That episode is creepy af. Both the creatures and the Doctor starting to go supervillain and the dark ending. Good episode. The first two specials are more forgettable than anything. I quite like the last three.
Lego Roan local man who dosent watch the actual episode dosent understand what water of mars means and says a deeply emotional ending is just person who wants to live wants to die
For me, 'Midnight' is the scariest thing doctor who has ever done. I just think it's pure genius. I love how you come out of the episode literally knowing nothing and it bothers you, and it never gets resolved. You never see anything, all you know is that it fucked the doctor much more than most aliens ever manage to do. Just the level of genius of literally having one guy in the cockpit see something, and you don't even see it. The planet is scary, the monster is scary, everything is just good.
Agreed. It's not even that the monster is scary on its own, it's how much the doctor loses control, and can't fight it, that is the scary part. And as you say, you learn nothing about the alien, just that the doctor barely got out and was actually traumatised.
Watching Catherine Tate perform the ending for Donna in Journey's End makes the episode more impactful for me than it should be because that character meant so much to me and to have to deal with the fact that she doesn't get to remember all the lives she changed breaks my heart.
For me, it wasn’t that she didn’t remember, it was that you see through her post- Memory Wipe behavior exactly how much she had grown as a person while she was with the Doctor. The loss of who she was was sadder for me
I was enjoying this for 1 hour and 37 minutes until you said that the master has a yellow coloured regeneration and my viewing is now completely ruined, his regeneration is a lot more white and pink, Please re film this video with the correct information, thank you DikPix
YES! THANK YOU, they said this on the Tennant discussion and it is quite a bit different. More colorful and chaotic. Its a bit hard to tell because of the pre HD cameras but I've always felt like Jacobi>Simm regeneration scene was one of the best bits in Davie's run.
when ten is in the past, he wears brown, when he is in the future, he is in blue. same with elevens bow tie. just thought to make this comment after your mention of suits :)
TBF the Doctor's Daughter has good sci-fi, with the rapid cloning meaning that legends are created much faster, so one week is like two thousand years because of their short lifespans. That's cool.
It is. Not to mention the idea of sending a team comprised half of humans and half of fish-men to perform a terraforming mission being a really clever idea.
@@RegularCody Oh God, don't even say that..... TBF, series 5 is brilliant (my second favourite series and in my top 3 along with series 3 and 4) and series 8 and 10 are decent too. Series 6, 7 and 9 are such a mess though. My personal average scores for series 1-4 are: Series 1: 7.76/10 Series 2: 7.28/10 Series 3: 7.96/10 Series 4: 8.25/10
The End of TIme is great and made me bawl like a bitch. The conversation with Wilfred about war and death/regeneration is cool. The doctors death is sad and is the only one I really cared about sans Eccleston. But when Tennant said "I don't want to go." I did burst into tears.
"I just want a mate" "YOU JUST WANT TO MATE?" "n-NO, A MATE, A MATE. I NEED A FRIEND" "I should hope so, Im not having any of that nonsense " Ngl best lines in the series
i saw in a con vid freema did that martha ended up with mickey because russell wanted martha’s arc to to end as “smith and jones” as like a poetic ending or smth lol
@@dublinjake They also both ended up taking active roles in Earth's defense after leaving his side--they learned from him, but they also moved on and learned to live independently of him.
Agreed! Currently doing a full rewatch of New Who since it first aired, and as of the end of Smith's era it's one of the three episodes to make me cry. The others being Family of Blood (Tennant REALLY sells John Smith's confusion and bravery at having to sacrifice himself without really knowing why) , and of course, Vincent and the Doctor. All of those episodes are at least 9/10 for me for eliciting that response.
I think my favourite episode is the Family of Blood 2 parter. The dark tone of that episode is an key example of why I think RTDs era was so much better than Moffat's. The Impossible planet 2 parter comes to mind as well. That's what Dr who should really be like.
Ecclstone, Tennant and Smith all had one moment where they lose it. Ecclstone had the bit with the Dalek in the cell, Tennant had the wrath of the time lord at the end of FoB. And Smith had the bit about the "people I love" in a good man goes to war. And looking at these you can see as a great example of RTDs era compared to Moffat.
@@sportaflopsupreme5313 Yeah, the whole story is excellent from start to finish. I love how deathly silent it is in the ruins and the Satan Pit compared to all of the chaos happening on the base. It's unnerving that everything's so crazy up there, but close to the source of the chaos it's so unnaturally quiet. Agree with Kris too, Family of Blood and The Satan Pit two parters two of my top 3 stories of New Who, along with Heaven Sent. I'm a sucker for atmosphere.
The best parts of Doctor Who are the inside jokes that the Doctor references like "Moisturize me" and "Are you my mummy" that appear in different episodes.
The scene with Donna and the window is amazing. Donna had such an amazing evolution and her mind wipe was truly tearjerking. It was so refreshing to see a male and female sharing so much screen time with no lovey dovey stuff. I think that is why Martha was not one of my favorites. She was in love when he clearly said that was not going to happen. when someone lies in a relationship that is frustrating but when someone tells the truth but you don't listen it makes it worse.
Fantasticrestofthe day Honestly, one thing I love about Martha is that she got over the unrequited love and chose to remove herself from the situation in the end. I’ll always love her for being the only new-Who companion to leave the Tardis of her own volition
Really question a lot of these ratings. The Daleks in Manhattan episodes really aren't that bad. They have some stupid stuff but the idea of the core idea of one of the Daleks thinking differently and legit actually teaming up with the Dr only to be betrayed by the rest was really cool. Also when the Dalek opens up and absorbs that guy it was really fucking creepy because of the Daleks were shown to be tiny before but this one is a massive squid with huge tentacles.
@@charleynewman5057 its entirely because they changed shit about how the Daleks were portrayed. People just can't handle that they behaved differently.
It's 1 Becauae they changed the Daleks and just like the other Daleks the idiotic fanbase refuses change and 2 because it's set in america and praises that era instead of constantly shitting on america like the British constantly want and do in so many episodes
'The Girl in the Fireplace' was rated too low. Even separating my own feelings from my rating (it's my favourite Doctor Who episode), I still think critically speaking it deserves at least an 8!
