These are the kind of anthology episodes I would like to see.. different military bases aircraft carriers area 51 hell even a space station episode would be amazing small islands there's so many different scenarios you can come up with to show the beginning of the falling out and all these different types of places.
It is kinda disappointing, that the main show never featured any famous sites of Washington DC. Imagine them search in the White House or Congress for some info on what happened and where the Government went... It's really horrible of the writers not exploring anything at all.
Why would they search for information? At that point they've all given up hope that the government will do anything and are just trying to build what they can. I agree it's a wasted opportunity to not have them scavenge for supplies or take cover from saviours there or whatever but your mcguffin is bad.
@Deactiv8dStylez well in the comics, right before they get to Alexandria, Aaron had to go into DC to help save Heath, Scott, and some others, but Scott didn't make it after getting back to Alexandria and fighting infection. But still very briefly they were in DC lol The Show just chose not to go into DC and instead simply show the skyline of the Washington monument. They still didn't touch much on the politics of it all though. It was a cameo in both instances.
@@onetallpheeeshyep, loved the comics, loved the series, even though everything was much more different on tv i still enjoyed the views they could use based off the budget they were allowed, they did everything they could, the skylines of the monuments and buildings, i did like how they did a skyline view of the mall as well when they were riding horses killing walkers left and right, gave us a realistic feel of what it would look like after a decade fallout. im ready for whats next in the series which is the ones who live.
they would've just found an abandoned White House probably full of walkers. The President and all important staff would've been moved to a bunker/secure location as soon as the outbreak started
The thing about the Wildfire Virus is that there is zero containment. Everyone is already infected, any death from any cause will result in a walker that could potentially create more. All it takes is one unobserved death inside even the most secure bunker can spell certain doom for the occupants.
Most people who die without help do so because their body fails. Those would make for very weak zombies indeed. Most people don't die overnight: Most have a history of becoming really old and weak, getting ill, or getting help with dying from things as cars or other heavy objects. The show did a great job at portraying a swine flu victim dying overnight, but most people don't die that quick and silent. While something to stay vigilent of, it can't be the reason most of the military failed so quick
what causes the virus they tell us that everyone is infected but what caused it, if someone who was in the space station died after day 0 would they be infected or be fine ? As they weren’t on earth for like 6 months and prior to them going their was no zombies
@@sjonnieplayfull5859What about astronauts when the infection started? they were in space before zombies appeared so will they turn if they die let’s say 5 months after day 1 if they been up their for 6 months before outbreak ?
For a long time I thought The Walking Dead would end with 1 of 3 options. 1) The main cast all die 2) The crew would come across the army making a push across country like in WWZ book 3) They walk off unto the sunset just to live another day.
As soon as they made it that everyone is infected and when anyone dies they turn, the entire story or rebuilding was dead. At that point, there is no rebuilding because everything could get wiped out at any time.
I wouldn't be mad if they have ended it in season 5 episode 11 when the group arrives to Alexandria and Rick hears the kids playing inside the walls. The group was in rock bottom at that point and devastated by Beth and Tyreese's deaths, it would have been cool to end it with us not knowing what Alexandria looked like but with that good ending tone. The whole point of the show was Rick trying to bring his people to a safe place to live, it would have been cool if Alexandria ended up being that place.
Considering Cobalt was about abandoning the Coasts and moving to the interior, I think that the President was moved to the Great Plains and what remained of the Government and Military became the CRM. Though they weren't originally the CRM. I think they were trying in good faith to restore order and fix the country, even in the months after the collapse officially ended. But, the President ended up dying, and maybe the line of succession was interrupted, and there was a power struggle for people to become the next "President". Whoever it was that won was an Autocrat who evolved the last of the USA into what we know as the CRM, a militant organization that does share the goal of restoring the United States, but not in a very democratic and peaceable way as you would expect with the successors to the American throne. I mean, we saw a powerful group of centralized people declare the Sixth French Republic in Daryl's show, so it's not out of the realm of possibilities that the CRM would declare a new United States or a Second United States or whatever.
I feel like the president would have been usurped/ assassinated. It’s always been about people taking from others. I can see how people would fight for that position in the apocalypse. Thinking they can take the world for themselves.
Yes me to I would love to see episodes like this but unfortunately the walking dead tv franchise has become so so bad. I mean you have to scrape the bottom of the barrel to have a show get as bad as the walking dead. The writing is the worst and the acting is horrible as well
The government west of the Mississippi exfils to NORAD in Colorado. The majority of the VIP's on the East Coast will exfil to the Greenbrier, in far-eastern West Virginia, the closest mountains for the DC elites to flee to. This is, and has been common knowledge for decades.
It’s theoretically possible. While in a direct fight no, but if everyone is infected, then you no longer have control no matter how many people you have. When anyone dies at any time you have the potential for them to horde up. Say you’re in a bunker and nobody is infected, it’s a perfectly safe zone. Then someone just has a health issue randomly during the night and turns, then kills 5 others then so on and so forth. People look at is as if a giant wave of zombies is just going to charge the military. Well if that wave is coming from everywhere and never ending as there are only a few million military personnel including reserves and 330 million + people, you’d still get completely overrun as you don’t have enough people to maintain control of the entire country. This isn’t even counting the crime, panic and people that would attack the government due to panicking. Walkers are less likely but if you take a place that’s ridiculously densely populated such as the cities, you’d inevitably lose control. Places like China would go real quick, and if they were runners than most wouldn’t be able to survive at all. It’s quite difficult to make fast succession headshots and even more difficult if those targets are all running at you from different directions.
First days should and would of been chaos my guess is they all got wiped out then soldiers destering, the army logistics bad etc and the us army not being actually deployed in the USA their might of been a bigger threat at the time like Russia or China maybe a ussr in this timeline
if they had prep time, sure, the thing is it happened SO fast that everything had already essentially collapsed by the time they realized what was happening, good luck fielding any sort of military when 90% of your force has abandoned to try and keep their families safe.
They basically took the idea of the Enclave from Fallout and applied it to the walking dead with the CRM, Padre, etc. My guess is Maj Gen Beale was the highest ranking official left so he's serving the role of the pseudo president now just based on the line of succession
@@topsdaily_productions That may end up being the case. I personally feel like their new govt functions more like a council with representatives from the major departments acting like a Congress. If Beal is head of the military, my guess is he gets his way more often than not lol
@@ian7064 the civic republic is unaware in what general beale does outside the walls. Beale holds a lot of authority but seems to lie to the civic republic on his actual intentions.
Fear the Walking Dead changed a few dynamics, IMO. We saw someone with enough command authority survive to give legitimate orders to the USS Pennsylvania to nuke Chicago, and of course the beginning of PADRE. In the first seasons we saw the National Guard establishing safe zones with supplies in LA and they had helicopters, supplies, and communication from someone, and a secure hospital, I bet that was a "PADRE Phase 1". I also wonder if the Civic Republic was part of the overall PADRE plan, but it got taken over by someone who saw the old world as gone and they needed to mobilize for a new kind of future. Also, in "Walking Dead: The World Beyond", we saw Huck's Marine squad clue in to needing head shots within a few hours after the zombie uprising, so it is safe to assume that not all military units lost cohesion and broke apart. It would be interesting to see what happened on any of the nuclear carriers at sea. A Nimitz-class carrier could hold out for a long time and send shore raiding parties for food. A sort of pirate Battlestar Galactica scenario. 😄
Maybe for a short webisode show like they did with the bike girl that we saw as a walker in the first episode when Rick finds the bike or the series they did that showed one of the locations that appeared in the show where there were trucks full of walkers because one of the characters from that one was leading them there. Not really interesting enough to carry on beyond 3 or 4 episodes, 6 at most. And what happens when people get sick and die on board? No where to run or hide and the ships basically become floating coffins for everyone on board.
I have to believe when the Alicia actress said she was leaving, the writers vindictively wrote her following the senator as way to humiliate her prior to leaving. Nothing else makes any sense that somebody could write something that stupid.
You guys must be, like, you know, crazy or something....I mean....I totally get it 😂😂😂😂😂😂🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️As Arno said to Alicia - "I'm insane? You're the one who told them to find the late, great Senator Vazquez so he could lead us to the promised land. How'd that go, by the way?"
@@TWDExplained Getting involved with large groups in the days after is nail in the coffin thinking.... Being a loner/Nomadic for 4-5 years is a better idea that way you can see what communities are doing... Are they true survivors with tech, animals, families etc... Or Are they Raiders take what they want kill the rest....
Doomsday bunker, if he even left the White House. No way Walkers would breach that security fence. The Walkers are so slow just one Secret Service agent could drop a hundred of them in just a few minutes. The White House has snipers on the roof. There are dozens of expert marksmen there with a ton of weapons and bullets. They have a ton of supplies and vehicles. They could drive around the city running down Walkers in the President's limo. That thing is very heavy with bullet resistant tires and windows.
Does the SS in the presidents guard have over 100 bullets and perfect aim for each headshot. Nevermind most of SS is prevention. They are taught to take bullets for the President. In a Zombie scenario they would throw themselves to be eaten to protect the President, his family and VIPs.
Not to mention as usual what zombie fiction. The real problem is never the zombies there the catalyst. It's all the social unrest that happens around it. Really have a real world example of this where COVID was nowhere near as devastating as let's say it's older sibling, Spanish influenza, but the absolute economic and social downfall globally was so horrifying. The only thing that has ever eclipsed it is polio and the black plague which literally changed the course of human history.
You forget everything is interconnected. You'll eventually run out of bullets. Or medicine. Food. Even morale in a crumbling world. You are always dependent on tens of thousands (at least, probably more!) of people at a time to get you your stuff you need eventually. The nation is like a body requiring sustenance that is cut off due to this virus, and then individual cells die en-mass, maybe even the body (nation) itself. Again, for a time sure, it could work. But the Walking Dead universe just goes on for like 20 years. There'd be hundreds of thousands of Walkers eventually. Even if they run them all down, you need some sort of long-lasting contingency and keep anyone left from not dying and then staying loyal and on-board. Even supplies will run out after a while especially if it's more rather than less people. You need to get power from somewhere. A lot is just dependent on generally working civilian infrastructure. Yes, there are contingencies, backup power, etc. But those only work for so long and require eventual resupply. I think people maybe over-estimate some things - at least at a crisis of that magnitude. The US might partly be more resilient in some areas but here in Europe, let me tell you, society would basically implode past 3 days without power and supply chain breaking down. And then after weeks of constant societal death and decline, whatever might be left of a government can't do shit either unless they somehow banded together with enough people to try some kind of restart at a place with sufficient spare resources and farmlands.
If you've ever played project zomboid you actually find out real quick how useless vehicles are when you're swarmed by a couple hundred zombies. Even though the presidents limo has a powerful engine, it can't push through 20000 pounds of flesh
@@TheVoltDenatsu Oh yeah so relatable as a PZ player. Question is tho in what lore (I know this is WD, but still in general) vehicles truly count as "attackables" like humans. Vehicles should be mostly inanimate objects to them - once they stop moving at least. Given the bulletproof glass you could in theory just kill the engine and pray they quickly lose interest. If they're smart enough to ID human targets and tell them apart from inanimate objects and other non-organic objects and assuming they can't see through the windows to see humans then they should quickly lose interest is no more movement and sound is made.
