As a summary: 1. Alex asked her wife and son to come to Moselle (both were not planning to go there that day). He asked Maggie to come so they could go visit his father. 2. He leaves the house to go see his mother WITHOUT his wife and it was later known that his father was hospitalized, so Alex requesr didn't make any sense. 3. He said he never step foot on the kennels, but everybody confirmed to hearing his voice in the video that is minutes away from the murder. 4. When the police comes, the first thing he says is "Listen, this is very simple, my son was on a boat accident 2 years ago ...". Why he felt he needed to give that information so right away? Seemed he wanted to explain the motive. Weird thing to do from a grieving father and husband. 5. During police questioning, he never shows anger for what has happened or demanded justice. He seemed to be Ok with the outcome. 6. In that same line, he never demanded police to find the murderer. 7. The scene was bloody, and he was spotless. Which normal person that sees their family members like this, dont come close to touch them and see if there's any pulse or just to cry next to them. It's guilty to me.
Exactly! I completely agree with you. And…Speaking from the side of someone who has lost a family member in an incredibly traumatic way, a wrongful death…..all you want to do is find out who did this and what happened. Think about it… this is the most powerful family in that area, who gets away with everything… and has so many people connected to them….how in the hell would Alex not be on a complete tear, trying to find out who killed his wife and son, and WHY…rather than suggesting a motivation or potential responsible party? The answer is simple - he knew who did it and was not concerned with who, how, or why. Guilty… and again as someone who had to sit through a trial… god that was painful for our family. I can imagine it must be VERY painful for him to listen to and see all this because he has to face what he has done. And he deserves it.
Alex is Guilty! He may get away with it from man, but God will punish him dearly for what he did. Not to mention the lake which burns with fire and sulfur after he is judged on the dreadful day of judgment.
Great work Detective David Owen. I was so impressed with his humble manner. Murdaugh underestimated this man. (11 August interview) I’ve watched the whole trial from Western Australia. What an incredible trial to see unfold.
Always good to be reminded, Karen: the overwhelming majority of the police are decent, intelligent and trustworthy. This guy is impressive and good. It's a pity the 95% good ones don't do better work getting rid of the maybe 0.3% bad ones.
A.M., while thinking he could out-smart anyone he ever met, is actually dumber than a soup sandwich. He disposed of his wife's phone by tossing it out the window less than a mile from the scene, and he left his son's phone at the scene. He sealed his fate. I hope his nightmares never cease.
I think you have to have a conscience for the nightmares to occur... and it remains to be seen whether Alex Murdaugh has one. Fwiw, I've listened to his phone calls from the jail: he never showed an iota of concern about the killers of his family. This is only one example, of course, but it's damned telling.
Alex going for a holiday with Maggies family after he killed her is another sociopathic personality trait, trying to make himself look innocent to stay in their good books, manipulate their support. What a piece of work!
Roadside shooting was contrived to setup his announcing his going going into detox to rationalize/deflect reason for resignation (firing) from law firm. Any focus in court proceedings on his true opioid addiction and/or O use during night of murders? Going into detox appears manufactured ploy to buy him time and gain sympathy.
He'd given Curtis $164,000 in cheques. That's not for pills... Curtis said AM got out of his car gun in hand. What if only Maggie was the target and Alex was pixxed Curtis had offed the boy or Curtis did them both too early? Or Curtis was the second shooter? Has Curtis given evidence yet?
@@tracy7722 yes! If he was going to commit suicide/pay someone to kill him (whichever it was), why would he need an insurance card? If dead, you don’t need medical attention.
@@irisdown9758 not to mention getting the witness to walk back and forth to the floor to point at something on the screen. Or giving their autobiography at the beginning.
They are like preachers slowly going somewhere they know the evidence they need but make the person comfortable ask questions don’t overwhelm the person get them talking them boom Got it
If they filtered out the incessant coughing, we might be able to hear the proceedings w/o being distracted every 5 seconds by yet another hacker. These hackers must be the worst people to sit beside in a movie theater or church...gross!
Exactly. If you know, you know. That’s a lie, and I’m not sure why he lied about that. Maybe he doesn’t want anyone to really look into where that money was going?
@@MarieAntoinetteandherlittlesis - I listened to a podcast with Eric Bland on, I believe he’s the attorney for the Sattersfield sons. Bland thinks it’s possible some money was hidden in the Bahamas, but also possible money could literally be buried on the hunting property somewhere. Large amounts of stolen funds in the form of cash is a weird burden. If you deposit it into a bank, red flags go up. Was it normal income? A gift? Income means taxes must be paid on it. Can’t recall what Bland said about a new owner of the hunting property being able to keep it if they found millions in cash on the property. I’m having doubts there is money stashed anywhere. Alex was in such a financial jam, wouldn’t he have used it to pay people back and just claim ‘accounting errors’ rather than killing his wife/son?
I'm irritated by all the negative comments regarding SLED. While it is true there were some mistakes made, these are humans working a complex scene in real time, many awakened in the middle of the night with little sleep. Defense lawyers had months and and months and outside experts assistance to review and nitpick every step the SLED agents made and they did so while making hundreds of dollars per hour. Give SLED that opportunity and perhaps perfection could be achieved. Just remember who responds when you dial 911. It will not be Poot or the Hog Wrestler and their entourage!
Alex had spent years ingrating himself with LE & manipulating circumstances in the county to benefit his family & friend's! You could tell LE was very nervous on scene! But I think they all knew who did it!
It wasn’t SLED that messed up, it was the first responding officers from the local law enforcement agency. They didn’t establish a crime scene and every man and their dog went through it.
The entire location should have been void of anyone but agents... Plus they should have looked around with drones and flashlights for tire tracks or any evidence of someone having been off to the side of the property hanging around waiting for opportunity to go in there a kill them... Golf cart no or atv tracks freshly made heading away from the scene but off the main roadways... They did none of this.
I think they did it right. No investigation is perfect. Like you said they are human and hindsight is 20 20. Alex gets off call with 911 was suspicious to me. He shows that at this moment he wanted to get his people there knowing they going to be upset and accidentally mess with the crime area.
you have to be a bot to have missed the whole "lying to the grand jury" thing right? This is ridiculous. How could you say a cop who lies about evidence to a GRAND JURY is a good cop?
What I don’t understand is when Agent David Owen is asked by the lawyer questioning him to put gloves on before opening the package which held Alex’s cargo shorts, but the lawyer picks up the shorts without gloves.
I thought the same when a previous female witness also put her gloves on to handle the evidence and straight after , the lawyer handles it without gloves.
@@cindygrobler765 I would think by know it should have been determined if there was any substantial evidence, I believe the Attorney was quite upset at all the time wasted going back and forth and, while all the evidence if anymore, would have been easier to find. Just my opinion. I thought about the samething about The Shorts when I saw The Attorney pulling them out., but I guess He knew He could.
✨Question: Mr. Alex stated to the police (as per police testimony) .. that when he arrived at the kennels that he immediately checked his son/wife to see if they had a pulse. Considering all the blood and gruesome scene surrounding the bodies .. How was Mr. Alex able to explain how he was able to check his son/wife for a pulse .. without getting any blood on himself, his clothes or his shoes ? ✨ What ever happened to the clothes he was wearing before the murders ? 🤔
Also in his several post murder interviews with detectives Alec NEver admits to insisting that Maggie meet him at Moselle. Blanca and Maggies sister testify that she was only there because Alec pressured her to come to go with him to see his parent.
They can't. Any witnesses testimony to this fact other than Maggie or Alex would be speculation or hear say. Maggie obviously can not testify and I doubt Alex will take the stand.
Maggie’s sister’s testimony is that Alex asked Maggie to come to Moselle and then join him in visiting his FATHER, who’s health had recently been declining. And then Alex went alone to visit his mother.
Lots of leading the witnesses, but unless the defense objects - keep on rolling. Both sides know constant interruptions and rephrasing of questions everyone knows has been entered evidence already pisses off and frustrates juries.
HERE IT IS FOR EVERYBODY............v the investigators suck.........they dont have any leads bc they suck......... so instead of admitting bshortcomings........ lets blame someone.
@@girlart9 they all do that. They have stuff they want to get in, cover, and if they don’t - they can’t use it in closing arguments. In a closing, you cannot use info that hasn’t been entered into evidence.
They don't use tents to protect the crime scene(s)? We do where I live as many counties of states do and as is done throughout our entire state. The tents prevent prying eyes, keeps ppl away from the crime scene who shouldn't be there, protects the scene from the elements like rain, snow, sleet, and dust from blowing in.
