Tickets for Through the Griffin TOUR are ON SALE NOW! supercarlinbrothers.com/events/ Tour dates: Boston - 6/2 New York City - 6/3 Philadelphia - 6/5 Washington, D.C. - 6/13 SEE YOU IN REAL LIFE BROTHER!
I think A Bug's Life is more important to the Pixar Theory than it seems. Flik being able to invent machinery and the ants staging a revolution against the grasshoppers is another example of animals increasing intelligence.
Plus, it also shows that animals are evolving based solely on their lifespans. It's made quite clear the grasshoppers have been enslaving the ants for years and Hopper seems to have been their leader throughout the entire enslavement. Normally, insects and arachnids have lifespans of between a mere 24 hours to a few months at best. So, for both the grasshoppers and the ants to have lived long enough that they can say they've done it for years says the animals have already evolved to survive far longer than is naturally possible in our time
Just wanta put my two cents in.....A Bug's Life explains how we got the monsters in Monsters Inc. Example, Mr Waternoose looks like a mutant spider, that's because he was once a regular spider intill the radiation from BNL changed him. Randall looks like a mutated chameleon. Ms Roz is a mutated Slug. I know Boo thinks Sully is a bear but what if his family where once bears? We know Sully has family because In M.U. his father was once one of the top Students there.
A theory for y’all to investigate… Question: Why are Riley’s memories in the third person POV? Answer: Because it’d be hard for the audience to understand what was happening if they were in first person POV like real memories. Better answer: Notice they aren’t ALL in third person. Her first memory is in fact first person. The next memories we see are made when Riley is a toddler, and those are third person. This is because, as an infant, Riley does not understand the concept of self as distinct from the rest of the world. Her perceptions are the entirety of reality. So a memory, a perception of the world, is through only her own eyes. But humans quickly learn that they are corporeally finite and that other people and the rest of the world are separate from themselves. When Riley is old enough to get this, her memories show her new understanding by shifting to a third person POV. By viewing memories this way, Riley has the ability to try to view situations from others’ POVs, to understand how she might be perceived by others’, etc.
Seamus Gorman rebooted the Pixar Theory when he tried connecting all of the films using easter eggs. He metaphorically whiped the board and started over.
Couple questions: how does Boo find out what the second death is and how to circumvent it? Also, wouldn't Sully still be vulnerable to the second death as normal because Boo never exists in a time after Sully dies? Seems like to avoid the second death you'd need to have someone be immortal in the normal sense first to go on remembering someone forever.
For the first question, I think they explain that as Boo grows up, she would look for ways to get to Sully under the assumption it’s magic. This would lead to her uncovering metaphysical truth about her world, none the least being the second death. As for the second, you might be right. I’ll need to go back and see if the Bothers covered that.
My thoughts exactly mate, not that bothered about part one, we can reason that it could be a tradition where she happens to be from or something. Part 2 however, you're correct. Unless Boo is alive in the monster world after Sully's death, OR he has been brought back into the human world via the door then he's a goner. Boo can create as many time loops as she likes, Sully will still die twice eventually. Taking this seriously for a second, however... if spirit Sully was able to walk through the doors, however, he could his spirit alive forever by returning to times when Boo (i keep typing Buu and that's just not the right universe at all hahahah) is alive or when Mike and co are alive, but you'd eventually end up with infinite Sullys lol
@@justdavelewisbut technically, she caused her own creation and is destined to go back into brave, and it’s easy to assume she was about to die when her past self went back, especially since she was trying to make a loop and she would have to think ahead a bit if someone were to remember someone in the pass, it would echo through time, especially if they make it so it loops and keeps making themselves do it Also, everyone has a second death, even if you are someone like Taylor swift or smth, eventually you will be forgotten because the memory of you can’t be kept up, however due to boo being in the past and looping her going to the past, she is always existing in a time period somewhere and keeps his memory alive, and according to how memory and time works in the Pixar universe, he is legitimately immune to second death
I would LOVE a TV Series about a 20 something Boo going on an Adventure trying to find Sully going throw different Doors using some kind of Machine she made but it sends her to different Times and she has Adventures in very Time Period she goes too and she learns Magic along the way. Then she arrives in Ancient Scotland and gets stuck there. That would be so Awesome. Respect and keep up the epic work.
My addition to the Pixar Theory: I like to think that Tia from Cars, and EVE from WALL-E, are one in the same, because they're both voiced by Pixar employee Ellisa Knight. So I basically think that towards the end of the Car age, Tia uploaded her consciousness to the Axiom to continue living. Which was then downloaded into an Extra-terrestrial Vegatation Evaluatior droid, or EVE, hence making them one in the same.
2:44 I was 6 when Inside out first came out. And Now I’m 15 and The sequel comes out in 3 months. 4:26 Elemental Is Pixar’s Zootopia. FR. I actually just subscribed. This is my first time subscribing to a channel.
Im a fiem believer of the Pixar theory for the most part. Ironically, the one part that I've just never been able to believe is Boo being the Witch lol
He is not remembered for a longer duration of time just because she time travels into the past, from her persepctive he is immortal, but in the time after she has traveled back to the past, in the future she left, he is dead.
Ooh it was my favorite as a kid! It's instant oatmeal with these little brown sugar pellets that dissolve when hot water is added, revealing little sugar dino shapes. 😊
How does travelling to the past prevent Sully's second death? It's clear that the afterlife also runs parallel with the "present". Otherwise NO ONE would ever be forgotten because there'd always be someone in the past to remember them. In his case it would be the Monstropolis time period and forward that would have to remember Sully.
