excellent video Paddy, but not the one we wait for. you were so tired less energetic you were in Sapa but you did not visit Lao Cai village? common Paddy, you might had a bad incident or something. i agree with downside of Sapa because of theme park look and child forced labor thing. awaiting for more.
Totally understand what you are saying about the working children Paddy. Great video though! Maybe on your next level you could Malaysia 😊. Look forward to your next vid.
I'm currently in Sapa having spent the last 4 days here and you missed the best thing about the area. It's not the town itself which in general is just visited by Vietnamese from other areas such as Hanoi who come for the cooler climate. The real beauty of Sapa is the local villages surrounding the town that make up the Sapa region. And I do not mean Cat Cat village which is also purely a tourist trap. I spent two days trekking with an ethical company who invest in the Hmong tribe, to provide education and a way out of poverty. We trekked through rice fields, met a 95 year old shaman, slept in a local's house and ate with their family. We had a life changing experience and it's a real shame you didn't see that side.
So true... For a more down to earth experience it is the less trodden paths. I wish to travel to that area before it is gone gone... THere are amazing bamboo groves near that area and Laos, which has the most amazing species of bamboo (largest in the world dendrocalamus sinicus, which grows 150 ft in a season). If you take pics.... i love see many.
@@paulcregan4647 All I'm wishing to show to people who have watched the video is that there's a really beautiful countryside around the town that is well worth the visit and to meet the wonderful people who live there, spend time with them and ensure the money spent in the area goes to that need it. Rather than to the town, give money to investors from outside who don't actually contribute to the welfare of the tribes and not actually see the majesty of the area. But naah you thought a snarky comment was in order. Oh and Sa Pa is both the town and the 16 regions surrounding it.
Yes, this is the Sapa I know too! We did the same trekk (well, may not have been the same company) 8 years ago, but did an overnight stay with a family in one of the villages. Always best to keep away from the main tourist areas 😊 although I have to say Sapa appears to have grown from what I’ve seen.
Absolutely agree! I think Paddy expected Sapa to be like Ha Giang Loop. However, they are totally different, which makes Vietnam's landscapes unique. During the wintertime, Sapa looks like a beautifully misty and foggy little town in Europe, but during the summertime, Sapa rice terraces are spectacular and mesmerizing with the bright golden yellow color covering the gigantic mountains. Sapa rice terraces are one of the most beautiful landscapes in Vietnam.
If talking about the most beautiful landscapes in Vietnam, people cannot bypass the stunningly beautiful rice terraces lying on gigantic mountains in Vietnam, especially in Sapa. Possessing 1,000 hectares, Sapa rice terraces particularly Vung Lung Sung field with the famous stair of 121 steps are one of the most amazing landscapes in Vietnam. In Ha Giang, it's best to drive a motorbike to enjoy the breathtaking scenery of the loop, but in Sapa, you have to trek for kilometers of trails between indigenous villages to take in the mesmerizing beauty of Sapa rice terraces. From July to September every year is the best time to visit the stunning bright green rice terraces in Sapa. However, the rice terrace fields reveal their most captivating beauty in the early September when the bright golden yellow rice fields are spectacular and magical completely covering the grandiose mountains under the blue sky. Just like a 3 - 4 day tour of Ha Giang Loop, to enjoy the mesmerizing beauty of Sapa rice terraces requires the same amount of time 3 - 4 days. Just go and see this place ... It's beyond your imagination.
You can actually ride your own bike down some of the trek routes in Sapa given it's a good bike, tho I would not recommend doing that. Accidentally did that in 2020, I got stuck in the middle of nowhere with the views then 2 trekking guys just saw me and be like "whatttt?". Saw some of the local ride into the path & I be like "they can do it, I can do it", well turns out they can, but I can't lol.
Stunning scenery! That being said, I appreciate your honesty and your heart for those children. I would feel the same way. Thank you for sharing your adventures with us and safe travels 🙏💝!
Hmong people usually have a lot of kids, and they can’t make a living just by working on the rice terraces, so Sapa is a good place for them to get some more money from the tourists. If Hmong couples only have 1 or 2 kids, they wouldn’t be in such a difficult situation. Kids working to support their families is a normal thing here. There are poor kids who have to work everywhere in Vietnam, regardless of their ethnicity. You could easily see farmers’ kids helping on the fields or take care of the animals. Children in Vietnam are helping their parents with their home businesses or their food stalls. Even kids in bigger cities have to do household chores or even cook. As long as those kids are going to school, it’s all good. Hmong children gets free education if they go to school. But as you can see, they’re surrounded by mountains, so it’s really hard for them to go to school and back home everyday. Teachers up their really care for the kids and they’re willing to stay at school and take care of them, but it would mean that the kids can’t come home, work and support their families. Of course many of them will choose money over education. And as a result, those kids will follow their parents, get married early and have many kids. If you’re not a Hmong, you will be in j ail for up to 20 years for having s*x with someone who’s under 16. But you can easily see 14, 15-year-old Hmong mothers. The British left India in 1947, and the Indians are still using Ganges River for fishing, irrigation, and bathing. And the river is also swollen with bodies. Cultures and beliefs are extremely hard to change, especially for people from ethnic minorities like the Hmong. We have to be patient and gentle, otherwise they’ll feel like we don’t respect their cultures. There are people from ethnic minorities that are going to school and even in university. The number is increasing steadily. And I believe at least some of them will succeed and become the inspiration for others, and then more and more of them will realize the importance of education. Once they are more educated, they will have more opportunities, either get a proper job in Sapa or work as a tour guide or even open their own homestay business. Our mission is to provide them education but they will be the ones who gets to decide which parts of their cultures should be kept and which ones should be abandoned.
Its a shame you didn't actually go to the villages up in the mountains with the rice paddies and incredible hikes/views. I completely skipped Sapa town and just found myself a super nice homestay in Lao Cai village for a week and it was one of the most beautiful and relaxing times I had in Vietnam. I agree with you about seeing the kids working but unfortunately I think that's just a cultural difference us westerners are lucky enough to not have to do. I'm sure all members of their family are working every day to keep money flowing and I'm sure they are grateful that they at least have the possibility of a tourist town nearby that can provide the villages with more money, albeit not being the best situation.
Was going to be my exact comment! People that loved 'sapa' normally actually mean they loved Lao cai. We only started in sapa town for bussing in and out and the rest of the trip in Lao cai and still after 3 different trips to Vietnam and 6 months living there, Lao cai is a highlight
Hi, what is the name of the homestay you stayed in Lao Cai Village? I'm planning my itinerary now and based on your comments, I will skip Sapa town and head out to the villages. thanks
@@mymotosai5036 Hoang Kim Homestay was the one I chose but there are plenty of good ones to choose from in the villages :) try not to go in down season, it’s more fun when you meet new friends than being alone - enjoy!
“do the Ha Giang loop every day of the week and twice on a Sunday!” outrageous and glad to see your honesty of the heart versus this is great and everything is hunky dory…looking forward to your next vid!
Visiting Sapa, Vietnam, and immersing myself in the vibrant culture of the Hmong tribe was an experience that left a lasting impression on me. From the moment I arrived in this picturesque region nestled in the misty mountains of northern Vietnam, I was captivated by the beauty of the terraced rice paddies, the colorful traditional clothing of the Hmong people, and the warm hospitality of the locals. Exploring the villages of the Hmong tribe allowed me to gain a deeper understanding of their rich traditions and way of life. I was humbled by their strong sense of community, their intricate handicraft skills, and their deep connection to the land. Walking through the lush green fields dotted with wooden houses and meeting with the friendly Hmong people gave me a glimpse into a lifestyle that felt both ancient and enduring. Interacting with the Hmong villagers, trying local delicacies, and participating in traditional activities like batik dyeing, embroidery, and dance performances helped me appreciate the heritage and cultural significance of the Hmong tribe. The genuine smiles, genuine interactions, and genuine bond that I formed with the people made me feel like a part of their community. Moreover, the breathtaking landscapes of Sapa with its terraced rice fields cascading down the mountainside, the fresh mountain air, and the serene beauty of nature all around added to the magic of the experience. Trekking through the hills, visiting waterfalls, and witnessing the simple yet fulfilling way of life in Sapa was truly a rejuvenating and soul-stirring experience. In conclusion, my visit to Sapa and encounter with the Hmong tribe was a deeply rewarding and enriching experience that I would rate highly. The authenticity, the cultural immersion, and the natural beauty of the region left an indelible mark on my heart and mind. If you are seeking a meaningful travel experience that allows you to connect with a unique way of life and appreciate the beauty of Vietnam's countryside, I highly recommend a visit to Sapa and an exploration of the Hmong tribe.
