Best Small Boat? Jon Boat - Flat Bottom Boat or V Hull?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- Is a flat bottom jon boat a better small boat than a V hull utility boat? In this video I talk about v hull jon boats, flat bottom boats, small utility boats and look at the advantages and disadvantages of both types of small boats. There may be no best small boat - but there are little boats that are better suited for certain tasks. I have owned both a 12 foot jon boat and a 12 foot V hull boat and learned a bit about the type of little boat that is best suited for me. If you're looking for a small boat, a little jon boat or other flat bottom boat offer some advantages over a V hull little boat. Depending on the types of water where you go boating or fishing, each little boat has pros and cons.
#flatbottomboat #vhullboat #utilityboat
Timestamps:
00:00 Introduction
00:56 Flat Bottom Small Boats - Jon Boats
04:12 V Hull Small Boats - Utility Boats
06:13 Wider Boats Are More Stable
❤️ Subscribe to my TH-cam Channel / waynetheboatguy
📷 Follow me on instagram! / waynetheboatguy
☞ Follow me on TikTok! / waynetheboatguy
▶︎▶︎▶︎Playlists About Boats
🚤 Tiny Boat/Jon Boat Stuff • Tiny Boat - Little Boa...
💰 Boat Shopping • Boat Shopping
🐋 Boston Whaler • Boston Whaler Videos
🛥 Boats, Boat Trips & Boat Accessories • Boats, Boating Trips, ...
⚡️ Electric Boats & Electric Boating • Electric Powered Boats...
🛶 Kayaks & Kayaking • Kayaking & Kayak upgrades
🪦 Curtis Creek Maryland Ship Graveyard • Curtis Creek Maryland ...
🎲 Boating Shorts • Boating Shorts
▶︎▶︎▶︎Boat Engines & Motors Playlists
💭 2 Stroke Outboard Motors • 2 Stroke Outboard Engi...
⛽︎ Mercury 2.5 hp two stroke outboard videos • Mercury 2.5 hp Two Str...
⚙️ Volvo Penta Maintenance & Repairs • Volvo Penta Maintenanc...
🌎 Newport NT300 electric outboard • Newport NT300 3 hp Ele...
🚽 Evinrude 2 - 2 hp engine • Evinrude 2 - old Evinr...
🔒 Seized Suzuki DF20 • Suzuki DF20 Short Shaf...
🔧 Inboard/Outboard Maintenance • Inboard Outboard (Ster...
▶︎▶︎▶︎ Boat Repairs & Projects Playlists
🛠 Low Cost Boat Repairs & Projects • Low Cost DIY Repair & ...
🔨 Boat Transom Projects • Boat Transom Projects
🧰 Boat Repair & Maintenance • Boat repair, maintenan...
🛞 Boat Trailer Projects • Boat Trailer Repairs &...
▶︎▶︎▶︎New Boater Playlists
📌 Boating Education & Tips • Boating Education and ...
📓 Boating Basics • Boating Basics for New...
🆘 Boat Safety • Boat Safety - videos t...
❄️ Boat Winterization • Boat Winterization
Sound effects and additional music is copyright free from iMovie
Some of the video clips come from Pexels
Pond video by Jyoti Pur from Pexels
Shallow water drone video by Claudiu Ciobanu from Pexels - บันเทิง
When I was a kid (12 years old) my friends and I built flat bottom boats made out marine play wood. About 8 ft long and a 5 hp engine. We raced them in the lake behind our homes. If you think they would leak, we seal them with paint, water sealer and brass screws. They were fun.
Damn, at 12 you must have been crafty, I built a 8 foot flat button v boat made out of regular plywood at 16 yrs old. I later extended it to 10 foot. You are correct they don't leak if made correct with sealer and good waterproof paint. One thing I remember I must have put a lot of brass screws in because my right wrist hurt for a month or so. LoL
@@doug3819 less serious in fact because it was in play wood !
I'm 12 and I also want to build a boat
My daughter is 13 and made an 8' boat out of plywood this past summer. They were known as seafleas or hydroplanes. She used a design out of popular mechanics from the '50s. However, the front half was not flat, and for the bending, she definitely needed my help (and both our ingenuity).
Should mention, sealed with waterproof glue, then seams were fibreglassed (which also required adult supervision).
In Australia we refer to the Jon boat as a punt and generally call the V-hull a dinghy. If they're made from aluminium, we call both styles a tinny. I've owned both punts and dinghies and I have found the v-nose punt to be the best fit for my needs, especially the ones where the V section extends about 1/3 of the hull length.
a tinny, I love it haha. You guys have the best names for stuff.
We call small vhull boats dinghys as well.
Virtually all 'v-bottom' boats constructed since the 1940s have been hybrids - v hull in front, flat in back. A hybrid hull remains stable in wind or wake, efficiently cuts and planes, and is reasonably stable from standstill to high speeds (until it chines). I have lived offshore on Georgian Bay all my life (Lake Huron), and so all my boats are v-hulls, river canoes excepted.
