I am Circassian from the diaspora in the United States and you have no idea how much it means to me to have a little representation of our culture done accurately. Thank you!
I'm from Slovakia and the term Caucasians defines nations from the Caucasus region. The american definition of caucasian has always confused me so much as it doesn't refer to geographical location. Also, I find peoples from this region so interesting regarding their cultures and physical appearance.
I don't know if you are aware of this or not, but in the 70-ies of the passed century (namly in 1977) There was created coproductional film of soviet Georgean republic and slovakia - ,,Racha, my love" (რაჭა, ჩემო სიყვარულო) Here is the link: th-cam.com/video/S4D41I776jQ/w-d-xo.html
Americans don’t understand the difference between race and ethnicity they just think of your white your white that’s it they are so ignorant North east south and west Europeans all have different ethnicity even though they are majority white the same way Brits are and Irish that’s why Europeans look different to Americans
@Raymond Palmer you dont even have to explain the science, i live in australia and i can tell a white brit from an aussie a mile a way, the same for Americans
Hahahahahahahaha omg that's so true! I can imagine nearly every caucasian who enters the U.S. must be shocked at how many people know about Kavkaz (they don't). Good anecdote!!
I also think it's our government's way of trying to appropriate cultures and history that do not belong to them hence why only here in America we call them caucasians
I am an American in a Caucasian Studies post grad program in Tbilisi. I enjoy the confusion in my own extended family when I tell them I am in Georgia to study the Caucasian culture.
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians «Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.» Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840) . "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303. Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population). Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
@@christian78478 nope, the weirdest explanation ever. Humanity derived from the same ancestors; of course you find groups would have some features that are similar but that doesn’t mean they derived from each one?? You’re looking at it all wrong if you need to input hair/eye/skin/skull into classifying an ethnicity. Even though Europeans and Caucasians are white complexion people; that doesn’t equate them to be under the same umbrella group. That’s the American view.
My wife is from Kabardino-Balkaria. Took her a while to understand that in the US, most people associate Caucasian with white. The whole ethnicity thing gets pretty confusing. She identifies as Kabardian, but many in her hometown prefer the more umbrella term Adyg or Circassian. Anyways, good video.
I am from Georgia and when coming to Canada I was telling people I was Caucasian and was met with hostility telling me I wasn’t because I have dark features and not a “blond blue eye” stereotype. Funny 🤣🤣
@Andy okey only place where u will hear people USE caucasian to mean white is literally America, outside of that, It's only Ethnicity. Caucasian only refers to people from Caucasus mountains.
@@devidevito8315 "Armenians form a distinctive cluster bounded by Europeans, Near Easterners, and the Caucasus populations. More specifically, Armenians are close to (1) Spaniards, Italians, and Romanians from Europe; (2) Lebanese, Jews, Druze, and Cypriots from the Near East; and (3) Georgians and Abkhazians from the Caucasus" This is from a study titled "Genetic evidence for an origin of the Armenians from Bronze Age mixing of multiple populations". Google it.
Wonderful video! I would love to hear more about the people of the Caucasus! As a central European man it is sometimes difficult to learn about the peoples of the edge of our continent.
Europeans and Arabs both go under the term "Caucasian". Why not call whites for Europeans instead? Perhaps white Americans wanted to distance themselves from Europe and didn't want to call themselves Europeans. Afro-American is a well-used term, why not Euro-Americans?
Wow. So much false statements, ignorance, misunderstanding of terminology, and rudeness here! 1) The phenotype of Arabs (a.k.a. Semites) are closely related to the phenotype of Europe, and the both are officially categorized as "Caucasian". 2) The term "Asian" involves such diverse groups of people that it serves little purpose in relation to phenotype, and is therefore mostly used in relation to geography. 3) Race is defined by so much more than just skin color. Not only that, it is in many circumstances a poor determinator for race. I've accepted that ignorant and lesser-knowledgeable people will exist. I'm not gonna mention any names here, but it's sad to watch when they push their false beliefs on to others as fact, and then proceed to tell others to do research. Also, please don't join a serious scientific discussion if you base your arguments on religion. But then again, religion is a statistical precursor for lower intelligence.
that would be the most logical solution, but semantics work in mysterious ways. america couldn't accept the metric system, do you believe it will re-assess its racial identification?
The reality is that the Caucasus = the land of the buffer zone nations. So unlucky to be stuck in-between the big three which are Russia, Turkey and Iran. Today, Armenia is allied with Russia and Iran against Turkey/Azerbaijan which have had there border with Armenia closed for over 20 years. This means 80% of landlocked Armenia is closed off from the world. Azerbaijan is allied with Turkey and somewhat Russia. Georgia hates Russia but tends to get along with everyone else. Some say any further conflict on the part of Azerbaijan against the small Republic of Nagorno Karabakh could throw the entire Caucasus into a major war since it could most likely drag in the big three.
The use of "Caucasian" to describe Americans and Canadians of European decent makes absolute no sense. How did that even happen? I heard it was because of a very ill informed forensic anthropologist that made the term popular.
it came about because europeans(12 tribes), starting in Israel 2500 years ago migrated to europe through the caucasus Mts . Where did you folks come from ? Caucasia. Oh, so your caucasians. and it stuck
You self hating Anglo ..that anthropologist also included North Indians and 'middle eastern people ' in that classification it was never ever an exclusive anglo thing and what are you talking about ??iranians score high on Caucasian DNA where as Anglos don't !!!so why are you stealing an ethnic term when your ancestry DNA results don't reflect that ..Iranians are ethnic Caucasus DNA as are Turkish people ever studied the result of Iranians then compared it to a an Anglo??anglos do NOT cluster anywhere near Caucasus people just be proud of your REAL heritage stop self hating ..and north West Indian DNA is closet to Caucasus DNA hence why dardic ,jats ,pathans and nuristani types score Caucasus DNA something that Anglo Saxons don't and since when do chechens look anywhere close to an English ,German ,Scottish person they don't !!their noses ,cheekbones ,eyes are very different because they are Caucasus mountainous people that do NOT overlap with north euro types and if you mean Caucasoid then that includes A LOT of the world ..stop trying to convince yourself that you are anything like actual Caucasians ..Caucasian countries ;southern Russia ,Armenia ,turkey ,Georgia ,Iran ,Azerbaijan and not surprisingly it those people from those Caucasian countries who score Caucasus DNA Iranians many times score up to 90 % Caucasian DNA I think that's a lot of their ancestry ...
Cassandra Ross You guys are so stupid. There is a big different between white NATIVE Caucasians and modern immigrant nations of Caucasus! Native people of Caucasus are Waynakhs and they are the ancestors of Germanic nations! The Germanic languages also originated from the Waynakh language and even the word "Germana" is Waynakh. During ww2, mongol russians and jew Stalin killed 60% of white natives/Waynakhs, because Stalin said that Waynakhs and Germans are "the same nation" and commended to kill all native people of Caucasus and have their territories to Turkic and Persian immigrants. The roots of the white race are in the mountains of Waynakhs,that's why white people are called Caucasian. At least learn the European history and from where each nation of Europe originated from. The biggest amount of Europeans arent even white and originated from the middle east and north Africa. Germanics originated to Caucasus. Slavic nations are Turkic-iranian tribes,etc...
Very good video Masaman! I've always wondered why Americans used the term Caucasian so incorrectly, when the Caucasians actually are not Europeans nor Middle Easterners. Caucasians are just Caucasians. Thanx for clarifying for those whom did not know this :)
Correct. And there is no such thing as a White Race. As somebody pointed out, when light Skinned Europeans, Americans, etc, get a Tan - Southern Europeans and South Americans , especially - what race do they become? Tannies? :-P I don't think so. The term Caucasian, despite its controversial origins, makes a lot more sense than White...
Arian Ka, The only educated answer on this board. Caucasian is not a color but a BONE STRUCTURE. You other ignorant people need to ask an anthropologist or a forensic scientist.
Thank you so much for this video. I was trying to explain this to someone and you have laid this out so simple and easy to understand. Great video and great job.
Armenians and Georgians are Caucasian. The dividing line between Europe and Asia. Azeris and turks are descendants of Seljuk Turk tribes which originated in Mongolia. They are not true caucasian people. But Turkic people’s. I dont see what the issue is here.
Interesting. I am Ingush and I was curious if you will say something about us and I can learn something. Well, maybe in the next video :). Great job, Mason. Thank you.
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians «Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.» Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840) . "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303. Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population). Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
My girlfriend is Armenian, was over in California for some celebrations and visiting with her family. Her cousins wife and sister were chatting with me and general linguistic stuff and they were saying when they heard Korean it almost sounded like Turkish to them. The Korean guy had a convo with them and I guess suggested that given how the Mongol Empire spread across the word it influenced both of those languages/regions. Pretty neat!
There is a proposed theory called the transeurasia language family that theorizes the Mongolic, Turkic, Koreanic, Japonic, and Tungusic languages originated somewhere on manchuria. There are two branches: Altaic and Japano-Koreanic. I suggest you to go and check it out
Melodically speaking Korean dies sound like Turkish, I don't speak either but having grown up with Turkish people in Germany and being a fan of Korean Drama I can say they sound similar
So good! Love that you included Serj Tonkian too! 🤘🏻🤘🏻 I’m not Caucasian, I’m just white. Real Caucasians and their cultures are far more interesting than my background. 😆
Don't sell yourself short. "White" is just used to make a distinction from terms like Black, which, thankfully has been turned into cultural terms of pride in much of the world, even though these had disparaging origins. Every heritage, whether Caucasian or Indo-European or many others, offer a ton of variety and distinct cultures and ethnicities. I have friends who are Black Americans, West African Americans, Iranian American, Irish American, and so on, and they all have interesting cultures and/or heritages.
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians «Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.» Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840) . "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303.
Monila Ninetynine it's all Fairy tale stories that we like to participate in. just a bunch of people, we definitely have cultural differences but the way we describe ourselves "racially" is obtuse at best
It's true about Russians. You would totally confuse them if you are a North American and you identified yourself as "Caucasian". To Russians the word "Caucasian" (кавказец in Russian) specifically refers to the people that originate in the regions along the Caucasus mountains. We should stop calling ourselves Caucasian when we simply aren't! Also in former USSR the term Caucasian relates specifically to the famous cuisine, dress, and general culture of the region. Shashlyk (shish kebab), Georgian Khachapuri (pizza) and khinkali (dumplings), plus Armenian lavash (flatbread like tortillas) are famous throughout the former USSR and originated in the Caucasus region. Mmmmmmmm Adjara Khachapuri is amazing. It's like a giant boat shaped egg-in-a-basket smothered in Caucasian cheeses and BUTTER!!!! Mmmm
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians «Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.» Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840) . "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303. Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population). Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
Same with the term African American. Most Black Americans are admixed with their ancestors being there as early as the 1400s. There are many Ethnic groups found in the U.S. Such as Mullato, Melugeoun, Creole, Mestizo, there are a few other lesser know mixes like India/Mexican and Chinese/Mexican and Native American/ Black and Native American/ European. These ethnic groups have been around for centuries but they just get lumped in white, black, Hispanic, Asian. Many identify as more than one based off family ancestry and genealogy. Modern boundaries have caused more conflict than resolved. Thanks for sharing these beautiful people and their culture
@@shaffy856 The term Black American isn't any better than African American tho. "Black" mostly means of African descent anyway, but some people might not like it because it's as if your skin color is your entire identity (as if people called you "slanted eyes American" if you're from East Asia). And also, they do need some term for this ethnicity and culture. Like Afro-Carribean does exist, so does Afro-American.
