Big Bang and Evolution in the Qur'an? | Nouman Ali Khan

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ม.ค. 2025

ความคิดเห็น • 186

  • @user-vj1pe1yc2g
    @user-vj1pe1yc2g 4 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Hello there. Could you please add subtitles option?

  • @outplayed4511
    @outplayed4511 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    SübhanALLAH

  • @alikkk824
    @alikkk824 3 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Ustad the truth is the more I have studied evolution origin of species etc I have almost lost my imaan. This vid was good but not good enough because there are other things I'm the quran that are bothering me it would be amazing if we could get objections and questions that actually effect the tenants of faith.

    • @muhammedamri9750
      @muhammedamri9750 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      The problem with the theory of evolution is thai it is basically theory. Even charles darwin himself wrote a letter to his friend claiming that he himself wasn’t sure about that. And infact more and more scientists claim that the credibility of this theory is questionable. A better place to start your research are established scientific facts. There is a difference between theories and facts. Hope that you would find truth starting from there

    • @alikkk824
      @alikkk824 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @@muhammedamri9750 brother with all due respect that msg you sent was sort of embarrassing in your part ive done Alot and when I say Alot you can beleive it. When people say that evolution is just a theory actually means and (sorr y to say this) doesn't know what they are talking about... evolution by natu r al selection has come along way in 200 years no one really even referral to Charles Darwin when it comes to this any more... we have massive evidence on evolution for example DNA fossile and speciation of animals around the world... I suggest to you brother that you do proper research and stop.listening to answers like that it's just a theory Muslims honestly sound silly when they say this. Look up yasir qadri on evolution for example... salam

    • @muhammedamri9750
      @muhammedamri9750 3 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      Well i started to search from the very beginning of whether there is god or not. Then i started comparing scriptures with science. Its then I knew about firawn and formation of embryo etc The fact that things in the quran about these things were accepted by people who specialized in this field really amazed me. And even things such as ants behavior such as communicating were discovered recently. Even it is revealed that ants have the closest similarity to human in their behaviour. And even things such as relativity of einstein also perfectly matches with quran. And even things such as the shape of earth which quran describes as the shape of an ostrich eggs , and about the expansion of earth are mentioned in the quran is really mesmerizing when you consider the fact that it was reavealed 1400 years ago. I do agree about the conflict with evolution but the last thing I would do is to risk my faith on a thing where there are differences in opinion. Anyway I don’t think anyone gonna find anything if they think of quran as a science book. Rather I would say it is a book of science. Anyway on the end its upto you

    • @muhammedamri9750
      @muhammedamri9750 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Apart from science ( I don’t know whether you consider this as important) the beauty and the depth of quran is something unmatchable. I live in south Asia and believe me there is this thing called dark magic and obviously these things cannot be proven by science so I would rather leave it apart. And when you consider about prophecies there are so many which have come true. I can’t exactly remember the country but if i am correct it is mexico or something like that and they have legalized having sex in public and the morality of it is is upto you to decide. But the fact the prophet Muhammed told that people are gonna have sex like donkeys in the road has indeed come true. And once again if you think deeply behind the wisdom of ruilings behind certain things concerning public matters you don’t have to look past west in things regarding the divorce rates and and things regarding premarital sex( this ofc differce regarding what you consider moral) and its a private matter. The thing is when you consider something regarding religion you simply cant compare it with physical things. Anyway bro its upto you and hope that you will find peace in mind 🖤

    • @sand8418
      @sand8418 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@alikkk824 Peace brother .d The problem with science is the sight they have, only gives the truth from their capacity. For example, if someone's eye was seeing bad, and they saw a person and thought it was a she. Well, this bad eyed person's max capacity to understand is a limit to see that person is "he" xD If that person's eye got better, in reality he would realise that the person he saw was actually a she xd and that's how science work. They "proved" many facts throughout history but how many of them they still believe? Just one example, they said that the sun was just standing still without turning for years and denied Islam since it says that the sun is turning. Few years ago, science realised that the sun was really turning. Then came to the same opinion of Islam xD This is a trial for Muslims almost every decade xD And whatever they proved, Islam was always right in the end xD So, do not get so hyped up "Oh no they found something against my religion." Well, they always found something like I told you before xD Even called it out as "scientific fact" and sold their books xD If people were to believe in Islam as fast as they believed in science, everybody would already been a Muslim xddd The linguistic miracle of the Qur'an is one of the most amazing parts for me to believe that whatever is written there is the truth xd whether I know it or not .d I will just believe it .d You have to balance your studies .dd Too much Islam or Too much science is no good .d As our religion teaches us to be balanced .ddd Peace be upon you .d

  • @Moumita_24-b7w
    @Moumita_24-b7w 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    U don't need to think so deep. Just think about your soul (ruh) . The conscious, which is not a physical thing, it's what Allah puts inside as a sign of his presence. Think about what's the purpose of you coming to earth and dying. Why is generations of humans coming and going? Whats the purpose of all these? Why do you feel guilt when you do something wrong?
    In biology, we say that mutations are random. Someone will randomly get a mutation and that will complete change his life just by a single DNA mistaking when regenerating cells. Its not mistake nor its a random mutation. Allah choses why one person get that mutation. Allah choses who will have autism and you will lead a healthy life. There is no answer to those questions that why one person gets a mutation and others don't.
    Think about the purpose of why are you living this life. What's the meaning of your existence. The theory of evolution talks about the process not the purpose of life.

