Alex Murdaugh brother John Marvin Murdaugh testifies: full video
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- John Marvin Murdaugh, the brother of Alex Murdaugh, testified in Alex's double murder trial. John Marvin told the court about the night of the murders and his brother's drug addiction.
Follow us on Twitter: @WLTX
Follow us on Facebook: @WLTXNews19
Check out our website: WLTX.com
#alexmurdaugh #murdaugh
When an uncle sheds more realistic tears emotions and empathy than the own father/husband speaks volumes
He seems to be the only decent of the bunch
@@rrksk ĺ
And he cried over the 2 victims especially Paul
He also lied like his brother too
@@rrksk oh God NO !! That's just what the Lawyers are banking on!!
He's a slippery character too. This family is full of slippery characters. I wouldn't trust any of them.
You got that right 😬.
Sounds like the sled guy rest of them are to
They are all slippy characters why is prosecution trying keep the lie they told about bloody clothes quiet . ,other stuff it not hear say if officer lying about where they found coat . Why wouldn't they want to go get phone . To me prosecutor lying trying hide stuff to trying make everything about money when their is clearly other reason someone would of killed them set Alex up
Let me tell you, not everything is as it seems. My ex husband was very affectionate with me in public, but at home it was a completely different story! Nobody would ever believe that we had a volatile relationship.
I'm so sorry you had to deal with that. I hope you are in a better place now. God be with you.
@@song4mozart I am in a much better place! I am at peace. It’s beautiful. Thank you. ☺️ I just want to raise awareness for people who don’t know, y’know? Not for myself, but so they can protect themselves.
@@paranoid_android33 ❤️
So sorry
Good for you for getting out.
He said he thought it was overblown that Paul killed a girl while driving his boat drunk? If I thought that, I would never admit it. Shows they are oblivious to how the majority of people function in the world.
To be honest. Everyone of the people on the boat we're drunk really drunk they all chose to ride with Paul. At any time they could have made their own choices. Not to mention his behavior had happened many times before. Not crashing but being a sloppy out of control drunk. Why would any of them ride on the boat to begin with.
@@j_rainsgoat3929 You wrote exactly what I was thinking since this horrific crash happened. Paul did not point a gun at the other"kids", all voluntarily took the boot ride not only once but twice being aware of the alcohol consumption and Paul's previous irrational behavior when under the influence. If they would have crashed into another boot and somebody on this boot had been killed, I believe they all should have been prosecuted.
The kids on the boat were over 18 and drunk. They made that choice to get on that boat. They could have called someone to pick them up or knocked Paul out. I mean according to all Paul's friends they new how he got when he drank but they all still enjoyed partying and living it up with him. Paul had the money to show them a good time of course they would stick around. Stupid choices get you bad consequences.
@@mistystrickland32 yep and can you imagine going up against Harpoland knowing your child want forced to drink and ride on his boat could've walked.away many times.
Yet Paul was the only one that killed her…
One thing that stands out is how influential the family was in the area spanning over decades; if the wife & son were genuinely murdered by some unknown individual, the police would stop at nothing to solve the case. There'd be mountains of evidence & leads, and there'd be a task force to speak with the media & follow up on every clue ; but here they "investigated" in a very haphazard manner, told the media there was no risk to the public from the shooter/s & seemed okay with burying the case. There wasn't any real interest in the case until it got big enough in the media to warrant another look at it by LE; but if that interest hadn't been there this case probably would never have made it into a courtroom. This family have been able to avoid the consequences of their actions for so long, they seem to believe they are untouchable, and after watching the Netflix series abt the family it's pretty clear that lying is just another thing they mastered during their privileged lives.
Only focusing on Alex is the problem!
Probably lack of funds to even investigate!
Maybe Alex was supplying them with drugs, anything possible.
Agree ! Did anyone notice how sooo much more emotional John M.Murdaugh is/was talking about Paul? I mean: GENUINELY .. not just sniffling, sobbing, cracking his voice when I thinks he should do so?
@@minomokwa744I didn’t notice that at all, his dad cried 100 times on the stand, ppl see what they want to see, hear what they want to hear…
These hillbillies sure do love to kill; animals and people!😮
"We're just a normal family doing normal family things." ...like decades-long financial swindling, manslaughter and a double murder.
For real he's a skumbag too like his brother
He talks about all the trips that his brother & Maggie took and properties with STOLEN money. Really Disgusting
Yes while the Satterfield brothers lost there home. The Highway Patrolman stuck while on duty is about to go bankrupt with medical bills. The Mother who's daughter was killed in accident was told she was getting a dime. All the time stealing millions from all of them and others. GOD HAS A FRONT ROW SEAT IN HELL 👹 💀☠️ FOR 👀HIM.
Good point. I hope Prosecution brings that up
Damn. You really put that into perspective 💯
WOAH BACK THERE!
John Marvin did not know Alec was stealing, so just settle down.
@@atonement7232 😀let them clutch their pearls
This family is crooked to the core. For three generations
Seems like ALL the police are crooked too ! They're ALL friends ! This is sooo wrong !
I read an article on that this week, there are two unexplained deaths in that area that they sispected Paul andvBuster but it was covered up. Maggie and Alex did a shitty job raising these kids they are apparently entitled spoiled brats. Oh its just so sad
5 generations counting Buster and pau pau.
5!
Do we just say things these days without any evidence or proof
This man shows more genuine emotion than Paul's own dad.
Yes!
Well of course! The Dad is a stone cold killer!
Alex mudaugh NEVER said anything about finding who killed his wife and son. Same with OJ they never looked for the killer
He seems to have had some feelings for Paul. Unlike Alex.
whoopdee doo
He didn't know his brother addicted for 20 yrs but y'all close family
Right?!?! So many secrets, every family has em.
All this "addiction" stuff has been overplayed, big time.
Folks need to realize that for a 57,000. a wk. "habit" and 10.00-15.00/pill street value of scripted oxies would mean AM was taking over 500 pills a day.
Sorry, no " buyer" of AM's BS here. And NO way he could have meticulously and consistently done all his money deals with such craftiness. Keeping faux accts., cooking the books more or less, all in pvt. Further, with such a big Firm, and his thenbest friend for yrs from childhood through law school and until the day AM was uncovered, you can bet your bipp6 everybody would have known he was " the addict." Hockeypuck. Overblown as a " convenience" trying to make it like AM was in lala land and was out to lunch the night if the murders.
And ppl thinking all that spitting out the police van door while cops were there: AM was a long time tobacco chewer...spitting and hock too-ing. Another " act." He flunked drama school. Big time.