We skipped Sapa town and went on a trek and overnight stay with a local tribe the Red Dao (organised by Phil and Hoa at their amazing company called Ethos based in Sapa) - it was the highlight of our trip to Vietnam! ✨ Anyone heading that way, don't miss it. Loving your vids Pad!
Sapa is anything but strange, it's truly a destination unlike anywhere in the world. Once you cross Sapa Valley on the on Sun World's Cable Car to the top of Fansipan, 10,326 feet, you'll be awestruck by the view and beauty of the area. This part alone is a once in a lifetime experience. Go and enjoy it.
Well... I've visited Sapa (three days) and my impressions were completely different. I didn't even know there was a cable ride and a waterfall close to the village. Imo you didn't show Sapa. Sapa is about hiking through rice fields from village to village. I didn't see one rice field in this video. Still enjoy your videos a lot. But you missed it on this one imo.
The water fall is from the other part of vietnam. He just highlighted and show a few nice destinations in vietnam at the beginning of the video. I don’t think it’s meant to be any where close to sapa
What a shame, Sapa has grown so much since our visit 8 years ago. We didn’t stay in Sapa itself, choosing a two day trek and a nights stay with a family in the rice fields….soo beautiful and something I will never forget. Loving your Vietnam travel Paddy and look forward to each video
Awesome videos, Paddy! The views are truly next level. I have to say, I'm glad you removed the flagpole thingymajig that you glued onto Super Dreamy. It was obscuring the views. Looking forward to the road trip to Ninh Binh.
Yes I agree! I’ve stopped watching a lot of the other TH-camrs as it just looks so fake and inauthentic and like a video put out by the tourism board. So I appreciate your authenticity and your narrative! You’re a great storyteller as well.
I spent 3 months in beautiful Vietnam. I would say Sapa was the only place we were severely harassed, by the locals. Paddy summed this place up really well. I am looking forward to returning in August to ride the Ha Giang Loop. In saying that definitely visit Sapa. We went hiking and saw the local villages. The hike started as a downhill climb through mud to end via a steep incline to reach the peak. My wife and I both fell. If you are over 40 and not fit, active and maybe experience, think twice about going hiking here.
Sapa is nice, bit to touristy for me. Wow, that cable car ride looks scary, had some beautiful views of the mountains. What, I love about you and your channel Paddy, I always leave with a little more knowledge and a bit more educated. Great video! Looking forward to more.
Paddy - I love the fact that you are not afraid to tell it how you see it, even though it may stir some debate with some subscribers. You don't sugar coat everything, which I appreciate. I agree with your sentiment that it may not be the best but still worth a visit to get the full Vietnam experience. Sad about the working kids though, but that's reality.
@Ryan The Hmong in North Vietnam was left untouched by the American war. They were involved in the previous French war, which ended with the battle for Dien Bien Phu valley in 1954. The Hmong in the south bore the brunt of the American war especially for those who chose to join the CIA and the Green Berets to fight against the communists. Visiting a tribe via hiking and live in a tribal home certainly would be a much different experience than riding a modern cable car and staying in touristy western style hostel.
Ahhh thanks Patty. So much for Sapa! I have watched other travel vlogs on Sapa and thought it looked so picturesque and quaint with the French influence BUT I really appreciated your take on the “actual” reality of the experience there. Cheers
Looks like you’re copping it here Paddy! I visited Sapa probably four years ago. Went with a trekking company for two days down through the valley staying in homestays and like everyone said, it was amazing. You’re usually so good at researching places it’s just a shame you missed out on the best that Sapa has to offer. 🤦♂️
Paddy I love your channel and enjoy all your videos but just as I traveled in Italy people try to sell their paintings and things on the street now consider that your in the beautiful country of Vietnam and just as your making money showing their country. The people there are trying to live on a tiny bit of money they receive selling their goods. So it’s kinda of like for like. While I value your honest opinions and feelings while you travel know that I also admire and feel they are a hard working good people and trying to work as you are is not really a negative of Vietnam. It’s more people trying to survive the only way they know that works. Enjoy the rest. Thanks again for sharing. Sapa is a beautiful place hope to visit one day too
I think you are experiencing a culture and generation gap - in the past it was the norm for even the youngest children, 4-5 years old, to help with farm chores. I’m 65, my grandfather didn’t go to high school he started working in a coal mine at 11 years old. My husband’s family was a subsistence living farmers in Romania who immigrated to the US in the 1950’s. My husband was 8 years old when he and his family worked as farm workers in the US harvesting crops. Its still common place and necessary for children in poorer countries to do chores to help their family . This is nothing to get upset about. Some of these traditions are passed down even in well to do families where kids are expected to do some chores - clean their room, help with dinner of the dishes. If you want to help the locals then take a picture with the kids. They are in the same business as you.
Paddy, you've missed out. One of the highlights of our Vietnamese Trip, and one of my travel highlights from anywhere was trekking with a lady (Little Chi) from the Sapa sisters. Staying with a Mong Tribe village etc. An incredible time!!! I'm worried that your slightly sniffy review of Sapa might put others off from going there, and these beautiful people need our tourist support. So anyone reading this, please explore this!!!!
Mike- Thanks for this comment. I always feel so uncomfortable with the hard sells that I probably miss out on great experiences. I appreciate your experience taking one of these tours. This helps me navigate my own feelings and push through to get to something real within the uncomfortability.
If I was traveling there I would take anyones comments ‘with a grain of salt’. I do not base my decisions on another’s experience. Drone shots from sites catch sights others miss, and I pay attention. 🙏🏻❤️
very happy to hear your comment because I am one of the people working in sapa sisters trekking adventure company in sapa i thank you very much for your appreciation. If anyone wants to learn and experience more about Sapa, please contact me for more information . thanks 😘
Love how you’re not afraid of running out of fuel on a deserted backroad in Vietnam (something that would freak out a lot of people!), but a cable car has you quaking! 😂 Really enjoying your videos, it’s really getting me excited for a trip to Vietnam in November 😊!
Very good to see this honest take which can be hard to get from some TH-cam vloggers. This is the information I want and wouldn't stop me going there just good to know these things otherwise it can be a downer. Keep up the good work Paddy.
I agree with Paddy, but also agree you should go to Sapa if you have the time. I know I am going to enjoy the Ha Giang Loop more when I get there in August.
It looks like Sapa town has been designed to look like what a Chinese tourist would expect an ex-French colony to look like. Maybe that's were the theme-park atmosphere comes from.
It has been 21 years since I backpacked solo in Vietnam but from what I have seen from all the various travellers to go there recently is that Sapa has changed the most of any place I had seen before. Almost unrecognizable!!! It was the quietest place in the whole country before. I just went on random hikes out into the countryside with a sugarcane for a walking stick!!Happy Travels Paddy
I was in Sapa then on to Lao Cai back in 1997, when VN 1st opened her door to tourism. Sapa town center was a dirt road, with the weekend market as the highlight of their social activities. I do not even recognize Sapa as the same sleepy town in these travel videos, sadly & I fortunately. It was such a quaint & very charming town, with barely any accommodations but for a few small hotels. I am headed back to Sapa with my daughter in June, and I hope to do the 2,3 day trek through the rice fields with her this time.