When Maggie went into the subway with Negan there were pictographs and cash in suitcases left behind. I feel this was a setup that never got a pay off. This seamed like it was about a rich well to do family or someone high up in the government.
@zVaRiaLxRecoil In TWD, we learn that EVERYONE has the virus. It only takes effect when someone dies. So the problem with these bunkers is that, if anyone there dies, they'll turn and the bunker will be compromised instantly
They didn’t mention Obama in the TV show plus the comic book and the TV show focuses on the rocks group Besides seven senator Eliza Vasquez didn’t exist in the real world, so I doubt it’s Obama. It might’ve been someone else since this universe does not relate to the world we live in it’s just a big ass end of the world scenario.
That's an interesting thought, I would like to read a series about the third generation in a zombie apocalypse fighting for resources. Each fraction having overriding "authority" from long dead forebears. -- The Trust's United States Army, born from a group of Congressmen and whats left of the military industrial complex. -- President Teller's United States Army, formed from a Senator and some Generals. -- The President's continuity of government program taskforce, which only had 3 Joint Chiefs and a former Vice President. -- The Revolutionary Brotherhood, the offspring of Marines that turned rebellious to save the local town. -- The United States Navy, started with an Admiral with a carrier group. As for TWD, without followers a President is just another asshole who can't farm. I think Stealth from Ex Heroes had it right: “So the Mount is now under the Army’s control?” “Technically, unless you seceded from the United States at some point in the past two years … yeah.” “Which United States are you referring to?” The question froze Smith and Freedom. It jarred the others, too. The man in the suit coughed once. “I … I’m not sure I understand your question.” Stealth crossed her arms. “Which states are still united? California has not had a functioning state government for twenty-two months now. There are no social services in effect. No taxes levied or laws enforced. Its borders and lands are not maintained. As a state, California has ceased to exist by any possible definition. From our own limited reconnaissance, I can say with some certainty it is not alone in this respect. Alaska. Arizona. Florida. Hawaii. Massachusetts. Nevada. New York. Oregon. Texas. Washington.” She paused for a moment, then added, “The District of Columbia.” Smith shifted his feet. “So I ask,” she continued, “which states are still running and operating to the extent they can form a united nation, one that you and these soldiers can represent?” Excerpt From Ex-Patriots, book 2 of the Ex- Heroes series by Peter Clines
I want to know how the zombies are still alive 12 years later. I know it’s a show, but literally no science backs up the zombies walking around for 12 years with minimal food and the elements cooking and freezing them. The flesh should have dissolved and fell off within the first few years.
You're also not accounting for new infections over years. One walker that lasted a year can infect more than 1 healthy human. The walkers multiple over time, not one night.
for me I try to not think too hard about this particular concept... I just tell myself there's something about the virus/pathogen that preserves the body to a certain degree. IRL the bones could no longer remodel and the skin and muscles would become desiccated. They would last maybe one or two weeks before their bones would crumble under their own weight and their muscles would tear in half.@@ciarajones4970
@@ciarajones4970yeah but for society to collapse to the level it had by the time rick woke up at the very least 60% of the population would've been infected within the first month probably more, and it's not like the dying stopped then. Within the first year like 80-90% of the earth's population would be dead or undead and since walkers would rot and decay and be unable to move within three months at most, so by year two or three there'd be minimal zombies and by year 12 the only zombies would be people who died and no one knew until they got up and attacked someone.
but we have seen many zombies growing in trees...covered in moss...decomposing ......first of all zombies blood shouldn't be wet and drippy....it should be more like a dust....blood coagulates
@@alanb8884 Right. I suppose in that situation, if I was Deanna, I would just say, "Look, they are all dead. I may be the only member left of the three branches, so I will be Acting President until further notice!". 😅
@@glennhubbard5008 It would be interesting at least TV show lore. To give us at least tidbits of what happened to the government and military seen we are a decade in the apocalypse already. Lets say Daryl stumbles into a old bunker facility. An upon entering the facility it turn out it has automatic reserved generators for power, he stumbles on a computer an we see a soldier on the monitor. An this soldier must be at least a Colonel in rank giving out his thoughts on the last days of the U.S and explaining how D.C was overrun. An he does not know if the president is safe as the military including the facility Daryl is on is being abandoned for more possible safer locations outside the mainland and to follow procedure like P.A.D.R.E. This would be enough info for us to work on in regards to the lore of the WD universe and might hint the US govt might still be active but probably in a much smaller scale in general and we don't know where they are currently.
I think the thing that's always made it impossible for me to take this show seriously is stuff like P.A.D.R.E. Legitimately, whenever the government or military are involved, the show will basically be like "So they built this fortressed area with layers of barriers and a bunch of guards with advanced weaponry and a bunch of supplies and training. But then they all died." Which leads to the question, "Okay, but how did they all die with all of those preperations and effective countermeasures?" To which the show's response is universally "I dunno. Zombies broke in and killed them, I guess. No idea how they actually managed to do it, but believe us, they totally did."
All it takes is one death within these fortified walls for them to become a coffin. Same thing happened to Crawford. One doctor died, which let him bite a few more people, which means those few more walkers take a few more out, and so on. Everyone's infected, and everyone dies someday. You either escape the walls, which is remarkably difficult given the layers of barriers, or you get bitten and die.
There's a Walking Dead comic called The Walking Dead: Typhoon (idk if it's canon or not) they talked about China and how it got infected. I heard that the Chinese government tried to contain it but the Capital of China, Beijing, went dark and so is the government. They never mentioned anything about the president after that. Probably he is dead or still alive somewhere but the interesting is that the president of that timeline is President Jiang Zemin the real world former president of China. But the thing is the President Jiang Zemin served his term until 2003 but the virus brokeout globally in 2010. But imo if the US President is still alive he'll definitely be with the high ranking military officers and the Chairman of the Joints Chief of Staff which at that time was either Admiral Michael Mullen or General Martin Dempsey (idk if it's gonna be the real life people or a fictional character) but imo I still think the President is still alive like if you think about the possibilities. The US houses many military bunkers, secret bases like Area 51 and probably a Aircraft Carrier out there in the ocean. But if I'm crazy to think this far I might be thinking of the US President and other countries president like Russia, China, UK etc meeting up and trying to make a cure. But that's just my speculation.
It's best said by Robert Burns: “The best laid plans of mice and men often go awry.” This is what happens in "The Walking Dead" clearly illustrates the fallacy of "Continuity Of Government" ("C.O.G."); whether it's in the Real World or Sci-Fi S.H.T.F. situations.
One thing that always bugged me is that after they go to northern Virginia, they never talk about the government and where the remnants could be. After Eugene told his lie, they still decided to go to DC for that very reason. I mean Mt. Weather is a well known bunker an hour or 2 from Alexandria set up for government VIPs. It's capable of housing thousands of people for years under a mountain without ever having to open the doors. Wouldn't it be a good idea to go check it out? Even if nobody made it there it's full of supplies and the perfect place to live, or at least have as a backup plan. Deanna being a congressman would have known about it and likely other governmental facilities. Even if they didn't want to take the story there, they could've at least mentioned it and explained it away somehow.
in all likelihood what remained of the government and the military retreated to underground shelters and they stayed there until they ran out of food and power - trapping them underground until they ran out of air , died and turned . @@guilhermehank4938
@@scottd1903Yeah there’s a lot of unexplained things. Like where did all the military vacate too after cobalt. They had a base, but it was never shown what happened to them. I mean a massive military installation would be stockpiled with supplies and soldiers so it would be an easy safe zone by then. They never tried for NORAD, Mount Weather, Raven Rock etc etc.
@@Mitch_Conner75926 I could see the bases being abandoned and looter, and NORAD is a long way away. But Mt weather is 67 miles (by road) from Alexandria. Literally an hour's drive. And it's sole purpose is for a situation like this. It's right down the freaking street, at least mention it. Like maybe ask deanna about it and she could say something like: unsure if anyone made it in there, but it's sealed shut and basically impossible to get in to. Or, the VIPs never made it there and it was looted early on and without those supplies living there would be nearly impossible. That's all it would've taken, but not to even mention it when they came all that way for something like it is a huge oversight in both the comics and show.
I like how you pointed out that the Plan, what ever it was, wasn't setup for a Zombie Apocalypse, since such a thing did not really exist (meaning the zombie genre), but instead I think the Plan was designed in case of just a biological outbreak, as it seems. I am sure in the real world, as crazy as it may sound, the US govt. has a plan for a Zombie Apocalypse. I would better that many countries have think tanks just creating plans for different things. Sure it may seem like maybe not since the US govt had failed in dealing with things in the past, like most recently COVID, but COVID was not a world ending event. But I have no doubt, behind the scene people in the govt. were getting ready if COVID turned out to become even more serious as a possible extinction event. Personally, I originally thought COIVD was Nature's way to deal with human population, but as it turned out, which is still not 100% factual, COVID might have been a human product and Nature had nothing to do with it. One thing is for sure as we have seen in TWD, the Earth will continue even after humans die off. In the TWD world Nature is slowly eliminating what humans have been, with Nature taking over cities and towns with overgrown. In FTWD we saw how Nature even washed out roads and bridges.
Tom Clancys The Division brings to life one of these scenarios, it's not zombies but an act of bioterrorism. The game was based off a real experiment or 2 to determine the U.S. and it's capabilities to fight a biological weapon or release, how we would win or lose, etc. You could apply that to TWD and it might just work
Covid is definitely man made. The funding for the gain of function research was from the DoD. The vaccine is from the DoD. Our own government funded its creation, then scrambled for a cure because they never intended for it to get out. At least not when it did.
In Galveston Texas, there is only one bunker that was built upon. This is an Island, so the bunker is on the highest point, the seawall side. I know this because as a child they turned the bunker into a spook house one year. Now a hotel stands over and around the bunker and it cannot be seen. Older BOI people know what I mean... I don't really want to give this hotel extra traffic, so I won't say their name.
Would’ve been awesome to have had a spin-off series about the federal government response to the outbreak….Prez, VP, military, Intel agencies, NIH/CDC, FEMA; comms/ccordination with foreign governments. Govt implementing Continuity of Operations/Government and evac of key officials to COOP sites, such as Mt Weather/Bluemont, VA, Cheyenne Mtn Complex, etc…
I believe that by that point there would be no Bunker complex left operating or life viable. Considering the rush of things (Cobalt was a last resort solution, a last resort solution that happened extremely quickly, so you can imagine that chaos was overwhelming at an alarming rate), rations and facility management alone would leave only a few complexes viable while the rest would have needed weeks and months of preparation before entering service. Knowing that rations would have been limited, it would have eventually caused whatever administrative branch left to either resort to relocation to another base of operations, thus abandoning the facility, or it will resort to scavenging which seems extremely unlikely, considering the secrecy that would have surrounded the whole affair, you can't just send personnel outside of secret facilities while knowing that they could compromise, even indirectly if chased by undead, the whole facility. In regard to Military, I think it does exist, but it is by no way considered an official state military whatsoever since by that point most governmental structures would not exist, some could have eventually joined to the CRM and other similar post-collapse organizations, while others would act either as a no longer official platoon or long ago deserted soldiers surviving alone or in some random pocket of survivors. All in all there are a lot of things left unanswered, such as special military units and organizations (Seals, marines, British SAS, NATO, UN), CIA, MI5 and the list goes on, certainly a lot of juice is left to be extracted from the whole universe
Yes COG was developed in the case of war or a terrorist attack. However, with the dead reanimating, that would put a cog in the COG. (intended) Now, could there still be nuclear powered naval ships and subs out in the oceans with military and even civilian survivors on them? After all, not all would have had the bad luck like the USS Pennsylvania did. As for resupply, lots of small islands in the South Pacific to find food. By the way, the U.S. Navy travels in a fleet with an aircraft carrier as its main ship. Obviously the fleet would not be complete due to loss of some ships not being to handle all the walking dead but there could still be some ships out there maybe even with ships from other navies with them. Disclaimer: I reserve the right to be wrong.