  • @theastronomer5800
    @theastronomer5800 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Remember that the verse which is often brought up (and re-interpreted) in support of the Big Bang can be found in pre-Quranic, man-made, creation myths. If you read the Sumerian creation story you'll see it is found in 21:30:
    “Enlil, lord Nunamnir, the En, his utterance cannot be countered, separated Heaven from Earth, separated Earth from Heaven.” - Krebernik 1998, p. 321, n. 805.
    This verse (and the myth) are of course wrong because the Earth did not exist at the time of creation (not for another ~9 billion years) and you cannot separate the Earth from the havens as it is part of the heavens (sky/universe). The classical tafsirs scholars understood the verses exactly as the myth and argued that the Earth existed but it did not rain on it until it was separated.
    No Muslim scholars has EVER suggested anything remotly resembling the Big Bang and only recently (decades after the Big Bang has been studied) do Muslims want to claim that it was in the Quran all along. I guess to be fair we could do that with many of the ancient myths, re-interpret them and claim that they are talking about something modern and scientific.

    • @ashcomics13
      @ashcomics13 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      you can claim that it was stolen from that but you still need to prove this for it to be valid. also whenever reading these scientific miracle passages or any ambiguous passage we must always take a position of humility and say only God knows.

    • @theastronomer5800
      @theastronomer5800 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@ashcomics13 Not stolen, lol. The Quran uses many pre-Islamic ideas (this one, the idea of seven heavens which was very common in ancient cosmologies, the idea that stars can fall, that all living things are made from water, stories from the Alexander Legends, stories from the Seven Sleepers, etc). It simply uses ideas that were around at the time. You see this in all religions - they are based on local myths.
      Historically, it's very clear that the Quran uses these. Why does it happen to employ exactly the stories that were locally know, why doesn't it contain any from China or from Scandinavia for example?

    • @sapnajahan1653
      @sapnajahan1653 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@ashcomics13 and now big bang is considered wrong...

    • @theastronomer5800
      @theastronomer5800 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@sapnajahan1653 How is the Big Bang considered wrong?! You might want to know what you're talking about before posting nonsense.

    • @theastronomer5800
      @theastronomer5800 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @Ishtiak Saiful Right. What exactly did he say about these things that were not mentioned before? I have read the Quran, where does it for example explain how the stars move? Where does it explain evaporation and condensation?

  • @veroshinn1058
    @veroshinn1058 ปีที่แล้ว

    MAY ALLAH FORGIVE ME....
    I have a question regarding the line which is ""We tore them apart (fataqa)..........""
    Here it says WE.... My question is here e is referred to whom?

    • @sibylleblaquier2318
      @sibylleblaquier2318 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      To Allah. Allah uses pronouns of ‘we’ in Quran to refer to his superiority

    • @bilkisutahir8821
      @bilkisutahir8821 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      It refers to Allah. Dear sister/brother anytime you feel waswas(uncertainty) in your heart just remember that Allah himself says in suratul ikhlas that He is One and He has no partners associated with Him.
      قُلْ هُوَالله أَحَد
      "Say He is Allah (who is) One"
      So don't let shaitaan make you start thinking things you shouldn't. May Allah bless you and increase our imaan 🙏

    • @byteme9718
      @byteme9718 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@bilkisutahir8821 Allah has many partners, mostly gay.

    • @LowOnSolipsism
      @LowOnSolipsism 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@byteme9718 The only thing gay here is you.

  • @farinafan7464
    @farinafan7464 ปีที่แล้ว

    People don't know what evolution mean.
    Evolution means there is a chance/possiblity/may be human come from champanzees becoz they have similar genes.hey hold on! It could also be possiblity from human to champanzees. And that second one is certainity mentioned in quran surah baqarah ayat 65_66
    Go check out the exact words, what God says about it, i bet if u are a beliver it will amaze u and raise ur iman!!!❤

    • @byteme9718
      @byteme9718 ปีที่แล้ว

      No scientist or educated person has ever claimed humans evolved from chimpanzees. This is just one example of the lies and ignorance uneducated Muslims are taught.

    • @MamaMama-sv3b
      @MamaMama-sv3b 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      It’s just theroy

    • @helios9240
      @helios9240 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@MamaMama-sv3bgerm theory is just a theory, even though we have 0 doubt in it.. there is a difference between theory in language and theory as a scientific definition.