I've watched a few of your videos in prep for my tour of the north and this was particularly enlightening. It's good to hear (and see) an honest review of a place, warts 'n' all. Thanks 🤗👍🏼
Hey Paddy, my wife and I, are very obsessed with your Vietnam videos 😅. We are currently in Sapa and we feel the same way you felt, with mixed feelings. And the weather is not helping us either to record our TH-cam videos 😢 Thanks for sharing your journey with us! 😊
Agree with you about the downside of Sapa. I think it is slowly changing into a theme park and losing its charm. I much prefer that time when there was no cable cars it took me 2 days to trek to the Fansipan peak. The sight on the top was almost like this, or even more cloudy, but the mountain views along the trekking paths were the most spectacular. It’s also a sad thing to see more and more kids are forced to make money from tourists by their parents. About 10 years ago, I met 2 little girls selling souvenirs such as handmade bracelets there. They told me they had to walk for many hours every day from their village to get to the town. After a while, one of the girls gave me 2 colorful bracelets but refused to receive money. I asked her if her mother would scold her for not selling anything, and she replied “it’s okay, mom said I could give it as a present to whoever I like”. I was deeply touched, and still keep them with me now.
There's a common misconception about "kids are forced to make money" in Vietnam. Nobody forced them. It's their culture. Kids in Vietnam aren't like kids in other countries like America. The kids are trying to help their parents in many ways they can. They don't play video games or hang around with friends and go to parties. If you watch Paddy's last Ha Giang Loop video in which you can see some kids of 3 or 5 years of age sitting along the road waiting for their parents. Paddy said, "This is Vietnam!" It's the culture that sets one apart from others.
@@allenarthurs2043 I know it’s a part of the culture, and many have to start earning money since young to support their families. But in many cases, the children have to work against their will because their parents control them, not as they don’t have enough to eat or live etc. Kids are always kids, they don’t tell lies to entertain us. If you talk to them, you would understand their stories.
@@maybelles2sun "the children have to work against their will because their parents control them"? Can you prove that? It's because I've been to Vietnam 3 times since 2015. There had been several kids as young as 6 following me around selling little boxes of Wrigley chewing gum when I was at the Ben Thanh Market in Ho Chi Minh City. Surprised and curious, I sat down talking to the kids, and they let me talk to their parents, who said their kids went to school in the morning and sold chewing gum or candies in the afternoon to help their families.
@@samuelclarkton2748 Never experienced such thing in HCMC as you did (maybe because I’m a local to them?!). But from my own experience, them kids never wanted to travel by foot for several hours away from their homes to the Sapa center to sell stuff for tourists at late night under such cold weather. I’m not generalizing them all nor trying to convince you, so let’s just agree to disagree if you find it difficult to believe.
Am very shocked to see so many negative comments here and so many supporting child labour as a cultural right! Child labour is a consequence of extreme poverty and no one in any culture is going to support this as an ideal, except those who benefit from this form of exploitation! Any parent in any culture wants safety, security, health and education for their children and the situation Paddy is illustrating does not provide these things. Please do not romanticise poverty but read the comments here from people living in this region explaining how education, child labour and poverty interact and research what is actually happening in regions you visit then support projects that aim to make education and healthcare more accessible and reduce exploitative labour patterns. Thank you Paddy for your informative episode, and also all the more rural ones you have already made showing other ways of life different from those in this episode.
It's tough. This happens all over the touristy places of SE Asia - I remember it being particularly bad in Cambodia and Myanmar. I would imagine that it's even worse now given the recent state of the world. I feel so bad for those kids just like you do.
I will be going to Sapa in 9 days time, but I pre booked a 4 day trek in the valley allready. This is why you should come to Sapa, not to hang around in the town. Places like Kathmandu in Nepal are the same. You should leave to city as soon as you can and do some trekking in the mountains!!!
25yrs ago it was still a small town and the Hmong people were mostly trying to sell blankets or if you didn't want that they were quite openly selling opium.
Great video fabulous sites. I think the cable car is awesome amazing trip. I think Sapa is an amazing place and with the budget they did a great job with such a beautiful place.
Hi paddy, being school teacher I really appreciate ur concerns, truthfulness experience about d little children from d bottom of my heart buddy ur a courageous traveller, sapa is beautiful there might not b too many places around sapa ,that cable car ride omg seeing itself is dangerous but u did it may god bless u bro nice vlog thnx 👏👍👌🇮🇳🙏
Great Armageddon/Deep Impact reference. Spot on. I had forgotten that those two movies were basically battling it out for best "space rock destroys Earth" movie that summer.
Paddy, you are adoringly entertaining. Even just looking at the photos my legs would wobble so absolutely certainly not going on that long cable car ride. Best of luck with your enviable adventure.
It`s school summer holidays now in VN , so the Hmong kids try to make some money by selling stuffs to the tourists , but they are not allowed to do it during school time . It`s a kind of summer job for them . Only adults are allowed to do it all year long . About the Fansipan , 6 or 7 years ago a young adventurous British guy tried to climb that mountain in solo without a local tour guide `s help . He fell down in a waterfall and died . His girlfriend who stayed in an hotel in town did not even call the police for help . Only after 3 days of absence , she decided finally to ask for help . The Sapa authority had to mobilize over 200 policemen , local volunteers , sniffer dogs and drones to look for him . Unfortunately , after 6 days of search in the jungle , they found his dead body with a broken leg in a ravine next to a waterfall . His father and his uncle flew to Vietnam a few weeks later to repatriate his corpse to the UK . Just want to tell you it`s not easy to escalade alone the roof of Indochina . Be careful and drive safely Paddy , because we do want to watch your full motorbike ride across Vietnam from North to South
Again another very interesting episode. Never been to Sapa so thank you for the tour. I haven't been to Vietnam in years, can you still find high-quality french style pastry and bread? I recall getting fantastic sandwiches made with fresh french style bread often better than in Paris.
Was in Sapa 20 years ago. I loved it. There was hardly a tourist in sight save a few fellow backpackers. The Sapa you experienced I don’t even recognize. Doesn’t even look like the same place.
Paddy, the good news is, there aren’t too many places like what you witnessed in Sapa. Ninh Binh and Tam Coc are stunning, with you all the way mate 🙏🏻🙏🏻
It makes sense now. Sunworld Is also the group that runs Ba Na Hills. Same incredible cable car ride. Same random imitation Europe and theme park ambiance
This is beautiful. Not sure if it's the camera or the way you adjusted but the video is so clear and colorful, it's just like the Hollywood picture. Thanks for the good work and sharing.
Let's see...there are groups called boy scouts and girl scouts in the west selling cookies in front of Walmart or the likes for their affiliations. Nothing new. On the same note, there are a lot of people out there who like touristy places like Disneyland, Vegas, etc. Having a place like Sapa is great for people who are in the nearby countries to experience without having to visit a western country. Things are designed like that for a good reason!
Those boy and girl scouts are raising money for different reasons than mere survival. The money they raise is invested into making the girls more successful and other useful life skills. Those Hmong children are very young and many are not in school because the parents are making them pander to the tourists.
@@doodahgurlie it happens to every country, developed or not. The reality is that there are kids who don't have an opportunity for a better education. It's sad but it's not new. It sucks, but it's reality. Also, we cannot assume the kids are unhappy just because of their action. Plus, not everyone is cut off for education. We should not judge the book by its cover. There are kids on the streets begging for money and not in school in the U.S. My point is it's nothing new. Regardless of who will benefit from the sales, the action is still the same - kids selling stuff on the street unsupervised. I hate to say it, but that's life. Besides, I would think it's an excellent trade skill acquired that education might not be able to provide.
Enjoying your videos as you now travel through Vietnam. Living in Thailand myself it has been very informative as you traveled around. Gave us new places to see ourselves, and I have lived here for over 10 years. Thank you for your professionalism.
Thankyou for your honest review too many people are payed to do a review of things that end up biased because a positive review is payed for. Your channel is amazing i am hooked. Love the honda dreams you should get an oil change chain and sprockets done at a workshop and make a video of how much that costs in Vietnam. I may be wierd but i like that stuff
@Ryan yeah he was just saying he didn’t like seeing kids working the streets alone so young and i agree it’s terrible. Obviously the reason behind this is complex and you seem to know alot more about it than me and probably most people. But as a westerner its a bit hard to see and he didn’t hide it from the camera which is good for viewers wanting to know what a place is like.