*_I've been wanting episodes or a spinoff with the military and government giving up on trying to save people cuz it was too dangerous so they left and went to Antarctica cuz walkers freeze and get stuck to ice._*
In a real world scenario, at least initially, the best option for survival and security from the dead would be in the mountains. They can't climb rocks and cliff sides. Find some scenic retreats like where the Buddhists live in mountainside temples in central Asia. As long as you have access to clean water, can grow plants and raise animals you can watch the world die off in almost complete safety.
If it's TOO secure getting there might be a problem. In addition unless it's been well provisioned with supplies then getting out and going to places where you can salvage will be another problem.
TWD teased going to Washington and seeing what happened to the government but we never got that we just ran into these communities run by Negan type characters.
For those interested, I know there are a lot of books on continuity of government, but a very good one is "Raven Rock", by Garrett Graff (subtitled The Story of the U.S. Government's Secret Plan to Save Itself - While the Rest of Us Die). Not withstanding the dramatic subtitle, it's a good look at the evolution of COG with tons of references.
I'm wondering what happened to the US troops deployed in iraq and Afghanistan. Those poor soldiers were left forever in a country with walkers and insurgents both trying to kill them with no way back home to their families. They should make a series on this. It would have been really cool if Abraham's character was a solider who made it out with the last plane leaving Afghanistan..
Something I haven't seen mentioned. Omaha is where Offutt AFB is. Home of "The Hole" The first Nuclear Command Bunker we built, it was the command post for SAC, now Strategic Command. the Orders for the USS Pennsylvania most likely came from there. Its where Bush landed on 9/11. Thats where the Joint Chiefs would have fallen back to once the wheels started to fall off.The problem with Raven Rock and Mt Weather is that too many people would show up at the gate thinking its safe. There are probably massive hoards surrounding both, then the supplies ran out. Whereas Omaha didn't fall, probably because the military prioritized keeping it under control from the start, so "The Hole" would stay secure. Maybe that's why the CRM gassed Omaha. to create a hoard that would surround "The Hole"? That's one way to stage a coup.
TWD has always short changed the US military. We are led to believe that units like the 101st and 82nd Airborne Divisions, the 10th Mountain, Rangers, SF, Seals, Marines would fall before slow moving easily shot down zombies?!? Not close to reality whatsoever.
Great video man ! There’s a reason you are the only TWDU content creator I follow. The CRM (imo) is a complete government remnant. With all forms of government that hadn’t died or been killed. It’s a splinter cell of sorts. But who knows
That (among other things) is why I liked Z Nation a lot more (that I would ever like anything from The Asylum! Oo ). The President shows up here in season 4 as the one hundred thirtieth and something President of the United States (since all the previous ones were killed and the ranking kept going down), there is a plan to be unleashed ("Black Rainbow", a flesh-eating bacteria that is supposed to kill the zombies, and all humans who are unprotected). But not only that, the series also addresses other topics that I only noticed TWD was missing afterwards: what about nuclear power plants? What about nuclear warheads and the strategies behind them, such as the "Dead Hand" in Russia, which can automatically trigger a nuclear strike? What about sealed-off military bases? These are points that are actually important, but were accepted as "well, that's just the way it is" in TWD.
Assuming the president survived the initial outbreak, his term would still end after his 4th or 8th year depending on when it happened. The SOTH would become acting president, and the line of succession would follow until a new president is elected. Cabinet positions would remain unchanged unless they died, resigned, or were fired.
That could be a great storyline, the President and the vice President or Secretary of State alive in separate bunkers and starting to scheme against each other!
or they might show another show where they have fortified military bunkers throughout different regions in the midwest and eastcoast and they emerge from it making contact.
In the UK, in the event of a nuclear war, the government splits up into several separate, independent governments, with each government having complete dictatorial control over everything in their respective district, including the military. The main government in the CGWHQ will still exist, but due to the EMPs and destruction they'll likely lose contact with the other government HQs and be incapable of governing distant areas. I imagine that the US has something similar. After the walkers cause complete societal collapse there is no one government or one president anymore. It's probably several different governments, each with it's own "president" (even if they don't have the official title of President they still have the all the powers + more of the real President).
I would have to argue that the President and both line of succession and upper military command all survived. More than likely, the P.A.D.R.E. aspect was a scenario similar to the Enclave in Fallout. That's what it seems like, especially if the island shown is Alcatraz. Now as to where the President could be...that is an interesting question. Way I see it, there are at least 5 possibilities: 1 & 2: Weather Mountain or Raven Rock. These are fallout shelters that have existed since the Cold War. 3: Under the White House. If you've ever seen "Olympus has Fallen," then you know about the system of bunkers under the White House. 4: The Pentagon. Unlike most facilities, the Pentagon doesn't have just a fallout shelter or bunker, but it also has a working self-contained nuclear reactor, which would provide unlimited power if needed. 5: Cheyenne Mountain, Colorado. Cheyenne Mountain is where NORAD is, which houses the facility to launch nuclear weapons. It also houses the DEW, Delayed Early Warning, system, and thus has the capability, being isolated and securable, of housing anyone associated with a Continuity of Government program. 6: Unknown. Why? Because POTUS was able to take off in Air Force One for an undetermined time. Military protocol would have been that if an outbreak happened on the plane, infected would be eliminated without question, including POTUS or anyone else, and if needed, Command would find a place to land -- probably at an Air Force base like Wright-Patterson in Ohio or Edwards in Arizona. At least, those are my educated guesses as to where those involved with Continuity of Government protocols would be in the Walking Dead universe.
Why does one person dying mean it's going to fall? The entire bunker probably has sealed off sections with security checkpoints, cameras everywhere and armed soldiers with automatic rifles. Even if someone does die without noticing it would only take one or two guys to take out a slow-moving zombie. If anyone else got bit, they would have hours to deal with that too. I don't see how any of these secure places could fall from the inside from one or two zombies.
The fanfiction i have seen and read through most are just scene descriptions and background plots, there is very little dialogue. That has been the complaint about fear is the dialogue doesn't progress . Everyone can write general plot background but the writers that can make realistic dialogue are a premium commodity.
Back in 2010 Frank Darabont was going to have the first episode of season two play out as following the soldier in the tank that Rick was in at the beginning of season one. It was going to explain how the military got overrun and how he ended up in the tank, but of course when they fired it kind of just went down from there.
I havent watched TWD in a long time so correct me if Im wrong, is it possible the president could have ended up in some sort of off shore oil rig similar to where the Enclave from Fallout ended up?
The problem with relying on the military is that each soldier, each sailor, each personnel has a family back home they will be worried about. It's one thing for a soldier to be deployed overseas and you believe your actions are making it safer back home. But if there's a complete societal collapse and zombies wandering around eating people.... a soldier from Utah that has been deployed in Oregon could care less about duty and more concerned about people he knows back in Utah. Desertion seems very likely as groups of soldiers will be taking whatever assets and supplies to make their way home. Suddenly the military is short staff and there may be fire fights to prevent some troops from leaving, etc. It will be complete chaos. I believe the scene in FTWD, where the soldiers and the CO went to raid some building and it's implied that the troops just fragged the CO.
The thing is, if they did survive, what would you be president of if the structured government and military have collapsed the title means nothing. Also if they were to appear at any point after the supplies ran out such as an extended period of time the legitimacy of their authority would be, because of how much time is passed so again it would mean nothing.
I’ve got no idea why but I am convinced that the remnants of the US government and military are still out there, waiting, building their strength, waiting for the right time to reclaim the United States back from the dead. For example, if the enclave or the brotherhood of steel from the fallout series can survive a nuclear war that pretty much ends all animal and human life on the planet, then I’ll always be convinced that the legitimate US Government still survives in TWD.
(I know they won’t) I really want them to reveal that the President, his cabinet, joint chiefs etc, are off the Coast, waiting, rebuilding the US Military back up and waiting for the right time to reclaim the United States back from the dead. And then we have a whole series following maybe a squad, the president and others seeing their progress in taking America back, taking city after city, state after state, reintegrating survivors back into the county and then it end with the last few million hordes on the west coast, and there’s a huge battle (LA for example) we see humvees with US marines clearing Building after building. The US Army, spotting one horde, letting the US airforce strafe them with A-10s F-15s B-2 etc. and at the end of it all we see the US flag on top of the tallest building, People All across the reclaimed US Celebrating, knowing that America is free from the dead once and for all, and the president giving a speech from his command center saying that America has been freed but the rest of the world awaits.
A space station one would be pretty cool. Maybe someone at nasa at ground control talks with them keeping them informed until the individual gets attacked.
I have wondered since the show started, what happened to those people that was running those i.c.b.m nuclear missle bunkers?Those cats had perfect shelter and weapons, food, medical facilities.No walkers was getting in by breaking down the doors.
In the FTWD radio waves podcast which is a fictional podcast set in twdu during the fall. In one episode they talk about Operation Noah in which the remaining government "took to the skies" in my mind this seems to be a hint at the CRM with helicopters and taking to the skies. Noah obviously refers to Noahs ark
Bunker is very temporary thing either way. 1 person suddenly dies within the bunker and can decimate the population. Just like what happened in TWD when people started dying of illness and prison turned into chaos temporarily.
I stopped watching the main show partly because they never addressed the origins of the virus(?) and because the characters never traveled beyond the area they resided in. I stopped caring about the wash rinse repeat story telling of having a new baddy every two years and all the filler episodes dealing yet with more interpersonal and intrapersonal drama.
Just saying I don't think any survivor would give a hot crap about a government official just showing up and being like look at me I'm from the government
I still dont understand why they never even try to leave Georgia, or go to the shore or something, around S4-S5, it can't be that bad everywhere, they should try to find new terrain. Someone please explain why they never leave. there could be doctors or some type of government still left on the whole planet.
They couldn't deal with society falling apart though. When everything around you falls apart, even your work schedule and logistics and cohesion will fall apart at some point, when your colleagues die or dip en mass and no more orders come in, when your PD gets abandoned or overrun or looted, when power goes out, etc. At least in major urban hubs without a strong military backup or assistance, you'd have a hard time. I reckon smaller communities could prolly turn to self-policing, deputizing and using the land or close by resources or stockpiles to their advantage, but in big towns and cities, it would be hard to keep cohesion and order. They can hardly in some topics nowadays - when everything falls apart and everyone dying turns into a rabies cannibal wanting to eat you, it'll be a lot harder.