I was born in Finland, so I am a Finn (with Irish and Swedish past relatives, too). Here in the U.S. the government forms used to have a box for "Caucasian", I checked "other" after all Blumenbach, who coined the word "Caucasian" for race specifically excluded Finns and Lapps (Sami). Now I usually see "White", I check that one.
roy staton it's true, although strictly speaking only the Southern Caucasus region is regarded by some as part of Western Asia, and even the only a small part if it
Just as a someone from Africa who becomes a US citizen can't be African-American while the Blacks who have been here since the 1600s are African-Americans!
Iranians are not Caucasian, neither Azerbaijan nor Armenia. Chechnya, Georgia, and surrounding countries are Caucasians, countries to the south are not, so don't lump yourself with them if you're not.
I believe the proper term for the larger "race" meaning is Caucasoid, which was used along with Mongoloid. This is a commonly used naming technique in biological systemics, where a "type" genus is used as the basis for the family name. For example, asters were used as the type genus for the aster family (asteraceae), but that does not mean that all species within the asteraceae are asters, some are sunflowers, daisies, or dandelions. So the use of the term Caucasian is basically a type of synecdoche. So, just as not all Mongoloids are Mongols (some are Japanese, some are Filipino, etc.), not all Caucasoids are Caucasian (Some are Latvian, some are Irish, etc), those two ethnic groups were just considered the "type" ethnicity for their respective races. These are old attempts at classifying human subgroups that may have made sense with the information available at the time, but since that information did not include information on human DNA sequencing, which wasn't mapped until 2003, it may not make that much sense any more.
Talking about Circassians, they (or as they call themselves, Adyghe) were divied into three ethnic groups based on their languages by the Soviet government. These are Adygeans (Republic of Adygea), Kabardian (the Kabardino-Balkar Republic), Cherkess (which is a Russian word for Circassians, in Karachay-Cherkess Republic) and also small people of Shapsugs (near Sochi in Krasnodar Krai). Cherkess and Kabardians speak Kabardino-Cherkess or basically East Circassian, and Adygeans and Shapsugs speak Adygean or West Circassian. But some might say they are dialects of the same language since even native speakers call it the same way, Adyghe. What I'm trying to say it's not reaaly correct to say that all what is left of Circassians are the Adygeans in Adygea. There are more descendants living in Russia.
If you look up the Caucasoid race, it does include people indigenous to Europe, Middle East, Northern Africa, Central Asia, and northern India/Pakistan. This has not changed. The race binds us together, not by skin color, but by skull and bone structure. This my friend is biological anthropology.
My father's family came from the Caucasus region. We had family in Dagestan, Armenia and Georgia! Yes, my family are real Caucasians. In Russia if you use the term it means you are an Asian from Caucasus. Russians do no call themselves Caucasians.
Hey Mason! Do a video on people from Northeast Asia vs Southeast Asia. They are more genetically different than most people think, not only in skin color but also in the teeth (sundadont vs sinodont), the eyes (epicanthic fold type), and ABCC11 gene which is responsible for dry earwax and underarm osmidrosis.
I am quite fascinated with your channel. You present information in such a researched and organized way. I learn a lot every time. Thank you for the work that you put into this.
Racist anthropology.. Ukraine birthplace of indo Europeans language family and none exist there now.. civilization started in frozen mountain of coucuses and migrated to fertile India not the other way round.. no ruins or religious practice or achiological evidence in coucuses vs rich civilization in India Harappa/mahenjodaro .. still such a sham is accepted and studied by all.. such a logical world
I have always found the Vainakhs (Chechens and Ingush) to be a very interesting group of people. They are natives of the Caucasus and linguistically they belong to the Northeast Caucasian or Nakho-Dagestanian language family. They also have a very strong clan system that has helped to preserve their culture over the years as they faced invasions and warred with numerous foreign groups with the Russians being the most recent. Another reason that I am interested in the Vainakhs is because the have the highest percentage of Y-DNA haplogroup J2a among them of any group in the entire world. Pretty much all of the J2a among the Vainakhs is part of the J2a1b-M67 subclade. The Ingush have the most J2a of any group in the world at around 88% overall. Next come the Chechens at around 55% J2a overall. Other Y-DNA haplogroups such as J1, and L3 make up most of the rest of Vainakh Y-DNA. Within the Caucasus genes and language tend to correlate quite strongly with each other and this is mainly due to isolation (mountainous terrain), and genetic drift.
this data is outdated. Chechens actually scores in J2a higher than 55%. All the data is in Chechen DNA project. The reason Ingush scores high in J2a is because they were kinda one of the clans in the past stuck in the mountains with almost no contacts with outer world. It's the same if you take one of the Chechen clans in the mountains, they would show the same results.
Very interesting ! The misuse of the term has always puzzled me! I have travelled to the Caucus region and its a real melting pot as you describe. Thankyou
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians «Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.» Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840) . "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303. Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population). Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
This video makes it clear that when we in the US equate "Caucasian" with "white person" we simply create more confusion. The video does a good job overall in describing who the Caucasians really are. Now if we could only figure out who the "white people" are....but that's much more complicated, and in fact impossible. If we ever did find a consistent way to define a "white person", we should then change the term, since none of us actually has skin which is white (apart for a few albinos perhaps). Thanks for the video. I appreciate your videos even when they contain assumptions that I consider erroneous, or overlook facts that I consider relevant. I regard them as the starting point of a discussion, and as you say in this video, you can later return to clarify points that may have been overlooked.
“White people” derived from Europeans, “whites” are Europeans. That’s it. There is no actual ethnic group that’s called “white”. Before the Europeans went to the “New World” no one on this earth mentioned of any ethnic group called “white”. It is not impossible to defined when it is already there before America came to be.
I really think that to get your point across you should just say northern European Because in the United States, in places, like around where I live, southern Europeans, maybe are not considered white. I actually had somebody tell me that the people in the Caucasians are not even white
Also, I would suggest you find out approximately when and where the mutation for the lighter skin SLC24A5 and SLC45A2 appeared - TLDR, somewhere in the south Caucasus or West Asia in general.
This video is not amazing at all. There are tons of false history information in this video. For example Circassians didn't flee to Ottoman Empire they were exiled by Russians after a 101 year long Russo-Circassian war. What Russians did was a genocide.
@@levishelm426 it’s funny they never talk about it but they always talking about the so called Armenian genocide I guess it’s to do with religion otherwise why would they be so silent for so long once people learn to get out of there religious bias and stop using religion to cause problems then there can be more peace in the world so much double standards justice should be for all or nobody
I have some suggestions -Greeks and Greek genes in Anatolia, the Turkish population trade with Greece in the 1920s -The Celts, their rise and fall and where they are today -Different ethnic groups of Eastern Europe and the balkans -How the Arab invasions in the early Middle Ages effected the genetic and/or cultural makeup of the Middle East -Christianity in the Middle East
Eos Prodromos Hmm, now that I think about it I don't really have much questions specifically, I just want to learn more stuff. Well what country do you live in?
I would like to see a video about Dalmatians like Eric Bana and Stana Katic. Especially the name since it is mostly associated with the dog and how diverse it is. I'm a new subscriber and am sharing them. Thank you for the excellent work.
I've always wondered about this! Thank you for making this. I've always found it strange when asked to fill in my ethnicity, and the only choice for me is, "Caucasian". I've NEVER considered myself Caucasian, but rather German/Irish or American European.
Exactly. If you know your specific heritage, say that. If you don't, even Indo-European American or European American would be more accurate, like you suggested. (European American = European heritage, American citizen, not American European, which would be the opposite.)
You are not really Caucasian 😂 you looks like Iranian people. The North Caucasus was pagans like Vikings. My ADN résultes proves that we are more European than you. 25% Irish, 10% scandinave, 8% baltes, 44% north Caucasus. My famille my is red-headed. We looks more European than 90% Georgian people. Even Tchétchène is more white people than you 🤷🏻♀️
@@НаидаМагомедова-й1д Real caucasus haplogroup is G and georgians are one of the fewest peoples to have the highest amount of G. They are real caucasians than western europeans claim.
@@НаидаМагомедова-й1д Tbilisi as far as I know is a diverse city, it has not only georgians but armenians, turks and azerbaijanis as well. And to be fair, Georgians also have J2 haplogroup, which is what you would consider "south european" like or middle eastern, but I've seen georgians who look pretty white, with blue eyes and all.
Caucasus = derived from Scythian kroy-khasis ("ice-shining, white with snow") But the word Kroy-Khasis ( Caucasus) has some meaning in our language where" kroi " is a vegetable ( with Spiky surfaces) and I'm a Khasi from India. In fact ,as per the pronunciation, the word "CAU" is much similar to "KEW" pronounced as KÉW which means "Wheat". Conclusion.😀
Can you do a full video on the meskhetians/ahiskans? I’ve heard lots of talk that they’re Georgian/Turks or that they’re the descendants of cuman-kipchaks and even Scythians
I've been to Tbilisi, Georgia. Real Caucasians are dark-haired in general with darker complexion than you would think in some regions. The Georgians reminded me of Italians and Turkish mashed up together. That's just my opinion. The Georgian alphabet is amazing and looks like Elvish from LOTR
I'm sure those who looked Turkish were azeri or armenian,or tourists. Georgia is multicultural and georgians in general are non-distinguishable from southern europeans
Please make a video on Kalita community from Assam, India. It's said to be the easternmost Aryan community as we share border with Bhutan, Myanmar. Our people even got blue, green eyes and fair skin. I've researched quite a lot but couldn't find anything.
I remember arguing about using the term Caucasian when I was in school. especially since they classified people from the Caucasus region as being Eastern European... I don't know how it is now a days but presenting facts in school that is contrary to what the paperwork says even if it goes along with what the book says added to the ways i was being classified is a disrupting force in class and being a troublemaker.
During the Soviet Union, schools in the USA were totally ignorant about Caucasus. Considered part of the "USSR Eastern Bloc", like the rest of Eastern Europe. I'm Armenian. It was hurtful because no one knew that Armenia had it's own civilization. It was just a "Soviet State" and that was all that mattered. Nothing else was taught about the region.
