What Just Happened In Tere Bin? | Wahaj Ali | Yumna Zaidi | Something Haute
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- What Just Happened In Tere Bin? | Wahaj Ali | Yumna Zaidi | Something Haute
Something Haute is Pakistan’s leading content creating platform the most credible opinion on Pakistan’s beauty, fashion & style, movies & TV scene.
Subscribe for the latest news and reviews on beauty products and Pakistani dramas & movies and exclusive celebrity interviews.
Something Haute’s TH-cam channel is managed by Dot Republic Media. All Copyright Rights Reserved.
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel:
bit.ly/somethin...
Follow us on Instagram:
/ somethinghauteofficial
Hassan's Instagram: / hchoudaryy
Aamna's Instagram: / thisisaamna
Visit our website:
www.somethingh...
Example of bad writing: Our Villain aka Anus kidnapped 2 girls Meerab and Marium and he didn’t dare to touch both the girls BUT on the other hand our Hero Murtasim sexually assaulted his own wife. And the worst part is the makers actually considered it to be acceptable in the storyline. They can’t rectify their mistake, I rest my case. 🤯🤯🤯🤯
Exactly my thoughts a week ago
So well out!
"Anus" hahahhaha
So true
Well said. Maryam assualt hoti to wo realistic lagta.
As an Indian, I have seen our dramas where the male leads are aggressive & sometimes toxic, but I haven’t seen or heard of Indian any drama in the recent years that involves sexual assault or rape by main lead. Therefore it was a shocker for me to see a well performed character like Murtasim doing the unimaginable & unthinkable. I am glad the feedback was sent to makers & team Terebin through the trend that youth is intelligent & aware about the sensitivity of the social issues & they cannot be used as clickbait & sensationalism.
This isn't anybody's fault but nooran
Exactly they are show aggressive, toxic but they don't do what tere bin makers, Nooran did showing the ML in a good light and then make him a rapist.
Qissa Meherbano Ka deals with MR and abuse but I haven't seen it in any other drama
Buddy i think showing MR is common in Pak , i hve seen many PPL saying it as Common in their dramas , jst this drama is watched by majority of Indians so there was a Need created to them to not showcase MR or else they would hve proceeded with the original script with MR
@@FarhaanBaig-pg1ou probably ur argument would be ryt buddy bcoz literally i hve not seen any of the Pak drama , it's jst many Pakistanis say MR as common so i believed it
Tere Bin is a typical case of gaslighting the audience: making controversial content for TRPs, getting social media outrage, making a choppy edit in reaction and then having people themselves feel bad for wanting a re-edited episode. Happens every-time where the blame is placed on the audience and producers get away with saying it’s for our audience- look we make content that the audience likes to watch. When in actuality the blame goes to content makers for ruining art for money.
Well said
So true....I guess originally they were gonna show MR then they were gonna show Murtasim's regret and then probably kill him off in the end-and thus the greatest tragedy ever written 😂😂😂...and now after all the editing if at this junction they kill off ML ...it'll be illogical and meerab will be bashed badly...as is happening now as well
Ooooh finally someone else validated my thoughts! Thanks Sania🙌
@@farhatjahan4784 I have an uncanny feeling that they will kill him...because nothing else explains the title and the promo..." jaan de sakte ho mere liye..blah blah.." and then the real bashing will start...
Killing him would be cherry on top as the production house would be successful in dividing audiences and fans who had loved a show so much ..(as is happening now ..aftermath of ep 47)...people from different countries had come together and given the show so much of love ...and the production house will be scott free cause we didn't want to see "MR "...so ruin the show by choppy editing and also show illogical story and ruin the female lead's character further more till the point of no redemption (if they kill the ML) and blame it on "audience ki demand"
Thank you for addressing the absurdities in the episode. We will take everything with a grain of salt because they steered away from marital rape. However, what I simply cannot fathom, regardless of marital rape or consensual sex, is Murtasim's casual treatment and attitude toward Haya in today's episode. She was the one who instigated everything. She not only bluffed and seduced him but created this huge misunderstanding between Murtasim and Meerab. Where did Murtasim's threat go? "Abhi sub kuch sach batao warna mujh se bura koi nahin ho ga." Bura nahin ho ga my foot. He is treating Haya like nothing happened. NO ONE HOLDING HAYA ACCOUNTABLE IS NOT JUSTIFIED... Murtasim should have been pissed at her and should have even told Maa Begum about the stunt she pulled last night because of which he had to talk to Meerab to salvage their relationship and that's why he wasn't there for Maryam's rukhsati. This would have made sense to Maa Begum as well. That knight in shining armor, Naurez, also came and threw hints at some perpetrator but didn't mention Haya's name at all. What is this "say nothing to Haya" policy? How do these guys plan to show her punishment? By making her commit suicide or showing her mad in the last episode? I can't wrap my head around this absurdity.
To address the absurdities, the makers made another set of absurdity.....🙄🙄🙄🤯
@@narjisrubab872 That they had to. That's how they could save it via editing alone. But even if it was marital rape, why is Murtasim not saying anything to Haya? That's not an editing fault.
@@hayaa-sd8yn The only logical explanation is that they would somehow show Maa Begum forcing Murtasim to marry Haya. And how would that happen if they keep calling her out for every other mishap?
Not just today but throughout the series ... Taking her for shopping and telling her what looks good on her 😂😂
👏
Rape is NEVER about sex. Rape is about POWER.
Yesss
Absolutely! Sadly, drama makers don't view it like that.
Rape is an act of violence, and its a crime
💯
@@organisinghome2305you obviously don’t get the whole understanding accepted worldwide that rape is about power,and not sex,as it is used in war too against women and young girls! It’d a fear,it leaves women vulnerable! Please go and do your reading on this!
Everyone is saying Tere bin is a trashy romance, but I always felt there is a lack of romance throughout the dram. Just a little romantic moments here and there that too implied by Murtasim. Meerab was always so reluctant not to see the love he had for her. By the time, she started realising and giving Murtasim importance romantically, all the drama about Maryam started. Upon realising his love for her, all Meerab did was taking advantage of it to help Maryam unite with her lover. She didn't value it the way she should have. I genuinely felt the moment when Murtasim revealed about his past dream of wildlife photography that was the perfect moment for them to breach the contract and go ahead with the intimacy. That was the most emotionally vulnerable they were infront of each other. That scene felt incomplete and no proper climax for the build up. From my view, That was the perfect ground for the baby. Then they could do all the drama afterwards and make them separated by the current track where Meerab sees Murtasim and Haya together (even though its illogical to the core but they were going with it anyway) and and she knows about her pregnancy. Meerab wanted to reveal about this and her trust and ego is completely shattered after the fight where Murtasim behaves cruelly maybe pointing towards Rohail and she goes away from the house. This would make more sense than the consensual intimacy drama. Who on earth would be devastated like this after a consensual intimacy. Why Meerab didn’t care about Maryam's ruksati at all when she was ready to ruin her marriage for MM's happiness? Why is Murtasim the most emotionally controlled person can't control his anger for his sister and doesn’t show up at the event? Why everyone is always so convinced about what Haya says despite all the things she has been doing? Why Ma begum and MM don’t demand for Meerab to be in the ruksati when it is the very reason MB had brought back her??
If only the writer had progressed the story this way, it would have made so much more sense than to introduce this MR track for no rhyme or reason. Murtasim's confession scene was so incomplete with Meerab helping Mariam elope right in the next scene. One thing that os consistent in Tere Bin is the absurdity of the story, cant believe they executed this screenplay without any level of content review process!
Your story is better Than the writers
I think the same 👍 way writer should do that
I wish they executed the story the way you told. That scene was perfect, you could feel mutual love and respect in that scene. But the questions you raised are logical questions and the script was written and directed by one of the most illogical people 🙄
Nooran makhdoom is too immature writer. There's nothing new in the story that made the serial famous but the romantic moments b/w meerab and murtasim. Audiences wanted to see the moment when meerab realizes murtasim love and tear off the agreement but maryam's track lost everything.
Haya still being unaccountable and no one questioning her is getting on the audience's nerves. As a writer, you CANNOT take such juvenile liberties and leave this key point unaddressed! PLEASE respect the audience's emotions and intelligence a bit!!
Thank you, from episode 1 till today she is behind most of the disasters in this family BUT she still gets away, hope she doesn't have a happy ending.