@@Unknown-ek1oxnot just that but in the real world we have cops that shoot at innocent civilians just because they heard an acorn falling I don't really think we should trust them anymore
In the spin off they should do civil republic flashbacks to the beginning when it was formed maybe a flashback to president or othor officials repairing to evacuate or going to Philadelphia
One of the points that many of these apocalyptic show scenarios gloss over is the fact that the logistical network for civilization is no longer available to survivors. Even in discussions about the military, which is arguably the biggest, fastest consumer of logistics (food, fuel, ammunition, whatever it is, the military will use it up faster), it will soon fail simply from a lack of resupply. There are no longer the industrial base that makes any of the things they need and hence, because of their rate of usage and depletion, will become organizationally irrelevant in the early days of such events beyond their stockpiled reserves. Separate posts and units may mutiny and become fiefdoms or enclaves (like in Fallout, LOL...) and become brutal in their survivalist tactics as any sense of nationhood would give way to the basic needs of survival. Technology would take a sudden leap backwards by a century as the delicate balance of maintenance would no longer be afforded and when things like electronics break, they're gone forever without hopes of replacement. Eventually, in the years to follow, spears and swords will be the weapons of convenience and firearms will be considered a luxury as ammunition becomes depleted. IMHO, one word. Scary.
good point about the resupply - I made some videos way back that talked a little about it - For communities popping up - a doctor, a good mechanic, construction worker, metalsmith, chemist - several other crafts/skills could be named - makes it seem like Morpheus in The Matrix telling Neo "Those are the minds we are trying to save!" As for bullets, as long as they can retrieve the casings - kinda easy to make bullets. TWD showed Eugene in a factory type setting - my brother-in-law has a 6x10 shed, and at a little bench inside he can make almost any bullet out there. It would take him a while to supply a militia I guess.
@@TWDExplained Making ammunition reliably is easy with today's production values. But once those finely factory produced grains of powder are used up, the kind of powder charges in weapons would be relegated to the reliability of munitions made and used in the civil war. That is, even with an expert armorer (a skill set that would decrease over time) bullets wouldn't be coming out with the kind of efficiency that could supply say, an entire platoon with a standard load out of 140 rounds per man. In fact, I would venture to say that firefights as we know it would no longer take place as munitions would become too valuable to spray and pray, or even to entertain a tactical notion of modern combat, ie. suppressive fire. Thus, IMHO, automatic weapons would no longer be a widely used weapon of consequence after a generation (ie. in the time of Carl or Judith Grimes growing up). Given the zombie attracting nature of firearms, that and the logistic considerations, weapons of choice would be close quarter martial alternatives like spears, axes, and knives, with perhaps a handgun held as an option of last recourse. Also, what many don't realize, is that the most valuable place worth defending is access to old technology. Being that electronics, computers and the other modern edifices of knowledge will no longer exist, the most important place on earth would be the public library as it holds the keys to the collected knowledge of a world that no longer can exist. If there's any way to claw back to that world, knowledge would be the absolute key as the people who can come up with the research would no longer be available.
DC is actually very intelligent in its design when it comes to hunkering down a defensive position. All their streets lead to a number of round abouts and parks to create choke points. This only allows very limited movement and only through certain parts of the city. Check it out
they should do a season of all seperate stories set in the first two weeks of the outbreak..get the view from the military..the president the senators eyes..it could easily work..each episode a different group of people..a new perspective on the horrors of the first month
I know it was just taken for granted that the military no longer existed in TWD universe. But seeing how strong groups such as the Commonwealth and CMR are make the collapse of the military even more absurd. Even taken together those groups wouldn't even have a tiniest fraction of the strength the armed forces have. I almost think the creators of TWD have some sort of resentment towards the military with how dumb & ineffective the troops were depicted.
I don't think there is any resentment, they just sort of blah blah blah over the outbreak because they didn't really have a way to make the collapse believable. IMO, WWZ and shaun of the Dead did a much better job at showing how a competent military would deal with an outbreak. The Last of Us showed us how no military would stop it.
@@Ratchetonater I agree and it was not an issue at all for me in the glory days of TWD. Also the few flashbacks showing the military at the hospital, napalming Atlanta were decent enough. But at the outpost in Fear TWD the army couldn't even shoot through a chain link fence. Then later they tried to build up the Commonwealth and CMR as powerful. Those groups are an absolute joke compared to a real military. Your opening point is spot in that the writers couldn't come up with a realistic way the military was beaten. So hence they basically just wrote them out of the show.
Which is why AMC may not go back to the start with a new show or a series we all want (the early days) - because of that reason (no realistic way the military would be beaten like they were)
The military protect their own. Anyone bitten in the first few hours or days would be rushed to medical whereupon they turn and the military gets attacked from within! By the time they realise what is happening structure has broken down and the only units surviving are squad or platoon level. That is why there is now active military after the first few days. @@TWDExplained
I would be really interested in any scifi or horror shows playing it straight with how well and poorly government and politics responds to crisis. Especially seeing different political parties and governments address the same issue differently. Kind like in the Book version of World War Z which would still make a wonderful anthology series.
The Civic republic republic was just remnants of the Philadelphia national guard Edit: they later also take in other military units and also WE NEED TO KNOW ABOUT FORT BENNING LIKE HOW THEY FALL THEY LITERALLY HAD 1 OF THE RANGER BATTALION STATIONED THERE KEEP IN MIND RANGERS ARE JUST UNDER THE TEIR ONE OPERATORS LIKE SEALS AND DELTA HOWWWWW AMC?????
I have a theory about how long the civic republic has been around. If you look at the gear they have an resources, the type of gear they have takes time to develop. You first draw up the plans an that takes a few years then you make prototype gear.Now prototypes of any thing can take way longer to make then you have to make adjustments to the prototype just to get a prototype that can be field tested. That stuff alone can take years to do.The resources, they had to have a large amount stock piled before the dead rose.They had to have huge amounts just to fix up cities to keep walkers out not to mention resources to take care of the people.
I was playing Lords of the Realm II (a medieval game) and they have a USA and American maps to play. I imagine it could be factions arising after a natural disaster but now they are stuck in effectively a Medieval setting.
Remember that military pilot in the walking dead season 3 with the governor that pilot said their base was overrun and they evacuated with what supplies they could grab or had and left.. got jammed up on the freeway and took the bird up to see what they see, anyway he said they were overrun so maybe the president or any government officials still maybe ran out of fuel and/or food and water and starved out or like you said as well they could have been attacked reaching the bunker or someone broke in and killed them hopefully there's a twist and closure with Rick and Michonne
most soldiers would prioritise the safety of their families and go awol to get to them so the military would effectively have been disbanded rather than defeated
Theres a book series called “the extinction cycle that does a way better job at explaining the downfall, continuance, and eventual resurgence of the military and government in the event of a “zombie apocalypse” (I say that loosely bc the zombies aren’t stereotypical zombies). It also makes a lot more sense than TWD universe just based of the infection rates/ circumstance in which you can turn, plus the zombies are a lot more dangerous than the pathetic, walking, mindless corpses. Theres a lot of plot-holes to TWD zombies that arent really explained other than “military dumb”
Worst thing they did was kill off Alicia's brother... the dude on drugs... he was the best of all of them. Him and the teacher that got shot in the helicopter of alllll places by a random bullet.
It would be cool to see something in the line of " The Enclave " from Fallout. The government coming back to retake the country with extreme methods, kinda like the CRM
There is always the possibility of some government officials left in the TWD universe like the president hiding in the wreckage of Air Force One with other government officials and even surviving military personnel
These are the kind of anthology episodes I would like to see.. different military bases aircraft carriers area 51 hell even a space station episode would be amazing small islands there's so many different scenarios you can come up with to show the beginning of the falling out and all these different types of places.
this would be cool
That's really where the goldmine is - AMC are you listening?
@@TWDExplained Hahaha Yeah right 😂
@@TWDExplained They only listen to Gimple, oh and Ian and Andy. XD
@@brianachim2670 very true...
The president is probably a self aware super computer President John Henry Eden in a bunker somewhere.
God bless the Enclave !
That's the "successor" you're referring to. The former would most likely be Dick Richardson
@@ernestocortez5820and no where else!
B*den got bit, but nobody noticed the difference. He talked and walked the same!
You watched too much Fallout
It is kinda disappointing, that the main show never featured any famous sites of Washington DC. Imagine them search in the White House or Congress for some info on what happened and where the Government went... It's really horrible of the writers not exploring anything at all.
They prob didnt think to even do such a thing tbh, now we can prob get a spinoff based on that alone
Why would they search for information? At that point they've all given up hope that the government will do anything and are just trying to build what they can. I agree it's a wasted opportunity to not have them scavenge for supplies or take cover from saviours there or whatever but your mcguffin is bad.
@Deactiv8dStylez well in the comics, right before they get to Alexandria, Aaron had to go into DC to help save Heath, Scott, and some others, but Scott didn't make it after getting back to Alexandria and fighting infection. But still very briefly they were in DC lol
The Show just chose not to go into DC and instead simply show the skyline of the Washington monument.
They still didn't touch much on the politics of it all though. It was a cameo in both instances.
@@onetallpheeeshyep, loved the comics, loved the series, even though everything was much more different on tv i still enjoyed the views they could use based off the budget they were allowed, they did everything they could, the skylines of the monuments and buildings, i did like how they did a skyline view of the mall as well when they were riding horses killing walkers left and right, gave us a realistic feel of what it would look like after a decade fallout. im ready for whats next in the series which is the ones who live.
they would've just found an abandoned White House probably full of walkers. The President and all important staff would've been moved to a bunker/secure location as soon as the outbreak started
The thing about the Wildfire Virus is that there is zero containment. Everyone is already infected, any death from any cause will result in a walker that could potentially create more. All it takes is one unobserved death inside even the most secure bunker can spell certain doom for the occupants.
Outside the bunker you have more freedom of movement.
use hart monitors etc ?
Most people who die without help do so because their body fails. Those would make for very weak zombies indeed. Most people don't die overnight: Most have a history of becoming really old and weak, getting ill, or getting help with dying from things as cars or other heavy objects. The show did a great job at portraying a swine flu victim dying overnight, but most people don't die that quick and silent. While something to stay vigilent of, it can't be the reason most of the military failed so quick
what causes the virus they tell us that everyone is infected but what caused it, if someone who was in the space station died after day 0 would they be infected or be fine ? As they weren’t on earth for like 6 months and prior to them going their was no zombies
@@sjonnieplayfull5859What about astronauts when the infection started? they were in space before zombies appeared so will they turn if they die let’s say 5 months after day 1 if they been up their for 6 months before outbreak ?
For a long time I thought The Walking Dead would end with 1 of 3 options.
1) The main cast all die
2) The crew would come across the army making a push across country like in WWZ book
3) They walk off unto the sunset just to live another day.
All three aren’t bad tbh
As soon as they made it that everyone is infected and when anyone dies they turn, the entire story or rebuilding was dead. At that point, there is no rebuilding because everything could get wiped out at any time.
The CRM is technically that army but I haven’t really watched any of the spin offs/continuations once Rick and the crew got to new Alexandrea
I would be happy with 1 if properly done
Also happy with 2 if it happened
I wouldn't be mad if they have ended it in season 5 episode 11 when the group arrives to Alexandria and Rick hears the kids playing inside the walls. The group was in rock bottom at that point and devastated by Beth and Tyreese's deaths, it would have been cool to end it with us not knowing what Alexandria looked like but with that good ending tone. The whole point of the show was Rick trying to bring his people to a safe place to live, it would have been cool if Alexandria ended up being that place.
