This man has a point. He is not blaming sex workers. He says that its their business. And he acknowledges also. He has an issue with the way they behave. Standing on roads. Shouting and creating a havoc. Sitting on scooters. Thats what bothers the general residents. He has a valid point. Do ur business sure. But be mindful of others too. There should be some mid way out. Movie is movie. Where they have glorified the prostitutes and gangubai. Which is one angle. But what about the general ppl? They also have life and business and may be they dont wanna be a party to this “business”. Thats all he is saying...
Ya but the movie wasn't just trying to glorify it, actually it did the complete opposite, u just think it's glorified because gangu went on to lead a better life But the opening scenes, where they beat the girls, the assault scene, the one where they were writing the letter to the girl's father, the one where gangu speaks to her mom, when the girls come back from school, etc... They all show the hardships of being a prostitute... The fact that even those women have feelings. The problem is that, that was yrs ago. Now, the area is different and the women are of this decade. So naturally it doesn't apply to these circumstances... I don't think they glorified it, I think they glorified ganga's life, but that was always glorious... They showed how she turned her pain into helping these girls... So.. Ya.. I disagree with that point
I lived initial 29 years of my life in kamathipura, now live elsewhere. My grand father had shifted to this area in 1950's may be. But, I couldn't survive more here because of red light area and cramped house. Today, I stand with another house in Mumbai but have deep emotions with kamathipura and like to return when things are better.
@@KarnatakavloggerNaaz786 pros-ti-tut-€$ are very important for our society. Yes, all the women being forced into it should definitely be strictly monitored and culprits should be punished. But many women willingly come into this profession and that's ok. Their service is very essential, its not something dirty to wipe out
@@SwatiSingh-ve6hv . Condition of nowadays government is like they can't provide any jobs to educated people these days , sex workers are not even taken into consideration
the movie is a movie, not a documentry. slb spent his childhood in kamathipura too. the film is based on Gangubai's life, the way things were *then*. It doesn't have to be the same now, therefore it's mostly accurate and It's an incredible film. Without it u wouldn't even know the great things that lady did. She fought for equality. Now what he's saying about people not marrying their daughters in the area, she fought for those women, the girls who needed education etc... when gangu made the girls so to school, it was the school who didn't accept them because they're seen as "tainted" just because they're born there..she gave up the only decent man she'ed met in a long time so that someone nice could marry the girl who wasn't getting accepted everywhere else idk what u mean by it's not that movie, let alone the fact that that was literally yrs ago, and obviously things are different now. *yet I agree with this video that, the fact that it's not their profession anymore, it's the way they behave. These are different women than the kind that gangu fought for, and I agree with his idea of development.*
There's a difference between the girls of sex workers in kamathipura red light area and the girls of local people. I am not saying this difference should be there. But, it is there. This man is a local there not from red light area, but these locals also face the problems which red light area people face which should not be done. Movie was phenomenal but SLB should have shown the life of locals also. Maybe after the movie gangubai is getting praised and prostitutes are seen with some respect but there's nothing done for locals there and after the movie kamathipura has completely recognized as red light area. But in reality it is not so..not whole kamathipura is a red light area.. locals also live there. This is what that man is trying to say. He is not blaming any sex workers, but telling his own problems.
@@rishikabisht1374 I completely agree, but what people need to understand is that the movie is set in a time where the entire area was red light. Whereas now it's only 10%, so SLB was historically accurate. NOW the situation is different, but it isn't his job to give u an update about the area decades later.... It's a film about one woman, not a documentary about a community.
@@perfectoleo693 well we don't know the way they behave now, times have changed and decades later we don't know the attitude of these women. Are they actually being rude and bringing the locality down? It sounds like that from what he's saying... When Gangu spoke for her community, it was that community yrs ago, when 100% of the area was of prostitution and girls were trafficked there, whereas now a lot of them are there because they were born there (nothing wrong in that, but the way they see life is different) I believe in that sense the women are different from then and now :)
Ok but why this going too far. Let it be . She should look out for gangubai's real story back in 2018/2019 or before that but why right after the movie release? I know we want to know the real and behind the stories but since there was not much issues why she's doing this all ??