Yeah, I don’t know as much about boats as I do fishing in general, but I bought an old 12’ Smoker Craft a few years ago and pretty quickly notice the same thing, wide and flat in the middle and stern, deep V in the bow. I love that I can drive off the floor I fabricated to fit the front half, and still climb back in over the rear gunnel. Put a mud motor on it a couple of years ago, and that opened up so many shallow water fishing opportunities. It’s early May and right now the panfish are heavy in the marshy shallows on few of my favorite lakes here in Michigan. Ya’ ain’t gonna get anywhere near these fish with a traditional outboard.
@@rogerharvey1698 I have that exact same boat. 12 ft Smokercraft, mines pre 1972 old lol. What mud motor kit/engine are you using? Does it get up to a decent speed?
seems to be a overstatement to say virtually all v hulls are hybrids. the V in the video was a semi v. you an tell by looking at the transom no v. I've had a few of the semi v style and several full v hulled boats. most runabouts are in full V configuration. i have a 18foot in full V hull, deep v in fact as well as my old lund which was a 16 foot 7 foot beam deep V. i have a couple friends that own jon style boats that are semi v. they will cut through the chop a little better than a flat bottom, (a tab bit better imo) nothing like a full v though.
@@drewp9112 That 'semi-v' you mention is one form of hybrid. I would include boats with a slight v at the transom as hybrids too. I can't recall seeing any mass produced full-v hulls since the 1940s.
@@1stcarpgroupcommissioner659 i regard a v hull as a hull that carries the v to the transom. my Tracker Targa V18 is imo a v hull boat. as was my old Lund v16 deep v. i dont know what would define those as hybrid they are not flat at the transom.
As somebody who is in the market for buying their first small boat, this channel is absolutely fantastic! Thank you so much for posting content like this!
Same here
My parents purchased a Lake home on Lake Hamilton in Hot Springs AR in 1970. Our first boat was a 14ft flat bottom with a 1968 18hp Evinrude. I'm 65yrs old now and have owned everything from Cobalts to BAJA's and never have had as much fun as we had in the flat bottom.
im on the catfish capital of TX with a 14ft deep wide v with 1959 18 hp evinrude and purr's like a kitten...gotta love those OG MOTOR'S
14 foot cabin cruserr exist
I have a 14 foot Jon Boat with the traditional square bow. I have a 9.9 Mercury outboard and a small trolling motor. I primarily use it for fishing. I absolutely love this boat. It has plenty of room, very stable, and is really fast with this motor! I don’t go out on rough days or huge lakes.
I had a 1448 Jon. Loved it. 9.9 hp and it flew in a smooth lake. Waves, it would beat you up bad. But all I do is fish small local lakes and it sneaks in to the shallows real well. Also, I've stood on a.seat, toes against the hull, and a like sized buddy doing the same. Both of us at about 250. And still had at least 12 inches of freeboard.
I have a 1971 12' mirrocraft v hul! You made it easy to choose between the two styles of small boats! I have a great time out on the water and enjoy my boat! Thanks!
I have a 12' Jon boat. the lakes I fish on are small (50-75 acres) and one has a restriction to electric motors. So for me a Jon boat with a 36lb trolling motor suits my needs just fine. Love your videos.
ektrc bayliñer best
Flat bottomed boats make your rockin world go round. 🎶
I had a 12' flat bottom jon boat for about 10 happy years. wife and I used it for pond fishing and picnics - hibachi on the front seat. That was 30+ years ago. I just bought a 12' Lowe Sea Nymph V Hull with a Mercury 6 hp 4 stroke. I usually go boating alone so the stability is not a problem. Looking forward to many hours on the pond / lake / river.
1954 14’ Alumacraft model F here, been in family since new. It’s what I call a semi-V, has V hull up front and flat going back. Put a nice floor in it and a 15hp Johnson, lots of fun opened up on a big lake! We love it, my family uses it weekly still. Great video!
How does that hull shape perform in shallow water? From what you describe, I have a very similar boat. 12ft smokercraft V in the front, flat in the back.
Any advice on how to get a floor down? Wouldn’t mind doing at least the mid section between the benches*
I Bought a 60' 14ft Alumacraft Model FD and i love it i have a 25hp johnson on it and it takes off handles wakes at speed really good.
@@74nova36 use foam sheets cut into strips to build the middle up, you can glue them together but not to the floor, and then marine plywood over leveled foam. Easy to remove on off to check for leaks /repairs.
Mini tug boat 21 moh 15 hp 16.6 mog 49 Mike rabge
My first boat was a 14 foot tracker Topper, I had a 1983 2 stroke 9.9hp Evinrude motor on the back. It was cool until the motor gave me problems, and it did terrible in rougher waters. We took on a lot of water one day on the river and that was the turning point for me. I prefer a bigger v-hulled boat. So I sold it and bought an 18 foot center console boat, repowered it with a new 2022 Suzuki 115hp 4 stroke outboard motor and I love it!
