‘Completely shambolic performance’: Douglas Murray slams Claudine Gay
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 มิ.ย. 2024
- Author Douglas Murray says former Harvard president Claudine Gay delivered a “completely shambolic” performance at a congressional hearing on anti-Semitism.
“Reaction to the resignation of the (former) president of Harvard Claudine Gay has been predictably divided,” Mr Murray said.
“For some, the university’s first black head deserved to lose her job after accusations of plagiarism and a completely shambolic performance at a congressional hearing on anti-Semitism last month.”
The former president resigned following public outrage over her testimony on anti-Semitism.
Ms Gay was asked, "At Harvard, does calling for the genocide of Jews violate Harvard’s rules of bullying and harassment - yes or no?"
Ms Gay responded with, "It can be, depending on the context".
“Amazing - all depends on the context apparently,” Mr Murray said.
“Anyway, some people are ignoring that and are claiming there is actually a sinister racial agenda in this sacking.”
Mr Murray was joined by author and activist Ayaan Hirsi Ali to discuss the controversial issue.
There's absolutely no honour in being hired for a job on the basis of the colour of your skin rather than your ability to do the job
You’re Irish and you support the Provisional IRA murderers of the innocent Australian civilians Stephen Melrose and Nick Spanos. Your opinion about anything is worthless.
@@johnhoyle4401You Soros useful idiots should all go away and leave normal people alone.
@@jamesmorrow1646 Where is your evidence for that disgusting claim, Honz? Do you seriously think all Irish people support the IRA?
hahahahahahahahahhahaha
@@richardlafleur8389 Sean Delap has said that he supports the Provisional IRA murderers of the innocent Australian civilians Stephen Melrose and Nick Spanos. Do keep up Dicky. Perhaps you should ask Sean Delap about it. He won’t reply, that dismal troll never does. Why aren’t you working on your scientific paper disproving that Climate Change is causing longer, hotter and dryer fire seasons?
D.I.E.
Diversity? Division!
Inclusivity? Intolerance!
Equity? Envy!
That's a good one! ....and spot on!
Excellent!
Discipline
Intelligence
Ethics
Well said.
Division, Exclusion, Indoctrination
I'm so happy Douglas Murray is filling in for Piers Morgan. He deserves his own show.
In artistic terms for me Douglas is a Rembrandt and Piers is a painting by numbers.
Piers Morgan is a creature of the media and entertainment. He constantly interrupts his guests when they disagree with his views. Murray wants to get to the truth and is concerned with the facts. And WAY more intelligent than Morgan and 99.999% of media hosts.
Please can we have Douglas all the time! He’s superb! He has patience, listens and lets his guests speak! Well done Douglas 👏👏👏
When it commes to brains, he is up there.
Ayaan and Douglas, two of the most intelligent people in the media.
And two brilliant authors!
Could not agree more, sir! Think if all teachers were like these too what a prosperous world we would live in for all.
@@adambohlin5112Yes, I've long admired Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Douglas Murray.
Agree 100%. Have admired both of them for many years now. Wish Douglas would run for office in the UK!
Except Ayaan has slipped a few IQ points when declared she was now a Christian. A fake Christian at that!
Please keep Douglas. Sorry Piers.
There’s a cartoon on the web that has her saying “you’re firing me because i’m a black woman” and the board reply “No! That’s why we hired you in the first place”
We hired you because you're black,
We're firing you because you can't do the job.
🫵😀 😂 🤣
Love this!
"My grandmother wouldn't trust Claudine Gay to herd her goats." OMG LOL 🤣🤣🤣 Her grandmother has more common sense than Harvard.
I can imagine by the end of her first day, Claudine Gay munching grass being watched over by a heard of goats sitting back, sipping Champaign and laughing at her.
Absolutely
Wise woman...her Granny would be proud..
I am in awe of these two individuals - brilliant, articulate, independent thinkers.
Exactly! Such a pleasure to listen for bright people.
RIGHT?!?! love them both. @@m.chumakov1033
Which 2 ppl ? Claudine Gay's sister who's a guest, or this stupid SkyNews host ??
🤢 🤕 🤮 a sodomite and an African invader
Absolutely brilliant and extremely brave!
So happy Douglas got Ayaan to speak on this topic. Bravo.
Douglas and Ayaan are an intellectual, truth telling dynamic duo!
Two brave, brilliant, clear-thinking and fearless people!
So nice and refreshing to listen to 2 intelligent and moral people.