I have always viewed it that it's about the complexity of time, the idea that if you take someone's memory back to before they even existed, ensures that it will be remembered in the future because its possible that the afterlife works on a sort of, weird plane. I can't describe what I'm thinking without sounding like I'm just talking you down... the Curse of a philosophy major, so if you want to know what I mean or want me to elaborate by all means ask, but I won't force it down your throat 😂
It’s day 42 of the quest and the “great question” I have is can you cover a Percy Jackson series. On a more serious note though, the Pixar theory has been something I’ve enjoyed the most about this channel, I’m glad to see a return to it.
I believe when Hector explained the rules, he meant that you have to hear the story from someone who knew the person in life, so Miguel and his family after hearing about hector from coco before she passed allowed hector to live further. Also, extrapolating this, it’ll probably mean that if you pass this first condition, you can now pass stories of the person you didn’t know in life and it’ll still keep the story alive since you’re hearing it. That’s what I wanna believe anyway.
@@samurexatlas7373 I interpreted it as Miguel's memories don't count so long as he's in the land of the dead (he effectively being "dead" himself), thus, he couldn't save Chicharrón. But they did count once he returned the land of the living. But that raises the question of whether or not Miguel coming back to life with memories of Chicharrón would bring him back from the after-afterlife as well?
@@Devlinator61116 I think once someone dies a second death, they are permanently gone. So no matter what happened, even if someone found some record of him, or Miguel told people about Chicharron, he doesn't come back because he already experienced a second death. I also get the feeling that Hector would still have died (again) if Coco didn't tell the family about him for the same reason you mentioned; Miguel's memories don't count because he was "dead" and the memories have to be passed by someone who was living. Otherwise, why would it have been important to "Remember Me" if Miguel could do it himself? It had to be Coco to pass down Hector's memories because memories from the Land of the Dead don't count.
@@yaroslavpanych2067, given that their existence is their job, I doubt there is a difference between his occupation and his species. It's not like Joy has a different name she uses in off-hours.
People forget emotions are chemicals reactions are not the chemicals themselves computers can have impuses and wavelengths going through their circuits
I was actually hoping there, he would make this point by showing the "mixed emotion" orbs. ...I suppose one can argue that an exchange of charge through protons and electrons is a chemical reaction as well? Or is that physics? ...I think it's "just" physics... oh, well. But then isn't chemistry "physics with chemical change"? And does that even apply when the through charges transmitted code / information that changes the resulting code / information? There's no chemicals / hormones involved like in the brain for emotions, and thus far we don't have (or aren't aware of ;) ) AIs that "feel"... but if we/they evolved them this far it would be a mere "informational reaction", which would be their equivalent of a chemical reaction (as theirs would be virtual while we need things more tangible/physical, hence chemical). This doesn't actually harm the theory much, in fact strengthens it, as the second-death is about the memory, the *information* of a being/person being lost... In terms of thoughts/emotions, these chemical and physical reactions, too, are the transference of energy/electric signals, charge, and, in a sense, information (action potentials, oscillations, zeroes and ones), just with an exchange of particles, atoms and molecules. So, yes. You made a good point, that makes this meta-memory theory more plausible even. And, this is good news for Wall-E, Eva and friends!
I see some connections of Ratatouille and wall.e based on a true story.. The world rats live in belong to their enemies not just humans snakes cats dogs birds. But I. End they a place don't to worry about any of them. That happened in real life and they ended. Up like the humans on the accium
I never thought about the colors in Elemental being connected to the emotions. That is a really interesting detail. Pixar is crazy if they think we will believe that they did not plan on connecting all of these movies.
I have a theory that the little girl that Sully sees after fixing boos door is not boo but her daughter. The reason she calls Sully kitty is because boos is a writer and writes children books based on her memories of the monster world but she thinks they were just dreams. If they ever make a true sequel she will have an existential crisis and have to come to terms with the fact that all those things were real and not dreams.
Did Carl Double kill Ellie when has through his stuff out to make his house litter did the mind workers throw out memories of her causing her the final death
So… you never talked about a bugs life in og Pixar theory of Pixar theory 2022.. so what DID they actually do? Also this is most important… but you should do least important
The og is older. The 2022 is a recap of it n also adding the newest movies upto that point (which I think it was Lightyear). N it is mentioned as a throw away line during the end I think it goes something like 'oh and at somepoint there's talking bugs butthey don't really matter cause it doesn't affect the theory at all' I like to think is like Finding Nemo, they have their own little world ( and we know there's humans cz there's a bug with a sign that says "Help, a kid broke my wings" . So place them where ever u want. Me personally I like to think is in a human place somewhere in Monster Inc, cz the city in A Bugs Life is in a erh similar if not the same place where Randell comes out of the closet.
In the real civilization inside your body has many copies of memories and takes out pages of less prioritized memories . But still memories going to the hear to longs and exhaled maybe the chemicals their imprinted on stay but their energy is exhaled
But how does memories keeping someone alive in the afterlife work with time travel? When is the present considered to be so that it can be decided if you should experience the final death or not?
If anything, going backwards in time partway through your life should just make Sulley's second death come that much sooner. But even then, if the doors are ALREADY time-travely in nature, she's either already succeeded by virtue of meeting him at all, or time travel won't save him. At this point we would need a movie specifically geared towards answering this question. And boy howdy, if we got THAT, I'd believe someone in Pixar is backing this theory intentionally (even if only after the fact due to its popularity). There's certainly a case to be made for Elements specifically invoking Inside Out's memory orbs and colors; it seems like that's VERY intentional, though it could potentially be for unrelated reasons. So maybe it's already happening, but maybe it isn't.
