One of the best videos explaining the offside rule. This is my go to video and during the soccer season, whenever I am assigned AR duties, I review before I take to the field.
Well explained. 2010 FIFA Soccer WC South Africa v Mexico at Soccer City FNB Stadium in Johannesburg. On the 37th minute, Vela's "goal" was correctly disallowed. Thanks to you super video, I have found a proper explanation. Much Thanks!!!
There are a lot more examples to show the peculiar nature eg you CAN be offside in your own half when you touch the ball having started in the opponents half in offside position and then run back into your own half, touching the ball before anyone else. There is often confusion between a deflection off an opponent (not goalkeeper) where you can still be offside and a deliberate kick/pass or miskick from same defendant where you would not be offside. Whereas any save from a keeper, deliberate or otherwise that rebounds to you in an offside position (when the ball was kicked) cannot be offside. Sorry, the rule itself may not be confusing but applying it in practice often is.
Hoyt Jeter you are correct. A player cannot be ruled offside if the opponent plays the ball to him directly or miscontrols a ball played to him by a a defending teammate. A player is also not offside if he steals the ball from the last defender (usually the goalkeeper).
8 Jan 2023. I have a rule. If a 'teacher' - of any persuasion - starts his talk by saying the subject is "simple" or "easy" I know that the 'lesson' will be of little use because the 'teacher' doesn't have empathy with his audience. Today Liverpool scored a second goal against Wolves, which VAR judged to be legal. But this article is "officially approved" and the law is "easy/simple" it suggests that the scorer (Salah) was offside. So much for simplicity and so much for the football authorities' control of the laws.
Alright. Now i understand a bit about offside. It's not hard to understand as you've said, but it's undeniably hard to determine and judging the situation in real play. The referee should fully be aware and very focus on the game as the players are all running fast here and there it might be very confusing to call the offside offence.
this offside rule is the best solution to the 1990 world cup where the matches were boring and with few goals because the defenders were well protected. to break the defenders line you need physical qualities. with the rule of 1995 there were 7.8 offfsides. with the rule of 2004 there were 4.8 offsides. with the rule of 1921 people stopped going to the stadium with only 2.58 goals. with the 1925 rule the goals increased to 3.69 goals. pele played with this rule. thanks to this rule soccer is interesting and we have the first records with messi and ronaldo.
I'm seriously surprised to hear that a player receiving a ball from a goal kick can't be penalized for being in an offside position. All this time I believed that the goal kick functions here on the same basis as an indirect free kick.
My understanding is if it has accidentally deflected off the defender, to the left forward, yes, they would be offside. However the defender had control of the ball and intended to clear the ball, just not where he wanted it to go. Since the ball was not a pass from his own player, the left forward would not be offside. That is how I remember the rule from when I took my ref class. Can any ref instructors address this, please?
OK, a right forward is carrying the ball up the side, crosses the ball to his left forward, who is onside at the time of the pass, but moves beyond the 2nd to last defender, to receive the cross. The player was onsides at the time the pass was made. Instead of a successful cross, a defender intercepts it.The left attacker, is now in an offside position. The defender misclears the ball, sending it sideways, to the attacker, who was onside when the teammate passed the ball. Ref called offside.
A player who is offside but not distracting the opponent. At 4:48 the player is clearly a distraction to the goalkeeper. If you are offside you are causing a distraction to defenders and goalkeepers as the player can later become active when play has caught up.
OK, I have a question:what if breakaway player has ball - loses ball (player gets in front of the ball by mishandle) and comes back to get ball before defender gets there? is player offsides? or in same context shoots the ball it hits the goal bounces behind player (still no defender there) player comes back to get ball to try another shot? Thanks!
Ok an attacker is in an offside position, the defender, who has the ball goes to clear the ball, it hits another attacker, who is onside, in the back, the ball then goes to the attacker who was originally offside when the defender played the ball. Is the attacker offside, because it was defender who played the pass originally and it just took a deflection????