I was so ashamed of those 3 head of university who couldn't just say the most decent word "YES" calling for genocide on any people is wrong
Well said! Shame it was.
They were capable of saying 'Yes' to their jobs... but to admit that? Well, some may say that was part of their jobs... while the Phantom Menace is an okay film, it should be looked at closely for some relation to what DEI is all about.
The reason they couldn’t is because they’re all racist, and they believe Israel are “oppressors”.
those 2 presidents sounded like Nazis on trial at Nuremburg.. it was shameful. imagine being asked if calling for GENOCIDE was a no-no and then waffling about context, - as Jewish students are being trapped in locked rooms with the mob hammering on the doors! modern USA is going like revolutionary France in 1793
It is quite incredible that the ex-President of Harvard commands some support from some people after her unbelievably crass answers to questions in Congress regarding the issue of antisemitism on campus. The only explanation can be that they are as warped as she.
Much admiration and respect to Douglas Murray and Ayaan Hirsi Ali for being the voice of reason 🙏🙏🙏🙏♥️♥️
What a well spoken young lady who makes a lot of sense when she talks. We need more people like this to promote meritocracy
You're very naive if you've bought into this myth about the death of "meritocracy".
@@themaskedman221 to be honest it's always been about plutocracy and still is. the power and advancement of the rich
@@themaskedman221"Stop noticing things. I know those in power continuously denegrate meritocracy as white supremacy and Zionism, but shut up."
Two of my favourite people having an honest, intelligent discussion. THANK YOU ❤
Never seen Douglas hosting before! Wonderful.
Amazing
@@lesleymaclennan7899An American 🇺🇸 voice here…I heartily endorse Douglas Murray as having his own program/time slot!
“My grandmother wouldn’t trust Claudine Gay to herd her goats”. So true Ayaan.
❤ 👍 👌 😂
This just shows how far you can go by cheating, what an example to all students
What you really saw in the absurd answer “depends on the context” is the contempt the left has for the right. We have totally lost our way.
I bet the nazis had thought of that one at Nuremburg. They might have got off
Honestly Douglas you're a much better interviewer than Piers Morgan, I can finally hear the guests talking
Hallelujah - this guest speaker should be APPLAUDED! Finally, common sense and rationality simply and strongly stated. 👏👏
Let’s bring her on many more programs. Hopefully, her intelligence and reasoning can be heard by many, many persons.
You should read Ayaan Hirsi Ali’s books Infidel and Prey. She’s an awesome person!
She's a role model to us all.
She is an amazing woman, scholar, and human generally, as is her husband Niall Ferguson (Historian of excellence).
she did a great interview on triggernometry on yt. And many others; just google her name.
this woman is phenomenal, it's a pleasure to hear such wisdom.
Thank you ! Such a bright woman . She doesn’t use her gender or skin colour to be where she is
We should all take example on her.
I am so tired of some social media people or political groups to use the racist card !
Thank you Douglas Murray you shine bright 🌟✨
Apparently lied on her initial asylum application in the Netherlands..only to be caught so she moved on to America to claim asylum..something fishy about her too..
We, as American Black people, don't care what you think because it was a racist. Alan Dershowitz allegedly did plagiarism, and nothing happened to him. I personally don't care because white people repeatedly have plagiarized Black inventors ' ideas, inventions, and creations throughout the decades. This was a witch hunt.
She’s written many books, absolutely fascinating life story!
@@lizzieck2576 will try to read !
There is nobody like Douglas and Miss Ali!
She is spot on. DEI has destroyed higher ed in America, and the consequences will reverberate for a generation. Harvard will not recover.
It’s destroying our healthcare in Canada
Started before DEI. US Dept of Ed's ma.rxi.st agenda been in place since 198Os.
As planned, it only took one generation to pervert the West.
Delusion, Extremism and Intolerance - would be a more accurate description of what DEI functionally offers. It demands that we believe things that aren't true and punishes us if we don't.
All those whose jobs have DEI in the title should switch those letters
Love how my comments are hidden. Did i speak truth, YT ????
An Excellent Woman
Brilliant
Good Interview Douglas
Good to be able to listen to two educated, articulate people discuss facts.
Ayàan speaks with utmost clarity on this subject!
Hirsi Ali is one of the few female success stories in islam, she ran from FGM in her home in Somalia, went to Holland where she thought she'd be safe but no and she had to run further to the USA.
She is a hero.
She's an opportunist of the ultimate order. She made up a story to gain status as a refugee in Holland, got put on a pedestal by affirmative action. Turned on a dime against the (socialist) party that promoted her to go their (opportunistic capitalist) opposites, only to be stabbed in the back there by her fellow opportunists.