I don't care who you tell vocally about your addictions but if you claim to spend 25 to $50,000 weekly on opiates and consume that amount of opiates it is not a secret to a soul.. the testimony that Curtis Smith is a $50,000 a week drug dealer is absolutely hilarious to me because a tree is known by its fruits.. if you are making that much money you are not going to live and look like Curtis Smith
That’s because HE WASN’T. It’s a LIE
As not a lawyer I believe Alec made up the story of being a drug addict that bad. Cover up for $greed and bad memory. The prosecution better get the ball rolling. Who is Alec drug supplier or how did he kept getting so much drugs ?
I am shocked the authorities allowed John Marvin to stay down there let alone clean up. Horrors...
FRIENDS with POLICE !!!
I agree. That blows my mind 😳
To me SLED have made so many errors, the protection initially of the crime scene was rediculas , amateurish , and again when John Marvin showed SLED the whereabouts s of Maggie's mobile they weren't interested , said they would do that later , l really do believe that Alex ... yes he's a crook in many ways and a liar but l dont believe he killed his son n wife , where a the motive ? Wheres the 100% proof ,
The night my brother made the conscious choice to suck on the end of a 12-gauge shotgun after the police were finished who do you think they turned the crime scene over to? The family that owned the place.. who do you think was responsible for cleaning up said remnants?
It's not like after the investigation the police department calls in a biohazard crew to clean up for you.. if the family has the money they can buy that service or the family is left picking brain matter off the ceiling fan.. if that was just a little too gruesome than oh well, I'm not the type that lives in dictates my every move on emotions and feelings.
@@willpp9999 collateral damage
John Marvin didn't fool me. He participated in the cover up regarding the boat case that resulted in a teenager's death. John Marvin pranced right up to the scene of the crash and hauled the wrecked boat away when the dead teenager's parents were REFUSED access to scene of the accident. Utterly disgusting. This guy is no different than the his brothers.
No south Carolina man questions why the cops ajd judges are polluting crime scenes for bags of silver.
@Star Mac: Yeah, he just blubbers better. 😭😢
Yeah and he helped Buster carry guns out of Mozelle, this guy has been compliant in this whole thing. His tears didn't fool anyone.
@@jaydenc4345 the cops n magistrates of south Carolina are to blame. The federals need to do a full comb through of the las 70 years and prosecute any currently alive persons or seizure of handed down estates. The people are the most godless perverted pill poppers in the usa. The bars in Charleston are filled to the brim with out of town single mothers speading stds from ship hopping greeks to mushy Charleston men with fatherless children abandoned somewhere with anyone. Eff south Carolina. The whole state is corrupt because it is a godless area.....
How do you know he hauled the boat away?
Every day I hear of a different victim of this family, crooks to the core.
Crooked for decades, and he has the nerve to tell the jurors that his friend, the police chief of another town gave him a ride to the crime scene. He has friends in the high places!
@@artwatch-y9j ...yeah, this flipping farm tractor salesman gets a police escort to the crime scene.....and not just any cop, he was escorted by the police CHIEF......
This family has been evil for a very long time!
No decades probably centurie
You sound pretty happy about that.
The lack of boundaries as a sign of “closeness” and emotional manipulation as a sign of “caring” is the red flags among dysfunctional families. A narcissistic family cult.
Seems like a family where appearances are better than actual reality of things. 🤦♀️
This is the comment I was looking for 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
The lack of boundaries where?
@@drewski8138 AM pretended to be close to Paul and Maggie. He pretended to care for them and being a close knit family, but he murdered them in cold blood - just like he pretended to be close to his clients, while stealing millions of dollars from them. He severely lacks self boundaries
Lacking boundaries is an UNDERSTATEMENT.
Save your sympathy. This man didn’t search for Mallory, instead he hauled his brothers boat. He hauled out drunken Paul’s overturned car and berated his terrified girlfriend for calling 911. He helped recover Maggie s phone (no tears then) which AM was so keen to show he’d called to establish his alibi. But he didn’t help unlock Paul’s phone, though the code was easy (Paul’s DOB). He flew to the Bahamas with Alex after his financial crimes were uncovered, probably to hide money. Went to Las Vegas with Buster. Took guns out of Moselle after the killings (no tears then)…….ad infinitum
I wonder if he nothing to do with Alex after this trial. I bet his whole family is still friendly with Alex.
Justice for Mallory Beach!😢
@lesliesmith719 Randy seems like the first brother who is starting to get it.
@@beez991 or at least the first to recognize the importance of appearing to do so.
Holy crap! I was totally feeling sorry for him.
The brothers are as big liars as Alex. I saw them on tv looking the interviewer directly in the eye and telling her they never knew of Paul ever drinking.
right?
Wonder why he didn't tell the lawyer about the 3rd brother
Wait...the brother of the accused murderer is allowed to clean up the crime scene less than 24 hours after the crime??? Unbelievable.
It’s called privileged
@@joiofjenz It wasn't deemed a crime scene anymore at that point according to sled.. and also its usually the victims' families who are in charge of cleaning after the police are done taking what they want.. it was even testified to later. Just from watching trials this is what I have seen!
You You I’m
Family is responsible for cleaning the crime scene or can hire a service to do it. Police do not clean crime scenes because they are not allowed to.
Craziest thing I've ever heard of!!!!
It's crazy that ANYONE would have felt comfortable going to that house alone after two family members had been brutally murdered and the killer was still on the loose. In the back of his mind.....he had to know.
he knows
your nuts
I’ve never heard of a family member cleaning up biological matter at a crime scene. Even if Alex didn’t murder his family, this trial has exposed a truly weird family.
NO IS NOT . Is it His nephew remained, He loves his nephew. Anyone would want to give a Christian consideration by respectfully picking up everything in this case his brain . If it is a body anyone, even a stranger would cover the body ! Don’t it be obvious that a uncle will want to honor his young nephew by giving the last respect picking up his remaining. Do you think it would have been “ NORMAL” just to leave his nephew remaining on the floor and JUST LEAVE ?
They don’t, it’s all bullshit…he would of cleaned up evidence before SLED knew is likely the story
for goodness sake calm down! It was a crime scene and nobody- absolutely nobody- should have been allowed to touch anything until forensics and law enforcement completely finished and opened area up again to the public. Anything else is criminal!
@@kelrogers8480 they told him it was okay to go there
In the UK as the family of a brutally murdered victim, we cleaned up the scene once the police had finished gathering evidence. No-one else was offering to do it.
So Randy’s first reaction to the deaths was to tell John Marvin to call a lawyer?
Hum!!! he suspected something was wrong about it from the first moment.
Any good lawyer would do the same. A spouse is the first suspect, and having a lawyer is very important.
Randy is an attorney. There's nothing suspicious about calling an attorney after something like this. The US Constitution guarantees the right to an attorney. Only a complete idiot wouldn't contact an attorney in a situation like this. There's no conspiracy here, it's basic common sense.
I've been so impressed with this judge, more than any judge I've seen in a long, long time.
lol
The Chandler case: Judge was excellent.