No seriously im azerbaijani georgian and its annoying when people say were literally a soviet state....and when americans call themselves caucasian like bro im literally living on top of the caucasus mountains tf?
The etymology and the current meaning of a word are often somewhat divergent. The word "naughty" derives from "naught" and originally meant poor, as in, having nothing in the way of property. Tinfoil hasn't been made out of tin since the discovery of affordable methods for refining aluminum. The word "anime" generally refers to a specific, highly stylized genre of cartoon that originated in Japan, but if you follow the word back to its roots, it literally means "bring to life" (which suggests far more photorealism than anime actually employs). The word "nice" comes from a French word meaning foolish. "Clue" used to mean yarn. "Caucasian" used to mean of or pertaining to the Caucasus -- but that meaning fell out of usage in the nineteenth century.
Гелани Шафи Адыгейцев и Черкесов забыл упомянуть!А насчёт Азербайджана,это как Россиянин или citizen of United States,у нас живут Аварцы,Лезгины,Татары,Талыши,Таты,Турки,Цахуры,Русские,Украинцы,Армяне,Курды и Евреи и все вмести мы Азербайджанцы!
6 ปีที่แล้ว +2
More likely in Anatolia and Middle East, no thanks to back stabbing Chechens and greedy gruze.
Yes right, Kavkaz Kham, Kavkaz Mokh😁Armenians are Kurd/Iranian mix and they came from Mesopotamia. folk music, language and folk clothes are the same as Kurds.
I am from Georgia and it makes really hard to explain where i am from, since when i say i am from caucuses people correct me that it is race not a place.
Being Russian, I was puzzled when I first encountered the word "Caucasian" referring to White people in general. I would call the race "Europeoid" (the other two big races being Negroid and Mongoloid - and these words have NO negative connotations, at least in Russian, just scientific terms). Speaking of "actual Caucasians" (from the Caucasus), unfortunately the first thing that springs to mind is racism. In Russia there's so much bloody racism, especially against Caucasians from the Caucasus, and against people from Central Asia. It's just everywhere. Of course, the actual people are just fine as any other people. I've had many acquaintances from the Caucasus, but never been to the region itself, yet. Thanks for the video)) I'm glad you've brought this thing up, about _real_ Caucasians. -- Mooreuva, ai biliiv dhat speling myst bi rifoomd.
True. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be Russian when I see the racism towards Caucasus. Most Russians are hypocrites as well. The reason most Russians hate Chechens and Dagestanis are not because they are from Caucasus it's because they are Muslims. And Armenians and Ossetians are treated just like Russians because they share the same religion.
@@СергейРоманов-п8ж i find it kinda funny when some russians with third reich symbolic say that hitler would wyped out all caucasians from great russia
It is mostly against Circassians not Caucasians. Just wanted to correct u there. Soviets? Yes. But Russia. Besides Circassians others have their own country. So they cannot directly exercise military power because they are not in their borders.
I'm confused. I have a black and white Siberian Husky with blue eyes!? Is he a "true dog" or a "mut" trying to pass himself off as a "true dog", or possibly a "wolf" in "dog's clothing"? I fear one day he may ask me these questions and I want to be prepared so he will not have a identity crises. Also I named him "Nikita" but when I introduce him to someone they start calling him a she. I put a blue collar on him but even that didn't help. I need help! !! I do ask that answers be respectful. Vlad
You did great!. When I first moved to America and I had to do some jobs about classifying races I couldn't believe that white anglo-saxons were the so called "Caucasians". I thought aloud "Who invented that race?"
The Anatolian branch of the Indo-European Language Family is not "intermediate between Iranian and European language subfamilies". There is fairly wide agreement that the Anatolian branch was the first one to split off from the others, i.e.: Proto-Indo-European ____|_______ | | Anatolian "Nuclear-Indo-European" The Iranian Language Branch, on the other hand, is part of the Indo-Iranian Branch. Armenian and Anatolian are geographically close branches, and they both have animate-inanimate (living-nonliving) gender systems rather than the more common masculine-feminine-neuter gender system of other Early Indo-European languages, but that doesn't necessarily imply a close relation. The current most popular theory of grammatical gender development in PIE says that the animate-inanimate gender system is the original PIE gender system and that the feminine gender was added later to the other, presumably still in contact, branches, via the addition of a suffix. (The remaining animate nouns became the masculine gender.) Thus, this similarity doesn't necessarily speak to a common origin for Anatolian and Armenian, simply to the idea that they both likely don't share a common ancestor with the others. (The 2 (maybe 3) languages of the Tocharian branch, which are often theorized to have been the second break away after Anatolian, were not recorded until the 5th century AD, at which point I believe they completely lacked grammatical gender, at least of the normal Indo-European variety.) Granted, languages do influence each other, and early Indo-European languages almost certainly spent a long time as a dialect continuum, allowing language changes to spread thoughout like waves, before completely separating from each other, but I really have no idea where you're getting these statements about the relative relatedness of different Indo-European Branches, and, given that some of them are clearly wrong, or at least very unusual claims, I don't trust them very much. There is also something called the Centum-Satem distinctionb which divides branches of Proto-Indo-European into 2 groups, but these groupings do not necessarily have common ancestors. PIE had a series of K and G like sounds in the same place as we pronounce the Y in "yes". These sounds moved back to became more K and G like in "Centum" languages and were "lenited" to more hissing-like sounds in the Satem languages. These are both extremely likely changes, so it's not really that surprizing that all branches fall into one of these two categories. The Balto-Slavic and Indo-Iranian languages are Satem. Armenian and Albanian both may be Satem or Satem-like. (Both branches have only one language, or only very closely related languages, so it's difficult to reconstruct their histories.) All the other branches are Centum.
He clearly wasn't talking about the Slavic Macedonians, as he knows they weren't there back then. It might just be that it's not entirely clear whether the "Macedonians" of the mid 1st Millenium BCE were really Greek or not.
@@Mr.Nichan not exactly as "greek" (while the name "greek" (greco) was a roman word to describe the greeks). The ancient greeks where call themselves as "hellenes" (Έλληνες/hellines). Ancient macedonians where describe themselves as "hellines" because they were took part in the olympic games that can go ONLY greeks and not barbarians. The ancient hellenes (greeks) call "barbarians" every non-hellenic speek people. Alexander I (macedonian king) proof to other hellenes (greeks) that they where not barbarians. (Sorry for my English)
Showing pictures of Azeris and then saying they don't look Caucasian is very weird, Azeris are Turkic people, Turks came from Central Asia, so Azeris can not be native Caucasians. Native Caucasians are Georgians (not only) who looks very different from Azeris
Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I AM Caucasian!!!! From North Ossetia and it is very very funny to see how this term is misused here LOL. In central Russia they call us "black asses" coz we have black hair and eyes! This story is very popular among my African-American friends )))
Its the same with Latins ! People from Mexico are not Latins ! they are Indian! Latin people are the white people from europe that their language evo from Latin !
You are totally wrong. The people in the Americas before Europeans came were Asian. Then came the Spanish and of course the largest amount of slaves from Africa came to Brazil. People only think of USA when it comes to slaves but Brazil had more than any other country. So most of the southern and central americans, (so called Latins) are Asian, Spanish, African, or a mix.
Yeah and the Asians crossed the land bridge from Siberia. Didn't need that fact since they are still Asians. Whatever, more information for whoever reads I guess.
"Meskhetian" is not a Turkish dialect. Meskhetia was a Georgian region populated with ethnic Georgians and this region was conquered by the Ottomans couple centuries ago..
Oh man. I love these videos!!!! I went to a Catholic grade school up to 6 grade We had geography courses from 2d grade on. The nuns had us study one country at a time where we would draw its’ boundaries, major rivers, capital and list 5 of it’s top exports. Ever since I have had an appreciation for history and how their economies developed. Total shame that in America we don’t have that anymore in our grade schools- it’s the basis of understanding people, civilizations, cultures and current events. If you doubt that just TH-cam Jimmy Kimmel tv show when they interview random Americans on the street- it’s it’s chilling to see how ignorant we are.
I took world history classes as well as college level AP European history classes in high school in the US just a few years ago, what are you going on about?
They are from the country Georgia - and they use the word in reference to their Mountain Region, also the Iberian - they're believed to be the Predecessors of the Basque (Iberian Peninsula), through theor only similarities in tradition, some words (Basque have the most Ancient pre-European, non-Latin Language). The Basque are the Predecessor lineage of the Irish. This the Georgian, Basque, and Irish - are the same ancient blood, now proven through DNA. These groups are also the Predominant group 80%, of Rh(-). There is also a lineage connection to the original Persians (Iranian today). That's the highlights on my people. Proud to be a hereditary member and prouder to share the exact soul energy - with Y O U and all living humans - and animals I suspect. I'm a Basque-Heorgian-Persian-Irish Caucasian and a white girl. No reflection on my black brothers and sisters, one need only look at me and - it's no secret - I'm Caucasian ☘🇮🇪🇺🇸 And the origin of Caucasians - due to region, rather than simply sk8n color.
Very nice video, however you fell into the trap of some groups who call Iran’s Azarbaijan province as South Azerbaijan.. actually the nation of Azerbaijan didn’t even exist until WW2, and that region which was annexed by Russians from the Turkish-Iranian Ghajar dynasty, was called “Arran”. During the Stalinist period the soviets named the region after the AzArbaijan (notice the capitalized A), the Iranian province with an eye to annexing the region, and even going so far as calling it South AzErbaijan (noticed the capitalized E), slanting the original Iranian name to make it sound more Russian (Azer v Azar). So please don’t fall into this trap again.
Yeah nah, we're circassian for example and there are plenty of us that are blonde and plenty that are dark haired. Some pass as white, some as asian/middle eastern, even in the same community or family (my mother has dark hair and passes as asian, her sister is blond with blue/grey eyes). It is more about some facial features actually. I am circassian, but no white person would call me white, even though i am far more 'caucasian' then europeans would ever be. Tbh the term really just erases our connection to the caucasus mountains. Bc i see people from georgia, dagestan, chechenya etc as my brothers and sisters and would like to use the term to identify with them as the collective of the people from the caucasus, but thanks to the term meaning 'white' i can't.
agreed!! im chechen which means im caucasian, it is sad that everyone thinks caucasian means white. even my history teacher said caucasian means white like wut
@@dollsite yeah, I wouldn't ever identify as white either. We're indigenous to the Caucasus mountains plain and simple. We are indigenous people. If I were to call myself white I'd be told no by white people. But I am Caucasian, the real deal. So are Chechens and Abkhaz and Kabardey. But I've seen most of us labeled as Middle Eastern tbh.