@@paramitalahiri3240 the movie is a movie, not a documentry. slb spent his childhood in kamathipura too. the film is based on Gangubai's life, the way things were then. It doesn't have to be the same now, therefore it's mostly accurate and It's an incredible film. Without it u wouldn't even know the great things that lady did. She fought for equality. Now what he's saying about people not marrying their daughters in the area, she fought for those women, the girls who needed education etc... it's not money when it comes to slb, don't say things for the sake of it pls
जब लोगो को इतनी प्रॉब्लम है सेक्स वर्कर से then Why these doesn't talk about Their rehabilitation.. कोई भी सेक्स वर्कर क्यों बन रहे है आप उन्हे अच्छा काम दे वो लोग ये काम छोड़ देंगे एक सभ्य समाज की जीती जागती तस्वीर उंगली सब उठाएंगे but उनके लिए करेंगे कुछ नहीं
@Diana exactly I felt if this role would have been portrayed by a grown woman with a few changes in their looks and makeup would have been a terrific movie over all just like how priyanka did justice to her role in Barfi and Vidya in Dirty Picture you can transform a person to look however you want them too Bhansali wanted Alia and he paid big time for it as many didn’t like it they found it boring too
Feeling bad for this person. Indian state has been woke since independence before woke was even a word and I don't think anything can be done about that area. Better to move out and leave that area to it's fate.
Sex workers are actually willingly working here, it's not something that they are bring forced into. They see it as a medium of easy money. Rather than wasting hours on getting ready , I wish they could do something worth living. There might be very few women who actually wanna leave this mean of earning money. If they want they ask for support from the government and actually work hard to uplift their standard of living.
@Prathamesh Adsul Dude it's real life not that gangubai movie. Some might want to leave but I don't think that's impossible . If they want they can leave . These guys can easily gain the media's attention if they do something worth catching their attention like protests and all. But only when every girl there is ready. The govn can surely provide a better place of living for them for some period of time. They can be given skill training classes. And then can join or make a organisation to support their livelyhood. If they wish they can come out of that shit.
@@champagneproblemz7386 No that's not my point that whether people will change their prespective or not. Rome was not built in a day sweetheart. Everything requires timr and patience. Them quitting those things will itself earn a sense of respect in the eyes of the people. We Indians might not be everything , but we surely are emapthetic. Not everyone wil trust them, but some will trust them but only if they actully want a change. These people can easily gain the govn. attention. These ladies might face rejection right now but their future generations won't . Till then they would be proudly living their life.
@@champagneproblemz7386 Not now but a day will surely come when they will be respected. Transgenders were also not considered as someone who was worth giving respect, but aren't we now treating them with respect. Again not everyone, but many are doing so. Your past will define you only for the next few years but your present and future can surely overshadow it.
Uncle ne sai bole sb.. Ab gangubai bni to kya sb dhnde wale k support me thodi jayege yr unki mjburi h sbki thodi or unke lye ek alag city hona chhaye... Izztdar b wahi bdnam b wahi to kaisa koi izzatdaaro ko acha smjega .
They were forced to do this. So called men are selling underaged kids for price. They don’t deserve this. And respectable males go there for sex those who are married are going there to have sex with underaged kids.
Iss Kaam Ko Tum Jayaz Kaam Bolre hai...Sharam Aana Chaiye tumhein reporter ....Kaam Karna hai So Izzat ka kro Shop mei mall Mei Kisi ke ghar ka kaam kro Housekeeping Banojao Zaruri nai hai ki Yehi Kaam karke paisa kamai..Okayy
Bhai woh log saare Bangladesh ka hi hai... Farji Aadhar card bana ke idhar dhanda kar rha hai..Mumbai, Bangalore, Kolkata jaisa city mein bhar bhar ke hai.
This man has a point. He is not blaming sex workers. He says that its their business. And he acknowledges also. He has an issue with the way they behave. Standing on roads. Shouting and creating a havoc. Sitting on scooters. Thats what bothers the general residents. He has a valid point. Do ur business sure. But be mindful of others too. There should be some mid way out. Movie is movie. Where they have glorified the prostitutes and gangubai. Which is one angle. But what about the general ppl? They also have life and business and may be they dont wanna be a party to this “business”. Thats all he is saying...
👍
Ya but the movie wasn't just trying to glorify it, actually it did the complete opposite, u just think it's glorified because gangu went on to lead a better life
But the opening scenes, where they beat the girls, the assault scene, the one where they were writing the letter to the girl's father, the one where gangu speaks to her mom, when the girls come back from school, etc...
They all show the hardships of being a prostitute... The fact that even those women have feelings.
