Why I Ditched the iPad Pro Magic Keyboard…
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ค. 2024
- I compare the best iPad Pro Smart Connector keyboards including Apple's Magic Keyboard, Smart Keyboard Folio, and Logitech's Combo Touch. Discover which offers the best typing experience, portability, versatility, and 'lapability' for the 12.9-inch M2 iPad Pro, and find the keyboard that best suits your needs.
📲 Devices Mentioned
12.9-inch iPad Pro
amzn.to/45nBQ7E
Apple Pencil Paperlike Grip
amzn.to/3OHPYSK
iPad Smart Keyboard Folio
amzn.to/3DXgnac
iPad Magic Keyboard
amzn.to/3OWRIsA
Logitech Combo Touch iPad Pro
amzn.to/44e6Iqe
🛒 Shop Grovemade accessories and get 10% off with promo code: BEARDFM10
grovemade.com/?rfsn=7170715.1...
Join my newsletter: beard.fm/blog
Twitter: / stephenrobles
Threads: threads.net/@stephenrobles
Mastodon: mastodon.social/@stephenrobles
Website: beard.fm
🎧 My Podcasts:
How to Learn with Stephen Robles: howtolearn.transistor.fm
Movies on the Side: www.moviesontheside.com
AppleInsider Podcast: appleinsider.com/podcast/appl...
HomeKit Insider: appleinsider.com/podcast/home...
Chapters
00:00 Introduction
00:30 Smart Keyboard Folio Review
03:26 iPad Magic Keyboard Review
06:30 Logitech Combo Touch Review
09:44 iPad Keyboard Conclusion
My Gear:
🛒 Earthworks Ethos Microphone: amzn.to/35hIh2h
🛒 Sony A7 IV Camera: amzn.to/3fZcp4S
🛒 Sigma 24-70mm F2.8 for Sony E-Mount: amzn.to/3qWe0yt
🛒 Earthworks Icon Microphone: amzn.to/3KLYLjq
🛒 Shure SM7B Vocal Microphone: amzn.to/3DzZe3n
🛒 Elgato Key Light Air: amzn.to/3EvNb8T
🛒 Sony a6400 Camera: amzn.to/3GlVqog
🛒 Sigma 16mm 1.4 Lens for Sony E Mount: amzn.to/3DxqyiK
🛒 ATEM Mini Pro: amzn.to/3dHfcyx
🛒 Sound Devices MixPre-3: amzn.to/3doT3EO
🛒 LG UltraFine 4K Monitor: amzn.to/301DMH5 - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
For anyone thinking about the Logi Combo Touch, especially for the larger 12.9” iPad Pro, within a single year the one I purchased has become stretched and loose around the speakers (where the material is thinner by design) and one corner - top left where the 3 primary control buttons are located.
This means I need to slip the corner onto the case before switching on or off or changing the volume using the case buttons. This is quite annoying but, OK, defo a 1st-world problem. Sadly it also reduces the protection levels of the case significantly, one of the reasons I went for this in the first place. I’m aware there are alternatives to using the case buttons but I am disappointed with the overall lack of quality and resilience of the case.
This is almost certainly less of an issue with smaller cases for the smaller iPad Pro but should be considered as a factor when buying for the 12.9”. Otherwise it’s a good case/keyboard combo for my use-case in most other aspects.
try heating the area with a hairdryer
they actually fixed it, I had gotten 4 replacements from Logitech with the same results then they said I wasn't eligible for any more replacements. so I called back and got a different person and they sent me another and I've not had any issues. even after removing my iPad multiple times. it holds its shape. I did end up getting a Magic Keyboard from amazon it was renewed $130, its great for using it on a desk or your lap but the Logitech is more versatile, has more function keys, and more angles
@@reycaribe may give that a go, cheers
Thanks a million! Just dodged a bullet today.
On the Logitech keyboard, if you remove and re-attach the keyboard backwards, you can then fold it back on itself. This trick also provides a more stable surface to prop the stand on when using narrow airplane seat back trays.
