I'd highly recommend showing the names on the screen when mentioning them (at least the first time around)...or maybe a link with all the tents mentioned (brief look didn't turn up anything). Remember, the (brand)names people "in the know" have heard hundreds of times could very well be a new thing for the majority of the people.
I am 50 and as soon as I get into any of my tents I regress to when I camped out in front of house with my mates in my ridge tent. Good Times. Helm 1 for me. Great all rounder. Merry Xmas, have a good one.
40 tents crazy! - I bought one 20 plus years ago on a whim during a sale and I still use it. What is it I think it is a Vango 200 (1991) good value but at the time I thought it cost me a fortune!
Call me sentimental, but your tent-journeys were so well delivered here and with your tear-jerking closing message, I think this is the best and most down-to-earth video I have ever seen. Thank you!
Got my Soulo after watching you, Andy B and Pat Dickenson's channels a few years back and never regretted it. I still love it and use it all year round and it's never let me down.
The very first of your TH-cam videos that I watched was when you were out in your Wild Country Helm 1. I was researching tents, having not gone camping for years. My husband’s brief was: find a sturdy tent which doesn’t weigh too much. We bought the Helm 3 (we never walk far with the tent - just pitch it and go off hiking) and we love it. I’ve watched almost every one of your videos since. Thanks for all the tips along the way :)
Vango tempest 200 was my first wild camping tent, did me proud on many cold snowy nights up Rhinog and around the Peak District. Now I use either a Ridge Raider or Southern Cross 1, depending on the time of year
I really want to go back and binge watch your older videos after watching this one. I've only used my Helm 1 once, but it definitely has a certain charm. Fair play for getting the steps in and cheers for the chat 👍
You said "It looked after me in some incredible places." That hits the nail on the head Paul doesn't it. I've kept my first tent from twenty years ago, the Terra Nova Solar Minor. Even though I haven't used it in years (it was superceded by an Akto), the TN looked after me and gave me a ton of great memories. As you say Paul, nothing beats that feeling of those first adventures, those associated memories. It's also that 'first tent' period where we literally learnt the ropes, made all the mistakes, maybe got wet, cold, picked the wrong spot etc., but nothing could stop us coming back for more could it? My camping routine is now slicker than ever, but I don't know if it is quite as much fun or as satisfying as the memories of riding out that first storm.
Interesting No 1. I was surprised when you sold it. I’ve been happy tempted to sell mine but nice before but I just can’t, I’m happy to carry the weight and it gives me the piece of mind to camp where I want and not worry if the weather turns.
My first solo tent was a Phoenix Phreeranger SL - blue and yellow, loved it. Spacious survived some interesting nights on Dartmoor, In the end (about 10 years) the coating completely degraded and started to smell of vomit, at which point I had to give up on it. I now have an Akto, less headroom, less space, but a bomb proof tent.
I had a Soulo 13 years ago but I sold it after a couple of seasons, too many little annoying things about it and too much faff putting it up compared to the tunnel tents I've been used to over the years. I replaced it with a Nallo 2 which I still have. Terra Nova still use double sided silicone coating on some of their tents.
Spot on - I moved from a Soulo to a Nallo 2 and can’t see the sense in a Soulo unless you really need your tent to be freestanding. Both are the same weight, but much better space and layout in the Nallo.
Great video, Paul. Really like how on many of the choices you explained the personal feeling that a certain tent gave you. Hey! Isn't that what life and camping is all about?!
Great list Paul. I think your point was spot on when you said that your requirements and preferences influence your decisions regarding the tent you need/want. I’m into long distance hikes carrying everything I need for 5 or more days so my tent needs are going to be quite different to someone going out for a relaxing overnighter with a few luxuries. Also the amount I spend on a tent influences the trips I do with it and my expectations about how it will perform.
Just stumbled across your channel on the lookout for my first one person tent. Got inspiration from you but what's more, I've rarely heard any wiser thoughts on the whole concept of trekking and adventure seeking than in your subordinate clauses. I'm impressed.
Enjoyed your top ten tents very much. I love my Terra Nova Southern Cross 1, it seems to take anything the weather can throw at it and you stay safe and dry.
I am camping since the late 60s... - it has always been a thrilling adventure... sometimes bigger, sometimes smaller, at first in the woods of central Europe, in S-Europe, then in Alpine regions, in Scotland and Wales, N-Scandinavia, the Polar Areas, in the deserts and savannahs of Africa and now steppes of Asia.... all of which without any such sophisticated tents and equipment as being available nowadays - however, today - ... nothing beats my Hilleberg (Keron 4GT)... it is second to none... plus my Trangia, a faithful piece of equipment for over 50 yrs.
I know what you mean about tents having special meaning and helping you get over things. My first tent was a Saunders Jetpacker, that tent and Hamish Brown’s book, “Hamish’s Mountain Walk” got me out into the hills, spending nights out that have given me a wealth of magical memories, rather than just day walks. I sold it to buy a roomier Spacepacker Plus, as a student I couldn’t afford to buy one without selling the other, but I’ve always regretted selling that tent. Robert Saunders made some great tents, so sad they’ve gone. I really enjoy your videos.
Brilliant video Paul . My Helm 2 Compact is fantastic. Was thinking getting a Hilleberg, but thought with all the reviews of Helms alongside Hillebergs I decided to go for the very affordable. All about getting out . Atb Tony
Ive only tested one so far Oex phoxx 2 Hasnt let me down and ive put it up @650m +(lord Herefords knob)easy to use and stood up to heavy wind and rain For a budget tent its great to get yourself out and see if you enjoy it for less than £100 especially when they got deals on i think about £69 is cheapest ive seen it go for brand new tho im now looking for a lighter option Probably gonna be a lanshan or xmid clone i think Cheers for all the info
Great video Paul. It really is a personal choice which you point out. And the more we go camping the more we change our ideal tent.for me now Paul I try and balance weight with comfort. Well done and it was nice to see some of your old videos taking us back and sharing your memories. Wonderful. 👍👣
Hey Paul. Thanks for the video. If you have time, could you test and make a video about the Snow Peak Minute Dome Pro.air 1? It's quite heavy at 2.95kg, and is advertised at 1P but has space for two long wide pads (130 x 220cm floor). Also some very odd / unique features, like 2 small side doors / massive mesh vents, unusual pockets, and a huge vestibule. Interested to see how it performs in wind and rain. Only rated to 1500mm in the rain but who even knows what that means. Thanks!