One of the big advantages of a Jon boat is how well they row, and how effective they can be with smaller motors. I have a 14ft Jon boat with a sliding rowing seat, and it really skims across the water. That flat bottom also means they can get up on a plane with a very small outboard.
Having grown up using small v-bottom skiffs, I think they are the absolute best for any kind of rough water, but for bays and smaller lakes the flat bottom has a lot of advantages.
Also your comment about how Jon boats handle is spot on. Even with a 5 horse, my Jon boat needs careful handling at speed. The back end has no resistance to turning and it's really easy for the boat to slew over badly if you try to turn too quickly.
I was able to row a family owned 14' flat bottom Jon boat and it was unreal how fast that thing could go.
I've owned several Jon Boats from 10 ft up to 14 ft. I usually do most of my boating on large lakes, so they pretty much beat me to death under power. My last three boats were V-hull boats. A 12 ft, a 14 ft and a 23 ft, powered with outboards from 3hp up to 115hp! All were more to my liking and a lot more comfortable under power. They worked great in waves and rough water like I find on big lakes. Four years ago I built a 12 foot, flat bottom, pointed boat. I call it a Fishing Skiff that I designed myself from pictures of various fishing boats I found on the internet. It has a good rocker, not much tumblehome and was rather unstable (similar to a canoe, which I've also owned two of) in the wind or on open water because of it's narrow width. So, I added two pontoons and now I can take it on big lakes. However, it only has an electric motor, so I don't travel very far or fast. Click my name if you want to see video of how I built it or see my first "Sea Trial."
Parker 2320 whales 235 cinqwset searay 230 sundacer
But is a 12 foot a better choice than a 14 foot? This video talks about the advantages of each size! th-cam.com/video/QBFMBts5UTE/w-d-xo.html
And if you're in the market for a brand new boat/engine/trailer for under $5,000 - here's a few options that I have put together: th-cam.com/video/SfJhaEXVKSQ/w-d-xo.html
Thank you sir for reading my comment love your channel!!!!
@@kennethwalsh5056 thank YOU!
Got a Lowe 1240. I haven’t touched my 12ft vhull since. Paired the lowe with a 9.9 Yamaha. Gets 28mph down river. Love that boat. Super controllable and super stable for fishing. I even added a plywood deck and a front mounted tiller trolling motor
Nice! From the web site, that one seems pretty wide, but they don't say how wide.
@@WayneTheBoatGuy If it's a 1240, it should be 40" wide across the bottom.
Cracking video Wayne... really enjoyed this.
I reasonably bought a 3.3 meter inflatable (10ft) , so a flat bottom. Super light and super shallow, it makes my fishing days more enjoyable 😁🎣
I have a 16’ crest liner AMF ‘77 v hull. I love it. It’s seen some very rough conditions and still remained floating.
I bought a Tracker Topper 12w 2 years ago in March. I use to have a bass boat many years ago when I tournament fished. It was a 1960's model so that should tell you how many years ago it was. We moved from Kansas to Alabama (summer of 2021) and I have considered purchasing a bass boat within a couple years. A personal friend of mine, Richard Gene the Fishing Machine, told me the boat I have is all I need. I'm only a couple miles from the Tennessee River and many other smaller lakes than the size of the river.
I love my Tracker Topper and plan on upgrading a lot of things including my outboard and installing a floor and storage. I will be adding those videos to my channel when I do so.
Thanx for this video brother. I'll be checking out more from you in the future. Thanx for adding to use your PFD when you weren't using one. We all make mistakes when filming. I know I do each and every time.
Yeah be sure to record all your upgrade and improvement projects!
I have an old 12' v-bottom aluminum boat made in the '60s by sears. I use it mostly for fishing in a small lake. It's actually quite stable to stand in so long as I'm in the middle to back. I have heard that the flat bottom boats are more stable, but I just got what I could find and afford, and it still gets me out on the water! Thanks for all your videos Wayne! Love the channel!
Thank YOU for watching!!
What motor you run?
@@Evening120 30lb thrust minn kota electric
Flat bottoms are good if you like to do things near the bank and occasionally want to get out on the bank without getting your feet wet.
@@matthewcacace6804 You'd be surprised how well your rig would handle a Johnson 15!
I have a 14' fiberglass flatbottom boat, and a 14' V Hull. And love them both
Only boat I've ever owned is my Alumacraft 1232, purchased that over the 14' because it was small enough to fit in my shed. Fun little boat, but man wake is my enemy. I've only used it a few times with the little 6hp Mercury, but it scoots at 17 to 18mph with just me in it. I added launch wheels on the back transom that fold up when in the water, and fold down when ready to launch or retrieve. I haven't had to back my trailer down since I've done that, saves so much time being able to just literally pull up to the ramp and walk it out to my trailer!