Atleast her character is consistent 😂
Okay we need to talk about the hypocrisy of these liberals and feminists. I mean none of them is bothered by the THAPPAR and Spitting scene...cuz victim was a man this time.
Also they have no issues that how the MARITAL RAPE kinda topics are being promoted now in dramas.. dont they know the psychological aspect of promoting such mature content given that the kids also watch dramas ???
Only thing they were bothered was MR being committed by the HERO (that didn't even happen still they are discussing it).
And now look at the shameless lady sitting over here. The way she is openly saying Utarny ki cheez... Kpry utar skty hyn to jooty bhi... And the male host repeating the same bakwas... What rubbish? Are they seriously here to promote Vulgarity only???
What was expected to be the most beautiful moment of confession, they turned it into the worst nightmare
We were really waiting for Meerub’s confession
Yes so true ..and drama would be a huge hit
Okay we need to talk about the hypocrisy of these liberals and feminists. I mean none of them is bothered by the THAPPAR and Spitting scene...cuz victim was a man this time.
Also they have no issues that how the MARITAL RAPE kinda topics are being promoted now in dramas.. dont they know the psychological aspect of promoting such mature content given that the kids also watch dramas ???
Only thing they were bothered was MR being committed by the HERO (that didn't even happen still they are discussing it).
And now look at the shameless lady sitting over here. The way she is openly saying Utarny ki cheez... Kpry utar skty hyn to jooty bhi... And the male host repeating the same bakwas... What rubbish? Are they seriously here to promote Vulgarity only???
Yes we want ese execute hota to acha hota Aggression to tha murtsim ko agr wo use remind karate ki usne start s Abhi tk us agreement ki kitni value rakhi h or use btata he changed him self for only her itna hone k bad wo slep to deserve ni krta tha n & she also confessed ki usne kitni gltiya ki h confession to hona tha pr jesa btya gya story hi change ho gyi or ek seen ki to range hi alg thi..that swal down on floor that means he lost his pride. Wo swal uski izzat ko represent krti h jo wo meerb ko smjhta h..remember his dialogues "ab wo bhi meri kuch lgti h maa izzat h meri or ap usse nuksan ni paucha skti" but story to kha s kaha ja rhi😔
While i appreciate the fact that they didn't tarnish the show by showing marital rape.....i still have in mind that originally murtsim's character had taken that turn and i still see him with same disgust....somehow i can't unsee it now....for me the show is ruined but still they atleast saved it somehow to whatever extent they could
Yea his attitude gave very disgusting feelings
Sameee it’s terrible that the original script takes that turn even the end of ep 46 ruined it for me their efforts for saving murtasim’s character were in vain
Same. I feel disgusted to even look at Murtasim now. The editing just worsen the situation.
Same, they just ruined the whole thing completely, at least for me.
@NISHI H thats the response audience gives when they idealize fictional characters and are too attached to a show.
I just have a few questions. Why did Nooran Makhdoom in an interview say “contract breach hoga, maza aayega” when she wrote in that Murtassim was gonna force himself on her? Is this her idea of enjoyment?
And why did Yumna Zaidi in an interview say apart from Murtassim, every character is grey…when in fact Murtassim was gonna assault Meerab? She said Murtassim wasn’t toxic.
I love Yumna and Wahaj so I will continue watching their dramas in the future too (and excuse this as a bad judgement call) but I really wanna know what was the rationale behind writing this contract breach scenario in the original script.
Writing a MR scene was unnecessary & awful, choosing to act it was bad decisions both on Yumna & Wahaj’s part, directing it while keeping it in was also bad and editing last week’s promo while sensationalising MR was clearly traumatic to many, many, many women. HOWEVER the absolutely most disgusting, arrogant & humiliating part is played by the production team and Abdullah Kadwani, tweeting ’we urge the audiences to wait AND NOT JUMP TO CONCLUSIONS’ which was followed by a most atrocious and ridiculous voice-over manouvre ever. So NO apologies, NO acknowledgement of misjudging that MR would be traumatic (and utterly bonkers), NO recognition and instead writing ’don’t jump to conclusions’ while having done exactly that which we all knew and concluded. Guys, I can take bad writing or acting but this type or arrogance-driven humiliation is many steps too far; do you think we’re all stupid? This was the first geo drama I was watching & clearly never again. Just who do you think you are, MR producer, and which world do you live in, Ms writer?
Couldn't agree more!💯
Exactly This created highest trp by leaving a MR cliffhanger
Okay we need to talk about the hypocrisy of these liberals and feminists. I mean none of them is bothered by the THAPPAR and Spitting scene...cuz victim was a man this time.
Also they have no issues that how the MARITAL RAPE kinda topics are being promoted now in dramas.. dont they know the psychological aspect of promoting such mature content given that the kids also watch dramas ???
Only thing they were bothered was MR being committed by the HERO (that didn't even happen still they are discussing it).
And now look at the shameless lady sitting over here. The way she is openly saying Utarny ki cheez... Kpry utar skty hyn to jooty bhi... And the male host repeating the same bakwas... What rubbish? Are they seriously here to promote Vulgarity only???
I hope Yumna took a huge sum of money for playing merub.. Apart from her breathtaking acting she deserves all the money for all the humiliations and hate Merub had to go through..
@@rehanatahir5736 do u see how humiliating and stupid merubs character is.. The writer is a women and she wrote THIS for women.. If yumna didn’t act so perfectly merub would have been the villain of the drama
@@jannat65514 yes exactly writer ko Yumna ky paou or hath chumny chahiyy jo usky pathetic or poor script ko apni mehnat or brilliant acting skills or qabliyat sy nibaiya or yaha tk pounchaiya h sari Zindagi norn ko iska sukar ada krna chahiyyy
It was her choice to play the character ..no one forced her and she has never said about any faults in her character
@@ammarzahid9202😢
Why am I still upset? Although I should be glad that what we all thought would happen didn’t happen because that would’ve been devastating but still I feel sad. Just as many of us here, I too am a huge fan of TB right since the first episode and have been contributing to its success sometimes watching an episode more than once! But I feel cheated! The writer really took the audiences for granted. We felt Meerab’s helplessness when she finds out about her parents and then forced marriage and were rooting for her and applauded her head strong mentality.
And then Murtasim, our Hero whom we loved and adored even respect so much for being a true man- always standing up for the weak, making right decisions for his people, taking a stand in front of his mother for his wife and most important how he dealt with his wife after he realized that he’s fallen in love with her! Absolutely loved that- I mean we haven’t seen someone like him in Pak dramas recently where the norm was becoming toxic and macho. He was like a breath of fresh air! I even made my husband watch some of his romantic scenes but he wasn’t really interested lol since he hardly watches dramas and brushed it off as aap or app ke dramey!
We really did put Murtasim on a pedestal and appreciated the gentleness that he handled Meerab with.
So coming back to ep 47- yes the narrative was changed since there was so much backlash and uproar on social media and the makers had to do it. But the real disappointment is with the writer, what was she thinking! That’s what makes me so upset still- you gave us his man who’s making all the right moves- madly in love with his wife ( yes, I cried with him when he confessed his love during the photography scene) always standing up for her, caring for her- and then bam you destroy him! Why did the writer even think about MR, why? You know that’s what was coming, we saw it in the promos- why did she first elevate his stature so much and then do this! This is something so unforgivable, and then to hint that it would be a happy ending meaning Meerab would had to forgive him! What! No! He’s the man who forgave his worst enemy, he’s the man who didn’t kill Rohail at the apartment after finding Meerab there, he even forgave his sister for all she did then why he couldn’t hold himself together this time- for the person whom he loves so much. When I watched ep 46 last week- the last 5 minutes were nothing short of shocking- I’m in the US and it is uploaded on TH-cam at 12PM and I watch it on my lunch break on my phone with my ear buds! (who can wait till 8PM) I gasped so loud when she slapped him even more when she spat- was not expecting that! She definitely over reacted- this is Haya who she knows by now has evil intentions- just couple of weeks ago when she was praying she told her that I knew everything and was watching your every move and also when Murtasim has repeatedly told her that she mean nothing to him then Meerab should have listened to him and slapped Haya.
It was really hard to follow the episode 47- their words were not following their actions for the obvious reasons. They could have ended the story here when she comes back- didn’t need to add Rohail back- Meerab had finally realized her feelings for Murtasim so she should’ve confessed- have a cute scene where she rips the contract and they live happily ever after considering the fact that it is ep 46 already.