Yup. Surprisingly, South and North Ossetia are delineated by natural barrage of Caucasus mountain, with no possibility to pass through in the past:))) So, by natural water divide range Ossetia (currently, north Ossetia) was delineated from Saachablo/Kartli, belonging to Georgia. That area before Sovietization of Georgia was dominated by Georgians, with some peasants/labor migrated from North Caucasus, including Ossetia. After establishment of Georgian Soviet Republic, an autonomous republic South Ossetia was created by communist rulers. Still that area was dominated by Georgian. In 70s a Rocky pass, engineering structure was built connecting so-called South Ossetia with North North Ossetia that allowed for significant inflow of Ossetians from North Caucasus to Tskhinvali region and entire South Ossetian territory.
South Ossetia is the Republic of South Ossetia. The Georgians never lived in the mountains of South Ossetia, they never controlled those mountain ranges and passes. Historically, Tskhinvali was a most northern Georgian town populated by the Georgian Jews, and further to the north from Tskhinvali were Ossetian mountain gorges uncontrolled by Georgia. The South Ossetians are aborigines of those highlands, whether do you like it or not.
ihsan aydoğdu yeah circassians are the real caucasians but till u write on turkish letters. try to write on your own caucasian alphabet and if you dont have one there are your native caucasian georgian brothers who have 3 kinds of alphabet. use it and respect your caucasian origins. ;)
and also i would be happy if anyone will forget this turkish second names like yours aydogdu, the second names which ends with oglu or something like turkish and use original caucasian second names. :) you are not turk brother you are caucasian and u want it or not you always will be caucasian and act like it
@Clerical Orthodox Fascist well no, thing that mesrop wrote it is a legend with only armenian claims with possibile bias, even if that is true it would only be true for asomtavruli alphabet, yet Georgians dropped asomtavruli for nuskhuri in 11th century and then they dropped nuskhuri for mkhedruli in 15th century, so only one out of our 3 scripts MIGHT come from Mesrop Mashots.
The indigenous, autochthonous peoples of the Caucasus are Georgians, Circassians, Chechens, Ingush and some peoples of Dagestan. And they are the basis of the Caucasian race. Other peoples came to the Caucasus in different periods of time.
It's like Chamel said, my father is Abkhazian and both my mother and paternal grandmother are Arab. My surname tells it all, though. Tabaza is a derived from "Abaza" which refer to Abazinia.
True Caucasians come from the areas around the Caucasus Mountains, which run from the Black Sea to the Caspian Sea. This includes Armenia, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Russia.
giorgi kun I’m from Iran/Armenia, surprised when I first saw I was 90% Caucasian on those Ancestry sites. I had to research and found out that yes, Iran, Armenia, Georgia, South Caspian Russia, were all Caucasian. Never knew that and it’s cool seeing we’re all sort of racially related.
Dont Look Back Twice Of course they’re not, that’s like comparing a Korean person to a Chinese. What I’m saying is that they share the same common ancestors, as in caucasians from the Caucasian region. Basically, they’re all their own kind of Ayran. North India for example, it’s mostly Indians yes? They were invaded by Aryans from Indo-Iran or Indo-Caucasia and basically absolved their culture, and is probably why North Indiana are so much paler. Now, Indian and British people are definently, NO WAY DIRECTLY related, but, they do still share the same common ancestors. A Brit today would be a very very very distant cousin of an North Indian.
I am Circassian from the diaspora in the United States and you have no idea how much it means to me to have a little representation of our culture done accurately. Thank you!
Circassia isnt real nerd
@@dkskcjfjswwwwwws413 Yeah, our country does not exist anymore and many of us are removed from our homeland. That is what a diaspora is.
@@dkskcjfjswwwwwws413 circasian is caucasians indo europeans caucas is eurasiatics aryans
@@dkskcjfjswwwwwws413 you dont know nothing by race even chinese is aryans is about noble peoples not race skinn colour
@@wolfhordes3841 the white aryans were noble that’s why the name stuck silly fat and young.
I'm from Slovakia and the term Caucasians defines nations from the Caucasus region. The american definition of caucasian has always confused me so much as it doesn't refer to geographical location. Also, I find peoples from this region so interesting regarding their cultures and physical appearance.
I don't know if you are aware of this or not, but in the 70-ies of the passed century (namly in 1977) There was created coproductional film of soviet Georgean republic and slovakia - ,,Racha, my love" (რაჭა, ჩემო სიყვარულო) Here is the link:
th-cam.com/video/S4D41I776jQ/w-d-xo.html
Same here, hello from Česko
Americans don’t understand the difference between race and ethnicity they just think of your white your white that’s it they are so ignorant North east south and west Europeans all have different ethnicity even though they are majority white the same way Brits are and Irish that’s why Europeans look different to Americans
I am 1/7 Georgian and 1/7 Russian
@Raymond Palmer you dont even have to explain the science, i live in australia and i can tell a white brit from an aussie a mile a way, the same for Americans
When I first came to USA I was confused with caucasian "term". Being from North Caucasus I was thinking how do they know caucasian people.
Where you from? I'm from Chechnya.
Hahahahahahahaha omg that's so true! I can imagine nearly every caucasian who enters the U.S. must be shocked at how many people know about Kavkaz (they don't). Good anecdote!!
I also think it's our government's way of trying to appropriate cultures and history that do not belong to them hence why only here in America we call them caucasians
🤣🤣🤣
@@Dkthearnactully right term for white people would be caucasoid
I am an American in a Caucasian Studies post grad program in Tbilisi. I enjoy the confusion in my own extended family when I tell them I am in Georgia to study the Caucasian culture.
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians
«Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.»
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840)
. "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303.
Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population).
Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
@@christian78478 yes, I know. I live in Georgia. Tbilisi is very nice.
@@christian78478 nope, the weirdest explanation ever. Humanity derived from the same ancestors; of course you find groups would have some features that are similar but that doesn’t mean they derived from each one?? You’re looking at it all wrong if you need to input hair/eye/skin/skull into classifying an ethnicity. Even though Europeans and Caucasians are white complexion people; that doesn’t equate them to be under the same umbrella group. That’s the American view.
Yes, it can really break the brain of someone who is out of the loop)))))
Hello
My wife is from Kabardino-Balkaria. Took her a while to understand that in the US, most people associate Caucasian with white. The whole ethnicity thing gets pretty confusing. She identifies as Kabardian, but many in her hometown prefer the more umbrella term Adyg or Circassian. Anyways, good video.
It’s because Americans are stupid. I know. I am one. Lol
Caucasian is the term for people of Caucasus region not the race.
Thanks for saying that I'm black I was so lost on this one lol learn something new
Ali Novruzov idiot
I am from Georgia and when coming to Canada I was telling people I was Caucasian and was met with hostility telling me I wasn’t because I have dark features and not a “blond blue eye” stereotype. Funny 🤣🤣
Abkhazia and “South Ossetia” is Georgia! 🇬🇪
@Andy okey only place where u will hear people USE caucasian to mean white is literally America, outside of that, It's only Ethnicity. Caucasian only refers to people from Caucasus mountains.
Caucasians: Ingush, Chechen, Georgian, Circassian, Lezgin, Avar.
it is north in south also azerbaijanis and in north u didnt even said full cechens qaraqaythaks and more
@Ivan Ivanovich Ivanovosky armenians not caucasian people !
Worrapşow Adige
So only the most useless Caucasians are Caucasian? Nice gatekeeping lmao
@@devidevito8315 "Armenians form a distinctive cluster bounded by Europeans, Near Easterners, and the Caucasus populations. More specifically, Armenians are close to (1) Spaniards, Italians, and Romanians from Europe; (2) Lebanese, Jews, Druze, and Cypriots from the Near East; and (3) Georgians and Abkhazians from the Caucasus"
This is from a study titled "Genetic evidence for an origin of the Armenians from Bronze Age mixing of multiple populations". Google it.
Wonderful video!
I would love to hear more about the people of the Caucasus!
As a central European man it is sometimes difficult to learn about the peoples of the edge of our continent.
Europeans and Arabs both go under the term "Caucasian". Why not call whites for Europeans instead? Perhaps white Americans wanted to distance themselves from Europe and didn't want to call themselves Europeans. Afro-American is a well-used term, why not Euro-Americans?
Europe want to distance themselves from American whites too
GridironVideos we Arabs are not white. Asians are closer to white than us
GridironVideos arabs are brown skiin fuck off
Wow. So much false statements, ignorance, misunderstanding of terminology, and rudeness here!
1) The phenotype of Arabs (a.k.a. Semites) are closely related to the phenotype of Europe, and the both are officially categorized as "Caucasian". 2) The term "Asian" involves such diverse groups of people that it serves little purpose in relation to phenotype, and is therefore mostly used in relation to geography. 3) Race is defined by so much more than just skin color. Not only that, it is in many circumstances a poor determinator for race.
I've accepted that ignorant and lesser-knowledgeable people will exist. I'm not gonna mention any names here, but it's sad to watch when they push their false beliefs on to others as fact, and then proceed to tell others to do research. Also, please don't join a serious scientific discussion if you base your arguments on religion.
But then again, religion is a statistical precursor for lower intelligence.
that would be the most logical solution, but semantics work in mysterious ways. america couldn't accept the metric system, do you believe it will re-assess its racial identification?
I agree with you. For me, caucasians are the peoples living in the caucasus and eurasia. The so called "caucasian race" originated in eurasia.
For me, it only means what it actually means.
North Africa too
Roma are you a Caucasian
@This Nigga I am not hindu.
The reality is that the Caucasus = the land of the buffer zone nations. So unlucky to be stuck in-between the big three which are Russia, Turkey and Iran. Today, Armenia is allied with Russia and Iran against Turkey/Azerbaijan which have had there border with Armenia closed for over 20 years. This means 80% of landlocked Armenia is closed off from the world. Azerbaijan is allied with Turkey and somewhat Russia. Georgia hates Russia but tends to get along with everyone else. Some say any further conflict on the part of Azerbaijan against the small Republic of Nagorno Karabakh could throw the entire Caucasus into a major war since it could most likely drag in the big three.
The use of "Caucasian" to describe Americans and Canadians of European decent makes absolute no sense. How did that even happen? I heard it was because of a very ill informed forensic anthropologist that made the term popular.
it came about because europeans(12 tribes), starting in Israel 2500 years ago migrated to europe through the caucasus Mts . Where did you folks come from ? Caucasia. Oh, so your caucasians. and it stuck
Cassandra Ross the answer is here en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circassian_beauties
Brett Rueter you’re really dumb. Semites from the Levant aren’t Europeans, other way around.