@@crystalshaw8744I saw that trial - another horrific one.
Glad you liked him. I am a paralegal. Found him obnoxious.
Objection overruled 😂
Looks like the whole family was allowed to sit and listen to the trial... But they are also defense witness. This is strange. Alex murdaugh is guilty.
Right?! I thought witnesses were barred from courtroom until they gave testimony...
True. Witnesses are not suppose to be listening or sitting in the court room, not until after they have testified under oath on tbe witness stand. Once they've testified, and been determined not to be called again, recalled - only then are they suppose to be allowed to sit in the court room and listen in.
I believe that is allowed in South Carolina.
It doesn’t matter they’re biased anyway beinf family, idk how them watching the trial could change anything ?
@@charlottecannon314 witnesses where ? Not everywhere’s the same
You know your family so well, but you only know what they WANT you to know. Every family has their skeletons. Things they don't want the extended family or others to know, see or hear. This is true of literally every family.
Yep the secrets that flowed out of my family over the years has been book worthy. LOL As far as I know we're only missing a murder. LOL
@@singlelifeok My aunt was shot and killed by her husband when I was 3. He hung himself in jail before he was convicted.
Agreed. The way he said the were a perfect couple. Or how they always were hand in hand. I doubt he is sharing the full picture.
@just.that.girl, Alex is not going to hang himself because he is not guilty of murder...
There are no secrets here. They enjoyed a Hootie concert and you're all suddenly convinced? GTFOH this family left a wake of bodies. It's silly it took this long for even suspicion to arise. I just wish I could stand next to a Murdock for one moment.
(Murdaugh... I'm convinced they pronounce it like that intentionally so they can claim "well I'm not Murdock so..... thats not me")
I find it interesting that this is the man who was allowed to load up and drive off with Paul's wrecked boat from where it sat immediately following that wreck and sure enough, despite living an hour away, he was right there in the middle of a Murdaugh crime scene once again.
This dude has helped Alex cover up a lot of crooked s**t
Y op😊
All AM had to do to be proven innocent was hand over the clothes he was wearing in that tree video. This whole trial would of never happened. Instead he lied and lied and wouldn’t turn over the clothes. To me that means he’s 100% guilty. Plus why didn’t he care about finding the killer? He don’t even remember what his last words to Maggie was.
@lsmyser1257 ...YOUR OBSERVATION IS SHORT AND TO THE POINT. AS CONCISE AS ONE CAN GET. AM WITH HIS LIES OF OMISSION SURE HAVE THEM GLARING. THE MISSING SHIRT GLARES LIKE A LIGHTENING STRIKE. YOUR COMMENT IS AS PERFECT AS IT CAN GET.
I wish the prosecution would just say that. And AM the idiot said on the stand that it was Maggie’s idea to meet at Moselle ! Gad. Her sister had previously testified that Maggie didn’t want to, was disappointed to have to go there. 65 mile drive too. And she also said AM also told Paul to come out there. Then gee, they were both shot. With AM at the scene. I don’t see why there needs to be a trial ! Just lock him up.
@@angelwings7930 If they didn’t have trials for scenarios like this, where would it end? How many others wouldn’t have a trial just _because_ …
@@lindamahrer7067 0000 p.
What is the tree video? I only know about the snapchat dog video, is there another?
I’ve never seen a witness be so animated and story tell. Most witnesses just answer in a few words as possible 😂
There's something weak about him
yes, the defense attorney had to cut him off right in the middle of a couple happy family stories....
@@dolocapo5430 It was a very odd and yes, definitely animated performance. My thoughts exactly.
Maybe because it’s the only time he can talk about Paul. I’m only a little through but I think he enjoys talking about him and probably doesn’t do it a lot after he passed.
This family should get academy awards for their great acting in trying to portray the most perfect family in the USA. Everything was great. The family is chock full of greatness. Every relationship is great. Yet they all know Alex left a path of destruction to every client whose lives were destroyed. He destroyed his whole families lives. He stole from his own family and destroyed the lawfirm his brother was a partner in. But according to his brother, his family is great🤣🤣
exactly! they had no idea that Maggie was talking to a Lawyer about getting a divorce and Alec so claimed drug addiction and the horrific boat accident… yes very good acting
They're all evil.
He doesn't believe Alex killed them. I believe that 100 percent. His testimony helps Alex. Whenever I don't want to believe it I just remember Chris Watts and what man is actually capable of.
No one in the family thinks Paul was driving the boat either
Chris Watts, Scott Peterson, Andrea Yates, Diane Downs, Casey Anthony...the list us endless
Chris Watts is pure evil. That case made me realize, there are monsters and they can be your actual family members. This is such a sad case.
I'm in no way advocating for Chris Watts, but at least he admitted it. Casey Anthony and AM dragging everyone through his is very disturbing
@@SpiritedSoul1986All those were obvious.
These kids were really blessed to have such uncles. No matter what happened these uncles did all for their nephews and for the brother.
I’m I’m 😆 on a
it seems they may have done way too much...
@jessaabraham: You do see that is a massive problem in this family, don’t you? There were never any consequences. No matter what happened, even if illegal all the uncles and granddad, aunties, and grandmas petted them, paid off the law and victims, or intimidated them, so that each subsequent younger generation was protected from any consequences and responsibilities, learning nothing, having no values, no empathy and after awhile you get people like Alex, Buster, and Paul. Especially Paul who John Marvin describes as flawless, but whose friends found to be hurtful, dangerous, and a drunken bully who was frightening and ultimately killed one, with no grief nor remorse. Paul pushed his old man’s last button with the boat crash, bringing down the rotten house and setting the stage for his father’s downfall. Paul and his mother, who was taking action that would have exposed Alex and his decades long misconduct, thievery, lying, manipulation, and corruption. In a way Maggie and Paul got exactly what they should have expected, a monster, just like them. They were cursed by incompetence and a lack of morals in the adults in their lives.
Yes they really did everything for them.
He loved Paul so very much that he ‘thoughtfully’ moved that boat very quickly from the boat wreck area!
Right?!
Right SHADIEST family I've EVER seen!
Great reference
His brother "I know Alec so well, we are a very close family". Also his brother "I had zero idea he had a major opioid addiction for over a decade". Son Buster "we are a very close family" . Also Buster "I don't know what date his birthday is" . Despite having JUST celebrated it the weekend before rmthe murders .
These things stood out to me too.
Honestly I believe the brother probably knows more based on his intuition, but the son probably knows a lot more. The son seemed very insincere and very unlikable. Spoiled.
I actually know someone who doesn’t know his mom’s bday at all. Now I’m noticing similarities bw him and Buster. Eerie.