The problem is that, that was yrs ago. Now, the area is different and the women are of this decade. So naturally it doesn't apply to these circumstances...
I don't think they glorified it, I think they glorified ganga's life, but that was always glorious... They showed how she turned her pain into helping these girls... So.. Ya.. I disagree with that point
Yes especially for girls how difficult to marry
A very passionate , honest and knowlegable father talking.
I lived initial 29 years of my life in kamathipura, now live elsewhere. My grand father had shifted to this area in 1950's may be. But, I couldn't survive more here because of red light area and cramped house. Today, I stand with another house in Mumbai but have deep emotions with kamathipura and like to return when things are better.
Ohhh
Allah kare prostitute khatm ho aur sahi mahol banjaye bachao ke future ke liye
P
@@KarnatakavloggerNaaz786 pros-ti-tut-€$ are very important for our society. Yes, all the women being forced into it should definitely be strictly monitored and culprits should be punished. But many women willingly come into this profession and that's ok. Their service is very essential, its not something dirty to wipe out
@@vishakha38 Hmm
@@vishakha38 so true
Agar ye log na ho to rape risk increase ho sakte h may b
This person has point in his speech , its tough for other locals to leave there . I'm not blaming sexworkers but there should be some middle way out
Exactly m a woman but m agree with what this man was saying...
Government should provide some other job to the women working there maybe and arrange shelter for them this could work maybe!?
@@SwatiSingh-ve6hv . Condition of nowadays government is like they can't provide any jobs to educated people these days , sex workers are not even taken into consideration
What an intelligent talking this man so wisely should understand few educated polititions
Agar English nhi aati ho toh Hindi me likh Lena chahiye
हिन्दी प्लीज 🙏🏻
His right he is not blaming the work they do his is blaming the way they behave
😳🤣😘
You are right, Yasmin
Exactly
This person spoke truth....Movies n media has downed the image more the real.
Repjies
the movie is a movie, not a documentry. slb spent his childhood in kamathipura too. the film is based on Gangubai's life, the way things were *then*. It doesn't have to be the same now, therefore it's mostly accurate and It's an incredible film. Without it u wouldn't even know the great things that lady did. She fought for equality. Now what he's saying about people not marrying their daughters in the area, she fought for those women, the girls who needed education etc...
when gangu made the girls so to school, it was the school who didn't accept them because they're seen as "tainted" just because they're born there..she gave up the only decent man she'ed met in a long time so that someone nice could marry the girl who wasn't getting accepted everywhere else
idk what u mean by it's not that movie, let alone the fact that that was literally yrs ago, and obviously things are different now.
*yet I agree with this video that, the fact that it's not their profession anymore, it's the way they behave. These are different women than the kind that gangu fought for, and I agree with his idea of development.*
True said
How are there women different than the ones gangu fought for? Can you elaborate? Genuinely asking
There's a difference between the girls of sex workers in kamathipura red light area and the girls of local people. I am not saying this difference should be there. But, it is there. This man is a local there not from red light area, but these locals also face the problems which red light area people face which should not be done. Movie was phenomenal but SLB should have shown the life of locals also. Maybe after the movie gangubai is getting praised and prostitutes are seen with some respect but there's nothing done for locals there and after the movie kamathipura has completely recognized as red light area. But in reality it is not so..not whole kamathipura is a red light area.. locals also live there. This is what that man is trying to say. He is not blaming any sex workers, but telling his own problems.
@@rishikabisht1374 I completely agree, but what people need to understand is that the movie is set in a time where the entire area was red light. Whereas now it's only 10%, so SLB was historically accurate. NOW the situation is different, but it isn't his job to give u an update about the area decades later.... It's a film about one woman, not a documentary about a community.
@@perfectoleo693 well we don't know the way they behave now, times have changed and decades later we don't know the attitude of these women. Are they actually being rude and bringing the locality down? It sounds like that from what he's saying... When Gangu spoke for her community, it was that community yrs ago, when 100% of the area was of prostitution and girls were trafficked there, whereas now a lot of them are there because they were born there (nothing wrong in that, but the way they see life is different)
I believe in that sense the women are different from then and now :)
Uncle ka bath pe point h.....So true 👍👍👍👍
chacha is very smart good reply 👍
True
Mahmood Munshi is right. It can be understood what problems they might be facing.😥
The second man spoke so real
Good expert person mehmood bhai great analysis,,, with great points of view🙏🙏🙏
True
Incredible uncle 👏
Very correct way to point out the issue
,🥰🥰🥰
Complete true point uncle..
