ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ย. 2015
- Bollywood lyricist and scriptwriter Javed Akhtar said that it was wrong to label kids as 'Hindu' and 'Muslim' right from birth. Recounting his early days of struggle in the film industry, Akhtar reminisced that he used to paint his name on every film poster on the streets credits were not given to scriptwriters back then. Shabana Azmi was also present, and she said that society conditions people to look down on women who have ambitions.
For latest breaking news, other top stories log on to: www.abplive.in & / abpnewstv 🔴Watch ABP News Live 24/7 • ABP NEWS LIVE 24*7: Ex...
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 3 // FNC vs FUT | EDG vs PRX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pw2T5v0ogDI/mqdefault.jpg)
Intelligent persons with great sense of humour...
I liked it.
fracckk!!!! liked her comment on identity , religion or community is just part of one part of person's identity.. Bravo!!
India: No country for smart, compassionate and thoughtful people. The new India is deeply divided, hateful and despite possessing degrees, is rather uneducated. The youtube comments on most Indian videos are an indication. Javed Sahab, despite sometimes being too passionate, is a great individual whose dissent needs to be heard far more.
+Timothy Thomas u r not understanding hindu dharma is not a religion .. it shows righteous way to live .... hindus never tried to spread like christian and islam .... what u have to understand is no body asked u to come to bharat ... ok u people came and killed people in bharat ... thats the history mr. ... javed shabana should be ashamed living in india they could not understand r still afraid to support hindu dharma .... may be u dont know .. u see wise smart intelligent compassionate etc people in india only .... u liked javed because they were brought up here ... ...
pls read the following .. carefully .. With more than 1000 years of Islamic & British rule the Ibrahimic/Abrahamic beliefs has entered the Hindu psyche. To add, Bollywood (Hindi film industry) caused further damage to the Hindu mindset, with all successful dialogues & lyrics writers (Kadar Khan, Hasrat Jaipuri, Salim Khan, Javed Akhtar etc.) hailed from the muslim community as Urdu is actually the preferred language of Bollywood. But wait a minute, why Bollywood? can Bollywood influence the masses in India to this extent? Does it deserve even a mention? Yes, the influence Bollywood has in India is mind-boggling and one can't be oblivious to it. The two things that capture the imagination of kids as well as adults in India are Bollywood and cricket.
In Hindi movies we keep hearing that how someone died or how an unfavourable outcome was the result of "Bhagwan/Khudah ki marzee" (God's wish) or how even a leaf cannot move without God’s will. Such nonsense was never entertained in the earlier Vedic era & was never a part of Vedic teachings. I've seen a renowned muslim actor who while playing a Hindu character is often seen in the movie doing "Salaam" & "Adab" an Arabic greeting gesture instead of Namaste, Namaskara or Pranaam.
Muslims do not consider themselves responsible for what happens to them but rather ascribe everything to the will of Allah. They believe that human actions are being watched and recorded for final judgment on the Day of Judgment (yome-ud-din). As a result muslims do not endeavour to change anything & facts speak for themselves. Islamic countries are poor (unless they have found oil, a natural resource formed during the Carboniferous period under the ground) & lag behind while all other nations are advancing in Science and technology. It is up to us to create wealth. When faced with calamities and natural disasters, we do not hide our heads under the sand saying it was the will of God/Allah. Rather we try to find ways to beat those calamities through science and technology, for eg. through remote sensing and Earth observation satellite programs (IRS, INSAT, IRNSS, RISAT, Cartosat etc.), we were able to save lakhs of lives by being well prepared for the 2nd strongest tropical cyclone ever to make landfall in India “Phailin” that hit east coast of India on October 12, 2013. Death toll during cyclone "Phailin" was a mere 44 as compared to 500000 people (yup five lakh people) lost their lives when cyclone “Bhola” struck the same region on November 12,1970. Science & technology can advance only through Purushaarth (free-will).