I actually liked this guy (still think Alec is 1,000% guilty), but this brother seemed really down to earth and genuine. Until he said the “boating accident was blown way out of proportion”. Yeah, he lost me there. I’m not going to value testimony from a witness when they say something so blatantly out of touch with reality.
I agree. It's really disrespectful to the young woman who died, and her family. He has strong family loyalty, and he only knew the sweet, hard working nephew Paul, not the drunken, obnoxious, irresponsible person who caused a terrible deadly boat crash. Blinders.
It might not have been “blown out if proportion” if the They hadn’t tried to obstruct the investigation, treated Ms. Beach’s family better, and immediately try to cover up what happened. This entire family is disgusting.
Everyone gets a bottle of water except for the black caregiver.Damn shame.
This guy is a wolf in sheep’s clothing!
Kelly, they wanted the jury to SEE her emotions! Shelley wound up being, in my opinion, the one who took him down aside from Blanca and the video. Listen to Mr Meadors closing-Shelley is a hero. 💗
This guy was the best witness the defense had! Not scientific, not a witness to the crimes, but a brother who loves and cares for his family, through everything they have been through! He seems like the family member who keeps them all together, not the big rich lawyer, but the hardworking independent family member!
With regards to John M's testimony yesterday, in the below youtube clip of his entire testimony, at the 1:08 mark Griffin starts asking about SLED searching the house and asked John if he was informed of any items seized. John replies he was told they found a coat but Owens would not tell him anything further and at 1:09 specifically states "they didn't tell me what kind of coat" and offers to identify it. At 1:10 he states Owens told him he could not or would not show him the coat. Griffin then asks him if sometime later John was asked to identify a blue raincoat. Griffin then asks John if he knew where the raincoat was seized from, and John replies "I knew where it was seized from because he (sic Owens) had already told me." Which version is it--Owens told him simply they found a coat with no description or Owens told him they found a blue raincoat? As if only ONE COAT exists in that gigantic house?
(PS Amazing how the killers didn't want to shoot Alex, and oh by the way why he shaved his body, was likely because oxy only survives in blood a short time 6-18 hours but lives on in hair 90 days and maybe because the head of SLED received a text to get a search warrant for Alex's hair and he got tipped off? He shaved EVERYTHING but amazingly, after 90 days never shaved himself again. A great analogy is when you get your hair dyed and it's been a month and your first inch is gray but the distal part of the hair strand still has color on it.
th-cam.com/video/BN05dZUYNlo/w-d-xo.html
That is the exact reason they put him on the stand. A smile and a tear doesn't mean he's any better then the rest of them. They have a long history in that family of deceit
Imagine being so dumb you actually think Alex is innocent
Yes ! And he’s honest ! But you can tell it hurts him
meh. He’s a gambler as well …throwing away other peoples money.
🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 ALL of them are lying sociopaths and he knew he’d seem so “normal” up there. 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
To me he seems just as creepy. They seem proud to be up there. I'd be so distraught.
@@hotdogtrainer5359 Yes.
@@hotdogtrainer5359 Really Creepy !!
I know it's hard for some people to tell the truth, but the truth is always better than a lie. So many lives ruined and lost because of one man's action. Such a shame.
Alex was more concerned about his reputation and lifestyle than his wife, and his own flesh and blood.
You’re about to see this whole county go down once the irs and fbi get involved
Bc they are ALL INVOLVED
2:07 👀
He's so helpful at crimes scenes... Especially when he moved the boat from the Mallory Beach crime scene. He needs to just go back to the casino with Buster!!... So sickening.
Now that's just good 😊.
Also in the Netflix doc it shows him also removing guns from the moselle property in the days after the investigation.
@TruthWorld. John Marvin is all about protecting the family.
The whole family are as privaledged & shady as he'll! And AM is as guilty as he'll - he admitted this when on the stand and asked by Jim 'did you kill your son and wife?' And before her replied individually, he rubbed his teeth with his tongue. His family knows he lies when he does that (body language 101)
@@chelseamiranda6651 It was not days after -- it was months. Eric Alan did the footage. He is an excellent source on YT.
Isn't this the guy that the police let haul away the boat that Paul was driving drunk and killed a young woman? It is so sad that the parents couldn't even view the boat at the scene, but the parents of the drunk driver and his uncle was allowed to go right up to the boat and his uncle hauled the evidence away.
They were all drunk teenagers that chose to ride with another drunk teenager..nobody made them do it..sorry to say it, but those are the consequences of bad decisions sometimes we make growing up.
@@auraterry3548 ok still doesn’t take away the fact that someone was killed and the driver of the boats family was allowed to interfere with the investigation immediately. 🤡
@@auraterry3548 just saw another comment of yours that said you don’t believe Alex is guilty. 🤡🤡🤡🤡 guess we found one of the murdaugh’s in the comment section
I’m not sure if he’s guilty either!
A family without moral
He’s the “perfect” witness. He knows enough about crime scenes to call his police officer “friend” to ask if it was okay to go to the crime scene. Why not call the detectives on the case? Also, he’s so overwhelmed with grief that he cleans the freakin crime scene. Again, he knew enough about crime scenes that he paused to ask if it was okay to go to a crime scene but not enough to pause and ask himself if it’s okay to clean up the crime scene. Give me 1 million breaks!!!!!!
What are you implying?
Why is he smiling? Twilight Zone. This whole family is nuts.
LOL
That’s the good ole “Joel Osteen” effect. Lol
🤣🤣
No matter the situation life does go on for the living. The day after I found my brother deceased from a chosen self-inflicted GS wound to the mouth and subsequently cleaning up the remnants thereof I was at work the day after and the following days. Not everybody dictates every aspect of their being on feelings and emotions.. I am a reality driven individual and if it is garbage from the past go talk to your therapist about it because I'm not living there. I don't care who you are.
So you called your police friend SPECIFICALLY because your truck was breaking down on the way to a family emergency..
And this police friend - who met you in the middle of the night at your specific request to make sure you get to this family crisis, gets out ahead of you and leaves you behind.. 🤔
Why do all their stories seem so incredible?
I know for a fact that did happened, I seen the truck the next morning by the bridges ,he's not lying .
They're ALL FRIENDS !
I was only about 10:15 pm. He knew the police friend would be going that way, so 100% makes sense.
because they are lies.
@@southernbelle4916 just cuz the truck was there doesn’t mean it was broke down. Tooooo many coincidences usually means something is off.
I have worked closely with John on a number of things and I am compelled to speak on his character. He is one of the finest men I have ever known. He almost always takes the high road. He is extremely generous and genuinely cares for people around him. He is a tough and fair man. Very misunderstood by those who do not know him closely.
Agreed.. This can happens to any family.
Generous enough to hide the murder weapons for Alec
He came across as such a very kind, truly caring and an honest man. I cannot begin to imagine how shocked and grief stricken he is .
He seems like a nice and down to earth man.