There were very few local officers at first. Sled arrived hours later. Alex was busy calling all his lawyer friends to come. Police were busy protecting crime scene bodies.
@@kimberley1449 - Alex purposely created a power barrier between his cronies and the cops, then SLED. Created ‘chaos.’ I hope the cops have learned the lesson. Doesn’t matter who it is - block everyone from the scene. I think the cops literally didn’t have the gear they needed soon enough - tents, etc. Putting sheets on dead bodies to shield onlookers at the risk of destroying forensics was absurd. Ban the onlookers. You can’t handle the hideous truth? Get away and don’t look. Don’t allow onlookers. But Illick was in charge.
I don’t think Alex has thought these murders out. He is up against men and women who have spent their entire life proving guilt of people like him. They have their reputations and egos on the line and there are a lot more of them. The “little detective” (as Paul was fondly referred too) will solve this last case from beyond the grave Alex Murdaugh lies about everything in he’s life and he is lying about this. Rip Maggie and Paul ❤ Rot in hell Alex
Huh???? With the exception of the 2 lead DAs the rest of their crew is fresh out of law school. The chick is annoying with her squeak voice and southern drawl and cocktail skirts .... and the speed talker... etc.the state will lose this case.
@@SuperiorDefense I think Paul's video with Alex's voice in the background was the final nail. It placed him there when he had previously denied it and then on the stand admitted he was actually there.
When you have a whole town know you and you're family, and are best friends with the law, have money and power, you assume you'll have help in covering, or rely on purposeful neglect from the law. He thought they'd believe me, because of who I am, didn't much care about the phone records, onstar location, and other evidence. When boat incident happened law enforcement allowed them to walk near the scene and remove the boat themselves. Walked in the hospital to intimidate the witnesses. Steal millions of dollars from people, I mean of course he thought he'd get away with it. Imagine how many towns are run by families like this.
Its hard to imagine a more evil person who could do all these things to friends and family? He is the best of the best con man! Look you straight in the eye and lie and not miss a beat!!! His crying is for himself and only for himself! I pray they find him guilty.
Crying ? He's wiping his eyes to act like he has tears but there're none. Who's going on vacation instead of trying to solve your wife and son's murder ??? He's apparantly not afraid that somebody is after him.
I can see how people fell for his lies! During testimony, sometimes i forget what he did for a split second. He's so believable. This makes him such a dangerous man and I wonder if he has done it before and whether his whole family was the same (including his wife)
What a lost soul--Alex Murdaugh. So misguided and truly confused about what matters and how to live your life. Truly bizarre behavior, truly bizarre decisions he made.
He's a lier. He falsified evidence to grand Jury. Your kidding right. All the prosecutors are lies. Alec was wrongly and unjustly accused of murder. He is a thief as he himself has pleaded guilty to stealing money. But what these cowards and All you follow the leader fools need to wake up. If this travesty isn't overturned and made right. We the people are in serious trouble. If the lied so easy and falsified evidence to commit Alec. anyone of us could be in the same situation
It seemed strange the crime scene nor the house wasn't secured for any length of time. The next day Alec's brother and one of the partners each testified they were at the kennels cleaning up the area. Additionally, Alec's former law partner testified upon going into the feed room he found a piece of Paul's skull still on the floor.
It isn’t law enforcement’s or medical personnel’s responsibility to clean up a crime scene, including body fluids and parts after an investigation is concluded. Basically any evidentiary materials and victims are what is secured.
@@PatchaChel should of but doesn't add or subtract as evidence in this case unless you're defending yourself from getting convicted for these murders and you're throwing any shit against the wall to see what sticks...quit fishing
@@pmasino Would you be able to recognize that's a brain sitting on the ground near your child's feet (at night, albeit maybe w/some lighting)? I wouldn't even be able to let my mind go there. It seems to me the only way you'd be able to know this is what it is, is if you saw it exiting his head! (AM's good at blurting out stuff inadvertently).
Seems odd to me that the house wasn't secured at the same time as the kennels/shed area. So many people were in the house prior to SLED examining it and housekeeper even moved the towel and shorts by the shower.
@@kimberley1449 HE didn't - as per testimony. Someone called his brother Randy and his son. Both called lawyers and friends. They felt they had to show up to support him. Well intentioned but still very unhelpful. I think when police kindly but firmly had sent them home (all but the brother and one close friend, and of course Buster) the lawyers and their spouses would have been secretely relieved.
That was deliberate. Alex had thought it through and utterly manipulated the police by having all those people show up. He got all those people over to the house to create that confusion and chaos and to contaminate the crime scene--while the police were trying to work with the evidence and do their jobs. He also put pressure on the police indicating how powerful he was, with all the people coming out in the middle of the night to support him. But it wasn't enough...the police were smart and they did a FINE job despite the chaos Alex tried to create having a zillion people show up.
His brother was filmed removing weapons from the property the next day and someone said the fathers property has never been searched. That's strange to me.
I don't understand how this man AM would get off..I mean the thing for me is that his Alibi was that he was Not there during the murders but the VIDEO confirms HE WAS!! That is gold right there. AM lied !
And now we have the video with his voice there mear minutes from their deaths, cell phone data, & the gm GPS data all proving he was there when they were killed!
They only object if it is a leading question, or evidence that has nothing to do with or is not permitted to be mentioned. There have been plenty of those, especially on the States last day of questions.
@@PetroicaRodinogaster264 yes but they can object to a ton of other things like outside the scope, speculation, and so on yet they hardly ever do. I've watched a lot of trials and this is the first I've seen where both sides tend to sit bk and say nothing even when the question is leading, they have on occasion but not much.
Even after the Trial, I am still surprised this Officer, after getting Alex's statement of lies, why he said seeing him before he changed and didn't ask him " How did you check Maggie and Paul for signs of life and NOT get a drop of blood on you, your hands, or white t-shirt?" He had him right there!!!
@@lindasites-cl1ye He did, EVENTUALLY. And they were shown to the Jury and noted not to have a single drop of blood on them. My point was he should of arrested him right then and there, but alas, he's never going to breathe free air again, so it's all good! I just wish they used the Death Penalty!
So they were holding the suburban in evidence? But because he was going on vacation he needed some clothes & golf clubs? And he was allowed to pick them up? WTF??????????
The entire property should have been closed as a crime scene the moment sled arrived. They should never have allowed any non-investigative staff on scene whatsoever. Instead they allowed the suspect and his friends and family to wander the entire property. Sled should have done deep forensics in the house as well as kennel area.
@@tresasauer7129 🤔🤔 I wonder if any Joe blow would of been allowed to leave and be treated with kid gloves like AM was. He should of been brought in immediately and interrogated and given a lie detector test
@@mariepresho3653 - the spouse is always immediately suspected. That house should’ve been off limits right away, and the warrant should’ve covered the mother’s house. Really sloppy police work.
@@mariepresho3653 a lie detector wouldn't have mattered any way they aren't admissible in court and have proved to be unreliable. Alex probably would've passed though as good of a liar and manipulator as he is.
Where are the clothes he was wearing two hours before he called 911? Those would be the ones he was wearing during the murders. They have vanished into thin air along with the murder weapons.
@@cynthiawoods1673 I think the clothes & gun were left at his Mom's that night & disposed of later! Maybe in Dad's casket with the guns! Eric Bland Esq pointed out that Alec was part owner in funeral home!
I'd have liked to know who put the dogs, Bubba and Grady away. That should have been included in the timeline. Clearly Bubba was still out when the video was taken. It's also interesting that their beds had not been put down, which I believe Maggie would normally have done. If they had still been out during the shooting, there would surely have been bloody paw prints.
The circumstantial evidence is overwhelming towards a guilty verdict, but we shall see how defense twist it! These attorneys rather slimy, so it should get interesting!
In addition to that… and probably the ONLY HONEST thing AM said is that the dogs were NOT barking at anyone in the area, because there wasn’t anyone there… No one there hiding waiting for you to leave so they could mow down your wife and son !!!
And his others comment that he didn’t want to go down to the kennels “because you always get SHOT when you go down there….” He meant hot but slipped up and had an honest moment!!!
They think he washed up and changed clothes after the killing. He had on different clothes and there was water in places that shouldn’t be to clean himself up and change his clothes.