Today we may call the outcome of our activities & events in our lives as fate, destiny, or use Urdu/Arabic terms like kismath, taqdeer, naseeb, muqaddar and other such nomenclatures, but what we should understand here is that the outcome is the result of Karma & NOT God's wish/will/intervention. WE ARE ACCOUNTABLE FOR EVERYTHING WE DO. In his book "The Jain Doctrine of Karma and the Science of the Genetics" the author Dr Sohan Raj Tater states there are two kinds of determinants of body processes and behaviour of organisms, one is Karma and the other is genes. Karma directs, instructs, motivate genetic codes and genes to function and mutate accordingly.Karma is the cause and genes is the effect. Prarabdh determines the form of body one takes in this life and the type of environment that is most suitable for it to work out. Whether the environment is pleasant or unpleasant is determined by the type of Karmas working out. Also your births and environments are determined according to the nature of your desires. Prarabdh places you in such suitable environments as are favourable for the gratification of your desires.
So it is one's Karma that will determine what a person receives by birth, that is, high, low or average intelligence, skin tone, voice, physique, health, worldly pleasures etc. Whatever, he/she has done in the past was his/her free-will (Purushaarth) and yesterday’s free-will is today’s destiny (Prarabdh). And what we are doing today, with proportionate to the karma performed in conscious state turns into best, medium or the lower category free-will. Thus, the destiny is not delinked to the free-will and the present destiny of the human being moves ahead with the free-will. Now the question arises that when a person understands that his destiny is not good, can he amend it or would have to continue moving in the same direction? The answer is simple, though the support of free-will always exists with the human being but mostly he/she does not do any work suddenly but move slowly with the momentum. Yes, if a person is not making any effort to change the destiny or there is no use of external force (Bahya Shakti) on the destiny, then whatever Prarabdh is with the individual, he/she continues with it. On principles, the change in destiny is not impossible. It could change but with the help of Gurupdesh (instruction from a renowned Guru), through Shaastra-shravan (acquiring Vedic wisdom & knowledge) or use of ones thought power but first, with the trouble in the life, downfall, one should understand that their destiny is not good for them or for others as well. When this message is clear, the human nature, sooner or later, is bound to change.
Contrary thinking or contrary action is necessary for the point that an individual wants to change. Remember, since destiny (Prarabdh) has been created due to freewill (Purushaarth), it is bound to change with the use of free-will itself. Like, for a person who wants to change the fate of greediness, he/she should have strong bout of generousness. So now the question arises what is more influential, destiny or the free-will? and the answer is conceptually neither destiny nor the free-will. Whichever is more operative at that moment has a greater impact than the other at that time. Some people believe that no one could turn the fate except God/Allah and consider the destiny and God's will and grace as the super authoritative and infallible and free-will as insignificant. But the Self-enlightened and brave speak contrary to it.
In Ramayan after Lord Ram defeated Ravana, He said to his wife Sita “Devena tu yata sampraptam paurushena tyapakritam”, meaning: “Oh Sita, whatever troubles, and inauspiciousness I got in the life due to the destiny, I have fought it with the free-will”?
thats what indian people understand ... follow ... live ...
+Timothy Thomas with knowing r without knowing if a person does a mistake and people who loves that person can cover the person ... suppose in a place where anger rules even good deed becomes baddeed simple ............. so u people r based on singular emotions ......... dharma shows manushya dharma .. means human duties responsibilities .. (pls donot talk about manusmriti no body follows it except islam and christianity)...
V sl The only question I have, how long did it take for you type up that entirely trite and 10th rate essay.
+Timothy Thomas hi u will be surprised if u knew the truth ... by the way do u think hindus r those people who were converted to christianity for money wine gjven by fathers .. stupid .. by the way those who converted for stupid teachings from ur bible r more cleverer than u .. may be u dont know that lol... javed is coward ..... he cannot denounce. islam .. r join dharma .. but he is living happily peacefully with hindus only ... getlost ..
that essay is more than enough for u ... bible based on love ur neighbour.. islam based on put fear in ur neighbour.. .. but what dharma means .. its entirely different ... which u cant think of because u believe that u r a sinner .. ... do u have opp. of sin .. do u even know what its .....by the way god is not there to take ur sins .. god is not ur body gaurd ... u do ur duties responsibilities be good be fair .. follow dharma .. can u understand that ..