Guy smiley over here, this whole family is just, idk..off.
Wow these Murdaugh men, they all sound so much alike.
Yeah I was gonna say the same thing, he sounds exactly like Alex, I didn’t see if Randy testified but I imagine he sounds the same lol
I just now made that comment. I agree!
Well they are brothers lol
@@GoldDiggerBarbie who's voice was it?
@@GoldDiggerBarbie Because evidence contradicted his original 1.5 year long story.
He needs to be investigated too, the way his dad helped Alex to cover up crimes sends a chill down my spine. It makes me wonder what else he covered up for his kids, himself and others over the years. This family had a grip on that area, everything needs to be looked at.
Are you just spewing baseless garbage or do you have some facts to back those allegations?
@@BLACKLACDTS nah, nothing baseless at all. It’s fact that the Murdaugh’s including Maggie have covered up crimes like Paul’s car accident where they came and cleared up all the beer cans and guns instead of calling the police. And the fact that they tried to pin the boating accident on another kid or Alex’s financial crimes. They had the law in their pocket and the whole town knows it. Every single incident around them needs to be reopened and investigated by non biased police/feds.
This man didn’t search for Mallory, instead he hauled his brothers boat. He hauled out drunken Paul’s overturned car and berated his terrified girlfriend for calling 911. He helped recover Maggie s phone (no tears then) which AM was so keen to show he’d called to establish his alibi. But he didn’t help unlock Paul’s phone, though the code was easy (Paul’s DOB). He flew to the Bahamas with Alex after his financial crimes were uncovered, probably to hide money. Went to Las Vegas with Buster. Took guns out of Moselle after the killings (no tears then)
@@sophiar6996 wtf did you just write?!? Haha.
Why would he search for Mallory?
How is he supposed to unlock Paul’s phone if the FBI couldn’t for over a year? It was his DOB and it took the FBI a year to figure that out? Lol sure
So he was spending time with his brother and Nephew? lol you sound absolutely ridiculous.. The police have not charged or even mentioned him in anything. He removed things from the house when he as given the ok to do so.
He sounds like a loyal Brother and Uncle To me who’s also a victim in all this and losers keep slandering him.
@@BLACKLACDTS very loyal, loyal enough to cover up their criminality and his own. Reopen all the cases surrounding these people, I said what i said! You can cry about it elsewhere!
The way they talk about Paul, Buster, and Alex leaving things everywhere; mainly Paul. They make it seem like it's something normal or something funny or cute. In reality it's because they had so much money that they didn't care about anything, everything was disposable to them. Nothing had sentimental value to them because if you have something you really care about, cherish, or you worked hard to buy something you are not going to leave it just anywhere; all the time, every time. That's really sad. Just goes to tell you a lot. That's why they were spoiled brats and that's why Alex annihilated his family, they were disposable to him.
Good point. True.
Perfect explanation👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Exactly. Nothing is sacred to this family but power.
They went in this direction to plant the idea that anyone could have taken Paul's firearms from the property at any point bc he left them laying around and not secured responsibly in the gun room. Trying to lead jury to believe someone else could have had the opportunity. Also convenient the gun killing Maggie hasn't been recovered but the ammo was described to match Paul's missing rifle.
Also shows how entitled he was. Assuming someone else would come along and clean up his messes…
This guy has watched the trial, as has Buster. They both know Alec, whom they tirelessly cover for, killed his wife and son. I think they are worried about what Alex will help string them up for of they don't cover up this crime as much as possible. They are covering for Alex like they are trying to save their own skin. I hope the police look into them. There is clear evidence that they are in on some of Alec's crimes. I see no sign that they feel Alec every did anything wrong. That's pretty messed up. The police did not secure the scene, they did not get a jump on evidence. This is all super fishy!!!
The police are their FRIENDS !
I can't imagine him cleaning up remains of a double homicide ..Keystone Cops
Very fishy!
Exactly. No embarrassment or conscience.
He and Buster are after the MONEY
As a Canadian, it’s disturbing to hear everyone seemingly talk so casually about guns.
As an American who abhors guns, it’s shocking to me, too! Utterly shocking!
Seeings how Canada is Larger than the US but the US has a Population of 321.2 Million population compared to Canadas much larger Country with a mere 35.8 million population. The state of California has more people than the entire country of Canada at 36 million people. Do the math on crime. Hunting, etc.
You'll wish you had one if someone decides to break in your house.
You’re funny
What do you mean? This was a hunting family on a hunting estate. The two dead people were shot with guns. What the hell else would they be talking about?
John Marvin reminds me of the scarecrow in Wizard of Oz.😂
Yes!! That’s who he looks like!😂
😅
I can’t unsee it now😅
Agree, he looks like the scarecrow.
Cunning resemblance
He sounds so much like his brother.
Kind of a raspy voice?
Identical!
Exactly ! What i said same lines, i don't know but i can tell you this! And so on .....
Not as annoying though. Ha ha
They all sound the same.
This is a family who has lost the love of the truth. ‘Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.’
Well put.
I'm sure this family has generations of skeletons and his brother doesn't seem forthcoming but shady like Alec 🤔
As far back as 65 years...I read that.
The level of how trashy this family is is absolutely deafening…. Like the entitlement and arrogance alone just makes this case so difficult to comprehend…
So true
8per ttttttt
Why is there still laughter in the courtroom . Sickening
I laughed at my grans funeral… I loved her more than even my immediate parents. She was the best and biggest inspiration in my life and I laughed in the middle of her funeral… people looked at me like a sickening person… but I didn’t care… I was laughing thinking about it being 2pm and she was correcting me… it wasn’t sickening
Edit: correcting me over daytime quiz tv
Ps… I think he is guilty AF haha. I’m not disputing that. I’m just playing devils advocate for situations I myself have not acted as most would expect
Unbelievably inappropriate
It's a trial for murder of his sister-in-law and his nephew by his brother. I know I am stating the obvious. That's the very reason the smiles and laughter are grossly inappropriate.
It's human nature. Finding funny in tragedy relieves tension. It's a light moment that everyone shared during the trial of an horrific crime. Gotta laugh to ease the tension.
It’s crazy how fast that family came crashing down but I honestly believe their corruption started over a 100 years ago and they probably got bolder and bolder, generation by generation, until Alex.
Yup. Hubris.🤷🏽♀️
I agree
"Doing my job"?
I'm convinced this brother is the CLEANER!!
Gotten oneself into an ungodly mess? Call John Marvin.
@@carlasimmons5546 Right!
@@misslee8168 Like the harvey keitel guy in pulp fiction.
The difference between this man’s reaction and Alec’s reaction in the police van in what he claimed at the time was minutes after finding the bodies only a few feet away from where they sat is enough to convict him to my mind. Alec never acted the way a shocked person would-he was orderly in his presentation punctuated with fake crying (wiping away tears that weren’t there), giving irrelevant details about sunflowers (a common thing for guilty people), no confusion, no wanting to know who did it. His brother shows how grieving people act.