I've used my vango zenith 200 for 8 years now and it's still going strong! Cracking little tent and its never let me down though I will admit i'm more of a 3 season / fair weather camper.
Couldn’t agree more about your vango. I’ve got exactly the same feelings for the Colman Cobra 2, it gave me my first taste of wildcamping. Nice to see my Helm 1 making an appearance too 😉
@@holmesaway went wild camping with a cheap hi gear ion 2 tent last year with a friend. Something I already has so just used it. Been looking at the cobra 2 as I've spotted it for £65. Is it worth picking up still with what else is out there now?
First tent same as many Brits Vango Banshee, then progressed to a Tempest cos I fancied the door at the front I then decide to go premium and wanted a bit more room so Southern Cross 2, realized I had to hump it about and thought I should of bought the SC1, however I solved that issue by buying a ...... Dog !, though I still have to hump the bloody thing up n down hills. Wouldn't change a thing. I know it 9 mth old but super vid Paul,keep rocking mate.
Really, really enjoyed all aspects of this video. Especially interesting to me was to finally hear your thoughts on the Southern Cross 1. I absolutely cannot justify another shelter, but if I could this is one I'd love to try - almost as strong as a Soulo but so much lighter.
Has to be the Nortent for me. You've started something now paul. You'll have to do a top ten of everything, from pegs to sleep systems. Brilliant video mate. big hugs from up North.
Really happy to see that you had the Terra Nova Helm Compact 1. It was because of you that I bought that one and I'm so happy to have it. As you say it's a tank. But now when I'm striving to reach 3 for 3 for my Kebnekaise trip next year I need to find a stable one sub 900g that don't break the bank to much... Since I need a lighter sleeping bag as well. 😂 A big thanks from the south of Sweden.
Love this trip down memory lane. You inspired me to go the soulo route, only a little lighter as i replaced the guys with dyneema and line locks for 2mm. It always sets the bar when i look at others. Andy just showed a pretty interesting example, again soulo-like with the Big Sky Chinook. That three pole geodesic design just works, just like it does for the allak (and its cloud peak 2 clone). I use an allak 3 for couple camps and its basically a giant soulo. The black label soulo 10mm poles are really solid too if you consider that one, I've used both soulos for different purposes and always sleep soundly in the worst weather. A feature i love is the T door (much better than D doors) where you can fully open the inside, or make is mesh. Plus as you say, its a good looking tent!
So good to see you back on top form and you seem full of energy again💪 have watched your videos for years now and picked up lots of great info. Keep up the great content and hopefully see you on a hill sometime👍
A most enjoyable video Paul, thank you. My top ten would have to include the Blacks Good Companions! I've been camping for about sixty years! Of course you've got a plan. I've been predicting for a while that you'd get another Soulo before too long. Good luck with your winter adventures, I'll also look forward to seeing some more of the Nallo.
Great list! In a couple of days the Nortent Vern 1 (new) comes to me. That is for me the perfect Soulo! I tried the latter but it was too small for me. The extra room and the better ventilation of the new Vern 1 might do the trick. The Vern 1PC is a truly wonderful tent, especially if you plan to leave it at campsight during the day very often (polycotton will be a lot more durable when exposed to sunlight than silnylon). The Vern 1 (new) is considerably lighter and seems to be as rugged as the Soulo.
I just scored a brand new Fjallraven Abisko 2 Dome for $1150.00 with every extra you will ever need …… footprint, mesh inner, inner tent pitch kit. The tent alone here in Australia is a ridonkulous $2640.00 AUD Also snared a new Hilleberg Rogen for $800.00 AUD. With footprint. Would cost almost $2000.00 AUD new. I agree with the Nallo range being awesome. I sold my 2 GT to fund the above. Brilliant tent but huge as stated here I will keep tge Abisko and Rogen for my tours. Can’t afford to keep buyi g tents to test sadly 😂
Thanks Paul. Another great video, and nice to see a top 10 that as you say, is not actually about what is best or trying to get people to support, but rather a personal memory fashioned pov! I would like to have approx all of them, but instead have a non listed one!! Cheers.
Great content Paul, thanks. Terra Nova Super Quasar for me every day of the week, including wet and windy nights out in the mountains...never given me any issues.
I just found your video from 2017 when you were out in your Vango Zenith... a quick look at Janet's Foss before you pitched-up for a frosty night. Happy memories from what you say. So nice.
Ive got a little vango cairgorm 100 that was my first tent since I got back into camping and although I now have an xmid and an msr hubba hubba nx2, your right nothing comes close to the first nights out in the vango there good solid little tents
My tents are all Tarptent models, i.e. NOTCH Li (Dyneema), MOMENT DW and SCARP 2. All have been modified to suit my needs. I have very few backpacking items that I have not modified in some way. ALL double wall Tarptemnts can be pitched in a rain storm INNER TENT PRE-ATTACHED TO THE FLY so it doesn't get wet when pitching or taking down. This is hugely important.
Good choice except id put the niak in there as its like a soulo for summer use. But also the cloud peak 2 simply for its budget. Brilliant starter tent.