You self hating Anglo ..that anthropologist also included North Indians and 'middle eastern people ' in that classification it was never ever an exclusive anglo thing and what are you talking about ??iranians score high on Caucasian DNA where as Anglos don't !!!so why are you stealing an ethnic term when your ancestry DNA results don't reflect that ..Iranians are ethnic Caucasus DNA as are Turkish people ever studied the result of Iranians then compared it to a an Anglo??anglos do NOT cluster anywhere near Caucasus people just be proud of your REAL heritage stop self hating ..and north West Indian DNA is closet to Caucasus DNA hence why dardic ,jats ,pathans and nuristani types score Caucasus DNA something that Anglo Saxons don't and since when do chechens look anywhere close to an English ,German ,Scottish person they don't !!their noses ,cheekbones ,eyes are very different because they are Caucasus mountainous people that do NOT overlap with north euro types and if you mean Caucasoid then that includes A LOT of the world ..stop trying to convince yourself that you are anything like actual Caucasians ..Caucasian countries ;southern Russia ,Armenia ,turkey ,Georgia ,Iran ,Azerbaijan and not surprisingly it those people from those Caucasian countries who score Caucasus DNA Iranians many times score up to 90 % Caucasian DNA I think that's a lot of their ancestry ...
Cassandra Ross You guys are so stupid. There is a big different between white NATIVE Caucasians and modern immigrant nations of Caucasus! Native people of Caucasus are Waynakhs and they are the ancestors of Germanic nations! The Germanic languages also originated from the Waynakh language and even the word "Germana" is Waynakh. During ww2, mongol russians and jew Stalin killed 60% of white natives/Waynakhs, because Stalin said that Waynakhs and Germans are "the same nation" and commended to kill all native people of Caucasus and have their territories to Turkic and Persian immigrants.
The roots of the white race are in the mountains of Waynakhs,that's why white people are called Caucasian.
At least learn the European history and from where each nation of Europe originated from. The biggest amount of Europeans arent even white and originated from the middle east and north Africa. Germanics originated to Caucasus. Slavic nations are Turkic-iranian tribes,etc...
Thank you for this video! I am Caucasian (ingush)☺
Do yo know which tribes from caucasus are closest to you? DNA analysis showed that after chechens, Georgeans are your blood brothers
322 hig что за 😂
@322 hig your whole family is inbreed.....
@@vepkhviajilikhauri6346 Correct, we share a common Genetic though Ingush unlike us received a lot of Turkic Influence from the North.
hello from Georgia, ingush brother❤️
Very good video Masaman! I've always wondered why Americans used the term Caucasian so incorrectly, when the Caucasians actually are not Europeans nor Middle Easterners. Caucasians are just Caucasians. Thanx for clarifying for those whom did not know this :)
Caucasian is not the color of the skin but rather it describes the bone structure of the face and jawline.
737PilotDocSportelloLovesShastaFay it’s definitely not skin idiot.
Correct. And there is no such thing as a White Race. As somebody pointed out, when light Skinned Europeans, Americans, etc, get a Tan - Southern Europeans and South Americans , especially - what race do they become? Tannies? :-P I don't think so. The term Caucasian, despite its controversial origins, makes a lot more sense than White...
Correct
Your named after where you're from..Caucus Mountains. Your color is Red, point blank !!!!
Arian Ka,
The only educated answer on this board.
Caucasian is not a color but a BONE STRUCTURE.
You other ignorant people need to ask an anthropologist or a forensic scientist.
Thank you so much for this video. I was trying to explain this to someone and you have laid this out so simple and easy to understand. Great video and great job.
Listen, as a Caucasian (Georgian) I am literally pissed at how Americans think this word is for every white people
Only in America
Adiga nissa I am from circassian moutian
Armenians and Georgians are Caucasian. The dividing line between Europe and Asia. Azeris and turks are descendants of Seljuk Turk tribes which originated in Mongolia. They are not true caucasian people. But Turkic people’s. I dont see what the issue is here.
Ur an Arab!
@edps cupcake Gerogians r basically Arabs
Omg finally someone mentioned Meskhetian Turks in one of these videos. Thank youuu
Long live Circassia ❤💂♂️
ADYGHE WAY WAY
Worapsow Adige
Adiga WAY WAY
Hello from Real Georgia!
Interesting. I am Ingush and I was curious if you will say something about us and I can learn something. Well, maybe in the next video :). Great job, Mason. Thank you.
Assalam Alaikum, bro.
You are a great man,young man! I'm a 62 year old student of your lessons..Thanks for that.
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians
«Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.»
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840)
. "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303.
Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population).
Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
My girlfriend is Armenian, was over in California for some celebrations and visiting with her family. Her cousins wife and sister were chatting with me and general linguistic stuff and they were saying when they heard Korean it almost sounded like Turkish to them. The Korean guy had a convo with them and I guess suggested that given how the Mongol Empire spread across the word it influenced both of those languages/regions. Pretty neat!
Armenians int’s not Caucasian people!
There is a proposed theory called the transeurasia language family that theorizes the Mongolic, Turkic, Koreanic, Japonic, and Tungusic languages originated somewhere on manchuria. There are two branches: Altaic and Japano-Koreanic. I suggest you to go and check it out
yes cuz turks are mongloid
Melodically speaking Korean dies sound like Turkish, I don't speak either but having grown up with Turkish people in Germany and being a fan of Korean Drama I can say they sound similar
@@miketyson7301 if they are Arab or Oriental Armenians then no they are not but otherwise yes they are
I am Georgian and I am a true Caucasian, as are my brothers Chechens, Innushi, Avars, Lezgins, I live in the mountains and are true wars🇬🇪
Exactly.
Are you saying that we armenians are not real caucasians?
@@mathilds6422 No Armenia is Indo-Europeans, And Caucasians are Georgians, Chechens, Ingush, Dagestanis, Abkhazians, Adygeans, Ossetians
Dude stfu before i throw a fucking history book right in your face
AND WE ARE NOT INDO-EUROPEANS STOP CALLING US THAT
So good! Love that you included Serj Tonkian too! 🤘🏻🤘🏻 I’m not Caucasian, I’m just white. Real Caucasians and their cultures are far more interesting than my background. 😆
Don't sell yourself short. "White" is just used to make a distinction from terms like Black, which, thankfully has been turned into cultural terms of pride in much of the world, even though these had disparaging origins. Every heritage, whether Caucasian or Indo-European or many others, offer a ton of variety and distinct cultures and ethnicities. I have friends who are Black Americans, West African Americans, Iranian American, Irish American, and so on, and they all have interesting cultures and/or heritages.
im real caucasian!! im georgian!! 🇬🇪🇬🇪❤️ ქართველი ვარ და ვამაყობ ამით!! 🇬🇪❤️💪🏻
🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
ყოჩაღ 🇬🇪👍
😂😂😂
აბა რა მეგობარო🥰👍👍
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians
«Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.»
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840)
. "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303.
Caucasian is not the same as white.
legofreak446 Because caucasian is not a race! I don't like people calling iranians caucasian. Just don't!
these people are white
Monila Ninetynine it's all Fairy tale stories that we like to participate in. just a bunch of people, we definitely have cultural differences but the way we describe ourselves "racially" is obtuse at best
What do you mean by "white??" Albino?
Dan Kahraman Very little melanin.
this is becoming one of my favorite channels....good work and ty, seriously.
It's true about Russians. You would totally confuse them if you are a North American and you identified yourself as "Caucasian". To Russians the word "Caucasian" (кавказец in Russian) specifically refers to the people that originate in the regions along the Caucasus mountains. We should stop calling ourselves Caucasian when we simply aren't! Also in former USSR the term Caucasian relates specifically to the famous cuisine, dress, and general culture of the region. Shashlyk (shish kebab), Georgian Khachapuri (pizza) and khinkali (dumplings), plus Armenian lavash (flatbread like tortillas) are famous throughout the former USSR and originated in the Caucasus region. Mmmmmmmm Adjara Khachapuri is amazing. It's like a giant boat shaped egg-in-a-basket smothered in Caucasian cheeses and BUTTER!!!! Mmmm
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians
«Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.»
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840)
. "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303.
Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population).
Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
We aren't Caucasian and I read the shit trying to write in the 1700s
@@Impaled_Onion-thatsmine You are really Caucasians.
Same with the term African American. Most Black Americans are admixed with their ancestors being there as early as the 1400s. There are many Ethnic groups found in the U.S. Such as Mullato, Melugeoun, Creole, Mestizo, there are a few other lesser know mixes like India/Mexican and Chinese/Mexican and Native American/ Black and Native American/ European. These ethnic groups have been around for centuries but they just get lumped in white, black, Hispanic, Asian. Many identify as more than one based off family ancestry and genealogy.
Modern boundaries have caused more conflict than resolved.
Thanks for sharing these beautiful people and their culture
@@shaffy856 The term Black American isn't any better than African American tho. "Black" mostly means of African descent anyway, but some people might not like it because it's as if your skin color is your entire identity (as if people called you "slanted eyes American" if you're from East Asia). And also, they do need some term for this ethnicity and culture. Like Afro-Carribean does exist, so does Afro-American.
I was born in Finland, so I am a Finn (with Irish and Swedish past relatives, too). Here in the U.S. the government forms used to have a box for "Caucasian", I checked "other" after all Blumenbach, who coined the word "Caucasian" for race specifically excluded Finns and Lapps (Sami). Now I usually see "White", I check that one.
I'm told by my European co-workers that in Europe "Caucasian" means west Asian (Iranian) not European. Only in America does it mean "White".
roy staton it's true, although strictly speaking only the Southern Caucasus region is regarded by some as part of Western Asia, and even the only a small part if it
Just as a someone from Africa who becomes a US citizen can't be African-American while the Blacks who have been here since the 1600s are African-Americans!
Iranians are not Caucasian, neither Azerbaijan nor Armenia. Chechnya, Georgia, and surrounding countries are Caucasians, countries to the south are not, so don't lump yourself with them if you're not.
Stormrider Caucasian expert.
iranians are not the only west asians and iranians arent even caucasian wtf
I believe the proper term for the larger "race" meaning is Caucasoid, which was used along with Mongoloid. This is a commonly used naming technique in biological systemics, where a "type" genus is used as the basis for the family name. For example, asters were used as the type genus for the aster family (asteraceae), but that does not mean that all species within the asteraceae are asters, some are sunflowers, daisies, or dandelions. So the use of the term Caucasian is basically a type of synecdoche.
So, just as not all Mongoloids are Mongols (some are Japanese, some are Filipino, etc.), not all Caucasoids are Caucasian (Some are Latvian, some are Irish, etc), those two ethnic groups were just considered the "type" ethnicity for their respective races.
These are old attempts at classifying human subgroups that may have made sense with the information available at the time, but since that information did not include information on human DNA sequencing, which wasn't mapped until 2003, it may not make that much sense any more.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_genus
This explains the concept of using a lower taxonomic term to form the name for the next taxonomic level up.
I really love your channel. It is truly fair, balance, and informative.