But they had to put us through this torture- I know these are fictional characters in a fictional story but still we become so attached to them- we root for them cry with him laugh with them.
Yumna is absolutely a delight to watch. But what can I say about Wahaj! I think I’m a fan for life, he is living breathing Murtasim I don’t think any other actor could have done justice to this role. His romantic scenes reminds me of SRK- how he used to romance his heroines! Sky’s the limit for Wahaj, this is just the beginning!
I’m the first one to watch TB on Wed and Thurs and MPHT on Mon- but what a drag that is becoming I’m only watching it for Wahaj! I wish they would stop showing in Pak dramas that if a husband or wife is talking to another man or woman then just jump to the conclusion that they’re cheating- come on we’re in year 2023 for crying out loud!
I think I’m going to give Pak dramas a break after these two and Kuch Ankhi- we become so invested in them just to be disappointed.
I’ve never written this much on a public platform before but it was building up since last week and had to let it out!
Very well said 👏 meri muh ki baat keh di
Totally concur with each word of yours Arooj
As I have said before Noura Makdoum has to be banned for life. She creates the most lovely non toxic hero in 45 episodes and can destroy him in 5 sec. That is what hurts the most.
Agree with you
very well written.
Tere Bin was successful because it started as a feel good romance. It would have been great to end it on that note without making it a soap opera. People would have loved to watch it again and again with spectacular chemistry from the lead pair, so in the long run it would have made more financial sense on views for the producers. Now people just jump to the 5 minutes of substance in each episode to see where the story goes and dread watching it again. Not a smart business move to drag this drama!!!
So you're telling me after she spat on him, slapped him, enraged him, and he pushed her, told her he'll show her the real meaning of contract and they had consenual intimacy after that?
YEH LOG HUMEIN CHUNTIYAN SMJHTY HAIN?
Nooran's inner mysoginistic self showed itself and it's so apparent they tried doing damage control with WhatsApp voiceovers.
These makers of drama always consider stupid dum jahil what not
@Tea Drinker Geo, 7th Sky must have learnt their lesson not to give away the story of the upcoming episodes in the promos!
@Tea Drinker Nooran Makhdoom was busy defending the marital rape 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼 saying it'll lead to the climax 🤔
this writer definitely smokes 🚬 some pure stuff
I feel Murtism is actually a guy right out of the writer’s own sexual fantasies.The looks, the charisma , the sex appeal, a caring and a considerate husband.
It feels she wants to protect Murtism in every scenario , even after the rape ( if they had taken the rape route) by showing his deep guilt and pain.
Unfortunately , that comes at the cost of throwing Meerub under the bus constantly. Even now , it’s her who threw herself on him and he is made out this super generous guy who feels sorry for having sex with her.
Nooran is jealous of Meerab :D
Men written by women writers are always something. And here I don't really mean in a good light.
This episode was senseless. It was obvious marital rape happened. But due to the criticism, they cut out the scene where Haya tells Meerub tell leave Murtasim’s life and go to Karachi. Furthermore, Meerub crying on the floor and leaving the house is a big deal as well as Murtasim smashing the mirror so its obvious they changed the episode & voiceovers because the voiceovers made no sense. The voiceovers did not match what happened.
100% true..they changed the story with senseless voice overs..
Yeah they definitely changed their monologues in that scene. The whole point of keeping the contract was that it would end when Meerab goes to Murtasim willingly so since that happened according to the redubbed voiceovers, it doesn't make any sense for Meerab and Murtasim to be upset.
Yes 💯
@@haramansari0904 exactly! Very good comment. The producers made a fool of themselves. They have no reason to be upset and have those reactions especially Murtasim smashing the mirror if marital rape didn’t happen.
Shut up meri jism meri marjiwali.
Lets not forget Meerab was forced into this marriage..regardless of how well she was treated by Murtasim ...no prisoner will ever easily fall in love or trust their imprisoner..people couldnt digest the fact that Meerab was taking her time..
100% agree
Tu naa karti forcly marriage, us time pe ghar se bhaagna tha naa.. abhi kiu bhaagi hai
Waqas k ghar nahi gaey k again murtasim k hawalay kardengay tu jab murtasim chor k gaya tha tab bhi naa jati.. tab tu baray aram se raat bhar gate pe bethi rahi.. wah bhae jab chaha baap bana liaa jab chaha disown kardia…aur waqas ne tu mana kia tha khud apni marzi se aey thi meerub
Ye himmat shadi se pehlay dikhani thi k andheri raat mai nikal jati akaili… atleast koi dosra tu suffer nahi hota naa
@@uzmaarsalan2471 She tried to escape...once she was chased till she met an accident..second time she was slapped...plz I dont even want to go get into this..its so ridiculous
To be honest we are all being kind to the actors and the tere bin makers, but even actors need to have some responsibility. Some things are unacceptable. You can't portray your male lead to be a rapist and get away with it. Now Malik zubair has more honour than murtasim it seems. It's really disgusting. Rape is never okay. How can they not have any conscience? worst is the writer. such a twisted mind being a woman
👍
So true...
The writer is terrible!!
The write is the actual culprit not Murtaism not meerub not director
Actors are equally responsible stop whitewashing them. These two actors are amazing and famous actors they should be responsible one too. At least they can stand against the sick and disgusting scenes.
Tere Bin will go down in the history of drama for being one of a kind . The love and support it got from its wonderful audience is remarkable. They loved it so much that they saved it from doing a blunder.Wahaj Ali and Yumna Zaidi along with the makers of Tere Bin should always acknowledge this.
I don’t think so
They made U turn
Well done ❤
Please something haute convey this message to Yumna Zaidi because I am on no social media. She is the best person, best actor and this she doesn't know. She has epitome of talent and she is sheer brilliance and she has proven time and again. She should from now on decide and nobody has any right to to injustice to her as an artist and as a person also. I feel that the person she is who is very serious about her work must be disturbed. She has power to bring people to watch her acting and kneel down in front of her and sing her praises. For eg She made Bakhtawar trending. Even many are watching tere bin for her only. This show is complete disgrace to her art. She has got a voice which has to be heard . She should take a stand for herself.she is extremely extremely good at what she does. These people has taken away all what she did for the drama. She has to be respected . That is it
14:03 thankyou Aamna for saying this...due to this whole TB fiasco I realized that people in don't even consider it as MR...and there's a huge number of viewers who were supporting murtasim's act by saying that there's no such thing in Islam. I'm an Indian muslim, I saw a comment of an Indian girl (not a muslim), she was condemning murtasim's act and was showing her disappointment and rightly so...but a user who was defending murtasim said "islam mei aisa kuch nhi hota" I was so furious with all those comments so it made me curious to know what Islam says about consent so I read some articles. And those articles stated exactly what you said...so thanks for quoting the facts. It's really sad that people use Islam to defend such horrible things. These people need education.
In this review, Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene and enjoying. Specially taking about keeping shoes during sex is too much. Looks like both are enjoying the sex topic.It's look like Hasan and Amna are doing review of Porn movie. 40:20 minutes Amna want to talk again about sex scene, then Hasan said may be they tried a sex position which was hurt to Merab, OMG, How both are talking openly abt sex scene in Detail, both are tharki reviewer. Shame on you Hasan & Amna. I think both of you share yours sex life. Shame on you. I was thinking this review by Indians, not Pakistani. We can't accept such review. May be Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene for Indian people. Even other people also review episode#47 of Teray Bin didn't review the way Hasan & Amna did in a vulgar way..
The U-turn which the makers took because of the backlash was absurd, however the brighter side is that the outrage was actually taken into consideration by the makers and it compelled them to make this change on this short notice. I don’t ever remember the last time any narrative was changed because of any back lash no matter how popular the drama was.
agreed
That's true but look what have they made it into..a complete senseless chaos!