Considering Cobalt was about abandoning the Coasts and moving to the interior, I think that the President was moved to the Great Plains and what remained of the Government and Military became the CRM.
Though they weren't originally the CRM. I think they were trying in good faith to restore order and fix the country, even in the months after the collapse officially ended. But, the President ended up dying, and maybe the line of succession was interrupted, and there was a power struggle for people to become the next "President". Whoever it was that won was an Autocrat who evolved the last of the USA into what we know as the CRM, a militant organization that does share the goal of restoring the United States, but not in a very democratic and peaceable way as you would expect with the successors to the American throne.
I mean, we saw a powerful group of centralized people declare the Sixth French Republic in Daryl's show, so it's not out of the realm of possibilities that the CRM would declare a new United States or a Second United States or whatever.
that seems SUS :> id like to see a spinoff of webisodes that lead into this with the president now. i'm highly invested
makes perfect sense.
I feel like the president would have been usurped/ assassinated. It’s always been about people taking from others. I can see how people would fight for that position in the apocalypse. Thinking they can take the world for themselves.
Yes me to I would love to see episodes like this but unfortunately the walking dead tv franchise has become so so bad. I mean you have to scrape the bottom of the barrel to have a show get as bad as the walking dead. The writing is the worst and the acting is horrible as well
The government west of the Mississippi exfils to NORAD in Colorado. The majority of the VIP's on the East Coast will exfil to the Greenbrier, in far-eastern West Virginia, the closest mountains for the DC elites to flee to. This is, and has been common knowledge for decades.
Never could buy that slow moving zombies could over take the military. They eventually could be funneled into kill boxes
It’s theoretically possible. While in a direct fight no, but if everyone is infected, then you no longer have control no matter how many people you have. When anyone dies at any time you have the potential for them to horde up. Say you’re in a bunker and nobody is infected, it’s a perfectly safe zone. Then someone just has a health issue randomly during the night and turns, then kills 5 others then so on and so forth. People look at is as if a giant wave of zombies is just going to charge the military. Well if that wave is coming from everywhere and never ending as there are only a few million military personnel including reserves and 330 million + people, you’d still get completely overrun as you don’t have enough people to maintain control of the entire country. This isn’t even counting the crime, panic and people that would attack the government due to panicking. Walkers are less likely but if you take a place that’s ridiculously densely populated such as the cities, you’d inevitably lose control. Places like China would go real quick, and if they were runners than most wouldn’t be able to survive at all. It’s quite difficult to make fast succession headshots and even more difficult if those targets are all running at you from different directions.
All I will say is if you've seen the first episode of the ones who live. I love how they handled it and I feel vindicated that my theory was right.
When you have people that turn to walkers inside your organization it’s high risk that you’ll be taken down from the inside
First days should and would of been chaos my guess is they all got wiped out then soldiers destering, the army logistics bad etc and the us army not being actually deployed in the USA their might of been a bigger threat at the time like Russia or China maybe a ussr in this timeline
if they had prep time, sure, the thing is it happened SO fast that everything had already essentially collapsed by the time they realized what was happening, good luck fielding any sort of military when 90% of your force has abandoned to try and keep their families safe.
They basically took the idea of the Enclave from Fallout and applied it to the walking dead with the CRM, Padre, etc. My guess is Maj Gen Beale was the highest ranking official left so he's serving the role of the pseudo president now just based on the line of succession
Beal is only the head of the CRM the actual CR has a separate Government and likely President atleast that's the impression I get
@@topsdaily_productions That may end up being the case. I personally feel like their new govt functions more like a council with representatives from the major departments acting like a Congress. If Beal is head of the military, my guess is he gets his way more often than not lol
@@ian7064 the civic republic is unaware in what general beale does outside the walls. Beale holds a lot of authority but seems to lie to the civic republic on his actual intentions.
Fear the Walking Dead changed a few dynamics, IMO. We saw someone with enough command authority survive to give legitimate orders to the USS Pennsylvania to nuke Chicago, and of course the beginning of PADRE. In the first seasons we saw the National Guard establishing safe zones with supplies in LA and they had helicopters, supplies, and communication from someone, and a secure hospital, I bet that was a "PADRE Phase 1". I also wonder if the Civic Republic was part of the overall PADRE plan, but it got taken over by someone who saw the old world as gone and they needed to mobilize for a new kind of future.
Also, in "Walking Dead: The World Beyond", we saw Huck's Marine squad clue in to needing head shots within a few hours after the zombie uprising, so it is safe to assume that not all military units lost cohesion and broke apart. It would be interesting to see what happened on any of the nuclear carriers at sea. A Nimitz-class carrier could hold out for a long time and send shore raiding parties for food. A sort of pirate Battlestar Galactica scenario. 😄
Maybe for a short webisode show like they did with the bike girl that we saw as a walker in the first episode when Rick finds the bike or the series they did that showed one of the locations that appeared in the show where there were trucks full of walkers because one of the characters from that one was leading them there. Not really interesting enough to carry on beyond 3 or 4 episodes, 6 at most. And what happens when people get sick and die on board? No where to run or hide and the ships basically become floating coffins for everyone on board.
Battlecarrier Nimitz, lol
I have to believe when the Alicia actress said she was leaving, the writers vindictively wrote her following the senator as way to humiliate her prior to leaving. Nothing else makes any sense that somebody could write something that stupid.
Yes, I can see more at the beginning but that far in, Alicia of all ppl would know better to follow a walker
You guys must be, like, you know, crazy or something....I mean....I totally get it
😂😂😂😂😂😂🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️As Arno said to Alicia - "I'm insane? You're the one who told them to find the late, great Senator Vazquez so he could lead us to the promised land. How'd that go, by the way?"
They made her crazyyy
@@TWDExplained TWD aka where living Humans are on the Endangered Species List....
@@TWDExplained Getting involved with large groups in the days after is nail in the coffin thinking....
Being a loner/Nomadic for 4-5 years is a better idea that way you can see what communities are doing...
Are they true survivors with tech, animals, families etc...
Or
Are they Raiders take what they want kill the rest....
Doomsday bunker, if he even left the White House. No way Walkers would breach that security fence. The Walkers are so slow just one Secret Service agent could drop a hundred of them in just a few minutes. The White House has snipers on the roof. There are dozens of expert marksmen there with a ton of weapons and bullets. They have a ton of supplies and vehicles. They could drive around the city running down Walkers in the President's limo. That thing is very heavy with bullet resistant tires and windows.
Does the SS in the presidents guard have over 100 bullets and perfect aim for each headshot. Nevermind most of SS is prevention. They are taught to take bullets for the President. In a Zombie scenario they would throw themselves to be eaten to protect the President, his family and VIPs.
Not to mention as usual what zombie fiction. The real problem is never the zombies there the catalyst. It's all the social unrest that happens around it. Really have a real world example of this where COVID was nowhere near as devastating as let's say it's older sibling, Spanish influenza, but the absolute economic and social downfall globally was so horrifying. The only thing that has ever eclipsed it is polio and the black plague which literally changed the course of human history.
You forget everything is interconnected. You'll eventually run out of bullets. Or medicine. Food. Even morale in a crumbling world. You are always dependent on tens of thousands (at least, probably more!) of people at a time to get you your stuff you need eventually. The nation is like a body requiring sustenance that is cut off due to this virus, and then individual cells die en-mass, maybe even the body (nation) itself.
Again, for a time sure, it could work. But the Walking Dead universe just goes on for like 20 years. There'd be hundreds of thousands of Walkers eventually. Even if they run them all down, you need some sort of long-lasting contingency and keep anyone left from not dying and then staying loyal and on-board.
Even supplies will run out after a while especially if it's more rather than less people. You need to get power from somewhere.
A lot is just dependent on generally working civilian infrastructure. Yes, there are contingencies, backup power, etc. But those only work for so long and require eventual resupply. I think people maybe over-estimate some things - at least at a crisis of that magnitude. The US might partly be more resilient in some areas but here in Europe, let me tell you, society would basically implode past 3 days without power and supply chain breaking down. And then after weeks of constant societal death and decline, whatever might be left of a government can't do shit either unless they somehow banded together with enough people to try some kind of restart at a place with sufficient spare resources and farmlands.
If you've ever played project zomboid you actually find out real quick how useless vehicles are when you're swarmed by a couple hundred zombies. Even though the presidents limo has a powerful engine, it can't push through 20000 pounds of flesh
@@TheVoltDenatsu Oh yeah so relatable as a PZ player. Question is tho in what lore (I know this is WD, but still in general) vehicles truly count as "attackables" like humans. Vehicles should be mostly inanimate objects to them - once they stop moving at least. Given the bulletproof glass you could in theory just kill the engine and pray they quickly lose interest. If they're smart enough to ID human targets and tell them apart from inanimate objects and other non-organic objects and assuming they can't see through the windows to see humans then they should quickly lose interest is no more movement and sound is made.
When Maggie went into the subway with Negan there were pictographs and cash in suitcases left behind. I feel this was a setup that never got a pay off. This seamed like it was about a rich well to do family or someone high up in the government.
The problem with the Bunker idea is people are still effected...once one person dies of anything the bunker is compromised.
lmao, big lmao
How? 🤣
@@zVaRiaLxRecoilEveryone is infected.
@zVaRiaLxRecoil
In TWD, we learn that EVERYONE has the virus. It only takes effect when someone dies.
So the problem with these bunkers is that, if anyone there dies, they'll turn and the bunker will be compromised instantly
@@zVaRiaLxRecoil Everyone's infected. If someone dies, they come back. Or have you not taken a look at any TWD media?
I don’t think knowing Who the president was doesn’t matter, but like that senator in fear, The Walking Dead, he might be underground in a bunker too
It would be Obama since it took place in October 2010
They didn’t mention Obama in the TV show plus the comic book and the TV show focuses on the rocks group Besides seven senator Eliza Vasquez didn’t exist in the real world, so I doubt it’s Obama. It might’ve been someone else since this universe does not relate to the world we live in it’s just a big ass end of the world scenario.
@@ronjay7831 figures it'd be Obama, still destroying the world 13 years later
@@ronjay7831They don’t use real people.
Nah, they took the senator to the Stargate in Cheyenne mountain and then the senator was whisk away to a site off-world where they chose to rebuild.
That's an interesting thought, I would like to read a series about the third generation in a zombie apocalypse fighting for resources. Each fraction having overriding "authority" from long dead forebears.
-- The Trust's United States Army, born from a group of Congressmen and whats left of the military industrial complex.
-- President Teller's United States Army, formed from a Senator and some Generals.
-- The President's continuity of government program taskforce, which only had 3 Joint Chiefs and a former Vice President.
-- The Revolutionary Brotherhood, the offspring of Marines that turned rebellious to save the local town.
-- The United States Navy, started with an Admiral with a carrier group.
As for TWD, without followers a President is just another asshole who can't farm.
I think Stealth from Ex Heroes had it right:
“So the Mount is now under the Army’s control?”
“Technically, unless you seceded from the United States at some point in the past two years … yeah.”
“Which United States are you referring to?”
The question froze Smith and Freedom. It jarred the others, too. The man in the suit coughed once. “I … I’m not sure I understand your question.”
