The mediator would be my choice. I like the way you do your battle videos. A numbering system rather than winner/loser in each category gives a more accurate depiction of your overall opinion.
Great comparison! I've got a 940 and the mediator, and between the two I prefer the less belly/pointier blade on the 940 so I'm just waiting for the day when I get my hands on the 9400.
I've been carrying the mediator for a couple months now. Love it so far. Smaller than my usual EDC. Was carrying a 583 Barrage. Once i got used to the size it was perfect.
I’ve been carrying the mediator for almost a year now. It’s become a perfect size for EDC in my opinion. It’s light in the pocket and has tht nice mini pocket clip. It’s a great choice
Hi. I just bought mediator. I noticed theres a slight blade play up n down when i wiggle down the tip. Is this normal? I could not notice it when i use it. But the play is there. I want to know whether this kind of play os normal or not. Because this one is my 1st auto knife. Thanks
Great comparison. I agree with the Mediator being a better value. I really like the 940/9400 but I think I like the Mediator more. Great video Triple E!
The sliding lock on the 9400 reminds me of the lock on the Ruike P138. Always wanted a 940 so I'd go 9400 (even though I can only own them as a collector in my state).
I love the blade shape of the Mediator, it's just such a simple and classic look. The Mediator is almost what I'd consider perfect: get rid of that snag area on the back end of the blade when it's closed, make it a wash or something other than the black coat, and give it the 9400s back safety lock (while somehow keeping the jimping) and you'll have close to what I'd consider a perfect aesthetic (and it wouldn't hurt to have scales that had a different pattern in them). All in all, great review. I've used the 940 for a long time, and the Mediator is the closest thing BM has come to offering me a useable replacement. Thanks for the review!
👍 Good, fair comparison of these two knives. I bought the 9400 so we do disagree on the “value” element. The term “super steel” tickles me as we have moved very quickly from one “super steel” to the next over the last decade. All knives become dull; therefore, to me a “super steel” is the one that is the easiest to sharpen, a factor not usually discussed in reviews. I don’t find sharpening all that hard or cumbersome but if someone does I believe Benchmade has a sharpening service. Your review actually validated my purchase of the 9400.
Thanks for the detailed comparison of these two! I'd personally prefer the 9400 because of its looks (the mediator being a little too aggresive for my personal taste) and how much I like my 940, but since where I live you're not allowed to carry auto's I've been mostly trying to forget that there's such a thing as a 9400 out there :-)
I was looking for a new knife and was considering both of these as well as a couple other Benchmades. I ended up with the Mediator due to the value of the better steel, the fact that it’s lighter, it felt better in my hand, and I also preferred it’s appearance/style. You really can’t go wrong either way. But I was able to purchase the Mediator for $18 less than what they were selling the 9400.
One year later and I’m still carrying the Mediator as my EDC. Absolutely impressed with it. I won’t be changing it out unless something else comes out that’s just blows it away. But I seriously doubt that is going to happen. Shame Benchmade discontinued this knife. But I’m so happy to have found one, and got it for a discounted price!!!
Ever since I first saw the mediator I’ve wanted one, but every time I’ve been close to picking one up there always seems to be something just a little bit more compelling to me that has just become available... It’s a shame Benchmade discontinued it though.. I would still really like to own one no doubt..
Super steel, super steel s30v s90v……good lord they’re both good steels and more than we all need for edc I’d think. If you can sharpen a knife you can sharpen a knife. If it was me I’d buy the mediator. Just because I don’t like the green and purple handle. But if I had to I’d carry the 9400 no problem.
@@TripleEEDC Never seen a new Mediator for $206 ever. Every where I looked it's $249 vs the 9400 at $229. I already have a Mediator but at $206 that's like buying new at used price.
MegaYangman there are a few places that have an unmarked price. Since Benchmade has MAP pricing, they could get in trouble if they advertised the actual price. As a result, I can’t post here who it is but if you email me at triple.e.edc@gmail, I’ll fill you in.
I love S90V! I’d take aluminum all day over G10 though, but I definitely would agree overall that if the materials and cost were the same, I would probably take the Osborne. Additional context: I am carrying an M4 940 Osborne today with Zirc aftermarket scales.