Hi Wayne, I am fortunate enough to have one of each: a 1236 Jon boated rated for 10 hp and a 12 Princecraft seasprite also rated for 10 hp. I find that the vhull is better suited for larger lakes, while the Jon boat is great for small pothole lakes. I do find that you are seated higher in the v-hull and it is therefore more comfortable for longer days on the water. The seats on the Jon boats are lower. When I bring my portable seat, I find that the center of higher in the Jon boat and not as stable. I have an 8hp Johnson 2 stroke, a Yamaha 4 stroke 4 hp and a minnkota 55lb electric motor. I prefer the 8 hp on the v-hull, and the 4 hp on the Jon boat. I had a 1032 Jon before , but I found it too unstable, even with the 4 hp. Better off with the 12 ft Jon boat.
I just Got a V hull. Been modding it, put in a floor and some paint. cant wait to test it out
My grandfather had a 14' or 16' V-hull Richline boat. He always said you can't beat a Richline. We buzzed around in the lake of the Ozarks quite often. I miss him and his boat.
Flat bottoms provide more initial stability. Rounded hulls have more secondary stability. The rougher the conditions, the more you'll want secondary stability.
A soft chine boat with a weighted keel and raised stern is ideal for blue water. A 'steadying sail is used on some trawler hulls to good effect. Full and semi-displacement boats will usually be rounded/soft chine boats that don't 'slap' the water.
@@youdonthavetoreadthispost.5850 I imagine most people won't be out in blue water conditions in a Jon boat, and I'm not aware of a Jon boat with a weighted keel.
That being said, I'd hate to be on a flat bottomed trawler if any existed.
@@wisenber And you'd be right. Small dories do quite well however. The soft chine, deep draft hulls wouldn't work in Jon boat country either. That said, the only thing more stable is a twin hull cat.
@@youdonthavetoreadthispost.5850 Or a trimaran. Mine will float in four inches of water and sail in about 8 inches. My 19 ft trimaran isn't blue water by any stretch, but she manages 6 ft waves without complaining.
@@youdonthavetoreadthispost.5850 One thing about small dories is that they are quite twitchy when lighly loaded. Dories with a hard chine need a lot of weight to achieve that legendary stability they are known for.
Love the way you present your video with a good dollop of humour: great 👍 stuff. Very entertaining. Thanks
This was very helpful. Took my new Suzuki 6 hp out on my 12 foot flat bottom boat yesterday and it was scary. I'm looking for a V hull for it now. Your video helped. Thank You
Hi Wayne, the negatives of flat bottom boat or the Jon boat are very easy to overcome. Trim tabs can very easily erase all the negatives plus the bow rise will also lessen.
Very nicely done video Wayne. Well edited as well.
I had the Tracker Grizzly Jon boat the 1860 it’s discontinued. It was from 2016. Im six feet four big boy and i could stand on the absolute edge of the boat and that thing was so stable the other side never came out of the water my brother was on land to see for sure. He owns the boat now in Florida and fishes it in salt and fresh! A great boat!!! All welded heavy gauge aluminum!!
18 fot tuser exist
Good video on the comparison of the boats. Thank you for sharing.
I grew up in little Bay Jamaica and we had were v Hull cotton wooden canoes so you're so right😊
This was helpful, we have gone full time RV, we want to be able to bring a small boat with us for fishing wherever we are camping, so it has to be light enough for the two of us to lift up and place on racks on top of our truck, and my husband isn’t a strong swimmer so stability is a must have!
My dad built a flat bottomed Jon boat in our garage in 1971. He ordered a custom made 14 ft (?) single sheet of plywood for the bottom. Otherwise a relatively easy build (my dad having already built a v-bottom boat)
Great in protected shallow waters, not so good in rough open water.
That didn’t stop my brother from crossing the Mississippi Sound to Horn Island. But I sure as hell wouldn’t have!
I'm from Florida and have only ever been on John boats. The flat bottoms and shallow water make it great for the rivers, creeks, and lakes. I moved to MN and saw the V hulls and fell in love a little. I lucked into one recently! 14 foot alumacraft - I'm glad to hear they have some benefits!
Nice!
v hulkà like yaghts capbin cryser best rliçw içrwan bamhas miamí tpo flïrad jeys
really great video, Wayne! thanks
18 ft lowe tunnel bottom pump runs above the bottom, it is the ultimate shallow water log jumping design. Turning is a bit unpredictable but is the shallow water king. 18ft Lund Alaskan model, a very good rough water design and a staple for natives around the coast of Alaska. One lost in the Bering sea floated 400 miles south and found floating half full of water.
Excellent & informative video! Thank you.
The Jon boat tracking issue can be solved by adding a keel (of sorts). I ran a 13 foot Jon boat with a 35 HP Mercury on it. At first it was REALLY snaky in the water. I added an aluminum strip to the bottom (exactly the kind that was also found on the side of my boat to stiffen it), and that helped A BUNCH.