I think he washed up with the hose first. Brain matter & blood. Kennel guy said it should have been dry. Took a shower. Drove the evidence to his Moms house. Called his brother & his brother took it away from mothers.( He called his Brother 1sr before the Police. He told the caregiver his visit to Moms was 40 minutes but she said "you were only here 15 minutes, 20 minutes tops. Told caregiver he would pay for her wedding (weird). Went back home to Moselle and THEN CALLED THE COPS. It gave him 1 - 1 1/2 hrs to pull this off. When the Cops came he was carrying his shotgun. That was a way to throw them off on gunshot residue, My theory!
8 to 10 people in the house Any one of them could have taken the bloody clothes and gun away from the scene when they left. If the police didn't secure the house they probably didn't search people's vehicles when they left.
Plus that woman sitting behind Murdaugh. Putting her scarf on and off, rubbing her nose, fiddling with her hair she never sits still, all captured as the camera in on him the whole time.
John Meadors was one of the heroes of this case. His closing work was simply spellbinding. So powerful. It's fascinating that John Meador's dad was a pastor. It's amazing how John took what he learned from watching his dad and his dad's preaching style, and how he adapted it, and he now uses that style so brilliantly in his court work. And he's putting his God-given gifts into use, in action to do God's work--to seek justice. Such a blessing!!! I'm grateful for both of John Meador's parents and for everything they taught him...about being real, about the power of the choices we make, all of it. They shaped their son into the powerful lawyer he is today!! Wow! His parents should be so proud of the person John became through the values they taught him.
So this detective goes to all that length to protect that evidence - then the lawyer straight up grabs the evidence -no gloves nothing … if there’s an appeal based on that evidence - then it’s completely lost? Uh wtf
wow. just ignorant. I hope you get a smarter jury than you, if you ever need one. What happened to 'innocent until proven guilty'? Why are framing evidence around one person simply because it's convenient/we don't like him?
@@notme1255 No, going by the evidence he is guilty! His being despicable isn't being tried! Only the double murder with cell & gps data proving he was there at the time of the murders & video evidence with his voice present with in a few short minutes (4!). The circumstantial evidence is overwhelming at this point & can be an easy conviction! However we won't know for sure until defense is done & jury comes back with their verdict! We have seen killers walk free before!:
Okay so what does everybody think about the testimony of the detective when he is discussing Paul's phone and its location when they arrived on the scene. So here is what we know, there is a specific part of the timeline that discusses Paul's video and conversation with his friend regarding his dog tail. Then the conversation stopped. Was it possible that Paul was ambushed when he was on the phone texting? And he dropped the phone when he was shot? And Alex does say in an interview that he was the one who picked up Paul's phone and put it back in his pocket.
Policy and procedure of the department Mr Owens works in dictates the use of gloves at any time handling evidence. This includes court. The Lawyer is not bound by this. Have a great day!
That's the one mistake that makes me wonder. Why wouldn't Alex have just admitted to being at the kennels and framing this to have happened when he left. He was the one that decided when the police were called. He did not plan this out well.
@@cristineconnell7803 true. It just amazes me that he thought to use 2 different guns but didn't think about anything else. I guess he really just thought they wouldn't question him about it.
Even if he told police he was at the kennels they would likely not believe Maggie and Paul were killed while he was gone at his moms because there sudden lack of cell phone activity around 8:49pm would tell the cops they were killed while Alex was there. Alex planned this terribly. He was better off hiring a hitman he could trust who would kill them while he was at his moms. He may have then got away with it.
If someone else killed his family using the family guns then why would those people take the guns with them? Taking the guns with you is an act from someone who doesn’t want the guns traced or examined. Anyone killing Paul with his own gun went through a bit of effort to do it specifically with those guns and would have left them on scene
he literally did, on the 911 call, to the police directly, during the questioning, etc. Literally said that the family from the boating accident probably did this because they'd been getting threats. Literally.. Why are you commenting when you haven't been paying attention?
@@notme1255 Setting the narrative immediately! Bu at an unnatural time! And why after did he say or do little to want or try to find the killer, sure he makes some appropriate noises while being interviewed, but as sister in law Maryanne Porter said, he wasn't showing that concern in his private or daily life! Anyone else would be talking nonstop about finding the murderer! Was all we could think of!
I am SHOCKED watching that prosecutor keep touching the evidence without gloves on but makes the witness wear gloves. When he grabbed the shorts, the witness even said “don’t you want gloves?” He is driving me crazy with his pacing, touching things and getting into the witnesses personal space. Someone should have told him to stay at the podium.
Really? Knowing his reflection in HIS community/Environment etc. really do you need to ask? OffCouuuurse it was fumbled. Beyond any football 🏈 game you’ve ever seen.
So A goes to check Pauls pulse but oh! Paul is laying face down with his arms UNDER him! What’d he do, check his ankle-oh no! His brain was lying there!
Detective made sure to be wearing gloves while touching the clothing then the lawyer comes over and yanks the shorts out of his hands with no gloves on and the detective kinda looks at him and hesitates to hand them over for a second 😂
Witness referred multiple times to Alex’s “green shorts”, but they look brown in the courtroom! Is he color blind? Did he observe Alex removing the short and handing them to him? Any way the shorts got switched?
I saw that too. I think the lighting in the courtroom falls far short of what the TV cameras need to photograph accurate coloring. I'm more baffled by the absence of blood. The shoes looked to me like there was enough dirt on the tops to warrant microscopic examination of both shoes, tops and soles and everywhere in between.
@@gaylegordon2038 I believe the clothes being worn during murders is with the guns, stashed at Mom's then possibly buried on their property, or with Handsome, who always was ready to clean up the family messes! 1st person Paul was calling after he killed Mallory Beach!
I sat on murder jury last summer. All evidence items were in see-through bags so all could inspect without touching actual evidence. Just a thought. These attorneys do seem extravagant in presentation. (Show boat- ing?)
@Susan Bengston Yes. We had all evidence ( bloody hair, clothing, bottles of fluids, etc available during deliberation. ALL sealed with chain of command tape intact. It was local case in our small town, which was brutal enough. So glad we didn't have to suffer through some of these attorneys.
They work from a tiny county in South Carolina. i looked up the murder rates and they've had 3 murders (not including these) since 2006. They're not used to prosecuting this level of crime whereas the same is Harpootlian's specialty. it will be interesting to see how the defense presentation goes (if prosecution ever finishes).
AM did everything to contaminate the scene by calling a lot of people. Calling was more important than answering the 911 dispatcher. He played everybody like all those cops who killed their wifes.
He didn't have blood on him because he'd went home before going to his mother's..he went back to the kennels AFTER for the big Discovery... thats my thoughts
I worked in the court service. Extremely stressful. They walk to help burn off stress! Not an easy job to do. They often go without adequate sleep. They have to know and remember vast amounts of detail and information
I bet he grabbed Paul's phone because he had a call, text, or Snapchat come in. Paul was communicating with like 3 or 4 different people around this time. Plus dealing with the dog. I forget how kids can do that so easily.
This officer may have known to stay off the crime scene until it was photographed and documented but the county officers either sure as hell didn't know or didn't care cuz by the time sled got there several officers had trampolled all over it. This was such a sloppy and unprofessional investigation imo, they all screwed the pooch on this one and I wouldn't be surprised if Alex has a hung jury and gets off because of their screw up and lack of physical evidence. I mean wth they let the housekeeper clean the home the next am and waited from June till Sept to get a full extraction of Alex phone, so messy
I agree with much, however a few other LE did do their job & there is enough circumstantial evidence for an easy conviction. We shall see what mud defense throws in!
Does anyone else think it’s strange for a man/family who just a few weeks prior lost their wife/daughter and son/grandson took a vacation ? I would have been a mess even then to think about vacationing seems a bit strange.
Alex deleted 5 outgoing calls to Maggie’s phone. I personally think that she must have set her phone down somewhere and she didn’t have a chance to grab it as she panicked and tried to run as he gunned them down. I think Alex had to keep calling her phone in order to find it. He needed her phone to see who she had spoken to so he could polish his alibi. He called Rogan because he saw the text Rogan had sent Maggie. He failed to get anything out of Paul’s phone because it died since it was already at 2% battery life when he filmed the kennel video He denied deleting the calls, but we all know you can delete them, but not from the phone company itemized list of calls. All he said about that was “he didn’t intentionally delete those calls “. I hope his days in prison are long and filled with pure misery.
July 28 2021 Alex wants to get personal items from his SUV, golf clubs! Going on vacation with Maggies family. 7 weeks after 2 important family members are dead and you're going on vacation??? I would still have been devistated. ARE THESE PEOPLE HUMAN?