So many dislikes shows Indiana don't understand intellectual people
Many pakistanis dont like him either.Many pakistanis leave negative comments about him as well.
+Badrul kabir hey stop tellling ur kids u r muslim and teach them dharma ... stop hiding in black cloth ... :P learn the meaning of dharma .. it certainly does not mean religion .........get it .. then lets chk ur intellect ...
+Badrul kabir so many understands RSS only.. that is the main problem in india
Here mostly butthurt muslims
Don't say this. He is our true hero. I salute him
The anchor looks really cute and beautiful.
How beautiful. Absolutely loved this. Wish I was there.
He is inspiration for all of us.Nd I think now he is more indian than me .
Wow Javed Sab is a gifted poet. So genuine and unique individual. A pleasure to watch him talking.
Am an atheist since 16 and is now 72.
Temples are an important economic activity. Most churches, temples, mosques generate tourism and create big opportunities. Imagine what was Tirupati, Shiridi or siddivinayak were 20 years ago?
Except this, Religion by large will destroy mankind sooner or later.
Very well said its about tolerant versus intolerant rather than among religions
Only fanatics will fail to understand their point of view
both are deep thinker
All atheist and sgnostics are deep thinker
Great thinker and social activist of time.
One of the greatest people in India today. A national treasure.
apko dekh kr humein realise hiua ki humein sachai se koso dur rhkha jata rha h
...
Javed akhtar ....a true gem..
Neither raise them watching bollywood Movie
Correct
Bollywood is the ruining society
Nice comments...
Wow just wow ...
I take it back
javed sir great
Modern women are now forced to study and work and contribute financially at the same time fill all the traditional expectations as well. Too much
If you listen Javed Akhtar any time, you will be proud to be an Indian first, and forget that he is Muslim, but our best friends Muslims themselves make us realize that he is not Hindu, what an irony.....i can't understand why Muslims don't respect Javed sir... Is it simply because Hindus respect him.... Its utter foolishness on Muslims part...
THERE ARE EXTREME HINDUS ALSO WHO DOES NOT LIKE HIM ...
Why Muslims don't respect Javedji because he talks about religion of which he has no knowledge. You can not judge any religion based on people mindset or action of a particular religion.
He's an atheist
We will blame, oppose and hate any person who criticize RELIGION,,,bcoz they are corelated not the ATHEIST,,,,,,,,Religion has a concept of CREATOR but the THINKER doesn't has that........
Because muslims are religious. Entire race is brainwashed. I am also born to muslim parents but i choose my own path like javed sir.
8:57 wtf😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Oh shit
Great man Javed sir
Javed akhtar good jobs sir
The sound quality is pretty pathetic. How you've managed that, I don't know,👎🏾
Why is Shabana's name misspelled??????....driving me nutsss
Devgn
A great Indian javed akhtar
Some people cannot talk about freedom follow religion or not they just dont let
Rule huwe darakhton k pass to phir se Jaya ja Sakta hay to kya aap guzre huwe waqt ko rok Kar phir se wahan pahonch sakte hay?????
Jawed Sahab bade hi Adam se ye kaheta Hun k aaj waqt hay kal Nahi Hoga agar pata chale k Islam hi sach tha to aakhirat me pachtak koi fayda Nahi Hoga acche se study kijiye aap Jo to Allah be aqle Saleem De rakkhi hay hay
My massage to everyone surch about Islam and think that we are not in the world without reason and we will go to our Allah after death .this is for every human being
Bhai tu sach mein doctor hai ??
Thanx for some vitamins...