Talking about Circassians, they (or as they call themselves, Adyghe) were divied into three ethnic groups based on their languages by the Soviet government. These are Adygeans (Republic of Adygea), Kabardian (the Kabardino-Balkar Republic), Cherkess (which is a Russian word for Circassians, in Karachay-Cherkess Republic) and also small people of Shapsugs (near Sochi in Krasnodar Krai). Cherkess and Kabardians speak Kabardino-Cherkess or basically East Circassian, and Adygeans and Shapsugs speak Adygean or West Circassian. But some might say they are dialects of the same language since even native speakers call it the same way, Adyghe.
What I'm trying to say it's not reaaly correct to say that all what is left of Circassians are the Adygeans in Adygea. There are more descendants living in Russia.
Cherkess is a turkish word, not russian
If you look up the Caucasoid race, it does include people indigenous to Europe, Middle East, Northern Africa, Central Asia, and northern India/Pakistan. This has not changed. The race binds us together, not by skin color, but by skull and bone structure. This my friend is biological anthropology.
Neth M. Koepke
Culture ALWAYS trumps stupid race!💪💪💪
@@Kc2fk
nice try, jew
@mystic1921 A yes African Americans have partial caucasoid blood. Slave mix with master.
@mystic1921 A agreed
@@st4r444 ..... Wrong! Thoae phenotype came frrom africa. Not just east africans. The caucasoid phenotype is in west and central africa.
My father's family came from the Caucasus region. We had family in Dagestan, Armenia and Georgia! Yes, my family are real Caucasians. In Russia if you use the term it means you are an Asian from Caucasus. Russians do no call themselves Caucasians.
well many russians hate Caucusians
Russians are the whites looking people in the world.
Caucasians its not asians
Russians are a mix of people.
@@АльХорезми-в6щ CAUCASUS IS IN ASIA
Hey Mason! Do a video on people from Northeast Asia vs Southeast Asia. They are more genetically different than most people think, not only in skin color but also in the teeth (sundadont vs sinodont), the eyes (epicanthic fold type), and ABCC11 gene which is responsible for dry earwax and underarm osmidrosis.
Very interesting. Thank you for the info
Excellent video hermano. I always learn a lot from you. Appreciate the research, content and simple to follow instruction. 💗
I am quite fascinated with your channel. You present information in such a researched and organized way. I learn a lot every time. Thank you for the work that you put into this.
My ethnicity is Ingush, thanks to the author for his work, I don't think many people in America know where the Caucasus is.
Thumbs up for Serj, regardless of content.
Serge = 💩
I tapped the video because of serj.
Racist anthropology.. Ukraine birthplace of indo Europeans language family and none exist there now.. civilization started in frozen mountain of coucuses and migrated to fertile India not the other way round.. no ruins or religious practice or achiological evidence in coucuses vs rich civilization in India Harappa/mahenjodaro .. still such a sham is accepted and studied by all.. such a logical world
Yanas world Starts = 💩
lol yeah I was actually SURPRISED to see ANYONE other than Kim K.
I have a friend from Armenia and he has a brown skin. He looks more Indian/Arabic and wouldn't be classified as "Caucasian" or "White" in the USA.
I have always found the Vainakhs (Chechens and Ingush) to be a very interesting group of people. They are natives of the Caucasus and linguistically they belong to the Northeast Caucasian or Nakho-Dagestanian language family. They also have a very strong clan system that has helped to preserve their culture over the years as they faced invasions and warred with numerous foreign groups with the Russians being the most recent. Another reason that I am interested in the Vainakhs is because the have the highest percentage of Y-DNA haplogroup J2a among them of any group in the entire world. Pretty much all of the J2a among the Vainakhs is part of the J2a1b-M67 subclade. The Ingush have the most J2a of any group in the world at around 88% overall. Next come the Chechens at around 55% J2a overall. Other Y-DNA haplogroups such as J1, and L3 make up most of the rest of Vainakh Y-DNA. Within the Caucasus genes and language tend to correlate quite strongly with each other and this is mainly due to isolation (mountainous terrain), and genetic drift.
Me being one of them ))))
this data is outdated. Chechens actually scores in J2a higher than 55%. All the data is in Chechen DNA project. The reason Ingush scores high in J2a is because they were kinda one of the clans in the past stuck in the mountains with almost no contacts with outer world. It's the same if you take one of the Chechen clans in the mountains, they would show the same results.
It is good to note, that for example Turkey used kidnapped women from all over Europe for their harem for the Sultans.
I have seen a few of your videos now. They are quite interesting. Thank you for them.
When I was young I was told I was Anglo Saxon. By the time I had to check boxes for race I was Caucasian lol. 🤷🏻♀️
Arabs Indians are also Caucasian
@@ilqar887 Yes mostly.
Right,The north European people are Anglo-saxon
@@jordancarpenter4093 not all but mostly Germanic tribes
@@ilqar887 Arabs and Indians aren’t Caucasian
Can you do a video on Slavic people? I have Slavic ancestry and it would be cool to learn more about it.
I see Serj Tankian, I click on that video.
Very interesting ! The misuse of the term has always puzzled me! I have travelled to the Caucus region and its a real melting pot as you describe. Thankyou
The White race is called "Caucasian race" in the name of Georgians
«Caucasian variety. I have taken the name of this variety from Mount Caucasus, both because its neighborhood, and especially its southern slope, produces the most beautiful race of men, I mean the Georgian; ... The Georgians belong to the most beautiful nations in the world. Everywhere, at any place, there can be seen tall men and slender women with noble faces, attractive features and large beautiful eyes........., Georgians are considered to be among the bravest and the most honest nations in the world; like all other Caucasian nations, they are also hospitable and reliable, as reliable, as their sabers are, and as swift and flexible, as their stallions, courageous in warfare and kind and soft-hearted at their homes. These people produces the most beautiful form of the skull, from which, as from a mean and primeval type, the others diverge... Besides, it is white in color, which we may fairly assume to be the primitive color of mankind and because ... in that region, if anywhere, it seems we ought with the greatest probability to place the autochthones of mankind.»
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840)
. "On the natural varieties of mankind: De generis humani varietate nativa". 1795 AD. P. 303.
Why is the term "Caucasoid" more right, than "Europoid" - because Caucasoid race is not only about skin color. it is about firstly the form of the skull. there are many Caucasoids, who are not European whites, for example North Africans (Berbers, Old Egyptians), Semites (Phoenicians, Assyrians, Arabs, Jews), Sumerians... Caucasus in this sense, is in the middle of this people, in the center, so this is more fair. If anyone wants to separate European whites from other Caucasoids, you can use a word - Aryan or just "white". Only Indo-Europeans and Ibero-Caucasians are Aryans . but despite of the fact, that Semites, North Africans and Dravids are Caucasoid, they are not Aryans (off course in their population, there are Aryans (white Caucasoids), but Only some of them as individuals and not their whole population).
Take a look at Georgians: th-cam.com/video/Ah-8zQYfmEY/w-d-xo.html
@@christian78478 no such thing as A “White Race”. That’s all been programmed to separate wealth from Africans of “Black Race”
This video makes it clear that when we in the US equate "Caucasian" with "white person" we simply create more confusion. The video does a good job overall in describing who the Caucasians really are. Now if we could only figure out who the "white people" are....but that's much more complicated, and in fact impossible. If we ever did find a consistent way to define a "white person", we should then change the term, since none of us actually has skin which is white (apart for a few albinos perhaps).
Thanks for the video. I appreciate your videos even when they contain assumptions that I consider erroneous, or overlook facts that I consider relevant. I regard them as the starting point of a discussion, and as you say in this video, you can later return to clarify points that may have been overlooked.
“White people” derived from Europeans, “whites” are Europeans. That’s it. There is no actual ethnic group that’s called “white”. Before the Europeans went to the “New World” no one on this earth mentioned of any ethnic group called “white”. It is not impossible to defined when it is already there before America came to be.
I really think that to get your point across you should just say northern European
Because in the United States, in places, like around where I live, southern Europeans, maybe are not considered white.
I actually had somebody tell me that the people in the Caucasians are not even white
Also, I would suggest you find out approximately when and where the mutation for the lighter skin SLC24A5 and SLC45A2 appeared - TLDR, somewhere in the south Caucasus or West Asia in general.
As a Circassian who lives in Turkey i can say that the video is amazing
Slm cerkez-adasim :)
This video is not amazing at all. There are tons of false history information in this video. For example Circassians didn't flee to Ottoman Empire they were exiled by Russians after a 101 year long Russo-Circassian war. What Russians did was a genocide.
@@levishelm426 it’s funny they never talk about it but they always talking about the so called Armenian genocide I guess it’s to do with religion otherwise why would they be so silent for so long once people learn to get out of there religious bias and stop using religion to cause problems then there can be more peace in the world so much double standards justice should be for all or nobody
it sucks
I have some suggestions
-Greeks and Greek genes in Anatolia, the Turkish population trade with Greece in the 1920s
-The Celts, their rise and fall and where they are today
-Different ethnic groups of Eastern Europe and the balkans
-How the Arab invasions in the early Middle Ages effected the genetic and/or cultural makeup of the Middle East
-Christianity in the Middle East
Eos Prodromos Hmm, now that I think about it I don't really have much questions specifically, I just want to learn more stuff. Well what country do you live in?
BulletBill110 Also a video on racial IQ differences would be good.
BulletBill110 probably Croatian.
Hoomin Beeing That would be extremely inflammatory.
I would like to see a video about Dalmatians like Eric Bana and Stana Katic. Especially the name since it is mostly associated with the dog and how diverse it is. I'm a new subscriber and am sharing them. Thank you for the excellent work.
I'm a Kist from Georgia 🇬🇪 Salamu Alaykum 👊🏼
Waalikum salam washa.. "kist" is one of Vinakh tribes 👍
I've always wondered about this! Thank you for making this. I've always found it strange when asked to fill in my ethnicity, and the only choice for me is, "Caucasian". I've NEVER considered myself Caucasian, but rather German/Irish or American European.
I'm French Basque Italian European American.
Exactly. If you know your specific heritage, say that. If you don't, even Indo-European American or European American would be more accurate, like you suggested.
(European American = European heritage, American citizen, not American European, which would be the opposite.)
i am georgian and i am real caucasian. 🇬🇪
You are not really Caucasian 😂 you looks like Iranian people. The North Caucasus was pagans like Vikings. My ADN résultes proves that we are more European than you. 25% Irish, 10% scandinave, 8% baltes, 44% north Caucasus. My famille my is red-headed. We looks more European than 90% Georgian people. Even Tchétchène is more white people than you 🤷🏻♀️
@@НаидаМагомедова-й1д Real caucasus haplogroup is G and georgians are one of the fewest peoples to have the highest amount of G. They are real caucasians than western europeans claim.
@@Dinosaur315all Georgians that I see in Tbilisi looks like irans or Arabs!