Didn’t even try that! Good tip!
I was gonna tell him the same thing but you beat me to it lol
@@dannggg Me too
Thank you for this video, helped me decide for my future iPad :)
THANK YOU so much for your review. "Lap-ability" is a term I hadn't heard of before your video, but is exactly what I'm looking for as I prepare to travel for an upcoming conference where I'll be looking to use my iPad for taking notes during the event. I appreciate your thoroughness and transparency in your review process and you definitely earned my subscription.
Super thorough, descriptive, and thoughtful rating, thanks!
Glad you enjoyed it!
This was the information I needed to make a decision today for me. Awesome summary. You didn't say what is best, but clearly explained what is best in which ways. Thank you!
Glad it was helpful!
I used the combo touch and the Magic Keyboard. I felt the combo touch gave my iPad better protection for portability and you can flip the keyboard around and hook it to the back of the iPad in tablet mode. Magic Keyboard was a little heavy to be portable but great for a desk set up for computer replacement.
I did like the protection of the Logitech for sure!
Thank you so much for explaining the differences. It’s quite clear now which one I’ll buy. You’re awesome. Have a great year from Australia 🇦🇺 🎉
Appreciate that, and thanks for watching!
Thank you for this comprehensive review. It was well presented and extremely helpful! Tyvm
Appreciate it! And will do an updated video if we get new keyboards in March!
I have both the Magic Keyboard and Combo Touch for my iPad Air. My significant other ended up getting the same iPad, so I gave the Logitech one to her and she quite likes it, while I’m in line with you on the lapability aspect. I use my iPad to type a lot more than she does, so I prefer the lapability of the Magic Keyboard while she prefers the ability to detect the keyboard when she doesn’t need it and still have a protective case. Works out pretty well.
I did like the Combo Touch detachable keyboard, for sure
@@beardfm yeah it’s cool how you can flip it around too if you attach the keyboard backwards. My sister has the 2018 Pro I think that you mentioned in this video and has the combo touch as well, and had good things to say about it but also doesn’t like the lack of lapability.
Great review and attention to detail with an authentic take on the options presented 👏🏽💪🏽
I appreciate that!
What a brilliant review. Covering all the use cases that one can think of. And well made also. Thumbs up.
Much appreciated!
Magic Keyboard is… worth it when it’s on sale. Totally agree on the portability. Gotta check out the Combo Touch.
And I noticed it’s on sale on Amazon!
Great video , cleared all my doubts
Interesting video! I went the opposite way with my M1 iPad Pro 12.9”. My Logitech Combo Touch keyboard (not the folio), a lot of the keys wore down and the letters were missing. The sides formed loops around the buttons and were bending away. Finally, as the keys were getting unresponsive and no longer were working in some instances. I had to angle it a certain way (re-discoverable every circumstance) for it to work. So now I have a brand new Apple Magic Keyboard! I’m loving it! I wish I had got it the same time when the iPad Pro was brand new, but I did love my Logitech Combo Touch keyboard while it was working. I don’t miss the function keys by the way. I think the Logitech Combo Touch keyboard is actually heavier than the Apple Magic Keyboard.
Magic Keyboard is still a great option, and simply the best for actually typing!
Appreciate the video and information. Thank you!
You're welcome!
You can clip the keyboard to the back of the case. Also if you turn the keyboard around you can have triangle configuration which makes it more stable on your lap
You can type on screen/tablet mode even with the Magic Keyboard attached. There is an icon in the lower right corner of the iPad that you can select when you put your cursor in the address bar.
I’m on my second Logitech keyboard. I loved the slim combo that I use(d) on my iPad 2nd gen & it didn’t weigh nearly as much as my current Combo touch but the slim wasn’t available for the iPad M2 Pro. It sticks out a lot more than the slim combo which could fold back on itself. I never type on my lap so that’s not an issue for me. I DO use the extra function keys though & they’re invaluable. I can easily turn the iPad on & off, mute & adjust volume. It has backlit keys & some other functions that I haven’t explored as I haven’t needed them. My husband has the Apple Smart Keyboard & likes it for his iPad Air 2020.
