I really love watching your videos and this one is great, as always! We don't agree much here to be honest, even with Marjorie, I'm not the biggest fan. Agree on Ilaria being a breath of fresh air, she's absolutely stunning! My feelings for Naomi Rivieccio are so powerful, I still remember how excited I was when I first heard her in these songs, she sounds like an ancient Italian princess in the Colloseum ! Glad you have found a way to create videos, hope we're gonna see a character ranking soon...
Glad to see a new ranking from you! It's funny how "your" great italian voices start at 20. It really shows how good these voices are! I can say we agree in most choices, especially your top 5! I haven't listened Mulan's voice that much, but seems like it's an amazing version! And the other 4 voices are truly gems! I will always love the Serena duo, and I'm glad you really Laura as Rapunzel, as she doesn't have too many fans sadly. Marjorie's Odette is truly amazing :D
I really enjoyed watching this, most placings weren't surprising at all because they reflect the opinions in your character rankings, but I loved reading the comments for each voice! I kinda agree with you overall (apart from, for example, your unpopular opinions on Simona or Barbara, but hey, they are called unpopular for a reason). I'm so glad you like Renata so much, she's a favorite for me and lots of other Italians
Yeah, sorry again for Barbara, Simona and Tosca, I know you guys really love them, and the nostalgia factor in more :/ I really wish Renata could have been Ariel since the beginning, she deserved to have her own big role! Marjorie is extraordinary, and has been my fav since a long time now :)
2 ปีที่แล้ว +3
Beautiful video! You managed to outdo yourself again with the incredible editing 😯😍
So glad to see a new one of these from you! Barbara Cola low is gonna kill me lol. I don't pay attention to Zipporah voices but I love your comment there! Big facts on Renata, I find they miscast her many times even though her voice is pretty in theory. For that I've never been able to fully love her. On the other hand I truly do not like the Italian Chang-E. I don't find she can handle the songs that well. I think a lot of us agree: the Frozen sisters are the peak for Italian dubs. Big loves. Overall I just love so much that you've been doing this so long but your tastes still ebb and flow; on my end my Disney tastes have stagnated though I have fond memories of my old loves. PS: Happy late bday :D
Glad to see a comment from you ^^ Unfortunately I’m not hearing again correctly so that’s probably my last video.. Oh really? What makes you say that (about Chang’e)? Yeah, tastes always evolve somehow I believe, though here I would say it’s rather much the same as it’s always been ^^ And thanks ^^ actually going to Disneyland today for that
@@charguigou I will never forgive myself for skipping France Disneyland when I was over there :/ IDK I find Erica a bit 'airy' and very inverse from what I consider my fav Chang-es (eg Croatian, English, Brazilian, French)
@@raneemacintosh6842 i don’t know well enough all Chang’e voices, but I know Brazilian is one of my least fav, sounds like Taryn, but in much more basic and forgettable
@@charguigou See I get that vibe yet somehow still like her quite a lot. Japanese is the abject worst to me. IDK what they've been doing, thank god for Mirabel, because Japanese princesses/heroines fell off big time.
So nice to see a new video from you! ❤️ It's a little difficult to express my opinion here since I adore the majority of the Italian voices and I have never considered them individually. My main disagreements are Tosca and Barbara's low places but overall we agree!
What a marvelous video! I'll never stop praising your elegant editing, and those 60fps images... so satisfying. About the ranking... my boy, Italian people will hate you hahaha. But, believe it or not, I won't, despite seeing Laura and Marjorie that high, who I don't really like (almost dislike actually). All the praises for my country's dubbers fulfilled me with joy, and that's the most important part. Thank you very much, and great job once again ;-)
I’m glad you could still enjoy the video a bit then ^^’ And I hope I remained respectful enough in my comments, only trying to explain my view, I’m not here to insult any singer
@@charguigou don't worry, you weren't disrespectful towards anyone. Dare I say that I would be much harsher than you were if I had to judge my own versions XD
Great to see a new video, my friend ;). We don't really agree though lol. Barbara Cola, Simona Pattituci, and Tosca are great fav's of mine. And I really dislike Laura Chiatti, and I also don't like Marjorie that much, but I do appreciate you putting Marianna Cataldi so high!