IT murdered the wife and son. IT will get away “Hung Jury”. Review the caretaker testimony regarding the wrapped hose and water spots at the kennel. Unless PROS team is replaced he”ll get away with it to a certain extent. Would be surprised if IT committed suicide. Regardless WE ALL KNOW he did it! Thumbs up👍🏻 if you believe he did. Go ahead and smash that button as if it was his head.
This detective was very capable and professional, even when AM's disgusting lead attorney harassed him! 👏 Did anyone ever ask where Maggie's vehicle was? Was it moved???
Omg I can’t remember what time I was where yesterday let alone trying if my wife, son were murdered and my Dad in the hospital and Mother in the state MS Libby was!!!
AM even had the presence of mind to give a shout out to the 911 dispatcher who took his call while he was busy describing the grisly details of what he'd just come upon. She was "very good". Holy Crow, try and focus instead of trying to win people over as such a thoughtful dude!
Alex was allowed to get his golf clubs and other items out of an impounded car, held in evidence. Tell me this family didn't have influence in South Carolina. I think his guilt was so clear they HAD to charge him with the murders. And then people were allowed to come and go from the main house and the kennel area the night of the murders. It helped to cover up clues also.
As a summary:
1. Alex asked her wife and son to come to Moselle (both were not planning to go there that day). He asked Maggie to come so they could go visit his father.
2. He leaves the house to go see his mother WITHOUT his wife and it was later known that his father was hospitalized, so Alex requesr didn't make any sense.
3. He said he never step foot on the kennels, but everybody confirmed to hearing his voice in the video that is minutes away from the murder.
4. When the police comes, the first thing he says is "Listen, this is very simple, my son was on a boat accident 2 years ago ...". Why he felt he needed to give that information so right away? Seemed he wanted to explain the motive. Weird thing to do from a grieving father and husband.
5. During police questioning, he never shows anger for what has happened or demanded justice. He seemed to be Ok with the outcome.
6. In that same line, he never demanded police to find the murderer.
7. The scene was bloody, and he was spotless. Which normal person that sees their family members like this, dont come close to touch them and see if there's any pulse or just to cry next to them.
It's guilty to me.
Exactly! I completely agree with you.
And…Speaking from the side of someone who has lost a family member in an incredibly traumatic way, a wrongful death…..all you want to do is find out who did this and what happened.
Think about it… this is the most powerful family in that area, who gets away with everything… and has so many people connected to them….how in the hell would Alex not be on a complete tear, trying to find out who killed his wife and son, and WHY…rather than suggesting a motivation or potential responsible party? The answer is simple - he knew who did it and was not concerned with who, how, or why. Guilty… and again as someone who had to sit through a trial… god that was painful for our family. I can imagine it must be VERY painful for him to listen to and see all this because he has to face what he has done. And he deserves it.
Facts I like the way u put this
@@annaleathompson2702 absolutely agree 💯
Yes and why didn’t he ask Buster to join them?! 🤔
Alex is Guilty! He may get away with it from man, but God will punish him dearly for what he did. Not to mention the lake which burns with fire and sulfur after he is judged on the dreadful day of judgment.
I’m retired…
And 2023 has become The Year of Listening To Alex Murdaugh YT Trial Clips While Taking Naps.
You nailed it !!!!! Lol
I'm not retired but same same
So it’s not just me. I’ve been listening to these at night, and today I took a nap to the sound of Alex Murdaugh testimony.
I watch them every day while cleaning the house 🤣🤣 what’s become of us
@@rebeccacotham1664 I think we need psychological help.
What an intelligent, well-trained professional.
One calm, cool, and collected man. Thoroughly believable and on target.
This Detective appears to me to be the best and most professional we’ve seen so far, thank goodness for his involvement in this case.
@susanbengeton3208- Thank you for saying what I was thinking………
But he didn’t know if it was a homicide??? He is an example of a standard SC police officer: dumb as dirt.
ffwd 2 hrs & the State's Witness has contradicted his own statements. The State is literally grasping right now & this Judge is useless
He lied to the grand jury keep watching
He lied to the GJ!!!!
People are afraid of Alex and his family!!!
Yep. Interesting body cam “eye talk” when Murdauch identified amongst on-scene sheriff personnel.
I think the murdaugh tentacles reach far 🤦
Not anymore
@@suzymoroka297 hope not.
Yes and they were afraid for good reason. His family owned the county!!
Great work Detective David Owen. I was so impressed with his humble manner. Murdaugh underestimated this man. (11 August interview) I’ve watched the whole trial from Western Australia. What an incredible trial to see unfold.
Always good to be reminded, Karen: the overwhelming majority of the police are decent, intelligent and trustworthy. This guy is impressive and good.
It's a pity the 95% good ones don't do better work getting rid of the maybe 0.3% bad ones.
@@TheDavidlloydjones absolutely…I am privileged to work for the WA Police as a public servant & see the great work they do.
Instead of A dingo ate my baby! It was “Bubba ate a chicken!”
@@sashek8451 I don’t think so 🙄. That’s a wrong analogy 🤨
@@TheDavidlloydjones 5% if we're going by a 100% rate.
A.M., while thinking he could out-smart anyone he ever met, is actually dumber than a soup sandwich. He disposed of his wife's phone by tossing it out the window less than a mile from the scene, and he left his son's phone at the scene. He sealed his fate. I hope his nightmares never cease.
I think you have to have a conscience for the nightmares to occur... and it remains to be seen whether Alex Murdaugh has one.
Fwiw, I've listened to his phone calls from the jail: he never showed an iota of concern about the killers of his family. This is only one example, of course, but it's damned telling.
@@mortalclown3812 He won't have any control over the spirits that will haunt him. He's doomed
Exactly!!
It didn't matter because they will get the phone records and Paul was talking to his friend. Why would a murderer take someone's phone.
Alex going for a holiday with Maggies family after he killed her is another sociopathic personality trait, trying to make himself look innocent to stay in their good books, manipulate their support. What a piece of work!
I didn’t know he went on vacation with Maggie’s family after the murders. I wonder what they think of him now?
The dude is just a monster, so its not surprising.
He didn't do it. It was someone who wanted to punish the boat thing.
@@elishh8173
No evidence!
Roadside shooting was contrived to setup his announcing his going going into detox to rationalize/deflect reason for resignation (firing) from law firm. Any focus in court proceedings on his true opioid addiction and/or O use during night of murders? Going into detox appears manufactured ploy to buy him time and gain sympathy.
And did Eddie only have one bullet?
He'd given Curtis $164,000 in cheques. That's not for pills...
Curtis said AM got out of his car gun in hand. What if only Maggie was the target and Alex was pixxed Curtis had offed the boy or Curtis did them both too early? Or Curtis was the second shooter?
Has Curtis given evidence yet?
Just like how AM atty said he was shot on the roadside cuz he wanted dead. No he didnt-he wanted a shot that would get sympathy not death
My exact thoughts….
He’s faking it all……badly 🙈
@@tracy7722 yes! If he was going to commit suicide/pay someone to kill him (whichever it was), why would he need an insurance card? If dead, you don’t need medical attention.
Well done, David Owen.
If they filtered out the useless questions it would cut 90% of the trial
Not to mention the State’s attorney walking from the lecturn to the witness and all the way back when the question is answered, every time.
@@irisdown9758 not to mention getting the witness to walk back and forth to the floor to point at something on the screen.
Or giving their autobiography at the beginning.
They are like preachers slowly going somewhere they know the evidence they need but make the person comfortable ask questions don’t overwhelm the person get them talking them boom
Got it
Most of these trials are pointless bullshit, but what are you gonna do you have to take the good with the bad.
If they filtered out the incessant coughing, we might be able to hear the proceedings w/o being distracted every 5 seconds by yet another hacker. These hackers must be the worst people to sit beside in a movie theater or church...gross!
$50K a week on opioids? What a crock.
He has so much nasal drainage. Is that a side effect of opioids? I know it's a sign of cocaine. Idk
@@yikes7963 there’s no way he has a coke habit right now. He’s in jail and never alone.
Exactly. If you know, you know. That’s a lie, and I’m not sure why he lied about that. Maybe he doesn’t want anyone to really look into where that money was going?
