotearoa more than ever before especially if Act get their way with interference of the Treaty of Waitangi.
@@bert454 this country is called new Zealand,tell me what has chole done for this country while in government ,nothing but collect a tax funded wage
@@eileencoulter6263 Aotearoa is its actual name.
New Zealand by the occupiers👍
@@bert454 actually it was a white man that came up with that name and the south Island is called that name not the north Island and that name has been placed by media and maori ellets the people have not voted on a name change
Chloe, how do you not see your private obsessions were roundly rejected…
Drama drama - sour grapes Chloe. Always emotive.
Passionate is a better word
@@jame2433 Sorry; I have zero tolerance toward an abject wicked Chloe ("From the River to the Sea").
@@jame2433brain damaged*
Chloe, try not to show too much jealousy that Brooke is a cabinet minister and you were kicked out of the room by two Labour governments
Chloe is more intelligent and more aware of issues than stupid Brooke
I am surprised that a neanderthal can write....
@@tonywood3660 that shouldn't really be very surprising given neanderthal intelligence was fairly comparable to our own and we share quite a bit of genetics. There is some evidence they could travel by sea and may have used stone tools. Their beautiful art alone would seem to indicate they where much like us with their cave paintings and our own been very similar.
But also don't you find it annoying that labor keep them out of power in 2017?
@@dbuckleton What? Chloe was an elected MP at 23 in the labour-greens-NZF coalition of 2017. What propaganda of ACT's have you been seeing that's making you think otherwise, haha. It's almost as funny as them trying to say it's the first ever three way coalition, as if 2017 never existed nor did any in the past
@@facepalm7345 Labor actually ran a minority government with NZ first in 2017, the greens got cut and instead gave confidence and supply.
Its amazing how Chloe gets so much air time, yet both Greens leaders are seen once a fortnight...
it would be good if they dont get any any time including Chloe ahah
She's in the grass waiting to strike. Marama wont see her coming.
Future prime minister - just have to wait until Winston's voter base dies off, which won't be too much longer now. Thank god.
thats because TVNZ leans to the left which is ridiculous. Any news organization should be neutral and not have any agenda.
@@parkerhal more likely james shaw.
Chloe for next PM!
Yeah right!
Ms Swarbrick needs to recognise the public has voted against her views and stop spouting a ‘grab bag” of nonsense.
Dont tell Chloe.She will blow a fuse.
The public didn't vote against her views, she was the third most popular PM vote and the greens were the third largest party by a significant margin
@@facepalm7345 I'm with you. Reading some of these inane comments makes me more concerned about what the next few years will bring.
Never knew my fellow kiwis were so selfish, gullible and plain stupid.
Really? @@Moamanly
@@Moamanly I'd almost argue a lot of these aren't even kiwis, most of them don't reply and I'm sure the comments had been disabled because most of them were not from inside NZ
Chloe's sole claim to fame remains as the face of the "Ok Boomer" meme.
She is completely detached from the day-to-day struggles and essential needs of the average New Zealander.
In a world where people can't secure their basic necessities-putting food on the table or a roof over their heads-climate change barely registers as a concern.
It's refreshing to see Brooke's commitment to pragmatic goals that actually matters to most, in stark contrast to the wild idealism of those chasing fleeting moments of sensationalism.
Actually that's not her sole claim to fame.
The government can do more than one thing at once. Just because the cost of living is a more immediate concern to some, doesn't mean you just ignore other major issues.
Chloe is also the person who agreed with her party co-leader when she said that violence in New Zealand comes from cis white males. What racist, targeted thing to say but Chloe was very happy to agree with her party leader when she said it. What does she have to say about that now???
@@kiwidave8930 the proverbial "spread oneself too thin" 👌.
@@npatnz384😂😂
If the majority of the parents aren't comfortable with the sex education that's being taught, then the way it is being offered to kids need to be looked at properly. First and foremost, parents need to consent to all sensitive education being taught to students. Children don't belong to the state. The government doesn't have to have this saviour complex. People can look after themselves!
If the majority? Is it the majority or just a small group who have outdated ideas. Not allowing children to understand basic biology allied to the idea if they don't know about "it" they won't do "it" means pregnant youth.
Look up " John money new Zealand david Reimer" they have used his work to justify what they are pushing for a few decades.
If you have a child you would know all schools send out information regarding to opt out if Sex Ed. Why any parent would do this is beyond me. No one is forcing or indoctrinating your children in N.Z public schools.