Yes sir! My Keel is the Key. Lol
13 fiiit cabjnncrus r s exist
I boated in on Inland Bays and I boated for years on a 12ft boat with V in the front but flat in the aft half. It gave the pros of both types.
I have a 16' fisher v bottom, with a Johnson J25 motor. When I got the boat there wasn't anything weight wise in the boat, it was fairly unstable, when moving around, or trading places with the person up front. Since then I've added around 120 pounds of weight (extra battery for added trolling motor, larger fuel tank, a couple of anchors etc) the extra weight has helped a lot with the stability.
That does seem to help!
Hey! Just found these videos! Love them! I just bought my first boat...a 1989 Grumman 14' V-Bass Boat...thank you!
Thank you for (hopefully) educating many small boaters with your correct definition of 'what is a Jon boat', (not spelled 'John' either). So many people, like you said, believe any small boat is a Jon boat which makes it very difficult to search for a true Jon boat on public classifieds. "Ignorance is bliss" so it's pointless to try to educate those who improperly label a v-hull as a Jon as they become very defensive of their lack of knowledge.
Everyone in Louisiana calls a flat bottom, Jon boat, a Bateau.
Thank u for the content. My wife and i are looking into purchasing a boat in the next few years so we are taking our time and doing our research and actually asking ourselves what we want out of the boat itself. Ty again
Cabinncruser 170 liters 42.5 gaons 250 NM rabge 281 ies range cmfull canb 15 fet 6 knch beds 7 feet 8 jnch bug cabin sex get wife iregebt
I have owned both along with many other ski, sail, pontoon, ... boats. For me I think in most situations the V hull is preferable. The draft difference is rarely going to be an issue and as you stated if you want a flat surface to walk on it is an easy/inexpensive modification. After that the benefits of better stability in rough waters and at speed are common issues. That said, flat bottoms are perfectly serviceable for many of the same situations.
One place I preferred flat bottom, flat front boats was for pick up/safety boats during ski shows. They seemed a little more convenient for picking up dropped skis and downed skiers.
You bring up some great points!
Thank you for making this!
I solved the issue by owning both. The jonboat for small lakes and duck hunting, the v hull for big lake fishing and bay crabbing. Both are extra wide and that really helps. Beware the skinny 30 inch floor jonboat - very unstable. My 12 foot jonboat has a 40 inch bottom and with 2.5 hp motor and trailer for $3000.
I have a 14.5 v-hull with a 30hp Merc. Good for the water I fish and for handling waves. I did deck it out with 2 flat floors , a front pitching deck and a rear casting deck. The flat floors make a big difference and reduce that side leaning when walking around. It feels safer with floors.
That thing must be pretty quick with a 30hp! I'm glad to hear the floors make it feel safer - that's what I hope to accomplish.
sçit ¹45 hybdé veßt boat 8 hoúrs 8 m0h 64 mioe eltrc rabge
I’m currently restoring an old 60s model v hull. I’ve never really messed with boat repair, so it’s a learn as I go process, but I was definitely thinking about adding a deck and possibly some flooring. How did you do the flooring on yours?
I've got a 14 ft alum vhull to with a 25 hp Johnson I've had foat bottom as well I like the vhull better it takes rough water alot better and I agree flat floors make it so much better
Scout 145 hybred best
Your videos are funny and wholesome, my daughter and I enjoy watching. Thanks for sharing!
I'm Canadian.
V-Hull for me due to their stability on big lakes when the conditions get ugly.
I have a 14" Lund SSV, 20" transom, tiller steer with a 25 HP merc and a 5HP merc long shaft kicker.
It's a great little rig and when it gets ugly I can still safely make it back to the launch.
New 5 hp propane outbard
I have 1448 flat bottom with a floor I put in and can take out . Using on fresh water electric motors only. For tide water I have a semi v 16 ft, Great video for new person on the water.
My favorite is a small pontoon boat. Very stable and easy to get on and off. Thanks for sharing.
Yes they do have some real advantages
Started with a 14 ft v hull as my first boat with a 25 hp and upgraded to a flat bottom smokercraft 1866 with a 90/65 jet. I mainly use mine for lakes and rivers but wouldn’t mind taking it in the salt in calmer waters
Ive got a tracker jon boat with a 30hp on it and its alot of fun to drive and also fish with.... its pretty quick 35mph.
I've owned both as well.
Ended up selling the Jon's and keeping the utility V's....
Jon's are typically cheaper and lighter weight but they have very shalloow freeboards and prefer very calm to no wind.
Utility Vs are more money and weigh heavier but deeper and can handle windier seas.
My opinion.
Great video. Liked and subscribed. I have a 1971 groom and 12 ft. V hull aluminum boat. Using a bulletproof 2.3 hp Honda four stroke, air cooled outboard. Since replacing the prop with an aluminum one with a slightly more aggressive pitch, I’m actually getting 8 miles an hour. Not going to win no races but it works good and gets me where I want to go.
8 mph is pretty cool with a 2.3!
Good job, Wayne. Well though out, and presented.