@@riluna3695 Yeah, agree. The memory is relevant in the time it is remembered. However, Boo creating and planting memorabilia of Sulley in the past, may create some sort of meta-memory; even if people won't know him personally just his image being ever present may count (like with that musician guy), esp. if it become a sort of archeologic find or mythical description that keeps popping up. Other than that, I think Boo's time travel may not be all that related to the second death. I'd think her memories of spending time at Monsters Inc. would made her seek out the "strange" things that are sorely amiss in her/our so very rational time, so going back to a time when myths and monsters were real seems like a good place to fill that sentimentality over her childhood experiences. So, yeah, still connected, but we may still yet find out through more movies how, and this may not be it yet (I need to rewatch Onward, there may be some more connected tissue hidden in it? The ongoing evolution and the father being (partly) pulled from a death-realm? If Boo had gone there / a presumably post-Wall-E future, then the keeping Sully's memory alive would be a much clearer case). How does Soul fit into this particular theory anyway?
The Pixar Theory is absolutely awesome, it's one of my favourite theories ever. But there is one problem: How does Boo time travel? She seems to exist in the mid 1950s and given that the average human lifespan is around 80 years, by the time she dies, it's 2030. Where in the world would she have gotten the technology to time travel in the year 2030? How would she do it? There isn't a single mention of time travel aside from Monster's Inc, but that takes place about 3000 years after Wall-e, which itself takes place 700 years after the films with humans like Up or Toy Story. Basically, the time travel technolgoy from the Monster world could work and send Boo back to Medieval Scotland but by the time she exists, it won't be invented for another 3750 years. Also, side note, the only Pixar movie that actively contradicts the whole "memories are important" thing is Cars. McQueen is shown to really dislike the idea of fame and having a remembered legacy. In Cars 3, Sterling says to him that retiring is the best thing for him because he'd be so much more famous and worth much more when he retires than he could ever be on the track. McQueen absolutely hates this. He doesn't do the racing for fame, he does it for himself. In Cars 1, McQueen refuses the Piston Cup and the Dinoco sponsorship simply because he's happy where he is, he feels he doesn't need the extra fame and is content losing the race and remaining at Rusteze. If McQueen had won that race and not helped The King, he would've been the most successful racer in history. The known record for Piston Cup wins is tied between The King and Lightning McQueen both having 7 Piston Cups each (though McQueen achieved that a lot faster). If McQueen had won that race and not let Chick win, he would have had 8 Piston Cups in 10 years, an absolute record. And having 5 Piston Cups in a row, and being the first rookie to win a Piston Cup. He would've have broken 3 racing records in his 10 year career. And he refuses it all for the sake of his friend (helping The King) and for his own happiness. Doc Hudson also goes on a path of having his old self completely forgotten after his crash, completely unlike that of Mr Incredible. Cars really is the oddball in the Pixar Theory
The Pixar Theory is really just a bunch of nonsense (born of a "capital mistake"), but, for the sake of argument, perhaps when Boo got older, she hid out in a child's room so she could sneak into the monsters' time, where time travel exists. That does raise another problem, though, because, as is established in the video, time travel in the monsters' time has only been seen to work on a sliding timeline, so Boo wouldn't be able to go any further back in time than when she left. So she would have to figure out how to improve time travel (as well as learn magic in a world where it does not seem to exist).
Pixar has long been against the Pixar Theory. They are not in any way trying to encourage it. It is just a bunch of nonsense come up with by a fan who, in Jay Ward's words (Pixar Creative Director), "had a lot of time on their hands. They may have had some other recreational activities..."
It has been such a stressful day. I don't want to hear about politics or differences of opinion, or about negative things. I just want to watch something that makes me a little happy. Waves wand..... Alohamora happiness..... Heeeeey Brother! Much better.
5:30 Since its to do with the "elements", as in fire and water, which aren't real elements, its probably more of a alchemical reaction than a chemical one.
I would love to see Super Carlin Brothers make an extensive video about The Tommy Westphall Universe. Maybe even do a collaboration with New Rockstars about the whole thing.
Thank god the sponsor isn't Better Help anymore... I love your content, but I admit, I had to stop watching for a bit because I couldn't stomach watching you guys support such a nasty business that has hurt so many people. >_
I can't believe you didn't include The Incredibles in the 5 most important Pixar theory movies. I feel like its more important than elemental. Its when A.I is created which is a huge part of the Pixar theory
This is the epitome of looking for evidence to back up your headcanon, and ignoring the evidence that might actually disprove it lol (but of course, the absurdity of it is kind of the whole appeal of the Pixar Theory in the first place). XD
I feel like that's exactly the point of fan theories - coming up with what you think is real or could be real, and looking for evidence to make it real. I love fan theories!
Not a joke, I keep waiting for your Inside Out 2 theory. I saw your Pixar theory on Elemental and how it supposedly connects to the original Inside Out. Now that its sequel is near, I was impatient to see how you can further connect Elemental to the Pixar theory, thanks to Inside Out 2's new emotions. But seeing Elemental have a good role here is a genuine but welcome surprise.
I never laughed so hard at this nonsense theory. Talk about stretching the made up facts to fit the theory. Thanks you for making my morning. Your videos are always so much fun.