I don't know a lot about football so sorry if my question sounds silly. But what if you are in an offside position the moment that a player from the opposite team kicks the ball in your direction. You then kick the ball in the goal. at 5:20 it says that it's offside when the ball rebounds off an opponent. But if it didn't rebound, if the opponent was actualy playing, he kicked it while you stood offside, you ran to the ball and shot it in the goal.Is it also offside or is it only offside if the the ball comes from you own team? I think that for the rest I finally got what offside means. Thanks for the video.
It depends on the situation: If the pass of your opponent player to you (while standing offside) was unintended, it's offside. But if the pass was played to you in a controlled manner, it is not offside. The referee has to decide if the was pass was played willfully or not.
Kardanwelle1994 Thank you for the help. So it the opponent player passes the ball in my direction because one of his teammates was standing very close to me. Then would it be regarded as offside? Because he didn't intend me to get the ball.
Haki7Hikari It does not matter intended or unintended. If it's not a rebound than it's not an offside, no matter close or far from you your opponent is. There is one more interesting thing. Suppose you are in an offside position. Suppose your team-mate does not want to give you a pass (forward direction), but he decides to give the ball back to your team's defender or a goalkeeper of your team (backward direction). But the ball suddenly rebounds of one of your opponents and moves to you. How do you think, is that an offside? Actually, that is NOT, because the initial after-pass direction was opposite (before the rebound). This is a real-life example.
Agreed. The video commentry suggests that the law as currently formulated is "Not Controversial" What? How can a player not gain advantage when offside and in the field of view of the keeper or a defender? The defending player will be distracted if they are open to receive a pass! How does that defender know if they are offside/not? It's hard enough for the officials to know, never mind the defenders. Of course the attacker in the offside position gains advantage. So they should be flagged.
not offside, if when the attacker played a through ball to his teammate, and his teammate was onside when this happened, then he is onside even if it deflects of a defender or if the defender intercepts and plays a ball back
Questions. What if the defense team plays the ball back and the player was in an offside at that time. And he gets the ball. Is that off-sides. So as long as the defender has possession then plays it to the goal keeper you can not be offside even if you were in an off side positions. So you can steel the ball and shoot. Correct.
This is a good video, but I find it humorous that it is described as "as easy as 1-2-3", and then spends the next 5 minutes detailing all the minutiae that determine 1 and 2. As I am finding out, the job of the AR in making offside calls is not an easy one.
I am puzzled. In the case of a free kick, should an attacking player be be deemed offside (a) only if he was in an offside position when the the free kick made contact with the ball? or (b) if he was onside when the free kick was taken, but raced a defender to the oncoming ball, leaving only the goalkeeper between the ball and the attacking player? If (b), as was in the case of one of Arsenal's goals in today's FA Cup semifinal, then - in the words of Charles Dickens, "If that is the law, then the law is an ass". We seem to have come to a situation where a TV watcher is in a better place to judge then the linesman. With current technology, couldn't - make that shouldn't - referees and linesmen also have a colleague in the stands?
1:57 I never knew you could be offside if you and the person you're passing to are beyond the last defender. I've never seen an offside given because of that! So does that mean all the sweaty goals I concede in Fifa 13 are really offside?
It's only offside if the player you are passing to is infront of the ball, one aspect of the offiside rule that the video failed to mention is that a player can only be offside if the ball is played forward.
24magiccarrot the video didn't fail to mention anything. The rule says that attackers closer to the goal line than the ball are offside. If the ball is played backwards then that condition isn't met.
@@haythamelshafie2164 because if the player passing the ball is already in front of all the defenders *except goalkeeper* then he can pass it to anywhere
@@PieTopia Thats not correct...it IS offside....in that case the offside line is drawn on the ball, so the receiving player is in front of the line: its offside. It wouldnt be offside if the player receiving the ball is behind the ball...or if its not involved in the play.
No because offside only affects the team in possesion. If a defender has the ball and an attacker runs behind them and the defender then passes back to the goalkeeper the attacker is no offside, he would only be offside if a team mate passes to him.
@@AnnieMaryJohn parking the bus is when the team mostly plays defensive with like all the players behind the half line. Bw you joke about around asking these ?
This one rule alone (offside) is what makes soccer so confusing and subjective, especially to the fans. It's places too much burden on the officials which can cause the perception of bias. It also leads to lower scoring games. Soccer to me is a great game in dire need of one major rule reform...law #11. I know it wont' happen but it should.