Children don't "belong" to their parents. Just because parents take issue with some things, they are going to stunt their childrens growth by not being educated on something as important as sex.
@@Yakub943who do you think children belong to?
You’re gonna say themselves. my kids ARE my kids bub, and I want to let my kids and my kids kids and their kids BE kids. Missing this won’t stunt their growth, it will save there lives.
you want 5 yr olds to be taught about rubbing themselves and each other and hours long gender confusing talks (and more) do you? In a classroom? And who may I ask would you approve to do that for your 5 yo? your gonna say, An expert. Yeah right, If you dig deep enough into the curriculum which was going to be introduced next year it’s completely inappropriate and supplied by third party agents from outside the school or an enthusiastic teacher/ principal/parent/ or inside out rep as is currently already happening in intermediate level up are you seriously saying your ok with that? That’s just not right. You probably think there will be less young pregnancies and suicides because if this ‘kindness’ . Kindness like that we can live without .
It's just amazing that anyone in the world would listen to a single word that Swarbrick utters. She gives nutters a bad name.
I don't think you ever have listened to a single word that Swarbrick said.
Climate crisis? Carbon in the atmosphere is .02%. We are like a grain of sand in an Olympic size swimming pool. Sorry, it’s not an emergency.
Who was consulted on sexuality education Chloe?
Everyone was represented. Are you personally attacked because no one asked you? Are you victimising yourself? Are you making illogical assumptions? Are you asking questions that don't need to be answered and are just there to waste time? Must have voted for national or act
@@facepalm7345 Ah yes, lets let the government force a highly contentious ideological perspective onto children (from the age of 5) with no input from the parents. How about we stop hyper focusing on sexualizing children and give them an education which they direly need when looking at the stats. Disgusting perspective.
The difference between these two women couldn’t be starker. It’s so good to see an intelligent, rational voice to represent us. The past 6 years have been an embarrassment.
Butting in with rubbish while someone is speaking is just disrespectful and rude.
Brooke is spot on!!! All i want for my children is to learn about literacy and numeracy and not some woke agenda shoved down their throats...that won't get them a job.
What planet are they going to work on?
Imagine if your children 'woke up' one day and respected everyone no matter how they chose to live their life! Better to send them off to work before they get any crazy ideas.
At last, these crazy are gone.
Couldn't agree more! I'm growing up with this woke agenda surrounding me, it is confusing, it is frustrating, all I want is the truth and seeing one of our MPs Chloe Swarbrick bow down to this ideology is disgusting, she is delusional and needs to have a long think about what this dangerous ideology has done to poor uninformed and overall defenseless children!
Replaced by the coalition of chaos, Peters is already running rampant.
Why are some comment sections available like this ones available, but some aren't ?
Nothing to do with this topic I know , i just notice this alot on 1 news and our other news media franchises.
perhaps the previous govt could not handle comments contrary to their WOKE agenda. Now that National is in govt. they are not really worried about a spectrum of comments
@@23fd22 nope more recent videos comments locked again
@@Mokomoko1995 when a creator uploads a video to you tube they are given the options of having comments on or off, And can also have comments available once checked by creator.
Exactly!!! They should be encouraging free speech and discussion instead of telling people what to think.
@@23fd22 exactly right.
Chloe is just pissed that shes no longer in the spotlight and its written all over her face.
Really? I think she genuinely cares about the future of NZ and she justifiably concerned.
She and her party are angry little ones
Insightful and so well articulated - not!
@1aotearoa11 no, she cares about her image and making bank in a long career in politics.
@AmonAnon-vw3hr clearly you know nothing about her.
Yes Brooje last governnent had no consultation at all. Pushed through policies late at night. No one aware of what was going on.
its funny how you only ever repeat what your lords tell you instead of thinking for yourself
I remember all the moaning about the last government - "too many white papers, too much consultation, not enough getting things done!"
@@AnthonyFlack its not about being realistic, its just about parroting random shit said about the side you dont like
Seems the policies that matter to the people doesnt matter to Chloë
Because she is thinking about the people who need it most and that's the best way forward. Unfortunately our current joke of a government tend to listen to no-one but rich boomers.
Nothing matters to Chloe only her woke agendas that helped the country get rid of the last regime. Swarbrick obviously not comfortable in the opposition benches.
Youve got that right, Politicians serve the people. Chloe contradicts herself in this interview.