Of course it was the soulo! I guessed it 😊 I know what you mean about your first tent. Mine was the vango hydra 200 plus which I got when I was 17 and my best mate and I hiked all round the lakes and Scotland together for about 6 years. So many memories 😊 “Old faithful” isn’t waterproof anymore (which I found out in the snow at 900m!!) but she’s still up in the loft!
First video of yours i watched was the helm 1. Bought it 2 years ago and love it. Served me well in all conditions. Only gripe is the inner is very bright. 😎
I'm glad the Helm 1 compact was there, got on the strength of your vid and others. As you said not just the kit but the experience.Good little vid thanks.
Hi Paul I totally agree when you said you can get emotions with certain tents. Back in the early 80’s as a venture scout, we got to use the Vango Force Ten ridge tent. I still remember what a brilliant piece of kit it was… in bright orange! Can you imagine having to carry those poles these days 🤣
You introduced me to the Soulo Paul … thank you 🙏 I also love the MSR Elixir And always promote the OEX Rakoon 2 so good for little money 🎉 Completely agree that the ‘favourite’ comes from a lot of different factors. Some from the heart ❤️ Thanks for always being there 👍
Hi Paul. I've got the Tarptent, and you can remove the poles at the end (at least you can on my one), meaning you can bundle them with the main poles and pack up the fabric into a tiny little bundle.
You can, but that means 10 more poles to attach and isn't what the design intended. It adds quite a bit of time and faff when pitching and taking down, especially in cold weather or whilst wearing gloves. I just leave mine attached. I agree though that they make packing the tent a bit harder.
...But between you and me... I've got a plan 😉 Can I just say how much I am enjoying your channel. Dusting off some old dreams and aspirations and encouraged by your pragmatic approach. Keep doing the things you want to do on this channel - you have a gift for communicating your passion and the things we really need to be thinking about. Its about the adventure and memories, not the gear - you dont wake up at 4am on a mountain top and sit looking at your tent going - WOW. you sit in your tent, or maybe it's in the foreground - but you are looking at the VIEW!
Only one tent for me and that is the Fjallraven Abisko lite 1. Small footprint makes pitching oh so easy to find and great ventilation. Once pitched it is going nowhere! So small, the wind has little to grab hold of to blow away! However if small spaces on long nights are not your thing, forget it!
The main reason I don't like small tents is that they can be problematic in the wind if you are tall. Often struggle with fabric smashing me in the face or feet in high winds. Personally I feel the MLD Trailstar is the best thing out there. It's big, light, and you can lie down in different positions inside.
So many great tents here. I'd love to have a go with so many of these. My current tent (I change my tent regularly every 15 years it seems :D ) is a Vango F10 Hydrogen with the AirBeam instead of a main pole. It wasn't cheap but it's well suited to the bikepacking I do as it packs really small and is pretty good on weight. To be honest I'd just like to be able to use it more.
Great list of tents and I appreciate the rationale you associate with each tent. Do you ever use a hot tent, realizing that you hike and carrying a stove might not be for you, just tried that this winter, love being able to use all four seasons.
I go back to my comment on an earlier video Paul - I’ve had a Soulo and now have a Nallo 2 (among too many others, but that’s another story!). The Nallo 2 is the same weight as the Soulo but provides much more space and a better vestibule arrangement i.e. in front of the inner, which for me is more usable than at the side. There will be no practical strength penalty over the Soulo, especially if you have a second set of poles for occasional use. The non-freestanding thing may matter to some of course.
Thanks for sharing. The Terra Nova Laser Photon 1 and Southern Cross looks nice. I don't see them here in the states. I've been taking out the Vik 1 mostly. Super fast to pitch. I only use 2 pegs/stakes. Paid $99. It's hard to go with tents with a big footprint now.
best tent ive ever bought is the Robinson voyager 2ex. everything you need in a tent, only down side is its weight 2.5kgs but it is a 4 season tent and hillibergs weight more than that.
Great list there Paul, I've not heard you ever mention Big Agnes tents. I have a Copper Spur HV UL2 and love it, its ideal for bikepacking, I'm not sure it would be strong enough for a wind blown hill top though. I need to try it.
You used to say two man tents were best and I told you a one man tent gives you more pitching options and is warmer. I am glad you agree with me now. 👍
Out of all of the tents I’ve had, the quickest one I’ve had to setup and the easiest would have to be the vango Alfa 3 and it’s one I parted with and regret it The one that seems to have caught my interest in your collection is going to have to be the helm 2 , it looks ace and seems to be one of the easier tents to setup and pack up. I’ve noticed that there is now a helm 3 that I’ve seen, having two young boys I’m tempted but as they get older they will be wanting a tent to them self’s so I’m not too sure if I’d get it
I knew you would regret selling the soulo, I had my red label one for 3 years, and yes you guessed it I caved in and have a BL one now, this tent has never let me down, so I wonder what is the plan Paul 🤔🙂
More than anything, the progress you have made being able to pass people and say hello rather than wait until they leave is admirable and you've done awesome. Thank you for sharing that 🙇
I’ve only done two wild camps in the same tent, both poor conditions (wind and rain) so it’s the vango banshee 200 for me. Only £100 and it’s nearly bomb proof.
"But between you and me, I've got a plan".. I can't handle this kind of suspense Paul 😂😂 I replayed the video 3 times just to make sure I didn't miss anything!
Good fair observations of knowledgeable trials. Much agree, No. 1 is No. 1. I have several Hillebergs, a Staika is a good go as well with a little more room. The Tarra is totally bomb proof. I tend to stick with black labels but also use a Jannu, with 10mm poles. Just in case. My Soulo is green, black label. I'll put it up against any other. My life counts on it and that's the baseline consideration of all shelters. I have many others over the last 50 years of camping. Some greats with many memories along the way.
Whilst doing research for my trips your channel has featured heavily, thanks for your honest opinions, Paul. Keep on doing what you enjoy and don't listen to the idiots out there. Take care.