Thank you for giving "Boom Town" some love. I've never understood the scathing hatred it's gotten. Fantastic idea to explore the consequences of the Doctor's interference, fantastic performances and camaraderie between the cast, fantastic witty dialog that only the irreverent Davies can come up with. "It was a VERY icy patch"
Just rewatched Season 1 today, Dalek and Boomtown were the best episodes for making the audience somewhat sympathetic to the villain. Season 1 also had the best shades of a not entirely morally “good” doctor which Boomtown shows pretty damn well.
Yeah I remember being really touched when I rewatched Boomtown. It's a better episode than I had remembered. Not that I ever thought it was bad. It's very humanistic.
I think you guys underrated the Daleks in Manhattan episodes quite a bit. The idea of Daleks evolving into something better was really cool. Dalek Sek was a really tragic character to me. And honestly I'm a sucker for the Doctor lecturing people on how much they suck, but how he believes in them and their inherent goodness.
The Idiots Lantern is set in 1954, not the 60s, and the Queen has a coronation not an inauguration. *_AND_* you say a cafeteria worker not a dinner-lady. *_COME ON_*
I mostly agree with you two, except as a music nerd I add 2 to some episodes where the music is so good e.g. The Girl in the Fireplace & Voyage of the Damned.
I think the Fires of Pompeii is worth an appreciation "glance" it works quite well, it's fast paced, nothing lingers too long, has all round wonderful acting (bar one or two of the antagonists like that old guy) and some amazing characterisation - for example you get to see a lot of Donna's compassion, in fact for the first time(don't forget about how some of the major themes and that impactful ending revolves around that characteristic) along with the very distinctive characters of Caecillius' family; you can tell what kind of person they all are, and the incredibly likeable character of big boy capaldi is very well crafted in order to make us feel so sorry for them when Vesuvius brings their world down, servicing the ending more altogether (and they are given a really nice satisfying ending so our attachment to them does see payoff as we see them all functional, jovial and successful - although this is just a nice little treat as opposed to something of larger substance) I find the crafted atmosphere and appropriate production value very charming and effective too, you can definitely admire their achievement of a roman setting, with suitably designed villains for the time period (in the same way as the witches in the Shakespeare code) just a few mental notes after rewatching it curiously - fyi i was in agreement that it was boring until now, since all i remembered was the weird lava people and bear in mind it isn't all positive: I noted some plotholes like how the aliens of the episode are described as being fragmented into virus-like ash particulates that laid in the magma under Vesuvius, and turn people it infects (those prophets and sisterhood women)slowly into them - but the girl i.e. peter capaldis daughter is still infected with it by the end of the episode, but her rocky arm just disappears in conclusion, i think its mostly the concept/structure just isn't that creative, in the way that an episode like "Midnight"s really is.
Underrated some Davies episodes (but not by much). And I mostly like the miniseries. I really liked Planet of the Dead and Waters of Mars. Though I like the very end of the final two so much that it makes up for the Master nonsense that was the rest of those. I even like the part where Tenant says goodbye to all his friends. Definitely hammy and indulgent, but it worked for me.
I’m not entirely sure how I listened for the entire 2+ hours but somehow you smegs are very entertaining... a little bit like listening to Russell Brand and Noel Fielding on that best of the year show... you guys figure out who’s who 😂. Definitely up for the rest of the seasons
How could you give father's day such a low score that episode had me crying like a baby. I was so emotionally invested. The thought of having to let my dad die to save the world, I dont know if I could do it.
On tennants clothing: when he's in the past he wears brown, when he's in the future he wears blue. there may be some inconsistencies in this but for the most part this holds up this also goes for matt, the colour of his bow tie changes when he goes from past to future!
I haven't watched the other part yet but I feel like you guys like the matt Smith era more and my theory is David's era is the best for most of the people even though it has some bad episodes is because of the david fangirls including myself. My heart broke every single time you guys said don't watch it🥺
Moment of silence for Mickey for the one thing worse than the friendzone... being second to doctor in every relationship. First rose then Martha the dude cant catch a break. Its like dating someone after they have just had an unbelievable ex which they arent quite over 😂
Half the comments: people complaining about the harsh ratings. Other half of the comments: people complaining about Max and Sam's lack of Who knowledge.
Voyage of the Damned has that awesome Doctor speech. That alone should get it several points. "First things first: One: we are going to climb through this ship. B... No, two: We are going to reach the bridge. Three or C: We are going to save the Titanic. And coming in at a very low four, or D, or that little IV in brackets they use in footnotes: Why... Right then. Follow me." "Hang on a minute. Who put you in charge? And who the hell are you anyway?" "I'm the Doctor. I'm a Time Lord. I'm from the planet Gallifrey in the constellation of Kasterborous. I am 903 years old and I am the man who is going to save your lives and all 6 billion people on the planet below... You got a problem with that? "No." "In that case... Allons-y!
Thanks for being the only people to do this on TH-cam- mad respect. But I've never met somebody who was not overwhelmed with the dalek prison shooting open
Ah you mad, I love the Christmas invasion! Best Christmas episode .... when I first watched this on tv I was also really sad to see eccelston go and resentful of tennant but they won me over with this ... don’t you think she looks tired ?! Genius !
New earth is also a lot of fun. Yeah it’s silly. But the two of them have great chemistry. And new New York, Apple grass, ifs hilarious nonsense. 5 is way too harsh , it’s a 7
I loved 99% of this video, but I'm very disappointed in the rating for David Tennants final two-parter. Idk why but those are my favourite episodes. Got great moments between the doctor and Wilfred, it has the master come back, it's wacky and weird, it's emotional, it's related to the timelords and the time war. It's weird and kinda upsetting to hear that people really hated it D:
In 2:04:55 she does not regenerate she was brought back to life by the Source. You guys also forgot the mini-episode ''Time Crash'' with the 5th Doctor.
@@willowsparks4576 _The Sontaran Experiment_ , the only two-part story Tom Baker did. There were to be another two Sontaran stories in the Classic era: The Invasion of Time (Tom again) and The Two Doctors (Colin Baker).
i completely disagree about the end of time, great episode very somber tone which i liked, i know classic who fans get really angry about ten not wanting to regenerate but i thought it was great character and he does have a companion there to work of, that being wilf who has some great observations about the dr and a unqiue way of thinking
Well the Doctor is 900 in The Doctor Dances, and is 909 in the bit with Smith in the diner at the start of S8 (I think it was S8, Smith's second series). Meaning that both 11 and 12 had a total run of less then 9 years of Doctor life, no wonder he didn't wanna go.