@@tls4022if chloe gets her way, everyone will be poorer
She is on an MPs salary, so she doesn't care.
Fortinately we don't have to pay any attention to what Chloe says.
Let's keep it that way.
Not many ever did. She is loud and represents a small minority.
You are talking about a future Prime Minister
@@Tsass0 I didn't mention Mark Mitchell.
@@Tsass0 lol
How will getting rid of minimum wage floors in industries (Fairpay agreements) arrest the cost of living for “majority of New Zealanders”?
Wankers
National and ACT don't care about average people they never have
Seems a bit rough before Xmas alright.
FPA's apply to everyone in an industry not just minimum wage workers
because supermarkets jst pass on the cost of higher wages onto the customers [inflation]....lol wht did u think the supermarkets and other huge corprates actually carried the cost....man the woke r naive
Probably because goods and services would be cheaper to provide?
I would certainly like to work with Brooke as a colleague rather than Chloe.
Yeah, I tell you Chloe's mates in Hamas aren't too keen to work with 'Queers for Palestine'
Yeah, it would be far easier to work with someone who just repeats what you tell her to than with chloe who can think for herself and apply logic to situations. She would get in the way of trying to cheat the system unlike brooke, who probably wouldnt even understand
Brooke spoke very well
Ah yes, people on over 150k a year crying about workers getting fair pay.
It's the small businesses - the first sector to get fair pay agreements was the hospitality sector. They have been hammered by Covid and then to turn around and demand a minimum wage of $30 per hour per worker on the weekend, is not realistic.
Yeah they should just be corrupt and protect corporate Interests like the rest of them. Big brain take.
Doesn't make sense, does it? Politicians trying to help low-paid workers instead of helping themselves. Chris Luxon would never do anything for New Zealand that didn't benefit himself personally. Greens are so weird with their helping other people nonsense.
@@AnthonyFlackćhłöê and the other hippies have held power for the last three years and lower income kiwis are struggling more than ever, is that their idea of helping people? You can tell she’s enjoying being in opposition though because now she can virtue signal more and not be expected to achieve anything
More enquiries from the parties who blasted Labour for working groups. Especially given that there was already an ongoing enquiry, the hypocrisy is real!
Chloe visions herself as both Helen Clarke and Jacinda the second, aye Chloe?
Yep, watch she'll get a job at the UN in a few years. That's her end goal.
They're very different politically, the left is pretty big, it would make sense you'd just attack her like every other person on the right in these comments, I can't find one critique on policy, funny that
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr Well it won't be due to her competence (is it ever...).The only way she'll get there is by trading on her(?) identity, whatever the hell that is.
Yeah because these women get into politics for the people... National leaders go into the private sector and enrich themselves before deciding they want to be the boss. Also .. it's sweet that you personally address her as if she's going to see your comment, she won't. She's busy being successful in her chosen career to be interested in your unhappiness
@davidwatson8367 lmfao take a look at the study of how women governed in the medieval era. They are incompetent to do what is right for the people and normally it ends in bloodshed.
No one is buying your biased coverage of anything anymore TVNZ.
Ms Swarbrick has already proven who she really is when yelled out the "river Sea" words passionately
Didn’t she just a disgusting show of bias for a person in parliament, Chloe needs to either pull her head in or leave NZ politics there is no place for personal bias in her job.
agreed
She's actually unhinged...she needs help..
River to Sea means annihilation of Israel and nowhere for Jews to live. And we thought the errors of Hitler would never be repeated. Chloe's catch cry makes it all so clear just how easy it was for Hitler to implement such evil.
I had so much respect for her until she posted her participation in the march on IG re: fighting for Palestine and screaming that quote. I questioned why she'd do that and not show compassion for loss of lives on both sides, and shouldnt she be condemning Hamas, not Israel? Not long after I responded with my question, all her followers came for me. They're all as unhinged as her, possibly worse. I gotta admit, I voted for the Greens because of her. Probably the biggest regret in my recent life lol.
Yeah get rid of the fair pay agreement we couldn't possibly have workers being treated fairly
More leaving for Oz, Im definitely considering it with this lot in power
@@muppetb.lansing8374 yep 70,000 have left in the last 12 months
@@muppetb.lansing8374 Leave for Aus to get the FPAs bc you cant get them here lol
Fair pay agreements are essentially a return to 'Award rate payments' These essentially force everyone doing the same job into the same pay rate, this is an absolute disaster as it forces an employer to pay the same rate irrespective of skill ,reliability, attitude etc.