@@MarieAntoinetteandherlittlesis - I listened to a podcast with Eric Bland on, I believe he’s the attorney for the Sattersfield sons. Bland thinks it’s possible some money was hidden in the Bahamas, but also possible money could literally be buried on the hunting property somewhere. Large amounts of stolen funds in the form of cash is a weird burden. If you deposit it into a bank, red flags go up. Was it normal income? A gift? Income means taxes must be paid on it. Can’t recall what Bland said about a new owner of the hunting property being able to keep it if they found millions in cash on the property. I’m having doubts there is money stashed anywhere. Alex was in such a financial jam, wouldn’t he have used it to pay people back and just claim ‘accounting errors’ rather than killing his wife/son?
It is if he snorts them which i think he does. Its the quickest way to get high other than injecting @yikes7963
I'm irritated by all the negative comments regarding SLED. While it is true there were some mistakes made, these are humans working a complex scene in real time, many awakened in the middle of the night with little sleep. Defense lawyers had months and and months and outside experts assistance to review and nitpick every step the SLED agents made and they did so while making hundreds of dollars per hour. Give SLED that opportunity and perhaps perfection could be achieved. Just remember who responds when you dial 911. It will not be Poot or the Hog Wrestler and their entourage!
Alex had spent years ingrating himself with LE & manipulating circumstances in the county to benefit his family & friend's! You could tell LE was very nervous on scene! But I think they all knew who did it!
It wasn’t SLED that messed up, it was the first responding officers from the local law enforcement agency. They didn’t establish a crime scene and every man and their dog went through it.
The entire location should have been void of anyone but agents... Plus they should have looked around with drones and flashlights for tire tracks or any evidence of someone having been off to the side of the property hanging around waiting for opportunity to go in there a kill them... Golf cart no or atv tracks freshly made heading away from the scene but off the main roadways... They did none of this.
_some_ mistakes ? the most basic rules were violated. A person watching TV a bit would have known better.
I think they did it right. No investigation is perfect. Like you said they are human and hindsight is 20 20. Alex gets off call with 911 was suspicious to me. He shows that at this moment he wanted to get his people there knowing they going to be upset and accidentally mess with the crime area.
I like this officer, too no nonsense, and straight to the point!😊he knows a KILLER when he sees one.
Yes, me too!
Yup, me 3!!! 🚔
Agree 👍
you have to be a bot to have missed the whole "lying to the grand jury" thing right? This is ridiculous. How could you say a cop who lies about evidence to a GRAND JURY is a good cop?
Yep me 4
What I don’t understand is when Agent David Owen is asked by the lawyer questioning him to put gloves on before opening the package which held Alex’s cargo shorts, but the lawyer picks up the shorts without gloves.
Cuz it’s a show.
My son asked me the same question
I thought the same when a previous female witness also put her gloves on to handle the evidence and straight after , the lawyer handles it without gloves.
@@cindygrobler765
I would think by know it should have been determined if there was any substantial evidence, I believe the Attorney was quite upset at all the time wasted going back and forth and, while all the evidence if anymore, would have been easier to
find.
Just my opinion.
I thought about the samething about The Shorts when I saw The Attorney pulling them out., but I guess He knew He could.
I thought the same. I actually thought that whole section was bordering on idiotic. It proved nothing.
✨Question: Mr. Alex stated to the police (as per police testimony) .. that when he arrived at the kennels that he immediately checked his son/wife to see if they had a pulse. Considering all the blood and gruesome scene surrounding the bodies .. How was Mr. Alex able to explain how he was able to check his son/wife for a pulse .. without getting any blood on himself, his clothes or his shoes ? ✨ What ever happened to the clothes he was wearing before the murders ? 🤔
Exactley
Exactly. A big fat lie.
His clothes AND the weapons!! Doh! Where are they???
@@sportsmediaamerica I think he got rid of them at his parents house somewhere
The are gone the housekeeper said it never seen again
THEY NEVER BRING UP WHY MAGGIE DIDN’T GO TO HIS MOTHERS ? THATS WHY SHE WENT TO MOSELLE
Also in his several post murder interviews with detectives Alec NEver admits to insisting that Maggie meet him at Moselle. Blanca and Maggies sister testify that she was only there because Alec pressured her to come to go with him to see his parent.
They can't. Any witnesses testimony to this fact other than Maggie or Alex would be speculation or hear say. Maggie obviously can not testify and I doubt Alex will take the stand.
No it is not why she went there. She did not like to go to see the mother she found it very upsetting.
Maggie’s sister’s testimony is that Alex asked Maggie to come to Moselle and then join him in visiting his FATHER, who’s health had recently been declining.
And then Alex went alone to visit his mother.
@@tiffknox6158 that’s what I heard as well
Refreshing to hear lines of questioning with clear intent and purpose, instead of wandering for hours going nowhere.
Lots of leading the witnesses, but unless the defense objects - keep on rolling. Both sides know constant interruptions and rephrasing of questions everyone knows has been entered evidence already pisses off and frustrates juries.
HERE IT IS FOR EVERYBODY............v the investigators suck.........they dont have any leads bc they suck......... so instead of admitting bshortcomings........ lets blame someone.
Yeah, his lawyers move at a snail’s pace. Silence between questions, looking up his next question. Etc.
@@girlart9 they all do that. They have stuff they want to get in, cover, and if they don’t - they can’t use it in closing arguments. In a closing, you cannot use info that hasn’t been entered into evidence.
Harpoo needs a nap!
They don't use tents to protect the crime scene(s)? We do where I live as many counties of states do and as is done throughout our entire state. The tents prevent prying eyes, keeps ppl away from the crime scene who shouldn't be there, protects the scene from the elements like rain, snow, sleet, and dust from blowing in.
That’s what I thought. Where’s the tents? Lots about this investigation were truly sloppy.
There were very few local officers at first. Sled arrived hours later. Alex was busy calling all his lawyer friends to come. Police were busy protecting crime scene bodies.
I noticed the police held up sheets to protect bodies from prying eyes.then covered bodies with tarps or body bags
They did put up coverage because rain was coming. But Alex had called everyone to the scene.
@@kimberley1449 - Alex purposely created a power barrier between his cronies and the cops, then SLED. Created ‘chaos.’ I hope the cops have learned the lesson. Doesn’t matter who it is - block everyone from the scene. I think the cops literally didn’t have the gear they needed soon enough - tents, etc. Putting sheets on dead bodies to shield onlookers at the risk of destroying forensics was absurd. Ban the onlookers. You can’t handle the hideous truth? Get away and don’t look. Don’t allow onlookers. But Illick was in charge.
I don’t think Alex has thought these murders out. He is up against men and women who have spent their entire life proving guilt of people like him. They have their reputations and egos on the line and there are a lot more of them. The “little detective” (as Paul was fondly referred too) will solve this last case from beyond the grave Alex Murdaugh lies about everything in he’s life and he is lying about this.
Rip Maggie and Paul ❤
Rot in hell Alex
Huh???? With the exception of the 2 lead DAs the rest of their crew is fresh out of law school. The chick is annoying with her squeak voice and southern drawl and cocktail skirts .... and the speed talker... etc.the state will lose this case.
How did they prove guilt?
@@926paaja girl stop. You sound ignorant.
@@SuperiorDefense I think Paul's video with Alex's voice in the background was the final nail. It placed him there when he had previously denied it and then on the stand admitted he was actually there.
When you have a whole town know you and you're family, and are best friends with the law, have money and power, you assume you'll have help in covering, or rely on purposeful neglect from the law. He thought they'd believe me, because of who I am, didn't much care about the phone records, onstar location, and other evidence. When boat incident happened law enforcement allowed them to walk near the scene and remove the boat themselves. Walked in the hospital to intimidate the witnesses. Steal millions of dollars from people, I mean of course he thought he'd get away with it. Imagine how many towns are run by families like this.
Its hard to imagine a more evil person who could do all these things to friends and family? He is the best of the best con man! Look you straight in the eye and lie and not miss a beat!!! His crying is for himself and only for himself! I pray they find him guilty.
Crying ? He's wiping his eyes to act like he has tears but there're none. Who's going on vacation instead of trying to solve your wife and son's murder ??? He's apparantly not afraid that somebody is after him.
Jeffrey Epstein
I can see how people fell for his lies! During testimony, sometimes i forget what he did for a split second. He's so believable. This makes him such a dangerous man and I wonder if he has done it before and whether his whole family was the same (including his wife)
Wonder if he’s trying to con the cons in prison now? 😂
What a lost soul--Alex Murdaugh. So misguided and truly confused about what matters and how to live your life. Truly bizarre behavior, truly bizarre decisions he made.
