Agree, though he is not really good at singing above like A3, however this pays off because his voice is insanely deep. Just listen to his "Alseep in the deep", he doesn't lose any resonance going down to a B1 and at the end he went down to an A1 in chest!!!
I never liked these bass battle videos just because the title causes flame wars. Gotta love both singers, although Geoff has an upper range advantage and better tone imo. Good clips.
So I see a lot of you guys miss the subhatmonic B0, but the problem is that I couldn't record Bobby's B0 from tiktok that is now outlawed in my country. BUT I completely forgot about his B0 in MY BOY. My apologies
Oh yeah, I HAVE thought of asking people to record that for me BUT It's a while since I posted that last video at the moment and I didn't want you guys to wait more.
The difference between two of them is Bobby's voice is richer and little bit thicker than geoff. But When geoff sing in the roon room full more Than bobby. Bobby's voice is one the type. Smooth, rich But geoff voice is mixed soft and loud. Everything he can do .
Nice work! Two of my favorite bass singers. Geoff has way more experience but damn, Bobby could actually keep up! PS, where is Bobby's subharmonic B0 :P
In the premiere I said that I could record there videos(Bobby's F1 in chest and subharmonic B0) because I'm russian and, sadly enough, foreign tiktok is now outlawed
This was amazing! Just two things that I noticed: 1. Why didn’t you include Bobby‘s F1 chest note? 2. Both Bobby and Geoff both have subharmonic B0‘s. Why didn’t you include them either?
In the premiere I said that I could record there videos(Bobby's F1 in chest and subharmonic B0) because I'm russian and, sadly enough, foreign tiktok is now outlawed
@@mintarobby No he doesn’t. He hits some F#1’s in chest. So far the only clear chest F1 that we got from him was in the „Friends on the other side“ song.
Sorry, but Geoff is the best bass for me. He has a recognizable timbre. His voice is lighter on low notes, but that's exactly what I like. I don't like very dark voices. You can listen to Geoff for a long time and not get tired. And he sounds good on high notes. His low notes are rich too.
Like others have pointed out, there are some low notes missing, but fans know they exist, anyway; like Geoff's B0 in "Halo" and whatever that low note was in "Enemy"... I have had my spectrum analyzer say it was a Bb0 and I have had it say it went all the way to F#0.
I know that bobby's got a B0 and a Breaf Bb0 in subharmonics. Also, I know about Geoff's B0 in HALO and subharmonic C#1 in ENEMY and a growled A0 there as well. I don't include Growls in my videos
@@rtsbass7829, never been a fan of the technique, either. It was the most unique growl I have ever heard, though; it sounded half growl and half subharmonic.
I love how Bobby was singing along to Voiceplay Oogie Boogie and singing Geoff's parts. I think Bobby needs to work on his upper range. In an interview with Tim Foust (another great bass singer) he talked about how its one of the things he teaches other bass singers to do instead of focusing solely on bass. In Geoff's career he started off singing higher notes not knowing of his abilities as a bass singer and then he started practicing a lot as a bass. Geoff considers himself a low baritone but everyone agrees hes a bass. Geoff learned a lot but he is older than Bobby. I think if Bobby had more practice on his higher notes, he could be an even better singer as he is now. Bobby definitely has a good start. Hes a really good bass. Just needs more. In all of the reaction videos ive seen of people reacting to Geoff in Oogie Boogie, everyone talks about his range. They talk about his higher notes. Of course all of them talk about his final note in that song but everyone all talks about how good of a range he has. Going from those high notes to that very low note. Bobby just needs to practice to get a bigger range than he has. (I dont know all the technical terms, i apologize. im not a musician)
I strongly agree with you!!! From the last song he did, he did high F's like nothing. By looking at The Sound of Silence cover from Bobby Waters, it is a pretty good to tell that he has been working on his upper high range more often, and I believe if Bobby continues like that, he will reach near to the lower 5th octave, like Geoff and Tim Foust do. It just takes lots of practice! Which would be cool to see him showing off more of his upper range, because if you observe from all voice types, the voice type that tends to have broader range are basses. The limit for a typical bass is either Bb4 of B4, which is stupid high for a bass because, that's not suposred for them to get that high, but anyways, that can be also affected by genetics.🤷🏻♂️ My best example: Since my childhood, I have been always able to get super high in my chest range(Up to G5)!!! But now, I am older with 18 years old, I can chest a Bb1 on a good day. Ps: Every voice is unique, and we should appreciate what each of us have to show off people our best skills, and not frustrating for what we can't change for ourselves :)
its like painfully obvious that he doesn't really know how to use the depth of his voice while belting in songs like the bass gang's version of iris. like yeah he sings those notes and they're on pitch but they're way too soft and bright for a bass voice imo. his low end is bonkers but his technique in his high end i dont think displays the strengths his voice could have
Geoff is a freak of nature, we shouldn’t be treating him as the standard if we’re talking about range. Bobby could work on the higher notes but I really don’t think it’s that bad for a bass
![2022 Bass Battle [Bobby Waters/Marwan Ayman/Peter Barber/Tomi Pizur] BASS GANG E2 - F0](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/S2OVuoNjwK0/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for making this, great video!