@@shanecollie5177 no it doesn't it protects workers from getting screwed over when workers can negotiate as a group they're strong when they individuals they're in a weaker position and that's exactly how National and ACT want it.
That was the same reason national brought in the employment contracts act in 1991 it was to screw over workers.
I remember Bill English on TV saying New Zealand was a low wage economy like it was a good thing.
Australia never tried to screw over their workers and they're in a far better position than New Zealand and that's why so many New Zealanders move over there.
She has quite an attitude of entitlement for someone whose party was in government for six years and did f*** all of any value.
The Greens have never done anything of value. They just get all those seats, take the perks and never make any difference to this country.
exactly, the level entitlement and smugness is honestly disguising. The greens dont speak for everyone.
Entitled to what?
@@AnthonyFlack My point exactly.
Chloe always just yelling and screaming these days.
It makes no sense to Swarbrick - no surprises there! Sat in her Chairman Mao suit carping on about what's fair and the environment. She'll be gone after this Term, disappears into the hole she keeps digging.
nobody likes a nag
Chloe you are a marginal voice. Democracy won. You and Hamas lost.
Brooke is calm collected and to the point. She never gets perosnal. A rare breed politician
Dare I say a future PM if we are lucky!
Not only that but fine beautiful woman.
Lol. That's because she barely has a pulse.. much like Seymore. Dreary as hell.
@@Alfonso_111 True one can listen to them then walk away non the wiser about anything.They must have had training on how to boringly speak and say nothing of substance.
@@jackohere1878 Just like you
Swarbrick is a - Grab bag of unhinged hot takes...
Such as?
Her river to the sea statement for a start, ignorant at best
@@nedread6700 So one statement. Quite the grab bag
How will re-focussing in literacy and numeracy help NZ kids? Genuine question from Chloe Swarbrick. Wow. She obviously thinks that learning about gender idealogy is more important than learning to read.
Treasury said wage growth would be 4% over the next year. If the Fair Pay Act is repealed, what effect will this have Treasuries projections?
It'll probably be lower than 4% then. Anything National passes regarding wages is for the purpose of lowering them.
Last I heard on the radio was that wages were expected to grow more slowly than the cost of living, and wage earners are being told "they expect too much".
The people have spoken Chloe.
Chloe and the Greens,Labour and Maori Party doesnt understand that concept.
Hi Brooke, come here and listen to Comrade Chloe rant... Some balance please
From the River to the Sea, no one voted for Chloe.
Doesn’t matter your green position, you are stuck in opposition 😂😂😂
Really, did she get elected to parliament with zero votes? Here was me thinking the Greens were the third-largest party in Parliament and that Chloe got more votes than Brooke.
Poor Chloe. She no longer has any relevance 😔😂 Brooke seems like an intelligent, classy woman.
Chloe is more intelligent than Brooke
@@pamrush5078stop smoking the green g😂🎉
Greens are infiltrated by WEF and young global leaders
Classy you may need to dumb it down for Chloe so she knows what you mean 😬🤣
Get your hand off it
HAVE PEOPLE NOT RELISED YET THAT THE GOVERMENT CANT MAKE OUR LIVES BETTER ONLY WE HAVE THE POWER TO BETTER OUR LIVES NOT SOMEONE WHOS TELLING US THEY WILL MAKE OUR LIVES BETTER WTF IS THIS!!!!
Yes, I agree, the nation needs weaning from the govt tit.
It's their job to listen to the people and represent us, we can make then do what we want
That's why the best places to live are places with no functioning government, like Somalia. You can be a pirate!
get her Chloe.. they have thick teeth to lie through.
Congrats, Brooke 🙌 you have my full support.
Will repealing the fair pay law increase employees incomes? As the PM said the goverment is there for all people.
Exactly. If they care so much about workers, why are they removing something that guaranteed hospitality and retail workers are protected?
Increasing low paid work through 'fair pay' laws leads to some unskilled workers with jobs getting paid more. It also means it now costs more to employ low skilled people, so employers are less likely to create new jobs. This leads to more unskilled people not having jobs and a life of welfare dependency.
@@chrish5184 - unemployment is low right now. The new government intend to drive up unemployment to reduce inflation.
Official unemployment is low but the not in work number is high. The unemployed are now counted on other lists such as long term sick. In the UK more than 50% of the 2.3 million long term sick have either anxiety, nerves or depression as their diagnosis. I don't know if the numbers for NZ are available.