@@sanamonster1 Wohh toh bas discuss karnay ke bhi kabil nahi hai😂
They had no choice. Showing a happy ending after the assault would’ve been a completely new low for TV and they realized that
Yes they changed it after backlash but butchered the story
Tbh, it would have been better if they didn't changed it, & showed meerab independently parenting her daughter as happy ending
Bcz Even if they now edited the rpe scene to save the show, the Audience will still watch it from the perspective that marital rpe happened, Otherwise the scenes won't make sense 😐
That scenario that aamna was talking about where they both are feeling guilty about having a toxic relationship is actually really profound and a really bold topic that they could have really touched upon instead of the writer going down the marital rape route that they had to retcon due to the backlash. It’s sad that fans and critics think more about the characters, their arcs and story plots than the writers and content teams themselves 😅
In this review, Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene and enjoying. Specially taking about keeping shoes during sex is too much. Looks like both are enjoying the sex topic.It's look like Hasan and Amna are doing review of Porn movie. 40:20 minutes Amna want to talk again about sex scene, then Hasan said may be they tried a sex position which was hurt to Merab, OMG, How both are talking openly abt sex scene in Detail, both are tharki reviewer. Shame on you Hasan & Amna. I think both of you share yours sex life. Shame on you. I was thinking this review by Indians, not Pakistani. We can't accept such review. May be Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene for Indian people. Even other people also review episode#47 of Teray Bin didn't review the way Hasan & Amna did in a vulgar way..
Writer threw Meerub under the bus again just to save Murtasim. But we know what happened...and the fact that Haya is still in that house shows the writer simply hates strong women and will make them appear as stupid as possible and instead give light to a woman with a criminal and amoral mindset just because she is obsessed with a man the writer is clearly also infatuated with. She's infatuated with a rapist, how sick and twisted is this writing.
Coconut ji aap ki baat bhi bilkul coconut jesi kadak aur sahi hai
@Munaf Ahmad that's my point. The writer made a woman who was strong willed into a blabbering idiot, she is trying to repeatedly make the point that when meerub doesn't listen to murtasim, something bad always happens. And i have no doubt that's how she planned on justifying the MR. She never gave meerub's character the chance to be strong, she broke her down in a horrible fashion.
Yes the writer could have should meerab strong and empowered woman. She could have completed her law degree after marriage and use a little bit of her brain every time she is shown as dumb
In this review, Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene and enjoying. Specially taking about keeping shoes during sex is too much. Looks like both are enjoying the sex topic.It's look like Hasan and Amna are doing review of Porn movie. 40:20 minutes Amna want to talk again about sex scene, then Hasan said may be they tried a sex position which was hurt to Merab, OMG, How both are talking openly abt sex scene in Detail, both are tharki reviewer. Shame on you Hasan & Amna. I think both of you share yours sex life. Shame on you. I was thinking this review by Indians, not Pakistani. We can't accept such review. May be Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene for Indian people. Even other people also review episode#47 of Teray Bin didn't review the way Hasan & Amna did in a vulgar way..
I wish everyone would acknowledge that the real hero of Tere Bin is only and only YUMNA ZAIDI! She has saved a bad character , a flawed script, murtasim’s character and Wahaj Ali. She deserves more and more credit. Whilst I strongly believe that MR should never have been part of the narrative but considering it had been shot already they should have gone ahead with it and let Murtasim’s character take the fall. Maybe he was meant to be grey. So what if he was not to end up as the perfect hero. I dont know why people feel more comfortable with hating the heroine than the hero. As much as I have loved wahaj ali as Mk , i wish he had the strength to go ahead with what he had signed up for and then take the backlash. In the current scenario everyone from the writer, producers to wahaj have saved their face and sacrificed yumna zaidi. If they had shown the MR, then meerab’s reluctance to accepting Murtasim would have finally made some sense but now they have further messed up Meerab. This is so unfair to Yumna. In Each and every scene , especially in the last confrontation, Yumna has outperformed wahaj but i feel she has not got the credit just because her character has been constantly sacrificed to save Murtasim!!!
Both actors are at fault. How the hell both agreed to do such a scene and then went on claiming that murtasim is not toxic
@@ayeza7267 i think Murtasim has been grey all along. He slaps his cousin, has anger issues, does soften a bit when he is trying to win meerab’s love but then when he feels she is not budging, he goes crazy and assaults her. I think the audiences may have misunderstood him as a hero when he wasn’t meant to be one. He warns meerab several times about the animal within him and delivers other such dialogues which suggest he is capable of violence. I think yumna agreed to do this scene because the assualt would have explained why she has been resisting Murtasim and not trusting him all along. And that would have somewhat redeemed meerab’s character. But now due to the pressure of the fans, they have changed the script and now the next few episodes will make no sense. In hindsight, perhaps they should have gone ahead with the assault and then we could have seen how Murtasim would have been punished for the deed!
Even if they now edited the rpe scene to save the show, the Audience will still watch it from the perspective that marital rpe happened, Otherwise the scenes won't make sense 😐
Thanks to the viewers for the backlash needed and
thanks to you guys as well to let the cast and crew of TB realize the mistake they were going to make .
The fact that non of the cast member , director or the producer felt that the writing is going wrong way is itself really shocking 🙄
In this review, Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene and enjoying. Specially taking about keeping shoes during sex is too much. Looks like both are enjoying the sex topic.It's look like Hasan and Amna are doing review of Porn movie. 40:20 minutes Amna want to talk again about sex scene, then Hasan said may be they tried a sex position which was hurt to Merab, OMG, How both are talking openly abt sex scene in Detail, both are tharki reviewer. Shame on you Hasan & Amna. I think both of you share yours sex life. Shame on you. I was thinking this review by Indians, not Pakistani. We can't accept such review. May be Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene for Indian people. Even other people also review episode#47 of Teray Bin didn't review the way Hasan & Amna did in a vulgar way..
Exactly 💯 . Malik zubair ne jo nhi Kia vo murtasim ne kr dia matlab doesn't make sense
Agree- even the actors had responsibility but then looking at dramas they have participated in the past where every time a woman’s spirit is broken and she shown to be happy ‘coming to terms with her fate’, looks like these are the types of scripts coming to them and they eventually find nothing wrong with it- it is after all a story to them and TBH in real life plenty of charismatic men are toxic in this way
On Twitter it was primarily Pakistani based outrage that I saw, hashtags were mostly originating from Pakistan too. I don’t think the makers deserve any accolades for changing the scene and further messing up the characters, it’s a sad day when artists and their hard work is thrown under the bus to save botched jobs of writers, directors and production houses. Meerab’s character once again saves Murtasim the pious, I feel Yumna’s character has been repeatedly slighted to save the hero at her expense. Makers deserve no credit for changing the scene, if they truly wanted to save the characters they would rewrite and reshoot, this was nothing but a lazy desperate last minute cover up to save themselves from more backlash.
Feeling sad for Yumna at the end all blame is on merab
I agree with everything but why did you leave actors aside? Why did they agree to shoot such heinous acts?
I agree with everything but why did you leave actors aside? Why did they agree to shoot such heinous acts?
I think Yumna and Wahaj are equally responsible for this. People were hoping against hope that the promo is misleading simply because there trusted yumna and wahaj for not shooting such scenes but episode 47 came as betrayal. It seeks like they did shoot such scenes but kept telling people Murtasim isn't a grey character. For me it was the actors who disappointed me because they were the only reason for me to watch this show
I’ve been trying to find a storyline that fits the scenes that were showed and the voiceovers and honestly nothing makes sense but this is the closest I’ve come and it relates to what you had said about shame:
Meerab consummated her marriage with Murtasim in the heat of the moment without giving it a second thought but once it was over she realized she lost the one thing she always thought she had control over. When she first decided to marry Murtasim she said something along the lines of I won’t cry anymore but I’ll make them (The Khan’s) cry. So after the consummation she may have felt shame or disgusted with herself that she wasn’t able to hold herself to a higher standard. I do also think she has a lot of conflict that hasn’t been resolved in her bc her marriage to Murtasim was technically forced bc she felt like she had no way out otherwise she would be homeless. Everyone betrayed her in the start but this time it feels like she betrayed herself because she gave into her desires, the one thing she told herself she wouldn’t do and why she always held back from accepting Murtasim. Meerab obviously has trust issues and that’s a wound that just got deeper with herself.
Now when it comes to Murtasim, his reaction was so exaggerated in the edited scenario but I like to tell myself is that the reason he’s so upset/ashamed is because of Meerab’s reaction. In the moment he gave in bc Meerab consented but when he saw Meerab being so upset he assumed she didn’t want this (bc obviously they don’t talk and never communicate). And Meerab has never explicitly told him she loves him so he thinks he betrayed her trust and he should’ve been the bigger person and stopped (even though again it was consensual). So he feels the guilt thinking Meerab regrets her decision.
This show has really gone off the rails and I wish they had just reshot it and ended it in 2 episodes but looks like we’re in for another 6-8 episodes of misery.
Thank you, now I understand what happened. I was so confused after watching the episode. I was like it seemed like it was consensual but they are both upset??
Yumna just nailed it...