Uncle Ji ki har baat point wali haii
i am here after, Aliya bhatt movie. GANGUBAI KHITHIYAWARI🔥❤❤❤
Me too
It would be better if they include English subtitles into this video. I only understand what they say only after scrolling down the comment section
The men Reveled very clearly situations
They behave in such a way because of their work
Ok but why this going too far. Let it be . She should look out for gangubai's real story back in 2018/2019 or before that but why right after the movie release?
I know we want to know the real and behind the stories but since there was not much issues why she's doing this all ??
Problem is .. Movies do not show the reality. Everything is money for them
@@paramitalahiri3240 that's goes to every biopic movie they put masala in it.
@@itsfact1151 check your English dude
@@paramitalahiri3240 the movie is a movie, not a documentry. slb spent his childhood in kamathipura too. the film is based on Gangubai's life, the way things were then. It doesn't have to be the same now, therefore it's mostly accurate and It's an incredible film. Without it u wouldn't even know the great things that lady did. She fought for equality. Now what he's saying about people not marrying their daughters in the area, she fought for those women, the girls who needed education etc...
it's not money when it comes to slb, don't say things for the sake of it pls
Sahi kahe ye sahab ne , takli genuine hai.
Thankyou 🙏🌹
Uncle ne baat toh sahi ki h
जब लोगो को इतनी प्रॉब्लम है सेक्स वर्कर से then Why these doesn't talk about Their rehabilitation..
कोई भी सेक्स वर्कर क्यों बन रहे है
आप उन्हे अच्छा काम दे वो लोग ये काम छोड़ देंगे
एक सभ्य समाज की जीती जागती तस्वीर
उंगली सब उठाएंगे but उनके लिए करेंगे कुछ नहीं
Point👍
padhe likhe log unemployed ghoom rahe .
India me itna population hai ki sabko kaam dena at present easy nahi hai. future me Shayad ho jaye.
And Alia did not even promote her movie or visit the area where the woman lived she did the biopic on it was all about making money
@Diana exactly I felt if this role would have been portrayed by a grown woman with a few changes in their looks and makeup would have been a terrific movie over all just like how priyanka did justice to her role in Barfi and Vidya in Dirty Picture you can transform a person to look however you want them too Bhansali wanted Alia and he paid big time for it as many didn’t like it they found it boring too
@@kajalkhatri1034 i agree but many people have praised her work in the movie and are actually recommending others to watch the movie.
@@kajalkhatri1034 true
No shit, she's an actress who works to make money. Wtf kinda point are u tryna make?
@@Rose-ws1se the exact fucking reason you took the effort to reply to a comment i already wrote that it's all about money
Dhanda karo toh izzat ka warna karo hi mat🙂🙂
Even the students who go to colleges nearby kamathipura get insulted
Promote Kashmir file, and support us kashmiri pandit
Feeling bad for this person. Indian state has been woke since independence before woke was even a word and I don't think anything can be done about that area. Better to move out and leave that area to it's fate.
**Mahmood Munshi ji is absolutely correct ✅✅✅✅**
Very true said.
Sahi kaha is admi ne.
I have lots if memory of this area.
Please Share some with us.
Aap yaha rehte ho
Sex workers are actually willingly working here, it's not something that they are bring forced into. They see it as a medium of easy money. Rather than wasting hours on getting ready , I wish they could do something worth living. There might be very few women who actually wanna leave this mean of earning money.
If they want they ask for support from the government and actually work hard to uplift their standard of living.
Who'll give them work? No one can trust them.
@Prathamesh Adsul Dude it's real life not that gangubai movie. Some might want to leave but I don't think that's impossible . If they want they can leave . These guys can easily gain the media's attention if they do something worth catching their attention like protests and all. But only when every girl there is ready. The govn can surely provide a better place of living for them for some period of time. They can be given skill training classes. And then can join or make a organisation to support their livelyhood.
If they wish they can come out of that shit.
@@champagneproblemz7386 No that's not my point that whether people will change their prespective or not. Rome was not built in a day sweetheart. Everything requires timr and patience. Them quitting those things will itself earn a sense of respect in the eyes of the people.
We Indians might not be everything , but we surely are emapthetic.
Not everyone wil trust them, but some will trust them but only if they actully want a change.