Stealth crossed her arms. “Which states are still united? California has not had a functioning state government for twenty-two months now. There are no social services in effect. No taxes levied or laws enforced. Its borders and lands are not maintained. As a state, California has ceased to exist by any possible definition. From our own limited reconnaissance, I can say with some certainty it is not alone in this respect. Alaska. Arizona. Florida. Hawaii. Massachusetts. Nevada. New York. Oregon. Texas. Washington.” She paused for a moment, then added, “The District of Columbia.”
Smith shifted his feet.
“So I ask,” she continued, “which states are still running and operating to the extent they can form a united nation, one that you and these soldiers can represent?”
Excerpt From Ex-Patriots, book 2 of the Ex- Heroes series by Peter Clines
clue, asshole who can't farm 😂 don't need them for sure.
I want to know how the zombies are still alive 12 years later. I know it’s a show, but literally no science backs up the zombies walking around for 12 years with minimal food and the elements cooking and freezing them. The flesh should have dissolved and fell off within the first few years.
science, logic and some other real world stuff does not apply to TWD it seems
You're also not accounting for new infections over years.
One walker that lasted a year can infect more than 1 healthy human.
The walkers multiple over time, not one night.
for me I try to not think too hard about this particular concept... I just tell myself there's something about the virus/pathogen that preserves the body to a certain degree. IRL the bones could no longer remodel and the skin and muscles would become desiccated. They would last maybe one or two weeks before their bones would crumble under their own weight and their muscles would tear in half.@@ciarajones4970
@@ciarajones4970yeah but for society to collapse to the level it had by the time rick woke up at the very least 60% of the population would've been infected within the first month probably more, and it's not like the dying stopped then. Within the first year like 80-90% of the earth's population would be dead or undead and since walkers would rot and decay and be unable to move within three months at most, so by year two or three there'd be minimal zombies and by year 12 the only zombies would be people who died and no one knew until they got up and attacked someone.
but we have seen many zombies growing in trees...covered in moss...decomposing ......first of all zombies blood shouldn't be wet and drippy....it should be more like a dust....blood coagulates
I felt Deanna as a member of Congress would have been President under the succession law.
Nope. VP, speaker of the House, then through the president's Cabinet, starting with the Secretary of State.
@@alanb8884 Right. I suppose in that situation, if I was Deanna, I would just say, "Look, they are all dead. I may be the only member left of the three branches, so I will be Acting President until further notice!". 😅
@@glennhubbard5008 It would be interesting at least TV show lore. To give us at least tidbits of what happened to the government and military seen we are a decade in the apocalypse already. Lets say Daryl stumbles into a old bunker facility. An upon entering the facility it turn out it has automatic reserved generators for power, he stumbles on a computer an we see a soldier on the monitor.
An this soldier must be at least a Colonel in rank giving out his thoughts on the last days of the U.S and explaining how D.C was overrun. An he does not know if the president is safe as the military including the facility Daryl is on is being abandoned for more possible safer locations outside the mainland and to follow procedure like P.A.D.R.E.
This would be enough info for us to work on in regards to the lore of the WD universe and might hint the US govt might still be active but probably in a much smaller scale in general and we don't know where they are currently.
I think the thing that's always made it impossible for me to take this show seriously is stuff like P.A.D.R.E. Legitimately, whenever the government or military are involved, the show will basically be like "So they built this fortressed area with layers of barriers and a bunch of guards with advanced weaponry and a bunch of supplies and training. But then they all died."
Which leads to the question, "Okay, but how did they all die with all of those preperations and effective countermeasures?"
To which the show's response is universally "I dunno. Zombies broke in and killed them, I guess. No idea how they actually managed to do it, but believe us, they totally did."
All it takes is one death within these fortified walls for them to become a coffin. Same thing happened to Crawford. One doctor died, which let him bite a few more people, which means those few more walkers take a few more out, and so on. Everyone's infected, and everyone dies someday. You either escape the walls, which is remarkably difficult given the layers of barriers, or you get bitten and die.
There's a Walking Dead comic called The Walking Dead: Typhoon (idk if it's canon or not) they talked about China and how it got infected. I heard that the Chinese government tried to contain it but the Capital of China, Beijing, went dark and so is the government. They never mentioned anything about the president after that. Probably he is dead or still alive somewhere but the interesting is that the president of that timeline is President Jiang Zemin the real world former president of China. But the thing is the President Jiang Zemin served his term until 2003 but the virus brokeout globally in 2010. But imo if the US President is still alive he'll definitely be with the high ranking military officers and the Chairman of the Joints Chief of Staff which at that time was either Admiral Michael Mullen or General Martin Dempsey (idk if it's gonna be the real life people or a fictional character) but imo I still think the President is still alive like if you think about the possibilities. The US houses many military bunkers, secret bases like Area 51 and probably a Aircraft Carrier out there in the ocean. But if I'm crazy to think this far I might be thinking of the US President and other countries president like Russia, China, UK etc meeting up and trying to make a cure. But that's just my speculation.
Typhoon is canon for the comic universe, in the twd comics the apocalypse starts in 2003
It's best said by Robert Burns: “The best laid plans of mice and men often go awry.” This is what happens in "The Walking Dead" clearly illustrates the fallacy of "Continuity Of Government" ("C.O.G."); whether it's in the Real World or Sci-Fi S.H.T.F. situations.
One thing that always bugged me is that after they go to northern Virginia, they never talk about the government and where the remnants could be. After Eugene told his lie, they still decided to go to DC for that very reason.
I mean Mt. Weather is a well known bunker an hour or 2 from Alexandria set up for government VIPs. It's capable of housing thousands of people for years under a mountain without ever having to open the doors. Wouldn't it be a good idea to go check it out? Even if nobody made it there it's full of supplies and the perfect place to live, or at least have as a backup plan. Deanna being a congressman would have known about it and likely other governmental facilities. Even if they didn't want to take the story there, they could've at least mentioned it and explained it away somehow.
I think the group mutally decided that the government is gone and its best to focus on what they will do now instead of hoping they appear someday.
@@guilhermehank4938 but they never bothered to check or even have a conversation about it. They went through Hell to get there for that very reason
in all likelihood what remained of the government and the military retreated to underground shelters and they stayed there until they ran out of food and power - trapping them underground until they ran out of air , died and turned . @@guilhermehank4938
@@scottd1903Yeah there’s a lot of unexplained things. Like where did all the military vacate too after cobalt. They had a base, but it was never shown what happened to them. I mean a massive military installation would be stockpiled with supplies and soldiers so it would be an easy safe zone by then. They never tried for NORAD, Mount Weather, Raven Rock etc etc.
@@Mitch_Conner75926 I could see the bases being abandoned and looter, and NORAD is a long way away. But Mt weather is 67 miles (by road) from Alexandria. Literally an hour's drive. And it's sole purpose is for a situation like this. It's right down the freaking street, at least mention it. Like maybe ask deanna about it and she could say something like: unsure if anyone made it in there, but it's sealed shut and basically impossible to get in to. Or, the VIPs never made it there and it was looted early on and without those supplies living there would be nearly impossible. That's all it would've taken, but not to even mention it when they came all that way for something like it is a huge oversight in both the comics and show.
Thanks for making videos on the things we literally BEGGED Gimple, Kang, and Kirkman for
I like how you pointed out that the Plan, what ever it was, wasn't setup for a Zombie Apocalypse, since such a thing did not really exist (meaning the zombie genre), but instead I think the Plan was designed in case of just a biological outbreak, as it seems. I am sure in the real world, as crazy as it may sound, the US govt. has a plan for a Zombie Apocalypse. I would better that many countries have think tanks just creating plans for different things. Sure it may seem like maybe not since the US govt had failed in dealing with things in the past, like most recently COVID, but COVID was not a world ending event. But I have no doubt, behind the scene people in the govt. were getting ready if COVID turned out to become even more serious as a possible extinction event. Personally, I originally thought COIVD was Nature's way to deal with human population, but as it turned out, which is still not 100% factual, COVID might have been a human product and Nature had nothing to do with it. One thing is for sure as we have seen in TWD, the Earth will continue even after humans die off. In the TWD world Nature is slowly eliminating what humans have been, with Nature taking over cities and towns with overgrown. In FTWD we saw how Nature even washed out roads and bridges.
Tom Clancys The Division brings to life one of these scenarios, it's not zombies but an act of bioterrorism. The game was based off a real experiment or 2 to determine the U.S. and it's capabilities to fight a biological weapon or release, how we would win or lose, etc. You could apply that to TWD and it might just work
I'm sure they've had top doctors/scientists researching the possibility of a zombie outbreak for decades lol
The US government actually confirmed they have a plan for a zombie apocalypse. Several actually.
Dude you need to stop trusting your government with your hypothetical future. Stop trusting them anyways.
Covid is definitely man made. The funding for the gain of function research was from the DoD. The vaccine is from the DoD. Our own government funded its creation, then scrambled for a cure because they never intended for it to get out. At least not when it did.
In Galveston Texas, there is only one bunker that was built upon. This is an Island, so the bunker is on the highest point, the seawall side. I know this because as a child they turned the bunker into a spook house one year. Now a hotel stands over and around the bunker and it cannot be seen. Older BOI people know what I mean... I don't really want to give this hotel extra traffic, so I won't say their name.
Would’ve been awesome to have had a spin-off series about the federal government response to the outbreak….Prez, VP, military, Intel agencies, NIH/CDC, FEMA; comms/ccordination with foreign governments. Govt implementing Continuity of Operations/Government and evac of key officials to COOP sites, such as Mt Weather/Bluemont, VA, Cheyenne Mtn Complex, etc…
Fear the Walking West Wing. 🧟♂
I believe that by that point there would be no Bunker complex left operating or life viable. Considering the rush of things (Cobalt was a last resort solution, a last resort solution that happened extremely quickly, so you can imagine that chaos was overwhelming at an alarming rate), rations and facility management alone would leave only a few complexes viable while the rest would have needed weeks and months of preparation before entering service. Knowing that rations would have been limited, it would have eventually caused whatever administrative branch left to either resort to relocation to another base of operations, thus abandoning the facility, or it will resort to scavenging which seems extremely unlikely, considering the secrecy that would have surrounded the whole affair, you can't just send personnel outside of secret facilities while knowing that they could compromise, even indirectly if chased by undead, the whole facility.
In regard to Military, I think it does exist, but it is by no way considered an official state military whatsoever since by that point most governmental structures would not exist, some could have eventually joined to the CRM and other similar post-collapse organizations, while others would act either as a no longer official platoon or long ago deserted soldiers surviving alone or in some random pocket of survivors.
All in all there are a lot of things left unanswered, such as special military units and organizations (Seals, marines, British SAS, NATO, UN), CIA, MI5 and the list goes on, certainly a lot of juice is left to be extracted from the whole universe
Yes COG was developed in the case of war or a terrorist attack. However, with the dead reanimating, that would put a cog in the COG. (intended) Now, could there still be nuclear powered naval ships and subs out in the oceans with military and even civilian survivors on them? After all, not all would have had the bad luck like the USS Pennsylvania did. As for resupply, lots of small islands in the South Pacific to find food. By the way, the U.S. Navy travels in a fleet with an aircraft carrier as its main ship. Obviously the fleet would not be complete due to loss of some ships not being to handle all the walking dead but there could still be some ships out there maybe even with ships from other navies with them.