Those functions keys are *very* nice to have...maybe a Magic Keyboard Gen 2 will add them...
@@beardfm that would make me consider it.
I’m an architecture student. I have a dedicated ‘work horse’ ASUS laptop for CAD and renders. It was KILLING my back tho, especially on days where I only have discussion-based classes that only require note-taking, maybe some sketching, and PowerPoint presentations. I bought an iPad Air to handle those “lighter” tasks for which the ASUS is just overkill. I’m gonna go with the Magic Keyboard only because I commute to school and stay typing up papers on the train. That lapability aspect is major for me
If you're using it as a laptop replacement in certain scenarios, the Magic Keyboard is a great choice!
Great review, thank you!
Glad it was helpful!
Ok, so the Smart Folio came in and I was excited. But after a few weeks, I’m going back to the Magic Keyboard. The TRACKPAD, PASS-THROUGH charging, FEEL OF THE KEYS & the ELEGANT LOOK of the damn thing makes it perfect for me. But your video made me try the Folio and so I’m going to keep it-when I want to go LIGHTER and still have most of the functionality of the Magic Keyboard, with the option to fold it back for writing with the Apple Pencil, I’ll just put the iPad in the Folio. Thanks again, sir!
I'm using the M1 iPad Pro for my main tablet and using with the smart keyboard folio. However these days I'm thinking again to change to the magic keyboard or just use the smart keyboard folio. Because of the magic keyboard's better durability.
Few weeks ago I slipped down at a slippery stairs. At the same time I was wearing a backpack inside there was my M1 iPad Pro with the smart keyboard folio attached. Unfortunately that made my M1 iPad Pro bent in a curve shape. Thankfully the screen was fine so I mostly bend in back to it's original shape, however it makes me think "Should I go back to the magic keyboard? Even though it will be more heavy and has a poor versatility". Also sometimes I miss the magic keyboard's cool features
like the trackpad and a second USB-C port.
Personally I take my iPad Pro in a backpack and use it outside very often.
I use my M1 iPad Pro for luma fusion video editing, draw with the Apple Pencil using Procreate app a little bit, watch TH-cam everyday and play Genshin Impact game very often.
So that's why I'm having a hard time thinking about changing my iPad Pro's keyboard or not.
On the magic keyboard, atleast on TH-cam anyways, you can play/pause with the space button, and skip fward/back or rewind/fast foward using the left arrow/right arrow
I have the Logitech Combo Touch. Very good to type on, and I can detach it when I want to use it in tablet mode. The problem is, after a long period of time, the rubber protection around the iPad started to peeled off. It becomes difficult to attach the keyboard because the peeled rubber gets in the way. And also, I lost my apple pencil because the peeled rubber case “pushed” my Apple pencil from the iPad.
thanks for the review
You’re welcome!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts 😊
Thanks for watching!
i have the logitech combo touch and i love it
yes when it comes to lap ability its bad but u can detach it and flip it then attach it again, this way you can have it stay behind the ipad
also it can be great on a lap when you have no plan to use the keyboard that way
Keyboard folio for me, great video, thanks
Shame they didn’t make a new model for new iPads
I've been using the Combo Touch for years and I can't imagine using any other keyboard. However, I've seen many great Magic Keyboard alternatives for way less than $350.00 and I'm always tempted to buy one but having an unprotected iPad is a no-go.
I know some of them offer super thin cases that work with those kind of keyboard but once you're use to having complete protection, it's hard to have anything less.
Recently got my wife the Combo and she loves it too!
You can flip the Logitech keyboard to the back… Just take it off, flip it 180, re-attach and turn it on the backside
I am looming for a keyboard for my iPad Pro 11” M1, I have a thick leather case on it I’ve been using, but am fed up with the onscreen keyboard, and I want something thin and light, so may just get the cheaper Apple Smart Keyboard folio. I appreciate not having to worry about grime getting under those keys either and it looks like it’s easy to clean. Shame it’s not backlit though.