The actress she is❤
I think Aamna is not happy with the Tere Bin track at all. She is well aware that how much damage has been made. She does not want to use harsh words or smash the team. For the very first time I felt her words are not going with her emotions that is why she just wanted to roast it. She kept it quite calm and simple. I liked it because she has great command on her words/emotions. She was the only critic who was continuously against the slap of Murtasim. It was mentioned in the article she wrote on Wahaj Ali.
On the other hand , in an interview Yumna said that Murtasim is not a bad man at all people were assuming wrong from the trailer. I think she thinks its ok for a man to force himself on his wife while he is in anger . So it was not a big thing for the whole team as nobody gave it a thought until the release of trailer. Actors also need to think a lot about the seriousness of topics. This is also a lesson for those who think screen doest not leave any impact on audience.
A very healthy and informative discussion by both anchors. Well done. As Indian, I came to know about your society. Thanks a lot Aamna mam and Hassan sir.🙏
Thanks for an open mind ❤
❤❤
"They did it for the first time, it was a bad night for them " was hilarious Amna!
I literally made suji halwa yesterday after work, I was so happy after they made Murtasim a HERO and not a villain!!
So sweet ❤❤
@@Realityalwaysstrike thank you 😊😊
The fact that that lady writer actually wrote marital rape scene itself is damn scary how do people write such things and think it is entertainment god thankfully this show was popular so audiance took things in hand and made them change the script but that lady noraan is not wrong this is not the first time rape show in Pakistani dramas remember ranjha ranjha kardi there too rape was shown and justified
#terebin this was just ridiculous episode.... Actually i am digest reader for the last 20 years and unfortunately writers glorify such masculine characters who even forced themselves toward their female partners. Marital rape happens in every second story and writers don't even realise that its toxic. The same is in case of writer #nooranmakhdoom. If she wants to portray meerub pregnant this could have happened with consent before the escape of marrium as both were having feelings. And the final dispute could be the marium's escape. I felt meerub triggered him by slapping and spitting on him... But yes the whole drama is a mess now...
The makers tried their best to cover-up the marital rape but it was too evident. She was trembling and looked so scared after leaving the house. A woman after consensual sex definitely doesnt look this distressed. She was clearly pressurized and got manipulated for that consent.
The real review started from 23:55 atleast for me 🤣🤣 this the discussion I'm waiting for. Love you guys ❤
This review is far better than the whole episode I loved it!
really enjoyed man !❤
Murtasim ne jutte nhi uttara was epic😂
I still cannot believe that the writer was going to make Murtasim, the Hero, stoop lower than Malik Zubair, the supposed Villain.
Make it make sense.
Its truly heart breaking to feel that Murtasim's words of "Ajeeb sa dard hota hain idhar idhar," pointing to his heart, are so relatable. The drama could have still achieved the same success had they shown a happy bedroom scene where the misunderstandings were resolved and both characters confided in each other. Unfortunately, everything has been ruined by this poor story line, and I feel like my five months have been wasted. Despite this, we cannot deny that there is an undeniable chemistry between the two lead actors, which makes them so special in our eyes. We are watching only for #yumhaj .However, I just can't bear it now when a channel shares posters with captions such as 'chartbuster' or 'millions of views'. If only I could show production houses that without chemistry between its leads, the drama is horrible, to say the least. Stop producing such erroneous scripts...Dil se sachi mein aah nikalti hain iss story ko dekhkey..kya ho sakta tha..aur kya bana diya!!production walein agar audience ki thodi shun ley toh age chalkey kuch logical dramas bhi produce karengey.Awam mein zyaada akal hain than the entire team of harpalgeo channel and 7th sky..sky mein nahi paataal lok rakho apna naam.stories aisi hain..ki dhartilok mein nahi patallok mein jagah milni chahiye.......😡 #sheerdisappointment
True. Nooran 's script should be banned. Story ki starting itni achchi thi. Bahot bahot achchi story bana sakte. Ek feudal ladka aur aur ek educated ladki. Murtasim shaadi ke baad achanak se itni mohabbat ki poocho mat. They could have shown slowly slowly falling fall each other. Unhe show karna chahiye tha car accident ke baad murtasim realises how much he loved meerub and meerub too. Aur phir meerub thoda down ho jaati, akadti nahi, zaleel nahi karti balki dono time ke saath saath compatible ho jaate. Dono ke normal scene hote jaise meerub batati ki wo kaise Karachi mein rehti thi. Murtasim apni baat batata, dono apne bachpan ki baatein share kartein. Aur murtasim ke chaahat wale part mein contract breach ho jaata.
Maza hi agya apka comment parh kr .. true sentiments .. pta chlta h audience Kitna invested thi or kitni disappointed h .
@@daniyaalmujahid4473 ya candel or flowers sy decorate krti or phir kehti I love you I can't live without you mujy tm sy mohabbat hochuki h mohabat jeet gai nafrat hargi agr bhya ye tamsha na krti to merb ye sab krti 💯 but writer loves bhya that's why she never ditch bhya
The best way to go about the episode without reshooting or that crappy editing was to show Murtasim shutting the door as if he is going to assault her but stops at the last moment and tell Meerub how badly he loves her and how upset he has been with her behavior towards their relationship....then his devastation & regret would have been justified. While Meerub's breakdown and so much pain would have been shown due to her actions (asking Miriam to run away or spitting on her husband and other shizz she has been doing so far) and the realization that what she did to him was wrong and how toxic they have been to each other despite how they feel for each other...so she leaves to probably I don't know to grow some sense or something. Then we could have had a leap and years later seen two actual grown-up adults reconciling.
Well said
I had the same thing in my mind
I always maintain that if the makers of Tere bin gave ordinary viewers a chance to write episode 47, they would be 100 times better than that incompetent Nooran Mukhtoom version! Even my friends teenage daughter could do a better job! Nooran has actually written a poor script all along with tarnishing Meerub’s character now she decided to make the very non toxic hero she created to be a rapist! Which we viewers after 45 episodes came to adore and couldn’t believe he could do this, nor could Meerub stoop this low to spit and slap him!
@@gerryburntwood9617well basically at this point Nooran Makhdooom is a deeply misogynistic writer with the way she’s portrayed meerub….at least have some dignity as a women yourself
He didn't even have to attempt it, that would be damaging enough. He honestly could have just closed the door and grabbed the contract and said: the only reason this contract has meaning is because I'm respecting your wishes so please don't reduce our relationship to a contract, let's talk about our differences and what we mean to each other, and meerub could have calmed down and finally expressed her love. We would finally get the episode we were all waiting for...but nooo writer doesn't want us happy
Love watching Hassan and Amna in action!They encapsulate the story with their thoughts, questions, hilarity!! Totally enjoy them, so many LOL😂 moments in their review!
I think we were trying to save Murtasim which resulted in this huge uproar not only for murtasim but for the story itself. It's simply because we as women saw some of our own reflection in Meerub regardless of all her flaws and we all felt that we DO NOT wish to be assaulted by anyone in life. Fathers do not wish their daughters to get assaulted and brothers not wanting their own sisters to get assaulted by their husbands.
Honestly while watching the promo for episode 47 I personally felt attacked and sick to my stomach 😢
WAHAJ ALI IF YOU ARE SEEING THIS BE GRATEFUL TO YUMNA ZAIDI ….SHE LET THIS SLIP IT ON HERSELF AND MADE HERSELF LOOK CRAZY IN THE SHOW…SHE MADE YOU A STAR …THIS WILL GO DOWN IN HISTORY…ENJOY YOUR STARDOM …STILL A YUMNA STAN AND WATCHING IT FOR HER ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
Yumna zaidi is the "martyr" of this show you can see that she totally sacrificed herself and tried to do justice with a character like meerub . And hats off to the makers of tere bin for taking such a drastic step though we don't know how the story will proceed but it was a big move by them
Yumna should never accept or even bother to consider for a minute, a script by Nooran Makhdoom
Yumna ❤️
@@shahmanz you mean next script
@@ammarzahid9202 yes exactly. Noone should accept. She's a weird thinker
She must have read the script and still accepted it so whats the credit given to her
Thank you for addressing these points. I couldn't have agreed more to this 👍👌👏
We don't have problem with MARITAL RAPE being shown on screen. Here, the problem was that they had build Murtasim's character in such a way in these 45 episodes that no one in this UNIVERSE would digest the fact that he would rape his wife. Wahaj made Murtasim such a likeable beloved character that we were emotionally invested and attached to his character beyond anyone's imagination. And anything extreme that he would do, would have had impacted big time to his audience.