Love you guys but getting kind of tired of the editing where you guys feel like you have to move back and forth so frequently. Just constructive criticism do what you want 😊
I really don't want to spoil the mood but I feel the idea of immortality is a curse rather than a blessing. Just think, by keeping sully's spirit or memory alive, by using time travel boo is basically made sully immortal but also that means sully is going to stay so long in the spirit world that he will witness the second death of all the people in the spirit World including a potential second death of boo, the one who is keeping him alive. I hope it's in him best interest that the time travel anchor is extending his second death and not keeping him immortal. Or else, he might be the few or the last spirit that is kept alive. I really hope Pixar fixes this or else it means sully is going to be in "the good place" ending scenario where he instead takes step into a door or something to be forgotten and experience his second death willingly
I still can't wrap my head around this permanent loop. Sure, Boo goes to the past and remembers the future, but that only affects the past... not the future after her memories. And what happens when she dies? Thats what's going to end the memory. If she kept the loop because she travelled back in the past to remember him then, how is that different than anyone else remembering someone in the past? If the time of the memory is meaningless, the need to travel in time for the memory is, too. Her plan doesn't make sense. It makes sense that she went into magic and time travel to meet him again, but not to "keep his memory alive". She will eventually die, and with her, his memory.
They have lost the emotion that is attached to them. They just become generic facts rather than eliciting any emotional response upon recalling them. For instance, think of someone you used to know a long time ago but are now entirely indifferent to. The memories of time spent with that person once made you feel a certain way, but now you just remember those moments as things that happened. The feelings you felt then have dulled or gone away entirely.
It would have been nice to see you guys mention Alex Bale's Pixar Theory here, in case this video was in any way a response to it. It's worth a watch if you happen to be reading this and haven't seen it yet
No Wall-e? That is also important, as it is the only way that onward and cars fits in. By the way, in Soul, the lights in the hall of you are also related to emotions in inside out.
Other than it being nonsense this is the reason why I hate the Pixar theory, it implies an incredibly sad story for boo because she spends her entire life chasing after her friend and as we see in Brave never achieves her goal
I disagree with the conclusion for sully because the second she goes back in time or the fact that he dies in the future not the present so his soul at the time of his death does not have anyone named boo remembering him therefore he gets a second death like everyone else
Ok how I just had to go through comments in a facebook thread debunking the theory of is Abby Parks from turn red or Violet Parr from incredibles is Boo By stating Boo’s name is Mary Gibbs Then there the ages and years Violet is 14 in 1962 Abby is 13 in 2002 Mary is 2 in 1999 Also the theory that Mary is Violet child Um let look at the years and ages again Violet would be 49 at the birth of Mary So Grandchildren is possible if Violet was mid twenties when she was a mother 1973 (age 25) so that child could be aged 24 in 1997 for the birth of Mary. Well didn’t mean to write a mini theory there.
Tickets for Through the Griffin TOUR are ON SALE NOW!
supercarlinbrothers.com/events/
Tour dates:
Boston - 6/2
New York City - 6/3
Philadelphia - 6/5
Washington, D.C. - 6/13
SEE YOU IN REAL LIFE BROTHER!
LOVE YOUR CONTENT GUYS 😊😊😊❤❤❤
That timeline alter like it because the world split into worlds and save their existence and save the humanity furture
fun fact: if you look up jonathan carlin, it lists his occupation as "bens brother"
Who is that "IT"? Why I would ask random it for such things and trust the answer
True! 😂😂 Ben must be Google’s favorite Carlin lol 😂😂
I think A Bug's Life is more important to the Pixar Theory than it seems. Flik being able to invent machinery and the ants staging a revolution against the grasshoppers is another example of animals increasing intelligence.
Plus, it also shows that animals are evolving based solely on their lifespans.
It's made quite clear the grasshoppers have been enslaving the ants for years and Hopper seems to have been their leader throughout the entire enslavement.
Normally, insects and arachnids have lifespans of between a mere 24 hours to a few months at best.
So, for both the grasshoppers and the ants to have lived long enough that they can say they've done it for years says the animals have already evolved to survive far longer than is naturally possible in our time
And if you believe Matpat's entry it's the bugs that become the cars instead of the weird sentient adopted petsonalies cars
Just wanta put my two cents in.....A Bug's Life explains how we got the monsters in Monsters Inc. Example, Mr Waternoose looks like a mutant spider, that's because he was once a regular spider intill the radiation from BNL changed him. Randall looks like a mutated chameleon. Ms Roz is a mutated Slug. I know Boo thinks Sully is a bear but what if his family where once bears? We know Sully has family because In M.U. his father was once one of the top Students there.
*Woody* turned into *Flik* like *Big Red*
Well there's also finding Nemo and ratatouille. Same concept so same important you might say
A theory for y’all to investigate…
Question: Why are Riley’s memories in the third person POV?
Answer: Because it’d be hard for the audience to understand what was happening if they were in first person POV like real memories.
Better answer: Notice they aren’t ALL in third person. Her first memory is in fact first person. The next memories we see are made when Riley is a toddler, and those are third person. This is because, as an infant, Riley does not understand the concept of self as distinct from the rest of the world. Her perceptions are the entirety of reality. So a memory, a perception of the world, is through only her own eyes. But humans quickly learn that they are corporeally finite and that other people and the rest of the world are separate from themselves. When Riley is old enough to get this, her memories show her new understanding by shifting to a third person POV. By viewing memories this way, Riley has the ability to try to view situations from others’ POVs, to understand how she might be perceived by others’, etc.
It never fails that every time I hear Boo say, "Kitty..!" At the end of Monsters Inc, I get full body chills and just wanna cry lol
Finally another Supercarlinbrothers Pixar video!!!
As was so will be.
A child's wish to save her kitty.
*The Pixar Theory* is legit the more you watch *Pixar* Movies. Don’t let that go over your memory bank
The Pixar Theory: Re-Booted
Re-BOOted
Nailed it@@denvitar3128
@@SuperCarlinBrothersyep❤❤❤❤
Seamus Gorman rebooted the Pixar Theory when he tried connecting all of the films using easter eggs. He metaphorically whiped the board and started over.