Imagine how boring the game would be without the offside rule. Offensively, you would put one tall, stout teammate right in front the opposition's goal all the time, and the rest of you would just kick the ball toward him/her. Defensively, since you always have an opponent BEHIND your back line, you wouldn't wanna crept forward. Dickless version of American Football...
Why do you even mention corners..? It seems obvious that you can't be offside since the ball is kicked from the very end of the pitch so the player who receives it will never be closer to the goal than the corner.
+Peur1386 Late, but here's the answer. You can take the corner kick from any spot inside that quarter circle in the corner. That leaves enough space for someone to be nearer to the goal line than the ball. :)
People explaining something should never, never say "this is easy" or "simple." If it were easy, no explanation would be necessary. Biting into an apple is simple and easy. Anything harder than that is not "easy." OK?
Make the goal mouth smaller. In hockey they allow players to be in front of the goalie blocking his view of play and they allow deflections right in front of him or her. It would be unfair to allow this in soccer but not if they made the goal smaller. Also the pitch is to big. The players look tiny and therefore in my opinion of course is the reason why there doesn't appear to be a whole lot of action going on. Upopular post but atleast I am explaining my view instead of just hating on it.
Im telling you the Offside rule is a wrong rule because it spoils the defenders and discourages the attacking team from doing their best. Who introduced it? Its a disaster for football. Remove it! Every player must put in his effort to attack and defend their stake in the game.
One of the best videos explaining the offside rule. This is my go to video and during the soccer season, whenever I am assigned AR duties, I review before I take to the field.
A very clear explanation of the offside rule, it has helped me clear up a couple of things.
Good video thanks for posting.
Please show this to EA
lol i was thing the same thing tbh
Who is EA
@@vsubhuti I think he means to say, as to EA Sports, video game developer.
Well explained. 2010 FIFA Soccer WC South Africa v Mexico at Soccer City FNB Stadium in Johannesburg. On the 37th minute, Vela's "goal" was correctly disallowed. Thanks to you super video, I have found a proper explanation. Much Thanks!!!
I remember that disallowed goal. People always say "but there is a player on the line". They need to review this video.
Thanks this helped me a lot cleared up a lot of questions that I had about this rule.
Clearly explained ..... Now no more confusions 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Great!! Excellent explanation!🙏🏼
So beautiful explaination!
Lovely piece I have tried to explain this rule to my gals but they don't always seem to get it. This explains it better.
thank you it was great explanation
This was really helpful
There are a lot more examples to show the peculiar nature eg you CAN be offside in your own half when you touch the ball having started in the opponents half in offside position and then run back into your own half, touching the ball before anyone else. There is often confusion between a deflection off an opponent (not goalkeeper) where you can still be offside and a deliberate kick/pass or miskick from same defendant where you would not be offside. Whereas any save from a keeper, deliberate or otherwise that rebounds to you in an offside position (when the ball was kicked) cannot be offside. Sorry, the rule itself may not be confusing but applying it in practice often is.
Hoyt Jeter you are correct. A player cannot be ruled offside if the opponent plays the ball to him directly or miscontrols a ball played to him by a a defending teammate. A player is also not offside if he steals the ball from the last defender (usually the goalkeeper).
great video thank you
Thank you sir ...need more videos ..
12 laws
good one...thanx fr clearing the idea....:)
This gave me a headache... Not the explanation I guess this is just too much for me to understand.
good explanation!
very useful information good video
great video!
loving the music.
8 Jan 2023. I have a rule. If a 'teacher' - of any persuasion - starts his talk by saying the subject is "simple" or "easy" I know that the 'lesson' will be of little use because the 'teacher' doesn't have empathy with his audience.
Today Liverpool scored a second goal against Wolves, which VAR judged to be legal. But this article is "officially approved" and the law is "easy/simple" it suggests that the scorer (Salah) was offside.
So much for simplicity and so much for the football authorities' control of the laws.
Thanku dear
Also, you can't be offside if an opponent player passes you the ball.