Absolutely with you on the Southern Cross 1. I’ve never felt that it was going to let me down and I’ve never felt the need to go further upscale. I wild camped with it around the Derwent Watershed and I’ll be bagging some Wainwrights in the new year. I’m sure it’ll do the job.
As a tent nerd/addict it’s always really entertaining to hear the reasons why someone likes a particular tent 👍. I really liked your list! I recently picked up the Vern 1 PC and I was quite surprised with the build quality when I first pitched it. Definitely up there with a Hilleberg. As a huge fan of canvas and canvas like materials the fabric definitely adds to the appeal. Some nice unique features as well. The design is almost like a Soulo and an Enan had a baby. Excited to take it out for a camp! P.S. like how you ended the vid
Thanks for this Paul. A superb video. I’m in the market for a new tent soon and have to say you may have sold the Helm 1 to me. I’ve not been out for ages and am out this Summer for a multi day exped. Thank you mate. More content like this please. ATB - Simon
@@thomasjeffersonlane9902 ah, but at 500 ish grms with a stout walking pole I have more room and it copes with mountain top gales ... mind I rarely use a inner other than midge season and use de rigo bubblewrap as a sleeping pad with a hot dog waterbottle to warm my 1/2 season bag up :) .... certainly not as plush as my mates soulo but at 2kg heavier I'll take it
What a great story Paul and totally agree that some things transcend mere technical capability. One of my favourite tents is an ageing vango mirage pro that's not light (but who cares) but it's like a faithful old dog. You what it is, and what it isn't, and therefore utterly dependable. Interesting that you placed the southern cross over the northern lite. I bought one based on your review of and comparison with the panacea, and I reckon it's as strong as almost anything with the poles fitted.
@@bak2earth711 I think weight is a highly personal issue, I don't notice the difference in practice between the mirage and my northern lite, but then I'm not hiking 15+ miles over several days. The only issue with the mirage is it's slightly small, and ventilation isn't great. The NL2 is definitely a better shelter in almost every way, though is absolutely reliant on trekking poles, unless your camping it very light winds
@@hillenthusiast as Paul said, it's a personal list. I'd still choose and NL2 over an sc2 largely because it's nearly half the price and I always carry trekking poles. I've never tried more exotic kit like hilleberg so my opinion is not as valid as Paul's
I'd love to see you testing out the new Vern 1 which will be coming put in February i think? I really wonder how it will compare to the Soulo as it should be similar in terms of weight but have more space inside.
A very informative video. You certainly have had/have some brilliant tents. I definitely like the look of the Southern cross and the laser compact all season tents. Since I started wild camping 18months ago, I have the MSR Elixir 2, which was my 1st. Then similar to u choosing between the Akto and Soulo, I too couldn’t choose between the Soulo and the Fjallraven Abisko Lite 1. I chose the Soulo BL and then later bought the Abisko. Both fantastic tents for different camping scenarios.
So pleased the Vern 1 PC made your top 3, it's definitely on my wish list. I have a Robens polycotton belltent I use for camping with my son and simply love the polycotton fabric - cool when it's hot, yet warm when it's cold. We've been in all weathers including treacherous storms and it's never let us down. So had been on a hunt for a small PC tent like that Vern for motorcycle trips yet no one else makes one like it. Can't wait to see more films with it. Keep up the great work 👍
I certainly wouldn't go for a ridge tent and well for some of the places I like to go like on top of a hill a thousand ft up or 2,000 ft backpack is 10 is ideal light. Especially when you're carrying radio equipment areas back battery pack food are better really for me so that Pakistan is absolutely the ideal in all conditions. Yeah, keep up the good work. Hopefully check out more and thanks. Thanks for your videos. God bless
I'd highly recommend showing the names on the screen when mentioning them (at least the first time around)...or maybe a link with all the tents mentioned (brief look didn't turn up anything). Remember, the (brand)names people "in the know" have heard hundreds of times could very well be a new thing for the majority of the people.
I am 50 and as soon as I get into any of my tents I regress to when I camped out in front of house with my mates in my ridge tent. Good Times. Helm 1 for me. Great all rounder. Merry Xmas, have a good one.
Nice video. The tent that get's you out there, making memories, is the best tent.
40 tents crazy! - I bought one 20 plus years ago on a whim during a sale and I still use it. What is it I think it is a Vango 200 (1991) good value but at the time I thought it cost me a fortune!
Call me sentimental, but your tent-journeys were so well delivered here and with your tear-jerking closing message, I think this is the best and most down-to-earth video I have ever seen. Thank you!
I love it when a video is recommended to me and it's a Paul Messner video that I haven't seen before.
Got my Soulo after watching you, Andy B and Pat Dickenson's channels a few years back and never regretted it. I still love it and use it all year round and it's never let me down.
The very first of your TH-cam videos that I watched was when you were out in your Wild Country Helm 1. I was researching tents, having not gone camping for years. My husband’s brief was: find a sturdy tent which doesn’t weigh too much. We bought the Helm 3 (we never walk far with the tent - just pitch it and go off hiking) and we love it. I’ve watched almost every one of your videos since. Thanks for all the tips along the way :)
The Hilleberg Anjan 2 is still my favorite tent. Its perfect for the UK and has done extremely well in high wind and even some epic summit camps.
Vango tempest 200 was my first wild camping tent, did me proud on many cold snowy nights up Rhinog and around the Peak District. Now I use either a Ridge Raider or Southern Cross 1, depending on the time of year
I really want to go back and binge watch your older videos after watching this one. I've only used my Helm 1 once, but it definitely has a certain charm. Fair play for getting the steps in and cheers for the chat 👍
You said "It looked after me in some incredible places." That hits the nail on the head Paul doesn't it. I've kept my first tent from twenty years ago, the Terra Nova Solar Minor. Even though I haven't used it in years (it was superceded by an Akto), the TN looked after me and gave me a ton of great memories. As you say Paul, nothing beats that feeling of those first adventures, those associated memories.