Thank you!
Had them both for a half century. When I was a kid I loved the flat for showing off and hopping. When I got older I like the smooth ride better with the V cutting through the waves.
I do miss my flat with a 50 hp. It was an animal…that I couldn’t control very well. I would pass bass boats with 175 hp motors all day long!
The problems I’ve had with Jon boats has been the low weight weight rating. Seems to be about half of that of a V bottom for some reason. The 12 and 10 ft boats I’ve had had a rating of around 300 pounds. The other problem with Jon boats is they don’t like to go straight. They seem to require more attention when you’re trying to steer or row in a straight line. They get off coarse quickly.
I have an Alumacraft 1448 that I bought new 4 years ago and added front and rear casting decks before I even got it wet 😁. This winter I removed all of the wood decking I put in and cut out the center bench to make more room for walking and I'm using only aluminum and EVA foam flooring this time around. I don't ever take it on any big water but it's very stable for 2 guys in smaller lakes and rivers. Having fished the boat now for a bit, I do wish I would've gone with a modified V or Vhull. It gets pretty sketchy when I'm around other boat wakes.
Did you lose and rigidity when you removed the center bench? I've been wanting to try some EVA foam flooring.
Wayne, I have both a 12' flat bottom jon boat and a 12 foot v hull, and use the flat bottom boat for super shallow tidal waters with hidden stumps etc.. The flat boat is very temperamental with a second person and needs a strong trolling motor or tiny outboard, weight sensitive and sort of dangerous in waves or wakes. I feel safer in the v hull overall, but the flat bottomed one is good for still shallow water fishing.
for fishing on ponds/smaller lakes without other boats i prefer a jon like the 1236 i have.. u could also go on larger water with a jon.. but then i would atleast go get a bigger boat.. at that point u cant carry the boat anymore and might aswell step up to a pe or polyester boat.. like a carolina skiff costs a bit more (or a whaler if u have big pockets).. but is also a lot safer on bigger lakes..
I have an-hull 16’ with 40 hp merc. I have encountered 3’ waves on my way home on the lake. The v-hull was the best boat in those circumstances. I have not seen a Jon boat style on our lake.
whaler 13 best
I was raised on deep V hull wooden boats. Graduated into semi deep V (3/4) aluminum hulls. The waters are the Puget Sound of Washington State.
Though in the past few years I have purchased a sit on top fishing kayak.
I use the aluminum (WW II era), for the rough salt waters, and the kayak for the ponds, lakes, etc. Though I have taken the kayak out on small craft warnings in the Sound.
That all said.. this old skiff is 12 ft and drafts about 5 inches loaded down.
Great video! Like you say beam is key, it’s amazing how much difference even a couple feet make when it comes to stability.
It really is!
I got a 14 foot Alumacraft v hull,and I love it.
I have a 12' john V-hull, just recently put a small deck up in the bow of the boat too!
I love my v hull have a deck that I put on top of the front seats I need to strip it soon though and redo the whole thing this winter. My wiring isn’t working to my electronics, only thing working is my trolling motor the little lake I like to visit is pretty busy on the weekend. But I can troll it in about 4-6 hours depending on if I’m catching fish anyways. Loved this video by the way
I have a 14 ft V -haul, which I did put a floor in which made it a little more stable. Plus I'm using a 6 hp Johnson., This boat get me around pretty good in creeks, rivers and the upper Chesapeake Bay. By myself with motor up, I can clear 6 inches of water using my ores to pole my way through.
VERY cool!!
V-hull for me just because I like to fish lakes and enjoy the rough water stability… Not hating on Jon boats, I just don’t have any experience with them, but I can see their shallow/river/pond water purpose! Face it, ALL Boats are great!! Fun video! Thanks!
Thank you! You're right - all boats ARE great!
Awesome I also own a 12 ft v haul aluminum boat and I love it.. I’ve owned non boats too but they do get bumpy on the water when it’s choppy.. fun drive tho lol
I have a 16' v bottom riveted John boat that old as sin but she has been the best most reliable boat I could ask for wether I'm running limb lines and catching beavers. That boat has taken me places my buddy's cant go with their flat bottom on a river or lake never had a problem with stability either
I have a 12' V hull aluminum boat. It’s perfect for me. Great video!👍😃
Cool, thanks!
I got a 13' V hull with a 7hp. Love it!
That's a great one-person rig!
I have a Bass Hound 10.2 semi V front and flat in back plastic Jon boat, and a Bass Raider 10.2 that's kind of a flat bottom with a small foot wide and 4" depth channel in the middle making it like a faux pontoon type boat. I really like both of them, I run them on a bunch of different power sources including a couple different minn kota bow and rear mounts from 36-49 lbs of thrust, several marine deep cycles, and a JNC660 jump pack for a backup. I also have a solar canopy which is mounted to a large umbrella, It is for days when I use the trolling motor or my higher power 2hp electric boat motor, I'm also working on a hybrid motor that can use gas or electric Lynch (AGNI) high power DC motor which is rated for up to 12kw but I'm only running between 0-4kw as I only have a 100ah 12v lead acid and 33 ah of 48v lithium batteries. I will be able to run it on both, although 12v is only 1 kw output.