Everyone keeps saying what a good marriage Alex had but they were separated. She was at the beach house and they were fighting about selling it. Alex wanted more money. He always wanted more money (sufficient motive, I should think.) when Alex called her and told her to meet him at the kennels, she was surprised and called her sister on the way saying that something fishy was going on with Alex.
His cold manipulation within sight of the blasted bodies, after showering and trying to convince the housekeeper that he was at the house longer than he was, are other signs of his guilt.
No way am I disputing if he did or didn't... not my job to, however comments like this is the best example of ruling your head with you heart/lack of logical thinking... thankfully you are not a member of the jury... guilty until proven innocent seems to be how every approaches life these days!
Learning the difference between "feelings" and emotions aswell as critical thinking is a skill that many don't have unfortunately.
How dreadful for all families involved. 😔
Alex is so cold, he's still blaming this on the boat case as if to say his son's actions contributed to his death. Maggie and Paul's killing was related to the boat case--Alex killed them becasue the boat case was about to expose his financial crimes.
Exactly. He is so obvious to me. Hopefully justice is served.
@CunningStunt017 I see no "heart ruling the head" in the comment. It's straight from the evidence; sound, measured calculated observations of a clear crime and its clear perpetrator.
They weren’t separated. They owned two homes and she preferred the one closest to the beach during the summer.
A dead teen girl. A dead gay kid. A dead maid . A dead wife and son. If this family ain’t the ultimate evil I don’t know what is
He’s got a degree in criminal justice and he does not know to back off from a crime scene…?
This!
Exactly 💯
I have some background in criminal science and there is a point in time where they “release” the scene. It’s not a secured scene after the crime scene techs have worked it. But it seems awfully quick to have released it. Usually defectives get sent out once daylight appears.
It’s beyond belief that law-enforcement would leave parts of Paul’s brain and skull just lying there.
I happen to know this from a friends unfortunate experience. The police only take away evidence. They typically give you a card for a crime scene clean up company, or if you can’t afford it, the family is left to clean up the mess. This may vary from state to state.
their not suppose to, PD is to secure the crime scene and get statements until crime scene investigators, homicide, forensics corner....etc to arrive- how do you NOT know that!!!
Law enforcement doesn't clean up the mess you have to hire a private company to do that yourself
The coroners are the ones that clean up maybe they didn't realise that those parts may have fallen off unbeknown to anyone?
@@tracieproctor2167 That’s not what coroners do. The family has to organise, and pay for Crime scene cleaners do it. They specialise in cleaning, and removing bio-hazardous waste. Otherwise the families has to do it themselves.
He helped his brother in every way he could after the murders
Of course.u would too
Yes, this is true. But in no way do I think this honest, genuine, sweet man knew or believed that his brother murdered his wife or son. I just believe based on the way he is talking and describing the events that he still finds it hard to wrap his brain around what has happened. He is still struggling 😪 Heck, this isn't my family and I am struggling to wrap my brain around this unbelievable tragedy and heinous crimes.
@@williamdilley7246 Not if my brother was as big an asshole as Alex Murdaugh. No way in hell.
@@tq2769 I was looking at it from a different angle .not the trying to help him not get caught one
What else was he supposed to do at the time? Do you have siblings?
Definitely weird how jolly he seems.....
Glad I am not the only one finds his humor of laughter too be strange .. don’t wanna pass judgment but too me this Uncle is selling his picture perfect Murdaugh story just like Alec and Randy has did … HUNG JURY FOR SURE
He's on medicine...
He's just a good liar 🤣
Well it’s kind of a Southern trait I think … to be sort of sing-song … it’s his nature … not a put-on. I thought he was intelligent and hurt.💔💔
@@MsSassySean ☑️
Especially after seeing the Netflix program I’m not at all impressed with this guy. He actively helped clean things up like moving guns out of a property after the murders. Wtf isn’t HE being prosecuted ???
Possibly to move guns so that no one who is suffering from massive trauma and grief would unalive themselves.
I haven’t watched the Netflix however I saw a drone video of them retrieving the guns on Ethan’s channel & I find it ultimately spish that the White truck pulls up at the kennels!!! Hiding the guns in a kennel would make sense!!!
@@kimlarso I’m sorry did you just say spish
@@kimlarso I think that happened long after the murders, when they were preparing to put the Moselle property up for sale.
@@fruitypeebils 😂👍. I believe in proper English too.
So sad. This man seems so genuine and so sad. He truly loved them. I feel for both families that are affected by this.
Definitely but people on here feeling bad for Alex , ridiculous, what about drivebys, do they feel sorry for people who do drive-by shootings two, I mean I couldn't believe the way people acting over him all I feel so bad for him and they put the hindko song everything I just feel bad for OMG that is disgusting disgraceful response, the guys are monster who killed his wife and son for money and people feel sorry for him on here unbelievable
JM knows this family’s history of lying, cheating, stealing. Not credible it’s all an act.
He’s in the club just wait. He’s one of them. Family of secrets hiding bad things. 😞
He loved Paul. He never says he loved Alex.
@@jacquelinesmith-lv3oe well, he's off to prison.
He seems nicer than the rest of the family. More real and it’s obvious he really loved Paul. 💔
@@bryandawkins4984you do realize these are real human beings right? With feelings and emotions. This isn’t a book you’re reading or a damn movie. So illogical.
Real human beings are dead also,
The whole generational family are rattlesnakes!!!!
@@bryandawkins4984 now his uncle is on trial? Seem super intelligent and intuitive. You know what happens when you assume remember?
@@bryandawkins4984 in your mind. I guess your own self perception is all that truly matter at the end of the day anyways. For all of us
I would love to hear cousin Eddie testify.Alex was the Boss Hogg of those counties and the same families for 100 yrs they all work together to protect each other.the sheriff is fired for the boat wreck .The house maid is dug up insurance fraud is everywhere drug dealing was big time and lots of money went missing.crime scene spoiled .situation normal for smugglers paradise.Its been this way forever
Like pirates never died.
The whole family are weird, what the hell is John Marvin smiling about and also, he brought his 12 year old daughter to a grisly murder trial. Who the hell does that?
Wow! He's proud to not have become a lawyer. Very telling!
I really had to think about it when he made that comment!
Guess he didn't want to dine publicly at the trough? Bad enough he was born into the mess, let alone with sibs who dined at the trough.
But, let's not forget this guy does hold a degree in criminal justice. I wonder if he ever worked utilizing this degree. Did he ever plan to continue onto pursue a JD?
Pretty funny how the courtroom laughed when he said he was proud not to be an atty. My sentiments exactly.