These people can easily gain the govn. attention. These ladies might face rejection right now but their future generations won't . Till then they would be proudly living their life.
@@champagneproblemz7386 Not now but a day will surely come when they will be respected. Transgenders were also not considered as someone who was worth giving respect, but aren't we now treating them with respect. Again not everyone, but many are doing so. Your past will define you only for the next few years but your present and future can surely overshadow it.
@@muskanku91 let's hope
ye kuch nhi hai . aap kolkata sona gache jake dekho
Interviewer alia bhat h 👍
Ye alia nehi hai
Uncle ne sai bole sb.. Ab gangubai bni to kya sb dhnde wale k support me thodi jayege yr unki mjburi h sbki thodi or unke lye ek alag city hona chhaye... Izztdar b wahi bdnam b wahi to kaisa koi izzatdaaro ko acha smjega .
Kisiko badnaam kyon hie manna??
@@saswatmishra539 badnam ki gali me rhoge to bdnam hi keh laoge
@@nehask7162 wohi toh kisiko badnaam kyon bolna kisi gali ko badnaam kyon bulana..
@@saswatmishra539 gali badnam wali hi h to bolege na.. Tmhare bolne s thodi izzt ya shaan bdh jayegi
We must help and make government responsible for happening all these. They all part of this ugliest picture. Talk. Talk and talk nothing else.
Sabse men to pehla wala vimal kha rha he 😂
Its shivaji maharaj 🙏 hath jodle nntr hath khultil
Hello it's Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj tarminas
Ye logo ko malum nahi hai chatrapati shivaji maharaj ke bareme
So what
Nice
Practical baat kar rahe hai bhai
Initially i thought she is aalia Bhat
Good vlog
Mu se supari nikalke baat karre baba😂😂😂
Very Good Business To Protect from xxxx
Ab ye kitne din tk gangubai gangubai chalega
th-cam.com/video/mut6l2zxJV0/w-d-xo.html vlog from Lahore Halloween
Ab to ye tourist point ban jayega
Until new movies announced,
@@sunilsuryavanshi2576 😂
Yaha missile chodna chahiye tha 😎🚩🕉️❤️🇮🇳
Ab to ye jaga bhi famous ho jayegi or log Jada jayege 😅
Eww
Ek baar kashmir bhi ghoom ke ana
Vha konsa red area h
Chatrpati shivaji maharaj bolo bhai
banda baat sahi kia...
Kya abhi b gangubai k Ghar me sex workers hain? Kya movie ki Tarah abhi b waisa hi hai
Out look seriously 😅🤣🤣🤣you guys need more research 🤣
Rahul Lala channel
Iss kaam ko respect 😂😂😂matlab kuchbhi..
They were forced to do this. So called men are selling underaged kids for price. They don’t deserve this. And respectable males go there for sex those who are married are going there to have sex with underaged kids.
Jo boyega wahi payega , sukh - dukh hai kya burey karmon , jaisi karni - waisi bharni .
Instead if doing these bullshit things, go promote the kashmir file if you’re truly genuine citizen of India 🇮🇳
Shame on u
@@kshaikh80 *shame on u Jihadi*
@@kshaikh80 shame on u and ur brothers and ur religious spokesperson and radicals
@@vivek-wl9qv jali kya teri problem sab ka hai lekin sabko sirf apna dikhta hai.but u became shameless now.
I support kashmir file not chutiya of alia bhat
3:27 😠👊
Gutkha na thuookego
रिपोर्ट वाली भी कैसे इंटरव्ह्यू ले रही है गुटेकेवाले का ????????
शी..
😂😂😂
Promote Kashmir files
9u
Abe chatrapati shivaji bol jandu samja Kay
interviewer is alia bhatt guyss
No..
👀😂😂
Iss Kaam Ko Tum Jayaz Kaam Bolre hai...Sharam Aana Chaiye tumhein reporter ....Kaam Karna hai So Izzat ka kro Shop mei mall Mei Kisi ke ghar ka kaam kro Housekeeping Banojao Zaruri nai hai ki Yehi Kaam karke paisa kamai..Okayy
What rubbish you say from Bangladesh. They are from west bengal, not from Bangladesh
west bengal bole to?
Bhai woh log saare Bangladesh ka hi hai... Farji Aadhar card bana ke idhar dhanda kar rha hai..Mumbai, Bangalore, Kolkata jaisa city mein bhar bhar ke hai.
AREEF