So very great to see a new video from you! I honestly really missed them! as always great work with the editing. I can't say we agree alot here lol. Tho I really like Italian Elsa like you do ;)
Italian voices are great so ranking them sounds just too tough for me but you did such a great job! After following you for so many years I can't say I didn't expect many of these placements, though haha I think Serena Autieri's was the biggest surprise as I thought she would be first heh. What you say about her LIG performance is so true! She was the one that made me fall in love with the song, but it took me years to realise that it was _specially_ her performance of that song that I liked. Actually number one might have been the biggest surprise, but not because of your opinion but mine. I've been attempting (key word) to make a Belle ranking, and I've realised my opinion towards her has changed a lot over the years and now hearing her Odette I get the same feeling and I hate it, I feel like I'm cheating on Marjorie and myself ;-; Her Thumbelina remains absolutely perfect to me, though, and I'm very glad that hasn't changed
Haha yeah for those who've been following for such a long time, this ranking isn't much of a surprise! Same here, it's especially with Frozen 2, while she's still awesome, that I realized that I love Serena's performance of "Let It Go" more than I actually love her for the character. I'm glad you like Marjorie too, she is truly unique. I'm glad you liked the video :)
Oh thanks that’s really sweet. I had to stop using AVS as it was lagging too much, so I used Filmora, and tired to keep the same essence of the editing anyway
First off, I love the new magic trail effect! It gives off such a whimsical feeling. Secondly, Italian is one of my three favorite languages, along with Japanese and Mandarin. My favorite voice is Ilaria; thanks for her placement!
Great ranking,Guillaume!! My only disagreements are Tosca and Barbara's low places...... But we share our favorites! My favorites are Ilaria de Rosa,Ludovica Comello,Violetta Zironi,Chiara Grispo,Naomi Rivieccio and Erica de Matteis. I agree with you,Guillaume,I respect your opinion!
As always, we share the same number one. Marjorie is the voice of my childhood, maybe because I always loved her voice that is soft but can also be strong, or pheraps because Belle is my favorite princess and she always had my favorite voice actresses (not only Marjorie but also Jana Warner and Bénédicte Lécroart). Tina Centi is my second favorite : she is probably the most talented singing voice actresses we Italians ever had. I always disagreed with you about Simona but I get your point and I think that a person who is not Italian cannot understand why it works for us. It goes beyond our affection for her, it is just that in Italy women are louder and maybe more expressive than in other countries. Plus, her speaking voice and acting are amazing. I agree that sometimes, during the songs, she overused it, sounding too much powerful and theatrical. But to our ears, it works.. That's how we speak and sing in our country.. En tous cas, encore une fois, je tiens à te remercier d'avoir créé et partagé une si belle vidéo, Guillaume.
Thanks a lot, and yeah we agree about Marjorie. Well, I do speak Italian for a lot of years now, and I'm used to Italian dubbings; Simona just sounds too much anyway. It's not a matter of being Italian or not here I believe, it's just a matter of taste and it works for some and not for others. Renata is just as expressive for example, but doesn't annoy me like Simona I mean. Grazie mille per il commento!
Sofia is just kid voices who are for most part pitched to sound kiddish. It’s just artificial sounding voices made for a cartoon, I can’t compare that to real voices and characters with big songs
I really love watching your videos and this one is great, as always! We don't agree much here to be honest, even with Marjorie, I'm not the biggest fan. Agree on Ilaria being a breath of fresh air, she's absolutely stunning! My feelings for Naomi Rivieccio are so powerful, I still remember how excited I was when I first heard her in these songs, she sounds like an ancient Italian princess in the Colloseum !
Glad you have found a way to create videos, hope we're gonna see a character ranking soon...
Glad to see a new ranking from you! It's funny how "your" great italian voices start at 20. It really shows how good these voices are! I can say we agree in most choices, especially your top 5! I haven't listened Mulan's voice that much, but seems like it's an amazing version! And the other 4 voices are truly gems! I will always love the Serena duo, and I'm glad you really Laura as Rapunzel, as she doesn't have too many fans sadly. Marjorie's Odette is truly amazing :D
I really enjoyed watching this, most placings weren't surprising at all because they reflect the opinions in your character rankings, but I loved reading the comments for each voice!