I understood it that hes proud hes doing something different from all of his family. I take pride in that too coming from a family of doctors. It somehow feels like you made it yourself or your a self made man, rather then getting a job through a relative as law families often do. That's just my interpretation though. I didn't get any other hints he dislikes lawyers or the profession.
probably cuz he KNOWS how they operate in bis family…
@@theserverroomtalks159 He's not a self-made man at all. He likely had full family support in starting his business. And it provides another tentacle into another part of the community.
The biggest take away from this testimony is the difference between this uncles true grief at the loss of Paul vs “The Alex Show”.
But after he makes the statement that his brother Alex has been completely cooperative with authorities the entire time, regardless of the big lie - the rest of his testimony loses all credibility. (Damn, at first I was thinking this was the “good” brother🤥)
Don’t think the defense thought this one through.
Yes, that's because there all selling a show, not telling the truth. That's the family motto. Make sure you're selling not telling.
I would protect my Brothers too All 5 Brothers I’am their only Sister ❤❤ God is their Judge Tears and Prayers for the Family 🙏God Has Blessed Them ❤
@@maryjemisonMaryjay1936 If I had a family member kill someone, I would have nothing to do with him/her.
Valerie Curtis at this point AM has not been found guilty. Even if the man is convicted, a loving family member, like this brother, would still cares and it is his prerogative.
@@walliegirl2, I agree with you. It is interesting that so far, the videos that I watched did not show anyone questioning the other brother, Randy Murdaugh. He is one of the lawyers that ended up taking a big financial hit when they discovered that Alex was stealing from the firm and the clients. I wonder if he lost all loyalty toward Alex after what he did to his friends and co-workers. Maybe he would have been a detriment to the defense's case. Alex's co-workers that were not related to him had nothing good to say about him.
Something I've noticed after watching John Marvin and Buster (Richard Alexander) Murdaugh's testimonies is that they both seem 'practiced', the same way a politician would be. Mannerisms, tone of voice, hand gestures, choice of words.... the men in the Murdaugh family conditioned themselves to appear affable, approachable, and honest. Buster's soft tone when he interjects "That's right" throughout his testimony shows he was trained in this way, in my opinion. We do know that Buster was removed from his university for plagiarism and I'm sure this gentleman sells a lot of equipment with his affability.
Very rehearsed. Buster is an immature clown, he’d never make it as a lawyer, even if it was handed to him on a silver platter. Spoiled elites get the wake up call they deserved.
Gina, very well written in relaying your thoughts. I agree whole heartedly.
Phonies
Very well trained.
This man is a snake and a liar too in my opinion. I can't believe everybody fell for his act. He reminds me of Bill Clinton , who also always had a (fake) anecdote to make his point
@@intrepidtomato 💯- he’s conspiring with AM now helping him in jail. This brother owns a rental place apparently, he ain’t broke. The whole family are elite crooks (the brother Randy hasn’t said much but thinks AM is not telling ‘all the truth’. They weren’t close.) Check out a channel called Eric Allen, did a great job on the story.
@@intrepidtomato#weasel
They have an answer to everything..,. God it’s just disgusting
Alex and his brother have the same memory issues
Selective memories. Selective responses. Sounds about right.
No one can remember everything! Especially at a very traumatic time!! Your mind is going 90 to nothing with so many thoughts and feelings!
Convenient amnesia. Except when it benefits them, then suddenly they "know for sure."
1:08:23 says everything! Judge Newman spoke of this in his sentencing! His brother describe this nightmare that Alex wakes up from, And I am sure he is seeing what he did to Maggie and Paul! He is reliving those moments! And I hope he continues seeing them! Until he admits to what he did he can never heal from it!
And the Oscar goes to Alex and his siblings 👏👏
And since when do family members clean up after a double homicide . This trial should've taken place in a different state !!
That's probably not even legal. 🤦♀️🤦♀️ Family members clean up crime scenes every day. SLED made too many mistakes with not processing the scene correctly but this fact alone isn't fully incriminating of any favoritism. I don't think he should've been allowed to give the cop a tour of the house though.
When it is no longer considered a crime seen, meaning the police, detectives, coroners are done with the scene, the family is responsible to either clean it or hire someone. I have a dear friend who's son had a friend that shot himself at her home. She had to clean up the blood. She was partly in shock and crying the whole time. So horrific.
This is the most transparency that I think I've seen in any of all the videos I've watched.. I thought it was heart warming to hear him say he would do anything to find the murder or murderers. I've been waiting to hear that frm Alex!!!!
3/4/23 thank you Lord that Justice was finally done!!! He is 100% percent guilty BUT even if he wasn't, everyone that died with his name attached is finally vindicated!!!! Thankyou to this jury for not allowing him to to be able to hurt anyone else's Family!!!
Tell him to look at the defendants table
Turns out he already knew the killer.
Dark side and sad realty of southern culture on full display in these testimonies.
Yea and his wife was having an affair with AM. Go listen to their phone calls it’s on here on TH-cam. It will make u sick. That’s not how brother and sister n laws talk to each other .
I’m not buying his reasons for cleaning up. I think he’s sincere in his grief but I also think he was protecting his brother. It’s what these folks seem to do.
No he really love his nephew is not like his brothe.😊
I didn’t see him in the 🚿 shower, but I believe he had a 🚿… 😂😂
Brother is a good actor... he's got the good ol boy act down pat.
With this family I'd bet it's not an act. They seem like the type of people who live by a very different set of rules than regular people do, and they do their sh*t right out in the open with that good ol' boy smile on their faces.
He sure does have it down to the “T”. They know their brother is a killer. They are trying to salvage the blemish on their family legacy.
This Murdaugh is the ONLY one I've seen showing emotions. God bless you, and your family sir. I'm glad you don't appear corrupt by the family career choice.
What a brother. I cant imagine having to do that cleaning. In my head this man did the cleaning out of love. I may be so far off, but that is what my heart is telling me. Thank God, Im not on that jury.
Normal families do not have nephews suspected in the death of others.
@ Georgia Amanatides. Since Paul drove the boat and had the wreck, it was more than suspected. He was responsible for her drowning and the injuries to the other passengers.
@@libbyworkman3459 since they all chose to get on the boat drunk I have no sympathy for any of them. You make horrible choices and you accept the consequences that come
@@SalAcceturra they Said afterward that they begged him to slow down or to let one of them drive the boat.
@Linda Hager wow....
@@libbyworkman3459 I agree but, for legal purposes, since it is only suspected of the surviving brother, I used the term I did.
Oh my G-D!! This guy had his own cops from different areas doing all this behind the scenes stuff and then he not only enters the crime scene but *cleans it up*?? Oh, no. Completely unbelievable as an act of innocence as well as he never talked to Randy about this before doing it? Wow, this is a bombshell right here.