Series 1: 7.5 Series 2: 5.7 Series 3: 5.4 Series 4: 5.9 Mini: 3 Rose: 8/10 End Of The World: 7/10 The Unquiet Dead: 6/10 Aliens Of London: 8/10 World War 3: 7/10 Dalek: 10/10 The Long Game: 6/10 Fathers Day: 8/10 Empty Child: 7/10 The Doctor Dances: 8/10 Boom Town: 9/10 Bad Wolf: 9/10 The Parting Of The Ways: 10/10 SERIES 2 The Christmas Invasion: 9/10 New Earth: 7/10 Tooth And Claw: 5/10 School Reunion: 8/10 The Girl In The Fireplace: 8/10 Rise Of The Cybermen: 9/10 Age Of Steel: 8/10 The Idiots Lantern: 5/10 The Impossible Planet: 9/10 The Satan Pit: 8/10 Love And Monsters: 8/10 Fear Her: 3/10 Army Of Ghosts: 8/10 Doomsday: 9/10 SERIES 3 The Runaway Bride: 8/10 Smith And Jones: 9/10 The Shakespeare Code: 7/10 Gridlock: 6/10 Daleks In Manhattan: 8/10 Evolution Of The Daleks: 7/10 The Lazarus Experiment: 3/10 Human Nature: 10/10 Family Of Blood: 9/10 Blink 10/10 Utopia: 9/10 The Sound Of Drums: 9/10 Last Of The Timelords: 7/10 SERIES 4 Voyage Of The Damned: 10/10 Partners In Crime: 10/10 The Fires Of Pompeii: 6/10 Planet Of The Ood: 9/10 The Sontaran Stratagem: 7/10 The Poision Sky: 8/10 The Doctors Daughter: 7/10 The Unicorn And The Wasp: 9/10 Silence In The Libary: 9/10 Forest Of The Dead: 8/10 Midnight: 9/10 Turn Left: 10/10 The Stolen Earth: 10/10 Journeys End: 9/10 The Next Doctor: 6/10 The Planet Of The Dead: 7/10 The Warters Of Mars: 8/10 The End Of Time Part 1: 8/10 The End Of Time Part 2: 10/10 SERIES 5 The Eleventh Hour: 10/10 The Beast Below: 7/10 Victory Of The Daleks: 8/10 The Time Of The Angels: 8/10 Flesh And Stone: 8/10 The Vampires Of Venice: 7/10 Amy's Choice: 9/10 The Hungry Earth: 7/10 Cold Blood: 8/10 Vincent And The Doctor: 10/10 The Lodger: 7/10 The Pandorica Opens: 8/10 The Big Bang: 8/10 SERIES 6 A Christmas Carol: 8/10 The Impossible Astronaught: 8/10 Day Of The Moon: 7/10 The Curse Of The Black Spot: 9/10 The Doctor's Wife: 9/10 The Rebel Flesh: 7/10 The Almost People: 8/10 A Good Man Goes To War: 8/10 Let's Kill Hitler: 9/10 Night Terros: 8/10 The Girl Who Waited: 7/10 The God Complex: 8/10 Closing Time: 8/10 The Wedding Of River Song: 7/10 SERIES 7 The Doctor The Widow And The Wardrobe: 7/10 Asylum Of The Daleks: 8/10 Dinosaurs On A Spaceship: 8/10 A Town Called Mercy: 7/10 The Power Of Three: 9/10 The Angels Take Manhattan: 8/10 The Snowmen: 7/10 The Bells Of Saint John: 8/10 The Rings Of Akhaten: 8/10 Cold War: 8/10 Hide: 6/10 Journey To The Center Of The Tardis: 7/10 The Crimson Horror: 8/10 Nightmare In Silver: 9/10 Day Of The Doctor: 10/10 The Time Of The Doctor: 9/10 SERIES 8 Deep Breath: 8/10 Into The Dalek: 9/10 Robot Of Sherwood: 8/10 Listen: 7/10 Time Heist: 6/10 The Caretaker: 9/10 Kill The Moon: 3/10 Mummy On The Orient Express: 9/10 Flatline: 10/10 In The Forest Of The Night: 8/10 Dark Water: 8/10 Death In Heaven: 9/10 SERIES 9 Last Christmas: 7/10 The Magacian's Apprentice: 6/10 The Witch's Famailiar: 9/10 Under The Lake: 8/10 Before The Flood: 9/10 The Girl Who Died: 8/10 The Woman Who Lived: 7/10 The Zygon Invasion: 7/10 The Zygon Invasion: 8/10 Sleep No More: 7/10 Face The Raven: 8/10 Heaven Sent: 10/10 Hell Bent: 6/10 The Husbands Of River Song: 8/10 SERIES 10 The Return Of Doctor Mysterio: 7/10 The Pilot: 9/10 Smile: 8/10 Thin Ice: 10/10 Knock Knock: 10/10 Oxygen: 8/10 Extremis: 7/10 The Pyramid At The End Of The World: 8/10 The Lie Of The Land: 8/10 The Empress Of Mars: 8/10 The Eaters Of Light: 7/10 World Enough And Time: 9/10 The Doctor Falls: 10/10 Twice Upon A Time 10/10 SERIES 11 The Woman Who Fell To Earth: 9/10 The Ghost Monument: 7/10 Rosa: 10/10 Arachnids In The UK: 6/10 The Tsangara Conundurum: 5/10 Demons Of The Punjab: 7/10 Kerblam: 8/10 The Witchfinders: 7/10 It Takes You Away: 6/10 The Battle Of Ranskoor Av Kolos: 7/10 Resolution: 9/10 SERIES 12 Spyfall Part 1: 8/10 Spyfall Part 2: 9/10 Orphan 55: 1/10 Nikola Tesla's Night Of Terror: 8/10 Fugitive Of The Judoon: 9/10 Praxeus: 7/10 Can You Hear Me: 7/10 The Haunting Of Villa Diodati: 8/10 Ascension Of The Cybermen: 8/10 The Timeless Children: 7/10 Revolution Of The Daleks: ????
I think Christmas invasions a great episode. I really liked seeing Rose react with the audience to the Doctors regeneration as it was the first time for Newvians. And seeing how the world reacts without the doctor is great. And the build up & exicution to Tennants arrival is amazing & won me over as the next Doctor.