I have the mediator-it is a very high quality auto,as good as my protechs,(or better),however the geometrics of that blade does not make it a good slicer,nor is it that good for penetration.It is a very good hard use blade.For MY edc needs,I prefer the protech newport,or the benchmade casbah
@@mistersmith3986 I’m cant imagine how that could have happened. the axis lock is one of the strongest locks on the market. Sal from Spyderco even acknowledged and gave credit to Benchmade for having one of the strongest locks. There are also videos online showing how much force must be applied for lock failure, and the axis lock had incredible results. Moreover, the axis lock keeps your fingers out of the blade path when closing, so how did it close on you? Is it possible you had a fake/clone? 940s do not feel like toys. They feel solid.
@@TripleEEDC You obviously haven't paid attention to all the people who have had Axis locks fail. And when I bring this up most Benchmade owners tell me that it can be repaired. Um, no. The whole point of a locking system is to NOT fail. It's like the brakes on a car. And there are stronger and more reliable locks than the Axis lock.
The mediator would be my choice. I like the way you do your battle videos. A numbering system rather than winner/loser in each category gives a more accurate depiction of your overall opinion.
I've been waiting on a comparison between these 2. I've had an axis 940, and have always loved the look of the mediator!
I think the mediator would be my choice. Great comparison!
Thanks!
Great comparison! I've got a 940 and the mediator, and between the two I prefer the less belly/pointier blade on the 940 so I'm just waiting for the day when I get my hands on the 9400.
I just received the 9400 satin blade, I've beyond pleased with it
Just discovered your channel. Like your format and just subscribed. Thanks for the nice comparison.
Thanks and welcome!
Never liked the Osborne but love the mediator, ordered one today, this one and the 4300 CLA are my favorite Benchmade models..
I've been carrying the mediator for a couple months now. Love it so far. Smaller than my usual EDC. Was carrying a 583 Barrage. Once i got used to the size it was perfect.
I’ve been carrying the mediator for almost a year now. It’s become a perfect size for EDC in my opinion. It’s light in the pocket and has tht nice mini pocket clip. It’s a great choice
Loving the 9400 so much. Thanks again🤙🏼
My pleasure! Thanks for watching and participating! Glad you’re enjoying it.
Hi. I just bought mediator. I noticed theres a slight blade play up n down when i wiggle down the tip. Is this normal? I could not notice it when i use it. But the play is there. I want to know whether this kind of play os normal or not. Because this one is my 1st auto knife. Thanks
Great comparison. I agree with the Mediator being a better value. I really like the 940/9400 but I think I like the Mediator more. Great video Triple E!
The sliding lock on the 9400 reminds me of the lock on the Ruike P138. Always wanted a 940 so I'd go 9400 (even though I can only own them as a collector in my state).
This was such a necessary comparison. Thanks for doing this. My choice would be the Mediator.
Uhhh !
Want both .
Slight edge to the mediator .
I love the blade shape of the Mediator, it's just such a simple and classic look. The Mediator is almost what I'd consider perfect: get rid of that snag area on the back end of the blade when it's closed, make it a wash or something other than the black coat, and give it the 9400s back safety lock (while somehow keeping the jimping) and you'll have close to what I'd consider a perfect aesthetic (and it wouldn't hurt to have scales that had a different pattern in them). All in all, great review. I've used the 940 for a long time, and the Mediator is the closest thing BM has come to offering me a useable replacement. Thanks for the review!
👍 Good, fair comparison of these two knives.
I bought the 9400 so we do disagree on the “value” element.
The term “super steel” tickles me as we have moved very quickly from one “super steel” to the next over the last decade. All knives become dull; therefore, to me a “super steel” is the one that is the easiest to sharpen, a factor not usually discussed in reviews. I don’t find sharpening all that hard or cumbersome but if someone does I believe Benchmade has a sharpening service.
Your review actually validated my purchase of the 9400.