The good part of being a hybrid is I can use the gas engine for propulsion and recharging the 48v battery simultaneously. The Yanmar hybrid engine for large boats uses the same exact motor. I also have a 5hp ducted fan power unit made with a 2 stroke snowblower engine that has a 22" tri blade pusher propeller, it's quite loud and unimpressive. Sometimes I use a 2 and 4 horse antique Johnson motors, or I have a couple 5hp Goodyear Sea Bees I use. In conclusion I love both jon boats equally and I always take both on every trip as there's 3 of us in my family, and we sometimes connect the boats-my 10 year old claims the Bass Raider
I have a 14’ 1970s V-hull with a modern 10hp engine. The boat is plenty wide and incredibly stable. I can stand right on the top of the bow. I definitely prefer the v-hull
That's a nice combination!
Hey this is an amazing video that shows the differences
I built a 10' flat bottom skiff with a rocker bottom . It is a copy of my uncle's 1930s old town skiff. It is extremely stable for only being 10'. It's rocker bottom front to back and keelson in the aft 1/4 makes it very stable and handles wonderful at speed. I have plans for both a 12' and 14' version of the same style boat. U do plan to build one of those sizes. That style is good for both rowing and power. The 10' version works well with 5hp i figure that i will use up to 10 hp on the 14' version. This is a planked hull skiff. Weigh-in at about150- 175 for the 10 ' version. The 14' version will be b 200 to 300 lbs, depending on the wood i choose to build it.
I have a 14 foot Lund V-hull with a 25hp Evinrude E-Tech engine. I use it primarily for fly fishing and I removed the plywood seats and built a flat deck (bow to stern) at the same elevation of those seats. I also made hatches for storage, and so we can sit exactly the way the manufacturer intended while under way, with our feet on the hull. When alone I can get it to plane off but with 2 men it won’t quite do it due to the extra weight of the deck BUT the deck is well worth the inconvenience as it makes an excellent (and very stable) platform for fishing.
That's crazy my 13' Duranautic V / Johnson Sea Horse 15 will get on plane with 800lbs of men & gear. Blows my mind.
@@elonmust7470 I don’t know much about boats and motors but for a 2 stroke, my engine doesn’t seem to tach out too high. Dealer says it’s normal so 🤷♂️
I grew up with a wooden flat bottum boat and I still miss the sound of the waves slapping the wooden bottum. But today I have an aluminum flat bottum boat and I think I prefer the flat bottum over the Vhaul because of the stability it provides. I've owned many boats over the years, flat bottums, V hauls, Speed boat, two man bass boat, but the boat I had the most fun with was a 11' Snark sailboat. I live along the Ohio River which you would not think it would be ideal for a sailboat, but I had a blast with it. I know I am differant, But I like rowing a jon boat. It needed i will use a trolling motor, but I prefer rowing. It is just so relaxing it is hard to beat the pleasure ut provides.
Just scored a '73 Gamefisher. A V hull fiberglass 12 footer. Sears called their jon, the "Jonfisher" by the way. Mine is rated for 14 hp. It came with a 15 hp Gamefisher (Merc), a 6hp Nissan and a 2hp Honda. Stoked!!!!
Wow 3 motors with the deal - NICE!
Have a 63 richline challenger mod v 14ft I got with a trailer for 500 bucks. Put a deck on the front and floor in the back with carpet. Put a 78 25hp johnson on it and absolutely love it. Been doing larger lakes, small lakes, and larger ponds with no issues. Going to try a few slow moving rivers this summer. Wife and I built it together and probably will never get rid of it
That's awesome and a great price!
14’ v hull. Great boat. Handles great. Hardly any concern with waves/wake
I have a 16ft (15' 11" if you wanna be a jerk about it) 1977 LoweLine Jonboat. With the 25hp yamaha on it, it will do about 40mph on smooth water with one person in it. It does not have any stability issues. Like mentioned though, it does not like large waves or a wake; the ride will get rough really quickly in rough waters in a flat bottom boat.
The Whaler style with two hulls and v in the middle is a great compromise, it handles well in a little chop, not "slapping" as hard as a pure flat boat, and it lets you move around easier than a v-hull that loves to rock and shift every time you move from one end to the other. I have an 11 foot whaler and two full size adults can move around and stand up and I can blaze through 2 to 3 foot wind waves without slapping the bottom to hard. The fact that the whaler style is also foam filled and "unsinkable" makes me much more confident when things do get rough. For reference I use mine in the pacific ocean (a bay). So I don't want a boat that will go straight to the bottom if swamped by a rogue wave, which are out there waiting for us when we least expect them.