It's also that 'first tent' period where we literally learnt the ropes, made all the mistakes, maybe got wet, cold, picked the wrong spot etc., but nothing could stop us coming back for more could it? My camping routine is now slicker than ever, but I don't know if it is quite as much fun or as satisfying as the memories of riding out that first storm.
Interesting No 1. I was surprised when you sold it. I’ve been happy tempted to sell mine but nice before but I just can’t, I’m happy to carry the weight and it gives me the piece of mind to camp where I want and not worry if the weather turns.
Enjoyed the heck out of this video Paul. I hope you keep making these videos for a long time to come.
My first solo tent was a Phoenix Phreeranger SL - blue and yellow, loved it. Spacious survived some interesting nights on Dartmoor, In the end (about 10 years) the coating completely degraded and started to smell of vomit, at which point I had to give up on it.
I now have an Akto, less headroom, less space, but a bomb proof tent.
I had a Soulo 13 years ago but I sold it after a couple of seasons, too many little annoying things about it and too much faff putting it up compared to the tunnel tents I've been used to over the years.
I replaced it with a Nallo 2 which I still have.
Terra Nova still use double sided silicone coating on some of their tents.
Spot on - I moved from a Soulo to a Nallo 2 and can’t see the sense in a Soulo unless you really need your tent to be freestanding. Both are the same weight, but much better space and layout in the Nallo.
Great video, Paul. Really like how on many of the choices you explained the personal feeling that a certain tent gave you. Hey! Isn't that what life and camping is all about?!
Thanks
Thank you so much for this. It really is appreciated
Great list Paul. I think your point was spot on when you said that your requirements and preferences influence your decisions regarding the tent you need/want. I’m into long distance hikes carrying everything I need for 5 or more days so my tent needs are going to be quite different to someone going out for a relaxing overnighter with a few luxuries. Also the amount I spend on a tent influences the trips I do with it and my expectations about how it will perform.
Just stumbled across your channel on the lookout for my first one person tent. Got inspiration from you but what's more, I've rarely heard any wiser thoughts on the whole concept of trekking and adventure seeking than in your subordinate clauses. I'm impressed.
Enjoyed your top ten tents very much. I love my Terra Nova Southern Cross 1, it seems to take anything the weather can throw at it and you stay safe and dry.
I am camping since the late 60s... - it has always been a thrilling adventure... sometimes bigger, sometimes smaller, at first in the woods of central Europe, in S-Europe, then in Alpine regions, in Scotland and Wales, N-Scandinavia, the Polar Areas, in the deserts and savannahs of Africa and now steppes of Asia.... all of which without any such sophisticated tents and equipment as being available nowadays - however, today - ... nothing beats my Hilleberg (Keron 4GT)... it is second to none... plus my Trangia, a faithful piece of equipment for over 50 yrs.
I know what you mean about tents having special meaning and helping you get over things. My first tent was a Saunders Jetpacker, that tent and Hamish Brown’s book, “Hamish’s Mountain Walk” got me out into the hills, spending nights out that have given me a wealth of magical memories, rather than just day walks. I sold it to buy a roomier Spacepacker Plus, as a student I couldn’t afford to buy one without selling the other, but I’ve always regretted selling that tent. Robert Saunders made some great tents, so sad they’ve gone. I really enjoy your videos.
Hamish's Mountain Walk!!! Oh yes a piece of inspiration 👍.
Brilliant video Paul . My Helm 2 Compact is fantastic. Was thinking getting a Hilleberg, but thought with all the reviews of Helms alongside Hillebergs I decided to go for the very affordable. All about getting out . Atb Tony
Ive only tested one so far
Oex phoxx 2
Hasnt let me down and ive put it up @650m +(lord Herefords knob)easy to use and stood up to heavy wind and rain
For a budget tent its great to get yourself out and see if you enjoy it for less than £100 especially when they got deals on i think about £69 is cheapest ive seen it go for brand new
tho im now looking for a lighter option
Probably gonna be a lanshan or xmid clone i think
Cheers for all the info
Great video Paul. It really is a personal choice which you point out. And the more we go camping the more we change our ideal tent.for me now Paul I try and balance weight with comfort. Well done and it was nice to see some of your old videos taking us back and sharing your memories. Wonderful. 👍👣
Hey Paul. Thanks for the video. If you have time, could you test and make a video about the Snow Peak Minute Dome Pro.air 1? It's quite heavy at 2.95kg, and is advertised at 1P but has space for two long wide pads (130 x 220cm floor). Also some very odd / unique features, like 2 small side doors / massive mesh vents, unusual pockets, and a huge vestibule. Interested to see how it performs in wind and rain. Only rated to 1500mm in the rain but who even knows what that means. Thanks!
I've used my vango zenith 200 for 8 years now and it's still going strong! Cracking little tent and its never let me down though I will admit i'm more of a 3 season / fair weather camper.
I have the zenith 100 and I'd agree with you, there fantastic tents although I have the nevis 200 as I can't find the zenith 200 anymore
My all time tent is my 1.48kg Vango F10 Nitro Lite 200 tunnel tent. Nobody has made a lighter full size tunnel tent that can withstand the conditions.
Couldn’t agree more about your vango. I’ve got exactly the same feelings for the Colman Cobra 2, it gave me my first taste of wildcamping. Nice to see my Helm 1 making an appearance too 😉
My first wild camp was also in a Cobra 2. I've had a few since, but still got the Cobra, even though I haven't used it in ages.
@@steviesteve750 same here, I’ll never sell it 👍🏻
@@holmesaway went wild camping with a cheap hi gear ion 2 tent last year with a friend. Something I already has so just used it.