Thanks
Great video. Corrected few things I wasn't sure. And this is the current ?
Alright. Now i understand a bit about offside. It's not hard to understand as you've said, but it's undeniably hard to determine and judging the situation in real play. The referee should fully be aware and very focus on the game as the players are all running fast here and there it might be very confusing to call the offside offence.
this offside rule is the best solution to the 1990 world cup where the matches were boring and with few goals because the defenders were well protected. to break the defenders line you need physical qualities. with the rule of 1995 there were 7.8 offfsides. with the rule of 2004 there were 4.8 offsides. with the rule of 1921 people stopped going to the stadium with only 2.58 goals. with the 1925 rule the goals increased to 3.69 goals. pele played with this rule. thanks to this rule soccer is interesting and we have the first records with messi and ronaldo.
Video looks like it came out of International Superstar Soccer 98...
No
Elaborate.
I'm seriously surprised to hear that a player receiving a ball from a goal kick can't be penalized for being in an offside position. All this time I believed that the goal kick functions here on the same basis as an indirect free kick.
thank you
So it means you go in opponent's half and goal then you were offside and goal cancelled
My understanding is if it has accidentally deflected off the defender, to the left forward, yes, they would be offside. However the defender had control of the ball and intended to clear the ball, just not where he wanted it to go. Since the ball was not a pass from his own player, the left forward would not be offside. That is how I remember the rule from when I took my ref class. Can any ref instructors address this, please?
someone can help me please..Where can i buy this DVD or CD complete Football Laws?
OK, a right forward is carrying the ball up the side, crosses the ball to his left forward, who is onside at the time of the pass, but moves beyond the 2nd to last defender, to receive the cross. The player was onsides at the time the pass was made. Instead of a successful cross, a defender intercepts it.The left attacker, is now in an offside position. The defender misclears the ball, sending it sideways, to the attacker, who was onside when the teammate passed the ball. Ref called offside.
A player who is offside but not distracting the opponent. At 4:48 the player is clearly a distraction to the goalkeeper. If you are offside you are causing a distraction to defenders and goalkeepers as the player can later become active when play has caught up.
OK, I have a question:what if breakaway player has ball - loses ball (player gets in front of the ball by mishandle) and comes back to get ball before defender gets there? is player offsides? or in same context shoots the ball it hits the goal bounces behind player (still no defender there) player comes back to get ball to try another shot? Thanks!
No, because he is not considered to be "interfering with active play", because the ball would not have been passed to him by a teammate.
Ok an attacker is in an offside position, the defender, who has the ball goes to clear the ball, it hits another attacker, who is onside, in the back, the ball then goes to the attacker who was originally offside when the defender played the ball. Is the attacker offside, because it was defender who played the pass originally and it just took a deflection????
I don't know a lot about football so sorry if my question sounds silly.
But what if you are in an offside position the moment that a player from the opposite team kicks the ball in your direction. You then kick the ball in the goal.
at 5:20 it says that it's offside when the ball rebounds off an opponent. But if it didn't rebound, if the opponent was actualy playing, he kicked it while you stood offside, you ran to the ball and shot it in the goal.Is it also offside or is it only offside if the the ball comes from you own team?
I think that for the rest I finally got what offside means. Thanks for the video.
It depends on the situation: If the pass of your opponent player to you (while standing offside) was unintended, it's offside. But if the pass was played to you in a controlled manner, it is not offside. The referee has to decide if the was pass was played willfully or not.
Kardanwelle1994
Thank you for the help.
So it the opponent player passes the ball in my direction because one of his teammates was standing very close to me. Then would it be regarded as offside? Because he didn't intend me to get the ball.
Kardanwelle1994
If you receive the ball directly from an opponent you canNOT be offside, regardless of intent.
yowoody85
thanks, that cleared up a lot.
I think I can assume I finally know what offside means.
Haki7Hikari It does not matter intended or unintended. If it's not a rebound than it's not an offside, no matter close or far from you your opponent is. There is one more interesting thing. Suppose you are in an offside position. Suppose your team-mate does not want to give you a pass (forward direction), but he decides to give the ball back to your team's defender or a goalkeeper of your team (backward direction). But the ball suddenly rebounds of one of your opponents and moves to you. How do you think, is that an offside? Actually, that is NOT, because the initial after-pass direction was opposite (before the rebound). This is a real-life example.