9 was expelling the time vortex, 10 was expelling radiation, 11 regenerated differently and so did 12. The Master was slightly different too, but none of them were different enough. It is a bit boring like you say.
so at 1:37:54 he talks about how they messed up the doctors regeneration cycle by having every doctor do the whole exploding arms bit, but if you watch the pre-quel they put out for Day of the Doctor, the eight doctor takes some sort of drink which forces regeneration causing him to become the war doctor and also change his regeneration cycle, so that now he has a different start up when regenerating. Also in the end i guess it doesn't really matter.
The impossible planet scared the absolute shit out of me when I saw it as a kid. The writing all over his face and that part when they realize the woman is outside the ship dead in the vacume of space stuck with me forever.
Omg, you must be really badass and really tough... Better not to mess with you bc you watched horror movies when you were 9 and never got scared by doctor who, Omg you are so coool
@@juliamuukkonen8674 It doesn't take being "badass" to not be scared by a childrens show. Doesn't make me tough, makes you soft XD. It's Doctor Who. Kids who watched it in the 60s have more of an excuse because they weren't exposed to as much and some of the old eps could probably be really creepy for a kid.
Lol don’t agree with most of these ratings purely because I enjoyed basically every episode of the Davies era because that man along with David Tennant made my childhood.
35:18-37:30 There's a bit that was supposed to be cut out skip it or spy on us - up to you
glorious
good to listen to while drawing lol
Leave. Tennant. Alone! 😭
He was saying goodbye to his friends!!! 😤
But for real. I want the rest of the episodes.
@@5Detective sameeee
the doctor is at his best when he is putting out multiple fires
If that is true, why didn't Chibnall write a TV show about Firefighters?
Ummmmmm
No, Chibnall, no!
"We woke up and a dog was pissing on our tent"
The doctor is the best when he's starting multiple fires
Lack of appreciation for The Waters of Mars
That episode is creepy af. Both the creatures and the Doctor starting to go supervillain and the dark ending. Good episode. The first two specials are more forgettable than anything. I quite like the last three.
Thanks for the warning, skipping that one don't think my heart can take it
Stanley Graham (yawn) it’s not that great, forgettable villain of the week with a tragic ending because the character who wants to live ‘wants to die’
Lego Roan local man who dosent watch the actual episode dosent understand what water of mars means and says a deeply emotional ending is just person who wants to live wants to die
Kob K. Local overly nostalgic person only cares about ‘emotional’ ending of boring episode
"Wilfred's not quite good enough"
YOU TAKE THAT BACK RIGHT NOW
For me, 'Midnight' is the scariest thing doctor who has ever done. I just think it's pure genius. I love how you come out of the episode literally knowing nothing and it bothers you, and it never gets resolved. You never see anything, all you know is that it fucked the doctor much more than most aliens ever manage to do. Just the level of genius of literally having one guy in the cockpit see something, and you don't even see it. The planet is scary, the monster is scary, everything is just good.
you have no idea how many times i’ve tried to look for what the mechanic saw 😭😭🤣
Agreed. It's not even that the monster is scary on its own, it's how much the doctor loses control, and can't fight it, that is the scary part. And as you say, you learn nothing about the alien, just that the doctor barely got out and was actually traumatised.
It's the closest the series ever came to just straight-up copying a Lovecraft story.
Watching Catherine Tate perform the ending for Donna in Journey's End makes the episode more impactful for me than it should be because that character meant so much to me and to have to deal with the fact that she doesn't get to remember all the lives she changed breaks my heart.
Yeah they underrated that episode. Season 4 was the best that Who ever got.
For me, it wasn’t that she didn’t remember, it was that you see through her post- Memory Wipe behavior exactly how much she had grown as a person while she was with the Doctor. The loss of who she was was sadder for me
@@charleynewman5057 no series 10 is the best who got
@@thedoctor1263 I couldn't get through it. It was better than some of Moffat's other seasons, but I just think he was a poor showrunner.
I was enjoying this for 1 hour and 37 minutes until you said that the master has a yellow coloured regeneration and my viewing is now completely ruined, his regeneration is a lot more white and pink, Please re film this video with the correct information, thank you DikPix
Petition for LazerzZ to be the 14th doctor
YES! THANK YOU, they said this on the Tennant discussion and it is quite a bit different. More colorful and chaotic. Its a bit hard to tell because of the pre HD cameras but I've always felt like Jacobi>Simm regeneration scene was one of the best bits in Davie's run.
Yo wtf are you doing here Lazerzz. Big fan btw
Torchwood: beyond TH-cams glitichy new comments system!
James why do I find your comments on every fucking doctor who video 😂
when ten is in the past, he wears brown, when he is in the future, he is in blue. same with elevens bow tie. just thought to make this comment after your mention of suits :)
And brown for Shakespeare
Also he wears the brown suit in midnight which is set in the future. Fits for most episodes though
@@rhodriwilliams2599 for the most part this theory holds
@Sam Thompson for the most part this theory holds
TBF the Doctor's Daughter has good sci-fi, with the rapid cloning meaning that legends are created much faster, so one week is like two thousand years because of their short lifespans. That's cool.
It is. Not to mention the idea of sending a team comprised half of humans and half of fish-men to perform a terraforming mission being a really clever idea.
This has some criminal underatings
Their average ratings for series 2, 3 and 4 are all below 6/10. Unbelievable.
3 and 4 especially
If they liked the Moffat Era more I wil riot
@@RegularCody Oh God, don't even say that..... TBF, series 5 is brilliant (my second favourite series and in my top 3 along with series 3 and 4) and series 8 and 10 are decent too. Series 6, 7 and 9 are such a mess though.
My personal average scores for series 1-4 are:
Series 1: 7.76/10
Series 2: 7.28/10
Series 3: 7.96/10
Series 4: 8.25/10
My top 3 series are definitely
4
1
3
Closely followed by series 10 with 12th doctor
Yeah if they had some episodes during the RTD era were rated low on this video imagine how low the Moffat era episodes will be rated
The End of TIme is great and made me bawl like a bitch. The conversation with Wilfred about war and death/regeneration is cool. The doctors death is sad and is the only one I really cared about sans Eccleston. But when Tennant said "I don't want to go." I did burst into tears.
"I just want a mate"
"YOU JUST WANT TO MATE?"
"n-NO, A MATE, A MATE. I NEED A FRIEND"
"I should hope so, Im not having any of that nonsense "
Ngl best lines in the series
Tekno Pathetic We sing your praises, Donna Noble!