You can tell he’s a veteran cop. There’s no tripping him up.
He's a lier. He falsified evidence to grand Jury. Your kidding right. All the prosecutors are lies. Alec was wrongly and unjustly accused of murder. He is a thief as he himself has pleaded guilty to stealing money. But what these cowards and All you follow the leader fools need to wake up. If this travesty isn't overturned and made right. We the people are in serious trouble. If the lied so easy and falsified evidence to commit Alec. anyone of us could be in the same situation
It seemed strange the crime scene nor the house wasn't secured for any length of time. The next day Alec's brother and one of the partners each testified they were at the kennels cleaning up the area. Additionally, Alec's former law partner testified upon going into the feed room he found a piece of Paul's skull still on the floor.
It isn’t law enforcement’s or medical personnel’s responsibility to clean up a crime scene, including body fluids and parts after an investigation is concluded. Basically any evidentiary materials and victims are what is secured.
The baseball size piece of Paul’s skull found in the feed room by Alex’s partner should have been secured by the investigation team.
@@PatchaChel should of but doesn't add or subtract as evidence in this case unless you're defending yourself from getting convicted for these murders and you're throwing any shit against the wall to see what sticks...quit fishing
Check Paul’s pulse!! Are you kidding me: he blew his brains! Seriously ? Seems to me that people are scared of Alex Murdaugh!
That seems rediculous to me too! If his brain is on the ground by his feet, why take his pulse>>>>> Is he stupid?
Not to check his pulse ..but to check Paul's phone. jmo
He didn’t check pulses. That’s been shown to be a lie. Clean shoes.
@@pmasino Would you be able to recognize that's a brain sitting on the ground near your child's feet (at night, albeit maybe w/some lighting)? I wouldn't even be able to let my mind go there. It seems to me the only way you'd be able to know this is what it is, is if you saw it exiting his head! (AM's good at blurting out stuff inadvertently).
Seems odd to me that the house wasn't secured at the same time as the kennels/shed area. So many people were in the house prior to SLED examining it and housekeeper even moved the towel and shorts by the shower.
At the time remember Alex had called the calvary to the scene before cops ever arrived.
@@kimberley1449 HE didn't - as per testimony. Someone called his brother Randy and his son. Both called lawyers and friends. They felt they had to show up to support him. Well intentioned but still very unhelpful. I think when police kindly but firmly had sent them home (all but the brother and one close friend, and of course Buster) the lawyers and their spouses would have been secretely relieved.
That was deliberate. Alex had thought it through and utterly manipulated the police by having all those people show up. He got all those people over to the house to create that confusion and chaos and to contaminate the crime scene--while the police were trying to work with the evidence and do their jobs. He also put pressure on the police indicating how powerful he was, with all the people coming out in the middle of the night to support him.
But it wasn't enough...the police were smart and they did a FINE job despite the chaos Alex tried to create having a zillion people show up.
His brother was filmed removing weapons from the property the next day and someone said the fathers property has never been searched. That's strange to me.
I don't understand how this man AM would get off..I mean the thing for me is that his Alibi was that he was Not there during the murders but the VIDEO confirms HE WAS!! That is gold right there. AM lied !
And now we have the video with his voice there mear minutes from their deaths, cell phone data, & the gm GPS data all proving he was there when they were killed!
Country bumpkin juror(s) remember the OJ imbeciles🤪
Thats what helped nail him
It’s that old “I stepped away for a minute …just when the “murderer” shows up!😂
It seems so weird to me that neither the defense nor the prosecutors hardly ever object
Yep
They only object if it is a leading question, or evidence that has nothing to do with or is not permitted to be mentioned. There have been plenty of those, especially on the States last day of questions.
@@PetroicaRodinogaster264 yes but they can object to a ton of other things like outside the scope, speculation, and so on yet they hardly ever do. I've watched a lot of trials and this is the first I've seen where both sides tend to sit bk and say nothing even when the question is leading, they have on occasion but not much.
@@PetroicaRodinogaster264 I myself believe the.subjects. that would be presented to each lawyer beforehand the trial day to be approved
I saw the defense object more than the prosecutor. I didn't watch all the time. But I thought the prosecutor should have objected much more.
Even after the Trial, I am still surprised this Officer, after getting Alex's statement of lies, why he said seeing him before he changed and didn't ask him " How did you check Maggie and Paul for signs of life and NOT get a drop of blood on you, your hands, or white t-shirt?"
He had him right there!!!
That would have put Murdaugh on the defensive. The officer was in detective mode.
Pretty strange hey
Should have taken his clothes right then & there
@@lindasites-cl1ye He did, EVENTUALLY. And they were shown to the Jury and noted not to have a single drop of blood on them.
My point was he should of arrested him right then and there, but alas, he's never going to breathe free air again, so it's all good! I just wish they used the Death Penalty!
He had to play nice until all the evidence was collected im sure he knew how powerful this family was.
So they were holding the suburban in evidence? But because he was going on vacation he needed some clothes & golf clubs? And he was allowed to pick them up? WTF??????????
The entire property should have been closed as a crime scene the moment sled arrived. They should never have allowed any non-investigative staff on scene whatsoever. Instead they allowed the suspect and his friends and family to wander the entire property.
Sled should have done deep forensics in the house as well as kennel area.
10000%, I hope they do a lot of reviewing and retraining after this.
💯💯💯💯💯💯
Hopefully they have learned from this case.
@@crisprtalk6963 I sure hope they’ve been doing meetings and reworking their reactions and reviewing appropriate investigative tactics, etc.
Shower / bathroom drain pipes
Agent is a very straightforward guy yet careful w/his words.
Ain't his first rodeo.
Your wife and son were killed and you go on vacation: my son died accidentally: I couldn’t go on vacation, was to hurt!
The lawyer called it vacation. He went to Maggie’s parents home in Florida. That’s not a vacation.
@@tresasauer7129 🤔🤔 I wonder if any Joe blow would of been allowed to leave and be treated with kid gloves like AM was. He should of been brought in immediately and interrogated and given a lie detector test
@@mariepresho3653 - the spouse is always immediately suspected. That house should’ve been off limits right away, and the warrant should’ve covered the mother’s house. Really sloppy police work.
@@tresasauer7129 Local LE scared to investigate too closely into the great & mighty Murdaughs!
@@mariepresho3653 a lie detector wouldn't have mattered any way they aren't admissible in court and have proved to be unreliable. Alex probably would've passed though as good of a liar and manipulator as he is.
Where are the clothes he was wearing two hours before he called 911? Those would be the ones he was wearing during the murders. They have vanished into thin air along with the murder weapons.
Aqua shirt khaki pants. They are in the tree photo before murder. Now they are missing with the shoes & guns. Blanca remembers what he was wearing
Stashed at Mom's, then buried later!
Hope they used scent dogs to check the house and where he’d traveled and had been tracked
Probably in the swamp at Moselle.
@@cynthiawoods1673 I think the clothes & gun were left at his Mom's that night & disposed of later! Maybe in Dad's casket with the guns! Eric Bland Esq pointed out that Alec was part owner in funeral home!
This guy looks so different from that interview in the police car. This whole deal has really affected people.
Agreed. I was thinking the same. Looks totally different
Yes!! Gained some weight I believe.
I said that too
Lawyers momma never taught him how to hand over scissors properly to someone.
I'd have liked to know who put the dogs, Bubba and Grady away. That should have been included in the timeline. Clearly Bubba was still out when the video was taken. It's also interesting that their beds had not been put down, which I believe Maggie would normally have done. If they had still been out during the shooting, there would surely have been bloody paw prints.
Do you see any owner putting a dog back in kennels after they have been up to a deceased family member?
Felt so sorry for the dogs.
Someone said they were starving the next day. Blanca has Bubba now. Not sure who has the other one.
Good question who did put the dogs away? One Bubba was hard to catch.
He’s so guilty, yet I’m not sure they’ve proved it legally. I guess we’ll see?
I think he's going to get away with it.
Right
The circumstantial evidence is overwhelming towards a guilty verdict, but we shall see how defense twist it! These attorneys rather slimy, so it should get interesting!
Where’s the slippers he had on when he went to his mom house or the same slippers his house keeper seen
I can’t get pass the fact that he was at the scene minutes before the murders. The prosecutors could have rested after that.
It sure did cinch the case!!
In addition to that… and probably the ONLY HONEST thing AM said is that the dogs were NOT barking at anyone in the area, because there wasn’t anyone there…
No one there hiding waiting for you to leave so they could mow down your wife and son !!!