One way to avoid the tourist traps and hounding. Don't get off the bike. 😂. I've been to sapa twice. Thoroughly enjoyed every moment of it. Partly because i don't have a motorbike license and sapa is really safe to ride a scooter. But i would recommend it only if you're good at cycling. For me sapa is the perfect place for a non planner like myself. Heck you can book your accommodation on the day you arrive. Tons and tons of cheap accommodations from home stays to eco lodges.. From the train to the buses. Everything can be done in the spur of the moment. even my scooter was just a random boy riding pass me and asking if i need a ride. Dont be afriad to say no if you think the deal sucks. But don't be afriad to say yes too! You'll be met with many plesant surprises! Many tried to push samples down my throat. I just take them and if it stinks i won't hesitate to not pay a single cent for it.. but on one encounter. I tried an authentic hmong apple fruit wine. Its the most amazing drink. And its only 100,000 dong ($4usd) per bottle and very nicely packed. I bought a dozen of them and it made one of the best souvenirs ever. From Paddy Field trekking to crazy glass bridges (100 times scarier than fansipan but 1hr away) Sapa never fails to disappoint. Who knows i might come back the third time. (;
These children live in villages far from town (sometimes they have to walk for 3-4 days), it is sad to see the children have to participate in making money. Partly because of the views of the Hmong, they give birth a lot (have a family of more than 10 children) and the way to raise a family at the present time cannot be enough just to grow crops and go to the forest to hunt... and the resort is how these kids feed themselves and help their parents
But giving them money or buying stuff from them will encourage that behavior and the cycle will continue. Don't buy from them and don't give them money so they girls can stay in school and get an education.
@@doodahgurlie Have you ever been to a remote village in the northern mountains? Each family group in the clan (5-7 families) lives in a large mountain, and only a few groups or dozens of groups have a school. To get to school you have to go from the top of the mountain to the valley and cross the trail, climb another mountain (sometimes 2 3 peaks) to reach the school. I've been to Sapa and participated in trekking in the villages.... and it's really hard for them to go to school at the moment!!!
@@doodahgurlie The only option is to stay at school. Schools up there are free. And there’s teachers who are staying at school and taking care of the students. But it’s really difficult because many of the kids have to help their families since Hmong parents usually have a lot of children. And if they don’t go to school, they’ll probably end up getting married at an early age and having many children.
We actually did hike Fansipan and took us 2 long and painful days 😂😂 it was INTENSE to say the least but the view was stunning❤️ but yea we felt the same with the kids when we visited. We also visited back in April so some people haven’t seen tourists in years and we had so many Hmong women all over us and even had a day where one wouldn’t leave us alone for 3 hours. So yea I’d recommend only driving through sapa town 😂
I think if you want to enjoy SaPa you should stay away from the town and go to one of the villages on the slopes of the mountain. I stayed in TaVan and it was great. Really beautiful, so peaceful and no busses/trucks and noisy restaurants. While SaPa town is just too crowded and noisy. And the views from it are not the best, you just have get further away from it.
yes awful cheesy Sapa, you got it but you are more diplomatic, Ninh Binh on the other hand is spectacular and more authentic when i was there 6 years ago, breathtaking, awesome video again bravo
Hi Paddy loving the videos.been watching for a month now. I was in Thailand back in June. I’m back in October for 2 weeks, then again at Christmas for 3 weeks. Unfortunately I can’t move there like you, but the videos really entertain me, and inspire me to reach my goal of eventually moving to Thailand.
Great to see Sapa and sad to see your bad experience..I was there 4 years ago and it wasn't like that and makes me sad to see those beautiful kids doing that..anyway the best is yet to came Paddy enjoy
Although it is sad to see young kids working in those conditions, we all have to remember that their situation would be much worse without the money they do make from being out there. We live a cushy life compared to them so we see it as a sad thing but this is their reality. You have a good heart Paddy. Thanks for what you do.
@@socialsuicide68 child labour was abolished many years ago. Maybe you need to be transported back to that time, be a child and be made to work. Worst comment ever written online.
@@steveth1000 The harsh reality dictates the action. I am sure if they have choice kids would like to be kids....but when they are born into poverty and have no choice it is just the way of life. Abolishing child labor is wonderful and noble effort only when it is truly put into action instead of just verbal judgment. It is similar to the hypocrites in America who crow about pro-life to ban abortion but none of them would want to shed a dime from their pocket to help feed and raise an unfortunate child who is brought into this world unwanted.
So sad to see how sapa has changed in twenty years. When I was there with my x partner we were two of probably less than a fifty tourists in the town. The streets were gravel no power in sapa in the day time. I remember asking why the power didn't work in the hotel and she just said no power in sapa. It became a joke between us when we ever got a power cut. We would just say no power in sapa. We did go trekking with one of the local mon girls who was great and stayed in amazing place in the mountains. But it's not going to be the same now. I fully understand with everything you said at the end. And I didn't recognise anything in the town at all. Very sad 😔
I was in Sapa in Dec 2008. Did a lovely hike, but I can't recognize the town in any way. Scenery still stunning though, but a lot more crowded. I totally get your point about being put off by the people trying to sell you something.
Paddy over 10,000 feet up and riding in a cable car. All I could think was, "Too bad his friend isn't there to force him into zip lining again." Thanks for taking us along.
![F.HERO Ft. JSPKK x ลำไย ไหทองคำ x M-PEE - ไม่สนิทบิดหมด (Thai Riders Anthem) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kPJZ0UihBfk/mqdefault.jpg)
More videos from Vietnam every 3 days this summer! Perfect time to SUBSCRIBE ✌
excellent video Paddy, but not the one we wait for. you were so tired less energetic you were in Sapa but you did not visit Lao Cai village? common Paddy, you might had a bad incident or something. i agree with downside of Sapa because of theme park look and child forced labor thing.
awaiting for more.
Have a nice day in Sapa.enjoy the views great journey.Paddy
Totally understand what you are saying about the working children Paddy. Great video though! Maybe on your next level you could Malaysia 😊. Look forward to your next vid.
Paddy whats the situation with the drone, I'm planning a trip there and want to bring my dji?
I'm currently in Sapa having spent the last 4 days here and you missed the best thing about the area. It's not the town itself which in general is just visited by Vietnamese from other areas such as Hanoi who come for the cooler climate. The real beauty of Sapa is the local villages surrounding the town that make up the Sapa region. And I do not mean Cat Cat village which is also purely a tourist trap. I spent two days trekking with an ethical company who invest in the Hmong tribe, to provide education and a way out of poverty. We trekked through rice fields, met a 95 year old shaman, slept in a local's house and ate with their family. We had a life changing experience and it's a real shame you didn't see that side.
So true... For a more down to earth experience it is the less trodden paths. I wish to travel to that area before it is gone gone... THere are amazing bamboo groves near that area and Laos, which has the most amazing species of bamboo (largest in the world dendrocalamus sinicus, which grows 150 ft in a season). If you take pics.... i love see many.
He did a video on Sapa not the surrounding villages of Sapa. Well done for spending a few days there though, you’re almost a local yourself
@@paulcregan4647
All I'm wishing to show to people who have watched the video is that there's a really beautiful countryside around the town that is well worth the visit and to meet the wonderful people who live there, spend time with them and ensure the money spent in the area goes to that need it. Rather than to the town, give money to investors from outside who don't actually contribute to the welfare of the tribes and not actually see the majesty of the area. But naah you thought a snarky comment was in order.
Oh and Sa Pa is both the town and the 16 regions surrounding it.
Yes, this is the Sapa I know too! We did the same trekk (well, may not have been the same company) 8 years ago, but did an overnight stay with a family in one of the villages. Always best to keep away from the main tourist areas 😊 although I have to say Sapa appears to have grown from what I’ve seen.
Absolutely agree! I think Paddy expected Sapa to be like Ha Giang Loop. However, they are totally different, which makes Vietnam's landscapes unique. During the wintertime, Sapa looks like a beautifully misty and foggy little town in Europe, but during the summertime, Sapa rice terraces are spectacular and mesmerizing with the bright golden yellow color covering the gigantic mountains. Sapa rice terraces are one of the most beautiful landscapes in Vietnam.