Either way it doesn't matter. If the cost of employing goes up there will be less employing behaviour. The only way this could work would be if NZ employers are making huge profits. Then increasing minimum wage would not lead to unemployment but would lead to a reallocation from fat cats to employers. But this is not the world we live in. If a company has massive profits other companies come in with lower prices and still make a profit. This is how competition works. Then employees can use their wages to but cheaper goods. i.e. they get richer despite not having a nominal pay rise. This is why the poor now have smart phones and access to the wntire world of knowledge via the internet. The poorest person in NZ today is, in many ways, richer than the Rockerfeller of 100 years ago. Of course, if you just look at pay rates this gets lost.@@AnthonyFlack
Repealing the FPA just won't help with cost of living but I'm glad it will help Foodstuffs underpay employees and make larger profits each day
Australia owns most of the banks in NZ, they cut deals with Countdown/Woolworths and somehow get goverment approval for things like the Gold card which they take advantage of. The banks send 1 billion dollars offshore. Almost none of the petrol stations are 100% NZ owned (there is only 1 NZ owned), either American or Australian owned.
Is it really any surprise that Foodstuffs have trouble keeping up when theyre against that barrage?
Yet, Foodstuffs is the issue. I dont think so personally, but yeah 😊
@@FrightF Source?
@@popethescope NZ companies office.
And the backwards thinking from this coalition government to scrap the world-leading law to ban smoking for future generations to help pay for tax cuts for the rich! Unbelievable.
I am so damn sick of woke government, go ACT, I'm very happy to see New Zealand back on track.
Why are we asking Chloe for her opinion? No one cares about her or her opinions.
some of those uncles in the comment section right now
Ranting in news comments sections about wokeness is their safe space
Yup, there are lot more of us than you think
Chloe is definitely Green. Green with envy, aye Chloe?
Brooke can't foot it with Chloe who clearly is better informed
Chloe Hates facts > Closing our refinery was madness > Sold out to WEF/BLACKROCK
Utter madness, Blackrock is our enemy. It will control us and strangle us.
And it was national who sold it?
channel infrastructure was/is a publicly traded company
So did you buy shares in channel? did you vote against the refinery shutdown.
NO?
Jog on l o s e r...
Brooke is a weird corporate cyborg. Chloe's a genuine passion person. Great choice in the election NZ.....
Yes. Voters did well. Much more reason for some positivity in NZ now with some sane voices and hopefully pragmatism.
Not out of the woods yet though given the endless bs propaganda by climate change catastrophists, and critical race theory protagonists, like Cloe..
I agree - New Zealand chose well. Good to see we're on common ground.
So true - what is it about uncles at Christmas and their hot takes?
All the uncles are going to be getting an earful this Christmas. I've had a gutsful of their hot takes.
❤ Brooke so professional
You mean blatantly lying?
And painful to listen to when nothing she says has any substance and every sentence she says contradicts the last
Genuinely feel sorry for you that you think that. She's a hollow, empty liar.
Now this ACT MP is in cabinet she think hard before she answers.She has to defend policies she personally disagrees with.
The priority of the government is to do what the people asked.
And only that.
It's called Democracy 🤨
I agree that's democracy, but if that's the case then whatever we have now is not democracy (maybe it's corporatism?), because the priority of the government is to do what their election campaign donors asked; in this case that's largely the real estate industry.
@silenthawkstudios9924 lol your conspiracy theories are cringe.
Gets a bit murky when you vote for policies they campaigned n, and then they change them after coming to power. But that's MMP for you.
Given that we will still be using fossil fuels for some time to come (even based on the Greens wildest forecasts), it is surely better that we extract them in NZ, refine them in NZ and use them in NZ rather than dragging them around the Pacific for our consumption. In addition, we gain the security of our energy supply and we can monitor the industry within NZ rather than accept however they are sourcing the fossil fuels overseas.
Also I note that due to our limited gas production, Huntly was forced to use Coal (imported from Indonesia) last year, it would surely be cleaner and greener to secure our gas supply from NZ than use the imported coal?
It seems we have a lot of positive initiatives coming our way, we just need a bit of positivity injected into our media and perhaps even the Green party and things could go well.
Why "given that we will be using fossil fuels". Why will we when wind and solar can produce the energy for EV or hybrid cars, truck and trains.