Sholay = The Good, The Bad and the Ugly+
The Magnificent Seven+Once Upon A Time in The West+For A Few Dollars More
Every one will teach to hid children what they believe they have right to teach you will not teach about religion because you don't believe but those who believe in religion/god they will teach about God what the amazing
And people will believe and fight and even kill other people for that religion which was given to them when they are child and not chosen by them, for the entire life.
Religion is used only as a convenience n hatred
The concept of good or bad and sin or reward are not subjected to only thinking but it needs a universal fact,law or settlement,,,,javed doesn't believe in this,,he believes in only self thinking,,,and lastly without a law ,religion ,a concept of good or bad anytime javed akhtar can do unfair means in his neighbourhood.....
You failed to understand his words. . Open your blindfold which your parents or elders put to keep you away from truth. Imagine you were born an orphan, you didnt know who your parents were, which religion would you be? How will you know which religion you belong to?
I do not mind a society in which women lead .but it summarily dismisses Indic civilization which dies not legislate patriRchy matriarchy can also beaccepted
Jo hmara mazhab k bare m kaha wo apni zindagi m hr taraf se nakyaab h
Chal be dafa ho bsd k
Yehi sikhaya gaya hai tumko tumhare parents ko tumhare mazhab ne. . Brainwashed illiterates. Apna blindfold kholo aur apni dharam ko dusro ki nazar se dekho, kitna mistakes milega tumko. Jaise tumlog dusro ki dharam mei mistakes nikalte ho, usi tarah apne dharam ka bhi dekh lo hazaro niklega. . Mei bhi tumhare mazhab ka hi hoon, par mei apni blindfold kabki utaar chuki hoon!
lets not enterfare one intenal matters
Sathyaga h budda
صم بکم عم فہم لا یعلمون
Jo Apne creater aut palanhaar Ka na hua uska Kya? An Aeroplane can not come into existence by a chance....how can this universe so precisely going on and on, Humans the most complicated entity can come into existence? Also so many systems to sustain life like air, water and maintained temperature for living things .. how can exist without a creator? This creator is only one....that is Allah!!
Not everything needs creator, who created Allah?
@@existentialbaby I know I am three years late but damn all you rational people grilling these brainwashed people in the replies
U completely fail.to.understand his point of view
It's not.for idiots.
the red dot appears
hum toh in dono par fidaye jaan ho gaye h
THERE IS NO GOD BUT ALLAH AND PROPHET MUHAMMAD IS THE LAST AND FINAL MESSENGER OF ALLAH.
I agree to your statement that "there is no god"
Javed akhtar discourages Islam to makes Hindu film industry happy for Money.
@@avradeep999 see another person hating someone based on religion!
Javed akhtar discourages every religion to make our world a better place and encourages use of intellect and braincells for upgradation of mankind. Superstitious beliefs should have no place in the modern world!
everything has creater..... Javed did u notice how does ur body fuction work... u must admit that there is superime power who creat everything... for me ALLAH, for others religion their gods like bhagwan, god,
but u never understand because ur family has never suffering failure .... u r under the test from the ALLAH...
may Allah bless u hidayat...
No body can create anything. Just give me one example of creation.
Correct...But question is who created Allah? Answer is imagination of Human brain..
Haar jaga same bhagchodi karte ho yr.. tolerance pe Rona chod k tolerate karna sikho. Unko kya Maana hai kya nahi manna hai yee unki marzi hai..
For me progressive minded means passive minded just do as you please no matter if people suffer .
Progressive minded is passive minded? Lol! Are you serious??? What an idiot!
0+0+0=0 or 0+0+0=1 ... If there is no GOD how existence came in to beings... First admit there is GOD then let child find which religion he want to believe... We are human beings living creatures not some random being in vast universe if yes then show first life in other places other than Earth... My opinion is Islam is Truth it is people choice to believe or disbelieve it's people's personal choice ..
