Excellent response Bishop Barron, but I think God knows everything prior to when it happens, during the event, and what happens after it. Even the catastrophic things that occur, He knows they will occur and He does permit such events.Not to be cruel in the least. Because He loves us! I know that may not make sense to many, but it's only one person's opinion. Have a Blessed evening!❤
God is. He is the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End, Infinite, Eternal Wisdom. So, being something more than a “bring”, God is outside of time. So, the answer is simply “yes”. We attribute all-knowing to God. Can we know all things about all people at once if we were outside of time? Could our human minds handle such a thing? So, if God is capable of such things, then yes he knows all that we will choose even before we do. Look at the last moments of Jesus with His Apostles. He knew every occurrence before it happened. This is why we must trust Him and make the right choices. So why does God not change the outcomes? Because they already happened for Him and He sees what we cannot see, the trickledown effect of that present moment to that which will occur in the far future which we will never see in our brief moment of life in time on this Earth.
Bishop barron could have told him to refer the basic cathechesis which teaches that- God is omnipotent, omnipresent and omniscient. There lies the answer to all his questions.
No free will = No sin See Genesis 2:16-17 God commissioned free will (self-will) in man in the garden by commandment - an irresistible will to fulfill one’s own desire (see Jeremiah 2:24). Eve came out of Adam’s flesh. When Adam took from Eve, he was taking of his own flesh, fulfilling it. Jesus was born with his own free will too. But his came with an overriding commandment (John 6:38). And “sin” for him was not possible. Go ahead, I say, boast and be proud of your own will. Celebrate it. It’s only there for you to trip up in life, and ever need a Savior.
We have free will but we don’t know everything. We make bad choices but we also make them because we don’t see the whole picture and we get doubts in the true existence of God. After our big mistake that’s the time we gain wisdom. But we are not all like me, some like our Holy Mother, has the wisdom, the trust, the love for our Holy God. Maybe that is the reason she was chosen to be the spouse of the Holy Spirit, the mother of the Son and the daughter of the Father. The handmaiden of the Lord. Generations will call her Blessed.
"He can know everything without determining everything that he knows". What does that mean exactly Bishop Barron? Without determining our choices or the decisions are free will takes us? Please clarify. Thank you
Seems pretty clear. For example, I can know that water is wet without causing it to be wet. God can know what we do without taking away our ability to do it.
@@ChaChaDancin having free will means our will is the cause of its own movement, but not the first cause, which is God. Now, by moving our free wills God does not deprive their actions of being voluntary, “but rather is He the cause of this very thing in them; for He operates in each thing according to its own nature.” (St. Thomas Aquinas, ST I, q.83, a.1 ad 3)
Actually no..he doesn't know everything. Jesus himself said that he did not know the time of his return. And many times in scripture GOD asks questions of ppl that he should've known the answer to if he knows everything. He knows all the choices we CAN make, but not necessarily what choice we will make
Aquinas was wrong. God does know everything from before the beginning and all completely in the future. This is His supernatural knowledge. However, God is not in some "Eternal Now"! That would mean God was forever experiencing everything such as when He had to experience His Son suffering the crucifixion. The fact is, God is METATEMPORAL. God has His divine timeline, which we cannot comprehend fully. This means He has a before, a now, and a future where He has events. But He has given us a timeline also in which He can interact with the world He created. So there are 2 timelines and God experiences both. God is eternal and so is His timeline. God is not arrested in some "eternal now."
A he is not a pig and priest what is the matter with you? He’s been to a great many years of school, studying theology and understanding the wisdom of the divine book and all the other books and all of the interactions with God and humanity so learn and study before you say such awful things about such an educated person.
A he is not a pig and priest what is the matter with you? He’s been to a great many years of school, studying theology and understanding the wisdom of the divine book and all the other books and all of the interactions with God and humanity so learn and study before you say such awful things about such an educated person.
I love the way that Bishop Barron responds so kindly to Owen's simple, yet profound question!
Bravo to both of them‼️👏👏
God Bless Bishop Baron!
Jesus, i trust my life in you & thamk you for your protection. AMEN ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yes, absolutely our Almighty God knows everything.He’s Alpha and Omega. Omnipotent God. Amen in Jesus Christ name our Lord and only Savior. 🙏
Infinite Wisdom
Great question and what amazing answer Bishop! Thanks for your teaching. God Bless you 🙏
Bishop Barron, can become a Pope🙏🏻❤️
Smart kid!! If I were to hear that answer at that age, I would’ve just said…
“What?…”😂
Did he know It would hurt like hell and I would be pretty much the very Same???
Excellent response Bishop Barron, but I think God knows everything prior to when it happens, during the event, and what happens after it. Even the catastrophic things that occur, He knows they will occur and He does permit such events.Not to be cruel in the least. Because He loves us! I know that may not make sense to many, but it's only one person's opinion. Have a Blessed evening!❤
Love God with all your heart ❤
Don't let people corrupt u stay around good people that live God❤
Amen 🙏
God is omniscient
He knows the end from the beginning
Yes a very good question
God is. He is the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End, Infinite, Eternal Wisdom. So, being something more than a “bring”, God is outside of time. So, the answer is simply “yes”. We attribute all-knowing to God. Can we know all things about all people at once if we were outside of time? Could our human minds handle such a thing? So, if God is capable of such things, then yes he knows all that we will choose even before we do. Look at the last moments of Jesus with His Apostles. He knew every occurrence before it happened. This is why we must trust Him and make the right choices. So why does God not change the outcomes? Because they already happened for Him and He sees what we cannot see, the trickledown effect of that present moment to that which will occur in the far future which we will never see in our brief moment of life in time on this Earth.