Been looking at the cobra 2 as I've spotted it for £65. Is it worth picking up still with what else is out there now?
@@TG91ism for that price absolutely. Brilliant tent for the money, just need to make your peace with not being able to fully sit up 👌🏻
Sorry I can't remember you ever tested a Robens tent....I missed it sometimes....strong tents ...for strong conditions....for less money....
I use my vango Nevis but then brought the Cairngorm 2 man tent. Great tent for the money .Only camp out in bad weather. Hasn’t let me down yet.
First tent same as many Brits Vango Banshee, then progressed to a Tempest cos I fancied the door at the front I then decide to go premium and wanted a bit more room so Southern Cross 2, realized I had to hump it about and thought I should of bought the SC1, however I solved that issue by buying a ...... Dog !, though I still have to hump the bloody thing up n down hills.
Wouldn't change a thing.
I know it 9 mth old but super vid Paul,keep rocking mate.
Really, really enjoyed all aspects of this video. Especially interesting to me was to finally hear your thoughts on the Southern Cross 1. I absolutely cannot justify another shelter, but if I could this is one I'd love to try - almost as strong as a Soulo but so much lighter.
Has to be the Nortent for me. You've started something now paul. You'll have to do a top ten of everything, from pegs to sleep systems. Brilliant video mate. big hugs from up North.
Really happy to see that you had the Terra Nova Helm Compact 1. It was because of you that I bought that one and I'm so happy to have it. As you say it's a tank.
But now when I'm striving to reach 3 for 3 for my Kebnekaise trip next year I need to find a stable one sub 900g that don't break the bank to much... Since I need a lighter sleeping bag as well. 😂
A big thanks from the south of Sweden.
I completely understand your #8! Its what got you into this adventure!
Love this trip down memory lane. You inspired me to go the soulo route, only a little lighter as i replaced the guys with dyneema and line locks for 2mm. It always sets the bar when i look at others. Andy just showed a pretty interesting example, again soulo-like with the Big Sky Chinook. That three pole geodesic design just works, just like it does for the allak (and its cloud peak 2 clone). I use an allak 3 for couple camps and its basically a giant soulo. The black label soulo 10mm poles are really solid too if you consider that one, I've used both soulos for different purposes and always sleep soundly in the worst weather. A feature i love is the T door (much better than D doors) where you can fully open the inside, or make is mesh. Plus as you say, its a good looking tent!
Used a Vango (not sure of model) in my first winter camp in Yorkshire Dales with my Dad loved the experience and was warm
So good to see you back on top form and you seem full of energy again💪 have watched your videos for years now and picked up lots of great info. Keep up the great content and hopefully see you on a hill sometime👍
A most enjoyable video Paul, thank you. My top ten would have to include the Blacks Good Companions! I've been camping for about sixty years! Of course you've got a plan. I've been predicting for a while that you'd get another Soulo before too long. Good luck with your winter adventures, I'll also look forward to seeing some more of the Nallo.
Great list! In a couple of days the Nortent Vern 1 (new) comes to me. That is for me the perfect Soulo! I tried the latter but it was too small for me. The extra room and the better ventilation of the new Vern 1 might do the trick. The Vern 1PC is a truly wonderful tent, especially if you plan to leave it at campsight during the day very often (polycotton will be a lot more durable when exposed to sunlight than silnylon). The Vern 1 (new) is considerably lighter and seems to be as rugged as the Soulo.
I’m lucky enough to have one in the way too. Can’t wait to test the new Vern 1 ⛺️
Fjällräven Abisko View is another great tent that is really versatile in a lot of situations. Not many vids out there on this tent…
I just scored a brand new Fjallraven Abisko 2 Dome for $1150.00 with every extra you will ever need …… footprint, mesh inner, inner tent pitch kit. The tent alone here in Australia is a ridonkulous $2640.00 AUD
Also snared a new Hilleberg Rogen for $800.00 AUD. With footprint. Would cost almost $2000.00 AUD new.
I agree with the Nallo range being awesome. I sold my 2 GT to fund the above. Brilliant tent but huge as stated here
I will keep tge Abisko and Rogen for my tours. Can’t afford to keep buyi g tents to test sadly 😂
Love that gentle walk around the flask and a stop off at flask end 👍
Thanks Paul. Another great video, and nice to see a top 10 that as you say, is not actually about what is best or trying to get people to support, but rather a personal memory fashioned pov! I would like to have approx all of them, but instead have a non listed one!! Cheers.
Cheers to your next plan. Thanks for the review. Wishing you peace and good fortune. Happy Trails!
Great content Paul, thanks. Terra Nova Super Quasar for me every day of the week, including wet and windy nights out in the mountains...never given me any issues.
I just found your video from 2017 when you were out in your Vango Zenith... a quick look at Janet's Foss before you pitched-up for a frosty night. Happy memories from what you say. So nice.
You really need to try the Hilleberg Niak. For three seasons it’s the dogs dangly bits.
Ive got a little vango cairgorm 100 that was my first tent since I got back into camping and although I now have an xmid and an msr hubba hubba nx2, your right nothing comes close to the first nights out in the vango there good solid little tents
Beautiful setting, where is that lake where you are walking?
My tents are all Tarptent models, i.e. NOTCH Li (Dyneema), MOMENT DW and SCARP 2. All have been modified to suit my needs. I have very few backpacking items that I have not modified in some way. ALL double wall Tarptemnts can be pitched in a rain storm INNER TENT PRE-ATTACHED TO THE FLY so it doesn't get wet when pitching or taking down. This is hugely important.
Good choice except id put the niak in there as its like a soulo for summer use. But also the cloud peak 2 simply for its budget. Brilliant starter tent.