Just got a 13 ft 1970 whaler and it’s awesome! Just put a merc 15 hp 4 stroke on it. Would like to get a 40
Growing up in the late 70's we had an 11' Boston Whaler. Loved it. I remember that I could pull up my 9 yr old sister to water ski - we had a 15 hp tiller style engine on it. I was 11. We did everything with that little boat, ski, fish, get to the beach across the bay, which could get pretty choppy sometimes. Now that we will be moving back to Florida after decades up north, I will be hunting for another one. Best all-around fun, easy and simple boat to have.
Mini tug boat Sam e size
I had a 12 ft porta bote for years . Fish Strawberry reservoir in Utah. Wonderful memories. Highly recommend. Plan to get a 14ft.
I've seen those Porta-Botes! They are pretty cool especially for people who don't have a place to store a boat.
@@WayneTheBoatGuy they are very stable as well
These bes 14 fiut 12 fot cabjn cabines
I've had a 1032 john, have a 1648 now and love it. Where I'm from a flat bottom less than 48 wide is a john, 48 plus is a river John, and a v front is called a mod-v. V hulls aren't as common where I live in ky. Most are larger for catfishing and carp harvesting. Lastly, we call v hulls, deep v's
The 1648 seems to be quite popular for obvious reasons. That terminology seems to align with a lot of the branding of the new boat models which can be confusing with so many slightly different styles but they all have their place! It seems there's much less variety when shopping older used boats.
Love my 12 foot flat bottom with 15hp Suzuki. Light and fast in smooth conditions and can be launched and access most water. If it's choppy, I stay home. Great for river use and can slide over logs etc.
"can slide over logs" - great point!
I like my 1436 Jon boat for small rivers, but use my 1648 for lakes. The 1436 is not good with chop or waves, but it really excels on small rivers and streams.
I have own both flat and V-hull. I love my 2000 Smoker Craft 16ft Super Fisher V-hull with a Mercury 20hp long shaft outboard motor. I can get up to 24 mph on calm water alone in the boat. With 3 adults on board I average 21 mph. When alone my comfort speed is 21 - 19mph for the smoothest ride. I pull my 11yr and 12yr old kids on a 50ft rope and float at 19mph. The #1 factor I prefer V-hull over flat bottom is being able to cut through white capping rough open water on a windy day, 7 to 15mph gusting winds. I simply keep my speed at 9 - 11 mph and cross open rough waters to get to a side cove of calm water. The con of a V-hull, it's a bit of a side to side unstable. You have to keep center of gravity on your standing. Putting in a sub flooring will be a great improvement on standing stability by 70%. Major improvement. But over all V-hulls are a smooth ride at high speed. Great video, I enjoyed it.
thanks for the sound advice
Just happened on your channel today and spent the entire video thinking I recognized those creeks. You’re on the Magothy! My in-laws live out in hickory point and I’m back by magothy bridge. I’ll have to keep an eye out for you on the river.
I own a 14 foot v haul with a 9.8 Johnson.
I Live on the western basin of Lake Eire, came here to see the difference of the situations and v haul is the way to go for my area, we don't have a lot of flat water around here. seems like the flat bottoms stick the flat water.
Thanks for the video.
I prefer 14' Jonboat for Gillnetting Chinook Salmon on River near the Mouth of Ocean. Right now have 14' G3 welded jonboat with 20 horse 4 stroke Nissan Prop. G3 sort of Heavy & sits deep in water. Few years ago had a 14' Lowe Flat bottom (Jonboat) Riveted with 15 horse 2 stroke mercury. Now this combo sleighed the Salmon. Sat low to water, turned on a dime with no problem getting on plane with half load fish/ice. each of these boats expected to hold plenty of Ice & a few Lg. coolers. when Salmon were running both boats maxed out around 40-50 (15-20 lb) Salmon before unloading & another load to follow. I am always cautious about waves/wake. The stability to operate with 1 person is exc. Main factor is stability to hold loads ice/salmon while safely walking front to back constantly. I enjoyed the Video & agree that ea. boat carries their own purpose.
I know I've commented a lot, but this is a great topic lol. Width! You nailed it when you mentioned stability. That's what everyone really wants. Comfort. Efficiency. Don't buy a 32" Jon! Get at least a 48" (width)
you nailed it I had a wide bottom 12 foot carolina skiff that was Very stable think it had a 60 inch beam last year i bough a small jon thinking i would just transport it in my pick up bed after finding out how unstable it was i gave it away worst boat i ever had
@@larzhillbot1443 skiffs seem like great boats. Never been on one
I got a Water Tender which has a mini Trujillo…best of both worlds. Very wide as well 😃
I went with a flat bottom. Stability and shallow draft are key for fishing and duck hunting in the coves and inlets of lakes here in Texas.
Nice!
lake larnwr gad jihn biat oayeónn boatshous vist síkd thise gitc254 foit fead ship yaghtß suze crise shipß cung 5 yeaggs 254 fout shios fed ships cimg lak kaner
This is very helpful. Thx
Thank you for the review