@@НаидаМагомедова-й1д Tbilisi as far as I know is a diverse city, it has not only georgians but armenians, turks and azerbaijanis as well. And to be fair, Georgians also have J2 haplogroup, which is what you would consider "south european" like or middle eastern, but I've seen georgians who look pretty white, with blue eyes and all.
Caucasus = derived from Scythian kroy-khasis ("ice-shining, white with snow")
But the word Kroy-Khasis ( Caucasus) has some meaning in our language where" kroi " is a vegetable ( with Spiky surfaces) and I'm a Khasi from India.
In fact ,as per the pronunciation, the word "CAU" is much similar to "KEW" pronounced as KÉW which means "Wheat".
Conclusion.😀
When Armenia was the most influential and largest country of Caucasus and the Middle East. There was no Caucasus.
hahaha really learn history
@@nickkharebava5525 go back to mongolia facked tatars
Can you do a full video on the meskhetians/ahiskans? I’ve heard lots of talk that they’re Georgian/Turks or that they’re the descendants of cuman-kipchaks and even Scythians
We’re not georgian, we’re turks, but I’d love s video about it, I feel like barely anyone knows about us
I've been to Tbilisi, Georgia. Real Caucasians are dark-haired in general with darker complexion than you would think in some regions. The Georgians reminded me of Italians and Turkish mashed up together. That's just my opinion. The Georgian alphabet is amazing and looks like Elvish from LOTR
Well majority are dark-haired with darker complexion but it really depends some have light hair and light eyes some don't.
@Pagani Zonda Lmao,Tbilisi is full of arabs.Georgians in general are white as balkan/southern europeans
I'm sure those who looked Turkish were azeri or armenian,or tourists. Georgia is multicultural and georgians in general are non-distinguishable from southern europeans
thats simply not true even in tbilis many people are white looking
There are many turkish ,Arabs and Armenians in Tbilisi. If you want to see real Georgians you must visit Georgian Regions.
Thank you for the great insight and explanation.
Thank you for this video, I am Circassian (Caucasian)! :)
Russia?
Lane Moje Im Meskhetian Turk with roots from North Caucasus. Salam
Lane Moje hi
Are you an Abaza, an Adyghe or an Abkhazian?
Lane Moje hey Jordan Peterson fan
I already watched your videos.i claim this is a educative channel with historical facts. perfection is not however withmuch good facts. thank guy 👍👍👍
Please make a video on Kalita community from Assam, India. It's said to be the easternmost Aryan community as we share border with Bhutan, Myanmar. Our people even got blue, green eyes and fair skin. I've researched quite a lot but couldn't find anything.
It is interesting how in Russia the term "caucasian" has pejorative connotations.
Because of five hundred years of war between Russia, Cossacks and the Adyge, Chechens and Irgush.
They like the Armenians though.
+Georgiy Ukhabin
Not as shit as you've been acting against anyone in the Caucasus for several centuries, particularily Circassians and Georgians.
Nobody in Russia cares about shit that happened 200 years ago. How people act today is more important.
+Lauris
Ofc you zombified idiots don't, but we do. Learn to understand that.
I remember arguing about using the term Caucasian when I was in school. especially since they classified people from the Caucasus region as being Eastern European... I don't know how it is now a days but presenting facts in school that is contrary to what the paperwork says even if it goes along with what the book says added to the ways i was being classified is a disrupting force in class and being a troublemaker.
During the Soviet Union, schools in the USA were totally ignorant about Caucasus. Considered part of the "USSR Eastern Bloc", like the rest of Eastern Europe. I'm Armenian. It was hurtful because no one knew that Armenia had it's own civilization. It was just a "Soviet State" and that was all that mattered. Nothing else was taught about the region.
No seriously im azerbaijani georgian and its annoying when people say were literally a soviet state....and when americans call themselves caucasian like bro im literally living on top of the caucasus mountains tf?
Great amount of research, respect you for that.
The etymology and the current meaning of a word are often somewhat divergent.
The word "naughty" derives from "naught" and originally meant poor, as in, having nothing in the way of property. Tinfoil hasn't been made out of tin since the discovery of affordable methods for refining aluminum. The word "anime" generally refers to a specific, highly stylized genre of cartoon that originated in Japan, but if you follow the word back to its roots, it literally means "bring to life" (which suggests far more photorealism than anime actually employs). The word "nice" comes from a French word meaning foolish. "Clue" used to mean yarn. "Caucasian" used to mean of or pertaining to the Caucasus -- but that meaning fell out of usage in the nineteenth century.
Real Caucasian people in Chechnya, Ingushetia and Georgia.
+Ruslan Tsivadze гамарджоба Биджо
Гелани Шафи Адыгейцев и Черкесов забыл упомянуть!А насчёт Азербайджана,это как Россиянин или citizen of United States,у нас живут Аварцы,Лезгины,Татары,Талыши,Таты,Турки,Цахуры,Русские,Украинцы,Армяне,Курды и Евреи и все вмести мы Азербайджанцы!
More likely in Anatolia and Middle East, no thanks to back stabbing Chechens and greedy gruze.
Yes right, Kavkaz Kham, Kavkaz Mokh😁Armenians are Kurd/Iranian mix and they came from Mesopotamia. folk music, language and folk clothes are the same as Kurds.
Не хрена не надо обесьнять...лично мне похуй как вы себе назавёте...вы только вы ковказы радуйтесь
Make a vidoe on Slavic people?
What?
legofreak446 eastern europe and baltics+Poland
Xtina xox beautiful people compared to you
Freak159753 Also they have done the most as one single ethnic group in the regards of contributing to sciences. Especially to nuclear science.
Freak159753 That is what they tell you. Lol
Once again, a brilliant exposition of an important topic in physical anthropology.
I am from Georgia and it makes really hard to explain where i am from, since when i say i am from caucuses people correct me that it is race not a place.
Ignorance at its highest level
Being Russian, I was puzzled when I first encountered the word "Caucasian" referring to White people in general. I would call the race "Europeoid" (the other two big races being Negroid and Mongoloid - and these words have NO negative connotations, at least in Russian, just scientific terms).
Speaking of "actual Caucasians" (from the Caucasus), unfortunately the first thing that springs to mind is racism. In Russia there's so much bloody racism, especially against Caucasians from the Caucasus, and against people from Central Asia. It's just everywhere. Of course, the actual people are just fine as any other people. I've had many acquaintances from the Caucasus, but never been to the region itself, yet. Thanks for the video)) I'm glad you've brought this thing up, about _real_ Caucasians.
--
Mooreuva, ai biliiv dhat speling myst bi rifoomd.
We're all one human race. Read Acts 17, when Paul spoke to the Athenians.
True. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be Russian when I see the racism towards Caucasus. Most Russians are hypocrites as well. The reason most Russians hate Chechens and Dagestanis are not because they are from Caucasus it's because they are Muslims. And Armenians and Ossetians are treated just like Russians because they share the same religion.
@@СергейРоманов-п8ж
i find it kinda funny when some russians with third reich symbolic say that hitler would wyped out all caucasians from great russia
It is mostly against Circassians not Caucasians. Just wanted to correct u there. Soviets? Yes. But Russia. Besides Circassians others have their own country. So they cannot directly exercise military power because they are not in their borders.
I'm confused. I have a black and white Siberian Husky with blue eyes!? Is he a "true dog" or a "mut" trying to pass himself off as a "true dog", or possibly a "wolf" in "dog's clothing"?
I fear one day he may ask me these questions and I want to be prepared so he will not have a identity crises.
Also I named him "Nikita" but when I introduce him to someone they start calling him a she. I put a blue collar on him but even that didn't help. I need help! !!
I do ask that answers be respectful.
Vlad
I feel your pain, bro
Bear Buster
SHE Who Looks Like He BUT SUPPOSED To Be It. Your dog is from LGBT community.
Eastern Europe is probably the furthest you can go and call people Caucasians.
You did great!. When I first moved to America and I had to do some jobs about classifying races I couldn't believe that white anglo-saxons were the so called "Caucasians". I thought aloud "Who invented that race?"
The real Caucasian:
Circassians
Abkhazians
Georgians
Chechens
Dagestan Peoples
exactly
The Anatolian branch of the Indo-European Language Family is not "intermediate between Iranian and European language subfamilies". There is fairly wide agreement that the Anatolian branch was the first one to split off from the others, i.e.:
Proto-Indo-European
____|_______
| |
Anatolian "Nuclear-Indo-European"
The Iranian Language Branch, on the other hand, is part of the Indo-Iranian Branch.
Armenian and Anatolian are geographically close branches, and they both have animate-inanimate (living-nonliving) gender systems rather than the more common masculine-feminine-neuter gender system of other Early Indo-European languages, but that doesn't necessarily imply a close relation. The current most popular theory of grammatical gender development in PIE says that the animate-inanimate gender system is the original PIE gender system and that the feminine gender was added later to the other, presumably still in contact, branches, via the addition of a suffix. (The remaining animate nouns became the masculine gender.) Thus, this similarity doesn't necessarily speak to a common origin for Anatolian and Armenian, simply to the idea that they both likely don't share a common ancestor with the others.
(The 2 (maybe 3) languages of the Tocharian branch, which are often theorized to have been the second break away after Anatolian, were not recorded until the 5th century AD, at which point I believe they completely lacked grammatical gender, at least of the normal Indo-European variety.)
Granted, languages do influence each other, and early Indo-European languages almost certainly spent a long time as a dialect continuum, allowing language changes to spread thoughout like waves, before completely separating from each other, but I really have no idea where you're getting these statements about the relative relatedness of different Indo-European Branches, and, given that some of them are clearly wrong, or at least very unusual claims, I don't trust them very much.
There is also something called the Centum-Satem distinctionb which divides branches of Proto-Indo-European into 2 groups, but these groupings do not necessarily have common ancestors. PIE had a series of K and G like sounds in the same place as we pronounce the Y in "yes". These sounds moved back to became more K and G like in "Centum" languages and were "lenited" to more hissing-like sounds in the Satem languages. These are both extremely likely changes, so it's not really that surprizing that all branches fall into one of these two categories. The Balto-Slavic and Indo-Iranian languages are Satem. Armenian and Albanian both may be Satem or Satem-like. (Both branches have only one language, or only very closely related languages, so it's difficult to reconstruct their histories.) All the other branches are Centum.
Mason, would you consider making a video about your own background? :)
(or would that sort of thing be a video for patreons only?)
Turkic people are not native to Caucasus like you say in the video, stop spreading lies.
Right, the video is totally inaccurate, to say the least.
you idiot
i am azerbaijani who live in turkey and turkish people is CAUCASIAN
How dare you question masaman!!
Turkish people came from the central asian steppes, they are related to tartars, huns.
"Ancient Greeks and Macedonians"????? Macedonians were-and still are- a Greek tribe.