He cleaned it up after the cops were done with it
AFTER
Alex has no emotion at all and John Marvin has too much of it.
Alec can turn on emotion or appearance of emotion when he needs it. They're all manipulative.
Alex is trying to make himself cry when talking about his dad but he just doesn't have it in him.
A few times he's slunched forward, bowed his head down towards his lap, and does that weird bouncy up and down with his head and shoulders. It gives the appearance of sobbing but when he finally straightens back up you can see he wasn't crying at all. It is weird behavior and appears intentional to me based on the timing of when he does it (when he'd be expected to cry he does it). Made my skin crawl the first time I realized that's what he was probably doing (could see the concerned glances from ppl sitting to the back of him, people thought he was sobbing). I wish I had a timestamp or link handy I am doing a terrible job trying to describe this haha
He’s as sleezy as his brother
I don't know what to make of this family. My brothers and I have had horrible fights, we have hurt each other badly, but at the end of the day, we would still die for each other.
"Just a normal family, doing normal family things", he says. Then goes on to talk about how he felt compelled to "clean his nephew's brains off the ground", while his killer brother sits there faking emotion like the true sociopath he is. But, just a "Normal family, doing normal family things". What the unholy hell?! Too bad this guy can't see the truth (and the killer) when it's staring him In the face or he does but like the mafia, this family stands by each other no matter what.
Claims he loved Paul SOOOO much and claims to care so much about him, but the dudes been buried for almost 2 years and still doesnt have a head stone. This whole family is F'd up and nothing would surprise me from any of them.
From a South Carolina news source it’s because they’re afraid of vandals.
So not having a headstone makes him a bad person. Maybe he spends his money on the living and not the dead. 😮
Guess they might have to exhume the bodies to get to the truth.
@@juanitamann yes this is what I've read also
Considering the time of these tragic murders. It’s possible bc the entire world was on not able to do much thanks to Covid & so many things were back ordered. Idk the ordering process & time frame for a headstone. But I do agree BY NOW THERE SHOULD BE ONE. It’s a family of lawyers they’re def on a different level of snake then the norm fam. But I also don’t know any “normal” families. There was others who had motive, however none of them were actually going to carry something like that out. More so on Paul, Maggie was just an innocent bystander. Only Alex had the true motive for them no longer being here & it serving an actual purpose for him. For Paul it’s money costing for his trial & the lawsuits they were facing. Maggie it had to have been financial gain, her life insurance & after everything coming out about his stealing she was more than likely going to divorce him,leave him by himself(which he couldn’t take I’m sure)& she would end up w/whatever was left when they divorced.
This family controlled at least 5 counties if not the whole state.
Investigations should go back 70 years.
I feel terrible for this guy. He's just an honest, good-hearted dude and great family member dragged through the ringer by a brother that doesn't deserve to breathe the same air as the rest of humanity.
I feel horrendously upset for this beautiful brilliant kind open honest soul too
God bless him n his fmily Sincerely Million times 🌼🌳🌞🌳🙏
Can't believe a room full of Lawyers and LE nobody didn't protect family members of possibly harm! Yet they cleaned and contaminated evidence sites! Protecting the family honor!!
@@annebiggins7180 should they have known that Alex was going to kill and then defended that in court?
@@annebiggins7180
I wish I understood what your point is!??
Who cleaned and contaminated the Crime scene? LE or the Murdaugh family?
We don't know how honest he is from a bit of testimony
Maggie and Alex should have been arrested a long time ago for enabling their underage son’s alcoholism, he became such a drunk! How could his parents turn a blind eye to Paul’s life spiraling out of control?!!! They never loved him because they didn’t put him into rehab, they didn’t stop his drinking and they covered up every time he was drunk driving and causing accidents😡
Alex used to fuel and fund underage drinking at mosel and he would leave the back door unlocked at the law firm for the kids to get in the hard liquor. That family ruined that small town with all their bullshit. someone should of kicked AM ass more than once. They are nothing but arrogant con artist that made bad decisions constantly
Honestly I feel bad for everyone else affected by this whole situation. My heart hurts for them & the victims (Maggie & Paul)😔
What about Stephen Smith, Gloria Satterfield and Mallory Beach?? Those are the real victims of this horrible family. Or how about the dozens of families they stole millions from?
Karma for Paul ….he should have rotted in prison….The victim was Mallory.
Dont forget three more people connected to the Evil defendant died
@@thegames-bd6mh The comment, I think, was made in reference to the brother’s testimony. Expressing sympathy for Maggie and Paul doesn’t take away from the sympathy felt for the other victims. People need to relax.
Maggie was no angel . The documentary showed that . She had her hands very dirty but I am sorry to hear about her passing.
He's a stark difference than his brother. Alex has a dark, cold energy about him. His brother seems charming and warm
At least his brother answers the question Alec would ask the question back to the guy all the time
Alec only repeated the question when the prosecutor asked him. It was to stall long enough to come up with an answer.
That gave AM enough time to think up his next lie!!
This man should never of touched anything at the crime scene ! Who allowed him to do so , isn’t that tampering with the evidence ?
Just a thought: I wonder if John Marvin went down to the crime to get rid of any incriminating evidence left instead of him saying that he owed it to Paul to clean it up.
Clearly!!
You cannot know how good a marriage is unless you are part of that couple. No matter how close you are to the couple. Couples can put on a display that is not genuine. I’m tired of people being asked “how good was their marriage?” You just can’t really know for sure.
Seems like the family is full of endearing, emotional good ol’ boys.
Wow he sounds so much like Alex...it's crazy how much you can sometimes pick out siblings
I think this testimony is a prime example of “you never know,” because he’s seems so emotionally invested in his family but I think he loves his family so much he’d do anything for them, even commit a crime, but seems so genuine.
Actions speak louder than words. He hauled the boat away, and started cleaning up the bodily leftovers, probably knowing that he shouldn’t have been doing any of it.
I think this whole family thinks they’re better than anyone else and don’t have to do things the way lesser people do things.
The brother isn’t the least credible, but now we have a pretty good idea who probably helped Alex after the murders.
Hearing that John Marvin took buster to Vegas made me think about gambling. Alex wasn’t spending his stolen money all on pills. What is another way to blow through cash? Gambling. It’s the fastest way to go through millions, and gamblers are as hard to treat as addicts.
The prison recordings absolutely back this theory up. Murdock is happily gambling in prison. He has been recorded trying any way possible to get money into prison as well. No matter who he needed to ask or manipulate, be it his family, or fellow prisoners.
There is no evidence that this brother lied!
John Marvin is not credible. He can be completely disregarded.
That and another woman.
@@dorisbrannon5141They think they know these people from a trial. It’s sad the world is full of judgemental people, who know nothing about this man, or his life. 😢
How lousy of am to lie up until Thursday that he was at the kennels