Ya'll have very similar tones to your voices but Bobby will always win it for me!
Thank you so much, I'm so happy you checked this video out!
Es tonto que comparen a Geoff con eso
@@kevinlara813 por que?
@@kevinlara813 Que dice este random
I love how it’s a very serious Bobby, and then it’s Geoff with wind in his hair, a smile on his face, flower petals, and a girls shirt on. 🤣
Geoff rattles my headphones more both love both! Great bass singers.
Bobby and Geoff Should do a song together
What's most impressive is how far deep they go in chest!!
And how smooth their subharmonics are 😬😬
Agree, though he is not really good at singing above like A3, however this pays off because his voice is insanely deep. Just listen to his "Alseep in the deep", he doesn't lose any resonance going down to a B1 and at the end he went down to an A1 in chest!!!
Look at that beautiful Disney princess of a man.... 😍😍
I never liked these bass battle videos just because the title causes flame wars. Gotta love both singers, although Geoff has an upper range advantage and better tone imo. Good clips.
Well, for the lowest range I would those Bobby
I appreciate the picture selection for Geoff in the thumbnail.
Same here😂
So I see a lot of you guys miss the subhatmonic B0, but the problem is that I couldn't record Bobby's B0 from tiktok that is now outlawed in my country.
BUT I completely forgot about his B0 in MY BOY.
My apologies
and Geoff's B0 in Halo
You have Geoff’s TikTok at 9:22. You mean you had already recorded it before TikTok was outlawed?
@@cishinoju I recorded it from a Geoff's tiktok compilation
Oh yeah, I HAVE thought of asking people to record that for me BUT It's a while since I posted that last video at the moment and I didn't want you guys to wait more.
Bobby B0 is legit 1sec after 7:55, so you have the whole clip except the ending ?
No competition - they are both equally brilliant 🥰
we need to consider that geoff is almost double the age of bobby. thats crazy
Wait what the fu
This was crazy! Nice work on this video!
Thanks!
The difference between two of them is
Bobby's voice is richer and little bit thicker than geoff.
But When geoff sing in the roon room full more Than bobby.
Bobby's voice is one the type. Smooth, rich
But geoff voice is mixed soft and loud. Everything he can do .
I don't know what the crap happened to the quality of the video, I was recording in 2K!
Sorry guys but I literally have no idea...
Nice video!
5:27 I think that's a B0.
Where is Geoffs B0 in from Voiceplay's cover of the Halo theme
That’s what I’ve wanted for a long time. Thank you so much!
My pleasure!
8:20 such amazing control
Geoff.... No doubt
This is so cool. 🔥🔥
Nice work! Two of my favorite bass singers. Geoff has way more experience but damn, Bobby could actually keep up! PS, where is Bobby's subharmonic B0 :P
In the premiere I said that I could record there videos(Bobby's F1 in chest and subharmonic B0) because I'm russian and, sadly enough, foreign tiktok is now outlawed
@@rtsbass7829 you could take the B0 in my boy and use videos sent in saved in your gallery of his F1 that get sent around
@@scraggyboi Yeah I know, I forgot about B0 in My Boy. Tho I don't have any saved recordings
This was amazing! Just two things that I noticed: 1. Why didn’t you include Bobby‘s F1 chest note? 2. Both Bobby and Geoff both have subharmonic B0‘s. Why didn’t you include them either?
In the premiere I said that I could record there videos(Bobby's F1 in chest and subharmonic B0) because I'm russian and, sadly enough, foreign tiktok is now outlawed
@@rtsbass7829 Aw man that’s unfortunate! Next time just ask me and I can record these for you.
Also in the Twenty one pilots mashup ft Voiceplay, Geoff hits F1 chest.
@@mintarobby No he doesn’t. He hits some F#1’s in chest. So far the only clear chest F1 that we got from him was in the „Friends on the other side“ song.
@@jmbmusic1 he included a Bb0 from Bobby at 5:27
Great video!
Super awesome video! 🤩🤩
Honestly, I love them both! 😍😍
Thank you for sharing. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Please stay healthy and take care. 🤗🤗
Sorry, but Geoff is the best bass for me. He has a recognizable timbre. His voice is lighter on low notes, but that's exactly what I like. I don't like very dark voices. You can listen to Geoff for a long time and not get tired. And he sounds good on high notes. His low notes are rich too.
Like others have pointed out, there are some low notes missing, but fans know they exist, anyway; like Geoff's B0 in "Halo" and whatever that low note was in "Enemy"... I have had my spectrum analyzer say it was a Bb0 and I have had it say it went all the way to F#0.
I know that bobby's got a B0 and a Breaf Bb0 in subharmonics.