Unfortunately the recent plot changes brought Meerab in bad limelight again. It is so illogical that a man and wife after having CONSENSUAL sex are upset and crying and breaking mirrors. Are we so foolish that we don't understand that this was a clear cut MARITAL RAPE which the makers tried to do damage control last minute by adding voice overs.
I'm so dissapointed 😞
Exactly !!! Couldn't have expressed it better
Firstly, I'm glad that the makers paid heed to the criticism and made changes as much as they could.
But Man, they made a joke out of the drama...koi bhi track daal do, kuch bhi plot line ho bas TRPs aur views mil jayen...TB never meant to be a great drama in terms of writing but it still got so much popularity that no other pakistani drama has gotten because of yumhaj and their chemistry and siraj ul haq's direction but the script did have some great romantic moments but over all the script was average. Had they ended it earlier with 30-35 episodes, it would have been remembered as the most popular drama that gave us a character like murtasim to cherish forever and the most loved lead pair but now it would be remembered because of this fiasco. Kahan se kahan le aaye.
And I'm not making a joke out of this whole situation but I literally cracked up when murtasim said "woh khud ko nahi rok payi, tum toh rok sakte they"😂 Meerub was admitting "tumhari marzi se hua toh ab tum kyun ro rhi ho" I mean... seriously?? If they consensually consummated their marriage then why both of them seem so upset??? Aur yeh ki iss baat par meerub ghar chhod kar hi chli jaye.That's bizarre. They saved murtasim but put meerub under the bus again.
They literally took it to the 90s Bollywood era...I think they heard Aamna out, when she said "yeh I hate you I hate you se I love you par aa jayenge"😂 In my mind I was thinking why are they so sad about consummation if it was consensually done but we all know the reason.
But on a serious note, I'm very disappointed that they made a joke of out of this drama. It could've been all n all romantic drama but these twist and turns made it a crap.
I was furious (to say the least) when I watched the last episode and promo but I'm sorry this episode looked funny to me.
And obviously it's clear that they have originally added MR track but had to remove it...and Nooran makhdoom was so confident about this twist that she actually said in her interview "maza aayega contract breach mei" thank you so much to the writer for doing this to us and for ruining your own show. Isey kehte hain apne pair par khud kulhadi marna. And why did yumna and wahaj agree to do this sequence(MR)...why didn't they realize this could go wrong while doing it, they could've saved it by resisting to do that but they did...I know It's their job but actors too have a social responsibility and they should never undermine that.
But now that they have removed the MR angle and saved murtasim..I wonder how are they going to save the plot but I guess plot is their least of the concerns.
P.s the only good thing about this episode was Yumna snd wahaj's performance...Yumna is a powerhouse of talent. Although I felt, her expressions did not match with the voice over but her expressions and her condition when she was roaming on road after leaving the house, said everything. It's only yumna that is saving the character of meerub otherwise it would be a disaster.
How come Murtasin didn’t take any action on Haya in the 48th episode? Does it make any sense??? Why does the writer till now keep protecting Haya?? I thought Nourez is going to uncover Haya’s Behayi. Even he doesn’t. What the hell is the writer playing with our brains?
Kiunk wo anaaaaat h hahaha😂
Very bad writing 😢
What infuriates me is Nooran’s IV wherein she said hum log bohot enjoy karenge contract breach. What a sadist! 😂
😂😂😂
Exactly..mujhe bhi yahi laga k is tarah breach hona tha contact jiske lie nooran makhdoom bekuf excited thi k bht maza ayega..how stupid she is being a writer
@@qnzsd4803 she is not a writer wo sirf star plus k dramas k scenes pick kar k tere bin bana daiti hy
@@zahidshah4550 star plus pe kabhi male lead jo itna acha shuru se dikhaya gaya ho vo ye harkat nhi karta hai jo murtasim k lie inhone likha tha k vo MR karega..agar protagonist hai or itna respectful banda hai uske lie aisa scene likhna is quite disgusting
@@qnzsd4803 g bilkul aur isi male lead ko bewi sy chanta parna aur us par thoka jana bhi nai banta....actually ye writer k apni soch hi morally ill hy
This is totally sick, basically the whole drama was about the normalisation of marital rape as a "punishment" , and the Ost was always about MR, they just used fhe word "bewafay" because they can't use the real word.
And for the FEMALE writer is a normal thing in a romantic relationship, like a normal fight, because they showed Murtasim like a romantic hero, not as a villain, how could the actors and the production agree at this in the first place?! For me even the actors lost all the respect
Shame on the writer being a woman she is glorifying rape. No right thinking woman will fall in love with her rapist. Hated that I watched the drama initially. still offended by it
@@nishih292jb reality hti haina wahan wo admi shuru sy khabes hta h...lekin isko murtasim itna acha q dikhaya jb yhi negative tha to.
@@nishih292 what reality?? So it happens does it mean it has to happen. What kind of twisted mind are you in. A romance based on rape is not romance. Some things are just black and white. If they wanted to portray rape why make murtasim to be a righteous person
@@nishih292
and 1 more thing, Rape is committed by humans without any basic self control as in animals. And humans are not animals. Some things are unacceptable. Which woman will fall in love with her rapist. Such regressive thoughts.
Quite happy to see the team that took this step to edit those scenes. This was really needed!
I love that you guys are on top of this issue and addressing it in a timely manner - great job and lots of love from Detroit, USA ❤❤❤
From Cleveland Ohio ❤🇺🇸👍🙏
We are in love with yumna and wahaj from India
Tere bin is best drama ever becoz of yumhaj chemistry... luv wahaj nd yumna performance... mostly yumna zaidi is finest best actress luv her expression nd acting... plzz yumhaj aur ek drama karre together
Thank you Hassan for acknowledging the uproar from Indian viewers and I'm proud of it. It was extremely dangerous to have shown an influential character like Murtasim khan do such a thing. Either people would have normalised it due to his charm because it's a tendecy of some girls and boys would have taken it as an example or an example would have been set that there's nothing like a good man because they've shown him do all the right stuff. They must have been out of their heads to progress towards something like this. Love you Aamna ❤ as usual really enjoyed your humour and the way you took the situation.. chef's kiss 😘
They destroyed this drama
When they shooted last few episdes they already knew tht this going to be a superhit drama in tht time they should chnged the story whatever Its nice they tried to chnge it now by editing.I hope yumna mam and wahaj sir will come together with a great story in future.Bcz this drama distraught us.We want to see them together with a well written story
Yumna zaidi deserves appreciations❤❤ unhone murtasim k character ko safe Kiya ha...
Her performance was outstanding..
Agreed, she was so good this week 💯
I just want to say that the way the drama team turned the story around has offended me even more. Jb bhi Murtasim ko oonchy maqam pe bithana ho to Meerab pe keechar daal do that's the only solution they have and that's what they have been doing since Meerab and Murtasim's marriage.
Exactly my point of view. Nooran mukhdom did blunder
Always be positive about murtasim guys, let me tell what is behind story,lets make it logical,
Murtasim locked the door and turned back, meerab shouts why you locked the door, what are you willing to do,
He replied, you know it very well whatt i can do with you, but i am gentle man and i respect you,
She said, oh you are gentle man, who was flirting with haya,
He replied, forgot saik meerab "shakal achi na hoto bat achi krliya kro or tmari to shakal bhi achi he to bat to achi kro, wese hi aaj tm bht pyari bhi lg rhi ho"
He respond, pyare to tm bhi lg rhe ho pr hayaa,
Murtasim said, yar haya ki bat bech me nhi laao, why would i hug her when i still didn't touch you without your consent,
Merab said me iska kya matlab smjhun??
He replied jo smjh aarha he smjhlo, both smiled.....🙃🙃🙃
Now they are regretting, yarrr maryam ki rukhsati ka to wait krlete...😂😂😂😂😮😮😮😅
@@Overdosed_On_Tea because meerab didn't want it, she needed more time, and she couldn't resist dashing murtasim, she did it with her will of lust and it was not her conscious decision, so the murtasim knows same and he is also sad for her,,
Kuch bhi hojae hm murtasim ko Ganda hota hua nhi dekh skte 😀😀❤️❤️
28:20 'We are all most let to believe she assaulted him " amna was so funny😂
HOW TO MAKE SENSE OF TERE BIN !