Any two players from the opposing team, goalkeeper or otherwise are considered as the last two defenders.
is this the FIFA trainer programme?
thnx sir
Agreed. The video commentry suggests that the law as currently formulated is "Not Controversial" What?
How can a player not gain advantage when offside and in the field of view of the keeper or a defender? The defending player will be distracted if they are open to receive a pass! How does that defender know if they are offside/not? It's hard enough for the officials to know, never mind the defenders. Of course the attacker in the offside position gains advantage. So they should be flagged.
Excellent thanks for this why fifa can’t f ing make videos like this
Please update the video till about deviations (2013)..
ممتاز
not offside, if when the attacker played a through ball to his teammate, and his teammate was onside when this happened, then he is onside even if it deflects of a defender or if the defender intercepts and plays a ball back
Love from kashmir
Now explain what happens if a player that's taking a cross gets carried off the pitch and then returns and touches the ball.....
Questions. What if the defense team plays the ball back and the player was in an offside at that time. And he gets the ball. Is that off-sides. So as long as the defender has possession then plays it to the goal keeper you can not be offside even if you were in an off side positions. So you can steel the ball and shoot. Correct.
Yes u are crct.After 8 yrs bro.Long time! I never even had a smartphone eight years back. Or else i would have certainly replied.☺️
This is a good video, but I find it humorous that it is described as "as easy as 1-2-3", and then spends the next 5 minutes detailing all the minutiae that determine 1 and 2. As I am finding out, the job of the AR in making offside calls is not an easy one.
anyone else here after Lukaku's goal for Belgium against Russia?
I am puzzled. In the case of a free kick, should an attacking player be be deemed offside (a) only if he was in an offside position when the the free kick made contact with the ball? or (b) if he was onside when the free kick was taken, but raced a defender to the oncoming ball, leaving only the goalkeeper between the ball and the attacking player?
If (b), as was in the case of one of Arsenal's goals in today's FA Cup semifinal, then - in the words of Charles Dickens, "If that is the law, then the law is an ass".
We seem to have come to a situation where a TV watcher is in a better place to judge then the linesman. With current technology, couldn't - make that shouldn't - referees and linesmen also have a colleague in the stands?
John McLeod (a).. its all about when the passer's foot makes contact with the ball.
P
6:48 if B passes to A, is A offside? Based on 6:26 he should be offside because he is nearer to the goal than the ball right?
Yes.
thanks
u r warmly welcome :)
he is offside
Finally the guys in my society will understand what an offside is xD
1:57 I never knew you could be offside if you and the person you're passing to are beyond the last defender. I've never seen an offside given because of that! So does that mean all the sweaty goals I concede in Fifa 13 are really offside?
It's only offside if the player you are passing to is infront of the ball, one aspect of the offiside rule that the video failed to mention is that a player can only be offside if the ball is played forward.
24magiccarrot the video didn't fail to mention anything. The rule says that attackers closer to the goal line than the ball are offside. If the ball is played backwards then that condition isn't met.
@KaitouKiddo0416 yes
Don't have a capture card sorry :-/.
6 : 00 is offside or not offside
ammm i didnt know about the goal kick!!
4:03 is it offisde to pass to ur teammate there
no it's not
PieTopia can you explain because I don’t know why that’s not offside
@@haythamelshafie2164 because if the player passing the ball is already in front of all the defenders *except goalkeeper* then he can pass it to anywhere
PieTopia ohhhhh
@@PieTopia Thats not correct...it IS offside....in that case the offside line is drawn on the ball, so the receiving player is in front of the line: its offside. It wouldnt be offside if the player receiving the ball is behind the ball...or if its not involved in the play.
can a pass back be off side??
No because offside only affects the team in possesion. If a defender has the ball and an attacker runs behind them and the defender then passes back to the goalkeeper the attacker is no offside, he would only be offside if a team mate passes to him.
No, exactly!
oozm
Not if the player you're passing to is behind the ball.