"Well you're not matin with me sunshine!"
That line was stupid. I’d like it better if she only misunderstood it once. But she misunderstood it like THREE TIMES.
@@elijahfordsidioticvarietys8770
She was doing it deliberately
That’s stupid
i saw in a con vid freema did that martha ended up with mickey because russell wanted martha’s arc to to end as “smith and jones” as like a poetic ending or smth lol
I thought he was just coupling up random characters.
@@elijahfordsidioticvarietys8770 Idk, the two characters who the doctor always shunned. There's a connection there. Sort of.
did they ever explained what happened to marthas fiance?
@@dublinjake They also both ended up taking active roles in Earth's defense after leaving his side--they learned from him, but they also moved on and learned to live independently of him.
Giving The Girl in the Fireplace a 7/10 should be illegal.
Agreed! Currently doing a full rewatch of New Who since it first aired, and as of the end of Smith's era it's one of the three episodes to make me cry. The others being Family of Blood (Tennant REALLY sells John Smith's confusion and bravery at having to sacrifice himself without really knowing why) , and of course, Vincent and the Doctor. All of those episodes are at least 9/10 for me for eliciting that response.
Father's Day is also really rough and I love it.
Meh. I still don't get what the big deal was. Impossible planet was much better. The girl who waited idea was done much better with amys character
I watched the weeping angels episode of Doctor Who when I was a child, absolutely terrified me, such a great episode.
Worst episode of the first four series
@@justsomerandomguyonline1144
why?
@@juliamuukkonen8674 because he has a hate boner against Moffat (anything not RTD)
I think my favourite episode is the Family of Blood 2 parter. The dark tone of that episode is an key example of why I think RTDs era was so much better than Moffat's. The Impossible planet 2 parter comes to mind as well. That's what Dr who should really be like.
Ecclstone, Tennant and Smith all had one moment where they lose it. Ecclstone had the bit with the Dalek in the cell, Tennant had the wrath of the time lord at the end of FoB. And Smith had the bit about the "people I love" in a good man goes to war. And looking at these you can see as a great example of RTDs era compared to Moffat.
I find the Moffat era more dark that the soap opera RTD. Chibnall kill the series.
I feel like Season 3 had some really high highs but super low lows
Kami Lee That describes most seasons actually
Ragerodracir true
Disappointed you didn’t mention the Doctor fighting off the lava monsters with a water pistol lol
*The doctor's at his best when he's putting out multiple fires*
@@mayflower2370 *NO CHIBNALL, NO!*
Should have called it “Max and Sam talk over each other for 2 hours and 35 minutes.”
The anger in your pfp makes this comment so much better.
The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit ..... 14/10. Damn, thats 4 extra points above max.
Worthy though
Those and The Family of Blood two parters are fucking amazing.
@@AVerySillySausage TRUTH
@@midastheunwise2423 You're absolutely right, I love the creepy signs of satan's presence throughout the first half... in the ood and the base's A.I.
@@sportaflopsupreme5313 Yeah, the whole story is excellent from start to finish. I love how deathly silent it is in the ruins and the Satan Pit compared to all of the chaos happening on the base. It's unnerving that everything's so crazy up there, but close to the source of the chaos it's so unnaturally quiet.
Agree with Kris too, Family of Blood and The Satan Pit two parters two of my top 3 stories of New Who, along with Heaven Sent. I'm a sucker for atmosphere.
You guys really seemed to struggle to get your heads round the concept of Turn Left 😂
yeh wtf a 6?? def a 8/9 at least.
I loved turn left! Definitely in my top 10. Can’t believe they only gave it a 6/10.
Yea it doesnt have the "slitheen Shit" cause its a divergence right during "the runaway bride"
The best parts of Doctor Who are the inside jokes that the Doctor references like "Moisturize me" and "Are you my mummy" that appear in different episodes.
The scene with Donna and the window is amazing. Donna had such an amazing evolution and her mind wipe was truly tearjerking. It was so refreshing to see a male and female sharing so much screen time with no lovey dovey stuff. I think that is why Martha was not one of my favorites. She was in love when he clearly said that was not going to happen. when someone lies in a relationship that is frustrating but when someone tells the truth but you don't listen it makes it worse.
Fantasticrestofthe day Honestly, one thing I love about Martha is that she got over the unrequited love and chose to remove herself from the situation in the end. I’ll always love her for being the only new-Who companion to leave the Tardis of her own volition
Pretty sure there was a slitheen in that bar where the tenth doctor finds captain jack before he regenerates
Really question a lot of these ratings. The Daleks in Manhattan episodes really aren't that bad. They have some stupid stuff but the idea of the core idea of one of the Daleks thinking differently and legit actually teaming up with the Dr only to be betrayed by the rest was really cool. Also when the Dalek opens up and absorbs that guy it was really fucking creepy because of the Daleks were shown to be tiny before but this one is a massive squid with huge tentacles.
Always liked that two-parter, never got the hate.
@@charleynewman5057 its entirely because they changed shit about how the Daleks were portrayed. People just can't handle that they behaved differently.
It's 1 Becauae they changed the Daleks and just like the other Daleks the idiotic fanbase refuses change and 2 because it's set in america and praises that era instead of constantly shitting on america like the British constantly want and do in so many episodes
I know right, I never got the hate people throw towards Daleks in Manhattan, they've honestly two of my favorite episodes
@@Enel97 it's still shitting on America because it focuses on how bad the Great Depression was for poor people.
'The Girl in the Fireplace' was rated too low. Even separating my own feelings from my rating (it's my favourite Doctor Who episode), I still think critically speaking it deserves at least an 8!
AGREED
It was rated too high to be fair it’s the weakest Series 2 episode by far
Even worse than 'Love and Monsters'? I strongly disagree with you there, man!
Nighteyes&Fitz yes
JustSomeRandomGuy Online, I totally agree! And I think that Love and Monsters is the best episode of the series, you bastard!
Thank you for giving "Boom Town" some love. I've never understood the scathing hatred it's gotten. Fantastic idea to explore the consequences of the Doctor's interference, fantastic performances and camaraderie between the cast, fantastic witty dialog that only the irreverent Davies can come up with. "It was a VERY icy patch"
Just rewatched Season 1 today, Dalek and Boomtown were the best episodes for making the audience somewhat sympathetic to the villain. Season 1 also had the best shades of a not entirely morally “good” doctor which Boomtown shows pretty damn well.