Couple questions: how does Boo find out what the second death is and how to circumvent it?
Also, wouldn't Sully still be vulnerable to the second death as normal because Boo never exists in a time after Sully dies? Seems like to avoid the second death you'd need to have someone be immortal in the normal sense first to go on remembering someone forever.
For the first question, I think they explain that as Boo grows up, she would look for ways to get to Sully under the assumption it’s magic. This would lead to her uncovering metaphysical truth about her world, none the least being the second death.
As for the second, you might be right. I’ll need to go back and see if the Bothers covered that.
I think the infinite time loop covers the infinite memory 😊 it’s a closed time loop outside of normal events
My thoughts exactly mate, not that bothered about part one, we can reason that it could be a tradition where she happens to be from or something.
Part 2 however, you're correct. Unless Boo is alive in the monster world after Sully's death, OR he has been brought back into the human world via the door then he's a goner. Boo can create as many time loops as she likes, Sully will still die twice eventually.
Taking this seriously for a second, however... if spirit Sully was able to walk through the doors, however, he could his spirit alive forever by returning to times when Boo (i keep typing Buu and that's just not the right universe at all hahahah) is alive or when Mike and co are alive, but you'd eventually end up with infinite Sullys lol
@@justdavelewisbut technically, she caused her own creation and is destined to go back into brave, and it’s easy to assume she was about to die when her past self went back, especially since she was trying to make a loop and she would have to think ahead a bit
if someone were to remember someone in the pass, it would echo through time, especially if they make it so it loops and keeps making themselves do it
Also, everyone has a second death, even if you are someone like Taylor swift or smth, eventually you will be forgotten because the memory of you can’t be kept up, however due to boo being in the past and looping her going to the past, she is always existing in a time period somewhere and keeps his memory alive, and according to how memory and time works in the Pixar universe, he is legitimately immune to second death
I would LOVE a TV Series about a 20 something Boo going on an Adventure trying to find Sully going throw different Doors using some kind of Machine she made but it sends her to different Times and she has Adventures in very Time Period she goes too and she learns Magic along the way.
Then she arrives in Ancient Scotland and gets stuck there.
That would be so Awesome.
Respect and keep up the epic work.
My addition to the Pixar Theory: I like to think that Tia from Cars, and EVE from WALL-E, are one in the same, because they're both voiced by Pixar employee Ellisa Knight. So I basically think that towards the end of the Car age, Tia uploaded her consciousness to the Axiom to continue living. Which was then downloaded into an Extra-terrestrial Vegatation Evaluatior droid, or EVE, hence making them one in the same.
Bingbong and other Imaginary friends might be the monsters after monster inc.
2:44 I was 6 when Inside out first came out. And Now I’m 15 and The sequel comes out in 3 months. 4:26 Elemental Is Pixar’s Zootopia. FR. I actually just subscribed. This is my first time subscribing to a channel.
Do cars have souls and is Sally a lost soul her human life .
Abd when woke up a car. Thats and drove and drove
Im a fiem believer of the Pixar theory for the most part. Ironically, the one part that I've just never been able to believe is Boo being the Witch lol
I still love the Pixar theory because of how creative it is❤
He is not remembered for a longer duration of time just because she time travels into the past, from her persepctive he is immortal, but in the time after she has traveled back to the past, in the future she left, he is dead.
I like to think it's pixar's way of reminding us not to forget the things that make us feel alive
As an Englishman in his 30's, I have a question. What is dinosaur egg oatmeal? I don't think we have that here in England but sounds awesome.
Ooh it was my favorite as a kid! It's instant oatmeal with these little brown sugar pellets that dissolve when hot water is added, revealing little sugar dino shapes. 😊
@@tgbluewolf I need to try this 😁
This got a thumbs up from me the minute Ben "wondered who wrote this"!! 🤣😂
How does travelling to the past prevent Sully's second death? It's clear that the afterlife also runs parallel with the "present". Otherwise NO ONE would ever be forgotten because there'd always be someone in the past to remember them. In his case it would be the Monstropolis time period and forward that would have to remember Sully.
I have always viewed it that it's about the complexity of time, the idea that if you take someone's memory back to before they even existed, ensures that it will be remembered in the future because its possible that the afterlife works on a sort of, weird plane. I can't describe what I'm thinking without sounding like I'm just talking you down... the Curse of a philosophy major, so if you want to know what I mean or want me to elaborate by all means ask, but I won't force it down your throat 😂
@@lewisbeer6156explain please
It’s day 42 of the quest and the “great question” I have is can you cover a Percy Jackson series.
On a more serious note though, the Pixar theory has been something I’ve enjoyed the most about this channel, I’m glad to see a return to it.
Just for clarification the five titles are:
Elemental
Inside Out
Coco
Monster Inc
Brave
The universe doesn't forget. Time might be the great beyond
Why didn't Hector go to the great beyond even if you stick to the movie itself when CoCo died . And how did Stinky peat come Alive
Because Miguel and his family remembered him. Miguel vividly, and he returned before Coco died. So Hector lived. Sorta. Death is weird.
I believe when Hector explained the rules, he meant that you have to hear the story from someone who knew the person in life, so Miguel and his family after hearing about hector from coco before she passed allowed hector to live further. Also, extrapolating this, it’ll probably mean that if you pass this first condition, you can now pass stories of the person you didn’t know in life and it’ll still keep the story alive since you’re hearing it. That’s what I wanna believe anyway.