Thanks for the detailed comparison of these two! I'd personally prefer the 9400 because of its looks (the mediator being a little too aggresive for my personal taste) and how much I like my 940, but since where I live you're not allowed to carry auto's I've been mostly trying to forget that there's such a thing as a 9400 out there :-)
Ok soy boy
I was looking for a new knife and was considering both of these as well as a couple other Benchmades. I ended up with the Mediator due to the value of the better steel, the fact that it’s lighter, it felt better in my hand, and I also preferred it’s appearance/style. You really can’t go wrong either way. But I was able to purchase the Mediator for $18 less than what they were selling the 9400.
One year later and I’m still carrying the Mediator as my EDC. Absolutely impressed with it. I won’t be changing it out unless something else comes out that’s just blows it away. But I seriously doubt that is going to happen. Shame Benchmade discontinued this knife. But I’m so happy to have found one, and got it for a discounted price!!!
so glad its an auto, i hate axis locks but love the look of the 940
I got the mediator getting the mini Osborne auto tomorrow
Let me know which one you like better!
Ever since I first saw the mediator I’ve wanted one, but every time I’ve been close to picking one up there always seems to be something just a little bit more compelling to me that has just become available... It’s a shame Benchmade discontinued it though.. I would still really like to own one no doubt..
I picked up the mediator for it style that I like more, better steel, and locking button.
Dude it tweakin out opening these knives fuckin up his table 😂
It’s a leather mat 😂
Super steel, super steel s30v s90v……good lord they’re both good steels and more than we all need for edc I’d think. If you can sharpen a knife you can sharpen a knife. If it was me I’d buy the mediator. Just because I don’t like the green and purple handle. But if I had to I’d carry the 9400 no problem.
I agree that S30V is more than enough for nearly any user. S90V is a better value at the price but both are excellent steels.
@@TripleEEDC and I just bought the mediator lol. Blade HQ for the win
For a little more money on the Mediator, you're getting better steel S90V vs S30V. Either way both are very good EDC knives.
The Mediator is actually cheaper ($206) from certain retailers.
@@TripleEEDC Never seen a new Mediator for $206 ever. Every where I looked it's $249 vs the 9400 at $229. I already have a Mediator but at $206 that's like buying new at used price.
MegaYangman there are a few places that have an unmarked price. Since Benchmade has MAP pricing, they could get in trouble if they advertised the actual price. As a result, I can’t post here who it is but if you email me at triple.e.edc@gmail, I’ll fill you in.
Loving both, but after such an indepth and informative review, I'm leaning even harder towards 8551BK. Thank you for such a great review.
G10 and s90v on the osborne would make it a clear winner
I love S90V! I’d take aluminum all day over G10 though, but I definitely would agree overall that if the materials and cost were the same, I would probably take the Osborne. Additional context: I am carrying an M4 940 Osborne today with Zirc aftermarket scales.
9400 is way less tactical for me & that's what I was looking for
Great choice!
I like the 940 better
I carrie both ..
I have on order a Benchmade mini reflex 2 auto. I'm sure I'll enjoy it too.
I have the mediator-it is a very high quality auto,as good as my protechs,(or better),however the geometrics of that blade does not make it a good slicer,nor is it that good for penetration.It is a very good hard use blade.For MY edc needs,I prefer the protech newport,or the benchmade casbah
Sorry man, the mediator looks way better.
That’s the great thing about design: everyone has a different aesthetic.
There's NO battle. I hate the 940, so I'll take the other knife.
What don’t you like about the 940? It’s such a classic design.
@@TripleEEDC It looks like a kids toy and feels like one too.
Also, an Axis lock failed on me ans I almost lost a finger. So there's that.
@@mistersmith3986 I’m cant imagine how that could have happened. the axis lock is one of the strongest locks on the market. Sal from Spyderco even acknowledged and gave credit to Benchmade for having one of the strongest locks. There are also videos online showing how much force must be applied for lock failure, and the axis lock had incredible results. Moreover, the axis lock keeps your fingers out of the blade path when closing, so how did it close on you? Is it possible you had a fake/clone? 940s do not feel like toys. They feel solid.
@@TripleEEDC You obviously haven't paid attention to all the people who have had Axis locks fail.
And when I bring this up most Benchmade owners tell me that it can be repaired. Um, no. The whole point of a locking system is to NOT fail. It's like the brakes on a car.
And there are stronger and more reliable locks than the Axis lock.