Disclaimer: I reserve the right to be wrong.
*_I've been wanting episodes or a spinoff with the military and government giving up on trying to save people cuz it was too dangerous so they left and went to Antarctica cuz walkers freeze and get stuck to ice._*
This!!!!
That would be so cool
frozen walkers wouldn't be too exciting to watch though. Eventually all the survivors would die and turn into frozen walkers themselves.
In a real world scenario, at least initially, the best option for survival and security from the dead would be in the mountains. They can't climb rocks and cliff sides. Find some scenic retreats like where the Buddhists live in mountainside temples in central Asia. As long as you have access to clean water, can grow plants and raise animals you can watch the world die off in almost complete safety.
If it's TOO secure getting there might be a problem. In addition unless it's been well provisioned with supplies then getting out and going to places where you can salvage will be another problem.
TWD teased going to Washington and seeing what happened to the government but we never got that we just ran into these communities run by Negan type characters.
As if there wasn't enough of them 😂
And that is all this show was. One of them after another.
For those interested, I know there are a lot of books on continuity of government, but a very good one is "Raven Rock", by Garrett Graff (subtitled The Story of the U.S. Government's Secret Plan to Save Itself - While the Rest of Us Die). Not withstanding the dramatic subtitle, it's a good look at the evolution of COG with tons of references.
I'm wondering what happened to the US troops deployed in iraq and Afghanistan. Those poor soldiers were left forever in a country with walkers and insurgents both trying to kill them with no way back home to their families. They should make a series on this. It would have been really cool if Abraham's character was a solider who made it out with the last plane leaving Afghanistan..
Would be an amazing Webisode or mini-series that has a soldier fighting for years to make it from the middle east back to the US
@@topsdaily_productions Only to find his zombiefied family and his country in ruins :(
Who cares?? They signed up for that JOB that they get paid for!! Y'all act like they do it for free🐑
@@Jbeeze82bruh this a TV show relax😂😂
@@Jbeeze82 Respect the troops.
Something I haven't seen mentioned. Omaha is where Offutt AFB is. Home of "The Hole" The first Nuclear Command Bunker we built, it was the command post for SAC, now Strategic Command. the Orders for the USS Pennsylvania most likely came from there. Its where Bush landed on 9/11. Thats where the Joint Chiefs would have fallen back to once the wheels started to fall off.The problem with Raven Rock and Mt Weather is that too many people would show up at the gate thinking its safe. There are probably massive hoards surrounding both, then the supplies ran out.
Whereas Omaha didn't fall, probably because the military prioritized keeping it under control from the start, so "The Hole" would stay secure. Maybe that's why the CRM gassed Omaha. to create a hoard that would surround "The Hole"? That's one way to stage a coup.
interesting
Great video, James! Very, very interesting what happened/happens to the government. Keep up the good work!
Thanks as always Snake, will do!
TWD has always short changed the US military. We are led to believe that units like the 101st and 82nd Airborne Divisions, the 10th Mountain, Rangers, SF, Seals, Marines would fall before slow moving easily shot down zombies?!? Not close to reality whatsoever.
Rick dicky Doo da Grimes: "this isn't a democracy anymore"
Great video man ! There’s a reason you are the only TWDU content creator I follow. The CRM (imo) is a complete government remnant. With all forms of government that hadn’t died or been killed. It’s a splinter cell of sorts. But who knows
Thanks!! Yes it could be - I hope we get more info on it and they do not just 'brush over it'
@@TWDExplained same dude. Same
Raven rock is fully staffed today so it is not that far to say that the government remnants are stationed there
Imo the military was just extremely incompetent in this universe
Just like real life.
meanwhile down in a secret bunker the president says nope i aint going out too many dead people walking lol
What about the Navy? 10 or 11 nuclear powered carriers? Many nuclear powered submarines?
That (among other things) is why I liked Z Nation a lot more (that I would ever like anything from The Asylum! Oo ). The President shows up here in season 4 as the one hundred thirtieth and something President of the United States (since all the previous ones were killed and the ranking kept going down), there is a plan to be unleashed ("Black Rainbow", a flesh-eating bacteria that is supposed to kill the zombies, and all humans who are unprotected). But not only that, the series also addresses other topics that I only noticed TWD was missing afterwards: what about nuclear power plants? What about nuclear warheads and the strategies behind them, such as the "Dead Hand" in Russia, which can automatically trigger a nuclear strike? What about sealed-off military bases? These are points that are actually important, but were accepted as "well, that's just the way it is" in TWD.
I'm curious what happened to the Cheyenne Mountain Complex.
Was probably overrun from the inside with walkers
Assuming the president survived the initial outbreak, his term would still end after his 4th or 8th year depending on when it happened. The SOTH would become acting president, and the line of succession would follow until a new president is elected. Cabinet positions would remain unchanged unless they died, resigned, or were fired.
I don’t think the president would fire anyone noticing the shit-show outside of their only line of defense
And I don’t think it would be possible to hold an election with the apocalypse
That could be a great storyline, the President and the vice President or Secretary of State alive in separate bunkers and starting to scheme against each other!
or they might show another show where they have fortified military bunkers throughout different regions in the midwest and eastcoast and they emerge from it making contact.
In the UK, in the event of a nuclear war, the government splits up into several separate, independent governments, with each government having complete dictatorial control over everything in their respective district, including the military. The main government in the CGWHQ will still exist, but due to the EMPs and destruction they'll likely lose contact with the other government HQs and be incapable of governing distant areas.
I imagine that the US has something similar. After the walkers cause complete societal collapse there is no one government or one president anymore. It's probably several different governments, each with it's own "president" (even if they don't have the official title of President they still have the all the powers + more of the real President).
Imagine someone like Thomas Eckhart, that would be dope!
I would have to argue that the President and both line of succession and upper military command all survived.
More than likely, the P.A.D.R.E. aspect was a scenario similar to the Enclave in Fallout. That's what it seems like, especially if the island shown is Alcatraz.
Now as to where the President could be...that is an interesting question. Way I see it, there are at least 5 possibilities:
1 & 2: Weather Mountain or Raven Rock. These are fallout shelters that have existed since the Cold War.
3: Under the White House. If you've ever seen "Olympus has Fallen," then you know about the system of bunkers under the White House.
4: The Pentagon. Unlike most facilities, the Pentagon doesn't have just a fallout shelter or bunker, but it also has a working self-contained nuclear reactor, which would provide unlimited power if needed.
5: Cheyenne Mountain, Colorado. Cheyenne Mountain is where NORAD is, which houses the facility to launch nuclear weapons. It also houses the DEW, Delayed Early Warning, system, and thus has the capability, being isolated and securable, of housing anyone associated with a Continuity of Government program.
6: Unknown. Why? Because POTUS was able to take off in Air Force One for an undetermined time. Military protocol would have been that if an outbreak happened on the plane, infected would be eliminated without question, including POTUS or anyone else, and if needed, Command would find a place to land -- probably at an Air Force base like Wright-Patterson in Ohio or Edwards in Arizona.
At least, those are my educated guesses as to where those involved with Continuity of Government protocols would be in the Walking Dead universe.
all good possibilities
Yeah this is true, the president is probably either at Mt. Weather or in the PEOC under the White House.
Bunkers can be a death trap in situations like this, one person dies and it falls.
Why does one person dying mean it's going to fall? The entire bunker probably has sealed off sections with security checkpoints, cameras everywhere and armed soldiers with automatic rifles. Even if someone does die without noticing it would only take one or two guys to take out a slow-moving zombie. If anyone else got bit, they would have hours to deal with that too. I don't see how any of these secure places could fall from the inside from one or two zombies.
@@nilbog2191 zombies turn other people into zombies and you're stuck. Duh.
@@kristingallo2158 just wait a couple months and the zombies in the other section of the bunker will have deteriorated by then.
@@nilbog2191 then it'll just stink and there's gonna be maggots and rats. Y'all have fun in the bunkers. I'm taking my chances in tree forts
The fanfiction i have seen and read through most are just scene descriptions and background plots, there is very little dialogue.
That has been the complaint about fear is the dialogue doesn't progress .
Everyone can write general plot background but the writers that can make realistic dialogue are a premium commodity.
The bunkers we have today are all connected with rail lines and underground roadways. Connect from west to east coast
That wouldn't surprise me one bit.
Back in 2010 Frank Darabont was going to have the first episode of season two play out as following the soldier in the tank that Rick was in at the beginning of season one. It was going to explain how the military got overrun and how he ended up in the tank, but of course when they fired it kind of just went down from there.
the padre book looks similar to the rebuild book maggie was given before maggie left to learn from the other group...
What if the cosmonaut is still alive in the iss and he's not infected and he is the cure ?
I havent watched TWD in a long time so correct me if Im wrong, is it possible the president could have ended up in some sort of off shore oil rig similar to where the Enclave from Fallout ended up?
God Bless President Dick Richardson!
@@roryscott2941 ...and God Bless his successor John Henry Eden.
It's TWD, so noone in gov or the military is competent. The Pres is very more than likely dead.
No absolutely not. DC VIP's evac to the Greenbrier in West Virginia, THEN they evac to their REAL shelter to ride the storm out.
The problem with relying on the military is that each soldier, each sailor, each personnel has a family back home they will be worried about. It's one thing for a soldier to be deployed overseas and you believe your actions are making it safer back home. But if there's a complete societal collapse and zombies wandering around eating people.... a soldier from Utah that has been deployed in Oregon could care less about duty and more concerned about people he knows back in Utah. Desertion seems very likely as groups of soldiers will be taking whatever assets and supplies to make their way home. Suddenly the military is short staff and there may be fire fights to prevent some troops from leaving, etc. It will be complete chaos. I believe the scene in FTWD, where the soldiers and the CO went to raid some building and it's implied that the troops just fragged the CO.
If you listen to the radio on tyrese's death scene (while hes in the car) you get to hear some of the CRM origins
The thing is, if they did survive, what would you be president of if the structured government and military have collapsed the title means nothing.
Also if they were to appear at any point after the supplies ran out such as an extended period of time the legitimacy of their authority would be, because of how much time is passed so again it would mean nothing.
good point
Imagine Rick and his group gettin ahold of a presidential bulletproof vehicle governor wouldn’t stand a chance😂
I’ve got no idea why but I am convinced that the remnants of the US government and military are still out there, waiting, building their strength, waiting for the right time to reclaim the United States back from the dead.
For example, if the enclave or the brotherhood of steel from the fallout series can survive a nuclear war that pretty much ends all animal and human life on the planet, then I’ll always be convinced that the legitimate US Government still survives in TWD.
(I know they won’t) I really want them to reveal that the President, his cabinet, joint chiefs etc, are off the Coast, waiting, rebuilding the US Military back up and waiting for the right time to reclaim the United States back from the dead. And then we have a whole series following maybe a squad, the president and others seeing their progress in taking America back, taking city after city, state after state, reintegrating survivors back into the county and then it end with the last few million hordes on the west coast, and there’s a huge battle (LA for example) we see humvees with US marines clearing Building after building. The US Army, spotting one horde, letting the US airforce strafe them with A-10s F-15s B-2 etc. and at the end of it all we see the US flag on top of the tallest building, People All across the reclaimed US Celebrating, knowing that America is free from the dead once and for all, and the president giving a speech from his command center saying that America has been freed but the rest of the world awaits.