To hold her up as a paragon of moral virtue is a perfect representation of the current west. I didn't think it could sink any deeper, but openly celebrating an ongoing genocide? come on
Yes she is!
An amazing lady.
She did not have to run to the US!! Nobody is killing people like Hirsi Ali in Holland
She ran away from the Netherlands because her immigration status was problematized on account of her lying on her initial application. It seems Hirschi Ali has a history of gaming the system (saying what people want to hear to curry favor…).
Excellent discussion, thank you both
We need this, Excellent! Thank you Murray and to invite this inteligent lady Hirsi Ali ! This is just à start ... we need cristal clear minds like both of you and put into place Sociaty, Universités, idéologiques.. love this conversation, from France with love❤
We need people who are critical thinkers like Douglas, not people who find information on tik tok.
Critical thinker’s Or upfront racists?
Murray said in many reports Hamas burnt 250 Bodies during their assault against the Zionist government Murray was lying, who said so the IDF said so, by admitting they mis counted the burnt bodies of Palestinians, Douglas Murray lied when in his reporting that Hamas built bunkers under hospitals in Gaza who said so! Ehud Barak said so during a CNN interview with Christiane Amanpour.
Douglas Murray gets away with it because the conservative media is selective about lies.
TikTok Tools.
Thank you for the truth 🙏 ❤
Nice to hear educated people talk about issues in a civil manner.
Imagine people of this intelligence running the U.K. things would be so much better than the ideologues that ignore logic and reason to import so many problems into the nation.
lmaooo... true
Yes, they are educated without being indoctrinated. They are still able to think critically and communicate truth.
Yes, it RARELY happens in the US
It's quite easy to be "civil" when you agree with each other 100%.
Top Lady
She spoke absolute sense
We have all gone mad over the past 7 years !
What a fantastic woman .. 👏🏻
"my grandmother would not trust Claudia Gay to herd her goats" -.............love it!!!!
😂😂
Loved it! 🤩
So good 😂😂❤❤
Equal to any of douglas put downs 😂😂😂❤❤❤
It's a brutal and brilliant joke 🤣🤣, I read it like this: not even someone with a bit of self-preservation 🐑🐏🐑and prudence 😶 would trust a wolf like that. And his violence 😤 was clearly seen when he opened his mouth in front of the microphone🎙️... Oopsss
" mediocre mafia" I'll be using that !
As always a brilliant interview by Douglas
I have read as much as I can of Ms Ali. I think she’s brilliant. But more than that, she is the epitome of courage and grace
She needs to be stripped of her degrees if she cheated via plagiarism to obtain them. There needs to be an investigation.
Fine job, Douglas. You're admired immensely
She was disgrace for university community.
What an amazing lady! Thank you great interview 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
She may have resigned but still there and collecting 900,000
Because she’s qualified, she worked hard to get where she’s. As a child of immigrants, her parents taught her the value of education and her determination put her at the top other than the corrupt politicians who were smearing her reputation
@@annecelestin8534Her published academic output puts her in the bottom 5th percentile of all academics in the US. I know of PhD candidates who have published more before they even defended their thesis. In what world does that make her qualified to be President of supposedly one of the most respected education institutions in the world? The rule of thumb in academia is publish or perish. She barely published enough to get a job as a professor at a community college.
@@annecelestin8534 Hahahahahahaha, good one, hahahahahahaha.
Yes, she should have been fired instead.
Ya right! Honest, hard-working people don’t need to plagiarize other people’s valid work. And she’s a hypocrite for not even acknowledging that calling for genecide is against Harvard’s policies. Everybody knows that if the call for genecide involved any other minority, she and the rest of the woke world would protest loudly. It’s only “free speech” and it only “depends on context” when the angry student mobs call for killing Jews.
I respect Ayaan Hirsi Ali so much! Her book Infidel was amazing. She’s a brilliant and wise woman.
She's so intelligent and articulate.
Ayian is a great person to be interviewed. A truly courageous person who has overcome many things to succeed.
This lady is highly intelligent and speaks so eloquently about where society is headed and how to change things for the better. It was great listening to her.
A new MLK. She speaks wonderfully.
Yeah, SHE should be the new President of Harvard.
President of the USA.
This woman is a true role model to anyone and everyone, i hope she goes from strength to strength
An inspirational woman who has lived and experienced life. Who isn’t prepared to sit back and listen to lazy thinking by people more interested in their jobs from a political standpoint.