Yeah I remember being really touched when I rewatched Boomtown. It's a better episode than I had remembered. Not that I ever thought it was bad. It's very humanistic.
Not to mention "She's climbing out the windows, isn't she?" was one of the funniest scenes in Who.
I think you guys underrated the Daleks in Manhattan episodes quite a bit. The idea of Daleks evolving into something better was really cool. Dalek Sek was a really tragic character to me. And honestly I'm a sucker for the Doctor lecturing people on how much they suck, but how he believes in them and their inherent goodness.
The first part is ok the second part is horrible
It's a cool concept but some of the script and a lot of the accents are hot garbage.
2024 and this is still such a fucking banger video series, hope you guys are alive :)
Human Nature/Family of Blood was Paul Cornell
when they said that it made me die inside :(
Season one is more complete because the music is so perfect. Especially parting of the ways feels like a song rather than a tv show.
Would you guys ever consider doing one of these for the recent RTD Tennant specials? Would be interested to see your take on them?
That human Dalek voice was spot on, also I had the human dalek mask, is was so big.
The absorber scared the shit out of me when I was younger
I want the midnight entity to stay just that an entity.
Christmas invasion is bad only because the doctor is literally asleep for 80% of the episode.
Jonathan Fradette And then he wakes up and does what seems like his stand comedy show.
I would totally sit through another video where you talk about and rate the rest of the seasons!
The Idiots Lantern is set in 1954, not the 60s, and the Queen has a coronation not an inauguration.
*_AND_* you say a cafeteria worker not a dinner-lady. *_COME ON_*
Okay boo
It completely ruined my immersion, gonna have to report the video now
I thought it was 1952 or 1953. I remember the Diamond Jubilee being like seven or eight years ago.
Wow, 2 mistakes in a 2 and a half hour video! God forbid.
And yes, they are referred to as 'Dinner Ladies' in the UK. *COME ON*
in the uk they are called dinner ladies
11:38 Fun fact, apparently Adam comes back in the comics as a villain cause the Doctor abandoned him 😂😂😂
the crabs are called macra and they're a 2nd doctor monster
The Macra were a Troughton villain you utter buffoons
Honestly the idiot lantern terrified me as a kid. Both the faceless people and the weird wire woman.
I mostly agree with you two, except as a music nerd I add 2 to some episodes where the music is so good e.g. The Girl in the Fireplace & Voyage of the Damned.
That operatic music that accompanies the Doctor being a badass is always great.
I think the Fires of Pompeii is worth an appreciation "glance"
it works quite well, it's fast paced, nothing lingers too long, has all round wonderful acting (bar one or two of the antagonists like that old guy) and some amazing characterisation - for example you get to see a lot of Donna's compassion, in fact for the first time(don't forget about how some of the major themes and that impactful ending revolves around that characteristic) along with the very distinctive characters of Caecillius' family; you can tell what kind of person they all are, and the incredibly likeable character of big boy capaldi is very well crafted in order to make us feel so sorry for them when Vesuvius brings their world down, servicing the ending more altogether (and they are given a really nice satisfying ending so our attachment to them does see payoff as we see them all functional, jovial and successful - although this is just a nice little treat as opposed to something of larger substance)
I find the crafted atmosphere and appropriate production value very charming and effective too, you can definitely admire their achievement of a roman setting, with suitably designed villains for the time period (in the same way as the witches in the Shakespeare code)
just a few mental notes after rewatching it curiously - fyi i was in agreement that it was boring until now, since all i remembered was the weird lava people
and bear in mind it isn't all positive: I noted some plotholes like how the aliens of the episode are described as being fragmented into virus-like ash particulates that laid in the magma under Vesuvius, and turn people it infects (those prophets and sisterhood women)slowly into them - but the girl i.e. peter capaldis daughter is still infected with it by the end of the episode, but her rocky arm just disappears
in conclusion, i think its mostly the concept/structure just isn't that creative, in the way that an episode like "Midnight"s really is.
I could watch these videos just for the random impersonations from the episodes.
Underrated some Davies episodes (but not by much). And I mostly like the miniseries. I really liked Planet of the Dead and Waters of Mars. Though I like the very end of the final two so much that it makes up for the Master nonsense that was the rest of those. I even like the part where Tenant says goodbye to all his friends. Definitely hammy and indulgent, but it worked for me.
Nice video guys, but I don’t really understand why you gave “fear her” the first 11/10 and a standing ovation.
Fear her is worse than evolution of the daleks, it's just so poorly written
I rate this doctor who rating video 10/10 it’s g(rate)
School reunion was filmed in my school. The opening physics class is actually my physics class today!
I’m not entirely sure how I listened for the entire 2+ hours but somehow you smegs are very entertaining... a little bit like listening to Russell Brand and Noel Fielding on that best of the year show... you guys figure out who’s who 😂. Definitely up for the rest of the seasons
Father’s day at 5/10 It’s a banger episode
How could you give father's day such a low score that episode had me crying like a baby. I was so emotionally invested. The thought of having to let my dad die to save the world, I dont know if I could do it.
Well then if you didn't save the world your dad would die anyway.
Read the Doc Oho's review. That episode is so overrated.
But then Rose didn't really know her dad, she only just met him in the episode.
On tennants clothing: when he's in the past he wears brown, when he's in the future he wears blue. there may be some inconsistencies in this but for the most part this holds up
this also goes for matt, the colour of his bow tie changes when he goes from past to future!
I haven't watched the other part yet but I feel like you guys like the matt Smith era more and my theory is David's era is the best for most of the people even though it has some bad episodes is because of the david fangirls including myself. My heart broke every single time you guys said don't watch it🥺
I can’t believe I choose today to re watch this and know RTD is back as showrunner!!!!!!
Moment of silence for Mickey for the one thing worse than the friendzone... being second to doctor in every relationship. First rose then Martha the dude cant catch a break. Its like dating someone after they have just had an unbelievable ex which they arent quite over 😂
There’s an alternate universe with a sitcom that has 10 and Rose living in the suburbs.
Man I wanna smoke weed with these guys so much!
Dude weed lmao
It’s so crazy to me that the monster that kicked the revival off is the Nestene! They haven’t really been seen since except at the Pandorica!
Half the comments: people complaining about the harsh ratings.
Other half of the comments: people complaining about Max and Sam's lack of Who knowledge.