@@samurexatlas7373 I interpreted it as Miguel's memories don't count so long as he's in the land of the dead (he effectively being "dead" himself), thus, he couldn't save Chicharrón. But they did count once he returned the land of the living. But that raises the question of whether or not Miguel coming back to life with memories of Chicharrón would bring him back from the after-afterlife as well?
@@Devlinator61116 I think once someone dies a second death, they are permanently gone. So no matter what happened, even if someone found some record of him, or Miguel told people about Chicharron, he doesn't come back because he already experienced a second death.
I also get the feeling that Hector would still have died (again) if Coco didn't tell the family about him for the same reason you mentioned; Miguel's memories don't count because he was "dead" and the memories have to be passed by someone who was living. Otherwise, why would it have been important to "Remember Me" if Miguel could do it himself? It had to be Coco to pass down Hector's memories because memories from the Land of the Dead don't count.
Maybe boos Soul already had advantages being the oldest soul in universe
11:16 That doesn't add up, people are TERRIFIED of AI! XD
Bro i just gotta say that ending line and the sip of the mug for that long made me sub real quick😅
4:52 WAIT does this mean that the elements understand the concept of God???
6:52 The little jelly-bean characters from Inside Out are called Mind Workers.
Mind worker is his occupation, not his name or "species"
@@yaroslavpanych2067, given that their existence is their job, I doubt there is a difference between his occupation and his species. It's not like Joy has a different name she uses in off-hours.
@@SgtSupaman thank you.
@@SgtSupaman The Mind Workers have names in the cast list - Bobby and Paula, named after their voice actors Bobby Moynihan and Paula Poundstone.
A bugs life show critical stage in evolution 🧬 animals inventing
People forget emotions are chemicals reactions are not the chemicals themselves computers can have impuses and wavelengths going through their circuits
I was actually hoping there, he would make this point by showing the "mixed emotion" orbs.
...I suppose one can argue that an exchange of charge through protons and electrons is a chemical reaction as well? Or is that physics? ...I think it's "just" physics... oh, well. But then isn't chemistry "physics with chemical change"? And does that even apply when the through charges transmitted code / information that changes the resulting code / information? There's no chemicals / hormones involved like in the brain for emotions, and thus far we don't have (or aren't aware of ;) ) AIs that "feel"... but if we/they evolved them this far it would be a mere "informational reaction", which would be their equivalent of a chemical reaction (as theirs would be virtual while we need things more tangible/physical, hence chemical). This doesn't actually harm the theory much, in fact strengthens it, as the second-death is about the memory, the *information* of a being/person being lost... In terms of thoughts/emotions, these chemical and physical reactions, too, are the transference of energy/electric signals, charge, and, in a sense, information (action potentials, oscillations, zeroes and ones), just with an exchange of particles, atoms and molecules.
So, yes. You made a good point, that makes this meta-memory theory more plausible even. And, this is good news for Wall-E, Eva and friends!
A video with J always makes my day! 🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I see some connections of Ratatouille and wall.e based on a true story..
The world rats live in belong to their enemies not just humans snakes cats dogs birds. But I. End they a place don't to worry about any of them. That happened in real life and they ended. Up like the humans on the accium
Pixar theory is always a treat! YES PLEASE !Thanks 🔥🔥🔥🔥❤️❤️❤️
My 2 year old had a breakdown because I said "no thank you" when he offered me sandwich meat. 😂
I never thought about the colors in Elemental being connected to the emotions. That is a really interesting detail. Pixar is crazy if they think we will believe that they did not plan on connecting all of these movies.
Happy good friday guys ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏
I have a theory that the little girl that Sully sees after fixing boos door is not boo but her daughter. The reason she calls Sully kitty is because boos is a writer and writes children books based on her memories of the monster world but she thinks they were just dreams. If they ever make a true sequel she will have an existential crisis and have to come to terms with the fact that all those things were real and not dreams.
Elemental Will always be canon! Right guys?
The loop theory doesn't make sense though, because he would only be "safe" inside the loop. And he lives outside of the loop.
Did Carl Double kill Ellie when has through his stuff out to make his house litter did the mind workers throw out memories of her causing her the final death
Watching your videos every Wednesday and Friday is LITERALLY the best part of my week! Thanks for being SUPER! :)
So… you never talked about a bugs life in og Pixar theory of Pixar theory 2022.. so what DID they actually do? Also this is most important… but you should do least important
The og is older. The 2022 is a recap of it n also adding the newest movies upto that point (which I think it was Lightyear). N it is mentioned as a throw away line during the end I think it goes something like 'oh and at somepoint there's talking bugs butthey don't really matter cause it doesn't affect the theory at all'
I like to think is like Finding Nemo, they have their own little world ( and we know there's humans cz there's a bug with a sign that says "Help, a kid broke my wings" . So place them where ever u want. Me personally I like to think is in a human place somewhere in Monster Inc, cz the city in A Bugs Life is in a erh similar if not the same place where Randell comes out of the closet.
@@locabsgg94 I place them before the humans became monsters but after cars
How do them living on in Coco correlate to the way souls work in Soul?
Is it just me or does the land of the dead from Coco look like the city from elemental?
In the real civilization inside your body has many copies of memories and takes out pages of less prioritized memories .
But still memories going to the hear to longs and exhaled maybe the chemicals their imprinted on stay but their energy is exhaled
No mention of Soul
Unfortunately not.
It’s my favourite Pixar film by far.
Has an excellent soundtrack too
I remember your original upload as a subscriber. I'm 28 years old and feel like I've spent more of my life subscribed to you than not 🤣
But how does memories keeping someone alive in the afterlife work with time travel? When is the present considered to be so that it can be decided if you should experience the final death or not?