Of course it was the soulo! I guessed it 😊
I know what you mean about your first tent. Mine was the vango hydra 200 plus which I got when I was 17 and my best mate and I hiked all round the lakes and Scotland together for about 6 years. So many memories 😊
“Old faithful” isn’t waterproof anymore (which I found out in the snow at 900m!!) but she’s still up in the loft!
First video of yours i watched was the helm 1. Bought it 2 years ago and love it. Served me well in all conditions. Only gripe is the inner is very bright. 😎
I'm glad the Helm 1 compact was there, got on the strength of your vid and others. As you said not just the kit but the experience.Good little vid thanks.
Hi Paul
I totally agree when you said you can get emotions with certain tents.
Back in the early 80’s as a venture scout, we got to use the Vango Force Ten ridge tent. I still remember what a brilliant piece of kit it was… in bright orange!
Can you imagine having to carry those poles these days 🤣
You introduced me to the Soulo Paul … thank you 🙏
I also love the MSR Elixir
And always promote the OEX Rakoon 2 so good for little money 🎉
Completely agree that the ‘favourite’ comes from a lot of different factors. Some from the heart ❤️
Thanks for always being there 👍
Hi Paul. I've got the Tarptent, and you can remove the poles at the end (at least you can on my one), meaning you can bundle them with the main poles and pack up the fabric into a tiny little bundle.
You can, but that means 10 more poles to attach and isn't what the design intended. It adds quite a bit of time and faff when pitching and taking down, especially in cold weather or whilst wearing gloves. I just leave mine attached.
I agree though that they make packing the tent a bit harder.
...But between you and me... I've got a plan 😉 Can I just say how much I am enjoying your channel. Dusting off some old dreams and aspirations and encouraged by your pragmatic approach. Keep doing the things you want to do on this channel - you have a gift for communicating your passion and the things we really need to be thinking about. Its about the adventure and memories, not the gear - you dont wake up at 4am on a mountain top and sit looking at your tent going - WOW. you sit in your tent, or maybe it's in the foreground - but you are looking at the VIEW!
Only one tent for me and that is the Fjallraven Abisko lite 1. Small footprint makes pitching oh so easy to find and great ventilation. Once pitched it is going nowhere! So small, the wind has little to grab hold of to blow away! However if small spaces on long nights are not your thing, forget it!
I love my Hilleberg Akto. Recently it kept me dry for two days in one of the most severe storms I have ever experienced.
The main reason I don't like small tents is that they can be problematic in the wind if you are tall. Often struggle with fabric smashing me in the face or feet in high winds. Personally I feel the MLD Trailstar is the best thing out there. It's big, light, and you can lie down in different positions inside.
Spent many times in wee tents in storms. I just zen out.
@@BrokenBackMountains I'm 6ft3
@@northernswedenstories1028 I'm 6 foot. I usually spend that time lying down on my side rather than sitting up.
So many great tents here. I'd love to have a go with so many of these.
My current tent (I change my tent regularly every 15 years it seems :D ) is a Vango F10 Hydrogen with the AirBeam instead of a main pole.
It wasn't cheap but it's well suited to the bikepacking I do as it packs really small and is pretty good on weight. To be honest I'd just like to be able to use it more.
Great point. The joy is in actually getting out on adventures. The tent is just a tool to help with that.
Just watched this again, but unfortunately, i can't like it twice. You're my favourite youtube channel, Paul.
Great list of tents and I appreciate the rationale you associate with each tent. Do you ever use a hot tent, realizing that you hike and carrying a stove might not be for you, just tried that this winter, love being able to use all four seasons.
You missed off the zhengtu 2. Best tent of 2023. 👌
I go back to my comment on an earlier video Paul - I’ve had a Soulo and now have a Nallo 2 (among too many others, but that’s another story!). The Nallo 2 is the same weight as the Soulo but provides much more space and a better vestibule arrangement i.e. in front of the inner, which for me is more usable than at the side. There will be no practical strength penalty over the Soulo, especially if you have a second set of poles for occasional use. The non-freestanding thing may matter to some of course.
I use my nallo 2 solo, can handle the weight but pack size is a struggle
Thanks for sharing. The Terra Nova Laser Photon 1 and Southern Cross looks nice. I don't see them here in the states. I've been taking out the Vik 1 mostly. Super fast to pitch. I only use 2 pegs/stakes. Paid $99. It's hard to go with tents with a big footprint now.
Loved your list and the you speak of it all . Thanks very much paul. Good luck to you.
I love my southern cross 1. Its almost perfect for me. However the big sky international chinook 1.5 has definitely caught my eye.
I’ve seen Andy Beavers new one. Looks great 😍
Brilliant mate… Love these sort of videos and I have to agree with what you chose as your number 1 👍🏼 ⛺️
best tent ive ever bought is the Robinson voyager 2ex. everything you need in a tent, only down side is its weight 2.5kgs but it is a 4 season tent and hillibergs weight more than that.
Great list there Paul, I've not heard you ever mention Big Agnes tents. I have a Copper Spur HV UL2 and love it, its ideal for bikepacking, I'm not sure it would be strong enough for a wind blown hill top though. I need to try it.
You used to say two man tents were best and I told you a one man tent gives you more pitching options and is warmer. I am glad you agree with me now.
👍
Out of all of the tents I’ve had, the quickest one I’ve had to setup and the easiest would have to be the vango Alfa 3 and it’s one I parted with and regret it
The one that seems to have caught my interest in your collection is going to have to be the helm 2 , it looks ace and seems to be one of the easier tents to setup and pack up. I’ve noticed that there is now a helm 3 that I’ve seen, having two young boys I’m tempted but as they get older they will be wanting a tent to them self’s so I’m not too sure if I’d get it
Nice video , looking forward to 'the plan' and you are right you cant recreate the first wild camp experiance ... :)
I knew you would regret selling the soulo, I had my red label one for 3 years, and yes you guessed it I caved in and have a BL one now, this tent has never let me down, so I wonder what is the plan Paul 🤔🙂
More than anything, the progress you have made being able to pass people and say hello rather than wait until they leave is admirable and you've done awesome. Thank you for sharing that 🙇
I’ve only done two wild camps in the same tent, both poor conditions (wind and rain) so it’s the vango banshee 200 for me. Only £100 and it’s nearly bomb proof.