I don't agree with Javed... Aise to agar aap apne bacche ko bachpan se lekar 18 saal ki age tak education na provide karo aur 18 ke baad usko puchu ke would you like to be educated then the child will certainly like to remain uneducated... Javed talk make no sense
E Kon chdumal log hi
?
Ek tera baap h or doosari teri maa
Relegion teaches morals...all relegion! Today the generations are being distracted by such people's, who are in the hands of industries like Fashion, Porn stuff sellers, and so on, they want to create or expand the markets of shamelessness. If moral values through the medium of religion is adequately given to our generations there will be no need of police and court in the society.
Mortality needs no religion. In fact religion denigrates morality.
Morality is not at all related to being brought up in a religion if you give your children good thoughts they will learn it and spread it
Religion? Moral? Are u kidding me?
We can see how morally u r talking here lol😂
Don’t raise kids on the tenets of religion: Javed Akhtar Sahab yehi bat agar dum he to masjid me jake bolie 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bhai wo atheist hain. Unko kisise fark nahi padta. He dismisses all religions equally
muslims of India,,, please change your religion. if you want to make India the best, most powerful, peaceful, and want to make Indian citizen most powerful in the world .
so please change your religion and accept any one of the four beautiful Indian religion.
Hindus+Buddhist +Sikh +Jain +christian +jews +parsees = no religious politics + beautiful india + no violence + prosperous India + highest growth rate +full of nationalism + most powerful country + most powerful citizen + peace ful nation + no dange + only talk on development + no poor people = India the super power + ideal nation of the world
I am atheist
Although Javed is very Intellectual, As one of his interview he spoke to that he used to study a lot, but his opinion about religion specifically in islam is totally wrong, better he should read the quran with translation .
Javed Akhtar made an extremely stupid statement that "if a child is brought up as an Atheist and asked to choose a religion at the age of 18, he/she will not choose any religion".
His statement only applies to religions with 'One God' concept (Abrahmic religions or maybe, Sikhism).
In Hinduism, concept of God is different..God is in every human as atman. What is important is an individual's karma and the path to achieve Moksha
In Buddhism, God has no importance at all. What matters is the rationality of thoughts as defined by Buddha, so as to follow a path to achieve Nirvana (Mokhsa)
In Jainism, once again God is not important. Instead the 24Jinas who attained Moksha are important and the path they took to achieve Moksha
Thus, at the age of 18, if one were to be given a choice, he.she would choose any of Hinduism, Buddhism or Jainism; or more specifically Hinduism since it is much wider in scope and includes several paths.
I don't find it stupid. He has raised his children and seen result himself. You are just making assumptions here without any valid evidence.
@@SocialCry - Hindu Sanatan Dharma has its roots in nature (5 mahabhootas), and it has evolved over thousands of years. It is the most natural 'way of life' for a human being. Buddhism and Jainism are rational but they also have a strict code. Hinduism has no strict code, there is flexibility; you can choose to become strict or become the most liberal, depending upon nature of the society.
@@vikramrazdan5680 *Then, I prefer to say Hinduism is not a religion. It is a set of or group of practices/faiths/cultures/traditions combined which the people living in indian subcontinent or more specifically people from Indus valley civilization followed. Because in Hinduism, Different people follow different gods/faith/ideologies and more...*
@@SocialCry - "A way of life" does not mean that Hinduism is not a religion, the difference is that it does not have a strict law as in other religions. Islam is also a 'way of life' governed by Sharia law. Christianity is also a 'way of life' governed by the Biblical law.
Hinduism is a 'religion' (by default) because there are religious minorities mentioned (without explaining the criteria) in the Constitution of India. Then there is the Hindu Marriage Act 1955 which confirms that Hinduism is a religion. The Hindu 'way of life' is Hinduism as per Supreme Court's interpretation of the Constitution of India.
@@vikramrazdan5680 As per the meaning of the word according to present world. Hinduism has become an religion. But actually there is no mention of the word in our scriptures. Hindu is actually a geographic identity rather than a religious identity. But with time, it has become more of a religion.