If anything, going backwards in time partway through your life should just make Sulley's second death come that much sooner. But even then, if the doors are ALREADY time-travely in nature, she's either already succeeded by virtue of meeting him at all, or time travel won't save him.
At this point we would need a movie specifically geared towards answering this question. And boy howdy, if we got THAT, I'd believe someone in Pixar is backing this theory intentionally (even if only after the fact due to its popularity). There's certainly a case to be made for Elements specifically invoking Inside Out's memory orbs and colors; it seems like that's VERY intentional, though it could potentially be for unrelated reasons. So maybe it's already happening, but maybe it isn't.
@@riluna3695 Yeah, agree. The memory is relevant in the time it is remembered. However, Boo creating and planting memorabilia of Sulley in the past, may create some sort of meta-memory; even if people won't know him personally just his image being ever present may count (like with that musician guy), esp. if it become a sort of archeologic find or mythical description that keeps popping up.
Other than that, I think Boo's time travel may not be all that related to the second death. I'd think her memories of spending time at Monsters Inc. would made her seek out the "strange" things that are sorely amiss in her/our so very rational time, so going back to a time when myths and monsters were real seems like a good place to fill that sentimentality over her childhood experiences. So, yeah, still connected, but we may still yet find out through more movies how, and this may not be it yet (I need to rewatch Onward, there may be some more connected tissue hidden in it? The ongoing evolution and the father being (partly) pulled from a death-realm? If Boo had gone there / a presumably post-Wall-E future, then the keeping Sully's memory alive would be a much clearer case).
How does Soul fit into this particular theory anyway?
Scraping the bottom of the barrel for videos, huh?
Elemental is just showing the van frost effect.
I think the incredibles should be included with the whole ai thing
We need another set of HP mugs!! I was collecting and still need a Hufflepuff one!
The Pixar Theory is absolutely awesome, it's one of my favourite theories ever. But there is one problem: How does Boo time travel? She seems to exist in the mid 1950s and given that the average human lifespan is around 80 years, by the time she dies, it's 2030. Where in the world would she have gotten the technology to time travel in the year 2030? How would she do it? There isn't a single mention of time travel aside from Monster's Inc, but that takes place about 3000 years after Wall-e, which itself takes place 700 years after the films with humans like Up or Toy Story. Basically, the time travel technolgoy from the Monster world could work and send Boo back to Medieval Scotland but by the time she exists, it won't be invented for another 3750 years.
Also, side note, the only Pixar movie that actively contradicts the whole "memories are important" thing is Cars. McQueen is shown to really dislike the idea of fame and having a remembered legacy. In Cars 3, Sterling says to him that retiring is the best thing for him because he'd be so much more famous and worth much more when he retires than he could ever be on the track. McQueen absolutely hates this. He doesn't do the racing for fame, he does it for himself. In Cars 1, McQueen refuses the Piston Cup and the Dinoco sponsorship simply because he's happy where he is, he feels he doesn't need the extra fame and is content losing the race and remaining at Rusteze. If McQueen had won that race and not helped The King, he would've been the most successful racer in history. The known record for Piston Cup wins is tied between The King and Lightning McQueen both having 7 Piston Cups each (though McQueen achieved that a lot faster). If McQueen had won that race and not let Chick win, he would have had 8 Piston Cups in 10 years, an absolute record. And having 5 Piston Cups in a row, and being the first rookie to win a Piston Cup. He would've have broken 3 racing records in his 10 year career. And he refuses it all for the sake of his friend (helping The King) and for his own happiness. Doc Hudson also goes on a path of having his old self completely forgotten after his crash, completely unlike that of Mr Incredible.
Cars really is the oddball in the Pixar Theory
The Pixar Theory is really just a bunch of nonsense (born of a "capital mistake"), but, for the sake of argument, perhaps when Boo got older, she hid out in a child's room so she could sneak into the monsters' time, where time travel exists. That does raise another problem, though, because, as is established in the video, time travel in the monsters' time has only been seen to work on a sliding timeline, so Boo wouldn't be able to go any further back in time than when she left. So she would have to figure out how to improve time travel (as well as learn magic in a world where it does not seem to exist).
They explain cars within the Pixar theory in another video
@@laurar1816 I know
Nice
I got first!🎉
2nd
the theory is dead; I doubt the Pixr staff care about creating it anymore sadly :/
Pixar has long been against the Pixar Theory. They are not in any way trying to encourage it. It is just a bunch of nonsense come up with by a fan who, in Jay Ward's words (Pixar Creative Director), "had a lot of time on their hands. They may have had some other recreational activities..."
Clicked so fast!
I'm not sure if Elemental should be considered canon.
I think it takes place before life itself, when the basic elements are all that exist.
What?! Elemental is VERY Canon! SO GOOD!
@@SuperCarlinBrothers😊😊😊❤❤❤
It has been such a stressful day. I don't want to hear about politics or differences of opinion, or about negative things. I just want to watch something that makes me a little happy.
Waves wand.....
Alohamora happiness.....
Heeeeey Brother!
Much better.
5:30
Since its to do with the "elements", as in fire and water, which aren't real elements, its probably more of a alchemical reaction than a chemical one.
Before watching I will guess that the most important movies are Brave, The Incredibles, Monsters Inc., Wall-E, And Coco
What do you think of the Alex Bale Pixar theory?
That one was a fun twist on this tired old theory.
If Miguel remembers Hector's friend after returning to the living is his second death undone?
I would love to see Super Carlin Brothers make an extensive video about The Tommy Westphall Universe. Maybe even do a collaboration with New Rockstars about the whole thing.