Also, I know about Geoff's B0 in HALO and subharmonic C#1 in ENEMY and a growled A0 there as well.
I don't include Growls in my videos
@@rtsbass7829, never been a fan of the technique, either. It was the most unique growl I have ever heard, though; it sounded half growl and half subharmonic.
@@johndeeregreen4592 I actually can EQ the growl so sound just like you said
I love how Bobby was singing along to Voiceplay Oogie Boogie and singing Geoff's parts. I think Bobby needs to work on his upper range. In an interview with Tim Foust (another great bass singer) he talked about how its one of the things he teaches other bass singers to do instead of focusing solely on bass. In Geoff's career he started off singing higher notes not knowing of his abilities as a bass singer and then he started practicing a lot as a bass. Geoff considers himself a low baritone but everyone agrees hes a bass. Geoff learned a lot but he is older than Bobby. I think if Bobby had more practice on his higher notes, he could be an even better singer as he is now. Bobby definitely has a good start. Hes a really good bass. Just needs more. In all of the reaction videos ive seen of people reacting to Geoff in Oogie Boogie, everyone talks about his range. They talk about his higher notes. Of course all of them talk about his final note in that song but everyone all talks about how good of a range he has. Going from those high notes to that very low note. Bobby just needs to practice to get a bigger range than he has. (I dont know all the technical terms, i apologize. im not a musician)
I strongly agree with you!!!
From the last song he did, he did high F's like nothing. By looking at The Sound of Silence cover from Bobby Waters, it is a pretty good to tell that he has been working on his upper high range more often, and I believe if Bobby continues like that, he will reach near to the lower 5th octave, like Geoff and Tim Foust do.
It just takes lots of practice!
Which would be cool to see him showing off more of his upper range, because if you observe from all voice types, the voice type that tends to have broader range are basses. The limit for a typical bass is either Bb4 of B4, which is stupid high for a bass because, that's not suposred for them to get that high, but anyways, that can be also affected by genetics.🤷🏻♂️
My best example: Since my childhood, I have been always able to get super high in my chest range(Up to G5)!!!
But now, I am older with 18 years old, I can chest a Bb1 on a good day.
Ps: Every voice is unique, and we should appreciate what each of us have to show off people our best skills, and not frustrating for what we can't change for ourselves :)
Not gonna lie A1s are the best chest notes for these singers in my opinion but geoffs *effortless* G1s are good too
C1 are you kidding me? How tf!? even with subharmonics how do you do that?
You gotta have a strong C2 for that
they actually hit b0
Geoff has gone to Bb0 and Bobby has gone to G#0 both using subs🤯
Hi, It would be better if the cuts were made at the matching volumes instead of mid sentences. Great collection though
Yeah, that's a great advice, man! I'll try my best!
@@rtsbass7829 Thanks man, your compose really give me encouragement to train
7:50, I think that F#1 for bobby was an air note
It might sound so cuz you didn't use earphones. When I used a good set I felt the vibrations so yeah...
where did you get the clip at 8:26??
th-cam.com/video/ke5M1I57-hw/w-d-xo.html
2:08:24
What happend to geoffs halo b0 ☹️
Bobby actually hits a clear F1 ok his tik tok
Yes but there's one problem, foreign tik tok is outlawed in Russia
@@rtsbass7829 Why?? That doesn't serve for anything!! Just let us be free!!😠😠😠
@@hugobasilio1303 I have no idea why is foreign tiktok outlawed
@@rtsbass7829 No problem! But you still have a good content of videos! You are great man!
@@rtsbass7829впн
0:37 wasted
0:37 wanted it
3:02
3:24 is
2:56
2:55
Bobby can hit deep notes but he will never be Jeff costellucci, he doesn't have the charisma of Jeff
Haha, okay
"Jeff" haha nicr
😂😂 that’s ok, I don’t want to be Geoff
@@the.bobbybass No no, he said Jeff, his twin co-worker XD
@@rtsbass7829 oh my bad, wrong guy
they both have good bass but bobby has no upper range at all lmao
Yeah sad to say but his range above about Bb3 is meh
its like painfully obvious that he doesn't really know how to use the depth of his voice while belting in songs like the bass gang's version of iris. like yeah he sings those notes and they're on pitch but they're way too soft and bright for a bass voice imo. his low end is bonkers but his technique in his high end i dont think displays the strengths his voice could have
Geoff is a freak of nature, we shouldn’t be treating him as the standard if we’re talking about range. Bobby could work on the higher notes but I really don’t think it’s that bad for a bass
@@JackHagar for bass it’s fine just for the high notes bud
I'm thirteen years old and I can sing even lower than them both. Am I getting old😨
Let’s hear it😂
☺️
Sure bud
I mean using fry or inhale 0th octave is easy as fuck but having a E1 chest is unbelievable for a 13 yo
Tim is way better
It’s not called tim vs someone… it’s geoff vs Bobby lol