And his others comment that he didn’t want to go down to the kennels “because you always get SHOT when you go down there….”
He meant hot but slipped up and had an honest moment!!!
They think he washed up and changed clothes after the killing. He had on different clothes and there was water in places that shouldn’t be to clean himself up and change his clothes.
I think he washed up with the hose first. Brain matter & blood. Kennel guy said it should have been dry. Took a shower. Drove the evidence to his Moms house. Called his brother & his brother took it away from mothers.( He called his Brother 1sr before the Police. He told the caregiver his visit to Moms was 40 minutes but she said "you were only here 15 minutes, 20 minutes tops. Told caregiver he would pay for her wedding (weird). Went back home to Moselle and THEN CALLED THE COPS. It gave him 1 - 1 1/2 hrs to pull this off. When the Cops came he was carrying his shotgun. That was a way to throw them off on gunshot residue, My theory!
8 to 10 people in the house Any one of them could have taken the bloody clothes and gun away from the scene when they left. If the police didn't secure the house they probably didn't search people's vehicles when they left.
I think his brothers helped.
They never secured the house until the next day. Never checked the shower drains. SLED, police UGH
@@islanderbyrd1881 With the mighty Murdaugh clan all over controlling the scene! The family was very much law enforcement in the county for 100 yrs!
Well, if we want to go there, Alex could have taken them the next day. He was free as a bird
Things got all ASMR when he was opening up all that sealed evidence holy cripes
Focus.
Driving me nuts this lawyer paces in front of the witness.
Yes I agree it’s very frustrating can’t he just stand still…😩😫
It doesn’t look like there’s much room for the attorney to stand still without blocking the jury’s view.
I agree. He is way too figety.
Plus that woman sitting behind Murdaugh. Putting her scarf on and off, rubbing her nose, fiddling with her hair she never sits still, all captured as the camera in on him the whole time.
@@dudzinski324 : and sometimes seems to be deliberately blocking the camera's view.
Its nice he got a good vacation in before the police set up a questioning. Nice they could arrange their schedule to accommodate him.
John Meadors was one of the heroes of this case. His closing work was simply spellbinding. So powerful.
It's fascinating that John Meador's dad was a pastor. It's amazing how John took what he learned from watching his dad and his dad's preaching style, and how he adapted it, and he now uses that style so brilliantly in his court work.
And he's putting his God-given gifts into use, in action to do God's work--to seek justice. Such a blessing!!!
I'm grateful for both of John Meador's parents and for everything they taught him...about being real, about the power of the choices we make, all of it. They shaped their son into the powerful lawyer he is today!! Wow!
His parents should be so proud of the person John became through the values they taught him.
Iiiiiiii
Spellbinding ??????? 😂😂😂😂 get a life
@@Sms8668 i have a life. Im a minister.
Well done Sir, It’s really great that this investigator was working this tragedy APPROPRIATELY, and Not enamored with the “Murdaugh” name!
Isn't it amazing that the guns were used for the murders belonged to Alex family duh
They never found the weapons.
Wouldn't that be speculation?
I haven’t seen that testimony. To my knowledge they do not have the actual murder weapon.
That was really stupid on his part. He honestly thought he could get away with most everything.
How do you know this?
@@jerrylazarony7684casings at maggie match casings found outside gun room. All fired from the missing tan AR15
No blood on Alex after turning his son around to check his pulse but the detective said he had the most blood around him? Hmm
where’s the graphic content?
So this detective goes to all that length to protect that evidence - then the lawyer straight up grabs the evidence -no gloves nothing … if there’s an appeal based on that evidence - then it’s completely lost? Uh wtf
The evidence has already been through forensic testing.
The detective is protecting himself as well. His training shows to always wear gloves to not contaminate evidence as well as yourself.
@@mwilson7842👍🏽
@@Harley08 yes it was.still should have been handled with gloves
Hahahaha
Big difference how police handled the farm hand and AM… 🤨
Man, I did not watch the actual trial live, but the fallout is incredible.
It was great! I have watched all but a couple days of the trial. I'm going back now to watch those.
You especially need to watch Alec on the stand.
P.S. The spouse is always in the Circle of Suspects.
No need to look for any lead…he is sitting right in front of you in the court!!
wow. just ignorant. I hope you get a smarter jury than you, if you ever need one. What happened to 'innocent until proven guilty'? Why are framing evidence around one person simply because it's convenient/we don't like him?
@@notme1255 No, going by the evidence he is guilty! His being despicable isn't being tried! Only the double murder with cell & gps data proving he was there at the time of the murders & video evidence with his voice present with in a few short minutes (4!). The circumstantial evidence is overwhelming at this point & can be an easy conviction! However we won't know for sure until defense is done & jury comes back with their verdict! We have seen killers walk free before!:
Okay so what does everybody think about the testimony of the detective when he is discussing Paul's phone and its location when they arrived on the scene. So here is what we know, there is a specific part of the timeline that discusses Paul's video and conversation with his friend regarding his dog tail. Then the conversation stopped. Was it possible that Paul was ambushed when he was on the phone texting? And he dropped the phone when he was shot? And Alex does say in an interview that he was the one who picked up Paul's phone and put it back in his pocket.
Hello 👋
That is an excellent theory
Can anyone explain to me why the agent had to wear gloves the whole time yet the lawyer touched everything without any gloves? I'm confused 🤔🤔🤨
Policy and procedure of the department Mr Owens works in dictates the use of gloves at any time handling evidence. This includes court. The Lawyer is not bound by this.
Have a great day!
That's the one mistake that makes me wonder. Why wouldn't Alex have just admitted to being at the kennels and framing this to have happened when he left. He was the one that decided when the police were called. He did not plan this out well.
Criminals always think they are smarter, & he had generations of experience in manipulating LE!
@@cristineconnell7803 true. It just amazes me that he thought to use 2 different guns but didn't think about anything else. I guess he really just thought they wouldn't question him about it.
@@Danijean85 He is very use to controlling the narrative with LE & investigations! Heck, it is a family legacy!
Even if he told police he was at the kennels they would likely not believe Maggie and Paul were killed while he was gone at his moms because there sudden lack of cell phone activity around 8:49pm would tell the cops they were killed while Alex was there. Alex planned this terribly. He was better off hiring a hitman he could trust who would kill them while he was at his moms. He may have then got away with it.
If someone else killed his family using the family guns then why would those people take the guns with them? Taking the guns with you is an act from someone who doesn’t want the guns traced or examined. Anyone killing Paul with his own gun went through a bit of effort to do it specifically with those guns and would have left them on scene
Why were the lawyers yelling at the witness/detective?
If there was another murderer you would think Alex would say find my wife and sons murderer. he doesn't say that.. the guy is guilty..
he literally did, on the 911 call, to the police directly, during the questioning, etc. Literally said that the family from the boating accident probably did this because they'd been getting threats. Literally.. Why are you commenting when you haven't been paying attention?
@@notme1255 Setting the narrative immediately! Bu at an unnatural time! And why after did he say or do little to want or try to find the killer, sure he makes some appropriate noises while being interviewed, but as sister in law Maryanne Porter said, he wasn't showing that concern in his private or daily life! Anyone else would be talking nonstop about finding the murderer! Was all we could think of!
Probably Buster was there helping the father kill Paul and Maggie
There shouldn't be anyone in the house.
When corruption interviews corruption it's always interesting
Who? What? Where? Why? Determines When S.L.E.D. is deployed ????? Who created The Sled team and why??
I am SHOCKED watching that prosecutor keep touching the evidence without gloves on but makes the witness wear gloves. When he grabbed the shorts, the witness even said “don’t you want gloves?” He is driving me crazy with his pacing, touching things and getting into the witnesses personal space. Someone should have told him to stay at the podium.
Took the words right out my mouth! How unprofessional. Exactly how the crime scene itself was handled tho so honestly not really too shocked.. lol
Yes, back and forth, blocking the witness from the camera…..I even yelled MOVE!” at the video…he was driving me crazy😛
I came here to say the exact same thing. like dude stop grabbing every damn thing and being weird!!! it drove me absolutely nuts!!!!
I thought he was the defense attorney
The clothing has already been processed. The gloves are for the protection of the handlers.
The tune at the end of these videos is a real toe tapper.
Alec had the gall to go out of town with Maggie’s family after he killed her sister and nephew! Evil as they come. Beyond scary
Case was clearly fumbled. Question is was this deliberate? Corruption is clearly at play here, how far up does it go?