Every word is just commonsense. Thanks you
The same people who were appalled by the "injustice" of Gay resigning are the same people who thought that the calling for the murder of millions of people was okay "depending on the context."
What's sad is that she is now both the first african-american woman to be hired by Harvard in that position, and also the worst performing/shortest time worked as just a person. How's that wokeness working out for you Harvard?
Hey, she made history twice!
Claudine Gay is not African American. Claudine Gay is Haitian American.
Great that these two articulate people can speak up for the truth and against the ridiculous.
Frankly, if Harvard feel the need to appoint another Black Woman as President, I think I have just seen Mr. Murray interviewing an excellent candidate.
Douglas is fabulous! He needs his own show! Ayaan is Amazing and so intelligent. We need her to lead the USA education system and straighten it out!
What an intelligent lovely woman
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a person of unparalleled courage and character - a heroine in the truest sense of the word. Her book "The Caged Virgin" was truly eye-opening.
How have I never encountered her before? She's terrific.
Last year, I tried to explain to my nephews that it's bad to copy at school !! Now I'll have to explain him why an expert elite cheater makes $900k a year and every dems are saying it's ok, no problem at all !! This time it's going to be harder to explain this !!
“Douglas, my grandmother would not trust Claudine Gay to herd her goats@😂😂😂
“Harvard, the place where DEI went to die”. Brilliant comment Douglas.
Such a Brilliant Articulate Accomplished woman. God Bless her and Dear Brilliant Douglas Murray for showcasing her and his Amazing eloquent contributions to our world
Is she? It seems she’s not as virtuous as you believe. Read other commenters
You mean the guest on this show is great, right? Not who they are discussing...
@@funvideoperson5268 yes, the guest. Of course
I read Gay's statement when she resigned. Was not surprised when she pulled the " race " card at the end of the statement.
She's a racist who is calling other racist, what an insane topsy-turvy world we live in.
Did she plagiarize it?😅😅😅😅
@@carmenmccauley585 Probably.
From what I read and hear, this had nothing to do with her skin, it was her double talk and acceptance of bullying and discrimination of Jewish students. UNACCEPTABLE. No teacher or president should show favoritism to a certain group of students.
Samuel l Jackson could have done a better job!
It's so very rare to find people who are independent and critical thinkers, who do not conform to, or comply with public opinion or pressure as to what is expected of them think or say! Thank you Douglas and Ayaan, you are a delight to listen to, and I wish there were more people out there like you.
Love Ayaan. She has the scars to prove her real struggles and her real worth. A true person of merit and courage.
It’s great that Douglas is sitting in Mr.Morgans chair
That was beautifully put!! Kudos to that lady
Excellent! Ali and Murray both are absolutely right.
It's actually really rare to see Douglas and someone else in complete agreement and talking sense.
He usually has to deal with complete idiots (expertly, I may add)
I like Aayan Hirsi Ali 👍
This woman talks sense. Not some crybaby " O woe is me"!
A strong, positive female
Its so refreshing to finally see a host who listens and doesn't interrupt every 5 seconds, Doug deserves his own show.
🇺🇸 Agree!
They are debating partners and sing from the same hymn sheet; of course he's not going to challenge her!
@@JC-lu4se Oh please, I’ve watched radical Islamists doing every schoolyard tactic to take away his right to speak and he is still has enough respect to listen to their utter nonsense the man has more patience and integrity than I could hope to have.
Great seeing these two excellent thinkers discussing this.
This lady is very wise.
It's good that Conservatives around the world are finally standing up for themselves. There was a time when that wasn't necessarily so.
Ha!! Not just conservatives! Many on the left, we’ve had enough of this BS! Claudine Gay should be fired totally from Harvard University! She’s been allowed to stay on as a full professor, which means she’s getting a butt-ton of money still from the University. 💩
I don't like to categorize these philosophers / thinkers of our time into left
or right, liberal / conservative. Let the common sense prevail.
This is not a Conservative initiative.
It's common sense
They still get cancelled and ostracised. You never see any on the BBC least of all coloured ones
@@erickoontz6835$900k
God bless this woman and douglas
Douglas, you are a great presenter, not just a great guest. You would also be a great Prime Minister. Please do more of this!
She was there just being at the right time, the right place, the right gender and the right color, nothing more period.
And the "right" sexual preference evidently, she "had it all".
And I am wondering if she also qualifies under her relationship type, anyone know?
You mean the wrong time...
Just like Kamala Harris.