The root of this drama at a very basic level, is internal conflict - between Meerub’s principles and her attraction to Murtasim. She is brought up as a liberated, progressive young woman by her adoptive parents and prides herself on protecting the rights of others. Friends of the opposite sex, and one of these male friends hosting a birthday for her, is not seen as controversial, she’s a typical progressive “city” girl. Her adoptive parents are clearly open minded and let her dream that she will become a lawyer. From this backdrop, she is yanked out of her life, told she is adopted and that she must marry her feudalist cousin, ending her life as she envisages it. She appears to have very little control over her future, and in desperation, demands an impractical agreement from her future husband. Sadly, we learn that this is also a compromise for him, as he too does not agree that she should be forced into this union. As his love for her grows, she continues to struggle even as she is attracted to him. She cannot let herself “give in” to this caring individual, because he and this new life represents the end her of own individuality, and somehow “validate” the injustice of what she had to go through. Time and again, she attempts to “do the right thing” in her view (and usually fails even though her intention is pure). While Murtasim charms her with his constant attention and claims of love, she prefers to believe that someone like her can never be one with a guy who appears to have such traditional views of marriage and family. She likes the attention, is attracted to him, hates the dynamic between him and Haya, yet cannot allow herself to accept him. Haya fans the flames effectively, and her plots to create misunderstandings between Meerub and Murtasim, and eventually take a toll on that relationship when Meerub is sent to Karachi after her attempts to help Maryam unite with her supposed true love. Meerub is so enthusiastic about her cause that common sense does not prevail, all she can see is “victim” of the feudalist lifestyle who needs her help - unfortunate and undoubtedly a segway to keeping the lead couple #terebin.
On the night of Maryam’s nikkah, a lot of us were looking forward to their reconciliation. Meerub has been gradually realizing that Murtasim shares her values on a deeper level (he helps people, takes the high road (forgives the older Malik), protects his own), trusts her, reiterates his love for her at every opportunity, will do anything to keep her in his life, and that she is undeniably attracted to him. If all went well, one would expect them to reflect on events, profess their love, and a beautiful union would ensue.
As luck would have it, with another one of Haya’s tricks afoot, this misunderstanding is the cause of an ugly faceoff between the two protagonists. One could argue that while Meerub knows full well that Haya is totally capable of this, she “prefers” to believe Murtasim is not innocent either as that would mean acknowledging that he truly loves her and accepting her own attraction to him. Tsunami like emotions create a scenario where they fight and then surrender to each other, once that always open bedroom door is finally locked! When the waves subside, each of them must face the reality of “how” the marriage was consummated. Meerub must acknowledge that her attraction to her husband proved stronger than her own values, and Murtasim has to live with the fact that he was not strong enough to hold out until she acknowledged her love for him. Certainly not traditionally romantic, although I would argue far more powerful, especially for Meerub, whose attraction for Murtasim is like an electric undercurrent (think Cat on a hot tin roof - Elizabeth Taylor/Paul Newman). Sparks fly, and the rest is history.
For those of us who believe in fate, this was one such fateful incident. Meerub’s path to realizing that they are meant for each other will not be easy - she said as much herself. Absence makes the heart grow fonder - once he is no longer there to profess his undying love, we hope she will reflect on his qualities, and how much he changed to be her ideal partner (the old Murtasim would not have forgiven his enemies, tolerated a sister’s affair or encouraged that Meerub continue her studies). The bond that was created between them in the time they were together will only strengthen with her pregnancy, and hopefully she will realize that they are not so different after all!
Any notion that their union was anything but consensual would create an irredeemable scenario for the progression of the drama, as it would pit Meerub against Murtasim yet again, and could only result in them living their lives #terebin. We will never know for sure what the writer intended - perhaps she will categorically confirm or deny this at some point. A happy ending is absolutely within reach now, but I do hope that along the way Meerub realizes that while they started out as two people from very different backgrounds, they have evolved into two individuals who not only share key values, their “ishq” for each other compels them to spend the rest of their lives together.
Omg what an explanation of the plot story of tere bin. It makes sense. I hope they will realize that they are incomplete without each other ❤❤
U wrote the review so well....am also from India
I am an Indian fan of TB and just love the show. I was also disturbed by the marital rape thought n was happy to note that it was edited. Aamna and Hassan are doing a wonderful job in educating the fans about marital rape, and no matter what, every woman has a right to say NO. NO MEANS NO.
Aamna and Hassan are very responsible and sensible people who are addressing this issue very sensitively. Thanks and kudos to them both.
At the same time not talking about spit & slap ,sorry do not approve
in today's episode 48 what a stellar performance by Yumna ....she sacrificed her character but her performance was top notch,heart wrenching..got shiver when she is all alone with no one around.....great execution Yumna great execution 👍👏👏
Ys she is amazing uske or b ache seane honge Kal k episode me jb murtasim usse assault krta hoga sb ruined ho gye wo ek jagh baith kr kaap rhi thi haya k samne sb cut kr diye
The journey of Tere Bin from being the Best Drama to the most Trash drama of the year.
Thanks Wahaj and Yumna for giving us Meerab and Murtasim but you deserved better and the audience deserved better for the immense love that they have given to the drama.
Why is no one talking about slapping and spitting on the husband? What a load of crap was this episode of tere bin. Made NO sense at all.
I don’t know when everything was getting better and Merab was falling in love with Murtasim why did she write MR in the story, Why??🤷♀️
She can breach the contract in a very good manner. I’m still in shock at how terrible her writing skills are, horrible turns and twists OMG🙆♀️
if the producers hadn’t change it than Tere Bin was completely and utterly ruined for audience on episode 47🤮
This writer has shoved Hayas shameless unwanted character in our faces from the very first episode, mark my words Haya will never get punished for her evil actions by this writer 🤦♀️
Agreed!
They'll never give haya the punishment she deserves..after Murtasim writer has focused the most upon haya's character,she's always winning 😏
Like Malik Zubair....who has been written off...no punishment
That's why I have been hating this writing from the beginning of tb
Yes. I have said it earlier episode 46 and specifically 47 could have been the best episodes with the highest TRPs if only madame Makdoum had thought of doing a proper confession from Meerub and then consummation of marriage. Just to put a separation track and prolong our misery they stupidly had to put this track.
Tere bin is a living proof that when greed comes in the picture the brains fly out of the window
The guilt came from the fact that When the act eventually happened ; it happened because of anger and not love. That’s heartbreaking for them as for months there has been extremely passionate flirting going on as a build up to what would have been the “perfect” consummation of love. And not just the submission to a carnal instinct - which is what this was.
Thank you Amna and Hassan for this beautiful and sensible review! It was very responsible of you guys explaining in detail what our religion says about a husband and wife’s relationship.
Sad that the writer did not pay attention to this point cause otherwise MR would not been written initially.
Anyways glad that finally it was not shown.
In this review, Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene and enjoying. Specially taking about keeping shoes during sex is too much. Looks like both are enjoying the sex topic.It's look like Hasan and Amna are doing review of Porn movie. 40:20 minutes Amna want to talk again about sex scene, then Hasan said may be they tried a sex position which was hurt to Merab, OMG, How both are talking openly abt sex scene in Detail, both are tharki reviewer. Shame on you Hasan & Amna. I think both of you share yours sex life. Shame on you. I was thinking this review by Indians, not Pakistani. We can't accept such review. May be Hasan & Amna are talking about sex scene for Indian people. Even other people also review episode#47 of Teray Bin didn't review the way Hasan & Amna did in a vulgar way..
Appreciate you reviewing Tere Bin episodes individually. There is way too much happening around it but not necessarily in it. Your platform allows for us to vent and share our thoughts. So thank you!
We still have to give it to team that they changed it in last minute ! Also i just love yumhaj they are so adorable i hope whenever they decide to work together next time i hope they choose some sane script ❤❤ #love Meerasim 😍❤️
Thank you for the review, guys. And for helping us make sense of the situation. We are heart broken that they played with us as an audience. I just about started watching Pak dramas, but now I'm put off watching anything further. It breaks my heart to say this but I am disappointed in Wahaj and Yumna. I trusted the actors when starting to watch TereBin, but I feel let down. The TB team just seems to be so proud of their ratings, TRPs and keeps posting only about this on social media. They haven't acknowledged us as their audience or our sentiments. We have been badly hurt. :( I don't know what they're so proud of.. :(
Episode no 47 is only 32 minutes long and your reaction video is 52 minutes long. You guys were only concerned about only one thing …. 😂😂😂😂😂
They are really cashing in on it!