If talking about the most beautiful landscapes in Vietnam, people cannot bypass the stunningly beautiful rice terraces lying on gigantic mountains in Vietnam, especially in Sapa. Possessing 1,000 hectares, Sapa rice terraces particularly Vung Lung Sung field with the famous stair of 121 steps are one of the most amazing landscapes in Vietnam. In Ha Giang, it's best to drive a motorbike to enjoy the breathtaking scenery of the loop, but in Sapa, you have to trek for kilometers of trails between indigenous villages to take in the mesmerizing beauty of Sapa rice terraces. From July to September every year is the best time to visit the stunning bright green rice terraces in Sapa. However, the rice terrace fields reveal their most captivating beauty in the early September when the bright golden yellow rice fields are spectacular and magical completely covering the grandiose mountains under the blue sky. Just like a 3 - 4 day tour of Ha Giang Loop, to enjoy the mesmerizing beauty of Sapa rice terraces requires the same amount of time 3 - 4 days. Just go and see this place ... It's beyond your imagination.
You can actually ride your own bike down some of the trek routes in Sapa given it's a good bike, tho I would not recommend doing that. Accidentally did that in 2020, I got stuck in the middle of nowhere with the views then 2 trekking guys just saw me and be like "whatttt?". Saw some of the local ride into the path & I be like "they can do it, I can do it", well turns out they can, but I can't lol.
Stunning scenery! That being said, I appreciate your honesty and your heart for those children. I would feel the same way. Thank you for sharing your adventures with us and safe travels 🙏💝!
Hmong people usually have a lot of kids, and they can’t make a living just by working on the rice terraces, so Sapa is a good place for them to get some more money from the tourists. If Hmong couples only have 1 or 2 kids, they wouldn’t be in such a difficult situation.
Kids working to support their families is a normal thing here. There are poor kids who have to work everywhere in Vietnam, regardless of their ethnicity. You could easily see farmers’ kids helping on the fields or take care of the animals. Children in Vietnam are helping their parents with their home businesses or their food stalls. Even kids in bigger cities have to do household chores or even cook. As long as those kids are going to school, it’s all good.
Hmong children gets free education if they go to school. But as you can see, they’re surrounded by mountains, so it’s really hard for them to go to school and back home everyday. Teachers up their really care for the kids and they’re willing to stay at school and take care of them, but it would mean that the kids can’t come home, work and support their families. Of course many of them will choose money over education. And as a result, those kids will follow their parents, get married early and have many kids. If you’re not a Hmong, you will be in j ail for up to 20 years for having s*x with someone who’s under 16. But you can easily see 14, 15-year-old Hmong mothers. The British left India in 1947, and the Indians are still using Ganges River for fishing, irrigation, and bathing. And the river is also swollen with bodies. Cultures and beliefs are extremely hard to change, especially for people from ethnic minorities like the Hmong. We have to be patient and gentle, otherwise they’ll feel like we don’t respect their cultures.
There are people from ethnic minorities that are going to school and even in university. The number is increasing steadily. And I believe at least some of them will succeed and become the inspiration for others, and then more and more of them will realize the importance of education. Once they are more educated, they will have more opportunities, either get a proper job in Sapa or work as a tour guide or even open their own homestay business. Our mission is to provide them education but they will be the ones who gets to decide which parts of their cultures should be kept and which ones should be abandoned.
Very well said!! Tourists need to be more aware and be more educated about the culture of the country they are visiting. Peace out 🥰
Its a shame you didn't actually go to the villages up in the mountains with the rice paddies and incredible hikes/views. I completely skipped Sapa town and just found myself a super nice homestay in Lao Cai village for a week and it was one of the most beautiful and relaxing times I had in Vietnam. I agree with you about seeing the kids working but unfortunately I think that's just a cultural difference us westerners are lucky enough to not have to do. I'm sure all members of their family are working every day to keep money flowing and I'm sure they are grateful that they at least have the possibility of a tourist town nearby that can provide the villages with more money, albeit not being the best situation.
Was going to be my exact comment! People that loved 'sapa' normally actually mean they loved Lao cai. We only started in sapa town for bussing in and out and the rest of the trip in Lao cai and still after 3 different trips to Vietnam and 6 months living there, Lao cai is a highlight
exactly!
Hi, what is the name of the homestay you stayed in Lao Cai Village? I'm planning my itinerary now and based on your comments, I will skip Sapa town and head out to the villages. thanks
@@mymotosai5036 Hoang Kim Homestay was the one I chose but there are plenty of good ones to choose from in the villages :) try not to go in down season, it’s more fun when you meet new friends than being alone - enjoy!
How quickly people forget kids in the west used to work as well until maybe the 40's/50's?
The Sapa Town is touristic. Outside in the hills and mountains is refreshing with the view of rice terraces and tea growing sides.
“do the Ha Giang loop every day of the week and twice on a Sunday!” outrageous and glad to see your honesty of the heart versus this is great and everything is hunky dory…looking forward to your next vid!
Visiting Sapa, Vietnam, and immersing myself in the vibrant culture of the Hmong tribe was an experience that left a lasting impression on me. From the moment I arrived in this picturesque region nestled in the misty mountains of northern Vietnam, I was captivated by the beauty of the terraced rice paddies, the colorful traditional clothing of the Hmong people, and the warm hospitality of the locals.
Exploring the villages of the Hmong tribe allowed me to gain a deeper understanding of their rich traditions and way of life. I was humbled by their strong sense of community, their intricate handicraft skills, and their deep connection to the land. Walking through the lush green fields dotted with wooden houses and meeting with the friendly Hmong people gave me a glimpse into a lifestyle that felt both ancient and enduring.
Interacting with the Hmong villagers, trying local delicacies, and participating in traditional activities like batik dyeing, embroidery, and dance performances helped me appreciate the heritage and cultural significance of the Hmong tribe. The genuine smiles, genuine interactions, and genuine bond that I formed with the people made me feel like a part of their community.
Moreover, the breathtaking landscapes of Sapa with its terraced rice fields cascading down the mountainside, the fresh mountain air, and the serene beauty of nature all around added to the magic of the experience. Trekking through the hills, visiting waterfalls, and witnessing the simple yet fulfilling way of life in Sapa was truly a rejuvenating and soul-stirring experience.
In conclusion, my visit to Sapa and encounter with the Hmong tribe was a deeply rewarding and enriching experience that I would rate highly. The authenticity, the cultural immersion, and the natural beauty of the region left an indelible mark on my heart and mind. If you are seeking a meaningful travel experience that allows you to connect with a unique way of life and appreciate the beauty of Vietnam's countryside, I highly recommend a visit to Sapa and an exploration of the Hmong tribe.
WOW, your talent with prose! TY for this "essay".
Weird how experiences are different.. I found it like a theme park in the mountains. Not enjoyable
cant rmember composing this .. must have been hacked by chat …
We skipped Sapa town and went on a trek and overnight stay with a local tribe the Red Dao (organised by Phil and Hoa at their amazing company called Ethos based in Sapa) - it was the highlight of our trip to Vietnam! ✨ Anyone heading that way, don't miss it. Loving your vids Pad!
Thank you so much for the tip!!
Thanks for recommending us :)
Sapa is anything but strange, it's truly a destination unlike anywhere in the world. Once you cross Sapa Valley on the on Sun World's Cable Car to the top of Fansipan, 10,326 feet, you'll be awestruck by the view and beauty of the area. This part alone is a once in a lifetime experience. Go and enjoy it.
The views R absolutely insane Paddy, good job 👍🏻😉👋
Well... I've visited Sapa (three days) and my impressions were completely different. I didn't even know there was a cable ride and a waterfall close to the village. Imo you didn't show Sapa. Sapa is about hiking through rice fields from village to village. I didn't see one rice field in this video. Still enjoy your videos a lot. But you missed it on this one imo.
The water fall is from the other part of vietnam. He just highlighted and show a few nice destinations in vietnam at the beginning of the video. I don’t think it’s meant to be any where close to sapa
@@hp4415wrong... he was talking about Silver waterfall that is 5min from sapa
What a shame, Sapa has grown so much since our visit 8 years ago. We didn’t stay in Sapa itself, choosing a two day trek and a nights stay with a family in the rice fields….soo beautiful and something I will never forget. Loving your Vietnam travel Paddy and look forward to each video
Awesome videos, Paddy! The views are truly next level. I have to say, I'm glad you removed the flagpole thingymajig that you glued onto Super Dreamy. It was obscuring the views. Looking forward to the road trip to Ninh Binh.