Good answer
Jordan Peterson brought me here
Im on shrooms lol and that broke my brain lol
Someone please do a commentary on this answer please????
God created everything and has devine foreknowledge. Can he be wrong?
Calvin: who said will is free?
Bishop barron could have told him to refer the basic cathechesis which teaches that- God is omnipotent, omnipresent and omniscient. There lies the answer to all his questions.
Of course God knows …… EVERYTHING
No free will = No sin
See Genesis 2:16-17
God commissioned free will (self-will) in man in the garden by commandment - an irresistible will to fulfill one’s own desire (see Jeremiah 2:24). Eve came out of Adam’s flesh. When Adam took from Eve, he was taking of his own flesh, fulfilling it.
Jesus was born with his own free will too. But his came with an overriding commandment (John 6:38). And “sin” for him was not possible.
Go ahead, I say, boast and be proud of your own will. Celebrate it. It’s only there for you to trip up in life, and ever need a Savior.
Short answer, yes.
I love my faith and Bishop Barron, but how does any human know what God knows.
Because God has told us. The Bible.
Sincerely? I did not get it
We have free will but we don’t know everything. We make bad choices but we also make them because we don’t see the whole picture and we get doubts in the true existence of God. After our big mistake that’s the time we gain wisdom. But we are not all like me, some like our Holy Mother, has the wisdom, the trust, the love for our Holy God. Maybe that is the reason she was chosen to be the spouse of the Holy Spirit, the mother of the Son and the daughter of the Father. The handmaiden of the Lord. Generations will call her Blessed.
Keep the faith.
@ ♥️
Bishop Baron for Pope we need an intelligent voice to express himself in the correct theological way
the kid with great wisdom.
Is this Owen from the @PatMcafeeShow ?
A tangled web
"He can know everything without determining everything that he knows". What does that mean exactly Bishop Barron? Without determining our choices or the decisions are free will takes us? Please clarify. Thank you
Seems pretty clear. For example, I can know that water is wet without causing it to be wet. God can know what we do without taking away our ability to do it.
@@ChaChaDancin But water does not choose to be wet.
@@ChaChaDancinCan God be wrong?
the fact that some indoctrinated dork in a funny outfit has to answer and not God, should tell you all you need to know.
God not only knows but also decrees the choices of our free will
Then it is not free will. And we are merely sock puppets.
@@ChaChaDancinThat's how it works with the christian God as he is described.
@@ChaChaDancin having free will means our will is the cause of its own movement, but not the first cause, which is God. Now, by moving our free wills God does not deprive their actions of being voluntary, “but rather is He the cause of this very thing in them; for He operates in each thing according to its own nature.” (St. Thomas Aquinas, ST I, q.83, a.1 ad 3)
Is this the same Owen that called into the Pat McAfee Show and BODIED Boston Conor? Sounds identical lol
Can we come say our for father's did not how who they are
Whom they were.
ah, what?
🫡🇻🇦
Actually no..he doesn't know everything. Jesus himself said that he did not know the time of his return. And many times in scripture GOD asks questions of ppl that he should've known the answer to if he knows everything. He knows all the choices we CAN make, but not necessarily what choice we will make
HUH???
Young boy: "This is a recorded message. Please leave a message after the beep."
Aquinas was wrong. God does know everything from before the beginning and all completely in the future. This is His supernatural knowledge. However, God is not in some "Eternal Now"! That would mean God was forever experiencing everything such as when He had to experience His Son suffering the crucifixion. The fact is, God is METATEMPORAL. God has His divine timeline, which we cannot comprehend fully. This means He has a before, a now, and a future where He has events. But He has given us a timeline also in which He can interact with the world He created. So there are 2 timelines and God experiences both. God is eternal and so is His timeline. God is not arrested in some "eternal now."
This sounds hilariously like an AI plant! (Sorry to the kid if you read this)
Yeah, that does not sound 10. 🤨
The ten year old had a bit of baby talk intro -
"Bishop Bewron".
A he is not a pig and priest what is the matter with you? He’s been to a great many years of school, studying theology and understanding the wisdom of the divine book and all the other books and all of the interactions with God and humanity so learn and study before you say such awful things about such an educated person.
Imagine talking this crap to children
I know, should make any interaction with the Catholic church 18 and above. Keep kids from indoctrination
Stop the nonsense the answer is yes..
You must be one of these types against having both faith and reason.
Why is she asking this pagan priest a question about this ?
Haha troll harder.
That was a boy lol
You thinks He's a pagan priest, but you still likes to listen to Him
Christ left us a Church
Pagan.. do you know the meaning? Lol
A he is not a pig and priest what is the matter with you? He’s been to a great many years of school, studying theology and understanding the wisdom of the divine book and all the other books and all of the interactions with God and humanity so learn and study before you say such awful things about such an educated person.