A space station one would be pretty cool. Maybe someone at nasa at ground control talks with them keeping them informed until the individual gets attacked.
I have wondered since the show started, what happened to those people that was running those i.c.b.m nuclear missle bunkers?Those cats had perfect shelter and weapons, food, medical facilities.No walkers was getting in by breaking down the doors.
In the FTWD radio waves podcast which is a fictional podcast set in twdu during the fall. In one episode they talk about Operation Noah in which the remaining government "took to the skies" in my mind this seems to be a hint at the CRM with helicopters and taking to the skies. Noah obviously refers to Noahs ark
Bunker is very temporary thing either way.
1 person suddenly dies within the bunker and can decimate the population.
Just like what happened in TWD when people started dying of illness and prison turned into chaos temporarily.
I stopped watching the main show partly because they never addressed the origins of the virus(?) and because the characters never traveled beyond the area they resided in. I stopped caring about the wash rinse repeat story telling of having a new baddy every two years and all the filler episodes dealing yet with more interpersonal and intrapersonal drama.
Just saying I don't think any survivor would give a hot crap about a government official just showing up and being like look at me I'm from the government
I still dont understand why they never even try to leave Georgia, or go to the shore or something, around S4-S5, it can't be that bad everywhere, they should try to find new terrain. Someone please explain why they never leave. there could be doctors or some type of government still left on the whole planet.
COG , pretty much don't put all your eggs in one basket idea. Also plenty of "resupply" sites all around the US and territories.
Just subscribed, I have so many questions and you have answered some. Just going to watch all your videos
Awesome! Thank you!
In real life, local cops could have take care of those slow moving, very weak zombies.
Keep in mind that, everybody is infected, and when they die, they turn, that why at least 7 bilion or more are dead or infected or zombies
They couldn't deal with society falling apart though. When everything around you falls apart, even your work schedule and logistics and cohesion will fall apart at some point, when your colleagues die or dip en mass and no more orders come in, when your PD gets abandoned or overrun or looted, when power goes out, etc.
At least in major urban hubs without a strong military backup or assistance, you'd have a hard time. I reckon smaller communities could prolly turn to self-policing, deputizing and using the land or close by resources or stockpiles to their advantage, but in big towns and cities, it would be hard to keep cohesion and order.
They can hardly in some topics nowadays - when everything falls apart and everyone dying turns into a rabies cannibal wanting to eat you, it'll be a lot harder.
@@Unknown-ek1oxnot just that but in the real world we have cops that shoot at innocent civilians just because they heard an acorn falling I don't really think we should trust them anymore
I think alot of the CRM are former gov. Officials and soldiers. I thought that the CRM is part of what's going on in France but I might be wrong.
In the spin off they should do civil republic flashbacks to the beginning when it was formed maybe a flashback to president or othor officials repairing to evacuate or going to Philadelphia
It be the same way IRL. People in the military will eventually abandon their posts just out of fear for their own family.
I'm a new subscriber and I've got to say that your videos are so much fun and thought provoking.
Yay! Thank you Peabuddie!!!
One of the points that many of these apocalyptic show scenarios gloss over is the fact that the logistical network for civilization is no longer available to survivors. Even in discussions about the military, which is arguably the biggest, fastest consumer of logistics (food, fuel, ammunition, whatever it is, the military will use it up faster), it will soon fail simply from a lack of resupply. There are no longer the industrial base that makes any of the things they need and hence, because of their rate of usage and depletion, will become organizationally irrelevant in the early days of such events beyond their stockpiled reserves. Separate posts and units may mutiny and become fiefdoms or enclaves (like in Fallout, LOL...) and become brutal in their survivalist tactics as any sense of nationhood would give way to the basic needs of survival. Technology would take a sudden leap backwards by a century as the delicate balance of maintenance would no longer be afforded and when things like electronics break, they're gone forever without hopes of replacement. Eventually, in the years to follow, spears and swords will be the weapons of convenience and firearms will be considered a luxury as ammunition becomes depleted. IMHO, one word. Scary.
good point about the resupply - I made some videos way back that talked a little about it -
For communities popping up - a doctor, a good mechanic, construction worker, metalsmith, chemist - several other crafts/skills could be named - makes it seem like Morpheus in The Matrix telling Neo "Those are the minds we are trying to save!"
As for bullets, as long as they can retrieve the casings - kinda easy to make bullets. TWD showed Eugene in a factory type setting - my brother-in-law has a 6x10 shed, and at a little bench inside he can make almost any bullet out there. It would take him a while to supply a militia I guess.
@@TWDExplained Making ammunition reliably is easy with today's production values. But once those finely factory produced grains of powder are used up, the kind of powder charges in weapons would be relegated to the reliability of munitions made and used in the civil war. That is, even with an expert armorer (a skill set that would decrease over time) bullets wouldn't be coming out with the kind of efficiency that could supply say, an entire platoon with a standard load out of 140 rounds per man. In fact, I would venture to say that firefights as we know it would no longer take place as munitions would become too valuable to spray and pray, or even to entertain a tactical notion of modern combat, ie. suppressive fire. Thus, IMHO, automatic weapons would no longer be a widely used weapon of consequence after a generation (ie. in the time of Carl or Judith Grimes growing up). Given the zombie attracting nature of firearms, that and the logistic considerations, weapons of choice would be close quarter martial alternatives like spears, axes, and knives, with perhaps a handgun held as an option of last recourse. Also, what many don't realize, is that the most valuable place worth defending is access to old technology. Being that electronics, computers and the other modern edifices of knowledge will no longer exist, the most important place on earth would be the public library as it holds the keys to the collected knowledge of a world that no longer can exist. If there's any way to claw back to that world, knowledge would be the absolute key as the people who can come up with the research would no longer be available.
TWD became the state troopers and highway patrol from Super Troopers.
The 3 circles interlocking have some type of meaning. I believe represent 3 separate branches/groups that are united.
DC is actually very intelligent in its design when it comes to hunkering down a defensive position. All their streets lead to a number of round abouts and parks to create choke points. This only allows very limited movement and only through certain parts of the city. Check it out
they should do a season of all seperate stories set in the first two weeks of the outbreak..get the view from the military..the president the senators eyes..it could easily work..each episode a different group of people..a new perspective on the horrors of the first month
Didn't they do that with a spin-off but totally screwed it up?
@@DirtyHardSock That was basically the first season of Fear the Walking Dead, yeah.
Great video Champ!!
Appreciate it! Thanks for watching!!!
I know it was just taken for granted that the military no longer existed in TWD universe. But seeing how strong groups such as the Commonwealth and CMR are make the collapse of the military even more absurd. Even taken together those groups wouldn't even have a tiniest fraction of the strength the armed forces have.
I almost think the creators of TWD have some sort of resentment towards the military with how dumb & ineffective the troops were depicted.
I don't think there is any resentment, they just sort of blah blah blah over the outbreak because they didn't really have a way to make the collapse believable. IMO, WWZ and shaun of the Dead did a much better job at showing how a competent military would deal with an outbreak. The Last of Us showed us how no military would stop it.
@@Ratchetonater I agree and it was not an issue at all for me in the glory days of TWD. Also the few flashbacks showing the military at the hospital, napalming Atlanta were decent enough. But at the outpost in Fear TWD the army couldn't even shoot through a chain link fence. Then later they tried to build up the Commonwealth and CMR as powerful. Those groups are an absolute joke compared to a real military.
Your opening point is spot in that the writers couldn't come up with a realistic way the military was beaten. So hence they basically just wrote them out of the show.
Which is why AMC may not go back to the start with a new show or a series we all want (the early days) - because of that reason (no realistic way the military would be beaten like they were)
The military protect their own. Anyone bitten in the first few hours or days would be rushed to medical whereupon they turn and the military gets attacked from within! By the time they realise what is happening structure has broken down and the only units surviving are squad or platoon level. That is why there is now active military after the first few days. @@TWDExplained
The CRM is probably what’s left of the actual U.S. military.
I would be really interested in any scifi or horror shows playing it straight with how well and poorly government and politics responds to crisis. Especially seeing different political parties and governments address the same issue differently. Kind like in the Book version of World War Z which would still make a wonderful anthology series.
The Civic republic republic was just remnants of the Philadelphia national guard
Edit: they later also take in other military units and also WE NEED TO KNOW ABOUT FORT BENNING LIKE HOW THEY FALL THEY LITERALLY HAD 1 OF THE RANGER BATTALION STATIONED THERE KEEP IN MIND RANGERS ARE JUST UNDER THE TEIR ONE OPERATORS LIKE SEALS AND DELTA HOWWWWW AMC?????
I have a theory about how long the civic republic has been around. If you look at the gear they have an resources, the type of gear they have takes time to develop. You first draw up the plans an that takes a few years then you make prototype gear.Now prototypes of any thing can take way longer to make then you have to make adjustments to the prototype just to get a prototype that can be field tested. That stuff alone can take years to do.The resources, they had to have a large amount stock piled before the dead rose.They had to have huge amounts just to fix up cities to keep walkers out not to mention resources to take care of the people.
They probably existed before as some sort of secret undrground army
I was playing Lords of the Realm II (a medieval game) and they have a USA and American maps to play. I imagine it could be factions arising after a natural disaster but now they are stuck in effectively a Medieval setting.
Civic Republic seems the most connected. In Dead City, Manhattan the military blocked up all the exits to isolate.....Nebraska ? Canada in the snow ?
Remember that military pilot in the walking dead season 3 with the governor that pilot said their base was overrun and they evacuated with what supplies they could grab or had and left.. got jammed up on the freeway and took the bird up to see what they see, anyway he said they were overrun so maybe the president or any government officials still maybe ran out of fuel and/or food and water and starved out or like you said as well they could have been attacked reaching the bunker or someone broke in and killed them hopefully there's a twist and closure with Rick and Michonne
most soldiers would prioritise the safety of their families and go awol to get to them so the military would effectively have been disbanded rather than defeated
He either went to camp David, and/or underground bunkers!
Not once in my life long obsession with zombie media have I ever wondered about the president. Cool vid tho
Theres a book series called “the extinction cycle that does a way better job at explaining the downfall, continuance, and eventual resurgence of the military and government in the event of a “zombie apocalypse” (I say that loosely bc the zombies aren’t stereotypical zombies). It also makes a lot more sense than TWD universe just based of the infection rates/ circumstance in which you can turn, plus the zombies are a lot more dangerous than the pathetic, walking, mindless corpses. Theres a lot of plot-holes to TWD zombies that arent really explained other than “military dumb”
Worst thing they did was kill off Alicia's brother... the dude on drugs... he was the best of all of them. Him and the teacher that got shot in the helicopter of alllll places by a random bullet.
He tripped exiting Air Force One and hit his head. 🤷♂️
did anyone notice the civic republic symbol sorta looks like a biohazard logo.
That was my first thought when I saw it.
Wait you are actually right
In an oil rig with the rest of his higher upss in the west coast
Great video brother
Much appreciated!!!
I have been watching the walking dead since March of 2016 I never once thought about the president 🧍🏿♂️
It would be cool to see something in the line of " The Enclave " from Fallout. The government coming back to retake the country with extreme methods, kinda like the CRM
There is always the possibility of some government officials left in the TWD universe like the president hiding in the wreckage of Air Force One with other government officials and even surviving military personnel