Voyage of the Damned has that awesome Doctor speech. That alone should get it several points.
"First things first: One: we are going to climb through this ship. B... No, two: We are going to reach the bridge. Three or C: We are going to save the Titanic. And coming in at a very low four, or D, or that little IV in brackets they use in footnotes: Why... Right then. Follow me."
"Hang on a minute. Who put you in charge? And who the hell are you anyway?"
"I'm the Doctor. I'm a Time Lord. I'm from the planet Gallifrey in the constellation of Kasterborous. I am 903 years old and I am the man who is going to save your lives and all 6 billion people on the planet below... You got a problem with that?
"No."
"In that case... Allons-y!
Thanks for being the only people to do this on TH-cam- mad respect. But I've never met somebody who was not overwhelmed with the dalek prison shooting open
Yoiu guys seem like the most casual fans ever and I love it. Makes the community feel way more diverse than toxic purist fanboys.
Casual? At least one of them watched all of classic who.
@@MrAllallalla "seem"
I'd more say chill
Ah you mad, I love the Christmas invasion! Best Christmas episode .... when I first watched this on tv I was also really sad to see eccelston go and resentful of tennant but they won me over with this ... don’t you think she looks tired ?! Genius !
New earth is also a lot of fun. Yeah it’s silly. But the two of them have great chemistry. And new New York, Apple grass, ifs hilarious nonsense. 5 is way too harsh , it’s a 7
Damn right, I love The Christmas Invasion.
I loved 99% of this video, but I'm very disappointed in the rating for David Tennants final two-parter. Idk why but those are my favourite episodes. Got great moments between the doctor and Wilfred, it has the master come back, it's wacky and weird, it's emotional, it's related to the timelords and the time war. It's weird and kinda upsetting to hear that people really hated it D:
I hope there is one of these for the Whitaker era when it is all broadcast
In 2:04:55 she does not regenerate she was brought back to life by the Source. You guys also forgot the mini-episode ''Time Crash'' with the 5th Doctor.
Murilo Lemos yeah that also links into the episode with the space titanic
I think that the gun sontaran episode is a Jon Pertwee episode and Sarah Jane's first episode in Doctor Who.
It is indeed. The most excellent "The Time Warrior".
Raafe Amir there was a sontaran episode with Tom baker after the cyberman episode
@@willowsparks4576 _The Sontaran Experiment_ , the only two-part story Tom Baker did. There were to be another two Sontaran stories in the Classic era: The Invasion of Time (Tom again) and The Two Doctors (Colin Baker).
13:46 in fairness, the POV shots were poking fun at 80s Doctor Who (cos of when the episode's set.)
Wait, 1:48:35 he uses the screwdriver to pop a cork? But I didn't think it worked on wood?
i completely disagree about the end of time, great episode very somber tone which i liked, i know classic who fans get really angry about ten not wanting to regenerate but i thought it was great character and he does have a companion there to work of, that being wilf who has some great observations about the dr and a unqiue way of thinking
Well the Doctor is 900 in The Doctor Dances, and is 909 in the bit with Smith in the diner at the start of S8 (I think it was S8, Smith's second series). Meaning that both 11 and 12 had a total run of less then 9 years of Doctor life, no wonder he didn't wanna go.
Series 1: 7.5
Series 2: 5.7
Series 3: 5.4
Series 4: 5.9
Mini: 3
Rose: 8/10
End Of The World: 7/10
The Unquiet Dead: 6/10
Aliens Of London: 8/10
World War 3: 7/10
Dalek: 10/10
The Long Game: 6/10
Fathers Day: 8/10
Empty Child: 7/10
The Doctor Dances: 8/10
Boom Town: 9/10
Bad Wolf: 9/10
The Parting Of The Ways: 10/10
SERIES 2
The Christmas Invasion: 9/10
New Earth: 7/10
Tooth And Claw: 5/10
School Reunion: 8/10
The Girl In The Fireplace: 8/10
Rise Of The Cybermen: 9/10
Age Of Steel: 8/10
The Idiots Lantern: 5/10
The Impossible Planet: 9/10
The Satan Pit: 8/10
Love And Monsters: 8/10
Fear Her: 3/10
Army Of Ghosts: 8/10
Doomsday: 9/10
SERIES 3
The Runaway Bride: 8/10
Smith And Jones: 9/10
The Shakespeare Code: 7/10
Gridlock: 6/10
Daleks In Manhattan: 8/10
Evolution Of The Daleks: 7/10
The Lazarus Experiment: 3/10
Human Nature: 10/10
Family Of Blood: 9/10
Blink 10/10
Utopia: 9/10
The Sound Of Drums: 9/10
Last Of The Timelords: 7/10
SERIES 4
Voyage Of The Damned: 10/10
Partners In Crime: 10/10
The Fires Of Pompeii: 6/10
Planet Of The Ood: 9/10
The Sontaran Stratagem: 7/10
The Poision Sky: 8/10
The Doctors Daughter: 7/10
The Unicorn And The Wasp: 9/10
Silence In The Libary: 9/10
Forest Of The Dead: 8/10
Midnight: 9/10
Turn Left: 10/10
The Stolen Earth: 10/10
Journeys End: 9/10
The Next Doctor: 6/10
The Planet Of The Dead: 7/10
The Warters Of Mars: 8/10
The End Of Time Part 1: 8/10
The End Of Time Part 2: 10/10
SERIES 5
The Eleventh Hour: 10/10
The Beast Below: 7/10
Victory Of The Daleks: 8/10
The Time Of The Angels: 8/10
Flesh And Stone: 8/10
The Vampires Of Venice: 7/10
Amy's Choice: 9/10
The Hungry Earth: 7/10
Cold Blood: 8/10
Vincent And The Doctor: 10/10
The Lodger: 7/10
The Pandorica Opens: 8/10
The Big Bang: 8/10
SERIES 6
A Christmas Carol: 8/10
The Impossible Astronaught: 8/10
Day Of The Moon: 7/10
The Curse Of The Black Spot: 9/10
The Doctor's Wife: 9/10
The Rebel Flesh: 7/10
The Almost People: 8/10
A Good Man Goes To War: 8/10
Let's Kill Hitler: 9/10
Night Terros: 8/10
The Girl Who Waited: 7/10
The God Complex: 8/10
Closing Time: 8/10
The Wedding Of River Song: 7/10
SERIES 7
The Doctor The Widow And The Wardrobe: 7/10
Asylum Of The Daleks: 8/10
Dinosaurs On A Spaceship: 8/10
A Town Called Mercy: 7/10
The Power Of Three: 9/10
The Angels Take Manhattan: 8/10
The Snowmen: 7/10