I do miss the backlight at times but overall it’s served me well!
Solid case for the folio….I own 3 other cases and I always come back to the Magic Keyboard lol.
If the combo touch was more lapable - it would easily win.
I would stick with if it had better lap-ability for sure.
I like just holding the iPad Pro with no case, i like the logi, but dont like having the case on it all the time. I have a M2 iPad Pro 11”, and found a magic keyboard with leather Dbrand Skin on it on facebook for $100 and i love it, only thing it needs is funtion keys, which may come in the next gen update. I DO hate the material the magic keyboard is made of, it always feels dirty/gritty. So i was so happy when i found the one on Facebook with skin
fourth option: use the separate magic keyboard and a really good case.
i find the smart keyboar folio tiring to type. You really need to depress the keys and there is resistance. i have pain issues and my hands will be throbbing.
Then with the 9th gen ipad there is the rugged model that is easier to type. btw- the smart folio can be flipped upside down for a third angle for sketching.
if anyone experiences delayed key typing causing letters to be missed on any ieyboard, you need to take off "sticky keys" and "slow keys" in accessibility features i think. a recent update seemed to turn on all these settings.
magic key board has no ipad protection for the tablet alone which is a deal breaker. magic keyboard typing is not as good as the imac magic keyboard that can be used if you choose "forget device" on your imac. An extra step for the top typing experience; otherwise you need to buy another case to use the tablet by itself. i find it easier to even use the screen keyboard in a pinch and like having my pen always attached and ready. i use the bogo case? or bugu? something like that.
winner for me: logitech combo touch that feels the most premium, or carrying your keyboard with you from the imac in a sleeve and mostly using just a plain keyboard. i cringe to spend $300 for a keyboard though.
what case are you using currently?
I had the apple folio for a long time and can agree. It's tiering to type on that. It's only good if you use it as a slim and light "case" out of which you can just grap your iPad from and only occasionally type on it. Also it's "dirt proof" since it has no openings. So when you are eating and watching something or using it to look up recipe while in the kitchen you don't have to worry about cleaning the keyboard after.
I had a meeting a few days ago and I just used a cheap case from amazon for the iPad and a magic keyboard I had from when I switched to one with touch ID. worked great. But you always need 2 things - the iPad in it's case and the keyboard in it's case or bag, also you have to charge the iPad and the keyboard, so there is a chance that you arrive at a meeting and your keyboard is out of juice. With the Logitech or Apple solution you have all in one.
I am currently testing the Logitech combo and it's okay, but it was 160 Euro. It's great for typing if you have a large surface like a table. If you are for example in bed you need a large tray to be able to fit the tablet and the keyboard.
Thanks for the great video. I haven’t had an iPad since the 2nd generation dinosaur and didn’t really want to wade through 10+ years for a comprehensive breakdown of accessories
You're welcome! And not sure if you bought one recently, but new models are rumored to launch in March (next month!)
I agreee. It’s way too heavy. Got the Logitech keyboard with the trackpad combo. Logitech magic touch pro. So much lighter and better. Ditch these heavy cases slash keyboards. I’m loving that combo touch. So much better and the key feel is amazing and clicky plus the backlit is amazing feature. I will be rocking it it on every iPad
Great review thanks and it cleared up some points for me, but not all. I have the 12.9 M2 iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard and the keyboard has some annoying drawbacks: No media keys is annoying (fumbling to turn down the volume is frustrating, likewise fast forward, etc); the Shift key on the keyboard I bought in Australia is not like the one in your video. It is only threequarter size to allow for the squeezing in of a tilde key. This is very annoying if you 10-finger type because your weakest finger (the smallest one on your left hand) easily mis-hits the key and you end up with a tilde or reverse single quote mark instead of a capital). Also, the Caps Lock key has to be hit in EXACTLY the right spot or it doesn't turn on/off. And one of the worst things for me is that the keyboard backlight only comes on when you are typing in very dark overhead light. This makes it pretty useless for anyone who doesn't spend a lot of time on an aeroplane when they have turned the cabin lights off. (I had a cheap Zagg Folio (?) keyboard on a previous iPad and you could turn the lights on/off at will. I realise that backlights are a power problem but the Zagg had two CR2032 button batteries that gave the keyboard power.) The Smart Keyboard Folio loses out for me because of no trackpad or media keys. And the Logitech Combo Touch loses out because of the 'lapability' problem and, I presume, the backlight keyboard problem -- unless there IS some way of turning it on and off at will. Does anyone know the answer to this? Many thanks.
