Nice, great video. It shows how Italy was pretty much screwed in our timeline simply by getting too late to the metaphorical party, no matter what I doubt they would have reached the heights France and Britain achieved or that Germany could have achieved. Also, totally unrelated, I ended up putting my question for the Q&A in the members' area, I apologize for any inconvenience and have already deleted it.
Considering only one channel member posted a question and I yk, failed to mark it members only, all good. But yeah, Italy was kinda SOL and I'd argue probably did as well as it could considering how behind it was
unless italy was a complete federal republic got a union with any country like france or spain or united in the 1400s (all unrealistic) theirs sadly no chance for italy to be strong to be honest
italy's situation in europe was always tricky. they should have untied in the middle ages (maybe by lumbardia surviving or something) but their unifiction camed VERY late.
The duchy of Milan came pretty close to unifying the north, until Gian Galeazzo Visconti which was the best duke of Milan died But when a single city/state in Italy became too strong the others always unified against the rising power But the truth is that we were disunited for too long and didn't have an unified identity until nationalism rose A Genoese or Venetian would never accept to be under Milan's rule for too long, unless through military occupation
if they really did unite in 1453 when florence, venice and milan were considered world powers then italy would have the largets colonial empire ever and would be a superpower still today
Then most likely option would be a Confederacy of liberal monarchies lead by the Pope That was Gioberti's plan The only way for it to succeed is probably Austria losing in 1848 and the other Italian states helping Piedmont more It'd be hard to make the italian states compromise, but if things go well we could have Italy as a Confederacy of liberal/parliamentary monarchies lead by the Pope That Italy sounds weaker on one hand, but at least there would be more of a federal model which could benefit Italy's diversity
I've always wondered if there was any outcome of the Napoleonic Wars were Napoleon can keep power in France and unify Italy under either the rule of his brother Louis or by some other means. A Bonparte Italy and an Austria that retains Venice would be pretty cool .
Nice, great video. It shows how Italy was pretty much screwed in our timeline simply by getting too late to the metaphorical party, no matter what I doubt they would have reached the heights France and Britain achieved or that Germany could have achieved.
Also, totally unrelated, I ended up putting my question for the Q&A in the members' area, I apologize for any inconvenience and have already deleted it.
Considering only one channel member posted a question and I yk, failed to mark it members only, all good.
But yeah, Italy was kinda SOL and I'd argue probably did as well as it could considering how behind it was
Your channel is awesome. i am glad i subscribed: idea what if the Shining Path took over Peru
You always make My day: idea: What if the sixtus affair succeded?
unless italy was a complete federal republic got a union with any country like france or spain or united in the 1400s (all unrealistic) theirs sadly no chance for italy to be strong to be honest
Spain-Italy reforming Rome Videntis style!
I mean an Italian did randomly make France really strong, nothing is more unrealistic than reality
Italy is a great power today, a founding member of the EU and the Earth's tenth economy, as well as one of the fastest-growing.
@@specil-kbut has a decline population has a pretty big south north economic devide with the south infested with mafia and gangs
That would be more a "Spain/France rules Italy" than Italy succeeding, though.
YES! Love your content ❤❤❤❤❤
italy's situation in europe was always tricky. they should have untied in the middle ages (maybe by lumbardia surviving or something) but their unifiction camed VERY late.
The duchy of Milan came pretty close to unifying the north, until Gian Galeazzo Visconti which was the best duke of Milan died
But when a single city/state in Italy became too strong the others always unified against the rising power
But the truth is that we were disunited for too long and didn't have an unified identity until nationalism rose
A Genoese or Venetian would never accept to be under Milan's rule for too long, unless through military occupation
if they really did unite in 1453 when florence, venice and milan were considered world powers then italy would have the largets colonial empire ever and would be a superpower still today
Nice video, buddy! Can you make a scenario in which Mexico replaces America to become the global hegemon?
Foto perfil fantástica meu amigo
great video
Hey! I’m Cecilia. It’s a delight to meet you!
Suggestion: What if Franz Ferdinand lived?
Hey can you do an alternative scenario of what if india gained independence in 1857
What if Austria gained the Rhineland in the Congress of Vienna?
Austria's worst nightmare
Millions weep
What if the Papal States had unified Italy?
Then most likely option would be a Confederacy of liberal monarchies lead by the Pope
That was Gioberti's plan
The only way for it to succeed is probably Austria losing in 1848 and the other Italian states helping Piedmont more
It'd be hard to make the italian states compromise, but if things go well we could have Italy as a Confederacy of liberal/parliamentary monarchies lead by the Pope
That Italy sounds weaker on one hand, but at least there would be more of a federal model which could benefit Italy's diversity
What if there was a Japanese Dynasty in China?
That just means either ww1 or ww2 that they occupy china and don’t use Manchu puppets
How about what if there was a muslim(Hui/Uyghur turkic) dynasty in China ruling over a confucian/buddhist majority
Continue continue part two pls
Hi, can you do a what if the ottomans didt collapse that hard?
Probably mad that Possible History released his version of this video right before AM did, considering the fact that PH has been begged to make this.
There was some moderate annoyance but nothing beyond some jokes that now aged poorly
4:44 did you mean Sardinia? lol
No, but I did fuck up the map
Yeah Italy My home 🇮🇹
Giusto 😊
Sei un bravo cittadino
I got a video idea.
What if Sweden won the Northern War?
Why not have Germany, Italy and Russia on side and Britain, France and Austria on the other side of the War?
I feel bad for austria just thinking about that
@@AlternosMundos But at the same time free independent Big Hungary.
Can you do what if the Franco British union happened being a 3rd pillar in the Cold War
if they didn’t take any algerian land, italy would definitely side with france
well, corsica would likely also be part of the problem, but i do tend to agree
What if the Battle of Mohacs was a victory for Hungary? What if the Ottomans were kicked out of the Balkans much earlier?
100 times better than the massacre that happend in our time line
I've always wondered if there was any outcome of the Napoleonic Wars were Napoleon can keep power in France and unify Italy under either the rule of his brother Louis or by some other means. A Bonparte Italy and an Austria that retains Venice would be pretty cool .
What to the African American guy that use to be in the comments
I still comment occasionally
@theOfficialCahokiaDawg yeah I was just wondering
@ You’re all good! Life’s been busy and I try my best to get here.
@theOfficialCahokiaDawg well hope you have a good day bro
@ you too god bless!
Hell yeah!
Hey dude do u have a discord or something?
Soon :)
@AlternosMundos nice
It's impossible 😂😂😂😂