THE INTRO DRONE SHOT IS PHENOMENAL !! Vietnam is sooo breathtaking! Love from Thailand 🇹🇭🙏❤️
Always be honest and transparent with your experiences. It’s so easy to sugarcoat everything as a TH-camr. Much love ✨💛
Always!
Yes I agree! I’ve stopped watching a lot of the other TH-camrs as it just looks so fake and inauthentic and like a video put out by the tourism board. So I appreciate your authenticity and your narrative! You’re a great storyteller as well.
You basically summed up Sapa perfectly! We were there 4 years ago and we had the exact some thoughts / feelings ☹️
I spent 3 months in beautiful Vietnam. I would say Sapa was the only place we were severely harassed, by the locals. Paddy summed this place up really well. I am looking forward to returning in August to ride the Ha Giang Loop. In saying that definitely visit Sapa. We went hiking and saw the local villages. The hike started as a downhill climb through mud to end via a steep incline to reach the peak. My wife and I both fell. If you are over 40 and not fit, active and maybe experience, think twice about going hiking here.
Sapa is nice, bit to touristy for me. Wow, that cable car ride looks scary, had some beautiful views of the mountains. What, I love about you and your channel Paddy, I always leave with a little more knowledge and a bit more educated. Great video! Looking forward to more.
Glad you enjoyed
@@PaddyDoyle.
Name of the magnificent big French building at Sapa?
Paddy - I love the fact that you are not afraid to tell it how you see it, even though it may stir some debate with some subscribers. You don't sugar coat everything, which I appreciate. I agree with your sentiment that it may not be the best but still worth a visit to get the full Vietnam experience. Sad about the working kids though, but that's reality.
@Ryan The Hmong in North Vietnam was left untouched by the American war. They were involved in the previous French war, which ended with the battle for Dien Bien Phu valley in 1954. The Hmong in the south bore the brunt of the American war especially for those who chose to join the CIA and the Green Berets to fight against the communists.
Visiting a tribe via hiking and live in a tribal home certainly would be a much different experience than riding a modern cable car and staying in touristy western style hostel.
Ahhh thanks Patty. So much for Sapa! I have watched other travel vlogs on Sapa and thought it looked so picturesque and quaint with the French influence BUT I really appreciated your take on the “actual” reality of the experience there. Cheers
Looks like you’re copping it here Paddy! I visited Sapa probably four years ago. Went with a trekking company for two days down through the valley staying in homestays and like everyone said, it was amazing. You’re usually so good at researching places it’s just a shame you missed out on the best that Sapa has to offer. 🤦♂️
He was a bit of a twat in this video.
Paddy I love your channel and enjoy all your videos but just as I traveled in Italy people try to sell their paintings and things on the street now consider that your in the beautiful country of Vietnam and just as your making money showing their country. The people there are trying to live on a tiny bit of money they receive selling their goods. So it’s kinda of like for like. While I value your honest opinions and feelings while you travel know that I also admire and feel they are a hard working good people and trying to work as you are is not really a negative of Vietnam. It’s more people trying to survive the only way they know that works. Enjoy the rest. Thanks again for sharing. Sapa is a beautiful place hope to visit one day too
I think you are experiencing a culture and generation gap - in the past it was the norm for even the youngest children, 4-5 years old, to help with farm chores. I’m 65, my grandfather didn’t go to high school he started working in a coal mine at 11 years old. My husband’s family was a subsistence living farmers in Romania who immigrated to the US in the 1950’s. My husband was 8 years old when he and his family worked as farm workers in the US harvesting crops. Its still common place and necessary for children in poorer countries to do chores to help their family . This is nothing to get upset about. Some of these traditions are passed down even in well to do families where kids are expected to do some chores - clean their room, help with dinner of the dishes. If you want to help the locals then take a picture with the kids. They are in the same business as you.
I can’t believe how sapa has changed. I was there 17 years ago. It was a small village.
Paddy, you've missed out. One of the highlights of our Vietnamese Trip, and one of my travel highlights from anywhere was trekking with a lady (Little Chi) from the Sapa sisters. Staying with a Mong Tribe village etc. An incredible time!!!
I'm worried that your slightly sniffy review of Sapa might put others off from going there, and these beautiful people need our tourist support. So anyone reading this, please explore this!!!!
Mike- Thanks for this comment. I always feel so uncomfortable with the hard sells that I probably miss out on great experiences. I appreciate your experience taking one of these tours. This helps me navigate my own feelings and push through to get to something real within the uncomfortability.
If I was traveling there I would take anyones comments ‘with a grain of salt’. I do not base my decisions on another’s experience. Drone shots from sites catch sights others miss, and I pay attention. 🙏🏻❤️
very happy to hear your comment because I am one of the people working in sapa sisters trekking adventure company in sapa i thank you very much for your appreciation. If anyone wants to learn and experience more about Sapa, please contact me for more information . thanks 😘
@@lindabuck2777 unfortunately lot of people use other people reviews to decide where they want to travel to
Sapa will be the most beautiful in winter, it's too bad if I don't go there in November, lol
Yeap ! Snow falls in September . But sapa 's beauty in summer and spring with out cloud
Love how you’re not afraid of running out of fuel on a deserted backroad in Vietnam (something that would freak out a lot of people!), but a cable car has you quaking! 😂 Really enjoying your videos, it’s really getting me excited for a trip to Vietnam in November 😊!
Very good to see this honest take which can be hard to get from some TH-cam vloggers. This is the information I want and wouldn't stop me going there just good to know these things otherwise it can be a downer. Keep up the good work Paddy.
I agree with Paddy, but also agree you should go to Sapa if you have the time. I know I am going to enjoy the Ha Giang Loop more when I get there in August.
It looks like Sapa town has been designed to look like what a Chinese tourist would expect an ex-French colony to look like. Maybe that's were the theme-park atmosphere comes from.
It has been 21 years since I backpacked solo in Vietnam but from what I have seen from all the various travellers to go there recently is that Sapa has changed the most of any place I had seen before. Almost unrecognizable!!! It was the quietest place in the whole country before. I just went on random hikes out into the countryside with a sugarcane for a walking stick!!Happy Travels Paddy
I agree so different than 15 years ago, so glad I got to see it then.
I was in Sapa then on to Lao Cai back in 1997, when VN 1st opened her door to tourism. Sapa town center was a dirt road, with the weekend market as the highlight of their social activities. I do not even recognize Sapa as the same sleepy town in these travel videos, sadly & I fortunately. It was such a quaint & very charming town, with barely any accommodations but for a few small hotels. I am headed back to Sapa with my daughter in June, and I hope to do the 2,3 day trek through the rice fields with her this time.
Old Paddy getting a bit grim on his travels. Haha nah we understand as everywhere has its pros and cons!
It's your heart and honesty that keep me watching, thanks for being you. Oh and for always being as scared of heights as me!!!
I actually preferred Deep Impact.... and didn't mind Sapa when I went there years ago.
The "to be continued" clips were very gorgeous , love how u review Sapa honestly , looķing forward to the famous Nin Binh vlog..
I've watched a few of your videos in prep for my tour of the north and this was particularly enlightening. It's good to hear (and see) an honest review of a place, warts 'n' all. Thanks 🤗👍🏼
Going into the mountains however is stunning. Stayed at a homestay with a family and was wonderful. A real highlight, the meal was utterly magnificent
Hey Paddy, my wife and I, are very obsessed with your Vietnam videos 😅.
We are currently in Sapa and we feel the same way you felt, with mixed feelings.
And the weather is not helping us either to record our TH-cam videos 😢
Thanks for sharing your journey with us! 😊
Agree with you about the downside of Sapa. I think it is slowly changing into a theme park and losing its charm. I much prefer that time when there was no cable cars it took me 2 days to trek to the Fansipan peak. The sight on the top was almost like this, or even more cloudy, but the mountain views along the trekking paths were the most spectacular.