To be fair, I don’t think the perfect keyboard exists yet. Brydge keyboards came close but they went out of business.
Hay sir, can u review ipad 10th gen, magic keyboard folio and apple usb-c for me?
Great video, sadly I have the 10.5-inch iPad Pro 2nd Generation which appears it is hard to find a keyboard for it. Which keyboard would you recommend for my model of iPad?
Thanks! And that’s tough with the age of the device. I don’t have a specific recommendation off hand but maybe see if there are Logitech options on Amazon for that size
Awesome! Thanks
You bet!
Excellent video!
Thank you very much!
I wish someone would design a thin keyboard like the Smart Keyboard Folio but incorporate a function key row (even if nothing more than the typical blue “fn” key in conjunction with the number keys at top, still lots of legacy systems that use these for IT Professionals) and a track pad. How would a track pad possibly be implemented in such a folio case? A fold over cover flap clasp (not sure that the correct name). But whatever the flap is called, it would fold over and attach to the back magnetically when “closed”, also protecting the expensive Apple Pencil from accidentally getting lost (just lost my 3rd one! Freaking annoying!). When in open/keyboard mode, the fold over flap now in open mode lays flat on the desk in front of the keyboard providing a place to rest your wrists w touch trackpad in between! The design could be adjusted to be wide enough for wrist area or just enough to provide area for the trackpad (tho I’d prefer full width of the case for wrist rests & comfort). The engineering challenge would be to ensure the flap lays perfectly flat when in open/keyboard mode *and* that the connector/ribbon cable hidden inside the flap is robust enough to not develop shorts after years of the flap being folded over the pencil area of the iPad whether a pencil is present or not. There could also be very small rubber “guides” that the flap fits between when folded over, which act as non-slip feet and a very slight elevator when the case is fully open! The back would also be designed to allow mag safe charging if truly incl in next iPads! Claiming my idea if such a thing is possible! ;-)
thank you, no one talsks about if they bend back or not in their reviews and i want it for drawing mostly so thats a biggy for me :D
I dont like the extra weight the logi case adds, you can definetly feel it vs with no case
Brydge Max+ is great as well.
Thanks for the detailed video, do you worry about losing the Apple Pencil since it’s only magnetically attached to the iPad?
I’ve never lost once since using this style from 2018, but I do wish they put a U1 chip or something for Find My in the Pencil
Miss the Smart Keyboard for the new M4 iPad Pros
Sorry but you are wrong about not being able to put Logitech Combo Keyboard on the back of the iPad and use the Ipad as an ipad only with the keyboard still attached. All you need to do is invert with the key facing inwards, keys touching the back of the case and it works perfectly
great review!, I think I would go with Smart Folio + Magic Track Pad (separate).. 🙄
That's a good combo too!
@@beardfm Thanks.. coz the Magic Trackpad I already have it.. 🙏🏻😁
3:40 The price is 299 on Apple. Still this channel has THE best reviews on You Tube. Fantastic job. LOVE your videos.
Wow, appreciate that 🙏🏼 thanks for watching!