There is something more: She also knew the right people. I understand An ex president got a particular person on the Harvard Board and she was instructed to support Gay for president.
More Ayaan Hirsi Ali please.
Yes, they are two educated, articulate, deep-thinking intellectual. A pleasure to listen to the two of you! Sensible people. Agree wholeheartedly with you both!!!!
I am from GREECE. Me too, celebrate her resignation! She is a desaster!
The way she left truly exposed her - no accountability, no regret. She was definitely not qualified in any way to lead. Busted.
But she will still "teach" there I understand.
These people have zero sense of accountability. It’s always someone else’s fault, that’s why they always fail.
She gets to stay on as a professor, despite all the plagiarism. Nice work if you can get it!
I absolutely love Douglas, especially that cheeky grin he gets when he knows he has won an argument or "poked the bear" 😂
OMG how is it about race when two of the women "targeted" because of their shameful, smug attitude to the antisemitism on their campuses are flipping white 🙄
It is an insult to use the "race card" to cover up her inadequacies but not surprising due to her history of the use of others hard work to promote her status.
Dougie is afraid to debate Dr. Norman Finkelstein
@@truthseeker96who?
@@fanfeck2844 You should just google Norman Finkelstein
@@fanfeck2844a psychopath oddball holding himself out as a historian.
@@truthseeker96 Nope, the other way around. Exposing that fool’s ignorance would be child’s play for Murray.
What a find!! Douglas on his own show with the spokeswoman par excellence ! I live these folks. A couple of beams of light in the darkness of wokeness!
What a wonderful, honest woman! SO CHEERING to hear a sensible, logical, educated voice, sounding out from all the rabble of disingenuous babble that has been forced upon us for years. Thank you. We need you in England. You don't even need to learn the language😀
Such a brilliant inspiring guest and a good news from Harvard finally
What an intelligental young lady. Breath of fresh air to not be a victum.
Amazing woman. It’s so rare to hear this opinion with such a clarity and eloquence.
I love this guy. I had not seen him until recently. Now I see him often. He is succinct in his on point commentary. FACTS matter.
It's a waste of time going to University if you want to be an independent thinker. The Media, film, theatre, TV, politicians and the humanities all think and talk the same. Boring and dangerous at the same time. Get your kids to a start business.
college is declining in USA .both in percentages of ppl going and wanting to go.. a decade ago about 70% of young ppl aspired to going, now its down by more than 10% and falling...
Owning/operating a business isn't for everyone (child of self-employed businessman here). And unfortunately, no one wants to hire without at least a college degree. Trump had the right idea--have businesses take in kids right out of high school. If they want to attend college, they can do so in their spare time as part-time students.
And please if able consider homeschooling during their grade school years!
This lady is brilliant and hits the nail on the head. Look at what the deep rot has done to a beautiful country like South Africa with the people similar to Claudine Gay pulling the race card... Getting a job in SA is based on skin colour and not competence.
Totally agree. The South African government is doing their best to ruin the country and then blame the whites
I cannot look around South Africa with it’s pot holes lack of electricity and water as the result of jobs for friends and not qualification led
All the top experienced white guys were let go and not replaced properly
Instead of training up people we have screwed the country
👍 👌 😂
Add Zimbabwe to the list , now one of the poorest countries in the world , well done the British Government for assisting Mugabe into power.
She should of been fired ffs..she is a disgrace,,why would you want her teaching your kids.
Beautiful people you two, and brilliant minds!!! Thank you!
Hooray! No one sector of society should be "sacrificed" for the sake of another on any basis - race or gender or neurodiversity or any other factor. Merits of hard work, dedication and determination should be rewarded.
a fraud should be punished
A fraud and a raging racist Antisemite!!!!@@docilenation101
What is Neurodiversity? It sounds like a faux word like Ci, ie, a word made up by the same group of people legitimising mental disorders as something we have to accept as normal behaviour?
Who said her papers were good those people men to be investigated
Wow! Refreshing. Hope we can get back to merit. Thank you 🙏
There can never be a context for the wholesale killing of innocent people, Jews or others.
Thank you for the video Mr. Murray.❤
This woman is such a breath of fresh air.
Two of my favorite people in the whole world, together. I admire them so much.
It is absolutely about race. She was appointed because of the colour of her skin, not the content of her character.
Ayaan would have been the correct choice for Harvard President ..... She is a miracle of brilliance
Claudine gay is a big disgrace. Very shameful. Thank god she resigned otherwise she should have been kicked out. This is not about racism but about misconduct.
Absolutely correct, how does she get there in the first place?