I do think the defense is trying to cause a mistrial
Really? Knowing his reflection in HIS community/Environment etc. really do you need to ask? OffCouuuurse it was fumbled. Beyond any football 🏈 game you’ve ever seen.
Conspiracies rarely work.
your not too sharp huh?
So A goes to check Pauls pulse but oh! Paul is laying face down with his arms UNDER him! What’d he do, check his ankle-oh no! His brain was lying there!
Plus if you touch him you will have blood on your hands, clothes, and shoes. Also tell me would any of your husbands would wear those shoes.
@@conniegaylord5206 lol about those gaudy shoes!
@@conniegaylord5206 lol Connie is the fashion Police. Those shoes are so ugly.
Yes that’s what I thought he is guilty
How long was it from Paul's video with the dog and bird in its mouth until they found Paul's phone with a dead battery?
from 8:44 to 10:34
Detective made sure to be wearing gloves while touching the clothing then the lawyer comes over and yanks the shorts out of his hands with no gloves on and the detective kinda looks at him and hesitates to hand them over for a second 😂
Witness referred multiple times to Alex’s “green shorts”, but they look brown in the courtroom! Is he color blind? Did he observe Alex removing the short and handing them to him? Any way the shorts got switched?
I saw that too. I think the lighting in the courtroom falls far short of what the TV cameras need to photograph accurate coloring. I'm more baffled by the absence of blood. The shoes looked to me like there was enough dirt on the tops to warrant microscopic examination of both shoes, tops and soles and everywhere in between.
@@gaylegordon2038 I believe the clothes being worn during murders is with the guns, stashed at Mom's then possibly buried on their property, or with Handsome, who always was ready to clean up the family messes! 1st person Paul was calling after he killed Mallory Beach!
This man lost his mother the day prior to his testimony.
Just because people are lawyers, police, judges doesn’t mean they aren’t corrupt and in on it just follow $$$$$
Alex killed his son Paul. But Paul’s video put his daddy in prison for life.
Hang on why didn’t he wear gloves?
I sat on murder jury last summer. All evidence items were in see-through bags so all could inspect without touching actual evidence. Just a thought. These attorneys do seem extravagant in presentation. (Show boat- ing?)
Seems wrong procedure to have people (attorney) handling evidence with bare hands, or even handling at all.
@Susan Bengston Yes. We had all evidence ( bloody hair, clothing, bottles of fluids, etc available during deliberation. ALL sealed with chain of command tape intact. It was local case in our small town, which was brutal enough. So glad we didn't have to suffer through some of these attorneys.
They work from a tiny county in South Carolina. i looked up the murder rates and they've had 3 murders (not including these) since 2006. They're not used to prosecuting this level of crime whereas the same is Harpootlian's specialty. it will be interesting to see how the defense presentation goes (if prosecution ever finishes).
I agree on wondering when the prosecution is going to ever be finished, Lol. The murder rate in our tiny county is extremely small, too.
@@laurajane4806: Right, the prosecution's handling of evidence is extremely sloppy and unprofessional. Almost grounds for a mistrial.
AM did everything to contaminate the scene by calling a lot of people. Calling was more important than answering the 911 dispatcher. He played everybody like all those cops who killed their wifes.
Agreed. He was doing his damnis to set the scene. I wouldn't have been able to stop crying and would never have gotten off the phone with 911.
He did not call them, they called each other and all came (he called his brother, and son, which is O.K.)
@@franziskani He knew that it wouldn't end there. He knows exactly how to play everybody.
He went on a whole vacation with that lady family after killing her?? That’s wild AF!😮
I swear I could listen to John meadors talk all day long.
He didn't have blood on him because he'd went home before going to his mother's..he went back to the kennels AFTER for the big Discovery... thats my thoughts
Distracting and annoying how this attorney turns in circles and walks around. Stand still!
Agreed but I don't think they care how we feel about that....we ate lucky to be able to hear / see any of the procedings at all.
I worked in the court service.
Extremely stressful.
They walk to help burn off stress! Not an easy job to do.
They often go without adequate sleep.
They have to know and remember vast amounts of detail and information
@@mandychadwick8762 Only way I could keep the brain juices flowing well! Lol
@@cristineconnell7803
I understand ❤️
The detective even asked the lawyer if he needs gloves on before handing him the shorts!! And lawyer said no!! WTH???
Alex eyes weren't blood shot....um ya cuz he wasn't really crying
I bet he grabbed Paul's phone because he had a call, text, or Snapchat come in. Paul was communicating with like 3 or 4 different people around this time. Plus dealing with the dog. I forget how kids can do that so easily.
My thoughts too
Why did the attorney handle the clothing without donning gloves?
Dumb dumb dumb!👍
This officer may have known to stay off the crime scene until it was photographed and documented but the county officers either sure as hell didn't know or didn't care cuz by the time sled got there several officers had trampolled all over it. This was such a sloppy and unprofessional investigation imo, they all screwed the pooch on this one and I wouldn't be surprised if Alex has a hung jury and gets off because of their screw up and lack of physical evidence. I mean wth they let the housekeeper clean the home the next am and waited from June till Sept to get a full extraction of Alex phone, so messy
I agree with much, however a few other LE did do their job & there is enough circumstantial evidence for an easy conviction. We shall see what mud defense throws in!
He too screwed up, it cannot even begin to list it.
You may have thought it sloppy but they were racing the rain that was coming.
His face when the lawyer grabs the shorts without the gloves after that whole ordeal he made out of being careful taking them out the bag lolllllll
Does anyone else think it’s strange for a man/family who just a few weeks prior lost their wife/daughter and son/grandson took a vacation ? I would have been a mess even then to think about vacationing seems a bit strange.
I guess it was part of the healing process?
Alex deleted 5 outgoing calls to Maggie’s phone. I personally think that she must have set her phone down somewhere and she didn’t have a chance to grab it as she panicked and tried to run as he gunned them down. I think Alex had to keep calling her phone in order to find it. He needed her phone to see who she had spoken to so he could polish his alibi. He called Rogan because he saw the text Rogan had sent Maggie. He failed to get anything out of Paul’s phone because it died since it was already at 2% battery life when he filmed the kennel video He denied deleting the calls, but we all know you can delete them, but not from the phone company itemized list of calls. All he said about that was “he didn’t intentionally delete those calls “. I hope his days in prison are long and filled with pure misery.
The “GOOD OL’ BOY SYSTEM” is STILL alive and well in South Carolina. WAKE THE HELL UP PEOPLE. GEEZ.
Great Detective 🕵️♂️ ❤
This was brutal. This man is being caught in all his lies. What in the heck must be going through the judges mind?
This is testimony from the cop. 😂
July 28 2021 Alex wants to get personal items from his SUV, golf clubs! Going on vacation with Maggies family. 7 weeks after 2 important family members are dead and you're going on vacation??? I would still have been devistated. ARE THESE PEOPLE HUMAN?
Maybe the guns were in the golf bag.
IT murdered the wife and son. IT will get away “Hung Jury”. Review the caretaker testimony regarding the wrapped hose and water spots at the kennel. Unless PROS team is replaced he”ll get away with it to a certain extent. Would be surprised if IT committed suicide. Regardless WE ALL KNOW he did it! Thumbs up👍🏻 if you believe he did. Go ahead and smash that button as if it was his head.
👍he did it..he has motive but the jury must feel the same.
Your comment didn't age well.
Why search the house at this point.there had been a lot of people in the house the night before
This detective was very capable and professional, even when AM's disgusting lead attorney harassed him! 👏 Did anyone ever ask where Maggie's vehicle was? Was it moved???
I'd be looking up in all the trees
Omg I can’t remember what time I was where yesterday let alone trying if my wife, son were murdered and my Dad in the hospital and Mother in the state MS Libby was!!!
AM even had the presence of mind to give a shout out to the 911 dispatcher who took his call while he was busy describing the grisly details of what he'd just come upon. She was "very good". Holy Crow, try and focus instead of trying to win people over as such a thoughtful dude!
Alex was allowed to get his golf clubs and other items out of an impounded car, held in evidence. Tell me this family didn't have influence in South Carolina. I think his guilt was so clear they HAD to charge him with the murders. And then people were allowed to come and go from the main house and the kennel area the night of the murders. It helped to cover up clues also.
Why was the Detective asked to wear gloves when handling the clothes evidence, and the lawyer just grabbed the shorts with his un-gloved hands?