That depends on which size the ipad is. standard is 299 meanwhile the 12.9 that he has is 349 😊
Great video. I really want the Magic Keyboard but it’s just too expensive (three kids and it’s Christmas). Did look at a refurbished one but think Smart Folio could be the way forward for me. I need the typing experience and can live without the touchpad. Really helpful video with very valid points.
I’ve been happy with the folio the past few months. Probably good used deals out there too!
I've been using the Logitech Combo Touch for about 4 months now. The main issue I have with it is that when you write on the screen with the Apple Pencil, the screen ripples. It makes me worry that it's damaging the screen but when I reached out the company, they said it was fine... I even got a replacement to see if it was a fluke and I had the same issue with the replacement. I'm debating just getting the Magic Keyboard because of it...
Yeah I don’t like a rippling screen. Magic Keyboard is still great, although rumors are new iPads and accessories in March so maybe hold off until then!
What is the actual model number of the Logitech Combo Touch? The Amazon link shows pictures of older version with speaker slots instead of holes and plus and minus buttons.
Not sure where to find that, but this is the item I bought on Amazon: amzn.to/45m4K8t
Satechi has an iPad stand that you can place. It looks like a mini iMac. And I bought their keyboard and got a Magic Trackpad. I think for home use it would be better than all these keyboards. Traveling though you know you already own one of Apple’s iPad keyboards so just take that when you travel Panay from home
I’ve been eyeing that Satechi one…
I have a question about the track pad. On all my laptops, I disable the track pad and use a mouse, as my hands hit the track pad when typing and it causes problems. Can you disable the track pad? Can you use a Bluetooth mouse with the iPad? I have an older generation 2 iPad (very old). All I do with it is watch movies or videos when I travel, along with answering some emails. I use a Brydge keyboard now, but it tends to drop a few characters when typing.
There is not a disable tracking feature, but you could go with the Keyboard folio that doesn’t have a trackpad, and connect a Bluetooth mouse! The folio won’t work with the iPad 2 unfortunately, but you could go with an iPad Air
@@beardfm My iPad is so old, but it works. The iPad air would be a downgrade size-wise. I'd go with the pro if I replace it. I don't really have a need for a mouse, I guess, as I mainly use it for movies/videos/TV.
I wonder if someone could 3d print an attachment to help the combo touch be lapable.
It could just print a Keyboard Folio 😏
I have found tht the folio has a limited lifespan. The reduced weight comes with a reduction in the quality of the build. The big problem is that because detaching/reattaching the keyboard over time was hard on the connection eventually causing the keyboard to fail. Went through a couple keyboards over the period I used it. Love the magic keyboard in spite of the price.
Really? I used the Folio for a solid two years, but rarely removed it from the case. I’ll keep an eye on its reliability going forward.
@@beardfm It wasn't taking it out of the case but rather removing the keyboard. Unlike you it felt weird to keep the keyboard attached when I was using it as a tablet. Over time I found that connection to wear to the point where the keyboard function was impaired.
Yeah I had the same problem with the Apple Smart Folio keyboard… at first it was great, no issues for a year, then all of a sudden it just stopped working and couldn’t connect to my iPad.. I was really bummed about it, I just leave it in my storage because I’ve tried cleaning it, restarting my iPad, and searched up various ways to get it to work and function again, but it just didn’t seem to connect properly. Unfortunately, the only keyboards I will be looking forward to from now on are the Magic Keyboard and the Logitech keyboards.
Solid review . And I don’t say that much 🎉
Appreciate it!
I just returned the Magic Keyboard. My first instinct was to open all the way so I could use it in full tablet mode. I was surprised it didn’t do that
Yeah that’s unfortunate
the issue, is that it wouldn't be stable at a steeper angle.
I returned mine for the same reason
Will the Logitech keyboard or the folio charge my iPad Pro 11 like the Magic Keyboard will? My iPad won't charge via the USB-C charging port but will when on a Magic Keyboard. They're just so expensive so I'm looking for a less expensive alternative. TIA!