I kinda agree with you overall (apart from, for example, your unpopular opinions on Simona or Barbara, but hey, they are called unpopular for a reason).
I'm so glad you like Renata so much, she's a favorite for me and lots of other Italians
Yeah, sorry again for Barbara, Simona and Tosca, I know you guys really love them, and the nostalgia factor in more :/
I really wish Renata could have been Ariel since the beginning, she deserved to have her own big role!
Marjorie is extraordinary, and has been my fav since a long time now :)
Beautiful video! You managed to outdo yourself again with the incredible editing 😯😍
Thank you :)
The clips are so smooth to see, and the transitions too!
We agree more or less, but at the end that's what opinions are :)
So glad to see a new one of these from you! Barbara Cola low is gonna kill me lol. I don't pay attention to Zipporah voices but I love your comment there! Big facts on Renata, I find they miscast her many times even though her voice is pretty in theory. For that I've never been able to fully love her. On the other hand I truly do not like the Italian Chang-E. I don't find she can handle the songs that well. I think a lot of us agree: the Frozen sisters are the peak for Italian dubs. Big loves.
Overall I just love so much that you've been doing this so long but your tastes still ebb and flow; on my end my Disney tastes have stagnated though I have fond memories of my old loves.
PS: Happy late bday :D
Glad to see a comment from you ^^
Unfortunately I’m not hearing again correctly so that’s probably my last video..
Oh really? What makes you say that (about Chang’e)?
Yeah, tastes always evolve somehow I believe, though here I would say it’s rather much the same as it’s always been ^^
And thanks ^^ actually going to Disneyland today for that
@@charguigou I will never forgive myself for skipping France Disneyland when I was over there :/
IDK I find Erica a bit 'airy' and very inverse from what I consider my fav Chang-es (eg Croatian, English, Brazilian, French)
@@raneemacintosh6842 i don’t know well enough all Chang’e voices, but I know Brazilian is one of my least fav, sounds like Taryn, but in much more basic and forgettable
@@charguigou See I get that vibe yet somehow still like her quite a lot. Japanese is the abject worst to me. IDK what they've been doing, thank god for Mirabel, because Japanese princesses/heroines fell off big time.
So nice to see a new video from you! ❤️
It's a little difficult to express my opinion here since I adore the majority of the Italian voices and I have never considered them individually. My main disagreements are Tosca and Barbara's low places but overall we agree!
Thanks :)
What a marvelous video! I'll never stop praising your elegant editing, and those 60fps images... so satisfying.
About the ranking... my boy, Italian people will hate you hahaha. But, believe it or not, I won't, despite seeing Laura and Marjorie that high, who I don't really like (almost dislike actually). All the praises for my country's dubbers fulfilled me with joy, and that's the most important part.
Thank you very much, and great job once again ;-)
I’m glad you could still enjoy the video a bit then ^^’
And I hope I remained respectful enough in my comments, only trying to explain my view, I’m not here to insult any singer
@@charguigou don't worry, you weren't disrespectful towards anyone. Dare I say that I would be much harsher than you were if I had to judge my own versions XD
Great to see a new video, my friend ;). We don't really agree though lol. Barbara Cola, Simona Pattituci, and Tosca are great fav's of mine. And I really dislike Laura Chiatti, and I also don't like Marjorie that much, but I do appreciate you putting Marianna Cataldi so high!
Thanks :) And yeah I know Simona, Tosca and Barbara are people's favourites, sorry for that
@@charguigou It's your opinion. Very glad that you're back!
So very great to see a new video from you! I honestly really missed them! as always great work with the editing. I can't say we agree alot here lol. Tho I really like Italian Elsa like you do ;)
Italian voices are great so ranking them sounds just too tough for me but you did such a great job! After following you for so many years I can't say I didn't expect many of these placements, though haha
I think Serena Autieri's was the biggest surprise as I thought she would be first heh. What you say about her LIG performance is so true! She was the one that made me fall in love with the song, but it took me years to realise that it was _specially_ her performance of that song that I liked.