The Bells Of Saint John: 8/10
The Rings Of Akhaten: 8/10
Cold War: 8/10
Hide: 6/10
Journey To The Center Of The Tardis: 7/10
The Crimson Horror: 8/10
Nightmare In Silver: 9/10
Day Of The Doctor: 10/10
The Time Of The Doctor: 9/10
SERIES 8
Deep Breath: 8/10
Into The Dalek: 9/10
Robot Of Sherwood: 8/10
Listen: 7/10
Time Heist: 6/10
The Caretaker: 9/10
Kill The Moon: 3/10
Mummy On The Orient Express: 9/10
Flatline: 10/10
In The Forest Of The Night: 8/10
Dark Water: 8/10
Death In Heaven: 9/10
SERIES 9
Last Christmas: 7/10
The Magacian's Apprentice: 6/10
The Witch's Famailiar: 9/10
Under The Lake: 8/10
Before The Flood: 9/10
The Girl Who Died: 8/10
The Woman Who Lived: 7/10
The Zygon Invasion: 7/10
The Zygon Invasion: 8/10
Sleep No More: 7/10
Face The Raven: 8/10
Heaven Sent: 10/10
Hell Bent: 6/10
The Husbands Of River Song: 8/10
SERIES 10
The Return Of Doctor Mysterio: 7/10
The Pilot: 9/10
Smile: 8/10
Thin Ice: 10/10
Knock Knock: 10/10
Oxygen: 8/10
Extremis: 7/10
The Pyramid At The End Of The World: 8/10
The Lie Of The Land: 8/10
The Empress Of Mars: 8/10
The Eaters Of Light: 7/10
World Enough And Time: 9/10
The Doctor Falls: 10/10
Twice Upon A Time 10/10
SERIES 11
The Woman Who Fell To Earth: 9/10
The Ghost Monument: 7/10
Rosa: 10/10
Arachnids In The UK: 6/10
The Tsangara Conundurum: 5/10
Demons Of The Punjab: 7/10
Kerblam: 8/10
The Witchfinders: 7/10
It Takes You Away: 6/10
The Battle Of Ranskoor Av Kolos: 7/10
Resolution: 9/10
SERIES 12
Spyfall Part 1: 8/10
Spyfall Part 2: 9/10
Orphan 55: 1/10
Nikola Tesla's Night Of Terror: 8/10
Fugitive Of The Judoon: 9/10
Praxeus: 7/10
Can You Hear Me: 7/10
The Haunting Of Villa Diodati: 8/10
Ascension Of The Cybermen: 8/10
The Timeless Children: 7/10
Revolution Of The Daleks: ????
i want you to talk about torchwood just because of how fucking good owen's arc is
I listened to the whole thing. Great to have in the background while I'm animating. Cheers lads
Gridlock definitely takes place after Shakespeare because they mention he took her to the past
Thank goodness they started with Eccleston! He killed it! Thanks for this great vid!
I think Christmas invasions a great episode. I really liked seeing Rose react with the audience to the Doctors regeneration as it was the first time for Newvians. And seeing how the world reacts without the doctor is great. And the build up & exicution to Tennants arrival is amazing & won me over as the next Doctor.
props for the ood mood moments
9 was expelling the time vortex, 10 was expelling radiation, 11 regenerated differently and so did 12. The Master was slightly different too, but none of them were different enough. It is a bit boring like you say.
so at 1:37:54 he talks about how they messed up the doctors regeneration cycle by having every doctor do the whole exploding arms bit, but if you watch the pre-quel they put out for Day of the Doctor, the eight doctor takes some sort of drink which forces regeneration causing him to become the war doctor and also change his regeneration cycle, so that now he has a different start up when regenerating. Also in the end i guess it doesn't really matter.
The regenerations definitely shouldn't have been massive explosions of time energy after season 1
The slitheen DO show up again. In the end of time, at the canteen where jack is.
Well, it's another member of the planet Racsacalicophalapatorious (I can't spell it) it may not be of the Slitheen family.
@@elliebrooke3987 ah yes, that is true. Got me there.
Unquiet Dead was my first episode actually. I don't remember it scaring me shitless as such, but I was extremely invested from that point onwards.
The impossible planet scared the absolute shit out of me when I saw it as a kid. The writing all over his face and that part when they realize the woman is outside the ship dead in the vacume of space stuck with me forever.
Lol you were soft. I loved that episode, Dr Who never scared me because I'd been watching horror movies and shit for years at the point. I was 9.
@@AVerySillySausage ooooooh sorry boss
Omg, you must be really badass and really tough... Better not to mess with you bc you watched horror movies when you were 9 and never got scared by doctor who, Omg you are so coool
@@juliamuukkonen8674 It doesn't take being "badass" to not be scared by a childrens show. Doesn't make me tough, makes you soft XD. It's Doctor Who. Kids who watched it in the 60s have more of an excuse because they weren't exposed to as much and some of the old eps could probably be really creepy for a kid.
Why do you have to look down on people who got scared by doctor who when they were a kid?
31:40 this episode along with the next episode really scared me when I was a kid
The Slitheen show up again in The End of Time part 2 in the Mos Eisley Cantina
How could you possibly forget the ood singing the Doctor back to his TARDIS?
2:06:00 Agatha Christie actually did discovery write her murder mysterious
This is an incredible video
24:34 Christopher Eccleston has said that he was suffering anorexia during filming
Macra in Gridlock are Troughton villains. And Human Nature/Family of Blood was written by Paul Cornell.
FIX UR MIC LEVELS
they do it the kids in school reunion the intro before the title sequence
Gatiss' best is a 6 out of 10.
Feels about right.
The guy who played the young master has sadly died.
Lol don’t agree with most of these ratings purely because I enjoyed basically every episode of the Davies era because that man along with David Tennant made my childhood.
1:20:20 WTF! 3/20! AM I LIKE THE ONLY PERSON THAT LOVES THAT EPISODE! I think it criminally underrated.
Love this. Found myself wishing I was in on the convo!
The silence in the library two parter is my favorite doctor who episode ever.
No it’s not
The Chloe Webber impression is the best I’ve ever heard
Abigail Wright made me crease