Neither of those keyboards have their own usb c port. Only the Magic Keyboard
best video on portability
Thanks!
The Combo Touch has some quality issues. The thinner rubber linings where the apple pencil and the speakers are tend to expand and warp out of shape. it seems that it doesn’t deal well with the heat the machine produces and kinda expands ever so slightly over time until it derails
Oh, that's not good. I *can* say the Folio holds up over time in my experience.
I had to replace it 3 times and finally just gave it up when the warranty ran out.
Update:
They made Version 2. Everything looks the same except that there’s more support at the weak spots. I couldn’t stand the warped one that I had and purchased the new one. Seems to be holding up well
@@gamux5 I had purchased the latest version and instead of warping or stretching, it cracked, so I have given up on these.
@@frogger2020 🥲
9:39 so weird I’ve used ams surface for years and never had a problem with using it on my lap. Granted not ideal but definitely doable. And in fact I’d argue in a more lounge or couch position it is definitely a better option (any time your lap is not completely horizontal let’s say)
I love my Logitech keyboard. I think you underrate the value of the Logitech function keys, otherwise your reviews are pretty thorough, thanks 😊
This is the 5th or so time I’ve watched this video. I just ordered the Folio. I will enjoy the slimness!
Nice! Glad you like it
I have a logitech and love it. I also think it works great on my lap, but that's just me. The iPad appears to bounce when they are typing on their lap. I think that would automatically remove it from my list of considerations.
With the Logitech combo you flip the keyboard around if you want it on the back and the keys are facing into the iPad, you don’t fold it over 😂🤣😂
I own an iPad Pro 11” M2 with a magic keyboard… and I love ot! It’s expensive but it’s a high quality premium keyboard….. an Apple!
It’s a great keyboard, no doubt
I have both, magic keyboard is still the best. Logitech folio has an issue with build quality of the rubber. And it takes so much space. Magic Keybaord 9/10 Lopgitech Combo 7/10
Damn, I really love the Folio due to the lightness and ability to effortlessly convert it to a tablet form by just flipping it around but the lack of track pad kills it for me.
At the same time the magic keyboard doesn't have that
The Logitech on paper is my best option here but i also just dont like the look of it 💀
I have the air 5 and the fact I cant use touch id with the combo touch makes it a deal breaker for me
Oh wow didn’t even think of that. Yeah would not use
Is the 4th generations folio keyboard working with the 6 th gen ?
If you get the same size iPad respectively it should work fine!
Thnx man!
Is there anew one coming out soon from apple?
Doesn't look like anything else is coming this fall. Hopefully early next year!
Glad I watched this. The Magic Keyboard doesn't let me use my iPad in IPAD MODE?? What?? I'm in the market for a new iPad for work and the Air with a Magic Keyboard was at the top of my list, but I guess not. Tablet mode is a must for me, and taking it out of the case is not an option.
Folio may be a better option!
I’m still using the 1st IPad Pro with Face ID, I believe its the IPad Pro 3rd Gen. I finally about ready to upgrade. I was kinda hoping a MacBook would come out with Face ID. I’ll probably get a new Cellular IPad Pro this year! I’m hurting on the puny 64GB that it came with base back then 😂
If you can hold out until March! Rumors say new iPads will launch then.
If they added the eye tracking software to the iPad the folio wouldn’t need the trackpad. 🔥😂
🤯 Vision Pro Folio…
The Magic Keyboard is the still go to for me. Folio typing experience is just atrocious, and the combo touch isn’t lap-able
Agreed on the Combo Touch, and Magic Keyboard is still an amazing experience, but for how often I like going into "tablet mode" for podcast editing, I'm trying the folio again. SO much lighter too
I bought a mint 12.9" Magic Keyboard on Amazon Renewed for $150 ... couldn't go wrong.
That’s a good deal!
@@beardfm the deal is still there I think 👍🏼
I would choose the Logitech Combo Touch keyboard
Function keys and detachable keyboard are nice features!