Actually number one might have been the biggest surprise, but not because of your opinion but mine. I've been attempting (key word) to make a Belle ranking, and I've realised my opinion towards her has changed a lot over the years and now hearing her Odette I get the same feeling and I hate it, I feel like I'm cheating on Marjorie and myself ;-; Her Thumbelina remains absolutely perfect to me, though, and I'm very glad that hasn't changed
Haha yeah for those who've been following for such a long time, this ranking isn't much of a surprise!
Same here, it's especially with Frozen 2, while she's still awesome, that I realized that I love Serena's performance of "Let It Go" more than I actually love her for the character.
I'm glad you like Marjorie too, she is truly unique.
I'm glad you liked the video :)
I always LOVE the new editing and style! You’re the best!!! >
Oh thanks that’s really sweet. I had to stop using AVS as it was lagging too much, so I used Filmora, and tired to keep the same essence of the editing anyway
First off, I love the new magic trail effect! It gives off such a whimsical feeling.
Secondly, Italian is one of my three favorite languages, along with Japanese and Mandarin. My favorite voice is Ilaria; thanks for her placement!
Haha thanks, I was afraid it would look a bit stupid, glad you liked the effect ^^
i missed your rankings!
Great ranking,Guillaume!! My only disagreements are Tosca and Barbara's low places...... But we share our favorites! My favorites are Ilaria de Rosa,Ludovica Comello,Violetta Zironi,Chiara Grispo,Naomi Rivieccio and Erica de Matteis. I agree with you,Guillaume,I respect your opinion!
Great video, loved it!! Would love to see a brazilian version of this video
I’ve already done a Brazilian ranking of heroines, you can find it on my channel
I expected that Serena to be #1 and that really surprised me haha Great job!
As always, we share the same number one. Marjorie is the voice of my childhood, maybe because I always loved her voice that is soft but can also be strong, or pheraps because Belle is my favorite princess and she always had my favorite voice actresses (not only Marjorie but also Jana Warner and Bénédicte Lécroart). Tina Centi is my second favorite : she is probably the most talented singing voice actresses we Italians ever had. I always disagreed with you about Simona but I get your point and I think that a person who is not Italian cannot understand why it works for us. It goes beyond our affection for her, it is just that in Italy women are louder and maybe more expressive than in other countries. Plus, her speaking voice and acting are amazing. I agree that sometimes, during the songs, she overused it, sounding too much powerful and theatrical. But to our ears, it works.. That's how we speak and sing in our country.. En tous cas, encore une fois, je tiens à te remercier d'avoir créé et partagé une si belle vidéo, Guillaume.
Thanks a lot, and yeah we agree about Marjorie.
Well, I do speak Italian for a lot of years now, and I'm used to Italian dubbings; Simona just sounds too much anyway. It's not a matter of being Italian or not here I believe, it's just a matter of taste and it works for some and not for others. Renata is just as expressive for example, but doesn't annoy me like Simona I mean.
Grazie mille per il commento!
Ótimo ranking,Guillaume!! Só discordo com algumas coisas! Nós temos as mesmas favoritas,não temos?
Italian is actually my favorite language.
😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃.
Omg I thought you said you were done making videos
Love
Odette's singing voice
Animated Belle's voice 2 movie
Rapunzel's voice
Elsa's voice
Melody's voice
Mirabel's voice
Change's voice
Fei Fei's voice
Moana's voice
Esmeralda's voice
Mulan's voice
Nice ranking, could you make a
ranking for European Portuguese?
Will come yeah
What movie is Fei Fei from?
Over the Moon, like Chang'e
As much I love the rankings, you’re always forgetting about Sofia. Elena literally wouldn’t exist without her.
Sofia is just kid voices who are for most part pitched to sound kiddish. It’s just artificial sounding voices made for a cartoon, I can’t compare that to real voices and characters with big songs
Am I the only one who found that Pocahontas is in bottom in almost all language rankings?
Dutch Disney Heroines Please.🇳🇱
Already done, check my channel
There is one
Megara Ariel Anastasia Moana
omg slay first pin me
New phone, who dis
@@charguigou ur phone privileges are now gone