Oooo
What if it's a goal punt and not a goal kick? Offside?
Yes
You can not be offside from a goalkick ? 🤷🏾♂️
some parent was going nuts because their was someone offsides near the sideline when an onside opponet recieved a pass and scored...that guy is a tool
Football offside rule should only apply to the halfway line and scrap all these imaginary lines that have to be drawn.
Oh right. Still, the offside rule is wrongly implemented in Fifa 13 because you can pass to a person in front of you when you've beaten the defenders.
You forgot another rule... If the ball is in motion! I've been called offsides so many times because Refs did not know this rule.
What if both Offenders passed the defenders?
It's very offside then.
@@jayken548 what is the importance of this rule?
@@AnnieMaryJohn so that players won't camp near the other post ? 😂😂
@@jayken548 i have 1 more doubt ... what do u mean by parking the bus?
@@AnnieMaryJohn parking the bus is when the team mostly plays defensive with like all the players behind the half line. Bw you joke about around asking these ?
This one rule alone (offside) is what makes soccer so confusing and subjective, especially to the fans. It's places too much burden on the officials which can cause the perception of bias. It also leads to lower scoring games. Soccer to me is a great game in dire need of one major rule reform...law #11. I know it wont' happen but it should.
Imagine how boring the game would be without the offside rule. Offensively, you would put one tall, stout teammate right in front the opposition's goal all the time, and the rest of you would just kick the ball toward him/her. Defensively, since you always have an opponent BEHIND your back line, you wouldn't wanna crept forward. Dickless version of American Football...
Craig Charles All sports have subjective rules. Offside is inherited from rugby, and does make sense.
+m0skit0zindahouse offside makes sense..
AFCA 1900 Thanks for repeating what I just said.
Greg Charles You meant to reply to Helix426 bro.
Still don't get it
Didn't get it
Why do you even mention corners..? It seems obvious that you can't be offside since the ball is kicked from the very end of the pitch so the player who receives it will never be closer to the goal than the corner.
+Peur1386 Late, but here's the answer. You can take the corner kick from any spot inside that quarter circle in the corner. That leaves enough space for someone to be nearer to the goal line than the ball. :)
+msolec2000 but no, its a rule even if no defender stands in penalty box there cant be offside, also from goal kick there is no offside
***** I know, I was only saying why corner kicks needed to be mentioned. :)
thanks!
P.S. I am not a Liverpool supporter :-)
People explaining something should never, never say "this is easy" or "simple." If it were easy, no explanation would be necessary. Biting into an apple is simple and easy. Anything harder than that is not "easy." OK?
Pretty sure you cannot do that in FIFA 13......Post a video on that.
I tryed explaing this to my gf today! Haha
Background sound disturbing to voice
not nearer to the goal! if it was your line would be arched!
سكر الكتاب
for me i think football should not have offside
but then they could have half of a team crowding the goal and that would multiply the number of goal opportunities by a lot
same to side
+Loocher Tuntrakul Very smart.
+Loocher Tuntrakul for me I think you are stupid
best explaination
But Rule is Waste
-Ofsajd !!
-Šta ofsajd,nije ga ni tako !? :DD xaxa
Rule has changed a lot since 2011 so this video is not suitable
Make the goal mouth smaller. In hockey they allow players to be in front of the goalie blocking his view of play and they allow deflections right in front of him or her. It would be unfair to allow this in soccer but not if they made the goal smaller. Also the pitch is to big. The players look tiny and therefore in my opinion of course is the reason why there doesn't appear to be a whole lot of action going on. Upopular post but atleast I am explaining my view instead of just hating on it.
I'm very glad that you could express yourself on the beautiful game in such a civilized manner.
The pitvh is definitely not big , it is perfect for runs in the attacking areas, and wide enough to prevent clogged midfield
You're saying that a 100mx60m pitch is too big to fit 23 people? Are you nuts?
Im telling you the Offside rule is a wrong rule because it spoils the defenders and discourages the attacking team from doing their best. Who introduced it? Its a disaster for football. Remove it!
Every player must put in his effort to attack and defend their stake in the game.
girlfriend
EA servers lol!