Shelled out the $579 Australian dollars for the Magic Keyboard and was blown away by how little it does for the money.
Even when not fully extended, my fingers keep hitting the screen when using the numbers. For that sort of case I would expect that the case held some kind of independent charge that could extend the battery of your iPad, but nope.
Returned after 1 hour and have ordered the Logitech and saved a few hundred dollars.
Zagg pro keyboard is nice too
I just wanted to say that you said the Magic Keyboard doesn’t light up. I might have gotten a newer model? But miy keyboard lights up..
I may have been wrong there. I think it has to be dark enough to trigger it.
Is it really true you can’t even use the iPad in portrait mode with the Magic Keyboard on it?
No portrait option with keyboard
I prefer the Logitech Combo Touch, protection and price.
For protection, it wins for sure!
damn I just wish there was a product somewhere between the two more expensive options...
Same. Rumors are a redesigned Magic Keyboard is coming next year though!
@@beardfm I ended up getting the Logitech Combo Touch because not having the back and the corners of the iPad protected was a bigger deal to me than not being able to comfortably type on my lap. If Apple really will release a redesign I wonder which design elements they're going to reconsider. Something tells me they're just going to add a function row and maybe make the package lighter? Either way I'm always excited for more iPad stuff.
Logitech Combo Touch is the best option
I’m not one to buy overpriced items that offer very little features compared to another brand for less but so much more. After what I paid to upgrade my IPad they should include a Magic Keyboard for free!
I use the Logitech Combo Touch on my lap every day, not sure why this didn't work for you, my friend!
Interesting! Maybe a height thing??
Which iPad are you lapping? 11 inch or 13 inch?
Grazie 🙏
Just so everyone is aware. The apple one with usb c port is the only one that will charge your iPad while using the keyboard. Helpful when the original port no longer works. This is iPad Pro #2 for me that the port has gone bad.
Very true!
Just use a portable bluetooth keyboard with full sized keys, much lighter, much cheaper, better typing experience along with a mouse and a folio cover to protect the iPad and prop it up in use. Save your money and your back and have a superior typing experience.
Which combo have you used?
I have an old 2017 iMac that I have on a desk in my spare room. What I found is it works best around the house to just use a cheap ESR folio case on the iPad- it sits well on my lap and I just use the Magic Keyboard from my iMac on my lap when I want to type. It cost nothing since I already had it, and it connects to the iPad seamlessly.
I’ve had my 12.9 Logitech combo keyboard nearly two years and early on the silicon around the speaker grills warped and I had big loop bits of silicon sticking out. One recently eventually snapped. Spoke to Logitech and it’s a defect so under warranty through Amazon I ended up getting refund as Amazon doesn’t do replacements. Wish I’d waited and gone through Logitech now as I’m missing the case big time.
Ooph!
I hear what you are saying. A couple of years ago after buying from Apple a basic iPad 9th generation top of the line model with the 256GB and the cell data option after looking around for several weeks, I decided to order from Logitech a Combo Touch but, they were "out-of-stock". So, I waited about six (6) weeks and to my surprise not only were they now back "in-stock " but also on sale with a 20 percent discount. I always, prefer to get products directly from the company that makes them, just in case there is an issue (smile...smile).
Logitech for me
It's a solid keyboard and trackpad, plus those function buttons are nice to have!
Apple Magic Keybord is the best for typing, bu thats it for me. Logitech is my fav and its not even close. dont like the smart folio at all
Do you use the Logitech on your lap at all?
yes. for me much easier compared to magic keyboard. i own both. plus it detatches which matters most to me
The winner is, the one you can afford.
Folio keyboard is the one I have and it has pretty bad typeability in my opinion. Not sure how you wrote a whole book on this thing.
just use knockoff ones of the magic keyboard
👀🙅♂️
It doesn’t need to be exposed to attach the Apple Pen..
No, but if you use a grip like mine from PaperLike, then it won't work with the Logitech case
Smart Keyboard Folio is one of the worst typing experiences ever.