It’s also a sad thing to see more and more kids are forced to make money from tourists by their parents. About 10 years ago, I met 2 little girls selling souvenirs such as handmade bracelets there. They told me they had to walk for many hours every day from their village to get to the town. After a while, one of the girls gave me 2 colorful bracelets but refused to receive money. I asked her if her mother would scold her for not selling anything, and she replied “it’s okay, mom said I could give it as a present to whoever I like”. I was deeply touched, and still keep them with me now.
There's a common misconception about "kids are forced to make money" in Vietnam. Nobody forced them. It's their culture. Kids in Vietnam aren't like kids in other countries like America. The kids are trying to help their parents in many ways they can. They don't play video games or hang around with friends and go to parties. If you watch Paddy's last Ha Giang Loop video in which you can see some kids of 3 or 5 years of age sitting along the road waiting for their parents. Paddy said, "This is Vietnam!" It's the culture that sets one apart from others.
@@allenarthurs2043 I know it’s a part of the culture, and many have to start earning money since young to support their families. But in many cases, the children have to work against their will because their parents control them, not as they don’t have enough to eat or live etc. Kids are always kids, they don’t tell lies to entertain us. If you talk to them, you would understand their stories.
@@maybelles2sun "the children have to work against their will because their parents control them"? Can you prove that? It's because I've been to Vietnam 3 times since 2015. There had been several kids as young as 6 following me around selling little boxes of Wrigley chewing gum when I was at the Ben Thanh Market in Ho Chi Minh City. Surprised and curious, I sat down talking to the kids, and they let me talk to their parents, who said their kids went to school in the morning and sold chewing gum or candies in the afternoon to help their families.
@@maybelles2sun what did you expect in communist country, human rights or kid education system ,they have no other choice.
@@samuelclarkton2748 Never experienced such thing in HCMC as you did (maybe because I’m a local to them?!). But from my own experience, them kids never wanted to travel by foot for several hours away from their homes to the Sapa center to sell stuff for tourists at late night under such cold weather. I’m not generalizing them all nor trying to convince you, so let’s just agree to disagree if you find it difficult to believe.
Am very shocked to see so many negative comments here and so many supporting child labour as a cultural right! Child labour is a consequence of extreme poverty and no one in any culture is going to support this as an ideal, except those who benefit from this form of exploitation! Any parent in any culture wants safety, security, health and education for their children and the situation Paddy is illustrating does not provide these things. Please do not romanticise poverty but read the comments here from people living in this region explaining how education, child labour and poverty interact and research what is actually happening in regions you visit then support projects that aim to make education and healthcare more accessible and reduce exploitative labour patterns. Thank you Paddy for your informative episode, and also all the more rural ones you have already made showing other ways of life different from those in this episode.
❤❤
It's tough. This happens all over the touristy places of SE Asia - I remember it being particularly bad in Cambodia and Myanmar. I would imagine that it's even worse now given the recent state of the world. I feel so bad for those kids just like you do.
So true!
It's their culture, and the kids seemed to be fine.
Thank you for sharing this. Been looking for info about Sapa. Hoping this year, I could visit it.
Wow Vietnam are beautiful country ❤️🙏
I will be going to Sapa in 9 days time, but I pre booked a 4 day trek in the valley allready. This is why you should come to Sapa, not to hang around in the town. Places like Kathmandu in Nepal are the same. You should leave to city as soon as you can and do some trekking in the mountains!!!
25yrs ago it was still a small town and the Hmong people were mostly trying to sell blankets or if you didn't want that they were quite openly selling opium.
Great video fabulous sites. I think the cable car is awesome amazing trip. I think Sapa is an amazing place and with the budget they did a great job with such a beautiful place.
Hi paddy, being school teacher I really appreciate ur concerns, truthfulness experience about d little children from d bottom of my heart buddy ur a courageous traveller, sapa is beautiful there might not b too many places around sapa ,that cable car ride omg seeing itself is dangerous but u did it may god bless u bro nice vlog thnx 👏👍👌🇮🇳🙏
Great Armageddon/Deep Impact reference. Spot on. I had forgotten that those two movies were basically battling it out for best "space rock destroys Earth" movie that summer.
I concur!
I'm Thai Sapa is one of my point that I'll visit in the future.
I Definitely will visit this place for my holidays in Vietnam.
Paddy, you are adoringly entertaining. Even just looking at the photos my legs would wobble so absolutely certainly not going on that long cable car ride. Best of luck with your enviable adventure.
wow beautiful landscapes
Ninh Binh is beautiful, less touristy and definitely worth checking out. When I was there it was compared to an Inland Ha Long Bay.
It`s school summer holidays now in VN , so the Hmong kids try to make some money by selling stuffs to the tourists , but they are not allowed to do it during school time . It`s a kind of summer job for them . Only adults are allowed to do it all year long . About the Fansipan , 6 or 7 years ago a young adventurous British guy tried to climb that mountain in solo without a local tour guide `s help . He fell down in a waterfall and died . His girlfriend who stayed in an hotel in town did not even call the police for help . Only after 3 days of absence , she decided finally to ask for help . The Sapa authority had to mobilize over 200 policemen , local volunteers , sniffer dogs and drones to look for him . Unfortunately , after 6 days of search in the jungle , they found his dead body with a broken leg in a ravine next to a waterfall . His father and his uncle flew to Vietnam a few weeks later to repatriate his corpse to the UK . Just want to tell you it`s not easy to escalade alone the roof of Indochina .
Be careful and drive safely Paddy , because we do want to watch your full motorbike ride across Vietnam from North to South
Thanks for your honesty! I just subscribed. No Sapa for me. Can't wait to see Ninh Binh in your next video!
Stunning sceneries. Thanks for your video.
Again another very interesting episode. Never been to Sapa so thank you for the tour. I haven't been to Vietnam in years, can you still find high-quality french style pastry and bread? I recall getting fantastic sandwiches made with fresh french style bread often better than in Paris.
Was in Sapa 20 years ago. I loved it. There was hardly a tourist in sight save a few fellow backpackers. The Sapa you experienced I don’t even recognize. Doesn’t even look like the same place.
Another great experience Paddy! Thanks for allowing us all to experience this vicariously through you. Beautiful!
You are so funny… I love how you narrate your experiences in Sapa.. I never laughed so hard to a video
Paddy, the good news is, there aren’t too many places like what you witnessed in Sapa. Ninh Binh and Tam Coc are stunning, with you all the way mate 🙏🏻🙏🏻
It makes sense now. Sunworld Is also the group that runs Ba Na Hills. Same incredible cable car ride. Same random imitation Europe and theme park ambiance
Cảm ơn bạn đã chia sẻ về đất nước việt nam chúng tôi ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ chúc bạn có những trải nghiệm thú vị ở Việt Nam
This is beautiful. Not sure if it's the camera or the way you adjusted but the video is so clear and colorful, it's just like the Hollywood picture. Thanks for the good work and sharing.
Let's see...there are groups called boy scouts and girl scouts in the west selling cookies in front of Walmart or the likes for their affiliations. Nothing new. On the same note, there are a lot of people out there who like touristy places like Disneyland, Vegas, etc. Having a place like Sapa is great for people who are in the nearby countries to experience without having to visit a western country. Things are designed like that for a good reason!
Those boy and girl scouts are raising money for different reasons than mere survival. The money they raise is invested into making the girls more successful and other useful life skills. Those Hmong children are very young and many are not in school because the parents are making them pander to the tourists.
@@doodahgurlie it happens to every country, developed or not. The reality is that there are kids who don't have an opportunity for a better education. It's sad but it's not new. It sucks, but it's reality. Also, we cannot assume the kids are unhappy just because of their action. Plus, not everyone is cut off for education. We should not judge the book by its cover. There are kids on the streets begging for money and not in school in the U.S. My point is it's nothing new. Regardless of who will benefit from the sales, the action is still the same - kids selling stuff on the street unsupervised. I hate to say it, but that's life. Besides, I would think it's an excellent trade skill acquired that education might not be able to provide.
Enjoying your videos as you now travel through Vietnam. Living in Thailand myself it has been very informative as you traveled around. Gave us new places to see ourselves, and I have lived here for over 10 years. Thank you for your professionalism.