"But between you and me, I've got a plan".. I can't handle this kind of suspense Paul 😂😂 I replayed the video 3 times just to make sure I didn't miss anything!
Good fair observations of knowledgeable trials. Much agree, No. 1 is No. 1. I have several Hillebergs, a Staika is a good go as well with a little more room. The Tarra is totally bomb proof. I tend to stick with black labels but also use a Jannu, with 10mm poles. Just in case. My Soulo is green, black label. I'll put it up against any other. My life counts on it and that's the baseline consideration of all shelters. I have many others over the last 50 years of camping. Some greats with many memories along the way.
Glad I have my Soulo black, people say its overkill for the UK, maybe they havent noticed all the storms we get these days.
Loved the Vango mention. I feel the same about my Banshee.
Everytime I pass the spot you camped at Malham Tarn I think of you!
Whilst doing research for my trips your channel has featured heavily, thanks for your honest opinions, Paul. Keep on doing what you enjoy and don't listen to the idiots out there. Take care.
Good choices, good to see the x-mid in there !
Absolutely with you on the Southern Cross 1. I’ve never felt that it was going to let me down and I’ve never felt the need to go further upscale. I wild camped with it around the Derwent Watershed and I’ll be bagging some Wainwrights in the new year. I’m sure it’ll do the job.
I have juts brought the Helm 2 as I wanted slightly larger tent to take the dog with me plus also for motorcycle camping.
liked video, relaxing to watch and smart talk. autumn is here, colours are amazing. thank you
As a tent nerd/addict it’s always really entertaining to hear the reasons why someone likes a particular tent 👍. I really liked your list! I recently picked up the Vern 1 PC and I was quite surprised with the build quality when I first pitched it. Definitely up there with a Hilleberg. As a huge fan of canvas and canvas like materials the fabric definitely adds to the appeal. Some nice unique features as well. The design is almost like a Soulo and an Enan had a baby. Excited to take it out for a camp! P.S. like how you ended the vid
Brilliant video, a tent is a personal preference but your top 10 is very understandable! I have the southern cross 1 and love it!
Thanks for this Paul. A superb video. I’m in the market for a new tent soon and have to say you may have sold the Helm 1 to me. I’ve not been out for ages and am out this Summer for a multi day exped. Thank you mate. More content like this please. ATB - Simon
Thanks Paul, always enjoy your episodes. You always inspire me to get out. Interesting tents.
Soulo ... its nice but heavy. My fav is the mld duomid .... adaptable, full mountain and incredibly light
@@thomasjeffersonlane9902 ah, but at 500 ish grms with a stout walking pole I have more room and it copes with mountain top gales ... mind I rarely use a inner other than midge season and use de rigo bubblewrap as a sleeping pad with a hot dog waterbottle to warm my 1/2 season bag up :) .... certainly not as plush as my mates soulo but at 2kg heavier I'll take it
Hi Paul hope your well. I look forward to watching your videos.
What a great story Paul and totally agree that some things transcend mere technical capability. One of my favourite tents is an ageing vango mirage pro that's not light (but who cares) but it's like a faithful old dog. You what it is, and what it isn't, and therefore utterly dependable. Interesting that you placed the southern cross over the northern lite. I bought one based on your review of and comparison with the panacea, and I reckon it's as strong as almost anything with the poles fitted.
Vango Mirage totally underrated 2016 model awesome, good strength but a bit heavy still use mine !
@@bak2earth711 I think weight is a highly personal issue, I don't notice the difference in practice between the mirage and my northern lite, but then I'm not hiking 15+ miles over several days. The only issue with the mirage is it's slightly small, and ventilation isn't great. The NL2 is definitely a better shelter in almost every way, though is absolutely reliant on trekking poles, unless your camping it very light winds
@@hillenthusiast as Paul said, it's a personal list. I'd still choose and NL2 over an sc2 largely because it's nearly half the price and I always carry trekking poles. I've never tried more exotic kit like hilleberg so my opinion is not as valid as Paul's
I have more of a history with the southern cross
I'd love to see you testing out the new Vern 1 which will be coming put in February i think? I really wonder how it will compare to the Soulo as it should be similar in terms of weight but have more space inside.
A very informative video. You certainly have had/have some brilliant tents. I definitely like the look of the Southern cross and the laser compact all season tents. Since I started wild camping 18months ago, I have the MSR Elixir 2, which was my 1st. Then similar to u choosing between the Akto and Soulo, I too couldn’t choose between the Soulo and the Fjallraven Abisko Lite 1. I chose the Soulo BL and then later bought the Abisko. Both fantastic tents for different camping scenarios.
So pleased the Vern 1 PC made your top 3, it's definitely on my wish list. I have a Robens polycotton belltent I use for camping with my son and simply love the polycotton fabric - cool when it's hot, yet warm when it's cold. We've been in all weathers including treacherous storms and it's never let us down. So had been on a hunt for a small PC tent like that Vern for motorcycle trips yet no one else makes one like it. Can't wait to see more films with it. Keep up the great work 👍
I certainly wouldn't go for a ridge tent and well for some of the places I like to go like on top of a hill a thousand ft up or 2,000 ft backpack is 10 is ideal light. Especially when you're carrying radio equipment areas back battery pack food are better really for me so that Pakistan is absolutely the ideal in all conditions. Yeah, keep up the good work. Hopefully check out more and thanks. Thanks for your videos. God bless