Because religion is what makes you believe in god but in hinduism there are ideologies supporting one God, multiple god and no god. So, i would better not call it a religion. But it's personal. You are free to call what you want.
Why is it that the whole world advising India when every country is raising children with religious value? Open your eyes and see who you advise?
Bakwas toking
Javed Akhtar possess shallow knowledge of modern science.
what is science?
javed akhtar is doing only chamchagiri of one community.he himself claims to be a non believer of god and religion.but he seems to be praising Hinduism and criticising Muslims and Islams.he doesn't have any right to speak on behalf of Muslims.let him do chamchagiri.we don't take him seriously.real life is not sholay or deewar.the example he is giving can be seen even in India for centuries.either he has not experienced or ignored
+suraj shah your sick
🤮
Bakwas
Haa, religion =bakwas
Javeed Akhtar is a double standard person. He gave up his religion for the sake of his profession and became an atheist. He is not alone in this way a lot of people from the film industry prioritize their profession over religion to save their existence.
Stop judging others
Sir agar apko lagta hai bachha 18 ki age me koi dharm nahi chunega to aap bhi dharm tyag do...
He already left his religion , He is an athiest! Adding unnecessary comments and spreading hate based on religion shame on u
Hindu log ko e batein pasand hogi musalmanou ko nahi
inka saaf agenda hai musalmaan muslamaan bane lakin hindu hindu na bane.....javed ji jaiye phle musalmaano ko ye sikhaiye
if he not repend .Allah will sure send him to hill.
🤡
javed akhter ap islam k bare me jante he kia hain ap islam ko study kren aur phir khood faisla kren k scha kon ha ap apne ap ko atheist kehte hain jab k ap hindu ke taref krte rahe hain
tu ky janta ha
bhag bhonsadike
Maine padha islam, zabse ghatiya religion. Aur kuch
javed sahab aap bhut dhoke me uor overconfidence me aapni life gujar rahe hai kuch sikho religion me marne ke bad ki jindagi ke bare me socho ser je
bas marne ke baad ka sochoo aor duniya ko baigan main mila dooo
Nahi ser jee aap galat samjhe hoo . javed sahab islam ko afganistan ya bar bar pakistan jese desh ka udharan dete hai but uor bhi desh hai duniya me muslim jo bjut age ja rahe hai malesia indonesia turky uor quran shafif ko pado uor dekho samjho Allha ne kiya farmaya hai . har religión me ache uor bure log hai zara samjhu world ko agar aap ko meri bat nori lage to sorry ser je
+Hermaan Quereshi bhai baat ye hai ki agar aap good human ho to aap good Muslim hai full 🌕 stop ✋.
Han bhai tumko sari sacchai pata hai...god ne tumko sapne me aake bataya hai sab
jawwad mobin SAJID baat to aise kar rahe ho aap jaise mar ke dekh chuka hai...
Dono musalmaan ke naam pe dhabba hai
Nahi hai voh musalmaan ...
Bandar kya jane adrak ka swaad.
An athiest, in other words, a disbeliever, is actually disregarding his creator... he is surely at loss in hereafter.. the poor javed akhtar!
A believer is a fool who can not think for himself and can believe anything thrown at him just for the fear of the hell. And in that process makes his entire life hell.
+cf delhi Believers, despite being sinners, are spiritually inclined to have a permanent life in hereafter.. while disbelievers, wandering aimlessly, find this world as their eternal home.. If so, they dare to survive permanently in this world.. if we have given many powers to lead a prosperous life in the way we want then why are we restricted at certain levels like death..Why we become helpless somewhere despite claiming to be omnipotent
There is no afterlife ... keep praying to a made up god and waste your life. Once your brain dies ... lights are out ... there will be absolutely NOTHING!
+S shenkupto It is desirable to be intelligent but undesirable to be excessive into it.. which leads a person to exactly what u said
+S shenkupto very true bro!
I'm also Ex Muslim n Agnostic