Mount Teide 3,715m Tenerife. You can drive through the clouds ,cable care up the final bit
Thankyou for your honest review too many people are payed to do a review of things that end up biased because a positive review is payed for. Your channel is amazing i am hooked. Love the honda dreams you should get an oil change chain and sprockets done at a workshop and make a video of how much that costs in Vietnam. I may be wierd but i like that stuff
@Ryan yeah he was just saying he didn’t like seeing kids working the streets alone so young and i agree it’s terrible. Obviously the reason behind this is complex and you seem to know alot more about it than me and probably most people. But as a westerner its a bit hard to see and he didn’t hide it from the camera which is good for viewers wanting to know what a place is like.
Thanks for amazing video. Keep up good works. Even I am Vietnamese, haven't got chances to go to these beautiful places in my own country.
Your videos are so brilliant...Sapa not my cupatea...tourism gone mad, but you sharing your experience is appreciated
One way to avoid the tourist traps and hounding. Don't get off the bike. 😂. I've been to sapa twice. Thoroughly enjoyed every moment of it. Partly because i don't have a motorbike license and sapa is really safe to ride a scooter. But i would recommend it only if you're good at cycling. For me sapa is the perfect place for a non planner like myself. Heck you can book your accommodation on the day you arrive. Tons and tons of cheap accommodations from home stays to eco lodges.. From the train to the buses. Everything can be done in the spur of the moment. even my scooter was just a random boy riding pass me and asking if i need a ride. Dont be afriad to say no if you think the deal sucks. But don't be afriad to say yes too! You'll be met with many plesant surprises! Many tried to push samples down my throat. I just take them and if it stinks i won't hesitate to not pay a single cent for it.. but on one encounter. I tried an authentic hmong apple fruit wine. Its the most amazing drink. And its only 100,000 dong ($4usd) per bottle and very nicely packed. I bought a dozen of them and it made one of the best souvenirs ever. From Paddy Field trekking to crazy glass bridges (100 times scarier than fansipan but 1hr away) Sapa never fails to disappoint. Who knows i might come back the third time. (;
sapa rất nhiều điểm đẹp có thể bạn chưa khám phá hết.
I understand your concerns about this place. Your a good person Paddy🙏
Thanks mate
These children live in villages far from town (sometimes they have to walk for 3-4 days), it is sad to see the children have to participate in making money. Partly because of the views of the Hmong, they give birth a lot (have a family of more than 10 children) and the way to raise a family at the present time cannot be enough just to grow crops and go to the forest to hunt... and the resort is how these kids feed themselves and help their parents
But giving them money or buying stuff from them will encourage that behavior and the cycle will continue. Don't buy from them and don't give them money so they girls can stay in school and get an education.
@@doodahgurlie Have you ever been to a remote village in the northern mountains? Each family group in the clan (5-7 families) lives in a large mountain, and only a few groups or dozens of groups have a school. To get to school you have to go from the top of the mountain to the valley and cross the trail, climb another mountain (sometimes 2 3 peaks) to reach the school. I've been to Sapa and participated in trekking in the villages.... and it's really hard for them to go to school at the moment!!!
@@NguyenHai-vx2kn They are already trekking to the city to sell stuff, which doesn't invest in their education nor set them up for a better future.
@@doodahgurlie The only option is to stay at school. Schools up there are free. And there’s teachers who are staying at school and taking care of the students. But it’s really difficult because many of the kids have to help their families since Hmong parents usually have a lot of children. And if they don’t go to school, they’ll probably end up getting married at an early age and having many children.
@Ryan I don't agree with your saying the Hmong are a suppressed minority in SEA. Please prove it.
Man you look like young Michel J Fox ! 😁this is cool! And you have great content, thank you.🙌
Gosh! Thanks a lot! Looks like I'll change my mind and visit Sapa😻
I was there in 2005 and it's fair to say it's changed somewhat. Just a sleepy hill market town.
We actually did hike Fansipan and took us 2 long and painful days 😂😂 it was INTENSE to say the least but the view was stunning❤️ but yea we felt the same with the kids when we visited. We also visited back in April so some people haven’t seen tourists in years and we had so many Hmong women all over us and even had a day where one wouldn’t leave us alone for 3 hours. So yea I’d recommend only driving through sapa town 😂
I am not scared of heights as I used to have, nowadays I am very much way more Brave Boy.
I think if you want to enjoy SaPa you should stay away from the town and go to one of the villages on the slopes of the mountain. I stayed in TaVan and it was great. Really beautiful, so peaceful and no busses/trucks and noisy restaurants. While SaPa town is just too crowded and noisy. And the views from it are not the best, you just have get further away from it.
yes awful cheesy Sapa, you got it but you are more diplomatic, Ninh Binh on the other hand is spectacular and more authentic when i was there 6 years ago, breathtaking, awesome video again bravo
Thanks Paddy! I'm planning to go during end Jul. Will def do the Hà Giang Loop
When I was there like what, 12 years ago, it was starting to get this touristy vibe. But there was no cable cart or anything yet.
Hi Paddy loving the videos.been watching for a month now. I was in Thailand back in June. I’m back in October for 2 weeks, then again at Christmas for 3 weeks. Unfortunately I can’t move there like you, but the videos really entertain me, and inspire me to reach my goal of eventually moving to Thailand.
On your way from Sapa to Hanoi , you should stop at some countryside towns like Moc chau-, Mai chau-, Son La Thai Nguyen etc
Hi Paddy, what set up you’re using ? Saw 2 gopro..? And the voice/sound ? A clip on mic connect to ..? And other set up? Thanks
Great to see Sapa and sad to see your bad experience..I was there 4 years ago and it wasn't like that and makes me sad to see those beautiful kids doing that..anyway the best is yet to came Paddy enjoy
Definitely a mixed bag there Paddy and very well explained
Although it is sad to see young kids working in those conditions, we all have to remember that their situation would be much worse without the money they do make from being out there. We live a cushy life compared to them so we see it as a sad thing but this is their reality. You have a good heart Paddy. Thanks for what you do.
Well said, all children have a right to work.
@@socialsuicide68 child labour was abolished many years ago. Maybe you need to be transported back to that time, be a child and be made to work. Worst comment ever written online.
@@steveth1000 The harsh reality dictates the action. I am sure if they have choice kids would like to be kids....but when they are born into poverty and have no choice it is just the way of life. Abolishing child labor is wonderful and noble effort only when it is truly put into action instead of just verbal judgment. It is similar to the hypocrites in America who crow about pro-life to ban abortion but none of them would want to shed a dime from their pocket to help feed and raise an unfortunate child who is brought into this world unwanted.
Same kind of the feeling here when I was in sappa three years ago
So sad to see how sapa has changed in twenty years.
When I was there with my x partner we were two of probably less than a fifty tourists in the town.
The streets were gravel no power in sapa in the day time.
I remember asking why the power didn't work in the hotel and she just said no power in sapa.
It became a joke between us when we ever got a power cut.
We would just say no power in sapa.
We did go trekking with one of the local mon girls who was great and stayed in amazing place in the mountains.
But it's not going to be the same now.
I fully understand with everything you said at the end.
And I didn't recognise anything in the town at all.
Very sad 😔
Interesting and honest perspective. We bypassed Sapa on a long trek in Vietnam in 2018
There is another few amazing waterfall too there and a bit away from Sapa
Nice video! Happy to be here! Thanks!
I was in Sapa in Dec 2008. Did a lovely hike, but I can't recognize the town in any way. Scenery still stunning though, but a lot more crowded.
I totally get your point about being put off by the people trying to sell you something.
Thanks ! You make this film very nice
Kids selling stuff on the streets? Wait for Ho Chi Minh city 😁😜 thanks for your content! And have a safe and amazing trip😉
Great one! Did anyone tell you that you look like Michael J Fox when he was young in Back to The Future time? 😅
Paddy over 10,000 feet up and riding in a cable car. All I could think was, "Too bad his friend isn't there to force him into zip lining again." Thanks for taking us along.
15 years ago Sapa was beautiful nice and peaceful, with small old houses with garden. It's spoiled now. What's a regret :(