Agree i just want to appreciate yumna she is not only good actress she is selfless human being she literally slaughtered her character for saving murtasim and tere bin 😢❤God bless u yumna
Hassan and Amna are not coming slow. Back to back reviews. ❤️
The reason Tere Bin got so out of control is to become "trending" and to grab eyeballs. So disappointed with how this series is going.
Now when I look at the poster I can see Murtasim looking sinister.
actually, now i am thinking that how did the makers not see this backlash coming? this show has been garnering views and ratings like never before since its starting . it has been getting unprecedented love. more than anything else, the love for murtasim and wahaj especially for playing the character, has been unmatched. how then, did they not see that murtasim taking such an action would literally shatter the audience? iska andaaza pehle ho jaana chahiye tha aur pehle hi reshoot kar lena chahiye tha. maybe they thought people would be okay with MR being slipped in for sensationalism, but that’s just unacceptable.
Tthey could've shown that HAYA was dreaming about this scene and reality nothing happened between them❤
Seriously.
Murtasim locked the door and approached meerab in anger her dupatta fells off , he throws things around scaring her sone more & asks her if he decides to take her then and there there is no escape ..tears of disbelief in her eyes melts murtasim s anger as if seeing meerab afraid of him has punched him in his gut..he moves back and says he did everything in his power to give her respect and value her consent in the relationship...despite living together and having feelings for her it was him who always held himself back because acc to him " merrab ki marzi & khushi were above his desires" ..but now he has realised that no matter what he does meerab would never accept him ..she will always have rohail in her life .. and now he doesn't want to be with a girl who spits on him and thinks he deserves to be bound by a contract to stay away from her ..
He goes in washroom cries and breaks mirrors ..
Meanwhile meerab feels stupid for coming to wedding to see murtasim and make things right she has flashbacks of " aurat mard ko mukamal krti hai" she removes all the jewellery in anger ( she had dressed up for murtasim) she cries her makeup get smudged and hair undone .. she sits on floor and cries her heart out ..
Haya enters taunts meerab ..meerab holds her hand and throws her out of the room ..realizes that it might be haya s plan and murtasim might be telling truth all along ..
Murtasim comes out and is about to leave she holds him back and tells that she has always only trust one man in her life i.e her dad and the trust was broken brutally.... he gave her freedom to live express and snatched it all in just a blink .. and she felt orphaned and was forced into a marriage with murtasim by the same man...
And now she has started feeling for murtasim in karachi .. she missed him and realised that he is an important part of her life that she cant live without.. she also admits that maryam was not the only reason she came for the wedding.. she couldn't bear that murtasim thinks she has rohail in her life...she confesses that she cant see murtasim not trusting her ..his trust in her means alot to her ..
She moves ahead and holds his injured hand bandages it and they both heal each other ☺
....
That is what i wanted to happen ..
P. S in the morning maybe murtasim can tease her about the contract that last night it seemed it was more difficult for meerab to abide by the conditions than murtasim 😂
@@Escapist... ❤ wish they still change it or re shoot and show someflashbacks 😭
Hasan and Aamna, you are both THE best critics. I love watching your show, you are informed, balanced and witty in equal measure. Aamna, you so articulately explained the Islamic reason why men are not permitted to force themselves on their wives . It causes pain and this is not permissible in our religion, simple!
I am so pleased you reviewed episode 47 today as I couldn’t wait to hear your thoughts. I think the makers tried their best to salvage the situation however, in doing so, I agree they have caused confusion. That said, despite the weak cover up, I am relieved Murtasim was able to claw back his saint like Muslim husband persona. Why Meerub is crying and ashamed is beyond anyone? I mean, why should she be consumed with guilt, like, come on dear, your husband is Murtasim, need I say more lol! Thanks for yet another fab review Hasan and Aamna, your fan from the UK 😊
Just My Thoughts:
They could have executed the plot differently but nicely. For example, when Merub came to Mariam's nikah and Murtasim, she could express her affection and love to Murtasim so that they could come on good terms with each other. As the deal wasn't broken yet, they could have shown some jealousy/teasing of Merub for Murtasim in response to Merub taking Murtasim into the room and breaking the contract. And they could handle each other's intimate feelings beautifully. Then they could create a misunderstanding with Haya so that they could enter the separation phase.
So the same night they could broke the contract , Mirab could be free (uski azadi ki din) and cry a lot. With this, they could justify their wedding day night conversation.
So true❤❤❤
Apparently, Meerab was fuming in so much anger that they had sex in the middle of the fight. Tere Bin is proven to be a real enemies to lovers because out of all the moments she could've given in she did it when they were both angry.
that's exactly what happened and aaj kal i think this is normal in any relationship, dekho, like many relationships are toxic and people fight and meerasim are just one of them. bahut realistic script change we all did lol.
Amna Issani you are well educated and no doubt one of the best critic of Pakistani entertainment industry.
And you guessed it so right.
You don't make judgement and review randomly.
Lots of love. No one guessed it Would be love and hate kind of scene by Meerub and Murtasim.
Yumna🧡🧡🔥🔥🔥that’s it… she’s the saving grace of tere bin❤ Her each & every single expressions were just so on point… she is one of the finest actress🧡🧡most of the time all the reviewers/ people are so madly in obsessed with their so called charming hero that they do not even want to give credit to yumna but man u have to accept the fact that yumna has given life to Meerab’s character❤ the production house has done real injustice with her this time & it’s not fair at all.. just to save your Hero you can’t just destroy your female lead.. that’s absurd…
Totally agreed with hassan and amna. We r so happy that they listen us and made changes for viewer's. Sad part is many viewer is still asking for real episode which includes marital rape. We should be thankful that they removed the wrong part and save such a lovely character like #murtasim and #meerasim i know some odd happened in episode and story bcz the sudden change but m happy they didn't make love story in to tragic love story. Now we have wait to see how they serve next episodes with this scenario that i m interested to see.
31:30 I had same thought . N even after intimacy resulted due to weak moment , someone would feel angry , frustrated or may be avoiding other one but not hurt n wrecked
Appreciated that maker respected audience backclash...n changed the episode..love love yumna.
It's a big lesson to writer, producer,director and actors not to do this mistakes in future. They ruined such a beautiful drama just to get gain trp...and i request actors like yumna and wahaj not to shoot scenes like spitting, slapping, marital rape..better leave the project in between...although they perform extraordinary but it gave a bad impact on society...giving a wrong message...because of backlash changes they made was also absurd..It's was better to reshoot and gave us a happy ending as hassan and amna said.
So,it's humble request not to play with the emotions of audience in future🙏.
.
Idk who is complaining about your regular videos. Must be some lifeless people.
Something haute is like our family, we discuss everything at our home after something is trending or something we are interested in we always discuss it, so it’s a platform where we all can discuss or vent out our thoughts.👍🏻
Sex between husband and wife, consensual, isn't dirty. Why is it being portrayed as shameful in this episode? I think it's wrong
The entire episode was chopped so badly nd the voiceovers made it even worse , when the actors already knew it was MR scene the foremost thing is why did they agree to do such scene
I would request you both to let the producer and the writer know that they can still fix it by re-shooting rest of the episodes .
Also give some sense/ reason of why Murtasim needs to apologize to Meerub when it was all consensual and she was the one who slapped and spit on him .
Yumna zaidi is best actress her expression her acting is best everrr yumna zaidi hats off❤❤❤👏👏👏👏 yumna zaidi luv her acting
Meerab saved Murtasim
Yumna saved Wahaj
❤❤
Wow Amna and Hasan such a wonderful and HAUTE discussion on Tere Bin. It was both serious and funny. You made our day! Wonderful thumbs upto to you both!👍
Yes 👍
Did they acknowledge the slap.and spit that it was wrong? Ive not watch the full show?
I think drama makers should have ended the show at episode 46 after this backlash. And they can come up again with season 2 with a good storyline where Meerub will confess her love and try to win Murtasim's heart because now Murtasim will be in Meerub's place. That way they will get time to reshoot. Audience would be happy to see yumhaj again and drama makers will be back in business.
I absolutely love you guys! I laughed so much watching you both ! Always completely on point with your analysis and reviews. A real pleasure to watch xx
This episode of tere bin was the most hilarious episode ever 🤣 lol. It was so senseless but that is what tere bin is from the start ( even more now yes). But it was nice that they edited it still better than the original one I think.