Thank god the sponsor isn't Better Help anymore... I love your content, but I admit, I had to stop watching for a bit because I couldn't stomach watching you guys support such a nasty business that has hurt so many people. >_
I can't believe you didn't include The Incredibles in the 5 most important Pixar theory movies. I feel like its more important than elemental. Its when A.I is created which is a huge part of the Pixar theory
This is the epitome of looking for evidence to back up your headcanon, and ignoring the evidence that might actually disprove it lol (but of course, the absurdity of it is kind of the whole appeal of the Pixar Theory in the first place). XD
I feel like that's exactly the point of fan theories - coming up with what you think is real or could be real, and looking for evidence to make it real. I love fan theories!
Not a joke, I keep waiting for your Inside Out 2 theory. I saw your Pixar theory on Elemental and how it supposedly connects to the original Inside Out. Now that its sequel is near, I was impatient to see how you can further connect Elemental to the Pixar theory, thanks to Inside Out 2's new emotions.
But seeing Elemental have a good role here is a genuine but welcome surprise.
I never laughed so hard at this nonsense theory. Talk about stretching the made up facts to fit the theory. Thanks you for making my morning. Your videos are always so much fun.
Love you guys but getting kind of tired of the editing where you guys feel like you have to move back and forth so frequently. Just constructive criticism do what you want 😊
What if there is an “Endgame” like movie from Pixar when/if the company ever shuts down? 🤞😬🤞
I really don't want to spoil the mood but I feel the idea of immortality is a curse rather than a blessing. Just think, by keeping sully's spirit or memory alive, by using time travel boo is basically made sully immortal but also that means sully is going to stay so long in the spirit world that he will witness the second death of all the people in the spirit World including a potential second death of boo, the one who is keeping him alive. I hope it's in him best interest that the time travel anchor is extending his second death and not keeping him immortal. Or else, he might be the few or the last spirit that is kept alive. I really hope Pixar fixes this or else it means sully is going to be in "the good place" ending scenario where he instead takes step into a door or something to be forgotten and experience his second death willingly
I still can't wrap my head around this permanent loop. Sure, Boo goes to the past and remembers the future, but that only affects the past... not the future after her memories.
And what happens when she dies? Thats what's going to end the memory. If she kept the loop because she travelled back in the past to remember him then, how is that different than anyone else remembering someone in the past? If the time of the memory is meaningless, the need to travel in time for the memory is, too.
Her plan doesn't make sense.
It makes sense that she went into magic and time travel to meet him again, but not to "keep his memory alive". She will eventually die, and with her, his memory.
Give how many Disney/Pixar movies there are out there, It'd be great to see more SCB videos of Pixar/Disney movies.
Is there a reason you don't credit Jon Negroni for creating the Pixar Theory. I know you expanded on it a lot but still.
Tell us you’re having trouble selling mugs without telling us you’re having trouble selling mugs 😂
How do you explain memories you haven't looked at in a while being clearer then memories looked more often
The ball is nice and clean so it’s clearer.
All that handling makes grubby fingerprints over time
They have lost the emotion that is attached to them. They just become generic facts rather than eliciting any emotional response upon recalling them.
For instance, think of someone you used to know a long time ago but are now entirely indifferent to. The memories of time spent with that person once made you feel a certain way, but now you just remember those moments as things that happened. The feelings you felt then have dulled or gone away entirely.
@@SgtSupaman I prefer my explanation
It would have been nice to see you guys mention Alex Bale's Pixar Theory here, in case this video was in any way a response to it. It's worth a watch if you happen to be reading this and haven't seen it yet
Are you ever gonna fit Kingdom Hearts in the Pixar theory since the Toy story world was confirmed to be canon
No Wall-e? That is also important, as it is the only way that onward and cars fits in.
By the way, in Soul, the lights in the hall of you are also related to emotions in inside out.
Día DE muertos, not día DE LOS muertos. Source? I’ve been Mexican my entire life
Other than it being nonsense this is the reason why I hate the Pixar theory, it implies an incredibly sad story for boo because she spends her entire life chasing after her friend and as we see in Brave never achieves her goal
Pixar Theory? Yes, please!
There will be a Re-Boot of the pixar theory 😉😉😉😉😉
I disagree with the conclusion for sully because the second she goes back in time or the fact that he dies in the future not the present so his soul at the time of his death does not have anyone named boo remembering him therefore he gets a second death like everyone else
Why haven’t you responded to Alex Bale’s Pixar Blooper Theory yet?
I'm surprised you haven't addressed the Alex bale Pixar theory
Have you been watching Coco with no sound? How are you getting to that pronunciation of Chicharrón?
I see boys are getting ready for Inside Out 2! Warming up the audience!
You should make a video of, what house does the Pixar characters get sorted to???
It begins with land before time y’all keep forgetting this
Hirolux! A man isn't dead until nobody lives for him
I never saw Sully on the Witch’s door before.
Ok how
I just had to go through comments in a facebook thread debunking the theory of is Abby Parks from turn red or Violet Parr from incredibles is Boo
By stating Boo’s name is Mary Gibbs
Then there the ages and years
Violet is 14 in 1962
Abby is 13 in 2002
Mary is 2 in 1999
Also the theory that Mary is Violet child
Um let look at the years and ages again
Violet would be 49 at the birth of Mary
So Grandchildren is possible if Violet was mid twenties when she was a mother 1973 (age 25) so that child could be aged 24 in 1997 for the birth of Mary.
Well didn’t mean to write a mini theory there.
Monsters, Inc takes place in 1955, based on the posters in the bedrooms.
Ben out here stopping his daughter from living that keto life
Boiling water is a physical change not a chemical change
You guys should remake the Pixar theory video
I love when they have those little family moments in the middle of a video ❤