@@motherofcatsnz Assuming we install enough wind and solar to meet the demand, we will also need some short term (batteries) and possibly longer term (pumped hydro) energy storage to allow us to keep the lights on during those calm nights. The pumped hydro will take a while to install (see how Snowy River 2 project is going in Aus). So we will need fossil fuel for a while for our electricity. In addition, we will still need fossil fuel for our cars, trucks and tractors (looking at how many older vehicles are still on the road today), we still need to reduce our reliance on the current overseas fossil fuel. Perhaps we aim for 2050 zero fossil fuels??
This legislation is around exploration, not extraction. If you're exploring, you're looking at long time horizons, where we should be carbon neutral by 2050. So either they will be bad investments because we won't use what they explore... Or we do use it and climate change gets even worse than predicted.
@@grahamfowke Anything "we" would get from the fossil fuel exploration would be a tiny percentage of what's there. It's not us exploring the coastlines and ripping up reefs, it's the global fossil fuel corporations like shell and exxon who couldn't give a rat's ass about us. By the time we even get oil or gas we wouldn't even need it, it is atleast a decade away if not more
Correct.
Anyone else playing the coalition "We have to be really clear here" bingo?
Its a case of "we didnt get into power so I'll shit talk the people who did get into power because im salty as hell i didn't get the job". Grow up. You wont win everything in life.
Chloe is obsessed with the sexualization of children. These are conversations for parents and their children. i am glad to see an adult like Brooke in parliament.
Brooke doesn't have her leader's capacity to isolate what she disagrees with when it comes to gender ideology, so that's frustrating.
not sure how safe sex education in high schools is "sexualizing" anyone. You realize sexual abuse can happen in the home right?
No she's not. This is entirely a projection on your part. Seek therapy
Well.... This is not about 'sex education' but gender ideology. Telling our children that gender goes beyond Male and Female.. and the fact that transitioning from male to female or viceversa is normal and encouraging schools to have unisex bathrooms etc etc etc etc etc etc etc. @@FraserM8
I 100% agree with you. Chloe has cero rights to introduce that sh*t to our children. My son and daughter go to school to learn maths, science, history, geography etc but none of that BS..
What a fantastic start! I was worried about the pay rises we could have expected under the FPAs and that we were making it way to difficult for the young ones to get cigarettes.
Finally a government that really looks out for us masochists!
Cringe.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr what's more cringe ya reckon? Paying for tax cuts by letting kids smoke or removing the Australian like industry bargaining system that would have increased our wages in line with the countries we all move to for said higher wages?
I guess this governments not only looking out for masochists but those of us who just can't get enough of that cringe! What a great day for NZ
You know we were supposed to be smokefree by 2025. what actually happened? people still smoke despite rapid price hikes to mitigate it and vaping is more popular than ever especially among vulnerable youths. this has nothing to do with kids smoking, you must vote green because you're high.
@@spaceli0n you raise an excellent point, if we can't achieve a perfect outcome then why try anything at all? It makes far more sense to do nothing and hope for the best then to try anything new. Thank you for your informed comment!
WOW CLEAR THATS DEFF NOT THE WORD ID USE FOR HOW THEY ARE PUTTING DETAILS OUT...... DOES ANYONE ELSE FEEL LIKE THEY TREAT US LIKE IDIOTS!!!!!
Swarbrick is not in the class of Brook
You're right, Chloe is levels above
We don't need Chloe telling us what we want or need. The people have spoken. Ta ta.
I wanted to see Chloe
1:Work for the private sector
2:start a business and be liable for wages and all employees benefits
3: Have children and let them be exposed to sex talks at school.
3s our of the question 😅😅
HA ha ha ha ha
@@chrisselkirk4330Good one Chris, did the other boys in the treehouse high five you and tell you that your joke totally burned that dumb girl...?
Is it weird for you that you have a list of demands for another person's life..? That's objectively weird yo. Besides, just because National leaders look after only themselves in the private sector before getting into politics, doesn't mean everyone has to..
Chloe was one of the co-owners of Olly cafe before she went into politics.
Thank you Uncle.
Chloe we just had 6 years of your lot in power. Roads in disrepair, hospital staff calling out time and time again for help. Record kids not at school. Record ram raids etc etc. Please be quite a lot of work must be done to fix your mess !
Woke Chloe
Thank god Greens didn't get in.
It's been the best year for Greens in their history actually.
@silenthawkstudios9924 that's pretty pathetic.
I think it’s laughable when you close comments on ballhead and senile Winnie stories, and yet open them on intelligent green discussion