Nothing to do with fyro"m" and its slavic inhabitants
He clearly wasn't talking about the Slavic Macedonians, as he knows they weren't there back then. It might just be that it's not entirely clear whether the "Macedonians" of the mid 1st Millenium BCE were really Greek or not.
@@Mr.Nichan They were Greek, ancient nations described them as Greeks.
@@krisavapine Did ancient Greeks describe them as Greeks?
@@Mr.Nichan not exactly as "greek" (while the name "greek" (greco) was a roman word to describe the greeks).
The ancient greeks where call themselves as "hellenes" (Έλληνες/hellines).
Ancient macedonians where describe themselves as "hellines" because they were took part in the olympic games that can go ONLY greeks and not barbarians.
The ancient hellenes (greeks) call "barbarians" every non-hellenic speek people.
Alexander I (macedonian king) proof to other hellenes (greeks) that they where not barbarians.
(Sorry for my English)
Showing pictures of Azeris and then saying they don't look Caucasian is very weird, Azeris are Turkic people, Turks came from Central Asia, so Azeris can not be native Caucasians. Native Caucasians are Georgians (not only) who looks very different from Azeris
absolutely
Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I AM Caucasian!!!! From North Ossetia and it is very very funny to see how this term is misused here LOL. In central Russia they call us "black asses" coz we have black hair and eyes! This story is very popular among my African-American friends )))
How could anyone thin that green eyes are ugly??? I think green eyes are the most beautiful eyes ever!!! You are such a cute mix!
🇦🇲🇦🇲 from Armenia ❤️
Its the same with Latins ! People from Mexico are not Latins ! they are Indian! Latin people are the white people from europe that their language evo from Latin !
@Celio Ribeiro More correctly, they're Native American. Indians are the inhabitants of... India!
Mexican is a nationality like American or Canadian. There's different types of Mexicans in Mexico.
You are totally wrong. The people in the Americas before Europeans came were Asian. Then came the Spanish and of course the largest amount of slaves from Africa came to Brazil. People only think of USA when it comes to slaves but Brazil had more than any other country. So most of the southern and central americans, (so called Latins) are Asian, Spanish, African, or a mix.
@@JoeBlack14 Latin America is a mixture of Native Americans of Siberian origin, Europeans and Africans.
Yeah and the Asians crossed the land bridge from Siberia. Didn't need that fact since they are still Asians. Whatever, more information for whoever reads I guess.
"Meskhetian" is not a Turkish dialect. Meskhetia was a Georgian region populated with ethnic Georgians and this region was conquered by the Ottomans couple centuries ago..
Oh man. I love these videos!!!! I went to a Catholic grade school up to 6 grade We had geography courses from 2d grade on. The nuns had us study one country at a time where we would draw its’ boundaries, major rivers, capital and list 5 of it’s top exports. Ever since I have had an appreciation for history and how their economies developed.
Total shame that in America we don’t have that anymore in our grade schools- it’s the basis of understanding people, civilizations, cultures and current events.
If you doubt that just TH-cam Jimmy Kimmel tv show when they interview random Americans on the street- it’s it’s chilling to see how ignorant we are.
As an American I agree with your consensus here. I think Kruchev was right. There going to destroy through our school system.
I took world history classes as well as college level AP European history classes in high school in the US just a few years ago, what are you going on about?
They are from the country Georgia - and they use the word in reference to their Mountain Region, also the Iberian - they're believed to be the Predecessors of the Basque (Iberian Peninsula), through theor only similarities in tradition, some words (Basque have the most Ancient pre-European, non-Latin Language). The Basque are the Predecessor lineage of the Irish.
This the Georgian, Basque, and Irish - are the same ancient blood, now proven through DNA. These groups are also the Predominant group 80%, of Rh(-).
There is also a lineage connection to the original Persians (Iranian today).
That's the highlights on my people. Proud to be a hereditary member and prouder to share the exact soul energy -
with Y O U and all living humans - and animals I suspect.
I'm a Basque-Heorgian-Persian-Irish Caucasian and a white girl.
No reflection on my black brothers and sisters, one need only look at me and - it's no secret - I'm Caucasian ☘🇮🇪🇺🇸
And the origin of Caucasians - due to region, rather than simply sk8n color.
quite interesting
Very nice video, however you fell into the trap of some groups who call Iran’s Azarbaijan province as South Azerbaijan.. actually the nation of Azerbaijan didn’t even exist until WW2, and that region which was annexed by Russians from the Turkish-Iranian Ghajar dynasty, was called “Arran”. During the Stalinist period the soviets named the region after the AzArbaijan (notice the capitalized A), the Iranian province with an eye to annexing the region, and even going so far as calling it South AzErbaijan (noticed the capitalized E), slanting the original Iranian name to make it sound more Russian (Azer v Azar). So please don’t fall into this trap again.
The nation of Azerbaijani Turks has always existed. But yes, like you said, it wasn’t CALLED Azerbaijan until 1918.
Love your videos. What is your educational background? You are brilliant.
Yeah nah, we're circassian for example and there are plenty of us that are blonde and plenty that are dark haired. Some pass as white, some as asian/middle eastern, even in the same community or family (my mother has dark hair and passes as asian, her sister is blond with blue/grey eyes). It is more about some facial features actually.
I am circassian, but no white person would call me white, even though i am far more 'caucasian' then europeans would ever be. Tbh the term really just erases our connection to the caucasus mountains. Bc i see people from georgia, dagestan, chechenya etc as my brothers and sisters and would like to use the term to identify with them as the collective of the people from the caucasus, but thanks to the term meaning 'white' i can't.
agreed!! im chechen which means im caucasian, it is sad that everyone thinks caucasian means white. even my history teacher said caucasian means white like wut
Autumn Trees uhm caucasian is a race we’re not white
@@dollsite yeah, I wouldn't ever identify as white either. We're indigenous to the Caucasus mountains plain and simple. We are indigenous people.
If I were to call myself white I'd be told no by white people. But I am Caucasian, the real deal. So are Chechens and Abkhaz and Kabardey. But I've seen most of us labeled as Middle Eastern tbh.
Ze Jh exactly, we’re caucasians and that’s that
Ze Jh and same if i ever called myself white, white people would disagree
Thanks For Video I Am Georgian (ქართველი)+ south ossetia isn't south ossetia it's kartli's part which took russia ;)
Yup. Surprisingly, South and North Ossetia are delineated by natural barrage of Caucasus mountain, with no possibility to pass through in the past:))) So, by natural water divide range Ossetia (currently, north Ossetia) was delineated from Saachablo/Kartli, belonging to Georgia. That area before Sovietization of Georgia was dominated by Georgians, with some peasants/labor migrated from North Caucasus, including Ossetia. After establishment of Georgian Soviet Republic, an autonomous republic South Ossetia was created by communist rulers. Still that area was dominated by Georgian. In 70s a Rocky pass, engineering structure was built connecting so-called South Ossetia with North North Ossetia that allowed for significant inflow of Ossetians from North Caucasus to Tskhinvali region and entire South Ossetian territory.
South Ossetia is the Republic of South Ossetia. The Georgians never lived in the mountains of South Ossetia, they never controlled those mountain ranges and passes. Historically, Tskhinvali was a most northern Georgian town populated by the Georgian Jews, and further to the north from Tskhinvali were Ossetian mountain gorges uncontrolled by Georgia. The South Ossetians are aborigines of those highlands, whether do you like it or not.
@@friedrichengels2475I am an Ossetian from Tskhinvali, until you talk nonsense, I think you have already believed it 😂
@@K.K648 An Ossetian from Tskhinvali with such an ID "@13Qartveli"? Did Ossetians begin to call themselves Qartveli?
ı am real caucasian :D (adige,şapsığ,kobl)circassian
ihsan aydoğdu yeah circassians are the real caucasians but till u write on turkish letters. try to write on your own caucasian alphabet and if you dont have one there are your native caucasian georgian brothers who have 3 kinds of alphabet. use it and respect your caucasian origins. ;)
and also i would be happy if anyone will forget this turkish second names like yours aydogdu, the second names which ends with oglu or something like turkish and use original caucasian second names. :) you are not turk brother you are caucasian and u want it or not you always will be caucasian and act like it
@@giorgichitaishvili2403 lol the Georgians didn't even invent their own alphabet though.
@@vy7925 we have three alphabets, each different from other, even if one of them was invented by some other peoples, two still remain
@Clerical Orthodox Fascist well no, thing that mesrop wrote it is a legend with only armenian claims with possibile bias, even if that is true it would only be true for asomtavruli alphabet, yet Georgians dropped asomtavruli for nuskhuri in 11th century and then they dropped nuskhuri for mkhedruli in 15th century, so only one out of our 3 scripts MIGHT come from Mesrop Mashots.
The indigenous, autochthonous peoples of the Caucasus are Georgians, Circassians, Chechens, Ingush and some peoples of Dagestan. And they are the basis of the Caucasian race. Other peoples came to the Caucasus in different periods of time.
I'm Jordanian and an Abkhazian descendant.
when did you descendants emigrate?
probably in 1865, when the Circassian genocide happened
by Abkhazian you mean Georgian i guess, which you don't really look alike (no offence) .
It's like Chamel said, my father is Abkhazian and both my mother and paternal grandmother are Arab. My surname tells it all, though. Tabaza is a derived from "Abaza" which refer to Abazinia.
I’m Lebanese and had my dna tested, I’m Canaanite descendant.
True Caucasians come from the areas around the Caucasus Mountains, which run from the Black Sea to the Caspian Sea. This includes Armenia, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Russia.
Im from Slovakia and few people in my life told me that I look like cauccasian.
I like your channel, man!
Abkhazia and "South Ossetia" (samachaglo) are occupied by Russia, they are part of Georgia.
I love Caucasian people.
im caucasian from Georgia,thank you,I love asian peoplw
giorgi kun
I’m from Iran/Armenia, surprised when I first saw I was 90% Caucasian on those Ancestry sites.
I had to research and found out that yes, Iran, Armenia, Georgia, South Caspian Russia, were all Caucasian. Never knew that and it’s cool seeing we’re all sort of racially related.
Dont Look Back Twice Of course they’re not, that’s like comparing a Korean person to a Chinese. What I’m saying is that they share the same common ancestors, as in caucasians from the Caucasian region. Basically, they’re all their own kind of Ayran.
North India for example, it’s mostly Indians yes? They were invaded by Aryans from Indo-Iran or Indo-Caucasia and basically absolved their culture, and is probably why North Indiana are so much paler. Now, Indian and British people are definently, NO WAY DIRECTLY related, but, they do still share the same common ancestors. A Brit today would be a very very very distant cousin of an North Indian.
white people go back to europe, black people go back to africa, mostly referred to sonic takin tark nigeria (not the turf)
@@deeepicgamer5845 // But all those peoole wouldn't be called Caucasian